Questions at Cabinet Meetings
Cllr Julian Tooke replied that this worked alongside the Local Transport Plan and Cllr Roger Whyborn outlined that as the scheme developed it would fit in with the Plan.
Every time Gloucestershire's minutes name Councillor Whyborn, as the council published it.
Cllr Julian Tooke replied that this worked alongside the Local Transport Plan and Cllr Roger Whyborn outlined that as the scheme developed it would fit in with the Plan.
Cllr Roger Whyborn acknowledged that he was not familiar with all the details of the specific case but was aware of the issue and recognised that long-running road adoption matters could be complex. He undertook to provide a written response and advised that, if a meeting would assist in progressing the matter, one could be arranged.
Cllr Roger Whyborn advised that he was unclear which specific aspect of the original question was being referenced but confirmed that the Council sought to ensure that communities were appropriately served by public transport. He added that where issues with bus stops or accessibility were identified they would be addressed as appropriate.
Cllr Whyborn explained that whilst the Council worked closely with Stagecoach through both informal engagement and the enhanced partnership, consultation on commercial services remained a matter for the operator. He noted that residents from Churchdown and Innsworth had attended a separate consultation event and that feedback from those communities had influenced changes to the revised services. He added that feedback received since the latest service revisions had been largely positive.
Cllr Whyborn advised that the works formed part of the Bus Service Improvement Plan capital programme and that he ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
7.7 Cllr Roger Whyborn, Cabinet Member for Sustainable Transport and Road Safety, explained that the decision had been taken in accordance with the Council’s Constitution, which distinguished between matters reserved for Full Council and those reserved to Cabinet and Cabinet Members. He noted that the matter had been considered by Cabinet and that delegated powers would be exercised in accordance with the Constitution and in the wider public interest.
Cllr Roger Whyborn advised that he would first seek to establish the reasons for the delays before deciding whether a site visit would add value.
Cllr Roger Whyborn agreed to investigate the matter further.
Cllr Roger Whyborn advised that improvements to the TRO process were being pursued as a priority, but he did not have the requested performance information available.
Cllr Roger Whyborn advised that the funding previously allocated to the schemes was no longer available.
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that within the cabinet paper there were details provided on the action being taken to improve the situation. Question 14 – David Redgewell expressed surprise on the level of housing within the area and asked if the housing targets were the correct ones?
9.1 Cllr Roger Whyborn sought Cabinet approval to extend the term of the council’s current Gloucestershire e-scooter contract for a further period of 12-months and to seek delegated authority to procure and award a contract for the provision of a new Gloucestershire-wide joint e-scooter and e-bike scheme.
Cllr Roger Whyborn, in response, explained that whilst members received a monthly TRO list, the point at which a project was added could be unclear, as it followed preliminary stages including design work and public engagement, prior to the formal legal TRO process. He acknowledged that some TROs appeared on the list for extended periods, and it was ... view the full minutes text for item 12.
Cllr Roger Whyborn stated that he was working through those issues with Stroud District Council. That work would need to be carried out properly in the right way. He referred to the Local Transport Plan.
Cllr Roger Whyborn , responded that the Council maintained a strategic overview of the entire network, closely monitoring it through the Enhanced Partnership with the main bus operators. He stated that, contingent upon funding such as through the Bus Service Improvement Plan, any network improvements identified as necessary would look to be addressed.
Cllr Roger Whyborn , in response, commented that he was unable to answer who was representing the county at the House of Commons. He added that whilst the Council did not directly operate the rail network, it maintained a strong interest in its operation, including lobbying for services, through collaboration with MPs and engagement with the Western Gateway organisation. Question 4 – David Redgewell referred to the English Devolution White Paper noting it made it clear that councils should have coterminous boundaries with local services such as fire, health and transport.
A petition from Cllr Tom Bradley, on behalf of Donnington Parish, calling for a 20mph speed limit through the village was presented to Cllr Roger Whyborn .
A petition from Cllr Craig Horrocks regarding a crossing for Cashes Green Road was presented to Cllr Roger Whyborn .
A petition from Cllr Stewart Dove to improve the 97/98 Stagecoach bus service in Churchdown was presented to Cllr Roger Whyborn .
A petition from Cllr Ray Donaghue to install a pedestrian crossing in Steam Mills was presented to Cllr Roger Whyborn .
Cllr Roger Whyborn , Cabinet Member for Sustainable Transport and Road Safety, replied that the programme would be rolled out across 4 years for all areas of the county that wanted it. 7.7 It was agreed, following a discussion, that the Commercial Strategy 2026-28 would be included on the agenda for the Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting on 15 April 2026.
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that he did not have an update on it at this stage and that this was something that WECA were leading on.
Cllr Roger Whyborn responded that the cabinet report provided details of the budget for infrastructure in the County but he did not have further detail on the Forest of Dean at this time.
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that there would be plans but he did not have the full details at this stage around locations.
In response Cllr Roger Whyborn stated that a County bus map was being produced with the aim to create an interactive map.
In response Cllr Roger Whyborn outlined that there were plans in place but explained that at this point in time it would not be able to route that via Cheltenham station, Question 8 - Rosa Kell asked regarding an extension of a bus route to Tetbury.
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that the route was one of the key areas the Council was looking to enhance within the financial year.
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that he was not aware of this. 4 Member Questions were submitted. No supplementary questions were asked.
7.1 Cllr Roger Whyborn and Cllr Paul Hodgkinson sought Cabinet approval to confirm the approach towards prioritisation, engagement, and decision making for the Safer Roads and Community 20s programme and to seek approval for the implementation of this programme.
8.1 Cllr Roger Whyborn sought delegated authority to allocate Local Authority Bus Grant funding that has been awarded to the council by the Department for Transport (DfT) for use in the period 2026-2030 and to also re-procure existing bus services and home to school transport services where those contracts are due to end between 1 April 2026 and 31 August 2027.
Cllr Roger Whyborn responded to confirm that officers would meet with residents to look at whether there was a safe fix to the problems. Question 11 - Steve Willetts commented that local residents being frustrated with the length of time it was taking for the developer to implement the works was an understatement. He referred to the proposed development at Taits Hill, Stinchcombe now being at appeal and said that one of the central reasons for refusal was the serious highways safety concerns, including the view from Gloucestershire Highways at that time that safe access could not be achieved.
Cllr Roger Whyborn agreed to provide Cllr Patient with the studies.
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that the council was taking a serious interest in that issue.
Cllr Roger Whyborn stated that the contract was not finalised and that the aim was to increase the frequency of Leckhampton buses. It was work in progress.
Cllr Roger Whyborn confirmed that there was an aim to carry it forward again in the upcoming budget.
Cllr Roger Whyborn confirmed that any new requirements would be followed.
Cllr Martin Horwood - Nature, Climate & Waste Reduction Cllr Roger Whyborn - Sustainable Transport and Road Safety Gloucestershire Youth Climate Group (GYCG):
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that measures would be introduced through a variety of providers. Question 2 – David Redgewell asked about design of bus shelters and whether the issue of access and seating was being fully addressed and would the designs receive some public consultation?
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that all of that would be taken on board. Question 3 – David Redgewell asked how the procurement would be affected by any new changes to a unitary authority or combined authority in the future?
Cllr Roger Whyborn replied that there was a limit on the amount of planning that could be done without knowing the future combined authority. Most of the actions associated with the renewed contract should be concluded within the lifetime of the County Council. If not, the contract would move across. 1 Member question was submitted for consideration.
7.1 Cllr Roger Whyborn sought approval for the procurement strategy and award of a concession contract for up to 20 years for a bus shelter supply, advertising and maintenance contract. 7.2 The aim was to replace aging infrastructure, enhance passenger experience, and generate revenue through advertising. The supplier would fund all capital costs and installation of any replacement / new shelters. The County Council expected to receive some annual revenue via a fixed payment and potential profit share from advertising. 7.3 The procurement included social value (15% of evaluation score) and sustainability requirements in the tender.
Question 18 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked whether the council could say that all revenue-funded elements would be launched in 2025/26?
7.4 A petition from Cllr Roger Whyborn regarding the Swindon Road Household Recycling Centre was presented to Cllr David Gray.
Question 15 – Cllr Roger Whyborn sought clarification as to whether consideration would be given to the installation of a front end on the incinerator.
Question 16 – Cllr Whyborn sought confirmation that the Council was considering carbon capture for the emissions produced by the incinerator.
1) Cllr Roger Whyborn 2) Cllr Colin Hay 3) Cllr Lisa Spivey 4) Cllr Wendy Thomas 5) Cllr Beki Hoyland 3.2 The Chair invited Rob Ayliffe, Director of Policy, Performance & Governance and Monitoring Officer, to outline the process for considering the call-in. The Committee was advised that the purpose of the call-in was not to consider whether or not the committee agreed with the cabinet decision but to consider whether the process for making the decision had been conducted in the proper way, and whether or not that process was consistent with the Council’s Constitution and in line with lawful decision making.
3.4 The Chair next invited Cllr Roger Whyborn, as lead signatory to the call-in notice, to present the grounds. A copy of the call-in notice can be accessed here .
3.5 Referring to the cabinet decision report, which was considered at the 18 September 2024 meeting, Cllr Whyborn stated that there was very little detail included in the report, which left members with no ability to understand how the current contract was performing, whether it would be the right decision to extend, how the current provider compared to others and what the risks of retendering would be.
Cllr Whyborn added that there was also no contract specification summaries nor key metrics such as financial data, KPIs or benchmarking included in the decision report.
3.6 Cllr Whyborn expressed concern that there had also been no pre-decision scrutiny to examine the next steps for this contract, again allowing members to better understand what the right option was in respect to extending or reprocuring.
Question 6 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked whose job it was to evaluate claims on our highways and whether it was the contractor who investigated the claim?
6.2 The Chair noted that Cllr Whyborn and Cllr Willingham had pre-submitted a number of questions, which they were happy to receive a written response to.
7.2 The Chair noted that Cllr Whyborn had pre-submitted three questions and a written response to these can be found at an Annex 1 of the minutes.
Question 6 – Cllr Roger Whyborn sought clarification as to how the funds for the scheme had only just become available. He also requested that work due to be completed outside the school as part of the scheme be completed during the school summer holidays.
Motion 937: Road Safety 11.1 Cllr Roger Whyborn proposed and Cllr Lisa Spivey seconded the following motion:
11.2 Cllr Whyborn stated that the number of serious road incidents remained high in Gloucestershire. 376 individuals were seriously injured on Gloucestershire roads in 2022, which was significantly higher than other areas in the UK. He added that whilst there was a slight drop in the numbers for 2023, it was too early to say whether this represented a continuous change. He recognised that behind each killed or seriously injured person there was a family suffering bereavement or the impact of life changing injuries.
11.3 Cllr Whyborn welcomed opportunities for cross party working on road safety, as well as the increase to this year’s Council budget for road safety, which had resulted in the recruitment of additional road safety engineers and officers.
Question 8 – Cllr Roger Whyborn questioned whether he could raise any issues with the Cabinet Member regarding accessibility on roads for residents who use mobility scooters.
Question 5- Cllr Roger Whyborn asked about the ambition to have 4 buses an hour on principle urban routes and 1 bus an hour on routes across the county. How likely was it to happen within the vision and ambitions of the BSIP?
Question 6- Cllr Roger Whyborn asked what was the target date was to achieve the one day cross-county ticket referred to in the report.
6.2 Officers provided responses to the thirteen pre-submitted questions from Cllr Willingham and Cllr Whyborn, which can be found at an Annex 1 of the minutes.
