Local government reorganisation
A Motion concerning the Council’s response to the Ministerial announcement of 16 July, 2026 relating to Local Government Reorganisation (LGR), was proposed by Councillor Simon Tagg and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Every time Newcastle-under-Lyme's minutes name Councillor Holland, as the council published it.
A Motion concerning the Council’s response to the Ministerial announcement of 16 July, 2026 relating to Local Government Reorganisation (LGR), was proposed by Councillor Simon Tagg and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Holland, in seconding the Motion stated that larger unitary authorities were less representative, less accountable and more remote from the communities they served. For Newcastle, LGR would mark the end of 853 years of history and identity and its residents would face large financial debts from another Authority.
Councillor Holland felt that LGR should not be happening – but to have the worst version imposed on this Council added insult to injury and deserved to be resisted. The Administration and officers were urged to leave no stone unturned in bringing to light any defects in the Government’s reasoning.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear
Councillor Holland introduced the proposed amendments put forward by the Conservative group. He stated that the Conservative group opposed on principle, measures within the report that impeded democratic accountability. They were open to the reform of the petition scheme and asked the Leader to justify his proposed changes.
Cllr Holland commented on the outrageous ways the site had been run and the Environment Agency failed to regulate it properly over a long number of years, welcoming the report and the work undertaken by the Council.
Councillor Holland stated that the Commercial Strategy would be considered at the September meeting and asked if it would be appropriate, within that report, to discuss how the Council was increasing or hoping to increase Bereavement Services income, including the introduction of the Pet Crematorium. If it was not appropriate, could a standalone report on Bereavement Services be considered by this Committee.
Councillor Holland requested a report on the Asset Management Strategy, given the changes that the new Administration would be bringing to it. The Service Director for Finance / S151 Officer stated that that should also come as part of the budget setting process.
Councillor Holland queried a reference to Appendix D and whether that should be Appendix C. This was confirmed to be the case.
Councillor Holland stated that a previous iteration of the Committee had received a detailed report on cyber risk and asked if officers remembered the content of that report. If it was still relevant, would it be worthwhile to share the document confidentially. The Service Director stated that he would be happy to share that, confidentially.
Councillor Holland referred to the cyber risk stating that the Council still did not have an insurance policy in place and asked if Members had any particular concerns regarding that element of risk that they would like to see investigated more. The Service Director suggested that, for the next meeting, a report be brought from the Service Director for IT and Digital regarding cyber risk and the insurance around it.
Councillor Holland stated that there was a narrative on page 6 of the risk register, under the action plan, which covered that.
Councillor Whieldon was proposed by Councillor Simon Tagg and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Mark Holland expressed his support for the report and highlighted that the changes that had been made in relation to procurement procedures.
Councillor Holland stated that the draft Terms of Reference stated that this was a politically balanced, six member panel and suggested that it could be a five member panel split 5:3 between the two main groups.
Cllr Holland wished to thank the Chair for his work as Chair of the Committee as well as all the officers who had been involved in the current 4 years cycle.
The Chair thanked Cllr Holland and said it had been great to serve the Committee, adding that he would be leaving the Council in May.
Councillor Holland paid tribute to the election staff and those who assisted every year on election days.
Following a lengthy debate, Councillor Holland proposed the recommendations and the Chair seconded. A vote was taken:
Cllr Holland enquired about the increase of the risk associated with the ministerial directive on air quality and whether this was due to the Council having failed to do something, or a lack of action from the government.
Cllr Holland wondered if one of the two new risks that had been added to the register, failure to adequately assess events, health and safety arrangements, was referring to a single event or to events generally.
In seconding the motion, Councillor Holland stated that the technical changes to Part F of the Constitution had been made in order to bring it into line with national legislation.
A Motion, concerning supporting our Borough’s Town Centre’s, High Streets and villages was submitted by the Conservative Group, proposed by Councillor Simon Tagg and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Holland seconded the Motion stated that the principle of the Motion was for whatever public houses were getting, so too should the whole of the high street. However, at the present time there was still no movement on that concession for pubs.
Cllr Holland commented that this was the official Government’s response and would be the same regardless of the ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Cllr Holland suggested that an answer could be sought from the County Council representative who was expected at the meeting and was not able to come, adding that MPs were best placed to do more detailed work on the matter and address digital exclusion.
Cllr Holland commented that percentages were useful as they enabled cross comparison between areas and demonstrated the work put into reducing crime and antisocial behaviours so long as they were going down.
Councillor Holland stated that, as he was compiling his report for the North Staffordshire Theatre Trust – at item 8 on this agenda, he was reminded of Stoke-on Trent’s City of Culture bid and, although unsuccessful it transformed the way in which the City thought about itself. Programmes like Civic Pride could do that.
On paragraph 4 – Kidsgrove Town Deal Update and Contract Awards Councillor Holland was pleased with the progress made on the Town Deal. The Leader or Portfolio Holder for Finance, Town Centres and Growth were asked how Many job opportunities were forecast with the development at Chatterley Valley West.
A Motion, concerning inappropriate accommodation for Asylum Seekers in Newcastle-under-Lyme was submitted by the Conservative Group, proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear.
Councillor Holland introduced the Motion which expressed concerns regarding the unsuitability of housing Asylum seekers in Houses of Multiple Occupation (HMO’s) or short term lets as they often lacked the necessary support infrastructure.
Cllr Holland shared his confidence that the report received was to be perceived positively as it was rare for a local plan to be adopted without any corrections and the take away was that the Plan was sound and would pass the inspection with the introduction of a few modifications. The fulfilment of the Council’s duty to cooperate had been successfully demonstrated which was a big plus.
Cllr Holland added that a sound local plan would give protection to the green belt as currently defined and ensure that inappropriate development would not be permitted in the future regardless of any evolution of the grey belt concept.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Burnett-Faulkner Following a long discussion on this item and Members requesting additional information, it was proposed to defer the item to a future meeting.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Gill Williams and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Holland stated that the money was welcome as it would go towards reducing bills and the future liability on the tax payer.
On paragraph 3 – Fields In Trust Councillor Holland asked the Leader if he welcomed the news that Village Green status had been given to three green spaces in the Westlands ward and if he agreed that the extra protection would compliment the protection given by the Fields in Trust status and stop development of the sites.
Councillor Holland, under Procedure Rule 4.3 of the Constitution, proposed to move the suspension of Procedure Rule 4.6 in order that the text of the Conservative Group’s amended Motion may be debated.
Councillor Holland seconded the Motion stating that the Motion was clear. The national framework for protecting the residents of Newcastle had failed in this instance and therefore the national bodies should be held accountable.
Question from Councillor Mark Holland to the Leader of the Council:
Councillor Holland did not ask a supplementary question Question from Councillor Richard Gorton to the Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage:
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Hutchison Members raised concerns regarding the proposed unadopted roads shown on the plans and on the refuse collection vehicles having to reverse down some roads following collections.
Councillor Holland proposed deferral to enable officers to enter into discussions with the developer regarding the unadopted roads and to gain more information on the bin collection arrangements.
Councillor Holland declared an interest as a resident of Clayton Road and asked if any information had been received on vehicle movements.
As no details had been received, Councillor Holland stated that he would abstain from the vote.
Amended recommendation proposed by Cllr Fear and seconded by Cllr Holland.
Cllr Holland commented that there was always an option to raise issues relating to Walleys Quarry at full Council as the item was included in the Leader’s statement.
Cllr Holland commented that the application was undesirable in his view for the reasons expressed by his colleagues. The development would equate to loss of agricultural land, trees and wildlife habitat regardless of the size and wider impact, and require various flood mitigation measures meaning the harms would outweigh ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Councillor Holland, as a member of the Planning Committee, stated that all members of the Planning Committee should be aware that item six of this agenda related to items that had yet to be determined by this Authority and therefore their interest should be noted.
Councillor Holland moved a grammatical correction to recommendation ( i )(a) requesting that ‘a 4-year terms of office’ be amended to read correctly.
Councillor Holland stated that the EA was a broken regulator, however, since they had been stewarding the site things did appear to be improving. The Leader was asked if he thought that the measures being taken would, in the long term significantly improve things and would it make the quality of life better for nearby residents. The Leader agreed with both Members and stated that it was key now that capping was completed and restored and that gas management was undertaken safely.
Councillor Holland stated that it was under the Labour administration that the former golf course closed and failed to ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Cllr Holland commented that he would be delighted to come to an extra meeting in March would that be necessary although felt that sufficient time had been given to review the policies.
Councillor Holland referred to a comment made by the Leader of Staffordshire County Council in a report to their Cabinet which stated that two tier local government worked in Staffordshire and struck the right ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Holland declared an interest on behalf of members of the Planning Committee in relation to item 6 and planning applications that had not yet been determined. Members who were concerned were asked to be mindful of not letting this interest predetermine the outcomes.
Cllr Holland enquired about Natural England’s representation and if there was anything the Council could have done in relation to the issues raised then.
Cllr Holland wondered about the likelihood of a statement of common ground being reached in good time in relation to further issues being raised including by other parties.
Cllr Holland raised there may be some inconsistency in the government policies which were promoting more housing on the one hand and a reduction in air pollution on the ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Holland asked if members would have to agree on the renewal of an agreement with the BID. The Deputy Leader confirmed it.
This was seconded by Cllr Holland and unanimously agreed.
Question from Councillor Mark Holland to the Leader of the Council “ We have seen an extreme spell of cold weather affecting residents of the Borough since the New Year. Many of our pensioners are still reeling from the governments cut to the Winter Fuel Allowance, some making a decision about whether to eat or heat.
Councillor Holland asked a supplementary question:
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear.
On paragraph 3 – Contract Award for the Digital Infrastructure Project Councillor Holland asked the Leader to outline how the distribution hubs at Community Centres would work and what benefits would be seen by the community.
Additional recommendations (xvi) and (xvii) proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Bryan
Councillors’ Lewis and Wilkes spoke on this application Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Burnett-Faulkner.
Councillor Holland welcomed the MTFS and was struck by how positive the outcome was. Reference was made to the One Council Programme and its success in bringing savings to the Council and transforming the way the Council worked.
Councillor Holland stated that earlier in the year, the government minister at the time had said that there was no longer a need for a bus gate and it would therefore be scrapped.
Councillor Holland wondered if the new government were of the same opinion as he was concerned that they would take a different view and reintroduce it.
A Motion was received concerning changes to winter fuel payments and protecting pensioners from fuel poverty, proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Simon Tagg.
Cllr Whieldon proposed that Cllr Holland be appointed as Chair in the absence of Cllrs Parker and Bettley-Smith.
Resolved : That Cllr Holland be appointed as Chair.
Councillor Holland, at the recent Economy and Place Scrutiny Committee, had asked what was thought to be of concern with the plan and the response was that the new Government would want to see more development and growth than the Council had planned for.
Councillor Holland referred to Policies included in the plan which benefited the Borough and its residents.
Cllr Holland wished to emphasize the fact that saying that a site was suitable for development at a strategic level and refusing a planning application to go through when the development was deemed unsustainable were not incompatible. The Committee was also not making the final decision which would be down to Full Council.
Cllr Holland wished to share the opposite view that progress was being made and that the organisation was being as effective as it could although not everything was visible.
Cllr Holland confirmed that a report on staff turnover as raised in the discussion about the Performance Report would be desirable.
Cllr Holland said that changes in national government could lead to a resurrection of the proposal and a close watch should be kept.
Cllr Holland wished for re-assurance that the strategy had been looked at carefully since the previous year and that necessary updates had been made. – Indeed it had been reviewed by the legal team to ensure the document was robust.
Cllr Holland welcomed the new auditors and pointed out a typo in the report in the name of the borough.
On paragraph 2 – Newcastle and Kidsgrove Regeneration Update Councillor Holland stated that a lot of levelling up money had gone unspent and said that it was great that this Authority was delivering the levelling up money awarded to it.
Councillor Holland referred to a document, produced by the Labour Party as part of the local elections campaign and raised concerns at a quote from the paper “we will widen devolution by asking all Councils, outside of an existing or combined authority to begin preparatory work to join together”.
Councillor Holland was concerned that this was a plan to take away Newcastle Borough Council’s independence. The Leader was asked if he too felt that this was a concern.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Jones.
This was seconded by Cllr Holland who expressed the wish for the Council to speak with one voice.
Cllr Holland reminded members of the importance of being united.
Cllr Holland commented that the Council had participated in a joint air quality group with the City Council and was doing what they could to mitigate the risk. It was to be noted that the issues mentioned in the report were complex, some of them involving international legal actions long with liaising with other authorities. The portfolio holder for Finance, Town Centres and Growth confirmed that the meetings were still taking place.
- Cllr Holland wished the Deputy Leader to comment on the resources freed up by the One Council programme which would be delivering better outcomes for residents who could now report issues online.
- Cllr Holland wished to know more about suggested designs. – The Deputy Chief Executive reiterated that while the building would be different, the design would be in line with what had been previously agreed and shared for planning.
Councillor Holland asked the Leader for an update on the construction timetable for the car park.
A Motion was received concerning Low Emission Zones and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Simon Tagg.
- Cllr Holland shared that the Localism Act provided communities with mechanisms to have greater control over development in their local area. Their weight however was reliant on having a proper Local Plan in place.
The Leader proposed an amendment to the Constitution which was seconded by Councillor Holland:
The working group is to look at social housing provisions in the borough and is composed of five members of which Cllr Hutchison (Chair), Cllr Bettley-Smith and Cllr Moffat (both Vice-Chairs), Cllr Grocott and Cllr Holland who all have different experiences and backgrounds.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Northcott Members felt that removing the condition was not appropriate and that a variation of the condition would be preferable. However, it was agreed that suitable wording for the condition could not be agreed upon at this meeting.
Amended recommendation proposed by Cllr Holland and seconded by Cllr Hutchison.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear.
This was reiterated by Councillor Holland.
It was moved by Councillor Sweeney and seconded by Councillor Holland that Councillor Simon Tagg be appointed as Leader of the Council.
Councillor Holland seconded this.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Mark Holland and seconded by Councillor John Williams Councillor Stephen Sweeney spoke on this application
Amended recommendation proposed by Cllr Reddish and seconded by Cllr Holland
Councillor Holland declared an interest in item 4 Revenue & Capital budget 2022/23 – First Draft Savings Plan - on the grounds that he was a Director of the Trust that ran the New Vic Theatre. Click here to watch the debate
Councillor Holland stated that, at Outline stage the Committee had determined that in order for the development to be acceptable, it should include the £5,579 per dwelling towards the maintenance of open land facilities. He did not see that that had changed as the Council was not allowed to secure S.106 agreements where they were not necessary.
Councillor Holland stated that, if the lack of that made the scheme unviable, it should not be approved.
Councillor Mark Holland put forward a motion of refusal stating that the developer needed to come back with a viable scheme.
Amended recommendation, to remove the word ‘forestry’ from Condition (vii) proposed by Councillor Jones and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Mark Holland felt that it would be helpful for the public to be exposed to more detailed information where possible and asked that Cabinet agree to more information being given when the document goes out to consultation ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Mark Holland and seconded by Councillor Paul Northcott.
Councillor Mark Holland made reference to the three grounds on which the previous application had been refused. Officers had stated that the dimensions of the proposed extension had been reduced.
This amounted to 20cm off the front and 19cm off the side and Councillor Holland was not convinced that the first reason for refusal on the previous application, relating to size and massing had been addressed.
Councillor Holland stated that he would be interested to hear other Members’ views regarding the second reason for refusal. That was in relation to encroachment into the root protection area of a highways tree. The Council’s Landscape Officer’s view was that the revised application plans were now acceptable.
Councillor Holland pointed out that in March, reference was made to the internal dimensions of the garage being 2.4m by 5.2m. However, the Manual for Streets asked for 3m by 6m to accommodate a parked vehicle. Therefore the garage could not count as a space.
Councillor Holland asked to see drawing P02 in its unrevised state and drawing 593.01 of the original application as they gave different dimensions.
The two plans requested by Councillor Holland did have different dimensions. The photograph showed the garage being narrower in the centre which was not reflected on the plans.
Councillor Holland asked the Leader if he agreed that it was nice to see that, within the Authority, so many people were working productively and that there was an excellent working relationship in Human Resources between the Council and the Trade Unions. The Leader agreed that the Unions were working closely with the Council and there was a good relationship with them. A Dying to Work Charter had just been signed which had been a cross-party venture.
Councillor Holland referred to the responses received, contained within the appendix, which had all been positive.
Responses had been received from Keele and Audley Parish Council’s and Councillor Holland asked if any others had responded.
Concerns were raised by Councillor Holland who stated that the Committee had been told this evening that the wording of condition 18 of the original decision issued by the Local Planning Authority was unjustifiable and against national policy. Officers were asked for assurance that this Authority had changed its practices in some way such that this wouldn’t occur again in the future. Elaine Moulton confirmed that the Policy changed following the issuing of that decision.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Northcott.
Councillor Holland supported the objections raised by Councillor Tagg. The extension did not sit behind the development line of Beresford Crescent. Reference was made to the Landscape Development Section’s comments regarding the tree root protection areas being unaffected if only two parking spaces were provided.
If this was to be used as a family home, Councillor Holland stated that he would like to see three parking spaces within the curtilage and, if it were to be used as a HMO he would expect to see three spaces minimum. Finally, with regard to the impact on the root protection area, the applicant had indicated that the roots from a mature highways tree intruded very slightly on the proposed development.
Councillor Holland stated that the tree was already there and the proposed development would infringe on the root protection area by 1.7m.
Councillor Holland shared the concerns of Members regarding the garages. This was a special circumstances application regarding impact on the Green Belt. The impact in terms of the footprint of the two garages compared to the existing buildings was interesting as was the difference in volumes.
Councillor Holland gave a verbal update for the Finance, Assets and Performance Scrutiny Committee which had met earlier this week to discuss the Medium Term Financial Strategy with a first draft of potential savings for the Council and a quarterly review.
Councillor Holland noted that the next meeting in January would undertake pre-decision scrutiny of the budget, fees and charges and related matters.
Councillor Gary White spoke on this application Councillor Northcott moved refusal of this application which was seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Holland felt that the correct test would be whether, had these additional features been present in the original application, would it have been approved. The Plinth and pergola had been acknowledged as appropriate development in the Green Belt by the officers so special circumstances needed to be demonstrated in order to approve them.
Councillor Holland seconded ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Holland stated that these were very good statistics with a hundred percent meeting of local performance indicators and said that it was a great tribute to the hard work of the officers.
Councillor Holland gave a verbal update on the Finance, Assets and Performance Scrutiny Committee stating that the Committee had met remotely on 25 June to discuss the Coronavirus recovery plan and had met again last Thursday with a fuller agenda.
Councillor Holland was hopeful that the next meeting, in December would be in person.
Resolved : that Councillor Mark Holland be appointed Chair for the Hearing.
Councillor Holland stated that the Scheme as set out in the Constitution had outdated language.
Councillor Jill Waring replaced Councillor Mark Holland as Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage.
Councillor Holland would replace Councillor Maxfield as member/substitute of the Council’s Scrutiny Committees and was also appointed as Deputy Leader of the Conservative Group.
A Motion was received on Brexit, proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Holland requested that the Motion be voted upon as printed stating that a ‘shopping list’ for the Borough would be sent to the Government.
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage – Councillor Mark Holland stated that people valued the regeneration of the town centre and by freezing the parking charges it would encourage people to visit.
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage – Councillor Mark Holland stated that it may be possible, in future, for the Council to find other ways of supporting the ICT users, possibly operating entirely in a ‘cloud’.
Councillor Mark Holland, the Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage stated that Clough Hall Park now hosted a Junior Park run which gives young people something valuable to do.
Councillor Holland agreed that the petition should be referred to the Heath, Wellbeing and Partnerships Scrutiny Committee to make recommendations for future actions.
Councillor Holland also thanked [name removed] for the work that she had undertaken.
Councillor Holland stated that the Constitution and member Support working Group would be happy to look more deeply into the wording.
Councillor Holland advised that this had been through the Constitution and Member Support Working Group.
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage, Councillor Mark Holland advised that issues with J2 had impacted upon the growth of membership at the facility. The Council had contracted Alliance Leisure to increase and retain the membership.
Councillor Holland referred to the award winning displays in the town and that last week, Newcastle had celebrated the Blue Band Award.
Moved by Councillor Simon Tagg and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Holland directed members to scan the Forward Plan which gave advance notice of upcoming decisions.
The Chair to the Constitution and Member Support Working Group, Councillor Mark Holland stated that the protocol had been circulated to members of the group and that they were happy with its content. A comment was made that it would be useful if officers, wherever possible , could contact any speakers should an application be withdrawn from a meeting which they were planning to attend.
Councillor Holland reminded members of the responsibility to undertake work which was directly relevant to this Committee with Councillor Kearon, in strengthening the direction of Councillor Holland’s comments with a plea to members to focus on matters which were in the control of this Committee to influence.
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage, Councillor Mark Holland welcomed the report stating that the Strategy would have a positive impact upon services, provided by the Council that the public did not see.
Councillor Holland seconded the recommendations and stated that the changes had been the subject of a technical review and affected by changes to Data Protection law and our own policies.
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage- Councillor Mark Holland stated that the centre received between ten and twelve thousand visitors each week and the Council had a responsibility to the taxpayer to get the best possible value and services from the centre. Members’ attention was drawn to paragraph 3.4 of the report and were advised that they would receive further updates in due course.
Councillor Holland stated that it was important to market the leisure centre better in the future.
Councillor Holland said that it was important that we did what we could to improve air quality within the Borough.
Councillor Holland, on behalf of the Cabinet, provided an update report in response to the recommendations made by the Scrutiny Committee on 4 March 2019. This included action to write to the Home Office seeking consideration of reclassification of Monkey Dust and further information on the Active Lives Children’s Survey. To date there had not been a response from the Home Office to the correspondence concerning Monkey Dust.
Councillor Mark Holland drew Members’ attention to paragraph 2.4 which outlines the economic benefits.
Councillor Sweeney totally supported the policy stating that it was good that a line of communication had been re-established with the Trade Unions Councillor Holland, the Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage endorsed the comments made, stating that the proposed policy had been endorsed by the Council’s Executive Management Team and the Trade Unions.
Councillor Holland was pleased to see this report and stated that progress had been made in producing a draft Single Use Plastics Strategy. The Strategy would now be referred to the Economy, Environment and Place Scrutiny Committee for comments.
Councillor Holland commented on ref 2.1 and 2.2 and praised the volunteers especially those at the Brampton Museum.
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage, Councillor Mark Holland welcomed the report stating that the reinvigoration of the Market was very important and Newcastle needed to continue as a market town. Further, the profile of the Town needed raising to bring in people from outside of the area, giving people a reason to visit and, to return.
Councillor Holland stated that good industrial relations were essential to the Council.
Councillor Holland supported the report, stating that it was important to move forward and to seek a way of avoiding charging for a Clean Air Zone.
Councillor Mark Holland seconded the recommendations adding that the Working Party had been working on this for some time and the, going forward, it would be easier to keep track of any updates.
Councillor Holland stated that the bus engine retrofit design was a separate scheme and reminded members that the buses were not owned by the Council. The Council’s Cabinet was eager to find a solution that did not include a chargeable clean air zone. In time the emissions would reduce as more vehicles became hybrid.
An amendment to the Motion, proposed by Councillor Mark Holland and seconded by Councillor Trevor Johnson was submitted, as follows:
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage, Councillor Mark Holland agreed with the Leader’s comments and commenced the Portfolio Holder for the work that had been undertaken.
Councillor Holland acknowledged Councillor Reddish’s suggestion and said that the Cabinet would like to look carefully at the provision of the sports centre and spending at the right time. The Council has a good working relationship with the Community Group.
Councillor Holland responded to Councillor Robinson’s question asking why amendments had not been submitted to the budget in respect of funding for the Sports Centre.
An amendment to the Motion, proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Simon Tagg was submitted, as follows:
Councillor Mark Holland spoke on this application.
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage , Councillor Mark Holland endorsed the previous comments and congratulated the Leader on negotiating the Deal.
Councillor Holland said that it was encouraging to see how much the document strengthened the Council’s corporate priorities, especially around town centres and growth.
Councillor Holland thanked Councillor Waring for the work that had gone into this. The project had received a warm reception at the Scrutiny Committee. It was in everyone’s best interest to have a flexible CCTV programme.
With regard to the Council Plan, Councillor Holland said he was happy that one of the Council’s Corporate Priorities had changed from being a ‘Co-operative Council’ to ‘Council Services Working for Local People’.
A Motion was received on the use of Single-Use Plastics, proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Jennifer Cooper.
The Leader reported minor changes to the Portfolio of the following Cabinet members as follows:- Councillor Mark Holland (Sport, Leisure and Culture) to include tourism.
The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Councillor Holland stated that, as per the Motion, a report would be taken to the appropriate Scrutiny Committee and that the process would get underway as soon as possible.
Revised recommendation proposed by Councillor Proctor and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Subsequently an amendment to the motion was proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Jill Waring :
Councillor Robinson asked The Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Councillor Holland why Clough Hall Park was no longer locked up in the evenings and why there was no formal consultation?
Councillor Holland spoke on this application.
Councillor Holland spoke on this application.
Proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Tagg.
Councillor Mark Holland – Portfolio Holder for Sport and Leisure.
Councillor Holland requested a correction to the first recommendation that the two existing committees be replaced by an employment committee and not a staffing committee as printed in the report.
Councillor Holland queried the number of unanswered calls and this had been as a result of the introduction of the new recycling service and election enquiries.
Councillor Holland paid tribute to the work undertaken by Councillor Gardner as the previous Chair .
Proposed by Councillor John Williams and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Holland commented on the change of the start time of the meeting. Whilst he appreciated that in some instances it is justifiable due to the amount of business, this evening’s meeting had been concluded in one and a half hours. He stated that some Members found it difficult to attend earlier due to work commitments and that some members of the public also found it difficult to attend if they were working.
Councillor Holland questioned the outcome from the consultation and how to ensure that the information generated was useful to inform future plans. Anna Collins hoped to achieve a co-production and co-design mechanism by asking questions such as “what services would be appropriate in your area”. Each of the community hospital sites were different and so may have different options, the optimum would be to achieve the best service model for each community.
Proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Northcott.
Proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear
Councillor Reddish moved and Councillor Holland seconded that a Special Council meeting be convened to consider the report.
An amendment to this motion was proposed by Councillor Loades and seconded by Councillor Holland concerning accuracy. A vote to amend the motion was lost
A motion was received, proposed by Councillor Holland, seconded by Councillor Fear regarding the EU Referendum.
With regard to membership of the Constitution Working Group and it was agreed that Councillor Holland would lead the group, together with Councillors Proctor and Spence, Councillor Winfield would attend on an ad hoc basis.
Councillor Holland declared an interest on application 15/01085/OUT as a Governor of Friarswood Primary School.
The motion was proposed by Cllr Holland and seconded by Cllr Reddish.
A named vote was requested by Cllr Holland and this request was confirmed by over 12 other Members in the Chamber.
The decision of the Cabinet had been called in by Cllr Sweeney, Cllr Mrs Heames , Cllr Loades, Cllr Holland and Cllr Northcott.
The decision had been called in by Cllr Holland, Cllr Loades, Cllr Sweeney, Cllr Jones, Cllr Huckfield and Cllr Northcott.
A second amendment to the recommendations was proposed by Cllr Sweeney and seconded by Cllr Holland and read as follows:
A representation had been submitted by Cllr Mark Holland.
Cllr Holland outlined his representation which focused on concerns of the residents of the Westlands Ward regarding the in principal earmarking of green spaces for development.
Question 4 Cllr Holland asked a question regarding three Council staff being employed on zero-hour contracts (when, according to the Sentinel on 21 August, the Council had phased them out).
Cllr Holland asked if a list could be drawn up of all past zero-hour contracts.
Question 5 Cllr Holland asked when the Leader would be moving from the City of Stoke on Trent to the Borough of Newcastle-under- Lyme?
The following question had been submitted by Cllr Holland:
Councillor Holland spoke on this application.
Members enquired as to whether the information referred to on page 5 of the agenda in relation to the minutes from the County Council had been provided to Cllr Holland. The enquiry would be passed to the Council Leader for clarification.
The Group consists of three Members, Cllr Elizabeth Shenton (Chair), Cllr Mark Holland and Cllr Nigel Jones. Members requested that clarity be sought from Cabinet as to what it viewed the role of a Cabinet Panel to be.
Cllr Holland raised some concerns with Cabinet Members regarding the new proposals. The main concern related to the fact that by having no Local Plan the Council was vulnerable to planning applications being submitted to which it would have little power to object. Concerns also related to the fact that the City Council would view the Borough Council as the junior partner in the relationship, that the City Council would not stick to the required timescales and that Option B (separate full local plan) in the report was the most cost effective option but had been rejected in favour of Option C.
I am informed it was understood at Full Council that he said he was going to publish them when responding in debate to Cllr Mark Holland.’ In response to the question, Cllr Snell stated that he was currently collating all the relevant information which included email correspondence as well as minutes, these would be published to Members in the near future. A Member asked why the Council was using Windows 7 rather than Open Office.
Question 3 submitted by Cllr Holland:
It was proposed by Councillor Mark Holland, seconded by Councillor Gillian Heesom and …
Councillor Mark Holland proposed the following amendment:- “That resolution 1 be deleted, and resolution 2 be amended to read:
It was agreed that Councillor Miss Baker, Councillor Cairns and Councillor Holland would form the working group.
An amendment was proposed by Cllr Holland who stated that there were no Government plans as yet only a decision to look at the evidence; therefore it would not make it harder (as set out in the proposal) for schools and other public services to recruit and retain good quality professionals.
Cllr Holland highlighted that this did not mean the Council should not voice concern or write to the suggested recipients.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Holland attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Feb 2026 | Planning Committee | Application for minor development - land rear of 57 high street, alsagers bank. mr mohammed saleem. 25/00851/pip | 3 for, 3 against, 6 abstained | ||
| 3 Feb 2026 | Planning Committee | Application for minor development - land off wereton road, audley. mr stephen adams. 25/00883/pip | Carried | 5 for, 3 against, 4 abstained | |
| 24 Nov 2025 | Health, Wellbeing & Environment Scrutiny Committee | Walleys quarry odour issues | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Jun 2025 | Conservation Advisory Working Party | Conservation and heritage fund | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2025 | Planning Committee | Application for major development - former jubilee baths, nelson place, newcastle. integritas property group (ipg) number 8 ltd. 25/00008/ful | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Feb 2024 | Council | Motions of members | Carried | 23 for, 16 against | |
| 11 Oct 2022 | Planning Committee | Application for major development - park hill farm, park lane. mrs pat pimlott. 22/00214/ful | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Sep 2022 | Council | Motions of members | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Nov 2021 | Council | Recommendations of the independent remuneration panel | Lost | 16 for, 24 against, 0 abstained | |
| 7 Oct 2020 | Employment Committee | Appointment of an appointments sub-committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Nov 2019 | Council | Review and update of the borough council of newcastle-under-lyme's council and committee procedure rules | Lost | 20 for, 21 against | |
| 25 Nov 2015 | Council | Motions of Members | Carried | 31 for, 19 against, 5 abstained | |
| 1 Jul 2015 | Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committee | Land Asset Disposal | Lost | 3 for, 5 against | |
| 18 Mar 2015 | Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committee | Urgent Business | Carried | 4 for, 1 against | |
| 25 Feb 2015 | Council | Capital Strategy 2015 | Lost | 26 for, 28 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2015 | Council | Scheme of Delegation in Relation to Planning Functions | Carried | 28 for, 25 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2015 | Council | Scheme of Delegation in Relation to Planning Functions | Carried | 27 for, 2 against, 24 abstained | |
| 16 Dec 2014 | Joint Finance, Resources & Partnerships and Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committees | Asset Management Strategy | Carried | 9 for, 7 against | |
| 16 Dec 2014 | Joint Finance, Resources & Partnerships and Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committees | Asset Management Strategy | 9 for, 9 against | ||
| 12 Sep 2012 | Council | Treasury Management Annual Report 2011/12 | Carried | 30 for, 9 against, 8 abstained | |
| 12 Sep 2012 | Council | Motions of Members | Lost | 12 for, 39 against | |
| 12 Sep 2012 | Council | Motions of Members | Carried | 38 for, 0 against |
Meetings Councillor Holland was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 23 of 30 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Holland declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Jul 2025 | Planning Committee, item 6 | Councillor Holland declared an interest as a resident of Clayton Road and asked if any information had been received on vehicle movements. | |
| 13 Mar 2025 | Economy and Place Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Cllr Holland declared an interest on behalf of members of the Planning Committee in relation to item 6 and planning applications that had not yet been determined. Members who were concerned were asked to be mindful of not letting this interest predetermine the outcomes. | |
| 13 Dec 2021 | Finance, Assets & Performance Scrutiny Committee, item 20 | Councillor Holland declared an interest in item 4 Revenue & Capital budget 2022/23 – First Draft Savings Plan - on the grounds that he was a Director of the Trust that ran the New Vic Theatre. Click here to watch the debate | |
| 29 Mar 2016 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Holland declared an interest on application 15/01085/OUT as a Governor of Friarswood Primary School. |
Where Councillor Holland sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 120 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2016 | 103 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Finance, Assets & Performance Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2019 | 36 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Standards Committee | Substitute | Jul 2016 | 32 | |
| Economy and Place Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Aug 2022 | 15 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Health, Wellbeing & Environment Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jun 2022 | 6 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Local Government Reorganisation Cabinet Panel | Committee Member | Mar 2026 | 1 | |
| Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2011 | 34 | |
| Cabinet | Guest | Dec 2017 | 24 | |
| Conservation Advisory Working Party | Guest | Sep 2011 | 13 | |
| Finance, Resources and Partnerships Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jun 2014 | 12 | |
| Health,Wellbeing & Partnerships Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2019 | 12 | |
| Staffing Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2013 | 10 | |
| Active and Cohesive Communities Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2012 | 4 | |
| Health and Wellbeing Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2014 | 4 | |
| Grants Assessment Panel | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 3 | |
| Audit and Standards Hearing Panel | Chair | Sep 2020 | 3 | |
| Employment Committee | Substitute | Oct 2020 | 3 | |
| Joint Finance, Resources & Partnerships and Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committees | Committee Member | Dec 2014 | 2 | |
| Cleaner Greener and Safer Communities Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2016 | 2 | |
| Economy, Environment & Place Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Nov 2019 | 2 | |
| Libraries Staffordshire Consultation | Committee Member | Sep 2014 | 1 | |
| Investigation and Disciplinary Panel | Chair | Dec 2018 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Task and Finish Group - Climate Change/Sustainability | Committee Member | Sep 2020 | 1 | |
| Appointments Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.