Named7 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 1 Report
34.1 The Cabinet Member for Resources, Councillor Wilson, introduced the report by reminding Members that this was the first time that this report had been available for publication by the deadline since the cyber-attack in 2021. He stated that new budget monitoring processes had been introduced and as a result, the Statement of Accounts for 2025/26 included a complete balance sheet of reconciliation and that the figures presented were for a closed year. He also informed that the largest issues for Q1 were parking, commercial property, cemeteries and the crematorium.
Said7 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 1 Report
Councillor Wilson highlighted a previously identified issue of the car park signage being inadequate and making it unintuitive for potential users to locate. He added that this was actively being rectified to increase usage.
Said7 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 1 Report
Councillor Wilson informed that previously, agreements with vendors had been drawn up on an individual basis but that this had now been streamlined to a standard agreement. He highlighted that the indoor market would be moving soon which signified a big change and improvements in the long term. He explained that this imminent move made it difficult to justify investments in the current location which would cease to be used.
Said7 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 1 Report
Councillor Wilson responded that it was predominantly due to age related issues; with the current cremators on year 35 of a 15-year life span. He assured that the cremators were functioning robustly, however, acquiring spare parts was a difficulty. He assured that mitigation plans were in discussion and keeping the ... view the full minutes text for item 34.
Named7 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Bringing Parking Enforcement Services In-House through TUPE Transfer
36.1 Councillor Wilson clarified the purpose of the report was to deliberate the next steps in the management of parking operations. He highlighted the options were to; bring management in-house, continue with the existing operator or look for alternative operators. He added that the current contract had been due to expire but that an extension was agreed whilst next options were considered.
Named7 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Bringing Parking Enforcement Services In-House through TUPE Transfer
Councillor Wilson voiced agreement with this, adding that they were not achieving best value for money with the current arrangement.
Said7 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Bringing Parking Enforcement Services In-House through TUPE Transfer
Councillor Wilson explained the intention was to retain the existing staff under Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) (TUPE), which would ensure the knowledge would continue, only the contract holder would change. He added that with the potential realisation of LGR, the logical decision would be to bring all operations in house under one uniform system.
Said7 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Bringing Parking Enforcement Services In-House through TUPE Transfer
Councillor Wilson confirmed that they would take all aspects into consideration.
Said26 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Private Sector Stock Condition Survey
In response to a follow-up query from Councillor Morgan, Councillor Wilson advised Members that interest on regular loans was not compatible with the Islamic faith and that ethical loans provided an alternative offering for the Muslim community.
Said26 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 3 Report
108.4 Councillor Wilson noted that the shortfalls in the in the Q3 Financial Monitoring Report and Money Plan recently considered by Council appeared to be different, with a forecast deficit of £349k in the Money Plan and a predicted deficit in the Q3 Financial Monitoring Report of £683k. He asked which document was the most up to date. The Head of Finance and Resources confirmed that both reports should be seen in parallel, with the Financial Monitoring Report providing retrospective figures and the Money Plan looking forward.
Asked26 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 3 Report
108.5 Councillor Wilson asked whether this suggested that the financial situation had deteriorated by £334k, or whether the deficits were not comparable. The Head of Finance and Resources confirmed that the figures were comparable, and that the Council was still expecting the deficit to continue to reduce towards the outturn of the financial year.
Named26 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 3 Report
108.6 In response to a further question from Councillor Wilson as to whether the forecast deficit in the Money Plan papers was too optimistic, the Head of Finance and Resources confirmed that in his view, the Council was not being too optimistic and that he expected the figures to align more closely in the remaining financial quarter.
Said26 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Future Opportunities for the Fleece
109.4 Councillor Wilson stated his view that the proposals were worthwhile, but noted that he wondered why the Phoenix Village Project were particularly interested in the Fleece site. He highlighted that development of the site would be a large, expensive and demanding project.
Said26 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2022-2024 Council Plan Six Month Update
110.4 Councillor Wilson noted that the action around supporting the recommendations of the Commission to Review Race Relations had been delayed and requested further information as to why, The Managing Director confirmed that the legacy organisation which emerged from the Race Commission’s work was newly formed and were still establishing their objectives. He advised that Officers had met with the organisation and they had confirmed that they no longer operated under the ‘GREAG’ name, however they were working to establish a business plan.
Named7 Feb 2024Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of questions 8 and 9 Councillor Wilson ... view the full minutes text for item 80.
Asked5 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Lease of Land at Hempsted Meadow
94.6 In respect of the narrative at 3.6 and the fixed rate income, Councillor Wilson asked whether the proposed long-term lease arrangement would be index linked.
Asked5 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Lease of Land at Hempsted Meadow
94.7 Councillor Wilson asked what the Council’s powers would be in the event of another pandemic.
Named5 Feb 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Leisure Services Update
97.10 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson regarding which facilities had been reopened since the closure of Aspire Leisure, Councillor Lewis advised that all facilities had been reopened apart from the GL1 sauna.
Asked10 Jan 2024Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 9 Councillor Wilson sought clarification of exactly when the draft accounts would be published given their importance.
Named10 Jan 2024Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources apologised for not previously advising the Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee (Cllr Wilson) of the change in priorities regarding the auditors. She stated that she was about to meet the Head of Finance and Resources to discuss the timetable and would share the outcome.
Asked10 Jan 2024Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 10 Councillor Wilson queried whether the draft accounts were still on course to be published before the May 2024 local elections. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that the intention was still to publish them before purdah so that they could be debated at Council in March.
Said8 Jan 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Peer Challenge Action Plan Progress Report
76.7 Councillor Wilson expressed his disappointment at the statements around Member behaviour.
Named8 Jan 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) Gloucester Urban Greening Project
77.4 In relation to a query from Councillor Wilson regarding the maintenance costs associated with the project, Councillor Cook confirmed that these would need to come out of Council’s normal budget, and that it was unlikely that the Council would be able to reclaim for administrative costs.
Named8 Jan 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Cemetery Rules and Regulations Review
78.6 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative at 3.2 and the proposal that no glass of any kind should be placed on the graves. He asked whether ornaments, such as glass jars, would be permitted.
Named8 Jan 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Proposed Sale of Land at Podsmead for the Purpose of Commencing Regeneration
79.4 Councillor Wilson referred to the planned demolition of 64 existing homes and asked whether residents of those homes would have guaranteed allocation of new homes in the estate. The City Growth and Delivery Manager confirmed that these residents would be given first choice on the new homes but would be able to opt to move out of the estate if they so wished.
Named8 Jan 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Proposed Sale of Land at Podsmead for the Purpose of Commencing Regeneration
79.5 In response to a further question from Councillor Wilson regarding the allocation of homes to families, the City Growth and Delivery Manager confirmed that the responsibility for housing allocation would remain with GCH, and that they would undertake housing needs assessments accordingly.
Asked8 Jan 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Proposed Sale of Land at Podsmead for the Purpose of Commencing Regeneration
79.6 Councillor Wilson asked for clarification as to the number of new homes included in the scheme.
Asked6 Dec 2023Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 14 Councillor Wilson sought clarification on whether the potential sale was driven by anyone else. The Leader of the Council reiterated that the issue was to have been addressed in the fullness of time anyway but that as an approach had been made the opportunity was being assessed.
Said27 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Point Item
65.3 Councillor Wilson noted that he shared Councillor Dee’s view and expressed that he found the proposed design disappointing.
Named27 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Point Item
In response to additional comments from Councillor Wilson, the Chair pointed out that the design proposals did include a plaque to provide context.
Asked27 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Community Safety Overview
66.5 Councillor Wilson asked whether the Community Wellbeing Team structure chart could be circulated to Members, to which Community Wellbeing Team Leader agreed that she would be happy to do so though the Democratic Services team.
Named27 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Community Safety Overview
66.6 In response to an additional question from Councillor Wilson regarding the Street Aware and Safer Streets Officers, the Community Wellbeing explained that these were different roles with different responsibilities.
Named27 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Community Safety Overview
66.7 In response to a further question from Councillor Wilson regarding the amount of time the Community Wellbeing team spent submitting bids, the Community Wellbeing Team Leader confirmed that bid writing did take up a significant amount of time when funding became available, as there was a need to be reactive when funding submissions opened.
Named27 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 2 Report
67.6 Councillor Wilson referred to the £500k utility charge for Aspire Trust and asked whether the Council had managed to recover any of this debt. The Head of Finance and Resources confirmed that this £500k was an historic debt from the previous financial year.
Named27 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 2 Report
In response to a further question from Councillor Wilson as to whether there was any possibility of the Council reclaiming any of this money, the Head of Finance and Resources noted that this was a possibility however it was dependent on the Aspire Leisure Trust’s liquidators.
Named27 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Report on the Impact of the Cyber Incident and the Lessons Learnt
68.4 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative in the report at 12.1 and the statement that the configuration of some systems had been customised by external consultants. He asked whether this had the potential to make the Council’s systems weaker if this happened in the future. The Managing Director noted that one positive arising following the incident was that the Council’s backups were still intact.
Asked8 Nov 2023Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 9 Councillor Wilson queried whether the 13.1% in the response should be a ratio rather than a percentage as the former was used by the Moody’s ratings agency in their rankings. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources invited the Head of Finance and Resources to respond. The Head of Finance and Resources confirmed that it should be a ratio but would double check.
Asked8 Nov 2023Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 10 Councillor Wilson sought more detail on how far the Council was from issuing a S114 Notice. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources ... view the full minutes text for item 40.
Said30 Oct 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Temporary Accommodation Acquisition Programme
57.5 Councillor Wilson expressed the view that the report was a good one and that he felt that the proposals were the right thing to do. He asked whether, even with increased interests rates, increasing the Council’s temporary accommodation through capital investments was cheaper than the current approach. The Corporate Director replied that it was, and that the Housing Innovation Manager was working closely with the Finance Team.
Said3 Oct 2023Planning Committee
Flat 1, 15 Green Lane, Gloucester GL3 3QT - 23/00341/FUL
Councillor Wilson addressed the Committee and made the following comments:
Named25 Sep 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucestershire Airport - September 2023 Update
40.2 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative in the presentation regarding improving communication with tenants and asked whether there had been an improvement in relations. The Airport Director confirmed that in his view, relationships with tenants were in a better place. He explained that the Chairman of Gloucestershire Airport had asked him to focus on customer relationships as a key priority, and that he had held face to face meetings with all key tenants with indications of progress.
Asked25 Sep 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucestershire Airport - September 2023 Update
40.3 Councillor Wilson asked for further information around training opportunities for air traffic controllers and commercial pilots.
Named25 Sep 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucestershire Airport - September 2023 Update
40.4 In response to a further question from Councillor Wilson regarding finances and the airport’s profit, the Interim Head of Finance confirmed that the airport had seen additional consultancy costs for the CGX development, and associated marketing and data collection costs had had an impact on the 2022/23 profits.
Named17 Jul 2023Audit and Governance Committee
Appointment of Chair and Vice-Chair
RESOLVED that:- The Audit and Governance Committee NOTE the appointments of Councillor Wilson and Councillor Gravells as Chair and Vice-Chair of the Committee.
Said3 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Blackbridge Sports Hub
20.5 Councillor Wilson commented that the scheme was impressive and uplifting, and expressed the view that a community sports hub would be a positive contribution to the city. He further noted that BCCBS should be commended for raising so much money for the scheme.
Named3 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Blackbridge Sports Hub
Councillor Wilson referred to 3.11 in the report and requested clarification as to access arrangements which the Asset Management Officer provided.
Asked3 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2022-23 Financial Outturn Report
21.4 Referring to paragraph 2.2(1)v in the report, Councillor Wilson asked how long it was likely to take for the volume of data to be fully analysed and reconciled. The Head of Finance and Resources confirmed that the process of re-hydrating the financial systems for 2021-22 was complete, and that the Finance Team were in the process of producing the 2021-2022 end of year accounts. He explained that once this was complete, the Finance Team would be able to work on the 2022-23 financial year.
Named3 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2022-23 Financial Outturn Report
21.5 Councillor Wilson referred to the challenges caused by high inflation and the pandemic and noted his understanding that the Council had used the VAT shelter to hedge against the interest rate rises. He asked whether the rates had risen more than expected, to which the Head of Finance replied that they had. He confirmed that the Council had taken out short term borrowing to cover year 1, with rates expected to return to more normal levels over the next few years.
Named3 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2022-23 Financial Outturn Report
21.6 In response to an additional query from Councillor Wilson, the Head of Finance and Resources confirmed that the Council was still working within the expected parameters.
Said3 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Annual Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee 2022-23
22.2 Councillor Wilson expressed his view that the report provided a good summary of the Committee’s achievements over the year.
Asked14 Jun 2023Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 15 Councillor Wilson asked if his understanding was correct that the H-Drive had been intended only for officer’s personal working documents. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources responded that this was her understanding too and asked the Managing Director for clarification. The Managing Director advised that although this was the case, at the time of the cyber incident some staff, having received unclear guidance, had documents on the H-Drive that should have been on a shared drive.
Asked14 Jun 2023Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 16 Councillor Wilson sought clarification on when the investigation report would be shared with Members. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources commented that a timeline was not ready yet as a key officer at the time had since retired but she reassured Members that a timeline would be available within a month. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources further advised that there would probably be a report for the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, focused on the experience of the public, and one for the Audit and Governance Committee with an emphasis on internal ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Named5 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Community Asset Transfer (CAT) Policy
9.10 Councillor Wilson ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Named5 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2022-2024 Year End Council Plan Update
10.5 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative around the plan to set up an in-house Home Improvement Agency and requested clarification as to whether progress on implementing this agency was delayed as a result of the cyber incident alone, or whether it had been delayed prior to the incident. The Housing Innovation Manager confirmed that the delays had been caused by the cyber incident, however as the recovery had progressed, the team now hoped to bring this action forward.
Named5 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2022-2024 Year End Council Plan Update
10.6 In response to a further query from Councillor Wilson regarding progress made on the Gloucester Digital Strategy, Councillor Norman noted that the Officers responsible for overseeing this strategy had been focusing on the recovery from the cyber incident. The Managing Director confirmed that ongoing conversations were taking place regarding a digital strategy for Gloucestershire, and Officers were deliberating on whether it might be sensible to wait for the outcome of the county-wide strategy discussions before progressing a refresh of the Gloucester Digital Strategy.
Asked5 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Blackfriars Priory Business Plan 2023-2028
11.6 Councillor Wilson asked for further information around the rationale behind not pursuing a 25-year lease straight away. He wondered whether ... view the full minutes text for item 11.
Named5 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Task and Finish Group Report – Damp and Mould
12.4 Councillor Wilson referred to the transfer of housing stock and asked whether the stock was of decent home standard. The Housing Innovation Manager reminded the Committee that the Task and Finish Group investigation and report was Member-led. He noted that he was aware of a small number of properties with problems however these tended to be linked to the age of the properties, with particular issues amongst homes built during the 1960s and 1970s.
Asked5 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Task and Finish Group Report – Damp and Mould
12.5 In respect of Recommendation 1, Councillor Wilson queried whether the City Council had sufficient resources to implement a landlord accreditation scheme. The Housing Innovation Manager noted that this had not been a priority in the past, however the idea would be to provide responsible landlords with accreditation confirming that they were good landlords.
Named24 Apr 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee Work Programme and Council Forward Plan
131.6 Councillor Wilson indicated that he would like the Committee to consider the 2022-23 Financial Outturn Report and it was agreed that this item would be added to the agenda for the Overview and Scrutiny meeting on 5 th June.
Named24 Apr 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Response to Corporate Peer Challenge
133.5 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative in the full Corporate Peer Challenge report at 4.4 and the statements that ‘consideration should be given as to whether resources in the Finance Team were sufficient to deliver the Quarter 3 and Quarter 4 budget monitoring reports’ and that ‘additional capacity’ may be needed. He asked for further information as to what had caused the peer review team to reach this conclusion.
Named27 Mar 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Integrated Care System Update
121.5 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative in the presentation concerning the development of a Gloucestershire Citizens Panel and asked for further information as to how the panel would operate. The Integrated Care Board Chief Executive confirmed that the ICB were in the process of advertising for representatives and would be in a position to provide further information over the next few months.
Named27 Mar 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Annual Equality Diversity and Inclusion Report 2022-23
122.7 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson regarding People Impact Assessments (PIA) and whether this was a statutory obligation, the Policy and Development Officer explained that a PIA screening process needed to be completed for every City Council report which considered the impact on protected characteristics. He noted that if any protected characteristics were identified, then ... view the full minutes text for item 122.
Asked27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Points Arising from Previous Meetings
102.6 Councillor Wilson queried how members of the public would be able to view the meeting recordings.
Said27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Points Arising from Previous Meetings
102.7 Councillor Wilson commented that the City Council was one of two of the Gloucestershire Councils which did not have webcasting facilities in place and noted that he was pleased that a concept had been identified.
Named27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 3 Report
104.2 Councillor Wilson referred to the Key Performance Indicator concerning the footfall at the Museum of Gloucester (CD & VE-1) and the narrative in the report noting that the exhibition programme had reached its income target for 2022/23 by the end of December 2022.
Named27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 3 Report
104.4 In response to a question from Councillor Wilson concerning PG-24 and the percentage of information governance responses compliant with statutory deadlines, Councillor Norman confirmed that it was possible that if a small number of individuals made a high volume of information requests, this could have an impact on response times.
Named27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 3 Report
104.5 In response to a follow-up query from Councillor Wilson, Councillor Norman explained that where several complex requests were issued to a particular service area, this could potentially cause a pressure point. She expressed the view that Members were privileged to have good working relationships with Officers and encouraged Members who were looking for information to interact with Officers at first instance before making an information governance request.
Named27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucester Monuments Review Implementation Update
106.4 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative in the report at 5.1 stating that ‘the first year of the implementation has seen mixed results.’ He expressed the view that the initial results were very positive and reflected on the challenges of implementing changes where the monuments were not in the ownership of the City Council, such as the United Reformed Church.
Said27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucester Monuments Review Implementation Update
Councillor Wilson noted that he was impressed with the progress to date and thanked the City Archaeologist for his work in attempting to implement the recommendations.
Asked27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucester Monuments Review Implementation Update
106.5 Councillor Wilson queried whether the Monuments Review implementation was putting pressure on the City Archaeologist’s workload. The City Archaeologist advised Members that the City Council had recently succeeded in obtaining some additional funding and it was hoped that this funding would be used to fund additional support from the Gloucestershire County Council Archaeology team.
Named27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucester Monuments Review Implementation Update
106.6 In response to an additional question from Councillor Wilson regarding the artefacts pertaining to George Whitefield, the City Archaeologist explained that the creation of the permanent display at the Museum of Gloucester had been delayed as a result of the cyber incident however Museum of Gloucester staff had obtained the relevant artefacts. He noted that he was grateful to colleagues at the Museum of Gloucester for their assistance.
Named27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucester Monuments Review Implementation Update
106.7 In response to a further query from Councillor Wilson, the City Archaeologist explained that the University of Gloucestershire had already funded some research and that he was cautiously optimistic that they would agree to funding the consultation exercise for education or interpretation projects.
Named27 Feb 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Cultural Strategy Update
107.3 Councillor Wilson referred to cultural events which had taken place at Kings Square and asked whether there were plans to repeat successful events from 2022, such as Polish Heritage Day, and whether there were plans for any new events in 2023.
Said30 Jan 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee Work Programme and Council Forward Plan
Councillor Wilson noted his interest in this item, as it was his understanding that few other Councils operated a similar Here to Help system.
Named30 Jan 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucester City Commission to Review Race Relations - Year One Update
94.6 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson as to whether the set of proposed goals had been agreed, the Policy ... view the full minutes text for item 94.
Named30 Jan 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Purple Flag Briefing
95.3 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative in the update concerning the overnight 12-hour assessment and asked whether judges would stay for the full duration. The City Centre Manager confirmed that the judges would stay for the full duration as every element of the night-time economy would be assessed, including taxi martialling, dispersal, security cameras and street medic coordination. He noted that this assessment was undertaken twice annually, once through the City Council and subsequently Purple Flag.
Named9 Jan 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Car Parking - Tariff Increase Report
80.5 Councillor Wilson referred to the proposed Car Parking Tariffs in Appendix 1 and observed that the proposed tariff increase for residents parking for 1 hour or less would be significantly higher than the other bands. He asked whether thought had been given to a more moderate increase across the bands.
Named9 Jan 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Car Parking - Tariff Increase Report
80.6 In response to further comments from Councillor Wilson regarding 1-hour tariff options still being offered by some authorities including Cheltenham and Worcester, the Director of Policy and Resources confirmed that Worcester City Council were also intending to review their car parking tariff banding.
Named9 Jan 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Car Parking - Tariff Increase Report
80.7 In response to an additional question from Councillor Wilson regarding on-street parking provision from Gloucestershire County Council, Councillor Norman confirmed that short stay on-street parking was available in designated ... view the full minutes text for item 80.
Named9 Jan 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Annual Report for Energy Costs and Energy Reduction Projects
81.3 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative at 3.6 and 3.7 in the report concerning commodity prices and commented that it was good to note that the City Council had procured commodity prices for 2023/24 at 61% below current market rates. He asked when the council’s contract with West Mercia Energy (WME) was initially put in place, and when the council was required to negotiate a new contract. The Director of Policy and Resources agreed to follow-up this information and provide the committee with clarification in due course.
Named28 Nov 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee Work Programme and Council Forward Plan
Councillor Wilson and the Chair indicated their support for this idea, and it was agreed that this item would be added to the Work Programme.
Named28 Nov 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 2 Report - 2022/23
61.4 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson relating to CWB-13 and the percentage of compliant food premises, the Financial Services Manager confirmed that Councillor Wilson was correct that food inspection visits were still being undertaken however there were ongoing issues with recording the data due to the cyber incident.
Asked28 Nov 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 2 Report - 2022/23
61.5 Councillor Wilson asked whether this data would be backdated. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that it would be, however she was not yet in a position to confirm the date as to when this data would be available.
Asked28 Nov 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 2 Report - 2022/23
61.7 Councillor Wilson asked whether the target time of 1 minute 55 seconds included the amount of time taken to read out the prompt message, The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that she would follow-up the query ... view the full minutes text for item 61.
Named28 Nov 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Affordable Homes Delivery - Update on Performance
62.5 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative at 3.22 in the report regarding the requirement in the Joint Strategic Plan that 35% of new homes built on the boundary of Gloucester and Tewkesbury should be affordable homes, and asked how legally enforceable this provision was. The Head of Place confirmed that as this was a policy, this was not enforceable by law but would be something that Officers would carefully consider alongside other planning considerations. The Housing Innovation Manager added that there were many planning balances that Officers needed to look at when assessing an application.
Named31 Oct 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Task and Finish Group Report - Engagement with Young People
52.7 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson, the Policy and Development Officer explained that there had been challenges with consulting young ... view the full minutes text for item 52.
Said3 Oct 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Points Arising From Previous Meetings
39.1 In noting the action point, Councillor Wilson stated that he was pleased the motion on tree planting was being actioned and asked if a map was available regarding where trees would be planted.
Asked3 Oct 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Environmental Crime Enforcement Update
41.5 Councillor Wilson asked whether 3GS would lose money as a result of being successful in its enforcement activity.
Said7 Sep 2022General Purposes Committee
Constitutional Changes
Councillor Wilson stated that he largely supported the proposed criteria for rejecting questions, in particular questions those relating to officers, but had reservations about preventing Members from asking similar questions within in a six month period. He also sought assurance that Members would be able to continue asking questions about matters where the Council had a role as an influencer rather than a decision-maker. He commented on the proposal to limit five questions per Member and suggested that in would better to limit the number of supplementary questions that Members could ask.
Named5 Sep 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Points Arising From Previous Meetings
28.1 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson as to when it was likely that the IDOX application would be restored, the Director of Policy and Resources confirmed that it was hoped that the application would be available towards the end of the week.
Said5 Sep 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Points Arising From Previous Meetings
28.5 Councillor Wilson requested that the full wording of notice of motions be provided in the agenda papers going forward.
Named5 Sep 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 1 Report 2022/23
30.4 Councillor Wilson referred to H-25 and the narrative confirming that 22 affordable homes had been delivered during Quarter 1 with 199 affordable homes scheduled to be delivered in total during 2022/23. Noting that there were ongoing supply chain issues in the construction industry, he asked whether there was a realistic chance of delivering the rest of the promised ... view the full minutes text for item 30.
Said4 Jul 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Homes for Ukraine - Gloucester Housing Update
19.6 Councillor Wilson expressed the view that the report was a reassuring read. In relation to the narrative concerning rematching, he asked whether it was likely that there will be instances of people needing to be rematched and if so, whether the Council had the resources to find alternative accommodation. The Housing Innovation Manager confirmed that the UK as a whole had started to see an increase in the number of guests and sponsors requesting a rematch and although not as great, the Housing Teams were seeing a slow increase in Gloucestershire.
Said6 Jun 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Point Item
6.1 Councillor Wilson requested a meeting with the Director of Policy and Resources to discuss some queries he had concerning the information provided by Gloucestershire Airport.
Asked6 Jun 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Year End Report 2021-22
8.4 Councillor Wilson queried why the annual target was still set at 2 minutes when response times back in 2020 sat around the 1-minute mark. He expressed the view that the Council should be more ambitious in setting waiting time targets. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources explained that although in her view the waiting time figures were healthy, sometimes cases were complex, and a Customer Services officer might be on a call for 15-20 minutes dealing with a complex query which could sometimes create a bottleneck.
Said6 Apr 2022Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 1 Councillor Wilson advised that some trees had been planted in inappropriate positions on Hucclecote Green. He sought reassurance that volunteer groups would not be left alone to rectify such situations and that in this case the Friends of Hucclecote Green would be assisted.
Asked6 Apr 2022Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 2 Councillor Wilson sought confirmation that the City’s own tree planting budget could be carried forward into the 2022/23 financial year irrespective of the deadline required to spend the grant money received for the same purpose. The Cabinet Member for Environment confirmed that the budget in question would be carried forward.
Asked28 Mar 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucestershire Airport Update
120.3 Councillor Wilson asked for clarification as to what the Airport’s main income streams were. The Managing Director confirmed that the main income streams were landing fees, fuel sales and rental income through the Airport’s business parks. She confirmed that Air Traffic Control was not a major income source.
Named28 Mar 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucestershire Airport Update
120.4 In response to a follow-up question from Councillor Wilson, the Managing Director confirmed that fuel sales could amount to up to 50% of the Airport’s income, however this was dependent on the time of year.
Named28 Mar 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Gloucestershire Airport Update
120.5 Councillor Wilson referred to the presentation and the comments concerning the use of drones. He referred to a previous incident involving drones at Gatwick Airport and asked whether there were any safety concerns with using drones in an airport environment. He also asked for clarification as to the relationship between drones and green initiatives.
Named7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Internal audit activity progress report
50.4 In response to a question from Councillor Wilson regarding how they were assisting Council services in response to the Cyber Incident, the Internal Auditor stated that, at the start of the Cyber Incident, work around processes were put in place, that they were currently undertaking a data exercise and that they had been liaising and working with the finance team. The Audit Risk and Assurance Group Manager added that since January, they had temporarily suspended their work due to the understanding of the position the Council was in. She added that they had been in contact with officers from Revenues and Benefits weekly.
Said7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Internal audit activity progress report
50.5 Councillor Wilson stated that his concern was that the controlled environment that existed before the Cyber Incident would be compromised and confirmed that he was reassured by the points made by the Internal Auditor and Audit Risk and Assurance Group Manager. He stated that it was his assumption that dealing with the Cyber Incident was taking up a lot of officer time. He said that some items contained in the year’s programme would have to rolled over into the next financial year.
Named7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Internal audit activity progress report
50.7 In response to a question from Councillor Wilson regarding whether it was feasible that some ... view the full minutes text for item 50.
Named7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Internal audit plan 2022-23
51.2 In response to a question from Councillor Wilson in regards to the Cyber Incident Support Audit referenced in the plan, the Internal Auditor stated that the Audit could take a variety of shapes. He stated that it could be a report, or consultancy work and that he could not yet confirm whether it would take the form of a formal report.
Named7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Internal audit plan 2022-23
51.3 In response to a question from Councillor Wilson, the Audit Risk and Assurance Group Manager stated that the Cyber Incident was not necessarily the biggest risk to delivering the Internal Audit Plan but that the incident meant that they may have to continuously adapt their work.
Asked7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Internal audit plan 2022-23
51.4 Councillor Wilson asked whether the external auditors had been kept up to date in regard to the Cyber Incident. In response, the Financial Services Manager replied that they had been having regular conversations with external auditors.
Said7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Treasury management strategy 2022/23
52.3 Councillor Wilson noted that he believed that the Treasury Management Strategy was prudent and risk averse, which he believed was the smartest course of action considering the wider economic/political situation.
Said7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Capital strategy 2022/23
53.2 Councillor Wilson noted that the report mentioned revenue budget implications. He stated that Capital projects had complicated depreciation values, and he asked whether there would be a potential impact whilst calculations were being done manually. In response the Financial Services Manager stated that this was something that was being looked at but prior year calculations were available to officers.
Said7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Audit and Governance Committee Work Programme
57.1 Councillor Wilson stated that the work programme only covered the next Audit meeting. He stated that there would be a work programme for the rest of the year provided at the next Committee meeting, when it became clearer where they were in regards to the Cyber Incident.
Said7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Audit and Governance Committee Work Programme
57.2 Councillor Wilson stated that in regards to the requirement to appoint an Independent Member, he understood why this had not yet happened owing to delays caused by the COVID-19 pandemic and the Cyber Incident but noted that it would soon be a requirement and that he would like to have it resolved by the next Audit Committee meeting.
Said7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Audit and Governance Committee Work Programme
57.4 Councillor Wilson noted that there was an issue with signing off Annual Accounts for auditing purposes across the country, predominantly as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Named7 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Audit and Governance Committee Work Programme
57.5 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson regarding the Annual Accounts, the Financial Services Manager confirmed that he would inform the Chair of the Audit Committee when the accounts were to be signed off.
Named28 Feb 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 3 Report
109.6 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative at 4.2 concerning the December cyber incident and commented that the incident had resulted in a swing of ... view the full minutes text for item 109.
Named28 Feb 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 3 Report
110.7 Councillor Wilson referred to the missing Quarter 3 data and asked whether it was likely that the data was permanently lost as a result of the cyber incident. The Director of Policy and Resources confirmed his understanding that the data back-ups had worked, and that the data should not be permanently lost.
Asked9 Feb 2022Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 2 Councillor Wilson asked if the other sources of funding and earmarked reserves referred to in the response had been identified yet. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that the route to recovery and its requirements were still being formulated.
Named9 Feb 2022Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
She reassured Councillor Wilson that these would be shared with Group Leaders when known.
Asked9 Feb 2022Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In respect of question 3 Councillor Wilson sought clarification on whether the cyber incident review would be independent. The Leader of the Council replied that although he believed an independent review might be beneficial, the decision would be taken when the recovery stage had progressed. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources pointed out that independent advice was being received as part of the recovery process so that an independent element might well be seen in any kind of review.
Said31 Jan 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Task and Finish Group Discussion
96.3 Councillor Pullen and Councillor Wilson confirmed that they felt that a Taskand Finish Groupfocusing on youngpeople wasa priority.
Named31 Jan 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Events and Festivals Report on 2021 and Plan for 2022-23
98.4 Councillor Wilson referred to the narrative at 3.8 confirming that the previouscarnival artspartnership hadnot appliedfor fundingfor GloucesterCarnival in2022 andasked whetherthere wasa concernthat thecarnival wascoming to an end. The Cabinet Member for Culture and Leisure confirmedthat there were some challenges posed by health and safety requirementsduring thepandemic butnoted thatthere wereproposals beingdeveloped fora different approach in thefuture.
Said10 Jan 2022Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Task and Finish Group Discussion
86.2 Councillor Wilson noted that in his experience, the most successful Task and Finish Groups were tightly focused on a specific issue. He suggested that food hygiene and safety challenges in the city might be an interesting issue for a Task and Finish Group to look into . He also suggested a Task and Finish Group reviewing how gambling licenses were issued in the city as a potential option.
Asked6 Dec 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Draft Money Plan 2022-27 & Budget Proposals for 2022/23
77.4 Councillor Wilson asked for the Cabinet Members’ views as to whether the assumptions contained in the Money Plan were over optimistic on inflation, referring to his understanding that the VAT shelter reserve increase was a one-off. The Head of Policy and Resources confirmed that the VAT shelter was a 15-year agreement following the stock transfer. He noted that the benefits were shared proportionately and were agreed at the point of the stock transfer.
Named29 Nov 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 2 Report
61.4 Councillor Wilson referred to the measure relating to average customer waiting time (CS-8). He noted that during the previous year, the average waiting time was 45 seconds – 1 minute which was considerably shorter than the current target of 2 minutes and asked why this was the case. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources explained that part of the reason for the reduced call volume during 2020 could be explained by people facing other challenges during lockdown.
Said29 Nov 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 2 Report
61.5 In response to additional concerns raised by Councillor Wilson regarding whether the current target was ambitious and whether officers were being challenged enough, the Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that she would share the feedback with the Head of Communities and Customer Services Manager at the next Cabinet Member briefing.
Said29 Nov 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Review of Office Accommodation
62.3 Councillor Wilson noted that he had first read about the proposals in the press. He referred to the Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources’ comments regarding favourable feedback from staff and asked how this feedback was gathered. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that the matter was raised by the Managing Director during a recent staff Q&A session.
Said29 Nov 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Review of Office Accommodation
62.4 Councillor Wilson requested clarification on the statement in the report that the option to relocate to the Eastgate was a temporary move subject to the review of long-term portfolio and office requirements. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources indicated that this wording alluded to the possibility of City Council staff returning to North Warehouse at some point in the future, however there was no option to end the tenancy contract with Regus in the short-term.
Said9 Nov 2021General Purposes Committee
Constitutional Changes
Councillor Wilson stated that he could not identify any benefits to changing the current approach to questions, as the proposals would result in more work for officers and barriers for the public, and Councillors would lose the ability to be spontaneous during meetings. He stated that the proposals would make the council less accountable to the public and would put members of the public off from engaging in the democratic process.
Said4 Oct 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Waste Street Scene and Grounds Maintenance Services - Transitional Progress
37.3 Councillor Wilson expressed the view that the most significant challenge for the service delivery was delivery of the appropriate fleet service vehicles, due to the UK-wide supply chain issues. He raised concerns that there was a possibility of the vehicles not arriving in time for the start of the new service contract in April 2022 and asked whether Ubico had any contingency plans in place to mitigate the risk.
Said4 Oct 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Draft Council Plan 2021-2024
38.3 Councillor Wilson expressed the view that there was little he disagreed with in the report and noted that the vision was a positive one.
Said4 Oct 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Draft Council Plan 2021-2024
Referring to promise set out in Priority 1 to tackle food poverty, Councillor Wilson raised concerns that this was a complex issue and that this could be an over-promise. He asked for further information on the specific steps which the Council would take to address the problem.
Said6 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Action Points Arising From Previous Meetings
23.6 Councillor Wilson noted his support for the idea and commented that it would be useful to have a review of action points from previous Council meetings.
Said6 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Membership of UK100 and Global Covenant of Mayors for Climate and Energy
25.5 Councillor Wilson welcomed the proposals and asked for further information about how the organisations would engage with the Council and how much of a role the Council would be expected to play.
Asked6 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Membership of UK100 and Global Covenant of Mayors for Climate and Energy
In relation to the mandatory monitoring reports referred to at 3.8(2) and 3.12, Councillor Wilson asked whether these reports could be combined to make the best use of resources.
Said6 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 1 Report
27.4 Councillor Wilson noted that the figures in performance indicator CS-6 indicated that around 45% of calls were being missed and invited comments from the Cabinet Member. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources explained that the definition of a ‘missed call’ was not necessarily always where the call had gone unanswered, but could also be where a call had been ended when the customer realised they needed a different department whilst in a queue. She noted that calls were also recorded as ‘missed’ where customers had left the queue because of time related reasons or where they had listened to prompts suggesting that the query could be addressed online instead.
Asked6 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 1 Report
27.5 Referring to the performance indicator relating to the percentage of broadly compliant food premises (CWB-13), Councillor Wilson asked whether the current value of 77% of food premises being broadly compliant with the required standards could be explained by officers carrying out checks more frequently, or whether more resources were needed in this area.
Asked6 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 1 Report
Councillor Wilson also asked for clarification as to whether the stickers were updated when it was found that a premises’ 5-star rating needed to be removed.
Said5 Jul 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2020-21 Financial Outturn Report
15.3 Councillor Wilson thanked Councillor Norman for the report and referred to the significant items of lost income included in the narrative at 5.1. He noted that the Government had supplied the Council with £ 4.5m in specific Covid-19 related funding but noted that the lost income figures appear to total £ 6.2m.
Asked5 Jul 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2020-21 Financial Outturn Report
Councillor Wilson asked for clarification as to how the Council had managed to fund the shortfall.
Named5 Jul 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2020-21 Financial Outturn Report
15.5 In response to a further question from Councillor Wilson about the Property Sinking Fund Reserve and the current earmarked balance of £ 300k, the Head of Policy and Resources confirmed that the Council previously aimed for the fund to reach £ 1m, however this was unlikely whilst the City was recovering from the Covid-19 pandemic. The Head of Policy and Resources noted that the Council may be in a different position in a few years.
Named7 Jun 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2020-21 Year End Performance Report
6.2 Councillor Wilson referred to the measure concerning the year-end Financial Outturn vs Budget (F-13), noting that this measure had been given PI warning status. He asked whether the warning status was based on Quarter 3 or Quarter 4 figures. The Head of Policy and Resources clarified that the figures refer to Quarter 3 and explained that Quarter 4 figures were still being calculated.
Said7 Jun 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2020-21 Year End Performance Report
Councillor Wilson welcomed the positive outlook on the Quarter 4 figures.
Named7 Jun 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2020-21 Year End Performance Report
6.3 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson regarding percentage of ‘broadly compliant’ food premises in the City (CWB-13) and that approximately one third of food premises were non-compliant in 2020/21, Councillor Norman noted that the Covid-19 pandemic had had some impact. The Head of Communities confirmed that the sample was targeted towards premises deemed as higher risk, rather than food premises where there were no previous concerns. She also noted that the Council was currently awaiting further guidance from the Food Standards Agency as to how samples should be taken going forward.
Named7 Jun 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee Work Programme and Council Forward Plan
7.4 Councillor Wilson referred to the Report by the Gloucester City Commission to Review Race Relations and noted that this is an important piece of work which the Overview and Scrutiny Committee should examine. It was agreed that this item be added to the Work Programme and agenda for the O&S meeting on 29 th November 2021. Supporting officers resolved to update the Work Programme and circulate it to Members following the meeting.
Said18 Jan 2021Audit and Governance Committee
Appointment of an Independent Member to the Audit and Governance Committee
Councillor Wilson stated that this seemed logical and Members were in agreement.
Asked11 Nov 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
Councillor Wilson asked if more information had come to light since an initial review by the consultants Grant Thornton of MGL which had failed to identify the detail of payments, including a £400,000 grant from the Gloucestershire Local Enterprise Partnership (Gfirst LEP), made by MGL in setting up its subsidiary the UK Digital Retail Innovation Centre Limited (UK:DRIC). The Leader of the Council answered by quoting from the MGL liquidator’s report to the effect that the grant appeared to have been spent on UK:DRIC transactions discharging the refurbishment costs of MGL’s premises which retain a value and concluding with the statement that Gfirst LEP was ` largely satisfied that the £400k was properly spent, and that officers within the LEP had seen documents supporting the expenditure as the project advanced.
Said11 Nov 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
Accordingly, we have not investigated this further at this stage .’ Councillor Wilson noted firstly that the liquidator’s report also found that these transactions were not recorded in as much detail as others and secondly that there were potential conflicts of interest with a person having been both a Director of Gfirst LEP and MGL and a Director of each being partners. He queried why assurances from the LEP were relied upon rather than the detail being shown. The Leader of ... view the full minutes text for item 44.
Asked14 Sep 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Public Question Time (15 minutes)
The minutes of that meeting state that " Councillor Wilson queried whether Councillor James had read the internal audit report in 2017 which followed on from the 2014 whistleblowing allegations.
Said15 Jul 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
Councillor Wilson noted that the Aspire Sports and Cultural Trust had announced the incremental re-opening of facilities commencing 25 th July 2020. He enquired if Members had met with them to assess their financial strength subsequent to the COVID-19 pandemic. The Leader of the Council confirmed that he was aware of the pressure Aspire was under but that no meetings with Members had taken place although officers were in regular contact.
Asked17 Jun 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
Councillor Wilson sought reassurance that any revenue shortfalls for local authorities during the COVID-19 pandemic were to be reimbursed by central government as had been implied by their public announcements and whether there was a plan in place should they not be. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that monthly accounts were being submitted and that the latest would be shared with opposition groups to make them aware of the current situation of the Council. She gave reassurance that the Leader of the Council, officers and herself were lobbying to receive a concrete plan for reimbursement beyond the £1.3 million already received and that Cabinet were considering how to manage portfolios in a range of best and worst case scenarios.
Named17 Jun 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
Councillor Wilson drew Members’ attention to the recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee (10 March 2020) concerning the former Marketing Gloucester Limited (MGL) and asked when they would be considered by Cabinet. The Cabinet Member for Culture and Leisure stated that the report by the MGL Interim Chief Executive discussed at that meeting would be brought to the next meeting (15 July 2020) and to the Overview and Scrutiny Committee before that. ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Said9 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Treasury Management Strategy
34.2 Councillor Declan Wilson stated that he believed that the ‘strategy was correct’.
Said9 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Capital Strategy
35.2 Councillor Declan Wilson pointed to page 62/63 of the agenda, that outlined the Council’s planned capital expenditure for 2020/2021. He stated that it was a useful ‘crib sheet’ outlining the main capital projects planned for the upcoming year.
Asked9 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Capital Strategy
35.3 Councillor Wilson asked for clarity on which projects would be considered by the Capital Projects Steering Group and which would be considered by the Property Investment Board.
Asked9 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Activity 2019/20 - progress report.
37.3 Councillor Wilson asked whether IT disaster recovery capability should be a higher priority. The Head of Policy and Resources responded that some IT Hardware was still at HKP, which was why Disaster Recover Plans had not been tested.
Named9 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Activity 2019/20 - progress report.
He added that once all hardware had moved, they would test Disaster Recovery Plans. 37.3 Councillor Wilson was given assurance by the Head of Policy and Resources that the 73 invoices unpaid for over 24 months (income from events) was not historically high when compared with previous years.
Asked9 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Activity 2019/20 - progress report.
37.4 Councillor Wilson asked whether the City Council employed a credit control officer. The Head and Policy and Resources responded that there are 2 officers within Civica.
Asked12 Feb 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
Councillor Wilson sought an update on the investigation into the UK Digital Retail Innovation Centre (UK:DRIC) subsidiary company of Marketing Gloucester Limited (MGL) referred to at the Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting of 19 December 2019 (Minute 6.14). The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources stated that requests to undertake an audit had gone out and that the review would commence at the end of February or beginning of March.
Asked12 Feb 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
Councillor Wilson sought confirmation that it would be undertaken by an external body. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that it would, reporting to the Head of Place as senior officer and herself as Cabinet Member.
Asked20 Jan 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Purpose, Authority, Role and Function
20.2 Councillor Wilson asked if the data analytics capabilities was being ‘bought in’ and expressed concern about resource implications. The Head of Audit, Risk and Assurance advised that there were three members of Internal Audit who were data analytics specialists. She added that it was being piloted at the County Council and that nothing extra was being purchased.
Said20 Jan 2020Audit and Governance Committee
Outside Bodies Draft Report
24.4 Councillor Wilson, who was a member of the working group, agreed that the response was very mixed and that a key element was the characterization of the work involved. He suggested that a protocol be drawn up.
Said15 Jan 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
Councillor Wilson noted that a question he asked at the Overview & Scrutiny Committee of 19 th December 2019 concerning the employment status and personal expenses of the MGL Chief Executive had been omitted from the draft minutes and asked that it be included. The Deputy Leader of the Council gave reassurance that the draft minutes would be amended and that a written response supplied.
Asked15 Jan 2020Cabinet
Leader and Cabinet Members' Question Time (15 minutes)
In reference to Appendix 3 of agenda item 10 (Marketing Gloucester Finance and Governance Review) Councillor Wilson sought confirmation that the recommendation by the consultants to commission a `full and comprehensive review of the UK:DRIC project as a matter of urgency’ would be acted upon. The Corporate Director advised that a brief to that effect was to be considered by the MGL Board the next day.
Asked6 Jan 2020Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Waste and Street Scene Contract - AMEY
7.2 Councillor Wilson asked for clarification on the legal implications of the new deed. He pointed to paragraph 10 which sets out the potential risk that the deed would be regarded as sufficiently substantial to render the contract materially different to the original one. The Corporate Director advised that the Council ‘s lawyers OneLegal had outlined the risks for thoroughness, however they considered the risk of challenges to be insignificant.
Named25 Nov 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Housing, Homelessness and Rough Sleeping Strategy
23.6 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson regarding his not seeing reference to homelessness prevention in the strategy, Councillor Watkins stated that there were discussions to be had with the County Council and partners.
Asked25 Nov 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 2
25.2 Councillor Wilson asked:
Asked18 Nov 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Contribution of Members to Outside Bodies: Aspire Trust and Citizen's Advice Bureau
5.7 Councillor Wilson asked if it would be helpful to circulate a skills set to which the CAB Manager replied that what was important was their presence rather than skills.
Named18 Nov 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Contribution of Members to Outside Bodies: Aspire Trust and Citizen's Advice Bureau
5.12 Councillor Wilson shared his view that there was an opportunity for organisations ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Said18 Nov 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Annual Audit Letter
7.3 Councillor Wilson stated that it was good to see an unqualified audit letter and queried whether there was an error in the gross expenditure figure. The Head of Policy and Resources confirmed that there was no such error.
Said18 Nov 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Activity Progress Report 2019/20
Based on this, Committee’s views were requested as to whether they require management attendance or if they would be satisfied that Internal Audit undertake a follow up review in 2020/21 reporting the outcomes to the Committee. 8.4 Councillor Wilson suggested that, as it was a minor issue, the audit be progressed. Councillor D. Norman concurred and stated that he was confident that changes would be made.
Said18 Nov 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Activity Progress Report 2019/20
8.5 Councillor Wilson noted that there were three claims for self-employed staff and queried why they were claiming.
Said18 Nov 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Based Internal Audit Planning Workshop
11.3 Councillor Wilson stated that such a session had worked well in the past.
Asked28 Oct 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Local Council Tax Support Scheme
8.1 Councillor Wilson asked whether households had been warned of the increase. Moreover, he queried whether the scheme was worth it, considering only £46,000 in savings would be made. In response, the Intelligent Client Officer explained that they had engaged households most likely to be affected by the scheme, through voluntary organisations and social media amongst others.
Said30 Sep 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Waste and Recycling Proposals
18.2 Councillor Wilson agreed with the need to make the investment and queried if there were any other plans to promote take up of the service other than flyers.
Asked22 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Audit and Governance Committee Outstanding Matters
6.3 In relation to minute 48, report on Disabled Facilities Grants (DFG), Councillor Wilson asked when this would be circulated. The Corporate Director reassured Members that he would write directly to Councillors to indicate when the report was likely to be ready for circulation.
Said22 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Statement of Accounts
7.3 Councillor Wilson noted that the July deadline to finalise the accounts was tighter than it had been and sought reassurance that Members would receive the final in good time to examine in detail over the summer for discussion at the September meeting. The Head of Policy and Resources explained that the statutory deadline had been brought forward from September to July and assured Members that a briefing note would be given should there be any change to the documents before them.
Said22 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Treasury Management Update - Annual Report 2018/19
8.2 Councillor Wilson noted that the interest rate forecasts (Appendix 2) were based on a favourable Brexit outcome. He sought clarification on what the impact of a `No Deal’ Brexit would be and whether the Council had funds on deposit in a European bank. The Head of Policy and Resources confirmed that there was no money on deposit in a European bank and that there was no official guidance to take measures against an unfavourable Brexit.
Asked22 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Deloitte External Audit Report 2018/19 (ISA 260 to those charged with Governance)
9.2 Councillor Wilson asked for clarification of the Management Override of Controls identified as a `Significant Risk’ on page 8 of the report and in particular whether this represented a standard finding. The Deloitte representative replied that this was a standard assumption in all audit reports and that in his opinion it did not represent a problem in this case.
Asked22 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Annual Report on Internal Audit Activity 2018/19
10.2 Councillor Wilson asked if the internal audit activity during the last quarter would be considered at the next meeting. The Group Manager confirmed that the outcomes from seven 2018/19 activities were reported to Committee through appendix 1 of the report (report pack pages 52 to 65).
Asked22 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Annual Report on Internal Audit Activity 2018/19
10.3 Concerning the finding that the Council’s e-tendering system, ProContract , was not being used for quotations in the majority of Low and Intermediate Value Transactions (Appendix 2 p.24), Councillor Wilson sought confirmation that remedial actions by corporate management would be reported to Members. The Group Manager reassured Members that updates would be provided through internal audit follow up of the raised recommendations within quarter 4 2019/20.
Said22 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Annual Governance Statement, Local Code of Corporate Governance and Council Wide Assurance Map 2018/19
11.2 Councillor Wilson pointed out that the hyperlink to the Whistleblowing Policy in the Corporate Governance Framework at Appendix 2 did not work. The Group Manager assured Members that this would be corrected.
Named22 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Strategic Risk Register Update and Risk Management Action Plan 2019/20
12.2 Councillor Wilson referred to the risk concerning the ability to respond to unexpected events (Appendix 1 SRR9.1) and asked if the current score of amber correctly reflected the urgency of the risk. The Corporate Director confirmed that this was the current assessment since certain actions had been taken to reduce the risk such as improving business continuity measures. He informed Members that the risk would be kept under regular review.
Asked1 Jul 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Year End Performance Report 2018-19
18.7 Councillor Wilson asked what had been the longest individual wait .
Asked1 Jul 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Outturn Report 2018-19
19.4 Councillor Wilson asked how the Council was allowed to spend the VAT Shelter.
Asked11 Mar 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Treasury Management Strategy
59.2 Councillor Wilson queried whether any hedging had been considered in relation to the UK’s proposed withdrawal from the European Union. The Head of Policy and Resources advised that, as it stood, there had been no advice to do so and that not doing so was not creating an issue.
Said11 Mar 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Activity 2018/19 - progress report
62.2 Councillor Wilson noted that there was a query in relation to the cash collection service being lost. The Head of Audit, Risk and Assurance advised that the information was not available at the time of publication but that a procurement exercise was underway.
Asked11 Mar 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Plan 2019-20
63.3 Councillor Wilson queried whether ad hoc risk were covered by the plan. The Head of Audit, Risk and Assurance advised that, where there was change, the audit team would focus on those areas. She further advised that cyclical programmes would be prioritised according to risk.
Asked25 Feb 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Q3
148.4 Councillor Wilson queried whether the £275k cited at para 6.2 of the Communities and Neighbourhoods portfolio included recoverable costs. The Head of Policy and Resources advised that this reflected the net position once housing benefit recoveries had been realised.
Asked25 Feb 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Q3
Councillor Wilson also asked whether the marketing and events manager position had been filled and Councillor Noakes confirmed that it had.
Named25 Feb 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Public Consultation for Draft Supplementary Planning Documents for Podsmead and Matson Estates Regeneration
149.5 In response to a query from Councillor Wilson, Councillor Haigh informed members that, in other areas, a group of residents would drive the regeneration.
Said21 Jan 2019Audit and Governance Committee
Management update report - DFG
48.5 Councillor Wilson acknowledged that there would be an underspend this fiscal year and that it may improve.
Asked7 Jan 2019Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance Monitoring Quarter 2
(1) Councillor Wilson sought clarification on whether the target for answering calls to the main Council telephone number included the length of the recorded message and the beginning of the call;
Asked3 Dec 2018Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Accessing the Private Rented Sector for Temporary & Permanent Accommodation
121.8 With reference to point 4 of paragraph 3.7, Councillor Wilson queried whether rental values would change after twelve months and further queried whether landlords may want different tenants.
Asked19 Nov 2018Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Progress Report 2018/19
Councillor Wilson queried how the audit could be satisfactory despite the significant underspend. 35.3 In response, the ARA Group Manager confirmed that the internal audit scope was specific to whether the DFG process in place at the Council was compliant with legislation and had been satisfied based on audit review and testing that it was. The Head of Communities stated that the Private Sector Housing team was reviewing how it dealt with DFG and how public awareness could be raised. He confirmed that the outcomes could be reported back to the Committee towards the end of the financial year.
Named19 Nov 2018Audit and Governance Committee
The Confidential Reporting Procedure (Whistleblowing Policy)
37.2 Councillor Wilson was given an assurance by the Corporate Director that the wording on the front of the policy would be reviewed to avoid any concern that it could be changed or dispensed with arbitrarily. He was also assured that any potential confusion about approached to external bodies would be reviewed and clarified.
Named19 Nov 2018Audit and Governance Committee
Treasury Management Performance 2018/19 - Six Monthly Update
38.2 Councillor Wilson was advised that the IFRS9 would not affect the Council for another five years.
Asked23 Jul 2018Audit and Governance Committee
KPMG External Audit Report 2017/18 (ISA 260 to those charged with governance)
6.2 Given the Finance team had sought external advice, Councillor Wilson questioned why the King’s Walk transaction was included as a risk in the Audit report. The KPMG representative advised that the purpose of the report was to assess accountancy activity that had taken place in 2017-18 and put forward recommendations for the future, hence the recommendation for the Council to seek external accounting advice if it enters into another complex arrangement.
Asked23 Jul 2018Audit and Governance Committee
Amey Street Scene Contract
12.7 Councillor Wilson queried the process for managing the contract and the performance of Amey and whether the Council were auditing the figures that Amey provided. In response, the Corporate Director stated that the Council received regular updates from Amey regarding their performance and returns which was how the discrepancy regarding recycling was flagged. He further stated that Council officers had been continuing to check stock levels at the depot.
Asked4 Jun 2018Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2017-18 Financial Outturn Report
66.7 Councillor Wilson enquired whether all staff are charged in full to the service area they predominately work in.
Said4 Jun 2018Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2017-18 Financial Outturn Report
66.9 Councillor Wilson noted that the cost for providing the Housing Subsidy had resulted in an overspend of £252,000 in the last quarter. He queried whether this would mean there would be an overspend of excess of £1 million in the coming year. He also stated that all of the portfolios have seen an increase in bad debt.
Asked20 Nov 2017Audit and Governance Committee
Annual Audit Letter 2016/17
35.2 Councillor Wilson asked for clarification of the status of the Barton and Tredworth Development Trust and whether there could be an update on any monies outstanding. The Head of Policy and Resources confirmed that an update would be circulated to Members.
Asked23 Jan 2017Audit and Governance Committee
KPMG Grants Audit Report
Councillor Wilson questioned whether software supplied by Civica was causing issues with the process, noting that they had failed in the past to apply software patches when required.
Asked19 Dec 2016Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Draft Money Plan 2017-22 and Budget Proposals 2017-18
Councillor Wilson asked if the four year settlement was in line with the original forecast. Jon Topping, Head of Finance, explained that it was.
Asked19 Dec 2016Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Draft Money Plan 2017-22 and Budget Proposals 2017-18
Councillor Wilson asked for clarification of how the percentage of new homes used to calculate New Homes Bonus would be reached. Jon McGinty , Managing Director, explained that during 2017-18 it would be calculated from 5 years of data and during 2018-19 would be calculated from 4 years of data.
Asked19 Dec 2016Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Draft Money Plan 2017-22 and Budget Proposals 2017-18
Councillor Wilson asked for the reasoning behind the increase in the General Fund, at a time of economic ... view the full minutes text for item 59.
Said28 Nov 2016Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 2 Report
Councillor Wilson stated it was an encouraging report with a large breakdown of figures, but that it did not show if there were any overall concerns in specific areas, such as an effect on performance due to financial changes and the resultant changed workloads for Officers.
Said28 Nov 2016Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 2 Report
Councillor Wilson also raised the matter of the discrepancy between the forecast income and the actual income for the Tourist Information Centre (TIC) and asked if it should be of concern.
Named28 Nov 2016Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Monitoring Quarter 2 Report
In response to a question from Councillor Wilson regarding the difference between the forecast and actual spend on Housing projects, Andrew Cummings explained it may have been due to lower take up of Disabled Facilities Grants but he would obtain the Councillor further information.
Asked28 Nov 2016Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Marketing Gloucester Performance Monitoring
Councillor Wilson asked how greater transparency could be ensured, given that the Council provided significant funds to MGL, and what the working relationship between MGL and The Council was like.
Said18 Oct 2016General Purposes Committee
Elections 2016
Councillor Wilson expressed this thanks to the Elections team for their hard work.
Said25 Mar 2015Cabinet
Recommendations from the Overview and Scrutiny Task and Finish Group on the Management of Parcels of Unadopted Green Land
Councillor Wilson, Member of the Task and Finish Group, advised that issues regarding safety had emerged as a result of the findings. He was pleased to note that Amey were committed to intervene in instances where threats to personal safety had been identified.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.