To Consider nominations/changes of Councillors to serve on Committees, Panels, Working Groups and Outside Bodies.
Licensing and Regulatory Committee – Councillor Smart to replace Councillor Bartholomew.
Every time Ipswich's minutes name Councillor Smart, as the council published it.
Licensing and Regulatory Committee – Councillor Smart to replace Councillor Bartholomew.
Planning and Development Committee – Councillor Smart to replace Councillor Muhith, Councillor Trenchard to fill the resulting vacancy for a substitute.
Councillor P Smart commented that in processes, such as steel making, where furnace use was constant, electric power would be cheaper, but that in cremation where use had peaks and troughs, the ability of gas fuelled furnaces to heat more quickly could deliver lower overall energy usage.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, noting that it was proposed to delegate authority for the Head of Waste & Fleet Services to purchase bins and bags through Public Sector Procurement Frameworks. This model would allow flexibility and give the Council the opportunity to take advantage of price fluctuations.
Councillor P Smart commented that given the intelligence and persistence of Gulls he did not think there was a truly Gull Proof Bag.
Councillor P Smart reported that the current bus shelter advertising agreement was due to expire at the end of March 2026 and it was proposed to procure a new 10-year contract. This agreement would primarily cover bus shelters in locations that were likely to attract advertising; the Council also provided some bus shelters in other locations within the Borough. The agreement would contain clauses requiring repair and maintenance of the bus shelters and would be transferrable to the successor authority resulting from the LGR; it would be possible in the future to incorporate bus shelters in other areas that were not already under contract.
Councillor P Smart commented that the agreement was financially beneficial to the Council as it provided bus shelters without incurring any installation or maintenance costs and income from the advertising. The incumbent supplier had the advantage of the shelters already being installed, but the outcome would be decided by the market; the proposed benchmark income for the contract was set out in the exempt Appendix 1 of the report.
As the required decision related to income rather than costs and was moderate in value, Councillor Smart proposed that the decision to award the contract be delegated to Officers as per recommendation 14.2.
Councillor P Smart commented that the current agreement included a few ‘free’ bus shelters that had been provided in locations unlikely to support advertising but did not know whether the structural integrity of the existing bus shelters could support a green roof. There was a clause within the agreement that required the replacement of life-expired bus shelters, and this could provide an opportunity to introduce bus shelters with a green roof. It was
The Chair welcomed Councillor P Smart and Officers to the meeting.
Councillor P Smart introduced Hannah Leys, Assistant Director – Operations, Mark Whiting, Head of Vibrant Town Services, Michael Carter, Waste & Cleansing Operations Manager and Michael Newsham, Integrated Transport Officer.
Councillor P Smart reported on the progress made against the recommendations of the Town Centre Cleanliness Task and Finish Group. The ‘This is Our Town’ campaign launched in May 2025 and there had been a high level of engagement with local schoolchildren who were invited to take part in a town-wide art competition; over 139 entries were submitted, and there had been appropriate press coverage at that time.
Councillor P Smart noted that waste collection continued to generate significant interest ahead of the implementation of the ‘Simpler Recycling’ project. It was anticipated that this would be rolled out in 2026 and would include changes to dry recycling collections and new food waste collections. Preparations were well underway: vehicles had been secured, and both caddies and most of the required bins had been ordered.
Councillor P Smart explained that in isolation the introduction of the chargeable brown bin service could lead to a slight increase in tonnage of residual household waste. This was due to a number of residents opting not to subscribe and instead disposing of compostable waste in their black bins. This waste often included wet material which was heavier and would increase the overall weight of residual waste.
Councillor P Smart explained that when the ... view the full minutes text for item 14.
It was agreed that Councillor P Smart be asked for an update on progress made in relation to the recommendations of the Town Centre Cleanliness Task and Finish Group.
Councillor P Smart sent apologies for lateness.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report which sought to extend the current practice of Senior Officers exercising their delegated authority for the procurement of vehicles in consultation with the Portfolio Holders for Environment & Transport and Resources; previously authorisation had been granted for periods of 3 years and 2 years, and this report sought authorisation for a further 3 years.
Councillor P Smart commented that it would be helpful to look at the LCWIP alongside SCC’s Local Transport Plan; the Council had requested a greater Park and Ride provision in the consultation on the Local Transport Plan as it was not a matter of preventing car use but looking at the proportion ... view the full minutes text for item 74.
Councillor P Smart commented that meetings had been held with officers to tackle the accumulation of rubbish in the area and the Parks Team would be looking at improvements to the shrubbed areas on Vernon Street and Austin Street.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, explaining that the Council’s vehicle maintenance and servicing requirements had been split into 4 lots.
Councillor Smart proposed that the award of the contract be delegated to the Head of Waste and Fleet so long as it was within the budget allocated. Tenders would be scored on a 60% price / 40% quality basis and vehicle maintenance space would be available by separate contract at the new depot site, if needed.
Councillor P Smart noted that the vehicle replacement programme meant that much of the fleet was now electric and that electric vehicles had a lower maintenance requirement. The Head of Waste and Fleet explained that there would be further replacement of the oldest remaining vehicles in the fleet and that these would be used to provide parts for other vehicles which would further reduce costs.
Councillor Smart had been dealing with casework and 2 reports of overgrown vegetation.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, noting that it was proposed to issue an open tender and to delegate the award of the contracts to Officers.
Councillor P Smart, Portfolio Holder for Environment and Transport, introduced his annual performance update. The key points made were:
Councillor P Smart reported that second brown bins would still be available. The Head of Waste and Fleet, Chris Taylor, reported that any number of brown bins would be available at a cost of £49.50. The higher price charged at present reflected the current pro-rata cost of the additional collections provided, and there were around 280 households with a second brown bin.
Councillor P Smart noted that the administration of such a system, or a system based on weight sometimes called ‘chip and bin’, would increase costs for everyone.
Councillor P Smart also noted that charging on an annual basis was the system adopted by all other Councils in Suffolk. The Head of Waste and Fleet noted that provision would have to be made for all bins to be collected even if relatively few were put out, and so if a pay by collection or weight system were put in place the charges would need to recover the full costs. The Council would however be offering a single collection service whereby residents could book and pay for a one-off collection, without having a bin.
Councillor Smart highlighted that the play area was in a secluded spot, hidden by Royston Drive.
Councillor P Smart added that the resident had also contacted him and Councillor Rudkin about this matter. Until the land was adopted, the developer should have been maintaining it, but this hadn’t happened, so the developer would need to bring the land back up to an adoptable standard before the Council could commence proceedings to adopt the land.
Councillor P Smart reported that Environmental Health were investigating an abandoned vehicle on Felaw Street.
Councillor Smart reported that the area of amenity land on Felaw Street opposite Bulstrode Road would have some trees planted on it in the upcoming tree planting season.
Councillor P Smart reported that when charges had been introduced in other areas of Suffolk there had initially been a significant reduction in take-up and so the Council was anticipating that the same would happen in Ipswich before the number of users increased and settled.
Councillor Smart noted that costs would ... view the full minutes text for item 37.
Councillor P Smart noted that Crown Pools had been controversial when it had been built and that the Council had had to find a way around the capital controls put in place by the then Government.
Councillor Smart noted that the proposed Aquatics Centre would be the seventh public swimming facility in Ipswich.
Councillor Rudkin reported that Councillor P Smart had helped to provide a temporary solution to the bin issue at the Observation Area on the Waterfront. A planning issue continued to be considered on Wherstead Road regarding ... view the full minutes text for item 67.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, commenting that the changes being introduced by Government were not simpler, but in fact more complex, both for residents and local authorities, as well as being more expensive. The Council would be required to offer weekly food waste collection from 2026, which would mean that kitchen caddies and kerbside collection vessels would need to be provided to residents, whilst the Council would need new vehicles and communal bins. The funding being provided was estimated to cover 58% of the additional costs in Ipswich, and only 68% in other areas of Suffolk where costs were lower.
Councillor P Smart noted that the former food waste collection service via brown bins had only accepted limited types of vegetable waste. The new service required by Government covered all food waste, including meat, and so required greater treatment and processing.
Councillor P Smart replied that the funding available was generally inadequate and that he believed the funding was based on a certain proportion of the population not ... view the full minutes text for item 101.
d) that Councillor P Smart replace Councillor M Cook as a substitute on the Joint Consultative Group;
Councillor P Smart confirmed that following the issue raised at the previous meeting regarding lighting at St Mary Stoke Church, discussions had taken place between the church and IBC’s Capital Project Team in which it was hoped that a positive resolution would soon be found. In the meantime, temporary measures had been implemented to reduce the urgency of the situation.
Councillor P Smart agreed to consider the matter further.
Persistent fly tipping issues in the area were being considered by Councillor P Smart to find a resolution.
20.1 Councillor P Smart, Portfolio Holder for Environment and Climate Change, introduced his annual performance update, the key points made were:
Councillor P Smart explained that the value of the recyclate was dependant on the quality, and that there was a trade-off between weight, which was reflected in NI 192, and quality. It was possible to get a much higher percentage score in this indicator at the expense of the quality of the material.
Councillor P Smart said that this would require bin inspections, but that it might be possible.
Councillor Smart noted that since COVID-19 work patterns had changed to a hybrid model which meant that household waste had increased as people were at home more.
Councillor P Smart explained that increasing the number of street trees in the Town Centre was a challenge due to infrastructure in place underground. The Head of Parks and Bereavement, Lisa Stannard, confirmed that the Council was highlighting to Suffolk County Council good locations on highways land where trees could be planted.
Councillor P Smart explained that one of the challenges was with contamination levels in blue bins serving multiple flats, as it only took one person to put the wrong item in the bin for the whole bin to be contaminated.
Councillor P Smart noted that even though Ipswich had a disproportionate amount of people with English as a second language recycling performance ... view the full minutes text for item 20.
Councillor P Smart said that he keenly anticipated the results of the surveys, noting that many tenants of other Social Housing providers in Bridge Ward were keen to move into Council homes owing largely to repairs issues.
Councillor P Smart commented that caution should be taken when comparing the data of the last 3 years as this had included the pandemic and the post-pandemic restrictions, and so would not be a typical dataset.
It was noted that unfortunately Councillor P Smart was unable to attend the meeting due to illness and so this update would be deferred.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, noting that the new depot would help the Council to prepare for the Recycling and Waste Strategy, and that the Council’s lease on its current depot would expire in January 2025 meaning its replacement was essential.
Councillor Smart noted that there had been an increase in the expected cost, mostly caused by inflation, but also contributed to by the identification of contaminants in the soil on site.
Councillor P Smart reported that the original budget had been set by Executive in December 2021, when the inflation rate was 5.4%; at that point it had been set at an appropriate level. Often contractors would absorb modest price increases, but what was unknown at that time was that inflation would more than double during 2022; paragraph 10.4 of the report identified that this inflation pressure equated to a budget increase of £3.1m.
The requested increase was explained in the report, and Councillor Smart was comfortable that the original budget was accurate at the time it was agreed.
Councillor P Smart reported that the Handford developments team combined had over 100 years of development and project management experience, in both the commercial and not for profit sectors, including construction project management of circa. 9 million square feet of logistics/warehousing space to BREEAM outstanding standard. He was therefore confident that Handford Developments had the experience and expertise to deliver this project.
Councillor Smart also commented that it would now be very expensive and cause significant delays to move away from using Handford Developments to manage this project and questioned what Councillor Holmes thought the Council might do if it weren’t happy with Handford Developments experience.
Councillor P Smart reported that the budget previously approved had been based on projected costs supplied by an independent qualified quantity surveyor including estimates for inflation. The increase in cost was ... view the full minutes text for item 27.
Councillor P Smart confirmed that he would speak to [name removed] after the meeting to provide her with a contact from Greater Anglia who may be able to help provide a group discount travel deal for the train and underground journeys.
Councillor P Smart reported that he had been dealing with ASB issues in Seldon Close. The term “fly tipping” was due to be referred to instead as “illegal dumping” to emphasise that this was an illegal and severe offence. The new terminology would be rolled out ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
Councillor P Smart reported that Vehicle Procurement had taken place successfully using a delegation for a number of years, and that the delegation needed to be renewed. It was proposed to allow the purchase of vehicles through any public sector procurement regulations compliant frameworks to allow greater resilience and flexibility.
Councillor P Smart commented that it would be difficult to know what vehicles would otherwise have cost and so such a report wouldn’t be easy to create. The Director – Operations and Place, James Fairclough, reported that car derived vans and cars were procured through the public sector discount list and that some discounts had been greater than 20%, but that ordinary list prices from the time of purchases had not been kept.
Councillor P Smart commented that the use of public sector procurement frameworks meant that the Council was already benefitting from discounts by procuring alongside other public sector organisations. The Director – Operations and Place reported that the receipts from auctioned vehicles were put into a reserve which was used for the purchase of equipment for vehicles or to purchase new additional vehicles.
Councillor Philip Smart asked about the deadline for applications, how funding would be allocated and what would happen to any unspent funding.
Councillor Philip Smart reported that he would be meeting on 3 March to progress a solution to the lack of alley gates in the Austin Street passageway.
Councillor Smart commented that SCC had indicated that there was no funding available for raised bus stop kerbs for the Service 16 bus route;
Councillor Philip Smart reported that there would be a street meet with the Police on 2 March on Kenyon Street providing an opportunity for people to raise their concerns.
Councillor Smart commented that bins had been installed on Tyler Street to tackle littering but with mixed results; there would be a public campaign on illegal dumping ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, explaining that the Council had declared a climate emergency in 2019 and that a 60% reduction in Greenhouse Gas Emissions had been achieved since 2008.
Councillor Smart noted that the Council’s green estate had an estimated Carbon storage value of approximately 37,000 tonnes per annum, and that this showed the potential for local offsetting should it be needed to maintain some services which could not be provided without some carbon emissions.
Councillor Smart thanked the members of, and Officers supporting, the Climate Emergency Working Group for their work over the past year.
Councillor P Smart reported that Greenhouse Gas emissions for Northgate Sports Centre had not been recorded in Ipswich Borough Council’s emissions as the Council had been managing Northgate Sports Centre on behalf of Suffolk County Council, and as part of this agreement the County Council had always retained responsibility for the building itself along with the provision of utilities. Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Northgate Sports Centre would have been recorded in the Suffolk County Council Greenhouse Gas emissions statement.
Councillor P Smart confirmed that the Greenhouse Gas report only relates to emissions arising from the activities of the Council and not its companies.
Councillor P Smart reported that any buildings owned by the Council, but which were leased or rented to others were not included within the Council’s Greenhouse Gas emissions.
Councillor P Smart commented that it was right to set challenging targets and for the Council to do all it could to achieve Carbon Neutrality.
Councillor Smart reported that the methodology for recording Greenhouse Gas emissions in 1990 could not be relied upon and so a more ... view the full minutes text for item 117.
Councillor Smart asked how much of the Council’s CCTV network was focussed on traffic.
Councillor Smart asked whether the NNDR saving was due to Ipswich Museum being closed or being subject to a revaluation.
Councillor Smart commented that generating additional income would be challenging with Ipswich Museum being closed for redevelopment.
Councillor Smart asked how energy savings arising from the closure of the museum would be accounted.
Councillor Smart noted that the net increase was only 7% after the changes had been applied.
Councillor P Smart reported that after discussion with PC Jarrett an affordable solution to the lack of alley gates in the Austin Street passageway had been found.
