Changes to Planning Committees
The views of Councillor Stamp were supported by Councillor A S Fluker, who proposed that the Council accept the recommendations set out in the report. This proposal was duly seconded.
Every time Maldon's minutes name Councillor Fluker, as the council published it.
The views of Councillor Stamp were supported by Councillor A S Fluker, who proposed that the Council accept the recommendations set out in the report. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker then proposed that Members be provided with a full breakdown of the costs involved, including a breakdown of Officer time, together with details of the process relating to the appointment of the commissioning Officer.
In proposing this, Councillor Fluker questioned whether Officer time had been included within the proposed £26,000 and commented that Members needed to fully understand the process around the appointment. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the Council accept the ‘OR’ recommendation as set out in the report, not to proceed with the purchase of Plot 1 or Plot 2.
In seconding the proposal, Councillor A S Fluker thanked the Planning Policy Manager for her work progressing the Local Plan.
Councillor A S Fluker suggested that the name “Rainer” be considered when naming streets in future developments. In response, the Leader agreed that the suggestion could be considered.
Following this, Councillor A S Fluker requested that the Leader also write to the West Mersea RNLI, which the Leader agreed to do.
Councillor Fluker referred to the legal challenge relating to the County Council elections and LGR. He questioned whether expenditure on the process should have ceased at an earlier stage and sought clarification on continued support for the proposed Mid Essex unitary authority. In response, the Leader stated that the actions taken had been in accordance with the mandate agreed by the Council and would continue unless or until that mandate changed.
Minute No. 5 – 24/00813/FUL Maltings Storage Shed, Station Road, Burnham-on-Crouch, Essex Councillor A S Fluker commented on the third paragraph of this Minute, advising that, in the explanation given by the Officer, specific reference had been made to the application being brought before the Committee due to its impact on the environment. He requested that the Minutes be amended to include reference to this.
In response, and following a brief discussion, it was agreed that the Minutes be approved subject to the paragraph referred to by Councillor Fluker being revised. The revised wording would be brought back to the next meeting of this Committee for consideration.
Councillor A S Fluker declared that the Committee Members knew the applicants for agenda item 5 26/00296/FUL – Land at 1 Imperial Avenue, Mayland, CM36AQ and agenda item 6 - 26/00053/FUL - Land North West of Riversleigh, Nipsells Chase, Mayland because the applicants were Members.
Councillor A S Fluker declared that they owned a property on Keelings road approximately 100 metres from application 25/01022/FULM – Land East of Bridge Wick Lane site.
Councillor A S Fluker declared that in relation to Agenda Item 5 – 24/00813/FUUL Maltings Storage Shed, Station Road, Burnham-on-Crouch, Essex, he owned property opposite the site.
At this point Councillor A S Fluker excused himself from the meeting, left the chamber and did not return.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that Councillor D O Bown be elected as Chairperson of the SE. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor L J Haywood proposed that Councillor A S Fluker be elected as Chairperson of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee (O&S). This proposal was duly seconded.
As there was an equality of votes the Chairperson exercised his casting vote in support of Councillor Fluker.
RESOLVED that Councillor A S Fluker be appointed Chairperson of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year.
Members Councillors: L J Haywood K M H Lagan W Stamp, CC Reform UK (2) Leader Councillor A S Fluker Members Councillor M G Neall It was noted that there were a further four Members of the Council not aligned to a political group.
Member call-in – Councillor A S Fluker – concerns about Settlement Boundaries and the Countryside, Design Quality and the Built Environment and the Housing Mix and how they are addressed in the proposal – Ref Policies LDP 2014/2029 Policies S8, D1 and H2
2026 / 27 Budget and Medium-Term Financial Strategy (Council Tax 2026 / 27) Councillor A S Fluker referred to the first paragraph of this Minute, advising how he had commented that the reserves of the Council belonged to council tax payers and fundamentally achieved by the sale of the Council’s housing stock. He also advised that he had highlighted how only £8,000 of the £2.7m spend had been spent in the Southminster ward. In response the Chairperson advised that the Minutes would be amended to ensure that his first point was included.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to a letter the Council had sent to major developers regarding consultants being appointed to review the Local Development Plan and asking them to bring forward new sites in the District for development. He asked the Leader if he could explain why this information hadn’t been shared with Members and why developers had been asked to place shape the District ahead of Members. In response the Leader commented the Council was using a consultant to help it shape the LDP work and review what work could be used in the new process.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the consultation response from Anglian Water objecting to the proposed development due to insufficient infrastructure in Southminster and queried if this was addressed within the reasons for refusal. He felt that Officers had come to the right decision and then proposed that the application be refused in accordance with Officers’ recommendation. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor Fluker proposed and amendment to his earlier proposal, proposing that the comments raised by Officers in relation to the Latchingdon appeal decision and Anglian Water be included as a reason for refusal.
Councillor A S Fluker raised concerns regarding the budget before Members and the proposal to make investment in capital repairs and renewals, suggesting that in his view investment across the district appeared to be uneven.
Councillor Fluker proposed, contrary to the proposals put forward, that the Council Tax for Maldon District Council be held at the same level as in 2025 / 26 and that to cover the shortfall in the proposed budget £189,000 be taken from the Council’s reserves. This proposal was duly seconded.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded.
The Chairperson then put the proposed amendment in the name of Councillor Fluker and the voting was as follows:
Councillor Fluker also noted that the Committee all knew the applicant for agenda item 7 25/00921/HOUSE - Paton Place, Nipsells Chase, Mayland.
Cllr Fluker has called in the application for the following policy reasons: LDP policy D1 (Design Quality and Built Environment) and E5 (Tourism) The Officer presented the report following this the Agent Tim Matthews addressed the committee.
Councillor A S Fluker then proposed that the application be approved contrary to Officer recommendations. This was Duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker declared that he knew the applicant for 25/00706/OUTM – Land east of Birch road, Tillingham.
Councillor A S Fluker advised that in the interest of openness and transparency that he knew the owner in respect of Agenda Item 6 - 25/00206/OUTM Land West Of Spratts Farm, Queenborough Road, Southminster , Essex and confirmed he was not declaring a pecuniary interest.
Applicant Gladman Developments Ltd, DJ Fisher Farms and L&A Barker Agent N/A Target Decision Date 20.06.2025 (Time Extension requested until 19.12.2025) Case Officer Chris Purvis Parish SOUTHMINSTER Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council Major Development and a Departure from Local Plan Policies ‘Called in’ by Councillor A S Fluker due to concerns about sustainable development, strategic growth, place shaping, the delivery of prosperous rural communities, the existing settlement boundary and the prevailing countryside, the proposed design quality and built environment, Climate Change and the Environmental Impact of the development, the impact on Conservation and Heritage assets, the impact of Agricultural and Rural Diversification and how they are addressed in the proposal – Ref Policies but not limited to S1 6) 11) 12) 13, S2, S3, S7 a) b) c), S8, D1 1) c) d) e) 4) 6) 8) 9), D2 6) 10) 11), D3 1), E4 1) 3) and H4 1) 2) 3) 4) 6) 7)
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the Planning Appeals Protocol that the Council agreed at an earlier part in the meeting and how he had attended a few planning appeals recently where Members had given evidence. He asked the Leader of the Council if Members could be encouraged to attend such appeals to find out how the worked process worked etc. and suggested that further training was required. In response the Leader advised that it might be useful to get the Planning Advisory Service to provide some training to Members.
Councillor A S Fluker had been joint Ward Member with Brian Beale and spoke of him leading the Council’s opposition for many years.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that a pre-commencement condition be added regarding the binding of roads after completion. In response the Principal Planning Officer advised that was included within the suggested conditions.
Business by Reason of Special Circumstances Considered by the Chairperson to be Urgent Councillor A S Fluker commented that during the last meeting it had been questioned why the matter relating to Devolution and Local Government Reorganisation was being brought forward as an urgent item of business as the Council had agreed at a previous meeting that this would be on the agenda for all meetings.
Councillor Fluker advised that the Chairperson had taken this on board at the meeting and therefore requested that this be noted.
Councillor Fluker referred to a comment made at the last meeting regarding the High Sherriff attending an event within the District and how she had sent her good wishes to the Council.
