Declarations of Interest
· Cllr P Layton - Prejudicial Interest - she is the founder of the group concerned · Cllr D Sammon - Prejudicial Interest – he is a member of the community group that would benefit from the funding.
Every time Merthyr Tydfil's minutes name Councillor Sammon, as the council published it.
· Cllr P Layton - Prejudicial Interest - she is the founder of the group concerned · Cllr D Sammon - Prejudicial Interest – he is a member of the community group that would benefit from the funding.
· Councillor D Isaac be elected as Mayor for the Municipal Year 2026/2027 The retiring Mayor Councillor P Layton addressed the Council The Senior Solicitor presented the past Mayors Medallion to Councillor P Layton and presented Councillor D Sammon with the past Consorts Pendant
Cllr Declan Sammon introduced the report and advised that Committee Members see the Culture Survey which is referenced in the report. In response to the questions from committee members, it was noted:
Presented by Councillor Declan Sammon.
Councillor D Sammon left the meeting.
Cllr Declan Sammon introduced the report.
· Partnership is chaired by Cllr Declan Sammon and includes key local authority partners.
Presented by Councillor Declan Sammon.
Cllr Declan Sammon introduced the report. In response to the questions from committee members:
Cllr Declan Sammon introduced the report. Correction was noted on page 96, Table 1 : ‘ Pentrebach ’ should read ‘Plymouth’.
Presented by Councillor Declan Sammon.
Councillor D Sammon presented the report.
Councillor D Sammon thanked Andrew Mogford for the work that has been carried out in relation to the report and for the support that will be given to members during the process.
Cllr Declan Sammon presented the report.
Cllr Declan Sammon presented the report and advised that the dates of future performance reports being presented to this scrutiny may need to be reviewed.
Councillor D Sammon declared an interest in Item 10 – Instrument of Government – Ty Dysgu as he currently sits on the management committee of Dy Dy sgu .
Presented by Councillor Declan Sammon.
Councillor Sammon asked for a correction to the Report be noted in regard to point 3.9 which refers to ‘four Equality Objectives’ which should read ‘six Equality Objectives’.
Cllr Sammon asked for a correction to the report be noted in regard to Page 11 of Appendix 4, the number of children looked after is 156, not 66, and the number of children on the Child Protection Register is 66, not 156.
Councillor Sammon advised the words in brackets (as at the end of quarter 1) in Recommendation 2.1 be removed.
Councillor Declan Sammon presented the report.
and · The number of children Looked After is 156 Councillor Sammon also advised that the feedback provided by elected members at the workshop in July would be circulated to all Councillors after this meeting.
Cllr D Sammon left the meeting.
Presented by Cllr D Sammon. Comments were made thanking Officers for the report. Resolved that: 2.1 The update of the action plan associated with the Empty Property Strategy 2022- 2026, be noted. 2.2 The approach, as outlined in this report, of prioritising by risk assessment of empty properties that have been empty over two years; be approved. 2.3 MTCBC will continue to participate in the National Empty Homes Grant scheme until the originally allocated funding has been exhausted or until WG withdraws the scheme, whichever comes first, be noted. 2.4 Data relating to activity against the Empty Homes Strategy will be provided to all elected members on a quarterly (and national indicator annually) basis via Public Protection Service updates, be noted.
Presented by Cllr D Sammon. In response to questions:
Presented by Cllr D Sammon. In response to a question from an elected member, the Officer noted that the process regarding complaints involving officers could be discussed. Resolved that:
Presented by Cllr D Sammon. In response to questions, Council was advised that: The Officer provided clarification regarding dealing with fly-tipping on private land. The Officer explained how cases are dealt with.
Comments were made noting the Scrutiny discussions, and Officers and Cllr D Sammon were thanked for the work done. Resolved that: 2.1 The report at Appendix 2 outlining policy changes/amendments on how fly-tipping could be managed on Council Land and Private Land, be approved.
Cllr D Sammon presented the report.
Cllr D Sammon informed the Committee of amendments to the report.
Cllr D Sammon noted that Paragraph 6 of Appendix 4 to Section 19 would be removed as it is already present in the Constitution. The Senior Solicitor then provided an update to Council , noting further amendments to the report.
Cllr D Sammon then presented the report. In response to a question from an elected member, the Officer explained the first stage of the Local Resolution Process.
Cllr D Sammon presented the report. In response to questions from elected members: · The Officer noted that the Citizen’s Panel would meet on a quarterly basis. · The Officer explained that the Scrutiny committees have their own Forward Plans and explained the processes of their Forward Plans. · The Youth Panel would be aimed at those aged 24 and under, and the Adult Panel would be 25 and above. · The Officer noted that Members will be informed of when a Citizen’s Panel is taking place. Resolved that : 2.1 The implementation of an annual Cabinet Forward Plan and respective quarterly updates be published on the Council’s website be noted. 2.2.
Cllr D Sammon presented the report. Resolved that:
Cllr D Sammon presented the report. In response to questions from elected members: · The Officer explained that the co-opted scrutiny members have been contacted and sent the remit for the committees, and they’ve been asked whether they would like to sit on a committee. · The Officer noted that the Members who have confirmed they want to continue their post have been appointed and their details have been updated on the website. · The Officer explained that if more than one person has applied for the same post, they may have to be interviewed or will be offered a position on a different committee. Resolved that:
The Committee agreed that Cllr D Sammon would prepare the evidence on behalf of the Councillors should an appeal be put forth. After the Committee discussed the reasons for refusal, it was Resolved that : The application be refused on the grounds of parking and highway safety.
Cllr D Sammon and A Mogford led the committee through the report.
Cllr D Sammon discussed the times of future meetings and whether they could be reconsidered, and the Chair noted that the times could be revisited if needed. The Chair also notified the committee that there will be a training session scheduled, and they will look at Members' involvement.
Cllr D Sammon then noted an amendment to the recommendation, and that it should read:
The Leader then announced that Cllr D Sammon will join the Cabinet as the new Cabinet Member for Transformation, Governance and Social Partnerships.
Cllr D Sammon addressed the Council, noting that he has accepted the role of Cabinet Member and would continue to work with councillors , officers and residents.
Councillor D Sammon took over as Chair for the remainder of the item. The following questions were asked: · Regarding the Redhouse , are you able to provide more detail in what support the council can provide at this stage? · Regarding the ITV report, could you confirm that the statement is accurate ?
Cllr D Sammon provided an update on the Fly tipping Task and Finish group.
The Committee agreed that Cllr D Sammon w ould prepare the evidence on behalf of the Councillors should an appeal be put forth.
The Committee agreed that Cllr D Sammon would prepare the evidence on behalf of the Councillors should an appeal be put forth .
Cllr D Sammon raised of Fly Tipping / Littering that was raised at the Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Meeting and confirmed that he would be emailing all Councillors in relation to the Task and Finish group that had been set up.
The Chair raised the Task and Finish Group set up by Cllr D Sammon and the feedback report on South Wales Police HQ and Public Service Centre Site Visit.
Councillor D Sammon then moved an amendment that ‘Before any decision is made on this matter that a full Consultation be undertaken with the residents of Merthyr Tydfil in relation to benefits and risks and that this Consultation be delivered to all residents in the same way as the Contact Magazine’ and this Motion was seconded by Councillor P Layton.
Declaration of Interest Councillor D Sammon having Declared his Interest in this item vacated the Chair and left the Meeting for this item.
Resignation of Committee Member and welcome to new Committee Member The Chair advised that Councillor Paula Layton had resigned from Standards Committee and welcomed Councillor Declan Sammon as her replacement.
The retiring Mayor Councillor D Sammon then addressed the Council.
The Senior Solicitor then presented the past Mayor’s Medallion to Councillor D Sammon.
Councillor D Sammon stated that the residents were very concerned and this was why a submission had been made by the Ward Members on behalf of the residents in the area together with the Petition signed by residents against the proposal (Appendix E).
Councillor D Sammon left the Meeting at 5.20 pm.
Councillor D Sammon referred the Council to the Notice of Motion and read out the Motion in full.
Councillor D Sammon left the Meeting at 2.27 pm and returned at 3.02 pm.
Can you confirm what the percentage is in Merthyr Tydfil in relation to population Councillor D Sammon requested that the officer provide the percentage figures for the number of Children Looked After in relation to the population in Merthyr Tydfil.
Councillor D Hughes proposed Councillor D Sammon as Deputy Mayor for the Municipal Year 2021 – 2022 and was seconded by Councillor J Davies.
Councillor D Sammon be elected as the Deputy Mayor for the Municipal Year 2021 – 2022.
The Chair advised the Committee that Councillor D Sammon wished to raise an item.
Councillor D Sammon addressed the committee and outlined the decision to call the Planning Department to his Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny in relation to frustrations from Councillors and residents that planning decisions are being made knowing that problems will arise from that decision.
Councillor M Colbran, Councillor C Davies, Councillor D Hughes, Councillor D Jones, Councillor S Jago, Councillor D Sammon, Councillor G Thomas and Councillor C Tovey having Declared their Interest in this item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
Councillor Declan Sammon declared a personal interest in Item 5 (Community Asset Transfer) as his community group has a number of leases through Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council.
Councillor Sammon did not leave the meeting.
Prior to the Planning Officer presenting the application Councillor D Sammon put forward a motion to defer the application.
Councillor A Barry, Councillor D Jones, Councillor M Colbran, Councillor D Hughes, Councillor C Davies, Councillor S Jago, Councillor D Sammon, Councillor G Richards, Councillor G Thomas, Councillor C Tovey, Councillor E Galsworthy and Councillor L Mytton Declared an Interest in Item 6 – Notice of Motion – Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council’s Response to the Current Financial Assistance for the Business Community . Clarification and guidance was also sought from the Monitoring Officer by Councillors regarding the need to make a Declaration of Interest.
The Chair advised that there was no business deemed urgent, however Cllr D Sammon raised an issue with the Chief Officer Planning and Neighbourhood Services on behalf of a Ward Councillor who was having difficulty with the call in process for committee consideration.
A request was made by Cllr D Sammon for Cllr C Davies (Cabinet Member for Social Services) to feedback to Cabinet in relation to the issue relating to getting better public involvement and feedback on the services · Is the pool budget based on population and how is the pool budget made up and managed · With the addition of Bridgend to the Partnership area on 1 st April, how are things working and are we now moving forward or are there still teething problems to be resolved · We have seen the Young Carers Annual Report but have the committee had sight of the Carers Annual Report · (WCCIS) Welsh Community Care Information System - are all partners now using the system · What reasons have been given for everyone not being able to access the system The Chair thanked the Officer for the report.
Councillor D Sammon then led the Committee in detail through the ‘Draft Task and Finish Group: Rat Infestations and Recycling Rates’ report and advised that a lot of the subject matter was in the remit of the Committee and welcomed input from the Committee prior to presentation of the report to Cabinet.
This suggestion was welcomed by Councillor Sammon who also stated that he would welcome the involvement of Committee Members.
The Chair then thanked Councillor Sammon for the update to the Committee.
Recommendation 2.11 as outlined within the report be approved Councillor D Sammon having Declared his Interest in recommendations 2.12.1, 2.12.2 and 2.12.3 left the Chamber for the consideration of these items.
· Can the figures be broken down to show each individual area in future reports · Can you highlight any advantages or disadvantages of the new larger Safeguarding Board · The report highlights radicalisation – are there any recorded incidents in Merthyr Tydfil Councillor D Sammon left the meeting 3.10pm · County Lines – Can you confirm that Merthyr Tydfil is currently free from this issue · NEETS are not included in this report – Does the safeguarding Board not cover this area The Cabinet Member thanked the officers for the excellent work carried out around safeguarding and thanked Nicola for an excellent report.
Councillor Declan Sammon declared his interest in Ref. No. 9 (Cent BC 4).
· Councillor Declan Sammon - Ref. No. 9 (Cent BC 4).
Councillor Declan Sammon left the meeting when Proposal Ref. No. 9 (Cent BC 4) was discussed.
Councillor D Sammon welcomed the development of the Early Help Hub but raised concerns in relation to the adequate evaluation being maintained with large scale cuts coming in the near future.
· Concerns were raised in relation to the negative outcomes against the following - %age CLA 1 or more change of School and %age of Care Leavers in education training employment (12 months) and an explanation requested to better understand the figures provided · Are there figures available for the number of care leavers in education, training or employment to compare with other school leavers · Currently the demand for Advocacy outstrips the numbers available, can you provide and explanation for this and what plans are in place to address the situation · Are there adequate staffing levels available to provide the level of service required Councillor D Sammon raised concerns that the mid-year update on Social Services Complaints, Representations and Compliments wasn’t listed on the agenda and asked whether it would be listed before the end of the year Resolved that The Scrutiny Committee Members provided feedback on the content of the report developed through completion of the self-evaluation process.
Councillor Sammon then referred to the ‘Draft Scrutiny Report – Pitch Fees and the Decreasing Rates of Participation in Team Sports in Merthyr Tydfil’ report and responded in detail to the questions raised by the Committee on the report.
Cllr D Sammon requested that a report be brought to the committee with a lot more information covering looked after children. He also requested that on the back of receiving the report can a task and finish group be set-up.
It was agreed that Cllr D Sammon would liaise with the Scrutiny Officer to bring forward the Looked after Children report and to provide further detail on what they would like included in the report.
Councillor D Sammon left the Meeting at 10.00 am.
Also do you consider single parent adopters Councillor Sammon thanked Angela for the report and the work the team carry out, he also thanked anyone who adopts because as a father and a grandfather it is quite distressing that 244 children have been referred for adoption · 86 children were placed for adoption during the year, 23% of the placements made were for children in sibling groups. How many families are out there that foster rather than going down the adoption route and how many foster parents go on to adopt · The report lists one of the team’s priorities is to drive up the conversion rate of adopter enquiry to application with the intention of increasing the rate of adopter approvals. Can you provide the committee with details off what systems have been put in place to improve this process The Chair thanked Angela for her attendance and again highlighted the need for more regular reporting to allow the committee to scrutinise.
The Chair raised the issue around the local authority and outside agencies reporting crimes and it was agreed that Councillor Sammon will take it forward.
(a) The Committee receive by the next Meeting a copy of the Recovery Plan (b) A Recovery Board be set up with the Terms of Reference and Membership to be agreed by both Parties Councillor D Sammon did not vote on the recommendations as he had Declared his Interest in this Item.
The Planning Officer introduced the item and provided the committee with the background in relation to the application and also explained that additional concerns had been raised by a local resident and by Councillor Sammon.
Councillor D Sammon presented the report to Committee.
Councillors A Barry and K Gibbs congratulated Councillor D Sammon and the Task and Finish Group for the work undertaken. Resolved that:
Councillor J Amos, Councillor D Sammon, Councillor A Barry, Councillor D Jones, Councillor G Lewis and Councillor S Jago having Declared their Interest in this item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
The Head of Service, Mark Anderton requested a meeting with Councillor D Sammon to discuss in greater detail the issues that were highlighted in his questioning · What if a complainant who has previous complaints upheld believes that this has resulted in the local authority holding grudges over the complainant, which results in poor service, can that complaint be escalated to stage 2 immediately RESOLVED that:
Councillor D Sammon having Declared his Interest in this Item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
Councillor D Sammon having Declared his Interest in this Item left the Meeting for the consideration of this item.
Councillor D Sammon then stated that he was a Council representative on the Leisure Trust.
Councillor D Sammon left the Meeting ... view the full minutes text for item 493.
Councillor D Sammon echoed the Chairs thoughts in relation to the Wellbeing reports as he had raised the same issues as Chair of Neighbourhood Services, Planning and Countryside.
The Monitoring Officer advised that Councillor G Thomas and Councillor D Sammon had Dispensation as the Council’s Representatives on the Merthyr Tydfil Leisure Trust.
The two Scrutiny Chairs within the Independent Group are Councillor T Skinner for Governance and Councillor D Sammon for Neighbourhood Services.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Sammon attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Sammon's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Sammon was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 5 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Sammon declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Sep 2025 | Cabinet, item 14 | Councillor D Sammon declared an interest in Item 10 – Instrument of Government – Ty Dysgu as he currently sits on the management committee of Dy Dy sgu . | |
| 1 Mar 2021 | Scrutiny : Neighbourhood Services, Planning and Countryside, item 438 | Councillor Declan Sammon declared a personal interest in Item 5 (Community Asset Transfer) as his community group has a number of leases through Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council. | |
| 30 Sep 2019 | Scrutiny : Joint Committee, item 350 | Councillor Declan Sammon declared his interest in Ref. No. 9 (Cent BC 4). |
Where Councillor Sammon sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 3 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Full Council | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 3 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Planning, Regulatory and Licensing | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 2 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Governance and Audit Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 1 | 14 Dec 2026 |
| Scrutiny : Joint Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2019 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.