Declarations of Interest
Councillor Rae, being an officer of the Ipswich Maritime Trust, declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 2 (IP/26/00357/VC) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.
Every time Ipswich's minutes name Councillor Rae, as the council published it.
Councillor Rae, being an officer of the Ipswich Maritime Trust, declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 2 (IP/26/00357/VC) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.
Councillor Rae commented that there was greater confidence that a plan to develop the site would come forward in the next 3 years.
Councillor Rae noted that the current policy only assessed the number of HMOs within an area rather than their size, and commented that larger HMOs would have a greater impact on an area; therefore, size should also be considered when the concentration of HMOs in an area was assessed.
Councillor Rae highlighted that parking was a significant issue in this area and parking spaces were not available on Woodville Road as suggested.
Councillor Rae questioned the reasoning that, because the property did not currently have three parking spaces as required in the parking guidance, the expansion could be permitted without providing the four ... view the full minutes text for item 101.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor Ross and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae commented that the hours of operation of the previous application had been discussed extensively in April 2025 when a significant number of representations from residents had been received, and it was considered that 8pm was appropriate given these concerns; no new evidence had been presented to justify the extension of hours.
Councillor Rae commented that the objections to the application were mostly with regards to the number of parking spaces and bin store concerns. The objections claimed that no additional car parking spaces would be provided, which was not valid as the current parking practice was unlawful. There was concern about odour from the proposed bin store and it being moved closer to the flats.
Councillor Rae commented that it was difficult to assess the impact without the detailed design and, given the objections already received, suggested that the reserved matters application should be brought to the Committee for consideration.
Councillor Rae commented that there was a lot to recommend in this application and acknowledged that the applicant was clearly a responsible person who intended to operate this HMO well. The property had been developed to a high standard and residents had been engaged with; however, bedroom 5 did not comply with the National Space Standards and was further impacted by there being no bathroom on the same floor. If the application had been for 5-bedroom HMO, it would have been acceptable.
Councillor Rae sympathised with the homeowner; however, Officers had considered the expert opinion of specialist Officers and there would be no grounds to go against that opinion.
Councillor Rae added that even if the tree was protected, works could still be undertaken to reduce its height.
Councillor Rae asked why the commercial use was limited to non-retail use given the footfall on route to the station. The Senior Planning Officer commented that because the site was outside of the defined retail core, a retail use would need to be sequentially tested; however, the space could be used as a restaurant.
· Education Primary School new build - £77,967 · Education Secondary School expansion - £29,939 · Education Sixth Form expansion - £29,939 · Early Years new build - £51,978 · Libraries improvements - £3,456 · Waste improvements - £2,240 · Monitoring fee (per SCC trigger point) - £519 Councillor Rae asked if the holding objection from SCC Drainage had been resolved.
Councillor Rae noted that the plans showed a lift and ramp access and asked if the flats met M4(2) or M4(3) accessibility standards and commented that this could be a missed opportunity if not.
Councillor Rae noted that condition 3 was missing the word “archaeological” in reference to the written scheme of investigation. It was confirmed that this condition would be amended accordingly and was only written in draft form.
Councillor Rae questioned whether the Committee was being asked to disregard the concerns raised by Suffolk Constabulary.
Councillor Rae asked whether the Electric Vehicle (EV) provision requirement applied to the 2 parking spaces and who would monitor the condition of the trees over the 5-year period.
Councillor Rae questioned why the longer period of 7 years was being considered in this instance as temporary car parks were usually granted permission for 2-5 years.
Councillor Rae commented that the area already experienced significant traffic congestion on match days, and the addition of 100 more car parking spaces would exacerbate the problem.
Councillor Rae commented that increased parking close to the football stadium should not be supported unless it was for special access purposes.
Councillor Rae disagreed with the assumption in paragraph 5.4 of the report that the proposed accommodation could not be classified as potential family housing. The criteria for assessing this, such as proximity to the town centre and lack of amenity space, could be applied to many existing flats or terraced properties in similar areas that were occupied by families. Consequently, the application failed to comply with Policy DM19 (protection of family housing).
Councillor Rae highlighted paragraph 5.19 of the report which referenced two nearby planning approvals for HMO use that had not been registered as HMOs.
Councillor Rae added that the HMOs would not have been required to be registered at that time and commented that checks should have been done to confirm their HMO status, as if they were HMOs, this application would be contrary to Policy DM20.
Councillor Rae proposed that the application be refused on the grounds of Policies DM19 and DM20, and this was agreed.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor M Cook and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae highlighted the requirement of condition 2 to submit details of noise mitigation measures before the development commenced and added that it would have been helpful for this information to have been presented to Committee, given the noise concerns raised.
Councillor Rae questioned why condition 2 did not include noise mitigation relating to the new padel courts and whether this should be added.
Councillor Rae observed the proposed hours of operation of 9.30am to 5.00pm;
Councillor Rae commented that the sequencing of appointments would be hard to enforce and asked how residents could report that the conditions were not being complied with. The Chair commented that the neighbours would monitor the situation.
Councillor Rae asked how realistic the estimate was for a development coming forward in 2028/29.
Councillor Rae commented that he had visited the building, and the original conversion had improved its aspect within the street scene; however, the proposed change was unlikely to release much additional space, and it was necessary to respect this historic building.
Councillor Rae commented that the previous temporary consent had included a condition requiring site improvements including landscaping; the planting had been done but had not been maintained.
Councillor Rae asked whether it was possible to grant consent for just 6 months to ensure that the required improvements were done.
Councillor Rae ... view the full minutes text for item 88.
Councillor Rae commented that the starting point of this matter was that the building had not been built in compliance with the original planning consent and complaints had been raised by neighbours in Fonnereau Road seeking enforcement action; the subsequent planning applications submitted had still not addressed those concerns.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor Ross and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae, being the Treasurer of the Ipswich Maritime Trust, who had submitted a representation on the application, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/24/00476/FUL) and left the room during the consideration of this application.
Councillor Rae noted the condition on the advertisement consent and asked how bright 600 candela per m 2 was and how that would compare with the illumination from recently approved street communication hubs.
Councillor Rae asked if the fee would be reduced as this was a partial audit. [name removed] explained that the fees were set and monitored by PSAA and that an exercise was currently being undertaken to identify what a fair fee for the process would be.
Councillor Rae asked if the industry had considered the capacity issues and how this could be resolved. [name removed] advised that the last report in 2020 identified a number of recommendations, of which one referred to the capacity of audit which included capacity in finance teams and the scope of the audit. The reset dates had been set and the recovery process would be implemented after this.
Councillor Rae asked if the sum owed by debtors accumulated until it was written off or if it was frozen. [name removed] advised that the debt was frozen and there would be opportunities for costs to be awarded ... view the full minutes text for item 27.
Councillor Rae queried the number of bedrooms provided in the flats as there was a discrepancy between paragraphs 1.3 and 5.3.2 of the report.
Councillor Rae questioned whether sufficient consideration had been given to the potential for noise transference between the flats and the adequacy of sound insulation.
Councillor Rae highlighted that there were Steps 1, 2 and 4 but no Step 3. The Senior Planning Policy Officer confirmed that this would be renumbered.
Councillor Rae commented that the property had been sub-divided as the two occupants were not able to live in the same space, so providing inadequate noise protection would not help that situation.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor MacDonald and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae commented that the feasibility issues had been considered for the previous reserved matters application and this was a modest extension of that scheme.
Councillor Rae asked why this development required planning consent.
Councillor Rae requested an enforcement update on the St Margaret’s Green car wash site.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor Rudkin and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae commented that the windows to service flats 9 and 10 were set low to the floor and suggested that these windows could be extended higher to improve lighting levels.
Councillor Rae commented that as some of the previous applications were allowed on appeal there could theoretically be many Hubs located on the same street.
Councillor Rae highlighted the representation received from the manager of the Revolution bar and the potential for anti-social behaviour outside of the venue and added that the Hub would create an extra obstacle given the high level of footfall in this location during the evening and on football match days.
Councillor Rae also referred to the concerns raised about advertising other shopping centres and bars that were in direct competition with the Buttermarket .
Councillor Rae proposed that the application be refused on the following grounds: the proposal did not enhance the sense of place; the proposal did not enhance the character of the town centre setting given the visual clutter and physical obstruction; the proposal did not enhance the digital communications network; impact on public safety; and this was agreed.
Councillor Rae proposed that the application be refused for the same reasons as stated for the full application and this was agreed.
Councillor Rae highlighted the request from SCC Highways for the Hub to be rotated 180 degrees so that the display faced the cycle storage facilities. The Planning Officer commented that the applicant did not support this request.
Councillor Rae commented that the Hub would be in a more modern setting, but the advertisement screen would be facing oncoming traffic and should be rotated 180 degrees.
Councillor Rae commented that in addition to not providing S106 contributions, it was a missed opportunity not to utilise the flat roof area to provide amenity space.
Councillor Rae noted that the Slade Street Car Park appeal had been allowed by the Planning Inspector; however, the conditions attached to the permission were stringent and would help to mitigate the concerns raised.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor M Cook and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae commented that defibrillators in the Council’s parks should be moved so that they were accessible 24/7.
Councillor Rae noted from the representations that a neighbour notification letter had not been received by 49 Malvern Road. The Senior Planning Officer commented that this had been an oversight, but a notification letter was subsequently issued; a site notice had also been erected at the site.
Councillor Rae noted that planning permission was requested for 5 years and that only 4 EV charging bays were proposed, which was inadequate to support the uptake in electric vehicle usage. The Development Management Team Leader commented that there was no requirement defined for EV charging bays within the Suffolk Guidance for Parking.
Councillor Rae asked whether the Council was obligated to follow the Suffolk Guidance for Parking or whether it was possible to require a greater provision of EV charging bays.
Councillor Cracknell attended as substitute for Councillor Frost and Councillor Rae attended as substitute for Councillor Blacker.
20.2 Councillor Rae asked whether the highest percentage of household waste sent for recycling and composting by other Councils was known.
20.3 Councillor Rae asked whether it was possible to identify how much of the waste remaining in black bins was recyclable.
Councillor Rae asked whether some statistics could be provided to reassure the public.
Councillor Rae asked whether this initiative would be accessible to people with disabilities.
Councillor Rae highlighted that there was an increasing demand for Council housing from private tenants as Council housing was of a better standard, with cheaper rents and better support for its tenants.
Councillor Rae expressed concern about the amount of detailed information still to be submitted and agreed prior to commencement within the conditions.
Councillor Rae commented that the number of HMOs within the street contravened policy DM20 within the latest Local Plan but understood that this was an existing HMO use, and that the policy could not be applied retrospectively. However, there were residents’ concerns about the lack of space to accommodate wheelie bins on the pavement and more information was required to demonstrate that a solution could be found.
Councillor Rae proposed that the application be deferred to enable further consideration of how bin and cycle storage could be managed on the site, including a management plan to set out how this would operate, and this was agreed.
Councillor Rae attended as substitute for Councillor Forster.
Councillor Rae asked whether it was possible to breakdown the planning enforcement cases in terms of whether they were proactive or reactive.
Councillor Rae asked how many people had attended the equivalent event last year. [name removed] commented that approximately 450 residents had attended.
Councillor Rae queried the hourly rate of the storyteller and artist, which equated to £75 per hour, which was much more than a schoolteacher was paid. [name removed] commented that he been paid £37 per hour when he had been a teacher previously; the rate for a high quality expert was £500 per day. 11.4.
Councillor Rae asked whether a statement could be provided by the Council’s Parking Officers to affirm that parking permits would not be allocated to residents within this development and questioned whether solar panels could be considered as part of the refurbishment works.
Councillor Rae highlighted that this site was used as a coach park on Ipswich Town’s home match days.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor Rudkin and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae noted that the indication within the Local Plan for this site to come forward for development in 2027/28 was only aspirational and not binding on the applicant; if a temporary permission was granted, there was no guarantee that it would not be extended beyond that consent.
Councillor Rae asked why the permission would be for only 7 years and not permanent given the proposed improvements to the building.
Councillor Rae thanked SCC for the prompt response to the dangerous layout of planters on the Milner Road closure after a cyclist had ridden into one of the planters.
Councillor Rae highlighted that there was a shortfall of £530 in the project costs and asked how this would be met.
Councillor Rae commented that the trial closure of the bridge linking Wellesley Road and Marlborough Road had been made permanent; however, residents had been reporting anti-social behaviour associated with the fixed seating that was installed as part of this scheme.
Councillor Rae asked whether the Police Design Out Crime Officer had been consulted about these road closure schemes.
Councillor Rae commented that there seemed to be a high proportion of administrative costs (project coordination, project management and project administration) for a relatively small project and questioned the different rates charged for these roles and whether they were delivered by different people.
Councillor Trenchard attended as a substitute for Councillor Mortimer, Councillor Rae attended as a substitute for Cllr C Smart, and Cllr Holmes attended as a substitute for Cllr T Lockington.
7.5 Councillor Rae asked what measures were being taken to further promote the Council’s cremation service. The Operations Manager for Parks and Bereavement explained that she was working with the Council’s marketing team to advertise both the cremation service and the stonemasons service. The Director - Development, Culture and Environment commented that people in Ipswich currently had two choices for cremation, with a more traditional chapel at Ipswich Cemetery or the much more modern feeling chapel at Seven Hills.
Councillor Rae asked how much funding was spent in Ipswich.
Councillor Rae commented that the Lloyds Arch location was not appropriate following the improvements to the Cornhill and the recent restaurant additions in that area.
Councillor Rae asked whether there were any street trading consents currently operating in the town centre in the evening.
Councillor Rae requested that a Street Trading Consent policy be considered to provide more information about what type of street trading would be appropriate at different locations across the town centre.
Councillor Rae suggested that empty shop units in the town centre might provide an alternative option rather than a mobile outlet.
Councillor Rae asked if there was any merit in deferring the applications to allow Officers to provide advice on suitable locations for this type of street food offer.
Councillor Rae proposed that condition 3 relating to hours of use be removed as this was not necessary for this community use within a town centre location, and this was agreed.
Councillor Rae commented that the introduction of a performance indicator tracking the number of referrals made to Ipswich Borough Council’s sports programmes by health partners was useful.
Councillor Rae, being a Spring Road allotment holder, declared an interest in Agenda Item 10 (CAC/21/14) and left the room during the consideration of this item.
Councillor Rae highlighted that the 5-year financial history for PHOEBE had seen income grow from £40k to nearly £400k by March 2021, but the expenditure had only been about £150k in that year.
Councillor Rae commented that projects had probably been delayed by the pandemic, but asked whether this existing income could be used in place of the requested funding.
Councillor Rae asked if the £1,000 was ring-fenced to events within the Central Ipswich area and whether any unspent funds would be returned to the Area Committee.
In relation to the 23 Brockley Crescent appeal, Councillor Rae asked how much the awarded costs would be. The Development Management Team Leader commented that it was up to the appellant to provide details of the costs they sought to reclaim; as yet, no letter had been received from the appellant on this matter.
Councillor Rae commented that the river path was an important walkway in Ipswich and asked how the improvement would be sustained after the 12 months’ increased maintenance.
Councillor Rae asked whether access could be from Woodbridge Road instead of Russet Road.
29.5 Councillor Rae noted that some drivers had avoided the closure of Milner Street by driving on the grass verges and asked that the permanent scheme be designed to prevent this.
32.1 Councillor Rae commented that he was pleased to see the designs for the new play equipment at Shaftesbury Square and asked that more notices be posted to inform residents.
Councillor Rae proposed that an informative be added to request that Suffolk County Council consider the need for further bollards to be installed immediately outside of the application site and this was agreed.
Councillor Rae, being an Officer of the Ipswich Historic Churches Trust, declared an interest in Items 2 and 3 (IP/21/00450/FUL and IP/21/00451/LBC) and left the meeting during the consideration of these items.
21.6 Councillor Rae highlighted the progress being made with the Council housing development on Grimwade Street.
Councillor Jones and Councillor Rae raised concern that the applicants did not want the BREEAM standard and Councillor Cook commented that the wording of the policy was weak.
Councillor Rae raised concern about site drainage and Councillor Kreidewolf noted there were many matters unresolved so was the application premature. The Planning & Development Operations Manager commented that there were many details still to be agreed.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor Jones and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae, being the applicant, declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Item 9 (IP/21/00478/FUL) and left the room during the consideration of this application.
Councillor Rae asked whether the floating floor could incorporate glass panels to enable the mosaics to remain visible.
Councillor Rae, being the Treasurer of the Ipswich Society, declared an interest in the Ipswich Garden Suburb applications (IP/20/00245/REM, IP/20/00306/REM and IP/20/00250/REM).
54.6 Councillor Rae noted that there was a further saving of £50k in 2022/23 relating to Customer Access, which would follow a £250k saving in 2021/22, and asked for more detail on the proposals for 2022/23. The Head of Finance and Revenues explained that the precise mechanism for making the saving in 2022/23 had not been identified but that it was considered to be realistic.
55.2 Councillor Rae noted that there was a low value investment in Heritable Bank dating back to 2008 and asked for more information about this. The Head of Finance and Revenues explained that this was an Icelandic Bank where the Council was still owed money, but commented that it might be reasonable now to write it off.
57.4 Councillor Rae asked whether statistics on the fraud rate were available. The Head of Internal Audit explained that the Annual Output Report, which would be presented to the Committee in July, contained statistics on the work of the team and the amount of fraud uncovered.
The Mayor confirmed that Councillor Adam Rae would act as consort and that any charity funds raised during her short term of office would be donated to Volunteering Matters, who had been Jan Parry’s Mayoral Charities.
The following amendment was PROPOSED by Councillor Rudkin and SECONDED by Councillor Rae:
Councillor Rae commented that Area Committee funding had been awarded at a previous meeting for organisations based outside of Ipswich that provided services across Suffolk.
Councillor Rae commented that progressing a policy to enable the removal of vehicles that were amassing unpaid parking tickets would be helpful in resolving issues currently experienced in residents’ parking zones.
Councillor Rae noted the information provided regarding Council Tax and the bad debt provision of £700k and asked if this meant the collection rate for Council Tax was currently low and why a high provision for bad debt had been made. [name removed] agreed to consider this in further detail following the meeting.
Councillor Rae asked if there had been any challenges regarding data security and data protection following the increased number of staff working from home. It was confirmed that there had been an increase in very minor email issues however, refresher GDPR and mandatory cyber training had been provided to employees. The process for which an employee could report a “near miss” or “minor incident” had also significantly improved.
Councillor Rae welcomed discussions to consider delegated authority for the Council to remove vehicles from the highway as there had been issues in Alexandra ward where illegal vehicles were left parked within residents’ permit zones, attracting numerous tickets as they could not be removed, and residents then receiving tickets for parking elsewhere because they could not use their own parking areas.
Councillor Rae noted the small additional amount for parking under audit fees and asked what the total income was in this area. John Chance, Head of Finance and Revenues, agreed to provide this information following the meeting.
Councillor Rae asked whether Citizens Advice had applied to the Council to the COVID-related Discretionary Grants funding.
Councillor Rae highlighted that 4YP had applied to the Discretionary Grants Scheme, which could potentially provide £10,000 towards the total project costs of £11,158.72 if successful.
Councillor Rae proposed that the determination of the bid be deferred to the next meeting when the outcome of the Discretionary Grants Scheme would be known to avoid paying for the same activities twice, and if that bid was successful, the Area Committee could then cover any shortfall in the project costs.
Councillor Rae offered to withdraw his proposal in favour of Councillor I Lockington’s offer of SCC locality funding.
Councillor Rae concurred that Area Committee funding was not the appropriate funding stream for this request.
a) that Councillor Rae be appointed to the St Margaret’s Charities for the Needy to replace Linda Erith (whose term of office had expired).
Councillor Rae asked whether the drop in the number of burglaries was because the number of incidents had fallen or whether people were not reporting crimes. Inspector McParland reported that the performance data was based on reported crimes and was a 12-month comparison, and stressed the importance of people reporting incidents.
Councillor Rae noted that free workshops had been provided on the Cornhill previously and asked why the proposed activities needed to be paid for.
Councillor Rae queried the cost of the session leaders (£180 per person per day) which equated to a gross equivalent salary of £43,000.
Councillor Rae commented that needles could still be deposited through the fencing and added that the fencing could merely displace problems elsewhere.
Councillor Rae asked whether this was more of a law enforcement issue and therefore a matter for the Police.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Rae and Councillor Trenchard as new members of the Committee.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Adam Rae to his first Central Area Committee meeting.
Councillor Rae noted that 30-35% of patients consulted their GP for social problems and asked whether there were enough Link Workers in place to cater for the number of referrals.
Councillor Rae asked what the waiting time was to see a Link Worker.
Councillor Rae asked how this year’s costs compared with previous years’ costs. [name removed] commented that there were higher costs when the event first took place in order to pay for equipment, but this equipment would be used again this year; however, the event would be branching out this year and the main costs were associated with printing/banners. The Ginnel Foto Community had also received support from other organisations.
Councillor Rae reported that the former Grinning Rat Public House would be opening this week as a vegan public house, selling vegan food and drink.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Rae attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Rae's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Rae was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 22 of 30 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Rae declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Jul 2026 | Planning & Development Committee, item 25 | Councillor Rae, being an officer of the Ipswich Maritime Trust, declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 2 (IP/26/00357/VC) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application. | Left the room |
| 2 Mar 2022 | Central Area Committee, item 51 | Councillor Rae, being a Spring Road allotment holder, declared an interest in Agenda Item 10 (CAC/21/14) and left the room during the consideration of this item. | Left the room |
| 22 Sep 2021 | Planning & Development Committee, item 56 | Councillor Rae, being an Officer of the Ipswich Historic Churches Trust, declared an interest in Items 2 and 3 (IP/21/00450/FUL and IP/21/00451/LBC) and left the meeting during the consideration of these items. | Left the room |
| 30 Jun 2021 | Planning & Development Committee, item 17 | Councillor Rae, being the applicant, declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Item 9 (IP/21/00478/FUL) and left the room during the consideration of this application. | Left the room |
| 2 Jun 2021 | Planning & Development Committee, item 6 | Councillor Rae, being the Treasurer of the Ipswich Society, declared an interest in the Ipswich Garden Suburb applications (IP/20/00245/REM, IP/20/00306/REM and IP/20/00250/REM). |
Where Councillor Rae sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning & Development Committee | Vice-Chair | Feb 2020 | 81 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Jan 2020 | 49 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Hackney Carriage & Private Hire Enforcement Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2022 | 16 | |
| Licensing & Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2022 | 10 | |
| Licensing & Regulatory Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2024 | 7 | |
| Central Area Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2019 | 29 | |
| Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Nov 2021 | 7 | |
| Audit & Governance Committee | Substitute | Feb 2020 | 6 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.