To Consider a Motion from Councillor MacDonald.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor MacDonald and SECONDED by Councillor Fisher:
Every time Ipswich's minutes name Councillor Fisher, as the council published it.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor MacDonald and SECONDED by Councillor Fisher:
Councillor Fisher noted that procedures including the inappropriate capitalisation of revenue expenditure would be reviewed and asked whether this was standard across local government. [name removed] confirmed that this was a standard requirement and had not been included due to any specific findings but because it represented an area for potential risk.
Councillor Fisher referred to the evaluation of pensions and noted that last year’s audit identified an understatement of the pension liability.
The pensions contributions had been reduced because the pension was fully funded, and Councillor Fisher asked whether there was cause for concern given that liabilities were now assessed as higher following that reduction.
Councillor Fisher noted that the narrative on financial performance highlighted the Council’s borrowing position and suggested that as this was a public facing document, it should also include reference to borrowing that was undertaken for cash flow purposes.
Councillor Fisher referred to the two different budget figures reported in the Statement of Accounts and commented that he understood the rationale for the higher figure and how it had been arrived at; however, a member of the public might question why there were two separate numbers. It was suggested that narrative be included to clarify why the figures were significantly different to avoid confusion.
Councillor Fisher referred to related party transactions which largely related to the Council’s group companies and included any transactions ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Councillor Fisher referred to the business rates earmarked reserves and questioned whether any surplus in the collection fund should be transferred directly to that reserve and moved as and when required.
Councillor Fisher asked how it was determined whether a surplus should be allocated to the business rates earmarked reserve or to the general reserve.
Councillor Fisher referred to the table at 1.6 which showed the net borrowing position and what loans had been taken out and what loans had been repaid. It was noted that the Public Works Loan Board maturity line showed £15m of new loans and £5.44m of rescheduled payments and it was suggested that both figures be reported separately instead of the net figures to provide greater clarity. [name removed] agreed that this would be added to future reports.
Councillor Fisher referred to the intergroup loans which showed a repayment of £750k and commented that to a casual observer this could appear concerning as it might look like the companies owed £121m but had repaid less than £1m. He suggested that additional narrative be included to clarify that all company payments were on schedule to avoid misinterpretation. [name removed] agreed that addition narrative could be included.
Councillor Fisher referred to the risk relating to the Hears Alarm Service and raised concern that the risk rating way high given that the switch off was scheduled for January 2027.
Councillor Fisher sought clarification on why the risk had only recently been added and the reason for its high rating. [name removed] confirmed that the risk had been included on the risk register previously; however, might have been added after the committee last considered it. [name removed] added that the increased risk rating reflected difficulties in identifying the right solution as the transition from analogue to the new system required replacement of units both in the control room and in residents homes, and the limited time remaining had contributed to the increased risk score.
Councillor Fisher noted that the time to complete recommendations had improved significantly and that the current position showed much stronger performance and demonstrated the effectiveness of the internal audit team.
Councillor Fisher referred to the internal audit report regarding a parking software company that owned the IP associated with the contract and asked whether Data Protection Impact Assessments were completed for all contracts or only those involving high risk data. [name removed] confirmed that DPIA’s had become more sophisticated over time and that although she could not confirm that every historic contract had undergone a full DPIA, standard clauses in IBC’s contract covered data protection requirements and the Data Protection Act set out the controller and processor responsibilities. It was noted that that the current procurement processes, combined with changes under the procurement act and data protection act, ensured greater focus with regards to special data.
9.4 Councillor MacDonald replied that he was pleased to hear that Councillor Fisher supported Ipswich's City of Culture ambitions and agreed that this was an opportunity for the whole town to come together behind a shared vision.
Councillor Fisher declared a pecuniary interest in this item, and left the room during its consideration.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor MacDonald and SECONDED by Councillor Fisher:
Councillor Fisher noted from the General Fund summary that there had been additional staff costs of roughly £0.5million this quarter and asked whether there this was likely to increase further before the end of the year and if any of this cost was due to supporting the LGR process.
Councillor Fisher asked how much of these costs were due to new employees and how much due to having to increase individual wages.
Councillor Fisher highlighted the transitional vacancies saving of £1million per year and commented that it didn’t make sense to report additional staff costs of £0.5million whilst claiming to have made transitional vacancies savings of £1million, it should be reported just one way.
Councillor Fisher commented that the annual cost of Agresso of £400k seemed excessive and asked how confident Officers were that it would not be required.
Councillor Fisher added that it was prudent to have the contingency as a back-up, and asked that if it was to be required, whether the supplier would be at fault and so present an opportunity to recoup the costs of extending the Agresso contract.
Councillor Fisher commented that the investment returns had dropped significantly from what was forecast, representing a percentage drop of 6.2%, which was steeper than the drop in interest rates, and added that the aim of Treasury Management was to generate cash for the Council.
Councillor Fisher noted that £16.2million was invested, which was much higher than before, but it was delivering less returns.
Councillor Fisher welcomed the proposed strengthening of the Contract Standing Orders, especially given the investment in procurement staff to tighten up processes.
Councillor Fisher noted the sign off processes for procurements above a certain limit, and asked whether there were any checks for repeat spends with the same supplier of amounts below these limits whereby the total spend across the year could exceed prescribed limits for sign off.
Councillor Fisher agreed with the principle of the levy to fund restoration works, especially as it would be the service users paying for the improvements rather than all taxpayers.
Councillor Fisher commented that when the levy was first introduced at the Regent Theatre, the levy was considered to be sufficient to cover future costs of improvements and asked what had changed in the interim so that the levy funding was no longer sufficient.
Councillor Fisher noted the table of levies applied at comparable venues nationally, some of which were higher, and asked whether the proposed levy of £2 was now sufficient to avoid having to request a further increase in future years, and if it was likely to not be sufficient in later years, whether it should be increased now.
Councillor Fisher welcomed the large number of projects being funded, and asked how the funding would be allocated to the projects as the funding would be released in 2 yearly tranches.
Councillor Fisher asked if the funding would be allocated in the order set out in Table 1, and then if there was any remaining funding, in the order set out in Table 2.
Councillor Fisher highlighted that when Executive had been requested to approve an extension to the project budget 2 years ago, assurances had been given that lessons had been learnt, expert advice had been taken and a significant contingency had been built into the budget, but the project was now £1.2million over budget. The £436k extra funding from fundraising was commendable, but would only be used to reduce the overspend. When the previous report was presented to Executive, Senior Officers had indicated that if there was a need to come back to Executive for more funding, the project would be paused; whilst this was one of the options in the report, it was not recommended.
Councillor Fisher commented that this was a wonderful project, and it was a worthwhile spend on Ipswich’s jewel in the crown; however, after taking advice and learning lessons, the project should not keep ending up in the same position of needing to request more funding. Once the project was complete, there should be a review and consideration given to increasing contingencies on large scale projects in the future as to keep coming back for more funding could lead to a lack of public trust.
The budget amendment which had been circulated electronically prior to the meeting was not moved by Councillor Fisher.
Councillor Fisher questioned whether the amount of time allowed for applications had been sufficient and if only the 4 previous recipients were able to apply.
Councillor Fisher commented that there appeared to be a 38% increase in Rough Sleeping and asked whether this was a national or local trend.
Councillor Fisher commented that he felt the Council was missing an opportunity to install electric cremators and that by the time the new cremators reached the end of their lifespan the majority of cremators would be electric.
Electric cremators offered savings in fuel costs and carbon emissions, and Councillor Fisher felt that the report did not reflect these.
Councillor Fisher noted that he had emailed Officers about a number of concerns.
Councillor Fisher said that electric cremators were more widely used in Europe and that he did not believe that an electric cremator would be more expensive to run.
Councillor Fisher suggested that the information contained in the papers was insufficient.
Councillor Fisher was concerned that the proposed end user of the site could have been located in a number of different buildings and that it wasn’t the best use of funds to spend money on this building.
Councillor Fisher commented that their attraction to this unit might well be because the Town Centre Regeneration Fund would be meeting the fit-out costs.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the Council was in consultation with the owners of the privately owned site.
It was MOVED by Councillor Phillips and SECONDED by Councillor Fisher:
In accordance with Part 4, Section 1, Paragraph 8.6 of the Constitution, Councillor Fisher requested that a recorded vote be taken, and this request was supported by more than five other Councillors.
Councillor Fisher asked whether it would be better for the Council to purchase these drinks on an ad-hoc basis rather than be in a contract. The Assistant Director – Governance, Shirley Jarlett, reported that procurement law required that this be subject to contract.
Councillor Fisher asked whether it was it was economically advantageous to be in such a long contract. The Assistant Director – Governance noted that longer contracts tended to deliver better value for the Council whilst the Chief Executive noted that the Officer time which would have to be spent on running multiple procurements were a shorter contract to be awarded would outweigh any savings which were able to be made.
Councillor Fisher asked whether Gull Proof Bags could be purchased for use in the Town Centre.
Councillor Fisher asked whether alternative periods of time, for example 16 years, had been considered for the replacement timescale.
Councillor Fisher asked for more information about the modern heating systems being fitted.
Councillor Fisher commented that it was good that the Council’s financial position seemed to have stabilised and asked for a breakdown of where savings had been made under the Corporate Saving Programme. The Director – Housing and Resources agreed to provide this by email.
Councillor Fisher asked how there had been both a reduction in income and an increase in costs in relation to temporary accommodation. The Director – Housing and Resources agreed to provide this information by email.
Councillor Fisher noted from the report that Executive had authorised the procurement of a framework in August 2021 for a 48-month period and that this had been delayed.
Councillor Fisher asked how contracts had been covered in the last 4 years, i.e. was it on an ad hoc basis, and, assuming that it was economically advantageous to procure through a framework, what had been done to progress the framework over this period.
Councillor Fisher asked, if procuring through a framework was more advantageous, whether the Council been overpaying on its contracts over the last 4 years.
Councillor Fisher commented that, by not having the advantage of a procurement framework in place for the last 4 years, the Council had not been as productive as it might have been, as whilst there might not have been additional spend from contract prices, there would have been greater spend in terms of officer time to service individual contracts.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the new contract would require new bus shelters to be installed regardless of which supplier was awarded the contract or if bus shelters would be replaced as and when required.
Councillor Fisher highlighted from paragraph 7.4 of the report that some shelters could be fitted with green roofs under the new agreement and asked whether the structure of existing bus shelters was strong enough to support a green roof.
Councillor Fisher commented that the General Fund variance of £1.2million in Quarter 1 was quite considerable, but that most of the variances had already been known when setting the budget.
Councillor Fisher commented that agency staff were being used to cover difficult to fill posts and that this had been an ongoing issue and should have been forecast when the budget was set. Similarly, the main variance on the HRA was the waking watch, which had been in place for a couple of years now.
Councillor Fisher highlighted that there had been an excellent take up of the brown bin subscription service compared to what was forecast, which would provide an additional £830k to the budget.
Councillor Fisher noted that when the subscription fee was introduced in September 2024 it was anticipated that the service would be cost neutral.
Given the increased level of take up, Councillor Fisher asked if the subscription fee for future years would be reviewed to reduce the fee to residents to make the service cost neutral.
Councillor Fisher commented that 2.55% initially seemed to be a reasonable increase; however, paragraph 10.3 of the report indicated that the proposed increase would see Ipswich become the 67 th most expensive authority out of 344 authorities, which he felt was not acceptable, especially given the areas of deprivation within Ipswich; Councillor Fisher added that the only way to address this going forward would be to not apply the CPI increase annually.
Councillor Fisher noted that 59% of customer contact was online and commented that it was likely to be more difficult to increase the level of digital contact from this position.
Councillor Fisher asked if there was an expectation that the upward trend would continue under the updated Strategy and whether the Strategy could be changed if it was proving difficult to increase the uptake of digital contact.
Councillor Fisher asked for clarification whether the Council would not be making redundancies but would just not replace customer advisors when they left, and Councillor Riley confirmed that would be the case.
Councillor Fisher noted that a lot of the funding would be coming from the Local Enterprise Zone Fund B and asked if there was a contingency plan in place in case there were issues with any of the main Enterprise Zone tenants, and whether Enterprise Zones would always remain in existence regardless of changes in Government given that the proposed funding for the car park was based on this income for the next 25 years.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor MacDonald and SECONDED by Councillor Fisher:
Councillor Fisher expressed concern about the amount of money already spent on trying to develop these sites and the money now being requested to create a scheme and asked whether this was affordable.
Councillor Fisher noted the £4.5million budget in the Capital Programme plus £500k of SPSL funding and asked whether there was a nominal budget in mind to develop a plan and if the developer was being asked to provide a range of options or work to a set of criteria.
Assuming that there was a plan ready to go, Councillor Fisher asked when it would be likely to deliver on affordability timescales.
Councillor Fisher commented that it sounded unlikely that all of the budget would be spent on the creation of a plan and asked whether the design cost was likely to be in terms of £100ks or £millions.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the development partner would be given a blank canvas to come up with designs or if it was possible to save money by giving a broad idea of what was wanted as there had already been investigative work undertaken on what the buildings could ... view the full minutes text for item 34.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor MacDonald and SECONDED by Councillor Fisher that:
It was MOVED by Councillor Fisher and SECONDED by Councillor Murray that:
Councillor Fisher highlighted the inclusion of revenue recognition as a new risk area and questioned whether this was due to it being reviewed for the first time, and whether associated risk was expected to decrease in future years. [name removed] explained that revenue recognition was commonly treated as a standard risk.
Councillor Fisher questioned the apparent discrepancy on capital borrowing between the narrative in the report and the table on page 6 which showed that only £20m had been used for the Capital Programme, which was less than a third.
Councillor Fisher suggested that from a governance point of view that if this was correct, the narrative should be clarified to better explain this to public readers. [name removed] agreed to follow this query up.
Councillor Fisher highlighted the significant importance of Treasury Management operations to the Council and noted that this function had become increasingly essential to the work of the Audit & Governance Committee in recent years.
Treasury Management provided a considerable income stream for the Council and Councillor Fisher questioned whether the Committee should consider adopting different approaches to this going forward.
Councillor Fisher asked if any changes had been made and asked if an additional appendix could be added to future reports which would identify how things had changed, and any changes expected in the future year (such as the removal of Area Committees). [name removed] agreed to consider this suggestion.
In response to a suggestion raised by Councillor Fisher at a recent Executive meeting, [name removed] confirmed that consideration would be given to how borrowing could be more transparently reported and how borrowing for long-term assets and borrowing for operational purposes could be identified.
Councillor Fisher questioned the assessment of risk related to increases in Public Works Loan Board interest rates which had been scored as a probability of “1” (very low). [name removed] confirmed that this risk was tied to gilt yields and public spending forecasts which were seen as stable in the short term by the Council’s external advisors. It was acknowledged that over a longer period of time the risk could be more significant.
Councillor Fisher noted Risk No.1 “Climate Emergency” and commented that the likelihood of the risk materialising was at the maximum score of 6.
Councillor Fisher questioned whether this increased likelihood warranted the inclusion of additional planned control measures and if the timeline should be reviewed. [name removed] agreed to take this suggestion away for further consideration.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the £1.3 million reduced Business Rates Appeals provision should be shown in the Business Rates Reserve. The Director – Resources and Housing, Ian Blofield, reported that the Business Rates Reserve was reviewed as part of the Medium Term Financial Plan setting process and that whilst it was possible to change this, it would need to be planned.
Councillor Fisher asked whether more information could be given about the purpose of loans taken out by the Council. The Director – Resources and Housing reported that this was complex as borrowing for multiple reasons was pooled into different loans.
Councillor Fisher commented that in the context of Local Government Reorganisation the Council’s financial performance was likely to come under increased scrutiny and suggested that showing the amount of borrowing which was asset backed would be helpful.
Councillor Fisher commented that there had been lots of short-term borrowing over the past year due to high long-term interest rates.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the Plan varied from existing practice. The Head of Planning and Development reported that the Plan formalised existing practices and that the Harm Assessment Form was the main new element.
Councillor Fisher said that whilst the document was very comprehensive, it seemed wasteful to have created 180 pages on 80 schemes which were unlikely to be funded, and commented that it was indicative of the difficulty of getting things done.
Councillor Fisher said that it was disappointing that a policy was required and asked whether it would impact on the Be Aware List.
Councillor Fisher noted that there had been a significant increase in the number of complaints not being dealt with within agreed timescales and asked if this needed to be looked into further.
Councillor Fisher commented that consideration should be given to extending timescales if they could not be achieved.
Councillor Fisher expressed concern that as the £59,000 was not allocated to particular areas , some parts of the town might miss out.
Councillor Fisher commented that the process for the allocation of Community Chest Grants seemed overly convoluted and was concerned that organisations might miss out if they came up with good ideas which Councillors hadn’t thought of.
Councillor Fisher asked whether compensation should be awarded on a discretionary basis given the Council’s difficult financial position.
Councillor Fisher noted that one of the justifications for paying compensation was that it protected the Council’s reputation and commented that the Council’s reputation as a housing provider was perhaps less important given that tenants generally didn’t choose to move into Council accommodation.
Councillor Fisher suggested that that service failures being addressed was more important than compensation being paid.
Councillor Ross reassured Councillor Fisher that the Council did always try to resolve service failures and reported that compensation was an effective way of putting things right for residents, as well as reducing the likelihood of them taking other action which would ultimately cost the Council more, such as housing disrepair claims.
Councillor Fisher noted that there had been a significant increase in the value of payments in 2024/25 and asked whether this was because of a few bad cases or a general increase in the number of people compensated.
Councillor Fisher thanked Councillor Ross for addressing his concern that compensation was simply being used to make difficult cases go away.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the strategy could be shared with the owners and managers of other high-rise buildings in Ipswich.
Councillor Fisher commented that the outside amenity space was insufficient for the needs of two children, ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Councillor Fisher noted the concerns raised in the representation from the owner of No.12 Malvern Close regarding the proximity of car parking to the boundary being contrary to Policies DM17 and DM18.
Councillor Fisher raised concern regarding the adequacy of the room sizes; whilst the current proposal was intended to only be used for temporary accommodation, Councillor Fisher was concerned that by granting planning permission, the property could be used by future occupants as an HMO with room sizes that would not meet the minimum standards.
Councillor Fisher commented that this would be an excellent addition to the street scene in Ipswich and the UK exclusivity of the installation would help raise the town’s profile.
Councillor Fisher highlighted that the current positioning ... view the full minutes text for item 15.
Councillor Fisher noted that the University of Suffolk was listed as a stakeholder/air quality partner and asked what role it played.
Councillor Fisher asked who had been consulted under the category of “bodies representing local business interests”.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the model used in this policy was specific to Ipswich Borough Council or a generic model that was used by other authorities.
Councillor Fisher asked whether landlords had the choice of accepting a civil penalty or being prosecuted and defending themselves at court.
Councillor Fisher commented that whilst he supported the policy, he did not feel comfortable about previous non-compliance and convictions being taken into account as this weighted the process too much towards one side.
Councillor Fisher asked whether this information was captured on a national database or held within each authority and shared across authorities.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the proposed policy was future-proofed against any changes arising from the Bill becoming legislation.
Councillor Fisher commented that ... view the full minutes text for item 122.
Councillor Fisher commented that there was an issue of perception and said that increased education and enforcement were needed to prevent waste being left on Town Centre streets.
Councillor Fisher asked whether enforcement was planned to be increased. The Director – Operations and Place, James Fairclough, reported that Executive had previously decided to explore a Waste Enforcement Contract and that a report on this would be brought back to Executive in due course.
Councillor Fisher commented that he was pleased that the response aligned with the Council’s aims in relation to Local Government Reorganisation.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor MacDonald and SECONDED by Councillor Fisher:
Councillor Fisher noted that more audit differences had been identified compared to previous years and asked if this was because it was an incomplete audit, things had been considered differently or for other reasons. [name removed] advised that the level of adjustments had been higher across a number of audits completed this year. It was noted that the preparation and quality of the work was always going up and therefore, different data and different questions may be asked compared to previous audits.
Councillor Fisher noted the Local Government Reorganisation taking place and asked if this was something to be concerned about with regards to future audits and ensuring that there were fully audited accounts. [name removed] explained that every set of accounts within other Local Governments in Suffolk were in a similar position and were consistent with each other in terms of where they were. The Audit sector was awaiting guidance regarding how to rebuild assurances.
Councillor Fisher noted that the reserves were below the set minimum reserves balance however; there was a significant number of reserves and contingencies held in other funding pots. The minimum balance had recently been raised from £2m to £4m due to financial volatility; however, the reserves were now below this.
Councillor Fisher asked from a governance perspective whether it was more important to make a surplus in the accounts, to keep contingencies and reserves, or to keep to the minimum working balance.
Councillor Fisher commented that he had been against raising the minimum reserves balance and that he did not understand why it had been set if the Council was prepared to go below it.
Councillor Fisher raised concerns regarding the governance arrangements around Treasury Management. It was understood that there were rules in place and procedures that Officers had to follow; however, the large loss this Quarter had been due to an increase in Capital Financing costs, with three large loans being taken out for cash-flow purposes.
Councillor Fisher commented that he did not feel that the governance arrangements were strong enough as the decisions made by Officers had had a large impact on the General Fund.
Councillor Fisher asked if the current governance arrangements should be reviewed, noting that Officers could take these decisions without any political oversight.
It was agreed that the points raised by Councillor Fisher would be discussed with Ian Blofield, Director – Resources & Housing, and followed up at the next Audit & Governance Committee meeting.
Councillor Fisher asked if the Corporate Fraud service undertook any work relating to business rates and write-offs, referencing a situation regarding a specific company. [name removed] advised that some aspects of work were undertaken in relation to business rates, with information provided to the National Crime Agency if required. The team worked collaboratively with the Shared Revenues Partnership service and controls had been improved, such as requesting more robust evidence of occupation.
Councillor Fisher asked if the post could be regraded. It was explained that the post had been regraded twice by IBC and then regraded higher when it was moved to East Suffolk Council. This was a bespoke area and hard to employ however, East Suffolk Council would be going out to advert again.
Councillor Fisher asked if the extensions to deadlines were for the right reasons. [name removed] confirmed yes and advised that it was one of her duties and responsibilities to monitor all recommendations.
Councillor Fisher commented that the biggest change in the General Fund position this quarter seemed to be attributed to capital financing costs and asked if this linked to the loans recently taken out.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the anticipated capital receipts would cover all of the 2 year loan or just the interest costs.
Councillor Fisher noted from the General Fund summary and Liability Benchmark graph that there appeared to be a funding gap of £60-80million over the next 3-4 years and so further loans would be required, and asked whether this would require the sale of further capital assets to cover the loan interest costs.
Councillor Fisher commented that most of the relief was offered to voluntary sector organisations but noted that any business could apply and asked if this happened.
Councillor Fisher asked how the policy criteria of ‘The Interest of Council Tax Payers’ was applied, i.e.
Councillor Fisher noted the progress made with 91% of the Council’s fleet producing zero emissions and asked whether any of the electric vehicles would need to be replaced soon, highlighting the need to consider resale prices which could be comparatively lower as electric vehicles depreciated quite quickly.
The budget amendment which had been circulated electronically prior to the meeting was MOVED by Councillor Fisher and SECONDED by Councillor Phillips.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor MacDonald and SECONDED by Councillor Fisher that:
Councillor Fisher asked whether the significant increase in Revenue Support Grant from 2026/27 was realistic. The Director – Resources and Housing, Ian Blofield, reported that an expert financial advisor had been used to estimate future years Revenue Support Grant payments.
Councillor Fisher expressed concern that earmarked reserves were being used for ... view the full minutes text for item 87.
Councillor Fisher said that the policy was useful for tenants but commented that it was vague about what outcomes might be in some areas where enforcement type action was needed.
Councillor Fisher commented that he recognised that the Council had a budget gap to fill but said that the Town Centre was already struggling and that he therefore didn’t agree with the proposed increases.
Councillor Fisher said that he welcomed the introduction of season tickets at Crown Car Park but said that this had taken far too long to put into place.
Councillor Fisher commented that there were also 1/3 rd fewer shops in Ipswich Town Centre than there had been in 2011.
Councillor Fisher noted that the Council had the right to object to the consultation being made public and asked for more information about this. The Head of Planning, James Mann, reported that the regulations would require Suffolk County Council to resolve any objections from Ipswich Borough Council before progressing its consultation but noted that there was no intention to lodge an objection.
Councillor Fisher welcomed the good recovery of housing debts and asked whether, given the ongoing cost of living pressures, it was possible to limit the rise in council rents, instead of applying the maximum increase.
Councillor Fisher asked whether sheltered housing tenants had been consulted on the increase of service charges over the next 3 years and whether it would be affordable for them.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the sheltered housing service charge was payable as a one-off yearly payment at the beginning of the year or as payments spread across the year.
Councillor Fisher was proud of the housing offered in Ipswich and of the work done to tackle homelessness, and congratulated officers on their continued success in securing government funding for homelessness initiatives.
Councillor Fisher noted from the Housing Strategy that the Ipswich population was projected to decrease by 2% by 2043 whilst the number of households was projected to increase by 3% and commented that there had already been greater demand for smaller houses and flats.
Councillor Fisher questioned why the housing targets for Ipswich were so high given that the number of households were only due to rise by 3%, which he calculated as a further 97 houses per annum.
In reference to the consultation response from a member of the public, Councillor Fisher welcomed the work being undertaken with Suffolk County Council and schools to tackle idling vehicles outside schools, and asked whether this work could be extended to other areas where idling could be an issue, for example, taxi ranks.
Councillor Fisher was concerned about rushing to prioritise some of these schemes without considering the wider implications: the provision of a crossing on Star Lane/Key Street that prioritised non-car traffic could increase congestion in the one-way system and worsen air quality; reducing car trips to the town centre by 50% by 2030 would seriously impact car park income and the Council’s finances.
Councillor Fisher noted the £750k contribution towards fit out costs and asked whether this was only for changes to the building to make the area suitable or if it would also provide items to fit out the Hub, e.g. desks, computers.
Councillor Fisher commented that there was a number of empty town centre buildings and asked whether there was a more suitable building that would cost less to fit out so that more of the grant could be used on the Hub itself instead of on the alteration of a Council building.
Councillor Fisher commented that he had seen the other Hub locations provided by the proposed tenant and added that it was surprising that there wasn’t another building where the Hub could be created and fitted out for less than £750k and asked whether the Hub had to be in a Council building.
Councillor Fisher highlighted the increased cost of the system and questioned whether it was appropriate to enter into a contract of this length given the potential changes to council structures arising from the Local Government Reorganisation.
Councillor Fisher asked for further clarification regarding the methodology used to agree the impact rating for the risks, noting that Climate Emergency had been given a higher grading than Finance. [name removed] explained that the grading and risk matrix was used when reviewing the risk register and each risk would be considered by all members of the Corporate Management Team to discuss the impact and agree the grades given to each risk. It was noted that the impact rating was on a scale of 1-4 and judgement was used to decide what grade would be given and identify which grade related to Red, Amber and Green.
Councillor Fisher raised that the Council was borrowing to support its cashflow and investing a lot in Capital Spend and noted that it appeared that considerable borrowing would be required for a number of years.
Councillor Fisher asked from a governance perspective, if there was a target number that should not be exceeded with regards to how much of the Council’s income was being used to repay its debt.
Councillor Fisher asked if the Public Works Loan Board borrowing was linked to interest rates or the gilt market and if this could raise issues for the Council. [name removed] confirmed that the PWLB was strongly linked to the gilt market as it was owned by the Government. The Council tracked interest rates on a daily ... view the full minutes text for item 41.
Councillor Fisher noted that the complaints process could be stressful for Councillors and that the 9 complaints received had not been assessed as a breach of the Code of Conduct.
Councillor Fisher asked if there was a set timescale that complaints had to be assessed and responded to. [name removed] acknowledged that Code of Conduct matters could be concerning to Councillors and advised that once a complaint was received, the Councillor would be contacted as soon as possible. There were a number of variables when dealing with these matters; this included requiring further clarification from the complainant and ensuring all forms were completed.
In response to Councillor Fisher, [name removed] explained that for any high-volume impact areas, such as Housing, the Corporate Fraud Team were involved as part of the gateway checks and due diligence work required at the start. It was noted that the Corporate Fraud Plan 2025-26 identified the areas within the Council which had risk profiles in place and an in-depth exercise had been undertaken with each Head of Service to record what corporate fraud risks were within that area, which would then be considered as part of the Fraud Risk Wheel. This was a good governance practice for anti-fraud which had been established by CIPFA.
Councillor Fisher noted that no whistleblowing reports had occurred in the last 12 months and asked if employees were aware of the whistleblowing procedures or if more publicity of this was required to enable employees felt safe reporting concerns. [name removed] confirmed that the whistleblowing policy was promoted frequently at the Council, raised at Senior Management meetings. Training on this would also be provided to senior officers by Protect, who was the UK’s leading whistleblowing charity.
Councillor Fisher referred to the Housing Benefits 2023/24 report and raised concerns regarding the 3 rd Action which had been given a target date of 31 March 2025.
All Council employees had a mandatory responsibility to report concerns if they believed a child was at risk and Councillor Fisher asked if a refresh for relevant service areas was required. [name removed] confirmed that in this instance the issue was immediately rectified, and the processes would be changing in response to this. [name removed], Assistant Director - Governance, advised that the suggestion for further safeguarding training would be considered further.
Councillor Fisher raised the potential Local Government reorganisation in the future and asked from a governance point of view if, as and when the decision took place, the Work Programme should include a set procedure around this that could be considered on a regular basis. 50.2. Shirley Jarlett, Assistant Director – Governance, advised that this would be considered when the Risk Register was reviewed, with the expectation that a new risk would added.
Councillor Fisher commented that paragraph 2.8 of the report was inaccurate as the Government was not intending to continue with the previous government’s spending plans in many areas.
Councillor Fisher noted that the Council had borrowed £30m to support its cashflow and said that finance costs were now 15% of revenue.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the Council was convinced that it would be able to repay its debts.
Councillor Fisher said that he did not feel it was unreasonable to ask a question about figures contained in the report presented and reiterated his question about the affordability of the Council’s borrowing.
Councillor Fisher noted that the budget was just 4% higher than the previous contract and that inflation had been significantly higher than this and asked how the increase in costs was expected to be limited to that amount.
Councillor Fisher commented that the proposed sale would be at the lowest price per acre achieved so far and asked for confirmation that the Council was not selling the site at a low price just to get a capital receipt. The Head of Property, Mel Chiknagi, explained that as this was a larger plot than the others a lower price per acre was to be expected; a letter of reassurance had been provided by the Council’s property agents confirming that, in their opinion, the sale represented best value.
Councillor Fisher commented that the proposed sale would allow the developer to make a profit on the development, an opportunity which he said that Council should have taken up.
Councillor Fisher said that the state would not break even as £3.9 million of public funding had been provided by the Local Enterprise Partnership (LEP) and commented that private developers made money out of redeveloping similar sites.
Councillor Fisher felt that these weren’t comparable because the Council didn’t own the land on which the Garden Suburb would be built.
Councillor Fisher commented that there had been less of an issue in 2024 than in 2023 and he hoped that there would be a continued improvement.
Councillor Fisher noted that the Council was paying Ipswich Central £100,000 to update the All About Ipswich website and asked whether Ipswich.love could work with Ipswich Central on providing one listings website.
Councillor Fisher noted that the BBC had submitted an FOI request to IBC which identified that there were a large number of unpaid fines for car parking. In response to this, the Council’s spokesperson and Portfolio Holder for the area had advised that a new clamping service had been introduced.
Councillor Fisher asked why the log identified in the report, which was not being updated, was rated ‘low risk’.
Councillor Fisher thanked [name removed] and her team for their work. It was
Councillor Fisher noted that the anticipated costs over 3 years were lower than the spend over the past 3 years and asked how this saving would be achieved. The Head of Waste and Fleet, Chris Taylor, reported that the specifications of tyres had been changed, to get the right tyres for the right vehicle. Since beginning this approach, savings of 11% had been made.
Councillor Fisher asked whether tenants would have to move out during works and how this would be managed if it was needed.
Councillor Fisher asked how leaseholders would be impacted. The Assistant Director – Housing reported that there was a legal process by which leaseholders had to be engaged with in relation to works and that this would be followed, in the same way as for other improvements.
Councillor Fisher asked whether there was a reason there were so many write-offs proposed in this quarter.
Councillor Fisher noted that there were very large variances, totalling around £3 million, in the first ... view the full minutes text for item 36.
Councillor Fisher asked how the cost pressures identified in quarter one would reduce in future years.
Councillor M Cook explained that there were a range of reasons which the Section 151 Officer could provide to Councillor Fisher with outside the meeting.
Councillor Fisher said that the proposal to introduce brown bin collections seemed likely to make a substantial profit despite being listed as a proposal where the cost recovery principle would be applied and asked for an explanation of this.
Councillor Fisher asked whether, if the service did make a profit, charges could be reduced in the future.
Councillor Fisher commented that there had been many issues raised around procurement at the Audit and Governance Committee and that he was disappointed that more changes hadn’t been made to what he described as a failing strategy.
Councillor M Cook asked Councillor Fisher to provide details of the issues which had been raised and the remediations he wished to see.
Councillor Fisher commented that these were included in various audit reports and in minutes of that committee’s meetings and that as Portfolio Holder Councillor M Cook should have looked at these.
Councillor M Cook said that he received copies of every internal audit report issued and saw the papers for the Audit and Governance Committee but felt that it was reasonable for Councillor Fisher to have to say specifically what he felt was wrong with the strategy.
Councillor Fisher noted that previously it had been hoped that the Regeneration Fund would be self sustaining and asked whether the proposals were for grants or if there was the possibility of these being loans. The Chief Executive reported that where the Council was acting as developer it might be possible to generate a return, and that whether any return was possible from the five owner/developer led proposals would depend on the detailed work which would be undertaken in the proposed development phase.
The Chair welcomed all present, including Councillor Ross, the Portfolio Holder for Housing, Councillor Fisher, the Lead Signatory for the call-in, and Ian Blofield, Director for Resources and Housing.
Councillor Fisher asked whether a demoted tenancy was a new enforcement option and if not, how often it was used.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the Council could do more to get people to downsize from under-occupied properties.
Councillor Fisher commented that whilst he supported the proposal to even out the increase over a number of years, he was concerned about the overall cost of administering and enforcing the scheme, suggesting that these should be reduced.
Councillor Fisher commented that greater freedom in relation to pavement licences was one of the good things which had happened as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Councillor Fisher said that he would prefer to see a greater number of charging categories, with the aim of making it easier and cheaper for small businesses.
Councillor Fisher commented that the fees, particularly for smaller businesses, seemed too high.
Councillor Fisher commented that paragraph 1.2 of the plan should be amended as it was not possible to ensure that all established eating places were rated 3, 4 or 5 in the national Food Hygiene Rating Scheme.
Councillor Fisher asked whether there was an error in paragraph 2.8 of the report, which said the tender would be assessed 60% on price and 40% on quality. The Assistant Director – Housing, confirmed that this should read 60% quality and 40% price.
Councillor Fisher asked why it was thought to be more cost effective to outsource this work, given that the Council had performed well on inspecting properties in 2023/24.
Councillor Fisher commented that he would prefer the work to be carried out by Council staff who could be trusted to do it well and prioritise residents safety, adding that he expected most of the checklist of 29 inspection points were already carried out by staff.
Councillor Fisher said that he wasn’t aware that outside contractors had been used for these inspections in the past and asked why it had been decided to do so now and how this was more cost-effective.
Councillor Fisher suggested that he might seek to call the decision in if answers to these points were not provided.
Councillor Ross offered to meet with Councillor Fisher outside of the meeting if that would be useful.
Councillor Fisher said that the Council’s failure to achieve its savings targets was disappointing, commenting that he had repeatedly been reassured by the administration that the savings targets would be achieved.
Councillor Fisher asked whether, given that the budgetary position was better than expected, raising parking charges could be avoided.
Councillor Fisher also asked whether borrowing for cashflow had taken place previously.
Councillor Fisher said that he opposed raising parking charges and suggested that by increasing charges the Council could encourage people to use other car parks, potentially meaning that income would not be increased.
Councillor Fisher commented that price comparisons with Norwich and Colchester didn’t reflect the relatively low wages in Ipswich.
Councillor Fisher suggested that a discount scheme for Ipswich residents would be welcome.
Councillor Fisher commented that since July 2022 charges had risen at double the rate of inflation, with Season Ticket prices increasing by 40%.
Councillor Fisher commented that it was not the role of the opposition to tell the administration how they would make savings.
Councillor Fisher asked why certain charges, for example the Coach Parking Fee, were not proposed to increase.
Councillor Fisher asked for confirmation that Suffolk County Council was responsible for provision for Care Leavers. The Head of Housing Advice, Bridie Green, confirmed that Suffolk County Council was responsible for this until the age of 18, or in certain circumstances, up to the age of 25.
Councillor Fisher noted that he had expressed concern about the level of demand when the proposal for additional chargers was originally made and commented that the Council ought not to rush in to providing the latest technology before the market had been given the opportunity to do so.
Councillor Fisher agreed that charging for the use of electric vehicle chargers was right and said that as electric vehicles tended to be owned by better off people it would be better to spend the money on subsidising bus services or other targeted support.
Councillor Fisher asked that the restoration levy funds be managed carefully to ensure that funds were available for future improvements.
Councillor Fisher commented that it was good to see the progress made but noted that concerns had been raised by a taxi driver about the loss of taxi rank spaces in Lloyds Avenue and asked whether there had been any consultation. The Director – Operations and Place, James Fairclough, reported that there had been two meetings with taxi drivers and that they were opposed to the loss of any capacity. Analysis of CCTV had shown that the maximum demand was 15 cars; only 11 spaces were proposed as part of the scheme but it was considered that this was the maximum number possible whilst delivering the objectives of the scheme.
Councillor Fisher noted that it was hoped that the scheme would increase footfall and therefore potentially demand for taxis and asked if other provision could be made.
Councillor Fisher asked whether a condition requiring bollards along the new footpath could be imposed. The Senior Planning Officer noted that Suffolk County Council had not proposed any bollards and that imposing a condition regarding the highway without the agreement of the Highways Authority would be difficult to defend or implement; an informative could however be added if that was the Committee’s wish.
Councillor Fisher declared a pecuniary interest in this item, and left the room during its consideration.
Councillor Fisher commented that the plans seemed very good but said that he was concerned about how the masterplan would be funded.
Councillor Fisher commented that the budget agreed in February 2024 had stressed the Council’s poor financial position, whilst the proposals would cost a significant amount.
Councillor MacDonald commented that Councillor Fisher had previously accused the administration of lacking ambition and was now criticising an ambitious plan.
Councillor Fisher commented that he thought the proposal was unaffordable and suggested that releasing images soon before the pre-election period was suspicious.
Councillor Fisher said that he agreed a feasibility study should be done around the Council’s office accommodation but said that the Grafton House site was not suitable for accommodation; he was also concerned about the message converting the Council’s offices to housing would send to the business community.
Councillor Fisher noted that Grafton House had been purpose built for Ipswich Borough Council and so felt it unlikely that a building from which services could be delivered more effectively would be found.
Councillor Fisher raised concerns about the proportion of Working from Home by Council staff and the contractual arrangements around this.
Councillor Fisher commented that Officers contracts should be changed to force them to work from home for a proportion of the time to ensure that there were enough desks available if the office space was reduced.
Councillor Fisher said that he was in favour of the recommendations except for those at paragraphs 14.4 and 14.5 of the report which related to future uses and redevelopment of the Grafton House site.
Councillor Fisher commented that many Councils were behind in their auditing, and it was positive that IBC was on target for where it was expected to be, which provided the Committee reassurance.
Councillor Fisher thanked the Officers for their work achieving this.
Councillor Fisher commented that at the beginning of this financial quarter the Council had been confident that the annual savings target would be met; however, at present only 30% of savings had been identified.
Councillor Fisher asked for further reassurance ... view the full minutes text for item 54.
Councillor Fisher thanked Officers for their time and efforts reviewing the Risk Register. It was suggested that under Climate Emergency, the planned control measure which stated “£9.6m capital funding for insultation, replacement boilers and PV panels for Council Houses in the period April 2021 to March 2025” be removed, as the target to be carbon neutral by 2030 only included Council services and operations, not the Council’s housing stock. [name removed] agreed that this would be removed.
Councillor Fisher asked if the work undertaken around trading companies had concluded and if [name removed] was assured that no further work would be required for 2024/25. [name removed] confirmed that the work was complete and the three proposed actions/recommendations, which were not of an overall material nature, were being considered by the Senior Management Team. The report would be issued to members as soon as possible.
In response to a question from Councillor Fisher, [name removed] confirmed that as she was independent, she could release any report stating that the actions had not been agreed; however, it was very rare to do so and was not anticipated on this occasion.
Councillor Fisher praised the position of the status of agreed actions and asked if the two actions under Resources and Housing would be completed on time. [name removed] confirmed that it was anticipated that the actions would be completed by the deadline.
Councillor Fisher praised the Police for the decrease in crimes and advised that the statistics should be highlighted to members of the public as often the perception of crime was much higher than it actually was.
Councillor Fisher commented that £1.212 million being released from Service Reserves suggested that there were in fact general reserves which could be used to support the Council’s overall financial position.
Councillor Fisher noted that efficiency savings had not been achieved and asked whether more significant cuts to services would soon be needed to balance the Council’s budget.
Councillor Fisher asked for reassurance that the Council was not putting off difficult savings and thereby making its financial position worse.
Councillor MacDonald assured Councillor Fisher that the administration took its priority to be a financially sustainable Council very seriously.
Councillor Fisher asked what mechanism would be put in place for monitoring progress against the action plan. The Chief Executive explained that the peer review team would return in the ... view the full minutes text for item 115.
Councillor Fisher asked why there were no external consultees on this strategy, commenting that input from those outside the Council would help ensure the latest technology was used where appropriate.
Councillor Fisher commented that a combined Digital and Communications Strategy might have been a good idea and asked whether the Council could work more closely with Suffolk County Council and others to co-ordinate messaging and communications.
Councillor Fisher noted that a large number of changes were proposed to the Council’s Contract Standing Orders and asked why that was the case.
Councillor Fisher noted that there were no tracked changes in the document and asked whether there had been significant changes.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the proposed two stage approach would increase cost. The Head of Major Capital Schemes reported that further design work was needed on the second phase which it was hoped would reduce the costs of that phase.
Councillor Fisher commented that the report misrepresented the number of jobs which had been created at the site as three of the buildings included in the number of jobs had not been constructed.
Councillor MacDonald noted that Councillor Fisher had been sent the breakdown of the 900 jobs to be created as a result of the development but agreed that some of these jobs would only exist once the units under development were occupied.
Councillor Fisher commented that it was good to see progress on the existing sites and asked whether future sites for development had been identified to maintain the pipeline of new Council homes.
Councillor Fisher commented that the cost increase amounted to 75% of Council Tax income for one year and that he hoped that lessons had been learnt about project planning and cost control.
Councillor Fisher added however that the spending could not now be avoided and hoped that the museum would be a place that the town could be proud of.
Councillor Fisher asked what would happen if further external funding could not be obtained. The Director for Operations and Place, James Fairclough, said that lessons had been learnt and noted that expert advice had always been sought and followed in designing the project. There was a significant contingency built into the revised budget and so further increases were not expected.
i) that Councillor Fisher replace Councillor Wilson on Planning and Development Committee;
Councillor Fisher queried the figure of 900 jobs having been created as a result of the redevelopment of the site and asked for a breakdown of this figure, also commenting that some of the jobs would be in the ‘gig economy’.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the new roundabout required to access the site would alleviate flooding issues on Sproughton Road. The Senior Estates Surveyor, Chris Bull, confirmed that the roundabout would be designed in consultation with Suffolk County Council and that it was hoped that its construction would help to alleviate existing flooding issues in the area.
Councillor Fisher asked for clarification regarding the £133k annual savings identified for external audit costs. [name removed] advised that a budget had been provided for the initial estimate when the increased audit fees were first reported from PSA; however, this had been less than anticipated.
Councillor Fisher commented that the earmarked reserves in both the HRA and General Fund had increased by a considerable amount and asked why this was not included as part of the report. [name removed] agreed to consider how the reports could better explain what reserves the Council had and the movement between them.
Councillor Fisher asked if the Committee should be concerned that the £1million additional interest on balances in the HRA had not been identified earlier. [name removed] advised that the HRA had a significant amount of money reserved for the build programme. Due to delays, the General Fund was ... view the full minutes text for item 41.
Councillor Fisher commented that he was concerned that reserves weren’t being reported clearly, suggesting that many of the Earmarked Reserves could be used to support the Council’s overall budgetary position.
Councillor Fisher asked why the Housing Revenue Account had benefitted from an additional £1m of income from interest.
Councillor Fisher asked why Property Services - Rental Income had decreased by £145k. The Section 151 Officer agreed to look into this and report back ... view the full minutes text for item 78.
Councillor Fisher noted that the strategy refered to housing meeting the Decent Homes Standard rather than the Ipswich Standard, and asked why this was.
Councillor Fisher noted that there would be a high number of internal and external surveys under the proposals and asked whether the Council would be able to complete these.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the reference to stopping repairing assets which were unviable in the long term referred to any specific properties such as the prefabs in Rushmere Ward.
Councillor Fisher asked whether references to Data Led Asset Management meant that cyclical replacement would be reduced or stopped.
Councillor Fisher expressed concern that the benchmarking report had not been commissioned sooner and used to inform the strategy and hoped that the document could be changed if that proved to be necessary.
Councillor Fisher asked whether more measurable targets could be set.
Councillor Fisher commented that funding of the local shopping parade programme was due to be announced shortly, so there might be some mitigation included in the proposed improvements for the Meredith Road shopping centre.
Councillor Fisher commented that Adshel had confirmed that they would reinstate the bus shelter but were waiting on SCC to schedule the works to minimise the impact on traffic.
Councillor Fisher noted that some homes had been left without water due to recent storms and highlighted that Anglian Water operated a ‘priority services register’ for vulnerable people or those with young families and would deliver bottled water to those affected; to sign up to this register, apply via the Anglian Water website:
Councillor Fisher commented that this was the most important element of the Towns Fund programme and noted that ideas for how it could be spent were invited.
Councillor Fisher asked for reassurance that ideas suggested by the Conservative Group would be considered appropriately, saying that in the past he felt ideas had not been taken seriously just because they had come from his group.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the ... view the full minutes text for item 69.
Councillor Fisher commented that he was concerned about funding for the All About Ipswich website being given to Ipswich Central, as they hadn’t advertised the tender to carry out the improvements to the work until 8 September, having given a deadline for queries of 25 August.
Councillor Fisher was also concerned that the opportunity had never been listed on the Ipswich Central website, which under their operating agreement, they were supposed to do.
Councillor MacDonald said that Officers would look into the issues raised by Councillor Fisher and noted that the Council was answerable to the Town Deal Board for its spending of Towns Fund money.
Councillor Fisher noted that the project was quite large and asked whether there was confidence in the timetable for delivery, noting that there was a 4-month gap between the delivery of Group 1 projects and the closure of that element of the project.
The gap referred to by Councillor Fisher was to allow payment and paperwork to be completed after projects had been carried out on site.
Councillor Fisher noted that this report had been considered by Executive in September 2023 and was now out of date, with the Quarter 2 report likely to be completed shortly. It was requested that where possible, scrutiny could be more effective if the report was considered by the Audit & Governance Committee closer to the time it was completed.
Councillor Fisher asked for reassurance that the thematic service reviews were progressing. [name removed] confirmed that a number of reviews had started, and progress reports would be provided in due course.
Councillor Fisher noted that income from car parking and sports had largely decreased over the years and asked why the predicted income had been so high as there had been no changes to the economic position of the Council. [name removed] advised that there had been regular shortfalls each year for both services. A £5m contingency income was set up in the first year of the pandemic and it was agreed that budgets would be retained at pre-pandemic levels and the contingency funds would be used to top them up.
Councillor Fisher noted that the Treasury Management report referred to the risk of non-compliance with the CIPFA code and asked for assurance that the Council was doing everything it could to comply with the code of practice. [name removed] advised that both codes were being complied with.
Councillor Fisher commented that businesses would look to the Council when deciding how to vote, noting that an abstention was said in the report to appear similar to a vote against the proposal.
Councillor Fisher asked whether Executive knew how Ipswich Borough Assets might vote in relation to its ballot.
Councillor Fisher asked whether the Council should send its thoughts on Explore Suffolk to Locus, the BID proposer, so that businesses could see what the Council’s position was.
Councillor Fisher asked what the Executive thought about the number of businesses not directly involved the visitor economy who would have to pay the levy, giving the example of a Dyslexia Charity shop.
Showing the latest 300 of 716.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Fisher attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 Sep 2019 | North West Area Committee | NWAC/19/07 Funding Request: Let's Talk Reading Literacy Programme | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Jul 2017 | Council | To Consider a Motion from Councillor R Pope | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Nov 2016 | Council | C/16/13 To Consider a Report from Councillor D Ellesmere on the Norfolk & Suffolk Devolution Proposal. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Sep 2016 | Council | C/16/07 To Consider a Report from Mrs K Forster, Chair of the Independent Remuneration Panel, on a Review of Councillors' Allowance Scheme. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jun 2016 | Council | Motion to Council - Suffolk Solidarity | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Fisher was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 11 of 18 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Fisher declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 Mar 2026 | Council, item 59 | Councillor Fisher declared a pecuniary interest in this item, and left the room during its consideration. | Left the room |
| 20 Mar 2024 | Council, item 71 | Councillor Fisher declared a pecuniary interest in this item, and left the room during its consideration. | Left the room |
Where Councillor Fisher sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2016 | 76 | |
| Executive | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 73 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Audit & Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2016 | 42 | |
| Planning & Development Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 14 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing & Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 3 | |
| North West Area Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2016 | 48 | |
| Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee | Guest | Jul 2017 | 5 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.