Democratic Services Committee Annual Report 2024-25
Councillor Hourahine seconded the report.
Every time Newport's minutes name Councillor Hourahine, as the council published it.
Councillor Hourahine seconded the report.
Councillor Hourahine declared an interest regarding his anticipated role as the Member Champion for Children Looked After.
The Presiding Member invited Councillor Hourahine, Chair of Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee to present the report, which apprised council and other interested parties on the role of scrutiny committees and highlighted the important work carried out during this period, as well as future actions to seek the continuation of improvement and engagement with stakeholders at every level in local democracy.
· Councillor Hourahine proposed a Motion that the meeting be adjourned to a later date when the Head of Law and Standards would present a written report for the Committee.
Councillor Hourahine seconded the report.
Councillor Hourahine seconded the proposal.
The Presiding Member invited Councillor Hourahine, the Chair of Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee to present the report.
Councillor Hourahine outlined topics discussed over the past year for each of the Performance Scrutiny Committees.
Councillor Hourahine looked forward to chairing the Overview and Scrutiny committee and took the opportunity to thank his scrutiny colleagues and Cabinet Members, Officers of the Local Authority and partners for their continued support.
Councillor Batrouni also thanked the Council’s champions: Councillor Lacey as mentioned above, Councillor Harris, Welsh Language Champion, and Councillor Hourahine, Anti-Poverty Champion.
§ Councillor Hourahine agreed with Councillor Fouweather that this point was made at committee regarding full consultation with Ward Members and therefore sort clarification.
Councillor Hourahine mentioned that the Superintendent’s predecessor talked about new initiatives coming into Newport regarding off road bikes.
Councillor Hourahine asked if the Superintendent could look into what could be done regarding a pro-active response from police.
The Chair noted that Cllr Hourahine had presented the previous year’s report at full Council and queried whether the Committee were content with a Member of the Committee presenting the report.
§ Councillor Hourahine mentioned that this had already been addressed with the Leader and a response had been given by officers through Scrutiny.
The Presiding Member invited the Chair of Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee, Councillor Hourahine to present the 2021/2022 Scrutiny Annual Report to Council.
Councillor Hourahine queried the context of the support to be provided in ward meetings, however the Chair clarified what was covered.
- Councillor Hourahine asked with regard to public feedback; who the wider groups be engaged with would be and when would it be the most likely for the committee to get that first part of public feedback.
- Councillor Hourahine referred to part 4.5 on page 29 where it states that Councillors can request a recorded vote. The Member asked the officers to clarify how many Councillors would be required to make a recorded vote.
Councillor Hourahine felt that there had been few instances of cases being referred to the Standards Committee and therefore shouldn’t be too onerous a duty on Monitoring Officers to accept the new duties.
- The Head of Law and Standards confirmed that Councillor Hourahine was correct in saying there had only been one misconduct hearing in Standards Committee over the past 20 years.
- Councillor Hourahine asked whether the Chair and the Head of Law and Standards would draft a letter back.
The Head of Law and Standards thanked Councillor Hourahine for his work on Standards Committee in light of the upcoming elections
· Councillor Hourahine noted how the petitions that he comes across in his ward mostly relate to resident parking and noted the last remark regarding to the timescale; that it should be essential for the council to have a timescale for the petitions to be dealt with. ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
No amendments were proposed § Councillor Hourahine asked if GAVO would benefit from this change. The Monitoring Officer advised that a written request be submitted to the Head of Finance who would be able to advise on whether they matched the criteria.
· Councillor Hourahine thanked the officer for the presentation and mentioned that 3-4 Members on the Standards Committee in the past did not participate in the mandatory modules and asked if there would be sanctions introduced for those who do not participate in the same.
· Councillor Hourahine queried if the Head of Service meant he would answer their questions directly or send them onto the Welsh Government.
· Councillor Hourahine queried if the political adviser roles would be paid pro-rata to the number of seats.
Councillor Hourahine enquired about the risk against Brexit and whether it was a blunt tool to define where the risks actually were as there was a difficulty in recruiting for care workers for care homes and it was noted that recruitment was sought in the community.
Councillor Hourahine stated that as it was a small team what availability was there in the whole finance system to allocate staff where they were most needed.
Councillor Hourahine moved the proposal and reserved the right to speak at the end of the debate.
· Councillor Hourahine mentioned he would like the minutes to reflect that the committee does have reservations on the methods of consultation. But it is noted that Members accept why the officers cannot do certain types of consultation at this moment in time and therefore confirmed he was content with it going ahead.
The Mayor invited Councillor Hourahine to present the 2020/21 Standards Committee Annual Report to Council.
