Declarations of interest under the Town Planning Code of Practice or any other communications from Members
Cllr Tony Louki had received almost 70 emails on item 4, replying to many, and he had also received correspondence on the data centre, item 6.
Every time Hounslow's minutes name Councillor Louki, as the council published it.
Cllr Tony Louki had received almost 70 emails on item 4, replying to many, and he had also received correspondence on the data centre, item 6.
Cllr Tony Louki advised that he had visited the Grove Road site (item 5) on several occasions including visits alongside Vincent Lacovara, Director of Planning and Buildings and had met many of the neighbours.
Cllr Tony Louki, who had called in the Application, spoke next. His main points were:
Additionally, neighbours were disturbed at the officer’s recommendation to approve the revised proposal and Cllr Louki advised that the current recommendation appeared to fail to consider neighbours’ anxieties on the new plan, which had changed very significantly since the initial, and only, consultation had taken place.
Cllr Tony Louki expressed his disappointment that the police had not taken part in the meeting as they hadn’t presented at the Area Forum for some time. He acknowledged their presence at the marketplace area of the meeting but felt that 20-30 minutes to answer questions at the public meeting would have been very helpful.
As Councillors, members made the effort to engage with the police regularly and gave them full support and Cllr Louki felt the police should support Councillors by attending to respond to residents’ questions, as the public may have different priorities to Councillors. He asked if a senior officer could be found to attend the next Area Forum meeting. The Chair advised that a senior officer had been written to and it was hoped someone could attend in April.
A resident asked why there was no consultation on the Ridgeway Road, Roadworks, which Councillor Tony Louki had confirmed to them had been on the schedule for a long time.
Cllr Tony Louki asked for the reasons and was advised by [name removed] that both the Applicant and objectors had been informed that the Application would not be heard and so were not in attendance, meaning that the Committee was unable to give the matter full consideration. This was due to there being issues with planning and heritage matters raised in the report which required further consideration by officers, who would need more time. The Applicant was fully supportive of deferral.
Cllr Louki asked for clarification from Vincent Lacovara, Director of Planning and Buildings. [name removed] confirmed [name removed] explanation that the Applicant and objectors were not present, having been advised that the item would not be heard due to issues around representations that had been made on the application.
Cllr Tony Louki expressed concerns about the lack of disabled parking on site as residents would find getting to on-street parking at a distance difficult whenever family or taxis wanted to collect them. [name removed] confirmed there would be no on-site parking, however Blue Badge spaces would be provided on Essex Place from existing bays, which were directly to the rear of the site, so easily accessible. Blue Badge holders were also permitted to park on single yellow lines.
Cllr Louki was also concerned about the apparent public access to certain areas and the effect this could have on residents living with dementia. [name removed] advised that although some parts of the building had hybrid access this would be well managed and monitored for residents’ safety and comfort. The 20% discount for five places had been specifically requested by the Council's Joint Commissioning Team and the Housing Team.
Cllr Tony Louki declared a non- pecuniary interest as a season ticket holder at Queens Park Rangers and recused himself from the vote.
Cllr Tony Louki commented that he felt the format could be improved on by adding clear descriptions of the proposals and additional graphics to make it easier for people to respond to the consultation. Ideally, he believed that it should be possible for respondents to be given the information required for answers without having to leave the page to research elsewhere. His comments were noted by officers.
Councillor Louki responded that it was important not to speculate before the announcement and that the Local Authority would work to limit inconvenience to residents, and plans would be shared with residents.
Councillor Tony Louki requested that Tim Hurley investigate and provide a plan to address the issues being created by the ongoing Cadent Gas works, which were causing disruption around the sites they were working on, through their inconsiderate behaviour.
Aurang Zeb Cllr Louki proposed an update on the Council's asset strategy for a future meeting. Nick Ljustina
Councillor Tony Louki stated that he had visited the Gilette Building as a guest of the owners on a previous occasion but had no pecuniary or other interest.
Councillor Tony Louki advised that although the votes were recorded in the body of the text for the minutes of item 5, (Homebase, Isleworth) they were not set out in a separate table as found in other items. The votes were as follows:
During the debate Cllr Tony Louki compared the council’s desire for 40% affordable housing in larger developments with the developer’s apparent aspiration for 0%, after having been originally granted 27%. He asked where future amendments might lead.
Cllr Tony Louki stated that he saw very little difference to the previously granted permission and agreed with Cllr Bowring’s assessment.
Cllr Tony Louki asked for enforcement reports to be presented. Matthew Rees advised that he could provide the information in the form of a newsletter to members.
Cllr Louki requested that the reports be made publicly available as a matter of record by including them on agendas in future.
Cllr Tony Louki advised that he was very familiar with the site but was not predetermined; he reserved his right to speak on the application.
Against: None Abstained: Councillor Tony Louki.
Councillor Tony Louki stated that there were enforcement issues in his ward dating back several years and asked for historic information to be provided in addition to current reports, suggesting spreadsheet format. Vincent Lacovara, Director of Planning and Buildings, advised that officers would review the possibility of producing a table.
Against – Councillor Tony Louki.
Cllr Louki had also met with constituents who had attended his surgery to object to the application.
Regarding Item 5, Land at Rothbury Gardens, Cllr Tony Louki wished it to be recorded that he had asked for conditions, should the Committee approve the Application, that refuse bins be placed on individual properties, not on public roads and that neighbours should be permitted to examine the Construction Plan. He had also raised questions about flood water attenuation tanks and consultations. Planning officers confirmed that a waste and recycling strategy, CLP, and drainage details were all secured via condition.
