45 Thornycroft Road, Liverpool L15 0EN (Picton Ward)
_____ Resolved that the recommendation be approved (Councillor John Prince dissenting).
Every time Liverpool's minutes name Councillor Prince, as the council published it.
_____ Resolved that the recommendation be approved (Councillor John Prince dissenting).
_____ Resolved that the recommendation be approved (Councillor John Prince dissenting).
_____ The Head of Planning advised the Committee that additional representations had been received from Councillor John Prince, Ward Councillor – Yew Tree Ward, advising that he supported the housing plan as this was for houses, as opposed to flats and as long as the drainage work, as mentioned, was carried out.
Councillor Prince, Chair, referred to needing to look at what the City Council can do through changes to its vehicle fleet and promotion of planting schemes on school boundaries. _____ It was agreed that Helen be thanked for the very informative presentation and the issues highlighted by members of the Committee be noted moving forwards with this initiative.
Councillor Prince, Chair, acknowledged the increased levels of early intervention through the Children’s Centres and associated service delivery.
Councillor Prince acknowledged all of the issues identified and advised that the Committee would be seeking an update report from the CCG and thanked the representatives for their contributions. Agreed that the report be noted / Chair’s comments ………..
Councillor Prince thanked members of the Committee for the quality of debate and contributions throughout the year.
Tribute was paid to Councillor Prince in the role of Chair.
_____ The Interim Head of Planning advised the Committee that – (i) a late representation had been received from Councillor John Prince, Ward Councillor – Yew Tree Ward, objecting to the Application on the basis that – · the consultation had been rather limited in scope, as residents within fifty metres of the development, on Ackers Hall Avenue, had not been included;
Councillor John Prince, Chair, referred to a reliance on temporary exclusions, the ability to use pupil premium to target attendance and not al schools using Welfare Officers. Agreed that the report be noted.
Councillor Prince, Char, endorsed the ongoing wortk and good progress achieved to date.
Councillor Prince, Chair, acknowledged the positive report which show signs of improvement whilst needing to draw out appropriate questions for the next report in line with a review of the main Anti Bullying policy.
Councillor Prince also highlighted priorities and perceptions of bullying, the positive indications from young people, ... view the full minutes text for item 91.
Councillor Prince, Chair, introduced the report, commending the manner in which the Committee has further developed the scrutiny function enabling detailed questioning during the course of the year. Thanks were expressed to Officers, Cabinet Member and Mayoral Lead Member similarly.
Members of the Committee raised the following issues – Ø The need to lobby on the principles of deprivation Ø Whether the formula amendments will affect the floor position of schools – it was advised there would be a phasing in period towards full implementation in 2020 Councillor Prince, Chair, acknowledged the ability of the Core Cities to illustrate the element of deprivation.
Councillor Prince, Chair, commended the good progress at KS1 and KS2, whilst highlighting the gender gap at KS4.
Councillor Prince introduced the report, commenting on the range of issues which the Committee had considered during the course of the year.
The following questions were submitted by the Chair, Councillor Prince, in relation to a published article “ Councillors urged to understand social workers' concerns” – With regard to national interest in Social Worker satisfaction levels what is the average caseload of Children's Services Social Workers in Liverpool City Council (LCC) and a comparison to previous months/years?
Minute No. 64 International Festival of Business 2014 (IFB2014) Evaluation Councillor Prince advised that he had visited St. Vincent’s School for the Visually Impaired as one of those linking to IFB2014.
The work of the data team was acknowledged. Ø Cllr Corbett also asked about the possibility of breaking down IDACI data around white working class and BME links Ø Different reporting requirements in the Academy sector for fixed term exclusions Ø The need for cross learning from schools around Primary attendance figures – it was advised that the Service is seeking to establish networks with schools’ buy-in _____ Cllr Prince highlighted the FAP policy as working well whilst needing to address Year 10 and 11 permanent exclusion levels whilst also considering FSM and ethnic group linkages for factors (this will be looked at). This was an overall excellent report. Agreed that the report be noted and both schools and the LLP be congratulated on the achievement of the figures outlined.
Cllr Prince, Chair, welcomed the very good report acknowledging the response rates. _____ Agreed that the report be noted, welcoming the responses and data provided . To consider a report submitted to inform the Select Committee of the initial findings of the ninth annual Bullying Audit 2014, whilst a full report will be provided once all audit returns are analysed.
· Councillor John Prince stated that most of the responses are given on the night and if not they are answered at the next meeting.
The Committee received updates from Councillor John Prince, Chair of Education and Children’s Services Select Committee, Councillor Hazel Williams, Chair of the Mayoral Select Committee and Councillor Barry Kushner, Chair of the Employment, Enterprise and Skills Select Committee.
Cllr Prince, Chair, welcomed the improvements outlined and it was agreed that the minutes be noted.
Cllr Prince thanked Cllr Hirschfield and the members of the Children’s Centres Review Group for the work carried out. Agreed that the Education and Children’s Services Select Committee notes that – (a) the Review Panel has received clear evidence that fifteen months from the completion of the re-organisation, (October 2012) Children’s Centres have made positive progress. The eight ‘new’ Advisory Boards (formed following the merger of sixteen Centres) are providing strong and effective leadership.
_____ Reason for Urgency The Mayor advised that in respect of Minute No. 242 (b) in relation to ‘School Family Support Service (EDCS/19)’, following consultation, the Chair of the Education & Children’s Services Select Committee (Councillor John Prince) had indicated that in respect of this issue that the Call-In procedure should not apply for the reason to ensure that service provision can be established at the earliest opportunity in accordance with the funding allocation. _____
_____ Cllr Prince, Chair, asked about the representation on the Board from Foster Carers, Regulation 33 visitors and the Select Committee. It was agreed that a Foster Carer representative and Members of the Select Committee be invited to attend and observe meetings, whilst it was noted that Assistant Director Suzanne Metcalfe represents the Regulation 33 visitors.
Cllr Prince, Chair, referred to the Board’s discussion around Care Leavers and the reference to the level of NEET (for Care Leavers) – it was advised that the value of apprenticeships with outcomes will be clarified whilst a focus will be maintained by Cllr Corbett on educational outcomes for Looked After Children through early intervention.
Councillor John Prince - Trans Pennine Trail Councillor Prince advised the Select Committee that he is the nominated Council representative to sit on the Trans Pennine Trail Steering Group.
Councillor Prince gave a verbal update on the work of the Steering Group.
Letter had been issued to all looked after children with a good level of response received. _____ Cllr Corbett and Cllr Prince had attended the recent Who Cares Trust event, being a North West regional conference for children in care, including workshops, and which had also linked up to the Children and Families Bill.
Cllr Prince thanked the Officers for the very informative presentation.
Cllr Prince, Chair, acknowledged the wider potential of on-line admissions and also congratulated the Officers involved. Agreed that the report be noted.
The Mayor advised that the Chair of the Education & Childrens Service Select Committee (Councillor John Prince) had agreed to this course of action in accordance with the procedure outlined in the Constitution and that the call in procedure shall not apply.
(Note: The Chair of the Education & Childrens Services Select Committee (Councillor John Prince) has agreed that this item be dealt with as a matter of urgency on the basis that the decision cannot be reasonably deferred and that the call in procedure shall not apply.) 2. Community ... view the full minutes text for item 161.
An opportunity was provided for Members / Officers to declare a personal or prejudicial interest in any matter on the agenda when the following were declared – (i) Councillor John Prince declared a personal interest in Minute No. Minute No. 94 ( Annual Behaviour and Attendance Report 2010 -11 ) as a Regulation 33 and Recommendation 41 registered visitor ;
Ø Cllr Prince acknowledged the excellent improvements and asked about certain reductions highlighted – it was advised that it is a key requirement for all schools to address any fluctuations in achievement levels particularly in case of any school below the floor target of 35% Ø Cllr Jolly acknowledged the improvements achieved in Liverpool year on year which was commended Ø Cllr Morrison referred to the increased achievement targets anticipated by the Secretary of State for Education through a renovation of GCSE examinations and if there had been any consultation with local authorities – it was advised that there had not been any contact whilst the Liverpool Schools Partnership represented a key approach to maintain the upward trajectory of examination results Cllr Corbett, Cabinet Member, referred to Building Schools for the Future as wrapping buildings around transformational education through devolved funding in a new way not pursued by the Secretary of State with a need to maintain the educational focus on children. Agreed that the information outlined in the report be welcomed and the Director be requested to convey the congratulations of the Committee to all teachers, support staff and pupils.
Cllr Prince confirmed this matter would be included on the work programme for the Select Committee.
Cllr Prince raised the following matters:
An opportunity was provided for Members/Officers to declare a personal or prejudicial interest in any matter on the Agenda when the following were declared – (i) Councillor Richard McLinden declared a personal interest in Minute Nos. 85 (Children's Health - CYPP/ ECM outcomes) by virtue of employment / grandparent of a disabled child, 87 (Question Time) and 88 (New School Admissions & Appeals Code and Consultation on Admission Arrangements for September 2013) as a member of the Liverpool Parent and Carer Forum and Regulation 33 registered visitor / member of the Fostering Panel respectively; (ii) Councillor John Prince declared a personal interest in Minute No. Minute No. 88 (New School Admissions & Appeals Code and Consultation on Admission Arrangements for September 2013) as a Regulation 33 and Recommendation 41 registered visitor ;
Cllr Prince also expressed thanks to all who had taken part in the recent consultation and related campaigns together with the work undertaken by the Officers. Cllrs Till, Brennan, McLinden and Hulme concurred with these comments.
Ø Cllr Dowling referred to vandalism and the need to look at the design of lids Ø Cllr Prince considered that location was an important element Ø Cllr Hanson supported the proposal to identify key locations and identify how to address geographical issues in conjunction with RSLs Ø Cllr Munby advised that it was acceptable for Neighbourhoods to lead on this matter with supplies being at acceptable levels and the issue being who distributes the grit Agreed that Officers be requested to co-ordinate distribution as much as possible with local infrastructure and other provision on a Ward by Ward basis which would allow each Ward to have a provision that is suited to its demographics and also be able manage the resource provided by the Council more effectively utilising partner agencies.
59 relating to the Children's Services Assessment 2010 as a Regulation 33 visitor ; (vii) Councillor John Prince declared a personal interest in Minute No.
(b) Cllr John Prince has requested that the possibility of spending the £29,000 commuted sum within a nearby part of yew Tree Ward be looked at;
________________ Committee and Member Services reported that a number of supporters were present and that Councillor Roger Johnston and Councillor John Prince were present in relation to the matter as Ward Councillors of Yew Tree Ward.
________________ With the permission of the Committee Councillor Roger Johnston and Councillor John Prince addressed the Committee ________________ Resolved that having considered all of the verbal representations and the written representations including those tabled at the meeting the objections be not sustained and the application be approved on the grounds of highway safety.
_____ Committee Services reported that no objectors were present and that Councillor Roger Johnston and Councillor John Prince were present to support the application.
_____ With the permission of the Committee Councillor Roger Johnston and Councillor John Prince addressed the meeting.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Prince attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 Sep 2026 | City Council Meeting | Changes in Committee Membership and Appointments to Outside Bodies | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Sep 2026 | City Council Meeting | Single Transferable Vote by Councillor Steve Radford, seconded by Councillor Billy Lake | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2026 | City Council Annual Meeting | Appointment to Cabinet 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2026 | City Council Annual Meeting | Appointment to Outside Bodies 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2026 | City Council Annual Meeting | Appointment of Co-opted Member to Constitution & Standards Committee and Appointment of Statutory Independent Persons | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2026 | City Council Annual Meeting | Constitutional Changes | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2026 | City Council Annual Meeting | Schedule of Committee Dates for 2026/27 and 2027/28 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2026 | City Council Annual Meeting | Audit Committee Annual Report 2025/26 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2026 | City Council Annual Meeting | Scrutiny Annual Report 2025/26 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 1 Apr 2026 | City Council Extraordinary Meeting | Conferral of Civic Recognition Awards | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 1 Apr 2026 | City Council Extraordinary Meeting | Conferral of Civic Recognition Awards | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 1 Apr 2026 | City Council Meeting | State of Health in Liverpool 2040 Progress Update | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Prince was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 11 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Prince declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Mar 2012 | Education and Children's Services Select Committee 2011/12, item 89 | An opportunity was provided for Members / Officers to declare a personal or prejudicial interest in any matter on the agenda when the following were declared – (i) Councillor John Prince declared a personal interest in Minute No. Minute No. 94 ( Annual Behaviour and Attendance Report 2010 -11 ) as a Regulation 33 and Recommendation 41 registered visitor ; | |
| 12 Jan 2012 | Education and Children's Services Select Committee 2011/12, item 80 | An opportunity was provided for Members/Officers to declare a personal or prejudicial interest in any matter on the Agenda when the following were declared – (i) Councillor Richard McLinden declared a personal interest in Minute Nos. 85 (Children's Health - CYPP/ ECM outcomes) by virtue of employment / grandparent of a disabled child, 87 (Question Time) and 88 (New School Admissions & Appeals Code and Consultation on Admission Arrangements for September 2013) as a member of the Liverpool Parent and Carer Forum and Regulation 33 registered visitor / member of the Fostering Panel respectively; (ii) Councillor John Prince declared a personal interest in Minute No. Minute No. 88 (New School Admissions & Appeals Code and Consultation on Admission Arrangements for September 2013) as a Regulation 33 and Recommendation 41 registered visitor ; | |
| 13 Jan 2011 | Education and Children's Services Select Committee 2010/11, item 49 | 59 relating to the Children's Services Assessment 2010 as a Regulation 33 visitor ; (vii) Councillor John Prince declared a personal interest in Minute No. |
Where Councillor Prince sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Council Meeting | Member | Jul 2008 | 6 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Education, Skills & Employment Scrutiny Committee | Member | Mar 2026 | 4 | |
| City Council Extraordinary Meeting | Member | May 2008 | 3 | |
| City Council Annual Meeting | Member | May 2026 | 1 | |
| Finance & Resources Scrutiny Committee | Member | Jul 2026 | 1 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Mersey Port Health Committee 2019/20 | Member | Jul 2008 | 4 | |
| Liverpool East District Committee | Member | Jun 2008 | 1 | |
| Planning Committee 2010/21 old | Member | Jun 2009 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.