· Councillor Hourahine queried if there should be a reason given for remote working, for instance, would personal choice be a reason for that.
· Councillor Hourahine noted that on page 32 on the second paragraph; it states that the Committee felt the induction was comprehensive but there was concern raised about the intensity of training with 37 modules being developed. The Member asked if the Committee is concerned about the training as he could not recall having that discussion.
Cllr Hourahine wanted to clarify that he had asked how long instruments lasted before they were written off ; the answer given at the time was 7 years. Andrew agreed to seek clarification from the manager of Gwent Music whether this answer was correct. This point was noted as needing to be corrected.
Councillor Hourahine, met with Democratic Services Officers at the Welsh Government regarding feedback on Councillor training, which they said was quite good, however Councillors never received overall feedback on this.
Councillor P Hourahine considered it was a two-part report, ie that the Motion and Local Government (LG) Act Wales 2021, were entirely separate things.
Councillor Hourahine reflected on the present Questions process and advised that there were ample opportunities for councillors to use the open questions forum. Guiding principles to chairing meetings was to be more succinct. Extending questions therefore did nothing to enhance the meeting.
On a separate note, regarding the New Act and remote attendance, Councillor Hourahine could see how it would work in rural areas but geographically, it was not appropriate for Newport and considered that remote meetings were de-humanising to councils.
Councillor Hourahine considered that the protocol was a priority for those present and those who attended remotely to be invited to speak fairly.
Councillor Hourahine referred to an action for the Head of People and Business Change in relation to the speculation on a raise in capital gains tax and it’s potential effect on the private housing rental market. It was confirmed that the Head of People and Business Change would go back to the service area to find provide more detail and it was not an action for the Audit Committee. An update would be provided in writing to the Committee.
· Referring to page 15 in the Agenda papers, Councillor Hourahine was disappointed with the table of risks, one risk had been addressed , however it was noted that the rest of the figures were static.
Councillor Hourahine expected this to be dealt with as close to the source as possible. The Chair agreed with the observation and referred to the target risk table, which he felt was a tick box exercise and considered the risk appetite was not there unless the scoring was changed from 1-10 to 1-5, therefore it was not sure what was a valid risk or not.
Councillor Hourahine referred to the matrix numbers and suggested there might be other ways of achieving a better outcome, rather than five by five, which might mean too many equal risks. The Head of People and Business Change advised that the table represented the top risks that the Council was dealing with. Most were incredibly difficult to address in ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Cllr Hourahine referred to page 85, Item 7 in the report which stated there were no financial issues relating to the report.
Councillor Hourahine considered that any changes to a process within Local Government usually meant that there would be financial implications, such as in the officer’s time. With this in mind, would there be more or less officer’s time to comply with the code, as it was rarely a static situation. The Chief Internal Chief Auditor Officer advised that there were no additional financial implications to bring this Code together.
· Cllr Hourahine asked whether Audit Wales gave reasonable notice to Council staff that an audit would take place, as services would be stretched to provide figures on time. In addition, were staff cooperating with the audit? The Wales Audit representative assured the Councillor on both counts that there were no issues and that there was a good working relationship with Newport City Council staff.
Councillor Hourahine queried the high turnover of management staff. It was advised that there had been changes, however going forward there was only one agency social worker out of 340 staff. There were still vacancies however the working relationship with staff was good, most of which came to the Council as students and stayed with us.
Councillor Hourahine added that social workers did a wonderful job and worked hard for the Council.
Councillor Hourahine raised a point on the Declarations of Interest form filled out by Members each year and whether they could be made more user friendly as it was discussed that Members were not always filling these out. The Head of Law and Regulation stated that reminders had been sent to Councillors from the Democratic Services Team in the last few months to remind them to keep their Declarations of Interest forms updated. The Head of Law and Regulation also explained that it was important for Members to keep their Declarations of Interest updated as after the elections Councillors were required to fill in a declarations form within 28 days but it needed to be continually updated e.g. a change in employment.
Councillor Hourahine asked whether present lay members were able to stand as Chair if they wished to and Councillor Hourahine also expressed a wish to sit on the appointments panel which Councillor Wilcox agreed with.
Councillor Hourahine asked as to whether those two complaints mentioned came back to the Chair. The Head of Law and Regulation confirmed that the Chair was not involved at all in the Complaints process, as members were to remain impartial. In the event that the Ombudsman found there was a case to answer then they would produce a report, then the Standards committee would have to view this report and have a full hearing.
Councillor Hourahine was happy to present the 2019/20 Standards Committee Annual Report to Council.
