Updated Appointments to Committees
Councillor Chubb was to replace Cabinet Member Councillor Ronan Browne as a substitute member on the Planning Committee.
Every time Melton's minutes name Councillor Browne, as the council published it.
Councillor Chubb was to replace Cabinet Member Councillor Ronan Browne as a substitute member on the Planning Committee.
The report was proposed by Councillor Browne and seconded by Councillor Child.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Browne, delivered his annual presentation to the Scrutiny Committee. During the presentation, he confirmed that as his administrations priorities are finalised then the Forward Plan would be updated.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Ronan Browne, asked how the Council could improve the collection of feedback from actual victims of anti-social behaviour (ASB), noting that recent survey results included responses from individuals who had not experienced ASB directly.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Ronan Browne, thanked the Corporate Policy and Communications Manager for the comprehensive report.
Councillor Browne advised the Committee that robust discussions would take place with each Cabinet Member regarding their respective portfolios and associated risks. He added that Cabinet Members would work openly with Directors to ensure transparency in decision-making and risk management That Cabinet NOTED the contents of the report and provided any observations or actions to the relevant officers accordingly.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Ronan Browne, advised that he had recently attended his first Leicestershire Leaders Group meeting, along with representatives from Leicestershire County Council and the Mayor of Salisbury and having been provided with further information and indicators and he would work constructively with whichever option progressed.
Councillor Browne emphasised the importance of working collaboratively and in a cross-party manner to support and complement the wider local government arrangements across Leicestershire. He acknowledged that additional resources would be required and advised that a report would be brought back to Cabinet once there was greater clarity regarding the proposed arrangements and the support required from the Senior Leadership Team.
Councillor Browne also stressed the importance of supporting staff and colleagues in developing their careers within local government in Leicestershire. He noted that local government reorganisation would have a significant impact on the workforce and confirmed that the Council would do everything possible to ensure a successful transition.
Thank you all.’ Vote of thanks for the retiring Mayor and Consort There was a vote of thanks for the retiring Mayor and Consort proposed by Councillor Browne and seconded by Councillor Holmes.
• Councillor Ronan Browne, Leader and Portfolio Holder for Corporate Leadership and Projects • Councillor Robert Child, Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Corporate Finance, Property and Resources • Councillor Alison Freer, Portfolio Holder for Corporate Governance, Waste and Environmental Services • Councillor Ian Atherton, Portfolio Holder for Customer Services, Communities and Helping People • Councillor Don Pritchett, Portfolio Holder for Planning Policy, Economic Growth and Town Centre • Councillor Simon Lumley, Portfolio Holder for Landlord Services and Social and Private Sector Housing • Councillor Joe Orson, Portfolio Holder for Community Safety, Health and Rural Affairs The Leader made the following speech:
Councillor Browne moved recommendations 2.1 to 2.8 en bloc excluding recommendation 2.3.
(Unanimous) Recommendation 2.3 Councillor Browne proposed recommendation 2.3 and Councillor Child seconded. On being put the vote, there were 26 for the motion, 1 against the motion and 1 abstention.
Councillor Browne proposed the recommendations as set out in the paper for the non-aligned Members en bloc, with the exception of Planning.
Councillor Browne proposed the recommendations in the report and Councillor Child seconded the motion.
(For 25, Against 0, Abstentions 3) At 9:15pm, as the meeting approached 3 hours in duration, in accordance with the Council Procedure Rules, there was a motion to continue the meeting beyond 3 hours by Councillor Browne, seconded by Councillor Child. (For 22, Against 1, Abstentions 5)
Uncontested appointments Councillor Browne proposed the recommendation for uncontested seats and Councillor Glancy seconded the motion.
Minute PL61 – Application 25/00845/FUL As Ward Councillor, Councillor Browne advised that he would be speaking on this application and therefore would leave the meeting for this item.
Minute PL62 – Application 25/00898/FUL Councillor Browne advised that there may be perceived bias for his participation in this application therefore he would leave the meeting for this item.
During the debate, Councillor Browne recognised that this can be a cross party activity and that the Conservative Group fully support the approach taken.
Councillor Browne proposed that the application be approved.
“In response to a question that Councillor Browne submitted as part of member question time (Full Council 12 February), the Portfolio Holder for Economic Growth, Town Centre and Leisure, stated the council has worked with local universities to host events designed to support SMEs in the borough area. Could the Portfolio Holder clarify what universities the council has worked with and what events have taken place or will be taking place as a result of said collaborations?
Minute PL41 – Application 22/00154/FUL - Avahan , Waltham Road, Thorpe Arnold Councillor Ronan Browne advised there could be perceived bias in him taking part in the above application due to his employment being directly involved in property development which involved negotiating on new buildings for children’s homes and therefore he felt it would be inappropriate to take part in the application and advised he would leave the room for this item.
Councillor Browne seconded the motion.
· Councillor Browne commented that the Conservative Group supports the motion.
· Councillor Browne stated that the Conservative Group supported the suggested amendments as they would, in their view, “smarten things up”.
The Leader of the Opposition, Councillor Browne, stated that this is the beginning of a process and that his view was that change is required, as Councils have struggled over the last 20 years. He added that Members needed a say before a decision is taken.
Councillor Browne was not present at the start of the meeting.
Councillor Ronan Browne seconded the motion.
(Councillor Browne entered the meeting at 18:09 following the officer presentation and advised that he had attended the briefing, felt able to take part in the debate and vote on the application.) (Councillor Siggy Atherton here returned to the committee.) (Councillor Allnatt here left the committee and exited the meeting room.)
Councillor Browne declared a personal interest relation to CO35 (Motion on 80th Anniversary of Operation Market Garden). He stated that he would leave the room when the motion is being considered.
At 7:22pm, prior to the consideration of this item, Councillor Browne left the meeting.
Councillor Browne seconded the motion and in doing so congratulated Councillor Glancy on leading the process. He stated that the solution was the best one with the options the Council had faced.
Councillor Browne who, on behalf of Conservative Group, thanked Malise for his years of service. He recalled that he had originally met Malise in 2002 and remembered that Malise took Council through two ... view the full minutes text for item CO15
The following motion was received from Councillor R Browne (Seconded by Councillor S Orson).
Cllr Browne congratulated all the staff particularly in the current climate.
Councillor Browne confirm that he was content to accept the amendment into the substantive motion and therefore the motion became:
Councillor Browne seconded the motion.
Distinguished guests, fellow Councillors, Ladies and Gentlemen,f irstly, may I thank my fellow Councillors and my proposer, Cllr Pip Allnatt and seconder, Cllr Ronan Browne for their support and the trust they have placed in me, for the election of Mayor of the Borough of Melton.
Councillor R Browne proposed Councillor S Atherton be elected Deputy Mayor of the Borough until the Annual Council meeting in 2025.
(For 23, Against 0, Abstentions 3) Councillor Browne questioned why there was no report from the Melton Safer Community Partnership, which was agreed at the Council meeting on 14 December 2023. In response it was confirmed that there was no report due to change in Chair of the Partnership and the report will be presented on 25 July 2024.
Cllr Browne declared a personal and pecuniary interest in item 10, protected characteristics for care leavers, due to his employer working with Leicestershire County Council to provide housing solutions for care leavers in Leicestershire. He is leading this work for his employer and therefore stated that he would not participate in the item.
The Leader congratulated Councillor Browne on becoming the Leader of the Conservative Group and Councillor Child on becoming the Group’s Deputy Leader.
- Ward Member notification for speaking at Planning Committee Recently, the Leader and Councillor Browne moved to suspend a procedure rule within the Constitution to enable Councillor Chris Evans to speak on an application affecting his and Councillor Simon Orson’s ward. The Leader believes in altering the notice period for Ward Members from days to before the commencement of the meeting.
During the debate Councillor Browne stated that the motion had the full support of the Conservative Group.
(Unanimous) At 7:26pm, upon the conclusion of this item, Councillor Browne left the meeting and did not return.
Councillor Ronan Browne declared an interest in relation to 23/01133/TPO, St Thomas A Beckets Church, Church Lane, Frisby-on-the-Wreake. As he had been requesting for the work to be done, he would withdraw from the meeting before the application is considered and therefore, he would not vote.
Councillor Browne proposed the application be refused contrary to Officer recommendations.
This proposal was seconded by Councillor Browne. The Legal Services Manager confirmed that these rules can be suspended. This was put to the vote and the motion was carried unanimously.
(Unanimous) The Mayor moved to a vote on the amendment proposed by Councillor Graham and seconded by Councillor Browne.
(Councillor Browne entered the meeting at 6.06pm during the Officer presentation which meant that he had not heard all the introduction to the item and therefore was not able to take part in the debate nor vote on this application.) (Councillors Allnatt and Higgins here left the committee and moved into the public gallery.)
The spaces shall be hard-surfaced and maintained in perpetuity.’ Councillor Browne proposed that the recommendation within the report including the above condition be approved.
Beth Johnson, Burton and Dalby Parish Council Caroline Chave, Agent Councillor Browne proposed that the recommendations within the report are approved.
Councillor Browne proposed that the application be refused contrary to Officer recommendation.
Councillor Ronan Browne asked the following question:
The Leader expressed thanks to Councillor Ronan Browne, the previous Portfolio Holder for Housing and Landlord Services, for the excellent work done with the housing department over recent years and in relation to the Tenant and Leaseholder Engagement Annual Report.
Councillor Browne seconded the motion.
The Portfolio Holder for Housing and Landlord Services, Councillor Ronan Browne, thanked the Scrutiny Committee for their work on the report and highlighted the hard work and commitment of the officers involved advising that any mould or damp problems reported to the Council would be dealt with and monitored for the following 6-12 months to make sure it is rectified. He also commented that tenants were now more aware on how to report any mould, damp or condensation issues.
The Portfolio Holder for Council Homes and Landlord Services, Councillor Ronan Browne highlighted:
The Portfolio Holder for Council Homes and Landlord Services, Councillor Ronan Browne, made the following comments:
The Portfolio Holder for Housing and Landlord Services, Councillor Ronan Browne, said that this report shows that we are in touch with the communities as we are putting the needs of tenants as the highest priority. The plan also aims to help tenants to save money with the acceleration of the replacement of storage heaters and replacement windows to improve the energy efficiency of homes. He praised the team for the number of properties that they had gained access to, to compile the stock condition survey, noting that it is an excellent figure in comparison with other councils.
Councillor Browne added that the Council needs to be committed to improving our housing stock.
Councillor Browne said he has written to both Michael Gove and the local MP regarding the proposed ceiling on rent that has been proposed and the detrimental effect a cap could have on the funding needed to improve and provide social housing.
Councillor Browne thanked the Senior Corporate Policy officer for all his hard work in supporting the team and thanked all the officers that have been involved in developing the Asset Management Plan. He also thanked the Scrutiny Committee as they have played a big part in a lot of the work that is being carried out.
The Leader also thanked the Scrutiny Committee, the officer team, and the Portfolio Holder, Councillor Ronan Browne.
The Portfolio Holder for Housing and Landlord Services, Councillor Ronan Browne enquired if there could be further discussions with the portfolio holders in relation to risk management so as to increase member engagement and oversight. [name removed] agreed that this would be a good idea and was confident the Chair of Audit and Standards would agree. [name removed] also confirmed the portfolio holders would benefit by being kept up to date on what is on the service risk register too.
The Portfolio Holder for Housing and Landlord Services, Councillor Ronan Browne, thanked [name removed] and her team for bringing the documents forward for review and for having a processes and structures in place to allow for documents to be readily available.
Councillor Browne advised there had recently been a workshop around the Asset Management Improvements on the Northgate Housing System and advised that these policies link into that and that officers have a clear system on what they are doing.
Application 22/00705/FUL - Flats North of Car Park, Chapel Street, Melton Mowbray Councillor Browne declared a conflict of interest due to his role as portfolio holder for Housing and Landlord Services and his subsequent involvement in the scheme and therefore advised he would not take part in this application and he would move into the public gallery.
· The doorway was of steel construction to ensure stability and weatherproofing · There was an information plaque displaying the history of the cells · There was appreciation for reaching a mutually agreeable design and appearance · There was disappointment from one Member that the original cells could not have been retained Councillor Browne proposed that the application be approved.
Raising the roof (Councillor Browne here left the meeting due to his interest declared at Minute PL33.) The Senior Planning Officer (RR) addressed the Committee and provided a summary of the application and advised the application was recommended for approval subject to conditions.
Councillor Browne, Portfolio Holder for Council Homes and Landlord Services introduced the report and moved the recommendations. The Leader seconded the motion.
· Members felt the report was well-written and comprehensive and reflected previous discussions on this application Councillor Browne proposed that the application be approved.
Councillor Browne seconded the motion.
The Portfolio Holder for Housing and Landlord Services, Councillor Ronan Browne thanked [name removed] and her team for producing a very thorough piece of work and a robust Plan. It was important for the Council to maintain its housing stock well, as new government regulations would require this.
The Leader thanked Councillor Browne, [name removed] and her team for their work, commenting that good progress had been made towards ensuring that the Council had effective control of compliance and health and safety issues. There was still much work to be done but the HRA Business Plan would help the Council to deliver excellent homes for tenants.
The Portfolio Holder for Housing and Landlord Services, Councillor Ronan Browne thanked Scrutiny Committee for its feedback on both the HR Business Plan and the Affordable Housing Development Plan. He thanked [name removed] and her team, noting that officers had ensured that Members had been well engaged. This had assisted gaining cross part support.
· It was agreed that Councillor Graham and Councillor Browne would write to Alicia Kearns, Member of Parliament for Rutland and Melton and to the Greg Clark, Secretary of State to reiterate concerns and why the government needed to do more to help people.
John Skerritt The following motion was proposed by Councillor Browne and seconded by Councillor Orson.
Councillor Ronan Browne, Portfolio Holder for Growth and Regeneration thanked the Director for Housing and Communities, the Assistant Director for Housing and their team for the work undertaken. He highlighted that the Policy provided a framework to manage the process of allocating housing to those who met the criteria and providing appropriate support (such as signposting to outside agencies) to those who were not eligible. The Council was working with others such as the private rental sector, housing associations etc. on the future supply of housing.
Councillor Browne declared a personal interest in relation to Minute Number CO69, Pay Policy Statement, due to his wife being a Council employee.
(At 8:04pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor Bindloss left the meeting and did not return.) (At 8:06pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor Browne left the meeting.) (At 8:07pm, during the consideration of this item, Councillor Browne returned to the meeting.)
Councillor Ronan Browne, Portfolio Holder for Council Homes and Landlord Services commented that this was the beginning of a new journey for the Council in relation to tenant engagement. Historically, the Council had engaged well with tenants but there had been added pressures and a lack of government focus on this area. Now prioritised with the help of the Charter for Social Housing Residents, engagement between tenants, officers and Members, facilitated through robust, meaningful discussion and listening to tenants concerns and ideas was vital to progressing in a collective and meaningful way.
Councillor Ronan Browne, Portfolio Holder for Council Homes and Landlord Services thanked [name removed] and her team for their work, noting the important collaborative work undertaken between Members and officers. He commented that community engagement was beneficial and the Council’s ... view the full minutes text for item 228.
Councillor Browne commented that there had been an increase in housing complainants, however he informed Members that this is a positive development as previously the Council weren’t recording them as robustly as we should have done.
Councillor Browne declared an interest in agenda item 4 - Melton Community Lottery - Scrutiny Feedback, as Secretary for Frisby , Hoby and Rotherby Cricket Club, which benefited from lottery funding.
Councillor Browne thanked the Assistant Director for Planning and Delivery for his and his team’s work on completing the SPD.
Councillor Ronan Browne, Portfolio Holder for Council Homes and Landlord Services thanked [name removed] for his work and welcomed the progress made to date, the proactive sourcing of local contractors and the future work (outlined in the report).
Councillor Browne proposed that Councillor Joe Orson be elected Leader until 2023 and paid tribute to his previous term as Leader and added that he believed that he was the right person to lead the Council over the next 3 years.
Councillor Browne declared a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 5, as the Secretary for the Cricket Club, which was a recipient of lottery funding.
Councillor Browne informed the Committee that he had reviewed the contract and found it to be robust but it needed to be managed better.
RESOLVED Scrutiny Committee CONSIDERED the report and AGREED that Councillor Browne would work with the Housing and Neighbourhoods Manager to develop feasible recommendations to be presented to Cabinet. These recommendations would be electronically circulated to Members of the Committee in advance of being forwarded to Cabinet.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Browne attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Browne's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Browne was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Melton has not published attendance for Councillor Browne's meetings yet.
What Councillor Browne declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Sep 2024 | Council, item CO30 | Councillor Browne declared a personal interest relation to CO35 (Motion on 80th Anniversary of Operation Market Garden). He stated that he would leave the room when the motion is being considered. | |
| 18 Apr 2024 | Council, item CO78 | Cllr Browne declared a personal and pecuniary interest in item 10, protected characteristics for care leavers, due to his employer working with Leicestershire County Council to provide housing solutions for care leavers in Leicestershire. He is leading this work for his employer and therefore stated that he would not participate in the item. | |
| 4 Apr 2024 | Planning Committee, item PL71 | Councillor Ronan Browne declared an interest in relation to 23/01133/TPO, St Thomas A Beckets Church, Church Lane, Frisby-on-the-Wreake. As he had been requesting for the work to be done, he would withdraw from the meeting before the application is considered and therefore, he would not vote. | |
| 29 Sep 2022 | Planning Committee, item PL33 | Application 22/00705/FUL - Flats North of Car Park, Chapel Street, Melton Mowbray Councillor Browne declared a conflict of interest due to his role as portfolio holder for Housing and Landlord Services and his subsequent involvement in the scheme and therefore advised he would not take part in this application and he would move into the public gallery. | Took no part |
| 24 Feb 2022 | Council, item CO57 | Councillor Browne declared a personal interest in relation to Minute Number CO69, Pay Policy Statement, due to his wife being a Council employee. | |
| 23 Nov 2021 | Cabinet, item 207 | Councillor Browne declared an interest in agenda item 4 - Melton Community Lottery - Scrutiny Feedback, as Secretary for Frisby , Hoby and Rotherby Cricket Club, which benefited from lottery funding. | |
| 7 Jan 2020 | Scrutiny Committee, item 35 | Councillor Browne declared a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 5, as the Secretary for the Cricket Club, which was a recipient of lottery funding. |
Where Councillor Browne sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Browne yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.