CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Monmouthshire/Councillor County Councillor Simon Howarth
CH

Councillor County Councillor Simon Howarth

Monmouthshire CouncilLlanelly Hill wardIndependentCouncillor since 2004
Follow Councillor Howarth's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
59%meetings attended261 of 440 since 2004, apologies 48
42times in the minutesAsked 4, said 21, moved 2, seconded 2
37recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
0declarations at meetingsInterests declared on agenda items
6committees in the last year19 committees in all

On the record

Every time Monmouthshire's minutes name Councillor Howarth, as the council published it.

Said18 Jun 2026People Scrutiny Committee

People Scrutiny Committee Forward Work Programme and Action List

Councillor Howarth requested that a future report be tabled on Domiciliary Care services in the north of the county. He also requested the Housing Allocations Policy and the Rural Allocations Policy be added to the work programme.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 18 Jun 2026, item 7Open the meeting
Said24 Feb 2026People Scrutiny Committee

Council and Cabinet Forward Work Programme

Councillor Howarth raised concerns about items being added to the planner after meetings, potentially missing scrutiny opportunities, and highlighted past issues with items like Tudor Street and County of Sanctuary not being properly tracked or included. Hazel Ilett clarified that the planner is updated live and accessible via the Council hub, and that scrutiny chairs and the team receive email notifications when new items are added. She encouraged members to check the planner regularly and noted the safeguard for scrutiny involvement.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 24 Feb 2026, item 7Open the meeting
Named24 Feb 2026People Scrutiny Committee

Council and Cabinet Forward Work Programme

The committee discussed the need for more advance notice and transparency, with Councillor Howarth emphasizing that last-minute additions undermine effective scrutiny and requesting improvements in planner management. Hazel explained the planner's new features, including date stamps for item additions and the requirement for officers to indicate scrutiny relevance, aiming for earlier and clearer planning. Members agreed to keep monitoring the planner, ensure items are not redacted, and maintain oversight of upcoming topics, including the Youth Service and Public Library Strategy.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 24 Feb 2026, item 7Open the meeting
Asked30 Sep 2025People Scrutiny Committee

Community Meals - Scrutiny of an approach to ensure a good quality and sustainable service model for Community Meals

·          Councillor Howarth asked whether the benchmarking for service costs included only Torfaen or also other similar rural authorities like Denbighshire, noting that Monmouthshire’s rural nature could affect costs and comparability. He highlighted the significant cost difference with Torfaen and questioned if a more similar comparator had been used.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 30 Sep 2025, item 4Open the meeting
Named30 Sep 2025People Scrutiny Committee

Community Meals - Scrutiny of an approach to ensure a good quality and sustainable service model for Community Meals

It was confirmed that in the next phase, comparisons would be expanded to include more similar authorities like Denbighshire, as suggested by Councillor Howarth, to ensure more relevant benchmarking.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 30 Sep 2025, item 4Open the meeting
Said30 Sep 2025People Scrutiny Committee

People Scrutiny Forward Work Programme and Action List

Councillor Howarth raised the Tudor Street lease and next steps.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 30 Sep 2025, item 6Open the meeting
Said30 Sep 2025People Scrutiny Committee

People Scrutiny Forward Work Programme and Action List

Councillor Howarth requested the item be added to forward work planner.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 30 Sep 2025, item 6Open the meeting
Named22 Jul 2025People Scrutiny Committee

Council and Cabinet Work Planner

Noted, Councillor Howarth highlighting the need for the planner to be updated to avoid potential calling-in of decisions.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 22 Jul 2025, item 9Open the meeting
Said17 Jun 2025People Scrutiny Committee

Play Sufficiency Assessment Report - To conduct pre-decision scrutiny of the report.

·        Councillor Howarth expressed concern about the lack of facilities for children to play sports during the winter in rural areas, specifically mentioning the need for 3G or 4G playing areas. He emphasised the importance of listening to children about what they want for play facilities, rather than deciding for them. He highlighted the success of the play facilities in Gilwern, noting that it was based on what the children wanted, and stressed the importance of consulting directly with children in other areas.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 17 Jun 2025, item 7Open the meeting
Said15 May 2025County Council

From County Councillor Simon Howarth to the Cabinet Member for Climate Change and the Environment

As a supplementary Councillor Howarth expressed disappointment in the response and asked if the Cabinet Member would issue an apology? The Cabinet Member explained that this was not a political decision but a necessary officer decision which the officer has apologised for not consulting on beforehand.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 15 May 2025, item 13Open the meeting
Asked15 May 2025County Council

From County Councillor Simon Howarth to the Cabinet Member for Climate Change and the Environment

As a supplementary Councillor Howarth asked why litter bins were being removed and not replaced without members, the public and local councillors being informed.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 15 May 2025, item 14Open the meeting
Named15 May 2025County Council

From County Councillor Simon Howarth to the Cabinet Member for Climate Change and the Environment

She asked that Councillor Howarth contact her with details of litter bins that needed replacing.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 15 May 2025, item 14Open the meeting
Said4 Mar 2025People Scrutiny Committee

Call In of the decision of Cabinet of 19th February 2025 regarding UK Shared Prosperity Fund 2025/26

Councillor Howarth:   ·         Councillor Howarth felt there was a lack of transparency about the Shared Prosperity Fund application process and insufficient scrutiny overall .?   ·         H e e mphasised the need for long-term viability and business cases for  ...  view the full minutes text for item 2.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 4 Mar 2025, item 2Open the meeting
Said1 Dec 2023People Scrutiny Committee

Call-in of the decision by Cabinet of 15th November 2023 in relation to developing the future of My Day My Life Bases.

Councillor Howarth also outlined his reasons for the call-in.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 1 Dec 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said10 Nov 2022Place Scrutiny Committee

Discussion on the Committee's Forward Work Programme

Councillor Howarth noted that in the investment committee this week there was discussion of a paper being brought to full council soon about the county’s broadband – this might help to inform the discussion and answer some questions.
From the council's minutes: Place Scrutiny Committee, 10 Nov 2022, item 5Open the meeting
Seconded4 Nov 2021County Council

Submitted by County Councillor A. Watts

County Councillor Howarth seconded the amendment. Debate ensued.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 4 Nov 2021, item 12Open the meeting
Named24 Jun 2021County Council

Monmouthshire replacement local development plan preferred strategy

County Councillor Howarth left at 16:34 County Councillor Dimitri Batrouni declared a non-prejudicial interest as a board member of Monmouthshire Housing Association. He referred to the phosphate issue being a significant problem. The officer that explained that they are making good progress with proactive discussions with stakeholders.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 24 Jun 2021, item 7Open the meeting
Named25 May 2021Adults Select Committee

To note the appointment of County Councillor S. Howarth as Chair

Councillor Howarth was proposed by Councillor Woodhouse and seconded by Councillor Brown.
From the council's minutes: Adults Select Committee, 25 May 2021, item 1Open the meeting
Moved13 May 2021County Council

Appointments to Committees

County Councillor Howarth proposed County Councillor David Jones as Chair of Democratic Services Committee, seconded by County Councillor Blakebrough.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 13 May 2021, item 8Open the meeting
Said14 Sep 2020Investment Committee

Assessment of commercial risk appetite

Councillor Howarth raised concerns around risks around grant funding and asked that officers come back for further discussion if full grant funding becomes available. It was confirmed that would be the case, and if a scheme comes forward with a potential of grant funding for commercial investment this would be brought through Investment Committee. Where there may be a case that does not require the Council to match fund, this may be a matter Council and Cabinet rather than Investment Committee.
From the council's minutes: Investment Committee, 14 Sep 2020, item 2Open the meeting
Said14 Sep 2020Investment Committee

Assessment of commercial risk appetite

Councillor Howarth agreed that this would be suitable for the short term and asked to see a list off assets under consideration.
From the council's minutes: Investment Committee, 14 Sep 2020, item 2Open the meeting
Named10 Sep 2020County Council

To elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2020/21

Councillor Howarth endorsed the comments of the Leader, adding that Councillor Woodhouse is well respected and has led our Council well through this difficult period.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 10 Sep 2020, item 2Open the meeting
Named16 Jul 2020County Council

Submitted by County Councillor V. Smith

The motion was seconded by County Councillor Howarth, who added his support based on the aspirations of the Council.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 16 Jul 2020, item 7bOpen the meeting
Seconded19 Sep 2019County Council

Capital Programme - 21st Century Schools Programme

The amendment was seconded by Councillor Howarth and debate followed.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 19 Sep 2019, item 7aOpen the meeting
Named17 Jan 2019County Council

To note the County Council Action List

Councillor Howarth referred to a petition relating to Dan Y Coed , Clydach presented on 10 th May 2018, and how the matter is still to be resolved.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 17 Jan 2019, item 11Open the meeting
Said20 Dec 2018County Council

Chairman's announcement and receipt of petitions

Councillor Howarth requested that responses to petitions are reported back to Council.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 20 Dec 2018, item 3Open the meeting
Said21 Jun 2018County Council

To note the County Council Action List

In doing so Councillor Howarth expressed disappointment at the length of time it has taken to receive a response from Monmouthshire Housing Association. He stated that he had agreed to the housing stock transfer on the basis that tenant’s needs would be looked after, and that queries would be addressed.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 21 Jun 2018, item 9Open the meeting
Named21 Jun 2018County Council

To note the County Council Action List

Councillor Howarth did not believe this to now be the case and would not continue support MHA.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 21 Jun 2018, item 9Open the meeting
Asked10 May 2018County Council

To receive the County Council Action list

Councillor Howarth questioned if there was a response to a petition he had previously presented regarding Monmouthshire Housing issues in Clyddach , and Welsh Government and the Heads of the Valleys road. The Deputy Chief Executive advised that she had not received a response to a formal letter written to MHA and would re-establish contact, and report back to Council with a response.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 10 May 2018, item 6Open the meeting
Named10 May 2018County Council

Appointments to Outside Bodies

Cllr Pavia to replace Cllr Howarth.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 10 May 2018, item 10Open the meeting
Asked6 Mar 2018County Council

Well-being Plan and Area Plan

Jones left the meeting at 12:30 Councillor Howarth asked if it was possible that while endorsing the plan, Council agree that the EQIA is placed at the start of the document rather than the end of the report, to allow a greater understanding.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 6 Mar 2018, item 9aOpen the meeting
Said18 Jan 2018County Council

To receive the action list of the meeting held on 14th December 2017

Councillor Howarth expressed dismay that representation from this Council at Monmouthshire Housing Association are unable to refer to issues raised by Council. He asked that Councillors are provided with a briefing list of responsibilities on Outside Bodies, and what can be expected of them in that role. The Chief Executive Officer agreed to issue a note on this to provide clarity.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 18 Jan 2018, item 7Open the meeting
Said14 Dec 2017County Council

Chairman's announcement and receipt of petitions

Councillor Howarth presented a petition on behalf of residents of Dan-Y- Coed , Clydach   who requested a full investigation regarding the embankment being constructed behind Dan-Y- Coed bungalows, which had been constructed without consultation.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 14 Dec 2017, item 3Open the meeting
Said14 Dec 2017County Council

City Deal

Councillor Howarth requested that should an MCC officer be successful, that position should be replaced as soon as possible.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 14 Dec 2017, item 9aOpen the meeting
Said9 Nov 2017County Council

11th September 2017

Councillor Howarth requested clarification regarding the issue of the new IT equipment to Members. Chief Executive to respond in writing.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 9 Nov 2017, item 7bOpen the meeting
Said9 Nov 2017County Council

Recycling Review - Final Business Case, approval of capital expenditure on vehicles and boxes

Councillor Howarth expressed thanks to the residents of Monmouthshire for reaching the recycling target. He questioned why the report had not been scrutinised by Select Committee. In response to a comment regarding the increase of number of vehicles, the Head of Operations added that the new vehicles would be needed regardless of the outcome of the debate.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 9 Nov 2017, item 10aOpen the meeting
Named18 May 2017County Council

County Council - 20th March 2017

In doing so Councillor Howarth referred to a petition relating to public rights of way at118 ,   Clydach Gorge, Gilwern and Llanelli Hill. He expressed disappointment that to date no response had been received . The Deputy Chief Executive agreed to look into the matter following the meeting.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 18 May 2017, item 5bOpen the meeting
Named18 May 2017County Council

Representation of Political Groups-Review

Councillor Howarth referred to previoys discussions surrounding select committees and asked that they be reviewed in 12 months, with regards to attendance. The Leader recognised the importance of continuity, and added that Democratic Services Committee may wish to consider adding a review as part of their work programme In response to a request for clarity regarding substitutions at meetings, we heard that Group Leaders could advise of a substitution up to one hour prior to the meeting. It was noted that this would not be the case with Planning Committee due to the requirement for statutory training.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 18 May 2017, item 7Open the meeting
Said20 Mar 2017County Council

Wales Audit Office Report on Safeguarding within the Kerbcraft Scheme in Monmouthshire County Council

Councillor Howarth requested clarification surrounding the grant for Kerbcraft from Welsh Government, and asked why this had not been itemised.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 20 Mar 2017, item 8aOpen the meeting
Said19 Jan 2017County Council

To confirm the minutes of the meeting held on 1st December 2016

Councillor Howarth requested information on the progress of the petition presented to Council 1 st December 2016. The Chief Executive agreed to follow this up.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 19 Jan 2017, item 5Open the meeting
Moved20 Oct 2016County Council

Zero Hour Contracts

County Councillor Howarth proposed a motion that the Audit Committee look at the zero hour contracts within Monmouthshire County Council, and a report be presented to Council at the earliest time possible. The motion was duly seconded.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 20 Oct 2016, item 9aOpen the meeting
Said21 Jan 2016County Council

Revenue and Capital Budget 2016/17 - final proposals following budget consultation

In presenting the amendment County Councillor Howarth highlighted the following regarding mandat es:
From the council's minutes: County Council, 21 Jan 2016, item 8aOpen the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Howarth attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
5 Mar 2026County CouncilCouncil Tax Resolution and Revenue and Capital Budgets for 2026/2722 for, 22 against, 1 abstained
5 Mar 2026County CouncilCapital Strategy and 2026/27 Treasury Management StrategyCarried25 for, 20 against
23 Oct 2025County CouncilDeposit Local Development Plan SubmissionLost20 for, 25 against
23 Oct 2025County CouncilDeposit Local Development Plan Submission22 for, 22 against
6 Mar 2025County CouncilCouncil Tax ResolutionCarried22 for, 21 against, 1 abstained
24 Oct 2024County CouncilDeposit Replacement Local Development PlanCarried21 for, 20 against, 1 abstained
24 Oct 2024County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Meirion HowellsCarried24 for, 0 against, 0 abstained
24 Oct 2024County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor HowellsCarried22 for, 1 against, 0 abstained
18 Jul 2024County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Lisa DymockLost18 for, 23 against, 0 abstained
18 Jul 2024County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Richard JohnLost16 for, 22 against, 1 abstained
7 Dec 2023County CouncilRelocation of pupil referral service south monmouthshireCarried23 for, 21 against, 0 abstained
26 Oct 2023County CouncilReplacement local development plan (rldp) preferred strategyCarried23 for, 22 against, 1 abstained
26 Oct 2023County CouncilFrom County Councillor Frances Taylor to County Councillor Catrin Maby, Cabinet Member for Climate Change and EnvironmentCarriedUnanimous
21 Sep 2023County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Alistair NeillLost21 for, 22 against, 0 abstained
22 Jun 2023County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Richard JohnLost15 for, 23 against, 2 abstained
23 Jun 2022County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Frances TaylorCarriedUnanimous
1 Oct 2021County CouncilAppointment of Chief Officer Social Care, Safeguarding & HealthCarriedUnanimous
3 Dec 2020County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor F. TaylorCarriedUnanimous
22 Oct 2020County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor D. BatrouniLost10 for, 20 against, 1 abstained
10 Sep 2020County CouncilTo elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2020/21CarriedUnanimous
5 Mar 2020County CouncilTreasury policy and strategy 2020-21CarriedUnanimous
5 Mar 2020County CouncilSafeguarding evaluation report april 2018 - march 2019CarriedUnanimous
5 Mar 2020County CouncilBudget decision - flood recovery responseCarriedUnanimous
19 Sep 2019County CouncilCorporate Plan Annual Report 2018/19Carried21 for, 8 against, 4 abstained
19 Sep 2019County CouncilCapital Programme - 21st Century Schools ProgrammeCarried13 for, 21 against, 1 abstained
19 Sep 2019County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor D BatrouniLost8 for, 13 against
20 Jun 2019County CouncilFrom County Councillor P. FoxCarriedUnanimous
20 Jun 2019County CouncilFrom County Councillor F. TaylorCarriedUnanimous
20 Jun 2019County CouncilFrom County Councillor D. BatrouniLost9 for, 22 against, 2 abstained
14 May 2019County CouncilTo elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2019/20CarriedUnanimous
26 Jul 2018County CouncilGovernance arrangements for proposed alternative delivery model for tourism, culture, leisure and youthCarried28 for, 9 against
26 Jul 2018County CouncilFrom County Councillor D. BatrouniLost15 for, 22 against
8 May 2018County CouncilTo elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2018/19CarriedUnanimous
20 Mar 2017County CouncilAppointment of chief officer, children and young peopleCarriedUnanimous
25 Jan 2017North Monmouthshire Area CommitteeArea Capital GrantsCarriedUnanimous
8 Jun 2016County CouncilAppointment of the Chief Officer, Resources.CarriedUnanimous
12 May 2016County CouncilAppointment of Democratic Services Committee and appointment of Chairman of the CommitteeCarriedUnanimous
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Howarth was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

County Council
88 of 111
Members' Seminars
2 of 58
People Scrutiny Committee
19 of 34
Taxi and Regulatory Committee
2 of 7
Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee
3 of 4
Licensing and Gambling Committee
0 of 2
Cabinet
37 of 50
Licensing and Regulatory Committee NO LONGER IN USE
22 of 34
Adults Select Committee
19 of 24
Strong Communities Select Committee
20 of 23
North Monmouthshire Area Committee
8 of 23
Joint Select Committee
11 of 21
Public Services Scrutiny Committee
7 of 13
Children and Young People Select Committee
6 of 12
Investment Committee
6 of 10
Place Scrutiny Committee
6 of 6
Democratic Services Committee
2 of 4
Economy and Development Select Committee
3 of 3
Central Mon Area Committee
0 of 1
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
+2
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 12 of 40 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Howarth declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

No declarations of interest by Councillor Howarth in the minutes read so far.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Howarth sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
County CouncilCommittee MemberSep 201511110 Dec 2026
Members' SeminarsCommittee MemberMay 201758
People Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJan 202334
Taxi and Regulatory CommitteeCommittee MemberJul 202578 Dec 2026
Performance and Overview Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJan 2024424 Nov 2026
Licensing and Gambling CommitteeCommittee MemberJul 2025215 Jan 2027
CabinetCommittee MemberNov 201550
Licensing and Regulatory Committee NO LONGER IN USECommittee MemberJul 201934
Adults Select CommitteeCommittee MemberFeb 201724
Strong Communities Select CommitteeCommittee MemberSep 201523
North Monmouthshire Area CommitteeCommittee MemberFeb 201623
Joint Select CommitteeCommittee MemberDec 201521
Public Services Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 201613
Children and Young People Select CommitteeCommittee MemberSep 201512
Investment CommitteeCommittee MemberOct 201910
Place Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberNov 20226
Democratic Services CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20164
Economy and Development Select CommitteeCommittee MemberJan 20163
Central Mon Area CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20161
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies