Notifications of requests to address the meeting
Post-Financial Settlement General Fund Draft Budget Update Report 2026-27 Cllr Jim Hakewill 6.
Every time North Northamptonshire's minutes name Councillor Hakewill, as the council published it.
Post-Financial Settlement General Fund Draft Budget Update Report 2026-27 Cllr Jim Hakewill 6.
Saunders Close, Kettering & Lawrence Factory, Desborough - Capital Works Cllr Jim Hakewill 9.
Tree Management Policy Marion Turner-Hawes, Dorothy Maxwell, Cllr Jim Hakewill 11.
Local Plan Timetable Cllr David Brackenbury, Cllr Jim Hakewill
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill reported that the Corporate Scrutiny Committee had undertaken an in ? depth and rigorous analysis of the 2025/26 Council budget in order to forecast key financial risk areas relevant to the preparation of the 2026/27 budget.
Cllr Hakewill noted the allocation of approximately 63% of the £405.5m General Fund budget for three demand-led service areas, with the late settlement announcement from Government providing scrutiny members with additional time to examine the impact of the settlement figures prior to the next meeting of the committee on 26 th January. It was noted that the forthcoming meeting would include scrutiny of wider budget matters beyond the three principal risk areas identified, with the final findings of Corporate Scrutiny on the 2026/27 budget being reported to the Executive on 10 th February.
Cllr Hakewill noted the committee’s appreciation of the Leader and Executive’s commitment to financial scrutiny in advance of recommending the budget to Full Council.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill and the cross-party scrutiny members for their involvement in the budget setting process before inviting Claire Edwards, Executive Director of Finance to introduce a report that sought to update the Executive following the publication of the provisional Local Government Finance Settlement for three years (2026-27 to 2028-29) that had been announced on 17 th December 2025 The meeting heard that the settlement represented the first multi ? year settlement in ten years and had provided funding certainty through to 2028/29. Members were advised that the draft budget approved on 16 th December had included assumptions reflecting the anticipated outcomes of the Fair Funding Review, as shown in Table 1 of the report.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak in relation to this item.
Cllr Hakewill commented on the proposed demolition of the Lawrence factory, noting long ? standing familiarity with the site dating back to before its acquisition by the former Kettering Borough Council in 2005.
Cllr Hakewill highlighted the continuing potential of the site to attract investment and broaden retail choice for residents of Desborough, Rothwell and nearby villages, a need made more pressing by recent local housing growth.
Cllr Hakewill expressed the hope that the Executive would view the current proposal not merely as an opportunity to clear and dispose of the land but as a chance to invite developer interest and secure both economic and social value through a long ? term vision for the area’s regeneration.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his contribution before inviting George Candler, Executive Director for Place and Economy to introduce a report that sought approval to progress the demolition of structures at the Saunders Close site in Kettering and the Lawrence’s factory site in Desborough, primarily due to health and safety concerns. Both sites were noted to be structurally unsound and subject to repeated arson attacks and antisocial behaviour. The Saunders Close buildings, formerly part of the County Council estate, had been highlighted by the police as a specific safety risk.
The Chair thanked [name removed] for her comments and invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill noted the importance of protecting the natural environment and welcomed the detailed tree management policy. Concern was expressed that some mature trees, particularly those of inappropriate species planted decades earlier, had become overbearing to nearby homes. Several cases were cited where large canopies significantly affected residents’ living conditions.
Cllr Hakewill requested a pragmatic approach to the small number of trees causing substantial impact on residents’ enjoyment of their homes and advised that any necessary removal should be accompanied by planting three or more replacement trees.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his contribution before inviting George Candler, Executive Director for Place and Economy to introduce a report that sought approval of the updated to ensure that the Council managed its vast and diverse tree stock responsibly, sustainably and efficiently, in accordance with statutory duties, best practice and whilst fulfilling its health and safety obligations.
The Chair thanked Cllr Brackenbury for his comments before inviting Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill reflected on the preparation of the Local Plan and the timetable to date noting that delays over the previous four years had hindered progress.
Cllr Hakewill stated that the approach now proposed was positive and pragmatic, enabling development of the first Local Plan for North Northamptonshire to replace the four existing plans. Reference was made to the Joint Core Strategy, which had been viewed as an innovative framework for directing development around towns and villages. Members were reminded that the Council still had a sound and defensible policy base for decision ? making, but that timely plan ? making would give communities and developers renewed confidence in shaping future development.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his contribution before before inviting George Candler, Executive Director for Place and Economy to introduce the report. It was explained that the Local Plan was a key statutory document setting out, through evidence and consultation, the strategic allocation of employment and housing land. Members were reminded that North Northamptonshire had inherited a strong track record of plan ? making, including the Joint Core Strategy and four Part 2 Local Plans, forming a hierarchy beneath which neighbourhood plans also carried planning weight.
Capital Programme Update 2025/26 Cllr Jim Hakewill 6.
Indicative Budget Timeline and Scrutiny Process 2026/27 – Update Cllr Jim Hakewill 7.
Traffic Enforcement Options Cllr Jim Hakewill and Cllr James Towns 11.
Zero-emission Bus Scheme Cllr Trevor Conway and Cllr Jim Hakewill 13.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the format of the report and suggested that an additional level of detail be provided in future iterations to allow for the tracking of projects dependent on time-sensitive Section 106 funding as well as those funded via government grants and solely through the Council’s capital programme.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the Mawsley SEND unit investment and noted the enthusiasm of the Corporate Scrutiny Committee in its scrutiny of proposed capital programme items.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments before inviting Claire Edwards, Executive Director of Finance to introduce the report which sought approval for capital schemes that had come forward for inclusion within the Council’s approved Capital Programme in year, in line with the delegations set out in Table 1 of the Capital Strategy approved by Full Council in February 2025. Members were also asked to note the proposed Zero Emissions Bus Scheme for £1.8m that formed part of the Bus Service Improvement Plan (BSIP) budget already approved within the Capital Programme, with reference to a separate report on the subject to be considered later in the meeting.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak on this item.
Cllr Hakewill noted that the Corporate Scrutiny Committee had considered and endorsed the Indicative Budget Timeline and looked forward to reviewing the overarching financial position of the Council and contributing to the budget-setting process in advance of the Council Tax-setting meeting on 19 th February 2026. The importance of early engagement with Executive Members and wider community input was emphasised.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments before inviting Claire Edwards, Executive Director of Finance to introduce the report which sought to outline the proposed 2026/27 budget-setting process for the General Fund, Housing Revenue Account (HRA) and Capital Programme. Timetables for scrutiny involvement were set out, with the aim of enabling timely feedback ahead of Council Tax-setting. The Executive was asked to consider the timetable, noting that it had already been endorsed by Scrutiny.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the proposal to expand the School Streets initiative beyond the pilot scheme. It was heard that the initiative benefitted pupils, staff, visitors and local communities, and support was expressed for wider implementation across Northamptonshire, including potential Scrutiny involvement in case studies.
Cllr Hakewill was provided with the opportunity to speak in relation to this item.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the enhancement to the public transport network, noting that government funding had been secured with a clear timescale for expenditure. He stated that the initiative would reduce emissions and potentially enable future expansion through new charging facilities. The project was recognised as well-financed, using tried and tested technology, and was expected to deliver benefits on viable routes.
Councilor David Howes (Deputy Leader of the Conservative Group), Councillor Emily Fedorowycz (Leader of the Green Group), Councillor Mark Pengelly (Leader of the Labour Group), and Councillor Jim Hakewill (Leader of the Communities Alliance Group) also addressed Council.
Agenda Item Speakers Item 5 – Annual Budget Scrutiny Report 2025/26 (Budget Consultation Submission from the Budget Scrutiny Panel of Corporate Scrutiny Committee) Councillor Jim Hakewill Item 6 – General Fund Final Budget 2025-26 and Medium-Term Financial Plan Chris Stanbra, Councillor Jim Hakewill, Councillor Dorothy Maxwell Item 7 – Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Final Budget 2025-26 and Medium-Term Financial Plan Councillor Jim Hakewill Item 8 – Capital Programme 2025-2029 Chris Stanbra, Councillor Jim Hakewill, Councillor Dorothy Maxwell
The Chair, Councillor Jason Smithers invited Councillor Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Councillor Hakewill stated that no public had been invited to attend the budget scrutiny sessions and not all of the Budget Scrutiny Panel had attended all meetings. The Centre for Governance and Scrutiny needed to come into the Council and undertake a root and branch review of scrutiny. Resources for the EAPs should be put towards scrutiny.
The Chair thanked Councillor Hakewill for his contribution before inviting Councillor Lyn Buckingham, Chair of the Corporate Scrutiny Committee to introduce the report which provided formal feedback from the Budget Scrutiny Panel on the Executive’s budget proposals for 2025/26.
The Chair thanked [name removed] for his contribution and invited Councillor Hakewill to address the Executive .
Councillor Hakewill stated that this was another budget of more Council Tax for less services . He asked what would change in these proposals as a result of the scrutiny process . The budget was a risk for everyone but decisions were made by a small group.
The Chair thanked Councillor Hakewill for his contribution and invited Councillor Dorothy Maxwell to address the Executive .
Councillor Hakewill stated that within the decent homes works for heating upgrades, we would be spending less each year as the budget would not be receiving an inflationary increase. The Council was investing less on tenants homes year by year. Some properties still had old irreparable oil fired boilers, leading to no heat or hot water.
The Chair thanked Councillor Hakewill for his contribution and then invited Councillor Lloyd Bunday, Executive Member for Finance and Transformation to introduce the report which set out the proposed budget for the HRA for 2025/26 and the key principles on which it was based together with the Medium-Term Financial Plan that covered the following four years to 2029/30.
The Chair thanked [name removed] for his contribution and invited Councillor Jim Hakewill to address the Executive .
Councillor Hakewill stated that the funding for the Northamptonshire Traveller Unit was increasing this year but then was a part reversal saving of £50k as there had been a reduction in the number of unauthorised encampments . The proposed travellers temporary stopping site at Rothwell Green Space should have been debated in January but was now not on the Forward Plan at all . Social media had been told that there was an alternative site but councillors had not and the situation was chaotic.
The Chair intervened and requested that Councillor Hakewill withdraw his comment about the situation being chaotic, which Councillor Hakewill declined to do .
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill queried what provision had been made for Executive Members to explain the impact of the local government financial settlement on Council Tax levels for 2025/26 in face-to-face meetings with the public.
Cllr Hakewill also queried how the Council justified raising Council Tax levels by the maximum of 4.99% in light of the loss of winter fuel payments for many vulnerable pensioners.
In relation to scrutiny of the budget, Cllr Hakewill questioned why budget scrutiny sessions had been poorly attended by members, with a recent meeting postponed at short notice.
In response to Cllr Hakewill, Cllr Bunday noted that the budget scrutiny process was public facing, with meetings recorded and papers publicly available and that it was not possible to meet with all residents in face to face meetings. Regarding the proposed increased in Council Tax levels for 2025/26, central government expected local authorities to raise Council Tax levels by the maximum allowable (4.99%) and based its local government financial settlement figures on this assumption. It was noted that the draft General Fund Budget proposals for 2025/26 had been presented to the Executive at its meeting on 19 th December 2024, with the provisional local government financial settlement having been received only the day prior to that meeting.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak on this item.
Cllr Hakewill suggested that residents were driving on the worst roads in living memory and questioned why the strategy before the Executive would do anything to improve this experience.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his contribution before inviting the Executive Member for Highways, Travel and Assets, Cllr Matt Binley to introduce a report that presented and sought adoption of the Council’s new Highway Asset Management Policy and Strategy. The documents set out how the Council would best manage the Highway Network, taking into consideration customer needs, local priorities, asset condition and best use of available resources, and the impact this would have on the future delivery of highway maintenance.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill stated that most people would be opposed to covering farmland with solar panels when siting panels on buildings would be less damaging for the environment.
Cllr Hakewill queried the Council’s policy for such installations and queried why reports on were not being tabled at the Council’s Planning Committee (North) as well as Planning (South), with plans sought for a joint committee to convene to consider the proposal. Queries were also raised regarding resourcing the Council’s involvement in the Development Consent Order and the report not having been presented to the Council’s scrutiny function.
Cllr Hakewill queried how the community could have confidence in management of capital expenditure in relation to an overspend regarding Earls Barton School expansion and questioned what contingency had been built into the project.
