Appointment of Vice-Chair
A proposal to appoint Councillor J Gray as Vice-Chair of the Committee was moved and seconded, whereupon it was RESOLVED that Councillor J Gray be elected Vice-Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Every time Huntingdonshire's minutes name Councillor Gray, as the council published it.
A proposal to appoint Councillor J Gray as Vice-Chair of the Committee was moved and seconded, whereupon it was RESOLVED that Councillor J Gray be elected Vice-Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor M Beuttell proposed and Councillor J Gray seconded the nomination of Councillor R Martin as Executive Leader of the Council for the ensuing term of office of all District Councillors on the District Council.
In opening the debate, Councillor J A Gray congratulated the Chair on his appointment.
At 7:13pm, Councillor Gray took his seat in the meeting.
In addressing the Chamber, Councillor J Gray expressed his opinion that the residents of the district should be able to express their views on the matter. It was his opinion that in order to maintain a democracy, it was only right that the Councillors of the District Council should surrender their power back to voters and allow them the gift of voting to elect the Councillors they chose at the polls in the Local Elections 2026.
Following a question from Councillor J A Gray, the Section 151 Officer advised that the Medium Term Financial Strategy would be updated and presented to the Council again in February 2026 alongside the new budget for 2026/27.
(Councillor J Gray, on behalf of Kimbolton and Stonely Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, G Pierce, Objector, and D Joseph, Applicant, addressed the Committee on the application).
(Councillor J Matthews, Stow Longa Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, and J Selwyn, applicant, addressed the Committee on the application).
In response to a question from Councillor Gray, the Chief Executive clarified that the Internal Governance Board meetings were formally Minuted and an action log reviewed in terms of actions arising, so that due diligence was followed and there was an evidence based structure in case any issues did arise.
In response to a question from Councillor Gray as to whether reassurance could be given that the recommended actions with regards to the One Leisure Pool Operations have been dealt with, the Chief Executive would provide a written response to the Committee with further details.
In response to a question from Councillor Gray, the Chief Executive commented that under the current Government timescales, HDC would be fully operational until 1 April 2028, so if there were any elements in the Constitution that needed to be addressed, they would be addressed. This was important in delivering good governance and effective decision making. She agreed with the suggestion that if things did need to be done before 2028, the pace could be picked up with regards to the Working Group.
Councillor J A Gray expressed his disappointment that despite the audit being completed, the Council was not in a position to sign off the accounts. In noting there was a going concern, he then queried how much of this was attributed to the availability of resources within Ernst & Young and internally within the Council. [name removed] responded that owing to the disclaimed audit opinion, the audit results report was where assurance had been received, with particular mention being made to the balance sheet.
In response to a question raised by Councillor J A Gray, [name removed] reported that sign off of the 2024/25 accounts would be expected at the December 2025 meeting.
Having queried the environmental risk relating to the “Failure to effectively respond to the climate change agenda in the required timeframe” comment was made by Councillor J A Gray whether this risk was appropriate to include in the Corporate Risk Register given this was outside of the Council’s control. The Corporate Director – Finance and Resources undertook to raise this with Senior Management Team and review accordingly.
Having received a response to a question raised by Councillor J A Gray querying the correlation and differences between sections 1 and 2 of RSM’s report a further question was then raised on how confident [name removed] was in terms of delivering the proposed Audit Plan. [name removed] responded that in the 18 years he had worked for RSM, he had never failed to deliver an Internal Audit Plan for any of his clients and that his team comprised of 40-45 Internal Auditors covering the East of England area with access to 220 Internal Auditors nationally. He also advised that he had access to specialist environmental and ICT auditors and drew attention to the importance of building effective working relationships with not only the in-house Internal Audit Team but with the Council’s Senior Management Team, Heads of Service and Service Managers.
Councillor J A Gray commended the Council on the approach it was now taking to address the governance issues faced by the Council which was echoed by the Committee. The Chair closed the meeting by thanking those present for their contributions to the meeting.
Councillor J A Gray reiterated previous concerns regarding the absence of any comprehensive monitoring report on the impact of the green bin subscription service since its introduction and sought an undertaking from the Executive Councillor that this be brought through the Overview and Scrutiny process within the next two months. In response to which, the Executive Councillor for Parks and Countryside, Waste and Street Scene sought clarification on the information which would be required from such a report and undertook to discuss the matter further with Officers. She also took the opportunity to reiterate that it was a matter for Overview and Scrutiny to lead their own work programme.
At 7:14pm, during discussion on this item, Councillor J A Gray took his seat at the meeting .
Councillor J A Gray queried what impact the issues highlighted at tonight’s meeting would have upon the 2024/25 final accounts. [name removed] responded that audit standards did not allow the auditors to rely on the work of the Internal Audit Team but that consideration would be given to the overall control environment as well as value for money conclusions.
In terms of areas for audit review, suggestions were made by Councillor J A Gray which included capital expenditure, specifically in relation to S106 and Community Infrastructure Levy funding, the Local Government Reorganisation and the Council’ insurance practices to include the tendering of insurance services.
A question was then raised by Councillor J A Gray querying what assurances would be delivered on risk and risk management events. The Corporate Director (Finance and Resources) advised of her intention to provide a regular report to the Committee on the Corporate Risk Register indicating actions which have moved, added or proposed for retirement. It was noted that options which might further be considered by the Committee could include Directorate reviews of risk or risk reviews by theme.
Whilst acknowledging many of the positive ideas within the Strategy, Councillor J A Gray expressed his concerns at the absence of any detailed proposals regarding the governance of the delivery fund. In response to which, the Executive Councillor for Climate, Transformation and Workforce reinforced the comments outlined within the report that open governance and transparent reporting of both spend and impact would be ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
In considering the contents of the report, Councillor J A Gray commented on the additional return which had been achieved on investment interest return compared to the budgeted position and an explanation was provided for this. A suggestion was also made that when considering the proportionality of investments, a better metric to consider might be what proportion of the Council’s net budget, is the income of the commercial investment portfolio currently making. In response to which, the Executive Councillor agreed that was a point worthy of further consideration.
Councillor J A Gray queried what sensitivities/analysis had been placed by the auditors upon the 2022/23 accounts, a time when the Council had changed its political administration. [name removed] undertook to investigate the matter with the previous Audit Manager and report back to the Chair outside of the meeting. She did however inform the Committee that a standard work programme would have been followed to review the budget and approvals process.
In response to a question raised by Councillor J A Gray, the Internal Audit Manager reported that he had not been informed of any risk events over the last two months.
Councillor J A Gray then delivered a brief update on the latest meeting of the Constitution Review Working Group on 12th November 2024 which had been a very productive meeting on the Council Procedure Rules.
(Councillor A Ford, Bythorn and Keyston Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, and R Keeling, applicant addressed the Committee on the application).
With reference to the implementation of the garden waste collection service, Councillor J A Gray commented on the absence of any regular updates or any detailed report on its performance to the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Environment, Communities and Partnerships). He outlined his continuing concerns that a major policy change was not being adequately monitored and that Members had requested information which had not yet been forthcoming. In response to which the Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Environment, Communities and Partnerships) reminded the Council that all Members were welcome to bring issues to Overview and Scrutiny for consideration.
Having expressed sympathies with both parishes, a suggestion was made by Councillor J A Gray to undertake a full review of all parish boundaries across the District. The Elections and Democratic Services Manager responded that this would be a large undertaking, with each parish being considered on its own merit and would also require a review of electoral arrangements across all three tiers of local government. It was then suggested that the Committee might consider an option to respond back to Glatton Parish Council requesting them to seek the views of the electorate via a petition.
Referring to case number 24/63, a question was raised by Councillor J A Gray querying whether an individual could join another Council following their resignation from another Council and prior to any formal investigation being undertaken. The Chief Executive reported that a similar matter had been discussed at the Standards Board for England which had concluded that it was in the public’s interest for the individual concerned to stand for election again.
Councillor J A Gray then queried what activities had been undertaken by the Council in respect of cyber security which was regarded a significant risk to the Council. The Chief Executive reported that testing of the Council’s systems and practices had been undertaken in May 2024, with additional resources put in place at the weekends. Phishing emails were regularly sent to staff, which would result in additional training if links were clicked on by staff that were unable to recognise the signs.
In response to a question raised by Councillor J A Gray, the Internal Audit Manager reported upon his immediate priorities which included closing off outstanding audit actions through effective engagement with service managers and staff, putting an action plan in place and actively working on it in response to the BDO quality assurance report on Internal Audit and identifying areas for audit in the Internal Audit Plan for 2025/26.
With reference to the organisation of the recent election of the Member of Parliament for the Huntingdon Constituency, Councillor J A Gray questioned the Executive Leader as to whether she agreed that the organisation of the election had been exceptionally well run, both by Officers and the candidates, their various counting agents and supporters at the Count. In indicating her wholehearted agreement to this comment, the Executive Leader took the opportunity to thank the staff and volunteers that had contributed to the success of the day and the evening, together with the weeks of preparation. She also took the opportunity to inform the Council that the ... view the full minutes text for item 21.
In response to a comment from Councillor J A Gray regarding where responsibility for Council employees lies democratically, the Executive Councillor for Climate Transformation and Workforce explained that in her view there was a distinction between policy and operation. Operational responsibility sat with the Head of Paid Services but setting the strategic direction was ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
In response to a question by Councillor Gray, it was confirmed that the Audit would focus on the value of both Property, Plant and Equipment and Investment Properties.
Councillor Gray drew attention to the significant problem of obtaining valuations represented for the Council.
Following a further question by Councillor Gray, the considerations taken into account when deciding how to use the National Audit Office’s guidance when carrying out evaluations were outlined. Having drawn attention to the fact that there had been a significant increase in the scale fee, Members were informed that most of the required work was built into the audit and that they would be formally notified of any variation.
Following a question by Councillor Gray about inherent and residual risks in relation to Risk Ref 350 in the Risk Movement Report, it was agreed the report would be revised for the next meeting. Whereupon, it was RESOLVED a) that the report be received and noted, and b) that it be confirmed that risks to the Council are being managed in line with the Risk Management Strategy.
As a result of a question from Councillor Gray about whistleblowing, t he Chair indicated that he was fully committed to the highest possible standards of openness, transparency and accountability. In that context, the Director of Finance and Corporate Resources stated that any such reports were directed to the Internal Audit Team for independent review.
Councillor Gray asked why the actual revenue expenditure showed a variance against the budget. In response it was noted that the budgets were prepared in advance and could only ever estimate income and expenditure, for example, income on investments was higher than expected as interest rates were significantly higher than anticipated. The Committee requested that the reference to the assumptions that had informed the budget plans for 2023/24 in February 2023 be reviewed.
Councillor Gray asked a question about work to implement the new P rocurement Regulations in October 2024 . It was reported that the Code of Procurement would be updated and presented to the Committee for its consideration and comment.
In response to a question by Councillor Gray, [name removed] stated that she was confident the Plan would be completed on time. Work would commence at the earliest opportunity and if possible prior to formal approval by the Council of the Plan.
Following a question by Councillor Gray, the Director of Finance and Corporate Resources reported that risk events were dealt with by service managers but that significant events would be reported to the Senior Leadership Team (SLT). They would be investigated and acted on as appropriate, including reporting to the relevant Member forum. However, it was necessary to manage how such information was used.
(Councillor David Fryatt, Brington and Molesworth Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, and A Moffat, agent, addressed the Committee on the application).
In responding to the remarks by the Executive Leader, the Leader of the Opposition Councillor J A Gray reiterated the importance in ensuring that targets were set appropriately. He also commented on the absence of any apparent self-reflection within the previous year, naming Civil Parking Enforcement and the pay negotiations as examples.
In terms of the number of actions within the refreshed Plan, Councillor Gray acknowledged that this was ambitious but urged the Joint Administration not to lose sight of the day-to-day functions that a growing number of residents were increasingly dissatisfied with. Reference was made specifically to grass cutting, bin collections and the garden waste subscription scheme. Comments were made regarding the increasing problems with rubbish and litter and blocked drains in the rural areas which in his opinion were not being addressed as adequately as in the urban areas.
In commenting on the proposed schedule the Leader of the Opposition, Councillor J A Gray commented on the level of the increases in some areas which were significantly above levels of inflation. Specific reference being made to some One Leisure charges and those for houses for multiple occupation.
Comment was also made with regards to the inclusion of the charge for the garden waste subscription charge and it was for this reason, Councillor Gray indicated that he would not be supporting the recommendation.
In responding to the presentation, Councillor J A Gray commented on the impression that he had received that the Board was not aligned and questioned whether this was a reflection of ineffective leadership.
Councillor Gray also commented on the irony of an Authority which was under a Best Value Notice increasing its precept by 200%.
With reference to the recent meeting of the Corporate Governance Committee, Councillor J A Gray took the opportunity to draw attention to issues relating to staffing levels around procurement. Members were advised that a significant number of the internal audit actions currently had procurement issues addressed against them and procurement regulations were about to get more complicated and would require additional staffing resources. The Executive Councillor for Customer Services agreed with the observations which had been made regarding the need for additional staffing and had already raised the matter with the Chief Executive.
Following questions from Councillor Gray on the Small Works Contract the Committee was advised that whilst it is taking longer than anticipated to resolve this issue Members were assured officers have a “path to success” and are working to accelerate and streamline the procurement processes within HDC, and the intention is to have this in place by April 2024. Committee indicated that it would like more details to a future meeting on how this will be delivered.
Following a request for further clarification on the position with the preparation of a new Commercial Investment Strategy from Councillor J A Gray, the Executive Councillor for Finance and Resources explained that it was hoped to commission this work in April 2024 when the Bank of England had indicated their expectations that inflation would start to steady and interest rates would be more consistent.
In response to which, Councillor Gray encouraged the administration to start work on reviewing the Strategy as soon as possible to ensure that the District Council were best looking after the assets and estate it had built up over the previous fifty years.
On behalf of Councillor T Alban, Councillor J A Gray outlined his disappointment regarding the brevity of Agenda items at the recent meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Environment, Community and Partnerships) and went on to question when members could expect to see an improvement in the quality of Overview and Scrutiny Agendas and work programmes.
On the recommendation of Councillor J A Gray, it was RESOLVED that Councillor G Welton be appointed to the membership of the Overview and Scrutiny (Environment, Communities and Partnerships) Panel in place of Councillor S Cawley.
Councillor Gray was reassured that the escalation of planning related complaints had halted following actions taken and would be reviewed by the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance & Growth). Whereupon it was RESOLVED (a) that the data relating to formal Stage One and Stage Two complaints received (2022/23) be received and noted;
Councillor Hodgson-Jones suggested that risks within the register were reduced and ordered based on priority; while Councillor Gray highlighted the benefits of modernising the Risk Management Strategy. The Director of Finance and Corporate Resources responded that risk cause and output were being reviewed with the expectation that some risks would be merged, allowing more severe risks to be focussed upon.
Councillor Gray was informed that the risk of incorrect data disposal while working from home was managed by the reduction in printed information, associated training sessions and encouraging staff to contact the InfoGov Team with queries.
Councillor Gray requested that future reports offered data on the cumulative days targets had been missed. Whereupon, it was RESOLVED that the contents of the report on compliance with the Information Rights Acts and Information Governance be noted.
Councillor Gray commended the budget outturn and contributions to reserves.
Councillor Gray noted that investment property balance had reduced between 2020/21 and 2021/22. The Fixed Asset Register valuation had been partially impacted by changes in the land/building split for two investment properties.
The Director of Finance and Corporate Resources confirmed with the Chair and Councillor Gray that the Annual Governance Statement, a replica of the March 2023 statement, had been signed today at the auditor’s request and that she was content for the Letter of Representation to be approved. ... view the full minutes text for item 32.
Councillor Gray complimented the presentation of the cumulative delay for overdue audit actions.
Councillor Gray was informed that a Constitution Review including formulation of the Shadow Cabinet would occur following introduction of the new Chief Executive Officer. He also suggested that Councillors and Officers collaborate on the Risk Management Reporting Framework.
(Councillor A Ford, Bythorn and Keyston Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, L Johnston and P Quarmby, objectors, and M Ellis, applicant, addressed the Committee on the application).
A ‘Thought for the Day’ was presented by Councillor Jonathan Gray.
Councillor S J Conboy moved and it was duly seconded by Councillor J A Gray that This Council:
Having thanked the Executive Councillor for the update on the audit delay and having expressed the view that there did not seem to be any undue reason for concern in relation to the emerging observations, Councillor Gray questioned whether interest income was allocated across reserves equally.In response to which Councillor Mickelburgh explained that different accounting practises will demand different technical rules to be followed.
In response to a question from Councillor J A Gray concerning when the Code of Conduct issues at the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Combined Authority were likely to be concluded, the Executive Leader reported that she did not have a definitive answer but expected this to be fairly shortly . From the advice that she had received, the Executive Leader was told that Cambridgeshire and Peterborough were being considered as equal partners to all others in any potential devolution process. The real challenge for the authority would be to find common ground and to identify those areas behind ... view the full minutes text for item 24.
(Councillor C Spink , Bythorn and Keyston Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, and A Ford, applicant, addressed the Committee on the application).
The Chair welcomed Councillor Jennings and Councillor Welton to the Panel and thanked Councillor Cawley and Councillor Gray for their valuable contribution over the past year.
Arising from which, Councillor J A Gray then queried the recent leadership and staff changes which had occurred within the Strategic Property Team, when a refresh of the CIS was anticipated and the savings which had been achieved relating to staff costs within the Planning Team. The Managing Director (Interim) responded that the new Strategic Property Asset Manager came with experience of working within a commercial and local authority background and that the immediate priority would be to review some of the Council’s investments with a view to generating longer term returns. In respect of the refresh of the CIS, the Committee noted that core principles for this would be established over the summer period and that further developments would be expected in due course.
Having welcomed the improvements which had been made to the Code, Councillor J A Gray queried the capacity of the Council to carry these principles forward. The Managing Director (Interim) responded that whilst being mindful of the priority being accorded to the completion of the external audit for 2021/22, together with the challenges which existed in recruiting to the vacant Corporate Director (Place) post, the key point of this Code would be to ensure that the seven principles were embedded within existing working practices. Additionally, the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance & Growth) would be reviewing the Corporate Plan Targets for 2023/24 at their meeting on 7th June 2023 and that efforts would be made to effectively utilise the current level of resources available within the organisation.
At 7:01pm, Councillor J A Gray, took his seat at the meeting.
Councillor J A Gray echoed the views of Councillor R J West and made comment that the Independent Remuneration Panel, tasked with undertaking the review of Member Allowances, had not spoken to him as Leader of the Opposition about the creation of the Assistant Deputy Executive Leader role which was deemed to be poor. Furthermore, he commented that the proposals would come at a cost to the taxpayer and that this was not demonstrating the best use of taxpayer’s money.
Prior to moving on to the next item, Councillor J A Gray raised previous requests to undertake a full review of the Council’s Constitution, in particular the need to add reference to the Shadow Cabinet. The Elections and Democratic Services Manager reminded Members that it was within the Committee’s gift to receive such a report at a future meeting and undertook to take this forward in conjunction with the Managing Director (Interim) outside of the meeting. In response to a question raised by ... view the full minutes text for item 42.
In response to a question raised by Councillor J A Gray, [name removed] expressed the view that he wasn’t anticipating anything significant to arise from the new payroll system, that the ... view the full minutes text for item 43.
Following a question raised by Councillor J A Gray, a brief explanation was delivered on the purpose and background of the Peer Review, where it was noted that the findings of the review had only recently been shared in draft with the Council.
In response to a subsequent question raised by Councillor J A Gray querying the level of resources available within the Internal Audit Service at a time when new business plans and priorities had recently been adopted by the Council, the Internal Audit Manager reported that at present she did not have sufficient resources as she was currently the only permanent member of staff in her team. She then went on to report that the Internal Audit Plan 2023/24 would be submitted to the Committee at a future meeting to enable the final outcome of the Peer Review to be incorporated as well as realigning the Plan with new corporate priorities and risks.
In respect of the latter, Councillor J A Gray sought assurances that the matter had been dealt with promptly given this was a highly regulated area of the Council’s work. The Managing Director (Interim) advised that extra resources had been given to the service as a means of preventing such issues from arising in the future again.
In responding to the Executive Leader’s presentation, Councillor J A Gray made several comments relating to the Strategy and its production. He referred to the comments made by the focus groups regarding the need to ensure that decision making, and funding was equitable and inclusive and driven by the people that it is meant to serve.
In indicating his qualified support for the Strategy, Councillor Gray reiterated that he had been reassured that work to refine the Strategy would be an iterative process and it was his expectation that this would be clearly evidenced. He also referred to the importance of the importance of the availability of an Action Plan in Quarter 1 of 2023/24 to monitor the success of the Strategy.
In response to the Executive Leader’s presentation and on behalf of the Conservative Group, Councillor J A Gray indicated his support for the priorities contained within the Plan, although in doing so, suggested that there was some resemblance to those adopted by the previous administration.
However, Councillor Gray expressed his concerns with regards to the absence of ... view the full minutes text for item 78.
Councillor J A Gray commented on the poor quality of the report and the idiosyncrasy of some of the recommendations which did not reflect the evolution of the workload which had taken place since the last review.
Arising from which and having welcomed the new appointment, Councillor Gray sought clarification as to what the Executive Leader considered to be his most pressing challenges.
The Panel heard, following a question from Councillor Gray that any entirely new settlements would be considered separately to this document and would go through the usual Planning processes.
Following observations from Councillor Gray, the Panel heard that an update to the Strategic Flood Risk Assessment 2017 in the form of Integrated Water Management Studies was underway which would address all aspects of flooding from recent years including surface water run-off from new developments.
The Panel heard, after a further question from Councillor Gray, that the approach to windfall sites had changed. The team were currently using available data for sites of less than 10 houses to formulate predictions for the future. It was acknowledged that this wording would be adapted to clarify the windfall definition and the methodology.
Concern was expressed by Councillor Gray over the detail contained within the Strategy and that it appeared that a lot of detail was still work in progress.
Councillor Gray expressed further concern that some of the Strategy may be aspirations of the coalition but questioned if this was what residents of the district wanted, especially if public funds would be used to implement them.
Councillor Gray observed that given the importance of having suitable targets for operational performance measures that are both realistic and stretching, it would be helpful for the Panel to have sight of the proposed targets for 2023/24. Having received agreement to this request, it was thereupon RESOLVED that the comments of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel be passed to Cabinet for their consideration when making a decision upon the recommendations contained within the report.
Councillor Gray has also been advised that funding for the activities listed in Table 2 has not yet been confirmed.
Councillor Gray requested that any projects that are amber or red are reported to future meetings.
Councillor J A Gray raised a question in relation to any update on the conclusion of the investigation of the Mayor and the impact that this was having on progress of the Combined Authority compared to other Combined Authorities, whereby Councillor Conboy reported that she had personally raised this with the Chief Executive and Improvement Board and urged them that the matter needed resolving that would also hopefully resolve the ongoing party politics issues.
Councillor Gray commented that the purpose of the Panel was to scrutinise the report and to give Cabinet comments and thoughts to reflect upon rather than have a debate on the budget. He;
Following an enquiry from Councillor Gray, the Panel were assured that there had been no concern over Counter Parties over the past year which required urgent withdrawal of funds (although an investment with Thurrock BC had caused concern but had in the end been repaid on time) and that risk of investing generally had been minimised through use of DMO (Debt Management Office) and money market funds Councillor Pickering enquired about the move to ESG products and the Panel were advised that whilst these products were still new to the market, an ESG compliance scoring mechanism is likely to be introduced by treasury advisors to help ascertain the right ESG investment products for the council’s consideration and also that reporting on this and other ESG developments would be included in future treasury management reports in due course.
It was clarified to the Panel, following a query from Councillor Gray, that the early repayment of the People for Places and respective PWLB loans had still proved beneficial for the Council. 4.6 Councillor Gray further enquired whether more caution would be exercised following issues recouping money in relation to CCTV Shared Service staffing. The Panel were assured that the team were fulling involved in ensuring due diligence across such matters, as was evidenced in the highlighted example.
Councillor Gray observed that amber may be a more realistic indicator for KA5 as it was optimistic to claim this project was on track.
It was further observed by Councillor Gray that some indicators had no set target which therefore made it difficult to ascertain progress. The Panel heard that this was acknowledged and that the targets and indicators would be reviewed with the introduction of the new Corporate Plan in the coming months.
Councillor Gray expressed concerns that there were discrepancies between the figures shown for staffing in the budget and MTFS considering the anticipated impact of the increase in minimum wage. The Panel heard that the team were confident that the budget was achievable however, this point would be re-examined and reported back to the Panel at a later date.
Councillor Gray commented that Management Information Dashboards would be helpful for both One Leisure and Planning services, recognising that the issues surrounding the Planning service had been ongoing for considerable time. The viability of these projects will be investigated and reported back to the Panel at a future meeting.
(At 7:06pm, during discussion on this item, Councillor J A Gray took his seat at the meeting).
In response to a question raised by Councillor J A Gray, the Internal Audit Manager confirmed that there were no specific actions that were of particular concern and that she had been thinking of ways to proactively issue meaningful reminders to Officers about their audit actions and highlighted the role of Senior Management in discussing these matters with Service Managers at one to one meetings.
A subsequent question was then raised by Councillor J A Gray on whether the Committee wished to be provided with more commentary around Senior Management’s actions and involvement in such matters. The Director for Finance and Corporate Resources responded by assuring the Committee that the Risks and Control Group highlighted any risks and concerns to Senior Management as necessary.
A question was raised by Councillor J A Gray querying who would be sitting on the Appointments Panel to interview candidates for the role(s). It was confirmed that this would comprise the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Committee, Director of Finance and Corporate Resources and the Internal Audit Manager.
A subsequent question was then raised by Councillor J A Gray on the proposal to appoint an individual on a three year term commencing 1st May 2023 and how this contradicted the benefit of corporate memory within the Committee given that all District Councillors would be up for election at the same time. In acknowledging this, it was suggested that further thought might need to be given to CIPFA’s recommendation for up to 2 individuals to be appointed with the start date of commencement varying for each individual.
Councillor J A Gray reminded the Committee of the request which had been made at the December 2022 Council meeting to undertake a full review of the Council’s Constitution. The Elections and Democratic Services Manager reported that there were currently no plans for a full review to be undertaken owing to the lack of budgetary provision but that a bid could be made in the future as part of the budget setting process.
Councillor Gray stated that whilst broadly supportive of the thrust of what is overall hoped to be achieved, there was particular concern that none of the proposals had been developed. It was further stated that greater detail alongside the business plans would be desirable before authority be delegated to others for decision making. The Panel were informed that external funding brought challenges of tight timescales but that this was something that the Executive were happy to reflect upon and come back with.
Councillor Gray enquired about continuity plans for the project due to the resignation of the lead officer. The Panel were advised that planning had been undertaken to ensure continuation of work during the recruitment process.
Councillor Gray further expressed that whilst remaining optimistic, there were some reservations about what could realistically be achieved and whether or not the views of local residents had been reflected in the identified pathways. The Panel were assured that the priorities within the report had been established following engagement with residents and communities.
In addition to this, Councillor Gray questioned whether Huntingdonshire would be a leader in some of the aspirations highlighted within the report. The Panel were advised that whilst the Council may not be a leader in these areas, it would be a facilitator in making them happen and setting a good example for residents to follow. Furthermore the Panel heard that through community engagement and working with partners to ensure communication between interested groups, a positive, proactive and supportive district community would be encouraged.
Councillor Gray praised the very experienced team for their work so far and expressed confidence in the time ahead, a sentiment which was echoed by Councillor Gleadow.
Councillor Gray observed that whilst the Plan was fairly future proof, it was important to engage with residents throughout the process.
Councillor Gray sought assurance that best practice was being taken from colleagues in neighbouring authorities. The Panel were assured that this was underway despite the developing stage of progress so far.
Following a further question from Councillor Gray, the Panel heard that the Local Plan would work alongside emerging strategies such as the Climate and Place Strategies. Collaborative work would be undertaken as the Page 184 of 498 project progressed to ensure assimilation and cohesion between Strategies.
Councillor Gray observed that whilst there is acceptance of the examiner’s report, it is important to liaise with local communities to establish and maintain the features which make their community special.
Councillor Gray raised concerns about the lack of items on the future work programme. The Panel were in agreement on this point and resolved to raise topics for consideration at future meetings.
Councillor J A Gray extended his condolences on behalf of his Group to former Councillor Giles’ family and referred to his recent attendance to receive his award as Honorary Alderman and appreciated his style of receipt in accepting the award that was typical of his style. He had the passion to serve his community and was at the forefront where decisions locally were being made and conveyed his best wishes to his wife Sandie and family and should be proud of the person Derek was.
In response to an update requested by Councillor J A Gray on the investigation of the Mayor and conveyed his best wishes to the Mayor of the Combined Authority in his recuperation.
Councillor Gray stated that whilst broadly supportive of the thrust of what is overall hoped to be achieved, he had concerns over the lack of detail contained within the report, expressly concern that all proposals were completely underdeveloped. It was further stated that greater detail alongside the business plans would be desirable before authority be delegated to others for decision making. The Panel were informed that external funding brought challenges of tight timescales but that this was something that the Executive were happy to reflect upon and come back with.
Councillor Gray observed the tight deadlines for the Priory Centre project and queried the confidence of the administration in delivering the project on time.
Following an enquiry from Councillor Gray on the delays relating to the allocated CIL funds, the Panel were advised that due to the economic climate and international supply issues, capital projects were experiencing delays nationally.
Councillor Gray complemented the Officer on the proposed response which was felt to strike to the heart of the issues and concerns shared by all.
Following a question from Councillor Gray regarding the development of further park and ride sites within the district, the Panel heard that the Executive Councillor agreed with the sentiment that there is a need to remain realistic about what may be achievable within the district and within the reach of the Greater Cambridge Partnership.
Councillor Gray observed that the figures relating to One Leisure were concerning and questioned the Executive Councillor on his confidence in the recently approved plan to increase fees and charges across the leisure centres. The Panel were advised that One Leisure had been heavily affected by the increase in energy costs and the recent rise in minimum wage, but that significant debate had been had surrounding the increase to fees and charges.
Councillor Gray reflected that this report had been published after the decision on fees and charges had been taken and thereby queried how the Cabinet had been able to make the decision without the supporting information. The Panel were assured that by applying the proposed fees and charges to the available Quarter One figures, the Cabinet had been able to forecast the impact this would have. The Panel were further assured that the figures would continue to be monitored so that further action could be taken to remedy lost revenue and footfall through commercial strategies or alternative pricing structures in the future.
Councillor Gray questioned the figures shown in Table 6, specifically what the amount £2.8 million related to as it was thought to be too low for the whole portfolio. The detailed response to this will be sought by the Officer and reported back to the Panel. Following the discussion, the Panel RESOLVED that the Cabinet be encouraged to endorse the recommendations within the report.
It was observed by Councillor Gray that the rural nature of Huntingdonshire was not at the heart of the strategy, in particular the lack of focus on walking and cycling routes in rural areas as compared to urban areas. The Panel heard that this sentiment was understood and covered by section six of the response.
Councillor Gray observed a carelessness in the approach of the County Council on this strategy with incorrect road labelling on the map at page 5 and incorrect figures for the population of Huntingdonshire, it was further noted that these inconsistencies did not inspire confidence in the Strategy.
Councillor Gray also observed that the strategy did not address the significant developments across rural areas of the district with specific reference to policy TSH1 in regards to sustainable growth, by this omission and the broad assumptions made, the robustness of the strategy must therefore be called into question. The Panel heard that the strategy will support the delivery of the Local Plan 2036. The Local Plan has sustainable growth at it’s core with not only the market towns but key services centres and smaller settlements being identified within the strategy.
The growth of developments in key services areas was observed by Councillor Gray, along with the lack of active or alternative travel options thus encouraging reliance on private car usage. The Panel heard that Huntingdonshire would be unlikely to see the disappearance of the private car any time soon, however it should be possible to use alternative transport methods for part journeys which would be progress.
Councillor Cawley and Councillor Gray observed that the One Leisure offer is not the same as it was pre COVID and enquired on plans to reinstate fitness classes and activities which were previously available. The Panel were advised that as that level of detail is not available within the report this would be investigated and communicated back at a later date.
Councillor Gray questioned the statement at KA1 and observed that a Climate Emergency had not been declared. He stated that this related to the cost of living crisis and felt that this inaccuracy was misleading.
Councillor Gray observed that the project at St Neots Riverside Walks should be shown as Red status due to unresolved objections from the Environment Agency making the project undeliverable within the given timescales. The Panel were advised that a progress status would be sought and reported back along with revised timescales.
(e) of the motion as set out below was moved by Councillor P J Hodgson-Jones and duly seconded by Councillor J A Gray that – 6. (e) A strategic plan that delivers UK energy security from renewable, nuclear, green hydrogen and other alternative energy generation programmes which, together with insulation schemes, is partly funded by taxation polices that disincentivise the use of fossil fuels.
In welcoming the feedback from the Executive Leader, Councillor J A Gray referenced the investigations at the Combined Authority and expectation of moving beyond the current situation, whereby Councillor Conboy expressed her similar concerns and reported that she had been assured that matters would be ... view the full minutes text for item 37.
Councillor J A Gray welcomed the presentation and drew Members’ attention to the strong legacy of the Commercial Investment Strategy in supporting what the report had highlighted.
Councillor J A Gray referred to the difficult start and was disappointed that the hard lobbying for a stand-alone Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Combined Authority was now resulting in lost opportunities with funding being returned to Central Government that could have been used to deliver key projects that could also have been attributed to the significant number of unfilled posts.
It was observed by Councillor Gray, that the CPCA needed to make some decisions and provide further detail whilst allowing local authorities scope to provide a more detailed response. The Panel were advised that the Cabinet report would be submitted alongside the response to compensate for the restrictive nature of the response form.
Councillor Gray observed that the Corporate Plan was for the whole Council to adopt, not just the joint administration and that it would be useful to refer to it as such. This point was noted and the messaging would be amended to reflect this.
Councillor Gray further observed that the new administration had inherited a very strong financial position from the previous administration, and whilst pragmatism is welcomed, the plan looked very similar to previous years with the exception of the climate emergency declaration. It was further stated that residents of Huntingdonshire had voted for change in the recent elections but that none was visible within the plan. The Panel heard that whilst there were current similarities to previous plans, change is coming.
Councillor Gray observed that the 2021/22 budget had been authorised during the remote covid Council sessions with no objections and only two abstentions, and that the reported surplus had left the new administration in a favourable position financially. It was also observed that Government grants previously available may not be available in the future.
Councillor Gray observed the strong financial position with plenty of reserves that the previous administration had left the Council in, therefore nothing of concern could be observed within the report.
Councillor Gray questioned the speed of response and customer satisfaction levels attained by the Legal Service. The Panel heard that indicators were reflective of the feedback received and it was noted that this may not be a fair reflection over time. The Panel were assured that regular meetings were held to identify and resolve any issues arising within the service.
Councillor Gray enquired on the thoughts and priorities of the newly appointed Executive Councillor in moving this body of work forward. The Panel heard that a balance would be struck between delivering new opportunities which aligned with the current administrations principles and maximising advantages and funding of the work already obtained. It was noted that the new Cabinet were grateful to the previous administration for the positive position achieved to date and would build upon this good work.
Councillor Gray enquired on the initial thoughts of the new Executive Councillor on this report and whether there were any additional areas of focus identified. The Panel heard that the new administration would be building on a great foundation but that as the district progresses post pandemic, new challenges will be faced. The proposed refresh of the Corporate Plan which is due to come through the democratic cycle in the coming months will help to identify revised indicators to ensure that the Council is best serving the needs of its residents.
Councillor J A Gray conveyed his congratulations to the new Chairman and Vice-Chairman and extended a warm welcome to the new and returning Members. He further paid tribute to the departing and retiring Members and calculated that this added up to 73 years of service amongst them. The departing Members included former Councillors L A Besley, G J Bull, A Dickinson, P L R Gaskin, H V Masson, D M Tysoe and R G Tuplin.
Councillor J A Gray was proposed by Councillor J Neish, seconded by Councillor S Bywater and upon being put the vote the Motion by Councillor Neish was declared to be LOST.
(At 7:03pm, during discussion on this item, Councillor J A Gray took his seat at the meeting).
Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Finance, opened the meeting with a prayer.
In conjunction with a report by the Chief Financial Officer and a PowerPoint presentation (copies of which are appended in the Minute Book), Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Finance presented to Members the 2022/23 Revenue Budget, the Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for the period 2023/24 to 2026/27, the Fees and Charges schedule for 2022/23, the Treasury Management Strategy, the Capital Strategy, the Investment Strategy, the Annual Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) Statement for 2022/23 and other associated matters for the Council’s consideration and approval.
By way of introduction and with the assistance of a power-point presentation (a copy of which is appended in the Minute Book), Councillor Gray proceeded to set out the guiding principles which had been used to put together the Budget for 2022/23. He drew attention to the challenging and complicated budget setting process on this occasion and extended his gratitude to the Managing Director and her staff in support of this process, as well as his Cabinet colleagues. He also referred to the impact of COVID and the ongoing macro-economic conditions that had contributed to the creation of a financial environment which was hard to predict.
Councillor Gray highlighted the Council Tax requirement for 2022/23 and the Administration’s intention to keep any Council Tax rises low but affordable which had resulted in an average increase of 1.8% per annum over the past 4 years. It was proposed that in 2022/23 Band D should be set at £150.86. He further explained that the Section 151 Officer had confirmed the robustness of the Budget and that the proposed 2022/23 Budget should not give Members any significant concerns with regards to the Council’s financial position.
In referring to the plan for the MTFS, Councillor Gray explained that he had confidence in the levers at the Council’s disposal and their ability to influence the cost of services, funding from grants and tax and income from traded services. Members also noted the assumptions that had been made to meet the challenges which included, keeping the minimum General Fund reserve, 2% annual pay rise, continued growth of the National Living Wage and the requirement for the Council to remain dynamic and innovative.
Councillor Gray explained that officers would be held to account over their service ... view the full minutes text for item 62.
(At 7:05pm, during discussion on this item, Councillor J A Gray took his seat at the meeting).
(Councillor M Patterson, Kimbolton Parish Council, Councillor J A Gray, Ward Member, N Jones, objector, and C Haynes, applicant, addressed the Committee on the application).
(Councillor J A Gray, Ward Member, S Cadwell, objector, and P Watson, agent, addressed the Committee on the application).
The Executive Leader undertook to ensure that Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Finance, provided a response to his further question.
Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Finance echoed the sentiments expressed by the Executive Leader and thanked [name removed] for her partnership and advice to the Council which had left the Council in a strong financial position. Members wished her well for the future. Whereupon, it was RESOLVED that Eric Symons, Interim Finance Manager, be appointed as the Council’s Chief Financial Officer/Section 151 Officer on an interim basis commencing on 1st October 2021 for a period of time not exceeding 12 months.
(Councillor C Palmann, Brington and Moleworth Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, and C George, agent, addressed the Committee on the application).
Following a question by Councillor Roberts on whether the Art Centre development in St Neots was a problematic investment for the Council, Councillor Gray reassured that although the commercial potential of this development has not yet been achieved, Huntingdonshire District Council is committed to supporting the repurposing and regeneration of this centre to fully benefit the residents and businesses of St Neots. The Panel were also reassured that overall the Council’s commercial estate contributed positively towards the budget.
Housing & Economic Development Councillor R Fuller Strategic Planning Councillor J Neish Corporate Services Councillor D Keane Leisure & Regulatory Services Councillor K Prentice Operations & Environment Councillor Mrs M L Beuttell Strategic Finance Councillor J A Gray Community Resilience & Wellbeing Councillor S Bywater b) that Councillor J M Palmer be appointed as Cabinet Assistant;
Councillor Fuller, then presented the details of the Cabinet Portfolios for the 2021/22 Municipal Year, with a few minor changes to their remits :- Councillor M L Beuttell, Operations and Environment Councillor S Bywater, Community Resilience and Wellbeing Councillor R Fuller, Housing and Economic Development Councillor J A Gray, Strategic Finance Councillor D Keane, Corporate Services Councillor J Neish, Strategic Planning Councillor K I Prentice, Leisure and Regulatory Services Councillor Fuller further confirmed the appointment of Councillor J Palmer as a Cabinet Assistant for the ensuing Municipal Year.
In conjunction with a report by the Chief Finance Officer (a copy of which is appended in the Minute Book), Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Finance and Resources, presented to Members the 2021/22 Revenue Budget, the Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for the period 2022/23 to 2025/26, the Fees and Charges schedule for 2021/22, the Treasury Management Strategy, the Capital Strategy, the Investment Strategy, the Annual Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) Statement for 2021/22 and other associated matters for the Council’s consideration and approval.
With the assistance of a power-point presentation (a copy of which is appended in the Minute Book), Councillor Gray proceeded to set out the guiding principles which had been used to put together the Budget for 2021/22. He then went on to outline some of the highlights within the proposed Revenue Budget which included the expected income pressures, the retention of all key services with investment, additional resources to drive economic development and growth, the accommodation of pressure from Covid -related growth and the receipt of ongoing Government support.
With regard to Capital Expenditure for 2021/22, Councillor Gray went on to outline some of the highlights in this area which included the impact of Covid on the delivery of the programme in the current year, a new focus on town centre improvement plans and a wider focus on seeking more grant funding to lessen the burden on the Council’s MRP.
(Councillor P Seabrook, Kimbolton Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, [name removed], agent on behalf of an objector, and [name removed], agent on behalf of the applicant).
Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Finance and Resources, drew Members attention to the main development since the last report in so far as there had been a fall in the Bank of England base rate soon after the pandemic broke out and had dropped further since but as this was not a major source of revenue for the Council. It was reported that the performance was as expected and the importance of the ongoing Commercial Investment Strategy and providing revenue to support the Council’s front line services equating to around 20% of the £4m revenue budget on a net basis. The report provided an important update for Members highlighting the safety of the investments and cash had been well looked after and paid tribute to the Members of the Finance Team during this difficult period looking after and stewarding the finances of the District Council.
In response, Councillor Gray reported that the Council had no plans to dispose of any of the property held for investment and drew Members to the values of these assets that had been made in the early part of lockdown this year where there was considerable uncertainty over property values and the Auditors had been erring on the side of caution when these had been assessed.
Furthermore, Councillor Gray explained that the value was also dependent upon how much was left on the leases attached to the properties, where the property value increased as a new lease was agreed. Attention was drawn to this evidenced in the report with considerable work undertaken on the existing portfolio but had been suffering the same as the wider property market being under pressure and as a result of active work to renew leases the property prices had continued to rise.
Councillor Gray reported upon his confidence with the properties listed, with the exception of the Rowley Centre that he felt was under the most commercial pressure but as the Council was the ... view the full minutes text for item 35.
By way of a report by the Finance Manager (a copy of which is appended in the Minute Book) Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Finance and Resources presented details of the outcome of the review of the Code of Financial Management as endorsed by the Corporate Governance Committee at their meeting on 23rd July 2020. The Code was reviewed regularly to ensure it reflected current legislation and the changing needs of the Council.
Whereby Councillor Gray explained that the service would continue to have free, full and unrestricted access to services and functions and all Council assets, systems, documents, information, employees and Members as set out in the Code. He further explained that there was a restructuring of the resource following the departure of the Internal Audit Manager and they had been working to see how a solution could be delivered effectively. Although there was an interim solution in place, it was felt that consideration should also be given to a shared service that could deliver across multiple platforms the internal audit outturn that the Corporate Governance Committee valued highly.
Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Finance and Resources, drew Members attention to the stable outcome during this period which showed the difference between borrowing that had been undertaken with an average amount payable at 2.76% compared to yields on investment of 6.5%.
(Councillor C Palmann, Brinton and Molesworth Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, [name removed], objector and [name removed], agent, addressed the Committee on the application).
Housing & Economic Development Councillor R Fuller Strategic Planning Councillor J Neish Corporate Services Councillor D Keane Leisure & Regulatory Services Councillor K Prentice Operations & Environment Councillor Mrs M L Beuttell Finance & Resources Councillor J A Gray Community Resilience & Wellbeing Councillor S Bywater b) that Councillor J M Palmer be appointed as Cabinet Assistant;
Councillor Fuller, then presented the details of the Cabinet Portfolios for the 2020/21 Municipal Year :- Councillor M L Beuttell, Operations and Environment Councillor S Bywater, Community Resilience and Wellbeing Councillor R Fuller, Housing and Economic Development Councillor J A Gray, Finance and Resources Councillor D Keane, Corporate Services Councillor J Neish, Strategic Planning Councillor K I Prentice, Leisure and Regulatory Services Councillor Fuller further confirmed the appointment of Councillor J Palmer as a Cabinet Assistant for the ensuing Municipal Year.
RESOLVED (a) that Councillor J A Gray be appointed as the Shareholder Representative to act on behalf of the Council as Shareholder of the Council’s Local Authority Trading Company; and (b) that Councillors S J Corney, M Humphrey, T D Sanderson and D M Tysoe be appointed to the HDC Ventures Shareholder Reference Group for the ensuing Municipal Year.
In conjunction with a report by the Head of Resources and PowerPoint presentation (copies of which are appended in the Minute Book), Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources, presented to Members the 2020/21 Revenue Budget, the Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for the period 2021/22 to 2024/25, the Fees and Charges schedule for 2020/21, the Treasury Management Strategy, the Capital Strategy, the Investment Strategy and the Flexible Use of Capital Receipts Strategy for 2020/21 and other associated matters for the Council’s consideration and approval.
In his opening remarks on completion of the Budget and MTFS, Councillor Gray referred to the time and effort involved with the long process that began in May 2019 and conveyed his gratitude to the Officers that had assisted, including the Managing Director and her staff, as well as the S151 Officer in the guise of [name removed] that had commenced this work at the beginning and had been concluded by [name removed] and well as his Cabinet Member colleagues.
In referring to the Commercial Investment Strategy (CIS), Councillor Gray explained that the Council had been close to completing the work set out after the CIS in 2015 that had been an important income stream to enable a balanced budget without the reliance on Central Government funding and the focus looking forward to the development of housing related acquisitions.
(At 7.13pm, Councillor J A Gray took his seat at the meeting).
Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources, drew Members attention to the economic review, the performance of the Council’s funds and the political uncertainty regarding the UK leaving the European Union.
Councillor Gray confirmed that uncertainty existed as economic growth remained low but he reassured Members that the CIS returns provided a higher rate of return, with £2.8m of investment income generated in 2018/19.This was necessary to achieve a balanced budget to support the provision of services to the District’s residents. He further reported that since he had last spoken at Overview and Scrutiny a further 10 leases had been signed, with the value of the leases of the residual estate and the value in the accounts risen and the value on the open market for potential purchasers increasing.
Councillor Gray reassured Members that the investments were overseen by the Commercial Estates Manager and her Team, who were keeping abreast of any changes in the market and taking these into account.
Arising from a question from Councillor S Wakeford as to whether the Council had given consideration to building a local industrial strategy to support the potential of the property investments in the CIS, Councillor Gray explained that phase 1 of the CIS had now drawn to a close and there now existed an opportunity to intervene at town centre level to use and influence the land holdings held in the District to build up what the Council already had access to. Whereupon, it was RESOLVED that the Treasury Management Performance over the period April to September 2019 be noted.
In conjunction with a report by the Managing Director (a copy of which is appended in the Minute Book) it was proposed by Councillor G J Bull, seconded by Councillor J A Gray and RESOLVED that Councillor R Fuller be elected Executive Leader of the Council for the for the period to the Annual Meeting in May 2022.
Councillor Fuller presented details of the Cabinet Portfolios for the remainder of the 2019/20 Municipal Year:- Councillor Ms M L Beuttell Operations and Environment Councillor R Fuller Executive Leader and Housing and Economic Development Councillor J A Gray Resources Councillor D N Keane Corporate Services Councillor J Neish Deputy Executive Leader and Strategic Planning Councillor J M Palmer Leisure and Health Councillor K I Prentice Communities Councillor Fuller also reported that Councillors J Neish, D N Keane and K I Prentice were the consequent ex-officio appointments to the Development Management, Employment, Licensing and Protection and Licensing Committees respectively.
( At 8.41pm, during the discussion of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. )
( At 7.11pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray entered the meeting. ) ( At 7.54pm, on the conclusion of this item, Councillor M S Grice left the meeting. )
This Council calls for more realistic projections for the duration of the Medium Term Financial Strategy approved by Council in February." In response Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Resources, indicated his surprise at the motion presented and confirmed that there had been a variance of 6% rather than 176.7%. Furthermore he explained the Council actively sought grant funding to help deliver the Healthy and Active Lifestyle Service and expenditure fluctuated on this year on year.
Councillor Gray explained that the Council had the best financial record of any District in Cambridgeshire and encouraged Councillor Sanderson to address the detail of any proposals in the draft budget cycle. He also confirmed that he believed the projection to be fair but had fluctuated and been subject to events to vary it.
Councillor J A Gray urged Members to encourage more volunteers and energise people to get more involved and welcomed [name removed] view on the prevalence of charity shops appearing on the High Street. In response, [name removed] explained that volunteers can be of any age and also the sector had welcomed an increase in business partners who had been able to offer more professional advice to local businesses. In respect of charity shops, [name removed] explained that she too had seen a change in the town centres and although the issue of business rates was not something that she could address, the beneficial aspect of residents visiting town centres to visit such premises and the resultant time spent in the towns should outweigh any of concern with the change in provision.
(Councillor M Hayes, Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, and [name removed], agent, addressed the Committee on the application).
Housing, Planning and Economic Development Councillor R Fuller Strategic Resources Councillor J A Gray Partnerships and Well-Being Councillor J M Palmer Digital and Customers Councillor D M Tysoe Operations and Regulation Councillor M L Beuttell b) that Executive Councillors be appointed to serve as ex-officio Members of the following:
Councillor G J Bull presented details of the Cabinet Portfolios for the 2019/20 Municipal Year:- Councillor Ms M L Beuttell Operations and Regulation Councillor R Fuller Housing, Planning and Economic Development Councillor J A Gray Strategic Resources Councillor J M Palmer Partnerships and Well-being Councillor D M Tysoe Digital and Customers Councillor Bull further confirmed the appointments of Councillors D N Keane and J Neish as Cabinet Assistants.
RESOLVED (a) that Councillor J A Gray be appointed as a Shareholder Representative to act on behalf of the Council as Shareholder of the Council’s Local Authority Trading Company; and (b) that Councillors S J Corney , K I Prentice, T D Sanderson and D R Underwood be appointed to the HDC Ventures Shareholder Reference Group for the ensuing Municipal Year.
In his opening remarks, Councillor Gray paid tribute the Head of Resources and his Team that had worked hard on the detail of producing the final budget and the efforts involved since the start of proceedings in July 2018. He also thanks his fellow Cabinet colleagues for their support and assistance in their particular areas of expertise, as well as effective contributions from the Overview and Scrutiny Panel Members.
Members’ attention was drawn to the highlights of the budget for the forthcoming year, in particular Councillor Gray reported that the budget gap was now £1.2m by 2023/24 but General Fund reserves was maintained at the 15% minimum requirement. It was noted that the Commercial Investment Strategy was contributing to deliver material benefits and there had been an increase of 20% since its approval in 2015, which was largely attributed to the work of [name removed], Commercial Estates Manager.
Councillor Gray reported upon the additional income that was likely to be generated from car parking charges with the change in charging structure through additional dwell times in the car parks. Further savings would be generated from the cessation of highways weed spraying; a contract that had been passed onto us from Cambridgeshire County Council but had been costing the Council more than budget had been allocated by the County Council.
Councillor J M Morris outlined a series of questions directed towards Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Resources, on the sale of the Council’s housing stock in 2000, specifically whether the £8,504 cost per property was good value for money, any unspent capital remaining of the £65m and a list of the top five capital projects and amount spent per project.
Whereby Councillor Gray confirmed that the receipt per property was net of government levy and not the market value of the house but based on a prescribed formula to ensure the Registered Social Landlord could trade effectively, but confirmed that the value transferred to the Council represented a fair value. He confirmed that no capital receipts remained and the five main capital projects were Pathfinder House and Eastfield House with a combined cost of £24.3m, £15.5m towards social housing schemes, £5m on town centre improvements, £4.8m towards Disabled Facilities Grants and £3.2m on the set up costs of the garden waste wheeled bin scheme District wide. It was also confirmed that the capital receipts were wisely invested for the benefit of the residents of the District.
( At 9.37pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. )
( At 9.02pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting. ) ( At 9.04pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray entered the meeting. ) ( At 9.05pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillors G J Bull and J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. )
Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources, addressed the Council on the budget principles and framework, together with focus on the future challenges faced by the Council.
Councillor Gray drew Members’ attention to the preparations that had been undertaken for the draft budget and reminded all Members of their opportunity to attend the forthcoming Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth) to respond and provide input into the draft budget.
Whilst reflecting on the challenging year for Council services, Councillor Gray referred to criticisms of budgets previously holding a surplus and reported that future years’ budgets would be reviewed to bring into line current variances. The reported projected overspend of £600k had been attributed to an increase in costs for waste collection, lower than expected income across One Leisure and an increase in the cost of homeless accommodation, however had been offset by in year savings of additional income in Development and lower costs from elections, special responsibility allowances and lower capital financing costs.
Members noted the 2019/20 budget and funding proposals of financial self-sufficiency and Councillor Gray highlighted some of the principles to support this, including an increase in Council Tax and a reduction in the provisional settlement of the Council’s grant for next year by £600k making it the fourth highest negatively impacted Council in England.
Councillor Gray reported that the draft 2019/20 budget and Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) had planned to take into account the fair funding review, a new system of allocating funding to Councils that would likely see a reduction of funding away from the District, potentially resulting in budget cuts of over £3m per annum by the end of the MTFS. Having reported this, Members noted that the District could benefit by opportunities for strategic growth, including redevelopment of key sites across the Council area, with an aim of closing the current MTFS gap of £1.6m.
Councillor T D Sanderson reported that the Independent group would be submitting an alternative budget proposal to the meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth) in January 2019 and questioned whether the draft budget was realistic, whereby Councillor Gray reported that the targets being set were at an achievable yet realistic level, rather than a target to meet desired outcomes at the end of the MTFS.
In so doing, Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources, placed on record his gratitude the Head of Resources and his staff for ensuring that treasury management procedures had been adhered to ensure that borrowing and investment transactions had been in accordance with best practice.
In noting that there had been little change economically over the previous six months, Councillor Gray also appraised Members of details of the performance of Council funds and Commercial Investment Strategy. In so doing, it was RESOLVED that the Treasury Management Performance over the period April to September 2018 be noted.
( At 7.05pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray entered the meeting. )
Councillor J A Gray moved the recommendations and was duly seconded by Councillor J D Ablewhite.
Councillor Gray commented that budget was an essential part of the process and as the Scheme dated back over 10 years there had been considerable changes since then. He reflected that he felt the report was fair and balanced and thanked those Members that had addressed the Panel.
In light of the suggested increase to the Executive Leader and Deputy Executive Leader, Councillor Gray drew Members’ attention to the increased volume of work with the Combined Authority and the suggested increases and decreases in Members’ Allowances was not inconsistent with practices elsewhere.
Councillor T D Sanderson raised a question in relation to the Integrated Performance Report of Quarter One and the overspend in One Leisure against the level of income generated, whereby Councillor J A Gray explained that the report that was submitted to the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth) had provided the reasons.
In conjunction with a report by the Managing Director (a copy of which is appended in the Minute Book) Councillor J A Gray Executive Councillor for Resources presented a report on a proposed mechanism to be taken by the Council as shareholder of its Local Authority Trading Company, HDC Ventures Ltd and proposals for establishment of a Shareholder Reference Group.
With the day-to-day operation of the company being the responsibility of the Directors and the Council was the sole Shareholder, Councillor Gray explained that it was necessary for the Council to determine a way of engaging with the Directors of the Board of the Trading Company.
Whereupon, it was RESOLVED (a) that Councillor J A Gray be appointed as Shareholder Representative to act on behalf of the Council as Shareholder of the Council’s Local Authority Trading Company;
In response, Councillor Gray reported that there were currently three serving Directors and former Councillor D Brown had submitted his resignation from the Board.
Councillor Chapman further questioned point 2 in the terms of reference and whether the action would be taken without the approval of the Shareholder Reference Group, whereby Councillor Gray explained that the Shareholder Representative would not be taking any action that had not been agreed by the Council in terms of its strategic direction.
Arising from a question from Councillor S Wakeford regarding the size of the Shareholder Reference Group, Councillor Gray explained that the size that had been determined was felt appropriate to the requirements currently but suggested that this could be re-visited in the future.
( At 8.05pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. )
Growth Councillor R Fuller Resources Councillor J A Gray Partnership and Well-Being Councillor J M Palmer Digital and Customer Councillor D M Tysoe Operations and Regulation Councillor J E White b) that Executive Councillors be appointed to serve as ex-officio Members of the following:
Councillor G J Bull presented details of the Cabinet Portfolios for the 2018/19 Municipal Year:- Councillor R Fuller Growth Councillor J A Gray Resources Councillor J M Palmer Partnership and Well-being Councillor D M Tysoe Digital and Customer Councillor J White Operations and Regulation In response to a question from Councillor B S Chapman, the Managing Director confirmed that former Councillor D Brown had not resigned as Director of HDC Ventures Ltd.
In response to a question by a Member, Councillor J A Gray, Executive Member for Strategic Resources, stated that he had received assurance from the Internal Audit and Risk Manager that he had sufficient resources to deliver an audit opinion. In addition, he expressed the view that the approach to audit should be to assist managers and promote best practice rather than to deliver enforcement. Audit should focus on areas where it was needed, which would be identified through the risk appetite statement.
(Councillor B Jewell, Great Staughton Parish Council, Councillor J Gray , Ward Member, [name removed], objector, and [name removed], applicant, addressed the Committee on the application).
In his opening remarks, Councillor Gray drew Members attention to the highlights of the budget for the forthcoming year, including proposals for an increase in Council Tax of 2% that was lower than state pension and wage increases and ultimately more affordable. Members also noted that the minimum level of general fund reserves was set to increase to £2.7m as a result of the grant settlement from Government, the Council’s policy to increase Council Tax and the savings, income and growth built into the 2018/19 budget and MTFS.
Councillor Gray reminded Members of the process of consideration of the draft budget, from informal Cabinet in December 2017 with Senior Officers through to consideration of the draft and final budget at Overview and Scrutiny and Cabinet. He reported that this was the seventh budget that he had delivered but had by far involved the most robust discussions and thanked all Members for their input.
Councillor Gray also appraised Members with the increase in capital investment specifically in Disabled Facilities Grants, with an increase from £300k in the current year to £800k in 2018/19 to ... view the full minutes text for item 58.
In response, Councillor Gray referred to his presentation and the CIS focus at looking at opportunities for investment in the High Street and would look to work with retailers in all of the market towns to take forward this vision.
(Councillor Mrs R Lloyd, Kimbolton and Stonely Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, [name removed], objector, and [name removed], agent, addressed the Committee on the application).
( At 8.27pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. ) ( At 8.44pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor Mrs B E Boddington left the meeting and did not return. ) ( At 8.44pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor Mrs D C Reynolds left the meeting. ) ( At 8.46pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor Mrs D C Reynolds returned to the meeting. )
In so doing, Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources, drew Members’ attention to the purpose of the Treasury Management to ensure that the Council had sufficient funding to meet its daily obligations, borrow when necessary to fund capital expenditure and ensure that any investment of surplus funds was balanced against risk.
Councillor Gray referred Members to Appendix E of the report and the Commercial Investment Strategy with associated purchases since approval of the Business Plan in December 2015.
It was anticipated that returns on yields of land and building investment were between 6% and 9% and Councillor Gray reported that this had been achieved and represented a significantly higher return than investments with financial institutions.
Councillor Gray explained that the Policy had been designed to address the management of very small parcels of land and Town and Parish Councils had been fully consulted as part of the disposal process, as well as the inclusion of ward members.
Councillor Gray provided an explanation of the how the disposal of small land parcels would be managed, whereby interests may be registered and the legal team would undertake the necessary work following the collation of a suitable batch of enquiries, rather than being dealt with in ad-hoc way, thereby minimising the resources involved.
Following a question from Councillor P Kadewere on the Post Office at threat of closure on the Oxmoor , together with issues surrounding the ability of the post master to sell certain goods within his store, in accordance with his lease and what assistance and support the Council could offer as landlord, Councillor J A Gray, Executive Member for Strategic Resources, explained that the premises had been leased from the Council as part of its commercial estate. There existed a dispute between the leasehold selling goods that the lease prevented him from selling, this was designed to support other shops in the area and prevent goods from being sold in direct competition.
Councillor Gray explained that discussions were on-going with the leaseholder to reach an amicable resolution on the matter.
The Executive Member for Strategic Resources, Councillor J A Gray, informed the Committee of the background to and purpose of the Policy. The Council currently devoted significant levels of resources to the disposal of small areas of land. The sale process was time consuming and complex.
(Councillor B Jewell, Great Staughton Parish Council, Councillor J Gray, Ward Member, [name removed], objector, and Mr m Mackay, applicant, addressed the Committee on the application).
( At 8.21pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. )
In response, Councillor J A Gray undertook to liaise with the Head of Resources to establish the feasibility for a reasonable extension of time working back from the meeting of the Council on 21st February 2018 where the budget would be approved.
( At 8.54pm, during the discussion of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. )
Commercial and Shared Services Councillor D Brown Transformation and Customers Councillor S Cawley Community Resilience and Regulatory Councillor Mrs A Dickinson Deputy Executive Leader and Housing and Planning Councillor R Fuller Strategic Resources Councillor J A Gray Devolution and Growth Councillor R B Howe Operations Councillor J E White
Councillor Bull presented details of the Cabinet Portfolios for the remainder of the 2017/18 Municipal Year:- Councillor D Brown Commercial and Shared Services Councillor S Cawley Transformation and Customers Councillor Mrs A Dickinson Community Resilience and Regulatory Councillor R Fuller Deputy Executive Leader and Housing and Planning Councillor J A Gray Strategic Resources Councillor R B Howe Devolution and Growth Councillor J White Operations
Commercial and Shared Services Councillor D Brown Deputy Leader and Development Management/Planning Enforcement Councillor G J Bull Transformation and Customers Councillor S Cawley Community Resilience and Wellbeing Councillor Mrs A Dickinson Housing and Regulatory Services Councillor R Fuller Strategic Resources Councillor J A Gray Growth Councillor R Harrison Operations Councillor J E White b) that the Executive Leader of the Council be appointed to serve as an ex-officio Member of the Employment Committee; and c) that Executive Councillors be appointed to serve as ex-officio Members of the following:
Councillor R B Howe presented details of the Cabinet Portfolios for the 2017/18 Municipal Year:- Councillor D Brown Commercial and Shared Services Councillor G J Bull Deputy Executive Leader Councillor S Cawley Transformation and Customers Councillor Mrs A Dickinson Community Resilience and Wellbeing Councillor R Fuller Housing and Regulatory Services Councillor J A Gray Strategic Resources Councillor R Harrison Growth Councillor J White Operations
In his opening remarks, Councillor Gray informed Members that he would be presenting the report at a higher level given the fact that it had previously been discussed at the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Customers) and the report had been made available to all Members prior to the Council meeting. Attention was drawn to Appendix 4 of the report that summarised the results of consultation with the business community that, although low, had been a higher response than the previous year.
Councillor Gray expressed his support to Members of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Customers) in consideration of the draft budget and their constructive input. He gave particular thanks to the Managing Director and her Team who had engaged in the process, together with consideration of challenges and direction from fellow Members of the Cabinet and to the Head of Resources, Finance Manager and Members of the Accountancy Team.
In drawing Members’ attention to the updated ‘Plan on a Page’ that outlined the Council’s vision and strategic priorities as part of the Corporate Plan, Councillor Gray explained that the Financial Strategy had been updated to reflect the reduction in the budget deficit that had been reported in the previous year as £3.6m in 2020/21 and had now been a predicted deficit of £1.33m in 2020/21 and £1.36m in 2021/22.
In reporting upon the huge accomplishments and significant progress made in achieving a budget surplus of £3m, Councillor Gray indicated that there were further savings to be realised as there was likely to be significant reductions in government grants; Revenue Support Grant and curtailment of the New Homes Bonus.
Commercialisation and Shared Services Councillor D Brown Housing and Regulatory Services Councillor R Fuller Operations Councillor J White Transformation and Customers Councillor S Cawley Community Resilience Councillor Ms A Dickinson Strategic Resources Councillor J A Gray Leisure and Health Councillor J M Palmer Growth Councillor R Harrison The Deputy Leader (Councillor G Bull) also has responsibility for Development Management and Planning Enforcement.
( At 9.30pm, during the discussion of this item, Councillor R B Howe left the meeting and did not return. ) ( At 9.31pm, during the discussion of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. )
Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources, addressed the Council on the budget principles and framework, together with focus on the future challenges faced by the Council. Attention was drawn to the timetable for the forthcoming budget setting process and Members noted that the Council was awaiting the draft settlement from the Department for Communities and Local Government.
Councillor Gray reminded Members of the achievements to date with the ZBB process that had resulted in an excess of £5m savings, service transformation, LEAN reviews and development of shared services. It was reported previously that the Council had submitted a four year strategic efficiency plan to the Secretary of State which was designed to allow for further savings and benefits for the local community.
Councillor Gray reported that the Council had been successful and received confirmation of the Multi Year Settlement Offer in November 2016.
Alongside income generation, Councillor Gray focussed on the efficiencies that had already been identified through ZBB, continuation of shared services, commercialisation through partnership with external organisations and transformation of services.
In concluding his presentation, Councillor Gray focussed upon the future and identified risks with the transformation programme of increasing the retention of business rates from 50% to 100% by 2020/21, a requirement to financially review proposals and policies going forward in light of Devolution and budget pressures in the last two years of the Medium Term Financial Strategy arising from potential removal of the New Homes Bonus and policy to freeze Council Tax.
In referring to the figures presented on the ‘Plan on a Page’, Councillor M F Shellens questioned the accuracy, whereby Councillor Gray explained that they would be updated post February 2017 following approval of the budget and additional years added. He referred to the uncertainty over the New Homes Bonus allocation but indicated his confidence in achieving the income through the commercial investments that could be further invested.
In response to a question from Councillor D B Dew on the potential for growth in business rates, Councillor Gray acquainted Members with the current formula and proposals for 2020/21, although it was still uncertain as to what responsibilities would transfer and the extent of the growth in the District.
Arising from a question from Councillor P D Reeve on the availability of the budgetary information for all Members, Councillor Gray explained that information would be available after publication of the Agenda for Overview and Scrutiny (Performance and Customers) on 3rd January 2017.
In so doing, Councillor J A Gray drew Members’ attention to the purpose of the Treasury Management to ensure that the Council had sufficient funding to meet its daily obligations, borrow when necessary to fund capital expenditure and ensuring that any investment of surplus funds was balanced against risk.
In reminding Members that following the approval of the Commercial Investment Strategy in December 2015 the Council’s strategy had been to generate additional income to assist in closing the Council’s forecast gap in the revenue budget, Councillor Gray drew attention to the estimated expenditure of £20m in 2016/17 and current forecast of £9.2m that had been on track.
Members also noted details of the asset investments and yields and in so doing Councillor Gray advised that guidance had been received to broaden the investments outside of the District and an Interim Commercial Estates Manager had been appointed to assist in the management of the investments.
Councillor Gray responded to questions raised by Councillor M F Shellens and explained that the asset investments and yields had not included loan investments made to Luminus , Huntingdon Gym and Huntingdon Regional College as it was only necessary to report upon Commercial Investment Strategy assets invested by the Council.
Councillor Gray further explained that inflation would be updated and adjustment made in light of any increase to interest rates and explained that even though the asset yields had been higher than the interest rate, it was not possible to borrow to invest in cash investments only to borrow to invest in physical assets.
In response to a question from Councillor Mrs R E Mathews on the ‘bail-in’ powers should a bank become insolvent and how the Council would mitigate against this risk, Councillor Gray explained that all finance that had been invested by the Council had been through instant access and should this problem arise it would be possible to remove the funds.
The Executive Leader, Councillor R B Howe reported upon variations to the Cabinet that he deemed necessary in the light of changes to his role and additional workload with the onset of Devolution and confirmed his appointment of Councillor G J Bull in replacement of Councillor Gray as his Deputy Leader.
Councillor Howe also confirmed the allocation of executive responsibilities as follows – Community Resilience Councillor Mrs A Dickinson Leisure and Health Councillor J M Palmer Operations Councillor J White Growth Councillor R Harrison Commercialisation and Shared Services Councillor D Brown Strategic Resources Councillor J A Gray Transformation and Customers Councillor S Cawley Housing and Regulatory Services Councillor R Fuller Councillor Howe expressed his appreciation to Councillors R C Carter, S J Criswell and D M Tysoe for their Executive Councillor roles that they had fulfilled since their appointment in May 2016.
( At 7.39pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray entered the meeting. )
( At 9.46pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor J A Gray left the meeting and did not return. )
Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources, addressed the Council on an update of the capital programme and investment. In so doing, Members were advised of the potential to achieve greater certainty and confidence by way of a four year budget settlement. It was reported that the Council had submitted a four year strategic efficiency plan to the Secretary of State which was designed to allow for further savings and benefits for the local community.
Councillor Gray updated Members on commercial investments since approval of the Commercial Investment Strategy Business Plan in December 2015 and acquisition of assets totalling £12.5m with a net yield of 7%. Reference was also made to proposals for introducing a Differential Charging Policy to enable further income generation.
In concluding, Councillor Gray referred to the forthcoming decision to be taken on the Devolution deal and the plan to continue to provide improved services to the Council’s customers through the most effective and efficient means.
In response to a question from Councillor M F Shellens on car parking charges, business rates and inclusion of inflation on the four year plan, Councillor Gray explained that the increase in car parking charges had been placed in the approved budget but reliance on business rates had been removed with greater emphasis being placed upon becoming more independent from government grants and clarity needed to be sought on whether the four year plan would be updated to reflect inflation.
In thanking the Chairman and Members of the Corporate Governance Committee for their work Councillor J A Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources, reiterated the sentiments of Councillor Francis and stressed the importance of their role in ensuring that the Council was acting both fairly and appropriately in the way that it conducted its business. Whereupon, it was RESOLVED that the Annual Report 2015/16 of the Corporate Governance Committee be received and noted.
On behalf of the Conservative Party and the Cabinet, the Deputy Leader, Councillor J A Gray, commended Councillor Reynolds tribute to [name removed] with his remarkable and varied life and the huge loss to his family and the Conservative Party.
At 7.07pm, Cllr Gray, Executive Councillor for Strategic Resources entered the meeting.
Regarding application no.38 as Cllr J Gray knew the Chief Executive of the applicant - START (Survivors & Abuse Recovery) - he withdrew from determining the award.
In conjunction with the Council, Councillor R Howe moved the recommendations and was duly seconded by Councillor J A Gray. Whereupon, the Cabinet RESOLVED i ) that the conclusions and the outcome of the Governance Review be endorsed (attached at Appendix A of the Officer’s report) that the establishment of a Combined Authority with a Mayor for the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough area would be likely to improve the exercise of statutory functions in that area;
In moving the following motion, Councillor J A Gray informed Members of his deep concerns of the recent incidents in the District and wished to draw these urgently to the attention if the Council and request the Executive Leader of the Council, Councillor R Howe, to write to our local partners such as the Police and Crime Commissioner advising them of this motion and enlisting their support in tackling racism and hate crime – “We are proud to live in a diverse and tolerant society. Racism, xenophobia and hate crimes have no place in our country. We Huntingdonshire District Council condemn racism, xenophobia and hate crimes unequivocally.
Councillors P D Reeve, P L E Bucknell and P Kadewere confirmed their support for the motion and Councillor M F Shellens proposed the insertion of the word “unanimously” after the words “Huntingdonshire District Council” in the second paragraph which was accepted by Councillor Gray.
Councillor Gray requested Members to indicate their support for the motion by standing, rather than a show of hands.
(Councillor J A Gray was in attendance for the interviews for the post of Corporate Director (Services)).
Strategic Partnerships and Shared Services Councillor D Brown Planning Policy, Housing and Infrastructure Councillor G J Bull Environment, Street Scene and Operations Councillor R C Carter Organisation and Customer Services Councillor S Cawley Community Resilience Councillor S Criswell Strategic Resources Councillor J A Gray Business, Enterprise and Skills Councillor R Harrison Leisure and Health Councillor J M Palmer Operational Resources Councillor D M Tysoe b) that the Executive Leader of the Council be appointed to serve as an ex-officio Member of the Employment Committee; and c) that Executive Councillors be appointed to serve as ex-officio Members of the following:
It was proposed by Councillor J A Gray, seconded by Councillor S Cawley and RESOLVED that Councillor R B Howe be elected Executive Leader of the Council for the period to the Annual Meeting in May 2018.
He also announced the Councillor J A Gray would be the Deputy Executive Leader and Vice-Chairman of the Cabinet.
Councillor R B Howe presented details of the Cabinet Portfolios for the 2016/17 Municipal Year:- Councillor D Brown Strategic Partnerships and Shared Services Councillor G J Bull Planning Policy, Housing and Infrastructure Councillor R C Carter Environment, Street Scene and Operations Councillor S Cawley Organisation and Customer Services Councillor S Criswell Community Resilience Councillor J A Gray Strategic Resources Councillor R Harrison Business, Enterprise and Skills Councillor J M Palmer Leisure and Health Councillor D M Tysoe Operational Resources.
At 7.08pm Councillor J Gray entered the meeting.
At 9.13pm Councillor J Gray returned to the meeting.
By way of reflection, Councillor J A Gray reminded Members that Council Tax had risen by 7.25% over the past six years and over the same period pensions had risen by 18.76% and average weekly wages had risen by 10.9%. Thereby illustrating that the Council had succeeded in keeping increases in line with working residents and pensioners.
Councillor Gray outlined the budget setting process that had been undertaken this year, including a robust Zero Based Budgeting (ZBB) exercise for all services, with £1.9m previously identified for removal from the 2015/16 budget and a further £4m of identified savings by the end of the MTFS.
In referring to the monthly budget ‘dashboard’ that had been received by Members, Councillor Gray reported that all services has been achieving their targets, whilst being prudent in the delivery of their services and expressed his appreciation to his fellow Cabinet Members and Officers for the end result.
Councillor Gray updated the Council on the MTFS Capital Programme and Commercial Investment Strategy (CIS), including the borrowing strategy to facilitate the capital programme and CIS. In summarising the funding statement, Members were advised of the key assumptions including the commitment to freeze Council Tax for 2016/17 and removal of the Revenue Support Grant as core funding by 2020/21.
Showing the latest 300 of 604.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Gray attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Feb 2023 | Council | Retirement of managing director | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Sep 2021 | Council | Chairman's engagements and announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Dec 2015 | Council | Consideration of moving to all-out elections | Carried | 39 for, 2 against | |
| 14 Nov 2012 | Council | Freedom of the district | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Feb 2012 | Council | MINUTES | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jan 2012 | Cabinet | Community Infrastructure Levy Draft Charging Schedule submission document | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Jul 2005 | Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Planning and Finance): 2002-06 - transferred to Service Support | Review of member development | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Gray was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 11 of 20 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Gray declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Gray in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Gray sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Member | Jun 2004 | 164 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Corporate Governance Committee | Vice-Chair | Dec 2016 | 35 | |
| Committees | Member | May 2015 | 11 | |
| Development Management Committee | Member | May 2026 | 2 | 14 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Member | Jul 2007 | 152 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Service Support): 2006-09 - transferred to Environmental Well-Being | Chair | May 2006 | 36 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Growth) | Member | Jun 2018 | 28 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Planning and Finance): 2002-06 - transferred to Service Support | Member | Jun 2004 | 22 | |
| Corporate Governance Panel | Member | May 2006 | 22 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Corporate and Strategic Framework): 2006-09 - transferred to Economic Well Being | Member | Jun 2006 | 18 | |
| Employment Panel | Member | Oct 2011 | 18 | |
| Grants Panel | Member | Jul 2015 | 13 | |
| Development Control Panel: changed to Development Management Panel - May 2009 | Member | Feb 2005 | 11 | |
| Joint Overview and Scrutiny Panel | Member | Jan 2005 | 7 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Performance and Customers) | Guest | Dec 2016 | 7 | |
| Development Management Panel (Decommissioned 18/05/2016) | Member | May 2009 | 4 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Environmental Well-Being) | Member | Jun 2009 | 4 | |
| Senior Officers Committee | Member | Jun 2016 | 3 | |
| Senior Officers Panel | Member | May 2014 | 1 | |
| Corporate Governance Committee & Section 151 Officer | Member | Dec 2015 | 1 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Communities and Environment) | Member | Jun 2016 | 1 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Economy and Growth) | Guest | Dec 2016 | 1 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Panel (Customers and Partnerships) | Guest | Feb 2019 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.