CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Lewes/Councillor Robert Smart
RS

Councillor Robert Smart

Lewes CouncilMeads wardConservativeCouncillor since 2015
Opposition Leader
Follow Councillor Smart's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
89%meetings attended196 of 221 since 2015, apologies 11
237times in the minutesAsked 7, said 83, moved 39, seconded 30
59recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
7declarations at meetingsInterests declared on agenda items
4committees in the last year12 committees in all

On the record

Every time Lewes's minutes name Councillor Smart, as the council published it.

Said15 Jul 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Right to address the meeting/order of business

Councillor Smart requested to address the Cabinet in relation to Agenda Item 10, Treasury Management Annual Report 2025/26.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 15 Jul 2026, item 14Open the meeting
Said15 Jul 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Treasury Management Annual Report 2025/26

Prior to Cabinet's consideration, Councillor Smart addressed the meeting and raised questions regarding:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 15 Jul 2026, item 18Open the meeting
Said20 May 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Appointments Report.

Councillor Smart added the Conservative Group’s congratulations to the Mayor and Deputy Mayor on their appointments and confirmed his support for cross-party working in the coming year in preparation for LGR.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 May 2026, item 9Open the meeting
Moved25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion: Pavement Accessibility and Maintenance in Eastbourne

·        Provides a written response  outlining priorities, planned actions, and indicative timescales.’ Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Goodyear seconded an amendment to add after ‘This Council resolves to:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 61Open the meeting
Seconded25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2026/27

General Fund Revenue Budget 2026/27 and Capital Programme Treasury Management and Prudential Indicators 2026/27, Capital Strategy and Investment Strategy Housing Revenue Account (HRA) and Rent Setting 2026-27 and HRA Capital Programme 2024-29 Licensing Fees 2026/27 Council Tax Reduction Scheme 2026/27 Councillor Small moved and Councillor Smart seconded an amendment to the budget as follows:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 62aOpen the meeting
Seconded25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Community Governance Review

Councillor Holt moved and Councillor Smart seconded recommendations from the Audit and Governance Committee on 18 February 2026. These were that the Council does not proceed to a stage 2 consultation on the creation of Parish Council or Councils, in the light of the consultation results at stage 1, but endorse the creation of Charter Trustees for Eastbourne.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 62dOpen the meeting
Said25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Treasury Management Report - Quarter 2 (Mid-Year Review)

Councillor Smart advised that he could not support the report.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 62eOpen the meeting
Seconded25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Calendar of Meetings 2026/27

Councillor Holt moved and Councillor Smart seconded approval of the proposed Calendar of Meetings for 2026/27. It was noted that the Council dates would be subject to final approval at the annual meeting of the Council, in accordance with legislation.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 63Open the meeting
Seconded25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Sussex Police and Crime Commissioner

To request that the Leader of the Council writes formally to the Minister of State for Policing and Crime and to the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners, asking them to give due consideration to the conduct of the Sussex Police and Crime Commissioner and its implications for standards and accountability nationally.’ Councillor Small moved and Councillor Smart seconded an alternative motion (amendment) as follows:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 64Open the meeting
Named25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Audit and Governance Committee – 19 November 2025 Cabinet – 10 December 2025 and 11 February 2026 Planning Committee – 16 December 2025 Licensing Committee – 26 January 2026 The Mayor advised that requests had been received from Councillor Smart to speak on the following minutes:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 65Open the meeting
Said25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Smart welcomed the structural survey on the bandstand and the change of plans on demolition as a result but challenged the way in which the administration had reached this point and communicated it.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 65Open the meeting
Said25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Smart raised questions on the selection of Boutique Modern as the contractor for this scheme, and the due diligence that had been carried out for this and advised he had been promised evaluation scoring and credit reports as part of the Scrutiny discussion but had not received them.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 65Open the meeting
Named25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Smart reiterated the concerns that he had raised at Cabinet on the way in which the Council’s exit from exceptional financial support (EFS) a year earlier than expected had been communicated, and that he believed the repayment of debt to have been achieved solely through the sale of two assets, and the agreement of the Government for the Council to clear £25m by paying half that amount.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 25 Feb 2026, item 65Open the meeting
Said11 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Right to address the meeting/order of business

Serena Stallard and Councillor Robert Smart addressed the Cabinet on (Eastbourne Local Plan – Draft Local Plan Consultation (Regulation 18) Councillor Robert Smart addressed the Cabinet on (Treasury Management Strategy, Investment Strategy, Capital Strategy and Prudential Indicators 2026/27).
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Feb 2026, item 51Open the meeting
Said11 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Eastbourne Local Plan - Draft Local Plan Consultation (Regulation 18)

Councillor Robert Smart, visiting member, addressed the Cabinet and referred to the housing trajectory set out in the draft plan. He noted the absence of an adopted Local Plan since 2018 and commented on the implications for planning control.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Feb 2026, item 52Open the meeting
Said11 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Treasury Management Strategy, Investment Strategy, Capital Strategy and Prudential Indicators 2026/27

Councillor Smart, visiting member, addressed the Cabinet on this item and queried that the report excluded key developments, although he welcomed the reduction in external debt. He spoke on how the Council had achieved the reduction in debt and referred to recent asset sales, together with the Government’s agreement to allow £25 million of long-term low interest loans to be repaid below their nominal value. He further commented on the Council’s recent press release regarding the repayment of exceptional financial support.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Feb 2026, item 53Open the meeting
Said16 Dec 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Welkin Site, Carlisle Road. ID: 250505

Councillor Smart (Ward Councillor) spoke in support of the application.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 16 Dec 2025, item 40Open the meeting
Named8 Dec 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for absence / declaration of substitute members

Councillor Smart was a substitute for Councillor Shore.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 8 Dec 2025, item 53Open the meeting
Asked26 Nov 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Minutes of the meeting held on 17 September 2025

Councillor Smart queried the accuracy of minute 42 in relation to Councillor Holt’s comments on the Bandstand.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 26 Nov 2025, item 44Open the meeting
Moved26 Nov 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Safe Spaces

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Lamb seconded the motion as set out in the agenda papers as follows:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 26 Nov 2025, item 50aOpen the meeting
Said26 Nov 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Audit and Governance Committee – 11 September 2025 Planning Committee – 16 September 2025 Scrutiny Committee – 22 September 2025 Cabinet - 24 September 2025 Councillor Smart spoke in relation to on minute 29 on the Eastbourne Bandstand of the meeting of the Planning Committee on the 16 September 2025 and raised his concerns with the approach the Council had taken and also asked why a complaint made by the Meads Community Association (MCA) had not received a response.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 26 Nov 2025, item 52Open the meeting
Named9 Oct 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for absence / declaration of substitute members

Councillor Smart was a substitute.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 9 Oct 2025, item 42Open the meeting
Seconded17 Sep 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Local Government Reorganisation and Devolution

Councillor Holt moved and Councillor Smart seconded a proposal to ‘ T o note the report ahead of it being considered and determined by Cabinet on 24 September 2025’.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 17 Sep 2025, item 39Open the meeting
Seconded17 Sep 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Community Governance Review

Councillor Small moved and Councillor Smart seconded an alternative proposal ‘To defer the decision on undertaking the so as not to incur unnecessary costs and allow for greater clarity on the Government’s position in regard to the East Sussex Local Government Reorganisation proposals and the Government’s policies on the creation of new Parish Councils’.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 17 Sep 2025, item 40Open the meeting
Said17 Sep 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Smart spoke in relation to Minute 20 of the Planning Committee on 19 August 2025, regarding Terminus Road – ID 250419, and his concern that this application from the Council had been discussed but a similar one from the Towner had not, and that the views of the Conservation Advisory Group had not been sought on one of the applications, and were not reflected in the officer report in relation to the Bandstand. He also raised a concern that registered public speakers were not able to speak on the Bandstand item at the Planning Committee this week as it was deferred.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 17 Sep 2025, item 42Open the meeting
Named17 Sep 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Holt in response suggested Councillor Smart talk to the Planning Team to get clarity on the Towner application. He stated that the view that the Council would be involved in any way in the demolition of the Bandstand was a misrepresentation and that the Council would do everything it could to protect and improve the Bandstand.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 17 Sep 2025, item 42Open the meeting
Said19 Aug 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Whinfell, 25 Upper Carlisle Road. ID: 250288

Councillor Smart (Ward Councillor) spoke in opposition to the application.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 19 Aug 2025, item 19Open the meeting
Said19 Aug 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Terminus Road. ID: 250419

Councillor Smart (Ward Councillor) spoke in support of the application.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 19 Aug 2025, item 20Open the meeting
Named9 Jul 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Right to address the meeting/order of business

Councillor Smart had requested to speak on Item 8 ( Houses in Multiple Occupation Supplementary Planning Document).
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 9 Jul 2025, item 13Open the meeting
Said9 Jul 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Houses in Multiple Occupation Supplementary Planning Document (HMO SPD)

Visiting member Councillor Smart spoke on this item and welcomed the HMO SPD. He thanked Matthew Hitchen and his team and looked forward to seeing how it would be implemented and used by the Planning Team and Committee.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 9 Jul 2025, item 15Open the meeting
Said11 Jun 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Strategic Finance Programme update

Visiting Member Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet on the item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Jun 2025, item 6Open the meeting
Named11 Jun 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Strategic Finance Programme update

Councillor Smart referred to budgetary projected figures included in the report and enquired to the publication date of the budget book.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Jun 2025, item 6Open the meeting
Asked11 Jun 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Strategic Finance Programme update

Councillor Smart questioned the impact on staffing and service levels as a result of the Council’s budgetary position.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Jun 2025, item 6Open the meeting
Named11 Jun 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Strategic Finance Programme update

However, Councillor Smart did not consider the Council’s financial position to be a result of homelessness and temporary accommodation, but believed it to be a result of historic decisions taken by the Council.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Jun 2025, item 6Open the meeting
Moved21 May 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Freedom of the Borough

The following motion was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Holt:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 May 2025, item 5Open the meeting
Seconded21 May 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Calendar of Meetings 2025/26

Councillor Holt moved and Councillor Smart seconded the approval of the Calendar of Meetings for 2025/26, as set out on the agenda.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 May 2025, item 16Open the meeting
Said21 May 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Calendar of Meetings 2025/26

It was noted that this included some amendments to dates since last considered at Full Council, in particular relating to the Local Government Reorganisation process, and Councillor Smart welcomed the confirmation of a September Council meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 May 2025, item 16Open the meeting
Named19 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Local Government Reorganisation and Devolution

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on the item. He outlined the two proposals for devolution and local government reorganisation (LGR) and highlighted the advantages and disadvantages to both. He referenced the published Assurance Review report, undertaken by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) and financial position of the Borough Council.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 19 Mar 2025, item 62Open the meeting
Named5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Petition - Sovereign Centre

Councillor Smart referenced support that had been provided by the Government for pools and asked if the Motcombe Pool would be reopened.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 5 Mar 2025, item 45Open the meeting
Seconded5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2025/26

Councillor Small moved and Councillor Smart seconded the following amendment:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 5 Mar 2025, item 46aOpen the meeting
Seconded5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Calendar of Meetings 2025/26

Councillor Holt proposed and Councillor Smart seconded acceptance of the draft Calendar of Meeting 2025/26. It was noted that the dates would be subject to final ratification at annual council in line with legislation It was noted that a Full Council meeting would be needed in September and it was likely a couple of other dates would need to be changed so that the Council could consider Local Government Reorganisation ahead of the submission deadline. These would be updated at Annual Council or as soon as the approval route was known after that.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 5 Mar 2025, item 47Open the meeting
Moved5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - No confidence in the Cabinet

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Belsey seconded the motion as follows:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 5 Mar 2025, item 48aOpen the meeting
Said5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - No confidence in the Cabinet

Councillor Smart spoke to his motion and set out his reasons for bringing it including his concerns around the performance and decisions of the Cabinet.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 5 Mar 2025, item 48aOpen the meeting
Said11 Dec 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Urgent items of business

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet on this item. He referenced discussions made at the Scrutiny Committee, including comments made by external public speakers. He enquired as to the business plan for the current arrangements with Wave Leisure and queried why the financial position of the Centre had deteriorated since July 2023, where a nil net cost position was reported.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Dec 2024, item 37Open the meeting
Said10 Dec 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

7a Meads Street, Eastbourne. ID: 240539

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee in opposition to the application.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 10 Dec 2024, item 56Open the meeting
Named9 Dec 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business

A request to address the Committee was also received from Councillor Smart.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 9 Dec 2024, item 38Open the meeting
Moved20 Nov 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Sovereign Leisure Centre

‘This Council resolves to ask Scrutiny Committee to explore all further options to keep the existing facilities of the Sovereign Leisure Centre open.’ Councillor Smart proposed and Councillor Small seconded a second amendment as follows:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Nov 2024, item 35aOpen the meeting
Asked20 Nov 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Local Employment and Training Supplementary Planning Document (SPD)

Councillor Smart asked questions in relation to whether this would have a negative impact on Eastbourne, and queried a comment made by the Chamber of Commerce on the consultation.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Nov 2024, item 36aOpen the meeting
Named20 Nov 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Local Employment and Training Supplementary Planning Document (SPD)

He suggested Councillor Smart write to the Chamber of Commerce directly on its comments.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Nov 2024, item 36aOpen the meeting
Named20 Nov 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Planning Committee – 17 September 2024 Audit and Governance Committee – 24 September 2024 Cabinet – 13 November 2024 Councillor Smart and Councillor Shore spoke on minute 30 of Cabinet on 13 November 2024 in relation to the ‘Strategic Finance Programme’.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Nov 2024, item 37Open the meeting
Named13 Nov 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Strategic Finance Programme

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item. He referenced the savings plan, detailed at Appendix 2 and asked what the annual budget of street cleansing was and a description of savings at Devonshire Park theatres for 24/25. He requested that Cabinet keep public conveniences open whilst satisfactory solutions were found.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 13 Nov 2024, item 30Open the meeting
Said12 Nov 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Eastbourne Magistrates Court, Old Orchard Road. ID: 240418

With the agreement of the Chair, Councillor Smart, Adjoining Ward Councillor, raised concerns regarding the application.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 12 Nov 2024, item 46Open the meeting
Named6 Aug 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group

Apologies for absence

Councillor Shore attended as substitute for Councillor Smart.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, 6 Aug 2024, item 8Open the meeting
Said23 Jul 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Article 4 Direction to withdraw permitted development rights in relation to Houses in Multiple Occupation

Councillor Smart spoke in relation to the report.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 23 Jul 2024, item 9Open the meeting
Named17 Jul 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Eastbourne Houses in Multiple Occupation - Options for Interventions

Councillor Smart applauded officers for progressing the matter since the Full Council motion in February 2024. He further referenced the Article 4 direction to remove permitted development rights relating to HMOs and potential exploration for other permitted development rights and a wider remit in the Borough.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 17 Jul 2024, item 14Open the meeting
Named17 Jul 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Eastbourne Houses in Multiple Occupation - Options for Interventions

Councillor Di Cara echoed comments made by Councillor Smart and added concerns around implementation and enforcement and the need for clearer interaction between planning and licensing departments as part of any enforcement action.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 17 Jul 2024, item 14Open the meeting
Named17 Jul 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Treasury Management Annual Report 2023/24

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 17 Jul 2024, item 18Open the meeting
Named17 Jul 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Treasury Management Annual Report 2023/24

Councillor Smart reiterated comments made previously, in relation to last year’s treasury management report and the CIPFA Assurance Review. Commenting on this year’s report, he referenced the short-term debt position of the Council, which was now reported at £80 million (£191 million overall debt). He raised concerns about the cost of the debt annually to the council, when compared to the current financial pressures and the council’s overall financial sustainability.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 17 Jul 2024, item 18Open the meeting
Said17 Jul 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Bedfordwell Road Project Update

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet whilst the meeting was in exempt session, as his comments referenced the exempt appendix.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 17 Jul 2024, item 19Open the meeting
Named15 Jul 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for absence / declaration of substitute members

Councillor Smart was a substitute for Councillor Goodyear.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2024, item 2Open the meeting
Asked15 Jul 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Housing Development & Property Update (to follow)

Councillor Smart asked that his opposition to the recommendations in the Cabinet report, based on his concerns that wider interest in the site (including private developers) had not been explored sufficiently, be noted.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 15 Jul 2024, item 10Open the meeting
Named11 Jun 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group

Apologies for absence

Councillor Goodyear was appointed as a member of the Group for the meeting by the Head of Democratic Services under delegated powers in place of Councillor Smart.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, 11 Jun 2024, item 2Open the meeting
Declared5 Mar 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group

Minutes of the last meeting

Item 17 – Declarations of interest Councillor Smart declared a non-pecuniary interest, having an in-depth knowledge of the building being considered, as his son-in-law was working at Bedes School,  ...  view the full minutes text for item 21.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, 5 Mar 2024, item 21Open the meeting
Said28 Feb 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Petition - EBC must give Defiant Sports compensation, an alternative site and hold a public meeting regarding Fort Fun

Councillor Smart welcomed the action taken to sign the lease for Archery and looked forward to seeing the Seaside Strategy when published.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 28 Feb 2024, item 53Open the meeting
Moved28 Feb 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMO) Study

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Goodyear seconded the motion.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 28 Feb 2024, item 56Open the meeting
Said28 Feb 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMO) Study

In presenting his motion, Councillor Smart confirmed that he would support the amendment from Councillor Murray, and this was confirmed by the seconder Councillor Goodyear.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 28 Feb 2024, item 56Open the meeting
Moved24 Jan 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Honorary Alderman - Barry Taylor

The following motion was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Lamb:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 Jan 2024, item 43Open the meeting
Declared9 Jan 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group

Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary Interests (DPIs) by members as required under Section 31 of the Localism Act and of other interests as required by the Code of Conduct.

