26P00194 - 9 North Street
Councillor David Bilbe X 2.
Every time Guildford's minutes name Councillor Bilbe, as the council published it.
Councillor David Bilbe X 2.
Councillor David Bilbe X 3.
Councillor David Bilbe X 6.
Councillor David Bilbe X TOTALS 10 1 0
Councillor Bilbe moved the motion to refuse application 26/P/00277 on the grounds that the proposed development had failed to demonstrate the very special circumstances necessary to justify inappropriate development within the Green Belt, contrary to Policy P2, and that it would harm the character of the landscape and street scene, contrary to Policies P1 and P3.
Councillor David Bilbe X 5.
Councillor David Bilbe X 3.
Councillor David Bilbe X 13.
Councillor David Bilbe X 10.
· Councillor Bilal Akhtar [no substitute] · Councillor David Bilbe [no substitute] · Councillor Yves de Contades [no substitute] · Councillor Richard Mills [no substitute] · Councillor Maddy Redpath [Substitute: Cllr Sue Wyeth-Price] · Councillor Howard Smith [no substitute] · Councillor Cait Taylor [no substitute] · Councillor Dominique Williams [no substitute]
Cllr David Bilbe X 5.
Cllr David Bilbe X 12.
Cllr David Bilbe X 4.
Councillor James Jones (No Substitute) Cllr David Bilbe (No Substitute)
Councillor Bilbe then moved the motion to refuse application 24/P/01821 on the basis that it had not been demonstrated that there was a safe and suitable place for two vehicles to pass along the access route, and that the site would therefore fail to provide adequate and safe ingress and egress, contrary to the National Planning Policy ... view the full minutes text for item PL98
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 2 Cllr Dominique Williams X 3 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 4 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 5 Cllr George Potter X 6 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 7 Cllr Stephen Hives X 8 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 9 Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr David Bilbe X 11 Cllr Vanessa King X 12 Cllr Joanne Shaw X TOTALS 11 1 -
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 2 Cllr Stephen Hives X 3 Cllr George Potter X 4 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 5 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 6 Cllr David Bilbe X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Howard Smith X 9 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 10 Cllr Vanessa King X 11 Cllr Dominique Williams X 12 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 13 Cllr Joanne Shaw X TOTALS 13 - -
The motion was seconded by Councillor Bilbe and was carried.
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr David Bilbe X 2 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 3 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 4 Cllr George Potter X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Masuk Miah X 7 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 8 Cllr Stephen Hives X 9 Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 11 Cllr Dominique Williams X 12 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 13 Cllr Vanessa King X TOTALS 9 - 4
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr George Potter X 2 Cllr Howard Smith X 3 Cllr Stephen Hives X 4 Cllr David Bilbe X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Vanessa King X 9 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X ... view the full minutes text for item PL88
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 2 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 3 Cllr George Potter X 4 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 9 Cllr Stephen Hives X 10 Cllr David Bilbe X 11 Cllr Dominique Williams X 12 Cllr Vanessa King X TOTALS 7 3 2
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr David Bilbe X 2 Cllr Stephen Hives X 3 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 4 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 5 Cllr George Potter X 6 Cllr Vanessa King X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 9 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 10 Cllr Dominique Williams X 11 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 12 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X TOTALS 6 4 2
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 2 Cllr George Potter X 3 Cllr David Bilbe X 4 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 5 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 6 Cllr Stephen Hives X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Vanessa King X 10 Cllr Dominique Williams X 11 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 12 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 13 Cllr Howard Smith X TOTALS 13 - -
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Richard Mills X 2 Cllr Cait Taylor X 3 Cllr Dominique Williams X 4 Cllr Stephen Hives X 5 Cllr Yves de Contades X 6 Cllr David Bilbe X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Vanessa King X 10 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 11 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 12 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 13 Cllr Howard Smith X TOTALS 12 1 0
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Richard Mills X 2 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 3 Cllr Howard Smith X 4 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 5 Cllr Masuk Miah X 6 Cllr Dominique Williams X 7 Cllr David Bilbe X 8 Cllr Stephen Hives X 9 Cllr Yves de Contades X 10 Cllr Cait Taylor X 11 Cllr Vanessa King X 12 Cllr Joss Bigmore X TOTALS 9 1 2
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr David Bilbe X 2 Cllr Vanessa King X 3 Cllr Richard Mills X 4 Cllr Stephen Hives X 5 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 6 Cllr Cait Taylor X 7 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 8 Cllr Masuk Miah X 9 Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr Dominique Williams X 11 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 12 Cllr Yves de Contades X TOTALS 11 1 0
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Vanessa King X 2 Cllr David Bilbe X 3 Cllr Yves de Contades X 4 Cllr Stephen Hives X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Dominique Williams X 9 Cllr Richard Mills X 10 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 11 Cllr Howard Smith X 12 Cllr Cait Taylor X TOTALS 10 2 0
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Richard Mills X 2 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 3 Cllr Yves de Contades X 4 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 5 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 6 Cllr Vanessa King X 7 Cllr David Bilbe X 8 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 9 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 10 Cllr Masuk Miah X 11 Cllr Stephen Hives X 12 Cllr James Jones X TOTALS 12 0 0
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Stephen Hives X 2 Cllr David Bilbe X 3 Cllr Masuk Miah X 4 Cllr James Jones X 5 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 6 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 7 Cllr Howard Smith X 8 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 9 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 10 Cllr Richard Mills X 11 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 12 Cllr Vanessa King X 13 Cllr Yves de Contades X TOTALS 13 0 0
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr George Potter X 2 Cllr David Bilbe X 3 Cllr James Jones X 4 Cllr Vanessa King X 5 Cllr Masuk Miah X 6 Cllr Richard Mills X 7 Cllr Cait Taylor X 8 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 9 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 10 Cllr Sue Wyeth-Price X 11 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 12 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 13 Cllr Patrick Oven X 14 Cllr Howard Smith X 15 Cllr Stephen Hives X TOTALS 14 1
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 2 Cllr Richard Mills X 3 Cllr David Bilbe X 4 Cllr George Potter X 5 Cllr Howard Smith X 6 Cllr Vanessa King X 7 Cllr Patrick Oven X 8 Cllr Masuk Miah X 9 Cllr Sue Wyeth-Price X 10 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 11 Cllr Cait Taylor X 12 Cllr James Jones X 13 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 14 Cllr Stephen Hives X 15 Cllr Gillian Harwood X TOTALS 15
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Dominique Williams X 2 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 3 Cllr David Bilbe X 4 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr Richard Mills ... view the full minutes text for item PL44
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 2 Cllr Masuk Miah X 3 Cllr Howard Smith X 4 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 5 Cllr Dominique Williams X 6 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 7 Cllr Patrick Oven X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Yves de Contades X 10 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 11 Cllr Vanessa King X 12 Cllr David Bilbe X 13 Cllr Stephen Hives X 14 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X TOTALS 14
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Patrick Oven X 2 Cllr Vanessa King X 3 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 4 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 5 Cllr Masuk Miah X 6 Cllr Stephen Hives X 7 Cllr Yves de Contades X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Dominique Williams X 10 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 11 Cllr David Bilbe X 12 Cllr Howard Smith X 13 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 14 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X TOTALS 14
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr David Bilbe X 2 Cllr Stephen Hives X 3 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 4 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 5 Cllr Yves de Contades X 6 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 10 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 11 Cllr Howard Smith X 12 Cllr Dominique Williams X 13 ... view the full minutes text for item PL49
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Stephen Hives X 2 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 3 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 4 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 5 Cllr Yves de Contades X 6 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 7 Cllr Dominique Williams X 8 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 9 Cllr Vanessa King X 10 Cllr Masuk Miah X 11 Cllr Howard Smith X 12 Cllr David Bilbe X 13 Cllr Patrick Oven X 14 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X TOTALS 14
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Stephen Hives X 2 Cllr Yves de Contades X 3 Cllr Richard Mills X 4 Cllr Patrick Oven X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 7 Cllr Cait Taylor X 8 Cllr Masuk Miah X 9 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 10 Cllr James Jones X 11 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 12 Cllr David Bilbe X TOTALS 12 In conclusion, the Committee
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Yves de Contades X 2 Cllr James Jones X 3 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 4 Cllr Richard Mills X 5 Cllr David Bilbe X 6 Cllr Cait Taylor X 7 Cllr Stephen Hives X 8 Cllr Patrick Oven X 9 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 10 Cllr Masuk Miah X 11 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 12 Cllr Joanne Shaw X TOTALS 7 2 3 In conclusion, the Committee
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr James Jones X 2 Cllr Cait Taylor X 3 Cllr Yves de Contades X 4 Cllr Stephen Hives X 5 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 6 Cllr Masuk Miah X 7 Cllr Richard Mills X 8 Cllr Patrick Oven X 9 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 10 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 11 Cllr David Bilbe X 12 Cllr Gillian Harwood X TOTALS 12 In conclusion, the Committee
In the circumstances, Councillor Bilbe will be invited to speak on behalf of the seconder, following which the Committee will debate the proposal and then take a vote on it. Reference of this planning application (and the associated Listed Building Consent application) to the full Council for determination will be decided by a majority vote of the Committee this evening.
Following the formation of the new Conservative Independent group, the Committee noted that Councillor David Bilbe had been nominated to join the Task Group.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bilbe attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Oct 2025 | Planning Committee | 25/P/00753 - Land to the rear of Manor House Flats, The Street, Tongham, Farnham, GU10 1DP | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Sep 2025 | Planning Committee | 25/P/00285 - Ruskin, Green Dene, East Horsley, Leatherhead, KT24 5RG | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Jun 2025 | Planning Committee | 25/P/00484 - 31 Rectory Close, Guildford, GU4 7AR | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Bilbe was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 23 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Bilbe declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Bilbe in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Bilbe sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | May 2023 | 49 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | May 2023 | 36 | 30 Nov 2026 |
| Joint Executive Advisory Board | Committee Member | Nov 2023 | 3 | |
| Corporate Governance and Standards Committee (up to May 2025) | Committee Member | Jun 2023 | 2 | |
| Community Executive Advisory Board | Committee Member | Sep 2023 | 2 | |
| Executive Shareholder and Trustee Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2024 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.