PC30
Councillor Bubb (Councillor Crofts substitute), Councillor Anota and Councillor de Whalley.
Every time King's Lynn and West Norfolk's minutes name Councillor Crofts, as the council published it.
Councillor Bubb (Councillor Crofts substitute), Councillor Anota and Councillor de Whalley.
The Chair thanked Councillor Crofts for being a substitute at the meeting.
In response to Councillor Crofts, the Interim Corporate Governance Officer explained ICO stood for Information Commissioner’s Office which is the supervisory authority for Data Protection matters.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, it was confirmed that the next CIL Spending Panel meeting was scheduled for 22 June, at which time applications relating to local projects would be considered.
The Chair thanked Councillor Crofts for being a substitute at the meeting.
Councillor Crofts asked about the implications of removing the statutory duty to cooperate. The Principal Planner explained that although the legal requirement had been removed, practical cooperation with neighbouring authorities was still necessary, statutory consultees still had to be engaged, and the need to demonstrate compliance to a planning inspector was now less stringent.
In response to comments from Councillor Crofts, the Portfolio Holder for People and Communities explained that making empty residential properties and flats above shops habitable would help bring more people into the town to support local businesses and highlighted how the two approaches complemented each other.
Councillor Crofts commented on the low response rate and Clive Joynes commented that 6.5% response rate was considered significant and the Committee would have to make a judgement on what was best for the Communities.
Councillor Crofts commented that it was suggested at a previous Planning Committee meeting that alongside where the buses park, the parking area would be extended into that area and asked if it was ever acted upon. The Regeneration Programmes Manager advised no further proposal was implemented.
Councillor Crofts stated that King’s Lynn town was not promoted fully as it should be.
Councillor Crofts suggested that coach companies should be encouraged to promote excursions and proposed using the Tuesday Market Place as a central coach parking area to attract visitors. He also believed that funding associated with the Shakespeare Barn had been intended to provide coach parking for visitors. In response, the Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Business confirmed that this was addressed within the King’s Lynn Masterplan.
Councillor Crofts commented on allotments included in the policy and sought clarification in what was meant by “without the consent of the Secretary of State”. He added untenanted allotments such as North Lynn and West Lynn, could be used by the Borough Council for other uses.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, it was confirmed that the map included in the draft Terms of Reference included all of the unparished area.
Councillor Crofts questioned whether the southern extent of the unparished area should be included and it was noted that this would need to be a separate specific question within the CGR process.
Councillor Crofts commented that it was important that the Civic Tradition and history of the Borough was not lost.
Councillor Crofts raised concern around a low number of Parish Councillors making important decisions, such as setting the precept, but acknowledged the need for the reduction in numbers and ultimately supported the recommendation.
Councillor Crofts questioned the control members had to ensure the parish council had spent the CIL funding that had been awarded and was advised this was monitored annually and parish councils had a statutory obligation to submit an annual report to the Borough Council on the CIL funding which had been spent or not.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, Councillor Lintern commented that coast parking facilities in the town centre would be looked at within the Car Parking Strategy and the King’s Lynn Masterplan.
Councillor Crofts commented that it was important that the Panel be kept up to date on work in this area along with updates on changes to the National Planning Policy Framework.
Councillor Kirk 9/1(a) West Walton Councillor Morley 9/2(a) Bircham Councillor de Winton 9/2(b) Brancaster Councillor Crofts 9/2(f) Outwell Councillor Ayres 9/2(g) Tilney St Lawrence
In response to Councillor Crofts, the Assistant Director for Resources and Section 151 confirmed the Council were currently borrowing £6.5m from Middlesbrough Teeside Pension Fund (£3.5m payable 7th February 2025 and £3m payable 24th February 2025). She added the Council had £4m invested with South Ayrshire Council until October 25.
Councillor Crofts commented that there was an empty green area next to the Charity Shop that could be considered.
The Chair thanked Councillor Crofts for being a substitute at the meeting.
Councillor Crofts asked how the limit of twelve would be controlled for events and the Applicant’s Representative stated that they would only accept bookings for up to twelve people.
Councillor Crofts referred to the Interested Party’s letter of objection and the referral to public nuisance relating to parking arrangements and the Applicant’s Representative stated that there was no on site car parking and customers who used the driveway were directed to alternative parking places. He stated that the area was not heavy with traffic.
Councillor Crofts referred to the shared driveway ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Crofts sought clarification on Oasis facilities and specifically the indoor bowls facilities used. He commented there was a lack of use in other leisure centres such as North Walsham and the Reef leisure centre. He referred to Oasis being on the sea front and added the toilets needed updating and to charge people for the facilities and commented this was a source of income which other Council’s use .
In response to Councillor Crofts, he commented at Lynnsport there was indoor bowls facilities including five rinks which could continue to be provided and was within a reasonable travel distance from Hunstanton.
Councillor Crofts commented that surrounding areas such as Wisbech did not have indoor bowls facilities and they were difficult to maintain as there was not the support for the facilities. He commented further he would support that the facilities at Hunstanton be closed and better facilities at Lynnsport provided to encourage usage.
Councillor Crofts asked if there was likely to be a change in CIL application arrangements for the next round.
Councillor Crofts referred to the Outwell application and explained that the railings were in poor state of repair and no organisation had taken ownership of them. The Parish Council would take responsibility for the railings if funding was awarded and this was important for the safety of users of the area. He supported the application for CIL funding.
Councillor Crofts commented that he supported the application for Emneth as it was a well-used playing field.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts it was explained that not all of the site had been decontaminated and work was being carried out as required during development. Options were still being considered for the proposed Active Travel Hub site which was still contaminated.
In response to a further question from Councillor Crofts, the Assistant Director explained that contracts had been agreed for some of the speculative units and some expressions of interest had been received for the light industrial units. The site had been marketed and the Council were in the process of carrying out a rebranding exercise and a wider marketing push. The Regeneration Programmes Manager agreed to keep the Panel updated on the marketing of the site.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts it was confirmed that the Savage Statue was outside of the Masterplan area and would not be affected. It was noted that the plan would note impact heritage assets near the site. The Regeneration Programmes Manager commented that interpretation and signage would be used to showcase and explain the history and heritage of the area.
Councillor Crofts asked if Councillor Anota wished to thank the Grounds ... view the full minutes text for item C:47
Councillor Crofts referred to the Gypsy and Traveller allocated sites and referred to tolerated sites. The Planning Policy Manager explained that it was a legal requirement to meet the needs of all of the communities and the consultation on the Borough Council’s preferred sites and policies was now open. He encouraged Councillors and anyone who was interested to make representations through the consultation process.
Councillor Crofts noted that there wasn’t a village hall in the Village so the application should be supported.
Councillor Crofts commented that the Customs House was suited for a food ... view the full minutes text for item RD108:
Councillor Crofts made reference to the titles of the wards in the report which were not accurate. He commented on his previous experience as Chair of Upwell Parish Council and Small Lode which was one mile long and with a number of sites concentrated in one area. He asked if the allocated sites were the tolerated sites, then what is the situation with planning permission.
Councillor Crofts stated that the NPPF stated that there shouldn’t be a high number of sites in one area and should not cause concern to other residents, he asked why there was such a high allocation in Small Lode.
Councillor Crofts stated families concerned were the same family and therefore would not be available for the open market. That Senior Planning Officer stated there was a direct need for those existing families on existing sites and the Council is seeking to make provision for these families.
Councillor Crofts asked Councillor Anota for an update on refurbishment of Downham Market toilets. He explained that it was moving forward and an updated proposal would be coming forward.
Councillor Crofts commented that the Internal Drainage Board Easement Strip was wider than he expected, and the Assistant Director explained that this was at the request of the Internal Drainage Board.
In response to further questions from Councillor Crofts relating to air source heat pumps, the Assistant Director explained that technology had improved, and they required the same amount of maintenance as a gas boiler. He explained that retrospective installations could be problematic, but they were generally fine in new builds. He explained that modern air source heat points were virtually silent.
Councillor Crofts referred to the market and events area and asked if there was a plan in place for its use. The Regeneration Programmes Manager explained that the use of the space would be driven by the buildings and property owners surrounding the area and could be used to supplement activities at the MUCH.
Councillor Crofts asked Councillor Beal how well used the Spinney area was, which was a similar multi user space in Hunstanton and Councillor Beal stated that it had been used a couple of times in the past year.
Councillor Crofts explained that licences would need to be in place for live or recorded music.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, it was explained that six sites had come forward following the call for sites. Additionally three Borough Council and one Norfolk County Council site had also been brought forward for consideration. It was confirmed that the Saddlebow and Blunts Drove sites were operated as public sites for Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation.
In response to a further question from Councillor Crofts regarding the overwhelming of sites and joint working with neighbouring Local Authorities, it was explained that the Council was required to meet their own accommodation needs for Gypsies, Traveller and Travelling Showpeople , but had met with Officers from Fenland District Council to look at joint working opportunities. It was also explained that the consultation would provide the opportunity for comments to be received by stakeholders such as Fenland District Council.
Councillor Crofts stated that he would not be addressing the Committee under Standing Order 34 on the Outwell application, but would now be taking part as a member of the Committee.
Councillor Crofts asked what assurances were in place to ensure that allocated CIL funds were spent correctly, and the Planning Control Manager explained that annual reports had to be provided and recipients also had to sign a contract and terms of reference. They also had to adhere to timescales and progress was monitored by the CIL Team. Monitoring methods were included in the Governance Document.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, it was explained that a variety of options would be explored once the expression of interest exercise had opened.
Councillor Crofts commented that work needed to be done to encourage coach trips into King’s Lynn. He suggested that research should be carried out on why King’s Lynn was not a destination for coach trips. He commented that coach parking should be made available on the Tuesday Market Place so that facilities were nearby.
Councillor Crofts was appointed Chair for the Hearing.
Councillor Crofts declared an interest in application 9/3(b) – Outwell and would take no part in the debate but would address the Committee under Standing Order 34.
Councillor C Crofts 9/3(b) Outwell
In response to Councillor Crofts question on when it was expected to have an update on the Local Plan Examination, Councillor Blunt stated that the work was almost complete and he would be discussing the criteria based policy with the task group Vice-Chair in readiness for the 26 April deadline. From there the Inspectors would decide if it was acceptable and make recommendations on the soundness of the process and following a consultation process it would come back to the Council for further consideration.
Councillor Crofts asked for an update on CIL applications from January.
Councillor Crofts asked for the breakdown of the amount of Council Tax collected which came to the Borough. This was confirmed as 7% which came to the Borough, and 3% of that was passed out to the IDBs leaving 4% to the Borough.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts it was explained that the engagement process would include an online survey, advertising on social media and would be as wide spread as possible using the resources available.
Councillor Crofts commented that he would like to see the Informal Working Group investigate attracting coach trips to King’s Lynn and West Norfolk.
Councillor Crofts commented that this type of facility had been popular in other parts of the Country and it was important to undertake a commercial venture to reduce the amount of leisure subsidy.
Councillor Crofts asked about the hire of rooms and extended opening hours. Natasha Hayes explained that the open libraries provision looked to open the facilities longer and ways of doing this safely would be looked at. It was the intention to make the facility as accessible as possible.
Councillor Crofts asked if safe storage facilities would be available and if there would be a charge for the use of facilities. It was explained that there would be a nominal charge and membership schemes and card entry systems were some of the solutions that were being looked at. The area would also be covered by CCTV and emergency exits would be available.
Councillor Crofts referred to the money that was to be spent to provide facilities for the Pontoons, but that there was no money for coach parking and facilities for coaches, which would encourage bus trips into the town. The Assistant Director agreed that it was important to provide facilities for coach parties, but queried if the waterfront was the right location for this.
Councillor Blunt gave an update on CIL following a question from Councillor Crofts.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, it was explained that the running of the facility was not a consideration in this application and Members were reminded that the project would be subject to development work.
Councillor Crofts broadly supported the project and felt that it was important that it was well marketed and needed to be cost effective. He made reference to commercial elements and that lessons should be learned from the previous failed HLF bid. King’s Lynn as a Heritage Centre needed to be promoted as a whole .
Councillor Crofts explained that he was keen on promoting coach trips into the town centre and this project could be a catalyst for this. Information was provided from officers on the CIO business plan and marketing support.
Councillor Crofts commented that a ‘salesman’ was needed to promote coach trips to King’s Lynn and survey coach companies to ask why they did not use King’s Lynn as a destination for trips. He also commented that a coach park was needed in the town centre and the Tuesday Market Place would be an ideal location as it had nearby facilities. The Panel generally supported increased promotion of the town centre for coach trips.
Following a question from Councillor Crofts, Councillor Dark gave an update on the work the Council and its Partners were doing to support Ukrainian refugees arriving in the country.
Councillor Crofts asked if Hardings Way would be considered as an alternative route into the Town and the Assistant Director informed Councillor Crofts that his comments would be considered.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, the Cemeteries and Crematorium Manager outlined the process for closing a Churchyard. He explained that it would transfer to the Parish, but they could forfeit this to the Borough Council. If the Parish decided to maintain the closed Churchyard, they would be responsible for health and safety issues.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts it was explained that if the Council was responsible for a closed Churchyard, it would be responsible for the whole area, including footpaths and walls.
Councillor Crofts explained that previously the Council used to get a percentage of Internal Drainage Board levies back from the Government and asked if this was still the case. The Assistant Director explained that this previously came through the Revenue Support Grant, but now nothing came back to the Council. She also made reference to the Revenue Support Grant and Rural Services Grant and that they were now only based on a one year settlement and would most probably not continue for much longer.
Councillor Crofts referred to Stoke Ferry Neighbourhood Plan and affordable housing. It was explained that options for affordable custom build housing would be explored and initial discussions had been held with Stoke Ferry Parish Council. It was noted that half of the site was allocated for housing within the Local Plan.
In response to a further question from Councillor Crofts, it was explained that issues such as maintenance of open spaces would be looked at in more detail as part of the planning application process.
Councillor Crofts asked Councillor Blunt what the timings were for the next CIL applications.
Councillor Crofts asked if more could be done to encourage coach trips into the town centre and Vicky Etheridge explained that she had been working with the Tourism Officer at the Borough Council on encouraging visitors to the town centre.
Councillor Crofts commented that the Tuesday Market Place would be ideal for coach parking as it was central and had facilities nearby.
Councillor Crofts supported the idea, but felt that a different location should be considered.
Councillor Blunt responded to a question from Councillor Crofts on the complexity of CIL. He explained he had been looking at the process which he was looking to simplify. Paper was to be taken to the CIL Spending Panel before its route through to Cabinet.
Councillor Crofts referred to the importance of tourism and making King’s Lynn a destination for day trips and excursions.
Click here to view the recording of this item on You Tube Councillor Crofts as Chair of Planning Committee was asked a question on the calling in of planning applications, to which he confirmed it was useful for them to be on planning grounds.
In response to a question on the timing of the reconvened Planning Meeting the following week, Councillor Crofts confirmed he had taken Councillor Joyce’s suggestion to defer. The reconvened meeting was decided upon as a suitable date shortly after the deferment.
Councillor Crofts as Chair of Planning responded to a question on not speaking to the public whilst on site visits.
C Crofts 8/2(c) Outwell The Chair, Councillor Crofts advised that he would not take part in the debate or vote on the matter. The Vice-Chair took the Chair for this item of business.
AGREED: Councillor C J Crofts be appointed Vice Chair for the meeting.
· Councillor Crofts declared that he was a Member of the King’s Lynn Internal Drainage Board and East of Ouse Internal Drainage Board.
Councillor C J Crofts – Item 9.
At the invitation of the Chair, Councillor C J Crofts Chair of the Planning Committee addressed the Panel and explained that he had concern when the sifting panel was initially set up. However, the Chair explained that he now fully supported the operation of the sifting panel. .
Councillor Crofts, Bubb and Kirk declared that they were Members of the King’s Lynn Internal Drainage Board, which had made comments on item 8/1(g) – Walpole Cross Keys.
The Minutes of the Meeting held on Monday, 3 February 2020 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair, Councillor C J Crofts.
The minutes of the meeting held on 2 December 2019 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair, Councillor Crofts.
The Chair, Councillor Crofts reported that any correspondence received had been read and passed to the appropriate officer.
AGREED: Councillor C J Crofts be appointed Vice-Chair for the meeting.
AGREED: Councillor Crofts was appointed as Vice Chair for the meeting.
Councillor Crofts explained that he had a specific issue relating to this which he would take up with officers.
The Chair, Councillor Crofts reported that any correspondence received had been read and passed to the appropriate officer.
The minutes of the meeting held on 29 July 2019 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair, Councillor Crofts.
The Chair, Councillor Crofts reported that any correspondence received had been read and passed to the appropriate officer.
The Minutes of the Meeting held on 1 July 2019 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman, Councillor Crofts.
The Chair, Councillor Crofts reported that any correspondence received and been read and passed to the appropriate officer.
Councillor Crofts declined the request and commented that it was not helpful of cost effective and members had the opportunity to ask questions in the Committee.
(iii) 19/00857/O Outline application with some matters reserved for site for construction of bungalow and garage at Plot 4, Abbotts Court, off Isle Bridge Road, Outwell Councillor Crofts took no part in the discussion as he was acquainted the applicant.
The Minutes of the Meeting held on 3 June 2019 and the Reconvened Meeting held on 6 June 2019 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman, Councillor Crofts.
Councillor Crofts declared that he was a Member of the King’s Lynn Internal Drainage Board.
The Chairman, Councillor Crofts reported that he had not received any correspondence.
The Chairman, Councillor Crofts declared that he was a Member of the King’s Lynn Internal Drainage Board.
The Chairman, Councillor Crofts reported that he had not received any correspondence.
Councillor Crofts commented that there were not many companies that offered bus trips to King’s Lynn and he felt that King’s Lynn should be promoted as a destination for coach excursions.
Councillor Crofts declared that he was a Member of the Internal Drainage Board, who had made comments on the application.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts it was explained that the result of the CCF bid was expected in April 2019.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts it was explained that allocated site F was part of the growth area and no specific progress had been made on this site, other than that it had been included in the IDP. The Panel was also informed that extra capacity in the highways network would be required before some of the development could come forward and development would need to be phased as necessary.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, the Property Services Manager explained that work was carried out to try and attract tenants such as flexible rent rates and stepped rents etc.
Councillor Crofts commented that he felt that bus trips into the town centre should be promoted more. He provided examples of bus trips to other locations, but commented that there were not many that came into King’s Lynn. He asked if this was something that the BID had been looking at.
18/00198/F Old Hunstanton : The Bungalow, Waterworks Road: Construction of 3 dwellings following demolition of existing bungalow: [name removed] stated that he still supported the application following the site visit. He felt that the proposal would not be as high as the former Linksway Hotel and referred to the modern building on the opposite side of the road and considered that the proposal would fit in with the area. In addition, he thought that the access would provide a better visibility splay.
Councillor Crofts referred to the history of the site and the fact that officers had originally recommended approval for 4 units on the site, which the Committee refused and was then ... view the full minutes text for item PC13:
The Chairman, Councillor Tyler, thanked Councillor Crofts, who had covered some Licensing Hearings for him when he was unavailable. He also thanked officers for their help and support.
Councillor Crofts commented that the Royal British Legion may already have a list and the Partnership and Funding Officer agreed to look into what records were already kept.
Under Standing Order 34 Councillor C Crofts commented on his vision for the encouragement of coach excursions to the town to encourage tourists to visit by providing user friendly drop off sites for coaches with some facilities. He had carried out research and very few coach companies came to the town for the day, when they did do to other towns with far less to offer. He therefore felt that this should be incorporated into the plan.
The Panel was reminded that Councillor Crofts had requested that this item be considered by the Panel.
Councillor Crofts explained that he felt that not many bus companies offered trips and excursions to King’s Lynn. He thought that work needed to be carried out to promote King’s Lynn as a destination for coach trips.
· A coach drop off point could be incorporated into the Riverfront Development Plan and Councillor Crofts agreed to attend Cabinet under Standing Order 34 when the item was discussed.
Councillor Crofts informed those present that he supported option three. He acknowledged the concerns about Hardings Way, but felt that the road was underused and consideration needed to be given to the cost benefit of the road.
Councillor Crofts referred to air quality issues along London Road and that if traffic was to increase the air quality would reduce.
Councillor Crofts also hoped that the riverfront area would be easily accessed to tourists and encourage bus trips to the area.
Councillor Crofts agreed that an entrance from Sea Lane would be better. He also agreed that the area was cluttered. He also referred to the hedge on the right hand side, which was out of the applicant’s control.
Councillor C J Crofts offered his apologies for the meeting on 12 October.
Councillor Crofts declared a pecuniary interest in item 8/3(g) – Upwell , and would leave the meeting during consideration of the application.
Councillor Crofts addressed the Panel under Standing Order 34. He commented that he would strongly support the introduction of pay to use loos. He referred to other Local Authorities who charged for the service and felt that Hunstanton was a prime area for a trial for a paid facility.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, it was confirmed that the costs to install pay to use loos would include equipment, but the biggest cost would be installing a power supply.
Councillor Crofts added that he was also grateful to have seen the site from the various locations. He also could not see any planning reason to refuse the application and therefore supported the application.
Councillor Crofts asked whether developers could be required to make affordable housing contributions before the site was completed. He added that affordable housing was needed in some areas but not others and asked whether it would be possible for money generated in that ward to be ring-fenced.
At the request of Councillor Crofts, the Democratic Services Officer outlined the differences between a Task Group and Informal Working Group to the Panel.
Councillor Crofts stated that he would prefer to see a small cul-de-sac which would be more in keeping with the surrounding area. He also referred to the potential traffic movements which would be generated by the development. He considered that there were other sites which were more suitable than this site.
Neighbouring Authorities – Plan Consultations At the meeting held on 10 April 2016, Councillor Crofts asked what procedures and policies were in place for dealing with cross boundary planning applications. The Principal Planner (Policy) explained that she had spoken to the Planning Control Manager and Principal Planner and they had confirmed that the relevant authorities consulted with each other if the application site had a cross boundary impact. One authority would take the lead role.
Site Allocations and Development Management Policies Pre-Submission Document – Draft Modifications Councillor Crofts had referred to a previous Government consultation relating to affordable housing contributions and that small developers did not have to make a financial contribution until after development had finished. The Principal Planner (Policy) explained that she had spoken to the Planning Control Manager and Principal Planner regarding a phased approach. Both officers had commented that the Borough Council do adopt a phased approach and seek comments from the Highways Authority, etc.
Councillor Crofts referred to page 16 – General Principles of Planning Consultation, bullet point 2 and suggested that the wording be amended to read:
Councillor Crofts referred to page 19 and the use of social media. In response, the Principal Planner (Policy) explained that the Council had included reference to the use of social media in future consultations to enable the use of social media where possible and also to assist with accessing hard to reach groups and the younger population.
Councillor Crofts proposed that this be agreed by the Committee, which was agreed.
Councillor Crofts suggested that publicity material could be sent out with the Council Tax bills and the Executive Director commented that the bills ... view the full minutes text for item RD64:
· Councillor Crofts referred to the Highways Ranger scheme and asked if they were responsible for clearing polythene out of bushes, which often looked unsightly. The Executive Director explained that this was the responsibility of the Borough Council. He explained that resources available were an issue, but perhaps certain problem areas could be targeted.
Councillor Crofts referred to the consultation period which was only four weeks and the LDF Manager explained that he hoped that responses about the methodology would be forthcoming. The subsequent ‘call for sites’ would be longer.
Councillor Crofts asked what procedures and policies were in place for dealing with cross boundary Planning Applications and the Principal Planner agreed to report back to the Task Group.
Councillor Crofts highlighted that page 82 had not had ‘at least’ added. The Principal Planner agreed to double check the plan and amend as required. She explained that the only exception to ‘at least’ was Hunstanton Policy F2.3 because of the different nature of the site, which was housing with care.
Councillor Crofts referred to a previous Government consultation relating to affordable housing contributions and that small developers did not have to make a financial contribution until after development had finished. The LDF Manager explained that this had been proposed to assist small developers who often could not afford to make the contribution upfront. The LDF Manager reminded the Task Group that the Government had introduced new rules relating to affordable housing and then subsequently withdrawn them.
· Councillor Crofts declared an interest in item 8/2(c), as a member of Upwell Parish Council but had not taken part in the debate.
Councillor Crofts referred to the Internal Drainage Board Levy and the Chief Executive explained that the Council was concerned regarding the Internal Drainage Boards levies which were paid by the Council to the various Boards. The levies counted as spending of the Council, but a contribution was made by Government as part of the financial settlement. Any substantial increase in the levies had an impact on the council tax payer who would pick up the residual costs.
Councillor Crofts referred to the public conveniences outside of the café and asked what improvements would be carried out to them. The Regeneration Project Officer explained that there were two sets of public conveniences within the area and both would undergo internal refurbishment along the same lines as the cliff top toilets. Improvements would be made to the external façade and this was detailed within the Activities Plan.
In response to a question from Councillor Crofts, the Enforcement Team Leader explained that a land charge would be placed on the land so that the Council could be reimbursed if any costs were associated with works where a notice had been defaulted on.
In response to a further question from Councillor Crofts, the Enforcement Team Leader confirmed that high hedge notices did not apply to fences. The Enforcement Team did deal with high hedges and a formula was used to determine if a high hedge was having a detrimental impact, which took into account the orientation of the sun and proximity to neighbours.
Councillor Crofts asked if there was a difference between mobile homes and caravans and the Housing Services Operations Manager explained that for the purpose of the residential caravan site licensing scheme it was considered to be a mobile structure and included park homes.
Councillor Crofts asked why the Borough Council sold food waste bags when they were widely available in supertmarkets . In response, the Council Information Centre Manager explained that the Council had decided to sell food waste bags.
Councillor Crofts referred to the affordable housing threshold and explained that he had recalled that a recent Cabinet report had changed the threshold to ten, however, the report stated that the threshold was five. He asked if Parish Councils would be made aware of the change to the affordable housing threshold. The Executive Director, Development Services explained that the Government had introduced the change in February 2015 and subsequently a report had been presented to Cabinet outlining the changes.
Councillor Crofts requested, and the Panel agreed, that Parish Council’s be informed of the position in relation to affordable housing and the Executive Director agreed to send out a briefing note.
Councillor Crofts pointed out that people living along Elm Road, Emneth , rather than at the back of B&Q as the notes stated, were experiencing problems with the impact of traffic onto the roundabout and expressed concern about the planning application for development which had been submitted.
Councillor Crofts commented on the local opposition regarding the West Winch proposal and asked if Parish Councils would be consulted again. In response, the LDF Manager explained that a petition of 90 signatures had been received at the consultation stage. A recommendation to Cabinet would be to reinstate the land at West Winch (approximately 320 units) as an allocation.
In response to questions from Councillor Crofts regarding applications being submitted and the timescales for representations to be made, the Executive Director, Planning and Environment explained that the planning process had a statutory consultation period and the Planning Committee would assess representations made. The test to be applied regarding the 5 year land supply was whether the proposed development was sustainable in the locality, in line with the NPPF.
Clarification was sought on the comment that Councillor Crofts request to be co-opted, to which it was explained that Councillor Crofts, a previous representative on the body had been undertaking a piece of work for them, and he would ask them in his own right if they would consider co-opting him for the duration of that matter.
Councillor Gourlay asked if Councillor Kittow could do the same, to which it was explained that she would have to contact them in her own right, not as a nominee of the Council in the same way as Councillor Crofts.
Councillor Crofts pointed out that people living at the back of B&Q, Emneth were experiencing problems with the impact of traffic onto the roundabout and expressed concern about the planning application for development which had been submitted. The LDF Manager pointed out that there were all sorts of reasons why the Council had not chosen that site and these would be discussed at the appropriate Hearing Session. He added that the Inspector would ask questions but there would not be a decision on the day.
Councillor Crofts referred to the affordable housing changes and asked what the situation was now that the Council had allocated sites with a 5 threshold.
Councillor Crofts asked if there was a need for the Informal Working Group – Black Bin Recycling which had been set up by the Regeneration, Environment and Community Panel to continue to meet if the Material Works Contract had ended.
Councillor Crofts referred to Air Quality Policy Action 5 which was to consider, with Norfolk County Council, if taxis and private hire vehicles could use the ‘bus only’ lane from Wisbech Road through to the Friars and Boal Street. He felt that this was a good idea as it would divert some traffic away from London Road and should definitely be progressed. The Environmental Health Manager explained that a local bicycle user group had raised concerns on this issue in that there would be additional traffic on the bus route.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Crofts attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee | PC19 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2026 | CIL Spending Panel | Review Funding applications and allocate funding to community projects | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2026 | CIL Spending Panel | Review Funding applications and allocate funding to community projects | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2026 | CIL Spending Panel | Review Funding applications and allocate funding to community projects | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2026 | CIL Spending Panel | Review Funding applications and allocate funding to community projects | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2026 | CIL Spending Panel | Review Funding applications and allocate funding to community projects | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2026 | CIL Spending Panel | Review Funding applications and allocate funding to community projects | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2026 | CIL Spending Panel | Review Funding applications and allocate funding to community projects | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2026 | CIL Spending Panel | Review Funding applications and allocate funding to community projects | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Aug 2023 | Council | Cabinet: 1 August 2023 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Mar 2023 | Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Jan 2023 | Council | Cabinet: 17 January 2023 | Lost | 23 for, 24 against, 1 abstained | |
| 26 Jan 2023 | Council | Cabinet: 17 January 2023 | Carried | 29 for, 14 against | |
| 25 Apr 2022 | Council | Notice of motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Mar 2022 | Council | Urgent business | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 31 Mar 2021 | Planning Committee | Chair's Correspondence | Carried | 14 for, 1 against, 1 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Crofts was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 21 of 29 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Crofts declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Jul 2023 | Planning Committee, item PC15: | Councillor Crofts declared an interest in application 9/3(b) – Outwell and would take no part in the debate but would address the Committee under Standing Order 34. | |
| 9 Sep 2020 | Planning Committee, item PC138: | · Councillor Crofts declared that he was a Member of the King’s Lynn Internal Drainage Board and East of Ouse Internal Drainage Board. | |
| 1 Jul 2019 | Planning Committee, item PC7: | Councillor Crofts declared that he was a Member of the King’s Lynn Internal Drainage Board. | |
| 3 Jun 2019 | Planning Committee, item PC3: | The Chairman, Councillor Crofts declared that he was a Member of the King’s Lynn Internal Drainage Board. | |
| 13 Mar 2019 | Planning Committee, item PC112: | Councillor Crofts declared that he was a Member of the Internal Drainage Board, who had made comments on the application. | |
| 5 Sep 2016 | Planning Committee, item PC28: | Councillor Crofts declared a pecuniary interest in item 8/3(g) – Upwell , and would leave the meeting during consideration of the application. | |
| 8 Feb 2016 | Planning Committee, item PC86: | · Councillor Crofts declared an interest in item 8/2(c), as a member of Upwell Parish Council but had not taken part in the debate. |
Where Councillor Crofts sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2015 | 90 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | May 2015 | 86 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Regeneration and Development Panel | Committee Member | Jan 2016 | 62 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Local Plan Task Group | Committee Member | Jan 2017 | 42 | |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2015 | 28 | |
| Licensing and Appeals Board | Committee Member | Sep 2015 | 19 | |
| Electoral Arrangements Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 2 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Constitution | Committee Member | Mar 2026 | 1 | |
| CIL Spending Panel | Committee Member | Jun 2026 | 1 | |
| Planning Committee Sifting Panel | Committee Member | Aug 2018 | 35 | |
| Custom Build and Self Build Policy Development Task Group | Committee Member | Feb 2017 | 13 | |
| Local Development Framework Task Group | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 10 | |
| Joint Panel Meeting | Committee Member | Mar 2022 | 7 | |
| the Regeneration & Development and Environment & Community Panel | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 5 | |
| Environment and Community Panel | Committee Member | Jan 2016 | 4 | |
| Corporate Performance Panel | Present Under standing Order 34 | Aug 2016 | 4 | |
| Regeneration, Environment and Community Panel | Committee Member | Mar 2015 | 1 | |
| Guildhall Complex and Creative Hub Task Group | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.