Questions at Cabinet Meetings
Cllr Colin Hay replied that the council was part of the F40 group of Local authorities who were under-funded in relation to schools. He outlined the issue of underfunding.
Every time Gloucestershire's minutes name Councillor Hay, as the council published it.
Cllr Colin Hay replied that the council was part of the F40 group of Local authorities who were under-funded in relation to schools. He outlined the issue of underfunding.
12.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval to approve and adopt the Property Maintenance Strategy.
14.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval to modify the council’s existing contracts for the provision of recycling, general waste, food and confidential collection services across participating schools and the council’s corporate estate properties by extending their terms for a period of twenty four months, from 30 April 2027 to 30 April 2029.
15.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval to modify the council’s existing call-off contracts for the provision of cleaning and caretaking services across participating schools and the council’s corporate estate under its framework agreement of the same name by extending their terms for a period of 6 months (from 1 August 2027) for the purpose of allowing sufficient time to procure a replacement contract for these services that reflects the council’s modified requirements arising from the forthcoming Local Government Reorganisation process He also sought delegated authority to procure a replacement Cleaning and Caretaking Framework Agreement and call-off contracts under it that will commence following the expiry of the above proposed extension.
Cllr Iain Dobie proposed and Cllr Piers Camp seconded the nomination of Cllr Colin Hay as Chair for this meeting.
Resolved – Cllr Colin Hay elected as Chair for this meeting.
Cllr Colin Hay advised that whilst a review of parking arrangements was underway, the Council currently lacked capacity to consider significant changes due to the demands of Local Government Reorganisation and wider estate reviews. He indicated that such issues may be considered as part of future arrangements by a successor authority.
Cllr Colin Hay advised that the Council was considering draft proposals and would seek to implement any changes in a balanced and sensitive manner, whilst engaging with staff and considering the needs of all groups.
11.3 Cllr Colin Hay requested a short adjournment to discuss the proposal.
Councillor Colin Hay was proposed by Cllr Turner and seconded by Cllr Luff, and there being no further nominations, it was
Councillor Chloe Turner was proposed by Cllr Hay and seconded by Cllr Luff and, there being no further nominations, it was
The Committee considered its representation on the LGPS Central Oversight Board and appointed Cllr Hay as the representative.
6.1 Cllr Colin Hay reported on the delivery of the Council Strategy during Quarter 4 2025/26, including the current performance and risk position. Cabinet was asked to consider the Council's revenue outturn expenditure for 2025/26, agree recommendations for reserve transfers; and approve additions and funding changes to the Capital Programme, noting the 2025/26 final capital outturn. ? 6.2 The final position at the end of 2025/26 was an underspend of £7.6 million. It awas explained that during this period there had been an improvement in performance and Senior Officers and officers on the ground were thanked. 6.3 Recommendation 3 and paragraphs 4 and 5 of the report proposed to transfer the balance to the Local Government Reorganisation Reserve, and the Risk & Opportunities Reserve. 6.4 It was noted that in the current year, there were additional savings required and there were some challenges relating to that.
Cllr Steve Robinson was proposed by Cllr Colin Hay and seconded by Cllr Richard Stanley.
13.1 Cllr Colin Hay introduced the report and informed members that a key point to note was that an appointment of a new member to the Independent Remuneration Panel (IRP) would take place on Friday 15 May 2026.
5.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval of the Stronger Futures Full Business Case (attached as an appendix) and approval of the investment required to mobilise and deliver the programme and its priority initiatives.
6.1 Cllr Colin Hay, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Finance, Assets and Transformation, introduced the item by emphasising the importance of the council adopting a stronger commercial mindset to ensure that public money was spent wisely and delivered maximum value.
7.1 Cllr Colin Hay introduced the item by reiterating some of the key areas of improvement that had already been identified during Review discussions – strengthening the council’s Forward Plan to enable scrutiny members early involvement in shaping cabinet decisions, limiting the number of items on scrutiny agendas to allow for better scrutiny and considering other avenues for member engagement e.g. all member briefings. Cabinet were keen for scrutiny to be more involved in the decision process.
7.4 Cllr Colin Hay, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Finance, Assets and Transformation, highlighted the Council Strategy Action Plan, which would enable the delivery of the priorities set out in the Council Strategy, and would enable the Council and public to monitor and challenge performance and outcomes. He also highlighted the Commercial Strategy 2026-28, which set out the Council’s approach to making best use of its resources through working with suppliers and customers.
Cllr Hay, in recognising that the decision on the Commercial Strategy had been brought forward, offered to provide members with a presentation on it so that they could ask questions and make suggestions.
9.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval for the draft action plan to deliver the priorities set out in the Council Strategy and a strategic performance dataset to monitor outcomes within the Strategy.
10.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval to adopt the Council’s Commercial Strategy for the period 2026 to 2028. The strategy outlined the Council’s approach to making the best use of its resources through working with suppliers and customers.
12.1 Cllr Colin Hay reported on the Council’s performance and risk during Quarter 3 2025/26.
17.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval of the proposed Schedule of Disposals in order to meet capital receipt targets.
6.1 Cllr Hay introduced the report which set out the action plan to deliver the priorities set out in the Council Strategy and the new strategic performance dataset to monitor the outcomes within the Strategy. He advised that as an administration, they recognised the importance of setting performance targets that represented where they wanted to go and enabled them to be held to account. He welcomed members comments and feedback as to whether this was the right document to use going forward.
6.7 Cllr Hay emphasised the importance of the work being undertaken by staff being visible, which was important for morale, alongside more recognition of good work.
8.7 Cllr Hay provided further information regarding the transformation work which was currently being undertaken. He explained it was about transforming services so that they were being delivered just as well, if not better, and more efficiently. He emphasised the impact of the SEND deficit on the Council’s ability to spend and on internal borrowing, and praised the finance team for putting together the 2026/27 budget under challenging circumstances.
Cllr Colin Hay, in response, stated that the Council would not be pausing its plans for parking permit increases. He commented that he did not recognise the figures referred to by [name removed] and would therefore need to provide ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
9.3 Cllr Lisa Spivey, Leader of Council, and Cllr Colin Hay, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Finance, Assets and Transformation, would first be asked to present the recommended budget that had been approved by Cabinet.
Cllr Colin Hay explained that in the last quarter’s budget monitoring report, approximately 95% of the savings targets were on track to be met by the end of the financial year 2025/26.
12.1 Cllr Colin Hay, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Finance, Assets and Transformation, outlined the recommendations from the Report listed in the agenda. He also highlighted that there had been a discussion at January’s Constitution Committee about whether further changes should be made to the public or member question process, but the committee had decided to not make any further amendments. 12.2 On being put to a vote, it was RESOLVED that Council: Approve and adopt the amended Terms of Reference for the Pensions Committee (as appended to the report), and their integration into Section 3 of the Council’s constitution. Adopt the consequential changes set out in Appendices 3 and 4, which were omitted from the original recommendations in 2021.
13.1 Cllr Colin Hay took the Pension Fund Annual report as read. He highlighted that Gloucestershire’s Pension Fund received an award for the Best Pension Fund of the Year (small) at the 2025 LGC Investment Awards. He thanked officers for their hard work. 13.2 Responding to a Member’s question about responsible investment, the Cabinet Member stated that he believed Gloucestershire’s Pension Fund worked under UK legislation including the UK’s international legal obligations. 13.3 When asked about whether radiological weapons were included in the list of controversial weapons on page 227 of the report, the Cabinet Member stated that he assumed this would be covered under the nuclear weapons category, but he would check and report back to the Member. 13.4 A Member questioned about how members and the public could have a say in the Fund’s annual review of the Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) risk management for its long term investments, it was explained that the role to review the Pension Fund’s long term investment sat with the Pension Committee, however the Committee was receptive to the views of members and the public.
5.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval to recommend the draft revenue and capital budget, Precept and the Dedicated Schools Grant budget for 2026/27 – 2029/30 to Council.
7.1 Cllr Colin Hay provided an update to Q3 end of year forecast for the 2025/26 County Council’s Revenue and Capital Budgets.
8.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought delegated authority to procure a contract for the provision of Fuel Cards for Gloucestershire County Council fleet including Fire Emergency Service vehicles.
13.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought Cabinet approval to adopt the Council’s Corporate Asset Management Plan 2026-2029 13.2 The Corporate asset management planning referred to the strategic approach an organisation took to manage its property assets in a way that effectively supports both its overall corporate aims and specific service objectives. The new provided an overview of the land and property estate, together with the main priorities for managing and developing those assets over the next four years in support of the Council’s services and key priorities.
Cllr Colin Hay stated that they had looked at other councils across the South West region and there were differences between how each council facilitated public questions.
Cllr Colin Hay confirmed there had been no request to add or remove public questions at either council or cabinet meetings. He highlighted that public questions were not included at scrutiny committees because they were not decision-making committees.
Cllr Colin Hay suggested the questioner should write to the Chair of the Police and Crime Panel for the Panel to consider.
Cllr Colin Hay stated whilst work was continuing between Gloucestershire County Council and the 6 District Councils regarding Local Government Reorganisation, it would be decided by the councillors who were elected to the shadow unitary authority to make the decisions on how to organise the new unitary council/councils.
Cllr Colin Hay confirmed there had been no previous suggestion to change the current process and members of the public were already able to watch the meeting live via the webcast. He agreed this was something that could be looked into in the future.
8.1 Cllr Colin Hay provided an update on Quarter 1 end of year forecast for the 2025/26 County Council’s Revenue and Capital Budgets. He reported on the Council’s performance and risk during Quarter 1 2025/26. 8.2 T he forecast of the year end revenue position, as at Quarter 1, was a net overspend of £224k.?The Member emphasised that the plan was on track. It was explained that this was an inherited budget from the previous administration. ? 8.3 The performance data within the report would be received by the relevant scrutiny committees. 8.4 The Adult Social Care directorate was forecasting an overspend of £2.745 million.
Cllr Hay thanked Officers at the County Council and the District Councils for working together to resolve that issue. Members commented on the importance of Junction 10 with regards to homes and to jobs. The Leader highlighted the partnership work that had taken place in this area, offering her thanks as well to all those involved.
16.1 Cllr Colin Hay sought approval for proposed Schedule of Disposals in order to meet capital receipt targets ? 16.2 Prior to the discussion, members were advised that, should Cabinet wish to discuss the contents of the exempt information reported at Appendix A of the report, consideration would need to be given as to whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting in accordance with Regulation 4(2)(b) of the Local Authorities (Executive Arrangements) (Meetings and Access to Information) (England) Regulations 2012. Cabinet agreed to consider this item without having to refer to the exempt information. 16.3 Approval of both Schedules of Disposals and the declaration of those sites as surplus to requirements, would deliver future capital receipts. It was noted this was a schedule that had been set by the previous administration.
At this point, the Chair of the Pension Committee, Cllr Hay joined the meeting.
At this juncture Cllr Hay left the meeting.
Question 16 – Cllr Colin Hay asked for the number of locations where the signage and road markings for Traffic Regulation Orders weren’t aligned and asked how long it would take to rectify the issues. He also asked for a specific answer on when issues in Pittville Street would be resolved.
Question 17 – Cllr Colin Hay questioned the Cabinet member about why a barrier to prevent residents tripping over a tree stump had been in place for over a year on Tamar Road.
13.1 Cllr Colin Hay, Chair of the Pensions Committee, presented the report. He stated that it was a statutory obligation for the report to be considered by Council and he highlighted the following points:
Question 13 – Cllr Colin Hay asked when free space in Shire Hall would be made available, and whether the Cabinet Member would commit to making it available and affordable for micro-businesses and individuals to use as office space.
1) Cllr Roger Whyborn 2) Cllr Colin Hay 3) Cllr Lisa Spivey 4) Cllr Wendy Thomas 5) Cllr Beki Hoyland 3.2 The Chair invited Rob Ayliffe, Director of Policy, Performance & Governance and Monitoring Officer, to outline the process for considering the call-in. The Committee was advised that the purpose of the call-in was not to consider whether or not the committee agreed with the cabinet decision but to consider whether the process for making the decision had been conducted in the proper way, and whether or not that process was consistent with the Council’s Constitution and in line with lawful decision making.
Question 5 – Cllr Colin Hay asked how much additional money would come from GCC’s reserves for the staff pay award if the agreed amount was higher than the 3% which had been budgeted for?
10.3 Cllr Colin Hay highlighted to members that the Corporate Scrutiny Committee had received a cabinet response to the Rural Estate Task Group at its meeting in May. He reiterated his disappointment that Cabinet were unable to support recommendations around increasing the Estate’s acreage.
On calling for nominations for the Chair, Cllr Hay was nominated by Cllr Brown and seconded by Cllr Turner.
On being put to the vote, Councillor Hay was duly appointed as Chair for the ensuing civic year.
Resolved That Councillor Colin Hay was elected as Chair for the ensuing civic year.
Resolved That Councillor Hay was appointed as the Brunel Oversight Board representative for the civic year.
Cllr Colin Hay was elected as Vice Chair.
10.3 A petition from Cllr Colin Hay was presented to Cllr Dom Morris to request the resurfacing of Priors Road, Cheltenham.
6.9 Cllr Colin Hay proposed, under Procedural Standing Order 11.1.3 , to ask the Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee to establish a Scrutiny Task Group to explore the issues raised in the report, and to present their findings back to Council in September.
Cllr Colin Hay: I served with Bill for quite a time in the 80s ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Question 11 – Cllr Colin Hay asked whether the Cabinet Member stood by his comment that the latest funding settlement was good.
Question 9 – Cllr Colin Hay suggested that the average cost for an authority to come out of a rating of ‘inadequate’ ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
7.3 A petition from Cllr Colin Hay on Zone 15 parking scheme was presented to Cllr Dom Morris.
Cllr Colin Hay stated he was a member of the National Trust in relation to Motion 924.
Councillor Hay was duly elected as Vice Chairperson for the ensuing civic year.
Cllr Colin Hay elected as Vice Chair
The Pension Board Annual Report presented to Council at this meeting was contained within the Annual Report at page 132 of the agenda (page 72 of the Annual Report), 12.5 Acknowledging the in-depth amount of work involved in producing the reports, Cllr Colin Hay, (a member of the Pension Committee), suggested a little more consideration might be required when selecting some of the images used to showcase the Pension Board Annual Report. The comment was noted.
Cllr Colin Hay, Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee, requested that the various Committee Chairs considered the commissioning intentions set out in the budget when setting committee work plans.
Cllr Hay emphasised the value of taking budget considerations into account when monitoring the performance of the Committee’s service areas.
Cllr Hay also stressed the importance of cabinet members attending scrutiny committee meetings to expand on commissioning intentions and to respond to questions. The requests were noted.
Cllr Colin Hay, Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee, presented the Audit and Governance Committee Annual Report.
Cllr Hay highlighted the work carried out by the Committee over the past year, notably its consideration of the strategic risk register, and thanked officers and members for their contributions.
Cllr Hay responded that the Committee could go into exempt session at any time, however some of the issues raised by the member might best be considered by the relevant scrutiny committees.
Resolved That Cllr Colin Hay was duly appointed as Chairman for the ensuing civic year.
Question 2 – Cllr Colin Hay asked for some idea of the cost to GCC and benefits that would come from having the Tour of Britain in Gloucestershire. He asked that the information be shared.
Question 7 – Cllr Colin Hay asked for assurances that the Cabinet Member would work with other road safety users to get the campaign off the ground to alert people of the changes to the Highway Code.
Cllr Colin Hay, Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee, presented the report on the appointment of external auditors.
Question 2 - Cllr Colin Hay asked given explore potential to purchase true renewable energy would member commit to bringing back options to Cabinet for sign off rather than delegate to Directors. As it would be a key decision would this be shared with Group Leaders and would the information include the percentage of generation that was green or other.
Question 3 – Cllr Colin Hay asked whether the member agreed that .025p per kwo amounting to less than .08% of electricity bill was hugely embarrassing?
Question 5 – Cllr Colin Hay asked, how the Cabinet Member knew that there was a consensus for a rotating chair for the Leadership Gloucestershire Climate Leadership Group given that he had not been present. He also asked how did he know that this would not be blocked?
Question 7 – Cllr Colin Hay asked if the member was striving for the 80% target, why did the member say at Environment Scrutiny that ‘ we are not’ Cllr David Gray replied that the County Council did not have the power for 80% reduction but was committed to doing its part. He referred to the communication strategy and the impact of those messages as well as the installation of e chargers across the County and the tree planting programme.
Question 8 – Cllr Colin Hay asked what the member was doing to keep 80% reduction by 2030 which was the commitment made.
Question 2 – Cllr Colin Hay asked what the public interest was in a winding up order?
Question 3 – Cllr Colin Hay asked what the value for money was of over £6,000 spent on the winding up order.
Vice-chair, Cllr Colin Hay, hoped that lessons had been learnt from the external auditor’s value-for-money report on the energy from waste facility at Javelin Park, one of the biggest contracts that the Council had ever entered into. He was anxious that social value including climate change was addressed and he hoped that this would be covered when the report was presented at the next Council meeting.
Question 6 – Cllr Colin Hay asked again for the additional cost, noting that there had been an independent consultant and an additional review.
Question 7 - Cllr Colin Hay asked how many care packages would be reviewed and altered and what the additional cost of this was.
Question 8 – Cllr Colin Hay stated that the independent report from the social worker should have been made available to councillors as a background paper to the decision being taken at the meeting background papers.
Cllr Colin Hay was appointed as Vice-chair of the Constitution Committee for the remainder of the 2021-22 Civic Year.
Cllr Hay quoted from Knowles on Local Authority Meetings where there was a reference to the importance that Widdicombe attached to being able to question the majority party on Council policy. He said that it was a fundamental responsibility to be able to call to account those people making decisions on behalf of the Council. There was a difference of view expressed among members with some believing that separate Council agenda items were no longer necessary as mechanisms were in place to hold decision makers to account.
Cllr Hay stated that given that at the Cabinet meeting the previous week the latest budget outturn had been presented it was disappointing that this would not be received at council until its meeting in September 2021.
The following supplementary questions were asked at the meeting Question 3 – Cllr Colin Hay asked how members would be able to influence and to be consulted on the spending of the Gloucestershire Restart Fund?
Question 4 – Cllr Colin Hay referred to the liberal democrat amendment at budget council to allow for some funding for members to distribute to communities. He asked if the Cabinet member agreed that councillors were best placed to help advise on how to distribute funds?
Question 5 – Cllr Colin Hay asked for confirmation that the general reserves funds would not be touched until the next budget setting period and asked how the member would consult with councillors on how to allocate.
Cllr Victoria Atherstone substituted for Cllr Hay at the meeting.
Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee –Cllr Phil Awford Children and Families Scrutiny Committee – Cllr Andrew Miller Environment Scrutiny Committee – Cllr Dom Morris Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee – Cllr Stephen Hirst Health Scrutiny Committee – Cllr Andrew Gravells Economic Growth Scrutiny – Cllr Matt Babbage Fire and Rescue – Cllr Jeremy Hilton Audit and Governance Committee – Cllr Colin Hay
Cllr Hay concurred with the previous comments and added that it had been a great and interesting committee to be a member off and it was helped by good chairmanship and he appreciated Cllr Theodoulou skills. Peter Clark wished to extend his thanks to Chairman, as he had made it very easy for a non expert, non councillor to be involved in the Pension Committee meeting and had always allowed questions no matter how foolish. The Chairman thanked the Committee for their kind words.
Question 10 – Cllr Colin Hay asked what proportion of children who needed a computer had received one as well as a 4G router. He asked how many children still needed that equipment.
Question 11 – Cllr Colin Hay asked if the ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Children and Families Capital Programme Update Cllr Hay referred to school capacity pressures in Bishops Cleeve and asked whether existing school sites would be taken into account when choosing a new site for a school. He emphasised the importance of not being in a situation where parents felt the need to drive their children to school.
Children and Families Capital Programme Update Cllr Hay asked the Cabinet Member to be clear around commitments for the school to be zero carbon, in relation not just to its ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Colin Hay declared a personal interest as the current Chair of the Gloucestershire Police and Crime Panel. The special responsibility allowance for the position did not form part of the Council’s allowances scheme but the IRP had indicated support for the allowance to be set at the same level as a Scrutiny Chair at Gloucestershire County Council.
Councillor Colin Hay led the service by sharing his experience at Srebrenica. Group Leaders signed a statement for the Council’s adoption of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (HRA) Working Definition of Antisemitism.
Question 6 – Cllr Colin Hay asked when the under-estimation had been identified regarding school places and whether the current figures were now correct.
Question 7 – Cllr Colin Hay asked the Cabinet Member to explain his understanding of the potential issues with the primary school site in Bishops Cleeve and why the local parish councils were concerned.
Question 9 – Cllr Colin Hay asked for the Cabinet Member’s understanding of glebe land as detailed in the answer.
Question 10 – Cllr Colin Hay asked if the consultation was effective when only one site was identified.
Cllr Colin Hay, Chair of the Gloucestershire Police and Crime Panel, advised that the Police and Crime Commissioner’s budget and precept had been supported unanimously by the panel. He noted that the increase in the funding available to the Police relied on a substantial rise in council tax. He acknowledged that the Government was fully funding the costs of extra 20,000 police officers with the Gloucestershire allocation expected to be 152.
Cllr Hay echoed the Chairs sentiment and wished Mark every future happiness in his forthcoming retirement.
Councillor Hay requested that in future the acronyms as referred to by the LGPS were used within the minutes. Resolved That the public minutes of the meeting held on 20 th September 2019 were approved as a correct record and signed by the Chairperson.
RESOLVED that Cllr Colin Hay be elected to the position of Vice-Chair of the Constitution Committee for the 2019-20 Civic Year.
4.1 As the original proposer of the motion at full Council on 28 November 2018, the Chair invited Cllr Colin Hay to introduce this item and explain the background behind the motion.
Cllr Colin Hay presented a petition to Cllr Norman calling for a review of residents’ parking in Cheltenham. He said that this had been promised six months after the introduction of the scheme six years ago.
Question 4 - Cllr Colin Hay asked how the Council could stop Thomas Keble School from reducing SEN numbers as this was against the law.
Q5 – Cllr Colin Hay asked for confirmation that all new and refurbished schools would have sprinklers.
Question 1 : Cllr Colin Hay Agenda item 5: Financial Monitoring Report Children and Families (Point 20) Cllr Hay asked the cabinet member to provide budget details on the funding spent on delivering the council’s youth support services over the past 10 years.
Question 2 : Cllr Colin Hay Agenda item 5: Financial Monitoring Report Children and Families (Point 24) In response to the comment that other authorities were experiencing the same recruitment and retention difficulties as Gloucestershire, Cllr Hay asked if this meant there was no agreement on the setting the salaries of permanent social worker staff and if the cabinet member could foresee a change in this position before 20 March 2019.
Question 3 : Cllr Colin Hay Agenda item 5: Financial Monitoring Report Children and Families (Point 27) Cllr Hay asked what advice had been given to the Schools Forum by council officers?
Question 4 : Cllr Colin Hay Agenda item 5: Financial Monitoring Report Children and Families (Point 27) Cllr Hay questioned the advice given at the Schools Forum meeting and asked if the cabinet member thought the recommendation to change from 'one in 75' to '1 in 40' would damage education standards and if the change had been agreed by all schools?
Question 2 – Cllr Colin Hay asked if the Leader were to get a box of matches would he want to start the incinerator with it or would he want to burn it down due to the extra costs being incurred? Was he proud of it?
Cllr Brian Oosthuysen to replace Cllr Eva Ward and Cllr Suzanne Williams (not present at the meeting) to replace Cllr Colin Hay.
Cllr Colin Hay suggested that there should be a mechanism for a motion to be referred to scrutiny without the need for a debate at Council. He said that with limited time available for motions at Council meetings there were occasions when there was not enough time to consider all the motions on the agenda. He believed that with the agreement of the Chairman and political group leaders particular motions could be identified for referral to scrutiny at the Council briefing which was held the week before Council meetings.
Cllr Mark Hawthorne, the committee chair, recognised the concerns raised by Cllr Hay but at the same time he was anxious that the scrutiny work programme was not dominated by items identified at full Council. Another member noted the importance of allowing each scrutiny committees to manage its own work programme.
Councillor Robbins was proposed by Councillor Hay, this was seconded by Councillor Hilton, and there being no other nominations for the Vice-Chair.
Cllr Colin Hay and Cllr Ray Theodoulou were proposed for the position of Vice-Chair of the Constitution Committee.
At the full Council meeting on 16 May 2018, Cllr Colin Hay had requested that the Constitution Committee to consider the procedural standing orders relating to amendments.
Cllr Hay explained that he had made the request because he was concerned at the way in which motion 812 relating to Police funding had been amended. He recognised that it was the Chair’s judgement on the validity of an amendment but he believed that in this particular case a completely new proposal had been put forward. He said that the amendment had changed the intent of the motion to such an extent that the original proposer and seconder were unable to support it.
The Committee considered a suggestion from Cllr Colin Hay on the inclusion of a separate procedure within the Constitution for budget council meetings.
Cllr Hay suggested that it could be easier, and less confusing, for a separate procedure for budget council meetings to be codified within the Constitution instead.
Question 10 - Cllr Colin Hay referred to the ‘appalling state’ of the section of Cheltenham High Street from Rodney Road to Bath Road. He asked how much would it cost to reinstate that area of the High Street?
Councillor Hay declared he was a member of Cheltenham Borough Council.
Councillor Hay declared he was a member of Cheltenham Borough Council.
In relation to Action 1, the Clerk informed the Committee that two nominations (Councillor Hay & Councillor Parsons) for the Vice-Chairmanship had been received by Democratic Services.
Councillor Hay raised a verbal question in relation to public interest in off shore tax havens and requested to know if any of GCC’s investments were in such accounts. It was agreed that the Head of Pensions would contact all of the investment managers used by the Gloucestershire Fund and seek assurances that none of the funds investments were placed “off shore” in order to avoid the payment of tax. IT was also agreed that a statement would be brought back to the next meeting of the Committee.
Action – Simon Harper Following a detailed discussion, Cllr Colin Hay proposed an amendment to the Constitution which determined that an oral question could be asked by a member of the public, provided that he or she gave notice of the question to the Chief Executive by 8am on the day of the meeting.
The Committee voted on the proposal by Cllr Hay, which was defeated.
Councillor Hay also declared he was a member of Cheltenham Borough Council.
Referring to page 24 of the agenda pack, Cllr Colin Hay, the member representing All Saints and Oakley, noted that the information under the Priors and Oakley Flood Alleviation Scheme related to a different decision.
Cllr Hay said that County Council officers had failed to provide him with information about the scheme and they had not had proper discussions with Cheltenham Borough Council. Another member also expressed concern about the approach taken by County Council officers who were now resorting to legal action on a particular aspect of the scheme.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, apologised for the lack of engagement with local members and he offered to meet Cllr Hay on site.
Cllr Colin Hay suggested appointing a Vice Chairman of the Committee, to facilitate at meetings in the absence of the Chairman. The committee noted the suggestion and agreed to consider at the next meeting.
He made special mention of Michelle Pidgeon in Democratic Services, who had provided day-to-day support to him in his role as Chairman, and Cllr Colin Hay, his Vice-chairman, for the support that he had provided over the course of the year. He said that it had been an honour to represent the Council at events across the county.
Cllr Colin Hay was proposed and seconded. There being no other nominations, it was:
RESOLVED that Cllr Colin Hay be elected as Chairman of Council for the 2016-17 civic year.
Cllr Hay made the Declaration of Acceptance of Office and signed the Roll of Members as Chairman.
Cllr Hay thanked members for their support.
He undertook to provide Cllr Hay and Cllr McMahon with a more detailed briefing including information on the distances that children were placed away from their family homes. A member expressed concern at the reduction in children centre provision at a time when the number of children in care was rising across the county.
Cllr Hay made a non-prejudicial declaration as a member of Cheltenham Borough Council.
Gloucestershire Economic Growth Committee Chairman of the committee, Cllr Colin Hay, reported that the committee had last met on 18 March 2015, the same day as the Economic Growth Joint Committee. This had allowed the members of the scrutiny committee to look at the same issues and the same approach would be followed for future meetings. A strong message had ... view the full minutes text for item 25.
Question 7 – Cllr Colin Hay asked that he be provided with details of what KPI information was, as outlined in the answer. He also asked that information provided in response to supplementary questions be available to all members.
Question 8 – Cllr Colin Hay asked that acronyms be fully explained in the responses to questions.
Motion 701 - Female Genital Mutilation Cllr Colin Hay proposed and Cllr Sarah Lunnon seconded the following motion:
Cllr Colin Hay and Cllr Sarah Lunnon , the proposer and seconder for the following motion on female genital mutilation (FGM), requested that it be deferred until the next meeting on 19 March 2014 to allow more time for a proper debate.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Hay attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Hay's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Hay was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 1 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Hay declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Mar 2020 | Constitution Committee, item 24 | Cllr Colin Hay declared a personal interest as the current Chair of the Gloucestershire Police and Crime Panel. The special responsibility allowance for the position did not form part of the Council’s allowances scheme but the IRP had indicated support for the allowance to be set at the same level as a Scrutiny Chair at Gloucestershire County Council. | |
| 9 Feb 2018 | Pension Committee, item 1 | Councillor Hay declared he was a member of Cheltenham Borough Council. | |
| 10 Nov 2017 | Pension Committee, item 62 | Councillor Hay declared he was a member of Cheltenham Borough Council. | |
| 1 Sep 2017 | Pension Committee, item 43 | Councillor Hay also declared he was a member of Cheltenham Borough Council. |
Where Councillor Hay sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Constitution Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.