[The Council rose to give a standing ovation to Janice Gotts for all her hard work and dedication to the Council and to wish her the absolute best for the future.] Councillor Matt Keane (Leader of the Labour Group), Councillor Emily Fedorowycz (Leader of the Green Alliance) and Councillor Jim Hakewill (Deputy Leader of the Independent Alliance Group) also addressed Council.
Motion 1 – Gypsy and Traveller Communities Councillor Jim Hakewill moved and Councillor Joseph Smyth seconded the following motion to Council.
The minutes of the extraordinary meeting of the Council held on 25 th January 2024 and Budget Council meeting held on 22 nd February 2024 were approved as a correct record and signed by the Chair, subject to the 22 nd February 2024 minutes being amended to reflect the correct spelling of Cllr Elliot Prentice’s forename, and to reflect that at minute 309 it was Cllr Hakewill rather than Cllr Fedorowycz who moved the Green Alliance amendment to the motion.
Name of Councillor Minute Number Interest Reason for Declaration Cllr Cedwien Brown 309 Personal Member of Save Rothwell Green Space Working Party Cllr Jim Hakewill 309 Personal Member of Save Rothwell Green Space Working Party Cllr Joseph Smyth 309 Personal Member of Save Rothwell Green Space Working Party
The Chair thanked Cllr Maxwell for her comments and invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill queried whether there were sufficient levels of experienced staff to enable the progress of the procurement process and further queried the scrutiny of figures detailed within the exempt appendix.
Cllr Hakewill also raised the matter of the report not being considered by an Executive Advisory Panel (EAP) or the Council’s scrutiny function.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments before inviting Cllr Gill Mercer, Executive Member for Adults, Health and Wellbeing to introduce a report that sought approval to procure a number of Public Health services as set out below, with a view to the new arrangements being in place by 1 st April 2025 · The 0-19 Health Visiting and School Nursing Service · Strong Start Service · Northamptonshire Integrated Sexual Health Service and HIV Service · Youth Counselling Offer (REACH) · Oral Health Promotion Service · Dental Epidemiology Survey In response to comments from the speakers, Cllr Mercer stated that the Council would continue to work hard with providers to build up strong relationships that could offer better control of performance as part of the move to disaggregate the service from West Northamptonshire as decided by the Shared Services Joint Committee at its meeting on 17 th January 2024 . It was noted that ongoing work relating to the procurement would be included as part of future Health Scrutiny agendas. Once the outcome of procurement was known the various options would be presented to the Council’s scrutiny function and the Active Communities EAP.
The Chair thanked Cllr Maxwell for her comments before inviting Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill requested that the lighting report referred to by the Chair be brought to a future scrutiny meeting and echoed comments supporting the climate change assessment tool.
Cllr Hakewill queried how funding for 2024/25 compared to the previous year and noted that that Council had received a real terms decrease in funding due to inflation.
Cllr Hakewill queried how the Leader would solve the issue of poor-quality highways repairs.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his contribution before inviting the Executive Member for Highways, Travel and Assets, Cllr Matt Binley to introduce a report that sought approval to add £1.069m of government funding derived from the cancellation of High Speed 2 northern phase 2 to the capital programme of highway maintenance to the 2023/24 in-year budget and additionally for 2024/25.
The Chair thanked Cllr Lee and invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill spoke to reference support for anxiety in being a barrier to accessing services.
Regarding transfer of assets or services, Cllr Hakewill queried what a place-led approach would mean.
Cllr Hakewill queried whether long-term funding would be available for any assets transferred, with a risk of potential double taxation, and questioned how this would be avoided.
Cllr Hakewill queried what amendments had been made to the report resulting from comments made by the Place and Environment Scrutiny Committee at its meeting on 5 th February 2024.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments and invited Cllr Dorothy Maxwell to address the meeting.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak to the Executive in relation to this item.
Cllr Hakewill noted the £35m delivery shortfall for the general fund Capital Programme and queried what measures would be put in place to create a viable and deliverable programme.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill spoke to welcome the initiative to increase biodiversity as part of the community orchards and micro woodlands schemes but made reference to potential loss of biodiversity elsewhere in the area.
Cllr Hakewill queried details regarding grant funding for tree planting, when funding would be available, ongoing maintenance of planted trees and the composition of project boards convened to monitor schemes approved.
Cllr Hakewill queried the budget deficit as set out in the report and questioned what the likely end of year figure would be given the increase since the previous reporting period.
Cllr Hakewill also questioned the use of funds from the transformation reserve to fund new education case management and regulatory case management systems and what transformation this spend would achieve The Chair then invited the Executive Member for Finance and Transformation, Cllr Lloyd Bunday to introduce a report that set out the forecast outturn position for the Council based on the Period 9 monitoring forecasts for the General Fund and the Housing Revenue Account (HRA).
Agenda Item Speakers Item 5 – Corporate Scrutiny Committee – Budget Consultation Submission Cllr Lyn Buckingham as Chair of CSC Cllr Lora Lawman, Cllr Dorothy Maxwell, Cllr Jim Hakewill Item 6 – General Fund Draft Budget 2024-25 and MTFP Cllr Jim Hakewill, Cllr Anne Lee Item 7 – HRA Draft Budget 2024-25 and MTFP Cllr William Colquhoun, Cllr Anne Lee, Cllr Lyn Buckingham Item 8 – Capital Programme 2024-2028 [name removed], [name removed], Cllr Jim Hakewill, Cllr Lyn Buckingham, Cllr Dorothy Maxwell, Cllr Joseph Smyth Cllr Anne Lee did not speak in relation to Item 7.
The Chair thanked Cllr Maxwell for her contribution and invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak on this item.
Cllr Hakewill spoke to note a lack of involvement in the budget scrutiny process by members outside of the Council’s scrutiny function as well as a lack of opportunity for the public to take part at meetings.
Cllr Hakewill also stated his disappointment that Executive members did not hold in-person budget meetings with the public.
Cllr Hakewill stated that while the national picture for local government appeared grim, the Council should look for ways to solve financial issues aside from ascribing deficits to external factors and concluded by querying whether legacy accounts for the former county council and Corby Borough Council had been signed off.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments before inviting Cllr Lyn Buckingham to address the meeting and present the report of the Budget Scrutiny Panel as Chair of the Corporate Scrutiny Committee.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill queried what risks were involved for the Council regarding previous legacy authority acquisition policies and whether an income pressure of £442k associated with a one-off rental pressure for the Commercial Property Portfolio would be exacerbated inf future.
Cllr Hakewill also referred to proposed revenue expenditure to fund a temporary travellers’ stopping site.
The Chair thanked [name removed] for his comments before inviting Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak.
Cllr Hakewill also spoke in relation to the proposed stopping site and raised concerns at the potential loss of green space, noting that it was not too late to remove the funding line from the Capital Programme. It was suggested that that proposal was likely to consume capital and revenue funds outside of best value criteria that could be directed to mitigate pressures on demand-led services.
Cllr Hakewill stated that it was not in the public interest to proceed with the proposal and that 25 pages of comments relating to the site concerned had not been provided to either the Executive of the Scrutiny Management Board as part of their considerations.
Proposing the report, Cllr Scott Edwards spoke to wish Cllr Christina Smith-Haynes well for the future and a full recovery, a sentiment echoed by Cllr Jim Hakewill during debate.
She stated the village supported the call-in by led by Cllr Jim Hakewill and that in practice very little consultation had taken place and that other sites had not properly considered.
Agenda Item Speakers Item 4 - Performance Indicator Report 2023/24 (Period 8 – November 2023) Cllr William Colquhoun, Valerie Anslow Item 5 – Culture, Tourism and Heritage Business Plan 2024-25 Cllr Jim Hakewill, Valerie Anslow, Dorothy Maxwell Item 6 – Northamptonshire Tourism Strategy and Local Visitor Economy Partnership for Northamptonshire Cllr Jim Hakewill, Lyn Buckingham, Dorothy Maxwell Item 7 – Specialist Drug and Alcohol Treatment for Rough Sleepers, or at risk of Rough Sleeping Cllr Jim Hakewill, Valerie Anslow Item 8 – Making of a Public Spaces protection Order (PSPO) for Rushden Town Centre Cllr Dorothy Maxwell Item 9 – Adoption of the Corby LCWIP Cllr Lyn Buckingham, Dorothy Maxwell, William Colquhoun Item 10 – Cleaning Service Contract Procurement Cllr Lyn Buckingham Item 11 – Budget Forecast 2023-24 at Period 8 Cllr Lyn Buckingham, Jim Hakewill, William Colquhoun Cllr William Colquhoun was not in attendance and consequently did not speak in relation to agenda items 4, 9 and 11.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting Cllr Hakewill queried whether it was considered acceptable to invest £855,000 in Culture, Tourism and Heritage in the current financial climate.
