Declarations of Interest
Councillor Andrew Barry declared an interest in the Home to School Transport element of Item 15. He would withdraw from the meeting while that matter was considered.
Every time Merthyr Tydfil's minutes name Councillor Barry, as the council published it.
Councillor Andrew Barry declared an interest in the Home to School Transport element of Item 15. He would withdraw from the meeting while that matter was considered.
Councillor Andrew Barry withdrew from the meeting during consideration of the Home to School Transport matter due to his declared interest. The Head of Regional Internal Audit Service advised that the follow-up audit of Home to School Transport, relating to 2025/26, had been finalized. The Committee agreed that the relevant Head of Service or Director be invited to the next meeting to discuss the Home to School Transport audit and actions being taken.
Councillor Andrew Barry returned to the meeting.
· Cllr C Jones – Personal Interest – family member uses the service · Cllr A Barry – Prejudicial interest Agenda Item 11:
· Cllr G Lewis - he has a family member who is a licensed taxi driver · Cllr A Barry – Prejudicial - Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Licence Fees
Councillor A Barry declared a personal interest in Item 6 as he is a business owner in Merthyr Tydfil.
Cllr J Thomas declared an interest in item 8 as they hold a hackney and private hire license Cllr A Barry declared an interest in item 8 as they hold a hackney and private hire license Cllr G Richards declared an interest in item 8 as a famiily member holds a hackney and private hire license Cllr L Davies declared an interest in item 7 as their wife works for the local authority Cllr M Jones declared an interest in item 7 as their husband works for the local authority
After hearing representations from Cllr Barry, the Ombudsman and briefly from Director Sarah King, the Committee found Cllr Barry to have breached paragraphs 4(b), 4(c) and 6(1)(d) of the Councillors Code of Conduct.
· Councillor Andrew Barry · Council Leader Brent Carter · Councillor Gareth Lewis · Councillor Julia Jenkins In response to questions from committee members, Planning Officers advised that:
Hoovers letters as public art) Ward Councillor Andrew Barry addressed the Committee in favour of the application and emphasised the economic, regeneration and employment benefits for the County Borough.
Cllr Julia Jenkins – organiser of community events; also noted Cllr John Thomas and Cllr Andrew Barry involved.
Cllr Jenkins referred specifically to traffic congestion, poor waste management and anti-social behaviour associated with HMOs that currently account for 80% of calls to local Cllrs Local Elected Member, Cllr Andrew Barry, also spoke on behalf of residents to echo Cllr Jenkins’ comments and referred to a car dealership lower down the road that would exacerbate the traffic congestion. He also referred to the anti-social behaviour association with HMOs and the effect they have on the value of neighbouring properties and the morale of residents.
· Cllr D Jones · Cllr A Barry · Cllr M Symonds · Cllr D Hughes But were able to participate.
Cllr A Barry left the meeting.
Declarations of Interest were received from: · Cllr A Barry declared a personal and prejudicial interest in items 29 and 30 and will leave the meeting for the consideration of the items. · Cllr D Hughes declared a personal and prejudicial interest in items 29 and 30 and will leave the meeting for the consideration of the items. Cllrs L Minett-Vokes and L Davies declared an interest after the debate on item 29 and left the meeting before the vote.
Declarations of Interest Cllr A Barry and D Hughes, having declared an interest in this item, left the meeting for the consideration of the item.
Declarations of Interest Cllr A Barry, D Hughes, L Minnett -Vokes and L Davies, having declared an interest in this item, left the meeting for the consideration of the item.
Cllr Andrew Barry leaves the meeting.
The Local Elected Member Cllr Andrew Barry discussed the economic and social difficulties in Merthyr Tydfil and noted that the proposed development could provide opportunities for future generations and create job and business opportunities.
Cllr A Barry then stressed the need for opportunities in Merthyr Tydfil.
Councillor A Barry declared an interest in item 6, Contract Procedure Rules, he has contracts with the authority.
Cllr A Barry left the meeting having declared an interest in this item.
Cllr A Barry rejoined the meeting.
Cllr A Barry raised a concern regarding the funding of Thomastown Park.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘.’ Resolved that: (a) The changes to the detailed at paragraph 3.3 be approved. (b) The delegation of authority to the Head of Human Resources in consultation with the Portfolio Member to make any future minor amendments to the Policy be approved.
Councillor A Barry left the Meeting.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the report. Questions were asked regarding the Section 151 cover and whether they would be able to attend Council meetings.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the report. Questions were raised in relation to the format of the report . A number of Councillors thanked the Officers and Councillors involved in the new constitution for their contributions.
Councillor A Barry proposed Councillor J Thomas as Mayor for the Municipal Year 2024/2025 and was seconded by Councillor J Jenkins.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘ 2024-2025’ report and advised of the following amendments to the report:
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘ 2024-2025’ report.
Councillor A Barry led the Committee through the ‘Representatives to Other Bodis for the Municipal Year 2024-2025’ report.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘’ report and moved the following amendments to the recommendations detailed in the report and was seconded by Councillor G Thomas:
Bereavement Councillor A Barry advised that former Councillor Mark Elliott had passed away and extend condolences to his family and friends.
Matthew Rivers led the Committee through the Quarterly Update on Corporate Risks Quarter 3 2023/24 report and together with Councillor A Barry and Liam Hull responded to the following questions raised:
The Chair then thanked Councillor A Barry and the Officers for the update to the Committee.
Declaration of Interest Councillor A Barry having Declared his Interest in this item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘’ report and moved the recommendations detailed at Paragraphs 2.1, 2.2, 2.3 and 2.4 of the report and was seconded by Councillor G Thomas.
Councillor A Barry also requested a Recorded Vote on this item.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘’ report and advised that under Paragraph 4.4 of the report it should read 2024/25.
Councillor A Barry then moved the recommendations as detailed in Paragraphs 2.1, 2.2, 2.3 and 2.4 of the report and was seconded by Councillor G Thomas.
Congratulations Councillor A Barry extended congratulations to Gareth Chapman who had been appointed by Welsh Government in relation to reviewing Armed Forces Liaison Officers (AFLO’s).
Councillor Andrew Barry declared an interest in Item 5, Recommendation 2.3: Home to School Transport and would leave the meeting when this item was being discussed.
Prior to the vote on the exclusion of press and public taking the meeting into the exempt session, Councillor Andrew Barry referred to a number of amendments in the reports:
Councillor Andrew Barry led the Members through the Budget Requirement and Council Tax 2024/25 report and moved the recommendations as contained within the report.
Councillor Andrew Barry introduced the report and requested that recommendation 2.3 be taken first so that he could leave the meeting in regard to his declaration of interest before taking Council through the remaining recommendations.
Councillor Andrew Barry returned to the meeting and led Council through the other recommendations in the report. He requested that recommendations 2.20 and 2.21 be taken before the recommendation relating to the Council Tax at 2.17. This would allow the Council to consider adjusting the resolution on the Council Tax, if it was required, at the end.
Councillor A Barry led the Members through the ‘Ombudsman Annual Letter for Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council - 2022/23 ’ report. The following comments were raised: It’s pleasing to see the decrease in reports and complaints, and it shows the good work of the Standards Committee. Resolved that: 2.1 The content of the Ombudsman’s Annual letter be noted and debated.
Councillor A Barry advised that this was the last Cabinet Meeting for Adele Lewis and thanked her for her help and guidance to the Cabinet. Counc illo r A Barry then l ed the Members through the ‘ Capital Monitoring 2023/24 – Quarter 3’ report. Resolved that: 2.1 The Quarter 3 Capital Monitoring Report for 2023/24 be noted. 2.2 The budget amendments for core-funded projects as outlined in 4.1 below be approved. 2.3 Variances to the budgets as per paragraphs 4.2 be noted.
Councillor A Barry led the Members through the ‘Budget Consultation 2024/25 ’ report. The Chair thanked Head of Communications Ceri Dinham , and her team for their valuable work in public engagement . Resolved that: 2.1 The results of the Budget Consultation be received, considered and approved.
Councillor A Barry provided a summary and background to the report and asked the Chief Finance Officer to provide detail. The Chief Finance Officer asked the Council to consider deferring decision s rather than reject ing so that all proposals can be discussed in the upcoming Special Full Council.
Councillor A Barry notified the Monitoring Officer that any deferments would be accepted.
Councillor A Barry proceeded by restating the recommendations and noting an amendment to the second bullet point of Paragraph 5.2 which reads:
Councillor A Barry provided a summary and background to the report and restated the recommendations . Resolved that: 1. The Treasury Management Outturn Report for 2022/23 be received, not e d an d approved. 2.
Councillor A Barry advised that this was the last Full Council Meeting for Adele Lewis and extended very best wishes for the future and thanked her for her work.
Councillor A Barry provided a summary and background to the report and restated the recommendations. Resolved that: 1. The Treasury Management Half Year Review Report for 2023/24 be received, noted and approved.
Councillor A Barry provided a summary and background to the report and restated the recommendations. Comments were raised regarding the involvement of trade unions during the budget setting process .
Councillor A Barry provided a summary and background to the repor t and restated the recommendations. Questions were raised relating to the impact o n collection rates other authorities , and whether any long-term empty properties have been brought back into use. Comments were made in reference to the impact of second homes and the concern of residents.
Councillor A Barry provided a summary and background to the report and read out the recommendations.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the report.
The following questions were then raised by the Committee and were responded to by Audit Wales, Councillor A Barry and Liam Hull:
· Best Practice across all 22 Local Authorities · Next Steps · Accountability / Capacity – Will there be a Lead identified for the Digital Strategy · Paragraph 13 – How much will this cost – Will extra staff be employed The Chair then thanked Audit Wales, Councillor A Barry and Liam Hull for the update to the Committee.
· The balance in relation to overdue / realistic targets – To ensure addressed appropriately · Sharing of this information with the Scrutiny Committees Councillor A Barry stated that it could be useful for this report to be referred to Cabinet / CMT to afford an opportunity to discuss and Saeif Jablaoui advised that he would raise this and respond.
Councillor David Hughes and Councillor Andrew Barry both noted how they were pleased to see the report.
Councillor Andrew Barry gave a brief background on the Governance and Audit Committee and the requirement to produce an annual report.
Councillor Andrew Barry provided a summary and background to the report and restated the recommendations.
Declaration of Interest: Councillor A Barry having Declared his Interest in this item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item. Sue Walker gave an update on Success in Learning and led the Committee through the report. The Chair inf ormed the Committee that he is a Governor of a school that is going through the 21 st Century School Development but noted that the s cho ol is n't in Merthyr Tydfil.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the
Councillor A Barry left the meeting as a question was raised about Home to School Transport.
Councillor A Barry returned to the meeting once the question had been answered by the Officers in attendance.
Councillor A Barry led the Members through the ‘Revenue Budget Monitoring 2023-24 – Quarter 2’ report.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘’ report and moved the recommendation as detailed in Paragraph 2.1 of the report that ‘The growth required for two days Trades Unions Facility time for both Unison and GMB until 31 st March 2024 be approved.’ This Motion was then seconded by Councillor G Thomas.
Saeif Jablaoui then led the Committee through the ‘Progress against ’ report and together with Councillor A Barry, Audit Wales and the Officers responded to the following questions raised:
Councillor A Barry also thanked Steve Jones for his excellent governance of finance and he would be missed.
Retirement of Head of Finance Councillor A Barry advised that this was the last Full Council Meeting for Steve Jones Head of Finance and extended very best wishes for the future and thanked him for his work over the years.
Councillor A Barry led the Members through the ‘Communications, Consultation and Engagement – Capacity Request’ report and moved the recommendation detailed at Paragraph 2.1 of the report and was seconded by Councillor G Thomas.
Steve Jones also referred to the report and together with Councillor A Barry and A Lewis responded in detail to the following questions raised by the Committee:
Cllr A Barry declared an interest in items 3 and 6 due to a transportation contract.
Cllr A Barry; It is incredibly difficult to plan ahead with such an unpredictable framework.
Councillor A Barry introduced the item to the committee and provided an update on the report.
The following questions were raised by the committee and answered in detail by the officer and Cllr A Barry (Cabinet Member) · In terms of the technical process does this report go to Cabinet for approval before or after it has been addressed at this committee · Clarity was sought in relation to how risks make it onto the risk register and what processes are used to identify risks across the Authority and who has the final say on whether a risk is added to the risk register · The risk appetite is set at 12 is that a standard risk appetite for all areas of the organisation · All risks go to Senior Leadership Team, who makes the final decision of what risks make it onto the risk register The Chair thanked the officers for the report and their responses to the questions raised.
Councillor A Barry introduced the item and highlighted the salient points within the report.
The Cabinet Member Councillor A Barry thanked the Auditors for the report and highlighted the importance of Internal Audit and would like to see how things move forward and welcomes a follow up report.
The Chair highlighted the poor attendance at the meeting and Councillor A Barry requested that the issue be raised with the Political Leaders to highlight the importance of the Governance and Audit Committee.
Councillor A Barry proposed Councillor John Thomas as Deputy Mayor for the Municipal Year 2023/2024 and was seconded by Councillor J Jenkins.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Revenue Budget 2023/24 – Transformation Programme’ report.
Councillor A Barry then moved the recommendations as contained within the report and was seconded by Councillor G Thomas.
The following questions were then raised on the report and were responded to by Councillor A Barry, Audit Wales and the Officers:
· Table 3 – Helpful to look through the recommendations to see if any can be closed down – Lot of outstanding issues with no end dates available – Useful to know these dates as some issues have been outstanding for a long time – Information if any have been actioned at all – Helpful for details on if work has been done, any outstanding recommendations or if recommendations have been superseded – To have more manageable numbers · Table 1 – Clarification requested on the 76.89% figure The Chair then thanked Councillor A Barry, Audit Wales and the Officers for the update to the Committee.
Cllr M Jones: Would like to reiterate the comments of Cllr A Barry and D Hughes and offer support. I would like to extend thanks to all officers for their hard work under pressure.
Councillor A Barry led the Members through the ‘Revenue Budget 2023/24 and Medium Term Financial Plan – Progress Report’ and moved the recommendations as contained within the report.
Questions were then raised on the report and were responded to in detail by Councillor G Thomas, Councillor A Barry and the Officers.
Councillor A Barry led the Members through the ‘Capital Programme 2023/24 to 2026/27’ report and moved the recommendation as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the Quarterly Update on Corporate Risks Quarter 3 2022/2023’ report.
· Roles and Responsibilities – The review of Risks spread across the Scrutiny Committees – Could a further column be added to indicate under which Scrutiny Committee the Risk was under The Chair then thanked Councillor A Barry and the Officers for the update to the Committee.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Rolling Programme – Corporate Risk update from Corporate Management Team (CMT) Members: Capacity’ report.
· Capacity – Recruitment – What might happen or what is here and now Clarification sought regarding an aging workforce and experienced staff – Are there succession plans in place · Further details requested in relation to the progression framework for Apprentices – What is being done regarding moving up in the Organisation – Are there any ‘good news’ stories – Situation in relation to Social Services – What opportunities are there in Social Services · What is an acceptable level of Risk · Paragraph 5.1 – Capacity 2 - Actions required to manage the Risk – Helpful to have further detail on the bullet points in the report – What are the long term actions The Chair then thanked Councillor A Barry and the Officers for the update to the Committee.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Corporate Self Assessment ’ report’.