Councillor Hourahine stated that at a previous school Governor meeting they attended it was mentioned that Skype could be made available but then it was not allowed as a physical presence was needed at meetings and the cost could not rest with the school. The Head of Law & Regulation stated that this was a separate area of legislation. Welsh government could legislate on this however and it was a practical problem issue for the Council.
Councillor Hourahine stated that they had attended Fire Services training, which would not have worked as well if the training were online. The Head of Law and Regulation confirmed that the Fire Services training was an information session rather than formal training.
Councillor Hourahine referred to the Boundary Commission Changes. The Monitoring Officer advised that there would be further information regarding this in the New Year.
Councillor H Thomas moved report, which was seconded by Councillor Hourahine seconded.
Councillor Hourahine also thanked [name removed] for Chairing the Standards Committee.
Councillor Hourahine agreed to present the report to Council on the 26 th November 2019 if Councillor Thomas was unable to do so.
It was agreed that either Councillor Thomas or Councillor Hourahine would present the report to Council The Head of Law & Regulation reported that three complaints had been made to the Ombudsman last year, but none of them had been accepted for investigation.
Committee No. of Vacancies / Replacements Nominations Received Planning Committee Replacement Cllr Malcolm Linton to replace Cllr Tracey Holyoake Sub-Committee 7 Vacancies Cllr Debbie Wilcox Cllr Gail Giles Cllr Paul Cockeram Cllr Majid Rahman Cllr Matthew Evans Cllr Jason Jordan Cllr Carmel Townshend Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee 1 replacement Cllr Phil Hourahine to replace Cllr Malcom Linton Performance Scrutiny Committee – Partnerships 1 replacement Cllr Christine Jenkins to replace Cllr Yvonne Forsey Performance Scrutiny Committee – People 1 replacement Cllr Malcom Linton to replace Cllr Ken Critchley to External Organisations Organisation No. of Vacancies / Replacements Nominations Received Police and Crime Panel Replacement Cllr Mark Spencer to replace Cllr John Guy Governing Body Governing Body No. of Vacancies / Re-appointments Nominations Received Caerleon High School Replacement [name removed] (to replace John Parfitt ) Tredegar Park Primary Replacement Cllr Ibrahim Hayat(to replace Jeanne Hugo) Malpas Court Primary Vacancy Amy Morris Glasllwch Primary School Vacancy [name removed] Primary School Reappointment William Langsford Malpas Primary School Reappointment Cllr David Mayer Ringland Primary Replacement Cllr Laura Lacey (to replace Cllr Rehmaan Hayat) Milton Primary - Replacement Cllr Rehmaan Hayat (to replace Cllr Laura Lacey) Ysgol Gyfun Gwynllyw Reappointment John Harris Rogerstone Primary Vacancy Alexandra Mlewa St Woolos Prima
- In response to a question from Councillor Hourahine, the Superintendent Ian Roberts outlined the success of Operation Harley which had targeted the illegal use of off road bikes.
- Cllr Hourahine thanked the local officer for recent attendance and actions following the St Julian’s ward meeting.
It was proposed by the Mayor, seconded by Councillor M Evans, and unanimously Resolved That Councillor Phil Hourahine be appointed Deputy Mayor for the ensuing year.
Councillor Hourahine, having made and subscribed to the Declaration of Acceptance for the role of Deputy Mayor, expressed thanks for his appointment.
- Councillor Hourahine asked that thanks be passed on for the time spent on a walking tour ahead of scrutiny of the City Centre PSPO.
Councillor Hourahine asked whether or not the union representatives had sight of the document. As it was a protocol document it did not need consultation with union representatives.
He also highlighted recent incidents of arson and ASB in the ward, which the Superintendent agreed to follow up outside the meeting. - Cllr Hourahine praised the new initiative against people trafficking. He also thanked the police for their response to the recent incident of harassment in Old Barn.
Councillor Phil Hourahine – Board Member of Newport Transport Councillor Mark Spencer – Board Member of Newport Transport Councillor Charles Ferris – Board Member of Newport Transport
Internal Committee No. of Vacancies / Replacements Nominations Received Standards Committee 1 vacancy John Davies (as the Community Council Representative) Carers Champion 1 replacement Cllr Tracey Holyoake to replace Cllr Ibrahim Hayat Performance Scrutiny Committee – Partnerships 1 replacement Cllr Yvonne Forsey to replace Cllr James Clarke Performance Scrutiny Committee – Place and Corporate 2 replacements Cllr James Clarke to replace Cllr Yvonne Forsey Cllr Ibrahim Hayat to replace Cllr Laura Lacey Social Services Rota Visits 1 replacement Cllr Jan Cleverly to replace Cllr Kevin Whitehead Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee 1 replacement Cllr Laura Lacey to replace Cllr Ibrahim Hayat to External Organisations Organisation No. of Vacancies / Replacements Nominations Received GAVO Local Committee 1 replacement Cllr Phil Hourahine to replace Cllr Christine Jenkins Governing Body Governing Body No. of Vacancies / Re-appointments Nominations Received Lliswerry High School 1 re-appointment Cllr Roger Jeavons Malpas Park Primary 1 re-appointment Cllr Jane Mudd Marshfield Primary 1 re-appointment [name removed] Primary 1 re-appointment Cllr Malcolm Linton Ringland Primary 1 re-appointment [name removed] Michael’s RC Primary 1 re-appointment [name removed] Referral Unit Management Committee 1 vacancy Cllr David Mayer Clytha Primary 1 vacancy [name removed] Park Primary 1 vacancy Cllr Val Dudley Llanwern High School 2 vacancies Shereen
Councillor Phil Hourahine – Board Member of Newport Transport Councillor Mark Spencer – Board Member of Newport Transport Councillor Charles Ferris – Board Member of Newport Transport
In response to Councillor Hourahine query on whether declarations of interest should be reviewed, the Head of Law & Regulation advised that this was already on the work programme under the ethical standards audit.
In response to a question from Councillor Phil Hourahine, the Leader agreed that the 123-129 Commercial Street development was excellent news for the city centre, building on the success of Friars Walk and extending regeneration to other parts of the city centre.
§ Gareth briefly outlined the purpose of the Standards Committee for Councillor Hourahine.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Hourahine attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Apr 2024 | Council | Appointments | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jul 2021 | Standards Committee | Part 2 Exempt or Confidential Items | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2020 | Council | Democratic Services Committee Minutes | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Nov 2019 | Council | Strategic Equality Plan Annual Report - 2018/19 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Sep 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion: #IPledge2Talk - Male Suicide Prevention Campaign | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Sep 2019 | Council | Appointment of Interim Chief Executive/Head of Paid Service | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Sep 2019 | Council | Scrutiny Annual Report 2018/2019 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jul 2019 | Council | Notices of Motion: Friends of the Earth Bee Initiative | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jul 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion: Guangxi Province Twinning | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jul 2019 | Council | Treasury Management Report - Financial Year 2018/19 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 May 2019 | Council | Election of the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 May 2019 | Council | Election of the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 May 2019 | Council | Appointment of the Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Feb 2019 | Council | Capital Strategy and Treasury Management | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Feb 2019 | Council | High Street and Retail Relief Scheme 2019-20 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Appointments | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion 1: Yulin Dog Meat Festival | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion 2: Motor Neurone Disease Charter | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Notice of Motion 3: Lucy's Law | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Council Tax Reduction Scheme | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Council Schedule of Meetings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2019 | Council | Mayoral Nomination 2019/20 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Nov 2018 | Council | Director of Social Services Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Nov 2018 | Council | Standards Committee Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Sep 2018 | Council | Treasury Management | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Sep 2018 | Council | Overview and Scrutiny Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Sep 2018 | Council | Democratic Services Committee Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Sep 2018 | Council | Mayoralty Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | Notice of Motion: Reducing Use of Plastic in Newport | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | Notice of Motion: DWP Office Relocation | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | Public Space Protection Order: Maesglas | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | High Street Rate Relief Scheme 2018-19 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jul 2018 | Council | Member Officer Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 May 2018 | Council | Election of the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 May 2018 | Council | Appointment of the Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Apr 2018 | Council | Notice of Motion: Period Poverty | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Apr 2018 | Council | Notice of Motion: Newport to Ebbw Vale Rail Track | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Sep 2017 | Council | Chief Officer Pay | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jun 2017 | Standards Committee | Matters Arising | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2017 | Council | Inauguration of the Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2017 | Council | Local Authorities (Standing Orders) (Wales) (Amendment) Regulations 2017 and the Size and Composition of Local Planning Authority Committees (Wales) Regulations 2017 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2017 | Council | Scrutiny Committee Structure | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Hourahine was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 10 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Hourahine declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24 Jul 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee, item 1 | Councillor Hourahine declared an interest regarding his anticipated role as the Member Champion for Children Looked After. |
Where Councillor Hourahine sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2017 | 64 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee | Chair | Jul 2017 | 61 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Democratic Services Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2020 | 28 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Standards Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 20 | |
| Governance and Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 14 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 3 | |
| Licensing (Taxi) Panel | Committee Member | Jan 2022 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.