Petitions
Councillor Rathbone submitted a petition on behalf of residents calling for improved pedestrian safety measures on Manor Lane between Southbrook Road and the South Circular, including the installation of formal pedestrian crossings.
Every time Lewisham's minutes name Councillor Rathbone, as the council published it.
Councillor Rathbone submitted a petition on behalf of residents calling for improved pedestrian safety measures on Manor Lane between Southbrook Road and the South Circular, including the installation of formal pedestrian crossings.
Supplementary to MQ4 Councillor Rathbone referred to the recent Members' Allowances Scheme and asked whether the Mayor believed council employees should receive the same percentage pay increase that had been applied to members' allowances.
The recommendations were MOVED by Councillor Rathbone, SECONDED by Councillor Wills and it was RESOLVED to approve:
The recommendations were MOVED by Councillor De Ryk, SECONDED by Councillor Rathbone and it was unanimously RESOLVED to approve:
The recommendations were MOVED by Councillor De Ryk, SECONDED by Councillor Rathbone and with Councillor Tam voting against and Councillor Shrivastava abstaining, it was RESOLVED that:
Councillor Rathbone declared an interest in Item 3 “Robins Court, Chinbrook Road, London SE12 9QW”. He informed the meeting that, as a Councillor for the ward in question, he had met with some residents who were objecting to the application. The nature of the meeting was to provide advice on the functioning of the planning system and not to express any opinions on the application.
Councillor Rathbone recused himself and left the room for the duration of this item.
The recommendations were MOVED by Councillor De Ryk, SECONDED by Councillor Rathbone and it was RESOLVED to:
On behalf of the PASC, Councillor James Rathbone introduced and summarised comments relating to the Council’s General Fund, and the Housing and Revenue Accounts (HRA) Budget.
that Councillor James Rathbone be Chair and that Councillor John Paschoud be Vice-Chair of the Committee.
Considering that , , Councillor James Rathbone proposed that the Committee should refuse the application.
It was MOVED by Cllr De Ryk, SECONDED by Cllr Rathbone and RESOLVED that the Council be agreed.
The Budget was MOVED by Councillor De Ryk and SECONDED by Councillor Rathbone.
Cllr Rathbone, Chair of the Public Accounts Select Committee, acknowledged that this was not a budget that anybody wanted to pass, having to make additional cuts and savings in addition to those previously budgeted for. He informed the meeting that, as a result of the proposals going through a full and rigorous scrutiny process, some proposals had been withdrawn, including cuts to funding for Lewisham’s participation in the Lewisham Youth Games, and to electoral services. He also acknowledged that the need to make further cuts was not due to mismanagement, rather growing pressures on social care, special educational needs and emergency accommodation.
MOVED by Cllr De Ryk, SECONDED by Cllr Rathbone and RESOLVED that the Council:
Councillor James Rathbone attended the meeting as a guest of the Committee and shared that he had recently participated in appointing formal co-optees to another Council Committee- the Audit and Risk Committee. There were 3 positions, and a formal application process, followed by interviews had led to the ultimate selection of candidates.
Councillor Rathbone presented a petition on behalf of residents in Aislibie Road in Lee, calling upon the Council to clear up dilapidated land at the rear of 334 Lee High Road which was in private ownership but because of neglect was causing a nuisance for residents.
It was MOVED by Councillor De Ryk, SECONDED by Councillor Rathbone and RESOLVED that the Council:
It was MOVED by Councillor De Ryk, SECONDED by Councillor Rathbone and RESOLVED that Council:
Councillor Rathbone, Chair of Public Accounts Select Committee presented a referral containing the feedback of the Select Committees on the proposed Budget reductions.
· Councillor Rathbone declared an interest as an employee of a Lewisham library (although not one of those run directly by the Lewisham library service).
Councillor Rathbone, Chair of Public Accounts Select Committee informed the meeting as follows:
1.1 Resolved : that Councillor James Rathbone be Chair of the Select Committee – and that Councillor Rudi Schmidt be Vice-Chair of the Select Committee.
Council Speaker (1) Councillor Tauseef Anwar Council Deputy Speaker (1) Councillor Hau-Yu Tam Planning Committee (A) (10) Councillor Peter Bernards (Forest Hill (Chair) Councillor Oana Olaru ( Downham ) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Hilary Moore (Grove Park) Councillor Ayesha Lahai-Taylor (Brockley) Councillor Liam Curran (Sydenham) Councillor John Muldoon ( Rushey Green) Councillor Natasha Burgess ( Catford South) Councillor John Paschoud (Perry Vale) Councillor Rudi Schmidt (Evelyn) Councillor James Rathbone (Lee Green) Planning Committee (B) (10) Councillor Jack Lavery (Sydenham) (Chair) Councillor Billy Harding (Forest Hill)(Vice-Chair) Councillor William Cooper (Evelyn) Councillor Sian Eiles (Brockley) Councillor Rachel Onikosi (Bellingham) Councillor Liz Johnston Franklin ( Ladywell ) Councillor Carol Webley-Brown (Crofton Park) Councillor Suzannah Clarke (Grove Park) Councillor Aliya Sheikh (Lewisham Central) Councillor Luke Sorba (Telegraph Hill) Planning Committee (C) (10) Councillor Jacq Paschoud (Bellingham)(Chair) Councillor Aisha Malik-Smith (New Cross Gate (Vice-Chair) Councillor Stephen Penfold (Brockley) Councillor Laura Cunningham ( Ladywell ) Councillor Hau-Yu Tam (Evelyn) Councillor Tauseef Anwar (Crofton Park) Councillor James Royston ( Catford South) Councillor Mark Ingleby (Hither Green) Councillor Sakina Sheikh (Perry Vale) Councillor Rosie Parry (Deptford) Strategic Planning Committee (10) Councillor Suzannah Clarke (Chair) Councillor John Paschoud (Vice-Cha
5.1 Councillor Rathbone introduced the item – noting his thanks to the Panel’s independent members and to councillor colleagues for their work over the year.
5.1 Councillor James Rathbone left the meeting room for the duration of this item.
Councillor James Rathbone, a Lee Green Ward Councillor outlined the history of the proposals since 2019 and expressed support for the latest recommendations Councillor Mark Ingleby, the Mayor’s Cycling Champion, added his support for the recommendations.
Councillor Amanda De Ryk moved that the recommendations be approved and this was seconded by Councillor James Rathbone.
Councillor Rathbone explained that the delay had been as a result of the pandemic and was in line with National Audit Office recommendations and it was then unanimously:
Councillor James Rathbone declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in item 4 as he was on the management team of a community library. Consideration of this item was subsequently deferred
Councillor Rathbone advised the Committee that the application site to be considered at Item 4, on the meeting Agenda was in his Ward.
1.1 Katie Wood, Scrutiny Manager, opened the meeting and requested members of the Committee confirm the appointments of Cllr Juliet Campbell as Committee Chair and Cllr James Rathbone as Committee Vice-Chair.
3.1 Councillor James Rathbone declared a personal interest in item 8 as he was a trustee of an organisation currently in receipt of a grant from the Council’s Main Grants Programme.
Overview & Scrutiny Committee (all 44 non-executive councillors) Councillor Paul Maslin (New Cross) (Chair) Councillor Octavia Holland (Lee Green) (Vice-Chair) Business Panel & O&S (Education) Business Panel (10) Councillor Paul Maslin (New Cross) (Chair) Councillor Octavia Holland (Lee Green) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Peter Bernards (Forest Hill) Councillor Juliet Campbell ( Blackheath ) Councillor Pat Codd (Lewisham Central) Councillor Louise Krupski ( Rushey Green) Councillor John Muldoon ( Rushey Green) Councillor Joan Millbank ( Telegraph Hill) Councillor Luke Sorba (Telegraph Hill) Councillor Susan Wise ( Perry Vale) Public Accounts (6) Councillor Pat Codd (Lewisham Central) (Chair) Councillor Alan Hall ( Bellingham) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Jim Mallory (Lee Green) Councillor Joan Millbank ( Telegraph Hill) Councillor Joani Reid (Lewisham Central) Councillor James Royston ( Catford South) Healthier Communities (6) Councillor John Muldoon ( Rushey Green) (Chair) Councillor Coral Howard ( Downham ) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Sophie Davis ( Forest Hill) Councillor Carl Handley ( Ladywell ) Councillor Samantha Latouche (New Cross) Councillor Lionel Openshaw (Evelyn) Children & Young People (8) Councillor Luke Sorba (Telegraph Hill) (Chair) Councillor Caroline Kalu ( Evelyn) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Colin Elliott ( Grove Park) Councillor Octavia Holland (Lee Green) Councillor Liz Johnston-Franklin ( Ladywell ) Councillor Jack Lavery (Sydenham) Councillor Hilary Moore (Grove Park) C
Council Speaker (1) Councillor Tauseef Anwar ( Crofton Park) Council Deputy Speaker (1) Councillor Pauline Morrison ( Crofton Park) Planning Committee (A) (10) Councillor James Walsh ( Rushey Green) (Chair) Councillor Royston ( Catford South) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Jimi Adefiranye (Brockley) Councillor Liam Curran (Sydenham) Councillor Pat Codd (Lewisham Central) Councillor Sophie Davis ( Forest Hill) Councillor Carl Handley ( Ladywell ) Councillor Octavia Holland (Lee Green) Councillor Luke Sorba (Telegraph Hill) 1 vacancy Planning Committee (B) (10) Councillor Suzannah Clarke (Grove Park) (Chair) Councillor Jacq Paschoud ( Bellingham) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Tauseef Anwar (Crofton Park) Councillor Aisling Gallagher (Lewisham Central) Councillor Liz Johnston-Franklin ( Ladywell ) Councillor Jack Lavery (Sydenham) Councillor Jim Mallory (Lee Green) Councillor John Muldoon ( Rushey Green) Councillor Lionel Openshaw (Evelyn) Councillor Alan Smith ( Catford South) Planning Committee (C) (10) Councillor Olurotimi Ogunbadewa ( Downham ) (Chair) Councillor Stephen Penfold (Brockley) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Peter Bernards (Forest Hill) Councillor Mark Ingleby ( Whitefoot ) Councillor Silvana Kelleher (Evelyn) Councillor Louise Krupski ( Rushey Green) Councillor Hilary Moore (Grove Park) Councillor James Rathbone (Lee Green) Councillor John Paschoud ( Perry Vale) Councillor Joani Reid (Lewisham Central) Strategic Planning Committee (10) Councillor John Paschoud ( Perry Vale) (Chair)
5.2 Councillor Rathbone (Chair of the Audit Panel) addressed the Committee – thanking officers for their support over the past year and recognising the valuable contribution of the Panel’s independent members. He also noted that the Council had been able to meet its primary financial reporting deadlines (in contrast to some comparator authorities) but that the Panel had some concerns about the Council’s core financial systems, which it was challenging and monitoring.
5.6 Councillor Brown and Cllr Rathbone proposed referrals for the Committee to make to the Public Accounts Select Committee. Following discussion with the Committee the referral was agreed and is listed in full below.
Councillor Amanda De Ryk, the Cabinet Member for Finance and Resources, moved that the recommendations be approved and this was seconded by Councillor James Rathbone, Chair of Audit Panel.
3.2 Councillor James Rathbone declared a non-pecuniary interest in items 6 as he was on the management team of Manor House Library and a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 as he was on the management committee of Metro VAL.
Councillor Olurotimi Ogunbadewa (Downham) Councillor Stephen Penfold (Brockley) Councillor Suzannah Clarke (Grove Park) Councillor Mark Ingleby ( Whitefoot ) Councillor Peter Bernards (Forest Hill) Councillor James Rathbone (Lee Green) Councillor Silvana Kelleher (Evelyn) Councillor Louise Krupski ( Rushey Green) Councillor Paul Maslin (New Cross) Councillor Jacq Paschoud (Bellingham) The meeting ended at 8.49pm
Overview & Scrutiny Committee (all 44 non executive councillors) Councillor Bill Brown (Chair) Councillor Sophie Davis(Vice-Chair) Business Panel & O&S (Education) Business Panel (10) Councillor Bill Brown(Chair) Councillor Sophie Davis (Vice-Chair) Councillor Liam Curran Councillor Kim Powell Councillor Juliet Campbell Councillor John Muldoon Councillor Luke Sorba Councillor Peter Bernards Councillor Joan Millbank Councillor Patrick Codd Public Accounts (6) Councillor Patrick Codd (Chair) Councillor Alan Hall (Vice-Chair) Councillor Jim Mallory Councillor Paul Maslin Councillor Joan Millbank Councillor Tauseef Anwar Healthier Communities (6) Councillor John Muldoon (Chair) Councillor Coral Howard (Vice-Chair) Councillor Leo Gibbons Councillor Sue Hordijenko Councillor Kim Powell Councillor Alan Smith Children & Young People (8) Councillor Luke Sorba (Chair) Councillor Caroline Kalu (Vice-Chair) Councillor Liz Johnston-Franklin Councillor Octavia Holland Councillor Colin Elliott Councillor Hilary Moore Councillor Jacq Paschoud Councillor Lionel Openshaw Safer & Stronger Communities (6) Councillor Juliet Campbell(Chair) Councillor James Rathbone (Vice-Chair) Councillor Pauline Morrison Councillor Sakina Sheikh Councillor Jim Mallory Councillor Carl Handley Sustainable Development (6) Councillor Liam Curran (Chair) Councillor Louise Krupski (Vice-Chair) Councillor Jimi Adefiranye Councillor Suzannah Clarke Councillor James Walsh Councillor Eva Stamirowski Housing (6) Councillor
Council Speaker (1) Councillor Tauseef Anwar Council Deputy Speaker (1) Councillor Pauline Morrison Planning Committee (A) (10) Councillor James Walsh ( Rushey Green) (Chair) Councillor Sophie Davis (Forest Hill) (V-Chair) Councillor Jimi Adefiranye (Brockley) Councillor Pauline Morrison (Crofton Park) Councillor Liam Curran (Sydenham) Councillor Carl Handley ( Ladywell ) Councillor Pat Codd (Lewisham Central) Councillor John Paschoud (Perry Vale) Councillor Luke Sorba (Telegraph Hill) Councillor Octavia Holland (Lee Green) Planning Committee (B) (10) Councillor Aisling Gallagher (Lewisham Central) Chair Councillor Alan Smith ( Catford South) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Jim Mallory (Lee Green) Councillor Leo Gibbons (Forest Hill) Councillor Tauseef Anwar (Crofton Park) Councillor Lionel Openshaw (Evelyn) Councillor Hilary Moore (Grove Park) Councillor Liz Johnston-Franklin ( Ladywell ) Councillor John Muldoon ( Rushey Green) Councillor Sakina Sheikh (Perry Vale) Planning Committee (C) (10) Councillor Olurotimi Ogunbadewa ( Downham ) (Chair) Councillor Stephen Penfold (Brockley) (Vice-Chair) Councillor Suzannah Clarke (Grove Park) Councillor Mark Ingleby ( Whitefoot ) Councillor Peter Bernards (Forest Hill) Councillor James Rathbone (Lee Green) Councillor Silvana Kelleher (Evelyn) Councillor Louise Krupski ( Rushey Green) Councillor Paul Maslin (New Cross) Councillor Jacq Paschoud (Bellingham) Strategic Planning Committee (10) Councillor John Paschoud (Chair) Councillor Leo Gibbon
Councillor Rathbone, Vice-Chair of the Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee tabled comments from himself and Cllr Campbell, a copy of which will be included in the agenda documentation. In the discussion that followed, the following key points were raised:
· Councillor Campbell, Committee Chair and Councillor Rathbone, Vice-Chair highlighted their findings from their visit to Glasgow City Council and the excellent work that the council appeared to be doing on embedding equalities.
Cllr Rathbone, on behalf of Cllr Campbell (Safer, Stronger Communities):
2.1 Councillor James Rathbone declared a personal interest in item 4 as he held a voluntary position on the management team of a community library in Lewisham.
Councillor Amanda De Ryk moved that the recommendations be approved and this was seconded by Councillor James Rathbone and it was then unanimously:
9.1 Councillor James Rathbone (Chair of the Council’s Audit Panel) introduced an urgent update from the Panel (a note is appended to the minutes) – the following key points were noted:
2.2 Councillor James Rathbone declared an interest in item 4 as he helped run Manor House Library, one of whose tenants, was a nursery.
2.1 Cllr Rathbone declared interests in item 9 as: a Council nominee to Voluntary Action Lewisham; a Council nominee to Citizens Advice Bureau Ltd;
Councillor Rathbone was elected as Chair of the Panel.
2.2 Councillor Rathbone declared a non-prejudicial interest in relation to item five as the treasurer of Lee Green Lives.
The referral was presented by Councillor James Rathbone, by the Vice-Chair of the Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, who laid out the recommendations made in respect of both Stop and Search and Prevent.
Overview & Scrutiny Committee (all 44 non executive councillors) Councillor Bill Brown (Chair) Councillor Sakina Sheikh (Vice-Chair) Business Panel & O&S (Education) Business Panel (10) Councillor Bill Brown(Chair) Councillor Sakina Sheikh (Vice-Chair) Councillor Liam Curran Councillor Jim Mallory Councillor Juliet Campbell Councillor John Muldoon Councillor Luke Sorba Councillor Peter Bernards Councillor Joan Millbank Councillor Patrick Codd Public Accounts (10) Councillor Jim Mallory (Chair) Councillor Louise Krupski (Vice-chair) Councillor Alan Hall Councillor Mark Ingleby Councillor Paul Maslin Councillor Joan Millbank Councillor James Rathbone Councillor Patrick Codd Councillor Juliet Campbell Councillor Tauseef Anwar Healthier Communities (10) Councillor John Muldoon (Chair) Councillor Coral Howard (Vice-Chair) Councillor Tauseef Anwar Councillor Peter Bernards Councillor Aisling Gallagher Councillor Colin Elliott Councillor Octavia Holland Councillor Olurotimi Ogunbadewa Councillor Jacq Paschoud 1 vacancy Children & Young People (10) Councillor Luke Sorba (Chair) Councillor Caroline Kalu (Vice-Chair) Councillor Liz Johnston-Franklin Councillor Octavia Holland Councillor Coral Howard Councillor Colin Elliott Councillor Hilary Moore Councillor Jacq Paschoud Councillor John Paschoud Councillor Paul Maslin Safer & Stronger Communities (10) Councillor Juliet Campbell(Chair) Councillor James Rathbone (Vice-Chair) Councillor Sophie Davis Councillor Stephen Penfold Councillor
Council Chair (1) Councillor Jacq Paschoud Council Vice-Chair (1) Councillor Tauseef Anwar Planning Committee (A) (10) Councillor James Walsh ( Rushey Green) (Chair) Councillor Tom Copley (Sydenham) (V-Chair) Councillor Jimi Adefiranye (Brockley) Councillor Sophie Davis (Forest Hill) Councillor Liam Curran (Sydenham) Councillor Caroline Kalu (Evelyn) Councillor Jacq Paschoud (Bellingham) Councillor Luke Sorba (Telegraph Hill) Councillor Skip Amrani ( Catford South) Councillor Octavia Holland (Lee Green) Planning Committee (B) (10) Councillor Aisling Gallagher (Lewisham Central) Chair Councillor Alan Smith ( Catford South) (V-Chair) Councillor Jim Mallory (Lee Green) Councillor Leo Gibbons (Forest Hill) Councillor Mark Ingleby ( Whitefoot ) Councillor Sakina Sheikh (Perry Vale) Councillor Suzannah Clarke (Grove Park) Councillor Pauline Morrison (Crofton Park) Councillor Silvana Kelleher (Evelyn) Councillor John Muldoon ( Rushey Green) Planning Committee (C) (10) Councillor Olurotimi Ogunbadewa ( Downham ) (Chair) Councillor Stephen Penfold (Brockley) (Vice-Chair) Councillor John Paschoud (Perry Vale) Councillor Peter Bernards (Forest Hill) Councillor James Rathbone (Lee Green) Councillor Hilary Moore (Grove Park) Councillor Louise Krupski ( Rushey Green) Councillor Paul Maslin (New Cross) Councillor Liz Johnston-Franklin ( Ladywell ) 1 vacancy Strategic Planning Committee (10) Councillor John Paschoud (Chair) Councillor Leo Gibbons (Vice-Chair) Councillor Paul Bell Councillor
Comments from the Safer Stronger Communites Select Committee on the Main Grants Programme Councillor Rathbone, the Chair of the Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee presented this report.
2.4 Councillor James Rathbone declared a personal interest in item 6 and 7 as he was a trustee of Lee Green Lives and a member of Lewisham Citizens Advice Bureau and Voluntary Action Lewisham .
The motion was moved by Councillor Rathbone and seconded by Councillor Moore.
Cllr Rathbone asked for a clarification on why this application was brought to committee as it doesn’t seem to raise any real issues or valid objections.
Councillor Rathbone stated that this might be a bit premature, and that until the contents of the Democracy Review report is out it was unhelpful for Panel Members to have discussions on their Terms of Reference. He said there might be new structures and systems included in the recommendations following the consultation.
Cllr Rathbone raised questions about sound insulation and if Environmental Health officers were satisfied with the original and amended proposal, as well as if we know what is the ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Cllr Rathbone asked for clarification on paragraph 6.33 and whether new units would meet required standard sizes.
Cllr Rathbone added that inclusion of retail was originally part of the development, and any future resident was aware of that.
2.3 Councillor Rathbone declared a personal interest in item 4 “Budget Cuts” and item 6 “Main Grants Programme Consultation Results” as he was a member of Lewisham Citizens Advice Bureau and Voluntary Action Lewisham and he was a member of the Board of Lee Green Lives and Manor House Community Library.
3.2 Mayor Egan thanked Cllr Rathbone for helping to set up the BAME Mental Health Summit, in conjunction with Healthwatch, Lewisham BAME Network and the other officers.
Councillor Rathbone asked whether any new green space would be provided.
Councillor Rathbone noted that No.81 has a similar extension.
Councillor Rathbone asked for clarification regarding permitted development rights relating to HMOs. Suzanne White explained that the conversion of a property to a HMO for 6 people or less would be permitted development.
Councillor Rathbone asked whether members could require an inspection of the property as a condition.
Councillor Rathbone stated that there is historic enforcement action at the property so this issue is pertinent. Planning Lawyer Kheng Chau stated that members can not consider the potential future use of the property.
Councillor Rathbone requested clarification of what was originally proposed. Suzanne White replied that a front rooflight was originally proposed and it was determined that a gable window would be a less harmful alteration.
Action >>>>>> Head of Financial Services Councillor Rathbone asked how much longer the Council would have to rely on reserves, and was told this would depend on several factors, and should be a question for management.
· Councillor Morrison left the room from 8.45pm to 8.50pm during which time Councillor Rathbone chaired the Committee.
Councillor Rathbone (CR), following up from CC’s question, wanted to know how much of the height was due to the pitched roof.
The motion was seconded by Cllr Rathbone.
Councillor Rathbone moved a motion to approve the application.
Members deliberated the proposals and Cllr Rathbone moved a motion to approve the application.
Business Panel & O&S (Education) Business Panel (10) Councillor Bill Brown(Chair) Councillor Juliet Campbell (Vice-Chair) Councillor Liam Curran Councillor Jim Mallory Councillor Pauline Morrison Councillor John Muldoon Councillor Luke Sorba Councillor Susan Wise Councillor Joan Millbank Councillor Alex Feis -Bryce Public Accounts (8) Councillor Jim Mallory (Chair) Councillor Louise Krupski (Vice-chair) Councillor Skip Amrani Councillor Bill Brown Councillor Alan Hall Councillor Mark Ingleby Councillor Paul Maslin Councillor Joan Millbank Healthier Communities (8) Councillor John Muldoon (Chair) Councillor Coral Howard (Vice-Chair) Councillor Peter Bernards Councillor Juliet Campbell Councillor Carl Handley Councillor Octavia Holland Councillor Sue Hordijenko Councillor Sakina Sheikh Children & Young People (9) Councillor Luke Sorba (Chair) Councillor Liz Johnston-Franklin (Vice-Chair) Councillor Andre Bourne Councillor Octavia Holland Councillor Coral Howard Councillor Caroline Kalu Councillor Hilary Moore Councillor Jacq Paschoud Councillor John Paschoud Safer & Stronger Communities (8) Councillor Pauline Morrison (Chair) Councillor James Rathbone (Vice-Chair) Councillor Tauseef Anwar Councillor Sakina Sheikh Councillor Sophie Davis Councillor Colin Elliott Councillor Alex Feis -Bryce Councillor Sue Hordijenko Sustainable Development (8) Councillor Liam Curran (Chair) Councillor Patrick Codd (Vice-Chair) Councillor Obajimi Adefiranye Councillor Suzannah Clarke Councillor Ma
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Rathbone attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Jan 2026 | Council | Treasury Management Outturn and Mid-Year Review 2025/26 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2025 | Council | Lewisham Local Plan - Main Modifications Consultation (Regulation 24 Independent Examination) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Jun 2024 | Planning Committee B | 135 minard road, london, se6 1nn | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Feb 2024 | Council | Council Budget 2024/25 | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 25 May 2022 | Council | Allocation of seats 2022 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Mar 2022 | Council | Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Mar 2022 | Council | Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Feb 2022 | Constitution Working Party | Constitutional Provision for the Awards of Honorary Aldermanic titles | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Feb 2022 | Constitution Working Party | Scrutiny-Executive Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Feb 2022 | Constitution Working Party | Scrutiny-Executive Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jan 2022 | Council | Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 May 2021 | Council | Cabinet Nomination | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 May 2021 | Council | Allocation of Seats 2021 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Mar 2021 | Council | Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jan 2021 | Council | Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jan 2021 | Council | Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Jan 2021 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee | Select Committee work programme | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Feb 2020 | Council | Motion 1 - Skips - Proposed Cllr Penfold Seconded Cllr Maslin | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jan 2020 | Council | Announcements or Communications | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jan 2020 | Council | Motion 1 Unaccompanied Migrant Children, Proposed Cllr Bonavia Seconded Cllr Gallagher | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Apr 2019 | Council | Allocation of seats 2019 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2019 | Council | Motion 1 proposed Cllr Rathbone seconded Cllr Moore | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2019 | Council | Motion 2 proposed Cllr Anwar seconded Cllr Krupski | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2019 | Council | Motion 3 proposed Cllr Walsh seconded Cllr Bernards | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2019 | Council | Motion 4 proposed Cllr Copley seconded Cllr Walsh | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jan 2019 | Council | Motion 1 Proposed Cllr Gallagher Seconded Cllr Feis Bryce | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jan 2019 | Council | Motion 2 Proposed Cllr Gallagher Seconded Cllr Dromey | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Rathbone was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 21 of 29 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Rathbone declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Apr 2025 | Planning Committee B, item 1 | Councillor Rathbone declared an interest in Item 3 “Robins Court, Chinbrook Road, London SE12 9QW”. He informed the meeting that, as a Councillor for the ward in question, he had met with some residents who were objecting to the application. The nature of the meeting was to provide advice on the functioning of the planning system and not to express any opinions on the application. | |
| 1 Dec 2022 | Public Accounts Select Committee, item 2 | · Councillor Rathbone declared an interest as an employee of a Lewisham library (although not one of those run directly by the Lewisham library service). | |
| 21 Sep 2021 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, item 2 | Councillor James Rathbone declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in item 4 as he was on the management team of a community library. Consideration of this item was subsequently deferred | |
| 16 Jun 2021 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, item 3 | 3.1 Councillor James Rathbone declared a personal interest in item 8 as he was a trustee of an organisation currently in receipt of a grant from the Council’s Main Grants Programme. | |
| 9 Sep 2020 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, item 3 | 3.2 Councillor James Rathbone declared a non-pecuniary interest in items 6 as he was on the management team of Manor House Library and a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 as he was on the management committee of Metro VAL. | |
| 9 Oct 2019 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, item 2 | 2.1 Councillor James Rathbone declared a personal interest in item 4 as he held a voluntary position on the management team of a community library in Lewisham. | |
| 12 Sep 2019 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, item 2 | 2.2 Councillor James Rathbone declared an interest in item 4 as he helped run Manor House Library, one of whose tenants, was a nursery. | |
| 16 Jul 2019 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, item 2 | 2.1 Cllr Rathbone declared interests in item 9 as: a Council nominee to Voluntary Action Lewisham; a Council nominee to Citizens Advice Bureau Ltd; | |
| 10 Jul 2019 | Public Accounts Select Committee, item 2 | 2.2 Councillor Rathbone declared a non-prejudicial interest in relation to item five as the treasurer of Lee Green Lives. | |
| 12 Mar 2019 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, item 2 | 2.4 Councillor James Rathbone declared a personal interest in item 6 and 7 as he was a trustee of Lee Green Lives and a member of Lewisham Citizens Advice Bureau and Voluntary Action Lewisham . | |
| 5 Nov 2018 | Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee, item 2 | 2.3 Councillor Rathbone declared a personal interest in item 4 “Budget Cuts” and item 6 “Main Grants Programme Consultation Results” as he was a member of Lewisham Citizens Advice Bureau and Voluntary Action Lewisham and he was a member of the Board of Lee Green Lives and Manor House Community Library. |
Where Councillor Rathbone sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jan 2019 | 33 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Public Accounts Select Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2019 | 19 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2019 | 17 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee B | Committee Member | Jan 2019 | 12 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| Audit and Risk Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2025 | 6 | |
| Housing Select Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 3 | 14 Jan 2027 |
| Safer Stronger Communities Select Committee | Vice-Chair | Feb 2019 | 9 | |
| Standards Committee | Committee Member | May 2022 | 6 | |
| Lee Green Assembly | Committee Member | Feb 2019 | 5 | |
| Audit Panel | Committee Member | Mar 2019 | 5 | |
| Planning Committee A | Committee Member | May 2022 | 4 | |
| Mayor and Cabinet | Committee Member | Feb 2019 | 3 | |
| Constitution Working Party | Committee Member | Feb 2022 | 2 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Business Panel | Committee Member | Feb 2023 | 1 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee (Call-In) | Committee Member | May 2024 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.