Information note: annual review of safeguarding and protecting children and adults 2025-26
· Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Sadie Billing N.B.
Every time North Hertfordshire's minutes name Councillor Muncer, as the council published it.
· Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Sadie Billing N.B.
· Councillor Paul Ward · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Dominic Griffiths · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Caroline McDonnell In response to questions, the Chair advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Claire Winchester In response to questions, Councillor Mick Debenham advised that the Government decision to pause LGR in Hertfordshire would have no impact on the allocation of grant funding proposed.
· Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Paul Ward · Councillor David Chalmers In response to questions, the Chair advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Martin Prescott The following points were made as part of the debate:
Councillor Ralph Muncer proposed Councillor Joe Graziano for Chair of the Southern Rural Community Forum, and this was seconded by Councillor David Barnard.
Councillor Ralph Muncer proposed Councillor Steven Patmore for Vice-Chair of the Southern Rural Community Forum, and this was seconded by Councillor David Barnard.
· Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Donna Wright · Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Laura Williams · Councillor Sadie Billing · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Steve Jarvis Points raised during the debate on the amendment included:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 16 seconds Councillor Keith Hoskins proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Vijaiya Poopalasingham · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Sean Prendergast · Councillor Keith Hoskins In response to questions, the Monitoring Officer advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Vijaiya Poopalasingham · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Sean Prendergast · Councillor Keith Hoskins · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis Points raised in the debate included that:
As part of the Debate, Councillor Ralph Muncer noted that his Group had voted to defend democratic processes in removing the previous leader. He noted that whilst the Conservatives would not support the nomination, they would not oppose it either, and would take the same action to remove the new Leader if the will of Council was not listened to.
The developer can be advised to pursue the matter further if they wish and if they voluntarily approach the council to review the name, to which they previously agreed then a new consultation can take place.’ (B) Expansion of the Chilterns Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Donna Wright, Executive Member for Place:
· Councillor Dominic Griffiths · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Donna Wright · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Laura Williams · Councillor Tamsin Thomas · Councillor Steven Patmore · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Sadie Billing · Councillor Joe Graziano · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Emma Fernandes · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Paul Ward · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Mick Debenham · Councillor Dave Winstanley · Councillor Vijaiya Poopalasingham · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Daniel Allen N.B.
Audio recording – 3 minute 28 seconds The Chair advised that there would be a presentation from Councillor Ralph Muncer during Item 8 – Local Government Reorganisation in Hertfordshire – Submission of Final Proposals.
The Chair invited Councillor Ralph Muncer to provide Cabinet with a verbal presentation.
Councillor Muncer thanked the Chair for the opportunity and highlighted the following:
The Chair thanked Councillor Muncer for his presentation. The Chair reminded Members that the formal advice received from Kings Counsel was that Cabinet must consider the vote from Full Council, but that it must not determine their decision. Cabinet must have an open mind as to act with a predetermined mind would be unlawful.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Caroline McDonnell · Councillor Sadie Billing In response to questions, the Shared Service Manager – Waste & Recycling advised that:
· Councillor Sadie Billing · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis In response to questions, the Regional Contract Manager for Everyone Active advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis In response to questions, the Strategic Planning & Projects Manager advised that:
· Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Sadie Billing In response to questions, the Climate Change & Sustainability Project Manager advised that:
Councillor Ralph Muncer noted the High Court Case with the Chief Constable of Northumbria Police and Northern Pride and suggested that Members should consider this in relation to the Crime and Disorder Matters item at the next meeting.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Paul Ward In response to questions, the Monitoring Officer advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Paul Ward · Councillor Ian Albert In response to questions, the Monitoring Officer advised that:
As part of the debate, Councillor Ralph Muncer suggested that additional clarity should be added to make it clear what a ‘reportable incident’ was and that examples of when neighbouring authorities may be required to assist in assessments of complaints received should be included in the Protocol document.
· Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Mick Debenham · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Jon Clayden The following points were made as part of the debate on the amendment:
Councillor Ralph Muncer proposed the motion as follows:
(A) Local Government Reorganisation Options Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Daniel Allen, Leader of the Council:
Until then, it would be premature for the Administration to express a preference.’ Councillor Ralph Muncer asked a supplementary question, as follows:
Having given due notice Councillor Ralph Muncer substituted for Councillor Patmore.
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Paul Ward · Councillor Vijaiya Poopalasingham · Independent Member John Cannon In response to questions, the Counter Fraud Manager advised that:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Independent Member John Cannon In response to questions, the Director – Resources stated that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Tina Bhartwas · Councillor Paul Ward · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Claire Winchester In response to questions, Councillor Donna Wright advised that:
Councillor Ralph Muncer noted that due to advice to delay stakeholder consultation, it would be more appropriate for the S106 Task and Finish Group to present their report to the Committee meeting in February rather than January.
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer, Councillor Ian Albert advised that the Strategic Priorities Fund had not been spent, as detailed in the table in paragraph 8.2 of the report.
· Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Joe Graziano · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Tamsin Thomas Points raised during the debate included:
Audio recording – 4 minutes 5 seconds Councillor Keith Hoskins, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote it was:
· Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Nigel Mason The Employment Committee then asked the Candidate formal interview questions as part of the interview process.
· Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Bryony May The Employment Committee then asked the Candidate formal interview questions as part of the interview process.
Councillor Keith Hoskins, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote it was:
Councillor Ralph Muncer nominated Councillor David Barnard for Chair of Southern Rural Community Forum.
Councillor Ralph Muncer nominated Councillor Joe Graziano for Vice-Chair of Southern Rural Community Forum.
Councillor Martin Prescott proposed Councillor Muncer and Councillor Steven Patmore seconded.
Councillor Ralph Muncer proposed Councillor Prescott and Councillor David Barnard seconded.
Councillor Daniel Allen proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Laura Williams · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Donna Wright In response to questions, Councillor Mick Debenham advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Donna Wright · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions, Councillor Val Bryant advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Donna Wright · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Claire Winchester In response to questions, the Managing Director advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt ... view the full minutes text for item 98.
Councillor Ralph Muncer thanked the Chair, Members, and officers for their engagement with the formation of the S106 Task and Finish Group so far.
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer on seeking the views of the Cabinet Panel on Environment regarding the Sustainability Strategy, the Committee, Member and Scrutiny Manager advised that this could be organised with them, and that all Members were able to attend meetings of the Cabinet Panel on the Environment.
The following Members took part in the debate on the amendment: · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Chalmers · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Sean Prendergast · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Tina Bhartwas · Councillor Daniel Allen Points raised during the debate included:
· Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Joe Graziano · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor David Barnard · Councillor Daniel Allen In response to questions, the Managing Director advised that:
Having given due notice Councillor Ralph Muncer substituted for Councillor Patmore and Councillor Nigel Mason substituted Councillor Poopalasingham.
Audio recording – 2 minutes 26 seconds Councillor Sean Nolan, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 58 seconds Councillor Matt Barnes, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer , the Revenues, Systems & Technical Manager advised that the figures relating to the number of households in which a Summons and a Liability Order was used and the amount of Council Tax collected from this method would be sent to all Members after the meeting.
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer, the Service Director – Resources advised that the contractor who operate North Herts Leisure Centre provided income based on the leisure facilities meeting certain conditions, including a working flume and adequate changing facilities.
“The assessment will be published in due course and has already been shared with the relevant parties.” (B) Response to Local Government Re-Organisation White Paper Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Daniel Allen (Leader of the Council):
Any decisions will be based on the evidence and what is the best outcome for the communities that we serve.” A supplementary question was asked by Councillor Ralph Muncer:
“Our county is diverse and any reform of local government should consider residents, businesses, local representatives and stake holders and a single unitary authority would take away from the communities we serve.” (C) Penalty Charge Notices (PCNs) – Issued Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Daniel Allen (Interim Executive Member for Planning and Transport) “How many Penalty Charge Notices (PCNs) were issued by this authority in 2024?” Councillor Daniel Allen gave a response as follows:
“15,623.” A supplementary question was asked by Councillor Ralph Muncer:
“I do not have figures like that off the top of my head, but I will get back to you with that data.” (D) Penalty Charge Notices (PCNs) – Appeals Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor ... view the full minutes text for item 86.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Paul Ward In response to questions, the Service Director – Place advised that:
(D) Impact of Family Farm Tax on Rural Communities in North Hertfordshire Councillor Ralph Muncer proposed the motion as follows:
Having given due notice, Councillor Ralph Muncer substituted for Councillor Patmore and Councillor Caroline McDonnell substituted for Councillor Ward.
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Vijaiya Poopalasingham · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Independent Member John Cannon In response to questions, the Service Director – Resources advised that:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Dominic Griffiths · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Independent Member John Cannon In response to questions, the Service Director – Resources advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Independent Member John Cannon · Councillor Sean Nolan In response to questions, the Service Director – Resources advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Sean Nolan · Independent Member John Cannon · Councillor Tina Bhartwas In response to questions, the Service Director – Resources advised that:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 41 seconds Councillor Matt Barnes, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer, the Service Director – Place advised that the new proposed scheme would commence from 1 April 2025, subject to legal agreements.
Councillor Matt Barnes, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt ... view the full minutes text for item 70.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Louise Peace · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Matt Barnes In response to questions, the Service Director – Place advised that:
As part of the debate, Councillor Ralph Muncer noted that he ... view the full minutes text for item 71.
· Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Laura Williams · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Vijaiya Poopalasingham · Councillor Paul Ward · Councillor Sam Collins In response to points of clarification, [name removed] advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Steve Jarvis Points raised in debate included:
(1) Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Nigel Mason, Chair of the Planning Control Committee:
The Chair thanked [name removed] for her presentation and invited Councillor Ralph Muncer to speak against the application.
Councillor Muncer thanked the Chair for the opportunity and provided the Committee with a verbal presentation, including that:
The Chair thanked [name removed] for his presentation and invited Councillor Ralph Muncer to speak against the application.
Audio Recording – 1 minute 57 seconds Councillor Ralph Muncer thanked the Chair for his work in developing the Scrutiny Charter, and noted recent feedback from the Peer Review which highlighted recent improvements in the scrutiny processes.
Councillor Matt Barnes, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Sean Prendergast · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to a question the Executive Member for Community and Partnerships advised that the increase in complaints regarding the new leisure provider were mainly associated with people getting used to the new booking system.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Laura Williams · Councillor Tina Bhartwas · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason In response to questions, the Executive Member for Housing and Environmental Health advised that this scheme would provide a six bedded unit for homeless single women and that Druglink were a very experienced charity which ran similar schemes elsewhere.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Donna Wright · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Tina Bhartwas · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Tom Tyson In response to questions the Executive Member for Enterprise and Arts advised that:
· Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Laura Williams · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Donna Wright In response to questions, the Culture and Facilities Service Manager advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer had raised a request to conduct a Task and Finish Group to investigate Section 106 funding at North Herts and possible alternatives.
Councillor Muncer advised that Section 106 funding in North Herts was not necessarily delivering the benefits to residents that it should and there was limited specific community benefit. The Task and Finish Group would look at whether Section 106 should continue in North Herts or whether it should be replaced.
· Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Matt Barnes Councillor Daniel Allen noted his support for the topic proposed and requested that the work conducted should not hold up the upcoming Local Plan Review.
In response to questions, Councillor Muncer advised that:
· Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Claire Winchester In response to questions the Chair advised that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee would be looking at dentistry at a future meeting and that he would consider adding social care to the work programme.
The Chair invited Councillor Ralph Muncer to speak against the application.
Councillor Muncer thanked the Chair for the opportunity and provided the Committee with a verbal presentation, including that:
In response to points of clarification from Councillor Val Bryant, Councillor Muncer advised that:
The Chair thanked Councillor Ralph Muncer for his presentation and invited [name removed] to speak as agent to the applicant, in support of the application. [name removed] thanked the Chair for the opportunity and provided the Committee with a verbal presentation, including that:
(A) Solar Farm Strategy Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Daniel Allen, Interim Executive Member for Planning and Transport:
If the proposals in the current consultation on the National Planning Policy Framework are brought forward, the Council will be expected to proactively identify sites for renewable and low carbon development when producing plans.’ Councillor Ralph Muncer asked a supplementary question, as follows:
They are the ones that are there to make these decisions and I will support them on the decisions that they make.’ (B) Proposed reforms to the National Planning Policy Framework Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Daniel Allen, Leader of the Council:
Any covering letter, political response or equivalent from the Council will be based upon the outcomes of the relevant motions that follow on from tonight's agenda.’ Councillor Ralph Muncer asked a supplementary question, as follows:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barns · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Daniel Allen Points raised in debate included:
Councillor Muncer stated that he looked forwarded to working with the appointees and marvelled at their experience.
Councillor Alistair Willoughby proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Councillor Ralph Muncer left the Chamber at 23:21 and returned at 23:23.
Councillor Ralph Muncer nominated Councillor Michael Muir as the fourth Member to the outside organisation the Baldock United Almshouses Charity.
· Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Claire Winchester · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Donna Wright · Councillor Laura Williams · Councillor Tina Bhartwas · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Louise Peace In response to questions, Councillor Daniel Allen advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Laura Williams · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Matt Barnes In response to questions, Councillor Daniel Allen advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Donna Wright In response to questions, the Service Director – Resources advised that:
· Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Louise Peace In response to questions, the Service Director – Place advised that:
· Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Daniel Wright The following points were raised during the discussion:
During the debate, Councillor Ralph Muncer thanked the Scrutiny Officer for the work in supporting the production of this Charter, and that it would help not only members of this Committee, but Members across the Council, to understand their roles.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Amy Allen Councillor Clare Billing, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Daniel Allen seconded and, following a vote, it was:
(A) Legal Advice Received on the Waste Contract Award Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Daniel Allen, Leader of the Council:
Councillor Ralph Muncer asked a supplementary question, as follows:
Other than that Councillor Muncer you have seen all the reasoning and it is all available to you’.
Audio recording – 50 minutes 15 seconds N.B Councillor Ralph Muncer left the Chamber at 20:23 and returned at 20:25, Councillor Dominic Griffiths left the Chamber at 20:25.
Councillor Ralph Muncer stated that this policy was strongly welcomed, and they were proud to support the armed forces covenant.
Councillor Ralph Muncer stated that as the last review was in 2006, a new review was long overdue. Parish Councillors had important roles, engaging with residents, and empowering the Communities, especially as their meetings tended to have greater public attendance.
· Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Sam Collins In response to questions, the Strategic Planning Manger advised:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Daniel Allen Points raised in debate included:
Audio Recording – 1 minute 50 seconds Councillor Matt Barnes proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Martin Prescott · Councillor Daniel Wright – Mason · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Jon Clayden · Councillor Matt Barnes In response to questions the Service Director - Place advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis In response to questions, Councillor Bryant stated that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes Points raised in debate included:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Martin Prescott In response to questions, the Scrutiny Officer stated that:
Councillor Ralph Muncer nominated Councillor David Barnard for Chair of Southern Rural Community Forum.
This was seconded by Councillor Ralph Muncer.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Daniel Allen Councillor Ruth Brown proposed and Councillor Daniel Allen seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Standards Committee Substitute would be Councillor Ralph Muncer.
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Claire Strong In response to questions the Committee, Member and Scrutiny Manager stated that:
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Richard Thake (11) The Chair reminded Members to submit the required elections expenses forms by 6 June 2024.
In response to a question from Councillor Muncer, the Principal Estates Surveyor stated that there had been no objections received from the public notices to date.
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Albert Points raised in the debate included:
Audio Recording: 1 minute 33 seconds Councillor Ruth Brown as Chair proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Val Bryant In response to points of clarification, [name removed] advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Dominic Griffiths Points raised in debate included:
· Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Independent Person Nicholas Moss · Reserve Independent Person Peter Chapman In response to questions, the Monitoring Officer stated that:
Audio Recording – 2 minutes 9 seconds Councillor Val Bryant, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Val Bryant Points raised in the debate included:
Councillor David Levett proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Matt Barnes In response to questions, the Controls Risk & Performance Manager advised that:
A) 4 Day Working Week The Chair noted that subsequent to the agenda publication there has been two amended Motions published as a supplementary document regarding the Motion proposed by Councillor Ralph Muncer, and to refer to the most recently published version, annotated with ‘as amended with today’s date’ The Chair invited Councillor Ralph Muncer to present the motion, noting that Councillor Ralph Muncer had been granted permission to speak for longer than five minutes on this item.
Councillor Ralph Muncer proposed the motion as follows:
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer , the Service Director – Resources advised that the change to the figures quoted in the Cabinet report to those included within the Council report, were to reflect the changes in the energy costs of the leisure centres. The subsequent change to figures within the Council report reflected the installation of the bee corridors (£10k) and additional Area Forum grants (£25k).
· Councillor Terry Hone · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Tom Plater · Councillor Sean Prendergast Points raised in the debate included:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Adam Compton In response to a question, the Service Director – Resources advised that Officers could claim travel expenses for travel carried out whilst on official duties.
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Clare Billing · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Adam Compton In response to questions, [name removed] and [name removed] advised of the following:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Clare Billing · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Mick Debenham In response to questions, Inspector Lant and Sergeant Adshead advised of the following:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Adam Compton In response to questions, the Executive Member for Housing and Environmental Health advised that:
· Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett In response to questions, the Service Director – Customers, advised that the Empty Homes & Second Homes Premium Policy was still in draft form and could not be finalised until government regulations had been received. The Service Director apologised that the draft policy was not circulated to Members with the agenda and advised that she would circulate a copy to Members following the meeting.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett Points raised in debate included:
Councillor Adam Compton, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer, the Committee, Member and Scrutiny Manager advised that rooms 2 and 3 would not solely be used for scrutiny meetings but could be used for any smaller committees and also Task and Finish groups to enable meetings to be held in a less formal environment to the chamber.
(A) Home Internet for Officers Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Ian Albert (Executive Member for Finance and IT).
“I assumed that you might be referring to a Freedom of Information request we had from the Taxpayers Alliance last year where we provided a full response in relation to staff working at home payments, we do allow staff that work at home to claim an allowance towards additional costs, but in direct response to your question, we do not pay for Officers home internet bills.” Councillor Ralph Muncer asked a supplementary question, as follows:
“So the answer to Councillor Muncer is no, working at home is good for the organisation, working from home has many benefits for staff as well as the Council and our residents, increases our resilience and business continuity as we saw during the pandemic. It has not led to any downturn in productivity, we are aware of the cost of living crisis and with limited pay increase, we feel a contribution to employees working from home costs is fair. Indeed 80% of our staff value, indeed highly valued the allowance.
The Local Government Association says flexible working is good for retention and morale and gives people the ability to have more balance which is good from a health perspective, but the important thing here is balancing what if the needs of the business and the needs of our staff it’s a win-win we believe we have and that’s where we are, but I know Councillor Muncer is also keen on financial returns and if I haven’t yet managed to convince him about the importance of working home we have also demonstrated some very clear financial benefits from homeworking. For floor two we are receiving annual rental incomes of nearly £50,000 a year, we are also recharging costs of over £50,000 including business energy usage, broadband etc. Altogether this means we have £100,000 worth of returned, more than twice the amount we are paying currently in working at home allowances.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Claire Strong In response to questions, the Executive Member for Finance and IT stated that:
· Councillor Tom Plater · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Tamsin Thomas · Councillor Simon Bloxham Points raised in debate:
Audio recording – 2 minutes 38 seconds The Chair advised that Councillor Ralph Muncer had advised of an error in the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee from the 7 November 2024. This related to his name being wrongly included within the list of Members who had received dispensation from the Monitoring Officer to take part in the Call to Account on the Harkness Court Project. As he was not on the Planning Control Committee, he had not been required to seek a dispensation.
N.B Councillor Ralph Muncer entered the Council Chamber at 19:46.
· Councillor Dominic Griffiths · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett In response to questions, the Controls, Risk and Performance Manager advised that:
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Dominic Griffiths Points raised in debate included:
· Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor David Levett In response to questions, the Leader of the Council advised that:
In response to questions from Councillor Ralph Muncer, the Chair advised that the Call to Account reports for the Harkness Court Project and Lord Lister Hotel would be presented at the next meeting of the Committee on Monday 29 January 2024.
· Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor David Levett In response to questions the Executive Member for Planning and Transport stated:
· Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason In response to questions the Shared Service Manager, Waste Management stated:
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes In response to questions the Service Director – Place stated:
Councillor Adam Compton proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded, and following a vote, it was:
As part of the debate, Councillor Ralph Muncer highlighted the cost implications for the Council if there were statutory or legislative changes. He noted it was important that any proposals were communicated effectively with both Members and residents and note the importance of the Overview and Scrutiny and Finance, Audit and Risk Committees in having oversight of any proposals.
As part of the debate Councillor Ralph Muncer noted that often rural residents felt left behind by the District Council and had to pay additional Council Tax to cover the Parish precept.
Councillor Muncer noted that District Councils had a statutory responsibility to provide elections and the related administration costs and therefore these costs should be borne by the District Council.
Audio Recording – 2 minutes 38 seconds In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer, the Committee, Member and Scrutiny Manager advised that:
· The questions Councillor Muncer had submitted after the last meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee were recorded in a supplementary document on ModGov .
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Dominic Griffiths In response to the questions, Councillor Dennis advised that she would contact the relevant Service Directorate and report back to Members on lessons learned from the complaints.
· Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Ian Moody · Councillor Val Bryant The Service Director – Enterprise presented their report entitled ‘Call to account on the Harkness Court Refurbishment’ and Appendices, and advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Clare Billing · Councillor Adam Compton In response to questions, the Service Manager - Waste stated that:
This amendment was seconded by Councillor Ralph Muncer.
Having been proposed, as amended, by Councillor David Levett and seconded by Councillor Ralph Muncer, following a vote, it was:
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer, the Committee, Member and Scrutiny Manager advised that he would ensure an invite was sent out to the Hertfordshire Constabulary to attend a meeting next year.
Audio Recording – 2 minutes 8 seconds Councillor Ruth Brown, as Chair, proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Adam Compton In response to questions, Councillor Ian Albert stated that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer had several questions on projects which were not put at the meeting. These were submitted in writing and a response had since been provided by Officers and these would be circulated to Executive Members.
Councillor Ralph Muncer welcomed the Scrutiny Officer to their first Committee meeting in their new role.
· Councillor Clare Billing · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason In response to questions, the Safeguarding Team Leader advised that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Daniel Wright-Mason · Councillor Nigel Mason In response to questions, the Controls, Risk and Performance Manager advised that:
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer the Scrutiny Officer advised that the invitation to settle had been sent this week.
(A) Council Response to London Luton Airport Application Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Elizabeth Dennis (Leader of the Council).
And we have, as Councillor Muncer will note, objected to parts of the expansion in principle.
I do have quite detailed commentary on this from Officers and, if it will save Council time this evening, I’m more than happy to provide that as a written response to Councillor Muncer, rather than reading it out as part of my response to this part of the question, or any supplementary.
Councillor Ruth Brown proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer regarding the recruitment of the temporary Service Director, the Service Director – Legal and Community advised that it was not for her to go into detail on the appointment process, but that interviews had been completed and the appointment was pending.
Councillor David Levett proposed, and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Clair Billing · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Adam Compton In response the Customer Service Manager stated that:
· Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Clare Billing · Councillor Dominic Griffiths In response to questions, Councillor Elizabeth Dennis clarified that:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer, the Service Director - Legal and Community advised that the Scrutiny Officer role was discussed with Group Leaders, and although a full time role would be ideal, the 17 hour role reflected the funding available. This could be reviewed following the recruitment process and when an Officer was in place.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Matt Barnes · Councillor Val Bryant · Councillor Clare Billing Points raised during the debate included:
· Councillor Clare Billing · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor David Levett In response to questions Councillor Allen stated that:
Councillor Faye Frost proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Councillor Gerald Morris nominated Councillor Ralph Muncer for Vice-Chair on the Standards Committee.
Councillor David Levett, as Leader of the Conservative group, withdrew the nomination of Councillor Muncer.
Councillor Ralph Muncer highlighted an error in Section 8.2 of the report and noted the date of Decision should read 21 June 2022 instead of 21 June 2023.
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Faye Frost · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis · Councillor Chris Lucas Points raised during the debate include:
(B) Breach of the Code of Conduct Investigation and Withdrawn Sub-Committee Costs Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Ian Albert (Executive Member for Finance and IT) The Chair advised that Councillor Albert was not in attendance and had provided a written response which had been published as a supplement to the agenda.
Having been invited by the Chair, Councillor Ralph Muncer read out his question as published and asked the following supplementary question:
(C) Fly-tipping Councillor Ralph Muncer to Councillor Amy Allen (Executive Member for Recycling and Waste Management).
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Tom Plater · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Keith Hoskins · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor George Davies · Councillor Claire Strong Points raised during the debate included:
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Adam Compton In response to the questions, the Service Director – Legal and Community advised:
· In response to an enquiry from Councillor Ralph Muncer there is no requirement under the Complaint Handling Procedures for the Complainant to accept the apology. They are consulted. If no response is received from a Complainant, and in the 9/2022 case, bearing in mind the time constraints and potential for a hearing on the day, it was accepted having consulted the Independent Person.
· In response to an enquiry from Councillor Ralph Muncer regarding the investigation report for 9/2022, this case never went to a full hearing and any request would be considered in the light of the ICOs decisions and the information regimes.
· In response to an enquiry from Councillor Ralph Muncer final hearings for complaints, were usually public, but this ... view the full minutes text for item 33.
Councillor Ralph Muncer proposed that the Council be addressed ... view the full minutes text for item 34.
Councillor Ralph Muncer thanked the applicants, and highlighted that play was important for children’s cognitive development. He commented that the County Council, Parish Council and Sports England may be able to help with funding.
Councillor Claire Strong proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and following a vote, it was:
Following questions from Councillor Ralph Muncer, [name removed] advised:
Councillor Ralph Muncer highlighted concern over reports that Luton Airport had submitted a development application to increase the passenger capacity to 32million passengers per annum. There was a public enquiry ongoing on the report, and advised that himself and colleagues would try to prevent the expansion.
In response to a question from Councillor Ralph Muncer, the Service Director – Resources advised that a pay offer had been submitted to the Unions and it was less than 12.7%, which would be covered by Councillor Albert under agenda Item 10 regarding the budget.
· Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Tom Plater · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Chris Hinchliff · Councillor Amy Allen · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg Councillor Ian Albert commented that it was important that Member’s Allowances increased. Playgrounds would not be closed under the budget. The administration wanted to work cross-party with the opposition and with residents to create a plan for Churchgate.
· Councillor Simon Bloxham · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor George Davies · Councillor Daniel Allen · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Ruth Brown Councillor Chris Lucas summarised that there had been an interesting array of responses to this matter. The current system was not known and loved by people but had rather propped up Conservative governments.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Gerald Morris In response to questions, the Senior Estates Surveyor and Service Director – Enterprise advised:
Audio Recording- 2 minutes 57 seconds Councillor Keith Hoskins proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and it was:
Councillor Ralph Muncer also thanked the public participants for their presentations and remarked that it is important that the Council understood the challenges faced by businesses in North Hertfordshire.
Councillor Muncer also commented that the council wanted thriving town centres, with a larger footfall.
· Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Mandi Tandi In response to questions [name removed] advised:
Audio recording – 20 minutes 50 seconds Councillor Ralph Muncer made the Committee aware of a public consultation based on the possibility of lowering the speed limit in Kimpton. This is available to respond to on the Hertfordshire County Council website.
· Councillor George Davies · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Claire Strong · Community Engagement Team Leader · Councillor Ian Moody · Assistant Community Engagement Officer The key points raised in the discussion were:
He proposed that this be changed to ‘Codicote and Kimpton’ ward and this was seconded by Councillor Ralph Muncer.
The Chair invited Councillor Ralph Muncer to speak as Member Advocate against the application, in place of the ward member Councillor Ian Moody.
Councillor Muncer thanked the Chair for the opportunity and provided the Committee with a verbal presentation, including:
· Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor David Barnard · Councillor Chris Lucas · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Gerald Morris · Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Keith Hoskins · Councillor Tom Plater · Councillor George Davies · Councillor Ian Mantle · Councillor Michael Muir · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Chris Hinchliff · Councillor Tom Tyson · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor Sean Nolan · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Lisa Nash · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor James Denselow · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Sean Prendergast During the debate at 22.15 there was a short adjournment to allow for a comfort break and the meeting recommenced at 22.23.
Councillor Ralph Muncer thanked those presented this evening for their presentations and their advice would support him as a Councillor to pass the message onto his constituents. It was important to continue to communicate with organisations and individuals, which will help understanding of support available, and that this should take place through various channels, both online and offline.
The Chair noted that Councillor Ralph Muncer, who was unable to attend this evening, has expressed his support for this grant application.
REFERRAL FROM SOUTHERN RURAL AREA COMMITTEE: 30 JUNE 2022- CLOSURE OF KIMPTON SURGERY The Chair of the Southern Rural Area Committee, Councillor George Davies commented that this was an item brought up during the Ward Matters section so he felt Councillor Ralph Muncer would be the best person to present this referral.
Councillor Ralph Muncer presented the referral from the Southern Rural Area Committee and highlighted the following points:
· Councillor Muncer thanked Members of Southern Rural for their interest on this topic to residents in Kimpton;
· Councillor Muncer is working alongside County Councillor Richard Thake to push for enhanced public transport provision in Kimpton.
· Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Tony Hunter · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Adam Compton · Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg · Councillor Alistair Willoughby · Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor Steve Jarvis · Councillor Keith Hoskins · Councillor Nigel Mason · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Tom Plater · Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Sam Collins · Councillor Ian Albert Following the vote it was:
Audio recording – 4:07 (1) The Chair welcomed those present at the meeting, especially Members attending their first Southern Rural Committee and the members of public who had attended to give a presentation and Councillor Ralph Muncer who had attended his first Area Committee meeting following his election in May;
· Councillor Muncer · Councillor Barnard · Councillor Strong In response to questions, [name removed] and [name removed] advised:
Closure of Kimpton Surgery – Councillor Ralph Muncer advised that there was a public consultation and a public meeting opposing the NHS closure of the Kimpton Surgery and that many residents attended. He stated that the closure of this surgery would force residents to travel elsewhere and would have a large impact on elderly and vulnerable people, as well as those who rely on public transport.
Councillor David Barnard proposed, Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor David Levett · Councillor Ruth Brown · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Judi Billing · Councillor Carol Stanier In response to questions, the Deputy Monitoring Officer advised:
Councillor Faye Frost proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
Councillor Claire Strong proposed and Councillor Ralph Muncer seconded and, following a vote, it was:
· Councillor Claire Strong · Councillor David Levett · Councillor Richard Thake · Councillor Ian Albert · Councillor Ralph Muncer · Councillor Sam Collins Points raised included:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Muncer attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Muncer's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Muncer was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 3 of 4 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Muncer declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Muncer in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Muncer sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2023 | 4 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Southern Rural Community Forum | Committee Member | Sep 2025 | 4 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2025 | 2 | 5 Jan 2027 |
| Southern Rural Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2022 | 1 | |
| Cabinet Panel | Committee Member | Jan 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.