Minutes of Cabinet
Councillor Khan indicated that he had not yet received the list of s106 funded projects which had been promised during the discussions recorded at Minute 43 – Capital Programme Outturn 2025/26.
Every time Hyndburn's minutes name Councillor Khan, as the council published it.
Councillor Khan indicated that he had not yet received the list of s106 funded projects which had been promised during the discussions recorded at Minute 43 – Capital Programme Outturn 2025/26.
Councillor Khan made a number of comments, as summarised below, and any responses were also recorded: Officers were thanked for their work around recycling rates. Investment under the Cabinet Action Fund was welcomed and it was pleasing to note that most applications had been accepted and that coverage was borough-wide.
Councillor Khan queried whether the amounts were evenly balanced across each ward and noted that no successful bid had yet been made in Baxenden – Response: Today’s report was intended to raise the profile of the Fund, which was available for all wards. The update served as a reminder for any areas that might feel they were missing out, to submit an application. Accompanying bank account details and evidence of a constitution were needed with any applications.
Progress on the Dome bid was welcomed, but Councillor Khan queried whether sufficient resource was available to get the bid ‘over the line’ and if there was an alternative plan if the bid was not successful. – Response: The Council was committed to the proposed approach and remained optimistic, so had not considered a ‘Plan B’ in depth. However, there would be alternative avenues to explore if the National Lottery Heritage Fund bid was unsuccessful.
The Council’s response to the issues at Rhyddings Mill was welcomed, but Councillor Khan expressed disappointment that this had come after the fire incident, rather than before.
Councillor Khan welcomed the use of experienced partner organisations on the delivery of key interventions. He noted that the new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham MP, hade made ending rough sleeping in the country a top policy pledge. The Government had previously announced a £3.5 billion programme nationally to end homelessness and rough sleeping.
Councillor Khan commented that he had initially been critical of the decision to for the Council to bring operation of the Market Hall back in-house, but he was now pleased to see that the various challenges had been met and this did appear to be the right approach. He noted that the whole team had an abundance of energy and that the recent videos had brought the project to life. The Leader summed up, noting that the project was going in the right direction and that progress would continue to be made.
Councillor Khan sought details of what schemes would be funded by s.106 funding in 2026/27. He understood that £45k of s.106 funding had been returned to the developers in respect of Foxwood Chase, as the deadline for its use had expired. He asked if any other s106 monies were at risk of being timed out.
Councillor Khan also noted the proposals in relation to Bullough Park and Market Chambers and asked whether it was proposed regularly to bring other schemes forward for funding from revenue reserves. The Leader responded that the situation would be kept under review. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision.
Councillor Khan queried the following and responses were provided as indicated: The disposal of assets, income from which supported the Capital Programme, often took time to complete. Had suitable assets for disposal had yet been identified? - Response: Two reports identifying assets for disposal were included later on the agenda. Could Opposition members contribute to the Cabinet Working Group, if considering further schemes for inclusion in the Capital Programme? – Response: The Working Group’s role was to monitor the agreed Capital Programme 2026/27, not to consider further additions to it.
Councillor Khan noted that Hyndburn Leisure was talking to other East Lancashire leisure providers about Local Government Reorganisation. He asked if the proposed subsidy was realistic under the circumstances. He also noted that the Cath Thom Leisure Centre had performed well since its opening and queried whether any lessons learned could be applied to other leisure premises.
Councillor Khan commented on the principle of existing councils funding the proposed changes and asked if Hyndburn could refuse to pay. The Leader responded that every other local authority subject to reorganisation was making a contribution and that in Hyndburn’s case the funding had already been identified from within reserves. The new ways of working within a unitary council would serve residents better.
Councillor Khan proposed the following changes to the work programme : - Two updates on the Market Hall should take place during the municipal year; November 2026 (prior to the re-opening of the Market Hall) and March 2026 (to report on progress since its re-opening) - the deletion of the Local Plan item, due to the Local Plan having recently been adopted by the Council - to bring forward the item on the Dome, from November to October. - to add an item on the Neighbourhood Board – Pride in Place funding, to provide an update report. Resolved - That the work programme for 2026/27, for the Communities and Wellbeing Overview & Scrutiny Committee, be approved subject to the proposed changes detailed above.
Councillor Zak Khan acted as substitute representative for Councillor Walker.
Councillor Khan referred to the number of dog complaints and enquired how the Council could respond to ensure suitable deterrents were in place to prevent future incidents. He referred to the importance of encouraging people to report dog fouling and stray dogs so that the Council could focus their services on hot spot areas. He also proposed publicly identifying those who were prosecuted to use social pressure to encourage people to look after their dogs.
Councillor Zak Khan noted that investment was continuing into the theatre, but he had not yet heard if the Working Group was meeting.
Councillor Khan invited the Leader to confirm if he remained committed to cross-party working, given the new political balance across the Council.
In connection with Minute 6 – Confirmation of Minutes, Councillor Zak Khan expressed concern that under LGR, Hyndburn’s democratic representation might be diluted, particularly by larger urban areas such as Blackburn with Darwen and Burnley.
Councillor Khan welcomed the proposed changes and stated that the Conservative Group had been pressing for the changes for 12 months. However, he was pleased to note that cross-party agreement had been reached on the matter, that the public could read out their own questions and that the Council was open to transparency. Councillors Mohammed Younis, David Heap, Andy Gilbert, Shabir Fazal all spoke in favour of the proposals and made some wider comments about reasons for the changes.
Councillor Zak Khan spoke in favour of the Plan, particularly around proposals in Oswaldtwistle, Huncoat Garden Village, new employment land and the reduction in the percentage of affordable homes on brownfield site developments. However, he highlighted some concerns over the removal of the three Green Belt site designations.
Councillor Khan spoke in favour of maximising brownfield site opportunities. He also noted that this was an opportunity to provide the evidence base for and influence the new unitary authority. He supported the recommendations, but called for the Council to be more creative, such as considering sites at Vine Mill or the Arndale.
In respect of Minute 348 - Provision of Leisure Services with Hyndburn, Councillor Zak Khan indicated that he had asked Cabinet for details of what management improvements had been implemented. He had subsequently received a response and had met with representatives of Hyndburn Leisure. It would be important for the Trust to liaise with other leisure organisations in East Lancashire prior to LGR.
In connection with Minute 349 - Article 4 Direction on HMOs, Councillor Zak Khan considered that this stance a should be maintained. He commented that Highfield House was an HMO, but that there was a need for this type of facility. However, the hoped that the Council could be more proactive in learning about who was resident there.
Regarding Minute 359 – Town Centre Levelling Up Funded Projects, Councillor Zak Khan welcomed the improvements. He was also pleased to welcome the appointment of Paul Fox as Town Centre Venue Manager in the light of his entrepreneurial spirit.
Councillor Khan asked how this level of development would be extended to Market Chambers.
The Minutes of the following meetings were submitted: Meeting (Municipal Year 2025/26) Date Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee 23 rd February 2026 Communities and Wellbeing Overview and Scrutiny Committee 9 th March 2026 Special Scrutiny Committee 25 th March 2026 Planning Committee 15 th April 2026 Management Review Committee 23 rd April 2026 In respect of Minute 317 – Capital Programme, at Page 9 of the Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 23 rd February 2026, Councillor Zak Khan expressed disappointment that his specific comments and issues about Pride in Place projects had not been fully minuted .
Therefore, this Council resolves: (1) To write formally to the Hyndburn and Ribble Valley (HARV) Domestic Abuse Team to recognise and commend their outstanding work within our community; (2) To write to Lancashire Constabulary to request discussions on additional initiatives, partnership working and preventative measures that can be introduced locally to combat domestic violence and abuse; and (3) To write to NHS Lancashire and South Cumbria Integrated Care Board to explore how local health services can further support early intervention, safeguarding, mental health support, victim protection and multi-agency cooperation to strengthen community safety across Hyndburn and East Lancashire.” Councillor Zak Khan recalled his experience when in the Police dealing with domestic violence. He commented that this was one of the most harrowing areas of work, but noted that relevant agencies had come a long way in identifying and tackling it. The Conservative Group supported the motion.
Councillor Zak Khan supported this investment, but enquired whether it might be premature, given that wider regeneration plans for the town centre might include this area of land. The Leader responded that investment in, or demolition of the skate park was needed now, because if its state of repair. The site was well used, did not attract anti-social behaviour and was remote enough from residential properties so as not to attract any nuisance complaints.
Councillor Khan noted the scale of the changes and that these had been implemented well. He asked whether complaints would be closely monitored.
Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP – Leader of the Council ; Councillor Melissa Fisher – Deputy Leader of the Council (Designate) and Portfolio Holder for Housing and Regeneration; Councillor Vanessa Alexander – Deputy Leader of the Council and Portfolio Holder for Resources and Council Operations; Councillor Clare Pritchard – Portfolio Holder for Transformation and Town Centres; Councillor Jodi Clements - Portfolio Holder for Education and Skills; Councillor Paul Cox Eaves – Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services; and Councillor Kate Walsh – Portfolio Holder for Culture, Heritage and Arts; Councillor Dad announced that he had taken a further decision, as Leader of the Council, to amend the detailed portfolios in the schedule of responsibilities, as follows: Portfolio Title Amendment Approved Transformation and Town Centres Bullet 3 to read ‘Town Centres and Market Hall Project’ Culture, Heritage and Arts Insert new bullet 6 to read ‘Haworth Art Gallery’ Councillor Khan requested that Portfolio Holders be open to responding, in good faith, to issues raised by Opposition members. He expressed concern that there might have been instances previously when Portfolio Holders had not always responded to members of the public when matters had been raised with them. The Leader of the Council gave an assurance that if councillors wished to discuss any matter, they should simply ask the relevant Portfolio Holder directly and also let him know.
Councillor Khan commented that none of the four public suggestions had been taken up, which was disappointing given that residents had engaged in the consultation exercise. He also noted that suggestions regarding Digital Transformation/AI Usage and HMOs had been rejected, but that both topics could potentially have a significant impact on the Borough. He expressed the view that individual overview and scrutiny meetings could potentially deal with more items of business without being overburdened, particularly as some reviews, such as Skip Days, might only require a light touch.
Councillor Khan endorsed the Leader’s comments about strong financial management and thanked him for the continuing investment into the Brookside initiative. He noted that income from garage rental and allotments was not reinvested directly into the development of those services and asked if other funding, such as s106 monies, could support them. He also asked what the Council did to chase up non recoverable Housing Benefit claims.
Councillor Khan acknowledged the need to maintain progress on delivery. He also noted that s106 funding had accounted for £67,054 of the capital financing and asked whether this had been spent on projects within the locality of the original planning development.
Martin Dyson, Executive Director (Resources) undertook to provide information on s106 expenditure to Councillor Khan. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision. Reasons for Decision The Council had authorised new additions to the capital programme of £2.726m at its meeting on the 27 th February 2025.
Councillor Khan enquired if Hyndburn Borough Council would be entitled to a share of the £387k reserves if the company was would up. The Leader responded that it was likely that any balance of reserves would ultimately transfer to LCCA. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision.
Councillor Khan welcomed the investment in this project and asked if additional National Lottery Heritage Fund monies might be available. The Leader commented that the current budget proposal was for the survey only. Anne Hourican, Senior Environmental Initiatives Officer, responded that the various capital allocations received so far were for the physical upgrades planned, such as the new entrance, etc.
The Leader reported that he had asked [name removed] to keep him and Councillor Khan updated on developments. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision. Reasons for Decision Budget provision was required to support momentum of the Brookside Restoration Initiative, which was one of the Council’s most significant environmental enhancement projects.
Councillor Zak Khan also spoke on behalf of the Conservative group to congratulate the Mayor on his appointment and noted the strength of his conviction when speaking in the Council Chamber.
Councillor Khan also spoke about the retiring Mayor and highlighted his dedication, integrity and passion for people. He noted that the Mayor had represented the Council at many engagements and had almost never had to turn down an invitation, supporting numerous charities and institutions, particularly those regarding youth issues. He had demonstrated the best of public service, continuing a family tradition.
The Leader thanked Councillor Zak Khan for his interest in this project and his support. David Welsby, Chief Executive, made the following announcement: Local Elections Outcome He welcomed new councillors to the authority and to their first formal meeting.
A nomination for Councillor Zak Khan was MOVED and SECONDED , following which a nomination for Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP was MOVED and SECONDED . The Mayor considered the order in which to take the votes and, having previously taken votes in the order of receipt of the nomination for the Appointment of Deputy Mayor (Minute 2 refers), he determined to do similarly for this item.
On being put to the VOTE the motion to appoint Councillor Zak Khan as Leader of the Council for 2026/27 was LOST .
Councillor Khan delivered a short speech about the leadership challenge. He had prepared two speeches, one in the event that he was elected as Leader of the Council and second if that was not the case. He explained why some members of his group had abstained from the second vote on this matter.
On a personal level, Councillor Khan commented that he had been born and bred in the area and had been elected to represent its residents. He believed that this was the right way forward under the circumstances. He expressed the view that local government was not about national politics, but about providing quality local services.
Councillor Khan indicated that where any vacancy had been identified as a Conservative position, he would be happy to consider sharing the seat across the Opposition groups. Resolved - That the appointments to outside bodies and organisations for the Municipal Year 2026/27, as set out in Appendix A of the addendum to the report, be approved, and in the case of those details which are not available in time for the meeting , that the Chief Executive be authorised to approve the membership in consultation with the leaders of the relevant political groups.
Councillor Khan indicated that this issue had been discussed in the Council Chamber on several occasions. The Conservative group were in favour of reinstating the previous rules about public speaking. He asked if the Motion could be taken now.
Councillor Khan enquired if the comments had been taken from a draft motion, which had had not met the eligibility criteria.
With the agreement of the Mayor the following Councillors were given permission to speak: Councillor Zak Khan paid tribute to the Mayor and to his colleagues, Councillors Peter Edwards and Danny Cassidy.
In respect of Minute 340 of the Planning Committee on 11 th March 2026, Councillor Zak Khan commented that he had spoken against the application for a housing development on land off Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle. The Committee had subsequently decided to refuse that application, contrary to the officer recommendations. He noted that comments made after the meeting had levelled a criticism that his objection might have adverse financial consequences for the Council.
Councillor Khan was of the view that this case illustrated that councillors had the ultimate responsibility locally for determining planning applications. The Leader endorsed the above view that councillors made the final decision. However, he acknowledged that officers had a duty to outline potential risks, which they did by means of written recommendations.
Councillor Zak Khan commented that he supported, in principle, the writing off of the trading debt, but enquired about the following whether the figure of £1,624m was the entire debt owed; whether HL could adequately maintain the buildings in the longer term under a full repairing lease; and what improvements to the financial management arrangement had been realised as a result of the negotiations with HL. Martin Dyson Executive Director (Resources) confirmed that the total debt figure was as reported. The Leader responded that a 30-year lease would enable HL to attract in additional funding and it had a track record of doing so previously.
Councillor Zak Khan supported the proposals and enquired if the Council had sufficient resource to monitor the impact on the local community of any planning approvals given.
Councillor Zak Khan also expressed support and asked about how the delegated powers in relation to making a CPO would be applied. The Leader commented that use of the CPO would be a last resort as the Council hoped to reach agreement with land owners through negotiation. Approval of the report was deemed a key decision.
Councillor Zak Khan indicated his support for the proposal and asked if other delivery partners had been considered and who the sports development officer would be accountable to.
Councillor Zak Khan also welcomed the proposals and hoped that the communications released would be able to effectively convey the rationale for this decision in a way which did not cause division within the community. The Leader acknowledged this sensitivity, as comprehensive feedback had been received on this issue. He gave an assurance that the press release would explain why this decision was being taken.
Councillor Zak Khan noted the planned opening date for the Market Hall in November 2026 and asked what the additional costs would be to the Council of operating the venue in-house.
Councillor Zak Khan – Spoke against the application.
The Leader of the Opposition, Councillor Zak Khan spoke of his sadness, noting that the Council Chamber would not be the same without her. She had left a lasting impact on Hyndburn, inspiring, caring and strong, a dear friend who would not be forgotten.
Appendix 3 set out the detail of the authority’s Treasury Management Practices 2026/27, comprising the 12 identified TMP areas, as follows: TMP1 Risk Management TMP2 Performance Management TMP3 Decision Making and Analysis TMP4 Approved Instruments, Methods and Techniques TMP5 Organisation, Clarity and Segregation of Responsibilities and Dealing Arrangements TMP6 Reporting Requirements and Management TMP7 Budget, Accounting and Audit Requirements TMP8 Cash and Cash Flow Management TMP9 Money Laundering TMP10 Training and Qualifications TMP11 Use of External Service providers TMP12 Corporate Governance Appendix 4 provided the Capital Strategy 2026/27, which included information on the following: · Overview and Scope · Capital Expenditure · Capital v Treasury Management · Service and Commercial Investments · Council Objectives · Capital Budget Setting Process · Monitoring of the Capital Programme Expenditure · Multi Year Schemes · Funding Strategy and Capital Policies · Procurement and Value for Money · Partnership and Relationships with Other Organisations · Management Framework · Performance Management · Risk Management; and · Other considerations Councillor Dad and Councillor Khan both thanked the Finance officers for all their hard work. Resolved – T
Councillor Zak Khan made the following comments and raised a number of issues in relation to the Pride of Place schemes.
In respect on Minutes 277 - Local Elections 2026, Councillor Khan noted that the Government had announced that it would no longer postpone local elections in those areas subject to Local Government Review as previously identified. He asked what additional costs there would be to the Council due to this decision. The Leader confirmed that no additional costs would fall to the Council beyond what had already been budgeted for to run elections.
Councillor Khan expressed the view that £63m would be wasted by the Government following their announcement of new capacity funding across the affected local councils. The Leader responded that this money was not ‘wasted’ but would help those councils to best deliver Local Government Reorganisation. Hyndburn would receive its share of this funding and an announcement on this was due to be made under a later Agenda item.
Councillor Khan made comments and/or asked questions, as summarised below: Regarding the LCC Levelling Up SGHS projects, he noted that these were concentrated on only two areas and asked if there were more borough-wide projects planned – Response: The Leader responded that the £50m allocated across east Lancashire would include £5m for Hyndburn. The projects had already been identified based on extensive consultations, so could not be reallocated. Further information was available on the LCC website.
Councillor Zak Khan considered that the work done so far was a good news story for the Council. He would be keen to see further publicity about how the Council was continuing to protect its green spaces and what positive impacts had been achieved in the light of the environmental duties now in place. The Leader responded that the updated Local Plan was expected to be adopted during the summer.
Councillor Khan queried whether the revenue costs of delays to the Market Hall project were sufficiently transparent. The Leader considered that the Council had been very open about this matter, even in the face of some criticism. The Market Hall should be completed by the end of the year and the Council wanted the traders to be on a sound financial footing should they chose to return indoors.
Councillor Khan made comments and asked a number of questions as shown below, to which responses were provided, as follows: Could the Cabinet confirm that around 5% of the Council’s baseline funding had been lost over a 3 year period, amounting to some £6.35m? - Response: This was correct. Would this Council receive a share of the £63m grant announce by the Government? - Response: The Council would receive an allocation from that grant. Would the above grant offset the whole of the financial settlement reduction, given that there were 315 councils in England, or would the use of reserves still be required? - Response: The grant was only for the 30 councils affected by the reinstatement of the elections.
Councillor Khan noted that there might be a veto to borrowing more money in the buikd up to transferring to a new unitary authority. He asked if there would be any opportunity to borrow more money. The Leader referred to earlier responses on the question of borrowing.
Councillor Khan noted that £300k had been allocated for the operation of the Market Hall following the departure of the original contactor.
Councillor Khan also asked about the total amount being transferred to reserves in 2026/27. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision. Reasons for Decision The report set out the Council’s Revenue Budget for 2026/27.
Councillor Zak Khan made some comments and asked a number of questions, as follows: He was pleased to note that a large number of Pride in Place schemes had been proposed. He asked what consultations had taken place about the schemes to be supported and what schemes had been rejected. Who had determined the Community Projects and Neighbourhood Projects identified?
Councillor Zak Khan added that a number of Conservative councillors had also attended the protests and that he was pleased to note the latest position. UK Town of Culture 2028 Details of the submission process for the newly created UK Town of Culture for 2028 had been published by the Government last week. This could potentially bring investment into Hyndburn.
Councillor Zak Khan commented that Accrington and Rossendale College was a great asset to the Borough and noted that the Chief Executive of the Group had recently been awarded a CBE. He also asked if attendees at the Forum were predominantly from the public sector.
Councillor Zak Khan indicated that he was pleased to see the improving statistics, as these initiatives had commenced under the Conservative administration in 2023/24. He sought further clarification about the end date for the figures provided, as in his experience different feedback was coming from the business sector. This might be due, in part, to the Chancellor’s Budget in Autumn 2025.
Councillor Brerton responded that he could look into the end date of the statistics, if necessary, but he understood that Councillor Khan already had access to that information. He was pleased that the Opposition had acknowledged the overall positive direction of travel.
Councillor Khan commented on Table 1 at Paragraph 4.2 and noted that the Total External Debt and Capital Finance Requirement at Q3 were broadly similar figures which offset each other. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision. Reasons for Decision Local authorities were required to manage their borrowing, investments, and cash flows in a way that was affordable, prudent, and sustainable.
Councillor Khan made the following observations and asked various questions as follows: Waste Services were predicting an £61k underspend. Could the saving be reallocated to enforcement activity? The announcement at Council on 15 th January 2026 about progress on the Waste Disposal contract was welcomed, as this should mean the no large financial investment would be required.
Councillor Khan made the following observations and asked various questions as follows: Appendix 3 of the report set out slippage into future years, for example expenditure on Wilsons Playing Fields Drainage, Hyndburn Leisure Centre Efficiencies and the Market Hall development. Was this linked to a lack of staff capacity, expertise or delays affecting delivery of the project? The Conservative Group had proposed additional project staff during the last Budget process.
She offered to arrange a site visit if Councillor Khan so wished. The project had been a ‘challenge’ and progress had been slower than the Council would have liked. However, the renovation of old buildings could often throw up unexpected complications.
Councillor Khan raised the following additional matters: Was an update available regarding project delivery and expenditure in Year 1 concerning the £20m Pride in Place Funding? He noted that, at Paragraph 5.9 of the report, the Huncoat Garden Village development was being supported by consultants. His understanding was that the controlling group had previously disapproved of the use of consultants for projects.
Councillor Khan welcomed the new service and commented that many councils already collected food waste. He noted that this would be new to the people of Hyndburn and asked whether vulnerable groups such as the elderly would have wrap-around support.
This comment was echoed by Councillor Khan. The Leader was pleased to note that the caddies were now being rolled out to all residents.
Councillor Zak Khan confirmed his support for penalising offenders and for publicising the increased fines in order to deter potential offenders. However, he was concerned that criminals would find a way to circumvent these measures. Before issuing fixed penalty notices, first the Council would need to collect sufficient evidence.
Councillor Khan commented that the strategy was a core document, but had been in need of an update as Hyndburn’s demography had changed over time. In particular, he noted the 5% increase in the ethnic minority population and the better understanding of disability leading to increasing numbers of residents and staff identifying themselves as having a disability. However, he did express some scepticism about impact of the strategy alone.
He added that, with the support of Councillor Khan, it had been decided to offer the awards of Freedmen to both, in recognition of their eminent and long service to the Borough. It was proposed to confirm the awards at the Council meeting on 26 th March 2026. 8) Fair Funding Settlement In October 2025, the Council had heard that it would be adversely affected by the planned introduction of the Fair Funding Review 2.0. Following a constructive dialogue with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and lobbying by Sarah Smith MP the final financial settlement had been better than initially expected.
In respect of Minute 213 – Local Government Reorganisation Proposals, Councillor Zak Khan commented that he would still wish to see clarity around the answers to the questions he had asked at the meeting (last paragraph, Page 18 of the Agenda ), particularly in relation to the views of Hyndburn residents during the consultation. He asked if any further information was available.
Councillor Zak Khan commented that the Local Plan and its final consultation stage was still within the remit of Hyndburn councillors to agree. It was the last chance for local representatives to get this process right, as the Borough would cease to exist in 2028. He expressed some concerns about the changes proposed to the areas no longer identified for inclusion in the Green Belt, particularly land north of Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle.
Councillor Munsif Dad summed up the debate, responding as follows: He acknowledged that Councillor Parkins had consistently made his views known about the Huncoat Garden Village proposal throughout the Local Plan process; He undertook to ask about a possible extension to the consultation period for the Main Modifications, as he also considered that the time period was too short; He commented that he was in favour of the extension of the Green Belt and that he would encourage officers to make the case for this, where realistically possible; He noted that the Planning Department would arrange for the formal consultation, but he encouraged elected members also to spread the word; He would be happy to meet the Head of Planning and Transportation, together with Councillor Khan, to discuss the consultation process; He was familiar with the Hopwood Street site and would prefer this to be developed for housing. The land was privately owned. Local residents currently wanted it the land left open, but it was not currently in a good state.
Councillor Khan indicated that Conservative Group supported the freezing of allowances and added that members generally did not become a councillor for monetary gain. The allowances available went some way to covering associated costs, such as for time off work.
The following matters were raised: In connection with Minute 225 (19 th November 2025 at Page 7, Paragraph 2) – Accrington Neighbourhoods Board, Councillor Zak Khan clarified that his point about independence had related to the appointment of the original Chair of the Board, who he did not believe met the definition of independent.
With regard to Minute 227 (19 th November 2025 at Page 20 Bullet 1) – Revenue Budget Monitoring 2025/26, Councillor Zak Khan noted that the Council had no control over the contractual issues relating to the Waste Disposal Site / Transfer Station.
In respect of Minute 228 (19 th November 2025 at Page 21, Paragraph 3) – Capital Programme Monitoring 2025/26-2027/28, Councillor Zak Khan reminded members that he had asked about the anticipated £0.428m underspend, he recalled that the Leader had previously indicated that there was a list of potential schemes being drawn up.
Councillor Khan expressed his hope that any surplus money would be spent in Hyndburn before Local Government Reorganisation.
Councillor Lorraine Cox was substituted by Councillor Zak Khan.
The minutes of the following board were presented: Name of Body Date of Meeting Leader’s Policy Development Board 23 rd October 2025 Councillor Khan enquired as to progress regarding the procurement of the new mayoral car and the proposed duration of the lease. Jane Ellis, Executive Director, (Legal and Democratic Services) reported that officers were considering a fully electric BMW 5 Series on two year lease and were on the verge of placing an order.
Councillor Khan also asked for an update on webcasting. [name removed] reminded members that the Board had agreed not to implement webcasting on the grounds of cost, but had approved a conference microphone system. The anticipated installation date was March 2026.
Councillor Zak Khan commented that it might be useful to receive an update on the measurable outcomes of the work of the Economic Development Team at a future meeting.
Councillor Khan was pleased to note that the outcome of the Fair Funding Review might be better than originally expected.
Councillor Khan asked how staff had been engaged in the process and if this would prepare the way for LGR. The Leader responded that this had been a bottom-up process, with service managers requested to consult their staff and to feed back any suggestions.
Councillor Khan raised a number of queries as summarised below and responses were provided by Councillor Dad, or the relevant officer, as indicated: Given that enforcement was a discretionary power, who was the decision maker when applying the public interest test (see Paragraph 6 of the Plan)? – Response: The Head of Planning and Transportation had delegated powers to make decisions about enforcement. However, the matter could be referred to the Planning Committee, particularly in controversial cases. The Leader of the Council had overall responsibility for the Enforcement Plan, as Portfolio Holder.
Councillor Khan expressed disappointment at the proposals, which he considered lacked innovation and relied on old ways of working. He raised the following queries: What were the reasons for the preferred operator parting ways and was this due to the Council’s actions? Whether specialist markets consultants were needed, given that an in-house model of operation was to be established?
Councillor Khan supported the provision of the subsidy, particularly given the health challenges faced by Hyndburn’s population. He noted the reduction in the level of subsidy for this year and the forecast reduction for future years and also queried the following matters: Whether the anticipated savings would be financed by increased revenue, or through lower energy, buildings and staffing costs; Whether more details of the new relationship between Hyndburn Leisure and the Council would made available in the forthcoming report; and Whether Hyndburn Leisure would be looking into the different levels of subsidy per attendance at its various venues (the Table provided at Paragraph 4.3 of the report refers).
Councillor Alexander confirmed that the details requested by Councillor Khan would be addressed in the forthcoming report as part of the Council’s overall approach. She added that the Council was not able to dictate what Hyndburn Leisure did operationally, but could influence it through maintaining a positive relationship and encouraging good working practices. Regarding the question about subsidies attributable to each venue, [name removed] added that the facilities mentioned were being looked at on a site-by-site basis, although it was recognised that some buildings were not as efficient as others.
Councillor Zak Khan noted that most points had been discussed at the Council meeting. He also agreed with the 3 UA model, but his main concerns centred around the consultations and evidence base and a sense that the matter was being rushed through without clarity about what the people of Hyndburn wanted. Information available at the Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee had only showed the postcodes of consultation respondents.
Councillor Khan welcomed the additional funding and thanked the Leader for his role in the appointment of a new independent Chair to the Board. He placed on record his thanks to the previous Chair, whom he knew personally and whom he respected, and wished him well for the future.
Councillor Khan then enquired about the following: What reassurance was there that the Board and its processes would remain independent and would it be free to make its own recommendations; Whether the Board’s recommendations would be taken forward as submitted, or would they be subject to alteration; How consultations with residents would be supported; Whether previous plans would be acknowledged and how previously identified projects could be prioritised so that some could commence straight away; How the Council would attract in additional private investment to add to the £20M Fund; and Whether the Board’s actions would be subject to the Council’s overview and scrutiny arrangements.
Councillor Zak Khan queried the relationship between the Council’s borrowing and investments and any timescales applicable to the Council’s main funding pressures (as outlined in the Revenue Monitoring report at Agenda Item 6), particularly in the light of the impending Local Government Reorganisation.
Councillor Zak Khan asked if the amount of underspend of £0.428m referred to in Paragraph 4.6 of the report, could be reallocated to be spent on other projects in-year, or if it would only be considered at year end for slippage into future years.
Councillor Khan added that it had been pleasing to see large numbers of young people attending the services, including those from scouts, brownies and various cadet organisations.
Councillor Khan endorsed the comments being made, noting that the meeting had been very productive. David Welsby, Chief Executive, announced the following: 5) Local Government Reorganisation (LGR) Members were about to discuss an item on Local Government Reorganisation, which dealt with the Council’s preferred model for the new local authority structure. The formal decision would be for the Cabinet to determine.
Councillor Zak Khan, Leader of the Opposition, was granted permission by the Mayor to make a brief announcement, as follows: 6) Councillor Marlene Haworth Councillor Zak Khan thanked members on both sides of the Chamber for their support and kind words directed towards Councillor Marlene Haworth at this difficult time. Councillors had put aside their political differences to reach out to a respected colleague who was dealing with a health issue. This gesture of support was very much appreciated.
In respect of Minute 167 - Motions (Motion 4), Fair Funding Review, Councillor Zak Khan commented that in the minutes of a recent Cabinet meeting he had been criticised for allegedly exaggerating some the negative impacts under the Review by highlighting that the Government could withdraw £5m from Hyndburn’s financial settlement. He noted that the Portfolio Holder had subsequently referred to that same figure when discussing the authority’s finances and he asked if his original statement would now be endorsed. He also asked whether the Leader of the Council had confidence in the Chancellor.
The Mayor advised that no supplementary question could be asked in the case of questions submitted on behalf of the public. 3) Proposed Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) – Application No. 11/24/0389 – Knuzden Moss Farm To the Leader of the Council (Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP) Submitted by Councillor Zak Khan on behalf of Vinette Davitt “The Planning Inspectorate has overturned HBCs decision to vote down the proposed BESS system in Stanhill, Oswaldtwistle.
While the Council understood residents’ concerns about protecting the Green Belt, it must also act within the legal framework that governed planning decisions and appeals. 4) Fly Tipping To the Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services (Councillor Stewart Eaves) Submitted by Councillor Zak Khan “Given the lack of uptake for recent skip days and the fact that it is fly-tippers that cause a stain on our communities, would the monies spent on this initiative not be better spent on more fly tipping deterrence measures such as cameras?” Councillor Stewart Eaves indicated that the Council was currently considering a number of measures to be put in place to try and reduce fly tipping. Cameras were one of the tools available and he would have like to support their wider use. However, they were not economically viable.
Councillor Khan asked the following supplementary question. He was pleased to note that the intention was to increase fines, but since evidence was required, cameras would help to support his approach. He asked if the Portfolio Holder would consider a localised solution for littering hot spots.
Councillor Zak Khan confirmed that he was happy with the proposed 5 clear working days deadline for the submission of questions and the proposed changes to prevent the available time for questions being dominated by a single councillor. He also noted that the current arrangements already limited councillors to one question of their own, except with the consent of the Chair, although no such restriction was now applied to questions submitted by members of the public. He supported the changes as proposed, but requested that, at the next Leader’s Policy Development Board, members consider whether to allow a supplementary question in the case of a question submitted on behalf of a member of the public.
The following matters were raised: In connection Minute 194 - Medium Term Financial Strategy, Councillor Zak Khan reiterated his earlier point about the Council’s finances, noting that Table 3 included funding gap figures in the pessimistic scenario as follows: 2026/17 - £3.3m 2027/28 - £4.6m 2028/29 - £5.6m.
Councillor Cassidy undertook to pass on the Leader’s thanks to Councillor Khan. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision. Reasons for Decision In October last year, the Council had invited a team of senior local government councillors and officers to undertake a Local Government Association Corporate Peer Challenge (“CPC”).
He anticipated that Councillor Khan would get in touch with the Leader or Portfolio Holder directly when available. He also placed on record his thanks to the Executive Director (Resources) and his team. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision.
In connection with Minute 87 - Minutes of Cabinet (Minute 46 – Accrington Neighbourhoods Board), Councillor Khan also noted that Sami Smithson was the new Chair and considered that this was a good appointment. He expressed disappointment that he had not received further information about the appointment process for the previous Chair.
Regarding Minute 83(4) – Question Time – Council Owned Garages, Councillor Zak Khan indicated that no response had been received by Councillor Haworth about the possible creation of a budget to maintain the garages.
In respect of Minute 89(3) – Motions on Notice – Welfare Motion, Councillor Zak Khan outlined an error in the minutes and clarified that in Paragraph 10, his statement was that the Opposition group would ordinarily have supported that particular motion, in principle.
The Mayor reiterated that, notwithstanding, the above, he was obliged to read out the questions in accordance with the Constitution. 1) Skip Days To the Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services (Councillor Stewart Eaves) Submitted by Councillor Clare Pritchard on behalf of [name removed] “Could the portfolio holder please provide an update to Council on the recent skip days?” Response: Councillor Eaves indicated that a written reply would be provided. 2) Council Reserves To the Portfolio Holder for Resources and Council Operations (Councillor Vanessa Alexander) Submitted by Councillor Steven Smithson “How much money does this Council have in its reserves?” Response: Councillor Alexander referred to a recently published report and indicated that a written reply would be provided. 3) Great Harwood High Street Accelerator Plan To the Leader of the Council (Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP) or relevant Portfolio Holder Submitted by Councillor Zak Khan “Following the successful roll out of £45,000 in grants for shop improvements in Great Harwood, will you roll this out this across the whole Borough and offer the same opportunity to other towns?” Response: Councillor Dad indicated that a written reply would be provided.
A supplementary question was asked by Councillor Khan on the following: Councillor Khan commented that the Leader of the Council appeared to be refusing to answer the substantive question and asked if he could answer it now.
The Leader reiterated that a written reply would be provided. 4) Local Nature Recovery Strategies To the Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services (Councillor Stewart Eaves) Submitted by Councillor Zak Khan on behalf of Vinette Davitt “How is Hyndburn engaging in the new Local Nature Recovery Strategies? - A new system to map the best opportunities for restoring nature to help focus efforts and target funding.” Response: Councillor Eaves indicated that a written reply would be provided and reminded all that routine questions could be submitted via the Council’s Contact Centre. 5) King George V Playing Fields To the Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services (Councillor Stewart Eaves) Submitted by Councillor David Heap “Please could the portfolio holder give an update on the reopening of King George’s playing fields?” Response: Councillor Eaves indicated that a written reply would be provided. 6) Accrington Cemetery To the Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services (Councillor Stewart Eaves) Submitted by Councillor Shabir Fazal OBE on behalf of Khuram Mehrban “What action will Hyndburn Council take to stop dogs fouling and walking over graves at Burnley Road Cemetery, and when will the promised fencing, water tap, and review of burial regulations for the Muslim section finally be delivered?” Response: Councillor Eaves indicated that a written reply would be provided. 7) Vehicle MOT Requirements To the Deputy Leader of the Council and Por
Councillor Zak Khan expressed disappointment at the changes being made to the membership of the Standards Committee, as he considered that the existing members were working well together.
The meeting was then adjourned for 5 minutes to allow members to take short break . 1) Live streaming of Meetings The following motion was proposed by Councillor David Heap and seconded by Councillor Zak Khan, with support from signatory Councillors Steven Smithson, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule A9: “This Council requests that the Cabinet consider making arrangements for all council meetings to be live streamed online for public viewing, this includes full council, cabinet and scrutiny meetings.” Councillors Mohammed Younis , Steven Smithson, Zak Khan spoke in favour of the motion on the grounds of transparency.
Councillor Khan indicated that the Opposition group was not willing to adopt this wording in place of their original motion. Accordingly, members proceeded to debate the amendment.
Councillor Zak Khan acknowledged the above points, accepting the need for some HMOs. However, he was of the view that residents wanted more control over their establishment and he considered that the original assessment of the evidence available in support of a Borough wide Article 4 Direction was flawed. Hence, an immediate review of this evidence base was being requested.
(2) This Council calls on the Cabinet to resolve to continue working towards the consideration of a full Article 4 across the Borough of Hyndburn which, if fully evidenced, is implemented in a timely and sustainable manner. 3) Support for Local Businesses amid Financial Pressures The following motion was proposed by Councillor Zak Khan and seconded by Councillor Steven Smithson, with support from signatory Councillor David Heap, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule A9: “This Council recognises the significant financial challenges currently facing local businesses across Hyndburn. The recent increase in taxes, predominately National Insurance (NI) contributions, has placed additional strain on employers, while high business rates - particularly within the hospitality and retail sector - are contributing to a worrying rise in business closures. Our local businesses are vital economic drivers.
Through these actions, the Council aims to provide meaningful support to the businesses that form the backbone of Hyndburn’s economy and long-term transformation, before it is too late for more of our local hard-working business owners.” Councillor Khan, highlighted the current financial pressures on businesses and the cost to the nation of out-of-work benefits.
Councillor Khan summed up by expressing disappointment that it appeared that the motion would not be supported by the controlling group. On being put to the VOTE , the motion was LOST . 4.
Fair Funding Review The following motion was proposed by Councillor Zak Khan and seconded by Councillor Joyce Plummer, with written support from signatory Councillor Danny Cassidy (who was no longer present), in accordance with Council Procedure Rule A9: “The Cabinet Report of 10 September 2025 detailing an update on the Fair Funding Review notes: "Hyndburn could experience a substantial reduction in funding under the revised methodology.
Hyndburn has been identified as one of the 49 most adversely affected authorities, with projected funding levels falling well below the baseline set out in the government’s consultation." This Council: Requests the Leader of the Council, along with Leaders of the Opposition parties, write a joint cross-party letter on behalf and signed by all Councillors, to Sarah Smith MP, the Chancellor and the Secretary of State for MHCLG - to urge them to conduct an urgent review and reverse Hyndburn's inclusion on the list of adversely affected authorities - in order to provide certainty to the residents in Hyndburn that they will not be disproportionately affected at a time of significant need across the Borough.” Councillor Khan recognised the need to avoid creating anxiety amongst the public about the potential outcome of the Fair Funding Review, but he highlighted the statement above contained within the recent Cabinet report. He hoped that a cross-party letter to the MP and relevant Government ministers would help to add weight to the previous consultation response. The predicted shortfall in funding was likely to be over £1m across all three scenarios outlined in the Medium Term Financial Strategy.
Councillor Khan summarised by noting that he had only been made aware of the outcome of the Fair Funding Review as a result of the LGA Corporate Peer Challenge. He expressed disappointment that the situation had not been shared with him earlier. On being put to the VOTE , the motion was LOST .
Councillor Zak Khan, Leader of the Opposition, commented on the announcements above, asked the following questions and received the responses as summarised below: Local Government Reorganisation – The questionnaire by the consultants was now live. What input did the Leader of the Council have into the survey and would the results be broken down into statistics showing the views of residents in each district council area?
Corporate Peer Challenge Review Visit – The overall process had been useful and Councillor Khan had himself provided some feedback to the peers. He had appreciated the opportunity to be involved in the Member Working Group for the review. Would the Peer Challenge feedback be shared widely and would the Member Working Group continue?
She undertook to reply directly to Councillor Khan with further details. The Leader of the Council added that Hyndburn Leisure had been selected to operate the centre because of its good track-record of service delivery. The centre should be viable, given that its first target of 200 members had already been met.
Accrington Neighbourhoods Board – Councillor Khan noted that the population of Hyndburn was around 80,000 and expressed a view that the recruitment process had not been transparent. Would the selection of the independent Chair be determined by the Leader and MP alone? Response: The Leader of the Council indicated that the application process had been open to all, but only six people had replied.
Councillor Zak Khan expressed a view that the Fair Funding Review would have a devastating effect on the Council’s finances and could reduce available resources by some £5m. He acknowledged that this was not a situation caused by the controlling group, but asked how they intended to deal with the consequences of any loss of funding. This was important because Hyndburn was the 16 th most deprived district in England.
Councillor Dad gave an undertaking to meet with Councillor Khan about this matter and reaffirmed that Cabinet members had already been considering potential solutions for the last few weeks. Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision. Reasons for Decision The Council had approved its annual Revenue Budget for 2025/26 and the Medium-Term Financial Strategy ( MTFS ) for 2025/26 to 2027/28 at the Full Council meeting on 27 th February 2025.
In respect of Minute 44 – (Minute 409), Councillor Khan, Leader of the Opposition, thanked Mark Hoyle, Head of Housing and Regeneration for information supplied to him recently in response to a question asked at an earlier Cabinet meeting about the updated risk register for the Huncoat Garden Village project.
With regard to Minute 46 – Neighbourhoods Boards, Councillor Khan indicated that he had not received a full explanation as to the selection process for the Board’s Chair.
In connection with Minute 46 – Economic Development Officer, Councillor Khan highlighted an error at the end of the paragraph underneath the ‘Economic Development Officer’ heading, which should read ‘…tenure as Portfolio Holder for Economic Development & Sustainability’.
Councillor Khan indicated that he welcomed the additional funding provided and expressed the view that rough sleeping had been a growing challenge over the last few years. Part of the solution might be to establish links into getting those individuals back into work.
Councillor Khan asked if a positive case study could be publicised to showcase the good work taking place. This would need to be with the consent of any individuals featured.
Councillor Khan asked whether any alternative systems had been considered.
Councillor Khan referred to the impending reorganisation of local government and asked how this might affect the Treasury Management Strategy. In particular, he asked if consideration was being given to bringing back investments into the Council’s accessible finances in order to support its priority projects.
Councillor Khan noted that Hyndburn had done well to secure external funding and gain interest from its external investments. He asked whether there would be sufficient time to spend surplus resources, if the Council chose to do so. Councillors Whitehead, Fisher and Pritchard responded that preparation for reorganisation was a priority in the Corporate Strategy.
Councillor Zak Khan was pleased to see that the Centre was on track and that it had not been unduly affected by the original contractor, ISG , entering administration . He expressed some reservations about the Centre being named after a former politician rather than, say, a local sportsperson.
With the permission of the Mayor, the Leader of the Opposition, Councillor Zak Khan, made the following announcement 4) Air and Army Cadets Headquarters Councillor Khan reported that, along with the Mayor, he had recently attended the official opening of the new headquarters of ... view the full minutes text for item 81.
1) Determination of Planning Applications To the Leader of the Council (Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP) or relevant Portfolio Holder Submitted by Councillor Zak Khan, on behalf of a resident, Vinette Davitt “I would like to raise the following question at the next full Council meeting please.
The Leader of the Council thanked the resident and Councillor Khan for the question. The standard target to determine a non-major planning application was 8 weeks and 13 weeks for a major application. 26 weeks was the maximum for a major application, unless a longer period had been agreed in writing. Normally, applications were decided within a shorter period.
A supplementary question was asked by Councillor Khan on the following:
Councillor Khan acknowledged that the matter was both contentious and complex and had been over four years in the making. He noted that residents were concerned about the application and expressed the view that providing more time for consideration might give the applicant an advantage. He asked what specifically were the reasons for granting the extension and if he could have a copy of those details.
Councillor Zak Khan commented that the 2023 version of the Strategy had been developed under the previous political administration, however, most of its priorities remained relevant. He was particularly pleased to see that the commitment to Sustainable Growth had been retained , as this reflected long-term thinking. He also understood the need to include Devolution as a new priority.
Meeting (Municipal Year 2024/25) Date Special Scrutiny Committee 5 th February 2025 Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee 20 th February 2025 Audit Committee 24 th February 2025 Licensing Sub-Committee 27 th February 2025 Communities and Wellbeing Overview and Scrutiny Committee 4 th March 2025 Licensing Sub-Committee 6 th March 2025 Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee 18 th March 2025 Planning Committee 19 th March 2025 Planning (Trees) Sub-Committee 19 th March 2025 Planning Committee 16 th April 2025 Meeting (Municipal Year 2025/26) Date Cabinet Committee (Street Naming) 21 st May 2025 Judicial Committee (Private Hire & Hackney Carriage Licensing) 5 th June 2025 Planning Committee 11 th June 2025 Audit Committee 23 rd June 2025 Councillor Zak Khan asked if it would be possible to record all Cabinet and Committee meetings. The Leader of the Council responded that this matter could be discussed at the next Leader’s Policy Development Board.
Councillor Khan indicated that the Opposition group did not wish to engage in the debate on motions and would abstain from any vote taken. The group had submitted two of its own motions for tonight’s meeting, which had been directly relevant to Hyndburn issues, on the subjects of a local member grants scheme and the extension of Article 4 Directions for Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs) across the Borough. However, these motions had not been accepted for inclusion on the Agenda.
In respect of Minute 399 - Accrington Stanley FC, Councillor Khan noted that a further meeting had been held with the football club after the aforementioned Cabinet meeting. He asked about the purpose of the meeting and any outcomes. The Leader responded that he would provide an update on this matter under Agenda Item 5 – reports of Cabinet Members.
In connection with Minute 409 – Huncoat Garden Village, Councillor Khan commented that he had not yet received the updated risk register in relation to the HGV project, which he had requested.
Councillor Khan expressed disappointment that two out of the three proposed Working Groups contained no Opposition representation.
Councillor Khan welcomed the engagement held with the public. He asked about the following:
Councillor Khan commented that the events now being held and draft Strategy were a credit to the officers and partners who supported them. He enquired about the outcome measures identified in section 6 of the document and asked if these were open-ended, or intended to be completed by the end of 2025/26.
Councillor Khan noted the good work undertaken by the Executive Director (Resources) and his team.
Councillor Khan commented that there were significant funds available within reserves and that the Opposition had made some suggestions about additional projects and expenditure at the Council’s Budget meeting in February 2025. He asked if these funds could now be utilised. Councillors Alexander and Dad responded that the Cabinet was currently looking at its priorities and would share some information on this in the near future.
Councillor Khan commented that he would wish to see capital spending maximised before local government reorganisation and asked if new projects could be added to the Capital Programme.
Councillor Khan expressed disappointment that many of the Opposition suggestions for scrutiny topics had not been included in the draft programmes. He also commented that only a limited number of suggestions had been submitted by members of the public and queried whether more could be done to engage the public in democratic processes such as this. In addition, he queried whether suggestions for topics raised in-year could be added to the work programmes.
Councillor Khan asked what alternative funding sources had been considered prior to contacting the Council. [name removed]- Barwood responded that initial funding had been secured from the Rural Community Energy Fund, but that further funding was required for legal and technical work, including negotiations with Network Rail. The proposed end-user for the energy generated, William Blythe Limited, had not been approached about funding to help set up the scheme, but the purchase price of the electricity would take into account some of the set up costs.
Councillor Khan echoed these sentiments and highlighted the retiring Mayor’s commitment to dignity and promoting the office of the Mayor. He also thanked the retiring Mayoress for her support.
It was proposed by Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP and seconded by Councillor Zak Khan, that Councillor Josh Allen be elected Mayor of the Borough of Hyndburn for the Municipal Year 2025/26.
It was proposed by Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP and seconded by Councillor Zak Khan that Councillor Noordad Aziz be elected to the Office of Deputy Mayor.
Councillor Zak Khan expressed concern about the removal of the facility for members of the public to submit question directly to the Council, as these often led to positive outcomes, such as in the case of the recent question about Oswaldtwistle Civic Theatre. He also queried why the petition scheme had been withdrawn as other authorties , such as Lancashire County Council, still operated a formal scheme. He expressed a view that these changes were eroding democracy.
In connection with the meeting held on 22 nd January 2025, regarding Minute 313 – Prudential Indicators Monitoring, etc., Councillor Khan indicated that he had not yet received a reply to his question about the expenditure plans of the Net Zero Working Group.
Councillor Khan commented that the Opposition Group supported the sentiment of the Motion in preventing environmental hazards, but was disappointed that the matter appeared to have been raised because of the forthcoming Lancashire County Council elections.
Councillor Zak Khan commented that Recommendation 8 (below) – Forward Planning, appeared not to have been fully implemented , as a number of reports at the meeting had been provided by way of a supplemental agenda. The Leader confirmed that this was still a work in progress.
Councillor Khan expressed disappointment that the overall level of funding allocated for advice and support for business, as this was less that the amount proposed by the Opposition at the Council Budget meeting. He requested that this funding be internalised for future years to ensure that this function was not diminished in the longer term.
Councillor Khan indicated that he was supportive of the proposals and engagement with the education sector. He hoped that the outcomes would be ambitious and visionary and was keen to work with the Controlling Group to shape the way forward.
Councillor Khan welcomed the support provided to Market Hall traders, but expressed a hope that businesses would not come to expect and rely on subsidies over the longer term. The Leader noted the possibility that the Market Hall project could overrun slightly which might need to be taken into account for the purposes of ending all concessions/financial support granted to these traders.
Councillor Khan noted that other wards had benefited from a similar approach to tackling anti-social behaviour and he hoped that this type of scheme could be rolled out further across the Borough.
Councillor Khan expressed a view that monitoring of standards was essential and that he would wish to see regular reports provided to councillors to maintain oversight of these arrangements.
Councillor Khan noted that the draft terms of reference provided for five councillors and reported interest from Councillor Josh Allen in taking up a seat. He also requested a second Opposition seat, if possible. The Leader confirmed that the working group would include cross-party representation, but that the proportionality was still to be determined.
Councillor Khan added that Councillor Cassidy, ( Huncoat Ward) had expressed the same view.
Councillor Khan requested a copy of any updates to the risk register following the above-mentioned review.
In response to a question from Councillor Khan, Councillor Whitehead indicated that the anticipated grant funding had enabled existing Council funding set aside for the Civic Theatre to be reassigned to focus on dry rot issues.
Councillor Khan confirmed that the proposed Opposition amendments to the Budget would be circulated later during consideration of this item, at the formal amendment stage of the debate.
Councillor Khan pointed out that he had spoken to traders and customers who had expressed concern that they were not being kept informed of what was happening. He requested that greater efforts were made to ensure regular communications with all concerned, particularly with the market traders. He also confirmed delay in the funding announcement by 6 months had not ... view the full minutes text for item 439.
Councillor Zak Khan raised a matter in respect of Minute 255 – Reports of Cabinet Members (Pay and Display On-Street Parking Consultation). He indicated that he had followed up this matter with representatives of Lancashire County Council and that they had confirmed that there were no current proposals to implement on-street parking charges in Hyndburn. Any request for such arrangements would need to be initiated by the Borough Council.
Councillor Zak Khan reminded Members that, at the Council meeting on 16 th January 2025, Councillor Steven Smithson, had proposed an extension to this contract to coincide with the date for reorganisation of local government in Lancashire.
Councillor Khan thanked the Leader for supporting cross-party working.
Councillor Khan asked how frequently the level of future financial support from the Council for the operation of Market Chambers would be reviewed. He noted that, given the projected timescales, this responsibility would become a matter for the proposed new unitary authority, which introduced an element of risk to any long-term arrangements.
Councillor Khan noted the strong financial position and asked whether there was any scope to reallocate capital funding to support the renovation of the Civic Theatre, Oswaldtwistle .
Councillor Khan noted the balance for the Climate Change Reserve (included in Table 12 of the report) and that there had been little call upon this reserve as at Quarter 3. He enquired if the Net Zero Working Group had any related expenditure plans.
1) Local Government Reorganisation To the Leader of the Council (Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP) Submitted by Councillor Zak Khan “Do you support the abolition of Hyndburn Borough Council, in favour of an East Lancashire Authority?” In the light of the report included at Agenda Item 13 and with the consent of the meeting, Councillor Khan withdrew this question The Mayor then read out the following questions:
Councillor Khan commented that he had posed a number of questions during Cabinet meetings and to Portfolio Holders directly, but that in some instances questions raised at the Cabinet remained unanswered.
Councillor Khan spoke against the amendment and commented that take up of the Household Support Fund was low. Councillors Fazal , Younis , Smithson and Cassidy also spoke against the amendment.
Councillor Khan raised some points in respect of Minute 208 – Reports of Cabinet Members as follows:
Councillor Dad responded that the full list of dates had not yet been set, but he would ensure that these were sent to Cllr Khan.
In connection with the Retrofitting Hub, Councillor Khan asked if a response had been received from the relevant Ministers about the funding announcement.
In respect of Minute 209 – Prudential Indicators Monitoring and Treasury Management Strategy Update, Councillor Khan asked whether the impact of increased employers’ contributions for National Insurance was now known . David Welsby, Chief Executive responded that the Government had announced that it intended to compensate local authorities for the increased costs of employers NI contributions.
Councillor Khan queried whether the choice of wards might appear to be politically motivated and whether it might have been more advantageous to apply the Article 4 Direction across the whole Borough.
Councillor Khan asked a number of questions which are summarised below, together with any responses provided:
Councillor Khan indicted that the Conservative Group also supported the decision to proceed with the development and would be happy to work with the controlling administration to make it a success and to secure the right housing for the Borough.
Councillor Khan expressed disappointment that the questions he had asked and the answers given at the Cabinet meeting had not been recorded more comprehensively in the formal minutes.
Councillor Khan indicated that this had been the subject of an earlier discussion between Councillor Whitehead and himself.
2) Change to Council Procedure Rules The following motion was proposed by Councillor Zak Khan and seconded by Councillor Danny Cassidy, with support from signatories Councillors Kath Pratt, Judith Addison, Loraine Cox, Josh Allen, Marlene Haworth, Mohammed Younis , Steven Smithson and Tina Walker, under Council Procedure Rule A9:
“ This Council approves a change to Council Procedure Rules that reverts to allowing motions and notices to be signed by at least two members. ” Councillor Khan indicated that he had sent a letter to the Chief Executive setting out the rationale for the proposal, which had subsequently been forwarded to the controlling group. In effect, democracy should be seen to be transparent. He acknowledged that when the change had been proposed initially, the Opposition had not noticed it.
Councillor Khan thanked Councillor Aziz for his update and acknowledged that the situation was as a result of circumstances outside the Council’s control. He enquired what responsibilities the Council now had for the site. He also asked who would bear the cost of the situation.
In response to a query from Councillor Khan, it was reported that the damaged new refuse lorry had now been repaired and was back in service.
Councillor Khan asked if details of how to arrange a ‘skip day’ could be circulated to all councillors.
Councillor Khan asked whether the increase in employers’ National Insurance contributions announced in the Government’s Budget had been taken into account within the Council’s finances. The Portfolio Holder responded that the Council would take a holistic approach to all of the budgetary changes announced today and report back as appropriate.
Councillor Khan thanked the Portfolio Holder for the risk information and the update on the Civic Theatre. He noted that some underspends logged were due to staff vacancies, particularly in services such as Planning and Building Control. He asked whether there would be negative financial consequences if the posts were filled .
Councillor Khan noted that capital receipts needed to be realised to fund the Capital Programme, in part, and asked if it was known which land or buildings would be proposed for sale.
Councillor Khan raised questions about a proposal for a strategic rail freight terminal and about how the decision on the overall project would be communicated to residents, to which Councillor Dad responded.
Three nominations had been received in advance of the meeting, two from Councillor Zak Khan who nominated Nick Whittaker and Eddie O’Brien and one nomination from Councillor Kimberley Whitehead who nominated Christine Heys.
The two nominations were received from Councillor Zak Khan.
He had worked collaboratively with Councillor Zak Khan, Leader of the Opposition, Councillor Danny Cassidy, Joint Deputy Leader of the Opposition and Councillor Shabir Fazal OBE, Green Party, to manage the situation. The work of all those involved had produced a positive impact. The situation had highlighted that Hyndburn was one community and that people would come together to listen and learn.
1) Local Plan To the Leader of the Council (Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP) Submitted by Councillor Zak Khan “The Council has a proposed replacement Local Plan which it endorsed for statutory (Regulation 19) consultation in late 2023. The plan is due for final submission to the Planning Inspectorate in coming weeks.
Councillor Khan asked the following supplemental question in accordance with Council Procedure Rule A2-2.2( vi ):
Councillor Zak Khan raised a number of matters in relation to the HGV project, as outlined below:
Councillor Khan also welcome the provision of the support.
Councillor Khan enquired about whether critical timelines could be applied to the individual risks identified within the report.
There had been one membership change to the Committee which had taken place at Full Council on 11 th July 2024: Councillor Zak Khan replaced Councillor Josh Allen.
Councillor Zak Khan, Leader of the Opposition, referred to Minute 22 – Appointment of Cabinet Committees and Cabinet Groups 2024/25. He enquired if the Economic Policy Forum and Net Zero Working Group would continue and offered to arrange a handover to the new Portfolio Holders.
Councillor Khan also commented that the decision at Minute 24 – Long Term Plan for Towns - Funding Update, which illustrated the controlling group’s continued use of consultants, appeared contrary to their stated position.
In addition, Councillor Khan repeated a comment made at the same meeting, in connection with Minute 26 – Provisional Financial Outturn Position - Revenue Budget Monitoring 2023/24, which (although not recorded in the formal minutes) had highlighted the healthy state of the Council’s finances.
He would be pleased to receive any information held by Councillor Khan.
He undertook to ask her to speak directly to Councillor Khan.
Councillor Munsif Dad BEM JP, Leader of the Council, gave a speech of welcome to the Mayor and his partner, Christine Sollis, the Mayoress, which was supported by Councillor Noordad Aziz, Joint Deputy Leader of the Labour group and Councillor Zak Khan, Leader of the Conservative group.
Councillor Zak Khan spoke in favour of the application.
Councillor Khan agreed to bring these names to a future meeting of the Cabinet.
Committees Cabinet Committee (Scrap Metal Dealers Act 2013) Councillor Stewart Eaves (Chair) Councillors Vanessa Alexander and Melissa Fisher Cabinet Committee (Street Naming) Councillor Noordad Aziz (Chair) Councillors Scott Brerton and Melissa Fisher 1 Conservative vacancy (attending as observer) Working Groups Cabinet Waste and Recycling Group Councillor Stewart Eaves (Chair) Councillors Munsif Dad and Kimberley Whitehead and 1 Conservative vacancy Net Zero Working Group Councillor Kate Walsh (Chair) Councillors Scott Brerton and Steve Buton Councillor Zak Khan enquired if the controlling group intended to continue to run the Economic Policy Forum. He explained that, in his experience, businesses liked continuity of support and it was important to continue to reach out to them.
Councillor Zak Khan enquired if the service would be sustainable in the longer term in the light of uncertainty around the amount of Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) funding. The Leader of the Council responded that the Council would make representations to Defra regarding any shortfall, as would other local councils.
Councillor Khan asked if any changes would be made to the composition of the Town Board and commented that the use of consultants appeared to be a change of policy within the controlling group.
Councillor Khan commented that the Council was in a good financial position.
Councillor Khan stated that he was pleased to see that the revenue outturn report did not support the view expressed by some that the Council had a ‘black hole’ in its finances.
Councillor Khan asked about the selection process for co- optees .
It was proposed by Councillor Marlene Haworth and seconded by Councillor Zak Khan that Councillor Josh Allen be elected to the Office of Deputy Mayor.
Councillor Zak Khan offered his congratulations to the new Leader and thanked the officers and Councillor Howarth for their hard work. He considered that the previous administration had set a sound foundation for what was to follow, including securing significant financial investment, and he pledged to lead a respectful Opposition, which would challenge policies, as necessary, whilst treating individual councillors courteously.
With the consent of the Mayor, Councillor Britcliffe invited Councillor Zak Khan, Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services, to speak about Bury Meadows.
3) Bury Meadows Councillor Zak Khan announced that the Net Zero Working Group, yesterday, had heard that work as due to start in spring on the creation of a nature reserve at Bury Meadows. The work would include an 18 months’ programme and discussions with interested parties.
Councillor Khan thanked Anne Hourican, Senior Environmental Initiatives Officer and Councillor Caroline Montague, for their work in this regard. Forestation and other ‘greening up’ projects were also taking place at this site. The community woodland project was ahead of schedule with over 4,500 trees planted by some 200 volunteers.
The Cabinet considered a report of Councillor Zak Khan, Portfolio Holder for Economic Development and Sustainability, providing an update and assessment of progress regarding Economic Development activity.
Councillor Khan highlighted the main areas covered by the report.
Councillor Mohammed Younis welcomed the report and indicated that he worked closely with Councillor Khan on Town Centre issues.
Councillor Khan responded that he had recently held discussions with one organisation that had been contemplating leaving the area and had been successful in making the case for them to stay. He was optimistic that better engagement with businesses made Hyndburn an attractive place to carry on a business.
Members considered a report of Councillor Zak Khan, Portfolio Holder for Economic Development and Sustainability, which provided:
Information about the energy efficiency measures installed in domestic properties in Hyndburn through various energy funding programmes and grant schemes; and A summary of the approach taken by the Council to promote funding opportunities and to support residents to apply for funding Councillor Khan spoke to introduce this report and to outline the work currently being undertaken by the Housing Strategy and Policy Manager and the Home Energy Reduction Officer. The Council had looked at the national picture and Government expectations. He emphasised that there were numerous challenges ahead, particularly around lack of knowledge and awareness and arising from existing levels of fuel poverty.
Councillor Khan responded that he was liaising closely with Rossendale Borough Council who were piloting a Net Zero Terrace Street project. He also hoped to establish an East Lancashire group to discuss common issues.
The Chair welcomed Cllr Zak Khan (Portfolio Holder for Economic Development and Sustainability), Mark Hoyle (Head of Regeneration and Housing) and Salma Choudhry (Economic Development Manager) to present this item.
Cllr Khan reported that he has already begun to work closely with Salma, and would like to record his thanks for the work already carried out in a short space of time.
Cllr Khan referred to the written report which was just a snippet of activity being carried out by the Council. He referred to recent news that the Council had received some Levelling Up funding for Great Harwood and insisted that economic development is about the whole borough, not just Accrington.
Cllr Khan highlighted the following from the report:
- Potential continuation of UKSPF - Devolution and the effects on future funding - Small Business Champion role - Supporting businesses outside of Accrington - Communication with small businesses - Feedback from small businesses - Encouraging good quality start-up businesses - Engagement with local colleges - What is the long term vision Cllr Khan ended by saying he is open to engagement with all Councillors on this topic at any time, and he would welcome input.
Councillor Khan reported that his role as Portfolio Holder for Economic Development was more focussed on commercial property rather than residential. Ultimately, the biggest issue with derelict commercial buildings as they are the responsibility of the owners, and the vast majority of buildings of this nature are in private ownership. His long term goal is for the Council to create an environment which encourages private investment in these buildings, and he is actively working with a number of businesses who are looking to relocate.
Councillor Zak Khan declared a personal interest in the item relating to the Hyndburn Councillors due to the inclusion of his own application for a dispensation and, therefore, did not take part in the vote. Resolved - That the applications for dispensations from the Hyndburn Councillors and Altham Parish Councillors, as listed in the minutes above, were approved for a period of 4 years from 13 th October 2023 to 12 th October 2027.
Councillor Zak Khan, welcomed the report and indicated that he had recently met with the Asset Energy Reduction Officer about net zero projects, as there was much work to do in Hyndburn.
Members considered a report of Councillor Zak Khan, Portfolio Holder for Economic Development and Sustainability, updating Cabinet on escalating the Council’s Economic Development function and seeking approval to sign up to the Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) Local Leadership Pledge.
Councillor Khan highlighted the main elements of the report and gave an update on some more recent activities. He reported that the first meeting of the Economic Development Forum had taken place this morning and had been well attended. The feedback had been very positive Approval of the report was not deemed a key decision.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Zak Khan, Portfolio Holder, Stuart Sambrook, Policy Manager, Sarah Whittaker, Regeneration Manager, Anne Hourican, Senior Environmental Initiatives Officer and Tim Brodest , Home Energy Reduction Officer to the meeting.
- Acquisition of Brookside / Bury Meadows nature reserve and plans to enhance the area - Partner involvement in the above - Flood management - Work on engaging with schools - Peat stores - Coal authority and mine heat exchanges Cllr Khan, Portfolio Holder said that he welcomed the enthusiasm from officers across Council departments who are involved in the Council’s green agenda. He said that whilst the Council can be a leader and an enabler in this, we can’t do it on our own. He sees the Net Zero Working Group as not just a Council group but one which should involve other stakeholders, schools and business leaders.
Councillor Zak Khan reported that he was aware that EU European Social Fund ( ESF ) funding was due to end soon, but that the organisation was currently applying for other funding streams.
He and Councillor Zak Khan responded to the following and responded to questions on the following:
Arndale Centre masterplan – Cllr Khan confirmed that this is something the Council are looking into, but there are numerous issues, mainly the private ownership of the building. However, the Council are working hard to engage the owners in the process. This is the start of the process but a number of options will be considered.
Electric vehicle infrastructure planning – Cllr Khan confirmed that this is mainly the responsibility of LCC as highway authority but the Council can influence planning.
Planning regulations and sustainable housing – Cllr Khan said he has begun discussions with officers to establish what measures can be taken to encourage new developments to be built more sustainably. He gave examples of some areas were decarbonised streets have been built with community heating systems.
The Chair thanked Stuart and Cllr Khan for attending the meeting.
Councillor Zak Khan responded that more housing was required in Hyndburn but that any plans would also have conditions attached before being approved. He explained that Huncoat Garden Village was a large project and required the specialisms that the Council did not have and, therefore, the appointment of consultants was necessary.
Councillor Zak Khan, Portfolio Holder for Economic Development and Sustainability, provided a brief verbal update of activity within his remit. This included:
Councillor Mohammed Younis , Portfolio Holder for Levelling Up, added that he had also met with Councillor Z Khan last week to discuss the town centre and had made contact with some prominent owners of town centre properties.
A summary of the appointees and their Portfolios was as follows Councillor Marlene Haworth – Leader Councillor Peter Britcliffe – Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Resources Councillor Steven Smithson – Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services Councillor Mohammed Younis – Levelling Up Councillor Kathleen Pratt - Housing and Regeneration Councillor Sajid Mahmood – Communities, Health and Wellbeing Councillor Zak Khan – Economic Development and Sustainability Councillor Loraine Cox – Leisure Transformation and Leisure Trust Full details of the Portfolio Responsibilities were set out in the report.
Councillor Zak Khan thanked the Portfolio Holder and officers for their work and applauded the Council for trying to undertake something new.
Councillor Zak Khan noted that the capital works to provide energy efficiencies had shown a good degree of foresight and further work would now be progressed.
Councillor Khan gave a brief speech about his year as Mayor and its many high points, culminating with a trip to the Houses of Parliament as a guest of Sara Britcliffe MP and attendance at the Royal Garden Party. He had been very proud to be asked to represent the Borough. He thanked his wife, family and friends, as well as officers and councillors for their support.
Councillor Zak Khan said that it is important to keep members of the public updated as there is a lot of misconceptions. Many don’t realise that the funding comes with strict criteria of what it is spent on and the Council should ensure we continue to communicate this.
Councillor Khan suggested that we could assist the levelling up process by ensuring we use local firms for the contract where possible.
Councillor Khan also asked what work is going on behind the scenes to encourage further investment into the town centre. Steve responded that UKSP funding has been allocated to promote the town centre, and numerous events are planned to generate footfall. The opening of these 3 major buildings in the programme will also generate more footfall.
Councillor Carole Haythornthwaite substituted for Councillor Zak Khan.
- Housing strategy including use of brownfield sites (former Huncoat power station as an example) where they are available - Strategic employment development close to the M65 - High quality housing and jobs integral to keeping people and attracting people to live in Hyndburn - External funding availability dictating which projects are brought forward at certain times Councillor Khan said he agreed that investment is required in housing and employment and he was supportive of the Local Plan. He suggested that the Council could communicate its intentions better in order to get a more positive response from the public. The Leader agreed with this, however, he pointed out that consulting with the public was not always straight forward, as the public often engage more if they are against something rather than if they are in support of it.
Councillor Khan said a lot of positive work is going on unseen and that we need to get better at showing the positive work. The Leader responded that positivity is high amongst local business leaders and stakeholders and the politics is causing negative issues.
Councillor Zak Khan said it seemed from the report that there was a clear preference for larger scale events with big pull factors rather than smaller events, and he supported this. However, he did indicate that he would like to see a more robust evaluation of the events funded through the Council to get a clearer picture of what works and what does not. He also said he hoped the process of funding large events would be a catalyst for smaller events to pop up on their own without the need for Council funding.
Cllr Khan said any review should consider increasing the amount of disabled parking spaces available in the immediate town centre.
Its membership would comprise the Council’s Green Agenda Champion (Councillor Caroline Montague), the Business Ambassador for Marketing Lancashire (Councillor Zak Khan) and the Chair of the Special Overview and Scrutiny Committee (Councillor Josh Allen).
All Members could provide suggestions by contacting Councillor Zak Khan.
Councillor Abdul Khan for Councillor Ayub Councillor Dad for Councillor Fisher Councillor Cassidy for Councillor Hurn Councillor Dominik Allen for Councillor Zak Khan; and Councillor Aziz for Councillor Whitehead.
Councillor Plummer acted as substitute representative on behalf of Councillor Khan.
In the absence of Councillor Khan (Chair), Councillor Fisher being Vice-Chair of the Committee took the Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Councillor Khan read and signed the Declaration of Acceptance of Office of Deputy Mayor.
Councillor Short acted as substitute representative for Councillor Khan.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Khan attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Khan's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Khan was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 3 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Khan declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 Oct 2023 | Standards Committee, item 260 | Councillor Zak Khan declared a personal interest in the item relating to the Hyndburn Councillors due to the inclusion of his own application for a dispensation and, therefore, did not take part in the vote. Resolved - That the applications for dispensations from the Hyndburn Councillors and Altham Parish Councillors, as listed in the minutes above, were approved for a period of 4 years from 13 th October 2023 to 12 th October 2027. | Took no part |
Where Councillor Khan sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 | 14 Jan 2027 |
| Special Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 | |
| Mayor-Making, Council | Committee Member | May 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.