Application for other development - 25-27 well st & 82 garden st, newcastle. marshallsay. 26/00051/cou
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Jones and seconded by Councillor Tift.
Every time Newcastle-under-Lyme's minutes name Councillor Jones, as the council published it.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Jones and seconded by Councillor Tift.
Councillor Jones declared an interest in item 6 - as an employee of Harper & Keele Veterinary School but would take part in the debate. Also, a declaration of interest was made for item 10 – protecting green spaces as both of his children attended Madeley High School.
Councillor Jones raised concerns regarding appeals being delegate to the Chief Executive, particularly in terms of impartiality and whether the change would be ACAS compliant. Concerns were also raised regarding the questions time frame as they would have to be submitted before the Council agenda was available.
Name of Organisation / Role Representative Aspire Housing Board Cllr Renshaw Business Improvement District Cllr Gullis Campaign to Protect Rural England – County Branch Cllr Machin Corporate Parenting Panel Cllr Kasperowicz Local Councils Network Leader Visit Staffordshire Destination Management Partnership Leader Go Kidsgrove Cllr Westcott LGiU Assembly Cllr Rogerson Local Government Association Leader Newcastle Partnership (Local Strategic Partnership) Leader North Staffs Victim Support Cllr Renshaw Parking and Traffic Regulations Outside London (PATROL) Cllr Renshaw Sir John Offley Almshouse Trust Cllr Whitmore Staffordshire County Council Health and Care Overview and Scrutiny Committee Cllr Stevenson Staffordshire Leaders Board Leader Staffordshire Playing Fields Association Leader Staffordshire Police, Fire and Crime Panel and associated panels Cllr Shaw Stoke-on-Trent and North Staffordshire Theatre Trust Limited (New Victoria Theatre) Leader Stoke-on-Trent and Staffordshire Local Enterprise Partnership Leader Newcastle-under-Lyme Almshouse Association Ward Councillors West Midlands Employers Leader Waste and Mineral Site Liaison Committee – Acton Composting Site (Committee is Active) Cllr Lefroy Waste and Mineral Site Liaison Committee – Holditch House Waste Site Cllr Barber Waste and Mineral Site Liaison Committee – Keele (Madeley Heath) Quarry (Committee not yet Active) Cllr Bettley-Smith Cllr Whitmore Waste and Mineral Site Liaison Committee – Knutton Quarry
Councillor Dave Jones stated that Peter was a man of few words although, when engaged in conversation was a very generous person. It was a real testament to Peter that he had the fortitude and stamina to win the conference attendance award.
On behalf of his group, Councillor Jones sent condolences to the family.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that it was an honour to second the recommendation and stated that throughout his long connection to the Borough, Sir Ian had served for a significant period of time as pro-Chancellor and Chair of Keele University Council and the University owed him a great debt.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that the Labour group would be supporting the recommendations outlined in the report.
Councillor Jones stated that his preferred model since 2018 had been for a Newcastle-under-Lyme unitary authority to allow for more services to be run locally as it was in the best interests of residents. Becoming a unitary authority would break up the control from upper tier ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor Dave Jones left the meeting at 8.11pm The Deputy Leader of the Council introduced a report seeking the adoption of the draft Statement of Licensing Policy 2025-2030.
Councillor Dave Jones had called in this application and had requested to speak remotely due to a family commitment.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that the Constitution Working Group did some thorough work on this and the Labour group were pleased to endorse the report.
On paragraph 2 – Walleys Quarry Odour Issues Councillor Dave Jones stated that the Environment Agency (EA) made a better operator than regulator as issues had plummeted since they had been in control of the site. The Leader was asked if he agreed that this vindicated all along that the problems with the site had been down to a rogue operator who had been unable to manage the site properly.
Councillor Dave Jones also thanked the Council’s grass cutting team. He stated that the creation of a Countryside Park was a fantastic amenity and bringing in more manageable paths would make it even more useable. A significant issue at present was anti-social behaviour caused by dirt bikes going around and asked for a pledge that when the country park was established that it be ensured that all measures be taken to prevent the access of these vehicles.
Councillor Dave Jones stated, on behalf of the Labour Group that the news of Councillor Panter’s passing had hit everyone hard. He had made public service his life commitment and was a true gentleman. Best wishes were sent to the family.
An amendment had been submitted, proposed by Councillor Dave Jones and seconded by Councillor Fox-Hewitt. The amendment solely supported a Unitary Council model for Newcastle-under-Lyme.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that reorganisation was a once in a generation opportunity to reset council services and design better provision for residents. The formation of the new unitary councils came with the proposal of more devolved powers over various services. It would provide an opportunity to have a seat at the table of ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor Dave Jones echoed Councillor Adcock’s comments. He stated that he had been disappointed with comments made in recent election literature and asked the Leader if he agreed that the comments were factually inaccurate and harmed the long standing agreement that Walleys Quarry remained an issue that united all Members in seeking a resolution.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that it was critically important that Council secure legal action in response to breaches of the abatement notice. The landfill site had been a plague over the past month with a number of real high-odour days. The odour had landed on Keele Campus, causing several issues including affecting an open day with prospective students turning up on a day when the smell was horrendous.
Councillor Jones stated that Wendy had been a fantastic Councillor and vociferous supporter for Town Ward and all of its interests. Wendy was wished well, including congratulations on the birth of her first grandchild. The Leader wished to be associated with these comments.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that the impact of Walleys Quarry on residents had been the Council’s primary focus for several years and the odours continued to have a detrimental impact on people’s health. Public Health and the UK Health Security Agency had stated that the levels of H2S in the environment surrounding the site was of a concentration that would impact on human health, both physically and mentally.
Question from Councillor Dave Jones to the Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning “My question relates to action to be taken by the Council at 5 Boggs Cottages, where personal permission was granted, at appeal, for the landowner and family to reside at the site following discharge of a number of conditions. Under the appeal, the conditions of granting permission required discharge of drainage details, provisions for facilities for water and sewerage by the 20th March 2023. The Council has since refused to discharge these conditions.
Councillor Jones asked a supplementary question:
Advice would need to be taken from lawyers regarding that but gave an undertaking that he would put that question to them and would report back to Councillor Jones.
Cllr Jones asked about the 3.5% pay award budgeted which fell under what had been actually awarded for the third year in a row. – This was discussed every year with the Staffordshire Chief Finance Officer Group with insights of what was happening at national level.
Cllr Jones asked – going forward how could we avoid making the shortfall four years in a row. He was advised that assumptions could only be based on the information that was received.
Cllr Jones asked the Portfolio Holder for Finance, Town Centres and Growth about an item under issues at paragraph 3.3. An amber action flag for Walleys Quarry stated that the Council was awaiting permission from the Secretary of State.
Cllr Jones understood that permission had now been granted. The Portfolio Holder was asked if he was confident that there was enough money in the budget to undertake the legal proceedings. The Portfolio Holder confirmed that he was.
Cllr Jones referred to the table outlining £3.286m in sales over the year. The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Town Centres and Growth was asked to outline what they were and how much was yet to be realised. The Portfolio Holder advised that some had come from Aspire and money from the new energy site.
Cllr Jones stated that he had not seen a list of asset sales at this Committee, Council or on the Cabinet agenda and asked the Portfolio Holder if he could advise where the information was available for members. The Service Director -Finance (S151 Officer) clarified the question which was related to bigger sales or sales happening in the future. The information would come to this Committee in the form of a table showing what the Council was expecting to achieve against what had actually been achieved but the actual assets were not included in ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Cllr Jones seconded the proposal stating that the impact that something as big as this would have had on staff needed to be shown.
Councillor Dave Jones introduced an amendment to the report outlining issues that the Labour Group had identified with the recommendations. Following a debate on the amendment, a named vote was taken.
Councillor Dave Jones advised of changes to the Labour group membership on the Planning Committee as follows:
Cllr Jones declared being employed by Harper & Keele Veterinary School which formed part of Keele University which was referred to in the Local Plan.
Cllr Jones asked who was involved in the site selection process as well as how many of the 168 sites were green belt versus brown sites and how many brown sites were refused or not included.
Cllr Jones wondered if Cabinet members had been involved in the site selection.
Cllr Jones asked what the best practical means were to address the odours in conjunction with the Environment Agency and what kind of impact legal settlements on the previous abatement notice would have on these.
Cllr Jones asked about children with complex mental health needs.
Cllr Jones asked about breathing apparatus.
- Cllr John Williams (JW), who was proposed by Cllr Jones as second longest service member of the Council (29 years) having taking part in pretty much every single committee; the nomination was seconded by Councillor Fox-Hewitt.
COMMITTEE CHAIR VICE-CHAIR Audit and Standards Cllr Paul Waring Cllr Gill Burnett-Faulkner Conservation Advisory Cllr Trevor Johnson Cllr Lilian Barker Licensing and Public Protection Cllr Joan Whieldon Cllr Trevor Johnson Planning Cllr Paul Northcott Cllr Nick Crisp Health, Wellbeing and Environment Scrutiny Cllr Rupert Adcock Cllr Ian Wilkes Economy and Place Scrutiny Cllr Andrew Parker Cllr Robert Bettley-Smith Finance, Assets and Performance Scrutiny Cllr Mark Holland Cllr Amy Bryan The Mayor finally invited the Leader and Cllr Jones to speak on nominations to external organisations.
Cllr Jones wished for the list shared by Cabinet to be amended and nominated six labour Group members to fill the roles instead.
Councillor Jones stated that there had been a significant amount of activity on the site lately that had concerned residents. There was a commercial vehicle parked there plus a number of caravans. The owner had been non-compliant and the Council had said that they were going to take enforcement action but nothing had happened.
Councillor Dave Jones and interest on an item contained within the Leader’s Statement (‘Keele in Town’) as an employee of Keele University and would not take part in the debate on that item.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that his Group would be supporting this item and stated that it was a shame that it had reached the stage where the Council had to use its Abatement powers.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Jones.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Jones and seconded by Councillor Fear.
Cllr Jones declared being employed by Harper & Keele Veterinary School located next to Walleys Quarry.
- Cllr Jones thanked officers for the reports and wished for the raw figures to be reviewed and notably those pertaining to the odours as recorded on 25 th and 26 th November as well as 13 th , 14 th and 16 th December 2023. The health consequences were dramatic meeting the definitions of environmental harm.
- Cllr Bettley-Smith agreed with Cllr Jones and reiterated the risks of long term consequences on health of low level exposure to a poisonous gas such as hydrogen sulphide.
Cllr Jones presented the proposed motion of suspension of the operating license at Walleys Quarry and expressed his support towards amending the motion in favour of a full closure of the site.
Cllr Jones moved the motion which was then seconded by Cllr Fox-Hewitt who summarised it as follows:
Cllr Jones supported the suggestions. The Leader wished to stick with the amendment as presented to the Council and clarified the wording.
Cllr Jones drew members’ attention to two red lines in the amendment:
Cllr Jones expressed his disappointment at the way the amended motion was drafted whilst ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that there had been some concerns over appropriate scrutiny of the report and had considered a call-in. However, the all-members teams briefing had answered many of those concerns.
Councillor Jones stated that he would like to see more of those briefings taking place.
The Leader, Councillor Dave Jones, Councillor John Williams and Councillor Stephen Sweeney paid tribute to Martin who then responded with thanks.
Councillor Dave Jones stated that at least one polling station was being relocated back into a school and asked the Returning Officer if he would like to make a comment on what impact that would have on the pupils.
Councillor Dave Jones proposed an amendment to the list of recommendations to include the development of an Animal Welfare Charter for the Borough as the third bullet point.
- Cllr Jones asked about Appendix 1 and where the evidence came for figures relating to planning applications, commercial property rates and car parking. – Planning applications fees were based on the actual budget and estimate in light of the last three years of applications actually received. The fees would be uplifted by 25% for minor cases and 35% for major ones. The property rent of £70,000 had already been achieved by the Commercial Property Team and the rents for industrial units had not been touched since pre- Covid .
Details would be shared by email with Cllr Jones.
Councillor Dave Jones requested more information on the essential requirement of the Degree given that everything else was experiential. The Service Director stated that it was noted as a Degree or equivalent experience.
Councillor Dave Jones asked the Leader if the Secretary of State had given any reason for declining a simple request to hold a public enquiry into the failings of the Environment Agency (EA).
- Cllr Jones wondered about how confident Cabinet members and lead officers felt about Capital and Centric capacity to translate the sort of works carried out at Stoke-on-Trent to Newcastle which was a very different town. – The Deputy Chief Executive provided a list of other small towns where projects had been undertaken by the company also out of the city centre. The contractors were very excited about working with the Council and a good proposal was to be expected.
Cllr Jones requested that a copy of the proposal be shared with members.
- Cllr Jones asked how confident members should be that all aspects of the projects and with regard to all sites would be completed and what was the timeframe for each part. – The Deputy Leader confirmed he was fully confident that everything would be completed and the Deputy Chief Executive said the timescales would be provided with the initial plans and costings proposal which should come around Christmas. York Place would probably be first, then Midway with works kicking off around late 2024, early 2025 and then ongoing for 12 to 18 months over 2025 and 2026. The Ryecroft development would start around the end of 2025 or early 2026.
Cllr Edgington-Plunkett and Cllr Jones wished to thank the Vice Chair and the working group for the comprehensive report provided and the upcoming presentation by Aspire Housing.
- Cllr Jones wondered about the consultees’ responses. – Comments received could be viewed in different parts of the document with the category of consultees being identified.
Councillor Dave Jones asked the Leader to confirm if the parking rates on the new car park would be charged in line with charges on Council car parks.
- Cllr Jones asked about the reliability of the system now in place in the event of odours coming back in the cold months and what would be the process if it were to occur. – The situation was very different from the previous year. Practices and processes were regularly updated and regular meetings were taking place with the operator so that the right action was taken at the right time. The respect of the abatement notice was being monitored and legal action could be undertaken in the event of a breach resulting in statutory nuisance.
Cllr Jones commented that residents may be more sensitive to odours than they were in the past and while lower levels of pollution may be recorded the number of complaints may still rise.
- Cllr Jones wished to have more information on the role of veterans’ charities. – The Council was working closely with those and veterans concerned by homelessness were signposted to the right place.
- Cllr Jones wondered why recommendations about involving developers in providing allotment plots were not implemented through section 106. – The recommendations formed part of the most recent Open Spaces strategy and were therefore not featured in previous developments.
- Cllr Jones wished to have more information about what would have happened in the cited case of the tumbler dryer fire if the neighbours hadn’t intervened. – The fire would have escalated and the situation would have been much more dangerous.
- Cllr Jones wished to know more about the technologies used and whether crews of three would be able to operate them. – The reduced crew would come to get the work started as soon as possible and be joined afterwards by other crew members to help operate the whole of the equipment.
Cllr Jones suggested that the team comes back after December to report on the outcomes of the trial once completed.
- Cllr Jones asked if communication had been engaged with the hospital regarding nearby cycling routes. – The standards required by the government were that cycle routes be segregated from both pedestrians and traffic. The County Council had picked a route that was safer and quieter and were keen to engage with cycling groups.
Cllr Jones wondered if the NHS dental care could also be added.
The Resolution was seconded by Councillor Dave Jones who spoke about the Borough’s history and ended by saying that the Borough was the best place to live, study and work.
Councillor Dave Jones proposed an amendment to the report that, in the event of the role of High Steward being re-established, the Chief Executive establish an independent Appointments Committee. The Committee would comprise of three Aldermen, agreed by Group Leaders. The Independent Appointments Committee would receive nominations for the role of High Steward and appraise the nominations before making a recommendation to Full Council for consideration for appointment.
Councillor Dave Jones had concerns regarding the bursary only being awarded to one of the cohort of ten and asked that Council consider expanding it to the whole cohort, should they secure a place at Keele University.
Amended recommendation moved by Councillor Jones and seconded by Councillor Dymond
Councillor Jones asked if a site visit could be set up with Severn Trent Water, officers and residents to raise their concerns directly with the Water Authority.
Councillor Dave Jones asked for an update on how the changes to the legislation regarding housing targets, which had moved from a statutory minimum to an advisory minimum had been considered post consultation on the earlier stages of the Local Plan. The Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning referred to paragraphs 5.2 and 5.3 of the report. At the time the report was written there had not been a final announcement on this subject – the consultation through the National Planning Policy Framework, so it was still unclear what the Government wanted to do or when they would respond to the consultation exercise.
Proposed by Councillor Fox-Hewitt and seconded by Councillor Dave Jones.
Councillor Dave Jones was invited to speak on behalf of former Councillor Silvia Burgess who wished to thank Members and officers for their support during her recent bereavement.
Cllr Jones shared his ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Amended recommendation, to include that piling be undertaken as per the time schedule in the Wardell Armstrong Noise Assessment report proposed by Councillor Dave Jones and seconded by Councillor Williams
Councillor Gary White spoke on this application Revised recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Dave Jones.
Councillor Simon Tagg moved and Councillor Dave Jones seconded that Marion Reddish, Mark Olszewski, Kyle Robinson-Payne, Julie Cooper, Elizabeth Shenton, Silvia Burgess, June Walklate, Sandra Simpson, Mary Maxfield and Tony Kearon be appointed as Honorary Aldermen for the Borough of Newcastle under Lyme.
A Motion was received concerning Realise and Achieve Training from the Aspire Group proposed by Councillor Dave Jones and seconded by Councillor Moffat.
Watch the debate here The second Motion concerned Fire and Rehire proposed by Councillor Dave Jones and seconded by Councillor Fox-Hewitt.
Proposed by Councillor Dave Jones and seconded by Councillor Andrew Fox-Hewitt.
Councillor Fox- Hewitt spoke on this application Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Reddish and seconded by Councillor Jones.
Councillor Jones declared an interest in application 18/01011/FUL at page 89 of the agenda as an employee of the Harper Keele Vet School . Consideration was given to a report on half-yearly Planning Obligations.
It was suggested that a meeting be arranged for residents, the Chair of Keele Parish Council, interested parties from the Planning Department and Councillor Jones to be arranged in order to appease any concerns.
Amended recommendation, to remove the word ‘forestry’ from Condition (vii) proposed by Councillor Jones and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Dave Jones referred to the scoping report stating that there were a large number of figures which made it difficult to interpret the locations of, for example ancient woodlands and areas of biodiversity and asked that when it went out to consultation, the public could be sure of the exact location of the sites. This could be through the use of additional maps or a list of locations.
Councillor Jones referred to options appraisals and housing need. He enquired whether the measures had accounted for the changing nature of work in response to the Covid pandemic with more people working from home.
Councillor Jones referred to the benefit of having a railway station in one of the towns, stating that this was a good idea. He would like to know more about the UK BAP Priority Habitats contained within the scoping report to see the locations of those. Biodiversity was also important and the report gave a proposal to take a large piece that was an exceptionally biodiverse plot of land within Keele Golf Course.
Councillor Jones proposed that, in addition to sending the documents to Cabinet for discussion, that it be recommended to Cabinet that the item be sent to Full Council for consideration.
Councillor Jones stated that he had received concerns from residents regarding digital exclusion and sought reassurance that any process would include an appropriate impact assessment on residents who were less digitally accessible.
Proposed by Councillor Mike Stubbs and seconded by Councillor Dave Jones.
Councillor Jones had concerns about the massing of the proposal and ... view the full minutes text for item 11.
Councillor Dave Jones declared pecuniary and non-pecuniary interests respectively on items 5 and 7, applications 20/01083/FUL and 20/01076/FUL.
As an employee of Keele University, Councillor Jones would not take part in any discussion or decision making on these items.
Councillor Dave Jones took no part in the discussion and did not vote on this application.
Councillor Jones stated that he did not support the demolition of the Community Centre without any clear plans of how the facility would be replaced but felt inclined to vote with the recommendation, in favour, in order to protect the environment for his residents.
Councillor Jones proposed that the recommendations of the Environmental Health Division regarding protection of the highway from mud and debris, be added.
Councillor Jones thanked the officers for the satisfactory conclusion.
Councillor Jones suggested that the letter also included a question as to what was likely to change between now and June in respect of current restrictions.
Councillor Jones reminded Council of a personal interest as an employee of Keele University and stated that the UN Goals have a strong local connection namely with the University that has the reputation for sustainability. Also, with the recent appointment of John Statham as the Professor of Sustainable Livestock Systems. John is a European recognised specialist in dairy cattle.
Councillor Jones had a number of reservations on this application. Part of a Council’s role is to be custodians of the Green Belt. Applications in the Green Belt are judged on the harm that they may cause but applications were also expected to adhere to requirements that were set out when planning permission was granted.
Councillor Jones pointed out that there had been six breaches of the original planning consent.
Referring to the pergola, Councillor Jones stated that this was the installation of a significant extension and the large concrete plinth with additional buildings on would cause harm to the Green Belt. The pergola was also visible from the road.
Councillor Jones asked the officer why this did not cause significant harm.
Councillor Dave Jones asked if this could be dealt with as part of the original appeal hearing or if it would need to be dealt with separately.
Councillor Dave Jones thanked the officers for the work that they had done and also thanked Silverdale Parish Council who would have offered to put up the funding had it been necessary.
Councillor Dave Jones asked what the timeframe was for confirmation of the final payment for the former Silverdale Station and Goods Shed.
Proposed by Councillor Stubbs and seconded by Councillor Jones.
Councillor Jones proposed that preference was for a virtual meeting on 6 October but, should that not be possible, a blended Hearing take place to ensure that the matter is heard as soon as possible.
Councillor Dave Jones proposed that two swings only be placed in this area and that the offer to replace the swing with something more sensible, by the developer be taken up.
Councillor Jones declared a non-pecuniary interest in application 20/162/REM as an employee of Keele University.
Councillor Jones declared a non-pecuniary interest in application 20/00291/FUL as an employee of Keele University.
Proposed by Councillor Moffatt and seconded by Councillor Jones.
Councillor Jones declared an interest as an employee of Keele University.
Councillor Jones commented on the strategic development within the Keele University growth corridor. He asked whether it was felt that the Council was at risk of ‘putting all of our eggs into one basket’ and what alternative sites/economic zones were being looked at. [name removed] stated that alternative options had been looked at previously and the next stage would show reasonable alternatives /options.
Councillor Jones was advised that there was an ‘exceptional circumstances case’ in respect of growth at the University.
Councillor Jones asked what was meant by the term ‘local’ under point e of Policy E3. He enquired whether ‘local’ meant ‘across the whole of Stoke on Trent’. [name removed] stated that there was perhaps a bit more work to do in relation to some references. ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Councillor Jones thanked officers for their informing of residents following a site visit.
Councillor Kyle Robinson: People and Partnerships Councillor Sarah Pickup: Corporate and Service Improvement Councillor Sylvia Dymond: Leisure, Culture and Heritage Councillor Allison Gardner: Environment, Recycling and Climate Change Councillor John Williams: Planning and Growth Councillor Mike Stubbs: Finance and Efficiency Councillor Dave Jones: Community Safety and Wellbeing.
An amendment to the Motion was tabled at the meeting, proposed by Councillor Kyle Robinson and seconded by Councillor Dave Jones:
Councillor Jones suggested that officers could involve neighbouring residents when they visited the site although [name removed] advised that it was important not to create conflict. However, residents could be informed of the outcome/progress of visits.
Councillor Jones declared an interest in agenda item 13 – application 19/20006/HBG, St John’s Church and would take no part in the discussion.
Councillor Jones took no part in the discussions regarding recommendation (i)
Councillor Jones seconded the proposal.
Councillor Jones asked the Portfolio Holder for Environment and Recycling if the landfill site at Walleys Quarry was producing hydrogen sulphite and if so, the quantities and finally a guarantee that this was not harmful to residents living near to the site.
Councillor Jones asked Councillor Trevor Johnson if he supported the concerns over health and the further investigation by Public Health England.
Moved by Councillor Simon Tagg and seconded by Councillor Jones.
Councillor Dave Jones asked the Leader of the Council for an update on the number of contact made through the website in connection with the odours from Walley’s Quarry landfill site.
Councillor Jones asked the Portfolio Holder for Community Safety and Wellbeing what the Council had done in respect of anti-social behaviour at the former Silverdale Railway Station site.
Councillor Jones advised Councillor Waring that there had been an increased severity of incidents but they had not been reported.
Councillor Jones requested a meeting with Councillors Waring, Rout and the police. This was agreed and would be arranged.
Councillor Jones asked the Portfolio Holder for Planning and Growth how Section 106 monies were distributed for the development of social housing.
Councillor Jones asked the Portfolio Holder if he would commit to more people bidding into that process.
Councillor Panter was pleased to see that this Council was committed to working with the County Council and Councillor Jones suggested working with the County Council to find a solution regarding the loss of school crossing patrols across the Borough.
Councillor Jones added that the service users were extremely positive about the service and that there were distinct advantages to having a “gang” participate as they would encourage members to keep attending.
The Chair of the Health and Wellbeing Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Dave Jones had requested to speak to the Cabinet with regard to the potential closure of sixty-three community beds at Bradwell Hospital on 28 October, 2016.
Councillor Jones raised concerns regarding the potential impact on patients and also the support staff who work at the hospital. He advised the Cabinet that a special meeting of the Health and Wellbeing Scrutiny Committee had been arranged for 26 October, 2016 and attendance had been confirmed by the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG), University Hospital North Midlands and the Staffordshire and Stoke on Trent Partnership.
In addition, Councillor Jones asked that Cabinet look into what help is available for the support staff at the hospital should they lose their jobs.
The following motion was received, proposed by Councillor Snell and seconded by Councillor Jones regarding the cuts made by Staffordshire County Council as a result in the shortfall of funding to the Better Care Fund:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Jones attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 Feb 2025 | Planning Committee | Application for major development - former jubilee baths, nelson place, newcastle. integritas property group (ipg) number 8 ltd. 25/00008/ful | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Feb 2024 | Council | Motions of members | Carried | 23 for, 16 against | |
| 28 Sep 2022 | Council | Motions of members | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Nov 2021 | Council | Recommendations of the independent remuneration panel | Lost | 16 for, 24 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Nov 2019 | Council | Review and update of the borough council of newcastle-under-lyme's council and committee procedure rules | Lost | 20 for, 21 against | |
| 13 Aug 2019 | Planning Committee | 5 boggs cottage, keele. 14/00036/207c3 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Jones was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 16 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Jones declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Jul 2026 | Council, item 1 | Councillor Jones declared an interest in item 6 - as an employee of Harper & Keele Veterinary School but would take part in the debate. Also, a declaration of interest was made for item 10 – protecting green spaces as both of his children attended Madeley High School. | |
| 11 Jul 2024 | Economy and Place Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Cllr Jones declared being employed by Harper & Keele Veterinary School which formed part of Keele University which was referred to in the Local Plan. | |
| 14 Feb 2024 | Council, item 2 | Cllr Jones declared being employed by Harper & Keele Veterinary School located next to Walleys Quarry. | |
| 1 Mar 2022 | Planning Committee, item 13 | Councillor Jones declared an interest in application 18/01011/FUL at page 89 of the agenda as an employee of the Harper Keele Vet School . Consideration was given to a report on half-yearly Planning Obligations. | |
| 2 Mar 2021 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Dave Jones declared pecuniary and non-pecuniary interests respectively on items 5 and 7, applications 20/01083/FUL and 20/01076/FUL. | |
| 23 Jun 2020 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Jones declared a non-pecuniary interest in application 20/162/REM as an employee of Keele University. | |
| 26 May 2020 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Jones declared a non-pecuniary interest in application 20/00291/FUL as an employee of Keele University. | |
| 6 Feb 2020 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Jones declared an interest as an employee of Keele University. | |
| 3 Dec 2019 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Jones declared an interest in agenda item 13 – application 19/20006/HBG, St John’s Church and would take no part in the discussion. |
Where Councillor Jones sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2016 | 81 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | May 2019 | 76 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Finance, Assets & Performance Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2023 | 5 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Local Government Reorganisation Cabinet Panel | Committee Member | Mar 2026 | 1 | |
| Economy, Environment & Place Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 14 | |
| Health and Wellbeing Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2016 | 10 | |
| Economy and Place Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2022 | 9 | |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2016 | 4 | |
| Cleaner Greener and Safer Communities Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2017 | 4 | |
| Health,Wellbeing & Partnerships Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2018 | 4 | |
| Licensing & Public Protection Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2020 | 4 | |
| Scrutiny Review Working Party - Walley's Quarry | Committee Member | Aug 2020 | 3 | |
| Public Protection Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2016 | 2 | |
| Health, Wellbeing & Environment Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Sep 2023 | 2 | |
| Active and Cohesive Communities Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2017 | 1 | |
| Investigation and Disciplinary Panel | Committee Member | Dec 2018 | 1 | |
| Employment Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2023 | 1 | |
| Appointments Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.