Moved9 Jun 2026Cabinet
Appointments Report
Councillor Stubbins proposed, seconded by Councillor Riches :- “That the appointments to outside bodies be confirmed and that Councillor Bannon be appointed to the Lancashire Police and Crime Partnership.” Councillors then voted:- Resolved unanimously:
Moved27 May 2026Audit Committee
Annual Governance Statement 2025/26
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins, seconded by Councillor Roger Dennison and resolved as follows:
Named18 May 2026Council
Executive Arrangements and the Scheme of Delegation to Officers
The Leader confirmed that Councillor Maddocks had resigned from Cabinet and that Councillor Stubbins had assumed responsibility for her portfolio area. No other changes to portfolios were reported.
Named22 Apr 2026Council
Audit Committee Annual Report
In accordance with Part 3, Section 5 paragraph 6.30 of the Council’s Constitution, the Chair, Councillor Stubbins, presented the 2025/26 Annual Report of the Audit Committee.
Moved18 Mar 2026Audit Committee
Internal Audit Strategy and Risk Based Plan 2026/27
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins, seconded by Councillor Brett Cooper and resolved as follows.
Named17 Dec 2025Council
Auditor's annual report 2023/2024
The Chair of the Audit Committee, Councillor Paul Stubbins, presented the 2023/24 Annual Report of the Council’s External Auditor, KPMG. The report was for noting.
Named17 Dec 2025Council
Auditor's annual report 2023/2024
Councillor Stubbins and the Section 151 Officer responded to a number of questions from Councillors.
Named23 Jul 2025Council
Appointments and changes to committee membership
· Appointing Councillor Stubbins and Councillor Tyldesley as substitute members of the Local Government Reorganisation Working Group Cllr Andrew Otway replacing Cllr Sally Maddocks on the Local Plan Review Group Appointing Cllr Gina Dowding to the Appeals Committee Cllr Sally Maddocks to become a substitute member of Council Business Committee Cllr Wilson Colley to replace Cllr Mandy Bannon as a substitute member of the Planning Regulatory Committee
Seconded10 Jul 2025People and Organisational Development Committee
Appointment of a Vice-Chair
It was moved by Councillor Jason Wood and seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins: - “That Councillor Caroline Jackson be appointed Vice-Chair of the People and Organisational Development Committee for the municipal year 2025/26.” There being no further nominations, the proposition was declared carried.
Seconded10 Jul 2025People and Organisational Development Committee
Gender Pay Gap Reporting - Options Paper
· Pay casuals a market supplement · Pay casuals according to the pay grade for the jobs they are undertaking The Committee was advised that at the meeting of JCC on 25 th June 2025, after discussing the financial and staffing implications of each option, JCC had agreed unanimously to recommend the option set out in paragraph 2.2.3 of the report “pay casual staff according to the pay grade for the work they are undertaking.” It was moved by Councillor Jason Wood, seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins and unanimously agreed. Resolved : - To further positively address the Council’s gender pay gap that casual workers pay be increased to match the bottom pay point of the grade relevant to the role being undertaken and casual workers are paid an hourly rate plus 12.07% for rolled up holiday pay – include this figure in the gender pay gap calculations.
Seconded10 Jul 2025People and Organisational Development Committee
HR Dashboard Annual Report - 2024-25
It was moved by Councillor Jason Wood, seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins and unanimously agreed.
Named12 May 2025Council
Appointment of Chairs
Councillor Stubbins was nominated by Councillor Metcalf-Riener, seconded by Councillor Brookes.
Named12 May 2025Council
Appointment of Chairs
With 30 votes for Councillor Stubbins and 19 votes for Councillor Hartley, Councillor Stubbins was appointed Chair of the Audit Committee.
Named23 Apr 2025Council
Audit Committee Annual Report
In accordance with Part 3, Section 5 paragraph 6.30 of the Council’s Constitution, the Chair, Councillor Stubbins, presented the 2024/25 Annual Report of the Audit Committee. He responded to questions from Councillors.
Moved19 Mar 2025Audit Committee
Internal Audit Plan 2025/26
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and seconded by Councillor David Whitaker and resolved as follows:
Moved19 Mar 2025Audit Committee
Proposed Accounting Policies and Critical Judgements in the Preparation of the Statement of Accounts 2024/25
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins, seconded by Councillor Isabella Metcalf-Riener and unanimously agreed:
Seconded6 Mar 2025People and Organisational Development Committee
Health and Safety Policy Development and Review
It was moved by Councillor Chris Harris, seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins and unanimously agreed.
Seconded20 Feb 2025Council Business Committee
Invitation from the Mayor of Lublin
After discussing the background to the invitation, the costs involved and whether the visit would cause any complications in the pre-election period it was proposed by Councillor Wood, seconded by Councillor Stubbins and agreed unanimously as follows.
Seconded20 Feb 2025Council Business Committee
Councillor Training and Development
This was seconded by Councillor Stubbins and the proposition was clearly carried
Named11 Dec 2024Council
Appointment of Chairs
Councillor Stubbins was nominated by Councillor Tynan, seconded by Councillor Riches.
Named11 Dec 2024Council
Appointment of Chairs
There were no further nominations and the Deputy Mayor declared Councillor Stubbins appointed.
Seconded27 Nov 2024Audit Committee
Exclusion of the Press and Public
It was moved by Councillor Whitaker, seconded by Councillor Stubbins and resolved:
Moved27 Nov 2024Audit Committee
Revised Financial Regulations
It was moved by Councillor Stubbins, seconded by Councillor Colbridge and unanimously resolved as follows:-
Named22 Oct 2024Cabinet
Local Area Energy Plan (LAEP)
(Cabinet Member with Special Responsibility Councillor Stubbins) Cabinet received a report from the Chief Officer – Planning and Climate Change that sought adoption of the Lancaster District Local Area Energy Plan.
Named25 Sep 2024Council
Appointments and changes to committee membership
· Councillor Brookes had taken the Green Group vacant seat on the Standards Committee · Councillor Stubbins had taken the Green Group vacant seat on the People and Organisational Development Committee · Councillor Stubbs had taken the places on Budget and Performance Panel and the Standards Committee left vacant by the resignation of Councillor Sophie Maddocks · Councillor Abi Mills had stepped down from the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, with Councillor Deery taking her place · Councillor Hamilton-Cox had stepped down from Licensing Committee to be replaced by Councillor Deery.
Seconded19 Sep 2024Council Business Committee
Consultation on the Draft National Planning Policy Framework
At the conclusion of the discussion it was proposed by the Chair, seconded by Councillor Stubbins and agreed by all present that “the draft response be approved for submission with the comments raised in the meeting taken into consideration and added where appropriate”
Moved31 Jul 2024Audit Committee
Strategic Risk Management
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and seconded by Councillor David Whitaker and resolved unanimously when put to the vote that the press and public be excluded at this point in order that Members could consider Appendix B which was exempt under paragraph 3 of Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act, 1972;
Named24 Jul 2024Council
Temporary Change to the Executive Scheme of Delegation
It was noted that Councillor Dowding would be temporarily replaced by Councillor Stubbins to take over her portfolio area of Climate Action from 1 August to 30 November 2024.
Named24 Jul 2024Council
Appointment of a Committee Chair
Following on from Minute 24, it was noted in a report from the Senior Manager Democratic Support and Elections, that Councillor Stubbins, shortly to take on temporary responsibilities as a Cabinet Member, was currently the Chair of Audit. The Constitution did not permit the Chair of Audit to be a Member of Cabinet, therefore he had stepped down from his position as Chair.
Seconded24 Jul 2024Council
Appointment of a Committee Chair
Councillor Gawith, seconded by Councillor Stubbins, nominated Councillor Hartley.
Seconded30 May 2024Council Business Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chair
It was proposed by Councillor Parr and seconded by Councillor Stubbins, “That Councillor Matthew Black be appointed Vice-Chair of the Council Business Committee for the municipal year 2024/25”. There being no further nominations, the Chair declared the proposal to be carried.
Moved22 May 2024Audit Committee
Strategic Risk Register Update
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and seconded by Councillor Peter Jackson;
Moved22 May 2024Audit Committee
Internal Audit Progress Report
It was moved by Councillor Paul Stubbins, seconded by Councillor Ruth Colbridge and resolved:
Named13 May 2024Council
Appointment of Chairs
Councillor Stubbins for the Audit Committee (proposed by Councillor Brookes, seconded by Councillor Dennison).
Named24 Apr 2024Council
Audit committee annual report
In accordance with Part 3, Section 5 paragraph 6.30 of the Council’s Constitution, the Chair, Councillor Stubbins, presented the 2023/24 Annual Report of the Audit Committee. He thanked officers who had supported the Committee and the Council’s governance during the year before responding to questions from Councillors.
Moved20 Mar 2024Audit Committee
Updated Risk Management Policy
It was moved by Councillor Paul Stubbins, seconded by Councillor Peter Jackson and resolved as follows;
Moved20 Mar 2024Audit Committee
Annual Review of the Internal Audit Charter
It was moved by Councillor Paul Stubbins, seconded by Councillor Sally Maddocks and resolved as follows.
Named20 Feb 2024Cabinet
Public Speaking
Councillor Stubbins had requested to speak as Ward Councillor with regard to Agenda Item 15 Commercial Property Sale.
Named20 Feb 2024Cabinet
Commercial Property Sale, Lancaster
In accordance with the Constitution (Cabinet Procedure Rule 18) Councillor Stubbins had requested to address Cabinet on this issue as Ward Councillor and spoke against the proposal. After a lengthy debate the proposal to sell the commercial property was lost and Cabinet agreed not to proceed with the sale at this time.
Moved12 Oct 2023Council Business Committee
Mid-Year Changes to the Committee Timetable
The Committee discussed the report and Councillor Paul Stubbins proposed to move the recommendations of the report with an amendment to recommendation 1 that “in consultation with the relevant Chair” be replaced by “with the agreement of the relevant Chair.” After further discussion it was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and seconded by the Chair: - “That the Committee agrees to delegate authority to the Chief Executive, with the agreement of the relevant Chair, to change a meeting date, venue or time should this becomes necessary after the timetable has been agreed.
Named19 Jul 2023Council
Questions under council procedure rule 12
The question was from Councillor Wild to Councillor Stubbins, as the Chair of the Audit Committee.
Said19 Jul 2023Council
Questions under council procedure rule 12
What items in note 42 of the 2019/20 accounts does the objection relate to?” Councillor Stubbins responded:
Named19 Jul 2023Council
Questions under council procedure rule 12
This matter is currently ‘live’ with the external auditor and pursuant to schedule 11 of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014 it is not appropriate for further information to be given on the grounds that it may prejudice the effective performance of the external auditor’s statutory functions.” Councillor Stubbins went on to provide information about the percentage of local authority accounts that were still not signed off (10% of Councils for 2019/20 and 27% for 2021/22) showing there are fundamental issues, some of which were related to external audit, some more technical.
Named19 Jul 2023Council
Questions under council procedure rule 12
“What is the taxpayer objecting to?” Councillor Stubbins referred Councillor Wild to the answer he had just given.
Named1 Jun 2023Council Business Committee
Appointment of Vice Chair
It was proposed by Councillor John Livermore and seconded by Councillor David Whitaker: “That Councillor Paul Stubbins be appointed Vice-Chair of the Council Business Committee for the municipal year 2023/24”.
Declared1 Jun 2023Council Business Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Paul Stubbins declared a non-prejudicial interest in agenda item 8: Response to Consultation: Introduction of a use class for short term lets and associated permitted development rights. This was due to his ownership of a HMO property in the district.
Moved1 Jun 2023Council Business Committee
Response to Consultation: Introduction of a use class for short term lets and associated permitted development rights
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and Seconded by Councillor David Whitaker that the consultation response should be formally submitted subject to the amendments suggested by the Committee.
Named22 May 2023Council
Appointment of chairs
Councillor Stubbins was nominated for the Chair of the Audit Committee by Councillor Brookes, seconded by Councillor Sally Maddocks. There were no further nominations.
Named22 May 2023Council
Appointment of chairs
The Mayor declared Councillor Stubbins appointed.
Named26 Apr 2023Council
Audit committee annual report
In accordance with Part 3, Section 5 paragraph 6.30 of the Council’s Constitution, the Chairman, Councillor Stubbins, had submitted the 2022/23 Annual Report of the Audit Committee.
Named26 Apr 2023Council
Audit committee annual report
Councillor Stubbins was not present at the meeting, having given apologies.
Moved22 Mar 2023Audit Committee
Refreshed Risk Management Policy
Councillor Stubbins proposed some minor changes to the wording of the Risk Management Policy for clarity, which were agreed by the Committee.
Said22 Mar 2023Audit Committee
Strategic Risk Management
Councillor Stubbins advised that it would be beneficial for the Committee to view lower-level risk management plans that underly the Strategic Register, to support assurance of the process, and that this might best be done as a part of a training event for the new Audit Committee post May elections. This recommendation would be taken forward to the Chair of the Committee appointed in the new administration. It was further agreed that risk management training should be extended to Cabinet and to Scrutiny Committees, as well as an invitation being open to all members.
Moved22 Mar 2023Audit Committee
Annual Review of the Internal Audit Charter
It was proposed by Councillor Stubbins and seconded by Councillor Whitaker:
Seconded22 Mar 2023Audit Committee
Proposed Accounting Policies and Critical Judgements used in the Preparation of the Statement of Accounts 2022/23
It was proposed by Councillor Clifford and seconded by Councillor Stubbins:
Seconded14 Dec 2022Council
Appointments to outside bodies
Councillor Dowding nominated Councillor Maddocks, seconded by Councillor Stubbins.
Seconded23 Nov 2022Audit Committee
Code of Corporate Governance
It was then proposed by Councillor Geoff Knight and Seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins:
Named28 Sep 2022Council
Appointments and changes to committee membership
The Green and Independent Group appointed Councillor Stubbins to the Personnel Committee.
Named27 Apr 2022Council
Audit Committee Annual Report
In accordance with paragraph 6.30 in Part 2, Section 5 of the Council’s Constitution, the Chair of Audit Committee, Councillor Stubbins, presented the Committee’s 2021-22 Annual Report.
Said27 Apr 2022Council
Audit Committee Annual Report
Councillor Stubbins responded to a number of questions.
Seconded23 Mar 2022Audit Committee
Internal Audit Strategy and Risk Based Plan 2022/23
It was proposed by Councillor Geoff Knight and seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins:
Said23 Feb 2022Council
Public Sector Audit Appointments The appointment of External Auditors from 2023/24 to 2027/28
Councillor Stubbins, the Chair of the Audit Committee, introduced the report and responded to questions. He then proposed:
Named26 Jan 2022Council
Questions under council procedure rule 12
(1) Councillor Stubbins to Councillor Caroline Jackson regarding the International Labour Organisation’s Violence and Harassment Convention (ILO C190).
Seconded16 Sep 2021Council Business Committee
Change to Dates of Budget and Performance Panel Meetings
It was proposed by Councillor Knight and seconded by Councillor Stubbins.
Asked21 Jul 2021Audit Committee
Internal Audit Resourcing
Councillor Stubbins enquired about whether available provisions from other authorities had been sought to fill the gap and deal with the accumulating workload. The Committee was advised that a review of the Audit Schedule had been carried out and it was expected that all audits would be completed by the end of the year.
Named23 Jun 2021Council
Audit Committee's Annual Report 2020/21
In accordance with the Council’s Constitution, the Chair of the Audit Committee Councillor Stubbins, presented the 2019/21 Report of the Audit Committee and answered a number of questions.
Moved23 Jun 2021Council
Motion on Notice - Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement
There was a lengthy debate before an amendment to the motion was moved by Councillor Stubbins.
Moved9 Jun 2021Audit Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chair
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and seconded by Councillor Adrian Duggan:
Named17 May 2021Council
Appointment of Chairs
In relation to the Audit Committee, Councillor Stubbins was nominated by Councillor Dant, seconded by Councillor Young.
Named17 May 2021Council
Appointment of Chairs
Councillor Stubbins received 32 votes.
Named25 Mar 2021Council Business Committee
Amendments to the Council's Constitution
It was noted that Councillor Paul Stubbins now had a fully functioning connection to the meeting and could take part from this point forwards.
Moved25 Mar 2021Council Business Committee
Amendments to the Council's Constitution
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and seconded by Councillor Joan Jackson:
Seconded25 Mar 2021Council Business Committee
Electoral Review of the City Council - Warding Pattern Consultation
It was proposed by Councillor Joyce Pritchard and seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins:
Named24 Mar 2021Council
Constitution - Audit Committee's Terms of Reference
The Chair of Audit, Councillor Stubbins, introduced the report. There were no questions.
Moved24 Mar 2021Audit Committee
Annual Review of Audit Committee Terms of Reference
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and seconded by Councillor Geoff Knight:
Moved24 Mar 2021Audit Committee
Annual Review of the Council's Counter Fraud Policies
It was proposed by Councillor Paul Stubbins and seconded by Councillor David Whitworth:
Seconded24 Mar 2021Audit Committee
Risk Management Progress Report
It was proposed by Councillor Geoff Knight and seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins:
Seconded25 Nov 2020Audit Committee
External Audit Plan: Year ending 31 March 2020
It was proposed by Councillor Geoff Knight and seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins:
Named22 Jul 2020Audit Committee
Annual Governance Statement 2019/20
Councillor Stubbins tabled an amendment to the AGS, which would replace the first sentence of section 4.2 (page 99 of the agenda) with the following text: “Further work is required to strengthen implementation of risk management practice and reporting across the Council's operations” t o then continue "Work completed in 2019 has included..."
Moved24 Jun 2020Council
MOTION ON NOTICE - Area-wide default 20mph speed limit for Lancaster
Councillor Stubbins proposed the following motion having given the required notice to the Chief Executive in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 15:- " Full Council notes that:
Named18 May 2020Council
Appointment of Chairs
Finally, the informally agreed list was proposed by Councillor Wood, seconded by Councillor O’Dwyer-Henry, as follows:- Councillor Thornberry – Planning Regulatory Committee Councillor Hartley – Licensing Committee Councillor Robinson – Personnel Committee Councillor Black – Appeals Committee Councillor Stubbins – Audit Committee Councillor King – Standards Committee Councillor Pritchard – Council Business Committee.
Moved18 May 2020Council
Committee Timetable 2020/2021 - Proposed amendments to Audit Committee meeting dates
Councillor Stubbins, seconded by Councillor Geoff Knight, proposed that the dates of the scheduled meetings be amended as set out in the report.
Named19 Feb 2020Audit Committee
Review of the Council's Counter Fraud Policies
Councillor Stubbins tabled an amendment to the Raising Concerns (formerly “Whistleblowing”) Policy, which would insert into section 6.10 (page 47 of the agenda) the following text:
Named27 Nov 2019Audit Committee
Review of the Council's Risk Management Policy
Councillor Stubbins tabled amendments to the report as follows (additions in italics):
Seconded27 Nov 2019Audit Committee
Review of the Council's Risk Management Policy
It was proposed by Councillor Oliver Robinson and seconded by Councillor Paul Stubbins that the recommendations as set out in the report, subject to the tabled amendments, be approved.
Moved13 Nov 2019Council
Motion on notice - recycling
Councillor Stubbins proposed the following motion having given the required notice to the Chief Executive in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 15:- “ Purpose:
Named26 Jun 2019Council
Appointments and changes to committee membership
The Mayor noted that the Green Group had requested that Councillor Stubbins be replaced on the Budget and Performance Panel by Councillor Young.
Named26 Jun 2019Council
Appointments and changes to committee membership
That (1) Councillor Stubbins be replaced on the Budget and Performance Panel by Councillor Young.
Named20 May 2019Council
Appointment of Chairs
For the Audit Committee, Councillor Stubbins was nominated by Councillor Dowding , seconded by Councillor Young.
Named20 May 2019Council
Appointment of Chairs
Councillor Stubbins received 31 votes.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.