Minutes of a previous meeting
Councillor Whieldon referred to item 15 on the Minutes regarding her request for a timescale for the implementation of the recommendations and asked when that would be done.
Every time Newcastle-under-Lyme's minutes name Councillor Whieldon, as the council published it.
Councillor Whieldon referred to item 15 on the Minutes regarding her request for a timescale for the implementation of the recommendations and asked when that would be done.
On Walleys Quarry Cllr Whieldon pointed out a typing error on page 3 of the report – “dour” instead “odour”.
On the Performance report overall Cllr Whieldon said that the KPI indicators suggested that the Council should be held up as an exemplar for other authorities.
In addition to this, Councillor Whieldon stated that she would like to see where the risk management comparisons were and where the cost benefit analysis had come from for the last two years.
Councillor Whieldon asked if there was any provision in the consultation for professional dog walkers with 5-6 dogs.
Councillor Whieldon stated that, within the Borough, the number of dog waste bins were limited and asked what the thoughts of the MMF Manager were on that.
Councillor Whieldon if the positions of the dog waste bins had been mapped to see if they were equally distributed. This was confirmed.
Councillor Whieldon referred to the signage for dogs/fouling stating that it was worn down and also, too high up on the posts to which they were attached and were therefore not doing their job.
Councillor Whieldon stated that it was worth noting how astute the Council had been in reaching the position of being financially sound.
Councillor Whieldon felt that testing should be done sooner rather than later as it could be too late by then. The Senior Audit Manager stated that if that were done, it would require further audit work, creating extra pressure on the Plan. If it was felt that it needed to be put in place it would have to be approved by this Committee.
Two nominations were received: Councillor Christopher Bailey and Councillor Joan Whieldon.
Councillor Whieldon was proposed by Councillor Simon Tagg and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Tagg stated that as Deputy Mayor for the past year, Councillor Whieldon had supported the Mayor – attending functions on his behalf, representing the Borough with dedication and enthusiasm, assisted by her Deputy Mayoress, Councillor Susan Beeston.
Councillor Whieldon was thanked for the work that she had done over the past year.
- 25 (twenty-five) votes in favour of Councillor Bailey - 15 (fifteen) votes in favour of Councillor Whieldon - 2 (two) abstentions Resolved : That Councillor Christopher Bailey be appointed as Mayor for the 2026-27 Municipal Year.
Name of Organisation / Role Representative Aspire Housing Board Cllr Renshaw Business Improvement District Cllr Gullis Campaign to Protect Rural England – County Branch Cllr Machin Corporate Parenting Panel Cllr Kasperowicz Local Councils Network Leader Visit Staffordshire Destination Management Partnership Leader Go Kidsgrove Cllr Westcott LGiU Assembly Cllr Rogerson Local Government Association Leader Newcastle Partnership (Local Strategic Partnership) Leader North Staffs Victim Support Cllr Renshaw Parking and Traffic Regulations Outside London (PATROL) Cllr Renshaw Sir John Offley Almshouse Trust Cllr Whitmore Staffordshire County Council Health and Care Overview and Scrutiny Committee Cllr Stevenson Staffordshire Leaders Board Leader Staffordshire Playing Fields Association Leader Staffordshire Police, Fire and Crime Panel and associated panels Cllr Shaw Stoke-on-Trent and North Staffordshire Theatre Trust Limited (New Victoria Theatre) Leader Stoke-on-Trent and Staffordshire Local Enterprise Partnership Leader Newcastle-under-Lyme Almshouse Association Ward Councillors West Midlands Employers Leader Waste and Mineral Site Liaison Committee – Acton Composting Site (Committee is Active) Cllr Lefroy Waste and Mineral Site Liaison Committee – Holditch House Waste Site Cllr Barber Waste and Mineral Site Liaison Committee – Keele (Madeley Heath) Quarry (Committee not yet Active) Cllr Bettley-Smith Cllr Whitmore Waste and Mineral Site Liaison Committee – Knutton Quarry
Councillor Joan Whieldon enquired about the timescale for the implementation of the recommendations.
Cllr Whieldon commented that a charter was almost legislative and cast in stone while a plan had to be flexible by its nature.
Cllr Whieldon commented that risk management required looking at what had been done historically along with what happened in the past and putting structures in place to reflect these and reduce risks in the future.
Cllr Whieldon wondered it was correct to say that there was a proactive aspect of the arrangements when things were put in place and a reactive one when the investigations carried out led to rethinking the framework in place.
Cllr Whieldon wondered how the Risk Management Policy Statement and Strategy compared to recommendations from the Institute of Risk Management and how other institutions were doing theirs.
Cllr Whieldon outlined the benefits of using a template to compare with other institutions doing the same thing and suggested regular reporting may be the way to refining the audit.
Cllr Whieldon thanked the Service Director for covering issues raised at the previous meeting.
Cllr Whieldon supported the Chair’s request adding that this, as well as the money recovery process, should be tracked not to drift on.
Cllr Whieldon suggested the use of the term “target date” instead of “achievement date” in the Delivery Plan and add a column with the date when the action has actually been implemented.
Cllr Whieldon raised the presence of blank boxes and vague timescales in the Delivery Plan. Lead partners’ names and titles were also missing.
Cllr Whieldon asked Cllr Hutchison if he could pass on a request for the grass cutting team to be mindful of the daffodils recently planted.
Councillor Whieldon stated that, despite difficult circumstances, the Council had managed to keep the Council Tax low and protect services. Very few people realised how much the Council had done under the current administration.
Question from Councillor Joan Whieldon to the Leader of the Council :
Councillor Whieldon asked a supplementary question:
Cllr Whieldon commented that when a project and a target are set out, things can change and if you don't go along with those changes and don't adapt to them, then the risk can escalate.
Councillor Whieldon stated that residents had benefited from a more stable winter period this year. The Leader was asked what further assurances could he give that the improved performance would be maintained long term. In addition, the lack of communication from the local MP was important to residents.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about matters that were to be actioned as referred to in the minutes.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about the relevance of the abatement notice given that the operator was now in liquidation as well as who was now in charge of the site would any further action be required.
Cllr Whieldon raised that the date the operator went into liquidation according the Companies House website was different from that given in the report – 27 th February as opposed to 28 th February.
Cllr Whieldon wondered if there was anything that could be done to prompt a response from the local MP further to the solicitation to assist and represent the Council in relation to the request for a Public Inquiry.
Cllr Whieldon proposed that the Leader write to the MP to reiterate his request for support in matters relating to Walleys Quarry.
Cllr Whieldon expressed the wish that the Environment Agency be contacted to provide information about any investigation carried out in relation to what was happening under the capping and if ground water pollution risks were being addressed.
Cllr Whieldon asked if the new government Minister in charge of waste had been contacted as suggested by the minutes of the previous meeting.
Cllr Whieldon said that a follow up on the request for a public inquiry on Walleys Quarry and related correspondence would be appreciated at the next meeting.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about Staffordshire Locality Improvement Framework and the difficulty in booking appointments with GPs especially for the elderly who struggle with the new ways of communicating via information technologies.
Cllr Whieldon wondered about statistics referred to in Staffordshire Community Safety Partnership Action Plan and whether a similar document could be produced for the Borough.
Councillor Joan Whieldon, Chair of the Licensing and Public Protection Committee seconded the recommendations stating that the Policy was instrumental to the Council as it set out how the Council dealt with pertinent and complex issues raised when administering this regime and without which, the Council could be open to challenge.
Cllr Whieldon wished to acknowledge the progress made since the previous year and thank both auditors and the team ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Whieldon expressed her satisfaction at the traffic light system used for risk management which was simple and effective.
Cllr Whieldon asked if the fire brigade was involved with the training provided on Evac chairs and breathing apparatus.
Cllr Whieldon added that doors should open outwards on fire exit routes so that people don’t get trapped in and questioned that this requirement was met on the ground floor of the building.
Cllr Whieldon asked if there were still a disaster recovery plan and how often it was updated and checked.
Cllr Whieldon thanked officers for the readability of the report.
Members shared their sadness to see her go, including Cllr Whieldon who said she would be missed and the Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Finance, Town Centres and Growth who took the opportunity to also introduce the current Finance Manager (Deputy S151 Officer) as her successor.
Cllr Whieldon noted the absence of response from the Secretary of State in relation to paragraph 1.6.3 and wondered if this would need to be followed up.
Cllr Whieldon also enquired about a public meeting due to be held by the Environment Agency at the end of September.
The Chair echoed Cllr Whieldon comments and stated that the public enquiry requested by the Council was awaited as a matter of urgency.
Cllr Whieldon wished to pass on her thanks to everyone involved in the launching event that took place in Thistleberry .
Cllr Whieldon asked if the Council would consider late applications would there be any fundings left.
Cllr Whieldon thanked officers for their involvement and for the map provided to the working group showing the location of the various play areas. This had been particularly useful and made it easier to bring the information to the attention of other committees.
Cllr Whieldon commented on the fact that it was a growing phenomenon requiring vigilance.
Cllr Whieldon commented that a Youth venue had indeed been closed in Chesterton and suggested that it may be a good thing to contact the County Council about it as such clubs would keep young people off the street.
Cllr Whieldon wished to add that board games clubs may be another option worth considering.
Cllr Whieldon reiterated her request that the Environment Agency be contacted to clarify the situation in relation to the public event that was supposed to be held at the end of September.
Cllr Whieldon wondered if Cllr Stubbs suggestion that the Council was marking their homework could not be rephrased as setting targets they wish to achieve.
Cllr Whieldon commended everyone involved in the delivery of projects.
Councillor Whieldon stated that residents were pleased that odours had diminished but were anxious about any possible future recurrence and were therefore seeking assurance that the EA would continue to do the job properly.
Councillor Whieldon asked if there was potential for increasing the number of parks and open spaces from the 88 mentioned in the report.
Cllr Whieldon wondered what happened when frauds and errors were identified as part of the internal audit process.
Cllr Whieldon asked if Cllr Stubbs could elaborate on how, why and when the changes would impact residents of the borough.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about digital communication in relation to clarifying the situation for residents and dispelling misinformation.
Cllr Whieldon asked if it was correct to say that the inspector could ask questions and make recommendations but could not mandate any changes.
Cllr Whieldon commented on the Deputy Leader’s statement that she had visited works completed by Capital and Centric in Stoke-on-Trent. The quality and conservationist efforts put into the structure had retained her attention.
Cllr Whieldon pointed out a typo – “properly accounts instead of property” which the Service Director for Finance noted.
Cllr Whieldon expressed her satisfaction at the financial outturn and balance sheets figures, the way they fitted against each other and the overall management of the funds by both officers and the Council.
Watch the presentation here Cllr Whieldon enquired about problem profiles.
Cllr Whieldon asked what the police would do once a problem had been identified to stop it from recuring.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about communication and publicity around the reporting process for members of the public witnessing offenses. She also asked if an audit of ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Cllr Whieldon commented that the group was scheduled to meet on the 30 th June and would be discussing the final report to be presented to the Committee.
- Cllr Joan Whieldon, who was proposed by Cllr Tagg and seconded by Cllr Sweeney. Reference was made to her election in 2022 following a successful career that took her around the world and provided her with expertise in mediation and dispute resolution, among other skills.
- 25 (twenty-five) votes in favour of Cllr Whieldon - 17 (seventeen) votes in favour of Cllr Fox-Hewitt - 1 (one) abstention Resolved : That Councillor Joan Whieldon be appointed as Deputy Mayor for the 2025-26 Municipal Year.
Cllr Whieldon kindly agreed to attend and chair the meeting on short notice.
Cllr Whieldon thanked the auditors for the clarity and readability of the report.
Cllr Whieldon seconded the Chair in welcoming the flexibility.
Cllr Whieldon asked if a comparative analysis would be incorporated.
Cllr Whieldon commented that page 4 of the Anti-Fraud and Anti-Corruption framework provided details of the work environment to be provided to employees which included in-house training covering fraud, fraud detection and fraud prevention.
Cllr Whieldon supported the Chair’s comments, highlighting that there was a consistency in the Committee membership which helped copping with this busy time of the year when everything is to be reviewed.
Cllr Whieldon said it wouldn’t be for her.
The Chair and Cllr Whieldon welcomed the suggestion.
Councillor Joan Whieldon was appointed.
Cllr Whieldon praised the work of Capital and Centric and everyone involved in preserving the heritage of the town.
Cllr Whieldon shared her thoughts that demolishing a building and then starting again from scratch doubled the costs and so revitalising an existing structure was likely to ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Cllr Whieldon mentioned her visit to the fire station thoroughly looking at all apparatus and talking to members of staff who provided direct transparent answers to all questions raised and should be commended for it.
The Chair who also attended the visit along with Cllr Lewis seconded Cllr Whieldon who added that other members would benefit from visiting the station.
Cllr Whieldon wondered if there were any plans in relation to ongoing construction works involving bigger buildings and different style of accommodation.
Cllr Whieldon wished to highlight that while odours and smells were commonly reported, these were indications of toxic gases which were a deeper problem regardless of existing health conditions people may have.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about drone footage showing considerable amount of water and what could be air or gas bubbling up at the surface.
Cllr Whieldon asked if a copy of those footages was provided to the Council.
Cllr Whieldon provided a verbal update on the first meeting of the Parks and Open Spaces Task & Finish Working Group, an information gathering exercise. Members had raised questions to which officers would provide responses at the next meeting of the working group scheduled on 24 th March.
Cllr Whieldon expressed her satisfaction at hearing that criminal orders were attached to shoplifting.
Cllr Whieldon welcomed the intention to ensure long term funding and enquired about additional resources available through the Prince of Wales.
Cllr Whieldon wondered if benchmarking was done against what had been done in the past, comparison with others across the sector and / or nationally.
Councillor Whieldon asked what monitoring was taking place regarding the Environment Agency and the closure notice.
Cllr Whieldon asked about the origin of the terms “best practical means” used in paragraph 2.5.
Cllr Whieldon expressed her concerns about the subjectivity of the expression which could be abused by lawyers.
Cllr Whieldon expressed doubts over the consistency of the government in relation to paragraphs 2.7, 2.11 and 2.12.
Cllr Whieldon wished to thank the officer for clarifying the ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Cllr Whieldon congratulated the team as well as the Council for protecting the green and open spaces and parklands so that development can come after that. She noted that there were, however very few litter bins and wondered if an audit could be undertaken.
Cllr Whieldon reiterated the need for the number of bins to be also reviewed.
Cllr Whieldon and Cllr Brown commended the report.
Councillor Whieldon stated that she had concerns regarding the television adverts put on by organisations to warn people of the dangers of gambling. There had to be cautious as to how much responsibility the Council took on.
Councillor Whieldon stated that the downflow of the Charter into schools would be wonderful.
Cllr Whieldon commented that risks were assessed at a moment in time and could be low to medium priority for a few weeks before they needed attention.
Cllr Whieldon expressed her appreciation of the traffic light system and the thoroughness of the reports.
Cllr Whieldon suggested that the long list of glossary terms to refer to was making the reading difficult and could be more thorough.
Cllr Whieldon praised the auditors’ work for including an executive summary and a glossary of terms.
Councillor Whieldon stated that no representative from Walleys Quarry was present throughout the Inquiry but they had put something in writing which stated ‘we note that the UK Health Protection Agency concluded in a recent study that living close to a well-managed landfill site does not pose a significant risk to human health. We work hard to ensure our operators do not impact local communities’. This quote suggested that with the report of the Committee of Inquiry and all of the medical responses – Walleys Quarry was not a well-managed site.
Cllr Whieldon suggested that the dates where reductions had been noticed seemed to correspond to dates of public enquiry. She also referred to monitoring done by local protest groups and lorries without registration plates coming to the site and leaving without doing a wheel wash meaning the dirt would then be carried onto the roads on long distances.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about the fire incident and expressed concerns about the exercise of freedom of information in relation to the report received.
Cllr Whieldon wished for assurance that the equipment to measure the emissions were regularly tested.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about paragraph 3.10 and whether there was any synergy between the work done around the strategy and the handling of planning applications with regards to fossil fuels, solar panels etc.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about the cars parked on grass verges in which a lot of maintenance efforts and money were put in.
Cllr Whieldon wished to lobby for the re-introduction of licenses for dogs.
Cllr Whieldon seconded the proposal.
Cllr Whieldon proposed that Cllr Holland be appointed as Chair in the absence of Cllrs Parker and Bettley-Smith.
Cllr Whieldon congratulated officers on their thorough work.
Cllr Whieldon expressed her appreciation of the work carried out by Capital and Centric around the station and of the fact the heritage façade would be kept.
Cllr Whieldon supported Cllr Stubbs’ comment and the response provided, adding that an executive summary in layman’s terms rather than glossary terms would also benefit members of the public.
Cllr Whieldon asked about what a sound local plan meant in terms of legal compliance.
Cllr Whieldon commented that the Council staff was a caring community and that dismissals were for the benefit of both the borough and the person.
Cllr Whieldon compared the projects to icebergs that would all of a sudden emerge and congratulated everybody for their hard work.
Cllr Whieldon commented that a lot of work and progress was being done by the Committee of Inquiry which she was a member of.
Cllr Whieldon commented that from her experience as a teacher one swimming lesson a week was not enough to make a child fitter as excess weight had more to do with a poor diet; this was a delicate topic to address with parents which could be perceived as too intrusive.
Cllr Whieldon wished to pass on personal thanks to people in charge of warming up the smaller pool which had made a difference for her when she was recovering from a broken back and hip operation.
Cllr Whieldon enquired about training and job shadowing to gain experience.
Cllr Whieldon congratulated the team on progress made and thanked them personally for when she herself got caught into a collision.
Cllr Whieldon commented that when it came to forecasting the best estimates were given and anything that was external to the borough and its financial reporting remained partly unpredictable.
Cllr Whieldon highlighted the wording of paragraph 6 of the Risk Management Policy Statement stating a list of actions the Council ‘would’ take to meet its responsibilities as opposed to ‘may’ or ‘could’, which she found re-assuring.
Cllr Whieldon highlighted the importance of getting things right the first time to ensure success.
Cllr Whieldon was appointed as Chair.
- Cllr Whieldon expressed concerns about the Council getting too involved in the mitigation of risks pertaining to the Sky building which could lead to responsibility in case something happened.
- Cllr Whieldon asked if proportionality had been taken into account when considering the number of complaints received and that of people who would actually be impacted. – Information was still being collated.
Cllr Whieldon commented that short timescales were necessary for people to stay in business.
- Cllr Whieldon asked about the figure of 8,190 properties and wondered if this including housing providers such as Aspire.
- Cllr Whieldon raised that contractors and providers had their own health and safety procedures and wondered if they were asked to follow the Councils’ policies as well. – Indeed they needed to comply with the Councils’ policies and procedures when working on site. Training and induction were provided with written responses to questions being requested to confirm proper understanding.
- Cllr Whieldon asked if the premises were required to display the ratings. – While the ratings were available on the Food Agency website, businesses were not required to display the information themselves.
- Cllr Whieldon expressed the need for policies to be aligned with neighbouring authorities and for education to start with children at school. – It was confirmed that an environmental Enforcement Education Program was undertaken with schools.
Cllr Whieldon commented there should be some leeway for changes in timetables.
- Cllr Whieldon highlighted the importance of having special permissions. – It was clarified that one set of provisions should not take precedence over another as they had separate regimes.
Cllr Whieldon asked if there was a process to track related wasted costs. A process was indeed in place for administrative costs (about £100 to £150 a month) with invoices being issued to individuals by the Finance team.
- Cllr Whieldon asked if it was possible to have a street sweeper to go and clean the gated areas to prevent further hazard. – The Council was working closely with Aspire Housing within the framework of a joint venture. Options were notably being explored to utilise their caretaking services and linking them with street scene teams.
- Cllr Whieldon suggested there could be dog parks.
Question from Councillor Whieldon to the Leader of the Council:
Does the Leader agree with me that there is no evidence the TRA actually represents the residents of Thistleberry and that the Thistleberry Residents Association is being run by somebody who does not live in Thistleberry?” The Leader verified what Councillor Whieldon had said. The TRA was being run by someone now living in Betley. For the last six to eight years it had not been a functioning Residents Association as far as the Leader was aware and that needed to be addressed.
Councillor Joan Whieldon asked, despite the due diligence conducted by RED Industries, the Council could not be confident that an Executive for the TRA existed or if any members lived in the Thistleberry Ward. What action was the Leader taking to satisfy himself that the due diligence was carried out by RED in a satisfactory manner and complied with the Section 106 agreement. In addition, could the Leader assure that if RED were not compliant with the Section 106 agreement, that action was or would be taken by the appropriate authorities.
- Cllr Whieldon wished the leader to confirm that the enhanced communication taking place with the company was working efficiently to reassure the population that everything was being done to solve the problem.
Councillor Joan Whieldon asked:
Councillor Whieldon then asked:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Whieldon attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24 Nov 2025 | Health, Wellbeing & Environment Scrutiny Committee | Walleys quarry odour issues | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Apr 2024 | Licensing & Public Protection Committee | Taxi tariffs - proposed increase | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Feb 2024 | Council | Motions of members | Carried | 23 for, 16 against | |
| 28 Sep 2022 | Council | Motions of members | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Whieldon was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 17 of 26 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Whieldon declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Whieldon in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Whieldon sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2022 | 39 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Audit and Standards Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 27 | |
| Licensing & Public Protection Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 26 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Public Protection Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2022 | 17 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Health, Wellbeing & Environment Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2024 | 8 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Finance, Assets & Performance Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Dec 2022 | 7 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2024 | 5 | |
| Economy and Place Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Mar 2023 | 7 | |
| Planning Committee | Substitute | Apr 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.