CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Fenland/Councillor Samantha Hoy
SH

Councillor Samantha Hoy

Fenland CouncilWisbech South wardConservativeCouncillor since 2013
Portfolio Holder for Culture, Housing, Licensing & Wisbech Town Board
Follow Councillor Hoy's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
78%meetings attended14 of 18 since 2013, apologies 1
104times in the minutesAsked 10, said 56, moved 2, seconded 5
0recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
0declarations at meetingsInterests declared on agenda items
2committees in the last year2 committees in all

On the record

Every time Fenland's minutes name Councillor Hoy, as the council published it.

Said19 Oct 2026Cabinet

National Planning Scheme of Delegation

·          Councillor Hoy said her concern is that when something falls to one person, it puts them in a difficult position. What one person puts weight on another might not, that is the benefit of a committee and decision making is better when not reliant on one person’s view.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 19 Oct 2026, item CAB24/26Open the meeting
Named14 Sep 2026Cabinet

Culture Fund Phase 3 - Recommendation from Culture Committee

Members considered a recommendation from the Culture, Arts and Heritage Executive Advisory Committee to create a Culture Fund Phase 3 to provide small grants funding to individuals, groups or organisation to deliver arts, heritage and culture events and activities across Fenland, presented by Councillor Hoy.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 14 Sep 2026, item CAB17/26Open the meeting
Named14 Sep 2026Cabinet

Culture Fund Phase 3 - Recommendation from Culture Committee

·          Councillor Mrs Laws stated that she welcomes this, there was one activity in Whittlesey yesterday and as Councillor Hoy indicated the applications submitted to the Arts Council are onerous, making it difficult for small charities to obtain grants.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 14 Sep 2026, item CAB17/26Open the meeting
Named14 Sep 2026Cabinet

Culture Fund Phase 3 - Recommendation from Culture Committee

·          Councillor Hoy made the point that in the recommendation it should be made clear that the £4,000 for each market town is to come out of the £40,000 total pot and that the increased funding for the festivals is to be used for cultural activities and not for staffing or infrastructure, which should already be budgeted for.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 14 Sep 2026, item CAB17/26Open the meeting
Moved14 Sep 2026Cabinet

Culture Fund Phase 3 - Recommendation from Culture Committee

Proposed by Councillor Hoy, seconded by Councillor Tierney and AGREED that:
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 14 Sep 2026, item CAB17/26Open the meeting
Said13 Jul 2026Cabinet

Wisbech High Street Update

·          Councillor Hoy said members were told that CPCA funding would be a quick process with no delay. To now be told that the scheme has been pushed back another quarter with the business case not yet having been sent to the CPCA is totally unacceptable in her opinion.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Jul 2026, item CAB12/26Open the meeting
Said13 Jul 2026Cabinet

Wisbech High Street Update

That request was put out to Avison Young because officers did not have sufficient experience to put forward a business case which could also be used for the lottery fund.    ·          Councillor Hoy noted from the planning portal that the application was received on 10 th April and validated on 13 th May. She accepts there is a process but noted that more controversial applications have been validated, decided and a decision notice issued in six weeks.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Jul 2026, item CAB12/26Open the meeting
Said15 Jun 2026Cabinet

Amendment to the Council's Housing Enforcement Policy

·          Councillor Hoy said it would have been useful to view track changes within the report to see what has been updated and expressed her concern about renters reforms. Appreciating this is national policy that discourages direct discrimination, it is her view that indirect discrimination happens all the time, for example refusal to accept tenants on benefits or those with either children or pets etc. She said the point of legislation was to stop unscrupulous landlords but there are always those who will find ways to subvert the rules and this makes it harder for decent landlords who are, after all, providing a service.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 15 Jun 2026, item CAB5/26Open the meeting
Said15 Jun 2026Cabinet

Amendment to the Council's Housing Enforcement Policy

·          Councillor Hoy said there never seems to be any punishment for bad tenants and sometimes the only recourse for landlords is the civil route.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 15 Jun 2026, item CAB5/26Open the meeting
Said15 Jun 2026Cabinet

Draft 6 Month Cabinet Forward Plan

·          Councillor Hoy said she was happy to wait for that but asked that consideration be given more swiftly to an agenda item about Wisbech Port. Some of it may be confidential but other parts such as assurance that the port will remain open will be useful given recent media comments.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 15 Jun 2026, item CAB6/26Open the meeting
Said15 Jun 2026Cabinet

Draft 6 Month Cabinet Forward Plan

·          Councillor Hoy pointed out that there was supposed to be a standing item on Wisbech High Street and asked for it to be discussed at the next meeting.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 15 Jun 2026, item CAB6/26Open the meeting
Named18 May 2026Council

Motion by Councillor Taylor

·        Councillor Hoy referred to the comments from Councillor Christy and about trusting the science but people are told that as a way to shut down anyone asking any questions, although she is not suggesting that is what Councillor Christy was doing, but she has heard it so many times over the years that anytime you ask any questions that you are a denier or a conspiracy theorist. She continued that 99% of the scientists thought  ...  view the full minutes text for item C8/26
From the council's minutes: Council, 18 May 2026, item C8/26Open the meeting
Named18 May 2026Council

Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Combined Authority (CPCA) Appointments

·        appoint the Leader of Council to act as the Council's appointee to the Combined Authority, with Councillor Hoy to act as his substitute;
From the council's minutes: Council, 18 May 2026, item C10/26Open the meeting
Said27 Apr 2026Cabinet

Wisbech High Street Update

·          Councillor Hoy said if 30 years was ambitious, then she was not sure FDC was ambitious enough. However, she was pleased to hear it was nearing completion and it was clear that the Council was fully committed to the project.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 27 Apr 2026, item CAB72/25Open the meeting
Said27 Apr 2026Cabinet

Change in Freedom Leisure contractual arrangements to an Agency approach (with CONFIDENTIAL appendices)

·          Councillor Hoy said as the contract signed with Freedom Leisure ends on a given date she wondered if the agency agreement would change this.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 27 Apr 2026, item CAB74/25Open the meeting
Said23 Mar 2026Cabinet

Air Quality Review and Assessment Statutory Reporting

·          Councillor Hoy said the need for additional monitors was mentioned at the County Council’s planning meeting about Saxon Pit. There was also some discussion about costs, presumably to Fenland, so it would be useful to know how monitoring was funded and how additional monitors could be obtained. Also, although she understands why air quality areas are revoked if they do not meet specific criteria, when it was done in Wisbech the process was not communicated in the best way.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Mar 2026, item CAB64/25Open the meeting
Seconded23 Mar 2026Cabinet

Air Quality Review and Assessment Statutory Reporting

Proposed by Councillor Imafidon, seconded by Councillor Hoy and AGREED to note the report, monitoring locations, plans and proposed actions to ensure the Council’s  ...  view the full minutes text for item CAB64/25
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Mar 2026, item CAB64/25Open the meeting
Said23 Mar 2026Cabinet

Fenland Inspire! Play Areas

·          Councillor Hoy said as this reduced the villages spend, she wondered whether Tydd St Giles should receive an extra piece of equipment instead.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Mar 2026, item CAB65/25Open the meeting
Said13 Mar 2026Cabinet

Local Government Reorganisation - Response to Statutory Consultation

·          Councillor Hoy said FDC should not be spending any money or wasting time on this process; there is so much work that the authority could be getting on with, and she is extremely frustrated by this. She thought FDC should not rule out potentially taking legal action in the future because this is not a good process in any way, shape or form for Fenland. LGR is regrettable and although it will be a good outcome if Government changes its mind, a great deal of time and money will already have been wasted which this council cannot afford.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Mar 2026, item CAB61/25Open the meeting
Named13 Mar 2026Cabinet

Local Government Reorganisation - Response to Statutory Consultation

·          Councillor Boden said Councillor Hoy is correct; the time and attention afforded LGR means less attention to other matters as officers’ time will be taken up increasingly by the process of transition to the new unitary authority. A host of things will not be  ...  view the full minutes text for item CAB61/25
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Mar 2026, item CAB61/25Open the meeting
Asked23 Feb 2026Cabinet

RECAP Waste Strategy

Councillor Hoy asked if she had correctly read in the report that energy from waste has been excluded from the RECAP waste strategy.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB54/25Open the meeting
Asked23 Feb 2026Cabinet

RECAP Waste Strategy

Councillor Hoy asked if the new food waste collection service could potentially impact council finances received from the brown bin service, if people use the new service, they may not want to purchase a brown bin.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB54/25Open the meeting
Seconded23 Feb 2026Cabinet

RECAP Waste Strategy

Proposed by Councillor Tierney, seconded by Councillor Hoy and AGREED to recommend to Council:
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB54/25Open the meeting
Said23 Feb 2026Cabinet

New and Updated Interim Planning Guidance

Councillor Hoy commented that the HMO guidance is a good addition and notes that the cumulative impact of other HMOs in the vicinity can be considered. However, she wondered how cumulative impact can be determined if an HMO’s existence is unknown, as a property containing less than five people would not need a licence and if they are not in an Article 4 area, planning permission will not be required.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB55/25Open the meeting
Said23 Feb 2026Cabinet

New and Updated Interim Planning Guidance

Councillor Hoy said she also liked the addition of the information about parking provision because it comes up time and again and the guidance is very useful.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB55/25Open the meeting
Named23 Feb 2026Cabinet

New and Updated Interim Planning Guidance

Councillor Mrs Laws said she would come back to Councillor Hoy on this.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB55/25Open the meeting
Seconded23 Feb 2026Cabinet

New and Updated Interim Planning Guidance

Proposed by Councillor Mrs Laws, seconded by Councillor Hoy and AGREED to:
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB55/25Open the meeting
Said23 Feb 2026Cabinet

Fenland Transport Economic Assessment including March to Wisbech Rail Funding from CPCA

Councillor Hoy agreed all Fenland needs transport improvements, but she would like to focus on the Wisbech Access Strategy. She finds it frustrating that £10.5m has been spent and yet not a single piece of road has been laid. All that was achieved was an old shop being knocked down that nobody wanted to be knocked down.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB56/25Open the meeting
Said23 Feb 2026Cabinet

Fenland Inspire! - Play Equipment

Councillor Hoy said she is pleased to see Westmead Avenue included separately and wants it on record that Fenland should not be waiting for pots of money in order to undertake basic maintenance work. The council is obligated to maintain services in order not to allow things to go to rack and ruin and there must be a budget for maintenance.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Feb 2026, item CAB57/25Open the meeting
Seconded23 Feb 2026Council

Corporate Budget 2026/27

Proposed by Councillor Boden, seconded by Councillor Hoy and AGREED that (i)          the revised estimates for 2025/26 as set out in Section 6 and Appendix A showing an estimated surplus of £107k which will be transferred to the Budget Equalisation Reserve be approved;
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 Feb 2026, item C55/25Open the meeting
Named23 Feb 2026Council

Licensing Service - S113 Agreement

Members considered entering into a Section 113 agreement with Huntingdonshire District Council for the provision of an interim Licensing Manager, presented by Councillor Hoy.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 Feb 2026, item C58/25Open the meeting
Said23 Feb 2026Council

Licensing Service - S113 Agreement

·        Councillor Hoy expressed the view that she believes that this proposal is unfortunately before the Council as a result of Local Government Reorganisation, and she does not believe that this will be the only scenario where this takes place. She expressed the view that this situation may arise in other services if officers choose to move on to other roles, and then it will need to be decided as to whether they are replaced for potentially a year.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 Feb 2026, item C58/25Open the meeting
Said23 Feb 2026Council

Licensing Service - S113 Agreement

Councillor Hoy added that she has had a number of people contact her with regards to expanding the licensing service in order to be more proactive rather than reactive, however, consideration needs to be given as to whether the authority invests money on a service which may not exist in 18 months’ time.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 Feb 2026, item C58/25Open the meeting
Said23 Feb 2026Council

Licensing Service - S113 Agreement

Councillor Hoy expressed the view that the situation could get far worse as matters progress and there needs to be decision made by Central Government as soon as possible as the uncertainty is having a significant impact.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 Feb 2026, item C58/25Open the meeting
Moved23 Feb 2026Council

Licensing Service - S113 Agreement

Proposed by Councillor Hoy, seconded by Councillor Christy and AGREED to enter into a Section 113 agreement with Huntingdonshire District Council for the provision of interim support to the Licensing Service and delegate to the Monitoring Officer to finalise and enter into any legal agreement in consultation with the Portfolio Holders.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 Feb 2026, item C58/25Open the meeting
Said16 Sep 2020Planning Committee

F/yr20/0531/voc

Councillor Hoy stated that she is not against the development but has concerns with the variations to the scheme to the northern part of the site, which is adjacent to Falklands Drive and comprises bungalows. She stated that her concern, and that of some of the residents in Falkland Drive, is that the variation to the proposal now includes two storey dwellings which will overlook the bungalows resulting in a loss of privacy and   the residents did not object originally as the proposal only included bungalows against their boundaries, but now the variation which includes the provision of 100% affordable homes appears to have been changed.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Sep 2020, item P28/20Open the meeting
Said16 Sep 2020Planning Committee

F/yr20/0531/voc

Councillor Hoy added that officers have also stated that the variation will lead to overlooking and in her opinion that there is no reason that the developer could not have left bungalows in the northern part of the site as bungalows are required in Wisbech and in her view that the two storey dwellings could have been placed to the front of the site, or in the northern part of the boundary of the site, as it appears that only 3 or 4 properties would be impacted. She reiterated that she has no problem with the proposal apart from her concerns with the new layout and she requested that the committee refuse the application on the basis of overlooking and ask the developer to review the plans in consultation with local residents to make the few small changes that are required to make the proposal satisfactory.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Sep 2020, item P28/20Open the meeting
Named16 Sep 2020Planning Committee

F/yr20/0531/voc

Members asked Councillor Hoy the following questions:
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Sep 2020, item P28/20Open the meeting
Named16 Sep 2020Planning Committee

F/yr20/0531/voc

·          Councillor Mrs French stated that Wisbech Town Council have offered no objections to the proposal and asked Councillor Hoy whether she had taken part in their discussions regarding the application?
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Sep 2020, item P28/20Open the meeting
Said16 Sep 2020Planning Committee

F/yr20/0531/voc

Councillor Hoy stated that she does not sit on the Town Council’s Planning Committee and she   believes that the Town Council may not have understood what the variations actually were when they were first submitted, as the information on the District Council’s website was not clear.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Sep 2020, item P28/20Open the meeting
Named16 Sep 2020Planning Committee

F/yr20/0531/voc

·          Councillor Sutton asked Councillor Hoy if she could advise him under what policy the committee could refuse the application, given that the separation distances in the proposal are exceeded by 2 metres in most places and under the national policy the distance allowed is 21 to 22 metres?
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Sep 2020, item P28/20Open the meeting
Said16 Sep 2020Planning Committee

F/yr20/0531/voc

Councillor Hoy stated that it is down to the Planning Committee members to make decisions dependent on policies. She made the point that she is only speak on behalf of the residents who do not wish to be overlooked and by making a few small changes to the proposal the concerns of the residents could be overcome.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Sep 2020, item P28/20Open the meeting
Said8 Sep 2020Cabinet

Project Update - Growing Fenland & CCC Capital Community Fund

Councillor Mrs Laws confirmed that she is referring to the CPCA applications ·          Councillor Hoy stated that she has been disappointed with the CPCA and agrees with Councillor Mrs Laws regarding the turnaround being a very short timeframe for submissions. She added that match funding is very difficult because everybody is short of money and some of the schemes in Wisbech have been put in place as the Town Council have funded projects through the County Council fund. She stated that whilst she appreciates the £1,000,000 that has been awarded, it is a difficult sum to work with but is sure it will be utilised with various projects and stated that, looking forward, if the opportunity arises again to bid for further funding, then she would hope that the scheme would be administered differently.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 8 Sep 2020, item CAB19/20Open the meeting
Named7 Sep 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel

Progress of Corporate Priority - Communities

Members considered the progress of the Corporate Priority, Communities, presented by Councillor Hoy.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Panel, 7 Sep 2020, item OSC12/20Open the meeting
Said7 Sep 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel

Progress of Corporate Priority - Communities

Councillor Hoy expressed the view that the numbers are low, compared to last year when the number was 95, but that it is for a much shorter period, and that due to Covid 19, formal inspections on properties has not been able to take place. She stated that with regard to registration, there is no formal landlord registration scheme or any licensing type of scheme in place apart from houses in multiple occupancy (HMO), however, the Landlord Forum which took place in early March, which was used to explain the new enforcement approach, appears to be working well and landlords seem to be taking action.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Panel, 7 Sep 2020, item OSC12/20Open the meeting
Said7 Sep 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel

Progress of Corporate Priority - Communities

Councillor Hoy stated that the mandatory HMO licensing which was introduced last year, initially meant that people were slow to sign up, however, because they now realise there are penalties if they do not register, there has been an increase in the number of registrations. She expressed the opinion that it has been successful and will be reviewed pre-budget time and she hopes that this approach will focus on the bad landlords.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Panel, 7 Sep 2020, item OSC12/20Open the meeting
Said7 Sep 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel

Progress of Corporate Priority - Communities

Councillor Hoy stated that an officer is now in post to address this issue, which has proved to be successful. She stated that there were 400 properties across the districts which have been empty for over 6 months and since the officer has been in post, 52 of those empty properties have been brought back into use.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Panel, 7 Sep 2020, item OSC12/20Open the meeting
Named7 Sep 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel

Progress of Corporate Priority - Communities

Councillor Hoy provided an explanation to members with regard to the meaning of the income and expenditure listed and also outlined the various processes that are in place in order for monies to be paid to the Council.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Panel, 7 Sep 2020, item OSC12/20Open the meeting
Said6 Aug 2020Council

Constitutional Amendments (Amendment to Planning Scheme of Delegation)

Councillor Hoy said she fully supported the report.
From the council's minutes: Council, 6 Aug 2020, item C17/20Open the meeting
Named6 Aug 2020Cabinet

Annual Report of the Council 2019/20

He added that the targeted work led by Councillor Hoy in acting against seriously defected private rented accommodation is starting to bear fruit.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 6 Aug 2020, item CAB8/20Open the meeting
Named6 Aug 2020Cabinet

Annual Report of the Council 2019/20

Councillor Hoy wanted to place on record her thanks to all the staff within the Housing Team, particularly with the way they took on the private sector housing enforcement work. Although it was a big change and a risk to try something new staff grasped it with both hands, taking a proactive approach to make it work.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 6 Aug 2020, item CAB8/20Open the meeting
Named6 Aug 2020Cabinet

Annual Report of the Council 2019/20

Councillor Boden thanked Councillor Hoy.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 6 Aug 2020, item CAB8/20Open the meeting
Named9 Jun 2020Cabinet

Homelessness Action Plan

Members considered the report presented by Councillor Hoy.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 9 Jun 2020, item CAB37/19Open the meeting
Said9 Jun 2020Cabinet

Homelessness Action Plan

Councillor Hoy expressed her thanks to all the officers involved in working on the strategy, which has been a long process. Cabinet AGREED to approve the Homelessness and Rough Sleeping Strategy and action plan 2020-2022.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 9 Jun 2020, item CAB37/19Open the meeting
Named12 May 2020Cabinet

March Future High Street Fund Bid

Councillor Boden thanked Councillor Hoy and asked if anyone had anything to add to her comments.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 12 May 2020, item CAB34/19Open the meeting
Named20 Feb 2020Council

To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.

She added that she has attended meetings along with Councillor Hoy and Councillor Benney, as well as a meeting with Charles Roberts from East Cambridgeshire District Council. She stated that the process  ...  view the full minutes text for item C65/19
From the council's minutes: Council, 20 Feb 2020, item C65/19Open the meeting
Named20 Feb 2020Council

General Fund Budget Estimates 2020/21 and Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2020/21 to 2024/25; Capital Programme 2020 - 2023.

In Favour: Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
From the council's minutes: Council, 20 Feb 2020, item C68/19Open the meeting
Named20 Feb 2020Council

Council Tax Resolution.

In favour of the proposal - Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
From the council's minutes: Council, 20 Feb 2020, item C69/19Open the meeting
Said20 Feb 2020Council

Proposed Removal of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA) .

·          Councillor Hoy expressed the opinion that all premises in Wisbech that apply to sell alcohol are faced with objections from Public Health who have shown concerns over additional premises selling alcohol in Wisbech which will add to the cumulative effect. She added that street drinking has reduced slightly due to the work that the council has been undertaking and also a greater police presence. She stated that the homeless hub has also helped by engaging with the street drinkers.
From the council's minutes: Council, 20 Feb 2020, item C70/19Open the meeting
Said20 Feb 2020Council

Proposed Removal of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA) .

·          Councillor Hoy expressed the view that she believes there is a solution to the problem and she will be working with the Cabinet members to find a satisfactory resolution.
From the council's minutes: Council, 20 Feb 2020, item C70/19Open the meeting
Asked20 Feb 2020Cabinet

Investment Board Terms of Reference

Councillor Hoy queried the wording in paragraph 1.2.2. of the Terms of Reference where it states “The Investment Board will comprise a maximum of two Cabinet Members…”, and wondered if the third is a non-executive member, when she understood the board would be made up of three Cabinet Members.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 20 Feb 2020, item CAB21/19Open the meeting
Said20 Feb 2020Cabinet

Investment Board Terms of Reference

Councillor Hoy said this was ambiguous and felt it could be written more clearly.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 20 Feb 2020, item CAB21/19Open the meeting
Named14 Jan 2020Licensing Committee

Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA)

Councillor Humphrey asked if Councillor Hoy, as leader of Wisbech Town Council, could explain why the town council is not behind this policy.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Committee, 14 Jan 2020, item LIC11/19Open the meeting
Said14 Jan 2020Licensing Committee

Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA)

Councillor Hoy said it was fair to say that there had been a long debate at both the last meeting of Licensing Committee and at full Council, and it was agreed that this policy is not about street drinking but is an extra tool for the Licensing Committee. However the public see it as something that would have an impact on street drinking.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Committee, 14 Jan 2020, item LIC11/19Open the meeting
Said14 Jan 2020Licensing Committee

Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA)

Councillor Hoy added that this is not the fault of Fenland District Council; she agreed that the policy was introduced with the best of intentions and in response to calls for action to solve the problem, but the issue of street drinking is vast and complex.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Committee, 14 Jan 2020, item LIC11/19Open the meeting
Said14 Jan 2020Licensing Committee

Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA)

Councillor Hoy further added that we are also trying to grow the Fenland night time economy.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Committee, 14 Jan 2020, item LIC11/19Open the meeting
Named14 Jan 2020Licensing Committee

Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA)

Street drinking and alcoholism is a wider issue and Councillor Hoy would be happy to work with the portfolio holders for Licensing and Community Safety in looking at these issues, such as homelessness and community safety, with a means to finding potential ways forward, but this is not it.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Committee, 14 Jan 2020, item LIC11/19Open the meeting
Named14 Jan 2020Licensing Committee

Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA)

Councillor Humphrey thanked Councillor Hoy, adding that he did offer an amendment prior to the meeting, but that did not seek any approval. He stressed that the CIA Policy was not about street drinking but was about new premises applications.   2.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Committee, 14 Jan 2020, item LIC11/19Open the meeting
Said9 Jan 2020Cabinet

Growing Fenland - Town Reports

Councillor Hoy said that a small change needed to be made to p.295 of the report.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 9 Jan 2020, item CAB7/19Open the meeting
Said9 Jan 2020Cabinet

Growing Fenland - Town Reports

However, Councillor Hoy said the report needs amending as it is incorrect and it lists every other town council.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 9 Jan 2020, item CAB7/19Open the meeting
Said9 Jan 2020Cabinet

Growing Fenland - Overarching Strategic Report

Councillor Hoy pointed out the same correction needed making within the report that she raised when discussing the previous agenda item. She agreed with the Chief Executive that more work was required on this report.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 9 Jan 2020, item CAB8/19Open the meeting
Said4 Nov 2019Cabinet

Play Areas

Councillor Murphy replied that this is happening now, and at the last Cabinet meeting in September Councillor Hoy suggested it would also be useful to have information in relation to non-council owned play equipment across the district, as this would give a true reflection of all play areas. This would help us to make informed future investment decisions based on need and ensure as far as possible there is equity of equipment across the area.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 4 Nov 2019, item CAB29/19Open the meeting
Said4 Nov 2019Council

Cumulative Impact Zone

Councillor Topgood seconded this proposed motion amendment and Councillor Mrs Mayor opened the deferral request for debate.    ·          Councillor Hoy agreed that Wisbech Town Council had objected but Councillor Tierney does not want the CIA at all. However, she was of the view that this should affect off licences rather than on licences. The biggest problem is that Public Health objects to every application and do not use the CIA properly.
From the council's minutes: Council, 4 Nov 2019, item C50/19Open the meeting
Asked28 Oct 2019Licensing Sub Committee

Determination of an application for a variation to a premises licence made under the provisions of the licensing act 2003

·          Councillor Hoy asked if a change of hours from midnight to 1.00am would affect the times of people drinking in the garden. Michelle Bishop explained it is the sale of alcohol which is the licensing activity and not the consumption.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 28 Oct 2019, item LH7/19Open the meeting
Said28 Oct 2019Licensing Sub Committee

Determination of an application for a variation to a premises licence made under the provisions of the licensing act 2003

Councillor Hoy said that in theory then, people could drink until, for example, 3am as this was not a licensable activity whether alcohol was being sold or not.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 28 Oct 2019, item LH7/19Open the meeting
Asked28 Oct 2019Licensing Sub Committee

Determination of an application for a variation to a premises licence made under the provisions of the licensing act 2003

Michelle Bishop confirmed this to be correct unless there was a specific condition prohibiting this.   ·          Councillor Hoy asked about live music; if we rejected their application today, would The Sportsman still be able to apply for a Temporary Event Notice (TEN)? Michelle Bishop advised that they could, however only the police or Environmental Health colleagues can object to a TEN as it does not go out for formal consultation.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 28 Oct 2019, item LH7/19Open the meeting
Asked2 Oct 2019Licensing Committee

Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA)

Councillor Hoy asked if the data was recent. [name removed] said that the data was four years old and although he had been unable to look at more recent figures in greater detail, he could not see there would be a massive difference. [name removed] added he has been involved in this area of public health for fifteen years and working on substance misuse for seven years, and the data trends have been similar in all that time.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Committee, 2 Oct 2019, item LIC8/19Open the meeting
Said2 Oct 2019Licensing Committee

Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment Policy (CIA)

Councillor Hoy felt that the data should have been more recent and said that the policy does not work because the figures have got worse not better.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Committee, 2 Oct 2019, item LIC8/19Open the meeting
Seconded18 Jul 2019Council

Treasury Management Annual Review 2018/19.

Proposed by Councillor Boden, seconded by Councillor Hoy it was AGREED that the report be noted.
From the council's minutes: Council, 18 Jul 2019, item C27/19Open the meeting
Said18 Jul 2019Cabinet

Play Equipment - Response to motion

Councillor Hoy commented that the amendment was useful as she was expecting the report to provide a breakdown of the play areas within the wards and the types of play equipment in those wards. The point of the original motion was that some areas did not have equipment and the report in September will show this.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 18 Jul 2019, item CAB17/19Open the meeting
Said16 Jul 2019Licensing Sub Committee

Determination of an application for a premises licence made under the provisions of the licensing act 2003 - heron foods, unit 9-10, horsefair shopping centre, wisbech

Councillor Hoy stated that there had been a store in the same complex as Heron which closed at least a year ago and it had a large area selling alcohol.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 16 Jul 2019, item LH2/19Open the meeting
Asked16 Jul 2019Licensing Sub Committee

Determination of an application for a premises licence made under the provisions of the licensing act 2003 - heron foods, unit 9-10, horsefair shopping centre, wisbech

The statistics showed there was no decrease in street drinking after it closed and Councillor Hoy asked [name removed] if he knew why that might be. [name removed] said that the drinkers probably diverted to the 19 other places selling alcohol in that area.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 16 Jul 2019, item LH2/19Open the meeting
Said16 Jul 2019Licensing Sub Committee

Determination of an application for a premises licence made under the provisions of the licensing act 2003 - heron foods, unit 9-10, horsefair shopping centre, wisbech

Councillor Hoy said based on that, if we were to offer a licence it would not make things worse. [name removed] added that the CIZ is in place for a good reason, there is supposed to be a rebuttable presumption saying that we would refuse any premises opening, so why we would want to increase the risk? He can only advise on the cumulative impact seen in the area.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 16 Jul 2019, item LH2/19Open the meeting
Said3 Jul 2019Conduct Committee

Committee of Standards in Public Life recommendations.

Councillor Hoy stated that the report suggests that the recommendations are to be implemented by the Council and the fact it is merely a summary of the larger report is not clear.   6.
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 3 Jul 2019, item CND5/19Open the meeting
Named27 Jun 2019Cabinet

Fenland Stations Regeneration Project

·        Councillor Hoy noticed that there was no representation from the County Council on the membership board and asked if they should be included, or at least be kept updated.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 27 Jun 2019, item CAB6/19Open the meeting
Named2 Nov 2018Conduct Committee

Conduct Committee Hearing - Councillor Sam Hoy

That Councillor Hoy had failed to treat others with respect in that she had referred to the complainant as nasty and aggressive on social media without having have met him herself;
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 2 Nov 2018, item CND3/18Open the meeting
Named2 Nov 2018Conduct Committee

Conduct Committee Hearing - Councillor Sam Hoy

That Councillor Hoy had bullied the complainant both herself and also by inciting others again via social media;
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 2 Nov 2018, item CND3/18Open the meeting
Named2 Nov 2018Conduct Committee

Conduct Committee Hearing - Councillor Sam Hoy

That Councillor Hoy had disclosed information on social media in contravention of the Data Protection Act; and 4. That the above acts could reasonably be regarded as bringing her or Fenland District Council into disrepute.
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 2 Nov 2018, item CND3/18Open the meeting
Said31 Oct 2018Conduct Committee

Conduct Committee Hearing - Councillor Simon King

Councillor Hoy introduced the Panel and external representatives. She clarified the Hearing Procedure contained within the Agenda Pack and asked if there were any preliminary procedural issues anybody wished to raise.
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 31 Oct 2018, item CND2/18Open the meeting
Said31 Oct 2018Conduct Committee

Conduct Committee Hearing - Councillor Simon King

Councillor Hoy confirmed that Jonathan Goolden would not be calling any witnesses.
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 31 Oct 2018, item CND2/18Open the meeting
Asked31 Oct 2018Conduct Committee

Conduct Committee Hearing - Councillor Simon King

Councillor Hoy asked Jonathan Goolden for his view on this.
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 31 Oct 2018, item CND2/18Open the meeting
Asked31 Oct 2018Conduct Committee

Conduct Committee Hearing - Councillor Simon King

Councillor Hoy asked Mike Magee for confirmation of the date that the Council were notified of Councillor Boden attending as a witness. Mike Magee said he believed it was Monday 29 October.
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 31 Oct 2018, item CND2/18Open the meeting
Said31 Oct 2018Conduct Committee

Conduct Committee Hearing - Councillor Simon King

Councillor Hoy said she was aware that Supplementary Documentation had been submitted by Tony Cheetham to the Council on Monday 29 October and asked for further information on this.
From the council's minutes: Conduct Committee, 31 Oct 2018, item CND2/18Open the meeting
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

Councillor Hoy explained that she is speaking as an objector as there is some background to the application which she outlined. She stated that in principle she has no objection to the development, it is in the local plan.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

Councillor Hoy commented that when she read the report, her main concern was and remains, how the development ties in with the Wisbech Access project and she felt the information provided was not necessarily correct as it stated that there was no date set for Wisbech Access works, when in fact the date of March 2021 had been put forward as the date of completion by Fenland District Council’s Cabinet, the Combined Authority and the County Council.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

Councillor Hoy commented that if Members were minded to grant permission the Developer could decide to start the access works themselves immediately and then in some 18 months’ time, the Wisbech Access Study will commence and undo the works the Developer has already undertaken. This will be a waste of money and disruptive for the local residents.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

Councillor Hoy commented that she has had various conversations with the Head of Planning and the Agent and thanked them for the help they have given. The update provided today does alleviate some of her concerns; and she does appreciate that applications need to be dealt with as they are submitted. The clause with regard to the monies is really important and she is pleased to see it included.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Asked15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

One of the issues still to receive clarification is with regard to the financial contribution for the Ramnoth Road roundabout junction as originally it was a medium strategy for the Access Study and when it went before the Combined Authority and Cabinet it got brought forward and Councillor Hoy asked whether this is because they are relying on a contribution from the Developer or because monies have been found elsewhere.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

Councillor Hoy commented that the clause outlines this issue and if the finances are needed for the Wisbech Access Study, the Developer’s money could then be used and if they were not reliant on it the money could go towards other aspects such as affordable housing or items for the local community.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Named15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

Members asked Councillor Hoy the following questions:
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Named15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

·          Councillor Mrs Laws asked Councillor Hoy to confirm which aspect she required clarification on.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

Councillor Hoy stated it is clarification on who is financing the Wisbech Access Strategy. The study has three stages and in the middle stage the roundabout had been mentioned. When the Combined Authority became involved, the roundabout was moved forward.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee

F/YR16/0792/F. The College of West Anglia, Elm High Road, Wisbech. Erection of 137 dwellings, alterations to Ramnoth Road and Elm High Road junction to form a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated works and infrastructure

Councillor Hoy stated that the Agent has pointed out that it is not dependent on the funding.  ...  view the full minutes text for item P16/18
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 15 Aug 2018, item P16/18Open the meeting
Named27 Jul 2018Corporate Governance Committee

Items of Topical Interest

Carol suggested that Councillor Clark could discuss the matter with Councillor Hoy in the first instance as the chairmen of the two committees.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Governance Committee, 27 Jul 2018, item CGC/16/18Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Hoy attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

No recorded votes at Councillor Hoy's meetings yet.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Hoy was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Cabinet
9 of 12
Council
5 of 6
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 14 of 18 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Hoy declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

No declarations of interest by Councillor Hoy in the minutes read so far.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Hoy sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
CabinetCommittee MemberJan 20261214 Dec 2026
CouncilCommittee MemberFeb 2026614 Dec 2026
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies