Questions from Councillors
Councillor Howard Smith asked the Leader of the Council the following question:
Every time Guildford's minutes name Councillor Smith, as the council published it.
Councillor Howard Smith asked the Leader of the Council the following question:
In his supplementary question, Councillor Smith noted that 30 new-build council homes had been delivered in 2019/20 and stated his ... view the full minutes text for item 33.
· Cllr Bilal Akhtar [no substitute] · Cllr Lizzie Griffiths [no substitute] · Cllr Stephen Hives [Substitute: Cllr Catherine Houston] · Cllr Richard Mills [no substitute] · Cllr Patrick Oven [no substitute] · Cllr Howard Smith [no substitute] · Cllr Cait Taylor [no substitute]
Councillor Howard Smith asked the Leader of the Council the following question:
“Like Cllr Smith, we heard the question asked by Zöe Franklin MP in Parliament on 1 July, and we agree that it raises an important issue. While Guildford is often perceived as an affluent borough, that headline masks the reality that there are communities within our borough that experience significant deprivation and face challenges around income, housing affordability, health outcomes and opportunity.
If Cllr Smith shares our view that additional resources are needed, then I would warmly welcome his support in making that case to Government.
Rather than debating the accounting treatment of money we do not currently have, let us work together to ensure that Guildford receives the funding it needs.” In his supplementary question, Councillor Smith highlighted that the Council had received a 7.5% increase in spending power through the Local Government Finance Settlement, which had been reported as the largest increase in Surrey. He stated that the funding methodology gave particular weight to population growth and economic deprivation and suggested that deprivation indicators had contributed significantly to the increased allocation.
Councillor Smith suggested that, where additional funding had been provided in recognition of deprivation, consideration should be given to directing those resources towards the borough's most deprived communities, including Westborough, Bellfields and Slyfield, and asked whether discussions could take place ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
Councillor Smith declared an interest in relation to application 26/P/00770 - 63 Beckingham Road, Guildford, GU2 8BT concerning Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), noting his predetermination.
It was agreed Cllr Smith would observe the presentation, address the meeting as Ward Councillor, then absent himself for the debate and votes for the items.
Councillor Howard Smith X 2.
Councillor Howard Smith X 4.
In accordance with Council Procedure Rule 12, Councillor Howard Smith asked the chair of the Committee the following question:
Councillor Howard Smith X 5.
Councillor Howard Smith X 4.
Councillor Howard Smith X TOTALS 11 0 0
The motion was seconded by Councillor Smith and was carried.
Councillor Howard Smith X 7.
· Councillor Bilal Akhtar [no substitute] · Councillor David Bilbe [no substitute] · Councillor Yves de Contades [no substitute] · Councillor Richard Mills [no substitute] · Councillor Maddy Redpath [Substitute: Cllr Sue Wyeth-Price] · Councillor Howard Smith [no substitute] · Councillor Cait Taylor [no substitute] · Councillor Dominique Williams [no substitute]
Upon the motion of The Mayor, Councillor Jane Tyson, seconded by Councillor Howard Smith, the Council unanimously
Cllr Howard Smith X TOTALS 14 0 0
Cllr Howard Smith X 5.
Councillor Lizzie Griffiths (No Substitute) Councillor Patrick Oven (No Substitute) Councillor George Potter (No Substitute) Councillor Howard Smith (No Substitute)
The Mayor, Cllr Howard Smith X 6.
The Mayor, Cllr Howard Smith X 8.
Councillor Smith declared an interest in relation to applications 25/P/01084 - 183 Applegarth Avenue, Guildford, GU2 8LP, and 25/P/01290 197 - Applegarth Avenue, Guildford, GU2 8LP concerning Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), noting his predetermination.
It was agreed Cllr Smith would observe the presentation, address the meeting as Ward Councillor, then absent himself for the debate and votes for the items.
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 2 Cllr Dominique Williams X 3 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 4 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 5 Cllr George Potter X 6 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 7 Cllr Stephen Hives X 8 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 9 Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr David Bilbe X 11 Cllr Vanessa King X 12 Cllr Joanne Shaw X TOTALS 11 1 -
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 2 Cllr Stephen Hives X 3 Cllr George Potter X 4 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 5 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 6 Cllr David Bilbe X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Howard Smith X 9 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 10 Cllr Vanessa King X 11 Cllr Dominique Williams X 12 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 13 Cllr Joanne Shaw X TOTALS 13 - -
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr David Bilbe X 2 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 3 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 4 Cllr George Potter X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Masuk Miah X 7 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 8 Cllr Stephen Hives X 9 Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 11 Cllr Dominique Williams X 12 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 13 Cllr Vanessa King X TOTALS 9 - 4
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr George Potter X 2 Cllr Howard Smith X 3 Cllr Stephen Hives X 4 Cllr David Bilbe X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Vanessa King X 9 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X ... view the full minutes text for item PL88
One of the borough ward councillors, Councillor Howard Smith spoke to object to the application.