· Explanation requested on the process for the report The Chair then thanked Councillor A Barry and the Officers for the update to the Committee.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Revenue Budget 2023/24 – Budget Proposals’ report.
Declaration of Interest Councillor A Barry and Councillor J Thomas left the Meeting when questions were raised and answered on Appendix 2 Ref 3.
Councillor D Hughes – Appendix 4 – References 10 and 11 Councillor A Barry – Appendix 4 – Reference 3 Councillor J Thomas – Appendix 4 – Reference 3 Councillor M Colbran – Appendix 5 – Reference 14
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Statement of Accounts 2021 / 22’ report, The ‘Annual Governance Statement 2021 /22’ and the Audit Wales ‘Audit of Accounts Report’.
Councillor J Jenkins then led the Members through the report and moved the recommendations as contained within the report and was seconded by Councillor A Barry.
Congratulations The Mayor advised that he had received the following correspondence from Councillor A Barry and shared the contents with the Council:
Armed Forces – Bronze Award Councillor A Barry advised the Council that Cyfarthfa High School had been awarded the Armed Forces – Friendly Schools Cymru – Bronze award and extended his congratulations to the School.
Can you confirm how officers came to that conclusion · The developers are likely to encounter problems due to previous mining on the site, do you believe they will be able to build 120 properties on the site · The traffic management survey estimates that 30% of residents won’t be travelling to work, can you confirm how that figure was calculated Councillor Clive Jones requested a response as to why the site visit was called by officers and not the members and why officers from the Highways and Engineering Department were not invited to attend · 121 new properties are proposed for the site, can you confirm how many existing properties are already accessing the junction that leads to the mini roundabout on Penheolferthyr · Clarity was sought in relation to the land to the south of the site and whether it was likely to be developed in future · Confirmation was sought as to whether the developers had investigated a possible entrance to the site via the slip road (A4060) Town Ward Councillor Andrew Barry requested clarity in relation to the traffic management and air quality surveys as he believed the figures didn’t add up 11.30am – Councillors J Davies and D Sammon left the meeting.
Councillor A Barry declared a personal interest in Item 5 (Proposal to Increase Hackney Carriage Fare Tariffs).
Councillor Barry owns a contract taxi company.
Councillor A Barry left the meeting due to his declaration of interest.
Notice of Motion Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the Notice of Motion and read out the Notice of Motion in full and moved the proposal as detailed in the Motion.
Councillor A Barry and Councillor K O’Neill also requested a Recorded vote.
Councillor A Barry then proposed an amendment to the recommendations in the report to include a third Option at 2.3 to read –‘None of the above’ and this amendment was duly seconded by Councillor D Hughes.
Councillor A Barry then sought clarification of the further amendment and sought clarification of the consequence of the further amendment on the Consultation Process.
Councillor A Barry then confirmed that he was happy to incorporate the further amendment in his amendment but this was not agreed by Councillor D Hughes the seconder to the first amendment.
Further comments were then made by the Members on the amendment as proposed by Councillor A Barry.
Councillor A Barry then requested a Recorded Vote.
The Chair welcomed Councillor A Barry, Fran Donnelly, Paul Williams, Hannah Brown, Alyn Dinham and Alison Anderson to the Meeting and referred the Committee to the ‘Human Resources and ‘Healthy Organisations’ report.
Councillor A Barry then led the Committee through the report and together with Officers responded to in detail to the following questions raised:
Councillor A Barry, Gregg Edwards and Rebecca Delaney then referred to the report and responded in detail to the following questions raised by the Committee:
Councillor A Barry led the Council in detail through the ‘’ report.
Councillor A Barry led the Council in detail through the ‘2023 Review of Parliamentary Constituencies – Initial Proposals’ report and recommended in relation to Paragraph 2.2 that ‘submissions be received by 28 October 2021’ be added.
Councillor A Barry then referred in detail to the ‘Corporate Risk Register – Highlight Report’ and together with the Officers responded to the following questions raised by the Committee:
Councillor A Barry referred the Members to the ’Sickness Absence Policy and Sickness Absence Procedure’ report and moved the recommendations as contained within the report.
Mark Thomas led the Committee in detail through the ‘’ report and together with Councillor A Barry responded to the following question raised by the Committee:
Mike Parry then led the Committee in detail through the report and together with Councillor A Barry responded in detail to the following questions raised on the report:
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Grievance Policy and Procedure’ report and moved recommendations 2.1 and 2.2 as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry then referred to the work that had to be undertaken regarding this and suggested a report be prepared by Andrew Mogford on trends in relation building closures.
· The Delta Variant · The safety of the public · Members of the public who were unable to access / use on line facilities · The number of people allowed into public buildings · Sanitation of public buildings · Are any meetings being held by the One Stop Shop on line · Could a facility for TEAMS Meeting be available in a public building for the public to speak to an Officer · Issues of confidentiality and privacy for users Councillor A Barry and Gregg Edwards then responded to the issues raised by the Committee.
Councillor A Barry led the Committee through the ‘Annual Risk Management Progress Report and Updated Corporate Risk Register for 2020-21’ report and moved the recommendations as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Council Tax Discounts for Long Term Unoccupied Properties’ report and advised of the following amendments to the report:
The Chair welcomed Councillor L Mytton and Councillor A Barry together with Council Officers to the Meeting.
Councillor Andrew Barry declared a personal interest in Item 6 (Welsh Government Transport Funding Bids 2021/22.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘’ report and proposed recommendations 2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 2.4 and 2.5 as outlined in the report with an amendment to recommendation 2.6 due to the withdrawal of Service Efficiency Proposal – Ref 31 – Household Waste Recycling Centres.
Ref 26 – Transport – Removal of School Transport (Edwardsville) Declaration of Interest Councillor A Barry and Councillor J Thomas then Declared their Interest in Ref 26 – School Transport as they undertake a School Contract and left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
Councillor L Mytton then referred to the original proposal of Councillor A Barry and proposed recommendations 2.1 to 2.5 as outlined within the report and recommendation 2.6 as amended by Councillor Barry and the further amendment to recommendation 2.6 due to Service Efficiency Proposals Ref 26, 29 and 30 being deferred.
Councillor Andrew Barry declared a personal interest in Item 5 (School Transport Contract Awards – Delegated Authority).
Councillor Barry owns a contract taxi company and currently has a school contract.
The Chair welcomed Councillor A Barry, Councillor G Thomas Cabinet Members, Alyn Owen, Chris Long, Paul Lewis, Sue Gow, Suzanne Stephens, Zoe Thomas, Deb Ryan-Newton, Lance Whiteley, Dan Bufton, Ryan Barry and Anouska Beaumont to the Meeting.
Councillor Andrew Barry declared a personal interest in relation to item 3 ‘Public Spaces Protection Order(s) Restricting Access Over Five Public Highways In Merthyr Tydfil Through The Installation Of Gates’ as he resides in William Street which is part of the area proposed to have gates installed.
Councillor A Barry, Councillor D Jones, Councillor M Colbran, Councillor D Hughes, Councillor C Davies, Councillor S Jago, Councillor D Sammon, Councillor G Richards, Councillor G Thomas, Councillor C Tovey, Councillor E Galsworthy and Councillor L Mytton Declared an Interest in Item 6 – Notice of Motion – Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council’s Response to the Current Financial Assistance for the Business Community . Clarification and guidance was also sought from the Monitoring Officer by Councillors regarding the need to make a Declaration of Interest.
Councillor A Barry referred to the ‘Agile and Homeworking Policy’ report and moved the recommendation at Paragraph 2.1 of the report.
Questions were then raised in relation to the Policy and Councillor A Barry stated that he would welcome Scrutiny looking at the Policy.
Councillor A Barry declared an interest in Item 9 - Local Transport Fund 2020/21.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Council Priorities and Budget Consultation 2020/21’ report and proposed the recommendation as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry having Declared his Interest in this item left the Chamber for the consideration of this item.
Councillor A Barry having Declared his Interest in this item left the Chamber for the consideration of this item.
Councillor A Barry referred to the ‘Capital Programme 2020/21 to 2023/24’ report and proposed a further recommendation that:
The Chair welcomed Councillor A Barry, Fran Donnelly, Hannah Brown and Paul Williams to the Meeting.
Fran Donnelly referred the Committee to the ‘Human Resources’ Report and together with Councillor Barry and the Officers responded in detail to the following questions that were raised by the Committee:
Councillor A Barry referred the Members to the ‘Welsh Government Consultation: Changes to Executive Governance Arrangements in Principal Councils’ report and proposed an amendment to recommendation 2.1 to read:
Councillor A Barry referred to the Notice of Motion and proposed the Motion in relation to ‘Letter of Apology’ and was seconded by Councillor K O’Neill.
Councillor A Barry referred to the ‘’ report and proposed the recommendations as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry led the Committee through the ‘Corporate Sustainability Programme – Budget Reduction Proposals’ report and referred to each recommendation as outlined within the report.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘Corporate Sustainability Programme – Budget Reduction Proposal’ report and referred to each recommendation as outlined within the report.
Recommendation 2.1 – Councillor A Barry advised of an amendment to the recommendation to withdraw ED 015 in relation to the Education Budget.
Councillor A Barry led the Council through the ‘Issuing of a Section 188 Letter to Trade Union’ report and proposed the recommendations as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry referred the Members to the ‘Corporate Sustainability Programme – Proposals’ report and the recommendations as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Corporate Sustainability Programme – Proposals’ report and advised that each recommendation would be addressed item by item to distinguish between those that would be heard as an exempt item and those that would be heard in open session at the Full Council Meeting on 23 October 2019.
Councillor A Barry then referred to the recommendations and advised which were deferred or were for consideration.
After a short adjournment the following was outlined by Councillor A Barry for clarification:
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Corporate Sustainability Programme – Proposals’ report and referred to the Recommendations as contained within the report and gave details of the Recommendations that were being recommended for withdrawal and the Recommendations that were being recommended for deferral to the Full Council Meeting scheduled for 23 October 2019.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Appointment of the Interim Chief Executive’ report and the recommendation as contained within the report.
Councillor J Thomas and Councillor A Barry having Declared their Interest in this item left the Chamber for the consideration of this item.
Councillor A Barry referred to the ‘Work Experience Scheme’ report and moved the recommendation as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry then accepted this addition to the recommendation but that this report be submitted to Full Council in twelve months.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘’ report and proposed the recommendations within the report.
Councillor D Roberts then proposed an amendment to recommendation 2.2 to read that ‘The collective input of the Council’s Corporate Management Team, Cabinet and Elected Members in addressing the financial challenges be accepted’ and this amendment was accepted by Councillor A Barry.
Councillor A Barry and Councillor J Thomas having Declared their Interest in this item left the Chamber for the consideration of this item.
Councillor A Barry referred to the ‘Proposed Medium Term Financial Plan 2019/20 to 2022/23’ report and advised that recommendation 2.2 should read £483,000 and not £430,000 and outlined the reason for this amendment.
The Chair welcomed Councillor A Barry and Councillor L Mytton Cabinet Members and Sue Walker to the Meeting.
Councillor A Barry referred to the ‘Post Entry Training Policy and Sponsorship Policy’ report and moved the recommendations as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry referred to the ‘Help for Pensioners Scheme 2018’ report and moved that Option 4.1 (b) as outlined in the report be accepted.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Revenue Budget Monitoring 2018/19 – Quarter 3’ report and advised that in Paragraph 1.1 it should read ‘was’ and not ‘will be’.
Councillor H R Jones and Councillor A Barry left the Meeting at 3.00pm.
Councillor H R Jones and Councillor A Barry left the Meeting at 3.00 pm.
Councillor Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Update on Progress in Managing the Council’s Corporate Risks’ report.
Sue Walker also referred the Committee to the contents of the report and together with Councillor Barry and Kerry O’Donovan responded in detail to the following questions:
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Overview and Scrutiny: Fit for the Future? Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council – Update’ report.
Andres Mogford together with Councillor Barry then responded in detail to the following questions raised by the Committee:
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Car Parking Report Update’.
· The Telephone Directory on the Intranet · Bobs Business · 2017 – 2022 Member Induction · IT Provision The following questions and comments were then raised by the Committee and were responded to in detail by Councillor A Barry and Ann Taylor.
· Supporting the global reporting of these payments · Registration of Carers · Freedom of Information requests · Diversity of Councillors The Chair then thanked Councillor Barry and Ann Taylor for the updates to the Committee.
Councillor A Barry referred the Members to the ‘Medium Term Financial Plan 2019/20 to 2022/23 – Update 1’ report and proposed a Recorded Vote on the recommendations as contained within the report.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Medium Term Financial Plan 2019/20 to 2022/23 – Update 1’ report and moved the recommendations as set out in Paragraph 2.0 of the report.
Remembrance Services Councillor A Barry referred to the Remembrance Services taking place throughout the County Borough and gave details of the Services taking place.
Councillor A Barry then led the Council through the amended report highlighting the amendments.
Councillor A Barry having Declared his Interest in this Item left the Chamber for the consideration of this Item.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Annual Scrutiny Report – 2017/2018’.
Councillor A Barry advised that the recommendation should include Audit Committee and also recommended that the comments of all Scrutiny Chairs that had been omitted from the report be submitted to a Meeting of Full Council.
Councillor A Barry and Councillor J Thomas having Declared their Interest in this item left the Chamber for this item.
Councillor A Barry and Councillor J Thomas having Declared their Interest in this Item left the Chamber for this item.
Councillor Andrew Barry declared his interest in item 8 (Delegated Authority for Taxi Licensing) and item 10 (Post-16 Home to School Transport) as he is a proprietor and driver of a taxi company.
Councillor Andrew Barry referred to the report and advised members of two additional recommendations, namely:
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Welsh Language Annual Monitoring Report for 2017-2018’.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘’ report.
Councillor J Amos, Councillor D Sammon, Councillor A Barry, Councillor D Jones, Councillor G Lewis and Councillor S Jago having Declared their Interest in this item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘’ report and referred to Paragraph 5.0 of the report and advised of the following amendment:
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘’ report and advised of amendments to the Paragraph numbers in the recommendations.
Councillor A Barry also proposed a further recommendation ‘that approval of the report be subject to Scrutiny’.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Statement of Wellbeing and Focus on the Future: Wellbeing in our Community’ report.
Councillor A Barry led the Committee through the ‘Medium Term Financial Plan 2018/19 to 2021/22 – Final’ report and proposed that Paragraphs 2.1, 2.2 and 2.3 as contained within the report be amended.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Annual Equality Report for 2016 – 2017’ and proposed a further recommendation.
Councillor A Barry then gave an update to the Committee on the Trust and responded in detail to questions raised by the Committee on the current position of the Trust.
Councillor A Barry led the Members in detail through the ‘Driving on Council Business’ report.
Councillor A Barry then referred to the report and recommended Option 2 the former Vaynor and Penderyn School site be approved as the preferred location for the new Ysgol-y-Graig Primary School together with recommendations 2.2, 2.3 and 2.4 as outlined within the report.
Councillor A Barry also requested a Recorded Vote.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the revisions to the Medium Term Financial Plan 2018/19 to 2021/22 which were approved at Council on 13 December 2017. He advised Members that there was an additional £63K to be added to the Pay Award (2018/19) amount of £300K as outlined in Table 6 at Paragraph 7.1 of the report.
Councillor Andrew Barry referred Committee to the report and provided a brief summary.
Councillor A Barry referred to ‘Report 3a – Customer Services Roles – Vacant Posts’ and advised of a correction in Paragraphs 2.3, 4.3 and 5.1.
Councillor A Barry referred the Committee to the ‘Review of Peripheral and Agency Workers’ report and advised of the following amendments:
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘Revised Medium Term Financial Plan 2018/19 to 2021/22 – Update December 2017’ report and also gave details of · Further Pressures – Pay Award and Children Looked After · Final Settlement Resolved that:
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the ‘’ report and advised that under Paragraph 5.7 the figure for GMB should read 960 and the Unison figure was unconfirmed.
Councillor A Barry having Declared his Interest in this item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
The Chair advised that a referral had been received from Councillor A Barry in relation to Capital Monitoring and the reports that had been considered at the Cabinet Meetings held 22 November 2017 and 25 October 2017 which referred to:
Councillor A Barry then gave details of the Battle and the actions of Sgt Collins and further advised that on Tuesday 31 October 2017 the Local Authority would be holding a Remembrance Service to re-dedicate the Memorial of Sgt John Collins VC, DCM which was located in the Memorial Garden at St Tydfil’s Old Parish Church at 11.00 am.
Councillor A Barry having Declared his Interest in this item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
Councillor A Barry referred the Council to the report and proposed that Elected Executive Members and Chairs be remunerated at Level One and the Civic Head and Deputy Civic Head be remunerated at Level Three.
Councillor Bill Smith – Shadow Board Member Councillor Andrew Barry – Shadow Board Member Councillor Dave James – Shadow Board Member Councillor Ron Clark – Shadow Board Member Councillor Chris Barry – Housing Tenant Councillor Leighton Smart – Housing Tenant The following declarations were made in regard to item 7 – Health, Social Care and Well-being Strategy 2008 – 2011 – Final Draft Strategy Councillor Mark Elliott - Employee Councillor Ian Clark – Member of his family works for Trust Councillor Derek Games – Local Health Board Member Councillor Jeff Edwards – Local Health Board Member Councillor Clive Jones – Local Health Board Member Councillor Ray Thomas – Local Health Board Member The Local Health Board Members advised that they each had a dispensation from the Standards Committee.
Councillor Chris Barry – Item 20 – Biffa Profit Sharing – ‘Martyrs to the Cause’ – Councillor Barry is Executive Chair of Martyrs to the Cause ..
Councillor A Barry – Item 13 – Regeneration Strategy 2007 – 2010 – Chair of Chamber of Trade – dispensation to speak but not vote.
Councillor A Barry – item 19 – Proposal for Stock Transfer – Shadow Board Member.
Councillor C Barry – Item 26 – Merthyr Tydfil Compact – Councillor Barry works for the NHS.
Councillor A Barry – Item 18 – Proposed new provisions for the controlling and regulating of street trading and other non commercial activities throughout the Borough – dispensation to speak but not vote.
Councillor A D Barry left the meeting.
A declaration of interest was received from Councillor A D Barry in regards to Item 24 – Proposed new provisions for the controlling and regulating of street trading and other non-commercial activities through out the County Borough – as he is a member of the Chamber of Trade.
Councillor Barry has a dispensation to speak but not vote on this issue.
Councillor A D Barry – Chairman of the Chamber of Trade – Dispensation granted to speak but not vote on this issue.
A declaration of interest was also made in relation to Extra Item Proposed New Standard Conditions for the Licensing and Control of Sex Shops by Councillor A D Barry as he is a local shop owner and a member of the Chamber of Trade.
Councillor A D Barry left the meeting at 18.55pm
Arising on minute number 392 Councillor A D Barry left the meeting and returned at the start of minute number 393.
Councillor A D Barry declared his interest in Item 3 and 4 – Planning Application P/06/0218 – Proposed mixed use development comprising retail units with Cinema above – Land at junction of Castle Street / Avenue De Clichey – President of the Chamber of Trade, ex-member of Georgetown Boys and Girls Club and owns an outlet shop within the town centre.
Councillor Barry had dispensation to speak on the issue other than the financial aspect of the application but could not vote on the application.
AS PRESIDENT OF THE CHAMBER OF TRADE AND AS A TRADER WITHIN THE TOWN CENTRE Councillor A D Barry be granted a dispensation in accordance with paragraphs 2 (e) and (f) of the Standards Committee (Grant of Dispensation) (Wales) Regulations 2001 and be entitled to speak on issues not relating to financial implications but not vote at on all retail matters throughout the County Borough except where any financial / funding matters are being discussed.
AS EX-MEMBER OF GEORGETOWN BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB Councillor A D Barry be granted a dispensation in accordance with paragraphs 2 (e) and (f) of the Standards Committee (Grant of Dispensation) (Wales) Regulations 2001 and be entitled to speak but not vote on any matter that may affect the Georgetown Boys and Girls Club except where any financial / funding matters are being discussed.
That Councillor Barry be advised to reapply for consideration of the right to vote after a minimum of 9 months following his resignation of not being a member of the above club.
Declarations of interest were received from Councillor A D Barry in respect of Item 17 as he was President of the Merthyr Tydfil Chamber of Trade.
RESOLVED That Councillor J Amos replaces Councillor A D Barry as the Chair of the Corporate Centre / FARM Scrutiny Committee That Councillor J Amos replaces Councillor A D Barry as the Vice Chair of the Principal Scrutiny Committee That Councillor J Amos replaces Councillor A D Barry as the Vice Chair of the Audit Committee That Councillor A D Barry replaces Councillor J Amos as a member of the Customer Community Services Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor S P Brown as Welfare Officer for Georgetown Boys Club (item 17), Councillor A Barry as Chairperson of the Georgetown Boys and Girls Club (item 17);
Councillor M Elliott, Councillor C Jones and Councillor A Barry as Cyfarthfa High School Governors in respect of the extra urgent item – dispensation to speak and vote.
Councillor A Barry left the meeting.
Councillor Clive Jones – Supporter Merthyr Football Club Councillor Dave James – Support Merthyr Football Club Councillor Andrew Barry – Owns outlet in town centre Councillor Steve Morgan – Chairman Rhydycar West Regeneration Partnership Councillor D D Games – Merthyr Heritage Trust Councillor P Brown – Secretary Merthyr Tydfil Anti-Opencast Campaign – Secretary Rhydycar West Regeneration Partnership Councillor L C Elliott – Preconceived vote Councillor J Taylor – Supporter Merthyr Tydfil Football Club – Preconceived vote Item 24 Fire Risk Assessment to Property Portfolio Councillor B Toomey – Operational Fire-fighter – Dispensation granted to speak and vote
Councillor A J Barry led Cabinet through the report.
The following declarations of interest were made:- Councillor A D Barry – Owns an outlet in town centre.
Councillor Andrew Barry – Item 06 – attended a meeting with the proposed developer of the Old Town Hall.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Barry attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Barry's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Barry was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 5 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Barry declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Sep 2026 | Governance and Audit Committee, item 97 | Councillor Andrew Barry declared an interest in the Home to School Transport element of Item 15. He would withdraw from the meeting while that matter was considered. | |
| 14 May 2026 | Full Council, item 45 | Councillor A Barry declared a personal interest in Item 6 as he is a business owner in Merthyr Tydfil. | |
| 4 Mar 2026 | Full Council, item 22 | Cllr J Thomas declared an interest in item 8 as they hold a hackney and private hire license Cllr A Barry declared an interest in item 8 as they hold a hackney and private hire license Cllr G Richards declared an interest in item 8 as a famiily member holds a hackney and private hire license Cllr L Davies declared an interest in item 7 as their wife works for the local authority Cllr M Jones declared an interest in item 7 as their husband works for the local authority | |
| 11 Jun 2025 | Full Council, item 60 | Declarations of Interest were received from: · Cllr A Barry declared a personal and prejudicial interest in items 29 and 30 and will leave the meeting for the consideration of the items. · Cllr D Hughes declared a personal and prejudicial interest in items 29 and 30 and will leave the meeting for the consideration of the items. Cllrs L Minett-Vokes and L Davies declared an interest after the debate on item 29 and left the meeting before the vote. | Left the room |
| 5 Feb 2025 | Full Council, item 573 | Councillor A Barry declared an interest in item 6, Contract Procedure Rules, he has contracts with the authority. | |
| 28 Feb 2024 | Full Council, item 716 | Councillor Andrew Barry declared an interest in Item 5, Recommendation 2.3: Home to School Transport and would leave the meeting when this item was being discussed. | |
| 12 Jul 2023 | Cabinet, item 138 | Cllr A Barry declared an interest in items 3 and 6 due to a transportation contract. | |
| 8 Jun 2022 | Cabinet, item 819 | Councillor A Barry declared a personal interest in Item 5 (Proposal to Increase Hackney Carriage Fare Tariffs). | |
| 24 Feb 2021 | Cabinet, item 418 | Councillor Andrew Barry declared a personal interest in Item 6 (Welsh Government Transport Funding Bids 2021/22. | |
| 3 Feb 2021 | Cabinet, item 352 | Councillor Andrew Barry declared a personal interest in Item 5 (School Transport Contract Awards – Delegated Authority). | |
| 6 Jan 2021 | Cabinet, item 265 | Councillor Andrew Barry declared a personal interest in relation to item 3 ‘Public Spaces Protection Order(s) Restricting Access Over Five Public Highways In Merthyr Tydfil Through The Installation Of Gates’ as he resides in William Street which is part of the area proposed to have gates installed. | |
| 16 Sep 2020 | Cabinet, item 818 | Councillor A Barry declared an interest in Item 9 - Local Transport Fund 2020/21. | |
| 25 Jul 2018 | Full Council, item 230 | Councillor Andrew Barry declared his interest in item 8 (Delegated Authority for Taxi Licensing) and item 10 (Post-16 Home to School Transport) as he is a proprietor and driver of a taxi company. | |
| 1 Nov 2006 | Full Council, item 445 | Councillor A D Barry declared his interest in Item 3 and 4 – Planning Application P/06/0218 – Proposed mixed use development comprising retail units with Cinema above – Land at junction of Castle Street / Avenue De Clichey – President of the Chamber of Trade, ex-member of Georgetown Boys and Girls Club and owns an outlet shop within the town centre. |
Where Councillor Barry sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full Council | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 3 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Scrutiny: Sustainable Merthyr Tydfil | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 2 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Democratic Services Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2025 | 2 | |
| Governance and Audit Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 1 | 14 Dec 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.