Councillor P Smart commented that both he and Councillor Connelly had attended an event at Stoke High School to celebrate the new School Parliament and noted the importance of teaching young people the value of democracy.
Councillor P Smart reported that there had been some success in Old Stoke following identified illegal scrap metal and reported that he had been dealing with various casework, including ensuring a resident’s status on Gateway Home Choice was upgraded.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, noting that the Council had increased its financial contribution to bus subsidies by 21%, but that rising costs meant that tenders received from operators for running services were significantly higher than even this increased contribution. It was unfortunately necessary therefore to remove the subsidy from some late night services which had the lowest ridership figures. Since the publication of the report Ipswich Buses had agreed to continue to run the services without subsidy from the end of the current agreement until the end of the year in order to allow time for costs for fall and ridership to increase.
Councillor P Smart commented that he appreciated that Suffolk County Council having a static budget for bus subsidies gave good reason to question whether alternative funding might be available, Ipswich Borough Council however remained hopeful of further funding opportunities in the future and the ability for these to be used to help support the provision of subsidised bus services; these opportunities might well come from sources other than Suffolk County Council bids to the Government. Ipswich Borough Council also subsidised routes which travelled into other districts and approaches had been made to East Suffolk District Council to see if it would be prepared to fund some of the services on routes entering its area.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, explaining that it was proposed to install a further 14 Electric Vehicle Charging Points across 7 of the Council’s car parks. The proposal would take advantage of a grant from the O n-street Residential Chargepoint Scheme which the Council had been successful in applying for and would make electric vehicle ownership more attractive for the many residents who didn’t have access to off-street parking.
Councillor P Smart explained that Blue Badge Holders would be able to park in these bays in short stay car parks and not pay for the first 3 hours of their parking in the same way they are able to now. The signage on the EV bays would make this clear.
Councillor P Smart explained that it was intended to use this year's remaining Air Quality budget of £123,680 and up to £41,320 from the 23/24 Air Quality budget; this would still leave £58,600 unallocated in the 23/24 budget.
Councillor P Smart said that he believed the project was a good use of the Air Quality budget as increasing the number of publicly available charging points in the Council’s car parks demonstrated IBC’s leadership role in tackling the climate emergency.
Councillor Smart noted that the installation of electric vehicle charging points was one of the few ways in which Ipswich Borough Council could seek to reduce transport emissions, which was the major contributor to poor air quality, and reminded the meeting that Suffolk County Council as the transport authority had a much larger part to play in improving air quality.
Councillor Smart highlighted that the total number of admissions across the year had been down 58%, but the retail had only been down 9%, and asked if this was due to a higher ‘spend per head’.
Councillor Smart commented that the budget report in the January 2023 meeting would need to reflect the closure of Ipswich Museum during its redevelopment.
Councillor Smart asked whether obtaining an uplift in Arts Council England funding would require more regular Internal Audits to be done.
Councillor Smart suggested that the wording of risk 1.12 be reworded as: “The impact of a pandemic (such as COVID) will be far reaching ….” to cover pandemics in general and suggested a revised probability of 2 or 3.
7.1 Councillor P Smart, Portfolio Holder for Environment and Climate Change, introduced his annual performance update, the key points made were:
7.3 Councillor P Smart reported that there had been a 50% increase in cremations as a direct result of the pandemic and that the 100% target had been maintained. Over the past year there had been an increased number of cremations owing to those at Weeley being out of use. The Council had improved its relationships with funeral directors as a result and this had further increased the amount of business the Council received.
7.8 Councillor Smart noted that significant progress had been made in reducing contamination, with performance now close to ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor P Smart confirmed that the Residents Parking Zone had been successfully implemented with only a few complaints from people outside the zone. Discussions had taken place regarding the issue of abandoned shopping trolleys within Ipswich, and it was confirmed that a report would be considered by Council on 12 July regarding granting powers so that a recovery fee could be charged to the owners of any trolleys retrieved.
Councillor P Smart queried the closure of the walkways during the day when there was a moderate level of use and commented that there was a clear line of visibility from Turret Lane along the section of the passageway covered by this application and whether this section of passageway could be stopped off at the other end instead.
Councillor Smart reported that Ipswich had a growing population with a need for outdoor activity space. The new Play Area Strategy reflected new design standards and national definitions and had been considered by the Environment & Climate Change Portfolio Working Group. The Action Plan to implement the strategy and install new play equipment had been developed by Officers based on a number of factors, including the type and condition of existing equipment available, the population served, and when Section 106 income was expected to be available.
Councillor Smart noted that later phases of work might change due to the impact of inflation.
Councillor Smart explained that there were a wide range of factors which had been taken into account when developing the programme, which included financial constraints and expected footfall, as well as current provision levels.
Councillor Smart reported that the site was defined by the Council as a destination site but that with the adoption of new national criteria it would need to be improved further to retain that definition for all age groups.
Councillor Smart introduced the report noting that the Council had committed to a target of climate neutrality by 2030. The report had been delayed, but it was now intended that a report be brought to Executive annually to monitor progress. To date, Ipswich Borough Council had achieved a two-thirds reduction in greenhouse gas emissions since 2008, and much of the Council’s contribution to climate neutrality would be indirect, for example, through planting trees and insulating Council homes.
Councillor Smart noted difficulties in measuring the Council’s performance in terms of reducing its contribution to Climate Change and that Groundworks had been contracted to provide much of the data that was included in the report.
Councillor Smart agreed that it was regrettable that new private sector homes were not built to the same standard and highlighted the difficulty of improving the energy performance of much of Ipswich’s Victorian housing stock.
Councillor Smart agreed that the proposal would benefit the school and its community and asked whether the boards could be refreshed as the schools population changed. [name removed] explained that the reverse of the boards onto which the mural was to be printed would be blank and so they could be reused, subject to being in good condition, if the project were repeated.
Councillor Smart reported that a Consultation on powers to charge supermarkets for the collection and return of abandoned Shopping Trollies was expected to be launched soon.
99.1 Councillor Smart introduced the report, explaining that the consultation on the new byelaws had shown 2 to 1 support for the changes and it was now proposed to apply to the Secretary of State for approval.
There were a number of comments in relation to cycling and Councillor Smart confirmed that existing cycle routes would be retained and that the new byelaws would allow the Council to designate additional cycling routes if it decided that this was the right thing to do. The new byelaws would also reinforce the Council’s policy of banning the launch of Sky Lanterns and Balloons.
Councillor Smart noted the language used in the byelaws was old fashioned and complicated as a result of the legal nature of the byelaws but confirmed that E-Scooters were banned under the classification of ‘motorised vehicle’; it was intended that when the byelaws were sent to the Secretary of State representations about this issue be made.
Councillor Smart agreed that this might raise the profile of the issue and also confirmed that, assuming they were made, the restrictions imposed through the byelaws would be publicised in Plain English.
86.1 Councillor Smart noted the benefits of the new depot, as outlined in the report, and explained that the detailed plans for the buildings and site remained subject to refinement.
Councillor Smart commented that proposed new depot would allow Ipswich Borough Council’s operations to become more climate friendly, with options for the use of Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil and Electric Vehicle Charging. The site would also house a vehicle maintenance unit, and the building would be much more pleasant for staff and visitors.
87.1 Councillor Smart reported that it was proposed to change the term of this contract to enable to Council to insist on the use of the new Vehicle Maintenance Facility at the new depot site when that became available.
Councillor Smart confirmed that it had not and that the contract term could still be changed simply.
Councillor T Lockington Councillor Jones (on behalf of Cllr Smart) Implementation of Tree Management Policy 3.
Councillor I Lockington Councillor Ross (on behalf of Cllr Smart) Maple Park 5.
Councillor Smart confirmed that there had been an increased number of abandoned shopping trolleys reported, which had to be collected by the Waste & Cleansing Team at a cost. To combat this issue, the Council would need to acquire powers under the Environmental Act which would then require agreement by full Council. Prior to this, a six-week consultation would take place between December and January with all affected parties.
Councillor Smart introduced the report, explaining that Ipswich Borough Council was one of very few local authorities where public toilet provision had been increased. There was a trend nationally towards the installation of composting toilets and it was proposed to replace four toilet blocks which had reached the end of their useful life with such facilities. The proposal would not only save money on maintenance in the longer term but also save 1.5 tonnes of Carbon Emissions per annum.
Councillor Smart noted that the environmental benefits of composting toilets were included in the report. It was clearly explained that replacement of these traditional public toilet facilities with composting toilet facilities would result in a direct reduction in both water usage and energy usage.
Councillor Smart clarified that the Council was not proposing that the proposals in this report go out for public consultation but that Officers consult Ward Councillors and Friends Groups about the location of these composting toilets within the parks rather than the provision itself.
Councillor Smart added that park visitor information and information within the composting toilets would make the environmental benefits of composting toilets clear.
Councillor P Smart explained that it was not intended to replace all public toilets with composting toilets, and that those in Major’s Corner were managed separately to those in Parks.
Councillor Smart confirmed that the consultation could be extended to those Councillors whose Wards abutted parks where composting toilets were proposed.
Councillor Smart noted that the COVID-19 pandemic had familiarised residents with using hand sanitiser and commented that the new toilets would provide facilities such as disabled access and baby changing tables ... view the full minutes text for item 56.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report, explaining that various options for the procurement of Tyre Management had been considered and that an open tender had been considered the most appropriate.
As the value of the proposed contract was relatively low, Councillor Smart recommended that the decision on awarding the contract be delegated to Officers.
15.1 Councillor P Smart, Portfolio Holder for Environment and Climate Change, introduced his annual performance update, the key points made in relation to the Parks and Bereavement Operations Area were:
Councillor Smart explained that the Council would be reviewing its play strategy so that it was clear how the Council’s resources in this area would be used.
Councillor P Smart explained that officers were in discussions with Suffolk County Council about wildflower verges but that these needed to be chosen carefully so as not to impact on road safety. The Operations Manager for Parks and Bereavement explained that ... view the full minutes text for item 15.
Councillor Smart reported that the Council had a range of fleet to maintain, including a number of specialist vehicles for refuse collection and street cleaning. Requirements of the tender included maintenance of the Council’s increasing number of electric vehicles, plus the criteria set out in paragraphs 2.8, 7.3 and 8.5 of the report, and tenders would be evaluated on a 60% cost:40% quality basis.
Councillor Smart recommended delegating the award of the contract to Senior Officers, as set out in recommendations 13.1 and 13.2 of the report.
Councillor Smart reported that approval for an approximate value of £3.2million represented the top limit for the award of the contract and expected the contract to come in under this amount.
Councillor Smart commented that maintenance costs had fluctuated over the past few years and even replacement vehicles would age in time; the estimate had been based on historic data but with an element of inflation added.
Councillor Smart commented that the assurance gradings were different to those previously used, where the top grading had been ‘Full Assurance’.
Councillor Smart commented, as an example, that there were museums that focused primarily on slavery and highlighted the importance of explaining the history involved.
8.1 Councillor P Smart introduced the report, explaining that the current byelaws dated from 1983 and did not cover a significant proportion of the Borough’s green spaces or many of the activities which now needed to be regulated.
Councillor Smart noted that the current byelaws included limited controls regarding dogs and that a Public Spaces Protection Order was proposed elsewhere on the agenda to deal with this issue rather than controlling this via a byelaw.
8.3 Councillor Smart explained that there was no evidence that suggested that the use of drones or e-scooters had been increasing to the extent that it was causing a considerable nuisance to park visitors, although there were instances of this occurring and where it was officers would ask e-scooter riders to dismount and/or those flying drones to stop.
Councillor Smart noted that the existing byelaws contained provisions relevant to drones and e-scooters, but only for those parks which the current byelaws apply to, whereas, if approved, the new model byelaws would apply in all the Borough’s parks and open spaces and these model byelaws also contained restrictions that covered these issues.
8.4 Councillor Smart explained that the relevant section for the flying of drones was a general prohibition in part 6 that stated ‘No person shall cause any power-driven model aircraft to: (a) take off or otherwise be released for flight or control the flight of such an aircraft; or (b) land in the ground without reasonable excuse’.
Councillor Smart added that the existing byelaws contained an exception to allow power-driven model aircraft to be used in the designated Chantry Park Model Aircraft Area on Wednesday and Sunday afternoons and after 10am on Saturdays.
Councillor Smart confirmed that the Council would be looking to include the Chantry Park designated Model Aircraft Area in the new byelaws.
Councillor Smart reported that Part 3 of the model byelaws contained a prohibition on motorised vehicles, which would include e-scooters.
8.5 Councillor Smart reported that as the Council proceeded with the review of park byelaws, a review of any historic restrictive covenants was also being progressed.
Councillor Smart noted that as the existing byelaws covered those parks where historic covenants were likely to exist, and the model byelaws were not dissimilar to the existing byelaws, it was not anticipated that any conflicts between the new model byelaws and any historic restrictive ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Councillor P Smart suggested that consideration be given to utilising the semi-circular piece of land adjacent to the turning head and the garages of 29 Jupiter Road, and also the narrow triangular portion of land opposite Plot 6, to increase the shared roadway area within the site.
Councillor Smart proposed that, in addition to the amendments above, condition 3 be further amended to read as:
106.1 Councillor P Smart introduced the report, explaining that 87 vehicles had been purchased by the Council using a delegation granted to the Head of Culture and Environment. These new vehicles were all significantly more environmentally friendly than the vehicles they were replacing and had led to a 40% reduction in emissions from the Council’s fleet.
106.3 Councillor Smart explained that the Environmental Impact Assessment section of the report was clear in the benefits that are realised from replacement lower emission vehicles and that specific references to a previous decision were not really necessary.
106.4 Councillor Smart noted that the proposed delegation was to allow the procurement of vehicles through any relevant Crown Commercial Services Framework and that it did not set out the parameters of what would be purchased, what fuel was to be used, when purchases were to be made, or the budget available.
Councillor Smart explained that Officers would have due regard to all these matters and any other relevant decisions made subsequent to this delegation being granted.
67.7 Councillor P Smart noted that fly tipping reduction measures had been introduced which seemed to be working with a significant reduction recorded since October 2020. There had also been an increase in Dog Fouling and a Suffolk wide campaign had been launched to deal with this issue.
Councillor Smart also reported that flooding issues on the London Road Allotments had been caused by a blocked drain on the highway.
Councillor Smart reported that the Antiques Roadshow programme recorded at Christchurch Mansion had been broadcast on BBC1 this week.
Councillor Smart suggested that the wording in the Environmental section on page 10 of the Business Plan be strengthened, with the opening sentence amended to “…outlines the Service’s active steps to fulfil objectives under the Climate Emergency”.
Councillor Smart added that decision-making should not only consider the environmental impact, but should also consider what could be done to move the Climate Emergency agenda forward.
Councillor Armitage confirmed the importance of ensuring that residents were aware of the lockdown rules and advised that there had been an increase in fly tipping around parts of Chantry and discussions would take place with Councillor Smart regarding this.
Councillor P Smart reported that an experiment had been undertaken in the Old Stoke Area of Ipswich to tackle fly tipping whereby large bins had been situated to encourage usage and reduce the problems there. It was possible this may become a permanent feature however; an update would be provided at a future meeting regarding the success of this.
Councillor Smart highlighted that the proposed plans for bedroom 14 did not provide access to the communal kitchen area without leaving the building.
Councillor P Smart declared an Interest in Item 6, E/20/31 Additional Restrictions Grant (ARG), and left the meeting during the consideration of this item.
Suffolk County Council (SCC) SCC Councillors Reid and West, Simon Barnett - Transport Development Manager Ipswich Borough Council (IBC) Councillor Philip Smart, Janine Last - Operations Manager for Customer Services, Michael Newsham - Integrated Transport Manager First Eastern Counties Steve Wickers – Managing Director, Philip Magill – Network Officer Ipswich Buses Steve Bryce – General Manager 43.2 SCC Councillor Reid explained that Suffolk County Council had 25 local bus contracts which supported 48 individual services across Suffolk. There were currently 29 bus services in Ipswich and 14 of these were subsidised by Suffolk County Council. The spend on routes serving Ipswich was £930,000, out of a total spend of £1.8 million.
43.4 Councillor P Smart reported that Ipswich Buses Ltd had reduced frequencies on many routes as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, noting that whilst welcome, grants from Government didn’t adequately cover the reduction in fare income.
43.5 Councillor P Smart commented that reductions in routes in some areas could make services more sustainable, noting that there had been wasteful competition for passengers in the Nacton Area until the 53 had been withdrawn. There was however an issue with money being wasted on new stops and shelters shortly before services were withdrawn; this was due in part to inadequate communication but also due to the restrictions of the 1985 Transport Act which prevented collaboration and meant that only 42 days notice needed to be given of changes to routes.
Councillor Smart commented that there were opportunities for improvements within the current legal framework but that most of the problems were caused by the 1985 Act.
Councillor Smart highlighted that the design and layout of housing developments needed to support the extension of public transport routes through housing estates.
Councillor Smart commented that the provision of an additional passing loop on the East Suffolk line between Woodbridge and Saxmundham would help to address these issues by offering greater flexibility to run more trains on the line during the day without compromising the rail timetable.
35.6 Councillor P Smart noted that Highways England was under pressure to deliver the scheme quickly and asked what contingency plans existed if workers were affected by the Coronavirus Pandemic. [name removed] explained that Highways England had been working within the restrictions imposed as a result of COVID-19 for a significant period of time and so had good working practices, however, they also had a large and resilient supply chain which could be utilised if needed.
Both Councillor Smart and Councillor Smith had attended a meeting at the Belstead Arms to discuss planning application issues and a thank you was issued to the venue for allowing the meeting to take place. There had been an increase in fireworks and the litter from those used in Gippeswyk Park had been reported. It was noted that public land should not be used for personal firework use.
Councillor P Smart reported that a meeting had been held with the Head of Waste & Cleansing at IBC to discuss the issue of fly tipping. It was anticipated that schools would be approached and that communication regarding the health and safety and environmental aspects be circulated to residents. Suffolk Waste Partnership would be issuing guidance regarding fly tipping on a County Wide basis and a message had been issued about the importance of ensuring correct recycling.
Councillor P Smart introduced the report and confirmed that following the climate emergency declared in 2019, the Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan had been designed to make the Council carbon neutral. The Council had made progress in this area since 2008 and by March 2019 a 39% reduction had been achieved.
Councillor Smart agreed and advised that in the Strategy the Council had stated that they would need to “develop a ‘carbon neutral by design’ ethos where everything that was proposed or implemented across the organisation would consider how it could be carbon neutral or contribute to reducing carbon as a matter of course. This would include being considered from the outset in all the Council’s projects as an integral element of decision making. There would be an examination in how the Council contributed to carbon neutrality through the actions of reports to Executive also.
Councillor Smart agreed that this would be an interesting point for further discussion as there were lots of considerations in understanding how changes to working from home and working from Grafton House affected the carbon footprint.
Councillor Smart introduced the report and confirmed that as part of the Council’s agreement to reduce Single Use Plastic, 150,000 disposable drink cups had been removed from theatres and replaced with reusable polycarbonate cups, 19,000 cable ties had been replaced with reusable alternatives, 4,800 single use water bottles had been removed and mobile workers issued with reusable bottles.
Councillor Smart advised that disposable cups were not provided for use by the public at any of the Council’s venues. Changes had been made so that disposable cups used at shows at the Regent Theatre and Corn Exchange would be replaced with polycarbonate cups that would be washed and reused;
Councillor P Smart noted that the majority of the changes had also been cost neutral.
29.1 Councillor P Smart introduced the Annual Update on the Environment and Climate Change portfolio. Key points made were:
29.2 Councillor Allen asked Councillor Smart to pass on thanks to staff at Bourne Park for their management during the pandemic.
Councillor Smart confirmed that he had not received an update on this issue and would seek information from officers at his next Portfolio Holder meeting with them.
Councillor Smart advised that Ipswich Borough Council was part of the Suffolk Waste Partnership agreement which meant that it was unable to change the service provision unilaterally. The Government’s position on kerbside collection was expected to be contained within the Resources and Waste (RAW) Strategy which was in the process of being produced.
Councillor Smart explained that the audit had been carried out to draw attention to the unnecessary use of plastics. Educational programmes were planned for staff and collapsible and reusable cups could be encouraged as part of this.
Councillor Smart confirmed that the climate change action plan, which was on the next Executive agenda, provided a breakdown of the Council’s carbon reduction plan. Air Quality would be a joint responsibility across different portfolios, as well as Suffolk County Council.
Councillor Smart explained that concerns had been raised about the Bridge Street closure and that Suffolk County Council would be monitoring the success of the scheme.
Councillor Smart agreed to find out from officers and report back to Councillor Pope.
Councillor Smart welcomed the review of Listed Building and Conservation legislation as there needed to be a better balance between building conservation and energy conservation.
Councillor Smart commented that of the low number of housing developments that had commenced, a high proportion of these were in fact Council housing developments.
Councillor Smart asked what could be done to get more of the sites with planning permission built out, for example, consider infrastructure contributions being paid when permission was granted rather than being triggered by a level of completion.
Councillor Smart also commented that developers were currently able to get planning permission on sites, which would increase their value and so allow them to borrow more to buy further land, without being required to commence any development.
Councillor Smart was concerned that developers could choose to wait for the proposed legislation, which would simplify the application process, to come into effect before progressing developments.
Councillor Smart proposed that the last sentence in the response to question 7(b) on the White Paper consultation response be removed, as there would still be cross-boundary issues to consider regardless of whether an authority was unitary or not, and this was agreed.
Councillor P Smart explained that much of the negative variance in the Environment and Climate Change Portfolio came as a result of having to use additional vehicles to get refuse crews to their rounds to reduce the risks ... view the full minutes text for item 36.
Councillor P Smart commented that despite the original proposed legacy of improvements to the East Suffolk Line, the proposed application would no longer provide any improvement to the parts of the route used by passenger services and there was no passing place proposed on the East Suffolk Line for additional freight trains, which after construction could have allowed for additional passenger services on that line. Additionally, Network Rail was not able to guarantee freight paths on other parts of the network to enable an increase in freight services across this part of Suffolk. Transport East and the New Anglia LEP had been pressing for improvements to Ely Junction, but even if approved, there was no guarantee that the improvements would be in place before the Sizewell C construction phase.
Councillor P Smart requested that the hours of operation as indicated in the report be secured by condition if other similar sites within the general area also had the hours of operation secured by condition. It was agreed to delegate the decision as to whether to apply an additional planning condition relating to operating hours (in accordance with other units) to Officers.
Councillor Smart commented that some of the projects in development under communities would not now be taking place, but hopefully could be rescheduled for the following year, for example, ISCRE’s involvement in relation to the Power of Stories exhibition. [name removed] confirmed that exhibitions, such as the Power of Stories, would be delayed as a result of the current closure and a longer lead in time would be required to enable external organisations to provide vinyls and graphics in support of these exhibitions. However, work on the ACE funded project ‘Decoding the Dead’ would be progressed soon.
Councillor Smart asked what type of precautions were being considered for the re-opening of the museums, e.g. face masks, temperature testing. [name removed] reported that health and safety plans had been drawn up and details would be finalised over the next few days, which would include the installation of Perspex screens.
Councillor Smart asked how to correctly label Risk 1.12 as the outbreak of the pandemic had already happened and its probability was now in effect an actuality, and whether the impact should be rated as 5 as museums had been closed; was the risk intended to be in relation to the current pandemic or the risk of a reoccurrence in the future.
- Concern about air quality and more car parks in the town centre - Parking Strategy has not been published - Ipswich needs comprehensive transport strategy to achieve carbon reduction Councillor P Smart proposed that an informative be added to request that consideration be given to resurfacing the strip of land on the western edge of the site where rainwater regularly collected, especially where allocated for disabled parking, and this was agreed.
Councillor Smart asked whether the Joint Museum Service offered online sales, or if it should offer online sales, for example for jewellery and science items, that could be available for people to buy later in the year for Christmas.
Councillor Smart commented that if investment was made available to support online sales for bespoke items, then it could also be used to retail other items, whilst being mindful of packaging costs.
Councillor Smart asked whether a catalogue of retail items could be displayed on the CIMS website indicating that they were available for sale at CIMS museums, which would give an opportunity for cross promotion of items.
Councillor Smart questioned why the total number of visitors across the service was showing an increase of 20%, but the total income was only showing an increase of 2%.
Councillor Smart commented that it would be hard to measure the involvement of people from disadvantaged areas unless postcode data was available.
Councillor P Smart confirmed the locations within the South West where a grit bin volunteer had yet to be identified and it was agreed that Councillors would try and engage with residents in those areas to secure volunteers. It was also requested that special recognition be recorded to [name removed], Integrated Transport Officer, who had undertaken an enormous task identifying all of the grit bins and locating volunteers for these.
Councillor P Smart: With regards to exploitation issues and joint working, In November 2018 the Police and Ipswich Borough Council visited a property in Harland Street where 27 people ... view the full minutes text for item 56.
Bridge Ward Councillor P Smart confirmed that the Residents Parking Scheme in Old Stoke was now at design stage and would hopefully be implemented by mid March 2020.
Councillor Smart proposed that condition 6 be amended to consider lockable bollards to protect the parking allocated for future residents, and this was agreed. The updated Officer recommendation of approval was put to the meeting and was lost.
Councillor Smart commented on the limited sustainable transport options for this site in light of there being no pavement on Bourne Hill towards Ipswich, a lack of bus stop provision and very limited bus services; to mitigate this would require new bus stops and a crossing to link them, but this was unlikely to be acceptable to Suffolk Highways due to the proximity of the A14 junction.
72.1 Councillor P Smart introduced the report, explaining that it was proposed that Ipswich Borough Council would carry out parking enforcement in parts of Mid-Suffolk and Babergh , following the decriminalisation of parking offences and withdrawal of parking enforcement by the Police. In return for taking this on Ipswich Borough Council would benefit from the income from Cromwell Square car park, which would be available to spend on transport related projects.
72.2 Councillor P Smart noted that there was still some uncertainty about the date on which the required Statutory Instrument would be made, however, the Council would require a minimum of 3 months to prepare for implementation.
Councillor P Smart explained that if the recommendations of the report were agreed officers would be empowered to enter into Civil Parking Enforcement Agency Agreements with Suffolk County Council and Babergh and Mid-Suffolk District Councils but that no irredeemable costs would be incurred until after the Statutory Instrument had been laid before Parliament.
21.1 Councillor P Smart introduced the Annual Update on the Environment and Transport portfolio. Key points made were:
Councillor P Smart explained that they had not been in use for long enough for an accurate picture to be given, however, a report to Executive reviewing the scheme was planned and he hoped that this would include the number of litres of fuel avoided.
Councillor P Smart explained that there was unfortunately a national trend for increasing amounts of black bin waste, although there were also local issues with contamination on some rounds being so bad that recycling was disposed of as if it were black bin waste. Councillor P ... view the full minutes text for item 21.
Councillor P Smart commented that any changes to the Westerfield crossing should be considered in relation to supporting the doubling of freight from Felixstowe rather than the temporary period for the construction of Sizewell C.
Councillor P Smart commented that the Rail-Led Strategy should not be ‘watered down’ and highlighted that the Integrated Strategy did not offer much improvement in comparison to the Road-Led Strategy.
Councillor P Smart also highlighted that the East Suffolk railway line improvements would help to encourage more sustainable travel in the future, which would help to support the aims of recent Climate Emergency declarations.
Councillor P Smart commented that the proposed housing on the fringes of Ipswich could equate to over 5,000 residents and highlighted the need for contributions to alleviate the impact on Ipswich.
Councillor P Smart added that although contributions were being proposed for A14 junction improvements, it would be preferable to consider how increases in traffic flows could better be mitigated, for example, similar traffic attenuation measures to those employed along Norwich Road where traffic was held at Bury Road and released at a rate that could be accommodated further along the road network.
Councillor P Smart also advocated contributions towards providing a bus network and public transport improvements. The Planning Policy Team Leader reported that a joint strategy would be put in place to mitigate transport and air quality issues relating to fringe developments, which would consider improvements to public transport. Officers would work with the Ipswich Strategic Planning Area Board to ensure that land would be reserved to deliver these improvements, e.g. bus stops, cycle network.
Councillor P Smart highlighted that contributions to mitigate the impact on Ipswich’s services needed to be made up front to be effective, e.g. the bus service on the Ravenswood was implemented at the start of that development.
Councillor P Smart reported that there had been a number of complaints made with regards to weed growth in pavements and Suffolk County Council had been requested to increase the budget for next years’ weed treatment programme, which had been reduced to only once per year.
42.6 Councillor Smart noted that the Police gave little priority to traffic offences as the fines levied were paid to Central Government, whereas any fines issued by the Council under a Traffic Regulation Order could be used to fund additional enforcement activity.
44.1 Councillor Smart explained that it was proposed to introduce a policy banning the release and sale of both sky lanterns and balloons on parks and open spaces controlled by Ipswich Borough Council. This policy would then be incorporated into the relevant byelaws as part of the ongoing review of Parks Byelaws.
Councillor Smart explained that the reason for introducing this ban was the significant environmental damage which could be done by balloons and sky lanterns.
Councillor Smart commented that whilst the ban could only cover Council land, he hoped it would set an example to others and raise awareness of the damage which could be done by releasing sky lanterns and balloons.
44.3 Councillor Smart replied that a policy was necessary to give officers a basis on which to decline requests, whilst the introduction of byelaws would enable parks officers to stop anyone from trying to release balloons and sky lanterns, which at present was not possible.
Councillor Smart, having a family member employed by the East of England Cooperative Society on this site, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/18/00948/OUTFL) and left the room during the consideration of this item.
Re: Steam Boat Tavern: Councillor P Smart queried whether the adjoining land was in different ownership to the building itself. The Planning & Development Operations Manager confirmed that the building and adjoining land were in different ownership, and therefore the Enforcement Officers had been engaging with the landowner, not the landlord.
Councillor P Smart advised that following an engineers report undertaken on the Anglian Water noise, a number of possible sources for the noise had been identified and work to solve these had been undertaken. It was requested that a special thanks to the Environmental Health Team at Ipswich Borough Council be placed on record for their work in resolving the noise issues for residents.
26.1 Councillor P Smart introduced the report, explaining that ‘Climate Emergencies’ had been declared by a number of Councils to show their concern over the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s findings which recognise the adverse global impact of the changing climate.
Councillor Smart explained that the decision to make the declaration was being brought to Executive to enable it to be taken quickly and to allow for action to be agreed.
26.2 Councillor Smart commented that declaring a ‘Climate Emergency’ would only be the beginning of a large amount of work to achieve carbon neutrality by 2030. A cross party working group would be created to draft a Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan.
Councillor Smart explained some of the projects which the Council had already undertaken to reduce its carbon footprint and noted that the report proposed £100,000 per annum of capital expenditure to fund the plan, as well as £50,000 to fund officer support in developing the Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan.
Question 1 – Councillor Holmes ‘Why has the Executive not put forward this proposal as a declaration for the full Council which is the position taken by the other councils, including Suffolk County Council, mentioned in the Report, which have declared climate emergencies?’ 26.4 Councillor Smart explained that it had been felt that the proposal needed action at the earliest opportunity and so rather than waiting for a debate at the next meeting of Council a report had been brought to Executive.
Councillor Smart commented that the benefit of the report being considered by Executive was that resources could be allocated and stated that Ipswich was no less committed than other Councils.
26.5 Councillor Smart confirmed that Performance and Monitoring would be an important part of the Action Plan.
26.6 Councillor Smart noted that a similar question had been answered at the previous Executive meeting.
Councillor Smart confirmed that the Council built homes to Level 4 of the Code for Sustainable Homes but that it couldn’t force other builders to do so.
Councillor Smart commented that all options, such as this proposal, could be considered as part of the process of agreeing the Action Plan but noted that there would have to be some trade-offs about what was included in the Action Plan.
Councillor P Smart, being acquainted with one of the objectors, but having not discussed the application with them, declared an interest in Item 2 (IP/19/00250/FUL).
Councillor Smart asked whether it would be possible to separate the previous years’ figures for the 2 venues. [name removed] commented that this could be done, but there would not be separate target figures.
Councillor Smart highlighted that the probability representing ‘Very High’ in the Impact Table should be ‘ > 75%’.
Councillor Smart asked whether the monetary values of the impact categories were reviewed periodically and how would this be done. [name removed] commented that these values would be looked at in terms of the overall budget of the Service.
Councillor P Smart requested that the minutes be amended to read that:
Councillor P Smart confirmed that as per the minutes on page 7, and the recommendations which the Committee had agreed regarding the bus stop relocation from 13 Heatherhayes, no changes would be made to what had been resolved. However, following an advertisement for a bus stop clear way order in Broomhayes, a late objection had been received and this matter would be considered further by Officers to try and find the best solution.
Bridge Ward Councillor P Smart reported that with regards to the Anglian Water noise issue, a survey report following an examination of this had been issued by consultants and provided to the Environmental Health team at Ipswich Borough Council. This detailed what remedial action could be undertaken between the Council and Anglian Water to address the situation however, in the meantime the direct line residents could ring for updates was 0345 791 9155.
Councillor P Smart confirmed that Gippeswyk Park, Christchurch Park and Chantry Park would not be used for parking. A presentation on the plans which had been put in place for the concerts would be provided at the next South West Area Committee meeting on Thursday 11 July 2019.
Councillor P Smart confirmed that the frequency of bus services was the responsibility of the bus operators and their commercial judgement, and was not a matter which the Council could advise on. Generally densest populations would have a higher frequency service.
Councillor Smart, having a family member employed by the East of England Cooperative Society on this site, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/18/00948/OUTFL) and left the room during the consideration of this item.
Councillor Smart raised concern about the vehicular access to the site for refuse vehicles and proposed that condition 9 be amended to ‘…. provision of access, including by refuse vehicles, and vehicular areas’, and this was agreed.
MAYOR’S COMMUNICATIONS The Mayor thanked Councillor P Smart and Councillor Ross for nominating her and went on to inform Council that the theme she had chosen for her year in office was “The Young are Our Future”. The Mayor was supporting the WASSUP and We Are Patrick projects, which were facilitated by Volunteering Matters (Registered Charity No.
Councillor P Smart reported on some recent changes to bin collections following the Council’s agreement to adopt the same method of disposal as other districts in the area to ensure brown bins could remain free for collection. The brown bin collections would no longer include any kitchen waste and in future they would only be used for garden waste. Tetra Pak and kitchen utensils would also no longer be eligible for blue bin waste.
Councillor P Smart confirmed that a meeting had been held with the Portfolio Holder for Housing and the Head of Housing at Ipswich Borough Council to discuss a scheme to improve parking on Glamorgan Road. A proposal was due to be put forward later this month.
137.1 Councillor P Smart explained that the report proposed the replacement of 67 small vehicles and 13 Heavy Goods Vehicles (HGVs). The replacement of these vehicles was necessary to ensure the reliability of the fleet.
137.2 Councillor P Smart reported that all of the small vehicles would be electrically powered, whilst the new HGVs would be more efficient diesel vehicles.
Councillor Smart noted that electric refuse lorries were being trialled but explained that the technology was not yet sufficiently advanced to allow the Council to purchase them and that the need for new refuse lorries was pressing.
137.3 Councillor P Smart explained that it was proposed to purchase these vehicles through the Crown Commercial Service Framework which gave the Council access to a range of discounts.
137.4 Councillor P Smart noted that the explanation to the delegation in paragraph 4.14 did not reflect that the Portfolio Holder for Environment and Transport would also need to be consulted on and agree to any purchases, but that the recommendation at 13.2 b did properly explain the proposed arrangement.
Councillor P Smart explained that the Council was committed to reducing the impact that its fleet of vehicles had on the environment and that this was clearly demonstrated in the report.
Councillor P Smart said that the replacement of vehicles with low or no carbon alternatives would be an important contribution towards achieving the Council’s reduction targets and that the reduction in carbon emissions would be measured through the regular carbon footprint calculations as part of the Council’s carbon reduction strategy.
Councillor Smart reported that the programme involved projects aimed at reducing emissions across all of IBC’s operations, therefore effectively offsetting emissions in areas where the Council was unable to make further reductions in carbon.
Councillor Smart added that one of the key deliverables of this vehicle replacement programme would be a 33% reduction in NOx emissions from the Council’s fleet of vehicles.
Councillor P Smart explained that the proposal would in fact only replace 40% of the Council’s vehicle fleet and that it was indeed the hope that future replacement programmes would be able to take advantage of newer, more environmentally ... view the full minutes text for item 137.
Councillor Smart, having met with objectors to the application, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/18/01013/FUL) and did not participate in the vote to defer this application.
Councillor Smart asked whether reducing the mass of the middle two houses could be investigated with the applicant.
Councillor Smart queried the future use of the vehicular areas and proposed that condition 8 be amended to request that these areas be retained in the future, and this was agreed.
It was RESOLVED on a motion MOVED by Councillor P Smart and SECONDED by Councillor Reynolds:
67.1 Councillor P Smart, the IBC Portfolio Holder for Environment & Transport presented this report which sought funding towards the cost of operating a No 4 bus service on Sundays and Bank Holiday daytimes for an 18 month experimental period. He explained the background of how First Eastern Buses Ltd had rerouted the Nos 75, 76 and 77 buses between Ipswich and Felixstowe which had resulted in a section between Bishop’s Hill and Bixley Road (and numerous residential side roads off this section) which included Felixstowe Road and Broke Hall, no longer being served.
Councillor P Smart said that this year’s fund had been already been allocated to subsidise other services but should the experimental service prove sustainable then the budget could be increased to include this service.
Councillor Smart asked about the characteristics of an ‘autism-friendly relaxed opening’ of the museums. [name removed] (Colchester Museums Manager) reported that on the first Sunday of the month, Colchester Castle was opened up an hour earlier and a calming atmosphere was provided by minimising unexpected noise, e.g. audio elements of the displays were switched off, papers towels instead of hand driers in the toilets; no people were excluded during this time, but visitors were made aware of what equipment would be switched off. Whilst the numbers involved in the autism-friendly pilots held so far were small, the feedback was very positive.
Councillor Smart asked whether there had been an audit of museums venues in terms of being dementia-friendly, e.g. visual layout, use of colours, patterns on flooring. [name removed] reported that a number of staff had received dementia awareness training, and consulting with appropriate stakeholders would be need to be factored into any future development of the museums services.
Councillor Smart commented that on the structure chart it was not possible to tell whether jobs were job-share and the number of people actually employed. [name removed] reported that some posts were split across Ipswich and Colchester, e.g. Exhibition and Display Officers; some roles were a combination of part-time posts in order to provide cover across different times of the day on a rota basis.
72.1 Councillor P Smart, Portfolio Holder for Environment and Transport, explained that bus services in most of the UK, including Ipswich, were run on a commercial basis, with operators required to compete rather than co-operate.
72.2 Councillor Smart explained that councils were allowed to subsidise socially necessary services, although the statutory duty to consider supporting services lay with Suffolk County Council, who were funded to do this.
Councillor Smart noted that as Suffolk County Council had the responsibility to consider subsidies they had been informed of the service changes made by First Buses in August 2018 and so would have had time to make arrangements to support a service before residents were affected.
Councillor Smart explained that Ipswich Borough Council only found out about the changes at the same time as residents and so did not have an opportunity to do this.
72.3 Councillor Smart reported that councils were restricted in what they were allowed to subsidise, and couldn’t, for example, pay to increase the frequency on an existing route, or create a new route which follows a largely similar route to an existing commercial one. It was however possible to subsidise a service to run additional services at times when it would not otherwise run.
72.4 Councillor Smart noted that he had suggested to First Buses that they run services via Lindbergh Road at Off-Peak times, however, they were not willing to consider this.
Councillor Smart had therefore looked at the possibility of subsidising the Number 4 bus to run on Sundays and Bank Holidays on an experimental basis.
Councillor Smart agreed to look into the condition of the stop at Tower Ramparts and explained that the bus stop at St Augustine’s Church had been moved as a result of a Suffolk County Council scheme and that he agreed that it had been badly placed.
Councillor P Smart reported that the response from the Old Stoke Resident Parking consultation had been very successful with 31% responses received of which approximately ¾’s of people had been in favour of the scheme. This would now be taken forward to Suffolk County Council for further consideration.
Also in attendance were Councillor P Smart as the Portfolio Holder for Environment & Transport, Sandy Martin MP for Ipswich and Michael Newsham, Integrated Transport Officer. 49.2 [name removed] confirmed that an unprecedented detailed aerodynamics study using computer modelling was being undertaken by the University College of London to determine how wind thresholds affected vehicle types at different speeds and directions of travel. The detailed 9 month study would be completed over the summer and would indicate whether the segregation of high sided vehicles off the A14 would be possible while allowing cars to continue during high winds or whether current closure thresholds could be decreased. The study would also indicate whether wind barriers could be installed on the bridge and how high sided traffic could rejoin the diversion route should it fail to adhere to any request to divert off of the main carriageway. 49.3 Work continued with Suffolk Highways to look at signage and alternative diversion routes and a proposal was being put forward to upgrade all the signs.
Councillor Smart commented that the introduction of a Variable Message Signage system in Ipswich was long overdue, explaining that the aim of the scheme was to reduce congestion by directing drivers to car parks where spaces were available.
Councillor Smart explained that there would be a criteria for which car parks were to be included on the signs, with car parks having to be of a certain size and not be temporary car parks. Invitations to be involved in the scheme had been issued to eligible private operators, and a number had already responded to say that they wished to be involved.
Councillor Smart noted that the costs would reduce should higher numbers of private operators join the scheme. There would be a small revenue budget implication, but it was hoped that additional car park income would offset this. 88.4. In accordance with Standing Orders Part 3 Section 3 Paragraph 3.5, the following question was asked :
What cost is being asked of the private car parks and would Executive consider waiving the costs if not enough private owners are willing to pay?’ Councillor Smart explained that the total amount of financial contribution that operators of private car parks would be required to contribute had not been finalised, as officers were currently gauging the level of interest.
Councillor Smart commented that it was not anticipated that Executive would waive costs for private operators, as any such decision would have a detrimental financial impact on the Council and constitute free advertising for the Council’s competitors.
Councillor Smart accepted that the system would be of greater benefit to the highway network if significant privately operated car parks were included, but noted that highways was actually a Suffolk County Council responsibility.
Councillor Smart noted that the system was configurable and that further operators could be added after the signs were installed.
Councillor P Smart, Portfolio Holder for Environment & Transport and Michael Newsham, Integrated Transport Officer at IBC were also both in attendance. 44.2 [name removed] said that following First Eastern’s previous attendance at the Overview & Scrutiny Committee they were now in a position to compare the passenger figures which showed an increase although traffic congestion continued to be the main impact on services. First Eastern Ltd were keen to work with IBC and Suffolk County Council to promote the use of the Park & Ride Service as often the journey from the London Road site to the town centre could be as little as 10 minutes, while this time could quite easily be the time spent queuing to get into a town centre car park. 44.3 [name removed] said that local businesses had been approached who could offer up to a 75% discount for staff using the Park & Ride Service. A successful bid had been submitted to Highways England to improve the infrastructure on parts of the Park & Ride network including the signs on the arterial roads advertising the sites.
44.8 Councillor P Smart said that Mid Suffolk and Babergh District Councils were also encouraged to use the service since their employees had moved to Endeavour House and this would benefit the passenger figures. In relation to commuters, even if the Park & Ride started earlier they could ... view the full minutes text for item 44.
Councillor P Smart explained that there were restrictions on what Ipswich Borough Council could subsidise, noting that much of the routes affected by these change ran outside of the borough boundary.
Councillor Smart added that in any case a tender process would need to be followed before the Council could subsidise a route, and that whilst Suffolk County Council had been informed of the changes in early September, the Borough Council had not been notified until much later and so had not ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
County Councillor West commented that he had raised this issue with the Head of Transport Strategy at SCC and added that he would discuss the matter with Councillor Smart, IBC Portfolio Holder for Environment and Transport, at their next meeting.
Showing the latest 300 of 489.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Smart attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Jul 2017 | Council | To Consider a Motion from Councillor R Pope | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Nov 2016 | Council | C/16/13 To Consider a Report from Councillor D Ellesmere on the Norfolk & Suffolk Devolution Proposal. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Sep 2016 | Council | C/16/07 To Consider a Report from Mrs K Forster, Chair of the Independent Remuneration Panel, on a Review of Councillors' Allowance Scheme. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jun 2016 | Council | Motion to Council - Suffolk Solidarity | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Smart was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 12 of 17 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Smart declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 Jan 2021 | Executive, item 74 | Councillor P Smart declared an Interest in Item 6, E/20/31 Additional Restrictions Grant (ARG), and left the meeting during the consideration of this item. | Left the room |
| 6 Feb 2019 | Planning & Development Committee, item 96 | Councillor Smart, having met with objectors to the application, declared an interest in Item 1 (IP/18/01013/FUL) and did not participate in the vote to defer this application. | Took no part |
Where Councillor Smart sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Executive | Committee Member | Jun 2012 | 154 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | May 2012 | 100 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Planning & Development Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2013 | 43 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Hackney Carriage & Private Hire Enforcement Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2026 | 1 | |
| Licensing & Regulatory Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2026 | 1 | |
| Licensing & Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| South West Area Committee | Committee Member | May 2012 | 71 | |
| Colchester & Ipswich Joint Museums Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2015 | 18 | |
| Strategic Overview & Scrutiny Committee | Guest | Jan 2020 | 6 | |
| Human Resources Committee | Substitute | Jan 2013 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.