Submitted by County Councillor Lisa Dymock
Councillor Dymock accepted the amendment and upon being put to a vote Council resolve to accept the motion.
Every time Monmouthshire's minutes name Councillor Dymock, as the council published it.
Councillor Dymock accepted the amendment and upon being put to a vote Council resolve to accept the motion.
Councillor Dymock thanked the school, governors, parents and pupils who had raised concerns and said the volume of correspondence she had received demonstrated the scale of the problem. She stressed that the issue was not whether parents of out-of-catchment pupils should receive free transport, but whether children could get to school safely, reliably and at an appropriate time.
Councillor Dymock questioned the accuracy of monitoring which had suggested passengers could board the X74, given the very different experiences reported by parents and pupils. She asked what would be done to address this apparent flaw in the data.
Councillor Lucas was proposed by Councillor Brown and seconded by Councillor Dymock.
Councillor Dymock was proposed by Councillor Lucas and seconded by Councillor Brown.
There were no other nominations; Councillor Dymock was appointed.
Councillor Dymock requested that school transport be added to the work programme. She said this was becoming a significant issue for residents and wanted scrutiny to examine the operation, accessibility and reliability of school transport services, particularly the role of Newport Transport in providing transport for out-of-catchment pupils.
A review of the Home to School Transport Policy is already scheduled for January, but it was agreed that a separate meeting could be convened as a Special meeting in order to address the members’ and residents’ concerns specifically. – ACTION Councillor Dymock requested a future item on Environmental Health reporting processes, explaining that both residents and councillors were experiencing difficulties submitting video evidence when reporting problems because there was no straightforward mechanism for uploading larger files. She suggested scrutiny should explore how the process could be improved. The suggestion was noted as a potential future work programme item.
– ACTION Councillor Dymock also requested a future discussion with Welsh Water, particularly its operational team. She referred to two recent burst water mains in Portskewett that had resulted in loss of water supply and road closures, arguing that scrutiny should hear directly from the organisation about service resilience and operational performance. The request was noted for consideration as a future committee item. – ACTION
As a supplementary Councillor Dymock asked if the Cabinet Member believed it to be acceptable for residents to continue using a road in such poor condition?
The officer also explained that delivery groups, likely mirroring the steering groups, will play a key role in maintaining engagement and that the most effective way to sustain participation is through the delivery of individual projects, which naturally engage residents and businesses Councillor Dymock asked how community engagement will be maintained and evolve throughout the delivery of the Placemaking Plans, expressing concern that public participation might diminish over time. She requested clarification on what specific metrics and ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor Dymock asked how more stallholders could be encouraged to attend Caldicot market, noting its accessibility and suggesting that the lack of a structure or cover might be a barrier. She enquired about the possibility of a temporary structure in the town centre to increase footfall and attract more traders. She suggested collaboration with Caldicot Town Team for storage solutions, as they have premises near the church, and mentioned that improved advertising by both the County Council and members could help make the market more vibrant.
Councillor Dymock asked about the Mystery Shopper initiative:
Councillor Dymock also asked about confidence in the accuracy and completeness of crime and incident data, especially regarding public reports and 101 call logging. She raised concerns that repeated incidents may not be accurately captured, affecting the neighbourhood police team's ability ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor Dymock added that by integrating remote and in-person participation into a seamless environment, we will be future-proofing our Council Chamber and enhancing the quality of debate. The features such as real time voting displays, clear speaker identification, and improvements to the live stream, will elevate the experience of all involved. The investment and modernisation will support greater accountability and visibility of the Council's proceedings.
As a supplementary Councillor Dymock referred to the condition of Caldicot Skate Park and Chepstow Skate Park.
Councillor Dymock was proposed by Councillor Brown, seconded by Councillor Lucas.
There were no other nominations, Councillor Dymock was appointed as Vice-Chair.
Councillor Dymock, Councillor Murphy as substitute.
The amendment was accepted by Councillor Dymock and debate ensued.
As a supplementary Councillor Dymock wished to discuss in more depth the accessibility for elderly residents, adding that newspaper adverts would be key.
As a supplementary Councillor Dymock expressed that the team at Caldicot Leisure Centre were exceptional. She referred to the skate park and asked what is happening in terms of repair works.
As a supplementary question, Councillor Dymock commented that doesn't help many women who want to return to the workplace and continue of their career with young children, so given the financial pressures on families and the tough barriers women must overcome to manage returning to work and managing caregiving, she asked the Cabinet Member to acknowledge the issue highlighted that women face in Wales, and across Monmouthshire, and accept it is holding women back from returning to work and add an increased pressure to those trying to manage work and caregiving?
Councillor Dymock noted that since submitting the question, the Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Planning and Economic Development had met with her on site and had addressed some of the concerns. She thanked him for his time.
He added that residents and Councillor Dymock are absolutely right to want the land to be in as good condition as soon as possible at the point of transfer. On site a landscaped area with a wonderful view was pointed out that has been surrounded by builders, rubble etc.
Councillor Dymock welcomed the opportunity for another site visit and asked for an introduction to the maintenance company who are going to be taking on the open areas.
Officers will keep County Councillor Dymock updated on progress. A site visit with the relevant Highways Team may be beneficial.
Councillor Dymock asked if updates could be provided via the MyMonmouthshire App.
Asking a supplementary question, County Councillor Dymock noted that residents are paying a significant fee and expect to receive the full number of collections. Whilst understanding the extra Christmas tree collections, the perception is that missed collections represent a loss of value for money. Unavoidable disruptions must be clearly communicated with practical solutions in advance.
Councillor Dymock asked if consideration could be given to provision of an additional collection for the residents affected.
As a supplementary question, County Councillor Dymock requested an update on the current welfare status of the dogs seized and how many have been domestically rehomed and plans for those not rehomed. The Cabinet Member was unable to provide any information due to the current legal proceedings.
Councillor Strong suggested that the age of the county is factored into the Placemaking Plans and Councillor Dymock suggested that Town and Community Councils are invited to participate as well .
Councillor Dymock stated that the consultation on the proposed changes was poorly timed and did not adequately inform or engage affected families as it took place in the summer holidays, when families are not in their usual routines. This reduced significantly the likelihood that parents or guardians would have had the time to engage fully with the process, and many families might not have even been aware that the consultation was taking place.
Councillor Dymock sought clarity as to whether the Equality Impact Assessment was published at the same time as the consultation; if not, she argued this would have limited the ability of respondents to fully assess the implications of the proposals and would undermine the transparency of the consultation.
Councillor Dymock : Councillor Dymock expressed concerns about the suitability of proposed sites for Gypsy and Traveller accommodations, highlighting issues such as noise pollution, land contamination, and lack of amenities. She raised concerns about the concentration of three of these sites being located all within one mile and concerns around the dual site proposal and the many challenges that creates.?She emphasised the historical significance of the area and potential ecological impacts, including the presence of protected species, as reasons against the development of certain sites. She mentioned the lack of safe access and egress, especially for large vehicles, and the absence of nearby amenities as challenges for the proposed sites.
Councillor Dymock criticised the consultation process, arguing that it did not adequately consider community feedback or engage effectively with the Gypsy and Traveller community, and expressed disappointment at the timing and the way information was presented to the public. She suggested exploring alternative solutions, such as collaborating with neighbouring authorities, enhancing existing sites with Welsh Government funding, and reconsidering the selection process for new sites. The reliability and transparency of the RAG ratings and the rationale for accepting or rejecting certain sites was questioned, and she emphasised the need for a transparent and inclusive process that takes all stakeholders along the journey.
Councillor Dymock proposed that the committee recommend Option 4.
Following the Place Scrutiny Committee meeting, any points made and those raised by Councillor Dymock, will be taken into account in a report for a Special Cabinet meeting on the 21st August 2024. If there is Cabinet support for this proposal, it will be included in the RLDP which, in October, Council will be asked to accept as the basis for public consultation throughout November and December.
Councillor Lucas was elected, proposed by Councillor Dymock and seconded by Councillor Brown.
Councillor Dymock was appointed, proposed by Councillor Brown, seconded by Councillor Davies.
The minutes were confirmed, proposed by Councillor Dymock and seconded by Councillor Strong.
In response County Councillor Dymock welcomed further conversations regarding the use of the Crick Road. https://www.youtube.com/live/YrqGJZgQOOw?si=NFv0Ch3wixhdCXog&t=2390
Councillor Dymock declared an interest, as two sites are in her ward.
Councillor Dymock spoke as the Call-in Lead, detailing the reasons for calling in the decision, as stated in the Call-in request. Cabinet Member Martyn Groucutt responded to the points of the call-in and Joanne Chase, Deputy Monitoring Officer provided clarification on the legality of the Section 106 agreement.
Councillor Dymock was nominated by Councillor Davies, seconded by Councillor Lucas.
Councillor Lucas was nominated by Councillor Dymock, seconded by Councillor Davies.
Councillor Dymock declared a personal non-prejudicial interest as the former Cabinet Member for Social Justice and Community Wellbeing, which covered Levelling Up.
Caldicot Town Council extended an invitation to County Councillor Dymock to attend the next meeting of the Caldicot Multi-Agency Problem Solving Group.
As a supplementary County Councillor Dymock welcomed the invitation and extended her support for future improvements.
Councillor Dymock declared an interest in the Castle Meadows petition, as the former Cabinet member for MonLife , and having met with Friends of Castle Meadows.
Strong Communities was proposed by Councillor Dymock, seconded by Councillor Lucas.
Jones was unavailable to provide a response Councillor Dymock agreed to accept a written response, a copy of which would be distributed to all Members.
It was agreed that Councillor Dymock would be vice-chair.
Further information as to the type of screening which is a concern provided by Tony Crowhurst via Councillor Dymock will be very welcome and included in considerations henceforth.
County Councillors Treharne, Davies and Batrouni left the meeting at 18:22pm, County Councillor Becker left the meeting at 18:30pm County Councillor Dymock left the meeting at 18:39pm
The Cabinet member also suggested that Councillor Dymock agrees to add the matter to the Strong Communities Select Committee Work Programme.
Councillor Dymock agreed to write to the PCC o behalf of MAGCP.
Councillor Dymock requested clarity on dealing with unpleasant or aggressive behaviours from certain members of the public. Members agreed this to be significant matter, and were advised that WLGA have issued safety documents which would be distributed. Personal safety training sessions are to be arranged.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Dymock attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 Mar 2026 | County Council | Council Tax Resolution and Revenue and Capital Budgets for 2026/27 | 22 for, 22 against, 1 abstained | ||
| 5 Mar 2026 | County Council | Capital Strategy and 2026/27 Treasury Management Strategy | Carried | 25 for, 20 against | |
| 23 Oct 2025 | County Council | Deposit Local Development Plan Submission | Lost | 20 for, 25 against | |
| 23 Oct 2025 | County Council | Deposit Local Development Plan Submission | 22 for, 22 against | ||
| 6 Mar 2025 | County Council | Council Tax Resolution | Carried | 22 for, 21 against, 1 abstained | |
| 24 Oct 2024 | County Council | Deposit Replacement Local Development Plan | Carried | 21 for, 20 against, 1 abstained | |
| 24 Oct 2024 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor Meirion Howells | Carried | 24 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 24 Oct 2024 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor Howells | Carried | 22 for, 1 against, 0 abstained | |
| 18 Jul 2024 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor Lisa Dymock | Lost | 18 for, 23 against, 0 abstained | |
| 18 Jul 2024 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor Richard John | Lost | 16 for, 22 against, 1 abstained | |
| 7 Dec 2023 | County Council | Relocation of pupil referral service south monmouthshire | Carried | 23 for, 21 against, 0 abstained | |
| 26 Oct 2023 | County Council | Replacement local development plan (rldp) preferred strategy | Carried | 23 for, 22 against, 1 abstained | |
| 26 Oct 2023 | County Council | From County Councillor Frances Taylor to County Councillor Catrin Maby, Cabinet Member for Climate Change and Environment | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Sep 2023 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor Alistair Neill | Lost | 21 for, 22 against, 0 abstained | |
| 22 Jun 2023 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor Richard John | Lost | 15 for, 23 against, 2 abstained | |
| 23 Jun 2022 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor Frances Taylor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Dec 2020 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor F. Taylor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Oct 2020 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor D. Batrouni | Lost | 10 for, 20 against, 1 abstained | |
| 10 Sep 2020 | County Council | To elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2020/21 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Mar 2020 | County Council | Treasury policy and strategy 2020-21 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Mar 2020 | County Council | Safeguarding evaluation report april 2018 - march 2019 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Mar 2020 | County Council | Budget decision - flood recovery response | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Sep 2019 | County Council | Corporate Plan Annual Report 2018/19 | Carried | 21 for, 8 against, 4 abstained | |
| 19 Sep 2019 | County Council | Capital Programme - 21st Century Schools Programme | Carried | 13 for, 21 against, 1 abstained | |
| 19 Sep 2019 | County Council | Submitted by County Councillor D Batrouni | Lost | 8 for, 13 against | |
| 20 Jun 2019 | County Council | From County Councillor P. Fox | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2019 | County Council | From County Councillor F. Taylor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2019 | County Council | From County Councillor D. Batrouni | Lost | 9 for, 22 against, 2 abstained | |
| 14 May 2019 | County Council | To elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2019/20 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Jul 2018 | County Council | Governance arrangements for proposed alternative delivery model for tourism, culture, leisure and youth | Carried | 28 for, 9 against | |
| 26 Jul 2018 | County Council | From County Councillor D. Batrouni | Lost | 15 for, 22 against |
Meetings Councillor Dymock was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 36 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Dymock declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Oct 2023 | Place Scrutiny Committee, item 1 | Councillor Dymock declared an interest, as two sites are in her ward. | |
| 25 May 2023 | Place Scrutiny Committee, item 3 | Councillor Dymock declared a personal non-prejudicial interest as the former Cabinet Member for Social Justice and Community Wellbeing, which covered Levelling Up. | |
| 30 Jun 2022 | Place Scrutiny Committee, item 3 | Councillor Dymock declared an interest in the Castle Meadows petition, as the former Cabinet member for MonLife , and having met with Friends of Castle Meadows. |
Where Councillor Dymock sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| County Council | Committee Member | May 2017 | 93 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Members' Seminars | Committee Member | May 2017 | 69 | |
| Place Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 37 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Democratic Services Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 21 | 14 Dec 2026 |
| Severnside Area Forum | Committee Member | Feb 2023 | 16 | 7 Jan 2027 |
| People Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2024 | 2 | |
| Strong Communities Select Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 38 | |
| Adults Select Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 25 | |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee NO LONGER IN USE | Committee Member | May 2022 | 18 | |
| Joint Select Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2017 | 14 | |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Oct 2020 | 13 | |
| Severnside Area Committee (2020) | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 11 | |
| Public Services Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2019 | 7 | |
| Children and Young People Select Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2017 | 5 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2017 | 3 | |
| Economy and Development Select Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2017 | 3 | |
| Standards Committee | Guest | Mar 2018 | 1 | |
| Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.