Manor Leisure Centre Update
Members considered the Manor Leisure Update report provided by Councillor Count.
Every time Fenland's minutes name Councillor Count, as the council published it.
Members considered the Manor Leisure Update report provided by Councillor Count.
· Councillor Count confirmed that a decision will be made in December but the time between now and then is to fill in the legally required blanks. If members were to decide today, they would be held responsible for a £20m plus decision without the legal backdrop. Some £1.25m has been spent to get to this point and members of the public may question that amount, but much of it has been spent on the design work.
Proposed by Councillor Count, seconded by Councillor Boden and AGREED to:
Councillor Count stated that they are not direct comparisons in any way or form, because the complete new rebuild would bring all the advantages that have been spoken about for many months, whereas the other option is to keep the Manor Leisure Centre running but he is expecting the Cabinet to make an informed decision in December.
· Councillor Count said he does not believe the letter will achieve the stopping of the freight train, but it is important for the public to see what this authority is trying to do and what it is fighting for and that is why he will support the motion. He admitted he does supports LGR but only if it is well thought ... view the full minutes text for item C18/26
Councillor Boden replied that in theory assets and liabilities are geographically based but it is not that simple in practice; Councillor Count is not wrong that a significant disproportionate amount of the assets of Cambridge City Council will end up going to the unitary authority which includes, and may only include, Cambridge City and South Cambridge and that is a matter of geography. The structural change order will lay out a lot of this in terms of the principles involved but there will also be a mediation and legal process to determine the anticipated many disagreements about which assets and liabilities are split and how they are split.
· Councillor Mrs Laws said she is supportive of this but like Councillor Count she is also concerned about the assets.
Councillor Count commended the Chairman and Panel for the valuable work they do.
Proposed by Councillor Woollard, seconded by Councillor Count and AGREED to acknowledge the broad scope of work undertaken by the Overview and Scrutiny Panel during 2025/26.
Proposed by Councillor Count seconded by Councillor Mrs Laws and AGREED to approve the amendments set out in Appendix A and note the minor amendment made by the Monitoring Officer in relation to the LGPS since the last meeting.
Councillor Count commented that March has a lack of sports pitches, so he is delighted that the Council provided support to help to secure a 3G pitch at Estover Field. However, the report mistakenly stated this was a £12million project when in fact it cost just over £1million and he asked that the minutes reflect that and the report be corrected.
(Councillor Count was advised following the meeting that the report correctly states the figure for the project is £1.2million. He realised he had misread it and so no amendments are required).
He asked if Councillor Count has met with or does he plan to meet with the new developer and builder and how confident is he in bringing the project forward on time and to budget given the uncertainties?
Councillor Count responded that it is great news that Sport England have agreed to fund £2 million towards this project, with Sport England having fed into this project from a very early stage and have made some very sensible and good alterations to the design which has been acted upon, with them agreeing to release the maximum amount permissible under this scheme. He made the point that there are two caveats, which are obtaining full planning permission, which is being considered currently, and the stop/go decision, does the Council go ahead which is a Cabinet decision that will be made later in the year.
Councillor Count stated that he and the Leader met with Alliance Leisure, who are the Council’s partners and the ones appointing through their framework Speller Metcalfe, and they received a full briefing on the company, its background and credit worthiness and the Council is happy to proceed on that basis but he has not met with Speller Metcalfe directly. He added that when they move forward with further meetings he will meet with whoever is necessary and beneficial to the project to bring it forward in the fastest possible time and at the lowest possible cost.
Councillor Count acknowledged that it was bad news that Curo ceased trading as the Council had been working alongside them for a long while to get the project to this stage and they were a great partner to work with but he has every confidence that Speller Metcalfe will be a good contractor based on the reports he has received about other leisure centres. He referred to time and budget, stating that he cannot give a 100% guarantee on anything, making the point it is a Cabinet decision whether the project goes ahead and that will be dependent upon many factors including timing and budget and it is not known at this time the impact of this change, he has been given confidence by officers that the process will happen on budget but it is anticipated that there may well be a later Cabinet decision because this new contractor has to look through every single detail to see if they agree with the methods of working, to see what they can mobilise and if they agree with costs and, therefore, there is likely to be a delay to the Cabinet decision but how this affects the overall programme actually being open on 1 January 2028 is uncertain.
Councillor Count made the point that when Speller Metcalfe was contracted, they ... view the full minutes text for item C7/26
Members considered the report concerning Acceptance of a Sport England Grant to support the redevelopment of the Manor Leisure Centre presented by Councillor Count.
Proposed by Councillor Count, seconded by Councillor Boden and AGREED to:
· Councillor Count asked if there was any chance that the Council could claim a refund on VAT paid previously.
Councillor Boden said unfortunately legal advice had confirmed the answer to be no, but he was pleased to see Councillor Count asking the same question.
· Councillor Count said he was surprised by the levels in Broad Street, March showing an increase, considering the success of the High Street redevelopment and less traffic. However, he believed the reason for this was that the measurements compared 2023, when works were ongoing and there was hardly anything going through, to the reopening in 2024 when there was an uplift in traffic. However, when compared to 20/21, the figures are much lower which shows the project to be a great success in its aims which included air quality improvements in the town centre and congestion reduction.
· Councillor Count welcomed the funding as a good news story. He asked for clarification on the March narrative at paragraphs 3.1 and 3.2, stating 3.1 named Peas Hill Road open space as the primary area, 3.2 then listed other areas, and it then referred to work after the initial two open spaces had been done, but he could only ... view the full minutes text for item CAB65/25
· Councillor Count said that this is a hugely successful project, being a combination of the Broad Street project, chaired very well by Councillor Seaton, and March Area Transport Strategy delivery, chaired very well by Councillor Mrs French. Despite initial public scepticism, his experience from living in March is that the vast majority have found this a success. He commented on improved air quality and the enhanced streetscape being used for outside eating.
Proposed by Councillor Seaton, seconded by Councillor Count and AGREED to accept bid 2 based on the responses detailed in the exempt Appendix 2 of the report and approve the disposal of the freehold interest in the property upon the terms reported herein and give delegated authority to the Leader of the Council, in conjunction with the Portfolio Holder for Assets and the S151 Officer, to approve the contractual terms securing the disposal of the property and to enter into all legal documentation required.
Councillor Count said the money will be very welcome as the area is desperate for transport improvements. It is unfortunate that whilst the public would say the biggest improvement would be for the County Council to get potholes fixed, the money cannot be used for that. He would, however, like to seek assurance that this is not going to delay the works relating to the March Area Transport Strategy (MATS).
Members considered the Manor Leisure Centre Redevelopment Project update report presented by Councillor Count.
Councillor Count advised the timetable for completion of the new building is on schedule for December 2027. In the meantime, Freedom Leisure will work with FDC to protect all jobs where possible during the build as staff will still be required to operate the dry side activities and prepare the new facility to open upon completion. Redeployment to other local facilities would also be an option and staff may have opportunities to take up vacancies at FDC where appropriate.
Proposed by Councillor Count, seconded by Councillor Mrs French and AGREED:
· Councillor Count thanked Councillor Taylor for bringing this forward, he is no expert in the field of farming and understands that Councillor Taylor has a great deal of expertise which he listens to. He has read this with some concern, because as a complete lay person, the one thing that jumped out at him was stopping the hunting of rabbits, knowing little about farming but he knows what happens when he drives around the area at night time and what happened in the 60’s with myxomatosis and if there is not something done about rabbits there will be an explosion.
Councillor Count expressed the view that he really does not understand where this is being driven from or what is driving it or how the farming community is going to be expected to carry on and what the alternative plans are. He hopes it can be explained that there is a counterpoint but does think that this is another thinly disguised attack on the rural way of life, with the voters for a Labour Government lying in urban areas and that people who represent them generally coming from urban areas.
Councillor Count made the point that the Minister for Agriculture is Daniel Ziechner from Cambridge who has had no jobs in agriculture in his life and is a computer IT expert and a career politician. He referred also to the hunting of birds using birds of prey being stopped, which is not a common practice in his experience, but he has seen it used in places such as football stadiums, Wimbledon, etc, and he struggles to think what the alternative is as this has been an effective management tool.
Councillor Count stated that this motion raises concerns with the people who may or may not listen and tells them there is something here that is happening that needs to be looked at.
Members received a presentation, in accordance with the public participation procedure, from Councillor Steve Count, District Councillor.
Councillor Count stated that there are some similarities and differences with the earlier applications that have been considered today, with the first difference being where security was raised but the nature of that business is very different to this one. He expressed the view that one of the main differences he sees on this application in terms of security is that this is at the end of a very long dead end and criminals might be lazy but they are not inherently stupid and it is known from the Police that they do not often choose to go to dead ends specifically when it is that remote and easy to close off.
Councillor Count hoped to bring out why the application should be refused in line with the officer’s recommendation, one of the obvious reasons is the sequential test for Flood Zone 3, which this fails on, and it is a simple and easy way to continue to say that this is unsuitable. He expressed the opinion that part of the reason this is in front of committee today is that there is a farming use assessment trying to justify the need for a dwelling but when the assessment is analysed it starts falling apart, with the need for security according to NPPF being very different to what is actually happening on the site, for example there is no livestock or envisaged livestock which is one of the core reasons it might be approved and security is shown in the assessment but this is no longer a substantial valid reason to approve.
Councillor Count expressed the view that there are no crime records for this site, which has been brought out by correspondence with the Police who have confirmed this by e-mail. He feels there are a number of planning policies this proposal contravenes including the one relevant to building in the open countryside and the officer’s report is correct in all respects but feels the Highways report from the County Council has fallen down as an application for the paddock which is on the same strip stated that there should be no further intensification of traffic on this road but they have not made those comments on this application.
