CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Gloucestershire/Councillor Iain Dobie
ID

Councillor Iain Dobie

Chair, Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Follow Councillor Dobie's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
0%meetings attended0 of 1 since 2013
123times in the minutesAsked 32, said 36, moved 2, seconded 3
0recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
0declarations at meetingsInterests declared on agenda items
1committees in the last year1 as Chair or Vice-Chair

On the record

Every time Gloucestershire's minutes name Councillor Dobie, as the council published it.

Moved2 Jul 2026Appointments Committee

Appointment of Chair

Cllr Iain Dobie proposed and Cllr Piers Camp seconded the nomination of Cllr Colin Hay as Chair for this meeting.
From the council's minutes: Appointments Committee, 2 Jul 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Update

Cllr Iain Dobie, (as Chair), introduced the item by referencing the focus of attention and commitment given by the members of this and the former committee to the delivery of maternity services in Gloucestershire in recent years.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Update

Cllr Dobie noted the concerns of members of the public, NHS employees, midwives and members of the committee to ensuring safe and accessible maternity care for the county.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Update

Building on the discussion from the previous meeting , Cllr Dobie acknowledged the increasing levels of demand for maternity services and how the nature of this demand had changed in recent years and the notable impact on services.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Update

In response to ongoing issues, Cllr Dobie thanked the Gloucestershire Hospitals NHS FT for continuing to provide regular updates and ongoing information sharing briefings to both himself, as Chair, and to the committee.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Update

Cllr Dobie welcomed Marie Crofts: Chief Nursing Officer and Helen Ford: Deputy Director and Programme Director for Children, Maternity and All Age Mental Health to the meeting, and invited them to present the ‘ Case for Change’ for the delivery of Maternity Services in Gloucestershire.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Update

For completeness, Cllr Dobie suggested that the committee combine an update from the Director for Safety and Medical Director, Professor Mark Pietroni, with consideration of the following updates before asking questions on the item as a whole.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Named26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Update

Cllr Dobie reminded members that no decisions would be required by the committee at this meeting. The presentations for consideration by the committee had been provided for information purposes only, for which members could comment on or express a committee viewpoint. After the meeting, any relevant comments would be collated to form a ‘committee response statement’ and shared with the Hospitals Trust/published with the minutes of the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Gloucestershire Integrated Care System (GICS) Performance Report

In response, the following comments were made by the committee: - Cllr Iain Dobie, as Chair, requested details/clarification on the NHS definition of "Medical Imaging" and whether X-Rays/the work of radiographers were included in the definition. The information was requested to gain a better understanding of issues affecting medical imaging in Gloucestershire and whether shortages of equipment and specialist trained staff are impacting on the county.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 5Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

NHS Gloucestershire Integrated Care Board (ICB) Report

The information to be considered as a possible joint matter of interest with the Children and Families Scrutiny Committee.   e)     Cllr Iain Dobie requested ongoing updates from the Gloucestershire Health and Care NHS Foundation (GHC) Trust on the delivery of services at Wotton Lawn Hospital, Gloucester.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 26 May 2026, item 6Open the meeting
Named10 Mar 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies

Cllr Iain Dobie, Chair of the Gloucestershire Health, Overview and Scrutiny Committee, welcomed everyone to the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 10 Mar 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Named10 Mar 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies

Chairs Opening Remarks a)     Cllr Dobie reflected on the value of the Joint Meeting held with the Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee meeting on 3 March 2026 and of the positive outcomes from the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 10 Mar 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Named10 Mar 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies

Cllr Dobie referenced recent reports on the national healthy lifespan being in decline and expressed concerns about whether this might be reflected by the healthy lifespan/life expectancy rates of the Gloucestershire population.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 10 Mar 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Asked10 Mar 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies

As Chair, Cllr Dobie enquired whether this was an area of work the committee might be interested in considering in more detail as a joint ASCC and HOSC scrutiny exercise involving dual hatted members of both committees.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 10 Mar 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Named3 Mar 2026Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Welcome and apologies

Cllr Iain Dobie, Chair of the Gloucestershire Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (HOSC), echoed these thoughts and referenced the overlap between social care in the community and NHS care, including services   provided by the county council and in neighbourhoods.
From the council's minutes: Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 3 Mar 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Said3 Mar 2026Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Welcome and apologies

Cllr Dobie emphasised   the importance of maintaining health independence and the value of adopting a coordinated approach from both a delivery and scrutiny perspective.
From the council's minutes: Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 3 Mar 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Named3 Mar 2026Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Welcome and apologies

Cllr Dobie supported the merits of both committees taking a more holistic approach to scrutiny.
From the council's minutes: Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 3 Mar 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Named3 Mar 2026Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Overview of the role and work of the Gloucestershire Health and Wellbeing Board

Chair of the Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Cllr Iain Dobie, invited Claire Procter, (Assistant Director: Public Health and Communities Team at Gloucestershire County Council), to present an overview of the work of the Gloucestershire Health and Wellbeing Board, including an update on the Joint Local Health and Wellbeing Strategy.
From the council's minutes: Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 3 Mar 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Named3 Mar 2026Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee

NHS Gloucestershire 5 Year Strategic Plan (Gloucestershire NOW: Wellbeing, Prevention and Maintaining Health Independence)

Chair of the Health, Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Cllr Iain Dobie invited Will Chapman, (Associate Director - Prevention & VCSE Partnerships: NHS Gloucestershire), to present the item.
From the council's minutes: Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 3 Mar 2026, item 5Open the meeting
Named3 Mar 2026Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee

NHS Gloucestershire 5 Year Strategic Plan (Gloucestershire NOW: Wellbeing, Prevention and Maintaining Health Independence)

Cllr Dobie reminded members that, at recent meetings of the Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee, the committee had received presentations on issues included in the NHS Gloucestershire 5 Year Strategic Plan. The presentations reflect the 3 Gloucestershire ‘NOW’ Themes identified as:
From the council's minutes: Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 3 Mar 2026, item 5Open the meeting
Named27 Jan 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies

Cllr Iain Dobie, Chair of the Gloucestershire Health, Overview and Scrutiny Committee, welcomed everyone to the meeting before introducing Shane Devlin, Chief Executive Officer of the Gloucestershire ICB and Bristol, North Somerset and South Gloucestershire Integrated Care Board (ICB) clustering arrangement to his first meeting of the committee.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 27 Jan 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Said27 Jan 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies

Cllr Dobie said he looked forward to meeting with [name removed] in the next few weeks.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 27 Jan 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Named27 Jan 2026Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies

Chairs Opening Remarks Cllr Dobie opened the meeting with the following statement:
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 27 Jan 2026, item 1Open the meeting
Named18 Nov 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Gloucestershire Integrated Care System (GICS) Performance Report

6.5      Reiterating comments from earlier in the meeting, Chair, Cllr Iain Dobie, referenced concerns about cancer wait time performance in Gloucestershire and proposed that that committee revisit the work of the previous committee in relation to the target by including a review of the recommendations made to full council in November 2024 to the committee work plan. Action by - Democratic Services Support Officer 6.6      Gloucestershire Healthwatch commended improvements in the performance of mental health targets. Children and Young Persons (CYP) mental health service and perinatal mental health service access remained strong and continued to track above the operational plan, with CYP access 10% above plan and perinatal mental health 1% above plan (as of August 2025).
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 18 Nov 2025, item 6Open the meeting
Named14 Oct 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Work Plan

N - Neighbourhood, Health and Care (18 November 2025) O - Online, Digital and Technology (27 January 2026) W - Wellbeing, Prevention, and Maintaining Health Independence (10 Mar 2026) Ø   (N) End of life care/future of health and care in Gloucestershire* (refer Cllr Dilys Neill comments at the 14 Oct meeting) Ø   (N) Gloucestershire GP Collaboration Group* (refer Cllrs Rebecca Trimnell and Adrian Bamford comments at the 14 Oct meeting) Ø   (N) Neighbourhood Health* (refer Cllr Dilys Neill comments at the 14 Oct meeting) Ø   (O) NHS Communications* (refer Cllr Ian Yates comments at the 14 Oct meeting) Ø   (O) Transition from analogue to digital* (refer Cllr Iain Dobie comments at the 14 Oct meeting) Ø   (W) Update on NHS 10 Year Plan* (refer Cllr Julia Gooch comments at the 14 Oct meeting) and items for consideration by the Gloucestershire Health and Wellbeing Board and Partnership Links to relevant items (including mental health topics) for consideration at future meetings of the Health and Wellbeing Biard and Health and Wellbeing Partnership Committee meetings to be circulated to members for information/noting.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 14 Oct 2025, item 9Open the meeting
Named15 Jul 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Welcome and Apologies

By means of introduction to the members and officers who supported the committee, at this, the first meeting of the new council, Cllr Dobie refereed to his previous years as Chair of the Committee, before thanking Cllr Andrew Gravells, former Chair and current member of the committee, for his hard work and commitment to not only the committee, but to health services in general.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2025, item 1Open the meeting
Said15 Jul 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Welcome and Apologies

In quotation, Cllr Dobie stated that the ‘purpose of scrutiny’ was to improve the lives of local people through improved public services.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2025, item 1Open the meeting
Named15 Jul 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Welcome and Apologies

Cllr Dobie hoped everyone agreed that the committee should act as a critical friend to both NHS colleagues and to officers from Gloucestershire County Council. He felt it was important to provide a friendly, but constructive critical challenge on behalf of the residents of Gloucestershire. In meetings open to the public, it was important to amply the voices of those people to whom the committee represented and to help drive improvement in a way that enhanced respect of the scrutiny process.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2025, item 1Open the meeting
Named15 Jul 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Welcome and Apologies

Cllr Dobie encouraged the committee to be self-disciplined and efficient in its work and to focus on issues that would be make a real difference to the lives of local people.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2025, item 1Open the meeting
Named15 Jul 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Terms of Reference

The hosting of joint committee meetings, involving the members of the respective scrutiny committees, was something Cllr Iain Dobie, as Committee Chair, and Cllr Rebecca Trimnell, Chair of the Adult Social Care and Communities Scrutiny Committee, (and a member of the committee), believed would be useful and add value to the committees’ work.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Named15 Jul 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Public Representations

It was agreed that, as Chair, Cllr Dobie request that the Gloucestershire Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust provide a written response to the representation.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2025, item 5Open the meeting
Said15 Jul 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Work Plan

Cllr Dobie suggested that the committee work plan discussion be seen as an opportunity to gain an understanding of the depth and range of issues that had been considered by the previous committee and to make a fresh start in how the new committee intended to identify priority areas for consideration.
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2025, item 9Open the meeting
Named15 Jul 2025Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Work Plan

Action by Cllr Iain Dobie/Rebecca Trimnell The dates of future committee meetings were noted:
From the council's minutes: Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2025, item 9Open the meeting
Said11 Nov 2020Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Children and Families Capital Programme Update Cllr Dobie outlined his support for the new school at Warden Hill but expressed concern with the apparent lack of communication with councillors, residents and parents. He asked if the Cabinet Member regretted withholding information until now?
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 11 Nov 2020, item 4Open the meeting
Asked11 Nov 2020Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Children and Families Capital Programme Update Cllr Dobie asked whether the target was for the new primary school in Warden Hill to open in September 2022.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 11 Nov 2020, item 4Open the meeting
Asked11 Nov 2020Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Children and Families Capital Programme Update Cllr Dobie asked whether local representatives would involved in a public view of the school.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 11 Nov 2020, item 4Open the meeting
Asked11 Nov 2020Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Children and Families Capital Programme Update Cllr Dobie asked whether there was a clear commitment to offset all CO2 emissions from construction of the new school and for it to be zero carbon once built.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 11 Nov 2020, item 4Open the meeting
Asked11 Nov 2020Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Children and Families Capital Programme Update Cllr Dobie asked whether the Cabinet Member would commit to funding living green walls for the new school as proposed in the School Street motion to full Council in June.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 11 Nov 2020, item 4Open the meeting
Said22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Cllr Iain Dobie advised Cabinet he intended to make the decision before them as easy as possible, with the aim of instructing officers to go ahead with the proposed trials.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Named22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

In line with the motion considered by council in June, Cllr Dobie, proposed that the county’s first pilot scheme commence at Warden Hill Primary School, (represented by Cllr Dobie as County and Borough Councillor, and as a school governor).
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Said22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Cllr Dobie said he was pleased that the paper to cabinet had supported his proposals.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Said22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Cllr Dobie informed members that, in recent weeks, alongside Warden Hill Primary School staff and others, he had attempted to persuade parents from driving up the unofficial school street during the Covid-19 crisis and enable children to walk and cycle to school safely. From first-hand experience, parents understood what he was trying to do and had adhered to the newly placed, (unofficial), “no dropping off or picking up signs” by parking their vehicles elsewhere, including the extensive parking area located a few metres away from the school.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Named22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Cllr Dobie believed moral pressure from other parents and pupils had added to the beneficial behaviour changes. Parents were choosing to walk and cycle with their children to school rather than driving along Durham Close, with no requirement for heavy handed policing.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Said22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Cllr Dobie agreed however, that it was important to make the new arrangements legal.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Said22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Cllr Dobie urged Cabinet to consider making this unofficial arrangement into an official pilot school street, possibly one of three pilots across the county?
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Said22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Referring to government efforts to encourage local authorities to establish school streets across the country by promoting walking and cycling, Cllr Dobie noted a statement from the Secretary of State for Transport, Grant Shapps , who had called on councils such as Gloucestershire to close streets for this purpose and had made substantial government funding available to do so and had introduced powers to progress quickly.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Named22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Cllr Dobie warned that unless bold in responding to this offer, notably by the closure of roads, the council might be at risk of receiving less government funding to encourage cycling and walking in the future.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Said22 Jul 2020Cabinet

Motion 859 (School Street Schemes)

Cllr Dobie urged the County to move quickly and, at the very least, arrange for pilot school streets to be put in place before  ...  view the full minutes text for item 5.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Moved24 Jun 2020County Council

Motions

Motion 859 – Fast-tracked introduction of ‘School Streets’ schemes Cllr Iain Dobie proposed and Cllr Nigel Robbins seconded the motion included on the agenda.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 24 Jun 2020, item 7Open the meeting
Said24 Jun 2020County Council

Motions

Cllr Dobie informed the meeting of the challenges outside schools at the beginning and end of the school day relating to traffic; he felt sure that each member of council would have witnessed this themselves. He outlined the benefits that could be generated by the introduction of the school streets scheme in Gloucestershire, including improved safety, and air quality and encouraged walking and cycling. He also stated that this scheme would benefit the wider community health and wellbeing, and support improved community spirit.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 24 Jun 2020, item 7Open the meeting
Said24 Jun 2020County Council

Motions

Cllr Dobie felt that there was excessive bureaucracy and delay built into the traffic regulation order process (TRO) which created an unhelpful barrier. He indicated that in his view there was also a lack of will to deliver these types of schemes within Shire Hall. Passing the motion would remove these barriers.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 24 Jun 2020, item 7Open the meeting
Said24 Jun 2020County Council

Motions

Cllr Dobie stated that the council’s travel plan promoted cycling and that the council had declared a climate emergency and had identified targets for reducing air pollution. He informed the meeting that this motion supported these shared aims and asked that members support the motion as it stands.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 24 Jun 2020, item 7Open the meeting
Named9 Mar 2020Constitution Committee

Health and Wellbeing Board Terms of Reference

At the Constitution Committee on 30 January 2020, the Committee considered a proposal from Cllr Dobie to add the additional wording to the terms of reference of the Gloucestershire Health and Wellbeing Board terms of reference:
From the council's minutes: Constitution Committee, 9 Mar 2020, item 25Open the meeting
Named6 Mar 2020Appointments Committee

Apologies for absence

Cllr Iain Dobie was present as a substitute.
From the council's minutes: Appointments Committee, 6 Mar 2020, item 2Open the meeting
Named30 Jan 2020Constitution Committee

Health and Wellbeing Board Terms of Reference

6.1        The Chair invited Cllr Iain Dobie to address the Committee on this item.
From the council's minutes: Constitution Committee, 30 Jan 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Said26 Jun 2019County Council

Cabinet Member Decision Statements

Cllr Iain Dobie, the member for Leckhampton and Warden Hill, expressed concern regarding the decision of the Cabinet Member for Economy, Skills and Growth to delay a decision on the expansion of Warden Hill Primary School until March 2020. He noted that the buildings at the school were in a desperately poor condition and he asked the Cabinet Member to visit the school with him.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 26 Jun 2019, item 47Open the meeting
Named26 Jun 2019County Council

Cabinet Member Decision Statements

He said that he would be prepared to visit the school with Cllr Dobie.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 26 Jun 2019, item 47Open the meeting
Named15 May 2019County Council

Election of vice-chair

Cllr Iain Dobie and Cllr Alan Preest were both proposed and seconded.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 15 May 2019, item 26Open the meeting
Named15 May 2019County Council

Motions

Motion 836 – Carbon action plan motion In proposing and seconding the motion, Cllr Iain Dobie and Cllr Jeremy Hilton accepted a friendly amendment from Cllr Rachel Smith (see highlighted text). This Council notes that:
From the council's minutes: County Council, 15 May 2019, item 34Open the meeting
Said15 May 2019County Council

Motions

Cllr Dobie spoke passionately in support of the motion. He stated that action needed to be taken now and urged that challenging and achievable targets be set to reduce carbon emissions. He noted that average global temperatures had increased significantly and sea levels were rising.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 15 May 2019, item 34Open the meeting
Asked13 Feb 2019County Council

Member questions

Question 3 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked that the revenue generated from parking charges in Cheltenham be committed to be spent in Cheltenham.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 13 Feb 2019, item 8Open the meeting
Named23 Jan 2019Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee

Scrutiny Review Update

4.3       Appointment of Vice Chairs Cllr Dobie used the example of national government where select committee chairs were appointed on the basis of political proportionality. This was seen as best practice. He wanted it on record that he felt that Scrutiny Chairs at the County Council should be appointed in the same way.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee, 23 Jan 2019, item 4Open the meeting
Named28 Nov 2018County Council

Motions

In seconding the motion, Cllr Iain Dobie referred to the downgrading of Accident of Emergency at Cheltenham General Hospital to Urgent Care. He said that the proposal to remove General Surgery facilities at Cheltenham posed a further threat to emergency services. He noted that this meant that if anyone at Cheltenham General Hospital required emergency surgery they would have to be transferred by ambulance to Gloucester Royal Hospital.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 28 Nov 2018, item 73Open the meeting
Asked28 Nov 2018County Council

Member Questions

Question 1 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked whether the cabinet member agreed that the net effect of the movement of the building of a new secondary school in Cheltenham would lead to more expensive housing and less community green space.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 28 Nov 2018, item 74Open the meeting
Named11 Sep 2018Health and Care Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Minutes of the previous meeting

The minutes of the meeting on Tuesday 10 July 2018 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman subject to the following amendment: - Cllr Iain Dobie had sent his apologies.
From the council's minutes: Health and Care Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 11 Sep 2018, item 42Open the meeting
Asked18 Jul 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 2 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda item 11 : To consider the future of selected care homes in Gloucestershire and the relevant consultation Cllr Dobie sought clarification on the statement given in the response to his question, stating ‘all residents will be able to choose a new care home dependent upon the availability of vacancies’.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 18 Jul 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Named18 Jul 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Dobie believed it was critical for residents to live in the local vicinity when considering the closure of care homes and asked Cllr Wilson to confirm if vacancies were available in nearby residential homes Response by: Cllr Roger Wilson (Cabinet Member: Adult Social Care:
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 18 Jul 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Said18 Jul 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 3 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda item 11 : To consider the future of selected care homes in Gloucestershire and the relevant consultation Cllr Dobie stated he had been interested to read Gloucestershire County Council (GCC) was “embracing technological advancement in telecare and artificial intelligence”.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 18 Jul 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Asked18 Jul 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

With this in mind, Cllr Dobie asked the Cabinet Member to give examples of how these advances might help in practice, in particular to loneliness, which, according to, Age UK, was estimated to affect over 1 million older people and could be as harmful to health as smoking 15 cigarettes a day.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 18 Jul 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Said6 Jun 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 1 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda item 10 : Commissioning for Residential and Nursing Care Home Provision in Gloucestershire Cllr Dobie suggested research had shown the turnover rate of the care sector workforce in Gloucestershire was higher than the national or South West regional rates.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 6 Jun 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Asked6 Jun 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Dobie asked the cabinet member to provide a statement on the number of vacancies advertised as a percentage of the workforce, and to confirm if number of vacancies was going up or down?
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 6 Jun 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Named6 Jun 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Response by: Cllr Kathy Williams (Cabinet Member: Adult Social Care – Delivery) Cllr Williams stated that it would be difficult at this stage to give the detailed figures and would get back to Cllr Dobie with a response after the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 6 Jun 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Said6 Jun 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 2 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda item 10 : Commissioning for Residential and Nursing Care Home Provision in Gloucestershire Cllr Dobie suggested that the failure of care companies was acknowledged as a major issue for the County Council.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 6 Jun 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Named6 Jun 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Dobie referred to Cllr Roger Wilson’s, (Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care:
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 6 Jun 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Named31 Jan 2018Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Noting the complexities of public health funding and referring to the response to a question from Cllr Iain Dobie at the Health and Wellbeing Board meeting on 23 January 2018, the cabinet member confirmed that the health sector’s spending on mental health, (in real terms), had increased each year since 2015/16.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 31 Jan 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Named23 Jan 2018Gloucestershire Health & Wellbeing Board

Members' Questions

4.1        A written question had been received from Cllr Iain Dobie. The question and answer are available on the council website and would be included in the minute book.
From the council's minutes: Gloucestershire Health & Wellbeing Board, 23 Jan 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Asked23 Jan 2018Gloucestershire Health & Wellbeing Board

Members' Questions

4.2        Cllr Dobie asked a supplementary question, asking again whether the Gloucestershire Clinical Commissioning Group ( GCCG ) would commit to applying its own ring fence to any central government funding it receives labelled mental health.
From the council's minutes: Gloucestershire Health & Wellbeing Board, 23 Jan 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Named23 Jan 2018Gloucestershire Health & Wellbeing Board

Members' Questions

The Accountable Officer, GCCG , and STP Lead, informed Cllr Dobie that the GCCG spent a large percentage of its funding allocation on mental health, and that mental health was also a key part of the STP . She was not sure how the funding could be ring fenced given the manner in which overall funding was allocated by central government.
From the council's minutes: Gloucestershire Health & Wellbeing Board, 23 Jan 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Named13 Dec 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 1 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda Item 9: To establish a new Secondary School for Cheltenham     (Pages 145 to 154 of the agenda pack) Cllr Dobie referred to the response to the question “I know Cllr Dobie has previously suggested county council use land it owns in Leckhampton as a site for a new academy" and stated that this was untrue and had never been suggested.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Dec 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Said13 Dec 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Dobie explained that, to build on Leckhampton Fields was a highly controversial matter within his division, and by using such words, Cllr Stowe was mischievously seeking to hand his political opponents a stick with which to beat him with during the upcoming Cheltenham Borough Council elections.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Dec 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Asked13 Dec 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Dobie asked Cllr Stowe to agree to delete the words from the formal record?" Response by: Cllr Lynden Stowe: Cabinet Member for Economy, Skills and Growth Cllr Stowe advised that the comments referred to in his response had been taken from the minutes of a meeting of full council last year.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Dec 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Named13 Dec 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Stowe suggested this should have been the time to challenge the comments and agreed to forward a copy of the words to Cllr Dobie.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Dec 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Named13 Dec 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Stowe suggested Cllr Dobie engage with Democratic Services, if not satisfied with this response.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 13 Dec 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Seconded6 Dec 2017County Council

Motions

Motion 800 - Adoption and promotion of electric vehicles Cllr Rachel Smith proposed and Cllr Iain Dobie seconded the motion included on the agenda.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 6 Dec 2017, item 73Open the meeting
Said6 Dec 2017County Council

Motions

Cllr Dobie explained that the motion aimed to nudge the Council in the right direction.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 6 Dec 2017, item 73Open the meeting
Named6 Dec 2017County Council

Motions

Cllr Smith and Cllr Dobie accepted the following changes to the motion (see the highlighted text):
From the council's minutes: County Council, 6 Dec 2017, item 73Open the meeting
Asked24 Nov 2017Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee

Health and Care Scrutiny Committee

Cllr Iain Dobie asked to clarify comments within the report of the Committee congratulating the 2Gether NHS Foundation Trust on performance against targets for the Children and Young People’s Mental Health Service. He stated that this was about congratulating them for improved performance whilst noting that all waiting time targets were still not being met. He emphasised the importance of including this.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee, 24 Nov 2017, item 71Open the meeting
Asked15 Nov 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Financial Monitoring Report 2017-18 (pages 47 to 68 of the agenda pack) Cllr Dobie asked whether ‘consistently investing in supporting people with learning disabilities’ meant cuts of £4 million in the last two years and £7 million since 2014-15?
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 15 Nov 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Said15 Nov 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Financial Monitoring Report 2017-18 (pages 47 to 68 of the agenda pack) Cllr Dobie expressed concern that the percentage of the Council’s Public Health budget spent on Mental Health had reduced from 2 % to 1.2%, compared to the national average of 1.6%. He asked the Cabinet Member whether he believed that the Council should be spending at least 2 %   of its budget on Mental Health?
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 15 Nov 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Asked27 Sep 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 1 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda Item 5: Financial Monitoring Report 2017/18 (Pages 1 to 14 of the agenda pack) Cllr Dobie enquired, in cash terms, how much the council’s mental health budget had reduced by, and why there had been no re-investment in improvements to mental health services.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 27 Sep 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Named27 Sep 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Wilson suggested Cllr Dobie meet with officers to gain a better understanding of how the budget was being managed.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 27 Sep 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Said27 Sep 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 2 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda Item 5: Financial Monitoring Report 2017/18 (Pages 1 to 14 of the agenda pack) Cllr Dobie said he was pleased with the response to the question, and the decision to transfer part of the underspend in the public mental health budget to the public   health reserve.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 27 Sep 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Asked27 Sep 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Cllr Dobie asked if other underspends would be ring-fenced for mental health?
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 27 Sep 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Asked27 Sep 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 3 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda Item 10: Direct Award Contract for Electronic Call Monitoring to Disability Community Care and Support Providers (Pages 103 to 110 of the agenda pack) Cllr Dobie enquired how checks on providers would be reported back to members and at which scrutiny committee? He asked what performance indicators would be in the public domain and in published contract reports to ensure carers allowed appropriate time between visits?
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 27 Sep 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Said18 Sep 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Question 2 : Cllr Iain Dobie Agenda Item 5: Children’s Services Improvement Plan (page 11 of the agenda pack) Cllr Dobie thanked Cllr Boyles for the responses to his 5 questions on the Children’s Services Improvement Plan and to the responses provided at the Full Council meeting on 13 September 2017.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 18 Sep 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Asked18 Sep 2017Cabinet

