Declarations of Interest
Councillor M Evans declared an interest in Item 4 as a family member lives on Groes Road..
Every time Newport's minutes name Councillor Evans, as the council published it.
Councillor M Evans declared an interest in Item 4 as a family member lives on Groes Road..
This question was also raised by Cllr Evans 2026/27:
Councillor Evans referred to schemes being put in place that aimed to reduce congestion on the M4, for example, the A48 from St Mellons to Magor, reducing two lanes for motorists, that would be used by a ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Councillor Evans supported the proposal.
The Leader formally moved Councillor Debbie Harvey as the Mayor for the municipal year 2026/27, which was seconded by the Opposition Leader, Councillor Matthew Evans.
Councillor Evans highlighted delays in replacing two damaged street name plates he reported last March. Despite being told one would be replaced within 6–8 weeks, neither has been fixed and one is now missing. He, therefore, questioned whether the Cabinet Member was satisfied with this level of service.
Councillor Evans felt that the Leader misunderstood the point. To have a three-course meal in a luxury place for residents and staff who would like an evening to remember, was a rewarding experience and therefore asked the Leader to reconsider.
The Leader was happy to meet with Councillor Evans to discuss a way to celebrate members of the community in an affordable way.
Councillor Evans referred to a school in Sutton Coldfield where pork was taken off the menu as a human error. This also happened in a school in Cardiff, where pork was taken off the menu.
Councillor Evans hoped that these issues should be debated in public, so that the Council could be united against these rumours on social media to dispel them and asked if the Cabinet Member agreed with this.
Councillor Howells will nevertheless meet with Councillor Evans to discuss the matter .
Councillor Evans referred to the university's contractual commitments related to the Newport knowledge quarter, referencing a 2018 application and a Memorandum of Understanding involving Newport City Council, University of South Wales, and Coleg Gwent. The university reportedly spent £3.2 million in Newport but left a £3 million shortfall, contrasting with £40 million spent on Treforest.
Councillor Evans felt it was important to reclaim promised funds or ensure development within the city.
Did the Leader therefore agree with Councillor Evans.
Councillor Fouweather should note that many of the questions raised have broad similarities to Cllr Matthew Evans questions and the response to Question 2025/10. However, this additional information should support clarity on paragraphs 3 and 4:
§ Councillor Evans referred to the use of drones by police and asked about the controls in place concerning privacy. Supt White confirmed that planned activities using drones only took place once a full assessment had been completed and authorised, including privacy considerations.
Councillor Evans referred to the 82 households with children in Bed and Breakfast accommodation and added that the Council had previously stated it would not put a child in this situation.
Councillor Evans felt that these statistics were shocking in terms of their impact for children and families but were also expensive.
The Deputy Leader formally moved Councillor Kate Thomas as the Mayor for the municipal year 2025/26, which was seconded by the Opposition Leader, Councillor Matthew Evans.
The Leader proposed the designation of Mike Wallbank as Monitoring Officer and Councillor Evans seconded the proposal.
Councillor Dimitri Batrouni – The Leader of the Council Councillor Matthew Evans – The Leader of the Opposition Councillor Kevin Whitehead – The Leader of the Newport Independents Councillor Mark Howells – The Leader of the Lliswerry Independents The Chair opened discussion by noting that whilst all Members had completed the Code of Conduct training the Committee felt it was worthwhile to continue meeting with the Group Leaders every other quarter to ensure full compliance and to establish a rapport.
Councillor Evans seconded the report.
The Presiding Member invited Councillor Evans to introduce the Notice of Motion, with Councillor Routley to second.
Councillor Evans read out the Notice of Motion and took the opportunity to add:
§ Councillor Evans supported the report.
Councillor Evans (Torfaen) asked if the costs relating to the roof had increased following the initial investment. The Newport Norse Representative explained that should the roof be repaired in a targeted way then the costs would be lower however should the roof need to be fully repaired then the costs would be higher. The Service Manager Environment and Leisure highlighted the issues found by the building surveyors such as the wooden battens, however the survey was conducted by drone.
Councillor Evans (Torfaen) asked were any actions outstanding from Audit Wales. The Finance Business Partner - Systems with Finance IT Project responsibilities explained that there was a £1 adjustment however there had not been any issues other than a narrative change on the Annual Return.
Councillor Evans (Torfaen) questioned how long the trail period was on the early and late slots. The Team Manager-Bereavement noted there was no requirement to stop the process, but the officers would inform the Committee in the future of the feedback.
The Presiding Member welcomed Councillor Evans back to the Council meeting and was pleased to see that he was feeling better.
Councillor Evans thanked everyone across the floor for their well wishes.
Councillor Evans seconded the report.
Councillor Evans felt that it was not appropriate ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
This would help provide a targeted evidence-based approach. § Councillor Evans referred to anti-social behaviour and the results of the bus and wi-fi survey in that people felt that they might be a victim of crime in Newport, which was concerning. Residents were tired of excuses and wanted concrete action and therefore hoped that this approach would bring the city back on track.
Councillor Evans then asked would residents be hit with massive council ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Cllr Matthew Evans (Leader of the Opposition) and Cllr Allan Morris (Leader of the Lliswerry Independents)
Councillor M Evans agreed that she was a passionate and intelligent woman who had made a difference.
