Policy for Delivering Local Lettings Plans for Affordable Housing Schemes
33.3 Councillor Pullen queried why the LLP only applied to the first lets on a scheme and questioned whether issues might arise after that period without further input.
Every time Gloucester's minutes name Councillor Pullen, as the council published it.
33.3 Councillor Pullen queried why the LLP only applied to the first lets on a scheme and questioned whether issues might arise after that period without further input.
Councillor Pullen asked for reassurance that there was therefore some flexibility in the scheme, to which Councillor Shervey responded in the affirmative.
34.2 Councillor Pullen noted the reduction of LGR contributions from £1 million to £200k had been attributed to ‘more accurate profiling on spend’ in the report. He asked for clarification on the meaning of this phrase.
34.3 Councillor Pullen queried the £200,000 service charge to QPark for management of the Forum car park and the low usage of the facilities.
34.4 Councillor Pullen asked regarding current actions to move Eastgate Market from a negative to a positive financial position, specifically questioning if actions were being taken against vendors currently in arrears.
35.2 Councillor Pullen noted that the report highlighted how busy the Committee had been. He also noted that a recent report produced by The Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) stated that Cabinet were not always openly welcoming to decisions or proposals from Overview and Scrutiny.
35.3 Councillor Gravells and Councillor Pullen both noted the importance of having access to reports within adequate advancement of meetings in order to do justice to the scrutiny with which they were entrusted .
Councillor Pullen noted his awareness of the pressures felt by both Councillors, to digest reports in the time given, and officers, in producing the reports on time.
107.6 Councillor Pullen thanked Councillor S. Chambers and Officers for the detailed report, and agreed that a briefing would have been helpful, suggesting that this was a matter for the Scrutiny Group Leads to consider for future meetings. He referred to 3.7 in the report and the statement that 73 households had refused to participate in the survey and asked whether the Council could have applied any legal pressure to encourage participation.
108.7 Councillor Pullen referred to the £130k reduction in expected income from Longsmith Street Car Park due to its continued closure, and asked for an update on the current position. He also asked for clarification as to the expected costs needed to reopen the car park.
109.6 Councillor Pullen expressed the view that the proposals were innovative and refreshing. He asked for clarification as to whether the Council intended to seek grant funding to prepare the site, with ... view the full minutes text for item 109.
110.5 In response to concerns raised by Councillor Pullen regarding the re-branding of the organisation, the Managing Director noted that the Council needed to be guided by them as it was inappropriate for the authority to drive the agenda on such a sensitive issue. He further noted that the organisation was also being supported by the VCS alliance.
Councillor Pullen suggested that the new Overview and Scrutiny Committee, following the local elections, may wish to invite the legacy organisation to a future meeting to provide an update on their vision going forward.
In respect of question 1 Councillor Pullen gave examples of inappropriate advice given by the City Council to residents that he had been informed of. He sought reassurance that residents who telephone the Council will be given the correct advice to resolve their issues. The Cabinet Member for Environment advised that when installing the completely new system some teething difficulties had been discovered which were being taken forward.
94.8 In response to a question from Councillor Pullen as to whether the new leaseholder would be able to sublease on the site, Councillor Norman advised that consideration would need to take place as part ... view the full minutes text for item 94.
95.4 Councillor Pullen thanked Officers and Councillor Cook for the detailed report. He asked for further details as to how the Council proposed to consult on the Climate Change Strategy. He wondered that as the strategy was such an important piece of work for the city, whether consideration could be given to consulting through roadshows as well as the usual online consultation methods.
95.5 Councillor Pullen referred to the narrative in the report at 3.8 concerning Member engagement, and asked whether consideration could be given to a Member Briefing following the 2024 local elections to brief new Councillors on the Climate Change Strategy.
96.5 Councillor Pullen suggested that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee consider establishing a Task and Finish Group to work with Officers to develop the new Housing Strategy. It was agreed that this could be a useful way forward and a future work consideration for the new Overview and Scrutiny Committee following the 2024 local elections.
Councillor Lewis confirmed that he would make follow up enquiries and that this information would be provided to Overview and Scrutiny Committee Members in due course, 97.3 Councillor Pullen asked for clarification as to what was meant by the LTS acronym. The Head of Culture clarified that this referred to Learn to Swim.
97.4 Councillor Pullen referred to the current membership figure which stood at 450, compared to a pre-closure membership of 1,032. He asked how soon it was likely to be before membership reached pre-closure figures.
97.5 In response to a further query from Councillor Pullen regarding membership figures, Councillor Lewis reiterated that he was encouraged by the latest figures and he felt it was positive that membership had reached 450 just 9 weeks following the closure of Aspire.
97.6 Councillor Pullen expressed the view that free car parking in Asda for Freedom Leisure customers and staff was a good idea, and queried whether the use of the car park came at a cost to the Council.
98.5 Councillor Pullen referred to 8.4 in the report regarding discussions with the county Library service and asked for clarification that the building was in the ownership of the County Council rather than the City Council, to which Councillor Lewis confirmed that it was.
98.6 Councillor Pullen asked whether it would make sense for the museum to expand into the library building when it became vacant.
76.8 Councillor Pullen noted that he was disappointed by the observation of the Peer Team that some Members behave badly. He stated that he had not been made aware of any complaints about the behaviour of Labour Councillors.
Councillor Pullen noted that Code of Conduct protocols had been reviewed by the Monitoring Officer and asked whether these related to Member or Officer Code of Conduct. It ... view the full minutes text for item 76.
78.4 Councillor Pullen observed that the report was an interesting read and asked for further information as to who would be invited to participate in the public consultation.
9.5 Councillor Pullen commented that he felt that the CAT Policy was a good document and that in his view the City Council should be encouraging asset transfers to community organisations.
Referring to the assessment process outlined at section 8.1 of the Policy, Councillor Pullen expressed concern that some organisations might not have the expertise to compile a full business case and asked whether the Council would be able to offer any support to organisations to assist them with their bid development.
9.7 In response to additional comments from Councillor Pullen, Councillor Norman stated that the policy provided a framework to work towards and aimed to formalise work the City Council was already doing.
10.7 Councillor Pullen referred to the plan to deliver a quality leisure offer for residents and asked for further information as to the reasons behind the delay.
10.8 Councillor Pullen expressed concerns around the confirmation in the report that the reduction of the use of Bed and Breakfast accommodation for temporary accommodation by 20% was not expected.
12.6 Councillor Pullen commented that the enquiry had been fascinating and thanked the Officers, Social Housing Providers and the local voluntary advice agencies who had taken part and supported the project. He stated that Task and Finish Group Members had learnt that in the past, damp and mould growth was more likely to have put down to a lifestyle issue. He noted that the project had confirmed that the issue was far more complex, with the condition of properties being a major factor.
122.5 Councillor Pullen reflected on his experience of attending the recent Holocaust Memorial service which he found to be an impressive and sobering event and asked that his comments be fed back to the event organisers.
122.6 Referring to the narrative in Appendix 1 and the council’s commitment to ensure that 95% of staff and Councillors receive training in ED&I by March 2024, Councillor Pullen asked whether this training was likely to be delivered in-house of by external organisations. He also asked whether the council planned to make this training mandatory. The Head of Culture confirmed that the council had committed money from the training budget towards ED&I training and that it would likely be a combination of in-house and external providers.
52.5 Councillor Pullen noted that, whilst the Overview and Scrutiny Committee had heard that good progress had been made on the statues and monuments review, he queried why the audit of this piece of work had been deferred. The Head of ARA advised that this would be a piece of consultancy work and that, as Terms of Reference had not yet been produced, it would be considered for next year’s plan.
52.6 With regard to the carbon audit being deferred, Councillor Pullen asked whether this was because the climate change action plan had not yet been produced. The Director of Policy and Resources advised that as the plan was still being drawn up, such an audit could not commence.
102.2 The Chair, Councillor Pullen, asked for an estimated timeframe as to when the webcasting of meetings was likely to be in place.
92.1 The Chair, Councillor Pullen, introduced the latest version of the Council Forward Plan and invited suggestions as to any items Members wished to add to the Overview and Scrutiny Committee Work Programme.
41.4 Councillor Pullen noted reference to a ‘Newton Hearing’ in respect of a counter-fraud case and sought clarity on what this meant. The Group Manager advised that such a hearing occurred where, despite a guilty verdict or plea, factual issues remained to be resolved ahead of sentencing.
Councillor Pullen commented that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee should also consider this report and Members agreed that the Peer Review Report should be added to the Work Programme.
81.5 Councillor Pullen referred to the St Oswalds Retail Park and asked whether consideration had been given to installing solar panels on the B&Q roof. The Director of Policy and Resources noted that this was likely to provide efficiency benefits for B&Q rather than the council but confirmed that the council could open discussions regarding their intentions.
82.6 Councillor Pullen referred to the key action to set up an in-house Home Improvement Agency to support vulnerable and disabled residents to remain in their homes and queried whether Gloucestershire County Council were expected to have any involvement as the responsible authority for adult social care.
In response to a query from Councillor Pullen as to whether HR processes had been activated, the Managing Director advised that it was a very difficult market to recruit to such a role and that the combined Monitoring Officer and Regeneration lawyer role was a prudent approach. It was also confirmed that it was not necessary to activate such processes.
60.1 The Chair, Councillor Pullen, introduced the latest version of the Council Forward Plan and invited suggestions as to any items Members wished to add to the Overview and Scrutiny Work Programme. It was noted that the Chair and Vice-Chair had proposed some amendments to the Work Programme due to revised report dates on the Cabinet Forward Plan.
63.7 In response to a query from Councillor Pullen relating to the Culture budget around Aspire Leisure, the Head of Culture suggested that he raise his query during the Budget Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting on ... view the full minutes text for item 63.
Councillor Pullen had asked for an update on the carbon neutral plan, and was advised that the Climate Change Officer was completing work on that specific issue, and they were still waiting for the Climate Change Action Plan.
52.4 Councillor Pullen thanked the Task and Finish Group for their report. He felt that the Group had focused their enquiry on the right service areas and asked whether the Task and Finish Group felt that officers understood that more needed to be done to engage with young people across the council and were open to change.
Councillor Pullen noted that the response rate on the public consultation was low with 15 responses in total, and acknowledged that the Group were likely hoping for a higher rate. He also requested further information about the appointment of the Youth Engagement Officer Lead.
41.4 Councillor Pullen asked how successful the contractor had been in educating and informing residents and business with regard to environmental crime. The City Centre Manager informed Members that the Council had managed to deploy 3GS to other parts and issue fines which had enabled Council officers to conduct outreach work in the community. He cited that, for example, in Barton and Tredworth, some issues had arisen as a result of business not having trade waste agreements in place. 3GS had been utilised to check this as a first point of contact and in some cases, fines had been issued subsequently.
41.6 In response to queries from Councillor Pullen, the City Centre explained that the responsibility for fly-tipping on private land was that of the owner of the land and that, in some cases, owners had been advised that if they were to engage in secondary fly-tipping, they themselves would be open to prosecution.
28.4 In relation to the update relating to the notice of motion item, Councillor Pullen requested that an additional update be brought before the Overview and Scrutiny Committee later in the year to update Members on progress in creating a Covid Memorial in Gloucester. In particular, he requested that officers provide further details on the monument design, the partnership and how the monument will be funded across the relevant organisations, and the involvement of local people. It was agreed that follow-up enquiries would be made with officers to ascertain the timeline and that this item would be added to the agenda of a future Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting.
6.5 Councillor Pullen stated he was pleased with the assurance levels provided and asked whether there should be an aspiration to achieve greater levels of assurance. The Head of ARA clarified that there was a low to medium exposure to risk and in order to get to the next level, all areas would require greater levels of assurance.
7.3 In response to a point raised by Councillor Pullen with regards to cyber insurance, the Director of Policy and Resources advised that the Managing Director had met with the Department for Levelling Up, Communities and Housing (DLUCH) and the Council’s insurers. A project would commence to explore a mechanism to provide protection in the future. Further, he noted that this would require support from the Treasury.
In respect of question 8 Councillor Pullen informed the Cabinet Member for Culture and Leisure that he had been told in a meeting with Richard Graham MP’s Chief of Staff that 62% of residents in the latter’s own survey opposed charges. He sought reassurance that residents’ opinions would be respected when making the decision. The Cabinet Member for Culture and Leisure made it clear that the opinions of residents would be taken into account when the decision is made but stated that he had not been ... view the full minutes text for item 116.
128.5 Councillor Pullen requested that the action point item providing updates on previous Council notices of motion be reinstated. It was noted that this item had been deferred from Overview and Scrutiny Committee agendas for the past few months due to the ongoing IT disruption which the City Council was experiencing. Members agreed to remind officers of the wording of motions which had been approved by full Council, and to send requests for an update on a particular notice of motion to the Democratic and Electoral Services Officer.
130.3 Councillor Pullen commended the achievements of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee over the course of the year and expressed the view that the Committee deserved recognition for these achievements, particularly given that many Members were newly elected in May 2021.
In respect of question 1 Councillor Pullen urged that rather than wait for central government decisions, preparations begin immediately to accommodate Ukrainian refugees. He asked if plans were being made, perhaps utilizing the Property Investment Strategy, to identify suitable properties avoiding the use of bed and breakfast (B&B) and hotel accommodation.
In relation to the Property Investment Fund she assured Councillor Pullen that she would consult officers and respond directly. The Cabinet Member for Planning and Housing Strategy expressed her own concern over the use of B&Bs and hotels but advised that the availability of temporary accommodation was still being explored so a firm answer could not be given at this stage.
50.2 Councillor Pullen pointed to page 6 of the report, which referenced an investigation into an individual who was undertaking a second paid job outside the Council on top of working for the Authority. He asked what the situation was in regard to City Council staff working second jobs and whether it was a HR or Audit issue. The Internal Auditor replied that with that particular case, the reason it was highlighted as a potential fraud issue was because the employee in question was alleged to have been working a second job, whilst on full time sick leave in their capacity as an employee at the City Council.
50.3 In response to a further question from Councillor Pullen, the Internal Auditor confirmed that City Council employees could have a second job outside of the Council and reiterated the reasons as to why that particular case was investigated.
108.2 Referring to the statement in the narrative that the Task and Finish Group would meet regularly, Councillor Pullen expressed the view that the timescale for the enquiry should be a short one and suggested that 3 months would be an appropriate timescale.
108.3 Councillor Pullen further noted that there were in fact 4 parts to the motion approved by full Council at the meeting on 27 th January, and that the resolution to actively involve young people in the process was missing from the narrative. He expressed the view that this was a very important resolution and hoped that this would be an active element of the Task and Finish Group enquiry.
110.8 In relation to the number of enviro-crime FPNs issued, Councillor Pullen asked whether the Committee could receive an update on where they were being issued and whether the team could provide information about any emerging patterns or trends. It was agreed that follow-up enquiries would be made with the Communities team, however the Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources noted that an annual report might be a better means of answering this query. ... view the full minutes text for item 110.
Chambers proposed and Councillor Pullen seconded the nomination of Councillor Lewis as Chair.
96.3 Councillor Pullen and Councillor Wilson confirmed that they felt that a Taskand Finish Groupfocusing on youngpeople wasa priority.
97.6 Councillor Pullen expressed the view that the report was fascinating andwelcomed theengagement withpartner organisations,particularly theUniversity of Gloucestershireand the GloucesterCommission to ReviewRace Relations.Councillor Pullennoted hisagreement withthe recommendations and the courses of action, and expressed the view thatpublic consultation was important.
97.7 Councillor Pullen referredto the narrative at ... view the full minutes text for item 97.
98.5 Councillor Pullen referred to the draft calendar of events at 3.9.2 in the reportand notedthat theKings Squaredevelopment wasshortly dueto becompleted.
99.7 Councillor Pullen referred to the narrative in Appendix 3 concerning targetaudiences and requested clarification on whether this included students.
In response to a question from Councillor Pullen as to why there would be an independent Member, the Head of ARA clarified that it had been recommended that all audit committees have an independent Member and that it was likely that this would become mandatory in the future.
39.3 Councillor Pullen asked, in relation to the election accounts, whether the Returning Officer received three fees, there having been three elections. The Principal Auditor confirmed that there was one fee but made up of three distinct claims. In respect of a special fraud investigation, the Principal Auditor stated that full details would be provided to the Committee.
40.2 Councillor Pullen noted that the Council’s target was to be carbon neutral by 2030 and that the City be carbon neutral by 2045. Whilst this was referred to in the report, he queried why it did not appear explicitly in the risk register. The Director of Policy and Resources explained that, as it was a key policy area the Council was working towards, it was not necessary to include as a risk on its own.
86.3 Councillor Pullen reiterated the need for any Task and Finish Groups to be clear and focused on a specific problem. He expressed the view that a small remit with a short time-scale would be the most effective way of getting the best from a Task and Finish Group investigation.
In respect of question 3, Councillor Pullen sought clarification on why a public consultation was not carried out in the period between July 2021 and the submission of the Lord Mayor status bid in addition to an apology for not having done so. The Leader of the Council gave reassurance that resident’s views would usually be sought in such matters but that in this case there was so much work to do for officers in preparing the bid within the timescale that it had not been possible. He reiterated that he had not committed to a public consultation and had stated that it would be made, if it were possible (Council 8 th July 2021 minute 19.5).
4.5 Councillor Pullen advised that he supported the proposals and asked for clarification about the appointment process for the posts at the present time.
4.8 In response to a question from Councillor Pullen regarding the proposal for a countywide role focusing on tackling health inequalities, the Managing Director advised that no decision had been made on where the role would be hosted, but that sufficient budget had been set aside to fund the City Council’s contribution.
60.4 Councillor Pullen expressed concerns that car parking income was an ongoing problem with little sign of improvement. He referred to the Sales, Fees & Charges claim which the Council had submitted for Quarter 1 and asked whether the Council could place a further bid to help towards the £ 500k shortfall in this area. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources clarified that the previous Quarter 1 return was the last Quarter Councils could submit Sales, Feels & Charges claims from Government.
60.5 In response to a further question from Councillor Pullen regarding the budget pressures and £ 326k shortfall from cemeteries and crematorium services, the Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that the lost income was mainly as a result of a reduction in income from wakes at the Arbor. She noted that she had been advised by colleagues in crematorium services that the next few months were predicted to be a busy period for the Arbor crematorium and further income would depend on whether people had the confidence to hold wakes. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that if further support was available from Government in due course, the Council would be at ... view the full minutes text for item 60.
61.2 Councillor Pullen referred to performance indicator CWB-13 relating to the percentage of broadly compliant food premises. He noted that the narrative indicated that the reduction of broadly compliant food premises was down to a shortage of qualified Food Safety Inspectors (EHPs) with the appropriate level of training.
Councillor Pullen asked how many EHPs were currently employed by the Council and how many EHPs should be employed by Councils.
62.5 Councillor Pullen thanked the Cabinet Member for her assurances on stability and noted that he felt that the recommendation was sensible in principle. He expressed the view that the location was ideal and that it was sensible for the Council to take an opportunity to make savings.
Councillor Pullen referred to a recent press release which described plans to bring the Council into the heart of the city. He noted that although relocating to the Eastgate Shopping Centre would move the Council into the city centre, customer services would still be located at the Gateway on Westgate Street and ... view the full minutes text for item 62.
Councillor Pullen stated that requiring notice for public questions would create an additional unwanted barrier to engagement, but that he supported the proposal to allow members of the public to request that their question be read out if they were unable to attend a meeting in person. In respect of questions by Councillors, he raised concerns that requiring notice would stifle debate and have a negative impact on the council’s meetings.
23.5 Referring to the timescale for asking officers for updates on the actions resulting from Council Motions, Councillor Pullen noted that the Group Leads had proposed a 6-month time frame between a motion being accepted and the Overview and Scrutiny Committee requesting an update.
25.7 In response to a question from Councillor Pullen about the Council’s climate change targets, the Leader of the Council confirmed that the targets were already ... view the full minutes text for item 25.
26.3 Councillor Pullen referred to the reduced income from parking outlined at 5.4 of the report. He noted that more people may be using public transport for environmental reasons and commented that there was less footfall in the city generally as many people were still working home.
Councillor Pullen asked for the Cabinet Member’s views as to whether this was a concern, and whether consideration had been given to adjusting to a more realistic target.
26.5 In response to a further question from Councillor Pullen on the reopening of the Arbor venue at the Crematorium, The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources confirmed that the Arbor had reopened and noted that she had recently visited the venue. She confirmed that a risk assessment had been undertaken and that the venue had robust Covid-19 safety precautions, including hand sanitizer stations. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources indicated that she was confident that there would be an improvement in income generated from the Arbor in the coming months.
6.2 Councillor Pullen noted that the PWLB was no longer available for commercial borrowing and asked from when this had been the case. The Accountancy Manager confirmed that this was following a consultation as, twelve months previously the PWLB had increased rates by 1% and this was an offsetting measure. He further stated that there was confidence that the PWLB could be used for regeneration purposes.
6.3 Councillor Pullen noted that the property investment strategy fund amounted to approximately £80m and asked how much had been allocated thus far. It was agreed that a full response would be circulated in due course.
7.5 Councillor Pullen queried how such terms as ‘substantial’, ‘satisfactory’ and ‘limited’ assurance were formulated. The Head of ARA confirmed that these were of standard use and definitions were provided. He further advised that benchmarking with other Councils would also take place.
7.6 Councillor Pullen noted the rapidity with which business grants were administered and asked how it was ascertained what the funds were spent on. The Head of ARA noted that the grants were available for a wide range of uses and at the discretion of the business owner.
9.3 In relation to Councillor Pullen ‘s query about the potential impact of The Gateway closing on telephone waiting times and the number of staff answering calls, Councillor Norman advised that this would be confirmed with Officers and a response would be circulated to Members.
8.6 Councillor Pullen suggested that the complaints procedure was difficult to find on the website and asked whether this could be made more prominent. He was informed that Cabinet and Officers would look at this and send a written response.
Councillor Pullen stated that he was pleased to see the suggestion of landlord licensing, that a scheme should be piloted and that a scheme would fund itself.
25.5 Councillor Pullen asked the running costs at the bus station had increased. The Head of Policy and Resources advised that there were higher costs incurred in order to maintain the facility to a high standard. He further advised that income would increase due to what the City Council would receive for each departure.
7.3 Councillor Pullen stated that he welcomed the report, moreover, that the developments showed that GL1 had become more than just a sports centre, but a community centre. Noting the £48,000 investment in the gym, he asked whether this had made a difference. Further, he asked whether they had been successful in retaining good staff.
9.2 Councillor Pullen opened the discussion. He questioned what would happen with the Longsmith Street Car Park in the redevelopment, and, moreover, what lifespan it had. The Cabinet Member for Regeneration and the Economy responded to say that the car park was largely no longer fit for purpose, something which was evident from its current condition.
18.5 Councillor Pullen stated that he supported the investment and hoped that prices would not be raised.
18.5 Councillor Pullen referred to CST2 and he questioned the customer waiting time for telephone recorded as 2m 03 secs. The Head of Policy and Resources advised that the new customer service portal would provide everything customers needed and give a much improved service.
19.6 Councillor Pullen noted that no income had been recorded for the property investment strategy.
18.7 Referring to Appendix 1 (list of groups funded), Councillor Pullen queried why Amey had been granted funding for a litter bin in the Grange area, given that it was not a voluntary organisation. He suggested that there were better uses for the available funds.
19.7 Councillor Pullen submitted that the ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
7.8 Councillor Pullen highlighted that the ’ fund had traditionally been underspent. In light of this, he felt it was pertinent to consider how the new policy was going to be made more visible.
7.9 In reference to Councillor Pullen‘s comments, The Intelligent Client Officer explained that the Council had attempted to ensure the budget was being fully utilised . Additionally, she made Members aware of some of the steps the Council had taken to ensure greater visibility for the new DHP policy. This included meeting with the target audience, meeting with partner agencies, input from partner agencies on policies, and a customer reception at Green Square where members of the Public could be assisted with their applications.
7.10 Councillor Pullen queried what measures , if any, were in place to help people complete their applications. ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
9.6 Councillor Pullen noted that whilst it is positive to see that the number of complaints is reducing in CST3, it would be helpful if information could be provided as to how many of those complaints are actually resolved. The Head of Policy and Resources advised that the relevant Officer would be contacted to provide information.
148.8 Councillor Pullen noted from Councillor Noake’s ... view the full minutes text for item 148.
149.7 In response to Councillor Pullen asking the residents present how they would conduct the consultation, Sarah stated that not everyone was technologically competent to the level which may be required through an online only consultation. She further stated that it was necessary to communicate with all organisation that were involved in the community.
140l.2 Related to the relocation of the Tourist Information Centre, Councillor Pullen suggested it was crucial to improve the frontage of the Guildhall as part of the development plan. The Corporate Director advised that this would be part of any development plan and that a number of wide ranging options were available.
Councillor Pullen referred to the hourly rate of £10.00 for childcare and enquired if this figure was in line with current rates. The Policy and Governance Manager advised this had been discussed with Members using the provision. She added that no requests had been made for adult dependent care allowances and that the Panel would work with Members if a request was received.
130.5 In response to an intervention from Councillor Pullen regarding achieving income targets, the CEO stated that more information would be forthcoming. She pointed to Aspire’s large social media reach of close to a million followers and that local schools had started to book Aspire facilities.
131.2 Councillor Pullen queried what impact moving to Shire Hall would have on performance trends in customer services.
131.3 In response to a question from Councillor Pullen as to the possibility of qualitative data being used as part of performance monitoring, Councillor Norman advised that this was but only the second such report and the performance management framework was still in its infancy. She further advised that she and officers welcomed suggestions for improvement.
120.5 Councillor Pullen stated that he saw the value in potentially pooling resources for community building. He noted that numerous community organisations were struggling with gaining grant funding and questioned whether it would be preferable to directly support already existing groups.
Councillor Pullen also asked what outcomes were being attempted and what a healthy community looked like.
121.3 Councillor Pullen shared his view that what was in issue was a lack of housing stock but that the incentives outlined were helpful. He stated that numerous landlords were reluctant to deal with those who may have complex needs and queried what would be done to change such attitudes.
122.3 Councillor Pullen noted that there were just two vacant market stalls and that, as such, he was surprised to see a deficit in that area. He asked for the Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Economy to clarify what a private management company would do to improve market income generation. It was confirmed that an answer would be circulated.
Cllr Pullen referred to the closure of the Hempsted Household Recycling Centre every Thursday announced by the County Council and asked if the Cabinet Member for Environment had been consulted. The Cabinet Member for Environment replied that the matter had been discussed at the last Joint Waste Committee meeting although he had not made a personal response.
Cllr Pullen further enquired if additional resources had been allocated to deal with any fly tipping that might accumulate when the centre was closed. The Cabinet Member for Environment responded that the situation would be monitored and the forthcoming environmental enforcement contractor (3GS) would address the issue if necessary.
Cllr Pullen informed Members that he had been made aware of some confusion among a range of organisations over who was to deliver the civic commemoration of Remembrance Sunday 2018 and sought clarification. The Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Economy confirmed that Marketing Gloucester Ltd would work with the City Council to ensure that the event would run to its usual high standard and the detail around this arrangement was be finalised imminently.
66.12 Councillor Pullen thanked Councillor Norman for his report and honesty. He questioned whether it was beneficial to keep rolling over the debt from previous years and if there was a better solution.
66.13 In reply Councillor Norman agreed with Councillor Pullen and stated that the Cabinet were planning to introduce long term portfolio budgets in the coming year to rectify ... view the full minutes text for item 66.
67.7 Councillor Pullen shared his view that it would be beneficial to have qualitative data to support the existing data.
In response to a query from Councillor Pullen regarding the success of the Trust in reaching young people, the Director stated that the Trust worked closely with partner organising to increase the involvement of young people in projects.
Cllr Pullen expressed frustration that the Planned Improvements to Manage Demand for Temporary Accommodation report (agenda item 8) published on 1 st May 2018 was not available for scrutiny by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee at its meeting the night before and asked that any decisions on the matter would be brought back to Councillors for consideration. The Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Economy indicated that the report had not been finalised in time to be circulated with the Overview and Scrutiny Agenda but he was aware that a comprehensive briefing on the issue had been provided to the committee instead. He emphasised the importance of reporting back to Cabinet and committee members on this particular issue, but reminded everyone of the need to avoid delay so that opportunities to address the problems were not missed.
Cllr Pullen sought further confirmation that should an option to acquire temporary accommodation be approved it would be referred to the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. The Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Economy confirmed that if it was possible to notify Councillors in advance that would be done and he reiterated Members’ commitment to be as open and transparent as they can.
In relation to agenda item 7 (Litter Strategy) Cllr Pullen expressed concern that uncollected refuse for recycling was building up on the streets of his ward and other parts of the City and asked when it would be removed. The Cabinet Member for Environment conveyed Members’ dissatisfaction that the recycling collections backlog built up during the recent period of adverse weather had not been cleared and took the opportunity to apologise to residents. He stated that he had pressed the matter with the contractor ( Amey ) and received assurances that the backlog would be cleared by Monday 16 th January.
Cllr Pullen noted that the recycling backlog was generating additional litter requiring street cleaning to be prioritised and asked when the City would be clean. The Cabinet Member for Environment acknowledged the issue and confirmed that litter picking was a priority required to be completed within days of the recycling backlog being cleared street by street.
Cllr Pullen asked if the recycling backlog had exposed the lack of a contingency plan. The Cabinet Member for Environment confirmed that there was a contingency plan in place but commented that refuse collection vehicles cannot operate in dangerous conditions such as had been experienced recently.
He informed Cllr Pullen that the matter would be raised with Amey . The Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Economy reiterated Members’ apologies to residents and dissatisfaction with the current recycling collection issue, he confirmed that when resolved a lessons learnt exercise would be held to minimise the risk of similar problems occurring again.
Cllr Pullen sought clarification of staffing levels within the Customer Service Team as he had received reports from residents that the Council contact telephone number (01452 396 396) was going unanswered on occasion with `staff shortages’ being given as the reason. The Cabinet Member for Performance and Resources stated that the matter would be raised with officers for investigation.
Councillor Pullen commented that the Labour Group would also not support the proposal of an earlier start time. He added that a number of Members did not finish work until 5.30pm and an earlier start time would not be practical for his Group.
Councillor Pullen commented that the majority of Council meetings were approximately 3 hours and the previous meeting was exceptionally long due to the contributions made by Members. He added that in order to manage the process of Council meetings, some areas could be condensed. He commented that ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Pullen asked if any discussions had taken place with the Trade. The Senior Licensing and Markets Officer advised that the two Trade members he had spoken to were in favour and the other Districts in Gloucestershire were considering introducing a similar requirement.
Councillor Pullen referred to paragraph 3.1 and asked if that level of staffing would be maintained following the introduction of the Together Gloucester initiative.
Councillor Pullen observed that some things would no longer be done and other things would be done differently.
Councillor Pullen was appointed Chair for the meeting.
Councillor Pullen asked if the Applicant would employ door staff if the conditions on the licence required them.
Councillor Pullen noted that the policy stated that vehicles over five years of age would not normally be accepted for licensing on the first occasion. He was advised that an older vehicle had been licensed on a previous occasion.
Questions to the Applicant by Members Councillor Pullen queried the date that the information leaflet in Kurdish had been provided to the Premises Licence Holder. The Applicant circulated an English copy of the leaflet to the Sub-Committee and confirmed that the Premises Licence Holder would have received this information at an early stage as the Trading Standards Service had reason to believe that he needed this advice. The Premises Licence Holder, through his supporter, denied ever having receiving this leaflet and the Applicant showed a copy of it to him.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Pullen attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Pullen's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Pullen was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 4 of 12 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Pullen declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Pullen in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Pullen sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 6 | 30 Nov 2026 |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 4 | |
| Council | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | 26 Nov 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.