CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Ipswich/Councillor Oliver Holmes
OH

Councillor Oliver Holmes

Ipswich CouncilSt Margaret's wardLiberal DemocratCouncillor since 2016
Follow Councillor Holmes's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
92%meetings attended218 of 237 since 2016, apologies 11
185times in the minutesAsked 52, said 75, moved 2, seconded 1
4recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
8declarations at meetingsLeft the room for 5 items
2committees in the last year5 committees in all

On the record

Every time Ipswich's minutes name Councillor Holmes, as the council published it.

Said3 Jun 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/26/01 Item 1 - Applications IP/25/00532/LBC & IP/25/00533/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that there was little detail provided about the community use areas, and asked whether these areas should be more strictly defined as Use Class F2 with no permitted development rights to control the future use of these areas.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 3 Jun 2026, item 9Open the meeting
Said3 Jun 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/26/02 Item 2 - Application IP/26/00014/FUL

Councillor Holmes noted that the application was compliant with Local Plan policies, but asked about the consideration of the wider public health implications, such as obesity, under paragraphs 96 and 97 of the NPPF relating to promoting good health and preventing ill-health, and refusing applications for hot food takeaways within walking distance of schools and other places where children/young people might congregate. The Planning Officer commented that there was a greater need to consider these matters and added that this aspect should have been included as part of the planning balance argument.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 3 Jun 2026, item 10Open the meeting
Said3 Jun 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/26/01 Item 3 - Application IP/25/00920/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that there was no specific use class category for aparthotels and questioned whether Use Class C1 was appropriate as there was nothing to restrict its use as service accommodation and this was not intended as residential accommodation. Whilst most stays were expected to be for 1-3 days, the proposed conditions allowed for a maximum of 90 days, in line with the London standards for Air BnB accommodation, which was used for employee/emergency accommodation, which would not be appropriate in this location.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 3 Jun 2026, item 11Open the meeting
Asked3 Jun 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/26/01 Item 3 - Application IP/25/00920/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked whether the sole/main residence element of  ...  view the full minutes text for item 11.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 3 Jun 2026, item 11Open the meeting
Said3 Jun 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/26/01 Item 5 - Application IP/26/00156/FPI3

Councillor Holmes commented that it was disappointing that the scheme proposed in the previous year had not been progressed and added that the boundary wall should be removed.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 3 Jun 2026, item 13Open the meeting
Said3 Jun 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/26/01 Item 5 - Application IP/26/00156/FPI3

Councillor Holmes highlighted that the car park was in a poor state of repair and commented that the reference in the planning balance to not undertaking works as it would be a wasteful use of public money was not a material consideration as other applicants for temporary car parks could make the same argument.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 3 Jun 2026, item 13Open the meeting
Said29 Apr 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/14 Information for Councillors, including Planning Enforcement Update 2025/26 Quarter 4

Councillor Holmes noted that Ipswich Sports Club had appealed one of the conditions and asked whether this had happened before or after the latest planning application for this site.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 29 Apr 2026, item 119Open the meeting
Said4 Mar 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/13 Information for Councillors

Councillor Holmes noted that a number of appeals against the installation of telecom hubs had been lost by the Council.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 4 Mar 2026, item 111Open the meeting
Asked7 Jan 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/11 Item 2 - Application IP/25/00595/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked whether the Management Plan included conditions with regards to litter control and whether daily inspections would be undertaken.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Jan 2026, item 92Open the meeting
Asked7 Jan 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/11 Item 2 - Application IP/25/00595/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked what items would be sold at the kiosk, and whether the proposal included outdoor seating.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Jan 2026, item 92Open the meeting
Said7 Jan 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/11 Item 3 - Application IP/25/00613/VC

Councillor Holmes raised concern regarding the proposed extension of operating hours, noting that when planning permission was previously granted, hours of use had been restricted to 8.00pm.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Jan 2026, item 93Open the meeting
Asked7 Jan 2026Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/11 Item 3 - Application IP/25/00613/VC

Councillor Holmes questioned why an extension to 10.00pm was being considered before the facility had opened and suggested that it would be more appropriate to monitor any issues first.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Jan 2026, item 93Open the meeting
Asked12 Nov 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/09 Item 1 - Application IP/25/00604/FUL

Councillor Holmes sought clarification on the definition of “vulnerable adults” which was not a planning or legal definition. The proposal was for a care home within use class C2, and the broad nature of the term could potentially cover individuals with mild dementia through to more complex needs, such as substance abuse.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 12 Nov 2025, item 75Open the meeting
Asked12 Nov 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/09 Item 1 - Application IP/25/00604/FUL

Councillor Holmes questioned whether the condition could be strengthened to specify more precisely the category of adults receiving respite care.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 12 Nov 2025, item 75Open the meeting
Said25 Jun 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/02 Information for Councillors

Councillor Holmes commented that the Council’s housing supply target had been vastly increased, and it would be more difficult to demonstrate a 5-year supply of housing land; therefore, the loss of appeals similar to 93 Spring Road could become a common occurrence.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 25 Jun 2025, item 30Open the meeting
Said28 May 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/25/01 Item 6 - Application IP/25/00224/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that DM19 would apply as residential units of this type could, and did, accommodate families. Additionally, the construction of a new primary school in the town centre provided justification that nearby family housing would be appropriate and needed in the area.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 28 May 2025, item 14Open the meeting
Said30 Apr 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/13 Item 5 - Application IP/24/00980/FUL

Councillor Holmes noted that the site was within the curtilage of the listed building, 167 Norwich Road, and asked whether there would be any consequent harm to the setting of 167 Norwich Road.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 30 Apr 2025, item 109Open the meeting
Asked30 Apr 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/13 Item 5 - Application IP/24/00980/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked whether permission had been requested to remove the trees as the site was in a conservation area.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 30 Apr 2025, item 109Open the meeting
Said30 Apr 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/13 Item 6 - Application IP/25/00093/VC

Councillor Holmes commented that the proposed tenure had been a key concern to residents when the original application was considered. The change to the National Planning Policy Framework in December 2024 set out the rationale for increasing the provision of social and affordable rent but was subject to the caveat of viability. The Chair commented that other developers had cited viability issues as a reason for not being able to provide affordable housing and therefore it was not unreasonable for this to apply to Council led developments.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 30 Apr 2025, item 110Open the meeting
Said5 Mar 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/11 Item 1 - Application IP/24/00004/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented on the sequencing of this application, which had been determined in August 2024 and had now returned with viability issues, which were probably known to the applicant in August but were now being considered as a discrete issue away from the main consent.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 5 Mar 2025, item 87Open the meeting
Said5 Mar 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/11 Item 1 - Application IP/24/00004/FUL

Councillor Holmes added that the NPPF encouraged the front loading of viability matters in decision making.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 5 Mar 2025, item 87Open the meeting
Said5 Mar 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/11 Item 2 - Application IP/24/00358/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that the site had been in continuous use for 50 years and was therefore not a temporary or meanwhile use as the use of the land as a car park had been established; consequently, the application should either be refused or granted a permanent approval.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 5 Mar 2025, item 88Open the meeting
Asked5 Mar 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/11 Item 2 - Application IP/24/00358/FUL

Councillor Holmes questioned whether 50 years as a ‘temporary’ use was contrary to the tests of reasonableness set out in the National Policy Practice Guidance and added that the applicant had used a string of temporary consents to avoid improving the site.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 5 Mar 2025, item 88Open the meeting
Named5 Mar 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/11 Item 3 - Application IP/25/00019/FPI3

Councillor Holmes concurred with the comments made by the Conservation & Design Officer that the continued use was undesirable, especially given the damage to the Waterfront Conservation Area. As the site was due to be developed within the next few months, there was little benefit to the public from this application.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 5 Mar 2025, item 89Open the meeting
Named5 Mar 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/11 Item 3 - Application IP/25/00019/FPI3

With regards to the assertion that if the site was left vacant it would attract anti-social behaviour, Councillor Holmes referred to the appeal decision of the St Margaret’s Green Car Wash application and the Planning Inspector’s view that the potential for anti-social behaviour had not been evidenced and therefore this matter should be given limited weight.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 5 Mar 2025, item 89Open the meeting
Declared5 Feb 2025Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, being known to one of the objectors, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/24/00597/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 5 Feb 2025, item 73Open the meeting
Said5 Feb 2025Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/10 Item 5 - Application IP/24/00995/FPI3

Councillor Holmes commented that his concerns about discouraging modal shift had been highlighted by SCC Highways in paragraph 3.2 of the report; however, there were plans for the redevelopment of this site that would hopefully come forward in the future.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 5 Feb 2025, item 79Open the meeting
Said11 Dec 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/09 Item 5 - Application IP/24/00633/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that this was an unsuitable property for a children’s home, highlighting the comments from Suffolk Constabulary that this was an  ...  view the full minutes text for item 68.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 11 Dec 2024, item 68Open the meeting
Asked24 Oct 2024Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/24/09 Report of the Homelessness and Rough Sleeping Strategy Task and Finish Group

Councillor Holmes asked whether the Task and Finish Group had received any evidence about what type of accommodation homeless men were placed in.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 24 Oct 2024, item 27Open the meeting
Declared16 Oct 2024Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, being known to one of the objectors, declared an interest in Item 2 (IP/24/00597/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 16 Oct 2024, item 55Open the meeting
Said16 Oct 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/08 Item 3 - Application IP/24/00586/VC

Councillor Holmes welcomed the amendment to Condition 2 to offer the use to nearby businesses rather than use by Crown House occupants only.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 16 Oct 2024, item 59Open the meeting
Named16 Oct 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/08 Item 3 - Application IP/24/00586/VC

Councillor Holmes still had concern about the impact of increasing the level of long-stay parking on modal shift given the car park being under-utilised and the demand for long-stay parking.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 16 Oct 2024, item 59Open the meeting
Asked18 Sep 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/24/07 Information for Councillors

Councillor Holmes asked whether any application for costs had been made in relation to the upheld appeals for the multifunctional communication hub applications.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 18 Sep 2024, item 51Open the meeting
Said24 Apr 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/14 Item 4 - Application IP/23/00959/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented on the width of the egress from the canopy roof and whether this could be made narrower to improve safety for pedestrians and other users.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 24 Apr 2024, item 123Open the meeting
Said6 Mar 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/11 Item 3 - Applications IP/22/01068/FUL & IP/22/01069/ADV

Councillor Holmes commented that it was unlikely that the existing permission would be built out at this stage resulting in 2 Hubs in proximity of each other.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 6 Mar 2024, item 100Open the meeting
Said6 Mar 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/11 Item 3 - Applications IP/22/01068/FUL & IP/22/01069/ADV

Councillor Holmes highlighted that the Planning Inspector had allowed a similar permission to be granted on appeal at this location previously.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 6 Mar 2024, item 100Open the meeting
Moved6 Mar 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/11 Item 4 - Applications IP/22/01059/FUL & IP/22/01060/ADV

Councillor Holmes proposed the recommendations in the report but there was no seconder.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 6 Mar 2024, item 101Open the meeting
Said6 Mar 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/12 Reducing Emissions: Low Carbon Guide for Developers

Councillor Holmes requested that information about the use of biomass boilers be included under section 10: Planning approach to installing different renewable technologies.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 6 Mar 2024, item 105Open the meeting
Said21 Feb 2024Central Area Committee

Policing Update

Councillor Holmes commented that illegal parking was happening on Arras Square outside St Stephens Church and asked whether  ...  view the full minutes text for item 59.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 21 Feb 2024, item 59Open the meeting
Said7 Feb 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/10 Item 1 - Application IP/22/01081/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that viability was the main issue but policy CS17 offered discretion to waive S106 contributions in line with demonstrated viability, and a condition was proposed to revisit viability on the occupation of the 20 th dwelling. Councillor  ...  view the full minutes text for item 87.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Feb 2024, item 87Open the meeting
Said7 Feb 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/10 Item 2 - Application IP/23/00357/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that the previous requirement for biodiversity net gain off site was not enforceable and highlighted that the woodland was not included in the application site.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Feb 2024, item 88Open the meeting
Said7 Feb 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/10 Item 4 - Application IP/23/00937/FPI3

Councillor Holmes commented that policy SP34 did not apply as it was unlikely that the proposed multi-storey car park provision would be delivered by 2026.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Feb 2024, item 90Open the meeting
Said7 Feb 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/10 Item 4 - Application IP/23/00937/FPI3

Reflecting on the recent appeal decision for St Margaret’s Green, Councillor Holmes commented that the presumption that a vacant site would be prone to vandalism could not be given weight unless there was evidence to support that claim.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Feb 2024, item 90Open the meeting
Named7 Feb 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/10 Item 5 - Application IP/23/00938/FPI3

Councillor Holmes reiterated the points raised on the previous temporary car park application.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Feb 2024, item 91Open the meeting
Asked7 Feb 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/10 Item 5 - Application IP/23/00938/FPI3

Councillor Holmes questioned the provision of electric vehicle charging points on this site which was to be provided as part of the proposed multi-storey car park development and asked whether the planning permission for that development was still extant.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Feb 2024, item 91Open the meeting
Said7 Feb 2024Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/10 Information for Councillors

Councillor Holmes welcomed the dismissal of the appeal for the temporary car park application on St Margaret’s Green and the view taken by the Planning Inspector in protecting heritage assets from harm.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Feb 2024, item 92Open the meeting
Said15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee

Unconfirmed Minutes of Previous Meeting

Re: Minute 53 (Application IP/23/00527/FUL), Councillor Holmes requested that the following context be included prior to his proposal to move the recommendations in the report:
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 58Open the meeting
Said15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee

Unconfirmed Minutes of Previous Meeting

“Councillor Holmes raised the following points:
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 58Open the meeting
Declared15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, being known to one of the objectors, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/23/00416/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 60Open the meeting
Named15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/07 Item 2 - Application IP/23/00685/FUL

Councillor Holmes concurred that the EV charging provision was inadequate given that other developments were providing much higher provision, for example, the permission for the Portman Road multi-storey car park would have EV charging capacity for up to 40% of its 750 spaces; increasing the EV charging provision would help to address air quality issues in the nearby AQMA on Star Lane.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 63Open the meeting
Asked15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/07 Item 2 - Application IP/23/00685/FUL

Councillor Holmes also questioned the lack of an AQEA given that the previous permission had expired in June 2022 and there had been no continuing use.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 63Open the meeting
Said15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/07 Item 2 - Application IP/23/00685/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that the NPPF stated that it was rarely justifiable to grant  ...  view the full minutes text for item 63.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 63Open the meeting
Named15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/07 Item 3 - Application IP/23/00689/FUL

Councillor Holmes reiterated the points that he raised in relation to application IP/23/00685/FUL.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 64Open the meeting
Asked15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/07 Item 3 - Application IP/23/00689/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked when the Ipswich Area Parking Plan, which would set out the provision of public car parks, was likely to come forward.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 64Open the meeting
Declared18 Oct 2023Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, being known to the applicant, declared an interest in Item 3 (IP/23/00633/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 18 Oct 2023, item 51Open the meeting
Asked6 Sep 2023Central Area Committee

CAC/23/07 Area Committee Application Form and Funding Guidelines

Councillor Holmes asked whether any applications were turned down as they didn’t meet the criteria and if this was reported to the Area Committee.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 6 Sep 2023, item 24Open the meeting
Said6 Sep 2023Central Area Committee

Community Intelligence - Verbal Update from Councillors

Councillor Holmes commented that there had been an increase in large mastiff-type dogs in parks and asked if the Council’s dog control Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) was working, i.e.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 6 Sep 2023, item 27Open the meeting
Said23 Aug 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/04 Information for Councillors

Councillor Holmes highlighted that the appeal decision for the Pooleys Yard application, which was outside of the central car parking core, had been allowed due to the lack of multi-storey car park provision on Portman Road.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 23 Aug 2023, item 40Open the meeting
Said23 Aug 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/23/04 Information for Councillors

Councillor Holmes highlighted that in the appeal decision relating to the mooring of the vessel on Wherry Quay, the Planning Inspector had cited that a second temporary permission was rarely justified and further permissions could normally be granted permanently.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 23 Aug 2023, item 40Open the meeting
Named11 Jul 2023Executive

E/23/14 New Way Depot Update

Councillor Smart also commented that it would now be very expensive and cause significant delays to move away from using Handford Developments to manage this project and questioned what Councillor Holmes thought the Council might do if it weren’t happy with Handford Developments experience.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 11 Jul 2023, item 27Open the meeting
Named28 Jun 2023Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, highlighted that he was known to the applicant, but did not have any other interest to declare in respect of Agenda Item 1 (IP/23/00351/FUL)
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 28 Jun 2023, item 17Open the meeting
Asked21 Jun 2023Central Area Committee

CAC/23/04 Funding Request: Chapter 82

Councillor Holmes asked whether there was any scope for funding for areas of educational deficiency following the review of the Opportunity Area funding.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 21 Jun 2023, item 11Open the meeting
Asked8 Mar 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/13 Item 2 - Application IP/22/01014/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked about the level of contamination on the land given the previous light industrial use on this site.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 8 Mar 2023, item 110Open the meeting
Said8 Mar 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/13 Item 4 - Application IP/23/00032/FPI3

Councillor Holmes highlighted that this application was requesting a longer meanwhile use of 5 years, compared to previous 2-year permissions, and asked whether improved surfacing and EV charging points should be requested.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 8 Mar 2023, item 112Open the meeting
Asked8 Mar 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/15 Suffolk Design Streets Guide

Councillor Holmes asked whether there was a sufficient differential between urban and rural street design, given the difference between Ipswich and the rest of Suffolk.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 8 Mar 2023, item 116Open the meeting
Declared1 Mar 2023Central Area Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes declared a non-pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 9 (CAC/22/15) Funding Request: Eastern Angles Theatre Company as he was previously a Trustee of Eastern Angles.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 1 Mar 2023, item 53Open the meeting
Said8 Feb 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/12 Consultation on Changes to the Planning System - December 2022

Councillor Holmes highlighted that the proposed changes at national and local planning authority level were conflicting and welcomed the Officers’ response to this consultation.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 8 Feb 2023, item 103Open the meeting
Said8 Feb 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/12 Consultation on Changes to the Planning System - December 2022

Councillor Holmes commented that the lessening of presumption and weight of balance was also significant and added that failure to deliver new housing had resulted in a loss of New Homes bonus in recent years.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 8 Feb 2023, item 103Open the meeting
Named11 Jan 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/10 Item 1 - Application IP/22/00767/FUL

In response to Councillor Holmes, the Development Management Team Leader confirmed that the Fison signage on the east elevation would be retained and not be painted over.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 11 Jan 2023, item 89Open the meeting
Said11 Jan 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/10 Item 2 - Application IP/22/00647/FUL

Councillor Holmes highlighted the listed buildings adjoining the site and the walled Jewish Cemetery within the site and was concerned that granting 5 years’ consent would remove any incentive to redevelop this unsightly vacant area.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 11 Jan 2023, item 90Open the meeting
Said11 Jan 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/10 Item 2 - Application IP/22/00647/FUL

Councillor Holmes added that the car park was currently an unauthorised use as the previous permission had expired early last year and highlighted that the applicant had not complied with the conditions of the previous consent.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 11 Jan 2023, item 90Open the meeting
Asked11 Jan 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/10 Item 2 - Application IP/22/00647/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked whether the proposed conditions for improvements to the car park could be made as pre-commencement conditions to ensure that they could be enforced.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 11 Jan 2023, item 90Open the meeting
Asked11 Jan 2023Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/10 Item 3 - Application IP/22/00913/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked whether there should be a condition to return the site to its original state when the proposed use expired in 7 years’ time.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 11 Jan 2023, item 91Open the meeting
Asked14 Dec 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/09 Item 2 - Application IP/22/00836/FUL

Councillor Holmes questioned the validity of the application as no  ...  view the full minutes text for item 79.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 14 Dec 2022, item 79Open the meeting
Said2 Nov 2022Central Area Committee

Responses to Public Questions

Councillor Holmes highlighted that there had been discussions a couple of years ago relating to an anti-idling policy for cars in the central area of Ipswich and asked for clarification as to which authority had the jurisdiction to enforce anti-idling.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 2 Nov 2022, item 33Open the meeting
Said2 Nov 2022Central Area Committee

Policing Update

Councillor Holmes noted the recent increase in burglaries and asked whether any publicity campaign was being considered to encourage residents to report incidents as many people had become reluctant to use the 101 reporting service due to lengthy delays.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 2 Nov 2022, item 34Open the meeting
Said19 Oct 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/07 Item 2 - Application IP/22/00220/FUL

Councillor Holmes noted that the Press had published an article on 5 October 2022 that stated that ‘the recommendation of officers was expected to be that permission be granted’ and questioned whether this was pre-determination.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 19 Oct 2022, item 59Open the meeting
Asked19 Oct 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/07 Information for Councillors, including Planning Enforcement Update

Councillor Holmes queried whether the property in paragraph 2.3 of the Planning Enforcement update should be 28 Churchill Avenue.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 19 Oct 2022, item 64Open the meeting
Named21 Sep 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/06 Items 2 & 3 - Applications IP/22/00682/LBC & IP/22/00683/FPI3

Councillor Holmes supported the bin storage area being internal and suggested that 240-litre bins be used to enable them to be manoeuvred out of the building more easily.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 21 Sep 2022, item 51Open the meeting
Asked7 Sep 2022Central Area Committee

Policing Update

Councillor Holmes asked whether the gang related violence had arisen from organised crime.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 7 Sep 2022, item 21Open the meeting
Said7 Sep 2022Central Area Committee

CAC/22/08 Area Action Plan

Councillor Holmes suggested that the reference to mitigating the effects of the pandemic be removed.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 7 Sep 2022, item 24Open the meeting
Named7 Sep 2022Central Area Committee

CAC/22/08 Area Action Plan

Councillor Holmes did not agree with the terminology ‘alleviate deprivation’ and was concerned that as St Margaret’s ward did not feature in the areas of deprivation there would be no opportunity for residents from this area to apply for funding.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 7 Sep 2022, item 24Open the meeting
Said24 Aug 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/05 Item 2 - Application IP/22/00542/REM

Councillor Holmes raised concern over the small number of cycle spaces proposed for the Visitor Centre as there should be greater encouragement of sustainable modes of transport.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 24 Aug 2022, item 40Open the meeting
Said24 Aug 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/05 Item 3 - Application IP/22/00337/FUL

Councillor Holmes commented that not all of the conditions under the previous permission had been discharged to an acceptable standard.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 24 Aug 2022, item 41Open the meeting
Asked24 Aug 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/05 Information for Councillors

Councillor Holmes asked about the procedure for the appeal relating to 1 Kettlebaston Way.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 24 Aug 2022, item 44Open the meeting
Named7 Jul 2022Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for Absence

Councillor Trenchard attended as a substitute for Councillor Mortimer, Councillor Rae attended as a substitute for Cllr C Smart, and Cllr Holmes attended as a substitute for Cllr T Lockington.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 7 Jul 2022, item 3Open the meeting
Said22 Jun 2022Central Area Committee

Policing Update

Councillor Holmes reported that there had been  ...  view the full minutes text for item 7.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 22 Jun 2022, item 7Open the meeting
Said1 Jun 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/22/01 Item 1 - Application IP/22/00253/VC

Councillor Holmes commented that Use Class E was rather broad and was concerned that the provision of medical/health services in Unit M could lead to an increase of traffic that would not be appropriate for a district centre.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 1 Jun 2022, item 9Open the meeting
Said27 Apr 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/21/14 Item 1 - Application IP/21/00692/FUL

Councillor Holmes raised concerns regarding the lack of lift provision and advised that this would stop people with mobility issues or other physical disabilities from being able to access the flats.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 27 Apr 2022, item 140Open the meeting
Asked27 Apr 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/21/14 Item 2 - Application IP/21/01148/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked if the proposed pedestrian route would be a dedicated public footpath up to the junction on Henley Road and if signage would be implemented to show that the footpath could be used by the public.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 27 Apr 2022, item 141Open the meeting
Said6 Apr 2022Planning & Development Committee

PD/21/13 Information for Councillors, including Planning Enforcement Update

Councillor Holmes welcomed the progress made on the Hay Hill Allotment site towards compliance with the planning conditions for this development, which was often difficult to achieve once the developers were no longer on site.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 6 Apr 2022, item 134Open the meeting
Said2 Mar 2022Central Area Committee

CAC/21/13 Funding Request: Restitute

Councillor Holmes noted that there had been only one family supported in Central Ipswich in 2 years and asked how engagement would be developed going forward.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 2 Mar 2022, item 54Open the meeting
Asked2 Mar 2022Central Area Committee

CAC/21/13 Funding Request: Restitute

Councillor Holmes also asked about the rationale behind supporting the partners of men who were arrested for accessing online child pornography.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 2 Mar 2022, item 54Open the meeting
Said2 Mar 2022Central Area Committee

Community Intelligence - Verbal Update from Councillors

Councillor Holmes commented that a new Statutory Instrument had been issued in relation to moving traffic offences that could potentially allow for enforcement action to be taken by the Council on behalf of SCC Highways, but this would require SCC to apply to the Department for Transport for this power to be transferred.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 2 Mar 2022, item 62Open the meeting
Asked2 Mar 2022Central Area Committee

Community Intelligence - Verbal Update from Councillors

Councillor Holmes asked for this matter to be raised with County Councillor West.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 2 Mar 2022, item 62Open the meeting
Asked5 Jan 2022Central Area Committee

CAC/21/08 Funding Request: Restitute

Councillor Holmes sought clarification on the definition of ‘victims of crime’ for this service; for example, were partners of people arrested for accessing online child pornography considered as ‘victims of crime’, and who could be referred/self-refer to this service, would this be anyone with a connection to the victim of crime.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 5 Jan 2022, item 42Open the meeting
Asked5 Jan 2022Central Area Committee

CAC/21/09 Spending Proposal: Greenways Countryside Project

Councillor Holmes asked if there was any plan to make the river path a cycle path as well.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 5 Jan 2022, item 43Open the meeting
Seconded17 Nov 2021Council

C/21/15 To Consider a Report from Councillor B Rudkin on the Adoption of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on British Muslims' Definition of Islamophobia.

It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor Rudkin and SECONDED by Councillor Holmes:
From the council's minutes: Council, 17 Nov 2021, item 36Open the meeting
Said10 Nov 2021Central Area Committee

Policing Update

Councillor Holmes noted that residents were often concerned that they did not hear back from police after making reports and that they then contacted Councillors. Inspector Mann agreed to discuss options for providing feedback to residents with colleagues.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 10 Nov 2021, item 28Open the meeting
Said10 Nov 2021Central Area Committee

CAC/21/05 Review of Park Byelaws

30.5        Councillor Holmes commented that it would be useful if the byelaws referred directly to drones and e-scooters. The Operations Manager for Parks and Cemeteries explained that the byelaws used legal terminology, but that signage and communications would be much clearer.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 10 Nov 2021, item 30Open the meeting
Asked22 Sep 2021Planning & Development Committee

PD/21/05 Item 1 - Application IP/21/00720/FUL

Councillor Holmes asked about the likely occupants of this development, if there was any limit on the number of people occupying each room and whether the proposed office areas could be converted to bedrooms, especially as there was no reference to the office areas in the Management Plan.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 22 Sep 2021, item 58Open the meeting
Asked22 Sep 2021Planning & Development Committee

PD/21/05 Information for Councillors, including Planning Enforcement Update

Councillor Holmes questioned why addresses had not been provided in relation to some of the cases in the report. The Planning & Development Operations Manager commented that addresses were not disclosed at this stage whilst there was a possibility of the issues being resolved without the need for formal enforcement action.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 22 Sep 2021, item 61Open the meeting
Named7 Sep 2021Executive

E/21/30 Financial Management & Control: Corporate Budget Monitoring - 2021/22 Quarter 1

Question 1 – Councillor Holmes on behalf of Councillor I Lockington Within the Quarterly Finance report we read in 6.1 that 11% of the savings for this year has been identified; is the Portfolio Holder sure he will be able to find the 89% and which of the 5 listed areas will be able to supply most of the savings for this year?
From the council's minutes: Executive, 7 Sep 2021, item 55Open the meeting
Named7 Sep 2021Executive

E/21/31 Parks Toilets

Question 2 – Councillor Holmes on behalf of Councillor T Lockington On 6th October 2020, I asked the Executive if there was ongoing work to replace all publicly owned and operated water-cleansed male urinals with dry toilet urinals, for environmental and long-term financial benefit. I am therefore pleased to see this item coming forward, but disappointed that the ecological as well as financial benefit of dry water systems are lightly represented in the agenda item. Can the Portfolio Holder assure me that when these proposals go out to consultation the ecological and financial benefits from major reduction in water consumption are fully represented in the accompanying literature and that there will be a clear explanation of the intended benefits posted at Park entrances and within the current toilets, to assist public understanding?
From the council's minutes: Executive, 7 Sep 2021, item 56Open the meeting
Named2 Sep 2021Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for Absence

Councillor Holmes attended as substitute for Councillor T Lockington.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 2 Sep 2021, item 10Open the meeting
Said25 Aug 2021Planning & Development Committee

PD/21/04 Item 3 - Application IP/21/00408/FUL

Councillor Holmes pointed out there was an extensive tree belt but raised concern about site visibility and flood lighting.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 25 Aug 2021, item 49Open the meeting
Named28 Jul 2021Council

To Receive any Declarations of Interest.

Item 8 – C/21/04 Revised local List SPD Councillor Holmes, who owned a property which was proposed to be included on the local list, declared a pecuniary interest in this item and left the room during its consideration.
From the council's minutes: Council, 28 Jul 2021, item 13Open the meeting
Said7 Apr 2021Planning & Development Committee

PD/20/18 Information for Councillors

Councillor Holmes commented that it was disappointing that enforcement action had been required to progress the historical issues relating to the Hayhill Allotments development. The Planning & Development Operations Manager commented that Officers were engaging with the developer regularly to ensure that these outstanding issues were progressed.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 7 Apr 2021, item 111Open the meeting
Asked10 Mar 2021Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes questioned whether the Conservative members of the Committee were required to make a declaration in light of the representation made on behalf of their Group in relation to Item 1 (IP/20/00781/FUL).
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 10 Mar 2021, item 98Open the meeting
Asked3 Mar 2021Central Area Committee

CAC/20/15 Funding Request: St Helen's Primary School Alleyway Mural

Councillor Holmes asked whether the mural was a removable display and if it would be resilient to ASB.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 3 Mar 2021, item 58Open the meeting
Said3 Mar 2021Central Area Committee

CAC/20/16 Funding Request: Future Inclusions - BAME Food Parcel Service

Councillor Holmes highlighted that the request was two-thirds administrative costs and one-third food costs and asked whether other funding was being used to provide the food.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 3 Mar 2021, item 59Open the meeting
Said3 Mar 2021Central Area Committee

Community Intelligence - Verbal Update from Ward Councillors

Councillor Holmes reported that he had been advising residents to use the Ipswich Furniture Project to collect large items to prevent fly-tipping in the area.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 3 Mar 2021, item 61Open the meeting
Declared13 Jan 2021Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, being a volunteer at the Ipswich Winter Night Shelter, declared an interest in Item 5 (IP/20/01001/FPI3).
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 13 Jan 2021, item 76Open the meeting
Asked6 Jan 2021Central Area Committee

CAC/20/12 Funding Request: Disability Advice Service (East Suffolk)

Councillor Holmes asked about the number of referrals and how many people in Central Ipswich would benefit.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 46Open the meeting
Said6 Jan 2021Central Area Committee

Community Intelligence - Verbal Update from Ward Councillors and SCC Councillors

Councillor Holmes commented that air quality remained an issue for local residents.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 49Open the meeting
Asked11 Nov 2020Central Area Committee

CAC/20/10 Adoption of the Central Area Committee Area Action Plan

Councillor Holmes asked whether non-COVID related applications were still being received.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 11 Nov 2020, item 35Open the meeting
Named23 Sep 2020Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, being a fellow Liberal Democrat Councillor to both of the applicants, declared an interest in Item 2 (IP/20/00637/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this item.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 23 Sep 2020, item 45Open the meeting
Said23 Sep 2020Planning & Development Committee

PD/20/09 The Planning White Paper 'Planning for the Future' and 'Changes to the current Planning System' Consultations

Councillor Holmes highlighted the democratic deficit in the plans and added that the public would only be able to make comments at the start of the plan period.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 23 Sep 2020, item 51Open the meeting
Said23 Sep 2020Planning & Development Committee

PD/20/09 The Planning White Paper 'Planning for the Future' and 'Changes to the current Planning System' Consultations

Councillor Holmes commented that the White Paper intended to make housing the priority, but the delivery of housing in Ipswich was not being delayed by the planning system, which was operating very efficiently.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 23 Sep 2020, item 51Open the meeting
Asked26 Aug 2020Planning & Development Committee

PD/20/07 Business and Planning Act and other changes to Planning Legislation

Councillor Holmes asked whether Officers would be submitting a response to the Planning White Paper consultation. The Planning & Development Operations Manager reported that the deadline for this consultation was mid-October and added that a summary paper would be brought to the appropriate Committee.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 26 Aug 2020, item 41Open the meeting
Said15 Jul 2020Central Area Committee

CAC/20/02 Funding for COVID-19 Related Projects

14.2        Councillor T Lockington requested that any new one-off project/service providers be mindful of, and encouraged to engage with, established voluntary groups already operating in the same area to ensure that there was efficient integration of services and to avoid any overlap of projects.  14.3        Councillor Holmes noted that the closing date for applications was 6 August 2020 and whether this would provide enough time for applicants to apply.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 15 Jul 2020, item 14Open the meeting
Declared1 Jul 2020Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, being known to the applicant, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/19/01140/FUL) and left the room during the consideration of this item.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 1 Jul 2020, item 14Open the meeting
Asked10 Jun 2020Central Area Committee

Updates from Ipswich Borough Council and Other Public Sector Organisations

Councillor Holmes asked whether there had been any progress in respect of the anti-social behaviour at the top of Fonnereau Road.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 10 Jun 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Asked10 Jun 2020Central Area Committee

CAC/20/01 Area Committee Grants and Financial Update

Councillor Holmes asked whether a 10% allocation for the Making a Difference budget was different to previous years and whether Councillors would still be involved in the allocation of this budget.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 10 Jun 2020, item 7Open the meeting
Asked10 Jun 2020Central Area Committee

CAC/20/01 Area Committee Grants and Financial Update

Councillor Holmes questioned whether the setting of objectives for the Area Committee Area Action Plan had been postponed due to the Coronavirus pandemic or whether this would be considered later in the year.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 10 Jun 2020, item 7Open the meeting
Named3 Jun 2020Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, having volunteered as an Overnight Team Leader at the Ipswich Winter Night Shelter, declared an interest in Item 2 (IP/20/00297/FUL).
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 3 Jun 2020, item 4Open the meeting
Asked4 Mar 2020Planning & Development Committee

PD/19/13 Item 3 - Application IP/20/00060/FUL

Councillor Holmes queried whether there should be an informative to highlight that no alterations would be allowed to the frontage of this building. The Development Management Team Leader commented that the existing informative could be strengthened to make reference to protecting the frontage of this building.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 4 Mar 2020, item 119Open the meeting
Said4 Mar 2020Planning & Development Committee

PD/19/16 Burlington Road Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Plan

Councillor Holmes commented that the Appraisal and Management Plans for some of the other Conservation Areas were also in need of review and asked whether it was intended to also bring these documents up to date. The Conservation and Design Officer reported that a couple of the Appraisal and Management Plans had already been redrafted to go out to public consultation, with the Park Conservation Area being the next one to be progressed.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 4 Mar 2020, item 123Open the meeting
Named4 Feb 2020Executive

E/19/49 Princes Street Car Park Extension

97.3       Councillor Barber explained that the legislation to which Councillor Holmes referred allowed local authorities to provide suitable parking within their area for the purposes of relieving or preventing congestion.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 4 Feb 2020, item 97Open the meeting
Named13 Nov 2019Planning & Development Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes clarified that the representation he had submitted in relation to Item 1 (IP/19/00022/FUL) was to highlight that the photographs originally submitted were of a different property; therefore, he did not need to make any declaration of interest in relation to this application.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 13 Nov 2019, item 72Open the meeting
Named29 Oct 2019Executive

E/19/34 Final Draft Ipswich Local Plan - Regulation 19

71.6       Councillor Jones commented that the figures in the plan were not, as Councillor Holmes had suggested, hopelessly optimistic.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 29 Oct 2019, item 71Open the meeting
Said18 Sep 2019Planning & Development Committee

PD/19/06 Item 4 - Application IP/19/00667/FPF

Councillor Holmes highlighted the need for the retention of the public rights of way in relation to the proposed Ipswich Garden Suburb development and the potential risk to the delivery of the foot/cycle bridge by the developer if the rights of way were to be altered.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 18 Sep 2019, item 55Open the meeting
Moved18 Sep 2019Planning & Development Committee

PD/19/07 Babergh and Mid Suffolk Councils Joint Local Plan Preferred Options (Regulation 18) Consultation

Councillor Holmes proposed that the fifth point of the Council’s proposed response be amended to also request contributions towards NHS medical services and public transport provision, and this was agreed.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 18 Sep 2019, item 57Open the meeting
Said11 Sep 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/19/09 Funding Request: Football and Wellbeing Programme

Councillor Holmes commented that the PCC also had funding available for diversionary activities for young people and added that there might be some synergy with that programme.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 11 Sep 2019, item 35Open the meeting
Named31 Jul 2019Central Area Committee

Presentation: Ipswich Northern Route Consultation

Councillor Holmes: Will the new route be a bypass/relief road or a strategic road? The outer route could be considered as a strategic road as it would complete the ring with the lower road.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 31 Jul 2019, item 22Open the meeting
Named31 Jul 2019Central Area Committee

Presentation: Ipswich Northern Route Consultation

Councillor Holmes:   In the highways modelling data published in January, it stated  ...  view the full minutes text for item 22.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 31 Jul 2019, item 22Open the meeting
Said31 Jul 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/19/06 Funding Request: Norwich Road Carnival

Councillor Holmes commented that it was not clear how this project met the funding objectives and how outcomes would be measured.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 31 Jul 2019, item 24Open the meeting
Said31 Jul 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/19/06 Funding Request: Norwich Road Carnival

Councillor Holmes also noted that the event was only 4 weeks away and asked whether commitments had been made.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 31 Jul 2019, item 24Open the meeting
Said31 Jul 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/19/06 Funding Request: Norwich Road Carnival

Councillor Holmes highlighted the minimal level of match funding and asked whether funding would be requested again next year.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 31 Jul 2019, item 24Open the meeting
Asked31 Jul 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/19/06 Funding Request: Norwich Road Carnival

Councillor Holmes asked about the closure of the highway and the current position with Suffolk Highways for permission to use the Barrack Corner location and noted that South Street had been the original location requested for this event.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 31 Jul 2019, item 24Open the meeting
Asked31 Jul 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/19/07 Spending Proposal: Wellesley Road Alley Gate

Councillor Holmes questioned whether this was a legacy issue as the budget for alley gates had been set up in January 2018 with its use subject to meeting the criteria of the new alley gate policy.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 31 Jul 2019, item 25Open the meeting
Asked24 Jul 2019Council

C/19/03 To Consider a Report from Councillor N Macdonald on the Ipswich Borough Council Housing Strategy 2019-24.

15.7       Councillor Holmes asked that the personal data of foreign rough sleepers not be shared with the Home Office to protect people from the results of the Government’s hostile environment policy.
From the council's minutes: Council, 24 Jul 2019, item 15Open the meeting
Named9 Jul 2019Executive

E/19/13 Proposal to Declare a Climate Emergency and Commit to Action to Achieve Carbon Neutrality

Question 1 – Councillor Holmes ‘Why has the Executive not put forward this proposal as a declaration for the full Council which is the position taken by the other councils, including Suffolk County Council, mentioned in the Report, which have declared climate emergencies?’ 26.4       Councillor Smart explained that it had been felt that the proposal needed action at the earliest opportunity and so rather than waiting for a debate at the next meeting of Council a report had been brought to Executive.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 9 Jul 2019, item 26Open the meeting
Named11 Jun 2019Executive

E/19/04 Tennyson Road Alley Gate

Question 3 – Councillor Holmes ‘Does the Executive consider that in light of the minuted assurances and resolutions of the Central Area Committee and this Executive, specifically:
From the council's minutes: Executive, 11 Jun 2019, item 9Open the meeting
Declared5 Jun 2019Central Area Committee

Declarations of Interest

Councillor Holmes, having worked at the Christ Church Night Shelter, declared an interest in Agenda Item 10 (report CAC/19/01).
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 5 Jun 2019, item 5Open the meeting
Asked6 Mar 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/18/22 Funding Request: Creative Computing Centre

Councillor Holmes asked how young people found out about the Club.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 6 Mar 2019, item 59Open the meeting
Asked28 Feb 2019Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/18/22 Annual Portfolio Holder Update - Community Protection and Customer Services

59.5     Councillor Holmes asked whether the lack of staff resources, resulting in the performance indicators LI 335 and LI 338 showing as ‘Red’, were temporary or were there ongoing problems with recruiting staff and Councillor Ross said that there was a shortage of skilled workers in this specialist area.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 28 Feb 2019, item 59Open the meeting
Named5 Feb 2019Executive

E/18/51 Response to Public Spaces Protection Order (PSPO) consultation

Question 1 – Councillor Holmes ‘Has the Executive abandoned proposals in the Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) consultation to make loitering an offence throughout Ipswich?’ Councillor Ross explained that the Council had not abandoned other proposed amendments to the PSPO, noting that paragraph 1.2 of the report stated that “A further report to the Executive is anticipated during 2019 to consider other areas of anti-social behaviour”.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 5 Feb 2019, item 118Open the meeting
Named5 Feb 2019Executive

E/18/51 Response to Public Spaces Protection Order (PSPO) consultation

Question 2 – Councillor Holmes ‘In relation to dog fouling provisions within the PSPO please could the Executive confirm:
From the council's minutes: Executive, 5 Feb 2019, item 118Open the meeting
Named5 Feb 2019Executive

E/18/52 Air Quality Action Plan

Question 3 – Councillor Holmes ‘ Does the Executive accept that the main national policy for improving air quality is now contained within the UK Plan for tackling roadside nitrogen dioxide concentrations (the 2017 Plan) and, if so, can they point to any researched and costed measures within the draft Air Quality Action Plan which will achieve the objective of reducing NO2 to legal compliance levels within the shortest time possible?’ Councillor Ross explained that the 2017 plan referred to by Councillor Holmes had been superseded by the Clean Air Strategy 2019 and the Road to Zero which were the Government’s main policy documents that addressed the issues of transport related air pollution.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 5 Feb 2019, item 119Open the meeting
Named5 Feb 2019Executive

E/18/52 Air Quality Action Plan

Question 4 – Councillor Holmes ‘How can the Executive demonstrate required reductions in NO2 emissions in Ipswich within the shortest possible time when the Local Plan Revision Policy DM3 anticipates that further congestion is likely to be generated within existing Air Quality Management Areas leading to increased NO2 emissions and that further roads are likely to become designated as AQMAs?’ Councillor Ross explained that action plan contained 27 actions which demonstrated how the Council and its partners intended to address air quality in Ipswich. The completion dates were considered realistic but challenging and had been designed to ensure that momentum was maintained to improve air quality.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 5 Feb 2019, item 119Open the meeting
Said9 Jan 2019Central Area Committee

Responses to Public Questions Received and Open Discussion on Local Issues

Councillor Holmes reported that he and Councillor Lockington had seen drug activity taking place in the open at 11.30am on Saturday around Tuddenham Avenue and Cemetery Road.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 9 Jan 2019, item 44Open the meeting
Said9 Jan 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/18/19 Spending Proposal: Ipswich Museums Workshops for School Visits

Councillor Holmes commented that this project met with the criteria of the Ofsted Framework to provide a broader curriculum and suggested that the workshops be publicised to school teachers.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 9 Jan 2019, item 45Open the meeting
Asked9 Jan 2019Central Area Committee

CAC/18/18 Funding Request: Out Loud Music Mural at South Street

Councillor Holmes asked about the lease arrangements on the two buildings. [name removed] reported that the main building was 2 years into a 15-year lease and the Smokehouse was 2 years into a 5-year lease with the option to re-negotiate for a further 5 years.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 9 Jan 2019, item 48Open the meeting
Named3 Jan 2019Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Highways England - Orwell Bridge Update

49.5     Councillor Holmes made reference to the considerable noise and pollution disturbances both in and around Ipswich as HGV’s travel the diversion routes through the town and villages especially at night time. [name removed] said that the guidelines suggest that where possible dual carriageways were used as alternative routes, away from schools and hospitals but there were not many options although future work could include looking at upgrading the standard of the diversion routes e.g. repairing potholes or loose drains. As the condition  ...  view the full minutes text for item 49.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 3 Jan 2019, item 49Open the meeting
Named27 Nov 2018Executive

E/18/32 Ipswich Local Plan Review Preferred Options

Question 2 – Councillor Holmes ‘As Suffolk County Council are likely to abandon construction of the Upper Orwell Crossings, which form a central part of transport planning under the Review, should not the Executive postpone the Review until the position is clear and appropriate alternative proposals are brought forward?’ Councillor Jones said that the Council should not postpone the consultation on the review of the Local Plan.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 27 Nov 2018, item 81Open the meeting
Named27 Nov 2018Executive

E/18/32 Ipswich Local Plan Review Preferred Options

Question 3 – Councillor Holmes ‘Will not the change to indicators for Key Objective 6, namely removing a 15% target for modal shift and replacing it with an essentially meaningless platitude to “… increase the proportion of journeys undertaken by sustainable means…” ensure car transport will overwhelmingly remain the method of travel in Ipswich until 2036 with the certainty of increased congestion and deteriorating air quality?’ Councillor Jones explained that the target set out in Chapter 11 for Objective 6 had been linked to the Travel Ipswich scheme but  ...  view the full minutes text for item 81.
From the council's minutes: Executive, 27 Nov 2018, item 81Open the meeting
Asked22 Nov 2018Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Ipswich Park & Ride Update

44.4     Councillor Holmes asked whether statistics for individual shoppers or commuters were recorded or just cars entering the Park & Ride sites?
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 22 Nov 2018, item 44Open the meeting
Said14 Nov 2018Planning & Development Committee

PD/18/06 Item 1 - Application IP/18/00833/FUL

Cllr Holmes, Ward Councillor for St Margaret’s, spoke on behalf of the local residents in objection to the proposals:- -         Officers report sets out the criteria for this application to be judged.
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 14 Nov 2018, item 63Open the meeting
Said27 Sep 2018Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/18/09 Write-Offs of Bad Debts 1 April 2017 - 31 March 2018

24.2     Councillor Holmes expressed concern about problems encountered with any business rate avoidance scheme and asked whether enough was being done to identify and deal with the problem as soon as it occurred.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 27 Sep 2018, item 24Open the meeting
Asked27 Sep 2018Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/18/11 Annual Portfolio Holder Update - Culture, Leisure and Corporate Support

26.4     Councillor Holmes asked whether the Culture & Leisure Working Group still met and the Portfolio Holder said that a future date would be set for a Working Group meeting at the Regent Theatre. She expressed concern about there being no consistent commitment to attend the Group which would enable a better understanding, especially around budget setting.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 27 Sep 2018, item 26Open the meeting
Asked27 Sep 2018Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/18/11 Annual Portfolio Holder Update - Culture, Leisure and Corporate Support

Councillor Holmes asked if there was a set pattern of regular meetings and the Portfolio Holder said that there was but there was no consistency of attendance of members.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 27 Sep 2018, item 26Open the meeting
Asked27 Sep 2018Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/18/11 Annual Portfolio Holder Update - Culture, Leisure and Corporate Support

The Officer said that a group activity would require insurance however, if the person being trained was an individual this would be more difficult in a public open space.    26.8     Councillor Holmes asked about the lease of St Stephens Church in which the Tourist Information Centre was held and the Chief Executive said that IBC were  ...  view the full minutes text for item 26.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 27 Sep 2018, item 26Open the meeting
Named10 Jul 2018Executive

E/18/12 Public Spaces Protection Order (PSPO)

Question 1 - Councillor Holmes ‘Does the Executive consider that powers preventing loitering over the   whole of Ipswich could be used to criminalise ordinary activities such as political protests in the town centre or large family gatherings in parks and as such would potentially contravene Article 8 (the right to a private and family life), Article 10 (the right to freedom of expression)   and Article 11 (the right to protest and freedom of association) of the Human Rights Act;
From the council's minutes: Executive, 10 Jul 2018, item 27Open the meeting
Asked5 Jul 2018Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/18/01 Task & Finish Group Update - Universal Credit

7.3       Discretionary Housing Payments (DHP) had been used effectively to make up shortfalls due to housing cost elements and those with long term conditions, whose situation would be unlikely to change, had been awarded a DHP for a 12 month period.   7.4       Councillor Holmes asked whether any prediction could be made about how many the total amount of claimants might be and [name removed], Operations Manager, Benefits and Business Support said that at the moment this would be difficult to predict. By 2023, the benefit caseload would be migrated across to Universal Credit so this was a watching brief.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 5 Jul 2018, item 7Open the meeting
Said5 Jul 2018Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/18/03 Closure of the Orwell Bridge Update

9.4       Councillor Holmes expressed concern about the lack of advance information available for residents when planned bridge maintenance was to take place or should the period of maintenance be extended.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 5 Jul 2018, item 9Open the meeting
Said25 Apr 2018Planning & Development Committee

PD/17/15 Item 2 - Application IP/18/00190/FUL

Councillor Holmes, St Margaret’s ward Councillor, spoke on behalf of local residents:
From the council's minutes: Planning & Development Committee, 25 Apr 2018, item 163Open the meeting
Named7 Mar 2018Central Area Committee

CAC/17/22 Funding Request: Future Female Society - 'More than Mum' Project

Councillor Holmes:   In addition to the Westgate ward, there were also some areas of deprivation within St Margaret’s ward.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 7 Mar 2018, item 75Open the meeting
Named6 Mar 2018Executive

E/17/71 Alley Gates Policy and Guidance

Question 2 – Councillor Holmes ‘While I support the need for alley gates in certain circumstances, the proposed Policy fails to address key legal issues. Could the Executive explain:
From the council's minutes: Executive, 6 Mar 2018, item 152Open the meeting
Named6 Mar 2018Executive

E/17/71 Alley Gates Policy and Guidance

c)     In consulting landowners and others about any proposed scheme, will the Council confirm to these parties that they will need to disclose the details of anti-social behaviour and the need for gates to any potential buyer on the sale of a property which could adversely affect the sale of a property.’ In response to Councillor Holmes questions, Councillor Ross explained that:
From the council's minutes: Executive, 6 Mar 2018, item 152Open the meeting
Said24 Jan 2018Council

C/17/14 To Consider a Report from Councillor Ellesmere on the Economic Development Strategy.

·          Councillor Holmes commented that the Strategy should place more emphasis on skills and education levels as this was an area in which Ipswich was not particularly successful, especially in terms of the proportion of residents who had achieved NVQ 4 and above .
From the council's minutes: Council, 24 Jan 2018, item 53Open the meeting
Said24 Jan 2018Council

C/17/14 To Consider a Report from Councillor Ellesmere on the Economic Development Strategy.

Councillor Holmes also commented that the Strategy  ...  view the full minutes text for item 53.
From the council's minutes: Council, 24 Jan 2018, item 53Open the meeting
Named17 Jan 2018Central Area Committee

CAC/17/15 Funding Request: ActivLives ActivHubs Programme 2018/19

Councillor Holmes: Both of the proposed hub venues in the report fall within the Westgate ward, so this wouldn’t cater for people living in the Alexandra and St Margaret’s wards;
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 17 Jan 2018, item 58Open the meeting
Named17 Jan 2018Central Area Committee

CAC/17/19 Funding Request: Alley Gate Funding

Councillor Holmes: Is this report pre-emptive as we do not know the criteria for the use of this fund? Paragraphs 10.3 and 10.4 set out significant legal issues; are we voting on a lawful policy?
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 17 Jan 2018, item 62Open the meeting
Asked4 Jan 2018Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Budget Proposals Presentation

49.8     Councillor Harsant asked when the proposals had gone out to consultation and the Chief Executive said that it would be available for consultation from 29 January 2018 onwards.   49.9     Councillor Holmes asked whether there was a risk on being reliant of income streams from IB Assets?
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 4 Jan 2018, item 49Open the meeting
Named22 Nov 2017Council

To Receive any Declarations of Interest by Councillors.

Councillor Holmes, whose spouse was affected by the proposed transitional state pension arrangements, declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 10 (Motion: State Pension Arrangements) and left the room during the consideration of this item.
From the council's minutes: Council, 22 Nov 2017, item 35Open the meeting
Named28 Sep 2017Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for Absence

Councillor O Holmes was also unable to attend the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 28 Sep 2017, item 19Open the meeting
Named31 Aug 2017Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for Absence

Councillor O Holmes was also unable to attend the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 31 Aug 2017, item 11Open the meeting
Named19 Jul 2017Central Area Committee

Community Intelligence - Verbal Update from Ward Councillors

Councillor Lockington reported that if anyone would like to volunteer for the Community Speedwatch initiative they should contact either herself, Councillor Jones or Councillor Holmes, all of whom had been trained. Training would be provided and the evidence gathered would be used to send letters to drivers logged as exceeding the speed limit, or in the case of excessive speed, to prompt a visit by the Police.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 19 Jul 2017, item 16Open the meeting
Named6 Jul 2017Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for Absence

Councillor O Holmes was also unable to attend the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 6 Jul 2017, item 3Open the meeting
Named11 Jan 2017Central Area Committee

Play Area Priorities for Central Ipswich

Councillor Holmes:   Does the list of 95 play area sites include those to be delivered from new developments, such as the Ipswich Garden Suburb?
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 11 Jan 2017, item 60Open the meeting
Named11 Jan 2017Central Area Committee

Chairman's Update on Actions from Previous Meetings

The Chairman reported that he had attended the official unveiling of the John Blatchly Memorial Armillary Sphere Sundial in Christchurch Park, together with the Mayor, Councillor Lockington, Councillor Holmes and Councillor Jones; the renovation of the sundial had been part-funded by the Central Area Committee.
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 11 Jan 2017, item 63Open the meeting
Named9 Nov 2016Central Area Committee

Presentation: Suffolk Trading Standards

Councillor Holmes: Is STS putting any pressure on Royal Mail to stop bulk posted scams?
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 9 Nov 2016, item 47Open the meeting
Named9 Nov 2016Central Area Committee

CAC/16/12 Funding Request: Installation of Litter Bins on Museum Street

Councillor Holmes: Why was funding not requested from the Town Centre budget?
From the council's minutes: Central Area Committee, 9 Nov 2016, item 49Open the meeting
Asked4 Aug 2016Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee

OS/16/03 Work Programme 2016/17 (includes a proposal form)

11.3     Councillor O Holmes asked to be part of the Orwell Bridge Speed Restriction Update and Councillor Debman asked that the previous representatives on the Task & Finish Group and the Chief Inspector of the Norfolk & Suffolk Policing Unit also be invited to attend for this item on 27 October 2016.   11.4     Councillor Debman asked that the Review of the Area Committees report be scheduled for 2 March 2017.
From the council's minutes: Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee, 4 Aug 2016, item 11Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Holmes attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
26 Jul 2017CouncilTo Consider a Motion from Councillor R PopeCarriedUnanimous
23 Nov 2016CouncilC/16/13 To Consider a Report from Councillor D Ellesmere on the Norfolk & Suffolk Devolution Proposal.CarriedUnanimous
22 Sep 2016CouncilC/16/07 To Consider a Report from Mrs K Forster, Chair of the Independent Remuneration Panel, on a Review of Councillors' Allowance Scheme.CarriedUnanimous
29 Jun 2016CouncilMotion to Council - Suffolk SolidarityCarriedUnanimous
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Holmes was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Planning & Development Committee
82 of 88
Council
70 of 75
Central Area Committee
45 of 49
Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee
18 of 22
Human Resources Panel
3 of 3
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 13 of 17 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Holmes declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

DateWhereWhat the minutes sayWhat happened
5 Feb 2025Planning & Development Committee, item 73Councillor Holmes, being known to one of the objectors, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/24/00597/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.Left the room
16 Oct 2024Planning & Development Committee, item 55Councillor Holmes, being known to one of the objectors, declared an interest in Item 2 (IP/24/00597/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.Left the room
15 Nov 2023Planning & Development Committee, item 60Councillor Holmes, being known to one of the objectors, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/23/00416/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.Left the room
18 Oct 2023Planning & Development Committee, item 51Councillor Holmes, being known to the applicant, declared an interest in Item 3 (IP/23/00633/FUL) and left the meeting during the consideration of this application.Left the room
1 Mar 2023Central Area Committee, item 53Councillor Holmes declared a non-pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 9 (CAC/22/15) Funding Request: Eastern Angles Theatre Company as he was previously a Trustee of Eastern Angles.
13 Jan 2021Planning & Development Committee, item 76Councillor Holmes, being a volunteer at the Ipswich Winter Night Shelter, declared an interest in Item 5 (IP/20/01001/FPI3).
1 Jul 2020Planning & Development Committee, item 14Councillor Holmes, being known to the applicant, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/19/01140/FUL) and left the room during the consideration of this item.Left the room
5 Jun 2019Central Area Committee, item 5Councillor Holmes, having worked at the Christ Church Night Shelter, declared an interest in Agenda Item 10 (report CAC/19/01).
Hover a line for the full wording.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Holmes sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
Planning & Development CommitteeCommittee MemberJul 20198818 Nov 2026
CouncilCommittee MemberMay 20167518 Nov 2026
Central Area CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 201649
Strategic Overview & Scrutiny CommitteeSubstituteAug 201622
Human Resources PanelCommittee MemberFeb 20183
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies