Exclusion of the Press and Public
When voting for the exclusion of press and public, Councillor Nash voted against the exclusion for the reason, paragraph 9 of Part 2, Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972 takes precedence over paragraph 3.
Every time King's Lynn and West Norfolk's minutes name Councillor Nash, as the council published it.
When voting for the exclusion of press and public, Councillor Nash voted against the exclusion for the reason, paragraph 9 of Part 2, Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972 takes precedence over paragraph 3.
The Panel supported the Cabinet recommendation, with Councillor Nash abstaining from the vote.
Councillor Nash referred to the ReFit programme and its reported underperformance.
In response to questions from Councillor Nash regarding proposed reforms to the Planning Committee process, Councillor Spikings, in her capacity as Chair of the Planning Committee, expressed disappointment with the proposed arrangements.
In response to Councillor Nash question on the unreasonable complainer’s policy and the ombudsman, the Interim Corporate Governance Manager explained there are currently two people on the unreasonable complainers policy and provided assurance these figures would be included in future reports. She provided assurance that all complaints were handled with ... view the full minutes text for item CP11
The Leader, Councillor Beales endorsed the request of future reports to the Panel to monitor data protection complaints, compliance with statutory timeframes, and outcomes Councillor Nash raised concerns about Councillors being directed to use FOI requests instead of their rights of access to information. The Chief of Staff and Monitoring Officer clarified that member inquiries should be handled through the appropriate channels and announced upcoming training to clarify access rights.
In response to a query from Councillor Nash on the Women for Scotland Supreme Court hearing and case law; the Chief of Staff and Monitoring Officer explained the need to respond to new guidance on equality and diversity. She explained that the council would review its facilities and policies in light of new guidance and case law, with scrutiny committees involved in the process.
Councillor Nash questioned what support was available for Members under stress. The Chief of Staff and Monitoring Officer explained support was to be considered on a case to case basis and the Local Government Association provides training on civility in public life and safeguarding for Councillors. The Leader endorsed the Chief of Staff and Monitoring Officer comments and advised it may not be formal support but assistance to Councillors was to be provided.
Councillor Nash felt that Standing Order 34 amendments now presented more barriers.
Councillor Nash asked about the EV vehicle fleet review and information on the makes, models, term of ownership and projected mileage of the vehicles along with details of the companies to be used.
Councillor de Whalley explained that this piece of work was ongoing and demonstration work would provide the information Councillor Nash had asked for and would be available in due course.
Councillor de Whalley agreed to provide Councillor Nash with details of the companies that were being used to take this piece of work forward.
Council was invited to review its proportionality following the resignation from Councillor Nash from the Independent Partnership.
The Vice-Chair, Councillor Nash referred to ... view the full minutes text for item A8
Councillor Nash referred to a recent Standards Committee meeting and requested that the Panel review the Complaints Process and Procedure. The Chair agreed to investigate this with officers for potential addition to the Work Programme.
Under Standing Order 34, Councillor Nash declared an interest in Item 7, Summary of 2023-2024 Code of Conduct Complaints.
Councillor Nash was present under Standing Order 34.
Under Standing Order 34, Councillor Nash referred to point of order 20.1: if appendix B was endorsed, 3 members of the Committee had an interest in Appendix B as members who attended the Standards hearing.
Click here to view the recording of this item on You Tube Councillor Nash suggested that an Informal Working Group be established to look at Devolution and Local Government Reorganisation.
Councillor Nash thanked the Procurement and Contracts Manager and Executive Director for supporting the group and felt that the Informal Working Group had provided common sense recommendations that would improve accountability. He also hoped that the recommendations from the Group would be considered during other contract processes.
Councillor Nash requested that the Panel look at the process of holding Statutory Officers to account as he felt the current process was not fit for purpose. The Chair agreed to look into this with officers.
Councillor Nash reiterated the comments made regarding promoting the success of the building, as he felt that the public had a negative perception of the site and were unaware of what was provided for local businesses and that it was commercially successful.
Councillor Nash asked for any feedback on the audit of the environmental impact of the council’s recycling. Councillor de Whalley undertook to respond in writing.
Councillor A Kemp (Norfolk County Councillor) Councillor Nash (Ward Member) Councillor J Moriarty (Portfolio Holder)
Councillor Nash seconded the motion.
Councillor Nash asked the Chair if he had received his email dated 27 th February 2024.
The Chair acknowledged receipt of the email and explained that he would liaise with Councillor Nash outside of the meeting.
Councillor Nash referred to indicator 2.10 which provided a target of tonnage of recycling collected.
Councillor Nash asked about the Taxi Testing Contract Informal Working Group and the Senior Democratic Services Officer agreed to arrange a meeting.
Councillor Nash agreed 5 Councillors would be the correct number.
The Chair, Councillor Dark commented that Councillor Nash had submitted this item for consideration by the Panel and suggested he be a member of the informal working group and invited other nominations for the informal working group.
In response to comments made by Councillor Nash on Councillor involvement to enable an oversight of the policy, the Senior Internal Auditor advised that he was not aware of any Councillor involvement.
Councillor Nash asked if it was possible to amend the policy to include Councillor involvement. In response, the Monitoring Officer outlined the legal process and undertook to review the request with the Senior Internal Auditor the following day.
Councillor Nash further commented on how staff could raise an issue and asked how Councillors could be assured that the policy was safe without any Member involvement. In response, the Senior Internal Auditor drew attention to the flow chart in the report which set out the criteria and the steps staff could take.
Councillor Nash asked if the role of the Monitoring Officer/Deputy Monitoring Officer and how the roles conflicted with the legal advice. The Monitoring Officer advised that she would look at the request and provide a response.
Click here to view a recording of this item on You Tube The Chair advised that the Panel was aware of a request received from Councillor Nash to have two members of the public.
Advice given by the Independent Person The Independent Person explained that the Panel received a written request from Councillor Nash received on 24 January 2024. The Independent Person’s provided advice and explained the Panel did not have to consider the request buy may wish to.
The Independent Person provided information on the request from Councillor Nash on having two individuals as McKenzie friends. She stated that McKenzie friends are individuals that attend court for somebody in the family court because proceedings in the family court were closed. In criminal courts any member of the public may attend.
If the Panel determined to follow the principles her advice would be that Councillor Nash makes a verbal application/request to the Panel, and details why he feels it is necessary and proportionate.
The Independent Person explained that she had never known an application for two individuals to be present as McKenzie friends, only one, and would therefore consider asking Councillor Nash to make a request for one only and added that it was doubtful that an application for two would meet the “necessary and proportionate” test.
She suggested that the Panel may then wish to ask if anyone in the room had any objections, and that the Panel may then wish to consider in private deliberation, as per the court process, whether what Councillor Nash has requested is necessary and proportionate. She added that the Panel may also wish to consider the risk of having members of the public involved. Members of the public are not bound by the same Codes of Conduct and suchlike that other people in the room may be.
Three Borough Councillors addressed the Panel in support of Councillor Nash, in accordance with Procedural Orders made by the Panel in advance.
Click here to view a recording of this item on You Tube The Chair invited Councillor Nash to present his request.
Councillor Nash proposed that this item be considered in exempt session under the Local Government Act section 100A.
The Monitoring Officer asked Councillor Nash to confirm which paragraph of Schedule 12A he referred to and added that the request was for the Panel to consider.
Councillor Nash outlined why in his view the item should be considered at tonight’s meeting.
Councillor Nash proposed that an Informal Working Group be set up to consider his request.
In response to questions and comments from Councillor Nash regarding a complaint he had personally raised and what would the right of appeal be, the Monitoring Officer explained this would be subject to a judicial review, legal advice by the complainant or by raising a corporate complaint/Local Government Ombudsman on the way the complaint had been handled. If the complaint was upheld by the Local ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Click here to view the recording of this item on You Tube Councillor Nash asked Councillor Dark as Chair of the Corporate Performance Panel when he would bring a contract award forward to scrutiny. He asked when the email would be sent to ask the item to come forward.
Click here to view a recording of this item on You Tube Councillor Nash asked for the 2021 Taxi Testing Contract to be considered at a future meeting.
Councillor Nash explained that [name removed] had been a customer of his approximately seven years ago. He commented that there was no financial interest and did not consider there to be a conflict of interest.
• Members Allowances • Council Tax Scheme • Revenue and Capital Outturn • Appointment of representatives to inquorate parishes • Officer Major Project Board Terms of Reference Councillor Nash commented that the Panel should scrutinise the Procurement Strategy and Regulations.
Councillor Nash stated that the Council had the policy in place to deal with such things and his view thought it was worth bearing in mind and considering, as Councillors dealing with the quasi-judicial procedure who had responsibility to the public. to learn the procedure so when officers perverted the procedure on behalf of voters, Councillors spotted the perversion of the course of justice and acted upon it.
Councillor Nash emphasised the inadequacy of Councillors on the Committee.
Councillor Nash declared an Interest in the IDC as he was involved in a complaint and added that one of the things the Council failed to pick up was that neither the person complained about or the complainant was interviewed. The IDC was delegated to appoint an external investigator at a cost of £700 per day plus VAT and in this particular case was 4 days and that only one meeting was convened.
Councillor Nash agreed with the statement made by Councillor Hudson that the investigation procedure used by the Council was ignored by officers.
Councillor Nash requested that it be recorded in the minutes that he asked for a definition on the public interest test for the purpose of the Model Code of Conduct.
Councillor Nash commented that he was appalled with the lack of support available for Mental Health and other welfare issues for Councillors and he referred to a recent issue where he had tried to contact officers for information and support.
Councillor Nash asked for an update on the Policy of Unreasonably Consistent Complainants and it was explained that the Informal Working Group looking at this were scheduled to meet again soon.
Councillor Nash commented that if policy was adhered to there would be less confrontation. In further debate, Councillors gave further examples of abuse received or bad behaviour. It was suggested that councillors should support each other as an individuals state of mind was not always apparent.
Councillor Nash commented that the tenants would have duty of care for waste disposal and asked whether it was possible for the Borough Council to provide a waste disposal facility for an additional charge.
In response to comments made by Councillor Nash on the level of service expected by residents when submitting an application, the Executive Director explained that each planning application was determined on a case by case basis. If a resident was unhappy with the service received then a corporate complaint form could be completed and submitted to the council.
Following comments from Councillor Nash, the Assistant Director, Environment and Planning added that a charge was made for pre-application advice but this was a voluntary service and applicants could not be forced to use the pre-application service.
The Assistant Director agreed to clarify situations where the pre-application service was not appropriate or utilised, following concerns raised by Councillor Nash about the pre-application service.
Councillor Nash wish for his dissention to be noted.
Cllr Blunt 8/1(a) King’s Lynn Cllr Kunes 8/1(a) & 8/2(b) King’s Lynn Cllr Joyce 8/2(b) King’s Lyn Cllr Kirk 8/2(e) West Walton Cllr Kemp 8/2(f) West Winch Cllr Nash 8/2(f) West Winch
Councillor Nash declared an interest and explained that since the meeting of 15 December information had been supplied to him which in his opinion brought into question the quality of the investigation behind the hearing. Further he received on Friday 28 January a notification from Norfolk Constabulary that at his request they would be contacting the Executive of the Borough Council to discuss one of the allegations made in relation to this case. In view of the information supplied to him independently, he was of the opinion that his position on this Panel had been significantly comprised and his continued involvement in this hearing would be inappropriate.
Councillor Nash was advised by the Monitoring Officer to vacate the seat on the basis that he had declared an interest and to allow the meeting to be quorate she invited Councillor Holmes to take the seat.
The Chair, Councillor Nash proposed the following motion to adjourn the hearing in view of the following reasons:
Councillor Nash drew the Panel’s attention to section 5.6 of the report: Customers who were in a protected group, including those who had reached pension age, were not subject to the weekly maximum council tax limit, and could receive up to 100% CTS.
Councillor Nash, seconded by Councillor Parish proposed an amendment to the Motion that the free parking on Sundays proposed above take place in January or February.
Click here to view a recording of this item on You Tube The Chair invited Councillor Nash to present his report which had been circulated with the Agenda.
Councillor Nash drew the Panel’s attention to Page 43, the four recommendations set out below:
Councillor Nash commented that he was speaking about this policy as he had had probably exclusive experience of being on both sides of the policy.
Councillor Nash added that based on his experience to make it fair and useful policy for all concerned it was important to discuss those matters. Most points were discussed and agreed on at the October 2019 Corporate Performance Panel meeting and it should hopefully not be too laborious to go through them again.
Councillor Nash thanked the Chair.
The Chair thanked Councillor Nash and invited the Monitoring Officer to address the Panel.
The Monitoring Officer commented that she understood that on the last occasion, advised legal advice had been requested on the proposals put forward by Councillor Nash.
Councillor Nash presented his report (copy attached to the minutes) and explained that he had brought this item to the Corporate Performance Panel on 21 July 2021 as his opinion was that the policy was not lawful. However, the council’s Monitoring Officer had determined that the council’s current Persistent Complaints Policy was lawful.
Councillor Nash advised that he had written his own report for the Panel to consider the changes he had identified.
Councillor Nash proceeded to read his report to the Panel.
In presenting his report, Councillor Nash made reference to the 2013 Persistent Complainants Policy.
Councillor Nash outlined his proposed changes to the policy.
The Chair summarised the two points made by Councillor Nash.
Councillor Mrs Spikings asked if legal advice could be obtained on the changes proposed by Councillor Nash.
The Chair stated that the 2013 policy with proposed amendments from Councillor Nash to be brought back to the Panel for discussion and asked that the 2013 policy be circulated to Members.
Councillor Ayres commented that Councillor Nash had undertaken a lot of work on the policy and asked if legal advice could be obtained and then be brought back to the Panel in an understandable context.
The Chief Executive advised that Councillor Nash would need to make it clear what exactly he wished the Panel to look at in order that legal advice could be obtained.
Councillor Nash explained that he was using headphones via Bluetooth which could be used for all microphones.
With regard to the comments made regarding the use of headphones, Councillor Morley added that he had observed Councillor Nash and that headphones and a mask was too onerous and asked if IT could come up with a better system with the use of loudspeakers.
Councillor Tyler commented that he had taken the advice of Councillor Nash and had invested in a set of earphones.
Under Standing Order 34, Councillor de Whalley commented that he found it difficult to hear in the Assembly Room and commented he had discussed earphones with Councillor Nash. Councillor de Whalley asked if there was a possibility that sound engineers could be contacted to improve the sound quality.
Click here to view a recording of this item on You Tube The Chair explained that he had received the request with Councillor Nash and that it had been placed on the Panel’s work programme for the 1 September 2021 meeting.
Councillor Nash stated that he had had a discussion with the Monitoring Officer and the Chair prior to the meeting and wished to bring the item as a matter or urgency.
Councillor Nash read out a statement as to why in his opinion the policy was unlawful and proposed that the current policy be suspended pending the September review.
Click here to view a recording of this item on You Tube In response to a statement from Councillor S Nash on a potential interest in Agenda Item 7 - the Anti-Fraud and Corruption Policy due to his own personal experiences with the Borough Council.
The Deputy Monitoring Officer advised that Councillor Nash did not have a declaration on interest.
In response to questions from Councillor Nash regarding Councillor Emails and mobile devices, the ICT Web Manager advised Councillor Nash to contact the ICT Manager direct.
Standing Order 29 Councillor Nash proposed that the reference to Council be amended to read “The Full Council or the entirety of the Council”. In response, the Monitoring Officer undertook to clarify the definition in the document prior to the Cabinet meeting and make an amendment if required.
Councillor Nash commented that the impact of 350 properties on the A10 would be significant, but the question was asked of officers who said that the Highways study showed no adverse impact.
Councillor Nash stated that it was a case of officers giving false advice, so how could officers advice be relied on.
Councillor Nash responded that it was not appropriate not to answer the question.
Councillor S Nash was present under Standing Order 34 for Item 8 and declared an interest as he was currently taking legal action against the Council.
Under Standing Order 34, Councillor Nash addressed the Panel and commented on the draft policy:
· Reference was made to the complaints section of the council’s website and Councillor Nash commented that the information published penalised the Councillor.
· Councillor Nash stated that he had been on the unreasonably persistent complainants register for 3 years and 9 months.
Councillor Nash called into question the content of the minutes and that the specific ruling of the Monitoring Officer to his query was not included in them.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Nash attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee | PC19 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Aug 2023 | Council | Cabinet: 1 August 2023 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Jan 2023 | Council | Cabinet: 17 January 2023 | Lost | 23 for, 24 against, 1 abstained | |
| 26 Jan 2023 | Council | Cabinet: 17 January 2023 | Carried | 29 for, 14 against | |
| 25 Apr 2022 | Council | Notice of motion | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Nash was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 8 of 18 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Nash declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 Mar 2025 | Standards Committee, item 10 | Under Standing Order 34, Councillor Nash declared an interest in Item 7, Summary of 2023-2024 Code of Conduct Complaints. | |
| 27 Feb 2023 | Corporate Performance Panel, item CP113 | Councillor Nash declared an Interest in the IDC as he was involved in a complaint and added that one of the things the Council failed to pick up was that neither the person complained about or the complainant was interviewed. The IDC was delegated to appoint an external investigator at a cost of £700 per day plus VAT and in this particular case was 4 days and that only one meeting was convened. | |
| 31 Jan 2022 | Standards Committee, item 2 | Councillor Nash declared an interest and explained that since the meeting of 15 December information had been supplied to him which in his opinion brought into question the quality of the investigation behind the hearing. Further he received on Friday 28 January a notification from Norfolk Constabulary that at his request they would be contacting the Executive of the Borough Council to discuss one of the allegations made in relation to this case. In view of the information supplied to him independently, he was of the opinion that his position on this Panel had been significantly comprised and his continued involvement in this hearing would be inappropriate. |
Where Councillor Nash sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2019 | 55 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Corporate Performance Panel | Committee Member | Mar 2020 | 37 | 12 Jan 2027 |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2022 | 3 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2025 | 2 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Constitution | Committee Member | Mar 2026 | 1 | |
| Electoral Arrangements Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2026 | 1 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Joint Panel Meeting | Committee Member | Mar 2022 | 6 | |
| Audit Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2024 | 5 | |
| Standards Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2022 | 4 | |
| Licensing and Appeals Board | Committee Member | Mar 2022 | 4 | |
| Appointments Board/Investigating and Disciplinary Committee | Observer | Nov 2019 | 1 | |
| Appointments Panel | Committee Member | Jul 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.