Exclusion of press and public
Audio recording – 02 hours 13 minutes 10 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Every time North Hertfordshire's minutes name Councillor Mantle, as the council published it.
Audio recording – 02 hours 13 minutes 10 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Councillor Sean Nolan proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, it was:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 53 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Dave Winstanley · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Bryony May · Councillor Nigel Mason In response to questions, the Senior Transport Policy Officer advised that:
Audio recording – 1 minute 52 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 51 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Claire Billing · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Emma Fernandes · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Dave Winstanley Points raised during the debate included:
Audio Recording – 2 minutes 8 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Clare Billing · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Jon Clayden In response to questions, the Principal Planning Officer advised that:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 25 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Caroline McDonnell · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Bryony May In response to points of clarification, [name removed] advised that:
Audio Recording – 37 minutes 31 seconds N.B Councillor Ian Mantle declared an interest due to his trustee position on the Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation and left the Chamber.
Audio Recording – 2 minutes 16 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason proposed, and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Councillor Ruth Brown proposed to grant permission and this was seconded by Councillor Ian Mantle and, following a vote, it was:
Councillor Sean Nolan proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, it was:
Councillor Ruth Brown proposed to grant permission, and this was seconded by Councillor Ian Mantle.
In response to a question from Councillor Ian Mantle, the Principal Planning Officer (Conservation and Enforcement) advised that:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Mick Debenham In response to questions, the Project Officer advised that:
The following Members took part in the debate on the amendment: · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Sean Prendergast · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Tina Bhartwas · Councillor Daniel Allen Points raised during the debate included:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Nigel Mason In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
Having given due notice Councillor Jon Clayden substituted for Councillor Brown, Councillor Val Bryant substituted for Councillor Allen and Councillor Mick Debenham substituted for Cllr Mantle.
Audio Recording – 2 minutes 14 seconds Councillor Nigel Mason, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
In response to a question from Councillor Ian Mantle, the Senior Planning Officer advised that the application was for 6 houses and not 5 houses as shown on the last slide.
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Sade Billing · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Val Bryant In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Ruth Brown Points raised in the debate included:
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Michael Muir In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed to approve planning permission and Councillor Michael Muir seconded.
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Emma Fernandes · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis In response to the questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
Audio recording – 1 hour 48 minutes 8 seconds N.B Councillor Ian Mantle declared and interest due to his appointment as the Council Representative on the Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation and left the Chamber and did not take place in the debate or vote.
Audio recording – 1 hour 56 minutes 38 seconds N.B Councillor Ian Mantle returned to the Chamber at 21:28.
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Sadie Billing · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Mick Debenham In response to the points of clarification, the Senior Planning Officer stated that:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Jon Clayden In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer stated that:
Having given due notice Councillor Steve Jarvis substituted for Councillor Peace, Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Moody, Councillor Ian Mantle substituted for Councillor Allen and Councillor Dave Winstanley substituted for Councillor Nolan.
· Councillor Simon Bloxham · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Mick Debenham In response to the points of clarification, the Senior Planning Officer stated that:
· Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Michael Muir In response to points of clarification, the Development Management Team Leader advised that:
Having given notice, Councillor Ian Mantle substituted for Councillor Mason and Councillor Dave Winstanley substituted for Councillor Nolan.
· Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Dave Winstanley · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Louise Peace In response to the points of clarification the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
Having given due notice Councillor Ian Mantle substituted for Councillor Nolan, Councillor Dave Winstanley substituted for Councillor Mason and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Moody.
Councillor Ian Mantle, Deputy Executive Member for Planning and Transport, presented the report entitled ‘Local Plan Review’ and advised that:
Audio Recording 25 minutes 48 seconds The Deputy Executive Member for Planning and Transport, Councillor Ian Mantle presented the item entitled ‘Local Plan Review’ and highlighted that:
Having given due notice, Councillor Ian Mantle substituted for Councillor Mason and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Moody.
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Louise Peace In response to the points of clarification, the Senior Planning Officer stated that:
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to the points of clarification the Senior Planning Officer stated that:
Having given due notice, Councillor Ian Mantle substituted for Councillor Mason.
Councillor Ruth Brown proposed amendments to Appendix B to the effect that Councillor Dominic Griffiths to become a member of the Standards Committee, Councillor Ruth Brown to become a member of the Council Tax Setting Committee, Councillor Ruth Brown to be removed as a substitute of the Joint Staff Consultative Committee, Councillor Ruth Brown to become a substitute of the Cabinet Panel for Environment, Councillor Ian Mantle to become a substitute of the Planning Control Committee and Councillor Keith Hoskins to become a substitute of the Joint Staff Consultative Committee.
Audio recording – 49 minutes 28 seconds Councillor Ian Mantle advised that the lease at [name removed] had been agreed with a voluntary organisation. The Hall was run by volunteer teams with a professional manager. The Hall was a valuable community facility, and the new lease brought stability so it could continue serving the community for years to come.
· Councillor Judi Billing – County Councillor · Councillor Jean Green – property interest · Councillor Adem Ruggiero-Cakir – partner works for the Council, however had not been involved in the Plan process or estates · Councillor Ian Mantle – LGCHF · Councillor Terry Hone – County Councillor and LGCHF Board Member · Councillor David Barnard – County Councillor and family affected by the east of Luton site, but stated he would not vote for or against · Councillor Michael Muir – County Councillor · Councillor Richard Thake – County Councillor · Councillor Chris Hinchliff – Employed by national charity CPRE, but not involved with CPRE Hertfordshire.
Councillor Brown proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and reserved his right to speak.
· Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor David Barnard · Councillor Chris Lucas · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Keith Hoskins · Councillor Tom Plater · Councillor George Davies · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Chris Hinchliff · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Lisa Nash · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor James Denselow · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Sean Prendergast During the debate at 22.15 there was a short adjournment to allow for a comfort break and the meeting recommenced at 22.23.
Councillor Ian Mantle declared an interest as the District Council’s nominee on the Letchworth Heritage Foundation which owns land included in the Local Plan 2011-3031.
Councillor Ian Mantle commented that the requested grant is too big a percentage of the total grant budget, while it is a worthy cause its not proportionate considering the other applicants.
Councillor Mantle proposed that the Committee provide a smaller grant rather than the full amount, of £1500.
Councillor Tom Plater echoed the suggestions of Councillor Mantle and Levett but instead felt half of the grant, £1700 would be suitable.
18:15 Councillor Ian Mantle proposed and Councillor Morgan Derbyshire seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed and Councillor Tom Plater seconded and, following a vote, it was:
23:30 Councillor Ian Mantle proposed and Councillor Adem Ruggerio-Cakir seconded and, following a vote it was:
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed Councillor Daniel Allen as Chair, and Councillor Amy Allen seconded.
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Mike Rice In response to a question from Members, the Senior Planning Officer advised:
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor David Levett In response to questions from Members the Senior Planning Officer advised:
Councillor Morgan Derbyshire proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote it was:
Audio recording – 29 minutes 35 seconds Councillor Ian Mantle proposed and Councillor Morgan Derbyshire seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Mike Rice · Councillor Amy Allen In response to questions, [name removed] advised:
Having given due notice Councillor George Davies substituted for Councillor Morgan Derbyshire, Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Tony Hunter and Councillor Amy Allen substituted for Councillor Ian Mantle.
Audio Recording – 1:40 Councillor Mike Rice, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and, following a vote it was:
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Mike Hughson In response to questions the Senior Planning Officer advised:
Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded, and, following a vote it was:
· Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor David Barnard A minutes’ silence was held in memory of Councillor Paul Clark.
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed Councillor Gary Grindal as Vice-Chair and was seconded by Councillor Amy Allen.
Audio recording – 4 minutes 58 seconds Councillor Ian Mantle declared that he was a member of the committee which administered [name removed] and therefore he would not engage with discussions relating to this part of the report.
· Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Simon Harwood · Councillor Morgan Derbyshire · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor George Davies In response to questions Richard Beasley, Consultant advised that the Local Government Boundary Commission for England will not change the Council’s electoral cycle and only look at Council Size and warding arrangements, which are impacted by the decision to be made at this meeting.
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions, the Principle Planning Officer and Senior Planning Officer advised:
Councillor Val Bryant proposed Councillor Ian Mantle as Vice-Chair and was seconded by Councillor Mike Hughson.
Councillor Morgan Derbyshire raised a Point of Order to confirm with the Chair whether Councillor Ian Mantle was a full Member of the Committee.
The Chair confirmed that Councillor Mantle had replaced Sue Ngwala who had stood down as a Councillor.
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed, Councillor Amy Allen seconded and it was:
Audio Recording – 29:53 Councillor Mike Rice proposed, Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and it was:
Audio recording – 58:34 Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation Councillor Ian Mantle provided an update on Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation including:
· Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Ruth Brown On the vote it was:
“Following the public consultation on the Local Plan modifications, could the Executive Members say when those responses were submitted to the Inspector, when the Inspector will be submitting his final report, and more importantly, when Council will be asked to adopt the local plan?” In the absence of Councillor Paul Clark, Councillor Ian Mantle (Deputy Executive Member for Planning) gave a response as follows:
Does the administration have any intention of actually putting some form of complaint in now and finally getting this moved on and get the local plan in place?” Councillor Ian Mantle responded:
· Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg In response to points raised Councillor Clark advised that it was the intention to incorporate the LCWIP and transport plans in to the masterplanning process.
· Councillor Tony Hunter · Councillor Ian Mantle Councillor Tony Hunter proposed, Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and on the vote it was:
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir In response to questions the Development and Conservation Manager advised:
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir In response to questions the Development and Conservation Manager advised that a condition on electric vehicle charging could be added to the recommendations of the report.
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed, Councillor Michael Muir seconded and it was:
Councillor Gary Grindal proposed, Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and it was:
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed, Councillor Gary Grindal seconded and it was:
Councillor Ian Mantle, Deputy Executive Member for Planning, raised that it was important that Central Beds were aware people used various forms of transport to get into North Herts from Central Beds and vehicles were not the only form of transport.
Councillor Ian Mantle also raised that it was important Hertfordshire County Council worked in conjunction with Central Bedfordshire in terms of bus provision as there were bus routes that passed through both Counties.
· Councillor Gary Grindal; and · Councillor Ian Mantle.
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed that Councillor Daniel Allen be elected as Chair of the meeting.
· Councillor Ian Mantle;
Councillor Mantle seconded the proposal and it was:
Audio Recording – 34 Minutes 20 Seconds Councillor Ian Mantle asked the reason that the item was in Part 2.
· Councillor Ian Mantle;
· Councillor Ian Mantle;
· Councillor Ian Mantle;
It was proposed by Councillor Morgan Derbyshire, seconded by Councillor Ian Mantle and:
Councillor Martin Stears-Handscomb proposed the recommendations in the report, as amended and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded.
Audio recording – 1 hour 42 minutes 52 seconds NB the presentation of the Part 1 report and it being proposed by Councillor Martin Stears-Handscomb and seconded by Councillor Ian Mantle is detailed in Minute 51.
· Councillor Ian Mantle;
Councillor Martin Stears-Handscomb proposed, Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and it was:
Councillor Gary Grindal proposed, Councillor Ian Mantle seconded and it was:
· Councillor Ian Mantle;
Section 4.8.9 It was proposed by Councillor Ian Mantle and seconded by Councillor David Levett that the limit of the number of questions of clarification (currently 3) asked of presenters at the Planning Control Committee be removed.
Section 9,8,2 It was proposed by Councillor Ian Mantle and seconded by Councillor Marin Stears-Handscomb that, in respect of the proposed wording of Paragraph (g) of the Terms of Reference the words “in their area” be removed so that it read:
· Councillor Ian Mantle;
· Appendix A - Action Plan Councillor Ian Mantle queried where the target figures were sourced from.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Mantle attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Mantle's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Mantle was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 5 of 7 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Mantle declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 21 Aug 2025 | Planning Control Committee, item 39 | Audio Recording – 37 minutes 31 seconds N.B Councillor Ian Mantle declared an interest due to his trustee position on the Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation and left the Chamber. | Left the room |
| 11 Jul 2024 | Council, item 31 | Audio recording – 1 hour 48 minutes 8 seconds N.B Councillor Ian Mantle declared and interest due to his appointment as the Council Representative on the Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation and left the Chamber and did not take place in the debate or vote. | Left the room |
| 2 Nov 2022 | Cabinet, item 131 | Councillor Ian Mantle declared an interest as the District Council’s nominee on the Letchworth Heritage Foundation which owns land included in the Local Plan 2011-3031. | |
| 8 Dec 2021 | Letchworth Committee, item 20 | Audio recording – 4 minutes 58 seconds Councillor Ian Mantle declared that he was a member of the committee which administered [name removed] and therefore he would not engage with discussions relating to this part of the report. |
Where Councillor Mantle sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jul 2019 | 5 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Control Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2024 | 5 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Letchworth Community Forum | Committee Member | May 2026 | 2 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet Panel | Committee Member | Jan 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.