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 2 Cllr George Potter X 3 Cllr David Bilbe X 4 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 5 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 6 Cllr Stephen Hives X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Vanessa King X 10 Cllr Dominique Williams X 11 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 12 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 13 Cllr Howard Smith X TOTALS 13 - -
Councillor Smith declared an interest in relation to the items concerning Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), noting that while he had views on HMOs generally, he had not predetermined any of the applications on the agenda and would consider them with an open mind.
The Chair accepted this declaration and was satisfied that Councillor Smith could participate fully in the debate and decision-making.
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Richard Mills X 2 Cllr Cait Taylor X 3 Cllr Dominique Williams X 4 Cllr Stephen Hives X 5 Cllr Yves de Contades X 6 Cllr David Bilbe X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Vanessa King X 10 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 11 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 12 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 13 Cllr Howard Smith X TOTALS 12 1 0
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Richard Mills X 2 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 3 Cllr Howard Smith X 4 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 5 Cllr Masuk Miah X 6 Cllr Dominique Williams X 7 Cllr David Bilbe X 8 Cllr Stephen Hives X 9 Cllr Yves de Contades X 10 Cllr Cait Taylor X 11 Cllr Vanessa King X 12 Cllr Joss Bigmore X TOTALS 9 1 2
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr David Bilbe X 2 Cllr Vanessa King X 3 Cllr Richard Mills X 4 Cllr Stephen Hives X 5 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 6 Cllr Cait Taylor X 7 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 8 Cllr Masuk Miah X 9 Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr Dominique Williams X 11 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 12 Cllr Yves de Contades X TOTALS 11 1 0
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Vanessa King X 2 Cllr David Bilbe X 3 Cllr Yves de Contades X 4 Cllr Stephen Hives X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Dominique Williams X 9 Cllr Richard Mills X 10 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 11 Cllr Howard Smith X 12 Cllr Cait Taylor X TOTALS 10 2 0
Councillor Howard Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 5.2, 25/P/01044 - 151 Applegarth Avenue, Guildford, GU2 8LP, on the grounds that he had pre-determined.
It was agreed that Councillor Smith would address the Committee as a Ward Councillor and then leave the meeting for consideration of the item.
Prior to the consideration of the application, one of the local ward councillors, Councillor Howard Smith spoke to object to the application.
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Stephen Hives X 2 Cllr David Bilbe X 3 Cllr Masuk Miah X 4 Cllr James Jones X 5 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 6 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 7 Cllr Howard Smith X 8 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 9 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 10 Cllr Richard Mills X 11 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 12 Cllr Vanessa King X 13 Cllr Yves de Contades X TOTALS 13 0 0
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 2 Cllr Richard Mills X 3 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 4 Cllr George Potter X 5 Cllr Howard Smith X 6 Cllr Cait Taylor X 7 Cllr Vanessa King X 8 Cllr Patrick Oven X 9 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 10 Cllr Joanne ... view the full minutes text for item PL57
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr George Potter X 2 Cllr David Bilbe X 3 Cllr James Jones X 4 Cllr Vanessa King X 5 Cllr Masuk Miah X 6 Cllr Richard Mills X 7 Cllr Cait Taylor X 8 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 9 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 10 Cllr Sue Wyeth-Price X 11 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 12 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 13 Cllr Patrick Oven X 14 Cllr Howard Smith X 15 Cllr Stephen Hives X TOTALS 14 1
The motion was seconded by Councillor Smith and was carried unanimously.
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 2 Cllr Richard Mills X 3 Cllr David Bilbe X 4 Cllr George Potter X 5 Cllr Howard Smith X 6 Cllr Vanessa King X 7 Cllr Patrick Oven X 8 Cllr Masuk Miah X 9 Cllr Sue Wyeth-Price X 10 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 11 Cllr Cait Taylor X 12 Cllr James Jones X 13 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 14 Cllr Stephen Hives X 15 Cllr Gillian Harwood X TOTALS 15
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Dominique Williams X 2 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 3 Cllr David Bilbe X 4 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr Richard Mills ... view the full minutes text for item PL44
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 2 Cllr Masuk Miah X 3 Cllr Howard Smith X 4 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 5 Cllr Dominique Williams X 6 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 7 Cllr Patrick Oven X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Yves de Contades X 10 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 11 Cllr Vanessa King X 12 Cllr David Bilbe X 13 Cllr Stephen Hives X 14 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X TOTALS 14
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Patrick Oven X 2 Cllr Vanessa King X 3 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 4 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 5 Cllr Masuk Miah X 6 Cllr Stephen Hives X 7 Cllr Yves de Contades X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Dominique Williams X 10 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 11 Cllr David Bilbe X 12 Cllr Howard Smith X 13 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 14 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X TOTALS 14
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr David Bilbe X 2 Cllr Stephen Hives X 3 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X 4 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 5 Cllr Yves de Contades X 6 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 7 Cllr Masuk Miah X 8 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 9 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 10 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 11 Cllr Howard Smith X 12 Cllr Dominique Williams X 13 ... view the full minutes text for item PL49
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Stephen Hives X 2 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 3 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 4 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 5 Cllr Yves de Contades X 6 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 7 Cllr Dominique Williams X 8 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 9 Cllr Vanessa King X 10 Cllr Masuk Miah X 11 Cllr Howard Smith X 12 Cllr David Bilbe X 13 Cllr Patrick Oven X 14 Cllr Richard Mills OBE X TOTALS 14
Councillor Bilal Akhtar – no substitute Councillor Vanessa King – Councillor Gillian Harwood (substitute) Councillor Howard Smith – no substitute Councillor Dominique Williams – Councillor Cait Taylor (substitute)
In accordance with Council Procedure Rule 13, Councillor Sallie Barker MBE proposed, and the Mayor, Councillor Howard Smith seconded the following motion:
Councillor Joss Bigmore – no substitute Councillor David Bilbé – Councillor Bob Hughes (substitute) Councillor Lizzie Griffiths – Councillor Gillian Harwood (substitute) Councillor Stephen Hives – Councillor Phil Bellamy (substitute) Councillor James Jones – no substitute The Mayor, Councillor Howard Smith – no substitute
After consideration of the application, the Chairperson, Councillor Vanessa King moved the motion to approve application 25/P/00484 and Councillor Howard Smith seconded the motion which was carried unanimously.
RECORDED VOTE LIST FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Vanessa King X 2 Cllr Catherine Young X 3 Cllr Stephen Hives X 4 Cllr Richard Mills X 5 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 6 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 7 Cllr Bob Hughes X 8 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 9 Cllr Masuk Miah X 10 Cllr Howard Smith X 11 Cllr Jason Fenwick X TOTALS 9 2 In conclusion, the Committee RESOLVED to refuse application 24/P/00505 subject to the reasons as detailed in the report.
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Jason Fenwick X 2 Cllr Bob Hughes X 3 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 4 Cllr Richard Mills X 5 Cllr Stephen Hives X 6 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 7 Cllr Catherine Young X 8 Cllr Howard Smith X 9 Cllr Vanessa King X 10 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 11 Cllr Masuk Miah X TOTALS 11 In conclusion, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 25/P/00080 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report.
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Vanessa King X 2 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 3 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 4 Cllr Catherine Young X 5 Cllr Bob Hughes X 6 Cllr Masuk Miah X 7 Cllr Jason Fenwick X 8 Cllr Howard Smith X 9 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 10 Cllr Stephen Hives X 11 Cllr Richard Mills X TOTALS 11 In conclusion, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 25/P/00081 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report.
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Jason Fenwick X 2 Cllr Vanessa King X 3 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 4 Cllr Richard Mills X 5 Cllr Howard Smith X 6 Cllr Masuk Miah X 7 Cllr Stephen Hives X 8 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 9 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 10 Cllr Bob Hughes X 11 Cllr Catherine Young X TOTALS 11 In conclusion, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 25/P/00194 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report.
Upon the motion of The Mayor, Councillor Howard Smith, seconded by Councillor Sallie Barker MBE, the Council unanimously
Upon the motion of The Mayor, Councillor Howard Smith, seconded by The Deputy Mayor, Councillor Jane Tyson, the Council unanimously
The Deputy Mayor, Councillor Howard Smith proposed, and the Deputy Leader of the Council, Councillor Tom Hunt seconded the following motion:
Councillor Smith left the meeting during the Council’s consideration of this matter.
(Councillors Steven Lee and David Bilbé had left the meeting at this point) RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Richard Mills X 2 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 3 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 4 Cllr Cait Taylor X 5 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 6 Cllr Vanessa King X 7 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 8 Cllr Pat Oven X 9 The Deputy Mayor, Cllr Howard Smith X 10 Cllr Dominique Williams X 11 Cllr Stephen Hives X 12 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 13 Cllr Gillian Harwood X TOTALS 13 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/00104 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report.
(Councillors Steven Lee and David Bilbé had left the meeting) RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Richard Mills X 2 The Deputy Mayor, Cllr Howard Smith X 3 Cllr Stephen Hives X 4 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 5 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 6 Cllr Dominique Williams X 7 Cllr Cait Taylor X 8 Cllr Pat Oven X 9 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 10 Cllr Vanessa King X 11 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 12 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 13 Cllr Gillian Harwood X TOTALS 13 0 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/01302 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the agenda.
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Richard Mills X 2 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 3 Cllr James Jones X 4 Cllr Cait Taylor X 5 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 6 Cllr Howard Smith X 7 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 8 Cllr Vanessa King X 9 Cllr Pat Oven X 10 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 11 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 12 Cllr David Bilbé X TOTALS 12 0 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/00473 subject:
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 2 Cllr Cait Taylor X 3 Cllr David Bilbé X 4 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 7 Cllr Vanessa King X 8 Cllr Howard Smith X 9 Cllr Pat Oven X 10 Cllr James Jones X 11 Cllr Richard Mills X TOTALS 11 0 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/00701 subject:
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 2 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 3 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 4 Cllr Richard Mills X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr Vanessa King X 7 Cllr David Bilbé X 8 Cllr Cait Taylor X 9 Cllr Pat Oven X 10 Cllr Howard Smith X 11 Cllr James Jones X TOTALS 12 0 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/00702 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report.
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 2 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 3 Cllr Vanessa King X 4 Cllr Howard Smith X 5 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 6 Cllr James Jones X 7 Cllr Richard Mills X 8 Cllr Cait Taylor X 9 Cllr Pat Oven X 10 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 11 Cllr David Bilbé X 12 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X TOTALS 12 0 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/01002 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report.
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 2 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 3 Cllr David Bilbé X 4 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 5 Cllr Howard Smith X 6 Cllr James Jones X 7 Cllr Richard Mills X 8 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 9 Cllr Vanessa King X 10 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 11 Cllr Cait Taylor X 12 Cllr Pat Oven X TOTALS 9 3 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/01008 subject:
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Howard Smith X 2 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 3 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 4 Cllr David Bilbé X 5 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 6 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 7 Cllr Cait Taylor X 8 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 9 Cllr Pat Oven X 10 Cllr Richard Mills X 11 Cllr Vanessa King X 12 Cllr James Jones X TOTALS 12 0 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/01035 subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report.
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Joanne Shaw X 2 Cllr Vanessa King X 3 Cllr Dominique Williams X 4 Cllr Pat Oven X 5 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 6 Cllr Howard Smith X 7 Cllr Yves de Contades X 8 Cllr Cait Taylor X 9 Cllr Maddy Redpath X 10 Cllr Joss Bigmore X 11 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X TOTALS 11 0 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to this application, the Committee RESOLVED to approve application 24/P/00772 subject to the conditions as detailed in the agenda.
The Joint Assistant Director for Planning, Claire Upton-Brown clarified that Councillor Howard Smith had not referred this application to the Committee, but rather she had referred it, owing to the interest and discussion surrounding HMOs at the Council.
The Chairperson, Councillor King agreed to permit Councillor Howard Smith to speak in his capacity as ward councillor for this application. He was therefore not a part of the Committee, gave his speech and left the room for the duration of the debate and decision made.
The Committee noted the concerns raised by Councillor Smith who stated that the character of an area was subjective and depended on how you defined it; was it by the shape of buildings, its amenities, or the community cohesion. Most of the HMO’s were located in a particular area and therefore the 15% figure given regarding the concentration of HMO’s was not entirely reflective of the overall situation. Was supportive of a couple of HMO’s but not the large numbers in Applegarth Avenue proposed which will inevitably affect its character.
The Committee noted concerns raised by Councillor Smith that a more prescriptive policy was required to help manage the number of HMOs permitted in any one area. Worplesdon Parish Council had also submitted concerns regarding the scenario in Applegarth Avenue which was welcomed. If family homes were lost in the long term, then this would have an effect upon local schools and their viability moving forward.
This week at the Annual Meeting Cllr Sallie Barker MBE was elected as The Mayor of Guildford and Cllr Howard Smith as Deputy Mayor. The Leader sent both best wishes for the year ahead.
Upon the motion of The Mayor, Councillor Sallie Barker MBE, seconded by The Deputy Mayor, Councillor Howard Smith, the Council unanimously
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr James Jones X 2 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 3 Cllr Cait Taylor X 4 Cllr David Bilbé X 5 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 6 Cllr Vanessa King X 7 Cllr Stephen Hives X 8 Cllr Howard Smith X 9 Cllr Jason Fenwick X 10 Cllr Richard Mills X 11 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 12 Cllr Yves de Contades X 13 Cllr Sue Wyeth-Price X TOTALS 13 0 0 In conclusion, having taken consideration of the representations received in relation to the application, the Committee.
RECORDED VOTE LIST COUNCILLOR FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN 1 Cllr Cait Taylor X 2 Cllr Lizzie Griffiths X 3 Cllr James Jones X 4 Cllr David Bilbé X 5 Cllr Stephen Hives X 6 Cllr Yves de Contades X 7 Cllr Bilal Akhtar X 8 Cllr Gillian Harwood X 9 Cllr Jason Fenwick X 10 Cllr Richard Mills X 11 Cllr Howard Smith X 12 Cllr Sue Wyeth-Price X 13 Cllr Vanessa King X TOTALS 13 0 0 In conclusion, having taken account ... view the full minutes text for item PL8
23/P/01085 – 80 The Mount, Guildford, GU2 4JB Councillor Howard Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in the above application.
Councillor Smith stated that he would leave the meeting when the above application was considered.
Councillor Howard Smith left the meeting for the duration of the consideration of this application owing to the non-pecuniary interest he declared.
Councillor Howard Smith had been the only nomination received.
In accordance with Council Procedure Rule 11, Councillor James Walsh proposed, and Councillor Howard Smith seconded the following motion:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Smith attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Oct 2025 | Planning Committee | 25/P/00753 - Land to the rear of Manor House Flats, The Street, Tongham, Farnham, GU10 1DP | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Sep 2025 | Planning Committee | 25/P/00285 - Ruskin, Green Dene, East Horsley, Leatherhead, KT24 5RG | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Jun 2025 | Planning Committee | 25/P/00484 - 31 Rectory Close, Guildford, GU4 7AR | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Dec 2023 | Council | Appointment of Joint Chief Executive/Head of Paid Service | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Smith was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 19 of 28 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Smith declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee, item PL155 | Councillor Smith declared an interest in relation to application 26/P/00770 - 63 Beckingham Road, Guildford, GU2 8BT concerning Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), noting his predetermination. | |
| 7 Jan 2026 | Planning Committee, item PL81 | Councillor Smith declared an interest in relation to applications 25/P/01084 - 183 Applegarth Avenue, Guildford, GU2 8LP, and 25/P/01290 197 - Applegarth Avenue, Guildford, GU2 8LP concerning Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), noting his predetermination. | |
| 3 Dec 2025 | Planning Committee, item PL70 | Councillor Smith declared an interest in relation to the items concerning Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), noting that while he had views on HMOs generally, he had not predetermined any of the applications on the agenda and would consider them with an open mind. | |
| 5 Nov 2025 | Planning Committee, item PL61 | Councillor Howard Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 5.2, 25/P/01044 - 151 Applegarth Avenue, Guildford, GU2 8LP, on the grounds that he had pre-determined. | |
| 31 Jan 2024 | Planning Committee, item PL4 | 23/P/01085 – 80 The Mount, Guildford, GU2 4JB Councillor Howard Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in the above application. |
Where Councillor Smith sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | May 2023 | 49 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | May 2023 | 37 | 30 Nov 2026 |
| Audit and Risk Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 7 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Overview & Scrutiny Committee (New) | Guest | Nov 2025 | 1 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Corporate Governance and Standards Committee (up to May 2025) | Substitute | Jun 2023 | 8 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Guest | Jul 2023 | 6 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee – Resources (up to October 2025) | Guest | Jun 2024 | 5 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee – Services (up to October 2025) | Guest | Jun 2024 | 4 | |
| Executive | Guest | Nov 2023 | 3 | |
| Housing Operations Board | Committee Member | Sep 2024 | 1 | |
| Executive Shareholder and Trustee Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2024 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.