Councillor Smart declared a non-pecuniary interest, having an in-depth knowledge of the building being considered, as his son-in-law worked at Bedes School, the previous owners.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, 9 Jan 2024, item 17Open the meeting
Seconded15 Nov 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Members' Allowances Scheme - Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel (IRP)

Councillor Holt moved a recommendation to accept the Independent Remuneration Panel’s recommendation in relation to the Members’ Allowance Scheme in full (option 1a) as set out in the report and this was seconded by Councillor Smart. It was asked that the thanks be extended to the Panel members for their work.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 15 Nov 2023, item 36Open the meeting
Seconded15 Nov 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Polling Station Review

Councillor Holt moved and Councillor Smart seconded the recommendations of the report.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 15 Nov 2023, item 37Open the meeting
Moved15 Nov 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Local Plan

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Small seconded an alternative motion as follows:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 15 Nov 2023, item 38dOpen the meeting
Moved15 Nov 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Local Plan

The alternative motion proposed by Councillor Smart was put to a vote and lost by 8 votes for, 19 against.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 15 Nov 2023, item 38dOpen the meeting
Named20 Sep 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Assurance Review follow up - CIPFA (Chartered Institute of Finance and Accountancy) Rapid Finance Review

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on the item. He queried the validity of the report, due to the reporting of the Council’s short-term debt management position.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 20 Sep 2023, item 18Open the meeting
Named18 Sep 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for absence / declaration of substitute members

Councillor Smart was a substitute for Councillor Goodyear.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 18 Sep 2023, item 16Open the meeting
Moved26 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Appointment of Standards Independent Persons

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor di Cara seconded a proposal that this matter be deferred until all Councillors had sight of the CVs of the proposed independent persons.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 26 Jul 2023, item 23Open the meeting
Named26 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Treasury Management Annual Report 2022/23

A request for a recorded vote was put forward by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor di Cara, meeting the threshold in the constitution.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 26 Jul 2023, item 24aOpen the meeting
Named19 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Provisional Revenue and Capital Outturn 2022/23

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet and questioned the Council’s financial controls, given the significant variances between the agreed budget in February 2023 to year end (31 March 23).
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 19 Jul 2023, item 11Open the meeting
Named19 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Stability and Growth Programme

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on the item and sought an analysis of the £5.9 million of cumulative revenue savings because of the Recovery and Stabilisation programme. It was clarified that this also included income as part of the figure. He also stated that net service expenditure had increased by 37% from the year before the Covid-19 pandemic.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 19 Jul 2023, item 13Open the meeting
Declared10 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for absence / declaration of substitute members

Councillor Smart declared he was substituting for Councillor Lamb.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 10 Jul 2023, item 2Open the meeting
Moved10 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Sovereign Centre Arrangements

Councillor Smart proposed the following amended recommendation (2) for the Cabinet’s consideration and was seconded by Councillor Goodyear.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 10 Jul 2023, item 12Open the meeting
Seconded24 May 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Borough Council Elections 2023 - Returning Officer report.

Councillor   (*newly elected) Devonshire Margaret Elizabeth BANNISTER, Christina Jane EWBANK* Stephen Alfred HOLT Hampden Park James Robert MURRAY Teresa Marie SAYERS-COOPER* Colin Richard SWANSBOROUGH Langney Anita MAYES* Alan SHUTTLEWORTH Candy VAUGHAN Meads Andrew William COLLINS* Jane Elizabeth LAMB Robert Christopher SMART Old Town Ali Asgar DEHDASHTY* Peter Robert DIPLOCK Amanda Jennifer MORRIS Ratton Nicholas John Raymond ANSELL* Colin Sidney BELSEY, David SMALL* St Anthony's Daniel David Anstey BUTCHER* Hugh Wayne PARKER Jenny WILLIAMS* Sovereign Penelope Rose DI CARA Nigel Royston GOODYEAR* Kshama SHORE Upperton Katherine Leah BALLARD* Robin Hugh MAXTED Patrick Joseph RODOHAN The report recommendations were proposed by Councillor Holt and seconded by Councillor Smart. Councillors congratulated all Councillors on their election and took time to thank and pay tribute to all those who had served the Council and stood down at this election including Councillors Babarinde, Choudhury, Dow, Freebody, Miah, Murdoch, Taylor, Tutt, Wallis and Whippy. Thanks were extended to the Returning Officer and his team for their work on the election.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 May 2023, item 9Open the meeting
Seconded24 May 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Calendar of Meetings 2023/24

Councillor Holt moved and Councillor Smart seconded the ratification of the Calendar of Meetings for 2023/24, as set out on the agenda.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 May 2023, item 12Open the meeting
Seconded24 May 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Annual Pay Policy Statement 2023-24

Councillor Holt moved and Councillor Smart seconded the recommendations set out in the report.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 May 2023, item 13Open the meeting
Named14 Mar 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Eastbourne Local Plan

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 14 Mar 2023, item 51Open the meeting
Seconded7 Mar 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group

Appointment of Chair for the meeting

Councillor Maxted proposed, and Councillor Smart seconded, that Councillor Rodohan chair the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, 7 Mar 2023, item 32Open the meeting
Said27 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

2 Denton Road. ID 220626

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee in relation to the application.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 27 Feb 2023, item 63Open the meeting
Asked22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Minutes of the meeting held on 16 November 2022

Councillor Smart asked for an amendment to the Minute 45(2), to include the addition of ‘but they are only a starting point’ in relation to the record on his statement on Eastbourne Local Plan Growth Strategy Consultation.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 48Open the meeting
Said22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Minutes of the meeting held on 16 November 2022

“Councillor Smart advised that he shared the Leader’s concerns that the housing numbers were flawed, but they are only a starting point, and that he would have wished to see the consultation started earlier and would like to see greater emphasis on employment sites”.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 48Open the meeting
Moved22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Eastbourne Local Plan - Protecting our Green and Leisure Spaces.

“ Councillor Smart moved and Councillor di Cara seconded an amendment to the motion, so that the motion would read as follows:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 54aOpen the meeting
Moved22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Eastbourne Local Plan - Protecting our Green and Leisure Spaces.

The amendment proposed by Councillor Smart was put to a vote and lost by 7 for, 13 against, with 2 abstentions.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 54aOpen the meeting
Moved22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2023/24.

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Shore seconded the following amendment as set out in an addendum tabled at the meeting:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 56aOpen the meeting
Said22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2023/24.

Councillor Smart then spoke to his amendment and on behalf of the opposition in response to the budget and set out why he considered that additional focus on capital disposals was required.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 56aOpen the meeting
Named22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2023/24.

Prior to the Council was moving the vote, Councillor Smart and then Councillor Holt were given the opportunity to sum up.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 56aOpen the meeting
Seconded22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Appointment of Monitoring Officer

Councillor Tutt moved and Councillor Smart seconded the recommendations set out in the report of the Chief Executive, recommending the appointment of Simon Russell as the new Monitoring Officer. In speaking to the recommendations, both Councillors thanked the outgoing Monitoring Officer, Oliver Dixon, for his excellent service to the Council and advice in this role and wished him well.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 57Open the meeting
Seconded22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Members' Allowances Scheme - Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel (IRP) Revisit

Councillor Tutt moved and Councillor Smart seconded option c) to reject the Panels’ recommendation in full and ask for a Panel to be reconvened early in the new Council, with a report due back to Full Council in November 2023. The compelling reason for doing so was that the report was now dated and the level of inflation was much higher than may have been expected three years ago. It was noted that the allowances had not increased since 2007.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 58Open the meeting
Said22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Members' Allowances Scheme - Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel (IRP) Revisit

In response to a question raised by Councillor Smart, it was confirmed that the Council could not commit itself in advance to accept any recommendations of a new IRP Panel without debate, when reported in November 2023.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 58Open the meeting
Seconded22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Calendar of Meetings 2023/24.

Councillor Tutt moved and Councillor Smart seconded that the proposed calendar of meetings for 2023-24. It was noted that the dates would be subject to formal ratification at annual council in line with legislation.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 22 Feb 2023, item 60Open the meeting
Named5 Dec 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Council tax and business rate base 2023/24

Following a proposal by Councillor Smart which was seconded by Councillor Lamb, the members of the Committee Resolved unanimously to support the Officer recommendations to the Cabinet, subject to the following, additional recommendation being considered:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 5 Dec 2022, item 47Open the meeting
Seconded16 Nov 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Result of the St Anthony's Ward By-Election

A resolution was moved by Councillor Tutt and seconded by Councillor Smart, and:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 16 Nov 2022, item 41Open the meeting
Said16 Nov 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Smart advised that he shared the Leader’s concerns that the housing numbers required were flawed, but that he would have wished to see the consultation started earlier and would like to see greater emphasis on employment sites.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 16 Nov 2022, item 45Open the meeting
Named2 Nov 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy 2023/24-2026/27

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 2 Nov 2022, item 25Open the meeting
Named2 Nov 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy 2023/24-2026/27

Following points raised, Councillor Holt agreed to meet with Councillor Smart following the meeting regarding presentation and a breakdown of pay related costs.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 2 Nov 2022, item 25Open the meeting
Moved20 Jul 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Support for Gatwick Airport's Northern Runway

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor di Cara seconded the following motion as set out in the agenda papers:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Jul 2022, item 29aOpen the meeting
Named20 Jul 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Support for Gatwick Airport's Northern Runway

“ In moving the recommendation, Councillor Smart read out a statement from the Chamber of Commerce in support of the extra runway at Gatwick Airport.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Jul 2022, item 29aOpen the meeting
Named13 Jul 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Treasury management annual report 2021/22

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 13 Jul 2022, item 13Open the meeting
Named11 Jul 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Election of a Chair

Councillor Kshama Shore was nominated by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Wallis as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 11 Jul 2022, item 1Open the meeting
Said30 May 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

The Tiled House, Chesterfield Road. ID: 211032

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee in objection to the application. The Committee raised concerns regarding visual impact, over development and impact on the neighbouring property.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 30 May 2022, item 6Open the meeting
Said30 May 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Moira House School, Upper Carlisle Road. ID: 220014

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee in support of the application. The Committee welcomed the proposal and the collaborative approach between the developer, residents and the Meads Community Association.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 30 May 2022, item 7Open the meeting
Said18 May 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Minutes of the meeting held on 23 February 2022

Councillor Smart advised that he did not consider the minutes to be complete but did not propose any specific amendments and indicated he would not vote against them.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 May 2022, item 4Open the meeting
Seconded18 May 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Appointments Report

Councillor Tutt proposed and Councillor Smart seconded the recommendations set out in the report and appendices, subject to a correction advised by Councillor Smart to the membership to the Grants Task Group from Councillor di Cara to Councillor Murdoch.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 May 2022, item 10Open the meeting
Seconded18 May 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Confirmation of the Calendar of meetings for 2022/23

Councillor Tutt moved and Councillor Smart seconded the ratification of the Calendar of Meetings for 2022/23, as set out on the agenda.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 May 2022, item 11Open the meeting
Said18 May 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Confirmation of the Calendar of meetings for 2022/23

In seconding, Councillor Smart advised that he would hope to see an update on the implementation of the CIPFA recommendations and financial position in July, but if not he would request that an additional Full Council meeting to be called in September for that purpose.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 May 2022, item 11Open the meeting
Moved18 May 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - New Hospital for Eastbourne

·                 East Sussex NHS Hospitals Trust to share its ‘Building for our Future’ Strategic Outline Case for Eastbourne’s brand new hospital with the Save the DGH Campaign Group for constructive scrutiny without delay.” Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Metcalfe seconded an alternative motion:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 May 2022, item 17Open the meeting
Named21 Mar 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Corporate performance - quarter 3 - 2021/22

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 21 Mar 2022, item 54Open the meeting
Named8 Mar 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group

Minutes of the last meeting

As Councillor Smart had not seen the minutes, he requested and the Chair agreed to defer confirmation to the next meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, 8 Mar 2022, item 35Open the meeting
Said8 Mar 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group

Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary Interests (DPIs) by members as required under Section 31 of the Localism Act and of other interests as required by the Code of Conduct.

Councillor Smart also requested it be noted that he had met  ...  view the full minutes text for item 37.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, 8 Mar 2022, item 37Open the meeting
Moved23 Feb 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2022/23.

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Shore seconded the following amendment which had been circulated at the meeting:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 23 Feb 2022, item 62aOpen the meeting
Said23 Feb 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2022/23.

Councillor Smart spoke to the amendment and spoke on behalf of the opposition group in relation to the budget. He recognised that the last two years had been overshadowed by Covid, and he applauded the response from the Council and the savings that had been achieved. He advised that he considered that it was appropriate to fund the full cost of £3m to renovate the bandstand  ...  view the full minutes text for item 62a
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 23 Feb 2022, item 62aOpen the meeting
Moved23 Feb 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion 3 - Maintaining Heritage Assets

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor di Cara seconded the motion set out on the agenda as below:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 23 Feb 2022, item 63Open the meeting
Seconded23 Feb 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion 4 - Cardiology Services at the Eastbourne DGH

Councillor Babarinde moved and Councillor Smart seconded the motion set out in the agenda and as below:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 23 Feb 2022, item 65Open the meeting
Named9 Feb 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

General Fund Revenue Budget 2022/23 and Capital Programme

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 9 Feb 2022, item 44Open the meeting
Moved7 Feb 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

A Coastal Concordat for England

·        Councillor Smart proposed the following recommendation – ‘That the Scrutiny Committee does not believe that local democracy is improved by the proposal for a coastal concordat and advises against it’. The recommendation was not seconded and therefore dismissed.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 7 Feb 2022, item 55Open the meeting
Named29 Nov 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Minutes of the meeting held on 13 September 2021

Councillor Smart referred to matters arising from the previous minutes and it was agreed that those would be dealt with later on the agenda.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 29 Nov 2021, item 30Open the meeting
Seconded17 Nov 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Anti-social driving

Councillor Lamb moved and Councillor Smart seconded the following motion, as set out on the agenda paper:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 17 Nov 2021, item 47bOpen the meeting
Said17 Nov 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

·         Licensing Committee – 27 July 2021 ·         Audit and Governance Committee – 28 July 2021 and 29 September 2021 ·         Planning Committee – 24 August 2021, 21 September 2021 and 19 October 2021 ·         Cabinet – 15 September 2021 and 3 November 2021 ·         Scrutiny Committee – 13 September 2021 Councillor Smart raised for discussion, Minute 12 ‘Reset and Recovery Programme’ from Cabinet on 14 July, and asked questions in relation to the certainty of the shortfall.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 17 Nov 2021, item 48Open the meeting
Said17 Nov 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Smart raised for discussion, Minute 26, ‘Medium Term Financial Strategy’ from the Scrutiny Committee of 13 September 2021 and scrutiny of finance, and Councillors Swansborough, Tutt, Freebody and Holt responded to the matters raised.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 17 Nov 2021, item 48Open the meeting
Said15 Sep 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Medium Term Financial Strategy

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 15 Sep 2021, item 24Open the meeting
Said13 Sep 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Minutes of the meeting held on 12 July 2021

Matters arising – Councillor Smart requested that responses be provided on the following points:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 13 Sep 2021, item 17Open the meeting
Named13 Sep 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Medium Term Financial Strategy

Councillor Smart put forward the following additional recommendation which was seconded by Councillor Di Cara:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 13 Sep 2021, item 26Open the meeting
Named28 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

The Chair reported a request from Councillor Smart to address the Committee regarding items 7 and 9.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 28 Jul 2021, item 6Open the meeting
Named28 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

The Chair agreed that Councillor Smart could speak for up to five minutes before the commencement of each item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 28 Jul 2021, item 6Open the meeting
Named28 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

External Auditor (Deloitte) report on the 2018/19 Statement of Accounts

The Chair then invited Councillor Smart to address the Committee regarding item 7 and thanked him for his comments.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 28 Jul 2021, item 7Open the meeting
Named28 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Redmond Review update and MHCLG External Audit Consultations

The Chair invited Councillor Smart to address the Committee re item 9.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 28 Jul 2021, item 9Open the meeting
Said28 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Redmond Review update and MHCLG External Audit Consultations

Councillor Smart spoke for five minutes and the Chair thanked him for his comments.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 28 Jul 2021, item 9Open the meeting
Moved21 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Engagement in Planning

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Lamb seconded the following motion, as set out on the agenda paper, subject to the inclusion of the words ‘local and’ before neighbourhood plans:   “This Council believes planning works best for residents when developers and the local community work together to shape local areas and deliver necessary new homes and related infrastructure.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 Jul 2021, item 37aOpen the meeting
Said21 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Engagement in Planning

Councillor Smart expressed his wish that, if approved, this position be communicated to the Government.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 Jul 2021, item 37aOpen the meeting
Moved21 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Deregulation of Planning

·         to undertake a wholesale review of Permitted Development Rights, ·         to make the national Planning Inspectorate more accountable to local people; and ·         to implement stronger controls to ensure Ministers making decisions on planning applications are not connected either financially or personally with Developers or related parties to the application." Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Lamb moved an amendment to the motion (which was tabled at the meeting):
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 Jul 2021, item 37bOpen the meeting
Said21 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Licensing Committee – 24 May 2021 Planning Committee – 26 May 2021 and 29 June 2021 Cabinet – 2 June 2021 and 14 July 2021 Scrutiny Committee – 12 July 2021 Councillor Smart raised for discussion, Minute 12 ‘Reset and Recovery Programme’ from Cabinet on 14 July, and asked questions in relation to the certainty of the £6.6m shortfall.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 Jul 2021, item 38Open the meeting
Said21 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Smart raised for discussion, Minute 15 ‘Provisional Revenue and Capital Outturn 2020/21’ from Cabinet on 14 July, and asked about the final costs in relation to the Devonshire Quarter Project and confirmation that the £4.6m of savings last year were correctly calculated.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 Jul 2021, item 38Open the meeting
Named21 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Councillor Holt gave assurance of the figures and advised that he understood the Chief Finance Officer was in the process of providing the detailed breakdown requested by Councillor Smart at the Cabinet meeting and he would follow up the response.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 Jul 2021, item 38Open the meeting
Named14 Jul 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Recovery and reset programme

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 14 Jul 2021, item 12Open the meeting
Seconded19 May 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Results of the Borough By-Elections 2021

Councillor Tutt moved the recommendation and Councillor Smart seconded the recommendation to receive the results of the by-elections held on 6 May 2021 and congratulate Councillor Babarinde and Councillor Shore on their election and to welcome them to the Council.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 19 May 2021, item 8Open the meeting
Seconded19 May 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Appointments

Councillor Tutt proposed and Councillor Smart seconded the proposals for allocations to Committees, other bodies, boards and appointment of Chairs and Deputy Chairs as set out in the Appendix 1 set out in the supplement to the agenda, subject to a correction to the membership to the Audit and Governance Committee to include Councillor Diplock as a member of the Committee and Councillor Babarinde as a substitute.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 19 May 2021, item 10Open the meeting
Seconded19 May 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Confirmation of the Calendar of Meetings for 2021/22

Councillor Tutt moved and Councillor Smart seconded the revised Calendar of Meetings for 2021/22 (as set out in a supplement to the agenda) to include the following amendments since considered at the last meeting:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 19 May 2021, item 11Open the meeting
Said19 May 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Confirmation of the Calendar of Meetings for 2021/22

Councillor Smart advised that he was supporting the calendar as he had been given assurances that an additional meeting of Full Council would be called if needed in the autumn to consider any revisions to the Council’s budget arising from the completion of the external assurance review.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 19 May 2021, item 11Open the meeting
Said19 May 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Scrutiny Committee – 8 February and 24 March 2021 Planning Committee – 23 February, 23 March and 20 April 2021 Audit and Governance Committee – 3 March 2021 Councillor Smart spoke in respect of the following minutes under Council Procedure Rule 14:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 19 May 2021, item 14Open the meeting
Moved24 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2021/22

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor di Cara seconded an amendment, which had been circulated to all Councillors, to add the following as an additional recommendation (11):
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 Feb 2021, item 24aOpen the meeting
Said24 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2021/22

Councillor Smart responded to the budget proposals on behalf of the opposition and presented his amendment. He paid tribute to residents and Council employees in their response to Covid 19, and in particular the speed of business grant distribution. He expressed his concerns that the final audited accounts for 2018/19 and 2019/20 had not yet been presented to the Council, and as to the uncertainties this created for the budget proposals.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 Feb 2021, item 24aOpen the meeting
Named24 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2021/22

The Council debated the budget in full, and Councillor Smart and Councillor Holt were given the opportunity to sum up at the end of the discussion.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 Feb 2021, item 24aOpen the meeting
Asked24 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Calendar of Meeting 2021/22

Councillor Smart asked for an additional Council meeting to be added to the calendar in September to consider any revised budget arising from the external assurance review required by Government as part of its capitalisation direction.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 Feb 2021, item 26Open the meeting
Named24 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Calendar of Meeting 2021/22

Councillor Tutt advised he was happy to discuss any necessary changes with Officers and Councillor Smart outside the meeting. He confirmed that the move to reduce the number of Council from 5 to 4 a year was agreed cross-party a few years ago and resolved by Full Council. Resolved – 1.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 24 Feb 2021, item 26Open the meeting
Moved8 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Treasury Management and Prudential Indicators 2021/22, Capital Strategy & Investment Strategy

·        Councillor Smart proposed that the Council should prepare a cash-flow forecast, which could be reported against at various stages during the year.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 8 Feb 2021, item 32Open the meeting
Said26 Jan 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Planning Application Performance and Appeal Record for the year 2020

Councillor Smart, Meads Ward, addressed the committee on the appeal record, referring to viability studies and pressure of housing shortages.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 26 Jan 2021, item 51Open the meeting
Named2 Dec 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Right to address the meeting

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, had requested to speak on agenda items 7 and 10b.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 2 Dec 2020, item 28Open the meeting
Named2 Dec 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Right to address the meeting

Given Cabinet and visiting members would be receiving a presentation for agenda item 7, it was agreed that Councillor Smart could cover his points under agenda item 10b.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 2 Dec 2020, item 28Open the meeting
Said2 Dec 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Corporate performance - quarter 2 - 2020/2021

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet on the Council’s financial performance.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 2 Dec 2020, item 32Open the meeting
Named26 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

The Chair confirmed that one request had been received from Councillor Smart, who then addressed the Committee in respect of Item 8 on the agenda, the External Audit 2018/19, within the allotted time of 5 minutes.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 26 Nov 2020, item 21Open the meeting
Named26 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

The Chair thanked Councillor Smart for his comments and with the Committee’s agreement, the order of Items 7 and 8 were swapped, so that the External Audit became the next Agenda item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 26 Nov 2020, item 21Open the meeting
Seconded18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Designation of Monitoring Officer

Councillor Tutt moved and Councillor Smart seconded the recommendations in the report to designate Oliver Dixon, the Head of Legal Services as the statutory Monitoring Officer.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Named18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Designation of Monitoring Officer

Councillor Smart in seconding the recommendation, thanked Peter Finnis for his excellent work on behalf of Eastbourne and its residents and wished him well in his retirement, and welcomed Oliver Dixon to his new role.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Seconded18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Conservation Area Advisory Group (CAAG) - Proposed changes to Terms of Reference and Status

Councillor Rodohan moved and Councillor Smart seconded the recommendations in the report to expand the remit and change the status of the Conservation Area Advisory Group (CAAG) in order to enable more flexible discussion and a broader input of knowledge into the decision-making process in respect of matters affecting Conservation Areas and Listed Buildings.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2020, item 11Open the meeting
Seconded18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Completion of Winter Garden Redevelopment

Councillor Bannister moved and Councillor Smart seconded the recommendation referred from Cabinet meeting held on 16 March 2020, to support Option 2 for the completion of the Winter Garden redevelopment.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2020, item 13aOpen the meeting
Named18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Completion of Winter Garden Redevelopment

Councillor Smart in seconding the recommendation outlined his concerns that the project had been delayed until this point and as to the budget involved.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2020, item 13aOpen the meeting
Named18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Completion of Winter Garden Redevelopment

Councillor Tutt responded to the points made by Councillor Smart in relation to budget for the project.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2020, item 13aOpen the meeting
Moved18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion 2 - Government Planning White Paper 'Planning for the Future'

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Ansell seconded an amendment to the recommendation, which had been circulated to all Councillors, as below:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2020, item 14bOpen the meeting
Moved18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion 5 - Financial processes

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Di Cara seconded the motion set out on the agenda, related to improving financial processes and accountability.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2020, item 14eOpen the meeting
Said2 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Minutes of the meeting held on 14 September 2020

Councillor Smart requested that the ‘heat’ map of houses of multiple occupancy in the borough requested at previous meetings be made available to the Committee.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 2 Nov 2020, item 12Open the meeting
Said20 Oct 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Esperance Private Hospital, Hartington Place. ID: 200565

Councillor Smart, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He stated that he did not oppose the change of use or principle of residential development, but a mix of bigger units was needed. He raised concerns regarding lack of parking and overdevelopment and agreed with the MCA that the application should be deferred.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 20 Oct 2020, item 26Open the meeting
Declared16 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Declaration of members' interests

Councillors Tutt and Dow and visiting member Councillor Smart declared a personal, non prejudicial interest in agenda item 13 (Improving recycling – public consultation) as members of the South East Environmental Services Ltd (SEESL) Board. They remained on the remote meeting whilst the item was considered.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 16 Sep 2020, item 10Open the meeting
Said16 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Medium term financial strategy

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 16 Sep 2020, item 15Open the meeting
Declared16 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Improving recycling - public consultation

Councillors Tutt and Dow and visiting member Councillor Smart declared a personal, non prejudicial interest for this item. They remained on the remote meeting whilst the item was considered.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 16 Sep 2020, item 17Open the meeting
Said14 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Minutes of the meeting held on 3 February 2020

·        Councillor Smart requested that the ‘heat’ map of houses of multiple occupancy in the borough requested at the previous meeting be made available to the Committee.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 14 Sep 2020, item 1Open the meeting
Named9 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

One request was received from Councillor Smart, who then addressed the Committee in respect of Item 7 on the agenda, the External Audit 2018/19, within the allotted time of 5 minutes.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Sep 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Named9 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

The Chair thanked Councillor Smart for his comments, and approved his request to be allowed to speak, briefly, a second time, following the verbal report from the Deputy Chief Finance Officers, and once all Committee members had had the opportunity to speak.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Sep 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Named9 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

External Audit Report 2018/19 (Verbal Update)

The Chair invited questions and comments from Councillors, including a brief comment from non-committee member Councillor Smart, and the Committee considered the issue.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Sep 2020, item 7Open the meeting
Said25 Aug 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

21-25 Gildredge Road ID: 200322 & 200332

Councillor Smart, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He stated that he was not against the application in principle but felt the obligation of affordability should continue irrespective of the outcome of the viability statement, and more parking should be provided.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 25 Aug 2020, item 15Open the meeting
Named15 Jul 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Financial assessment of Covid-19 update

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 15 Jul 2020, item 4Open the meeting
Named3 Jun 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Initial financial assessment of Covid-19

Visiting member, Councillor Smart, addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 3 Jun 2020, item 71Open the meeting
Said16 Mar 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Completion of the Winter Garden redevelopment

Visiting member, Councillor Robert Smart addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 16 Mar 2020, item 62Open the meeting
Named4 Mar 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

A request was received from Councillor Smart regarding Item 7 on the agenda.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 4 Mar 2020, item 27Open the meeting
Said4 Mar 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

Following an invitation from the Chair to address the Committee, Councillor Smart spoke and voiced his concerns about the delay in the publishing of the External Audit of Accounts, and specifically, the lack of apparent progress, the potential for impact on next budget planning, and that there was no personal representation from the external auditors at the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 4 Mar 2020, item 27Open the meeting
Named4 Mar 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

The Chair thanked Councillor Smart for his comments and it was agreed to move to the next item on the agenda: an update report from the Chief Finance Officer regarding the External Audit.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 4 Mar 2020, item 27Open the meeting
Said25 Feb 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Wood Winton, 63a Silverdale Road ID: 190861

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee from the public gallery in objection to the application due to its increase in scale. He also highlighted that the Lead Local Flood Authority had objected to the scheme due to the lack of information provided. Members were informed that houses No.2 to No.6 would increase from 48 square metres to 63 square metres and house No.1 would increase from 75 square metres to 109 square metres.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 25 Feb 2020, item 92Open the meeting
Said19 Feb 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Council Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2020/21

The Council considered the Section 25 Statement of the Section 151 Officer (Chief Finance Officer), a General Fund Summary and the recommendations from the meeting of Cabinet held on 5 February 2020, in respect of the:    General Fund Budget 2020/21 and Capital Programme Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Revenue Budget and Rent Setting 2020/21 and HRA Capital Programme 2019-23; and Treasury Management and Prudential Indicators 2020/21, Capital Strategy and Investment Strategy Councillor Holt made his budget speech setting out the proposals, and Councillor Smart responded on behalf of the opposition.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 19 Feb 2020, item 31Open the meeting
Named18 Sep 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

A request was received from Councillor Smart just before the start of the meeting, regarding the minutes of the last meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 18 Sep 2019, item 19Open the meeting
Said18 Sep 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

Following an invitation by the Chair to address the Committee, Councillor Smart spoke for 10 minutes and voiced his concerns about the delay in publishing the statement of accounts and asked if the Council had met its obligation to publish a notice and provide explanation of the delay. He also raised concerns regarding levels of transparency, citing a £2m transaction from 2017 that he could not find in the 2018 reporting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 18 Sep 2019, item 19Open the meeting
Named18 Sep 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Right to address the meeting/order of business.

The Chair thanked Councillor Smart for his remarks. As the Chief Finance Officer was not present to respond, his comments would be reported to her after the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 18 Sep 2019, item 19Open the meeting
Said11 Sep 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Housing delivery update: Bedfordwell Road - Exempt appendix 1

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 11 Sep 2019, item 31Open the meeting
Said25 Jun 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Glebe Cottage, 4 Grassington Road. Application ID: 190264

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee (from the public gallery) in objection to the application. He said the current consultation to extend the College Conservation Area to encompass Grassington Road would, if formally adopted, have an impact on the site. The Committee discussed the application and felt that the resolution to refuse the application should include an additional condition regarding overdevelopment.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 25 Jun 2019, item 6Open the meeting
Named21 May 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Annual Council

Minutes of the meeting of Council held on 20 February 2019.

The minutes of the meeting of the Council held on 20 February 2019, were confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Mayor, subject to a correction to minute 48, replacing Councillor Smith with Councillor Smart in the list of Councillors voting against the motion.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Annual Council, 21 May 2019, item 3Open the meeting
Said23 Apr 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Meads House, 26 Denton Road. Application ID: 190038

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee (from the public gallery) in objection to the application, stating that he and the local residents were not against redevelopment of the existing building into a small number of residential units. He raised concern regarding parking, overdevelopment and the impact of the application. [name removed], agent, addressed the Committee in support of the application, he explained that the rear extension had been reduced in depth and that the parking allocation met the requirements of the Highways Authority.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 23 Apr 2019, item 115Open the meeting
Said26 Mar 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Wood Winton, 63a Silverdale Road - Application ID: 181206

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee (from the public gallery) in objection. He referred to the access, flood risk, living environment, tree preservation orders (TPOs), and reduction of conditions. He said none of the issues had been addressed by removing one dwelling.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 26 Mar 2019, item 108Open the meeting
Moved11 Mar 2019Eastbourne Borough Council General Licensing Committee

Hackney Carriage Fares

Councillor Smart proposed a motion to accept the proposal.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council General Licensing Committee, 11 Mar 2019, item 13Open the meeting
Said26 Feb 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Spring Mead, 25 Meads Brow. Application ID: 181058

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee (from the public gallery) in objection, stating that the scheme was of poor design and visually intrusive and out of scale and character for the area. He recommended additional conditions be added to the resolution, to strengthen the officers’ reason for refusal.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 26 Feb 2019, item 98Open the meeting
Said26 Feb 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Kempston, 3 Granville Road. Application ID: 190103

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee (from the public gallery) in objection, stating the landlord had failed to maintain the building and to apply for a court injunction to prevent its demolition.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 26 Feb 2019, item 99Open the meeting
Moved20 Feb 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Tree Stump Removal

This work should include the replacement of the tree stumps with a suitable type of tree which will not disturb the pavements but will act to cut pollution from traffic. ” Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Freebody seconded an amendment to the motion so that it reads as follows:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Feb 2019, item 51aOpen the meeting
Said20 Feb 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Special Scrutiny Committee – 17 January 2019 – Minute 40 – Performance Management 2018/19 – Quarter 2 (Part B – Financial Performance) – raised by Councillor Smart.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Feb 2019, item 52Open the meeting
Said20 Feb 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Discussion on minutes of council bodies.

Planning Committee – 22 January 2019 – Minute 88 – College Conservation Area Appraisal – raised by Councillor Smart.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Feb 2019, item 52Open the meeting
Said22 Jan 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

4 Denton Road, Eastbourne. Application ID: 181020

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee (from the public gallery) on behalf the adjoining resident, stating that he fully supported all the objections that had been raised in regard to this application.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 22 Jan 2019, item 84Open the meeting
Said22 Jan 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

College Conservation Area Appraisal

Councillor Smart thanked all those involved in the report and urged Members to agree the recommendation.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 22 Jan 2019, item 88Open the meeting
Said11 Dec 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Wood Winton, 63a Silverdale Road, Eastbourne. Application ID: 180569

Councillor Smart requested to speak against application 180569, Wood Winton 63a Silverdale Road Eastbourne, but was refused by the Chair as there was already one Councillor speaking against the application. This was amicably agreed before the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 11 Dec 2018, item 72Open the meeting
Said11 Dec 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Kempston, 3 Granville Road, Eastbourne. Application ID: 180985

Councillor Smart addressed the committee in objection of the application, stating that a draft report regarding an extension to the College Conservation area would be presented to the committee in January, and that the property may then be within a Conservation area.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 11 Dec 2018, item 74Open the meeting
Said23 May 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Asset investments and disposals.

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 23 May 2018, item 9Open the meeting
Moved9 May 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Parking on pavements and verges.

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Taylor seconded a notice of motion that:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 9 May 2018, item 19Open the meeting
Said21 Mar 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Local car parking standards for new residential development.

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet and recommended that they reject the officer’s recommendations.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 21 Mar 2018, item 71Open the meeting
Said21 Mar 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Devonshire Park redevelopment.

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet and although acknowledging the issues that were outlined in the report, raised concerns with the project’s rise in cost and cuts to the proposed works at the Winter Garden.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 21 Mar 2018, item 73Open the meeting
Said21 Mar 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Corporate performance - quarter 3 - 2017/18.

Visiting member, Councillor Smart addressed the Cabinet and commented on the presentation at appendix 4 of the report.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 21 Mar 2018, item 74Open the meeting
Moved21 Feb 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Speakers at planning committee.

Councillor Smart moved and Councillor Freebody seconded a notice of motion:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 21 Feb 2018, item 110Open the meeting
Said23 Jan 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

26 Denton Road. Application ID: 171224.

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the committee in objection stating that the scheme was out of character and overdevelopment.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 23 Jan 2018, item 90Open the meeting
Said23 Jan 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

Former Police Station, Grove Road. Application ID: 171819.

Councillor Smart, Meads Ward Councillor, addressed the committee in objection stating that parking in the area had already reached saturation point and he also objected to the bulk, height and loss of light.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 23 Jan 2018, item 93Open the meeting
Declared9 Jan 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group

Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary Interests (DPIs) by members as required under Section 31 of the Localism Act and of other interests as required by the Code of Conduct.

Councillor Smart declared an interest in item 6, Meads House, 26 Denton Road, as he felt he had predetermined his decision on this item.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group, 9 Jan 2018, item 34Open the meeting
Named9 Jan 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group

Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary Interests (DPIs) by members as required under Section 31 of the Localism Act and of other interests as required by the Code of Conduct.

Councillor Smart did not address the Group on this item, he did remain in the room whilst this item was discussed.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group, 9 Jan 2018, item 34Open the meeting
Said8 Jan 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Licensing Act Committee

Council Licensing Policy Statement - Review of Cumulative Impact Policy, Licensing Act 2003.

Councillor Smart requested further information regarding the licensing fees and the Functional Lead Quality Environment agreed to provide the details to the committee following the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Licensing Act Committee, 8 Jan 2018, item 9Open the meeting
Named4 Dec 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Research Survey.

The Committee considered the findings of the Maternity Services Survey which had been recently conducted by the Council under the ownership of the Monitoring Officer, in partnership with Councillor Robert Smart, and under the supervision of the Office for National Statistics.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 4 Dec 2017, item 13Open the meeting
Said4 Dec 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Research Survey.

Councillor Smart reported that the survey had identified the following key findings:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 4 Dec 2017, item 13Open the meeting
Named4 Dec 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Research Survey.

Members also extended their gratitude to Councillor Smart for the comprehensive nature of the report, and to Council Officer, Devan Briggs, who had been responsible for inputting the vast amount of data received and constructing the final report document.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 4 Dec 2017, item 13Open the meeting
Seconded15 Nov 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Local car parking standards for all new residential developments

Councillor Freebody moved and Councillor Smart seconded a notice of motion:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 15 Nov 2017, item 95Open the meeting
Moved2 Oct 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Licensing Act Committee

Council Licensing Policy Statement - Review of Cumulative Impact Policy, Licensing Act 2003.

It was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Freebody to defer the decision until further information were obtained and reported back to the Committee. The information requested by the Committee formed part of the resolution.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Licensing Act Committee, 2 Oct 2017, item 5Open the meeting
Named13 Sep 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Confidential minutes of the meeting held on 12 July 2017.

Subject to an amendment agreed between Councillor Smart and the Cabinet, the chairman was authorised to sign them as a correct record.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 13 Sep 2017, item 37Open the meeting
Named4 Sep 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Survey.

The Committee considered the report of the Monitoring Officer and Councillor Smart on the Maternity Survey which had been sent to all mothers who registered births across East Sussex in 2016. Members were invited to endorse the methodology and subsequently endorse that the outcome of the survey be received and debated by the Committee at the Scrutiny Committee meeting in December.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2017, item 6Open the meeting
Named4 Sep 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee

Maternity Survey.

·          Commending Councillor Smart and the Monitoring Officer for conducting the survey.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2017, item 6Open the meeting
Said29 Aug 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee

St Andrews Church, Blackwater Road. Application ID: 170156.

Councillor Smart, Ward Councillor, addressed the committee in objection stating that the scheme was a gross over development. He also expressed concerns about the validity of the parking survey.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee, 29 Aug 2017, item 36Open the meeting
Asked12 Jul 2017Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet

Corporate performance 2016-17.

14.1 Councillor Smart asked questions about the abortive costs of the Downland farms sales and profiling of the Hampden Park retail park acquisition in the capital programme.   14.2 Cabinet considered the report of the deputy chief executive and director of regeneration and planning reviewing the council’s performance against corporate plan priority indicators and action targets; financial performance of general fund revenue expenditure, housing revenue account and capital programme; and treasury management activities, for the fourth quarter of 2016/17 and also the position at year end, against the targets set for the full year.   14.3 Appendix 1 gave detailed information on non-financial performance including details of the devolved ward budget spend for the year. Members highlighted the significant reduction in reported incidents of fly tipping and both catering and the events programme showing income above target.   14.4 The final outturn for service expenditure for the year 2016/17 was £15.1m. The table at appendix 2 of the report showed the council‘s financial outturn as compared with the agreed budget at service level.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, 12 Jul 2017, item 14Open the meeting
Moved16 Nov 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Implementation of EU Referendum Result.

The following motion was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Ballard:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 16 Nov 2016, item 49Open the meeting
Moved4 Oct 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group

Minutes of the meeting held on 23 August 2016.

An amendment to the minutes of the meeting held on 23 August 2016 relating to application 160894, Western View Café was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Belsey .
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group, 4 Oct 2016, item 23Open the meeting
Declared4 Oct 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group

Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary Interests (DPIs) by members as required under Section 31 of the Localism Act and of other interests as required by the Code of Conduct.

Councillor Smart declared a personal interest in application 161055, Rompa Pavillion as a member of ROMPA and remained in the room but did not take part in the discussion.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group, 4 Oct 2016, item 25Open the meeting
Moved20 Jul 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Memorial Benches.

The following motion was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Taylor:
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 20 Jul 2016, item 30Open the meeting
Said9 Mar 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Urgent items of business.

Councillor Smart requested that an item relating to the budget process be added to the agenda and this was agreed by the Committee. The item was placed at the end of the agenda.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Mar 2016, item 24Open the meeting
Moved9 Mar 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Planning Report 2015/16.

It was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Sabri that BDO report back to the Committee relating to the impact on their audit if the materiality level was set at £1 million. This was agreed unanimously by the Committee. [name removed] stated that the official report would be considered at the September 2016 meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Mar 2016, item 25Open the meeting
Said9 Mar 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Budget Process.

Councillor Smart commented on the role of the Audit and Governance Committee in terms of scrutinising and monitoring the budget process. The Financial Services Manager advised that she would be circulating the Committee’s terms of reference and responsibilities, set out in the Council’s constitution, in addition to guidance from the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) and slides from a previous member training session.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Mar 2016, item 28Open the meeting
Moved9 Mar 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Budget Process.

Councillor Smart proposed that it be confirmed that the independent scrutiny and examination of the council’s budget process, procedures and practices fall within the terms of reference of the Audit and Governance Committee. The Senior Head of Corporate Development and Governance advised it was not within the Committee’s remit to determine the content of its constitutional responsibilities.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Mar 2016, item 28Open the meeting
Named9 Mar 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Budget Process.

Given the different interpretations of the committee’s terms of reference, it was agreed that the matter be discussed further between the Chairman and Councillor Smart outside of the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Mar 2016, item 28Open the meeting
Moved2 Dec 2015Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Urgent Items of Business.

A request to add an urgent item of business to the agenda was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Taylor. The proposal was lost by 4 votes to 3, on the Chairman’s casting vote, on the grounds that the item did not meet the criteria of requiring an urgent decision.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 2 Dec 2015, item 17Open the meeting
Moved18 Nov 2015Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Scrutiny annual programme 2015/16.

This matter was reported and moved by Councillor Smart on behalf of the Scrutiny Committee and seconded by Councillor Ungar.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2015, item 38Open the meeting
Said18 Nov 2015Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Scrutiny annual programme 2015/16.

Councillor Smart highlighted the proposed reviews on safer policing to commence with a presentation by the District Commander at the December meeting and the Towner on its performance and future funding which was scheduled for June 2016. It was noted that a presentation from the Highways Agency on progress of the A27 improvements east of Lewes would now take place on a date to be confirmed in February 2016.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2015, item 38Open the meeting
Moved18 Nov 2015Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council

Motion - Reduce the rate of VAT on tourism to 5%.

An amendment proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor Di Cara that the first use of the word “tourism” be replaced with the word “accommodation” was lost by 17 votes to 9.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council, 18 Nov 2015, item 41Open the meeting
Moved23 Sep 2015Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee

Minutes of the meeting held on 24 June 2015.

An amendment to the minutes of the meeting held on 24 June 2015 relating to the draft Annual Accounts 2014/15 was proposed by Councillor Smart and seconded by Councillor di Cara.
From the council's minutes: Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee, 23 Sep 2015, item 8Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Smart attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCouncil Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2026/27Lost7 for, 16 against
25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCommunity Governance ReviewCarriedUnanimous
25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilTreasury Management Report - Quarter 2 (Mid-Year Review)Carried15 for, 7 against, 1 abstained
25 Feb 2026Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCalendar of Meetings 2026/27CarriedUnanimous
17 Sep 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - Grass CuttingCarried19 for, 5 against
17 Sep 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCommunity Governance ReviewCarried6 for, 19 against, 1 abstained
17 Sep 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - Addressing Women’s Rights and Violence Against Women and GirlsCarriedUnanimous
5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilPetition - Sovereign CentreCarried18 for, 0 against, 7 abstained
5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCouncil Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2025/26Lost8 for, 17 against
5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCouncil Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2025/26Carried17 for, 8 against
5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilApproval of Licensing Fees 2025/2026Carried19 for, 0 against, 3 abstained
5 Mar 2025Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - No confidence in the CabinetLost8 for, 17 against
25 Sep 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - Securing the Future of Airbourne for Eastbourne's Economy and CommunityCarriedUnanimous
18 Sep 2024Eastbourne Borough Council CabinetStability and Growth ProgrammeCarriedUnanimous
28 Feb 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - Gaza ConflictCarried17 for, 0 against, 7 abstained
28 Feb 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - To support the youth voice in EastbourneCarried7 for, 17 against
28 Feb 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCouncil Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2024/25Carried17 for, 7 against
28 Feb 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCouncil Budget and Setting of the Council Tax for 2024/25Carried17 for, 7 against, 0 abstained
13 Dec 2023Eastbourne Borough Council CabinetEastbourne Carbon Neutral 2030: Annual ReportCarriedUnanimous
15 Nov 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - Holocaust Memorial DayCarriedUnanimous
15 Nov 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - BylawsCarried23 for, 2 against, 2 abstained
15 Nov 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - Local PlanCarried8 for, 19 against
15 Nov 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion - Housing and Homelessness ChallengeCarriedUnanimous
26 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion on Highways DisrepairCarriedUnanimous
26 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion on Highways DisrepairCarriedUnanimous
11 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory GroupAppointment of Deputy ChairCarried2 for, 0 against, 2 abstained
10 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny CommitteeSovereign Centre ArrangementsLost3 for, 5 against
24 May 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilAppointment of Deputy Mayor.Carried19 for, 0 against, 6 abstained
27 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee2 Denton Road. ID 220626Carried4 for, 2 against, 0 abstained
22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilEastbourne Local Plan - Protecting our Green and Leisure Spaces.Carried7 for, 13 against, 2 abstained
22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilEastbourne Local Plan - Protecting our Green and Leisure Spaces.Carried14 for, 0 against, 8 abstained
22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilScrutiny of Gatwick Airport's Carbon Neutral Accreditation (response to Council Motion)Carried12 for, 8 against, 2 abstained
22 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMembers' Allowances Scheme - Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel (IRP) RevisitCarried6 for, 12 against, 4 abstained
6 Feb 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny CommitteeUpdate on Scrutiny of Gatwick Airport Ltd (Carbon Neutral Accreditation/Northern Runway development) - verbal updateCarried5 for, 2 against
5 Dec 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny CommitteeCouncil tax and business rate base 2023/24CarriedUnanimous
13 Jul 2022Eastbourne Borough Council CabinetCost of Living CrisisCarriedUnanimous
11 Jul 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny CommitteeElection of a ChairCarriedUnanimous
23 Feb 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilLocal Council Tax Reduction Scheme.CarriedUnanimous
23 Feb 2022Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilAppointment of External Auditor.CarriedUnanimous
24 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilLocal Council Tax Reduction SchemeCarriedUnanimous
24 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilApproval of Licensing Fees and Charges 2021-22CarriedUnanimous
24 Feb 2021Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion 1 - Use of Emergency Accommodation in EastbourneCarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilDesignation of Monitoring OfficerCarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilProposal for a Joint Staff Advisory Committee and Joint Appointments and Appeals CommitteeCarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilConservation Area Advisory Group (CAAG) - Proposed changes to Terms of Reference and StatusCarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMembers Allowance Scheme - Independent Remuneration Panel ReportCarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCompletion of Winter Garden RedevelopmentCarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilTreasury Management Annual Report 2019/20Carried15 for, 9 against, 1 abstained
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion 1 - NHS Walk in CentreCarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion 2 - Government Planning White Paper 'Planning for the Future'Carried9 for, 16 against, 1 abstained
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion 2 - Government Planning White Paper 'Planning for the Future'Carried17 for, 0 against, 10 abstained
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion 3 - Carers' RightsCarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion 4 - Council MeetingsCarried24 for, 1 against, 1 abstained
18 Nov 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilMotion 5 - Financial processesCarried17 for, 1 against, 9 abstained
10 Jul 2019Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCarbon NeutralCarriedUnanimous
16 Nov 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilSovereign ward: Resignation of Councillor Ray Blakebrough.CarriedUnanimous
9 Mar 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance CommitteePlanning Report 2015/16.CarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2015Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilBoundary review.CarriedUnanimous
18 Nov 2015Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilBoundary review.CarriedUnanimous
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Smart was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Eastbourne Borough Council Full Council
44 of 48
Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee
40 of 40
Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group
18 of 31
Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet
29 of 29
Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group
36 of 38
Eastbourne Borough Council General Licensing Committee
6 of 9
Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance Committee
6 of 6
Eastbourne Borough Council Licensing Act Committee
4 of 6
Eastbourne Borough Council Annual Council
5 of 5
Eastbourne Borough Council Planning Committee
4 of 4
Eastbourne Borough Council - South East Environmental Services Ltd (SEESL) Board
3 of 3
Eastbourne Borough Council Licensing Act Sub-Committee
1 of 2
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 8 of 13 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Smart declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

DateWhereWhat the minutes sayWhat happened
5 Mar 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, item 21Item 17 – Declarations of interest Councillor Smart declared a non-pecuniary interest, having an in-depth knowledge of the building being considered, as his son-in-law was working at Bedes School,  ...  view the full minutes text for item 21.
9 Jan 2024Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory Group, item 17Councillor Smart declared a non-pecuniary interest, having an in-depth knowledge of the building being considered, as his son-in-law worked at Bedes School, the previous owners.
10 Jul 2023Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny Committee, item 2Councillor Smart declared he was substituting for Councillor Lamb.
16 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, item 10Councillors Tutt and Dow and visiting member Councillor Smart declared a personal, non prejudicial interest in agenda item 13 (Improving recycling – public consultation) as members of the South East Environmental Services Ltd (SEESL) Board. They remained on the remote meeting whilst the item was considered.Stayed and took part
16 Sep 2020Eastbourne Borough Council Cabinet, item 17Councillors Tutt and Dow and visiting member Councillor Smart declared a personal, non prejudicial interest for this item. They remained on the remote meeting whilst the item was considered.Stayed and took part
9 Jan 2018Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group, item 34Councillor Smart declared an interest in item 6, Meads House, 26 Denton Road, as he felt he had predetermined his decision on this item.
4 Oct 2016Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory Group, item 25Councillor Smart declared a personal interest in application 161055, Rompa Pavillion as a member of ROMPA and remained in the room but did not take part in the discussion.Took no part
Hover a line for the full wording.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Smart sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
Eastbourne Borough Council Full CouncilCommittee MemberMay 20154818 Nov 2026
Eastbourne Borough Council Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20154014 Dec 2026
Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Advisory GroupCommittee MemberMar 2022315 Jan 2027
Eastbourne Borough Council CabinetOther MemberJun 20202916 Dec 2026
Eastbourne Borough Council Conservation Area Advisory GroupCommittee MemberJun 201538
Eastbourne Borough Council General Licensing CommitteeCommittee MemberOct 20159
Eastbourne Borough Council Audit and Governance CommitteeOther MemberJun 20156
Eastbourne Borough Council Licensing Act CommitteeCommittee MemberOct 20156
Eastbourne Borough Council Annual CouncilCommittee MemberMay 20155
Eastbourne Borough Council Planning CommitteeOther MemberAug 20204
Eastbourne Borough Council - South East Environmental Services Ltd (SEESL) BoardCommittee MemberMay 20223
Eastbourne Borough Council Licensing Act Sub-CommitteeCommittee MemberJul 20172
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies