Minutes of Cabinet
The Cabinet was informed of an update to the minutes as presented, to include the name of Councillor Judith Addison in the section marked ‘In attendance’ on the covering page.
Every time Hyndburn's minutes name Councillor Addison, as the council published it.
The Cabinet was informed of an update to the minutes as presented, to include the name of Councillor Judith Addison in the section marked ‘In attendance’ on the covering page.
In response to a question by Councillor Judith Addison, it was reported that Tom Birtwistle, Environmental Health Manager - Housing Standards, was the relevant officer for queries in relation to the maintenance of empty properties.
In response to a question by Councillor Judith Addison, it was noted that the Homeless in Hyndburn Group continued to meet on a quarterly basis.
Councillor Judith Addison enquired about how often the Green Flag awards were reviewed. This was every 3 years. Hyndburn had the most Green Flag awards of any Lancashire Borough.
Councillor Addison queried whether the Council usually sold land assets at auction and whether this limited the Council’s level of influence as to future use of the sites. The Leader indicated that the Council’s Property Team provided advice about the most appropriate method of disposal of land assets, of which sale at auction was one option. The reports later on the agenda recommended various methods of disposal on a case by case basis.
Councillor Addison noted that expenditure on the LGR Programme Director had already been pre-authorised under the Assurance Framework. She asked who this officer was. David Welsby, Chief Executive, indicated that Lancashire County Council had now appointed an LGR Programme Director (Peter Lloyd).
Councillor Judith Addison cited the Nutall Street Mill site, which had been granted planning permission for 100 homes, but which had never been built. The market would only support low-cost homes and many developers could not, therefore, afford to build in the Borough. However, she noted that there had been some successes, with Home & Bargain building premises on the decontaminated Rhyddings Mill site.
With consent of the committee, item 3 was taken first on the agenda Councillor Judith Addison was nominated and voted in by majority vote to be Vice Chair of the Planning Committee 2026/27.
Councillor Judith Addison made the point that s106 funding was highly regulated and that developers could challenge the Council via arbitration if they believed that the amounts set were excessive. In Hyndburn’s case, the imposition of s106 burdens could make certain projects unviable. The Leader referred members to Paragraph 4.9.11 of the Revenue Budget Outturn Report (Minute 42 above refers ) for an explanation of the use of s106 funding.
Councillor Addison commented that heritage advice was sometimes provided by Growth Lancashire Limited (GLL) at this Council’s Planning Committee meetings. Jane Ellis, Executive Director (Legal and Democratic Services) confirmed that this would have been carried out under a contract for heritage advice.
Councillor Addison commented that the Methodist Chapel in the vicinity was now closed and that the building might be available for use in connection with the Brookside Initiative. [name removed] indicated that the building had been used previously for some small community gatherings and this had been useful. However, the chapel now had significant structural issues and the building was generally in a poor state of repair.
Councillor Judith Addison noted that it would not be good practice to open up meetings to live questioning by the public, as it was likely that the technical officers who would have the specialist knowledge to repsond were unlikely to be present at the meeting. Resolved (1) That Council notes that training will be arranged for all members of the Planning, Licensing and Taxi Licensing Committees in respect of their respective code of practice as soon as possible in the new municipal year and requires all members of those Committees to attend training prior to serving on the relevant Committee in the new municipal year. (2) The Council agrees to review and update the Member Officer Relations Protocol and requests that a further report be presented to Council as soon as possible in respect of the same, following consultation with the Leaders Policy Development Board in respect of the updated protocol.
Councillor Judith Addison sought clarification about how elected members should comment on the proposed Main Modifications and whether this should be by direct e-mail or as part of the public consultation process. She also spoke about the modification proposed in connection with land at Hopwood Street. The land had originally been included in the Derelict Land Programme, but had subsequently been allocated for housing in the 1996 Local Plan.
Councillor Judith Addison remarked that the list of special responsibility allowances still included an amount for Chair of Area Council, a role which no longer existed. She suggested that this allowance should be removed at the next available opportunity to update the scheme. Resolved - That the Council: (1) Having considered the views of its independent remuneration panel as set out in paragraph 4 of the report, agrees to amend the members allowances scheme to remove the special responsibility allowance payable to each political group whip and group secretary, with effect from 1 st April 2026.
He explained that specific legislation was required for the sale of public assets and indicated that he would provide a full response to Councillor Addison. Resolved - That the reports and the Council’s financial position be noted.
Councillor Addison referred to the importance of records being kept up to date.
Councillor Addison expressed concern about the increasing number of people who did not think they should apply for planning permission and consequently, more were breaching regulations.
Councillor Addison acted as substitute representative for Councillor Heap.
Councillor Judith Addison outlined the size of the population typically represented by ward councillors in unitary authorities and expressed concern about the ability of elected members to manage that workload.
Councillor Judith Addison raised a point of order in connection with the controlling group’s intention to provide written responses, in the light of Council Procedure Rule 2.2 ( vi ), which stated, inter alia , the following: “Questions will be put by the chair of the meeting and will be taken in the order in which they are received by the Chief Executive and will receive an oral answer.
Councillor Judith Addison enquired if the changes would result in redundancies at CVMU .
Councillors Zak Khan and Steven Smithson spoke in support of the retention of Council email access on personal devices and Councillor Addison spoke about the flexibility of having a single device for both Council and personal use. Councillors Noordad Aziz, Vanessa Alexander and Kimberley Whitehead spoke about cyber security, which was the rationale for the rolling out of Council provided devices. All acknowledged that this might lead to councillors carrying more than one portable device at a time, but this was necessary to strengthen security.
Councillor Judith Addison added that speculators often took advantage of the cheaper property prices in the region to establish HMOs and children’s care homes.
Councillor Heather Anderson, Councillor Dave Parkins and Councillor Judith Addison acted as substitutions for the above.
Councillor Addison spoke against the automatic delegation of prior notification and prior approval. In particular, she was concerned that members of the Planning Committee should have the ability to have their say on issues such as 5G masts, even though the Government had provided greater powers to telecommunications companies. By way of example, the 5G mast proposals on Harvey Street, Oswaldtwistle, had given rise to a number of concerns from residents.
Councillor Judith Addison spoke in favour of retaining the public’s right to ask a question. She expressed some concern about how a system of ward councillors submitting questions on behalf of residents would work in practice. Issues might include public not knowing who their ward councillor was, lack of availability of the councillor(s) concerned, councillors not willing to forward questions to the Chief Executive and negative responses if not forwarding questions on.
Councillor Addison noted that the Planning Code of Good Practice made reference to the role of Chief Planning and Transportation Officer, but that other documents referred to the post as Head of Planning. Jane Ellis, Executive Director (Legal and Democratic Services), undertook to check which was the correct term, for consistency.
Councillor Addison acted as substitute representative for Councillor Walker.
Councillor Addison referred to onerous lease terms and conditions on many public buildings, putting off many organisations from using the buildings and asked if this was an issue being considered.
Councillor Judith Addison acted as substitute representative for Councillor Tina Walker.
Councillor Addison asked if the pitches would be fenced, this would only be whilst works completed as they are open for public use.
Finally, he thanked Councillor Judith Addison for supporting him and his Mayoress , Melanie Storey, during his mayoral year.
The Chair thanked Councillor Judith Addison for all her hard work last year as the Chair.
Councillor Judith Addison queried whether the allocation of seats on the various overview and scrutiny committees (5:2:0:0) represented best practice, given their role in scrutinising the Cabinet. The Chief Executive clarified that the allocation of seats was a function of the political balance calculation and proportionality rules.
Councillor Addison asked whether the date of the Mayor Making Council meeting on 29 th June 2024 had been reviewed in the light of the General Election on 4 th July 2024. The Chief Executive responded that this had been considered. The date of the General Election did not impact directly on Council meetings and the planning and organisation of the Mayor Making event would need to commence in early June.
The Chair, Councillor Judith Addison informed the committee that she lived on Catlow Hall Street, Oswaldtwistle however was not a Councillor for that ward and her property is not near the applications listed.
Councillor Judith Addison declared a personal interest in Motion 2 (Civic Theatre) at Agenda Item 10 – Motions submitted on Notice, as an independent trustee on the Board of Hyndburn Arts Limited, which had managed Oswaldtwistle Civic Arts Centre and Theatre before its closure.
It was also reported that at the same Council meeting, Councillor Judith Addison had been appointed to this Committee in place of Councillor Josh Allen.
Members considered a request submitted by the Leader of the Conservative Group on behalf of the group, to give effect to a change to the membership of the Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee, to replace Councillor Josh Allen with Councillor Judith Addison.
Resolved - That a change to the membership of the Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee, to replace Councillor Josh Allen with Councillor Judith Addison, be approved with immediate effect.
Councillor Judith Addison supported any commitment to invest in the townships and remarked that less than 50% of the Borough’s residents ... view the full minutes text for item 195.
Councillor Addison acted as substitute representative for Councillor Cassidy.
Councillor Judith Addison suggested that Councillors may benefit from training on how to use this system when it is fully restored. Simon agreed to arrange this.
Councillor Judith Addison substituted.
The Leader of the Council clarified that Councillor Judith Addison would remain the Deputy Armed Forces Champion.
Councillor Judith Addison declared a personal interest in item 3 – Town and Country Planning Act 1990 – Tree Preservation Order, relating to 31 Alice Street, Oswaldtwistle due to her knowing the applicant and revealing that she would be unlikely to provide an unbiased decision.
Councillor Addison took no further part in the discussion or determination of the item, although remained in the room.
Councillor Judith Addison asked if there was a contingency should costs increase. Steve responded that approximately 30% was allowed for in the bid. The current piece of work being carried out by the Project Director should give a more firm indication of expected costs.
Councillor Judith Addison substituted for Councillor Dominik Allen.
Councillor Judith Addison asked about a cultural strategy for Hyndburn Leisure. Lyndsey responded that culture and heritage will have a section in Hyndburn Leisure’s overall strategy, and the Council has committed to a borough wide culture strategy which Hyndburn Leisure will support.
Councillor Judith Addison said that the published expenditure over £250 can often be difficult for the public to understand and asked if it could be published in a more meaningful way. Martin Dyson responded. He said that the information we publish is compliant with the transparency code.
Councillor Judith Addison asked how we account for section 106s monies. Martin Dyson explained that this was not part of the transparency code. The Leader of the Council said this information can be requested from the Chief Planning Officer.
Councillor Addison reminded Members that only those councillors who had participated in the discussions at the last meeting regarding application 11/21/0644 - Land at Maple Crescent, Rishton , could take part in the debate and vote upon Item 3B on today’s Agenda.
Councillor Judith Addison substituted for Cllr Allen.
Councillor Judith Addison declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 9, Minute 71 – Hyndburn Arts Strategy, in view of her role as a Trustee of Hyndburn Arts Limited.
· Cllr Addison overall impression of the site was good, just concerns over no regulatory body checks on the facility.
The proposed membership was as follows:- Cabinet Committee (Scrap Metal Dealers Act 2013) Councillor Loraine Cox (Chair) Councillors Paul Cox and Miles Parkinson OBE Cabinet Committee (Street Naming) Councillor Loraine Cox (Chair) Councillors Munsif Dad and Miles Parkinson OBE Councillor Judith Addison (attending) Cabinet Committee (Digital Economy) Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP(Chair) Councillors Joyce Plummer and Paul Cox Covenant Commemoration Working Group Councillor Miles Parkinson OBE (Chair) ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
There was no substitute representative for Councillor Addison.
A Point of Order was raised by Councillor Judith Addison, regarding to the operation of Rule A23.3 of the Council Procedure Rules, in relation to the appointment of the Mayoress and Consort. The matter was to be addressed later in the meeting.
The declaration of the Returning Officer of those elected at the local elections held on 2 nd May 2019 was submitted as follows:- Electoral Ward Name and Address of Elected Councillor Party Altham Councillor Miles Parkinson 13 Calf Hey, Lynwood Park Clayton Le Moors, BB5 5XW Labour Barnfield Councillor June Harrison Owl House, Plantation Road Accrington, BB5 6RU Labour Baxenden Councillor K Pratt Mayroyd , 120 Hollins Lane Accrington, BB5 2JS Conservative Central Councillor Mohammad Ayub 68 Willows Lane Accrington, BB5 0RT Labour Church Councillor Loraine Cox 27 Pansy Street South Accrington, BB5 4BS Labour Clayton-le-Moors Councillor Melissa Fisher 33 Collingwood Clayton-le-Moors, BB5 5QP Labour Huncoat Councillor Eamonn Higgins 232 Avenue Parade Accrington, BB5 6QW Labour Immanuel Councillor Judith Addison 77 Catlow Hall Street Oswaldtwistle, BB5 3EZ Conservative Milnshaw Councillor Paul Cox 27 Pansy Street South Accrington, BB5 4BS Labour Overton Councillor Patrick McGinley 24 Whalley Road Great Harwood, BB6 7TF Conservative Rishton Councillor Kate Walsh 21 Cattle Street Great Harwood, BB6 7NG Labour St Oswald’s Councillor Chris Knight Mill Hill Cottage, 60 Mill Hill Oswaldtwistle, BB5 3LX.
The Leader of the Council - The Leader congratulated Councillor Judith Addison as she would be receiving an award from the High Sheriff of Lancashire.
The following issues were raised from the Cabinet Meeting, 18 th July 2018 - Minute 81 & 82, Lease of Coach House building at Rhyddings Park in Oswaldtwistle - Councillor Judith Addison referred to the exclusion of the public and that those Councillors not at Cabinet should not be excluded from viewing the reports on mod.gov.
There was no substitute representative for Councillor Addison.
The following motion was moved by Councillor Judith Addison and seconded by Councillor Peter Britcliffe under Council Procedure Rule A9:- “That this Council investigates the work of To Inspire (formerly Chaigley Manor Trust) and the reasons for them being over three years late presenting their accounts to the Charity Commission. The Charity exists to benefit young people up to the age of 25, particularly those who are resident in the Borough of Hyndburn.” After a debate, the motion was put to the vote and declared carried.
The Call-In was sponsored by Councillor Judith Addison.
Councillor Judith Addison (Sponsor) was in attendance at the meeting and the undermentioned reason was given for the call-in:- “The controversy about the sequoia tree has arisen because Ward Councillors and local residents were never consulted about the Stage 2 Bid, despite statements to the contrary in the Customer First Analysis dated 20 th May 2016. It was only at Stage 2 that the relocation of the Market Cross and consequent felling of the sequoia tree were introduced – they did not feature in the Stage 1 Bid or in the planning consent for the refurbishment and improvement of the Park – Planning Application No. 11/14/0359”.
It was then proposed by Councillor Peter Britcliffe and seconded by Councillor Judith Addison, “That it be recommended to Cabinet that the sequoia tree should not be removed and is retained as part of the refurbishment.” A named vote was requested in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 16.5 and the vote was as follows:- For:
The following motion was moved by Councillor Judith Addison and seconded by Councillor Peter Britcliffe under Council Procedure Rule A9:- "This Council deplores the proposal by Lancashire County Council to close three out of five Hyndburn Libraries in the townships of Clayton-le-Moors, Oswaldtwistle and Rishton. Libraries are not merely lenders of books but serve as a community focus for a range of resident activities covering all age groups.
The following motion was moved by Councillor Peter Britcliffe and seconded by Councillor Judith Addison under Council Procedure Rule A9:- "Oswaldtwistle residents oppose the proposed closure of their local library by Lancashire County Council on cost grounds. Last October the town was proud to commemorate the Centenary of its Carnegie Library, which not only lends out books but welcomes people of all ages to a range of free learning activities in a warm and friendly environment. If the County Council can no longer fund our Library we ask Hyndburn Borough Council to support our proposal for a resident group to take over the building and operate it as a Community Library so that this much-valued local facility is not lost." At the meeting, the mover of the motion proposed the deletion of the words “by Lancashire County Council on cost grounds”.
Councillor Judith Addison declared a personal interest in planning application, 11/15/ 0297, former Social Club and land at James Street, Oswaldtwistle , as she was a governor at St Andrew’s Primary School which was located near the site of the planning application.
Councillor Judith Addison (retired member) Member of National Union of Teachers: Councillor Peter Britcliffe Former Fire Brigades Union Official:
Council was asked to formally approve Councillor Judith Addison to be the Council’s Armed Forces Champion, to replace Doug Hayes, who was no longer able to fulfil this role as he was moving abroad. members showed their appreciation of his work over the years to support the armed forces community and best wishes were conveyed to him and [name removed] for their future.
Resolved - That Councillor Judith Addison be appointed as the Council’s Armed Forces Champion, to replace [name removed].
The following motion was moved by Councillor Julie Livesey and seconded by Councillor Judith Addison under Council Procedure Rule A9 :- 1. That this Council regrets that as from July, the 14A bus will not serve Green Haworth in Oswaldtwistle .
Councillor Judith Addison attended the meeting as substitute representative for Councillor Marlene Haworth.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Addison attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Addison's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Addison was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 4 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Addison declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11 Jan 2024 | Council, item 260 | Councillor Judith Addison declared a personal interest in Motion 2 (Civic Theatre) at Agenda Item 10 – Motions submitted on Notice, as an independent trustee on the Board of Hyndburn Arts Limited, which had managed Oswaldtwistle Civic Arts Centre and Theatre before its closure. | |
| 19 Apr 2023 | Planning (Trees) Sub-Committee, item 378 | Councillor Judith Addison declared a personal interest in item 3 – Town and Country Planning Act 1990 – Tree Preservation Order, relating to 31 Alice Street, Oswaldtwistle due to her knowing the applicant and revealing that she would be unlikely to provide an unbiased decision. | |
| 23 Sep 2021 | Council, item 133 | Councillor Judith Addison declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 9, Minute 71 – Hyndburn Arts Strategy, in view of her role as a Trustee of Hyndburn Arts Limited. | |
| 16 Dec 2015 | Planning Committee, item 336 | Councillor Judith Addison declared a personal interest in planning application, 11/15/ 0297, former Social Club and land at James Street, Oswaldtwistle , as she was a governor at St Andrew’s Primary School which was located near the site of the planning application. |
Where Councillor Addison sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Vice Chair | Jul 2024 | 3 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2024 | 2 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Standards Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 | 14 Jan 2027 |
| Mayor-Making, Council | Committee Member | May 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.