Overview & Scrutiny Annual Report 2025/26
Councillor P Bennett, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report and provided an overview.
Every time Malvern Hills's minutes name Councillor Bennett, as the council published it.
Councillor P Bennett, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report and provided an overview.
Councillor P Bennett, raised concerns that the changes would reduce local democratic involvement in planning decisions and undermine the protection of the Malvern Hills National Landscape.
The amendment was seconded by Councillor P Bennett.
The Chairman, Councillor P Bennett, introduced the item.
This will be deferred to the Council Meeting in September 2026, to allow Councillor Bennett to present.
Councillor P Bennett, thanked officers for their work, whilst observing that the plan reflected Government dictated national planning policy priorities rather than local priorities, and expressed concern at the lack of regeneration of existing urban areas and the reuse of vacant buildings, noting that the overall approach appeared largely driven by national targets and developer-led housebuilding.
Councillor P Bennett, sought clarification on the timescales for the draft SPD to be brought back to Council following the consultation period. Ian Macleod, Director of Planning and Infrastructure, confirmed that consultation responses would be reported back prior to adoption.
Councillor P Bennett, paid tribute to all those involved in developing the Strategy and reflected on the events of 2018, when two people experiencing homelessness died in Malvern, expressing appreciation for the work undertaken to help ensure such circumstances would not be repeated.
Councillor P Bennett, asked whether the Malvern Hills National Landscape Partnership had responded to the consultation.
Councillor P Bennett advised the Committee that information and overview on the Food Waste Service, including the services’ rollout later in the year, would be brought to the agenda at future meetings.
Councillor Bennett also advised that the Committee would be kept informed about the development of Church Street.
The Committee were also advised that Councillor Bennett would be in conversation with Vic Allison, Chief Executive, about Malvern Hills District Council (MHDC) events and their advertisement to Councillors to ensure Councillors were aware of all upcoming events.
Councillor Bennett advised that he would like to add the upcoming Food Waste Service to the Work Plan as well as discussing recycling and illegal waste.
Councillor P Bennett, queried, in light of the County Council’s financial position and the potential for a Section 114 notice and delays in collecting council tax, whether any contingency had been considered. Andy Baldwin, explained that any additional costs arising from the County Council’s inability to set a council tax or precept would be borne by the County Council.
Councillor P Bennett, noted that the use of indoor fireworks, particularly flares, should be carefully considered in light of the recent incident in Switzerland, drawing on his 30 years’ experience in the nighttime industry and the risks involved, and suggested that appropriate guidance be provided should such issues arise locally.
Councillor P Bennett, queried how differences in VAT rates, which could affect the viability of building renovations, related to variations in CIL charging, and whether this had been taken into consideration. Hannah Davies, explained that the distinction between greenfield and brownfield sites addressed the matter, as viability assessments for brownfield sites took into account remediation and redevelopment costs, which was why lower rates were applied to these site typologies.
Councillor P Bennett advised that there would be an additional meeting taking place in March to accommodate the Environment Agency to discuss flooding across Malvern.
Councillor P Bennett asked what the assurance was that there would not be an overspend on the theatre project, and that there would not be any changes that would impact the cost.
Councillor Bennett advised the Committee that there would be an additional meeting at the end of March 2026, related to modelling for the River Severn, the River Teme, and an upcoming report from the Surface Water Drainage and Flooding Related Issues Task and Finish Group.
Councillor Bennett asked if, in the meantime, an update on any changes could be provided to the Committee as and when they come in, and that other updates from the County Councillors can also be provided.
Councillor P Bennett arrived at 6.01pm.
Councillor P Bennett, echoed concerns regarding the proposed development at Rushwick , observing that the anticipated strengthening of the train line to improve its commercial viability had not materialised.
Councillor P Bennett, queried whether there were any assurances that LGR would not entirely disrupt delivery of the plan. Ian Macleod, advised that officers were proceeding on the basis of securing the strongest possible position for the South Worcestershire authorities leading into the LGR process and that, if a plan could be progressed within the LGR timeframes addressing the revised housing numbers and providing the greatest possible protection, this would be pursued.
Councillor P Bennett, welcomed the equal weighting given to the three strategic authority footprint options within the proposal and expressed satisfaction that earlier Member concerns on the matter had been taken into account.
Councillor P Bennett, highlighted that there remained no definitive information on which services would transfer to a strategic authority, cautioning that, should some countywide functions ultimately move to that level, the analyses and projections underpinning the various reports produced would be undermined, and expressed concern that decisions were being made in the absence of a full understanding of the eventual governance structure.
Councillor P Bennett, highlighted that there were suggestions that some primates may be being kept in the district under unknown and harmful conditions, and while expressing opposition to the private keeping of primates, noted that implementing the licensing regime could be a sensible interim measure to bring such animals into the open and safeguard their welfare.
Councillor P Bennett, emphasised the importance of addressing air pollution, highlighting it’s tangible impact on health and the critical need for implementing appropriate regulations to safeguard communities.
The recommendation was proposed by Councillor D Clarke, seconded by Councillor P Bennett and unanimously Vote: For 27, Against 0, Abstention 0 RESOLVED that Council:
Councillor P Bennett, in response to questions raised earlier in the meeting regarding noise pollution, advised that complaints regarding aircraft disturbances could be effectively addressed by contacting Gloucestershire Airport’s air traffic control, citing a previous instance where effective action was taken following such a report.
The Committee noted that Councillor Paul Bennett would raise the matter with Worcestershire County Council (WCC).
Councillor P Bennett, proceeded to express relief that under a South Worcestershire option there was a greater likelihood of the South Worcestershire Development Plan being retained, emphasising its significance in safeguarding heritage and preventing uncontrolled development, and confirmed his support for a two unitary option on this basis.
Councillor P Bennett, wished all involved every success with the plan, echoed criticism of the Government’s withdrawal of funding, expressed concern that communities partway through the process were now faced with uncertainty over the completion of their plans, and noted a personal connection to Hanley Castle, with family ties to the village, concluding by thanking those involved in the plan for their work.
Councillor P Bennett, Chair of Overview and Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report and proceeded to provide an overview.
Councillor P Bennett noted that National Parks were facing potential funding cuts and stressed the importance of properly caring for and preserving protected landscapes for the future.
Councillor P Bennett, sought clarification on whether households currently unable to have bins had been considered in the design of the caddies. Ian Edwards, explained that the caddies would be 23 litre kerbside and 7 litre indoor, and food waste vehicles were smaller, enabling access to areas that current collections could not reach, though there would be some areas where the service could not be provided, and if a suitable caddy could not be provided for a household, and they wished to participate in the service, an alternative solution would need to be found.
Councillor P Bennett, expressed concerns at the prospect of Herefordshire being left isolated with a population of 200,000, well below the government’s 500,000 target for new councils, and sought clarity in the coming months on how Worcestershire County Council’s (WCC) debts would be managed and questioned the security of the South Worcestershire Development Plan with a transition to a unitary authority.
Councillor P Bennett, emphasised the importance of considering the deliverability and feasibility of different service provision options when evaluating unitary and strategic ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor P Bennett, spoke in support of two unitary councils for Worcestershire, outlining practical reasons for the preference, including security for the South Worcestershire Development Plan and risks Malvern Hills could face with resource allocation under a single unitary authority.
Councillor P Bennett, questioned the impact of potential devolution on the Plan. Ian Macleod, Director of Planning and Infrastructure, advised assuming the Plan was adopted, the Plan would remain in place with an immediate review, proceeding to highlight the advantage of having an adopted plan in place.
The recommendation was proposed by Councillor D Harrison, seconded by Councillor D Clarke and Vote: For 29, Against 0, Abstention 0 Councillor P Bennett was not present for the proposal or vote.
Councillor P Bennett, spoke in support of bringing forward such decisions to hold people to account and act as a deterrent.
Councillor P Bennett joined the Council Meeting at 6:11pm Councillor N McVey, called for a named vote on the Motion. In accordance with section 21.2 of the Council’s Constitution a vote was taken, and at least one fifth of the members present and entitled to, voted in favour of a named vote.
Vote: For 14, Against 17, Abstention 0 RESOLVED that Councillor P Bennett be appointed as Chairman of Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the remainder of the 2024/25 Civic Year.
Councillor P Bennett, spoke of the importance of ensuring an appropriate member allowance so not to preclude individuals on low income from becoming councillors.
Councillor N McVey, proposed the nomination of Councillor P Bennett to the Malvern Hills Trust, seconded by Councillor N Mills and Vote: For 27, Against 0, Abstention 0 RESOLVED that the Council appoints Councillor P Bennett and Councillor M Victory to the Malvern Hills Trust (MHT).
Councillor P Bennett, called for a named vote on the motion. In accordance with section 21.2 of the Council’s Constitution a vote was taken, and at least one fifth of the members present and entitled to, voted in favour of a named vote.
Councillor D Clarke proposed and Councillor P Bennett seconded and it was Resolved that The Minutes of the meeting held on 09 April 2024 were confirmed as a true and correct record, and signed by the Chairman.
Councillor J Owenson, Councillor D Clarke, Councillor P Bennett, Councillor P J Cumming, Councillor S Rouse, Councillor M Driscoll, Councillor P Whatley, Councillor J Watkins, Councillor M Allen, Councillor C Wile and Councillor T Wells spoke to the report under discussion.
Councillor S Rouse, Councillor P Bennett, Councillor J Watkins, Councillor P Whatley, Councillor J Owenson and Councillor C Wild spoke to the report under discussion.
The recommendations were proposed by Councillor N McVey, seconded by Councillor P Bennett.
Cllr P Bennett arrived at 6.34pm, after the Officer’s presentation and public participation, and was advised by the legal representative that he would not be able to vote on this item.
Cllr P Bennett arrived at 6.11pm prior to the debate on this item Proposals and Recommendations:
Councillor P Bennett left the meeting at 6.30pm prior to this item.
Councillor P Bennett returned to the meeting at 7.07pm prior to this item.
Councillor P Bennett left the meeting at 7.37pm prior to this item.
Councillor J Owenson moved the following Motion, which was seconded by Councillor P Bennett.
Councillor J Raine moved the following Motion, which was seconded by Councillor P Bennett.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bennett attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Sep 2026 | Executive Committee | Confirmation of Minutes | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Sep 2026 | Executive Committee | Revenue and Capital Monitoring | Carried | 9 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 15 Sep 2026 | Executive Committee | Quarterly Performance Report 2026/27 - Quarter 1 | Carried | 9 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 15 Sep 2026 | Executive Committee | Street Naming and Numbering Policy | Carried | 9 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 15 Sep 2026 | Executive Committee | Church Street and Edith Walk Public Realm Improvement Schemes | Carried | 9 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 Jun 2026 | Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Confirmation of Minutes from Previous Meeting | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Jun 2026 | Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Overview & Scrutiny Annual Report 2025/26 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 May 2026 | Council | Election of Chairman of the Council 2026/27 | Carried | 24 for, 0 against, 5 abstained | |
| 12 May 2026 | Council | Election of Vice Chairman of the Council 2026/27 | Carried | 28 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 12 May 2026 | Council | Election of Leader of the Council 2026/27 | Carried | 17 for, 10 against, 2 abstained | |
| 12 May 2026 | Council | Election of Leader of the Council 2026/27 | Lost | 12 for, 13 against, 4 abstained | |
| 12 May 2026 | Council | Election of Deputy Leader of the Council 2026/27 | Carried | 16 for, 9 against, 4 abstained | |
| 12 May 2026 | Council | Election of Deputy Leader of the Council 2026/27 | Lost | 11 for, 13 against, 5 abstained | |
| 12 May 2026 | Council | Appointments to Committees, Sub-Committees and Panels 2026/27 | Carried | 14 for, 8 against, 6 abstained | |
| 12 May 2026 | Council | Appointments to Committees, Sub-Committees and Panels 2026/27 | Carried | 11 for, 8 against, 9 abstained | |
| 24 Mar 2026 | Council | Developer Contributions SPD Approval to Consult | Carried | 22 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 24 Mar 2026 | Council | Addendum to the Private Sector Housing Assistance Policy | Carried | 21 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Feb 2026 | Council | Council Tax & Budget 2026/27 | Carried | 23 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Feb 2026 | Council | Treasury Management & Investment Strategy | Carried | 23 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Jan 2026 | Council | Medium Term Financial Plan (MTFP) 2026/27 - 2028/29 | Carried | 23 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Jan 2026 | Council | Pay Policy Statement | Carried | 23 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Jan 2026 | Council | Statement of Licensing Policy Review | Carried | 23 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Jan 2026 | Council | Community Infrastructure Levy Draft Charging Schedule | Carried | 23 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 6 Jan 2026 | Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Confirmation of Minutes from Previous Meeting | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Dec 2025 | Council | South Worcestershire Development Plan Review Main Modifications Consultation | Carried | 24 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 16 Dec 2025 | Council | Local Development Scheme 2025-2027 | Carried | 26 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Nov 2025 | Council | Confirmation of Minutes of Previous Meeting | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Nov 2025 | Council | Destination Zero Review 2025 | Carried | 25 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Nov 2025 | Council | Removing Barriers to Developing New Affordable Housing - Designated Protected Areas and Shared Ownership Housing | Carried | 24 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 23 Sep 2025 | Council | Confirmation of Minutes of Previous Meeting | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Sep 2025 | Council | Primate Keeper Licensing | Carried | 21 for, 2 against, 4 abstained | |
| 23 Sep 2025 | Council | Statement of Licensing Policy Review | Carried | 27 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 23 Sep 2025 | Council | Air Quality Supplementary Planning Document | Carried | 27 for, 0 against, 0 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Bennett was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 13 of 18 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Bennett declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Bennett in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Bennett sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Sep 2025 | 11 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Southern Area Planning Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 7 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Sep 2025 | 6 | |
| Executive Committee | Guest | Sep 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.