The Chairperson had responded in that meeting advising why there hadn’t been anyone from the Council at that event and Councillor Fluker requested that the good wishes be noted. In response, the Chairperson advised that he had noted the comments and was meeting with the High Sheriff in September.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the application be approved, in accordance with the Officers’ recommendation. This proposal was duly seconded.
Following further discussion, the Chairperson moved the proposal in the name of Councillor Fluker, subject to the amendments detailed in the Members’ Update and additional conditions detailed. Upon a vote being taken this was duly agreed.
Minute 8 – Maldon District Growth Options Councillor A S Fluker queried the resolution in respect of this Minute item as he felt that further testing on Options 3 and 5 with the inclusion of Althorne and Land at Stow Maries had been agreed. In response the Chairperson advised that the sites referred to were included as part of Option 5 and therefore the Minutes would stand as written.
Councillor A S Fluker raised a query regarding publication of the Strategy and Resources Committee minutes from the meeting on 12 June 2025 and proposed that noting of these Minutes be held over to the next Council meeting. Subsequently the Chairperson agreed that any Minutes not published would be brought back to the next Council meeting.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded.
Applicant Ellen & Paul Pearse Agent N/A Target Decision Date 30 June 2025 Case Officer Hayley Sadler Parish BURNHAM SOUTH Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council Councillor / Member of Staff Councillor A S Fluker supported the application and proposed that the Committee accept the Officers recommendation to approve this application. This was duly seconded.
The Chairperson then moved the proposal in the name of Councillor Fluker to approve the application. Upon a vote being taken this was duly agreed.
At that time Councillor A S Fluker was identified as the nominated Member should this application go to appeal.
Members were advised that because Officers were unable to defend some of the reasons for refusal due to a professional conflict of interest confirmation was being sought as to whether Councillor Fluker was still be happy to be the lead Member for the hearing.
Councillor Fluker confirmed that he was happy to be the lead Member for this appeal and sought further clarification regarding the appeal.
The Officer explained that Officers were looking for the nominated Member to defend the decision at appeal with Officer support and had Councillor Fluker not been happy Officers would go out to a planning consultant to defend the appeal.
The Officer asked Councillor A S Fluker, as the nominated Member for the appeal, if she could liaise with him regarding proceedings for the appeal, along with Councillor A Fittock as the other Ward Member.
Councillor Fluker agreed to this, pointing out that Councillor R G Pratt was the other Southminster Ward Member and not Councillor Fittock.
Councillor A S Fluker sought confirmation as to why Agenda Item 7 (Maldon District Five Year Housing Land Supply 2025 / 26) had been withdrawn. In response the Leader explained that the report was withdrawn as it was felt at this time there wouldn’t be consensus in the chamber, and it would go back to the Member Working Group for further consultation with them and Members as a whole.
In response to a question from Councillor Fluker regarding whether the Planning Policy Working Group had agreed recommendation (ii) in Agenda Item 8 – Maldon District Growth Options the Leader advised he would respond to this outside of the meeting.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the application be approved, as per officer’s recommendations.
Following the discussion, the Chairperson put the proposal in the name of Councillor Fluker and upon a vote being taken this was approved.
Committee Non-aligned Member nominated Performance, Governance and Audit Committee Councillors M G Neall and U G C Siddall-Norman Strategy and Resources Committee Councillor A M Lay Licensing Committee Councillors A M Lay and U G C Siddall-Norman Overview and Scrutiny Committee Councillors V J Bell and A M Lay Joint Standards Committee Councillors V J Bell and U G C Siddall-Norman Investigating and Disciplinary Committee Councillor A M Lay Investigating and Disciplinary Panel Councillors M G Neall and U G C Siddall-Norman During the nomination of non-aligned Councillors to the Joint Standards Committee, Councillor A S Fluker was nominated but declined the nomination.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the Planning Policy Working Group (PPWG) advising that traditionally this had been made up of an equal balance of Members from the North and South of the District.
Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in Agenda Item 5 – 24/00886/FUL and 24/00887LBC Cartlodge Outbuilding attached to South West of Barn, Reddings Farm, Reddings Lane, Tillingham , Essex relating to an ad-hoc unsolicited meeting he had attended with a third party connected to the application.
In the interest of openness and transparency Councillor Fluker explained that the application had been discussed at this meeting, no planning officer was present which was contrary to the Members’ Code of Conduct and having taken advice he would leave the meeting following the Officer presentation and any public speakers.
Minute No. 537 – Strategy and Resources Committee – 23 January 2025 In respect of the query raised by Councillor A S Fluker and the written response that Councillor J Driver had advised he would provide, Councillor Fluker advised that he had received a response from Councillor Driver but did not feel this answered all his questions. He requested that the response be sent to all Members and / or amended. In response the Chairperson advised that the Minutes of this meeting would be checked.
Minute No. 574 – Questions to the Leader of the Council in accordance with Procedure Rule 1(3)M In respect of the last question raised by Councillor A S Fluker, Councillor J Driver advised that the meeting of the Committee in question had taken place on 13 February 2025 and on 16 February he had provided as full a response as he could, given that he had not chaired the two meetings in question.
Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in Agenda Item 11 – Polling Places Review as he was a Member of Southminster Parish Council and Agenda Item 14 - Adoption of the EV Charging and Low Emissions Strategy 2025-2028 as he owned an EV.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to an error with the polling notices for Southminster in the last election and asked that for future elections the polling station was shown as Community Hall 1, King George V Playing Field and the situation was monitored with the Clerk at Southminster Parish Council, with regards to availability. In response the Officer advised this was duly noted.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the EV charging points outside of the Council offices which people were not currently charged to use. He proposed an additional recommendation, that Officers consider an upgrade of the EV charging machines to make sure that users had to pay for the electric and that it was fair and reasonable. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed as an amendment to the recommendations.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the Council agree the recommendation set out in the report. The Chairperson then put the recommendation which was duly agreed.
Councillor S J Morgan, Chairperson of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee presented the report and advised that following a referral from Councillor A S Fluker a detailed scrutiny exercise on the corporate project around Land at Heybridge had taken place by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and the report set out the lessons learned and findings. He noted the importance for the Council to view the lessons learned so that it was clear on project deliverables for future endeavours .
Councillor A S Fluker asked the Leader of the Council if he would join him in commending Thurrock Council for reducing its debt from £1.5 billion to £1 billion through disinvestment and the sale of assets. In response the Leader of the Council advised it was not his place to comment on another Local Authority.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded and the voting was as follows:
Councillor A S Fluker provided the Council with information relating to a similar site and then proposed that the recommendation be amended, and the Council also write to the Health Secretary. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed.
Minute No. 507 – Fees and Charges Additional Information: Car Park Charges – Burnham-on-Crouch Councillor A S Fluker referred to a question he had raised at this meeting which he felt should have been Minuted . The Chairperson agreed that the Minutes would be reviewed and requested that the following be added to the Minutes.
Following the Officers’ presentation, Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the recommendation be agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that a report be brought to a meeting of the Council to appoint Members to the proposed PL Partnership Board and that the recommendation set out the report be agreed. This was duly seconded and agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker referred Members to and quoted a guidance note from the Monitoring Officer on Committee processes.
Following lengthy discussion, Councillor Fluker advised he was still uncomfortable and asked the Chairperson to consider deferring the following items of business. This was not considered.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. The Chairperson confirmed that this vote related only to Agenda Item 13 – Funding Request – Council Offices, Princes Road and he would consider Agenda Item 14 separately. A vote was then taken, and the voting was as follows:
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote in relation to recommendation ( i ).
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote in relation to recommendation (ii).
Councillor A S Fluker referred to work of the Car Park Task and Finish Working Group and the proposed policy change to introduce car parking charges in Burnham-on-Crouch. He commented that when the Working Group recommendations were brought forward to Committee Members of the Working Group had not supported the policy or the recommendations leaving the officer presenting the report in a difficult position.
The Leader of the Council thanked Councillor Fluker for his question and provided some further information regarding the debate of this matter at the Committee meeting. If any officer was put in a difficult position he apologised on behalf of Members. He advised that in the future better awareness of the process of reporting from a Working Group to a Committee or the Council was required.
