Review of Fixed Term Contracts - Confidential Report
Proposed by Councillor Nawaz, seconded by Councillor Mrs Davis and AGREED the report recommendations.
Every time Fenland's minutes name Councillor Nawaz, as the council published it.
Proposed by Councillor Nawaz, seconded by Councillor Mrs Davis and AGREED the report recommendations.
· Councillor Nawaz stated that Deborah Moss had used the term ‘resource dependent’ during her presentation and he asked her to expand on that point. Deborah Moss explained that there were no time targets associated to any of the actions, and she added that some had been LGR specific and there had been other tasks which were seen to be more of a priority to work on. She made the point that a lot of the actions are her responsibility and that is dependent on fitting it in amongst her day job essentially.
· Councillor Nawaz asked whether Unison is the only union that officers are part of at Fenland? Carol Pilson explained that Unison is the largest union that the Council has, but there are individuals that are members of other unions as well.
Councillor Nawaz asked whether that poses an extra risk or less risk? Stephen Beacher explained that he is not aware of any other ballot for any industrial action.
· Councillor Nawaz asked whether the figures of Union membership could be provided to the committee? Stephen Beacher stated that he would ascertain the number of officers who belong to a union.
· Councillor Nawaz stated that he is delighted to see the way that the risk score has been configured.
· Councillor Nawaz referred to the point which refers to disabled facilities grants and overtime final report, port management and temporary accommodation and he asked for the associated timescales.
· Councillor Nawaz stated that he agrees that there is an intrinsic value in having an individual with an external opinion who may probably have a broader and more impartial view who could add value to the proceedings of the committee. He added that the process would be the Chairman of the Committee in conjunction with the Section 151 Officer or the Monitoring Officer along with the Head of Internal Audit to approve the job description and undertake the recruitment and selection process.
· Councillor Nawaz added that he agrees that any significant amounts need to go out to competitive tender and sometimes there is an element of inertia which gets in the way, and, in his view, it is probably the worse reason for going down this route. He explained that he has scrutinised all the points in the report, and has concluded that the circumstances and the relatively small amounts mean he is happy with the exemption.
Councillor Nawaz asked members if they had anything to discuss regarding the workplan.
It was proposed by Councillor Christy, seconded by Councillor Foice-Beard and agreed that Councillor Nawaz be appointed as Chairman of the Audit and Risk Management Committee for the municipal year 2026/27.
It was proposed by Councillor Nawaz, seconded by Councillor Mrs French and agreed that Councillor Foice-Beard be appointed as Vice Chairman of the Audit and Risk Management Committee for the municipal year 2026/27.
· Councillor Nawaz stated that he believes that the population figures of Fenland used in the report have been taken from the 2021 census, however, that the figure will have increased considerably. He added that in Whittlesey alone there has been a thousand new houses built so, in his opinion, the figure would have increased.
· Councillor Nawaz stated that there is a typographical error within the report where it refers to the figures concerning the Council’s budget. Sian Warren confirmed that the External Auditors have also identified the typographical error which has now been amended accordingly in the accounts that will go forward in November.
· Councillor Nawaz referred to the report where it refers to the Whittlesey Station development which he is pleased to see but he questioned why the southern relief road for Whittlesey does not receive a mention especially as work has already commenced. He added that he is aware that some expenditure has already been incurred, and asked whether that expenditure has been through the District or the Town Council? Sian Warren explained that there was some work undertaken on the relief road, but it was captured in the previous year.
· Councillor Nawaz referred to the report from the Head of Internal Audit which upon reading he found it to be encouraging but questioned how independent the independent auditor is. Deborah Moss stated that she has provided that audit opinion as she holds the position of Head of Internal Audit and within the annual report agenda item there is the requirement for her to explain her organizational independence. She added that she does not have any organizational responsibility or any line management as she is required to be independent.
· Councillor Nawaz referred to the external auditors who have issued a disclaimed audit report on the Council's financial statements for 24/25 and whilst he is not familiar with the information provided, he is somewhat concerned about the disclaimed audit. He added that the report makes reference to the requirement to conclude work by the 25/26 back stop date which is the deadline and it also states that due to the lack of evidence over the movements and balances means that they are unable to conclude that 2023/2024 financial statements are free from material and pervasive misstatement of the financial statements.
Councillor Nawaz added that it states that they have explained that they anticipate issuing a disclaimed 25/26 audit opinion as well and he asked officers to explain this further. Peter Catchpole stated that there is a whole audit ... view the full minutes text for item ARMC44/26
· Councillor Nawaz asked for clarification as to whether there are any management consequences because of no compliance? Sam King explained that completion rates are monitored and discussed at Corporate Management Team meetings. She added that a performance dashboard has just been competed so that any compliance issues can be followed up.
