Growing baldock strategic masterplan
· Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Ruth Brown ... view the full minutes text for item 18.
Every time North Hertfordshire's minutes name Councillor Muir, as the council published it.
· Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Ruth Brown ... view the full minutes text for item 18.
Councillor Michael Muir was absent.
Councillor Michael Muir was absent.
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Sade Billing · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Val Bryant In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
Councillor Ruth Brown proposed and Councillor Michael Muir seconded and, following a vote it was:
Councillor Michael Muir proposed to grant permission and this was seconded by Councillor Ruth Brown.
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed to approve planning permission and Councillor Michael Muir seconded.
In response to the request for additional landscaping on site by Councillor Michael Muir, the Development and Conservation Manager advised that there was a standard condition for landscaping that could be submitted.
Councillor Michael Muir proposed the amended recommendation and Councillor Ruth Brown proposed, and following a vote, it was:
Councillor Ralph Muncer nominated Councillor Michael Muir as the fourth Member to the outside organisation the Baldock United Almshouses Charity.
Councillor Michael Muir was absent.
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Mick Debenham In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Sadie Billing In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised that:
Having given due notice Councillor Joe Graziano would substitute for Councillor Michael Muir.
Councillor Ruth Brown proposed and Councillor Michael Muir seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Councillor Michael Muir confirmed his withdrawal from the Baldock Town Twinning Association.
Having given due notice Councillor Steve Jarvis substituted for Councillor Peace, Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Moody, Councillor Ian Mantle substituted for Councillor Allen and Councillor Dave Winstanley substituted for Councillor Nolan.
· Councillor Simon Bloxham · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Mick Debenham In response to the points of clarification, the Senior Planning Officer stated that:
Having given due notice Councillor Dave Winstanley substituted for Councillor Nolan and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Moody.
· Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Steve Jarvis In response to questions, the Service Director – Resources confirmed that the boiler replacement at leisure centres would be air source heat pumps and the boiler allocation could be found on page 9 of the Appendix.
Having given due notice Councillor Ian Mantle substituted for Councillor Nolan, Councillor Dave Winstanley substituted for Councillor Mason and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Moody.
Having given due notice, Councillor Ian Mantle substituted for Councillor Mason and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Moody.
· Councillor Michael Muir · Deolinda Eltringham · John Webb · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Roger Lovegrove · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Chris Hinchliff · Julia Sonander In response to the questions, the Strategic Planning Officer and Strategic Planning Manager advised:
· Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Michael Muir · Deolinda Eltringham · John Webb · Councillor Chris Hinchliff In response to the questions, the Biodiversity Net Gain and Local Recovery Strategy Project Manager advised:
Having given due notice, Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Simon Bloxham and Councillor Dave Winstanley substituted for Councillor Daniel Allen.
Having given due notice Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Simon Bloxham.
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Louise Peace Councillor Michael Muir proposed that the application be approved, subject to additional conditions regarding the installation on EV chargers and PV panels on site.
Councillor Michael Muir proposed the application be approved, subject to the provision of an Environmental Management Statement, and Councillor Sean Nolan seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Nigel Mason In response to the points of clarification the Senior Planning Officer stated that:
Councillor David Levett proposed, with the amendments included, and this was seconded by Councillor Michael Muir and, following a vote, it was:
Having given due notice, Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Ian Moody, and Councillor Dave Winstanley substituted for Councillor Daniel Allen.
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Dave Winstanley In response to the questions, the Senior Planning Officer and Oliver Sowerby, representative from HCC Highways Authority advised:
Having given due notice, Councillor Cathy Brownjohn substituted for Councillor Mason and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Levett.
· Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Ian Moody · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Val Bryant In response to the points of clarification, the Development and Conservation Manager stated that:
Councillor Michael Muir nominated Councillor Michael Weeks for Chair of the Baldock and District Area Forum. There was no seconder for this nomination.
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Faye Frost · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Chris Lucas Points raised during the debate include:
· Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Juan Cowell In response to the questions, [name removed] advised:
A discussion was held amongst Members regarding the remaining budgets of the Committee and following this Councillor Michael Muir proposed the amount be increased to £1,500.
Audio recording – 38 minutes 4 seconds Councillor Michael Muir advised that he had allocated all of his £90k from the County Council Highways Budget for the 2023/24 financial year.
Audio Recording – 100 minutes and 46 seconds The Chair drew attention to the point raised by Councillor Michael Muir in the previous agenda item, and clarified that the line referring to Weston Hills, Baldock referred to a car park on Chalk Hills, Baldock.
Having given due notice, Councillor Amy Allen substituted for Councillor Willoughby and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Moody.
In response to a question from Councillor Michael Muir, the Senior Planning Officer advised that it was for Highways to address the matter of visibility when entering the road.
Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Gerald Morris seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Simon Bloxham · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor George Davies · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Ruth Brown Councillor Chris Lucas summarised that there had been an interesting array of responses to this matter. The current system was not known and loved by people but had rather propped up Conservative governments.
Councillor Michael Muir raised a Point of Order and noted that Members who were more than two months behind on Council Tax could not take part in this debate or vote. The Monitoring Officer noted that this was the case when setting the budget. The Monitoring Officer confirmed, having sought advice from the Service Director – Resources, that Members could vote on this item, even if in Council Tax arrears.
· Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Keith Hoskins · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Thomas Plater · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Daniel Allen A minute of commemoration was held in memory of former Councillor Judi Billing MBE.
Councillor Michael Muir noted his concerns regarding the Baldock warding proposals. He advised that he agreed with the proposed names, but disagreed with proposals to make the proposed new housing to the north of Baldock part of a wider Gravely and Ashwell rural ward. These 3000 new houses would become part of the town of Baldock, just as the Clothall Common development in the current Baldock East ward had previously.
Having given due notice, Councillor Nigel Mason substituted for Councillor Sean Nolan, Councillor Steve Jarvis substituted for Councillor Phil Weeder and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Ian Moody.
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised:
Councillor Michael Muir noted that this was a tree he had used on many occasions as a photographer and it would be a shame for this to be refused.
Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Morgan Derbyshire seconded and, following a vote, it was:
The Chair invited Councillor Michael Muir to speak against the second application as Member Advocate.
Councillor Muir advised:
The Chair advised Councillor Muir that anecdotal evidence was not suitable at the Planning Control Committee meeting.
Having given due notice Councillor Nigel Mason will be substituting for Councillor Val Bryant and Councillor Michael Muir will be substituting for Councillor Morgan Derbyshire.
Audio recording – 1:21 It was noted by Councillor Michael Muir and Councillor Nigel Mason that they were present at the previous meeting but their names were not on the list of Councillors present.
· Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Simon Bloxham · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor David Levett Points raised in the debate included:
· Councillor Judi Billing – County Councillor · Councillor Jean Green – property interest · Councillor Adem Ruggiero-Cakir – partner works for the Council, however had not been involved in the Plan process or estates · Councillor Ian Mantle – LGCHF · Councillor Terry Hone – County Councillor and LGCHF Board Member · Councillor David Barnard – County Councillor and family affected by the east of Luton site, but stated he would not vote for or against · Councillor Michael Muir – County Councillor · Councillor Richard Thake – County Councillor · Councillor Chris Hinchliff – Employed by national charity CPRE, but not involved with CPRE Hertfordshire.
· Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor David Barnard · Councillor Chris Lucas · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Keith Hoskins · Councillor Tom Plater · Councillor George Davies · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Chris Hinchliff · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Lisa Nash · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor James Denselow · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Sean Prendergast During the debate at 22.15 there was a short adjournment to allow for a comfort break and the meeting recommenced at 22.23.
Councillor Juan Cowell nominated Councillor Michael Muir.
Councillor Alistair Willoughby proposed and Councillor Michael Muir seconded and, following a vote it was:
· Councillor Michael Weeks · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions, [name removed] and [name removed] advised:
· Councillor Michael Weeks · Councillor Juan Cowell · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Alistair Willoughby In response to questions the Senior Transport Policy Officer advised:
· Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Juan Cowell · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Michael Weeks · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Steve Jarvis Councillor Steve Jarvis commented that it would be nicer to host Councillor surgeries in the High Street in Baldock, but the most populated place is probably Tesco.
Councillor Michael Muir asked the Committee that they should let him know of any road issues in the town so he can deal with them as a County Councillor.
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Chris Hinchliff ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
· Councillor Ruth Brown · John Webb – Transition Town Letchworth · Councillor Michael Muir · Paul Ward – Knebworth Parish Council · Edward Leigh – Senior Transport Policy Officer · Mike Clare – Hitchin Forum · Councillor David Levett · Julia Crear – Living Streets · Bill Sellicks – Hitchin Forum In response to questions the Head of Road Safety and Active Travel advised:
Having given due notice Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Simon Bloxham, Councillor Nigel Mason substituted for Councillor Sean Nolan, and Councillor Amy Allen substituted for Councillor Alistair Willoughby.
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Tom Tyson In response Thomas Howe advised:
Having given due notice Councillor Amy Allen substituted for Councillor Alistair Willoughby, Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Simon Bloxham and Councillor Nigel Mason substituted for Councillor Sean Nolan.
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Nigel Mason In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised:
· Councillor Michael Muir · Aimee Flack · Diane Ketcher · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Chris Hinchliff · John Webb · Deolinda Eltringham In response to questions, the Policy Officer advised:
Councillor Michael Weeks nominated Councillor Michael Muir.
· Councillor Michael Weeks · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Alistair Willoughby In response to questions from Members the Community Engagement Officer advised:
Councillor Michael Muir informed the Committee that he has spent all of his Highways Budget Allocation for 22/23, but needs to decide how to spend the 23/24 budget, so if any Councillors are aware of any roads that need to be serviced let him know.
Councillor Michael Weeks nominated Councillor Michael Muir.
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Simon Bloxham · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor David Levett The Monitoring Officer provided advice regarding the decision that had already been taken – thereby treating the Letchworth Civic Trust as an uncontested appointment following the withdrawal of Councillor Phil Weeder.
Having given due notice Councillor Ian Moody substituted for Councillor Michael Muir.
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor David Levett In response to questions from Members the Senior Planning Officer advised:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 04 seconds Councillor Jim McNally, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Michael Muir seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions Rob Bakewell and Iain Page advised:
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Michael Weeks · Councillor Juan Cowell · Councillor Jim McNally The Community Engagement Officer advised that this was the group’s first application since 2013 and some funds had been found elsewhere to help with other repairs on site.
Councillor Michael Weeks proposed that the grant request be made up to £1000, to assist with repairing damage caused by vandalism last night and Councillor Michael Muir seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Jim McNally · Councillor Michael Weeks · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Juan Cowell In response to questions, Sarah Hammond-Ward advised:
Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Michael Weeks seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Michael Weeks · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Juan Cowell · Councillor Steve Jarvis In response to questions Agata Kisicka and Ethel Morrell advised:
Having given due notice Councillor George Davies substituted for Councillor Morgan Derbyshire, Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Tony Hunter and Councillor Amy Allen substituted for Councillor Ian Mantle.
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Mike Rice · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to points raised in the debate, the Planning Officer advised:
Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Ian Moody seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Having given due notice, Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Tony Hunter.
· Cath Boughton – Royston First Manager · Cathy Andrews – Letchworth BID Manager · Jim McNally – Baldock Big Lunch Committee · James Willis – Hitchin Arts Group · Ashley Hawkins – Community Engagement Officer · Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Sarah Dingley · Tom Hardy – Hitchin BID Manager · Emma Rowe – St Mary’s School PTA Points raised included:
Having given due notice Councillor Simon Bloxham substituted for Councillor John Bishop and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor Tony Hunter.
· Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Mike Hughson In response to questions the Senior Planning Officer advised:
Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Ian Mantle seconded, and, following a vote it was:
· Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Simon Harwood · Councillor Morgan Derbyshire · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor George Davies In response to questions Richard Beasley, Consultant advised that the Local Government Boundary Commission for England will not change the Council’s electoral cycle and only look at Council Size and warding arrangements, which are impacted by the decision to be made at this meeting.
Councillor Michael Muir advised that, should the Coronavirus Support Group apply for grant funding at a future meeting, he would likely be a trustee and would therefore declare an interest at the appropriate time.
· Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Jim McNally · Councillor Juan Cowell The debate and questions included the following points:
Councillor Muir, as President of the Royal British Legion in Baldock, advised that this was due to a decision taken when cases were still high, but hymns would return for future events.
Councillor Michael Muir advised that the County Council Highways Funds for 2021/22 had been allocated, but there was around £30,000 available for schemes in 2022/23. He encouraged Members to contact him with possible suggestions where these outstanding funds could be spent.
Councillor Muir advised that there had been a request from the Wilkie family to have a bench on the High Street in honour of Nurse Wilkie who had worked in the town.
Having given due notice Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor David Levett, Councillor Simon Bloxham substituted for Councillor John Bishop and Councillor Amy Allen substituted for Councillor Mike Hughson.
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions the Senior Planning officer advised:
Having given due notice Councillor George Davies substituted for Councillor Mike Rice and Councillor Michael Muir substituted for Councillor John Bishop.
Councillor Morgan Derbyshire proposed Councillor David Levett as Vice-Chair and was seconded by Councillor Michael Muir.
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor David Levett · Councillor George Davies In response to questions, the Senior Planning Officer advised:
Councillor David Levett proposed and Councillor Michael Muir seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 28 seconds Councillor Jim McNally proposed and Councillor Michael Muir seconded and it was:
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Jim McNally · Councillor Michael Weeks · Lisa Patterson Andrew Mills, Service Manager – Greenspace, advised:
Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Michael Weeks seconded and it was:
Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Michael Weeks seconded and following a vote it was:
· Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Adem Ruggiero-Cakir On the vote it was:
Councillor Michael Muir advised that he was a Hertfordshire County Councillor.
Councillor Ian Mantle proposed, Councillor Michael Muir seconded and it was:
· Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Mike Hughson · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Michael Muir · John Webb In response to questions Anni Sander noted:
· Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Mike Hughson · Councillor Steve Jarvis Topics raised included:
Councillor Michael Muir proposed that Councillor Jim McNally be elected Chair which was seconded by Councillor Juan Cowell.
Councillor Jim McNally as Chair proposed that Councillor Michael Muir be elected Vice-Chair which was seconded by Councillor Juan Cowell.
Audio Recording – 14 Minutes 11 Seconds Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Steve Jarvis seconded and it was:
Councillor Michael Muir informed [name removed] that her ward Councillor (Tom Tyson) was not present at the meeting.
In response, Councillor Michael Muir proposed that the amount of funding awarded be reduced further to £500.00 and that he would make up the rest with his Hertfordshire County Council Members Locality Budget.
Audio Recording – 11 Minutes 33 Seconds Councillor Michael Muir proposed that the full amount requested be awarded to Ashwell Playgroup which was seconded by Councillor Steve Jarvis.
Audio Recording – 30 Minutes Councillor Michael Muir proposed and Councillor Steve Jarvis seconded.
· Councillor Michael Muir;
· Councillor David Levett; and · Councillor Michael Muir.
· Councillor Michael Muir;
Councillor Muir advised that he would need to know the amount that was required and then he could check his locality budget balance.
Councillor Michael Muir provided the following updates:
Councillor Michael Muir reported that he had distributed approximately 70 Town Talk flyers to shops. However, as many of them were closed during the pandemic restrictions, he had to post them through the letterboxes.
Having given due notice Councillor Ian Albert advised that he would be substituting for Councillor Helen Oliver and Councillor Michael Muir advised that he would be substituting for Councillor Michael Weeks.
Councillor Muir advised that he had and interest as a Baldock County Councillor. It was expected that 3,300 houses would be built in Baldock on County Council Land, despite the dispensation, he would listen to the debate but would not be voting this evening.
· Councillor Michael Muir;
· Councillor Michael Muir.
· Councillor Michael Muir; and · Councillor Michael Weeks.
Audio Recording – 26 Minutes Councillor Muir proposed, Cllr McNally seconded and it was:
· Councillor Michael Muir;
· Councillor Michael Muir;
• Councillor Michael Muir;
· Councillor Michael Muir.
Having given due notice Councillor Michael Muir advised that he would be substituting for Councillor Val Shanley and Councillor Tom Tyson advised that he would be substituting for Councillor Sean Prendergast.
· Councillor Michael Muir.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Muir attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Muir's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Muir was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 3 of 4 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Muir declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Muir in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Muir sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jul 2019 | 5 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Baldock and Villages Community Forum | Committee Member | May 2026 | 3 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet Panel | Committee Member | Feb 2022 | 3 | |
| Planning Control Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2024 | 1 | |
| Standards Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.