Car Park Charges – Burnham-on-Crouch In response to a query by Councillor A S Fluker regarding consultation with the Doctors surgery, and why Members of the Car Parking Task & Finish and Finance Working Groups had not supported the proposal at the last meeting of the Strategy and Resources Committee, Councillor Driver advised that he would provide a written response.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the Council agree the recommendation and thanked the Interim Chief Finance Officer, commenting that the position was much better than that reported 12 months ago. This proposal was duly seconded and upon a vote being taken was agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in this item of business as he was a harbour commissioner.
Members were reminded that this Committee had originally received a report from the Working Group on this scrutiny item request submitted by Councillor A S Fluker. The request sought review of various issues arising from the extensive history of the corporate project involving the potential acquisition of land by the Council with a view to providing affordable housing and generating a commercial return. It was noted that this corporate project had effectively been closed by Council decision in November 2023.
Councillor A S Fluker declared in relation to Agenda Item 11 – Hythe Quay Dredging Project that he was a Maldon Harbour Commissioner.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the Committee accept the recommendations as set out in the report. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed.
· Councillor A S Fluker proposed Councillor C P Morley.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to a comment made by the Leader of the Council regarding turning land in Burnham-on-Crouch into housing at the last meeting of the Strategy and Resources Committee and asked whether he stood by this. In response the Leader advised that this comment was a response to a separate statement and there was no plan for any such development.
Minute No. 387 – 24/00017/FULM – Glebe Meadow, Adjacent King Georges Field, Station Road, Southminster, Essex Councillor A S Fluker expressed some concern that the Minutes did not fully reflect the points he had raised at this meeting, particularly that the application was contrary to Policy D1 regarding both design (specifically the tapering between existing properties at Vicarage Court and the proposed new properties) and loss of amenity, and contrary to Policy S8 due to the size of the buffer zone, which he commented had reduced.
Councillor Fluker then provided further detail of the points he had raised at the last meeting and he commented that the reasons for refusal should reference Policy S8.
The exact wording was to be agreed with the Chairperson and Councillor Fluker outside of the meeting.
Applicant Benferri Developments Limited Agent JCN Design & Planning Target Decision Date 29.11.24 ( EoT ) Case Officer Lisa Page Parish SOUTHMINSTER Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council Major Application Call in Councillor A S Fluker – Policy D1
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the Committee accept the Officers’ recommendation and approve the application.
Councillor A S Fluker asked the Leader of the Council whether the Council was ... view the full minutes text for item 398.
Applicant Benferri Developments Limited Agent JCN Design & Planning Target Decision Date 29.11.24 ( EoT ) Case Officer Lisa Page Parish SOUTHMINSTER Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council Major Application Call in Councillor A S Fluker – Policy D1 Following the Officer’s presentation, [name removed] an objector, Councillor Harold on behalf of Southminster Parish Council and [name removed] the Agent addressed the Committee.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that if the Committee were minded to approve this application that a further condition be included in perpetuity to safeguard the boundary of the George V playing field. He raised some concerns referencing land ownership, highways issues , loss of amenity, design [1] and policies D1 and S8 of the Local Development Plan (LDP).
Councillor Fluker then proposed that contrary to the Officers’ recommendation and in relation to the above policies D1 and S8 1 that the application should be refused. He advised should the applicant choose not to resolve these issues and proceed to public inquiry he would be happy to address the Planning Inspector as the Ward Member. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed to approve the application in accordance with the Officer’s recommendation, which was duly seconded.
Following a brief discussion where Members aired concerns regarding construction works in respect of Condition 5 (Construction Management) and the impact on the access road to the application site, the Chairperson put the proposal of Councillor Fluker to the Committee which was agreed by assent.
The Committee discussed the proposal of Councillor A S Fluker to start the South Eastern Area Planning Committee meetings at 7:00 pm.
The Chairperson confirmed that a Motion would be presented at the next Council meeting and requested Councillor Fluker to draft and submit the Motion on behalf of the South Eastern Area Planning Committee.
In response to a question from Councillor A S Fluker regarding the recent Leisure Contract extension and report to consider the new Leisure Contract, the Leader of the Council referred to the delay in bringing the report forward, explaining that the new contract would be a 20-year contract and it was important for Members to be involved in the decision-making process. Part of the delay was also to enable involvement of the new Chief Executive who started on Monday 14 October.
Councillor A S Fluker disclosed that in relation to Agenda Item 6b – Motion from Councillor K M H Lagan, he represented the Council on the Maldon Harbour Improvement Commissioners.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the recommendations set out in the report be agreed. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed.
During the debate, Councillor A S Fluker asked that it be minuted that he would not close someone’s business down and they should be consulted with.
In accordance with notice duly given it was noted that Councillor A S Fluker was attending as a substitute for Councillor Haywood.
At this point of the Meeting Councillor A S Fluker entered the Council Chamber.
Councillor A S Fluker then spoke to his request and the reasons behind it given the history of this project. He made particular reference to the nature of the approach to local landowners, the changing ambition of the project, and the involvement of Members throughout, concluding that it should have been closed much earlier.
Councillor A S Fluker declared a non-registrable interest in this item of business as he was a frequent user of the hospital.
Councillor A S Fluker asked the Leader of the Council if he would join him in thanking [name removed] for the enormous amount of work she had put into the Central Area Master Plan and the design code and note the importance of having local officers involved in the LDP review. He continued referring to a recent meeting of the Planning Policy Working Group where Members were asked to agree policy guidelines with regards to gypsy travelers and travelling showman and the potential of where these new site locations would be.
Councillor Fluker asked the Leader if he agreed with him and rather than hold non-decision-making member briefings an update on the Local Plan review was brought to the Council as a matter of urgently and for the benefit of all Members so that they could look at the spatial planning, Healer and the call for sites. In response the Leader of the Council advised that he had requested briefings for all Members of the Council on the Local Plan as it was crucial to ensure that all Members were informed, and this was to be scheduled in an evening within the next month. If after this if Members felt there was the need and a decision was required a report could be brought forward to the Council.
Councillor A S Fluker commented on the application and then proposed that the application be approved as per Officers recommendation. This proposal was duly seconded.
Following some debate, the Chairperson moved the proposal in the name of Councillor Fluker and this was duly agreed.
Applicant [name removed] – Savannah Properties Agent [name removed] - Q Square Group Ltd Target Decision Date 21.08.2024 Case Officer Fiona Bradley Parish MAYLAND Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council Member Call In – Councillor A S Fluker – Policies S1, S3, S7, S8, D1, H1, H2, H4, H5 Departure from the local plan Major Application It was noted that a Members’ Update had been circulated prior to the meeting advising that additional representation had been received from Interested Parties.
Following the Officer’s presentation, in response to a request from Councillor A S Fluker, with the permission of the Chairperson, the Head of Service: Development Management & Building Control read out a statement sent to Members earlier that day in response to an email that had been sent to Members from the Agent, [name removed] on the evening of 23 July. Following this an Objector, [name removed] and the Agent, [name removed] addressed the Committee. The Chairperson then opened the floor for debate.
Councillor Fluker asked the Chairperson if it would be possible for meetings of the Committee to start at 7pm. The Chairperson confirmed this could discussed at the next meeting of the Committee.
Applicant [name removed] - Target Decision Date 03.07.2024 Case Officer Hayley Sadler Parish ASHELDHAM Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council Member Call In – Councillor A S Fluker has called in the application for the following policy reasons: LDP policy D1 (Design Quality and Built Environment) and S1 (Sustainable Development)
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the recommendation as set out in the report be agreed. This was duly agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker requested that his dissent be noted.
Following presentation of the report by the Assistant Director, Councillor A S Fluker referred to the recommendation and proposed that this be a recommendation to the Council.
Councillor Fluker withdrew his earlier proposition at this point.
Councillor A S Fluker agreed with Councillor Stamp, referred to the dramatic drop in the strategic assessment number and how the location of houses was important, especially with regarding to education. He proposed that a confidential report be brought back to the Council, to avoid delays going back through the Working Group and then coming forward to the Council. This proposal was not supported.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to previous Motion he had raised regarding not going ahead with the affordable housing project in Heybridge, how the Motion was being dealt with by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee (O&S) and the time it was taking Officers to prepare a lessons learnt document. He asked the Leader of the Council if he would agree with him and help him get sight of this much needed document. In response the Leader of the Council reminded Members how he did not attend the O&S but was sure that the Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson of the O&S would take responsibility to ensure that items were reported in a timely matter so the Committee could scrutinise how that work took place.