Councillor Nawaz reiterated what the consequences are for non-compliance? Sam King stated that there is an element of encouragement to managers to ensure that they schedule time for staff to compete the training and where they do not then managers can be taken down a formal route should that become necessary.
· Councillor Nawaz stated that he was both shocked and surprised after reading the report with regards to the intrusiveness the legislation comes with, which has led him to be concerned about civil liberty issues. He added that all personal intimate details can be accessed by the Council which he likened to being spied on by private personal detectives.
Councillor Nawaz added that he is delighted that the use of the investigatory powers is very rarely used and if there was the requirement to use the act, then that would come with the approval of a Magistrate with adequate democratic oversight.
· Councillor Nawaz stated that he notes the report reflects that there are no serious concerns, and he asked for clarification whether there are areas which are giving cause for concern and if so, are the relevant officers aware of that fact?
· Councillor Nawaz expressed the view that he believes that that is the way to operate to improve things and not to be adversarial but rather to interrogate and challenge the status quo continually to get the best out of each other.
· Councillor Nawaz referred to 4.3 of the report where it makes reference to the fact that there is a vacancy for 0.4 FTE, and he asked whether the vacancy has been filled? Deborah Moss explained that a member of staff transferred internally from the Transformation Team and that member of staff did not want a full-time post which in turn left the shortfall of 0.4. She added that it is unlikely that the 0.4 vacancy will be filled, but now the team are managing to produce enough audits in order to form an audit opinion.
· Councillor Nawaz asked whether Deborah Moss is managing to keep up the momentum? Deborah Moss explained that this is not her role as her responsibility is the monitoring and she has a spreadsheet and tracker and everyone has access to that so that they can see their own actions. She stated that is the tool that is used for teams to be able to add their own status updates, with her role being to pull reports from the tracker in order to be able to report to the committee.
· Councillor Nawaz expressed the view that it is a very good idea, and the report provides detail of the seven exemptions which are mainly of smaller amounts. He added that the seven of them equate to £456,518 and he referred to 1.1.2 of ... view the full minutes text for item ARMC50/26
He added that he along with Councillor Nawaz have received training from the Combined Authority as they are members of the CPCA Audit Committee.
· Councillor Nawaz referred to 2.1 concerning the responsibilities of the committee and from reading the report it appears to be the most important committee albeit not the easiest of committees. He expressed the opinion that he really feels that further training is required and feels that Audit and Risk and Overview and Scrutiny Committees are kind of two sides of the coin in many ways with some overlaps.
Councillor Nawaz asked members if they had anything to discuss regarding the workplan.
· Councillor Nawaz asked whether data protection is something else that the committee could receive training on? Peter Catchpole explained that members will be able to complete a training session via the online training portal.
· Councillor Nawaz said communities are best placed to make decisions tailored to their needs in health, education and social services because they know what they need. The Government’s version of devolution is entirely misplaced and will make representation quite remote compared to now and the communication and relationships between residents and their elected representatives will be more difficult. This is a missed golden opportunity to level up Fenland which is currently the 80 th most deprived of the 317 local authority districts in England.
It was proposed by Councillor Nawaz, seconded by Councillor Imafidon and resolved that Councillor Gary Christy be elected as the Chairman of the Employment Committee for the Municipal Year 2026/27.
It was proposed by Councillor Christy, seconded by Councillor Imafidon and resolved that Councillor Nawaz be elected as the Vice-Chairman of the Employment Committee for the Municipal Year.
Sam King responded that first aiders are volunteers and it just happens that more staff working at Fenland Hall have volunteered, however most accidents involving staff working from the Base occur off-site. · Councillor Nawaz said he found the report interesting but having noted 63 e-learning courses on offer, queried how many of them are relevant or necessary. He asked if any comparative correlation had been made between stress, poor mental health and hybrid working, or whether there was any difference between those who worked in the office and those who worked from home. Sam King responded the Council robustly follows all health and safety legislation; the courses are not onerous with the shortest being about 15 minutes long.
· Councillor Nawaz asked how learning is enforced and what action is taken against staff who do not undertake mandatory training. Sam King replied that completion rates are tracked monthly and CMT informed of those who do not do the training.
Staff are always encouraged to do their training and given free time to do it but there are no sanctions. · Councillor Nawaz referred to the number of slips/trips/falls and although he agreed that the increase is due in part to enhanced reporting, he could not accept the increase is entirely due to that. Aarron Locks advised that Environmental Services, where most accidents occur, is a high-risk area. A lot of work has been done with that team to encourage reporting and despite the increase in figures, it should be noted there has been a drastic reduction in working days lost.
Councillor Nawaz expressed his thanks for the responses to his questions and concluded that he felt encouraged by ... view the full minutes text for item EC4/26
Proposed by Councillor Nawaz, seconded by Councillor Benney and AGREED to approve the revised Health and Safety Policy and Statement.
· Councillor Nawaz asked how installing telematic technology will ensure HMRC compliance for fleet usage. Sam King advised that because HMRC govern the taxing of benefits in kind, individuals using a company vehicle for personal use would be in breach of HMRC guidelines and may attract a higher tax rate.
· Councillor Imafidon asked if mandatory drug testing could be included in the policy and Councillor Nawaz said that was a good point as the police are increasingly finding more drivers under the influence of drugs than alcohol. Sam King said she would need to report that request to the Union group.
Proposed by Councillor Imafidon, seconded by Councillor Nawaz and AGREED to ... view the full minutes text for item EC6/26
· Councillor Nawaz asked if the Council had been consulted on the new legislation before it was enacted. Sam King advised that the Government started consultation 18/24 months ago and HR professionals were asked to collate a regional response. She added that it is worth noting that the content of the Employment Rights Act has changed substantially and the intricacies of the act delivered thus far have changed significantly to the first consultation but because the Council operates very well with its trade union, they are not that much of a concern.
Proposed by Councillor Imafidon, seconded by Councillor Nawaz and AGREED the report recommendations.
Proposed by Councillor Nawaz, seconded by Councillor Benney and AGREED the report recommendations.
· Councillor Nawaz stated that given the situation and LGR recruiting a new manager is going to be unwise and he feels this is a sensible arrangement as this Council may end up with Huntingdonshire after LGR.
Proposed by Councillor Tierney, seconded by Councillor Nawaz and AGREED to enter into a Section 113 agreement with Huntingdonshire District Council for the provision of suitably qualified Transport Manager to be named on the Council’s Operators License with the Traffic Commissioner and delegate to the Monitoring Officer to finalise and enter into any legal agreement in consultation with the Portfolio Holder.
Councillor Nawaz asked about the reference to fraud and corruption on the last slide as whilst he understood fraud in the common sense of the word, he was struggling with corruption, because that would not necessarily involve two different parties. He asked Katey Mills to elaborate on corruption, including who was involved and what figures existed for that? Katey Mills responded that the fraud team does not investigate corruption, with the Fighting Fraud and Corruption Locally Strategy being a strategy set by Central Government and is named through that.
Councillor Nawaz asked whether there had been any collusion from within staff and whether she could provide any information? Katey Mills responded that, in the 23 years she had worked as part of the team, no corruption or collusion involving members of staff had been identified in respect of frauds committed against any of the local authorities.
They have set up a new committee which will meet next month to look at sources of pollution particularly, but not exclusively, from Saxon Pit, with representation from himself, Councillor Nawaz and Councillor Branton. Furthermore, the Environment Agency have agreed to move a top-notch monitoring station to the near edge of Saxon Pit to record in more detail what is coming from there. When they produce their report in the summer, he will be keen to see that due attention is paid to what they uncover before firm decisions are made as to how matters proceed, particularly in respect of particulates.
· Councillor Nawaz referred to the state of some of the road connections in Whittlesey and he highlighted that the bridge has been operating a one lane system for well over a year and that was supposed to be the towns main arterial connection between the east and the west of Whittlesey. He explained that to the west is the transport hub of Peterborough, with journeys resulting in huge delays which he has also encountered and has had to allow extra time to make various trips to Peterborough.
Councillor Nawaz expressed the view that the roads are riddled with potholes and likened some to the size of craters, resulting in many people suffering damage to their cars in various forms and costing residents hundreds of pounds.
Councillor Nawaz thanked Councillor Mrs Laws for bringing forward such an important subject and he will wholeheartedly support the motion.
· Councillor Nawaz expressed the view that he finds it unbelievable that one of the very few councils in the country can maintain its Council Tax despite the previous high inflation in the previous 3 or 4 years. He stated that he cannot think of any other political party who has managed to sustain the same amount of Council Tax for nine years running and he will fully support the proposal.
· Councillor Nawaz expressed the view that society and the community as a whole may function better and more efficiently if there was not the perpetual interference from Central Government. He stated that he would like to praise the officers for the excellent work that they undertake as, in his opinion, they deserve their pay award and he urged everyone to support the resolution.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Nawaz attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Nawaz's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Nawaz was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 10 of 12 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Nawaz declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Nawaz in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Nawaz sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 6 | 14 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Risk Management Committee | Chairman | Feb 2026 | 4 | 30 Nov 2026 |
| Employment Committee | Vice-Chairman | Jun 2026 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.