Question 12 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked for ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
5.1 Cllr Roger Whyborn presented the task group’s report in the absence of the Chair Cllr Wendy Thomas. He outlined the background to the task group’s work and explained that the group had met with a wide range of partners including bus and community transport providers. He detailed the recommendations that the group had made, with a number of them relating to improved communication.
Motion 919: Declaring a Roads Emergency 8.1 Cllr Paul Hodgkinson proposed, and Cllr Roger Whyborn seconded the following motion:
Question 7 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked about the data and asked why did the strategic cycleway largely omit the Cotswolds given the numbers of killed and seriously injured?
Question 8 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked what was the mechanism to engage with the council to get things done in relation to TROs.
Question 21 – Cllr Roger Whyborn requested that a list be provided of parishes and districts who had made known to GCC their view of wanting to see 20mph schemes introduced, and those who had passed resolutions to that effect.
Cllr Roger Whyborn asked whether the Cabinet Member’s answer meant that he had accepted the policy of filling one pothole at a time while ignoring the other potholes in the area.
Cllr Roger Whyborn asked whether the Cabinet Member had been persuaded by the team to change his mind and that he no longer accepted that the roads were in a terrible state.
Question 8 - Cllr Roger Whyborn asked whether there had been serious underfunding in road safety and whether 2022 wasn’t looking any better.
Question 4 - Cllr Roger Whyborn asked whether the cabinet member could assure members that the resurfacing for the Tour of Britain route was not coming from the highways repairs budget?
Question 5 - Cllr Roger Whyborn asked what indications had the DFE given to the County Council about any future rounds of funding for public transport?
Question 12 - Cllr Roger Whyborn asked if the cabinet member understood the extreme sense of disempowerment felt by communities over speeding and did he have any plans to do anything about that.
Question 13 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked where and when did the member propose to plant the 500 trees at the Arle Court Transport Hub.
Cllr Roger Whyborn presented Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, with a petition calling on the Council to install an electronic pedestrian crossing on Warden Hill Road to help pupils attending Bournside , Belmont and Bettridge Schools to cross safely.
Question 10 - Cllr Roger Whyborn asked how much national funding was anticipated to be allocated to Gloucestershire in relation to the bus back better.
Question 16 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked when the member would anticipate serious inroads being made into cross ticketing in Gloucestershire.
Question 17 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked to what extent the Council could expect a reduction in carbon use during the period of the contract.
Cllr Roger Whyborn noted that he was a Director at the Cheltenham airport.
Cllr Roger Whyborn 6.
Question 22 – Cllr Roger Whyborn asked whether the S106 funding was driving the timescales and whether the focus was on the Hatherley Lane. He asked for some information to be fed back to himself and Borough members.
Motion 876 - Call to adopt 20mph maximum speeds in areas where vulnerable road users and vehicles mix Cllr Roger Whyborn proposed and Cllr Gill Mosely seconded the motion included on the agenda.
Cllr Whyborn stated that this motion was about reclaiming the streets for the people who own them. This was about safety, climate change, an improvement in air quality and encouraging a shift from cars to other transport modes. 20mph should become the default speed; should be the speed across wide areas, except through routes; and would discourage ‘rat-running’.
Cllr Whyborn emphasised that in contrast to some other areas Gloucestershire County Council has taken little action. Some of the larger cities have adopted wide ranging zones, and the entire city of Portsmouth is 20mph with few traffic regulation orders (TROs) required.
Cllr Whyborn stated that Cabinet should commit highway funds to this issue.
Question 11 – Cllr Roger Whyborn questioned whether the Council would be engaging with the DfT on the specific issue of county councils having more powers to regulate their own bus services.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Whyborn attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Nov 2022 | Environment Scrutiny Committee | Bus Improvements Task Group | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Whyborn was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
No meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Whyborn declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Whyborn in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Whyborn sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Environment Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2022 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.