§ Councillor Evans had mixed views on the report and referred to figures in the corporate plan as inadequate. Whilst he recognised that radical action was needed, empty properties are a complex issue which may not be addressed under this approach. Whilst there were statutory exemptions to the payment of premiums, a more pragmatic approach should be taken.
There are only 15 second homes in Newport and Councillor Evans did not believe that their council tax should double and may not be worth collecting or chasing.
Councillor Evans was not against taking reasonable actions against the backlog of empty properties blighting the city but could not support the changes regarding second homes and would therefore abstain from supporting the report.
Councillor Evans seconded the report.
The Leader formally moved Councillor Ray Mogford as the Mayor for the municipal year 2024/25, which was seconded by the Opposition Leader, Councillor Matthew Evans.
The Leader of the Opposition, Councillor Evans also supported the nomination of Councillor R Mogford as Mayor for 2024/25.
§ Councillor Evans explained the role of a PCSOs, who provided key support in community policing.
Councillor Evans wanted assurance that Newport communities were not disadvantaged by a freeze on the recruitment of PCSO’s.
Supt White agreed on the importance of PCSOs and assured Councillor Evans that there are good levels of PCSO support in place. Based on needs and demands they would be placed in the community where needed.
At the request of Councillor Evans, the amendment was circulated to Members for their information.
The Chair asked the Leader of the Opposition, Councillor Matthew Evans to provide an update.
Cllr Evans informed the Committee that all Members had completed the Code of Conduct training and added that the figures for attending additional training had been requested.
Cllr Evans noted that it had been previously discussed that there was often an overlap with training where Members may be required to repeat the same training for external positions they hold and queried whether this could be discussed.
Cllr Evans noted that there had been no complaints about Councillor Conduct since the last update.
The Chair thanked Cllr Evans and invited the Leader of the Newport Independents Party, Cllr Whitehead to speak.
§ Cllr Evans asked a hypothetical question about his back garden and the Superintendent advised that such instances would be dealt with on a case-by-case basis and could be deemed as criminal damage, but similar situations would be checked with other agencies such as Welsh Water before making a determination on this.
Councillor Evans asked what judicial powers the police had in relation to travellers and how difficult this was to enforce. Superintendent White stated that Section 60 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 2022 was introduced to give police more powers to deal with illegal encampments, however, three criteria under this legislation had to be met before this could be enforced: significant damage to land, significant disruption, and significant distress. Encampments had set up in Newport in the past with pockets of incidents of theft, damage, and disorder but it was not deemed to be significant.
Councillor Evans requested that Councillor Reeks be nominated to be LEA Governor for Jubilee Park School.
The Chief Superintendent assured the Council that residents can call anonymously through Crimestoppers. § Councillor Evans referred to the use of e-bikes, quad bikes on roads.
Councillor Evans had witnessed these proceeding through two sets of red lights and speeding on Queensway.
Councillor Evans said he observed that there was a police van on the opposite side of the road that did not appear to take any action.
Councillor Evans went on to say that he appreciated the sensitivities around this, and asked if the Chief Superintendent could explain why it was not as easy to stop these bikes in some cases. The Chief Superintendent agreed that it was not as simple as stopping a car or other licensed vehicles. The Chief Superintendent added that whilst the police had to act proportionately, this did not excuse people to break the law.
§ Councillor M Evans echoed the comments of the Leader and added that the report was clear and concise.
Councillor Evans also requested that future reports provide percentages to contextualise the figures.
§ Councillor M Evans referred to the compliance targets suggesting that access to training should be made easier for Members and officers to attend, as safeguarding is important.
§ Councillor M Evans responded by saying that he had not yet received a response.
The Leader added that the cross-party support was tremendous and thanked Councillor Evans who was in attendance for events throughout the day as well as colleagues from other political parties.
Councillor Evans agreed to look at the one of payment at a later date.
Councillor Evans asked about the urgency in hiring the roles as it relates to which ones will be sought to be filled first.
Councillor Evans would like the staff to be informed of the positive report.
It was moved and seconded by Councillor Evans that Councillor Mudd be appointed as Leader of the Council.
B (Pages 11 - 12) Councillor Routley presented the report to the committee in place of Councillor Evans who sent his apologies for not being able to attend.
The Chair noted that the stencil was not filled in like the others and noted that Councillor Evans had stated that they did not feel the need to do refresher training and that maybe there’s a need to look at this in the future to make it less onerous with hybrid meetings making training easier.
Councillor Cockeram confirmed that on the report Councillor Evans stated that he felt there was no need to duplicate training if people received training as part of their day job.
§ Councillor Evans on behalf of the conservative group fully supported the report.
§ Councillor M Evans referred to the 20mph enforcement across the city and asked would police resources be affected by maintaining this.
The Superintendent assured Councillor Evans that front line officers would not redirected from other duties to dealing with new speed enforcement issues.
The Deputy Leader was delighted to formally move Councillor Watkins as the Mayor for 2023/24, which was also seconded by Councillor M Evans.
Councillor M Evans understood that whilst there was no provision in the Standing Orders for the Deputy Leader to speak, his Conservative colleagues were of the view that the Deputy Leader could deputise for this item in the absence of the Leader.
Councillor Morris echoed the comments of Councillor M Evans and believed that questions had been covered by the Deputy Leader in the past.
The Leader, Councillor Evans, Whitehead, Jordan, Morris and Al-Nuaimi all took the opportunity to say a few words of personal thanks for Gareth’s hard work and support during his 39 years of working for the Council and wished him a long happy retirement.
§ Councillor Evans referred to Asylum Seekers and refugees being placed in Newport without the police being notified. Whilst this was not an issue for the majority of placements, there could be people with criminal backgrounds being placed in the city. Was there anything that the Police could do to rectify this?
Councillor Jane Mudd – Leader of Newport Labour Party Councillor Matthew Evans – Leader of Newport Conservative Party Councillor Allan Morris – Leader of Independent Party Lliswerry Councillor Kevin Whitehead – Leader of Newport Independent Party The Chair expressed his concern to Councillor M.
Councillor Evans apologised for the absence of his peer.
Councillor M Evans seconded the motion.
The Presiding Member invited Councillor Evans to speak:
It was moved and seconded by Councillor Evans that Councillor Mudd be appointed as leader of the Council.
This was seconded by Councillor Evans.
The Leader moved the approval and adoption of the Pay & Reward Statement 22/23.This was seconded by Councillor Evans.
This was seconded by Councillor M Evans. Resolved : That Standing Orders be waived to enable the emergency motion to be presented.
We will support all efforts to secure a peaceful and diplomatic solution, and for conflict and loss of life to be avoided .” The Motion was seconded by Councillor M Evans, who took the opportunity to speak.
Cllr M Evans thanked the Leader for inviting him to second the Motion.
Councillor M Evans went on to say:
Councillor M Evans, therefore requested an amendment which was seconded by Councillor Fouweather, that further information on the job description and remuneration be referred back to the Democratic Services Committee for further discussion.
§ Councillor M Evans spoke in support of the amendment., The appointment of a Presiding Member was originally turned down in 2019 because there was a cost to this role and was not sure if it was a fixed term appointment of five years. In addition to this, it was felt that the role of the Mayor would be diminished and under valued and should therefore go back to the Democratic Services Committee.
At this point, Councillor Evans asked for a recorded vote on the amended motion.
The Leader was delighted to formally move Councillor Kellaway as the Mayor for 2022/23, which was also seconded by Councillor M Evans.
The general view was that it was welcome, Councillor Matthew Evans was concerned about the number of modules so discussed that the main thing was to identify which were mandatory and specific to individual roles so they can undertake certain roles. Although there was an initial concern – the team explained to the Committee that Members didn’t have to attend all of the modules; that is why they wanted to clarify which ones would be mandatory or specific to their committee role.
§ Councillor Whitehead supported the motion and agreed that biodiversity was very important and mentioned the increased reporting of Himalayan balsam that strangled the brook in Bettws and hoped that this would be addressed as part of this motion. § Councillor M Evans informed colleagues that the Conservative group would support this motion, as well as supporting previous council initiatives such as the Bee ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor M Evans welcomed and fully supported the motion, although he was disappointed not to have been consulted beforehand.
The Leader moved the report, which was seconded by Councillor M Evans.
Councillor Matthew Evans asked:
The Leader proposed that Councillor D Williams was elected Mayor of the City of Newport for the coming year and this was seconded by Councillor Matthew Evans .
The motion was moved by Councillor M Evans and seconded by Councillor Routley.
Councillor M Evans introduced the motion by advising councillors to consider asking the Welsh Government to implement a referendum. This would give the Welsh Parliament the opportunity to debate the benefits of engaging with the electorate on an issue that affected everyone across the city.
Councillor M Evans mentioned that after a public enquiry, by the Independent Commission concluded that an M4 relief road should go ahead. The First Minister however took the decision not to debate this recommendation and therefore did not go ahead with the construction of the relief road.
Councillor M Evans mentioned that previous Leaders had supported the M4 relief road. A non-binding referendum would show the strength of feeling of the residents of Newport, one way or another. This would be more meaningful than a petition.
Councillor M Evans confirmed that it was the black route.
The initial for Councillor M Evans and C Evans being excluded.
In addition, Councillor M Evans asked that the sentence be changed to ‘He’ commented instead of ‘they’.
Councillor M Evans, considered it should be changed at local level to allow back benchers to ask questions as well as including public participation as this was encouraging democracy, therefore it was ideal to make a recommendation at this meeting.
Councillor M Evans referred to the extension of 15 minutes to Questions to the Leader and considered that it would be ideal to make a recommendation to change this at today’s meeting.
Councillor M Evans was however disappointed that this issue ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Councillor M Evans, agreed that the e-Learning platforms should be relatively simply designed for Councillors. There was an incredible amount of information and if councillors were to be encouraged to access these, modules could be streamlined. There were 37 modules, which was far too many and these should be streamlined.
Councillor M Evans also preferred attending the Civic to meet with councillors at training sessions.
The motion was moved by Councillor Routley and seconded by Councillor M Evans.
This was seconded by Councillor M Evans.
The Mayor congratulated Councillor Matthew Evans on the award of his MBE.
Councillor Evans stated that there could be a look at inclusion of the people we represent and as ward meetings were suspended maybe remote surgeries could be held in future to connect with people.
Councillor Matthew Evans asked:
It was proposed by the Leader and seconded by Councillor Matthew Evans that that Councillor Tom Suller be appointed Mayor of the City of Newport and Chair of Council for the current municipal year.
Councillor Matthew Evans, asked that it be noted that he would be voting against the recommendation of the Appointments Sub-Committee.
I am unable to comment on this specific case, as I am unaware of the resident’s details, but if, Cllr Evans, you wish to provide me with a name and address, I will ask officers to investigate.
The Minutes of the above Committee from 24 October 2019 and 20 February 2020 were noted, along with the following recommendations, which was presented by Councillor M Evans in the absence of the Chair of Democratic Services Committee.
Councillor M Evans, referred to page 11 under Leader’s Questions, Council Tax increases. First paragraph should read that the Council Tax increase should not be any more than the inflation rate.
This was seconded by Councillor M Evans.
Councillor M Evans referred to the Public Spaces Protection Order (PSPO) in relation ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor M Evans referred to the Presiding Officer item, which went to the Committee on 24 October 2019. The Monitoring Officer advised that the Minutes would be brought to Council following the approval at the next meeting of the Democratic Services Committee.
Leader’s Questions Councillor M Evans thanked the Leader and continued with his question in relation to budget proposals, requesting that the Leader would extend the consultation period, as Caerphilly Council had started their consultation period much earlier. In addition to this it was suggested that apart from any rise in inflation, there would be a freeze on Council tax increases to council.
Councillor M Evans was invited to ask a supplementary, where he reiterated that he hoped for the sake of Newport residents that the only increase to the council tax would reflect the rate of inflation with no further increases by the Council.
The Leader also mentioned that it would be remiss of her not to acknowledge volunteers that help keep Newport tidy, including Councillors Forsey and Councillor M Evans. Hygiene factors were very important and all members needed to be aware of all the activities.
Councillor M Evans congratulated the Leader endorsing the Mayor’s comments and mentioned that being Leader of the Council was a difficult and challenging job as well as being WLGA Leader, especially in the current political climate and on behalf of the conservative group wished the Leader all the best.
The Leader had since spoken with her colleague Councillor M Evans, Leader of the Opposition and was happy to amend the report to read that should there be a 12 month extension, the Leader, Deputy Leader and Leader of the Opposition take this decision jointly, in order to have a politically balanced panel. The Leader therefore requested that the Chief Legal Officer present at Council note the changes.
Councillor M Evans, thanked the Leader for this and fully supported the report.
Councillor M Evans referred to the summary on page 44 of the Annual Report, outlining the major developments and achievements that year and suggested that there was room for improvement. The page in question was not descriptive enough and provided no evidence of what was being done . It was felt that there was a need to be more succinct and focus on what had been achieved .
Councillor M Evans therefore advised that he would support the report but felt there was room for improvement and that in future there should be a list of achievements included The report was seconded by Councillor Al-Nuaimi .
Leaders Questions Orb Steelworks Councillor M Evans referred to the announcement that hundreds of jobs were under threat at TATA Orb Factory which was disappointing news for the workforce, family and wider community and thoughts were with them at this difficult time. Support was offered from AMs and MPs and a statement was given by Ken Skates, Wales Economy Minister who said that the Welsh Government would do everything it could to support individuals, the community and supply chain affected by the news .
Councillor M Evans did not recall anything being mentioned sooner by the Leader and asked what had the Council therefore done over the past few years and since the announcement to address their concerns.
In addition, Councillor M Evans asked the Leader to address what the Council had done over the past few years. The Council had an economic development department that would be expected to be involved in such matters ,in addition, could the Leader also be more specific on what assistance would be offered to the employees now and in the past.
I would refer Councillor Evans to my previous response to his earlier question on climate change (2019/19), which clearly sets out the considerable amount of work already being undertaken by this Council to address problems of climate change.
· In relation to the enforcement of the City Centre Public Space Protection Order, particularly relating to begging within 10 metres of a cash point, Councillor Matthew Evans highlighted that this continued to be an issue for local residents both at night and during the day.
The motion was moved by Councillor Matthew Evans, seconded by Councillor Chris Evans.
Leaders Questions M4 Relief Road In relation to the Welsh Government’s recent decision not to build the M4 Relief Road, Councillor Matthew Evans asked the Leader whether this meant that Newport residents would continue to face the same issues with heavy congestion and air pollution, and sought assurances that the Leader would stop any attempts by the Welsh Government to close motorway junctions in Newport.
Councillor Evans asked a supplementary question to seek assurances that the funding outlined by the First Minister would spent in Newport to address transport and congestion issues.
Post Appointed Leader and Chair of Cabinet Cllr Debbie Wilcox Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Equalities and Assets Cllr Mark Whitcutt Cabinet Member for Education and Skills Cllr Gail Giles Cabinet Member for Social Services Cllr Paul Cockeram Cabinet Member for City Services Cllr Roger Jeavons Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Housing Cllr Jane Mudd Cabinet Member for Licensing and Regulation Cllr Ray Truman Cabinet Member for Community and Resources Cllr David Mayer Cabinet Member for Culture and Leisure, and Business Manager Cllr Deb Harvey Opposition Spokespersons Councillor Matthew Evans announced that he would act as Leader of the Opposition. Opposition spokespersons were announced as follows:
It was proposed by Councillor Wilcox, and seconded by Councillor M Evans and unanimously Resolved That Councillor William J Routley be elected as the Mayor of the City of Newport for the next year.
It was proposed by the Mayor, seconded by Councillor M Evans, and unanimously Resolved That Councillor Charles Ferris be appointed Deputy Mayor for the ensuring year.
- Councillor M Evans raised concerns regarding safety in the city centre, Detective Superintendent Ian Roberts outlined that there were around 30 incidents in the city centre and the police work with those affected to consider the underlying issues. When considering homelessness and rough sleeping, the officer outlined the importance of striking the balance between supporting vulnerable people and taking appropriate enforcement action.
Councillor M Evans spoke in support of option 3a, as it addressed the under-representation of Rogerstone in the most practical way within the options available, and provided 2 wards of 2 councillors each, rather than creating single member wards.
Councillor M Evans spoke against option 4a. citing the discussion supported at the Democratic Services Committee that the Mon Bank area of Pillqwenlly was closer in proximity to Stow Hill which made Option 4b a more practical option.
Cllr M Evans moved the following amendment:
Newport Economic Network Councillor M Evans raised concerns regarding the Cabinet’s stated commitment to openness and transparency; firstly citing that a Cabinet Member had refused to answer a questions at Scrutiny Committee relating to the Newport Economic Network; and secondly citing examples of significant decisions being taken in private. In order to promote openness and transparency, the Leader was asked whether a public meeting with local business people would be held to listen to their concerns and issues. The Leader outlined that the Newport Economic Network was an external meeting, and the answer to the question asked needed to come from the Network rather than the Cabinet Member.
The Leader agreed to pass on Cllr Evans comments to the Chair of the Network and seek clarification on the points raised. In relation to the decisions taken confidentially, the Leader highlighted the established precedence for this approach and issues of commercial confidentiality that can impact on the availability of information ahead of decisions relating to major projects.
As a supplementary question, Cllr Evans queried the amount of detail included in the minuted decisions in the examples cited. In response, the Leader asked that the advice previously given by the Chief Executive and the Head of Law and Regulation regarding public access to reports be circulated.
Newport Market Councillor Matthew Evans raised concerns from Newport Market traders about the lack of communication from the Council about the plans for the development, and asked whether proposals would be brought before full Council for consideration.
- Councillor Matthew Evans reiterated concerns about illegal parking and in particular the impact of this on those with disabilities, young children and elderly people who were greatly affected by the obstruction and safety issues resulting from this problem.
The motion was moved by Councillor Matthew Evans, and seconded by Councillor Ray Mogford:
In moving the motion, Councillor Matthew Evans condemned the cruelty and inhumane way in which the animals were treated at this festival, and urged the Council to agree to write a strongly worded letter condemning the practices of festival. It was emphasised that it was the treatment of the animals at the festival that was to focus of the petition.
Economic Development Summit Councillor Matthew Evans asked for confirmation as to whether an Economic Development Summit was taking place this Thursday at the Celtic Manor, and if so, who had arranged it, who was invited, and asked for clarification as to why it was being held in private. The Leader clarified that a round table discussion was being held with interested parties emanating from the discussions at the Newport Economic Network. Invitees included the Leader and Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Housing as Members of the Network.
As a supplementary question, Councillor Matthew Evans asked how this summit would address the issues in the city centre. The Leader clarified that this type of discussion would allow for a detailed and frank discussion with the Newport Economic Network. There were limits to the role of the Council in improving the economic environment within the national context, and the purpose of this meeting was to look for tangible and realistic actions and outcomes for Newport.
- In relation to parking enforcement, Councillor Matthew Evans asked for confirmation of the approach being taken by the Police up until the transfer of responsibilities to the Council, following a letter circulated by the Chief Constable in April indicating that support would be withdrawn from December 2018. o The Chief Executive reported that he had subsequently spoken to the Chief Constable who had given verbal assurances that he was prepared to extend this deadline to 30 June, ready for the transfer of responsibilities on 1 July 2019. Formal confirmation of this was expected shortly.
Newport Market Councillor Matthew Evans asked for an update on the development proposals for Newport Market, and when progress would be reported to Cabinet. The Leader responded that due diligence was still taking place and when completed would go to the next stage of development, including reports.
Councillor Evans queried how long the due diligence would take, highlighting the pressure on traders at this time of year, and requesting an update before Christmas.
The Leader highlighted the liaison taking place with the traders at the moment, and agreed to provide a response to Councillor Evans on the details of the timeframe.
The Council’s corporate plan gives a commitment to deliver a second HWRC site in Newport, and as Councillor Evans will be aware, a comprehensive review of the waste strategy has been carried out to help us meet Welsh Government recycling targets. Scrutiny has made recommendations to the Cabinet Member, and these form part of the public consultation exercise that commenced in mid-October.
Parking Charges at Belle Vue Park Councillor Matthew Evans raised concerns about the impact of introducing parking charges at Belle Vue Park, asking how this linked with the Council’s wellbeing objectives.
Councillor Matthew Evans proposed the following amendment to the order:
Speaking to the amendment, Councillor Matthew Evans put forward that the current ban on aggressive begging was unenforceable, and the proposal to introduce an exclusion zone around cash points would create the same problem.
University Provision Referring to the Labour manifesto commitments to support university education in the city, Councillor Matthew Evans asked about the number of university students currently studying in Newport, speculating that it must be less than the 9,000 students studying here in 2012.
Councillor Evans asked a supplementary question about the relationship with the university, referencing the previously vibrant student scene in the city, with only a fraction of USW’s 20,000 students now coming to Newport.
With regards to item 4 (Independent Remuneration Panel - Determination 43) Cllr Matthew Evans wanted it recorded that there were differing opinions on the reimbursement of costs of care and whether claims should be anonymised.
Post Appointed Leader & Chair of Cabinet Cllr Debbie Wilcox Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Assets, Equalities and Member Development Cllr Mark Whitcutt Cabinet Member for Education and Skills Cllr Gail Giles Cabinet Member for Social Services Cllr Paul Cockeram CM for Streetscene Cllr Roger Jeavons Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Housing Cllr Jane Mudd Cabinet Member for Licensing and Regulation Cllr Ray Truman Cabinet Member for Community and Resources Cllr David Mayer Cabinet Member for Culture and Leisure, and Business Manager Cllr Deb Harvey Opposition Spokespersons Councillor Matthew Evans announced that he would act as Leader of the Opposition. Opposition spokespersons were announced as follows:
It was proposed by Councillor Wilcox and seconded by Councillor M Evans and unanimously Resolved That Councillor Malcolm Linton be elected as the Mayor of the City of Newport for the next year.
It was proposed by the Mayor, seconded by Councillor M Evans, and unanimously Resolved That Councillor Phil Hourahine be appointed Deputy Mayor for the ensuing year.
- In response to a question from Councillor Matthew Evans, Superintendent Roberts assured Council that Gwent Police would continue to carry out parking enforcement until those powers were transferred to the Council.
The motion was moved by Councillor M Evans and seconded by Councillor Wilcox:
In moving the motion, Councillor M Evans cited the campaign by the South Wales Argus in 2002 to get the Ebbw Vale line “back on track”. There was cross party support then and now for the reopening of the line, and progress was needed as a priority.
Councillor Matthew Evans reported that Cardiff Council were considering introducing congestion charges and levies on car parking, and asked the Leader to rule out any similar plans being introduced in Newport. The Leader responded that she recognised the particular issues with parking in Cardiff, but could not comment upon the actions of another Council, and would not be drawn into any promises to rule this out. In response to a supplementary question, the Leader confirmed that there were no immediate plans to look at such measures.
Councillor Evans also raised concerns over the level of investment in the metro project, with a focus on the Cardiff Central hub, when the Ebbw Vale rail link also needed to be progressed. As a point of clarification, the Chief Executive explained that the metro project was linked to, but separate from, the plans to improve facilities at Cardiff Central; the works at the station were needed and would have been proposed with or without the metro project going ahead. The Chief Executive also explained that the partner authorities were in discussions about setting up joint scrutiny arrangements for the deal, which would need to work alongside our own scrutiny arrangements.
Councillor Matthew Evans asked a question on improvements to the subway between Gold Tops and the city centre. He questioned why money was being spent on this project instead of the proposed footbridge.
· Superintendent Roberts provided the latest position on 101 calls in response to Councillor M Evans question about ongoing problems with the service.
Councillor Matthew Evans asked when the Leader had last met with traders at Newport Market, and whether the Leader was aware of the current petition started by traders at the Market, asking for stall rent reductions and improved facilities.
The motion was moved by Councillor Matthew Evans and seconded by Councillor William Routley:
Speaking to present the motion, Councillor Matthew Evans highlighted the positive economic, environmental and social impact the Relief Road would have on Newport and the wider area, and urged Councillors to support this motion to push for progress on this project.
Councillor Matthew Evans asked for further details of the three new schools to be built, including timescales and funding. The Leader responded that a bid had been submitted as part of Band B of the 21 st Century Schools programme, and the Council was confident that that match funding would be received. Plans being made included new schools in Glan Llyn , and on the Whiteheads development.
Responding to the Leader’s answer, Councillor Evans highlighted the advice given to his administration at the time of the Band A bid, that match funding was not available for a higher bid.
Councillor Evans asked a supplementary question on secondary provision, citing concerns over increasing pressure on secondary school places. The Leader responded that secondary capacity was a statutory responsibility, and some schools were over capacity but others were under capacity. There were opportunities for using funding through streams like section 106 for increasing provision in this area.
Members of the IRP had visited the Council earlier this year and during his interview Councillor Evans had queried some of the questions as he believed some of them had pre-determined answers. The DS&C Manager confirmed that feedback from the visits to Councils by the IRP would be included in the final report.
The Council should discourage organisations within the Newport City area from releasing sky/Chinese lanterns and look for more appropriate alternatives.” The motion was moved by Councillor Matthew Evans and seconded by Councillor Kevin Whitehead. Following the presentation of the motion by the Leader of the Opposition, the Leader of the Council clarified that Members of the Executive would vote but not speak on the motion, as any final decision on a ban would be a matter for Cabinet.
Councillor Matthew Evans asked how confident the Leader was that sponsorship would be attracted for the proposed City of Democracy festival, following the recent consultants’ report, and Cabinet’s decision in July to support the festival idea but not allocate funding to it.
It was proposed by Councillor Wilcox and seconded by Councillor M Evans and unanimously:
It was proposed by the Mayor, seconded by Councillor Matthew Evans and unanimously Resolved That Council Richard White is appointed Deputy Mayor for the ensuing year.
New Members Councillor Wilcox introduced the following newly elected members in the Labour Group: Rehmaan Hayat, Phil Hourahine, Jason Hughes, James Clarke, Stephen Marshall, Herbie Thomas, Yvonne Forsey, Graham Berry, Tracey Holyoake and Laura Lacey Councillor M Evans introduced the following newly elected members in the Conservative Group: William Routley, Joan Watkins and Val Dudley.
Councillor Matthew Evans announced that he would act as Leader of the Opposition. Opposition spokespersons would be as follows:
Councillor Mogford was concerned about the impact of rising rates on local rural businesses Councillor K Thomas and Councillor Al Nuaimi welcomed the initiative and the positive impact on small and medium businesses Councillor M Evans welcomed the initiative but felt that it in no way matched what was available in England.
Councillor Evans stated that targeting anyone because they come from a different country, or they are a different colour, or have different sexual is completely unacceptable and as a society we cannot tolerate. It was comforting that locally incidents had remained static over the past few ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Outcomes Monitoring Property Services Review, Cllr M Evans reported that, at the last meeting, he had requested a presentation regarding the Newport Market as part of the City Centre Regeneration Update, programmed for the September meeting of the Committee.
Councillor Charles Ferris to be Chair (Councillors Huntley, Suller, Guy, Ali, Williams and Ferris each declared an interest in this item and did not vote on the specific appointments) Councillor Wilcox announced that appointments of members to the committees and to outside bodies will be passed to the proper officer and recorded in the minutes (See the appendix to these minutes) Councillor M Evans also announced that appointments of members to the committees will be passed to the proper officer and recorded in the minutes (See the appendix to these minutes) Governors:
It was proposed by the Leader of the Council and seconded by Councillor M Evans and unanimously:
Councillor Truman, Councillor Matthew Evans and Councillor Williams agreed that members from all parties would wish to thank Councillor Bright for his excellent service as Leader, referred to some of his major achievements and passed on best wishes for the future.
· Improving independent living for older people · Ensuring people have the right social services to meet their needs · Ensuring people have access to suitable accommodation · City Regeneration and Development · Supporting young people into education, employment or training · Ensuring the best educational outcomes for children · Increasing recycling Preventing Offending and Re-offending of young people Councillor Matthew Evans supported the general principles but made a general comment about the need to address basic issues which were of concern to residents in all wards.
Chief Inspector Warren informed Councillor Guy that the CCTV in the City Centre remains an important tool in gathering evidence Councillor Matthew Evans asked if the reintroduction of the barriers would help the police. Chief Inspector Warren stated that potentially it could help but the geographical inspector would have a local view.
The challenge as the budget reduced were to maintain services locally and eliminate waste Superintendent Bull informed Councillor Ferris that antisocial behaviour powers could be used to address the issue of people on bikes in Friar’s Walk and the city centre Superintendent Bull informed Councillor Ali of action being taken locally on local issues in Pill and all options were being explored Councillors Kellaway, Cockeram and Al Nuaimi wanted to record thanks to local officers Superintendent Bull agreed to discuss specific issues relating to drug dealing with Councillor Harvey Superintendent Bull informed Councillor M Evans that conversations as to definitions within the proposed Public Space Protection Order would need to be had between officer and the Local Authority .
He recommended a version of the Order that did not carry a ‘No rough sleeping ‘measure and in which the “No Begging” measure was replaced by the following: “No person shall beg in a manner which is aggressive or intimidating, or which harasses members of the public.” Councillor M Evans moved an amendment to support the original recommendations made by the Scrutiny Committee to the Cabinet Member which suggested that the Order should include the “No Begging” measure and the ‘No rough sleeping’ measure.
This amendment was seconded by Councillor Fouweather In moving the amendment, Councillor Evans stated that the £1,000 fine referred to in the media would be a final measure. He sated this was not an assault on the homeless but that no-one should be sleeping rough or begging on the streets.
Councillor Evans stated that some people have to go to work in fear and can witness excrement, vomit and discarded needles.
Councillor Evans had recently been on patrol with the police and had viewed the extent of these problems. Business people had said that needles on the floor were unacceptable. People needed support but so did the businesses.
The Cabinet recommended adoption of the Strategy and Delivery Plan to Council for adoption Councillor M Evans was concerned about increasing bus lanes and considered other options should be considered. It was important for all traffic to move forward in the city centre. He considered more could be done to encourage small businesses.
Councillor Matthew Evans asked Council to consider the following motion for which appropriate notice had been given:
Councillor Evans stated that the Opposition had asked for positions but to no avail. He mentioned some specific cases where unelected representatives were appointed in favour of local elected members. He considered the protocol followed for LEA governors should be implemented for outside bodies.
He stated that he could give no guarantees but that he felt that some progress could be made In the light of the statement by the Leader of the Council, Councillor Evans agreed to withdraw the motion
He also mentioned the role that would be played by the Independent Remuneration Panel who would provide observations on proposed changes to pay to Chief Officers in the future Councillor Matthew Evans moved an amendment to read “ To advertise for an appointment to the new post on the grade of Heads of Service level 3” Councillor Evans mentioned the original proposals reflected an increase of £15,000 and challenging times remained. He mentioned savings that had been made to services of a similar amount. He said that staff morale was important as well as money.
In summing up Councillor Matthew Evans mentioned the need for officers to feel job satisfaction as well as money. He mentioned the need to be prudent at these times. The Chief Executive stated that surveys show that staff satisfaction had increased since 2012.
Councillor Evans pointed out that scrutiny committees played an important role and considered that a ratio of three scrutiny committees to nine cabinet portfolios was insufficient. He believed more scrutiny committees were needed and they needed to meet more frequently than was currently happening. The Head of Democratic Services pointed out that there was no funding to support extra committees at this time.
‘ ‘Councillor M Evans did not agree to endorse the strategy, due to not having sufficient time within this item to question the review group on its findings.’ The Committee requested that minutes from the meeting on 4 August 2015, Joint with Licensing, to consider the Public Spaces Protection Order, be circulated.
‘ ‘Councillor M Evans did not agree to endorse the strategy, due to not having sufficient any time within this item to question the review group on its findings.’ The Committee requested that minutes from the meeting on 4 August 2015, Joint with Licensing, to consider the Public Spaces Protection Order, be circulated.
Councillor M Evans did not agree to endorse the strategy, due to not having sufficient time within this item to question the review group on its findings.
I am not clear if Councillor Evans is revitalised after his year as Mayor or as he has been selected to fight the Assembly election The difficult decision to reduce expenditure on the Mayoralty and events, including the cessation of the awards ceremony was taken by the Cabinet and Council as part of the budget process last year.
It was proposed by the Mayor and seconded by the Leader of the Council and unanimously Resolved That the Council’s thanks be given to Councillor Matthew Evans and Tina Hatton – Evans for the manner in which they had discharged the duties as Mayor and Mayoress.
Response Councillor Evans congratulated the Mayor on his election. He expressed pride in serving the City as Mayor. He described a number of highlights of his year and mentioned the support he had received.
He mentioned the successful year supporting the Teenage Cancer Trust and the Sea cadets announcing that some £43,000 had been raised to be shared between the Charities Councillor Evans thanked Councillor Atwell and [name removed] for their support as Deputy Mayor and Deputy Mayoress over the past 12 months.
Councillor Evans paid particular tribute to his wife and thanked her for her support as Mayoress.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Evans attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 27 Feb 2020 | Council | Democratic Services Committee Minutes | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Nov 2019 | Council | Strategic Equality Plan Annual Report - 2018/19 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Sep 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion: #IPledge2Talk - Male Suicide Prevention Campaign | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Sep 2019 | Council | Appointment of Interim Chief Executive/Head of Paid Service | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Sep 2019 | Council | Scrutiny Annual Report 2018/2019 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jul 2019 | Council | Notices of Motion: Friends of the Earth Bee Initiative | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jul 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion: Guangxi Province Twinning | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jul 2019 | Council | Treasury Management Report - Financial Year 2018/19 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 May 2019 | Council | Election of the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 May 2019 | Council | Election of the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 May 2019 | Council | Appointment of the Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Feb 2019 | Council | Capital Strategy and Treasury Management | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Feb 2019 | Council | High Street and Retail Relief Scheme 2019-20 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Appointments | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion 1: Yulin Dog Meat Festival | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion 2: Motor Neurone Disease Charter | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion 3: Lucy's Law | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Council Tax Reduction Scheme | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Council Schedule of Meetings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Mayoral Nomination 2019/20 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Nov 2018 | Council | Director of Social Services Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Nov 2018 | Council | Standards Committee Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Sep 2018 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee | Election of a Chairperson | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Sep 2018 | Council | Treasury Management | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Sep 2018 | Council | Overview and Scrutiny Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Sep 2018 | Council | Democratic Services Committee Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Sep 2018 | Council | Mayoralty Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | Notice of Motion: Reducing Use of Plastic in Newport | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | Notice of Motion: DWP Office Relocation | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | Public Space Protection Order: Maesglas | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | High Street Rate Relief Scheme 2018-19 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | Member Officer Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 May 2018 | Council | Election of the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 May 2018 | Council | Appointment of the Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Apr 2018 | Council | Notice of Motion: Period Poverty | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Apr 2018 | Council | Notice of Motion: Newport to Ebbw Vale Rail Track | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Sep 2017 | Council | Chief Officer Pay | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2017 | Council | Inauguration of the Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2017 | Council | Local Authorities (Standing Orders) (Wales) (Amendment) Regulations 2017 and the Size and Composition of Local Planning Authority Committees (Wales) Regulations 2017 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2017 | Council | Scrutiny Committee Structure | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 31 Jan 2017 | Council | Nomination of the mayor for the coming municipal year | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2016 | Council | Election of the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2016 | Council | Appointment of the Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Jan 2016 | Council | Nomination of the Mayor 2016-2017 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2015 | Council | Vote of Thanks | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2015 | Council | Appointment of the Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Evans was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 8 of 12 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Evans declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Jul 2026 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee, item 1 | Councillor M Evans declared an interest in Item 4 as a family member lives on Groes Road.. |
Where Councillor Evans sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Apr 2015 | 79 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2017 | 70 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Democratic Services Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2015 | 26 | |
| Streetscene, Regeneration and Safety Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2015 | 19 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.