Previous Minutes
· Councillor Booth said it was not reflected in the minutes that he had asked it to be noted that he disagreed with the Section 113 agreement being held in exempt session.
Every time Fenland's minutes name Councillor Booth, as the council published it.
· Councillor Booth said it was not reflected in the minutes that he had asked it to be noted that he disagreed with the Section 113 agreement being held in exempt session.
For that reason, he does not support the motion although he does agree with elements of it. · Councillor Booth said Councillor Summers had summed up his own opinion. He fully supports Local Government Reorganisation (LGR), and it cannot come soon enough, change does need to occur.
He stated that he invites the Leader of the Opposition to contact him at the earliest possible opportunity to inform him which outside bodies which are currently not allocated to the Fenland Independent Alliance he would like to be allocated and as he did every year with Councillor Booth he is sure they will be able to make a mutually agreeable deal to ensure that the optimal solution is made as to who will represent the Council on the outside bodies. He added that the appointments to outside bodies are not going to be made until the next meeting of Cabinet in June.
Councillor Booth stated that he had spoken to Peter Catchpole before the meeting and had raised the point of there being the need for defined roles and responsibilities and crossover between personnel. He referred to issues around people not being able to respond to requests and asked whether that should now be almost eliminated with the new structure? Peter Catchpole responded that he had spoken to Sian Warren that day for two hours and, unless any more requests had recently been provided, the Council was totally up to date with the audit requests.
Councillor Booth clarified that members used to receive a spreadsheet showing the parish or area involved and any timescales, for example where there was a five-year deadline, which had been provided when there had been dedicated Section 106 officer. Deborah Moss responded that she could do that and that it would fit quite nicely with the scope of the audit, which was going to concentrate on the money side rather than on anything else.
Councillor Booth stated that an extra meeting might be needed to accommodate the business. Peter Catchpole replied that the Annual Council meeting in May might result in new members joining the committee, and that the position would, therefore, need to be reconsidered after that.
Councillor Booth, as Leader of the Opposition, asked the following questions under Procedure Rule 8.4:
Councillor Booth added that information will be useful for Town and Parish Councils especially in light of the fact that the consultation exercise has commenced, and a number of Parish and Town Councils have responded to that and there is a tight timetable being proposed.
Councillor Booth added that previously there was a commitment given that meetings on Friday afternoons would try to be avoided and it appears that every meeting concerning Local Government Reorganisation (LGR) has taken place at 4pm on a Friday and he asked why this date has been chosen.
· Councillor Booth stated that he supports the motion, and he added that it is disappointing that it will not emerge as a matter of course with the Local Plan. He added that as various stages of the Local Plan are reached then the appropriate evidence will be obtained, however, there needs to be assurances that it is put in place.
Proposed by Councillor Boden, seconded by Councillor Booth and AGREED the resolution set out in the report for the Council Tax requirement be approved.
· Councillor Booth stated that he has deep reservations concerning the proposal as it took the Council 7 years previously in which to prepare a Local Plan using the assistance from Peterborough City Council. He added that now the Council finds itself in a situation where they are trying to deliver a new Local Plan within 2 years but are still having to go to another Local Authority as that is where the resources are.
Councillor Booth stated that he has concerns that there will not be the commitment and the time needed from officers to be able to deliver a Local Plan in the timeframe but there appears to be no other option.
· Councillor Boden stated that he agrees with Councillor Booth that all authorities facing abolition are going to find it increasingly difficult to recruit officers that are being dissolved but the proposal and the Section 113 Agreement is the best option available and he provided assurance that he attends monthly meetings with Councillor Mrs Laws to monitor the progress that is being made on the Local Plan with the available staff.
· Councillor Mrs Laws stated that she does understand the concerns of Councillor Booth, but she explained that other options have been explored, including consideration being given to whether agency staff are used but with that brings a considerable cost and then there is the risk that agency staff dictate their working hours. She stated that by entering into an agreement then there is the certainty of the manpower which the Council will have, making the point that by going to an agency there is also the possibility of introducing an individual who is not familiar with Fenland.
· Councillor Booth stated that a report was taken to Cabinet regarding the Port and asked if the action plans are going to be implemented this year as there has been several reviews and as, yet no action plans have been put in place.
Councillor Booth suggested that under commercial fees where it stated, ‘a review of operations’, this means that a decision is going to be made once the actions have been completed.
· Councillor Booth stated that currently it is predicted that the Council has a £300,000 deficit but there is an expectation this will become a surplus, He asked where will this extra funding be coming from to cover the shortfall?
Councillor Booth continued that the budget states that there will be a two million deficit for next year and he would like to understand where the Council will be making additional savings? is there a plan in place as to how the Council are going to cover that shortfall and if so, can this be shared with members?
· Councillor Booth commented that the Council has put in place the performance measures but was not sure if the business plan has been looked at alongside the performance measures as a dedicated item and this could be something that the committee could consider for the future looking at all the KPI’s together as a whole.
Councillor Booth asked for his question from the last meeting to be chased and an answer provided.
Councillor Booth asked if there has been any conformation that Vision Zero will be attending the next meeting as he felt it important that they attend. Amy Brown confirmed she has been in contact with the relevant officers about attending and that this will be a combined presentation with the Road Safety Partnership.
· Councillor Booth stated that he will support the motion, but he does have concerns that the moratorium is only for 6 months. He made the point that the Wisbech rail project has been ongoing for a number of years and, in his opinion, 6 months is not long enough ... view the full minutes text for item C22/20
Councillor Booth stated that members should note that it is a statutory requirement that items are placed on the Forward Plan at least 28 days in advance of consideration and that is why the Chairman was required to use his urgent powers of delegation on this occasion.
· Councillor Booth referred to page 198 which shows three high recommendations one of which is for limited assurance opinion for licences and asked for clarification as he expressed the opinion that limited is quite poor in relation to what we normally have for Fenland. The Internal Audit Manager explained that it referred to an audit which took place early last year and the high risk recommendations referred to procedures, resilience and business continuity and information that was being communicated on the Council’s website which was out of date and inaccurate. All of the recommendations were dealt with within three weeks of the report being issued and they are no longer risks and she is confident that they are now complete.
· Councillor Booth expressed the view with regard to the possibility of an Independent person forming part of the Committee, it is something that should be considered and the position advertised. He added that it will strengthen the governance arrangements and the Committee will receive the views from an external person’s perspective.
· Councillor Booth stated that he agrees with the Chairman with regard to the postponement. He added that if this is something that is considered going forward a person specification could be drawn up to ensure that the correct person is appointed.
· Councillor Booth referred to the action log which had been presented. He added that this could be the first item to be added to that log so it would be good practice to ensure areas of concern or focus can be tracked.
· Councillor Booth stated that an action plan ... view the full minutes text for item CGC8/20
· Councillor Booth expressed the view that it is concerning to hear the presentation. He asked whether it was known when the recruitment freeze will be lifted and whether the committee need to be highlighting their concerns.
Councillor John Clark stated that he concurs with Councillor Booth.
· Councillor Booth, questioned, that as the recruitment freeze has been lifted is there now the opportunity to consider filling the vacancy in the Audit team.? He expressed the view that he knows that recruitment is not an overnight process and asked when do officers anticipate that the audit team will be able to resume their normal functionality. The Head of HR and OD stated that she intends to work with the Internal Audit Manager to progress this immediately.
The Head of HR & OD stated that this was something that was reviewed on an adhoc basis going forward, because the daily covid meetings took place which enabled there to be an element of capture learning and the risk register could then be populated as a result of that · Cllr Booth stated that at the previous meeting he had raised some observations and he cannot see them reflected in the risk register, the Head of HR & OD stated these would be reflected in the next review presented to Committee.
Councillor Booth asked how much lobbying we are doing through the Local Government Association to get better clarity from the Government around what additional payments they may be making.
Proposed by Councillor Boden, seconded by Councillor Booth it was AGREED that the report be noted.
Councillor Booth thanked Councillor Laws for her kind words. He said the plan was part of the Localism Act and he would encourage other parishes and villages to follow the same route to help influence the way they can grow their communities.
Councillor Mrs Laws said she fully appreciated the amount of work that has gone into this and would agree with Councillor Booth that she would encourage any village to go through with a neighbourhood plan. It can take a lot of time and be very challenging but is worthwhile when it comes to planning decisions and taking local people’s views into account.
(Councillor Booth declared an interest in that he helped develop the therefore will not vote on the matter but reserves the right to speak if anyone has any questions).
Councillor Booth thanked Councillor Boden for taking on board the comments raised at the last meeting and acting to give them the opportunity to help shape what he feels is a more democratic solution.
Councillor Booth said it was a minor observation but 19.1 mentions the raised hand function and we must remember that if we do change to a different method of meeting, this will have to be taken into account at that time.
Councillor Booth was going to suggest the same as Councillor Sutton, that this be reviewed in six months’ time to see how it works in practice. However, his main concern is the member call-in process which was only changed a few years ago. His understanding at that time is that it would be a consultation between the heads of Planning and Legal and the Planning Chairman.
If in six months’ time, Councillor Sutton or Councillor Booth wish to seek a revision then that is fine but he does not think we will be in that position then.
Councillor Booth said that he does not think Action 1 relating to rent charged by the County Council to early years providers should be marked as completed. They state they are looking at a payment holiday for the rents but he believes there is an issue regarding affordability. One of the preschools in his village has expressed concern about future sustainability because of their tight budget and so he believes we need to keep a watching brief on this item. 2.
Councillor Booth said that although he appreciates the time taken by Inspector Lombardo to respond to Action 2 regarding road safety and police enforcement of speed limits, he is concerned that speeding is still a big issue.
Councillor Miscandlon agreed with Councillor Booth but said that having spoken to the Police and Crime Commissioner on this issue within his ward, he was advised that if the speeding is considered to be legally dangerous than the advice is to call 999. Report on 101 otherwise. Police will respond to 999 where the situation is life threating to other road users and pedestrians.
Councillor Booth said he would still like the item left open to monitor for the future but he was thankful for this useful information.
Councillor Booth said that although Councillor Boden mentioned there is an impact on other authorities he felt the report lacks their thoughts on the scheme; although we are the setting authority we need to have a better understanding of the actual impact of the scheme on them. County Council gets the prime share of council tax we collect but it would be interesting to know the effect on other authorities particularly for future years.
Councillor Booth said he also raised the issue of the percentage variance last year and would particularly like to know the implications regarding administration. 3.
Councillor Booth said he agreed that a recommendation regarding consultation should be put forward to Cabinet and also he takes on board Councillor Boden’s comment regarding administration. We need to think about the socio-economic impact of changing the rate. For example, where does paying council tax lie in budgeting as a priority for people on limited budgets?
Councillor Booth said that although he broadly agreed with the draft report, his only comment would be in relation to the call-in at Section 6 of the report. The majority talks about the process but there is little actual wording around the debate that took place in relation to the call-in and he feels it would be useful to expand paragraph 6.7 to include this.
Councillor Booth said he wished to move a recommendation that the Panel adopt the report but on basis we amend Section 6.7 as he had highlighted.
Proposed by Councillor Booth, seconded by Councillor Wicks that the Overview and Scrutiny Panel approve the annual report for forwarding to Council on the basis that there be an amendment to Section 6.7. A vote was taken on the proposal which was defeated.
Councillor Booth said that December would be far too late and that this would be almost two years anyway. He felt an earlier date should be agreed; particularly given issues that have previously arisen around winter time. 3.
· Councillor Booth stated that at the Annual Council meeting in 2019, there was a debate with regard to the days on which meetings are held. He added that there was a commitment for meetings to be held on Thursdays, but this now does not appear to be the case and questioned why?
· Councillor Booth, added that the debate that took place with regard to Freedom Leisure at the Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting on 8 June 2020 can be viewed on You Tube.
· Councillor Booth stated that he has read the changes to the Constitution and expressed the opinion that whilst he appreciates that due to the pandemic there needs to be a new way of working he has concerns that some of the changes that have been introduced such as not allowing public speaking or petitions will stifle the democratic process. He added that the virtual Planning Committees have enabled members of the public to make representations, and therefore, members of the public should be able to present at meetings of the Council.
· Councillor Booth commented that some members may recall that a motion had been discussed previously at Council, where consideration had been given with regard to holding meetings of the Council virtually.
· Councillor Booth stated that the report states that political parties will have to vote against motions in the Constitution, which he is concerned to read. He also questioned what the review period is for these amendments.
Councillor Boden expressed the opinion that, progress has been made with virtual meetings taking place over the last few months and therefore he would like to discuss this further with Councillor Tanfield and Councillor Booth to review whether further changes can be made.
· Councillor Booth asked whether this can be reviewed within the next 3 months.
· Referring to page 6, item 21 Councillor Booth said he understood there should be an action to look into a question he asked regarding county council and the rates they were going to be charging pre-schools.
Councillor Booth said that Action 5 on road safety and speed prevention lacked information in not stating the amount of work the police are going to do in relation to their enforcement role. He said that there was a lengthy explanation about prevention work but it is enforcement that needs to work hand in hand with prevention.
Councillor Booth added that he is a Community Speedwatch volunteer and therefore has experience of this.
Councillor Booth commented on the timeliness of the report saying it should be seen as an interim rather than final report. It would have been useful to get feedback on areas where we could improve in the future, e.g. the lack of coordination with the national delivery scheme working with the Council. Members of staff needing to change or request a food delivery do not know which company is providing the delivery;
Councillor Booth queried the timeline as he was not convinced about this based on what he had read in the member briefing. Under 4.5 of the briefing paper, we could have decided not to give support or limited support and Freedom could have terminated their contract, so that suggests a time span, however he is not disputing the decision taken. 2.
Councillor Booth suggested Anglian Water be invited to attend a future meeting. He has had complaints regarding water pressure due to increased usage with more people at home during this pandemic. Although this has improved, it would be useful to have them discuss their infrastructure and maintenance programme.
Councillor Booth also suggested that Clarion come before the end of the year as the opportunity was missed for them to attend in March. 3.
Councillor Booth requested that Freedom Leisure attend earlier than November so they can advise how they expect to get services up and running again.
Members received a presentation in objection to the application, in accordance with the Public Participation Procedure, from Councillor Gavin Booth as District Councillor.
Councillor Booth stated that he spoke to Officers in February and was advised that further reports had been requested regarding provision of traveller pitches and flood risk. He added that looking at the online file these do not appear to have materialised for public viewing and therefore, the justification Officers have given to approve this site after it has been refused twice in the last 3 years, demonstrates a lack of consistency in approach. He also requested that he was kept informed of progress on the application, sadly this did not happen.
Councillor Booth expressed the view that, in his opinion, the appeal site used to bring this third application is completely different in nature to the site in Sealey’s Lane, which is in the open countryside He stated that the officer report appears to dismiss the previous reasons for refusal even though they have not changed over the last 3 years and in his opinion the report does not make it clear enough that the site has been developed and occupied since October 2019, even though it was refused twice.
Councillor Booth stated that with regard to flood risk, the last correspondence on file from the Environment Agency is dated 3 January 2020 and objects to the proposal. He questioned why Officers are putting such weight on the agent’s report, when in the past the Environment Agency report would determine the nature of flood risk and is also contrary to previous decisions made regarding caravans and flood risk, given their vulnerable nature.
Councillor Booth expressed the view that with regard to open countryside, it appeared that Officers have now changed their mind on why this is not a consideration citing the nursery at the end of Sealey’s lane as justification. He added that the T junction with Harrold’s Bank has been developed for a considerable number of years with farm buildings, a nursery and property, situated some distance from this proposed development and the site in question is quite visible in the open countryside and different in nature to the site referred to in the appeal at Bevis Lane.
Councillor Booth expressed the opinion that with regard to traveller status there is no public report on file regarding the provision of traveller sites across the District, however previously it was determined there were sufficient at this time, ... view the full minutes text for item P80/19
· Councillor Booth highlighted that C55/19 (point 4), should read, that there was a motion which was considered by ’Council’ in May 2019.
· Councillor Booth stated that C58/19 (point 6), should read ‘democratic’.
· Councillor Booth addressed Councillor Boden, for an update with regard to parish street lighting which was discussed earlier at Cabinet.
· Councillor Booth stated that he will be supporting the budget but made reference to page 76 of the council agenda pack, item 8.2, where the council net services expenditure is shown to rise on a year on year basis. He stated that if the council were business like in their approach as had the figure as a 0% rise, then savings would not need to be sought.
· Councillor Boden stated that we do not know any further details of other financial aspects which may change in the next twelve months · Councillor Boden stated that with regard to property investment, the council is not going to invest in property companies; it is going to invest in property funds which are carefully regulated and only those that have sufficient liquidity and are approved from the Section 151 Officer. · Councillor Boden referred to the point that Councillor Booth had highlighted with regard to net services expenditure and the medium term financial strategy, is to make an estimate based on the council’s current financial position and to look at what the likely expenditure will be over the next few financial years.
· Councillor Booth stated that he was expressing the view that the council does not have a policy in place which asks officers not to increase the budgets over the medium term financial period.
In Favour: Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
In favour of the proposal - Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
· Councillor Booth stated that in his opinion, the policy should not be removed. He added that the consultation responses that were received were in favour of keeping the policy, including Public Health. He added that he is pleased to hear that further work is being undertaken to try and find a solution.
· Councillor Booth asked for clarification with regard to the review period over the frequency of the cycle of meetings.
· Councillor Booth expressed the view that this is a policy and if members are minded then they can vote against the policy.
Councillor Booth suggested that in relation to Action 1, there is still work to be carried out on the formatting of reports.
Councillor Booth highlighted that the Council had previously attended community meetings in the district’s villages alongside the Police and asked for commitment that the Council would revert back to this process, as over recent months there has been no representation from them. Dan Horn explained that the Council try to consult with residents subject to the resource available and confirmed that the Council work closely with the Police and try to hold community events in town locations which the rural community visit too, such as supermarkets.
Councillor Booth reiterated that these community engagement events are held in the district’s towns and as a result, the villages do not benefit.
Councillor Booth referenced page 112 of the report and the assessment that the Council’s street lighting contract is performing ‘exceptionally well’. He asked what consultation had taken place to obtain this feedback. Carol Pilson explained that the service is performing well from a contract management point of view.
Councillor Booth stated that it must be clear in reports if statistics are the opinion of officer’s or service users.
Councillor Booth asked that in future, the report contains the service level performance of the street lighting contract and should include feedback from service users.
Councillor Booth explained that he had exercised the right to call-in this Cabinet decision due to his concerns surrounding the accountability and governance arrangements of the proposed Investment Board. He explained that the governance arrangements propose a quorate of only two members with one non-voting officer in attendance. He highlighted that in instances where there is not a unanimous decision the Leader will be able to exercise his casting vote as chairman of the board.
Councillor Booth stated that this is not democratically appropriate and he recommends that membership to the Investment Board is increased which will both reduce the burden for board members and increase member involvement in the decision making process.
Councillor Boden thanked Councillor Booth for his feedback and agreed that it was highly appropriate to call-in this item for consideration due to its importance.
Councillor Booth thanked Councillor Boden for his explanation but reiterated that the current arrangements do not include the proposed mechanism and therefore his concern still stands.
Councillor Booth welcomed this.
Councillor Booth asked for clarification that non-board members will be prevented from attending meetings of the Investment Board and will be unable to exercise their ‘right to speak’.
Councillor Booth asked for assurance that the delay experienced in this year’s audit will not occur again. Mark Hodgson confirmed that there is no audit deadline contained within UK regulations. The only requirements are that local authorities must publish a draft set of accounts by 31 May and the final accounts by 31 July.
Councillor Booth highlighted that whilst there may be no deadline, presumably accounts cannot be signed off years after being published. Mark Hodgson agreed and confirmed that the accounts are signed off as soon as EY have assurance. If EY cannot perform this during their allocated timescale, then he agreed that this should be raised as a concern.
Councillor Booth asked if Mark Hodgson had been briefed of the Council’s new Commercial Investment Strategy (CIS) and asked what impact this would have on future audits. Mark Hodgson confirmed that he had been briefed on this and whilst it would not effect this year’s audit, it will impact future audits Councillor J ... view the full minutes text for item CGC24/19
Councillor Booth asked for assurance on the governance arrangements as neither of these entities will be required to report directly to the Corporate Governance Committee or a separate Audit Committee. He expressed concern in relation to the audit arrangements and asked if there were adequate skills and qualifications within the Council’s internal audit team to undertake this work.
Councillor Booth asked for confirmation that members are still responsible for their individual registration as data controllers. Anna Goodall confirmed that members are now encompassed under the Council’s own registration as data controllers.
Councillor Booth recommended that the report is amended to provide further information on the roles of specific officers and contact details for these officers. Anna Goodall agreed to consider this.
Councillor Booth recommended that a schedule of training is included in 6.9 of the report.
Councillor Booth asked how regularly the Data Protection Policy will be reviewed. Anna Goodall stated that the internal audit had recommended that the Council develop a ‘policy on policy’ which will collate all of the Council’s policies to ensure they are being updated and reviewed accordingly.
Councillor Booth asked if the Council have officers on standby in case of a natural disaster (page 106 of the agenda pack). Sam Anthony confirmed that there will be a rota of emergency on-call officers that cover throughout the year. This rota also ensures that officers are within a commutable distance to the district at all times. 2.
Councillor Booth highlighted the reduction to risk 17 (page 109 of the agenda pack) and suggested this may need to be reassessed as a majority ruling party in Government may implement legislative changes which could impact the Council.
Councillor Booth suggested that risk 3 (page 110 of the agenda pack) is amended to show the reduction in the likelihood of the current risk as the inherent risk has not changed. Sam Anthony agreed.
Councillor Booth recommended that the Council’s process for organisational change is not clearly articulated in the report (page 111 of the agenda pack). Sam Anthony agreed to incorporate this.
Councillor Booth referenced risk 2 – Brexit (page 114 of the agenda pack) and stated that the wording needs to be amended in relation to the withdrawal agreement and a ‘no deal’ Brexit. Sam Anthony agreed to review this.
Councillor Booth referenced risk 20 (page 121 of the agenda pack) in relation to the Council’s CIS. He stated that further information needs to be included in relation to the management of this risk and the governance arrangements. Sam Anthony agreed to review this.
Councillor Booth asked for further information in relation to a data breach which had recently been reported in the local press. Anna Goodall explained that the breach related to information that had been sent out to members of the public regarding the Local Plan review. Inadvertently, as a result of human error, the email addresses were included enabling all recipients to see all other consultee’s email addresses.
Councillor Yeulett asked a question on behalf of Councillor Booth. He stated that the metrics of the Business Plan do not align with the priorities set therefore this makes it difficult to ensure the plan has been delivered. In particular, additional metrics are required in relation to; health and wellbeing, recycling rates and how these can be improved, how the Council successfully measures the promotion of culture and heritage, community safety, regeneration and inward investment (currently this only shows the number of planning applications) and the delivery of infrastructure (no milestones are given to measure against the projects discussed).
Councillor Boden thanked Councillor Booth for his question and agreed that it is very important that these objectives can be successfully measured. He explained that in many cases there are no direct measures that can be quantified and welcomed member’s suggestions on this matter. He explained that the Council only have marginal control of certain outcomes for example; health and wellbeing are largely influenced by other organisations.
Councillor Yeulett asked a question on behalf of Councillor Booth. He stated that the MTFS shows an increase to the Net Service Expenditure to 2024/25 of £1.448m. He highlighted that page 58 of the agenda pack states that there is a 0% general inflation rate for this period and asked what the increases represent.
Councillor Yeulett asked a question on behalf of Councillor Booth. He stated that the fees and charges relating to the Port do not reference the results of the Overview & Scrutiny Panel’s Economic Development Review which determined that the maintenance and capital costs of the Port are generally the cause of the service not being cost neutral. He asked officers to confirm if these costs will be included in the charging structure for the Port.
Proposed by Councillor Boden, seconded by Councillor Booth, Councillor Mrs Mayor opened the item for discussion.
· Councillor Booth stated that he will support the proposal. He expressed the view that although there is an equalisation reserve, he would hope that it will not become normality where there are surpluses. He added that service costs for the next 4 to 5 years need to be reviewed going forward.
Proposed by Councillor Boden, seconded by Councillor Booth, and Council AGREED to adopt the recommendations within the report.
Councillor Booth said in relation to minute OSC20/19 point 44; he has heard reports that trees in Wisbech Park are being removed and not replaced and asked for further clarification on this. Carol Pilson confirmed that there is no Council endorsed policy in relation to the replacement of trees however each tree replacement is assessed on its own merits. She agreed to look into this further.
Councillor Booth stated that Full Council had recently considered a motion in relation to the decriminalisation of parking and asked whether officers had explored combining the enforcement of this with the current enforcement service. Carol Pilson confirmed that officers continue to monitor how the two projects could run in parallel with one another. She explained that Kingdom (LA Support) offer a wide range of enforcement services however combining these projects would be dependent on member’s priorities at the time.
Councillor Booth asked if the delay in work at Ely North will stop the implementation of the Wisbech to Cambridge rail line. Rowland Potter explained that a study is current underway to assess the impact of this with the outcome expected in March 2020. He confirmed that this work will have a transformational impact as it will provide a service that does not currently exist, on to a main line rail link and is a fundamental part of the Wisbech 2020 Vision.
Councillor Booth stated that there have been complaints on social media regarding some of the facilities and building maintenance at the Hudson Leisure Centre in Wisbech and asked what is being done to tackle this.
Councillor Booth asked that if these comments could be addressed on social media to improve the public’s negative perception. Matt Hunt agreed to consider this.
Councillor Booth asked if members could be provided with a key list of the contractual requirements and Freedom Leisure’s delivery against these. Phil Hughes confirmed that this data would be available in April 2020.
· On page 5 under item 8 of the agenda pack, Councillor Booth said the minutes should read that he had actually asked how many new businesses had relocated to Fenland as a result of making enquiries.
Councillor Booth seconded the motion and Councillor Mrs Mayor asked for a vote to be taken on the motion.
· Councillor Booth said that his concern is that there is a lot more that needs to be determined with this policy.
Councillor Booth also pointed out areas within the report which he feels need updating, for example p.124, section 3.4 of the agenda pack incorrectly states that the Council’s housing stock was transferred in 2017. He would also ask that the board oversee the arrangements; currently under these proposals it says there will be a minimum of two ... view the full minutes text for item C46/19
· Councillor Booth said the policy aims are good.
· Councillor Booth said he was in no doubt this is a good policy but he just wants to make sure it is not too restrictive and puts people off. He said that the wording seems quite rigid and does not offer the flexibility as suggested by ... view the full minutes text for item C47/19
Councillor Mrs Mayor proposed to adopt the recommendations, seconded by Councillor Booth.
In relation to minute OSC14/19 Point 52; Councillor Booth clarified that the figure of 61% of settlement status applications he stated, had been the figure reported in the media.
Councillor Booth explained that he had had further conversations with Nick Harding in relation to the planning enforcement figures reported to members.
Councillor Booth raised concern that not enough enforcement action is being taken but explained that Nick Harding had assured him that the Council are taking a proactive approach in relation to planning enforcement.
Councillor Booth highlighted that Councillor Mrs Mayor had welcomed Councillor Wilkes during minute number C28/19.
Councillor Booth asked, on behalf of Councillor Sutton, for an update on 11-12 High Street, Wisbech.
Councillor Booth asked Councillor S Clark for an update on the audit of the Freedom Leisure contract.
Councillor S Clark agreed to provide Councillor Booth with this information after the meeting.
Councillor Booth asked Councillor Mrs French how the Council can be assured that they are receiving the best deal in relation to the new street light energy provider (page 59 of the Agenda Pack).
Councillor Mrs French agreed to provide Councillor Booth with this information after the meeting.
Councillor Booth asked Councillor Benney if statistics could be provided in relation to how many new businesses are starting up in Fenland as oppose to just the number of enquiries the Council have dealt with. Whilst he knows the result of enquiries can take a long time to deliver, these figures would be useful.
Councillor Benney agreed to provide Councillor Booth with this information after the meeting.
Councillor Booth explained that at the recent Overview & Scrutiny Panel meeting, members had requested that certain performance metrics were removed from Portfolio Holder Update reports and said he was disappointed that these figures are still being reported.
In relation to Action 1 on the Action Plan; Councillor Booth thanked officers for their response but stated that the figures show that only 5% of breaches are resolved when a formal notice is issued by the Council. He suggested that these figures reflect that the Council could do more in relation to planning enforcement and asked that his comments are passed back to Nick Harding.
Councillor Booth questioned the green RAG rating for performance indicator LP1 ARP1 as whilst monthly the target has been exceeded, cumulatively it is underperforming. Peter Catchpole explained that the RAG rating has a 10% tolerance and therefore is still classified as a green RAG rating. He reiterated that the original target given to the Council was 12 days however the Council asked for this to be reduced to 8 days.
Councillor Booth stated that the target reported to members should include the tolerance level of 10%.
Councillor Booth asked for further assurance that the Council are using the powers available to them.
Kathy Woodward highlighted that amendments had been made to the reporting of recommendations shown in Appendix B of the report (page 15 of the agenda pack), as requested by Councillor Booth at a previous meeting. She informed members that the overdue recommendation (page 15 of the agenda pack) has now been satisfied and is no longer overdue.
Councillor Booth requested the following amendments to the minutes:
· C15/19 (Item 1 on page 17) failed to capture that Councillor Booth said it is our role as a point of collection authority that we had a role to play in trying to influence schools and other organisations.
· C16/9 (Item 9) incorrectly states that Councillor Booth had pursued the review (of the play area) 18 months ago, and should have said that was when he became aware of the issue.
Councillor Mrs French thanked Councillor Yeulett and confirmed she will investigate and report back. · Councillor Booth asked Councillor Clark for an update on the progression of having KPI’s put in place at the Freedom Leisure facilities.
Councillor Clark thanked Councillor Booth for the question, saying she will look into this and get back to him.
· Councillor Booth asked for members to be given more information about the local household waste recycling centres so councillors could promote their use. He had not been aware there were so many local bring sites across the district and promotion may help increase recycling rates.
Councillor Tierney advised that more information could certainly be made available and he recommended Councillor Booth email the Portfolio Holder concerned who would be happy ... view the full minutes text for item C22/19
Councillor Booth commented that it needs to be recognised that it was under the Chairmanship of Councillor Boden that many of these items were first looked at.
Proposed by Councillor Booth and seconded by Councillor Skoulding, and AGREED to adopt the report.
Councillor Booth stated his support for the report, advising the committee will be undertaking a lot more work going forward, given recent briefings on commercial investments, and the transformation programme.
Proposed by Councillor Topgood, seconded by Councillor Booth and AGREED to adopt the report.
· Councillor Booth added that the amended motion was not ... view the full minutes text for item C25/19
Councillor Booth highlighted that the minute OSC2/19 should reflect that he had proposed the signing of the previous minutes and this had been seconded by Councillor Miscandlon.
Councillor Booth highlighted a typographical error in relation to minute OSC5/19 Point 42; the wording should read LGO and not LOG.
Councillor Booth highlighted a typographical error in relation to minute OSC5/19 Point 42; the repetition of the word ‘at’ in the statement.
Councillor Booth asked for a further breakdown in relation to the Planning Enforcement action taken relating to planning breaches reported in the previous Action Plan.
Councillor Booth asked why Councillor Boden and Councillor Mrs French were not in attendance at the meeting.
Councillor Booth highlighted that there are cost implications for both members and officers for deferring this agenda item.
Councillor Booth asked officers what the impact would be in deferring this item to a later meeting date. Mark Saunders explained that this item was considered earlier in the Overview and Scrutiny’s Work Programme last year, but was moved to an earlier meeting date to allow for a longer consultation period. He confirmed that considering the item at the Overview and Scrutiny Panel meeting on 2 September 2019 would still allow officers time to accommodate any consultation period.
Councillor Booth asked if officers could prepare comparative figures reflecting an 8.5% contribution rate. Mark Saunders agreed to include this information in the subsequent report.
Councillor Booth asked if the subsequent report could highlight any savings to the Council based on an ‘average’ Council Tax Support Scheme. Mark Saunders agreed to include this information.
Councillor Booth queried why this agenda item needed to be moved to a later meeting date. Officers confirmed that this was due to there being no NHS representative available to attend the meeting.
Councillor Booth raised concern that there appeared to be a ‘single point of failure’ in relation to having no alternative NHS representative available to attend.
Councillor Booth highlighted that in reference to Minute CGC32/18, all members of the Corporate Governance Committee had given thanks to Councillor Sutton and Councillor Tanfield for their work as members of the Corporate Governance Committee during the previous Municipal Year.
Councillor Booth asked that future reports considered by the Corporate Governance Committee contain further details in relation to those areas wheter the External Auditor has sought assurances.
Councillor Booth asked how the Council’s return on investment compares with others. Mark Saunders confirmed that the external assessors carry out these benchmarking comparisons and they meet with the Council regularly throughout the financial year to provide assurance and offer advice. They have suggested previously that the Council could marginally improve returns by investing in higher risk organisations.
Councillor Booth explained that following his career in Financial Services, Local Authorities tend to make investment decisions based on organisations Credit Ratings. He highlighted that companies domiciled in the UK tend to have lower credit ratings than International companies however it is often the case, that these UK companies can be a safer investment.
Councillor Booth highlighted that the map contained within the report (page 29 of the agenda pack) is not clear.
(Councillor Booth declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a former employee of Yorkshire Building Society and the Council had previously held investments with the Building Society)
Councillor Booth suggested that further assurance on the delivery of change and transformation should be included in the report (page 138 of the agenda pack). He added that the report needs to include the control and assurances the Council have in place over the effective delivery of these projects and partnerships.
Councillor Booth suggested that the report should include separate information relating to recommendations made to Anglia Revenues Partnership (ARP). Kathy Woodward confirmed that ARP’s recommendations are reviewed by their own respective Committee and the ARP Joint Committee therefore they may not need to be considered by the Corporate Governance Committee.
Councillor Booth thanked Kathy Woodward for her response but suggested that ARP’s statistics should be reported to the Corporate Governance Committee to satisfy the Council’s own governance. He asked how the Council get assurance from ARP.
Councillor Booth asked if members could be provided with the general themes of the recommendations. Kathy Woodward said this could not be included in the report as there are a number of recommendations made but agreed to provide members with further information on the themes of these recommendations at subsequent meetings.
Councillor Booth suggested that the response to point 1.13 (page 169 of the agenda pack) should be ‘No’ as members skills and experiences are not individually assessed. He suggested that this should be considered.
Councillor Booth agreed but reiterated that in response to point 1.13 of the report, the answer should be no as this skill assessment has not been carried out.
Councillor Booth suggested that the response to point 4.6 (page 173 of the agenda pack) should be amended to ‘Yes’. He explained that just because our external auditors adopt a substantive audit approach, this does not been that there is not appropriate co-operation between the internal and external ... view the full minutes text for item CGC9/19
Councillor Booth agreed that it would be prudent to include this on the Council’s Risk Register to ensure resilience within the Council.
It proposed by Councillor Booth and seconded by Councillor Cornwell that Councillor Yeulett be nominated as Vice-Chairman of the Overview & Scrutiny Panel for the Municipal Year.
Councillor Booth asked that Minute Number OSC45/18 point 16, be amended to reflect that Clarion had mentioned that they have grant funding for community groups available and are keen to promote this across the district.
Councillor Miscandlon proposed that the ratification of the Previous Minutes be deferred as only Councillor Booth was present at the meeting of 18 March 2019.
Councillor Booth highlighted that there was an outstanding action from the previous Municipal Year regarding Contact Centre Statistics. Izzi Hurst agreed to follow up the response for this action.
Councillor Booth asked if there is staffing capacity within the planning service to cope with the day-to-day workload, aside from the Local Plan Review. He highlighted that previously there had been recruitment issues within the team. Nick Harding highlighted the improvements from the previous year’s statistics and confirmed that the service has less agency staff now following a successful recruitment drive.
Councillor Booth suggested that officers provide tangible statistics in the future to show members the number of Full Time Equivalent (FTE) staff working within the service and where there are vacancies in the team.
Councillor Booth asked for clarification on the validation statistics provided on page 10 of the agenda pack as he has heard varying statistics during recent seminars and meetings.
Councillor Booth explained that this report is considered as a backward look on the progress of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel.
Councillor Booth highlighted a formatting error with the bullet points on page 27 of the agenda pack, point 5.6.
Councillor Booth asked that point 5.25 and 5.26 referencing the Economic Development Review (page 29 of the agenda pack) be merged and incorporated into one point.
Proposed by Councillor Booth, seconded by Councillor Miscandlon and AGREED;
Councillor Booth asked that members invite Councillor Tierney to a future meeting to discuss his portfolio;
Councillor Booth asked if the Clarion review scheduled for the meeting on 20 April 2020 be moved to an earlier meeting date to allow members to assess earlier if there are any ongoing heating issues during the winter months.
Councillor Booth stated that he did not support this amendment to the meeting dates as precedence has been set that Council meetings historically have taken place on a Thursday.
Councillor Booth asked if the dates could be amended to take place on another Thursday in the month to ensure members availability.
Councillor Booth highlighted that part of Councillor Seaton’s Portfolio includes ‘Dilapidated Buildings and Enforcement’.
Councillor Booth asked that officers ensure that the Independent Review Panel will be impartial and truly independent of the Council in all ways.
Councillor Booth supported Councillor Sutton and asked that the Independent Panel consider future review dates during their deliberations.
Councillor Booth seconded the motion and Councillor Mrs Mayor opened the motion up for debate.
Councillor Booth presented his motion regarding the improvements to Play Equipment owned by Fenland District Council;
Councillor Booth asked if future reports could include financial information in relation to appointments.
Councillor Booth gave his apologies for the previous meeting.
Councillor Booth highlighted that Leisure Services falls under the remit of this Corporate Director and asked if resources are in place to monitor the new contract with Freedom Leisure adequately. Kathy Woodward explained that the Freedom Leisure contract is managed by a dedicated Contracts Manager who reports directly to the Head of Leisure Services. She added that the Head of Leisure Services will report into another member of the Corporate Management Team and if she believes there to be any issues with the reallocation of service areas, she will raise this.
Councillor Booth suggested that additional audits are carried out in relation to the Freedom Leisure contract as it is still in its infancy and contracts usually face the most issues within their first year. He asked if an audit could be carried out on a six monthly basis. Kathy Woodward explained that as the contract is new, the amount of days allocated to it is flexible.
Councillor Booth asked if days allocated to the Traveller Sites audit (Appendix A of the Agenda Pack) should be reallocated to the Freedom Leisure Centre contract.
Councillor Booth explained that members direct policy however it is the officers’ responsibility to develop the SLA as per the policy approved by Full Council. He added that if there is an issue with this, the policy may need to be reconsidered by members.
Councillor Booth asked if the Council will get assurance from FACT in relation to the concerns reported in the Press regarding the division in income of their not-for-profit account and commercial account. Kathy Woodward confirmed that the Council have requested this information from FACT and are awaiting their response. She added that the accounts will be for 2019/20 and not the previous years.
Councillor Booth asked if the Council are liaising with Cambridgeshire County Council in relation to their investigation into FACT. Kathy Woodward confirmed that the Council’s Transport Manager is liaising with Cambridgeshire County Council however both Councils have different business models with FACT and therefore separate concerns and recommendations.
Councillor Booth asked if the Council’s SLA ... view the full minutes text for item CGC31/18
Councillor Booth explained that as a member of the Economic Development Review Group and the Overview and Scrutiny Panel, a decision will be made on the service post elections. He explained that the Review Group came to the following conclusion in relation to the trading accounts of the service areas in question;
Councillor Booth agreed and added that the CPCA’s proposal in relation to their Growth Service is still in its infancy at the moment.
Councillor Booth discussed the current Market Town studies and explained that these studies will not consider the viability of markets but rather the viability of Market Towns in general.
Councillor Clark thanked Councillor Booth and Councillor Sutton for raising their concerns in relation to the trading accounts of these service areas which has ultimately led to the Economic Development review being undertaken.
Councillor Booth asked for an explanation why the committee had previously been told there were no complaints when the data showed 78 complaints received to February 2019, with 103 received the previous year.
Councillor Booth commented that he would still expect to see some complaints regarding enforcement as it is a contentious area. He further stated that it would be good governance practice to examine the statistics to see if there are any particular areas of concern.
Councillor Booth recalled that one of Clarion’s policies in a previous development at Parson Drove was ... view the full minutes text for item OSC45/18
No questions had been submitted under Procedure Rule 8.6 and Councillor Booth, as leader of the main opposition group, asked questions under Procedure Rule 8.4 as follows:
· Councillor Booth asked for an update on the 11-12 High Street, Wisbech project.
Once agreements are in place, updates will be provided to members and posted on the High Street website, which contains regular updates whereby members can follow progress on the overall HLF project. · Councillor Booth thanked Councillor Seaton for the information and asked if the Combined Authority (CA) is involved?
Councillor Seaton stated the only involvement it has is in acting as a safeguard in that if, for any reason, the developer should not be able to complete the development, we have a commitment from the CA to fund the remaining part of the development to completion. · Councillor Booth asked for an update on the purchasing of new equipment for council meetings, are we still hiring equipment, such as the audio system, and what expenditure has been incurred to date?
He suggested, for a more detailed explanation, this question should be asked of the Portfolio Holder at portfolio holder questions. · Councillor Booth referred to a recent report on recycling on BBC Look East ... view the full minutes text for item C58/18
· Councillor Booth asked how much the audio equipment has cost to date and, although he appreciates the procurement process has to be followed, why is it taking so long to get the new equipment?
Councillor Buckton advised he will get back to Councillor Booth on costs as he does not have this information to hand. However, the new equipment will be in place for the first meeting of the new Council in May.
· Councillor Booth stated that at Overview & Scrutiny meeting he had raised that the performance indicators were not fit for purpose, the report claims that they have been amended but looking at the tracked changes, the only change is that ‘Freedom’ has been added to the front of leisure centres, everything else is the same. He is disappointed that despite assurances that this would be looked at, no real changes have been made. Some of these performance indicators do not measure what the Council is trying to deliver so how do we know if we are successful or not?
Councillor Booth commented that in light of what has just been agreed, with a surplus of £100k, we need to make sure that we use that to offset any potential increase next year instead of going into reserves.
Proposed by Councillor Booth, seconded by Councillor Sutton and AGREED to pass the resolution set out in the revised report as follows:
· Councillor Booth asked what would happen to the neighbourhood plans. They cannot go against a local plan but if it changes so dramatically, will they have to be started again?
She added that she understood the comments made by Councillor Mrs French and also agreed that Councillor Booth was correct, any drastic difference to the plans would mean they would have to be started again. A neighbourhood plan works in conjunction with the local plan so members must look at what the community wants to put forward, but the local plan takes priority.
However, although there may be a slight variation, community minds would likely have the same objective. · Councillor Booth mentioned that a workshop was held after the PAS report, which is not referenced in the report. One idea was for a working party on the local plan, and he hopes this will be taken forward. Nick Harding, Head of Planning, said as a consequence of reviewing the local plan some elements of the neighbourhood plan are already in place which will fall by the wayside.
· Councillor Booth recalled many years ago that there was going to be an investigation into the returning officer fees as it was felt archaic to pay a fee for what is essentially a service provided by the Council, particularly when councils are having to cut budgets. There could potentially be a saving here and should the Council not write to the local government minister regarding this?
Since then the only increases are the nationally agreed cost of living rises. · Councillor Booth said, in relation to Councillor Sutton’s point, there is a difference between having a policy and a contract of employment. This is just a policy that we follow going forward to set a salary.
The public do have a perception of the payment being too high but, as Councillor Booth said, this is a policy not a wage negotiation.
· Councillor Booth asked Councillor Oliver for an update with regard to the use of mobile CCTV in rural areas, which is a subject which has been raised before, but due to the associated costs for installation it was deemed as not being cost effective. He asked that now there is mobile WIFI could this subject be explored further.?
· Councillor Booth has a concern over a comment in the report which mentions that the equipment would be replaced when it came to the end of its serviceable life and, in his opinion, the replacement equipment should not be sourced just on the manufacturers’ advice as it may still be perfectly usable.
· Councillor Booth asked for clarification with regard to staffing and asked whether the staff based at both authorities will all take part in a consultation exercise to apply for the available positions.
Councillor Booth said that in relation to his statement regarding the pension fund, he was stating a point rather than asking a question.
Councillor Booth asked for further information regarding the lower than anticipated Planning Fees (page 22 of the Agenda Pack). Kamal Mehta explained that the original budget took in to account the increase in fees and also anticipated applications being submitted to the Council. Unfortunately these anticipated applications would have generated large sums for the Council however have not materialised causing a shortfall in the Planning Fees.
Councillor Booth highlighted that other Local Authorities are still currently consulting on this.
Councillor Booth asked if members could be made aware of updated budget information.
Councillor Booth suggested that as Ports run at a deficit, they should be subject to a higher increase in their fees and charges as they do not bring in a high level of income.
Councillor Booth asked why Wisbech Yacht Harbour was not subject to an increase in their fees and charges.
Councillor Booth asked if the Council had undertaken benchmarking research in relation to burial ground fees (page ... view the full minutes text for item OSC34/18
Councillor Booth highlighted that on page 71 of the Agenda Pack, there is a bullet point missing under the Economy section.
Councillor Booth said whilst there is emphasis on vulnerable members of the community, the general supporting of communities as a whole should be included. He said the report does not focus on the quality of life within Fenland and asked that emphasis be put on this. He highlighted that to attract people to Fenland there must be a viable economy and social community.
Councillor Booth said the Performance Indicators contained within the report do not match up to the specific areas and may not be relevant in measuring these areas.
Councillor Booth asked that it be noted that in relation to his declaration of interest (minute C42/18) he took no part in the discussions or voting for this item.
No questions had been submitted under Procedure Rule 8.6 and Councillor Booth, as leader of the main opposition group, asked questions under Procedure Rule 8.4 as follows;
· Councillor Booth asked for an update on Cambridgeshire & Peterborough Combined Authority’s (CPCA) skills and apprenticeship budget.
· Councillor Booth asked Councillor Oliver for the default rate of enforcement action taken as part of the Wisbech Alcohol Project and how successful the Project has been in stopping street drinkers.
· Councillor Booth agreed that it is necessary for the Overview and Scrutiny Committee to consider this earlier to allow time for any amendments or comments made to be considered.
Proposed by Councillor Seaton, seconded by Councillor Booth and AGREED to approve the Council Tax Reduction Scheme effective from 1 April 2019 as set out in Section 2 and at Appendix A to the report contained within the Agenda Pack.
· Councillor Booth highlighted that the Overview & Scrutiny Committee are considering the Fees and Charges for 2019/20 at their meeting on 14 January 2019 and asked why approval is required before this meeting.
Proposed by Councillor Booth, seconded by Councillor Oliver and AGREED;
· Councillor Booth said in reference to minute OSC22/18, he had stated that unless comparisons are made with like-for-like local authorities, the statistics will not be useful to the Council.
Councillor Booth highlighted that the figure of 14% is used in the Council’s Mid Term Financial Strategy so any future changes will need to be reflected in this.
Councillor Booth explained that as a member of Corporate Governance Committee he had been present at the recent meeting. He explained that members had had to make difficult decisions during CSR about certain services and the committee felt that effectively, these highlighted areas are loss-making and the true cost of these are not being reflected when the Council set their Fees and Charges. He highlighted that whilst the Council is not a business, it must operate in a business-like way to ensure the tax payer is getting the best value for money.
Councillor Booth said the Council must consider how accounts are produced and how we run these functions commercially.
Councillor Booth asked that members are provided with a breakdown of the achieved targeted savings of CSR1.
Councillor Booth said paragraph 4.1 of the report (page 34 of the Agenda Pack) states that ‘the Council have maintained front line services through alternative service delivery models’. He highlighted that many service areas have been cut back and asked the wording to be amended.
Councillor Booth said in relation to minute CGC13/18, the intention was that officers would report their findings on FACT back to the Corporate Governance Committee and not just the Chairman.
Councillor Booth highlighted that the valuation of the Leisure Centres should remain fairly static as the Council are still retaining ownership of them. He added that Freedom Leisure are intending to improve and invest in the Leisure Centres which may make a nominal difference to the valuation. Mark Hodgson agreed that this is EY’s working assumption and the effect of this will depend on Freedom Leisure’s capital input into the centres as to whether this will affect the value of the physical assets.
Councillor Booth highlighted that this will depend on the agreement the Council have with Freedom Leisure in relation to the ownership of any new assets.
Councillor Booth added that as they were under the threshold for reporting it was not necessary to include them in the report.
Councillor Booth asked if the audit fees charged by EY will change in light of the recent staffing changes. Mark Hodgson confirmed that the fees are set by the regulator and any staffing changes within EY will not ... view the full minutes text for item CGC18/18
(Councillor Booth declared an interest as the Council hold investments with building societies and he is an employee of the Yorkshire Building Society.
Councillor Booth left the room for the duration of this Item)
Councillor Booth asked for further information on the ‘Street Scene – Enforcement’ audit and the ‘Corporate Assurance – Transparency’ audit referenced in Appendix A on page 55 of the Agenda Pack. Kathy Woodward confirmed that the medium enforcement recommendation relates to the monitoring and flow of information the Council has with their Contractor. Work is ongoing in ensuring procedures are in place for this.
Councillor Booth asked if the outdated information found on the website was information that the Council has a statutory duty to publish. Kathy Woodward confirmed that it related to statistics the Council must publish and these have now been reviewed and updated.
Councillor Booth asked if Kathy Woodward was confident that a governance process was in place to ensure the website is updated regularly and to avoid this issue happening again. Kathy Woodward said that one of the recommendations made was to ensure ownership is taken of this task and confirmed that this is now in place.
In relation to the Conduct Hearing on 31 October 2018, Councillor Booth asked for confirmation that the internal audit team had no concerns or recommendations in relation to Members Expenses and asked how members can be assured that this issue will not happen again. Kathy Woodward said that in light of the Conduct Hearing and the press surrounding this, she had extended the sampling size when she audited this area and confirmed that sufficient processes are in place to prevent this issue reoccurring in the future. She added that the test samples had satisfied her criteria and is confident that the procedures in place are being strictly adhered to by officers processing claims.
Councillor Booth asked if Kathy Woodward believed that the complaint dealt with at the Conduct Hearing on 31 October 2018 was an isolated incident. Kathy Woodward confirmed that she did.
Councillor Booth said whilst he was pleased with the format of the report, there still appears to be confusion surrounding the difference between actions and mitigation. Anna Goodall noted this.
Councillor Booth asked what the abbreviation MTSP meant as shown on page 81 of the Agenda Pack. Anna Goodall explained that this referred to Management, Trade Union & Staff Partnership which has replaced Staff Side within the Council.
Councillor Booth confirmed that the lower risks within the Council, do not feed in to this report.
Councillor Booth asked why the Fire Service was the lead authority for the area’s Brexit focus group. Kamal Mehta confirmed that this had been initiated by Central Government to ensure that suitable arrangements are in place within the Emergency Services if a ‘no deal’ Brexit causes civil unrest within the UK. 7.
Councillor Booth asked if there have been any changes in Local Government Legislation or advice released on the impact of Brexit. Kamal Mehta confirmed ... view the full minutes text for item CGC21/18
Councillor Booth stated that there are other car-share schemes and providers available locally. Kathy Woodward clarified that car-share schemes are classed as social travel which is different to the Dial-A-Ride scheme therefore FACT are the only provider of this in the district.
Councillor Booth asked if the Council are paying for legal advice in relation to this matter. Kathy Woodward confirmed that they are not.
Councillor Booth stated that a review of this should not take place as part of the next Comprehensive Spending Review (CSR) as this may not take place soon enough. He asked if the review could take place after the Service Level Agreement (SLA) review next year.
Councillor Clark agreed with Councillor Booth.
Councillor Booth asked if the Council’s Internal Audit team could verify the accuracy of the journeys FACT claim for, with the individual users of the service. Kathy Woodward explained that contacting the individual users would be outside of the Internal Audit Team’s normal remit.
Councillor Booth said the journeys must be recorded as users are required to call and book them with FACT and FACT claim the money back via the Council.
Councillor Booth said members require an added level of assurance that the journeys being claimed for by FACT are genuine. Kathy Woodward explained that she had considered attempting to validate these figures by observing actual journeys taking place on buses however this would take up the Council’s ... view the full minutes text for item CGC22/18
No questions had been submitted under Procedure Rule 8.6 and Councillor Booth, as leader of the main opposition group, asked questions under Procedure Rule 8.4, as follows:
The Leader replied that the Combined Authority has been asked to provide the information requested, unfortunately that has not yet been received and asked if it would be acceptable to send Councillor Booth a written answer as soon as possible.
Councillor Booth stated that would be acceptable and he felt other members would also be interested in this. The Leader advised he will make sure members are informed. · could the Leader confirm if the Combined Authority is investing in affordable housing projects in Fenland and if so when will this take place? The Leader responded as follows:
As well as this there is a further 3 sites controlled by Registered Providers which will deliver a further 189 affordable homes with completion dates to be determined.” Councillor Booth thanked the Leader for the update. · can the Leader give an update on the review of local government structure in Cambridgeshire being undertaken by the Combined Authority?
The Leader thanked Councillor Booth for the question and confirmed he would provide a hard copy of the answer. The Combined Authority continue to work with their appointed consultants, ResPublica, to develop public service reform proposals, which at this time are specifically focussed upon future sustainability and social care and health. The details of these proposals have yet to be established and will be shared with the leaders and their constituent councils once they become available.
· Councillor Booth asked Councillor Mrs Laws if she could confirm the actions planned to improve the planning processes involving Parish and Town Councils following the PAS review, and when will these actions be delivered?
Councillor Booth added that the parish councils are aware of the reports available to them but they are frustrated not to hear directly from planning officers. An automated message stating reports are available is not in the spirit of better engagement envisaged, resulting in parish councillors feeling ignored and that their local knowledge is not being utilised.
(Councillor Booth declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item by virtue of the fact that he works for the Yorkshire Building Society)
· Councillor Skoulding felt that microphones could be shared and an integrated voting system too expensive when people can simply put their hand up. · Councillor Boden stated functioning microphones are important in order to do the work of this Council and it is commendable to propose a system that can be added to with additional functionality if required in the future, but he shared Councillor Skoulding’s concern regarding the cost of the voting system and felt it was not value for money for such a small council. · Councillor Tierney agreed with this view, although he felt that we have to be forward thinking regarding webcasting. · Councillor Booth agreed with all the comments, but felt the webcasting costs are too expensive and need to be looked at again. · Councillor Pugh felt the projector/screen costs were too expensive and needed to be reconsidered. · Councillor Sutton stated there is no doubt a new system is needed, but questioned the number of microphones required and felt that these could be shared. · Councillor Booth suggested an amendment, and that members look at Option 2.
Councillor Booth proposed to amend the recommendation to Option 2, and investigate Option 4, this was seconded by Councillor Yeulett.
Councillor Booth agreed that would be the case.
Showing the latest 300 of 369.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Booth attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Booth's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Booth was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 7 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Booth declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Aug 2020 | Council, item C15/20 | (Councillor Booth declared an interest in that he helped develop the therefore will not vote on the matter but reserves the right to speak if anyone has any questions). | |
| 18 Jun 2019 | Corporate Governance Committee, item CGC6/19 | (Councillor Booth declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a former employee of Yorkshire Building Society and the Council had previously held investments with the Building Society) | |
| 20 Nov 2018 | Corporate Governance Committee, item CGC19/18 | (Councillor Booth declared an interest as the Council hold investments with building societies and he is an employee of the Yorkshire Building Society. | |
| 15 Nov 2018 | Council, item C42/18 | (Councillor Booth declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item by virtue of the fact that he works for the Yorkshire Building Society) |
Where Councillor Booth sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 6 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 6 | 14 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Risk Management Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 3 | 30 Nov 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.