Executive director's report: economy, environment & infrastructure
7.1 The attached pre-submitted questions were received from Cllr McFarling. The second question was answered verbally in the meeting.
Every time Gloucestershire's minutes name Councillor McFarling, as the council published it.
7.1 The attached pre-submitted questions were received from Cllr McFarling. The second question was answered verbally in the meeting.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/local-transport-infrastructure-carbon-benchmarking-tool 7.3 In response, Cllr McFarling acknowledged the existence of current assessment tool but raised concern regarding its largely qualitative nature, suggesting that more quantitative data and clearer measurement of carbon impacts would support more informed decision-making. Officers recognised this feedback and agreed that there may be scope to refine current processes to provide more quantitative analysis.
7.1 A petition from Cllr Chris McFarling on Tutshills was presented to Cllr Dom Morris 7.2 A petition from Cllr Rob Vines for a pelican crossing on Lobley’s Drive was presented to Cllr Dom Morris 7.3 A petition from Cllr Matt Babbage ‘Scrap the proposed zone 16 and also allow roads in zone 15 to opt out’ was presented to Cllr Dom Morris 7.4 A petition from Cllr John Bloxsom ‘Campaign for a Zebra crossing near The Bear of Rodborough’ was presented to Cllr Dom Morris 7.5 A petition from Cllr Andrew Miller on traffic calming measures in Tuffley Avenue was presented to Cllr Dave Norman 7.6 A petition from Cllr Suzanne Williams to clear the traffic and stop the multiple road closures in Swindon Village Ward was presented to Cllr Dom Morris
Question 5 – Cllr Chris McFarling asked why the Cabinet Member had cited that Energy from Waste facilities produced less than 5% of the CO2 of the equivalent landfill facility when Government guidance stated that the 5% figure should not be used to determine the lifecycle emissions of incineration versus landfill.
Question 10 – Cllr Chris McFarling questioned the figures around how much it cost to incinerate Gloucestershire’s waste and the £15 million additional funding that was stated in the 2024/25 Budget as being a result of energy produced at the facility being sold.
Question 13 – Cllr Chris McFarling further explained that the reason why the 5% figure around C02 emissions should not be used for Energy from Waste facilities, in comparison to landfill, was that the 5% figure did not include emissions from the facility itself, but instead was limited to the transport to and from Javelin Park, whereas all landfill emissions were included. He questioned why this was being used as a valid comparison and asked what the full carbon footprint of incinerating Gloucestershire’s waste was.
Motion 930: Notice of Motion – Free Bus Travel for Gloucestershire Veterans and Service Personnel 8.1 Cllr Cate Cody proposed, and Cllr Chris McFarling seconded the following motion. This includes a friendly amendment from the Conservative Group which was accepted prior to the meeting:
8.3 In seconding the motion, Cllr McFarling emphasised that supporting this motion today was simply the right thing to do, particularly at this time of year in remembrance. He welcomed the amendment by the Conservative Group which would ensure the programme was properly costed and the Council therefore spent what it was able to.
Question 13 – Cllr Chris McFarling asked if GCC were working with academy schools to stress test their buildings against climate change and whether it would be necessary to make them more climate proof.
Question 14 – Cllr Chris McFarling asked the Cabinet Member to acknowledge that further major infrastructure development projects should require a true biodiversity net gain and not cause further loss to the natural habitats.
Question 6 – Cllr Chris McFarling asked whether the Cabinet member would re-consider writing to central government to increase active travel investment. He also asked that such a letter emphasised the urgent need to decarbonise the transport sector in response to the climate emergency.
He invited Cllr McFarling to visit the Hub to see the work already being done.
15.2 Cllr Chris McFarling was proposed and seconded.
RESOLVED that Cllr Chris McFarling be appointed to the Severn Estuary Partnership until May 2025.
Question 1 – Cllr Chris McFarling requested that the Council meet with representatives from the New Forest to discuss the successful implementation of 40mph on Forest of Dean roads.
Question 3 – Cllr Chris McFarling asked how GCC could promote the importance of decreasing carbon emissions with district councils before carbon budgets were exhausted in 2025.
1) Cllr Jeremy Hilton 2) Cllr Lisa Spivey 3) Cllr John Bloxsom 4) Cllr David Drew 5) Cllr Chris McFarling 6) Cllr Beki Hoyland The decision was called in in accordance with Council’s Constitution Outline of the Process Committee Chair, Cllr Stephan Fifield, referred to the sensitivity of the issue and asked that the committee consider the information in a positive and kindly manner.
Councillor McFarling was also proposed and duly seconded.
Cllr Beki Hoyland proposed and Cllr Paul Hodgkinson seconded that Cllr Chris McFarling be nominated as Chair of the Environment Scrutiny Committee.
1) Cllr Jeremy Hilton 2) Cllr Lisa Spivey 3) Cllr John Bloxsom 4) Cllr David Drew 5) Cllr Chris McFarling 6) Cllr Beki Hoyland The Chair announced that an extraordinary meeting to consider the grounds for the calling in of the cabinet decision and to determine whether the committee agreed, wholly or partially, with the call in had been arranged at 2.00pm on 20 July 2022.
Cllr McFarling declared that he was an owner of an electric vehicle, due to the forthcoming discussions on the electric vehicle charging rollout.
In relation to item 6, Cllr Chris McFarling declared his representation on the Joint Wye Valley AONB Advisory Committee and as a supporter of the Friends of the Lower Wye Group.
Question 10 – Cllr Chris McFarling stated that it would take time for the trees to grow and so far no form of carbon capture had been cost effectively trialled, he asked what other forms of carbon sequestration were feasible in Gloucestershire to hit net zero?
Cllr Chris McFarling declared a personal interest in item 8, Motions, Motion 878 EU Settlement Scheme, and that he would therefore not participate in the debate.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor McFarling attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Nov 2022 | Environment Scrutiny Committee | Bus Improvements Task Group | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor McFarling was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
No meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor McFarling declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24 May 2022 | Environment Scrutiny Committee, item 3 | Cllr McFarling declared that he was an owner of an electric vehicle, due to the forthcoming discussions on the electric vehicle charging rollout. | |
| 9 Mar 2022 | Environment Scrutiny Committee, item 3 | In relation to item 6, Cllr Chris McFarling declared his representation on the Joint Wye Valley AONB Advisory Committee and as a supporter of the Friends of the Lower Wye Group. | |
| 30 Jun 2021 | County Council, item 15 | Cllr Chris McFarling declared a personal interest in item 8, Motions, Motion 878 EU Settlement Scheme, and that he would therefore not participate in the debate. |
Where Councillor McFarling sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Environment Scrutiny Committee | Vice-Chair | Jul 2022 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.