Cllr Tony Louki asked for mature trees to be planted at the site and raised the anticipated large power need by a data centre as an issue, given the number of such facilities in the borough and resultant power shortage. He asked how the site would guarantee sufficient power. [name removed] advised that direct supply would be obtained from the National Grid.
Cllr Louki advised that he had visited the land at Rothbury Gardens site (agenda item 5), met residents and developers and had shared information with Planning officers about the historic usage of the site. Cllrs Sharma and Stroud-Turp had also visited the site.
Councillor Tony Louki moved refusal of the recommendations, but the motion was not seconded.
Cllr Louki also added that in relation to item 5 of the agenda, he called this into the committee and he has had meetings with both officers and residents. On item 7, he had voted against Park Road at the committee, and he had also registered to speak at the public enquiry.
The Chair enquired as to why Cllr Louki called this application in and whether he should leave due to pre-determination.
Cllr Louki explained there was no pre-determination, he had meetings with residents and applicants, but he had not made mind up. He wanted to bring it to the committee due to the interest in the area and the neighbourhood and he wanted to know more information on this application.
Following the debate Cllr Louki decided he would not partake in the vote.
Councillor Louki provided assurances that ward members would get in touch with petitioners on the matter.
Cllr Louki has serious concerns on the application and therefore moved refusal; however, this was not seconded by any member. Therefore, the motion failed.
Cllr Louki moved refusal, which was seconded by Cllr Lal, on the grounds of the impact on the openness of the Metropolitan Open Land and the impact on transport, and Members voted on the motion for refusal as follows:
Cllr Bowring then moved approval, which was seconded by Cllr Louki, Cllr Stroud-Turp introduced an amendment to change the length of the application to 5 years rather than the 2 years proposed, members then voted on the length of the application, starting with the 2-year option first, which the majority voted for. Members then voted unanimously to approve the planning application.
Cllr Louki had visited the site in connection with item 6 and spoken to the agent and had visited the site with officers in connection to item 7 and met the applicant.
Cllr Louki advised that he had called in item 7, when it had not been in his ward and that he had no interest to declare in connection with the application.
Cllr Louki moved refusal because he felt that there would be harm to visual amenity and harm to the character and appearance of the Conservation Area.
Against - None Abstain - Cllr Louki
Councillor Louki moved deferral to allow for further discussion, which was seconded by Councillor Collins and Members voted on deferral of the application, as follows:
Matters Arising Councillor Louki apologised for his use of the word ‘kids’ when referring to officers in planning and enforcement at the last meeting. He advised that it was a turn of phrase he often used and was in no way meant to be a slur on officers working their way through their planning careers.
Cllr Tony Louki agreed, adding that it was also essential to improve the Sunday service and advised that the imminent ULEZ extension may have an effect on public transport.
Cllr Louki advised that access to public transport was a project of his and remarked on the excellent progress made at Isleworth. The St John’s residents’ Association had been very active in this area and there had also been additional funding from s106 payments on two local developments.
Cllr Louki advised that it was up to members to keep the Plan up to date by updating it with any projects they were involved with.
All Members had received a communication from the objector in connection with item 4 on the agenda and Councillor Louki had received information a while back from the architect in connection with item 5.
Councillors Louki and Smart advised that they had visited the site in relation to item 5 and Councillor Louki advised that he had sat on the Planning Committee when item 6 had previously been considered.
For - Councillors Atwal Hear, Chaudhary, Collins, Denniss, Foote, Ajmer Grewal, Shivraj Grewal, Vickram Grewal, Mitchell, Sarai, Smart and Todd, Against - None Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor Lambert moved deferral to allow for a definition of acceptable or unacceptable levels of dust to be established and for a monitoring regime to be agreed, which was seconded by Councillor Louki. Members voted in favour of deferral, as follows:
· Councillor Louki asked how demand for allotments would be met. [name removed] confirmed that a review of allotment ownership was important to ensure that the waiting list could be properly managed.
· Councillor Louki asked what strategies would be employed to help local people manage their allotments. [name removed] indicated that a lot of boroughs ran allotment societies, which [name removed] cited as good practice, adding that the submitted allotment strategy and action plan sought to address this issue.
The Chair, Councillor Steve Curran, advised that a letter from the Mayor, Councillor Tony Louki, had been received by the Committee. The letter said that the report contained inadequate detail and also errors, namely that the implementation date if not called in, of 30 December, did not take account of the Christmas break or weekends and that the Homebase site was referred to as being in Syon when it was in Osterley & Spring Grove ward. It was confirmed that the site, although in the area of Syon and very close to the ward border, was in fact within Osterley & Spring Grove ward and the implementation date should be 13 January 2021.
Councillor Tony Louki gave apologies for leaving the meeting at 7pm to attend Mayoral duties. There were no declarations of interest.
Councillor Tony Louki, Mayor of the London Borough of Hounslow, made the following announcements:
The Mayor, Councillor Tony Louki, stated that his vote had not been recorded under any decision and he wished it to be recorded that he had in fact voted with the majority group consistently.
Corinna assured him that Councillor Louki was very enthusiastic about taking the work forward.
Corinna noted that she had already discussed this with the current mayor, Councillor Tony Louki, and agreed to follow the matter up with him after this meeting. (ACTION: Corinna Smart) Trustees:
See report by Melek Ergen, Planning Officer (agenda item 5) Matt Brewer spoke in support of the application and Councillor Louki spoke in objection.
See report by Melek Ergen, Planning Officer (agenda item 6) Owain Nedin spoke in support of the application, Laurence Hawcroft spoke in objection and Councillor Louki spoke as ward councillor.
See report by Kosma Nykiel, Planning Officer (agenda item 7) and the Addendum Report Julie Martin spoke in support of the application, Laurence Hawcroft spoke in objection and Councillor Louki spoke as ward councillor.
Councillor Shaheen then thanked Councillor Louki for his work as Chair over the past number of years.
Councillor Louki noted that had secured funding from CIL and S106 towards proposed improvements at Quakers Lane. He had been in meetings with the Head Teacher and parents at Marlborough Primary about the proposals.
In connection with item 6, Councillor Louki advised that he had attended a number of public meetings and Councillor Biddolph advised that she had received correspondence.
Councillor Collins, Vice-Chair, opened the meeting as Councillor Louki would be delayed due to other Council commitments. Apologies were received on behalf of councillors Lambert and Saeed.
[name removed] wished to record his thanks to Councillor Louki for the opportunity to present at the Area Forum, and to Councillor Curran for his continued support of the charity, which originated in Australia. The charity was had been operating in Hounslow for 35years, starting at Isleworth and Syon School and now based at a main chapel building on Isleworth Cemetery, which before its current use had been vacant for 40 years.
As this fell after the Annual Meeting of the Council in May, Councillor Collins wished to record members’ sincere thanks to Councillor Louki for his chairmanship over the past two years.
For - Councillors Collins, Foote, Ajmer Grewal, Pritam Grewal, Lambert, Mitchell, Siddhu and Todd Against - Councillor Biddolph Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor Louki moved refusal on the grounds that the proposal failed to demonstrate very special circumstances beyond that, which had already been granted, the applicant had failed to carry out an adequate ecology assessment and had not fully investigated the impact. The Committee did not feel that it was possible to mitigate against the impact on the ecology on the site, which was heathland of national importance.
Councillor Tony Louki felt it was important for the panel/Councillors to do a detailed survey of the locality when they carried out the policy review.
Councillor Tony Louki felt it would be unfair to rely on the resource of just one enforcement officer. He felt that other enforcement officers across the Council would be a useful resource and it would be helpful for the enforcement officers across departments to work together.
In terms of consultation/feedback, Councillor Louki suggested it would be useful to take the policy to the Area Forums and the Residents Forum for feedback.
Councillor Louki moved approval of the recommendation and this was seconded by Councillor Purewal and unanimously agreed.
For - Councillors Biddolph, Collins, Foote, Ajmer Grewal, Pritam Grewal, Gurung, Lambert, Mitchell, Siddhu, Smart and Todd Against - None Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor Todd moved the officer’s recommendation for approval, which was seconded by Councillor Louki and Members voted in favour of the application, as follows:
Councillor Louki declared an interest in Agenda Item 5, noting that he held the role of secretary to the Friends of Thornbury Park group.
Councillor Louki also declared that he was a council appointed Trustee of Isleworth & Hounslow Charity Freeholders in relation to the property next door to the site for item 7 and he had met residents and visited the site in connection with item 4.
Councillor Collins moved deferral to allow for the amenity space provision to be reconsidered and the opportunity for the affordable housing offer to be re-negotiated, which was seconded by Councillor Louki.
Councillor Louki also declared that the architect in connection with item 4 was a family friend and that he was a co-trustee with Shirley Sylvester from Shepherds Bush Housing Association in relation to item 5.
Cllr Louki led a Call-In, signed by 8 Councillors. The stated reasons for the call in were:
Request for the Call-in – C llr Tony Louki Cllr Tony Louki , lead member of the call-in, noted that the reasons for the call-in were set out in the call-in form. He provided background to the item, noting that the Education Funding Authority (EFA) had been responsible for the site since April 2016. He also noted that contractors built the school and widened the road.
Cllr Tony Louki : further statements and questions to Cllr Curran Cllr Louki had some further questions and statements to Cllr Curran and these were allowed by the Chair:
· Cllr Louki questioned why there was a delay between the testing of the site and the SMD.
The Area Forum confirmed the appointment of Councillor Tony Louki as Chair for the forthcoming municipal year.
The Area Forum agreed the appointment of Councillor Tony Louki as its representative on the Community Investment Advisory Panel for the forthcoming municipal year.
· Councillor Tony Louki (Chair) * To focus on clean routes to school (Marlborough, Green, Isleworth & Syon) * Improvements to Quakers Lane * Improvements to Isleworth and Syon Lane stations · Councillor Mel Collins * To continue the roll out of Boston Manor Park and Gunnersbury Park improvements · Councillor Guy Lambert * To focus on step free access to the Thames Path · Councillor Theo Dennison * To focus on the footpath to South of the railway line at Brentford station.
Councillor Louki asked that Councillor Dunne proposed another project as this duplicated the clean routes to school and other capital improvements for which he had already secured resource.
Cllr Tony Louki confirmed that the Panel had met as arranged; Cllr Salman Shaheen added that a further meeting was soon to take place.
Cllr Tony Louki suggested that the election manifesto pledges should be added in along with qualifications regarding what would mitigate current high risk levels going forward.
Cllr Salman Shaheen moved to agree the recommendations, seconded by Cllr Louki, which members agreed unanimously.
Cllr Tony Louki asked for details as the case was in his ward, which [name removed] advised he would obtain.
Cllr Louki asked how the Council could maintain pressure regarding the 47 properties not verified for illegal tenancies at Brentford Towers, given the potential loss of both revenue and housing stock. [name removed] advised that two properties had been verified since the report was written. Officers continued to visit the addresses until the door was answered, failing which an investigation is launched.
Cllr Louki asked if the team used methods such as cross-referencing council tenancies with the Electoral Register and working with Housing Associations. He added that LBH had 100% investments in some Housing Associations since 1990. [name removed] said that investigations were part of the National Fraud Initiative which was conducted across the country every two years; the team investigated any concerns that were flagged up.
Cllr Louki referred to a case in which an illegal tenant had been evicted only to be rehoused by the same housing officer who had evicted them and asked what checks were carried out on people who presented as homeless. [name removed] advised that the process was to be enhanced to make it as robust as possible but it couldn’t be made too difficult for genuine cases.
Councillor Louki advised that he had called in the application in relation to item 5 and had met with residents on site. He had also arranged a public meeting in connection with items 6 & 7, when the application was submitted.
Councillor Louki moved refusal, which was seconded by Councillor Gurung and Members in favour of refusal of the application, as follows:
Councillor Louki moved refusal, which was seconded by Councillor Collins and Members voted in favour of refusal of the application, as follows:
Members raised concerns about the design and external appearance of t he proposed development and its impact on neighbouring properties Councillor Louki moved refusal, which was seconded by Councillor Foote and Members voted in favour of refusal of the application, as follows:
Councillor Louki noted that the Isleworth Society were willing to help keep the area by the gates free from leaves and he felt that a precedent had been set with a similar application in relation to a cinema on London Road.
Councillor Louki had attended the pre-presentation on Item 8 and Councillor Foote advised that the building was used by British Airways Pensions and he was in receipt of a BA pension.
For - Councillors Biddolph, Foote, Ajmer Grewal, Pritam Grewal, Shivraj Grewal, Gurung, Lambert, Mitchell, Siddhu, Smart and Todd Against - None Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor Louki noted that a number of issues had been raised by the objectors, including the installation of blackout windows, clarification of the opening hours and the provision of a management and business plan.
Councillor Louki requested information in relation to the freeholder, leaseholders and management agents.
Councillor Louki moved deferrral,in order for the relevant points to be addressed, which was seconded by Councillor Biddolph. and Members voted in favour of deferral, as follows:
Councillor Todd moved approval, which was seconded by Councillor Louki and Members voted unanimously in favour of the application.
Councillor Louki requested that the budget of £105,750 p.a. to fund the Schools programme be index linked and for review reports to be provided either back to the Planning Committee or to the Lead Member as part of the terms of the S.106 agreement.
Councillor Pritam Grewal moved the officer’s recommendation for approval, which was seconded by Councillor Louki and Members voted unanimously in favour of the application.
Councillor Louki noted that the viability would be reviewed during implementation of the development and he requested that the amount of money received and how it had been used be reported back.
On behalf of the Area Forum, Councillor Collins wished to record thanks to Councillor Louki for his chairmanship of the Area Forum over the past year.
Councillor Louki queried whether the overall cuts amounted to more than the 12% proposed for voluntary and community sector budgets. It was noted that these were the last of the historical savings agreed in 2015 and that budget reductions in total amounted to approximately 36% since 2014/15
Councillor Louki recommended considering the need of young people, perhaps groups funded previously which have been impacted through recent cuts. This was agreed.
Councillor Louki queried the type of services we get from London Councils and whether they offer value for money. It was agreed that this would be discussed at the July meeting.
Councillor Louki asked whether the Community Partnership Unit was talking to organisations about different funding models and approaches. Aine Hayes outlined the work of the Community Partnership Unit on this including - commissioning the Hounslow Voluntary Sector Support Service which provides funding advice - encouraging and supporting groups to measure outcomes, rather than just outputs - developing a crowdfunding platform.
Councillor Louki recommended community engagement training for all officers.
Councillor Louki queried the need to spend money on a review and whether we had the information needed already. He was reassured that the research would consider and build on what was already available and that this consultation was needed to ensure that we get this strategy right as it will shape the direction of our work with and support for the voluntary and community sector in the future.
Councillor Louki highlighted the importance of maintaining the existing type of grants and support for the sector, ensuring that funding was not absorbed into wider service delivery such as social care. He also recommended that Community Infrastructure Levy and community assets are considered and would welcome a clear strategy on community buildings.
Matters Arising Councillor Louki advised that he had not yet seen a list of all CIL recommendations made by the Planning Committee and that he was willing to receive the information by email.
Councillor Louki moved the officer’s recommendation for approval, which was seconded by Councillor Rajawat and Members voted unanimously in favour of the application.
In light of Councillor Carey’s recent ill health, Councillor Louki noted that he and Councillor Curran would visit Councillor Carey during his convalescence at home.
c) Councillor Louki had abstained on both votes and Councillor Lambert had voted in favour of the application on the second vote (item 4, page 2 refers).
d) Councillor Louki had moved refusal, which had not been seconded prior to the vote for approval (item 6, page 3 refers).
Councillor Louki moved refusal was seconded by Councillor Gurung and Members voted as follows:
Councillor Louki requested that CIL be used towards St Johns Gardens and went on to move the officer’s recommendation for approval, which was seconded by Councillor Smart. Members voted unanimously in favour of the application.
See report by the Head of Development Management (agenda item 11) Councillor Louki requested that a list of all CIL recommendations made by the Planning Committee last year be reported back to the Committee.
See report by Melek Ergen, Planning Officer (agenda item 7) and the Addendum Report Conor Doyle spoke in support of the application and Councillor Louki asked questions on behalf of Patrick McMahon, who had applied to speak in objection.
Councillor Louki raised the importance of preventative work with young people, particularly in the transition to secondary school; supporting care leavers; and challenging white extremism. Existing work was discussed including - the annual Junior Citizenship Scheme for Year 6 students - anti-crime and safety workshops delivered by Outside Chance to Year 6 students - Parent Zone which will support children and professionals who work with families on online resilience Councillors asked for further information on the number of students and which schools have been engaged in the Junior Citizenship scheme and Parent Zone.
Councillor Louki moved refusal of the application and enforcement action for the removal of the dome on the grounds that very special circumstances had not been proven to allow permission and the S.106 obligations had not been delivered, which was seconded by Councillor Lambert. Members voted unanimously in favour of refusal of the application and for enforcement action to be taken.
For - Councillors Atwal Hear, Chopra, Grewal, Gurung, Lambert, Malik, Rajawat, Smart and Whatley Against - Councillor Todd Abstain - Councillor Louki.
It was also suggested that Councillor Louki be invited to join or contribute to this group due to his initial contribution on this topic in mid-2016 The Group has met once and set out a term of reference for comment by the Panel. The Group has also been guiding some research by the Year Here Fellows.
Councillor Louki declared an interest in the Northumberland Estate Area item and noted that he would not take part in the discussion on this matter.
Against: Councillor Carey Abstain: Councillor Louki
Councillor Louki also declared that he had called in item 10, as Chair of the Isleworth & Brentford Area Forum.
Councillor Louki moved refusal on the grounds that there would be an impact on the conservation area and the neighbouring historic buildings, which was seconded by Councillor Collins and Members voted in favour of refusal as follows:
For - Councillors Chopra, Collins, Gurung, Lambert, Malik, Mehrban, Mir, Rajawat, Smart, Todd and Whatley Against - None Abstain - Councillor Louki
For - Councillors Atwal Hear, Chopra, Collins, Grewal, Gurung, Lambert, Malik, Rajawat, Smart, Todd and Whatley Against - Councillors Mehrban, Mir and O’Reilly Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor Louki wished to record the Area Forum’s congratulations to friends’ groups and staff at the Council responsible for the three parks that had recently been awarded Green Flag status (St John’s Park, Jersey Gardens and Boston Manor Park).
Councillor Louki moved refusal, which was seconded by Councillor Collins, and Members voted in favour of refusal, as follows:
The Area Forum confirmed the appointment of Councillor Tony Louki as Chair for the forthcoming municipal year.
The Area Forum agreed the appointment of Councillor Tony Louki as its representative on the Community Investment Advisory Panel for the forthcoming municipal year.
Councillor Louki vacated the Chair for the discussion on this item, having declared a personal interest in the matter.
Councillor Louki noted that he had requested this item be discussed at Area Forum because of the disagreement aired between parties at a previous meeting. He stated that ward members had already discussed the matter in detail and suggested that the statutory consultation would provide an opportunity for wider consultation.
Councillor Louki moved to amend the current operational hours for St Mary’s Crescent from their current hours of 9.30am – 5.30pm Monday to Friday to the new times of 10am-12pm Monday to Friday.
Councillor Louki had also attended a public meeting in relation to item 4.
For - Councillors Atwal Hear, Chopra, Collins, Grewal, Khan, Lambert, K.Malik , N.Malik , O’Reilly, Rajawat and Whatley Against - None Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor Louki had submitted apologies for his late arrival. There were no declarations of interest.
Councillor Louki joined the meeting at this point.
Councillor Louki declared that he was a Council nominated trustee on the Isleworth & Hounslow’s Charity, who had made an objection in relation to item 9. Councillors Lambert and K.Malik had visited the site for item 6 and met the owner of the land.
Councillor Louki seconded the motion and Members voted as follows:
Councillor Louki moved approval, which was seconded by Councillor Lambert and Members voted in favour of the applications, as follows:
Councillor Louki seconded the motion and Members voted as follows:
Malik, Rajawat and Whatley Against - Councillor O’Reilly and Lee Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor Louki supported the officer’s suggestion and moved to progress to statutory consultation on that basis.
Councillor Louki noted that a public meeting on the planning proposals for the Gillette development site would be held at St Francis of Assisi Church, Isleworth on Monday 30 January from 7.30pm.
Councillor Whatley had received contact from the horse riders in connection with item 5 and Councillor Louki had been to the site with the National Trust and representatives from the horse riders.
Councillor Louki had also been to an exhibition in relation to item 8 and had run public meetings in relation to item 9.
Malik, N.Malik and Whatley Abstain - None The motion was, therefore, lost and Councillor Louki proposed approval, which was seconded by Councillor Grewal. Members voted as follows:
b) Councillor Louki asked if a condition for car parking had been agreed in relation to the Conquest Club. [name removed] advised that it was still being negotiated and it was agreed that the matter would be referred to ward Members for Osterley and Spring Grove before it was finalised (item 3, page 1 refers).
Councillor Collins asked for the condition to be amended to say that the doors had to have a width of 900mm and Councillor Louki asked that officers undertake to discuss employment with the operators, particularly in relation to technical apprenticeships.
O’Reilly and Whatley Against - None Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor O’Reilly advised that her son had played rugby for Grasshoppers in relation to item 4 and Councillor Louki advised that he and Councillor O’Reilly had also called item 4 into Scrutiny.
Matters Arising Councillor Louki asked officers to ensure that the developers were reminded that the conditions and S.106 agreement obligations agreed as part of the original planning permission still applied, particularly in relation to the tree surveys (item 5, page 2 refers).
Councillor O’Reilly advised that she was a member of the Conservative Party, in relation to item 4; had been a governor at Hounslow Town School, in relation to item 5 and had met with the officer and Councillor Louki to discuss item 6.
Councillor Louki advised that he had also received communications in connection with item 6.
Councillor Louki moved refusal, which was seconded by Councillor Lee and Members voted as follows:
Councillor Louki joined the meeting at this point.
For - Councillors Anderson, Atwal Hear, Chopra, Collins, Grewal, Hughes, Lambert, K.Malik , N.Malik , Rajawat and Whatley Against - Councillor Lee Abstain - Councillor Louki
Matters Arising Councillor Louki asked that it be emphasised that the Committee had been keen to make recommendations in connection with CIL (item 15b), page 2 refers).
The Chair proposed deferral for the information to be provided, which was seconded by Councillor Louki and Members voted unanimously in favour of deferral.
Councillor Collins moved the officer’s recommendation for refusal, which was seconded by Councillor Louki and Members voted as follows:
For - Councillors Anderson, Atwal Hear, Chopra, Collins, Grewal, Khan, Lambert, K.Malik , N.Malik , O’Reilly and Whatley Against - None Abstain - Councillor Louki
Councillor Louki proposed that the Committee recommend spending of CIL to local parks and open spaces in and around the Hounslow Central ward.
Councillor Tony Louki asked for a verbal update on progress from officers. Lewis Aldous, Licensing Manager advised that there had been considerable progress on this since January, 900 historic records had been logged on to a spreadsheet in preparation for the next stage which would be to load them onto the IT database, Flare.
Councillor Tony Louki sought further clarity on the licensing database; [name removed] confirmed that the final end result would provide information at ward level and include scrap metal licences.
The Chair had given permission for Councillor Louki to speak on this item for five minutes.
The Chair advised that at Cabinet briefing it had been agreed that he would meet with Councillor Louki to discuss the proposed designated area in more detail. Subsequent to that meeting some changes to the designated area had been made.
Councillor Louki referred to Appendix 1 which outlined the original area proposed for the Neighbourhood Planning Area for Osterley. He expressed concern that the changes made to the proposed designated area had resulted in the omission of Osterley Park.
Councillor Louki urged Cabinet Members to refuse the report and he expressed concern that the amended area was not well thought out and could be subject to legal challenge.
At a vote members voted by majority to approve the recommendations in the submitted report, with the exception of Councillor Curran who was not in the meeting for the vote and Councillor Louki who abstained from the vote. No members voted against the proposals and, therefore, the vote was carried.
Councillor Louki raised concerns that there was not enough recreational space in the development and advised that he would like to see a S.106 contribution towards local green space. [name removed] advised that a sum of £203,000 had been identified as CIL (Community Infrastructure Levy). CIL covered five issues and one of those was parks.
Councillor Louki advised that he was aware that there was a protocol for the spending of CIL, but felt that the Committee should be able to flag up areas where money needed to be spent. He asked for a report to be provided to the Planning Committee prior to the report being presented to Borough Council in October, to allow for the Planning Committee to consider a mechanism for having an input into the process. That mechanism could then be included in the recommendation in the report to Borough Council.
Councillor Louki referred to item 135 on page 3, where he felt that they had given more reasons for refusal of the application, including the appearance of the historic wall and a possible listed application. The clerk advised that, although it was now policy for short minutes only to be provided, comprehensive notes were still being taken and that she would liaise with planning officers to ensure that any further information required was provided (item 135, page 3 refers).
Councillor Hughes moved that the application be withdrawn, as requested, which was seconded by Councillor Louki and Members voted in favour of the proposal as follows:
For - Councillors Anderson, Chopra, Collins, Grewal, Hughes, K.Malik , N.Malik , O’Reilly, Rajawat and Whatley Against - Councillors Lambert and Lee Abstain - Councillor Louki
a) Hounslow Heath Councillor Tony Louki, [name removed] and other residents spoke in support of keeping Hounslow Heath as a free resource for all residents. They believed that the Heath was an asset to the whole Borough and were trying to involve local residents in their campaign to save Hounslow Heath.
Members felt that the application should be refused on the grounds of impact to highways safety and the general amenity to the street and Councillor Louki asked that officers investigate which department would best deal with any instability in the wall.
Councillor Todd moved the Committee’s endorsement of the officer’s recommendation to refuse the application, had an appeal not been lodged, which was seconded by Councillor Louki and unanimously agreed by the Committee.
Councillor Louki declared that he was a Council nominated Trustee of the Isleworth & Hounslow Charity Trust Board in relation to the neighbouring site for item 4, but that it was a non-pecuniary interest.
Councillor Mehrban commented that she felt that the building was too modern for Hounslow and Councillor Louki added that he felt that the design was bland. [name removed] advised that the building was designed to be a landmark and to have a civic presence, although he acknowledged that the design was subjective.
Councillor Louki wished to record his thanks on behalf of the newly re-established Friends of Thornbury Park for the recent results of partnership working by the police colleagues, Carillion and Council staff and St Mungo’s charity to deep clean areas of the park and help move a long-standing group of homeless people from the park.
Councillor Louki amended the submitted briefing note, changing “Northumberland Gardens” to read “Northumberland Avenue ”. He recorded his thanks to officers for their work to date on the matter and added that he was in discussion with the report author on the possibility of maximising parking provision at the A4 end of Northumberland Gardens.
Councillor Louki moved approval of the officer’s recommendation, subject to the inclusion of an additional recommendation that any objections resulting from the statutory consultation should be referred to ward members to resolve in consultation with the Chair and officers. The Chair called for a vote on the recommendations, as amended, which was supported by all members present.
Councillor Louki proposed that any ‘in principle’ decision should include improvements to the independent war memorial on Borough Road/ College Road, Isleworth.
Councillor Louki left the room at this point.
Councillor Louki re-joined the meeting at this point.
Councillor Tony Louki as the lead councillor requesting the call-in set out the reasons for the call-in. He recognised the very difficult position that the council was in to meet its obligations to ensure that there were sufficient school places in the Borough. The call-in was not questioning this but was about whether a robust decision-making process was being followed in relation to the finances and assets in question and whether the Council was getting best value for money.
This had resulted in further information being made available to Councillor Louki on 27 January 2016.
Attempts had been made to set up a further meeting with Councillor Louki on ... view the full minutes text for item 55.
See report by Ciaran Coughlan, Planning Officer (agenda item 10) and the Addendum Report Councillor Louki felt that more work needed to be done because there were issues around knotweed and access. He also commented that the proposal was next to a controlled parking zone and he believed that there may be a contention about ownership of the land.
Some of the neighbours had complained that they had not been informed and Councillor Louki moved deferral to allow people to apply to speak at the meeting, which was seconded by Councillor Mehrban.
Councillor Louki reminded members that the next meeting of the London Road Interest Group was scheduled for next Wednesday at Spring Grove House and that all were welcome.
In view of the discussion at the meeting, Councillor Louki proposed rejecting the officer’s recommendation and instead proceeding with formal (statutory) consultation on controlled parking with residents of Avenue Road, College Road (between London Road and Ridgeway Road including Beechen Cliff Way and Henley Close), Grove Road, Overton Close and Parklands Grove. He proposed that the matter should only be brought back to this Area Forum where consensus could not be reached and added that, should the decision be made to proceed with the parking controls, a review be carried out within a year of any parking controls being implemented.
Councillor Louki proposed improvements to the amenity area at Cranford Close, Isleworth, including the railings and kerbs.
Rob Heslop, Traffic Engineer, explained, in response to a question from Councillor Louki, that it would not be possible to restrict access to controlled parking for residents of flats at Central House which were not part of the current planning application. Jessica Farmer, Legal Adviser, confirmed that any obligations or conditions could only relate to matters connected with the current application. Marilyn Smith confirmed that there was a very high PTAL for this location and it was reasonable that occupants of the units which were subject to this planning application should not be entitled to controlled parking zone permits.
Cllr Tony Louki requested numbers be kept fully up to date to enable an accurate response if, for example, a bookmaking chain claimed that there had been a fall in numbers; the statistics would also allow proliferation to be used as an argument in reviews. [name removed] advised ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
- Councillor Louki requested a worksheet/tracker sheet of actions to be monitored regularly and for items to be identified as resolved where applicable. Committee Members should email the Chair and Vice Chair, with copy to Officers, items for consideration at future meetings that have come to their attention.
Councillor Louki asked Members to email Ben Knight with any items for the Work Programme.
This was seconded by Councillor Louki and unanimously agreed by all members present.
Councillor Louki proposed that early consultation was instigated for the extension of the Rothbury Gardens CPZ to include Northumberland Gardens and for the creation of additional residential parking along the grass verge immediately opposite Northumberland Gardens.
Members present unanimously agreed the proposal to send the matter to Planning Committee, with the exception of Councillor Louki who had left the meeting for the duration of the discussion.
Councillor Louki suggested that the working title of the “Love London Road” could be amended to “London Road Interest Group”, which he felt would convey the seriousness of the issues. In contrast Councillors Dennison and Dunne preferred the current working title of “Love London Road”, which they suggested worked better for branding events and projects aimed at bringing improvements to the area. The Chair suggested that the main focus of the Action Sheet was to give members autonomy on proposing and completing projects.
Councillor Louki requested that Gillette Corner should be included after Boston Manor Road under PP9, ensuring that the project covered the whole stretch of the A4 up to and including Gillette Corner.
Councillor Louki suggested that members proceed with their individual projects without delay.
Councillor Tony Louki spoke in objection to the application. He raised concerns that the loading bay on London Road would cause the traffic to back up along the road from east to west. He asked that condition three be changed in the Addendum Report, so that the loading bay was no longer open to all vehicles to park outside the hours of loading.
Finally, Councillor Louki asked if a condition could be attached to ensure local recruitment.
In response to questions from the Committee, Councillor Louki advised that he felt that the loading bay should be in operation until 3 pm instead of 4 pm because of school runs. They had a delivery plan and he felt that they needed to pin down the hours so that there were no late deliveries. He pointed out that buses would need to get around trucks parked in the loading bays.
This motion was seconded by Councillor Louki .
Councillor Louki emphasised that this was a rolling work programme and it was helpful for members to add to it.
Councillor Louki sought clarification on the status of the application for 489 London Road. Mark Frost confirmed that, since the reports had been published, the applicant had offered mitigation in respect of the loading bay and servicing times, which had led the officer to recommend approval of the application. Members present supported the proposal to determine the application at Planning Committee.
b) Councillors Pritam Grewal and Nisar Malik had attended a meeting with an officer and the owner of the property in connection with item 4. c) The Chair advised that Councillor Louki would be commenting on some of the issues in connection with item 6.
See report by Stephen Hissett , Planning Officer (agenda item 6) and the Addendum Report Councillor Louki had attended the meeting to comment on the report. He felt that it appeared to be a good development and acknowledged that there was a need for housing, although noted that employment land would be lost. He questioned the 40% maximum amount of affordable and felt that it could be slightly increased, commenting that there were a lot of people living in temporary housing.
Councillor Louki noted that the PTAL (public transport accessibility level) was good and commented that, if car parking was being cut back and residents were not allowed parking permits, use of public transport should be encouraged and there needed to be safe access to Isleworth Station. He felt that a contribution towards public transport should be considered and commented that the area between Isleworth Station and Thornbury Park had been neglected and was in need of improvements.
Councillor Louki asked that further discussions about the S.106 contributions take place and be approved in consultation with the Chair and ward Councillors. He advised that suggestions had already been submitted in response to the consultation.
Councillor Louki suggested that, in addition to making the plea to local residents at Area Forum meetings, police colleagues could email Area Forum members their request for local intelligence, which members could then circulate to residents encouraging them to contact their local officers. In response to questions the following comments were made:
Councillor O’Reilly noted her support for consultation with residents not currently within a CPZ and moved Option A in the submitted report, seconded by Councillor Louki. The motion was carried by a unanimous vote in favour by all members present.
Cllr Tony Louki asked officers if it was usual to have no legal adviser present; he advised that as a point of principle it was completely wrong for there to be no lawyer on such an important committee. Elected members formed the committee to steer licensing policy in a borough with over 4,000 licensed premises but meetings were regularly cancelled and he felt that the current situation gave cause to question whether the Licensing Committee was taken sufficiently seriously by officers. He asked that both Chief Executive Mary Harpley and Richard Gruet , Assistant Director Corporate Governance, be made aware that members objected to the fact that the meeting was taking place without a legal adviser.
Cllr Louki referred to page 4, bullet points 3 and 4:
Councillor Tony Louki was appointed Vice Chair of the Children & Young People’s Scrutiny Panel.
Councillor Louki noted that his reasons for calling in the application were in respect of health and safety in relation to the use of neighbouring properties.
Councillor Louki suggested that officers liaise with members of the voluntary sector on this matter. Action:
Councillor Louki reported that he had called the application in because of the anticipated impact resulting from what he described as a ‘drastic change of activity at the site’. He sought members’ support for the application to be determined at Planning Committee where these issues could be aired.
Councillor Louki spoke as the referrer of the application to the Planning Committee, following consultation with local residents. He advised that concerns were not just over the cars in the car park, but also lorries and vans. There was a wide area of road around ASDA in Hounslow and other stores with longer opening hours were situated on busier roads.
Councillor Louki requested that officers ensure that the current CPZ operational times were enforced, not only in this location but across the borough. He asked that the item be brought back for further consideration in six months for member comment to take account of the outcome of the licensing process for 1 Clifton Road.
Taking into account the addition of requests made by Councillor Louki, Councillor Dennison moved approval of the officer’s recommendations, which was unanimously supported by all members present.
Councillor Louki noted the importance of publicising the availability of this grant to local people to encourage them to bid for funding for the benefit of local people.
Councillor Louki suggested that Area Forum meetings could be held in alternative venues around the area over the course of the year.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Louki attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Louki's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Louki was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 12 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Louki declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 May 2025 | Planning Committee, item 7 | Cllr Tony Louki declared a non- pecuniary interest as a season ticket holder at Queens Park Rangers and recused himself from the vote. | |
| 31 Jan 2019 | Brentford and Syon Area Forum, item 29 | Councillor Louki declared an interest in Agenda Item 5, noting that he held the role of secretary to the Friends of Thornbury Park group. | |
| 10 Jan 2019 | Planning Committee, item 1 | Councillor Louki also declared that he was a council appointed Trustee of Isleworth & Hounslow Charity Freeholders in relation to the property next door to the site for item 7 and he had met residents and visited the site in connection with item 4. | |
| 9 Oct 2018 | Planning Committee, item 1 | Councillor Louki also declared that the architect in connection with item 4 was a family friend and that he was a co-trustee with Shirley Sylvester from Shepherds Bush Housing Association in relation to item 5. | |
| 28 Sep 2017 | Brentford and Syon Area Forum, item 28 | Councillor Louki declared an interest in the Northumberland Estate Area item and noted that he would not take part in the discussion on this matter. | Took no part |
| 7 Sep 2017 | Planning Committee, item 1 | Councillor Louki also declared that he had called in item 10, as Chair of the Isleworth & Brentford Area Forum. | |
| 9 Mar 2017 | Planning Committee, item 1 | Councillor Louki declared that he was a Council nominated trustee on the Isleworth & Hounslow’s Charity, who had made an objection in relation to item 9. Councillors Lambert and K.Malik had visited the site for item 6 and met the owner of the land. | |
| 10 Mar 2016 | Planning Committee, item 104 | Councillor Louki declared that he was a Council nominated Trustee of the Isleworth & Hounslow Charity Trust Board in relation to the neighbouring site for item 4, but that it was a non-pecuniary interest. |
Where Councillor Louki sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Licensing Panel | Member | Mar 2015 | 8 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Member | May 2021 | 4 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Hounslow South, Isleworth and Osterley & Spring Grove Area Forum | Member | Apr 2026 | 2 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Borough Council | Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Development Presentation | Member | Feb 2017 | 4 | |
| School Travel Assistance Appeals | Member | Jan 2016 | 2 | |
| Stage Three Complaints Panel | Member | Mar 2015 | 1 | |
| Licensing & General Purposes Committee | Member | Jun 2018 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.