Councillor A S Fluker raised some concern regarding recommendation (iii) particularly monitoring the spend. He proposed that recommendation (iii) be amended, and the Strategy and Resources Committee receive reports on a regular basis to monitor the spend in relation to the costs detailed. This proposal was duly seconded.
The Chairperson then sought clarification from Councillor Fluker on the wording of his earlier proposal.
The Chairperson put recommendations ( i ), (ii) and (iv) to the Council and asked Councillor A S Fluker to clarify his earlier proposal in respect of recommendation (iii).
Councillor Fluker withdrew his earlier proposition and proposed that in respect of recommendation (iii) the Council agree costs of up to £400,000 subject to review once the business case had been agreed by the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (DLUHC). This proposal was not seconded. The Director of Strategy and Resources provided the Council with additional information regarding the £400,000 and confirmed that until such time as the investment plan was approved there would be no expenditure.
The Chairperson moved to recommendation (iii) and in accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded. The Chairperson put the vote and the voting was as follows:
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the recommendations set out in the report be agreed. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that Councillor J Driver be elected as Chairperson of the Strategy and Resources Committee.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote which was duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker commented that the membership of the Board needed to be amended to state Opposition Leaders and he proposed that this change be made. In response the Chairperson clarified that as advised by the Director of Strategy and Resources this had been agreed by the Council earlier.
Councillor A S Fluker advised of an amendment to Appendix 1 of the report, that under the Maldon Harbour Improvement Commissioners reference should be to Blackwater Estuary Siltation Steering Group, not Blackwater Estuary . This was noted.
Minute No. 479 - any other items of business that the chairperson of the committee decides are urgent Councillor A S Fluker proposed the wording of this Minute be amended to include additional context, specifically reference to Steve Wright, a Creeksea resident, being a Radio DJ who had previously attended this Committee and promoted Burnham-on-Crouch.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the application be approved in accordance with the Officer’s recommendation and this was duly seconded.
The Chairperson put the proposal of Councillor Fluker to the Committee and it was agreed.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded.
Council Constitution – Scheme of Delegation – Service Delivery Councillor A S Fluker highlighted point 9 on page 54 of the report pack relating to Officers consulting with Ward Members regarding enforcement cases and he provided some additional information in relation to this.
The Chairperson thanked Councillor Fluker for highlighting this.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the Leader implying that the Council would be moving from the Council Offices and if this was the case that the Corporate Projects Working Group be informed of this and the reasons why. He then referred back to the last Council meeting and the response the Leader had given to comments from the Liberal Demoract Group Leader that Section 106 monies would be used to support local health care.
Councillor Fluker sought clarification that the Leader meant in accordance with the conditions of 106 agreements . In response the Leader explained that it was not known what the future would bring and how this would impact on the location of the Council. He reminded the Council of previous discussions regarding the use of the Council building and the need to ensure it did not get the Council into debt.
Councillor A S Fluker then proposed that the Council accept the recommendations as set out in the report. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed by assent.
Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in this item of business as a frequent user of the phlebotomy services at St. Peter’s hospital.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the Strategy being very robust and proposed that the Committee agree the recommendations as set out in the report. This proposal was duly agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker declared an other registerable interest regarding Agenda Item 5 23/01236/FULM - Land to the South of Keelings Road, Dengie, Essex, as he owned Keelings , the property mentioned in the report.
Councillor Fluker added that he also knew the landowner who was engaged in business with Southminster Parish Council of which he was a Member. Due to this he would address the Committee at the appropriate time after which he would leave the Council Chamber and take no further part in the meeting.
Application Number 23/01236/FULM Location Land to the South of Keelings Road, Dengie, Essex Proposal Erection of a 19 MW Solar PV Array, comprising ground mounted solar PV panels, with co-located 5 MW battery energy storage system (BESS), vehicular access from Keelings Road, internal access tracks, landscaping and associated infrastructure including security fencing, CCTV cameras, and grid connection infrastructure including transformers, substation compound buildings and cabling route to the point of connection Applicant BSR Energy Agent [name removed] – ADAS Planning Target Decision Date 21.03.2024 Case Officer Kathryn Mathews Parish DENGIE Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council A 19MW solar farm is a development of strategic interest as defined in the Council’s Scheme of Delegation Member Call-in by Councillor A S Fluker referencing Policies D1, D2, D3, D4, E1, E4, E5 (3)
On the Corporate Project – Land Acquisition item raised by Councillor Fluker, the Working Group had already received fairly detailed information, but to enable Members to get a more complete understanding of how the project had begun and developed, some further and specific information has been sought from Officers. This would be received at a future meeting of the Working Group.
Councillor A S Fluker stated that all Members present knew one of the applicants in Agenda Items 5. 23/00796/FUL - Land North West of Riversleigh, Nipsells Chase, Mayland and 6. 23/01056/VAR - Paton Place, Nipsells Chase, Mayland as they were a Member of Maldon District Council.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer’s recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor W J Laybourne. Upon a vote being taken there was an equality of votes and the Chairperson used her casting vote to vote against the approval of the application.
The proposal in the name of Councillor Fluker was therefore not agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer’s recommendation, due to the development being compliant with policy D1 of the Local Development Plan. This was seconded by Councillor U C G Siddall-Norman.
The Chairperson then put the proposal in the name of Councillor Fluker to approve the application contrary to the Officer’s recommendation to the Committee and upon a vote being taken this was agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker wanted to pay tribute to Steve Wright who passed away recently and wanted his family and friends to know that the Committee’s thoughts were with them during this difficult time. Radio DJ Steve Wright, who sadly passed recently.
Councillor Fluker expressed that the Committee was thinking of [name removed] family and friends at this difficult time [1] .
Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in this item of business.
Following some debate on the first page of Appendix 1 (page 423 of the agenda pack), Councillor A S Fluker proposed that all the savings listed on this page be agreed. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that saving proposals 4 and 5 not be supported but that the Director of Strategy, Performance and Governance brings back a report to the Council in relation to these proposals. This proposal was duly seconded.
Following further discussion, Councillor Fluker amended his proposal, proposing that this Committee recommended to the Council that all savings be agreed with the exception of proposals 4 and 5. This proposal was duly seconded.
The Chairperson clarified that Councillor Fluker was referring to pages 424 and 425 of the agenda pack and proposing (with the exception of items 4 and 5) approval of all items listed on these pages down to savings proposal number 40.
Councillor Fluker confirmed this was correct. Upon a vote being taken this proposal was duly agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the application be refused, contrary to Officers’ recommendation, under Policy D1 as it had not been demonstrated that the harm the development would cause was outweighed by its benefits in this case. He further clarified that this was particularly in relation to the impact of the proposal on The Crib. This proposal was duly seconded and upon a vote being taken was agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to comments from Officers and his understanding from this that the Council could agree the Officers’ recommendation ... view the full minutes text for item 437.
Councillor A S Fluker paid tribute to all those in the emergency services and healthcare sectors, thanking them for their work and wishing them and their families a happy Christmas. He raised comments on Minute No. 3 - Minutes – 14 September 2023, No. 11 – South Eastern Area Planning Committee Management and No. 21 – Commercial Project Decision.
Councillor Fluker proposed that subject to these he was happy to agree the Minutes of the last meeting.
Councillor Fluker asked that it be recorded he did not support the Minutes for a variety of reasons and was happy to discuss these with the Monitoring Officer.
Councillor A S Fluker commented on the Schedule particularly in relation to pest control and green waste. He proposed that in relation to green bins there not be any increase. This proposal was not seconded.
Councillor Fluker then raised questions in relation to the beach huts and car parking season tickets for the Hythe Quay, Town Centre residents car parking season tickets and Sports pitches. In response the Chairperson reminded Members that the proposed Schedule had come through the Strategy and Resources Committee (S&R) and the Council needed to approve so that Officers could action them.
The Chairperson suggested that with the exception of the points raised by Councillor Fluker that the fees and charges Schedule be approved.
Councillor Fluker suggested that the Chairperson along with the Chairperson of the S&R with the appropriate Director consider responses to his questions.
At this point Councillor A S Fluker requested ... view the full minutes text for item 399.
Councillor A S Fluker asked the Leader of the Council if he would agree with him and pay tribute to [name removed] and [name removed], two Council Officers, who went the extra mile on Friday 8 December 2023 to assist a vulnerable constituent with a safeguarding issue. He asked the Director of Service Delivery to pass on his thanks to those Officers.
Councillor Fluker then referred to policies brought forward by the Leader of the Council and how he felt the emerging savings policies were Officer led initiatives and how excluding investment income the Council’s annual deficits would soon be in excess of £2.5 million. He asked the Leader if he could tell residents, in his capacity of Leader of the Maldon District Independent Group, what his policy was on making savings and whether he had any. In response the Leader advised how he had recently had a meeting with other Group Leaders, including the District Support Group, where they went through the Corporate Plan and identified what their priorities were.
He disputed the annual deficit amount Councillor Fluker referred to. The Leader advised how within the next six months, based on the resident survey an update to the Corporate Plan would be undertaken. He reiterated the importance for Members to have the opportunity to influence the Corporate Plan, ... view the full minutes text for item 406.
Minute No. 246 – South Eastern Area Planning Committee Management Councillor A S Fluker referred to two points of discussion at the meeting when this item was debated which had not been recorded in the Minutes. These related to the number of people present at South Eastern Area Planning Committee meetings and the upload / download speeds and ping latency which he felt were very important in relation to the item being discussed. The Chairperson asked that this be noted.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the ‘Green Waste Bin Service’ item highlighted in Appendix 1 appended to this item on the agenda and particularly reference to ‘and in line with other authorities’ . He expressed concern regarding the proposed change to the Council’s policy and resulting fee increase.
Councillor Fluker then proposed that reference to ‘and in line with other authorities’ in this item be deleted. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker provided the Council with some background information relating to his Motion which included detail of the purpose of the New Homes Bonus when it was set up by the Government and how he felt the Council owed its residents to spend the monies on infrastructure.
Councillor Fluker then presented his Motion (as set out below) and duly seconded by Councillors L J Haywood, M G Neall, W Stamp and J C Stilts. That at its meeting on Thursday 2nd November Council resolves to agree that the New Homes Bonus reserve and the additional monies received through new Business Rate income should not be used to support the General Fund but should instead be used to deliver District wide infrastructure projects for the benefit of all residents and with regards new Business Rate income support for local businesses and commerce.
In summing up at the end of the debate, Councillor Fluker referred to Southminster being in the lowest 20% of council areas with regards to deprivation and referred to [name removed] (government minister) saying that NHB should be used for infrastructure. He noted the comments regarding costs and cuts but felt this was a bigger issue and something the Council should be thinking about. He then put his Motion.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded.
The Chairperson then put the Motion in the name of Councillor Fluker to the Council and the voting was as follows:
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the Leader of the Council having confirmed or reconfirmed the importance of Members treating each other with respect and dignity and the importance of the Nolan principles. He referred to a meeting of the Strategy and Resources Committee (S&R) where the Leader had made comments about some members of the Committee for which he later apologised .
Councillor Fluker asked the Leader if he agreed with him that he was a hypocrite and if he could explain to the Council and residents why he wouldn’t do the right thing by his own words to the Council and resign. In response the Leader informed the Council that at the S&R meeting he made no personal comments regarding any Councillor but had made reference to a political party, his apology had been accepted by the Chairperson of that Committee. At no point had he had an issue with his behaviour and always abided by the Nolan principle.
Councillor A S Fluker declared that he was a Harbour Commissioner.
Councillor A S Fluker requested that his vote against the recommendation be recorded.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the report be recommended to the Council for approval with the exception of the Dengie 100 capital bid which should go back ... view the full minutes text for item 342.
Councillor A S Fluker spoke to the report and then proposed that subject to the removal of items 5 and 28 (as detailed in Appendix 1) all savings be agreed and presented to the Council.
Following the debate Councillor Fluker amended his earlier motion proposing that item 5 be included and advising that item 28 would be subject to legislation. He then proposed that the Section 151 Officer explore all the options as set out in Appendix 1 to the report and come back to this Committee with further information, at which point, if necessary, items could be excluded. This was duly seconded.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor Fluker requested a recorded vote. Before putting the proposal to Members and in response to a query, the Chairperson clarified that the proposal would involve the Finance Working Group and Section 151 Officer continuing to review all savings detailed in Appendix 1 before coming back to this Committee. He then put the proposal to the Committee and the voting was as follows:
Applicant [name removed] Alex Eatough – Plainview Planning Ltd Target Decision Date 10.07.2023 Case Officer Lisa Greenwood Parish MUNDON Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council Member call-in by Councillor A S Fluker, regarding Policies S1, S8 and D1 of the Local Development Plan (LDP).
Councillor A S Fluker proposed to approve the application contrary to the Officer’s recommendation and this was seconded by Councillor W J Laybourne.
Councillor Fluker requested that his and Councillor Laybourne’s vote for the proposal be recorded in the minutes.
Minute No. 269 – Delivery of Section 106 Capital Projects 2024 / 25 Councillor A S Fluker referred to the last paragraph on page 6 of the agenda pack and clarified he was not speaking in respect of all projects, just skateparks and had outlined his reasons for this at the meeting. He asked that this be recorded. The Chairperson advised he recalled that and the Minutes would be amended accordingly.
Councillor Fluker advised that at the time he had responded to the apology given by Councillor R H Siddall, saying it was not sincere and had requested this be recorded in the Minutes, but it was not.
Councillor Fluker referred to the resolution of the Committee detailed in the Minutes (which he felt was correct) and differing information which an Officer had referred to outside of the meeting. In response, the Chairperson requested that this point be reviewed on the recording to make sure the resolution was Minuted as agreed by the Committee on the night.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to Southminster Ward and the number of rural businesses within it. He asked Officers to explore if there was any way the Council could give support to businesses on the marshes that had specific needs.
Councillor Fluker proposed that the recommendation as set out in the report be agreed and suggested that Members refer to Section 42 of the Local Government Act 1988 or the Assistant Director – Service Delivery for further information. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker drew Members’ attention to Agenda Item 11 – Leisure Contract Update and referred to the huge amount of public interest in the Splash Park. He queried why this report was considered to be of a confidential nature or commercially sensitive and highlighted that reports of this nature normally detailed a reason for this which was not apparent for this report. In response, the Interim Chief Finance Officer advised that the report had been excluded due to the commercial sensitivity of the cost information that was linked to one specific provider and the level of detail in the report was not in public domain.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the matter be deferred to the meeting of this Committee on 23 November 2023. This was not seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker raised concern regarding the proposed new S106 Officer post and the need for possible further consultation, the annual costs related to such projects, what other projects the ... view the full minutes text for item 269.
Councillor A S Fluker declared a pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 6 – 23/00670/FUL - 7 High Street, Burnham-on-Crouch, Essex, CM0 8AG, as he owned a freehold property close to the application site and would leave the Chamber at that item.
Councillor A S Fluker returned to the Chamber at 20:38.
Minute No. 156 – Motions from Councillor W Stamp (Motion 09/2023) Councillor A S Fluker referred Motion 2 and raised the following points of accuracy:
Minute No. 157 – Motions from Councillor R H Siddall (Motion 10/2023) Councillor Fluker clarified that in respect of Motion 1 he had said that all Motions should stand deferred to the appropriate Committee as to do otherwise would be anti-democratic.
Minute No. 164 – Provisional Outturn 2022 / 23 Report Presented to the Strategy and Resources Committee on 22 June 2023 Councillor Fluker commented that his pre-amble to his proposal should have be included in the Minutes. He reminded the Council that he had referred to the impact and disruption to residents from the developments in Maldon, Heybridge, Southminster and Burnham-on-Crouch and how the New Homes Bonus should be used to offset that disruption by providing local infrastructure rather than adding to the General Fund.
Councillor Fluker then referred to paragraphs 5 (a proposal he had made) and 8 (confirmation from the Chairperson that his proposal had been seconded) alongside the ‘post meeting note’ added which he challenged.
In response to the discussion Councillor M G Neall confirmed that at the last meeting of the Council he had seconded the proposal in the name of Councillor Fluker in relation to this item of business.
In response to a question from the Chairperson, Councillor Fluker clarified he wished the Minutes to be amended to show that Councillor Neall had seconded his proposal. The Chairperson advised in light of this information that under Rule 22 he would need go back and check before reporting back to the Council once he had clarity on the matter.
Minutes No. 143 – Motions from Councillor A S Fluker (Motion 08/2023) Councillor S J N Morgan referred to his response to a question from Councillor W Stamp regarding a remark he had made in a meeting.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed an amendment that the Assistant Director of Planning accounted for and reported any slippage to the Strategy and Resources Committee, along with an update on costs from the Section 151 Officer. He advised it was important to understand why there was slippage, particularly in light of the importance of this project.
Councillor Fluker further proposed that recommendation (ii) be amended to include a report to the Council. This proposal was duly seconded.
He then put recommendation (ii) advising that if this failed, he would then ask Councillor Fluker to raise his earlier proposition again.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. The voting for recommendation (ii) was as follows:
The Chairperson advised that following a request he had agreed to allow Councillor A S Fluker to raise a matter under this item of business.
Councillor Fluker referred back to reports that Area Planning Committees used to receive on a regular basis regarding appeal decisions. He requested that these reports be reinstated as they were very informative and useful. In response the Chairperson advised he was happy to meet with Officers to discuss this.
At this point, Councillor A S Fluker referred to an application this Committee had previously deferred to the District Planning Committee for consideration and requested more information on this matter. Officers confirmed with Members that they would seek clarity from the Monitoring Officer and provide an update.
Councillor A S Fluker disclosed a non-pecuniary interest for Agenda Item 5 - 22/01005/FUL - Land at Theedhams Farm, David Fisher Way, Southminster, CM0 7BD, in that he was a director of a company which operated nearby and he believed that he knew the land owner.
Robinson - Simpson Hilder Associates Target Decision Date 17.02.2023 EoT to 28.07.2023 Case Officer Jonathan Doe Parish SOUTHMINSTER Reason for Referral to the Committee / Council Call in by Councillor A S Fluker with reference to policies D1 and E3.
Councillor Fluker proposed that the application be approved, in line with the Officers recommendation, and this was duly seconded.
A debate ensued, after which and in accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded and the voting was as follows: For the recommendation:
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the recommendations as set out in the report be agreed. The Chairperson put this to the Committee, and it was duly agreed.
Following further debate, Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the Committee only agree recommendations (iii) and (vi) as set out on the report. This proposal was duly seconded. Upon a vote being taken the Chairperson declared that the Motion was lost.
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote on recommendation (v). The Chairperson put this recommendation to the Committee and the voting was as follows:
Minute No. 50 – Adjournment of the Meeting Councillor Stephens raised and it was duly noted that this Minute should refer to the proposal of Councillor R H Siddall and not Councillor A S Fluker.
Minute No. 47 – Notice of Motions In respect of Motion Three and a question from Councillor A S Fluker as to why this had not been actioned, the Chairperson advised that the Director of Strategy and Resources would be providing Members with a verbal update on Devolution at Agenda Item 7.
Minute No. 52 – Leaders and Composition of Political Groups (continued) Councillor Fluker referred to the last paragraph in this Minute regarding the Leader of the Opposition and questioned why it had not been actioned as the meeting recording indicated it had been agreed by assent. In response the Lead Legal Specialist and Monitoring Officer advised that this had not been a decision of the Council although the Chairperson confirmed that he had declared this at the time. The Lead Legal Specialist and Monitoring Officer clarified that at that time he had provided the Chairperson advice, which he had accepted, according to the Council’s constitution.
Councillor A S Fluker provided some background information to his Motion and presented Motion 1, as set out below, to the Council:
In accordance with Procedure Rule No. 13 (3) Councillor A S Fluker requested a recorded vote. This was duly seconded.
The Chairman then put the Motion in the name of Councillor Fluker to the Council and the voting was as follows:
Councillor Fluker advised that he wished to withdraw this Motion. The withdrawal was supported by the seconder of the Motion.
Councillor A S Fluker raised a Point of Order referring to Procedure Rule 4 stating that all Motions except the one from Councillor Morgan and his own should be referred to the appropriate Committee.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to the excellent work of the LGA on the Council’s Medium-Term Financial Strategy and raised some questions in respect of the recommendations detailed in the report. He then proposed an additional recommendation that in the best interest of value for residents, businesses and customers and the protection of our resident’s cash reserves the Finance Working Group delivers a cost neutral budget for the municipal year 2024 / 25.
At the request of the Chairperson, Councillor Fluker repeated his motion adding in the words ‘endeavor to’. The Chairperson confirmed that this had been seconded and he would now move each recommendation individually.
Councillor Fluker confirmed his proposal, ... view the full minutes text for item 162.
Councillor A S Fluker commented on the report and requested that when Committees were dealing with high impact corporate recommendations that these be recommended to the Council for approval rather than resolved by a Committee. He expressed concern regarding use of the New Homes Bonus (NHB) to support the General Fund and how additional business rate monies should be used to support and attract new businesses to the District.
Councillor Fluker then proposed that no funds from these two reserves be allocated without approval of the S&R.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed to approve the application in accordance with the Officer’s recommendation and this was duly seconded. The Chairperson put the proposal to the committee and this was agreed by assent.
Following a discussion regarding the proposed cost of the annual permit and aligning this with the annual permit charges for the High Street car parks, Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the proposed annual permit at the Council office car park be increased to £625. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that Councillor S White be appointed to the Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Officer Working Group. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed an amendment to recommendation (iii) requesting that the Chairperson of the Committee be included in the consultation. This proposal was duly seconded and agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker advised that the proposal was not within the settlement boundary of Latchingdon and how the Local Development Plan (LDP) directed in such cases development should be confined to ‘urban areas’.
Councillor Fluker proposed that the application be refused, contrary to Officers’ recommendations, as the proposal did not represent sustainable development and the adverse impacts would outweigh the benefits of the scheme contrary to policies S1, S8, D1 and H4 of the LDP and National Planning Policy Framework. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the application be approved in accordance with Officers’ recommendation. This was duly seconded.
It was proposed by Councillor W Stamp and seconded by Councillor A S Fluker that Councillor J C Stilts be elected as Vice-Chairperson of the Maldon District Council for the Municipal Year.
In accordance with Procedure Rule 4, the Chairperson informed the Council of the receipt of three Motions which had been duly proposed by Councillor A S Fluker and seconded by Councillors W Stamp and J C Stilts, as set out on the agenda.
Councillor Fluker read out Motion One (as detailed below) and provided additional background information regarding the Motion.
During the debate that followed Councillor Fluker raised a Point of Order in relation to Procedure Rule 4 clarifying that the Motion was about having an all Member Working Group and not the mechanics of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF).
Councillor Fluker then summarised his Motion and the Chairperson put the Motion to the Council.
Councillor Fluker read out Motion Two (as detailed below) and provided additional background information regarding the Motion.
Councillor A S Fluker raised a further Point of Order relating to Procedure Rule 4 advising that he had submitted a Motion and looked forward to debating it at the July Council meeting.
Councillor J C Stilts nominated Councillor A S Fluker be appointed to the DWG taking the place vacated by Councillor Lagan. This was duly seconded and agreed.
Councillor Fluker proposed that the quorum of Working Groups be changed to refer to a specific number, he suggested three Members.
Having provided some detail regarding budget shortfalls relating to the 2023 / 24 budget, Councillor A S Fluker asked the Leader of the Council why he had voted to support the 2023 / 24 budget and Medium-Term Financial Strategy. He also asked why the Leader had not supported the Motion to the Council in 2022 for an Autumn budget which he felt would have improved the financial position of the Council. In response to the Leader of the Council agreed that future of the Council was important and how the Council still had £5m of reserves.
Councillor D O Bown proposed that Councillor A S Fluker be elected as Chairperson of the South Eastern Area Planning Committee. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor Fluker advised that he wished to stand down and not be considered for the post of Chairperson of this Committee.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that Councillor W Stamp be elected as Vice-Chairperson of the Strategy and Resources Committee. This proposal was duly seconded.
Councillor W Stamp proposed that Councillor A S Fluker be appointed as Chairperson of the Committee for this meeting. There being no other nominations this was agreed by assent.
RESOLVED that Councillor A S Fluker be appointed as Chairperson for the meeting.
Councillors A S Fluker and W Stamp declared a non-pecuniary interest relating to Agenda Item 5 23/00076/FUL - Land North West of Riversleigh, Nipsells Chase, Mayland and Agenda Item 8 23/00266/VAR - Paton Place, Nipsells Chase, Mayland, in that the applicant was a colleague at Maldon District Council and Councillor Fluker suggested that this would apply to the other Committee Members present.
Councillor Fluker also declared that he knew the Agent for Agenda Items 6 23/00079/FUL and 7 23/00080/FUL - Land between 45 Steeple Road and 1 Mill Road, Mayland.
Councillor A S Fluker also spoke regarding the proposed extraordinary Council meeting on 8 June, highlighting the need to communicate with Members and resolve the situation quickly. In response to a comment, Members were advised that meetings between Group Leaders had been informal and it was up to those Leaders to share relevant information with their respective Members.
Councillor A S Fluker expressed concern regarding the report from the Independent Remuneration Panel and drew particular attention to allowances for Vice-Chairmen of the main Committees. He proposed that the Council reverse the Members basic allowance back to where it was to show to the public that the Council was trying to close its budget deficit and not spending money on Members. The Chairman advised that this report was not discussing the Members’ basic allowance and referred to the recommendation on the table, duly seconded.
Councillor A S Fluker queried whether paragraph three on page 10 was incomplete, as he thought Members had agreed his proposal which had been seconded. In response to this query, Officers advised that they were unable to provide clarification until records had been checked. The Chairman advised that the Committee Clerk would look into this matter and report back to the Council at the start of the second session of this meeting at 7pm.
In accordance with Procedure Rule 4, the Chairman informed the Council of the receipt of six Motions which had been duly proposed by Councillor A S Fluker and seconded as set out on the agenda.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to how Motions 3 and 7 had previously been accepted by the Council but he had withdrawn all his Motions at a previous meeting of the Council. He commented on the redaction of the information regarding these Motions on the accompanying papers, a number of enquiries he had received regarding the redactions and how no one from the Council had contacted him in advance of the meeting to discuss his Motions.
Councillor Fluker advised how he had lost all confidence in the administration and the Council and therefore withdrew all his Motions in order that they may be considered by the new administration following the elections in May. He advised this was in accordance with the Rules and was with the agreement of his seconder.
Councillor Fluker raised a Point of Order in relation to Rule 2 and advised he was reporting himself to the Monitoring Officer on the basis of what the Chairman had just said about him.
Councillor A S Fluker asked the Leader of the Council if she was satisfied with the income generated through the Corporate Project Strategy.
The Leader highlighted that the Commercial Strategy which she believed Councillor Fluker was referring to had been discussed by the Finance Working Group and projects sat within the remit of different Working Groups. She advised that the Strategy had recently been refreshed and renewed and referred to a number of private and confidential reports coming forward relating to this on which she could not comment at this stage of the meeting.
Councillor Fluker referring to a proposed Motion to the Council regarding the Local Development Plan and emerging policies and comments made that the HELA (Housing and Economic Land Availability) document was not an emerging policy. He asked the Leader of the Council to explain bearing in mind those comments why the Planning Inspector had concluded that they were. The Leader explained this was a complex issue and she referred to a response provided in ... view the full minutes text for item 680.
Item 8 – 2023 / 24 Budget and Medium-Term Financial Strategy Further to earlier discussions the Chairman invited the Committee Clerk to report on her findings following the earlier query raised by Councillor A S Fluker. The Committee Clerk advised Members that the paragraph in question should be deleted as it did not relate to the Minutes of the Council meeting on 22 February 2023 and had been included in the Minutes in error.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the ... view the full minutes text for item 652.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed that the Monitoring Officer be asked to provide a report regarding this matter. This proposal was duly seconded. The Chairman then put each of the proposals to the Committee but following a separate vote being taken on each they were declared lost.
In response to a Point of Order raised by Councillor A S Fluker, the Chairman confirmed that in accordance with Procedure Rule 4(3) he could hear a Motion or refer to it to a Committee. The Senior Manager – Service Delivery and the Corporate Health and Safety Specialist provided the Council with detailed information regarding assessment of the Council Chamber risk assessment carried out and confirmed that the current approach was in accordance with the Council resolution in February 2022. The total number of persons that could be accommodated in the Council Chamber was noted, however Officers advised that this number should be restricted to 44 in the Member and Officer area and 11 in the public area.
Motion 1a : Councillor A S Fluker advised that this Motion had been dealt with. At this point he referred to how as a new Member he had been invited to different departments to understand what went on behind the scenes and hope that this could be picked up for new Members in May 2023.
Motion 1b: Councillor Fluker referred to the hard work of the Senior Specialist Co- ordinator Housing and his team and then gave some further background information regarding this Motion. He referred to the Housing team being under-resourced and hoped that the Motion would bring forward a review of that department particularly regarding resources.
Councillor Fluker then put his Motion 1b, as set out below, to the Council.
‘That at its meeting on 23rd February 2023 Council declares a ‘Homeless Crisis’ and resolves to agree that at the next meeting of Council the Corporate Leadership Team presents an updated strategy to reduce homelessness in the District.’ Following a question from the Chairman, Councillor Fluker clarified he would consider amending his Motion to not be so prescriptive regarding the need for a report to come before the next Council meeting, following a steer from Officers. The Director of Service Delivery introduced the Lead Specialist Community and Senior Specialist Co- ordinator -Housing to the Council. He reassured Members that Officers were looking at resources through Council decisions and changes to the structure for the housing team.
At this point in the meeting Councillor A S Fluker withdrew all his outstanding Motions.
In response to a Point of Order raised by Councillor A S Fluker the Director of Resources advised that the last report to the Council on the Princes Road project outlined the progress made and advised that the Council would receive further updates as progress became available. He informed Members that there was nothing to update at this time.
Minute 457 – Area Planning Committees Review Councillor Fluker raised a point of accuracy in the sixth paragraph of this Minute, noting that reference to “…a level requirement’ should be ‘legal’. This amendment was noted.
Councillor Fluker queried the information Minuted regarding members’ having a legal requirement and the Monitoring Officer clarified that this was the case, and the Minute was correct.
Minute 2 - Business by Reason of Special Circumstances Considered by the Chairman to be Urgent Councillor A S Fluker drew Members’ attention to the following errors which needed correcting:
The Chairman then called on Councillor A S Fluker to move his alternative budget proposal. The Director of Resources circulated to Members hard copies containing details of the proposed amendment with Officer comments.
Councillor Fluker advised that he wished to make an additional proposal in accordance with Procedure Rule 1(13)(b). He referred to the significant draw down on reserves necessary over the forthcoming year which he felt was unsustainable and highlighted the comments of the Section 151 Officer who cautioned that unless the Council acted sooner its reserves would run out.
Councillor Fluker then provided ... view the full minutes text for item 583.
Councillor A S Fluker referred to Southminster and requested that Officers liaise with the Parish Clerk to ensure that planned roadworks etc. were not due to be carried out on polling day. This was noted.
Target Decision Date 01.03.2023 Parish Mundon Case Officer Lisa Greenwood Reason for Referral to the Committee/ Council Called in by Councillor A S Fluker, with regard to Policy D1.
At this point the Chairman invited Councillor A S Fluker to correct some information that he provided during the earlier session on 26 January 2023.
Councillor Fluker advised that during the discussion on the Maldon Citizen Advice – Funding Request he had referenced a member of staff being paid £60,000, this was incorrect, and he apologised to the Citizens Advice Bureau if it had caused any problems for them. He clarified that he should have said there were 14 part-time members of staff and that on average they are paid £17,000 per annum.
Councillor A S Fluker spoke about the total figure being within the Council’s budget and proposed that the Council’s application to the SEPP be submitted but that the £172,700 within the General Fund be ring-fenced for highways projects.
Councillor Fluker repeated his earlier proposition that the recommendations be agreed and ring-fence the surplus amount for funding future projects. Following further debate, the Chairman moved this proposal which was duly agreed.
Councillor A S Fluker raised a number of concerns regarding the Procurement Exemption and proposed that the matter be referred to the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
The Chairman advised Councillor Fluker that this was not a matter for the Committee but something he could report himself.
Councillor A S Fluker proposed an amendment to the proposal that such payments should be signed off by the Director of Resources / Section 151 Officer or his deputy. This was not supported.
In response to question from Councillor Fluker, Officers provided detail regarding the recruitment process and advertisement of vacancies. Officers agreed to feedback to Human Resources the suggestion to add a note to the Council’s website asking people to contact the Council for any vacancies. The Chairman referred to proactively advertising vacancies on the Council’s website and requested that Officers take this forward as an action from the Committee.
Showing the latest 300 of 982.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Fluker attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 Jul 2024 | Council | Appointment of Chief Executive (Head of Paid Service) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Nov 2023 | Council | Commercial Project Decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Mar 2023 | Council | Project Proposal and Funding Request | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Nov 2022 | Council | Maldon District Local Development Plan Continued | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2022 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | 22/00263/VAR - The Old Clubhouse, The Quay, Burnham-on-Crouch, CM0 8AT | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2022 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | 22/00368/HOUSE- The Moorings, Seaview Parade, St. Lawrence, Essex | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Apr 2022 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | 21/01240/VAR - Paton Place, Nipsells Chase, Mayland, Essex, CM3 6EJ | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Aug 2020 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | 20/00404/FUL - Dengie Hundred Sports Centre, Burnham-on-Crouch | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Jul 2020 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | 20/00345/FUL - Land Adjacent Orchard House, Nipsells Chase, Mayland | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 May 2019 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | FUL/MAL/19/00142 - Land Adjacent 104 Imperial Avenue, Mayland | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Oct 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | FUL/MAL/18/00798 - Rooms 8 & 9, Mayland Industrial Estate, Steeple Road, Mayland | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Sep 2018 | Finance and Corporate Services Committee | Superfast Broadband in Maldon District | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Sep 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | FUL/MAL/18/00796 - Redwood Park, Downhall Road, Bradwell-on-Sea, Essex | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Aug 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | TPO 8/91 - The Orchard, Nipsells Chase, Mayland | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Aug 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | FUL/MAL/18/00787 - Land East of Goldsands Road, Southminster | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Aug 2018 | Appointments Committee | Appointment of Director of Strategy, Performance and Governance and Head of Paid Service | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Aug 2018 | Appointments Committee | Appointment of Director of Strategy, Performance and Governance and Head of Paid Service | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | HOUSE/MAL/18/00448 - 85 Nipsells Close, Mayland | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Jul 2018 | Community Services Committee | South Essex Parking Partnership Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Jul 2018 | Community Services Committee | Air Quality Update and Proposed Declaration of an Air Quality Management Area on Market Hill, Maldon | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Jun 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | HOUSE/MAL/18/00319 - Fiddlers Rest, The Endway, Althorne, Essex, CM3 6DU | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 May 2018 | Community Services Committee | Review of Allocations Policy | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 May 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | OUT/MAL/18/00277 - Land West Of Mill House, Mill End, Bradwell-On-Sea, Essex | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 May 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | FUL/MAL/18/00285 - Casimir 134 Imperial Avenue, Mayland | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 May 2018 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee | FUL/MAL/18/00333 - Springfield Nurseries, Steeple Road, Latchingdon, Essex, CM3 6LD | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 May 2018 | Appointments Committee | Monitoring Officer Appointment | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Fluker was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 29 of 40 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Fluker declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Jul 2026 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee, item 171 | Councillor A S Fluker declared that the Committee Members knew the applicants for agenda item 5 26/00296/FUL – Land at 1 Imperial Avenue, Mayland, CM36AQ and agenda item 6 - 26/00053/FUL - Land North West of Riversleigh, Nipsells Chase, Mayland because the applicants were Members. | |
| 14 Jul 2026 | District Planning Committee, item 149 | Councillor A S Fluker declared that they owned a property on Keelings road approximately 100 metres from application 25/01022/FULM – Land East of Bridge Wick Lane site. | |
| 24 Jun 2026 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee, item 110 | Councillor A S Fluker declared that in relation to Agenda Item 5 – 24/00813/FUUL Maltings Storage Shed, Station Road, Burnham-on-Crouch, Essex, he owned property opposite the site. | |
| 14 Jan 2026 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee, item 439 | Councillor A S Fluker declared that he knew the applicant for 25/00706/OUTM – Land east of Birch road, Tillingham. | |
| 9 Apr 2025 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee, item 651 | Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in Agenda Item 5 – 24/00886/FUL and 24/00887LBC Cartlodge Outbuilding attached to South West of Barn, Reddings Farm, Reddings Lane, Tillingham , Essex relating to an ad-hoc unsolicited meeting he had attended with a third party connected to the application. | |
| 3 Apr 2025 | Council, item 625 | Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in Agenda Item 11 – Polling Places Review as he was a Member of Southminster Parish Council and Agenda Item 14 - Adoption of the EV Charging and Low Emissions Strategy 2025-2028 as he owned an EV. | |
| 13 Feb 2025 | Council, item 546 | Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in this item of business as he was a harbour commissioner. | |
| 23 Jan 2025 | Strategy and Resources Committee, item 504 | Councillor A S Fluker declared in relation to Agenda Item 11 – Hythe Quay Dredging Project that he was a Maldon Harbour Commissioner. | |
| 26 Sep 2024 | Strategy and Resources Committee, item 314 | Councillor A S Fluker disclosed that in relation to Agenda Item 6b – Motion from Councillor K M H Lagan, he represented the Council on the Maldon Harbour Improvement Commissioners. | |
| 12 Sep 2024 | Council, item 277a | Councillor A S Fluker declared a non-registrable interest in this item of business as he was a frequent user of the hospital. | |
| 14 Mar 2024 | Strategy and Resources Committee, item 664 | Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in this item of business as a frequent user of the phlebotomy services at St. Peter’s hospital. | |
| 12 Mar 2024 | District Planning Committee, item 652 | Councillor A S Fluker declared an other registerable interest regarding Agenda Item 5 23/01236/FULM - Land to the South of Keelings Road, Dengie, Essex, as he owned Keelings , the property mentioned in the report. | |
| 1 Feb 2024 | Strategy and Resources Committee, item 463 | Councillor A S Fluker declared an interest in this item of business. | |
| 23 Nov 2023 | Strategy and Resources Committee, item 335 | Councillor A S Fluker declared that he was a Harbour Commissioner. | |
| 20 Sep 2023 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee, item 258 | Councillor A S Fluker declared a pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 6 – 23/00670/FUL - 7 High Street, Burnham-on-Crouch, Essex, CM0 8AG, as he owned a freehold property close to the application site and would leave the Chamber at that item. | |
| 26 Jul 2023 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee, item 180 | Councillor A S Fluker disclosed a non-pecuniary interest for Agenda Item 5 - 22/01005/FUL - Land at Theedhams Farm, David Fisher Way, Southminster, CM0 7BD, in that he was a director of a company which operated nearby and he believed that he knew the land owner. | |
| 25 May 2023 | South Eastern Area Planning Committee, item 35 | Councillor Fluker also declared that he knew the Agent for Agenda Items 6 23/00079/FUL and 7 23/00080/FUL - Land between 45 Steeple Road and 1 Mill Road, Mayland. |
Where Councillor Fluker sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| South Eastern Area Planning Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2015 | 114 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Dec 2015 | 97 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| District Planning Committee | Committee Member | May 2019 | 57 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Strategy and Resources Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2019 | 37 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Statutory Annual Council | Committee Member | May 2016 | 10 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Chairperson | Dec 2015 | 9 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee (meeting as the Crime and Disorder Committee) | Chairperson | Mar 2016 | 4 | |
| Council Constitution | Committee Member | Jul 2026 | 1 | |
| Finance and Corporate Services Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2016 | 30 | |
| Audit Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2015 | 23 | |
| Planning and Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2016 | 21 | |
| Appointments Committee | Deputy | Sep 2017 | 20 | |
| Council Extraordinary - Planning | Committee Member | Nov 2015 | 19 | |
| Community Services Committee | ex-Officio | May 2017 | 18 | |
| Performance, Governance and Audit Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2019 | 16 | |
| COVID-19 Interim Measures Group | Committee Member | Mar 2020 | 8 | |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2017 | 6 | |
| Appointments Board | Committee Member | Nov 2019 | 5 | |
| Joint Standards Committee | Non-elected, non-voting | Jun 2017 | 1 | |
| North Western Area Planning Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2020 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.