Councillor Count expressed the opinion that a 2 ½ thousand tonne barn takes 337 vehicular movements to fill and unfill down a single track road bordered by a drain all the way along, with no passing places and there are paddocks along here and a livery yard around the corner on Flaggrass Hill and he is surprised that Highways did not put that comment into this application. He stated that Highways after submitting their no objection description did submit in a subsequent e-mail that they considered this for the storage of machinery only and did ... view the full minutes text for item P100/25
Councillor Boden added that both he and Councillor Count, speaking on behalf of the County Council, never stop asking for further investment in broadband to make sure that it is brought up to adequate standard and continues to be improved.
Councillor Count echoed all the positive comments that had been expressed. However, he has just received the unsettling news that Fenland is now above the national average for coronavirus; it may be that this is in part due to the outbreak at the Princes Factory and he is currently waiting analysis on this but we had been fairly confident that we had previously been in a low coronavirus area. However, even if it was still low we have to work on the assumption that it is prevalent in our communities.
Councillor Count added that it is encouraging to read in the report the work undertaken ... view the full minutes text for item OSC6/20
Councillor Count and Councillor Connor will form part of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee in place of Councillor Hay and Councillor Mrs Mayor.
In Favour: Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
In favour of the proposal - Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
Councillor Boden said that Councillor Count had questioned why the reserve balance was reduced from £2.622M to the exact sum of £2M, suggesting that a detailed calculation may produce a more appropriate and precise figure.
Councillor Boden will be sending a more detailed explanation to Councillor Count to show what officers have suggested. However, the amount of reserves as a proportion of our spend is what is important and Members will be considering the figures further before setting the main budget.
Councillor Count referred back to the postponement of works at Ely North and confirmed that the Mayor of the CPCA is lobbying Central Government. He said the upgrade work is essential to the project due to train paths that will be released to allow access direct access to Wisbech .
Councillor Count added that if the direct line between Wisbech and Cambridge is not available, this will mean passengers travelling to Cambridge or Peterborough will have to change at March Railway Station. He informed members that whilst the service will be impacted locally, it will also impact other regions that rely on that train line. He explained that consideration is being given to the possibility of delivering a shuttle service which again will be dependent on the timetabling and Ely North junction.
· Councillor Count thanked the Independent Review Panel for the work they had undertaken saying that it was not widely known that about 30% of councillors’ time was taken up on reaching these judgements.
Councillor Count stated that he disagreed entirely with Councillor Sutton’s opinion.
In favour of amending the original Council meeting dates, as per Councillor Mrs Mayor’s proposal – Councillor Benney, Councillor Boden, Councillor Bristow, Councillor J Clark, Councillor S Clark, Councillor Connor, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor ... view the full minutes text for item C6/19
Councillor Boden stated that Councillor Count had submitted a question in relation to 11-12 High Street, Wisbech . He asked if the agreed back-to-back sale has fallen through and does this expose the Council to financial risk. Gary Garford confirmed that a confidential report was agreed by Cabinet in relation to the purchase of the property but did not include a back-to-back purchase and sale.
Councillor Count agreed that that the Council does need a modern system for meetings and the current situation is unfit for purpose, however, he would suggest now is the time to explore webcasting further, but for a cheaper option, which is transparent, the way for the future and will help with engagement.
Councillor Count said in relation to point 26.1 in the report, it is best practice for tenants to put into writing any complaints or issues as it provides a record.
Councillor Count suggested the wording be amended to ‘any other deemed breech to which the Statutory Notice applies’. Richard Cassidy agreed to consider this however ‘justifiable’ needs to be included in the event of a Court case.
Councillor Count reiterated the usefulness of public consultation feedback prior to the Committee. He asked if the charges associated to Statutory Notices on 2.3 of Appendix A, could be applied to any other areas in the Council. Richard Cassidy said this depends on legislation and generally the Council can recover any additional costs through the Courts once a Statutory Notice has been served.
Councillor Count suggested that this plan should form part of the Council’s Corporate Strategy. Richard Cassidy agreed to consider this in the Corporate Plan next year.
Councillor Count asked why there were no specified locations mentioned in point 3.1 of Appendix A. Richard Cassidy confirmed that the locations are not specified as this will allow the Council to make any amendments to where parking controls apply without having to amend the policy.
Councillor Count asked if the wording could be changed in relation to the 5.5 of Appendix A. Richard Cassidy said guidance relating to this is set by the Home Office and the wording relates to the statutory meaning of Formal Cautions.
Councillor Count asked for clarification on Councillor Booth’s proposal.
Councillor Count said he was happy for these items to be decided by the Chairman and members call-in process, as per the Constitution.
Councillor Count agreed but said there is a risk that the public will bring politically-motivated items to the Committee, therefore the process needs to be sufficient in deciding what is heard at Committee level.
Councillor Count asked if an item relating to benchmarking in relation to Corporate Spending, could be added to a future meeting date. Anna Goodall confirmed she would consider this.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Count attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Count's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Count was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 18 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Count declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Count in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Count sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 12 | 14 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 6 | 14 Dec 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.