Questions at Cabinet Meetings

Relating his supplementary question to all 5 of his original questions, Cllr Dobie asked the Cabinet Member to ‘look him in the eye’ and ‘state man to man on behalf of all the vulnerable children in the care of the council and its officers’, if Cllr Boyles ‘personally believed the Children’s Services  ...  view the full minutes text for item 4.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 18 Sep 2017, item 4Open the meeting
Seconded13 Sep 2017County Council

Motions

Cllr David Brown proposed and Cllr Iain Dobie seconded the following motion:
From the council's minutes: County Council, 13 Sep 2017, item 61Open the meeting
Said13 Sep 2017County Council

Motions

In seconding the motion, Cllr Dobie said that the Council’s duty of care did not end when outside providers were employed to deliver services on its behalf. He believed that the way that Cleeve Link operated before it collapsed was exploitative as staff were not paid travelling time between appointments. He was concerned at the impact on vulnerable people and was anxious that a similar situation did not arise again.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 13 Sep 2017, item 61Open the meeting
Asked13 Sep 2017County Council

Member questions

Question 1 -   Cllr Iain Dobie asked that the Leader ask Democratic Services to ensure they had alternative phone number and email address so all members could be updated in the event of issues such as the ICT disruption that had occurred.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 13 Sep 2017, item 62Open the meeting
Asked13 Sep 2017County Council

Member questions

Question 2 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked how much working time had been lost by staff at Shire Hall and those working remotely due to the failure.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 13 Sep 2017, item 62Open the meeting
Asked13 Sep 2017County Council

Member questions

Question 4 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked if the Cabinet Member could provide more information including a detailed breakdown on the £400k extra support to people with disabilities.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 13 Sep 2017, item 62Open the meeting
Asked22 Mar 2017County Council

Member questions

Question 1 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked if the independent report on air pollution monitoring in Gloucestershire could be made available to the Health and Care Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 22 Mar 2017, item 22Open the meeting
Asked22 Mar 2017County Council

Member questions

Question 2 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked why the County Council had declined to set an example by using electric vehicles.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 22 Mar 2017, item 22Open the meeting
Asked22 Mar 2017County Council

Member questions

Question 16 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked whether the Leader would speak to the Local Government Minister to ensure Gloucestershire was first in the queue for being able to retain 100% business rates.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 22 Mar 2017, item 22Open the meeting
Named7 Dec 2016County Council

Ambulance response times (motion 759)

Cllr Iain Dobie, Chairman of the Health and Care Overview and Scrutiny Committee, stated that it was important to consider the report in the context of a national situation where no ambulance services across the country were meeting targets for response times. He believed that the Government was starving funding to health and social care which was leading to a national crisis. He noted that overall spending was going down in terms of the proportion of health spending to Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
From the council's minutes: County Council, 7 Dec 2016, item 78Open the meeting
Asked7 Dec 2016County Council

Member questions

Question 4 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked:
From the council's minutes: County Council, 7 Dec 2016, item 79Open the meeting
Asked7 Dec 2016County Council

Member questions

Question 5 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked ‘At the last Council meeting I noted that at the Gloucestershire Health and Care Overview and Scrutiny Committee the GP-led Gloucestershire Clinical Commissioning Group reported that County Council cutbacks in support packages for vulnerable adults with learning difficulties would have health consequences.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 7 Dec 2016, item 79Open the meeting
Said29 Jun 2016County Council

Member Questions

Question 2 – Cllr Iain Dobie   stated that given that 45-50% of children coming into care suffered from mental health problems would there be the separation of mental health provision for looked after children?
From the council's minutes: County Council, 29 Jun 2016, item 51Open the meeting
Named18 May 2016Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Work Plan

During consideration of the work plan, the committee received an update on a proposal from former scrutiny committee member, Cllr Iain Dobie.
From the council's minutes: Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 18 May 2016, item 8Open the meeting
Named18 May 2016Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Work Plan

Members recalled that, at an earlier meeting, Cllr Dobie had proposed that the committee consider replacing the council's diesel fleet with less damaging automated technologies.
From the council's minutes: Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 18 May 2016, item 8Open the meeting
Seconded11 May 2016County Council

Motions

The following amendment proposed by Cllr Paul Hodgkinson and seconded by Cllr Iain Dobie was accepted by the mover and seconder of the original motion. The amendment therefore became the substantive motion.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 11 May 2016, item 36Open the meeting
Asked11 May 2016County Council

Member Questions

Question 1 -   Cllr Iain Dobie asked whether the Cabinet Member would commit to making Gloucestershire a cycling county aiming to double the investment figure per head to £2?
From the council's minutes: County Council, 11 May 2016, item 37Open the meeting
Asked11 May 2016County Council

Member Questions

Question 2 - Cllr Iain Dobie asked whether the Cabinet Member believed that all schools should be academies by 2020.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 11 May 2016, item 37Open the meeting
Said23 Mar 2016County Council

Members' Questions

Question 1 – Cllr Iain Dobie noted the response which outlined that there were currently no or very few viable alternatives to diesel. He asked whether advantage could be taken of new technology which provided electric vans at competitive prices. He commended the Police and Crime Commissioner’s Office for committing to buy electric alternatives for the Police vehicle fleet..
From the council's minutes: County Council, 23 Mar 2016, item 22Open the meeting
Asked23 Mar 2016County Council

Members' Questions

Question 15 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked for   the Cabinet Member’s views on the direction from Government   to form academies and expressed his concerns around the availability of local secondary school places and the local authority not having oversight of school improvement and catchment areas.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 23 Mar 2016, item 22Open the meeting
Named23 Mar 2016County Council

Members' Questions

In response, Cllr Paul McLain explained that the local authority did not currently have many of the controls outlined by Cllr Dobie and that there would still be oversight of school based planning. In relation to concerns around secondary school places, he stated that the extra demand for places from the Leckhampton development could be met from the expansion of existing schools in the area.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 23 Mar 2016, item 22Open the meeting
Asked23 Mar 2016County Council

Members' Questions

Question 16 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked whether, if parents in the area of the Leckhampton development wished to set up a free school, would the Council make some of its land available if approached?
From the council's minutes: County Council, 23 Mar 2016, item 22Open the meeting
Named9 Mar 2016Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Work Plan

The committee noted an earlier proposal from Cllr Iain Dobie proposing that the committee consider options to replace the council's current vehicle diesel fleet with less damaging automated technologies. Several members supported the proposal and requested a briefing note on the County Council’s intentions to support and promote alternative automotive vehicle technologies in Gloucestershire at the committee meeting on 18 May 2016.
From the council's minutes: Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 9 Mar 2016, item 10Open the meeting
Named13 Jan 2016Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Work Plan

The committee noted a proposal from Cllr Iain Dobie for the council to consider appointing a Member Champion from which to promote the benefits of cycling in Gloucestershire.
From the council's minutes: Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 13 Jan 2016, item 7Open the meeting
Named13 Jan 2016Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee

Work Plan

18 May 2016 The committee considered a proposal from Cllr Dobie proposing that the committee consider replacing the council's diesel fleet with less damaging automotive technology. Speaking in support of the proposal, the committee requested a paper on the Gloucestershire County Council’s activities to promote electric vehicle use in Gloucestershire at the committee meeting on 18 May 2016. It was suggested that the relevant cabinet portfolio holder attend the meeting to answer questions.
From the council's minutes: Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee, 13 Jan 2016, item 7Open the meeting
Asked25 Mar 2015County Council

Member questions

Question 3 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked for clarification over the favourable terms referred to in the answer in relation to the bidder. He asked whether this included green spaces or was purely in financial terms.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 25 Mar 2015, item 23Open the meeting
Named26 Feb 2014County Council

Members' Questions

Question 1 – Cllr Iain Dobie referred to the issue of self harming in private schools and asked whether Cllr Binns was satisfied that the help and support provided by the Council on self harming was equally available to private schools.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 26 Feb 2014, item 16Open the meeting
Asked4 Sep 2013County Council

Members' Questions

Question 3 – Cllr Iain Dobie asked whether there were plans in place in response to the Government’s announcement of additional funding for cycling, including reinstating a dedicated officer position, or creating ways of fulfilling the roles of the post.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 4 Sep 2013, item 69Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Dobie attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

No recorded votes at Councillor Dobie's meetings yet.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Dobie was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee
0 of 1
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 0 of 1 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Dobie declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

No declarations of interest by Councillor Dobie in the minutes read so far.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Dobie sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
Health Overview & Scrutiny CommitteeChairOct 20261
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies