Great Ouse Valley Trust
Councillor Gardener seconded the recommendations raised by Councillor Martin.
Every time Huntingdonshire's minutes name Councillor Gardener, as the council published it.
Councillor Gardener seconded the recommendations raised by Councillor Martin.
Councillor Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 25/63 by virtue of being a Member of the Fire Authority, a Member for Cambridgeshire County Council and a Member of Grafham Parish Council.
Councillor I D Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 25/4 as a Cambridgeshire County Councillor.
In response to a further question on the process from Councillor Gardener, it was clarified that each Council within the region would submit their preferred outcome option and that this would then be presented forwards on behalf of the region.
that Councillor C Tevlin be appointed to the membership of the Licensing Committee in place of Councillor I D Gardener.
Councillor Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 25/38 by virtue of being the County Councillor for Kimbolton and a Member of the Fire Authority.
Councillor Gardener expressed frustration that he had not been informed of The Local Development Order (LDO) for Brampton Cross. His concern is that the LDO only allows communities one opportunity for comment and the final decision is made at Cabinet rather than the Development Management Committee (DMC). The Panel heard that this would be taken away and an answer sought.
Councillor Gardener and Chapman sought clarification regarding engaging with Parish Councils concerning developments for sites within their area but also if sites bordering their area will be included in this as well. The Panel heard that at the next stage of consultation, there will be a draft local plan which will include all of the sites and will go to all the Parish Councils.
Councillor Gardener expressed concern in point 3:3 which advises Inspired Solutions (IS) have not completed any developments but have agreements in place for 750 homes for other Local Authorities and wanted clarification of how many homes have actually been completed. He surmised that if they have not completed any other developments, how can we guarantee that they can deliver. The Panel heard that per the report, IS have not completed any properties to date but are at various stages of completion in different areas.
Councillor Gardener requested confirmation that if there is an issue with another Authority, can Huntingdon pull out at any point without incurring additional costs. The Panel heard that the Council will continue with their due diligence throughout the project and the only costs incurred would be legal costs for this due diligence. Only once it reaches the point when they have sites that they are actively considering and entering into lease agreements, would the Council incur additional costs.
Councillor Gardener expressed his appreciation for the report and asked for clarification pertaining to page 54, noting the year read 2014 instead of 2024. The Council were asked how they are going to help the businesses in the district that struggle to hire additional staff due to the increase in National Insurance and Business rates as the report did not include this information. The Panel heard that this was a draft document and still had edits, ensuring errors will be corrected.
Councillor Gardener conveyed disappointment over the PI18, 9% reduction in household waste recycled and reused since the implementation of the Green Wastes subscription service.
Following an enquiry from Councillor Gardener in relation to Marina safety standards, the Committee heard that in the case of Marinas where the Council enforce health and safety then this would include the power and pontoons of the marina but not the boats themselves. It was agreed for any specific examples to be further discussed outside of the meeting.
Councillor Gardener gave his thanks to Officers for the report and requested that comparative data from previous years would be helpful in order to measure successes.
Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 24/71 by virtue of being the Cambridgeshire County Councillor for Kimbolton.
Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 24/71 by virtue of being a member of the Fire Authority.
A proposal to appoint Councillor I Gardener to the Vice-Chair of the Panel was moved and seconded. On being put to the vote the proposal was declared to be LOST.
Councillor I D Gardener then outlined his concerns regarding potential future development within the Grafham Water area and the need to retain this as a rural natural landscape. In response to which and with reference to the points which had also been made regarding development on ... view the full minutes text for item 39.
It was observed by Councillor Gardener, that it would be helpful to see regular updates on the progress and development of the action plan at Scrutiny. It was agreed that this would be a productive way forward. The Panel also heard that climate resilience would be built into the ... view the full minutes text for item 37.
Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 24/26 by virtue of being the Cambridgeshire County Councillor for Alconbury and Kimbolton.
In response to a question from Councillor Gardener about the dates for the local exhibitions, the Panel were assured that the dates and locations of these would be communicated out to Members once they were available.
The Panel were assured following a question from Councillor Gardener that an interactive map is available to residents which would allow them to identify sites both within their own and neighbouring parishes so that they may comment accordingly on how this may impact them.
In response to an observation from Councillor Gardener relating to the TING bus service, the Panel heard that the information in the report was relevant to a point in time and was the information provided by transport providers across the district.
Following a further question from Councillor Gardener, on the amount of houses that have been built in comparison to the potential amount of houses proposed, the Panel heard that this information is included in the Further Issues and Options consultation document in chapter 6. The amount of houses required will be developed and incorporated as outcomes of the NPPF consultation are known and included as the Plan moves forward.
The Panel heard, following a query from Councillor Gardener, that the forecast for PI23 was forecast as amber due to this being a new measure and that the team were being cautious due to the seasonality of the service.
Following requests for clarification from Councillor Cawley and Councillor Gardener over the proposed purchase of an additional location for the Cromwell Museum and the long term ownership of that property, the Panel were assured that whilst the ownership would sit with Huntingdon Town Council, grant agreement documents would have clauses built in to protect this asset and clarify the use of funds from any future sale.
Following a question from Councillor Gardener regarding the location of sensors on the Great Ouse River, the Panel heard that detail on this ... view the full minutes text for item 19.
In response to a question from Councillor Gardener relating to rural areas, the Panel heard that CIL funding was strategic and that the revised approach to Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) would allow for the meaningful portion of CIL to go further. It was clarified that the funding was available for those looking to unlock growth with a strategic intent or benefit, and that the team would look to engage with parishes to establish how CIL could be generated to meet their aspirations. It was noted that this was only one type of many funding opportunities available to parishes.
A proposal to appoint Councillor I Gardener to the Vice-Chair of the Committee was moved and seconded. On being put to the vote the proposal was declared to be LOST.
Councillor I Gardener declared a Non-Registerable Interest in Minute No 66 by virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of the District Council and as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor I Gardener also declared a Non-Registerable Interest in Minute No 67 (c) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor I Gardener declared an Other Registrable Interest in Minute No 60 by virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of the District Council and as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor I Gardener also declared an Other Registrable Interest in Minute No 62 (b) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of the District Council and as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
following an enquiry from (i) Councillor Gardener on the progress and implementation of the Electrical Vehicle Charging Scheme, it was noted that the Panel had been informed that whilst there were updates on project deliveries within the Appendix to the report, the Electrical Vehicle Strategy was still in the implementation process but that progress would be reported back to the Panel in due course; and (ii) Councillor Jennings enquired how the team would be managing the success of projects where the measure was stated to improve perception. Following which the Panel had been assured that work was underway on how to better demonstrate and articulate project success and that this measure would be developed into a more tangible measure and that this would be further elaborated in a future report.
Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 23/78 as Chair of Grafham Parish Council.
Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 23/78 as Cambridgeshire County Councillor for Alconbury and Kimbolton.
Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 23/78 as a member of the Cambridgeshire Fire Authority.
Following an enquiry from Councillor Gardener on the progress and implementation of the Electrical Vehicle Charging Scheme, the Panel heard that whilst there were updates on project deliveries within the Appendix to the report, the Electrical Vehicle Strategy was still in the implementation process but that progress would be reported back to the Panel in due course.
Following questions from Councillor Blackwell and Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that it was hoped that active travel could be developed in rural areas to connect and improve routes between villages, towns and points of interest. It was also stated that the funding mentioned within the report was designed to develop feasibility studies for up to five areas which in turn would allow those applicants to mobilise and bid for funding to fulfil the project as it becomes available.
Arising from the presentation, Councillor Gardener outlined the concerns being expressed by his residents at the recent increase in the Mayoral precept given the lack of public transport within the rural areas. He also raised a number of specific questions regarding the Ting service including the potential expansion of the areas served and its use for post 16 transport. In response to which, the Executive Leader reiterated that the Authority was trying to secure more public transport services within the rural areas.
Councillor Gardener was encouraged to discuss issues further with Combined Authority representatives outside of the meeting.
Councillor Gardener was enthusiastic about the proposed involvement with Parishes and suggested a similar format to recent Planning meetings would be productive.
Councillor Gardener queried money allocated to a project in Spaldwick and whether or not this had received planning permission ahead of the funding decision.
The Panel heard that details would be circulated to Councillor Gardener after further investigation.
Councillor Gardener commented that it was positive to see that works would be beginning on the Wheatsheaf junction project.
Councillor Gardener observed that under Operations in Appendix 1, it was suggested that work to clear watercourses would be reduced, however Councillor Gardener advised that the watercourse in Hinchingbrooke Country Park can affect flooding in the neighbouring villages, specifically Alconbury if it is not kept clear, therefore maintenance of this watercourse would be greatly appreciated by local residents.
Following a question from Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that investment properties are revalued annually, the valuations take into account rents received (and lease lengths) so although there is an awareness of empty units at present, specifically at the Rowley Centre, the property value figures will not be adjusted until the 2023/24 year end.
Councillor I Gardener declared a non-registerable interest in Minute 23/36 as a member of the Development Management Committee.
Councillor Gardener expressed concern that the Call for Sites had created confusion in some Parishes. In response, the Panel heard that a frequently asked questions section was being developed for the website to help alleviate these concerns.
Councillor Gardener was pleased to see that rural communities from the district were represented within the groups, and further suggested that, as a major employer within the district, Kimbolton School should also be involved.
Councillor Gardener further enquired ... view the full minutes text for item 34.
Following an enquiry from Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that work was ongoing to re-let the empty properties at the Rowley Centre in St Neots and that it was anticipated that marketing the two spaces together would generate greater interest.
It was observed by Councillor Gardener that some items were showing as a green status for the year when in actual fact they were currently under an amber status. It was explained that the current amber status was shown on the graphs and that the reason for the year end status showing as green was due to anticipated improvements over the year that would result in an overall green status. The Panel were advised that future reports would be revised to show both current and year end statuses in all summary tables.
It was further observed by Councillor Gardener that the report layout was not as clear as the presentation previously shown to the Panel regarding the updates to the report style. Consideration would be given to amending the layout to reflect this feedback and the views of other stakeholders.
Following a question from Councillor Gardener, it was noted that clarification would be given on PI 13 results and whether withdrawn applications were included.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a Non Statutory Disclosable Interest in Minute No 16 (a) b y virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor Gardener observed that the report and Executive Councillors had highlighted that the fee was being introduced for those who used the service, and enquired if that meant that residents could request refunds for those services which their Council Tax pays for but that they do not use. The Panel heard that the Joint Administration were aware that this would not be a popular decision but that it was necessary to protect the service for those residents who wished to continue to use it. The Panel heard that garden waste collection is a non statutory collection and that the Council is no longer able to deliver this service free of charge.
Councillor Gardener observed that it would have been helpful to see where changes had been made from the previous policy and queried the life expectancy of the policy. The Panel were advised that the anticipated review date of 10 years would be fluid to allow for earlier or later revision depending on external factors and best interests of residents.
In response to concerns from Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that a communications plan would be developed to ensure St Neots residents were proactively communicated with regarding the planned works to trees in the Market Square.
In response to a question from Councillor Gardener on whether agricultural workers would be included within the definition of key workers, the Panel heard that there was a suggestion that this term maybe replaced with Essential Workers by Government in the future, the Council would expect this type of demand to be identified as part of Housing Needs Surveys in local parishes the Council would then use opportunities to meet that demand, within existing policy in the Local Plan.
The Panel heard, following a question from Councillor Gardener, that fleet maintenance was ongoing in line with the Climate Strategy, with great success, with the aim to maintain current fleet rather than invest in new vehicles.
Following an enquiry from Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that the progress of the Market Towns projects would be seen across the spectrum of Corporate Plan Targets.
Councillor Gardener requested that he remain on the Flooding Working Group for any future meetings given his involvement in the Overview and Scrutiny Flooding Study and given the flooding issues which had occurred within his Ward.
Councillor I D Gardener declared an Other Registrable Interest in Minute No 8 (a) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor I D Gardener declared an Other Registrable Interest in Minute No 53 (a) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the areas he represented as a Member of Huntingdonshire District Council and of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor Gardener declared a Non-Registerable Interest under Minute 22/93 as Cambridgeshire County Councillor for Alconbury and Kimbolton and as the Chair of Grafham Parish Council.
The Panel were advised, following a question from Councillor Gardener, that although the team wished to engage with parish councils it would not be practical or achievable to visit all throughout the district therefore alternatives were being developed.
Councillor R J West moved and it was duly seconded by Councillor I D Gardener that This Council a) Notes the data collected by the National Air Traffic Service regarding the recent flight path changes at London Luton Airport.
With reference to a specific situation recently involving his own parishes and having paid specific tribute to Councillor I D Gardener, Councillor Alban reiterated the value that could be obtained from parishes working together and being enthused by other successful parishes. He emphasised the value in encouraging peer to peer training in this way.
Councillor I Gardener declared a Non-Registrable Interest in Minute No 49 (b) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor I Gardener declared a Non-Registrable Interest in Minute No 49 (c) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor Gardener enquired what communication parishes could expect with regards to the scheme. The Panel heard that the Council was obliged to publish the details on the website but are planning to email local parishes to notify of its publication. It was further advised that local members could help this communication by informing parishes at any upcoming meetings.
The Panel heard in response to a question from Councillor Gardener, that travel times shown were during peak time however travel times to GP Surgeries were during non-peak times as this is when most residents would access that service. In response to a further question, the Panel heard that the frequency of bus services had been considered rather than individual operators and that the TING service had not been included at this point as it is unknown whether this service will still be available at the time of the Local Plan’s final publication.
Councillor Gardener observed that parishes which border the A14 may be able to advise on ... view the full minutes text for item 76.
The Panel heard, in response to a question from Councillor Gardener, that in relation to flood mitigation measures, the Council would take a steer from the owners of land on what they would like it to be considered for. Should the land owner put forward a site for a particular use it would be assessed for that use. The only instance when an alternative use may be considered on a site would be if, for instance, someone put forward a site for a particular commercial use and in consultation with Economic Development colleagues it is revealed that there would be a better market for an alternative commercial use.
The Panel heard, following a question from Councillor Gardener, that policies in neighbourhood plans could not be used to assess the sites. This will be a planning policy ‘off’ assessment of sites, so the technical assessment of site will disregard both the Local Plan and any Neighbourhood Plan. The submitted sites will be consulted on later as part of a further issues and options consultation, giving the opportunity for communities to put representations in on the sites in their area, and whether they support or object or suggest alternative uses.
Concern was expressed by Councillor Gardener that up to now engagement had mainly been focused on urban areas of the district but was pleased to see that it was planned to consult with rural areas which make up a large proportion of the district.
The Panel were reassured that work was ongoing in rural areas and would continue to be an ongoing dialogue to ensure engagement across the whole of the district Following a further question from Councillor Gardener regarding the change in operator for the TING service which has created confusion and loss of confidence amongst residents, the Panel heard that this would be further investigated and reported back.
Councillor Gardener enquired how the Strategy would be updated following the proposed engagement with rural areas later in the year. The Panel heard that whilst there were no further mass rounds of consultation planned, there would be continued engagement alongside the help of all Councillors and the Strategy would be subject to constant reflection alongside an annual review process.
In response to a question from Councillor Gardener on whether the Panel will be consulted on the detailed design of the Market Square, Members have been advised that any such input will be through the local consultation process over the coming months.
Councillor I Gardener declared a Non-Registrable Interest in Minute No 45 (d) by virtue of the fact the applicant was a close associate, left the room for the duration of the item and took no part in the discussion or voting.
It was clarified to the Panel, following a question from Councillor Gardener, that following long term vacancies in the street cleansing service, three posts had been deleted after being identified as no longer required.
Councillor Gardener thanked all members and external bodies involved in the report, a sentiment which was shared by the Panel.
By means of a report by the Chief Planning Officer (a copy of which was appended in the Minute Book) the was presented to the Panel Councillor Gardener observed that clearer labelling to the maps would be helpful specifically mentioning labelling of village halls and flood zones. The Panel heard that the level of detail would be incorporated as much as possible given the scales involved with further detail being added online. Furthermore it was advised that a suite of water management studies would be undertaken and would assist future planning decisions within the district.
Councillor Gardener queried whether the Active Travel Feasibility Studies were purely for cycleways, in response to which, the Panel heard that all active travel suggestions were encouraged. The Panel heard about a specific example of the cycleway alongside the A1 from Brampton to Alconbury which did not link into Alconbury village, following which the Panel were assured that the lack of integration had been previously flagged with the County Council.
Councillor Gardener agreed with the comments made by other Panel members and suggested that the funding could be spent on other matters given the current economic climate. The Panel heard that the previous administration had shelved the Wayfinding project but that the Joint Administration felt the project had value and had thereby reinstated it.
Councillor Gardener observed that due to the number of feasibility studies having been undertaken in St Neots recently, the available funding could have been impacted and thereby not able to fulfil what originally hoped.
Following questions from Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that the Council were working closely with St Neots Town Council to ensure cohesion between the Priory Centre project and the potential purchase of the Oast House property by St Neots Town Council.
Councillor Gardener suggested that improvements to local bus routes with regular and reliable services from rural areas into the towns would assist in connecting residents to Cambridge without the need for additional park and ride infrastructure. The Panel heard that the public transport responsibility lies with the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Combined Authority, who are the Transport Authority and following a number of transport related consultations recently it remained important to continue to share feedback and concerns from the Council. It was observed that communication between the GCP and CPCA on this matter would be helpful.
In response to statements by Councillor Gardener and Councillor Pickering, who felt that positive improvements and options to improve active travel should form part of the response, the Panel heard that such suggestions would be welcomed by the Executive Councillor.
The Panel agreed that there were many issues across the district with the failure to link pedestrian and cycle routes to form a district wide network, specific examples from Alconbury and Hail Weston were given by Councillor Gardener and Councillor Cawley. It was further observed that until valid alternatives were offered for rural areas, residents would not have a valid alternative to private cars thus affecting carbon targets and aspirations for the district.
It was observed by Councillor Gardener that the document holds grand aspirations but lacked in the detail of how this would be achievable for the district. The Panel heard that the detail is expected to follow as the strategy is finalised and the action plan taken forward and linked into the County Council Transport Investment Plan.
Councillor Gardener enquired about the increase in days to process new benefit claims in PI13, the Panel heard that whilst there is some seasonality to claim processing this is reflective of the increase in claims received for processing due to the current economic climate.
In response to a question raised by Councillor I D Gardener on the lack of bus service provision in the proposed bus network to the west and north of Huntingdonshire, whereby Councillor Conboy assured Members that the concern would be raised to ensure that any network covered the whole of Huntingdonshire, including the rural areas.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-registerable interest in Minute 22/33 as Ward Member for Alconbury.
Councillor Gardener enquired about the potential for the Alconbury Flood Group applying for funding in the future. The Panel heard that an application could be made to future rounds of CIL and that would be considered assuming that it met the relevant criteria and provided the required supporting information.
Following questions from Councillor Pickering and Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that the options being developed for the St Neots Priory Quarter were merely adding detail to the work already undertaken. The Panel were further assured that the team were using all previous studies available to them and were not seeking to redo previously undertaken work but to add detail to it and to ensure that it reflected current market rates in a rapidly changing economic climate.
Following questions from Councillor Wells and Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that that the team would be liaising with both town and parish councils to maximise communications channels.
Councillor Gardener enquired on the anticipated timescales for the reintroduction of preplanning application advice service as this had previously been a useful revenue stream for the Council.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 12 (d) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the areas he represented as a Member of Huntingdonshire District Council and of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Disappointment was expressed by Councillor Gardener that the document did not go into enough detail on the subject of public transport. It was stated that rural communities are not served by public transport, and that rural roads are often perceived to be unsafe for cyclists, therefore these communities are unable to make any alternative decisions for transport other than by private car.
The Panel heard that the report specifically highlighted demand responsive travel in Ramsey, however Councillor Gardener argued that this issue is district wide and not restricted to the towns which are better served than rural areas.
Councillor Gardener again highlighted that the report focused on the market towns within the ... view the full minutes text for item 17.
Following a further enquiry from Councillor Gardener, the Panel were assured that the new administration would be assessing the progress to date and would communicate with members and residents as this develops and moves forward.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 68 (a) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Having received an enquiry from Councillor Gardener, the Panel were advised that although the agreement presented remained extensively unchanged, there had been implementation of a new IT system and support, which had resulted in greater efficiencies for the service.
Councillor I Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 64 (b) by virtue of having an association with the applicant.
Councillor Gardener left the meeting and did not participate on the discussion or voting on the item.
Following questions from Councillor Gardener and Councillor Mrs Wilson, the Panel heard that some road markings within the district are classed as being in acceptable condition, however work would be undertaken where marking fall below this standard to ensure that all signs and lines within the district would be to an acceptable standard and in addition be digitally catalogued.
Councillor Gardener enquired regarding the maintenance of highway markings and the Panel heard that where it can be demonstrated that markings have fallen below an acceptable standard and are affecting enforcement of offences, lost revenue could be reclaimed.
Councillor Gardener commented on the increase in active travel within the district, in particular the local bus services being run in conjunction with the Combined Authority. The Panel heard that the model presented was one of close working with key partners which allowed access to baseline data highlighting the impact and trajectory of trends even if there was no statutory duty on the district.
In response to a question by Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that cases would be looked at individually on a case by case basis by an experienced and dedicated team who would keep a sensible and fluid approach to applications.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Item No. 68 by virtue of his position as Chairman of Grafham Parish Council.
Following an enquiry by Councillor Gardener on collaborating with local flood groups, the Panel were advised that due to restrictions by the Environment Agency, tree planting could not be established alongside watercourses, however works were ongoing to ensure ditches and balancing ponds remained effective. Furthermore it was noted that whilst the Council was not the responsible authority regarding flooding, the team would endorse ... view the full minutes text for item 41.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 53 by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented.
Councillor I D Gardener also declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 55 (c) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Division he represented on Cambridgeshire County Council.
(d) that Councillor I D Gardener be appointed to the membership of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth );
Following a question from Councillor Gardener, the Panel heard that there were plans to roll out bin sensors in bins beyond town centres and that it was hoped that grants would be available to fund this. The Panel also heard that the Council were working together with National Highways to find a solution to littering in laybys along major routes across the district.
Following a comment from Councillor Gardener regarding human waste being thrown from HGVs into residential land, the Panel were advised that such acts could be reported on the Council’s website.
Councillor Gardener raised the issue of cycle route improvements, which would have positive benefits on health, active travel and the environment. The Panel heard that an active travel map was being investigated.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 43 (g) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Huntingdonshire District Council and of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 33 (a) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor I D Gardener also declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 33 (b) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 32 by virtue of the fact that he was registered with Buckden Surgery, which could be affected by the terms of the proposed S106 Agreement.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 12 by virtue of the facts that the application related to the Ward he represented and that he had an association with the applicant.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 70 (c) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented.
Councillor I D Gardener also declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 70 (d) by virtue of the facts that the application related to the Ward he represented and that he had Chaired meetings involving representatives of the Parish Meeting, the County Council and the Developer. He confirmed that he had not expressed a view on the application at the meetings and would make up his mind on it on the basis of the Committee’s deliberations.
Councillor Gardener expressed his support for the bid but stated that the maximum that the District Council should contribute was £80k. The Panel, RESOLVED that the Cabinet be recommended to approve the allocation of £100,000 of CIL towards the scheme, subject to the conditions as outlined in the recommendations.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 59 (c) by virtue of the fact that that the application related to the Ward he represented.
Councillor Gardener expressed the view that the proportion of funds obtained from CIL should not exceed 50% of the project cost. Members suggested that the County Council should be requested to make a greater contribution to the scheme. In response, the Panel was informed that such a restriction might not be beneficial and that the project was subjected to match funding.
Councillor Gardener stated that his residents’ main concern was that the noise from a plane at 8000ft would be approximately 55db (according to NATS documentation) and the ambient background noise within parts of the countryside would be 29db. At these levels noise from planes would be intrusive for residents living in rural areas of the District.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No. 46 by virtue of having an association with the applicant.
Attention is drawn to a cycle route shown to be in Grafham Parish by Councillor Gardener. It was confirmed to Members that the cycle route referenced only showed an indicative route and that policies could only be applied within the Neighbourhood Plan area.
Councillor Gardener then raised the issue of employees’ mental health. In response, it was confirmed that the Council had taken a number of steps in order to support staff with their mental health including: the provision of Mental Health First Aiders for confidential one to one conversations, virtual drop in sessions and ensuring managers check on the wellbeing of their staff.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in relation to Minute Number 35 by virtue of being a Member on the Development Management Committee.
A query was raised, by Councillor Gardener, on how the Council are able to manage change going forward if the proposals are adopted, particularly with larger developments. In response, it was noted that the Government would prefer planning permission granted at an earlier stage but that the response will emphasise that phasing should remain.
Councillor Gardener raised a concern over the possibility of a lack of capacity on the B-roads around the A141 once the upgrade had been completed. In response, Members were reassured that phase two of the study would involve more in-depth analysis to ensure the local road network had sufficient capacity to cope. It was noted that this would also include changing prioritisation of some routes to ensure the majority of the traffic was directed where it was intended.
Councillor Gardener raised a concern regarding HGVs using minor routes as short cuts and sought assurance that the response would emphasise there was a need for official routes for HGVs. In response, it was noted that the consultation as a whole took a strategic approach across the Cam-Ox corridor and that particular incidents of HGVs using minor routes, particularly through villages, should be taken up with the relevant Highway Authority.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Minute No. 21 by virtue of the fact that the applicant was a client of his employer.
Councillor I D Gardener declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Minute No. 16 by virtue of the fact that the applicant was a client of his employer and left the meeting for the duration of the discussion and voting on the item.
Councillor I D Gardener also declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Minute No. 17 (e) by virtue of the fact that the applicant was a client of his employer and left the meeting for the duration of the discussion and voting on the item.
RESOLVED that Councillor I D Gardener be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
On behalf of the Panel, the Chairman formally welcomed Councillor Gardener and Councillor Roberts and thanked Councillor Davies for his time serving on the Panel.
The Returning Officer reported that following by-elections in the Alconbury Ward on 12th December 2019 and St Ives East Ward on 13th February 2020, Councillor Ian Gardener and Councillor Adam Roberts respectively had been elected to the District Council.
(b) that Councillor I D Gardener be appointed to the membership of the Development Management Committee;
(d) that Councillor I D Gardener be appointed to the membership of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth) in place of Councillor J W Davies; and (e) that Councillor I D Gardener be appointed to the Appeals Sub-Group.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Gardener attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Overview and Scrutiny Annual Report | Carried | 33 for, 0 against, 8 abstained | |
| 22 Feb 2023 | Council | Retirement of managing director | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Sep 2021 | Council | Chairman's engagements and announcements | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Gardener was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 19 of 28 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Gardener declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Mar 2026 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 60 | Councillor Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 25/63 by virtue of being a Member of the Fire Authority, a Member for Cambridgeshire County Council and a Member of Grafham Parish Council. | |
| 12 Nov 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Joint Group, item 1 | Councillor I D Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 25/4 as a Cambridgeshire County Councillor. | |
| 8 Oct 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 35 | Councillor Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 25/38 by virtue of being the County Councillor for Kimbolton and a Member of the Fire Authority. | |
| 2 Apr 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 68 | Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 24/71 by virtue of being the Cambridgeshire County Councillor for Kimbolton. | |
| 2 Apr 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 68 | Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 24/71 by virtue of being a member of the Fire Authority. | |
| 4 Sep 2024 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 24 | Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 24/26 by virtue of being the Cambridgeshire County Councillor for Alconbury and Kimbolton. | |
| 20 May 2024 | Development Management Committee, item 65 | Councillor I Gardener declared a Non-Registerable Interest in Minute No 66 by virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of the District Council and as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 20 May 2024 | Development Management Committee, item 65 | Councillor I Gardener also declared a Non-Registerable Interest in Minute No 67 (c) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 22 Apr 2024 | Development Management Committee, item 58 | Councillor I Gardener declared an Other Registrable Interest in Minute No 60 by virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of the District Council and as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 22 Apr 2024 | Development Management Committee, item 58 | Councillor I Gardener also declared an Other Registrable Interest in Minute No 62 (b) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of the District Council and as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 3 Apr 2024 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 73 | Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 23/78 as Chair of Grafham Parish Council. | |
| 3 Apr 2024 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 73 | Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 23/78 as Cambridgeshire County Councillor for Alconbury and Kimbolton. | |
| 3 Apr 2024 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 73 | Councillor I Gardener declared an other registerable interest in minute 23/78 as a member of the Cambridgeshire Fire Authority. | |
| 4 Oct 2023 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 30 | Councillor I Gardener declared a non-registerable interest in Minute 23/36 as a member of the Development Management Committee. | |
| 17 Jul 2023 | Development Management Committee, item 15 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a Non Statutory Disclosable Interest in Minute No 16 (a) b y virtue of the fact that the application related to the area he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 22 May 2023 | Development Management Committee, item 6 | Councillor I D Gardener declared an Other Registrable Interest in Minute No 8 (a) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 17 Apr 2023 | Development Management Committee, item 52 | Councillor I D Gardener declared an Other Registrable Interest in Minute No 53 (a) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the areas he represented as a Member of Huntingdonshire District Council and of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 5 Apr 2023 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 89 | Councillor Gardener declared a Non-Registerable Interest under Minute 22/93 as Cambridgeshire County Councillor for Alconbury and Kimbolton and as the Chair of Grafham Parish Council. | |
| 20 Mar 2023 | Development Management Committee, item 48 | Councillor I Gardener declared a Non-Registrable Interest in Minute No 49 (b) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 20 Mar 2023 | Development Management Committee, item 48 | Councillor I Gardener declared a Non-Registrable Interest in Minute No 49 (c) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 20 Feb 2023 | Development Management Committee, item 43 | Councillor I Gardener declared a Non-Registrable Interest in Minute No 45 (d) by virtue of the fact the applicant was a close associate, left the room for the duration of the item and took no part in the discussion or voting. | Left the room |
| 5 Oct 2022 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 31 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-registerable interest in Minute 22/33 as Ward Member for Alconbury. | |
| 18 Jul 2022 | Development Management Committee, item 10 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 12 (d) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the areas he represented as a Member of Huntingdonshire District Council and of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 25 Apr 2022 | Development Management Committee, item 67 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 68 (a) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | Development Management Committee, item 62 | Councillor I Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 64 (b) by virtue of having an association with the applicant. | |
| 23 Feb 2022 | Council, item 60 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Item No. 68 by virtue of his position as Chairman of Grafham Parish Council. | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | Development Management Committee, item 52 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 53 by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented. | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | Development Management Committee, item 52 | Councillor I D Gardener also declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 55 (c) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Division he represented on Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 22 Nov 2021 | Development Management Committee, item 41 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 43 (g) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Huntingdonshire District Council and of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 20 Sep 2021 | Development Management Committee, item 28 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 33 (a) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 20 Sep 2021 | Development Management Committee, item 28 | Councillor I D Gardener also declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 33 (b) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented as a Member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 20 Sep 2021 | Development Management Committee, item 28 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 32 by virtue of the fact that he was registered with Buckden Surgery, which could be affected by the terms of the proposed S106 Agreement. | |
| 21 Jun 2021 | Development Management Committee, item 11 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 12 by virtue of the facts that the application related to the Ward he represented and that he had an association with the applicant. | |
| 19 Apr 2021 | Development Management Committee, item 69 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 70 (c) by virtue of the fact that the application related to the Ward he represented. | |
| 19 Apr 2021 | Development Management Committee, item 69 | Councillor I D Gardener also declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 70 (d) by virtue of the facts that the application related to the Ward he represented and that he had Chaired meetings involving representatives of the Parish Meeting, the County Council and the Developer. He confirmed that he had not expressed a view on the application at the meetings and would make up his mind on it on the basis of the Committee’s deliberations. | |
| 15 Feb 2021 | Development Management Committee, item 56 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No 59 (c) by virtue of the fact that that the application related to the Ward he represented. | |
| 14 Dec 2020 | Development Management Committee, item 44 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in Minute No. 46 by virtue of having an association with the applicant. | |
| 7 Oct 2020 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth), item 29 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a non-statutory disclosable interest in relation to Minute Number 35 by virtue of being a Member on the Development Management Committee. | |
| 17 Aug 2020 | Development Management Committee, item 20 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Minute No. 21 by virtue of the fact that the applicant was a client of his employer. | |
| 20 Jul 2020 | Development Management Committee, item 15 | Councillor I D Gardener declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Minute No. 16 by virtue of the fact that the applicant was a client of his employer and left the meeting for the duration of the discussion and voting on the item. | Left the room |
| 20 Jul 2020 | Development Management Committee, item 15 | Councillor I D Gardener also declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Minute No. 17 (e) by virtue of the fact that the applicant was a client of his employer and left the meeting for the duration of the discussion and voting on the item. | Left the room |
Where Councillor Gardener sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth) | Member | Mar 2020 | 67 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Member | Feb 2020 | 46 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing Committee | Member | May 2024 | 9 | |
| Licensing and Protection Committee | Member | May 2024 | 9 | |
| Committees | Member | Jun 2020 | 7 | |
| Development Management Committee | Member | Mar 2020 | 54 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Customers and Partnerships) | Member | Jan 2021 | 10 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Joint Panel | Member | Jul 2023 | 2 | |
| Licensing and Protection Sub-Committee | Member | Jul 2024 | 2 | |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Member | Nov 2024 | 2 | |
| Senior Officers Committee | Advisory Member | Feb 2023 | 1 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Joint Group | Member | Nov 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.