Said16 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Leader & Deputy Leader Question Time
Councillor Francis advised that there are traffic congestion problems at both ends of the district currently and asked if the Leader had heard of any infrastructure plans during their discussions with the Member of Parliament and others? Did they have any updates of any solutions going forwards?
Said16 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Service Performance Report (Q3 & Q4)
Councillor Francis noted on page 35, it notes Forest Fitness Centre are extending their lease and mentions about a completed full conditions survey of Cinderford Leisure Centre.
Said16 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Service Performance Report (Q3 & Q4)
Councillor Francis noted page 28, on 3.2 Publica Partnerships. Does the DFR have any further ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Moved14 Jul 2026Development Management Committee
P0503/26/FUL- Lydney Harbourside Destination Harbourside, Harbour Road Lydney Gloucestershire GL15 4ER
Committee Debate Councillor Francis proposed that they accept the Officers recommendation, noting that the café was a well-used facility at the docks and it would be nice if there were some forethoughts to building a permanent structure there, dependant on lease renewal and with the current council structure being reorganised in the next couple of years. It would be a valuable thing for the community to have there, to bolster a tourism asset.
Named21 May 2026Full Council
Allocation of Seats to Political Groups and Appointments to Committees
Councillor Nick Evans was appointed the Chair and Councillor John Francis as the Vice Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Named21 May 2026Full Council
Appointments to Outside Bodies
For (25) Against (0) Abstain (0) Councillor John Francis nominated Councillor Stuart Graham.
Named12 May 2026Development Management Committee
Apologies
· Councillor John Francis substituted by Councillor Ian Whitburn · Councillor Clayton Williams · Councillor Trevor Roach
Said5 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
The Scrutiny Forward Plan
Councillor Francis agreed, stating that additional meetings would provide flexibility and allow the Committee to respond promptly to new developments.
Said5 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Local Government Reorganisation
Councillor Francis agreed, expressing concern that political considerations risk reducing equitable representation. Option four was described as too vague and not reflective of each council’s scrutiny responsibilities.
Said5 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Task & Finish Group - Long Term Empty Homes Strategy
Councillor Francis raised concerns regarding planning restrictions associated with properties above shops. It was suggested that improving the accessibility of information relating to such restrictions would be beneficial and could be incorporated into cross team working.
Moved19 Feb 2026Full Council
Cllr John Francis
Councillor John Francis proposed.
Asked28 Jan 2026Full Council
Councillor John Francis
Supplementary Councillor John Francis asked for confirmation that with 2000 houses on the Forest of Dean side and 2500 houses on the Tewkesbury side, would mean a total of 4500 houses on the A40?
Said28 Jan 2026Full Council
Councillor John Francis
Councillor John Francis said to ensure transparency for any type of plan that is put together and for it to be watertight and a plan that is not turned down by the inspectorate, members need to be advised of developments that affect their wards. Could members have assurance that members will be informed in the future?
Named28 Jan 2026Full Council
Appointments - Outside Bodies
Councillor Trevor Roach nominated Councillor John Francis Councillor Chris McFarling seconded the nomination There were no further nominations Agreed by majority – Councillor John Francis was appointed the FoDDC representative for the Local Government Association Rural Commission.
Said28 Jan 2026Full Council
Cabinet and scrutiny committee reports
The January Scrutiny report will be included in February’s agenda, but Councillor John Francis said there was a task and finish group set up looking at the empty homes strategy, and there is a meeting on Friday 30 January at 10.30am. Please could member forward any questions they may have.
Asked22 Jan 2026Full Council
Councillor John Francis
Supplementary Councillor John Francis asked for confirmation that with 2000 houses on the Forest of Dean side and 2500 houses on the Tewkesbury side, would mean a total of 4500 houses on the A40?
Said22 Jan 2026Full Council
Councillor John Francis
Councillor John Francis said to ensure transparency for any type of plan that is put together and for it to be watertight and a plan that is not turned down by the inspectorate, members need to be advised of developments that affect their wards. Could members have assurance that members will be informed in the future?
Named22 Jan 2026Full Council
Appointments - Outside Bodies
Councillor Trevor Roach nominated Councillor John Francis Councillor Chris McFarling seconded the nomination There were no further nominations Agreed by majority – Councillor John Francis was appointed the FoDDC representative for the Local Government Association Rural Commission.
Said22 Jan 2026Full Council
Cabinet and scrutiny committee reports
The January Scrutiny report will be included in February’s agenda, but Councillor John Francis said there was a task and finish group set up looking at the empty homes strategy, and there is a meeting on Friday 30 January at 10.30am. Please could member forward any questions they may have.
Seconded9 Dec 2025Development Management Committee
P1081/25/FUL Land Adjacent Bridewell Farm, Woodland Road, Christchurch
Councillor John Francis seconded the proposal.
Moved11 Nov 2025Development Management Committee
P0649/25/LBC The George Hotel 21 - 23 Church Street Newent
None Ward Members Speaking Councillor Gill Moseley & Johnathan Beeston Member Questions Members were able to ask questions regarding this application during the previous application Committee Debate Councillor John Francis proposed that they accept the Officers recommendationto grant consent.
Named14 Oct 2025Development Management Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Simon Phelps nominated Councillor John Francis which was seconded by Councillor Dave Tradgett. The Committee agreed by assent.
Seconded8 Jul 2025Development Management Committee
P0121/22/OUT - Land Off Bradfords Lane, Newent
Councillor John Francis seconded.
Seconded10 Jun 2025Development Management Committee
P0155/25/LBC - Dean Heritage Centre, Lower Soudley, Cinderford, Gloucestershire, GL14 2UB
Councillor John Francis seconded the proposal.
Named22 May 2025Full Council
Allocation of Seats to Political Groups and Appointments to Committees
Councillor Nick Evans was appointed the Chair and Councillor John Francis as the Vice Chair of the Strategic Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Moved8 Apr 2025Development Management Committee
P0965/22/LBC - St John The Evangelist Church, Boxbush Road, Coleford
Councillor John Francis proposed that as per the previous item, they delegate authority to officers.
Said8 Apr 2025Development Management Committee
P1449/23/FUL - Land at Stepps Farm, Monmouth Road, Longhope
Councillor John Francis agreed with Councillor Tradgett and added that extra housing is a benefit and the improvements to include an attenuation pond and revised water drainage to alleviate flooding is welcomed.
Named20 Mar 2025Full Council
Publica Transition Plan - Phase 2
Councillor Adrian Birch Proposed Councillor Jackie Dale Seconded Questions None Debate There was no debate The Chair thanked the Independent Programme Director for his comprehensive report and Councillor Francis and the Scrutiny Panel for the work that they have conducted. It has greatly helped our understanding of the work that has been done.
Named6 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Transition Plan - Phase Two
Councillor John Francis provided an update to the committee regarding the repatriation of services from Publica.
Named6 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Transition Plan - Phase Two
Councillor Francis invited Andrew Pollard, Interim Programme Director (IPD) to add any other information he may feel the committee should be aware of. The IPD advised that the (DFR) and other section 151 officers from all of the Councils have been involved in this process right from the start, making sure the figures are appropriate and assured.
Named6 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Transition Plan - Phase Two
The clear principle of all of the Councils is to TUPE as many staff where possible, however the figures that Councillor Francis has described are best estimates at this stage because when you have a fragmented workforce that do not fall into a clear TUPE category, it will be up to the staff themselves if they wish to apply for the roles when they are advertised.
Said6 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Transition Plan - Phase Two
Councillor Francis noted that there has been great deliberation and conversation around the wellbeing of the staff and making sure they are supported through these changes. We want to make sure all the services we provide work well and are looking at how these will be delivered however, we are also concerned about the wellbeing of our staff and actually bringing them with us on this journey is paramount.
Said12 Dec 2024Full Council
Councillor Andrew McDermid
Councillor John Francis suggested an amendment; to empower Cabinet to engage in active dialogue with Councils that are ... view the full minutes text for item 15.1
Said8 Oct 2024Development Management Committee
P0580/24/FUL - Brook Cottage, Blaisdon, Longhope, Gloucestershire
Debate Councillor John Francis said there was no policy to fall back on regarding density or what happens with areas with AirB&B’s on, and this should be considered and, if it could, be incorporated into the local plan.
Named26 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor John Francis was nominated and seconded.
Named26 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair
There were no other nominations, therefore Councillor John Francis was elected.
Named25 Jul 2024Full Council
Outside Bodies - Gloucestershire Economic Strategic Scrutiny Committee
Councillor John Francis nominated Councillor Philip Burford.
Named25 Jul 2024Full Council
Publica Transition Plan
Debate Councillor John Francis wanted to thank the CEO, Chief Finance Officer, and the Interim Programme Director for all their hard work, and all members that attended the various panel meetings that participated in this process for their help and assistance.
Named18 Jul 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Review - Transition Plan Report
The Chair briefly introduced report HPS.116 and welcomed the Chair of the Scrutiny Panel for the Repatriation of Services from Public to the Council, Councillor John Francis.
Said18 Jul 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Review - Transition Plan Report
Councillor John Francis said there needs to be a way of collaboration with the other authorities when it comes to the transfer of services.
Said18 Jul 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Review - Transition Plan Report
Councillor Francis stated the recommendations within the report are supported but the following should be considered by Cabinet when making their decision and more importantly at the implementation stage, if progressed.
Said18 Jul 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Review - Transition Plan Report
Councillor Francis advised that phase 1 would approximately cost £100,000. There may be some savings to be had, however it was prudent to ensure the costings were robust.
Named18 Jul 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Publica Review - Transition Plan Report
The Chair thanked Councillor Francis for the panel’s consideration and input.
Said11 Jun 2024Development Management Committee
P0271/24/OUT - Land West Side of Church Road, Longhope
Ward Members Speaking Councillor John Francis urged members to strongly consider the officer recommendation believing the scale of the development is completely out of context considering the ribbon of development that exists along Church Road. The proposals proximity to the conservation area is inappropriate and there are many issues with flooding. This development would negate any wildlife gains and have a detrimental impact to the area.
Named30 May 2024Full Council
Councillor Appointment to outside body - 'Our Forest'
Councillor John Francis nominated Councillor Simon Phelps.
Said9 Apr 2024Development Management Committee
P1348/23/FUL Barn At Meredith Lane, Tibberton
Ward Members Speaking Councillor John Francis advised the view of the Parish Council is to support the application. The prominent view of the existing building is not in keeping with the nearby listed building; however, the proposed scheme will enhance the visual amenity and sit better in the landscape. Therefore, urged members to approve this application.
Asked9 Apr 2024Development Management Committee
P0015/24/OUT Land At The Swan Ledbury Road, Staunton
Questions Councillor John Francis asked for clarification on the importance of the Chartist site and main reasons they have given for refusal?
Said19 Mar 2024Development Management Committee
P0971/23/FUL - Little Millend, Clearwell
Debate Councillor John Francis said any business plan changes over time because of the external costs incurred by the business. After consideration of the finances, there does not appear to be enough money to pay back the commercial mortgage or to support the business, so would suggest removing the holiday let clause.
Said19 Mar 2024Development Management Committee
P1710/23/FUL - Land to the East of Church Road, Longhope
Ward Members Speaking Councillor John Francis stated that his main concerned was the flooding risk to this development and others downstream with flooding occurring several times over the past 20 years. It was also thought that the new houses were not in keeping with other buildings in Longhope with residents expressing concerns about the layout and design. There needs to be consideration of the intrusion of privacy of all the houses that this scheme builds behind.
Said12 Mar 2024Development Management Committee
P0971/23/FUL - Little Millend, Clearwell
Debate Councillor John Francis said any business plan changes over time because of the external costs incurred by the business. After consideration of the finances, there does not appear to be enough money to pay back the commercial mortgage or to support the business, so would suggest removing the holiday let clause.
Said12 Mar 2024Development Management Committee
P1710/23/FUL - Land to the East of Church Road, Longhope
Ward Members Speaking Councillor John Francis stated that his main concerned was the flooding risk to this development and others downstream with flooding occurring several times over the past 20 years. It was also thought that the new houses were not in keeping with other buildings in Longhope with residents expressing concerns about the layout and design. There needs to be consideration of the intrusion of privacy of all the houses that this scheme builds behind.
Named7 Mar 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny panel - Repatriation of Publica Services
Councillor John Francis updated the Committee regarding the Scrutiny Panel for repatriation of services from Publica to the Council. He advised that the panel met on the 26 February and viewed the draft terms of reference. He was recommending them to the Scrutiny Committee to agree.
Named22 Feb 2024Full Council
Chief Executive Officer's Updates
First meeting of the Scrutiny Panel Chaired by Councillor John Francis is to be held on Monday 26 February 2024 to agree the Terms of Reference.
Seconded12 Dec 2023Development Management Committee
P0397/23/FUL - Land Off Varnister Ruardean
Councillor John Francis seconded.
Said14 Nov 2023Development Management Committee
P0971/23/FUL - Little Millend, Mill End, Clearwell.
Councillor John Francis stated that if the holiday let was still making money it wouldn’t make sense for the owner to apply for a change of use so would be supportive of the change of use to a residential dwelling.
Asked2 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Forestry England Update
Councillor John Francis asked how the Forestry are preparing for the risk of forest fires now that the climate is increasing in temperature. Would Cannop Ponds be a source of water in such an event?
Asked10 Oct 2023Development Management Committee
P1034/23/FUL – Land at Sunnybank, Elton Lane, Elton GL14 1JJ
Member Questions Councillor John Francis asked about a previous application requesting a passing places on the lane.
Said12 Sep 2023Development Management Committee
P1266/21/FUL Land at Church Road, Longhope.
Councillor John Francis stated that his main concern was still the flooding aspect due to the history of flooding on Church Road. He advised that he was a great supporter of affordable housing, but still thought that this was the wrong site.
Said12 Sep 2023Development Management Committee
P0278/23/FUL Copperfields, Yartleton Lane, May Hill, Longhope.
Councillor John Francis noted that the current property is not fit for purpose and needs demolishing. He advised in his opinion that although there are concerns for the height of this property, he urged the committee to be bold and looked to support this type of development.
Said8 Aug 2023Development Management Committee
P1266/21/FUL Land At Church Road, Longhope
Ward Members Speaking Councillor John Francis stated that his view had not changed since the July meeting reiterating that he felt this development was in the wrong place due to the risk of flooding and the ecology of the site.
Said2 Aug 2023Full Council
Huntley Neighbourhood Development Plan
Debate Councillor John Francis stated there had been a lot of work in this, with community input resulting in differing opinions, however have worked very hard to put this together and give themselves a clear direction for the future.
Said27 Jul 2023Full Council
Huntley Neighbourhood Development Plan
Debate Councillor John Francis stated there had been a lot of work in this, with community input resulting in differing opinions, however have worked very hard to put this together and give themselves a clear direction for the future.
Said11 Jul 2023Development Management Committee
P1266/21/FUL Land At Church Road Longhope
Ward Members Speaking Councillor John Francis stated although favourable of the Community Land Trust, the question remained as to whether the site was suitable. There are many differing views on ecology and drainage, which were not applicable to the site but questioned if the drainage systems will be able to cope in adverse weather.
Said11 Jul 2023Development Management Committee
P1266/21/FUL Land At Church Road Longhope
Councillor Francis said on balance, ecology and the long-term drainage aspect needs to be seriously considered before a decision could be reached.
Said11 Jul 2023Development Management Committee
P1775/22/FUL Land Adjoining Lonehead, Little London
Councillor John Francis said planning constraints inform what can and cannot be done on the site and would not be supporting the application.
Said13 Jun 2023Development Management Committee
P01249/22/OUT Yew Tree Inn, Longhope
There were no speakers Ward Members Speaking Councillor John Francis stated he had no objection to the proposal.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.