Cllr Hakewill questioned when the Cornerstone development would open, and whether it would be during 2024/25 impacting finances during that period.
Cllr Hakewill also queried risks associated with potential failure to implement new governance model proposals contained within the report and the scale of savings detailed within the business plan.
Finally, Cllr Hakewill queried costings for a greenhouse project at Chester House.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments and invited Cllr Valerie Anslow to address the Executive.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill queried when the future report referenced in recommendation 3.1b would be submitted to the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill asked when delivery arrangements and costings would be in place for the Local Visitor Economy Partnership Strategy.
Cllr Hakewill stated that it was essential that individual venues within the strategy be provided with individual profit and loss accounts, with all direct costs and overheads allocated to each in proportion thereby offering a clear financial direction.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments and invited Cllr Lyn Buckingham to speak on this item.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill queried how the Council would recruit specialists required to deliver the Specialist Drug and Alcohol Treatment for rough sleepers and questioned the expected point at which the service would be fully staffed and operational.
Cllr Hakewill also referenced diverse figures provided for the number of rough sleepers identified, querying how best value would be achieved with the complement of staff required when baseline figures for rough sleepers were so wide-ranging.
Cllr Hakewill concluded by questioning the input of the Health Scrutiny Committee into the report given its consideration at a meeting on 9 th January 2024.
The Chair then invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak on the item.
Cllr Hakewill queried what financial impact the recently announced Spending Management Panels would have and whether these would be public meetings.
Cllr Hakewill questioned whether there was a process for reclamation of costs associated with replacing street furniture damaged as a result of car accidents.
Referencing the Council’s reserve figure, Cllr Hakewill queried what percentage of that figure could be used that was not ringfenced and whether utilising contingency funds was the same as accessing reserves.
Cllr Hakewill asked for tangible outcomes regarding meetings with government regarding additional funding or helping to achieve greater financial stability for the Council and concluded by asking what useful learning had been acquired by the Leader following his appointment to the Local Government Association Board (LGA).
Agenda Item Speakers Item 5 - Performance Indicator Report 2023/24 (Period 7 – October 2023) Cllr Mark Pengelly, Cllr Anne Lee, Cllr Lyn Buckingham Item 6 - Amendment to Adult Social Care Charging Policy Cllr Matt Keane, Cllr Dorothy Maxwell Item 7 – Travellers Temporary Stopping Site Land at Junction 3 of the A14, Rothwell Cllr Jim Hakewill, Cllr Matt Keane, [name removed], Cllr Dorothy Maxwell Item 8 - Approval of Department for Transport (DfT) Additional Highway Maintenance Funding 2023/24 and 2024/25 Cllr Lyn Buckingham, Cllr Dorothy Maxwell, Cllr Jim Hakewill Item 9 – Northamptonshire Safeguarding Children Partnership Annual Report 2022-23 Cllr Anne Lee, Cllr Dorothy Maxwell Item 10 – Draft Budget 2024-25 and Medium-Term Financial Plan Cllr Lyn Buckingham, Cllr Jim Hakewill Item 11 – Housing Revenue Account Draft Budget (HRA) 2024- 25 and Medium-Term Financial Plan Proposals Cllr Lyn Buckingham Item 12 – Capital Programme 2024-2028 Cllr Jim Hakewill Item 13 – Capital Programme Update 2023/24 Cllr Anne Lee, Cllr Jim Hakewill Item 14 – Budget Forecast 2023-24 at Period 7 Cllr Lyn Buckingham, Cllr Jim Hakewill Cllr Mark Pengelly was not in attendance and consequently did not speak in relation to agenda item 5.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill suggested that the proposal before members should be considered within the emerging Gypsy and Traveller Local Plan process and made reference to the public consultation on the scope and options of the proposal and associated Sustainability Appraisal Scoping Report that had taken place between 5 th April and 31 st May 2023, noting that the projected timescale for the North Northamptonshire Gypsy and Traveller Local Plan proposed consultation on the draft in Spring 2024.
Cllr Hakewill expressed the view that local communities should be confident of the processes involved in decision making and be aware when major policy decisions such as provision for the Gypsy and Traveller community would be scrutinised.
Cllr Hakewill made reference to negative public perception of the site being used as proposed, effectively destroying a valuable green space.
Cllr Hakewill concluded by requesting that the item be withdrawn and considered as part of the consultation process for the North Northamptonshire Gypsy and Traveller Local Plan.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments before inviting Cllr Matt Keane to address the Executive.
The Chair thanked Cllr Maxwell for her comments and invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the additional funding and referenced the reporting requirements outlined by the DfT that would allow local people to see for themselves how the money was being spent.
Cllr Hakewill stated that scrutiny was needed to understand how funding was being spent, referring to additional funding of £1.5m received in the previous financial year and queried the specifics of its utilisation.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his contribution and invited Cllr Matt Binley, Executive Member for Highways, Travel and Assets to introduce a report that sought approval for the addition to the capital programme of £1.069m of additional highway maintenance capital funding for each of the financial years 2023/24 and 2024/25 as announced by the Department for Transport (DfT).
Cllr Jim Hakewill was then invited by the Chair to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill questioned when the Executive would be holding face-to-face meetings in local towns to explain the budget to residents.
Cllr Hakewill referred to fees and charges, noting that income derived from these was important to support Council services, however, he considered that these significant costs were being raised behind closed doors and asked what involvement Executive Members had in agreeing revised fees and charges.
Cllr Hakewill also queried when the Executive would request that the Council’s scrutiny function examine the implications of these charges for residents and businesses for 2024/25.
The Chair invited Cllr Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill made reference to the section of the report that detailed risks associated with the draft Capital Programme 2024-2028 and stated that he felt it was unreasonable to herald future delivery of plans as part of the programme only for these to remain undelivered, questioning how the Executive would deliver the draft programme given the significant underspend on capital projects to date.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the funding for Montsaye Academy but queried its source.
Cllr Hakewill also queried the reasoning for the timing of approval for an increase in the capital programme for Isham Bypass to be funded from Department for Transport (DfT) grant.
In response to Cllr Hakewill, Cllr Bunday stated the Montsaye Academy funding was coming from the Higher Needs Dedicated Schools Grant. Regarding Isham Bypass, a governmental announcement had required an urgent decision to be taken.
Cllr Jim Hakewill then spoke to ask the Executive Member what in-year efficiencies had, and would, be utilised to avoid using contingency and reserves funds to mitigate overspending.
It was moved by Councillor Jim Hakewill and seconded by Councillor Zoe McGhee that the Corporate Scrutiny Committee welcome the report and its recommendations and recommend the report in full to Full Council. On being put to the vote, the motion was carried unanimously.
A personal interest was declared by Cllr Jim Hakewill prior to speaking in relation to agenda item 4.
The following interests were declared:- Name of Councillor Minute Number Interest Reason for Declaration Cllr Jim Hakewill 247 Motion 2 (Kettering Leisure Village (KLV)) Personal Interest Provision of support/advice to KLV users, but confirming the retention of an open mind in respect of all eventualities relating to what could happen to KLV in terms of decisions to be made.
Motion 2 – Kettering Leisure Village Cllr Jim Hakewill moved and Cllr Keli Watts seconded the motion to Council, as set on the agenda for the meeting.
Councillor Fedorowycz MOVED and Councillor Dell SECONDED the nomination of Councillor Hakewill.
Under this item, Councillor Hakewill queried whether Councillor Pengelly could be reinstated as the Council’s representative on APSE for 2023/24.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill made reference to the cost of engaging consultants during the initial phase of the development process, stating that setting up public meetings to allow residents and local businesses to contribute to the vision would be more beneficial.
Cllr Hakewill then made extended reference to Kettering Leisure Village and was informed by the Council’s Monitoring Officer that comments relating to this matter were not relevant to the item under consideration.
In response to Cllr Hakewill’s comments, the Chair spoke to note that there had already been an initial engagement process involving community representatives, local businesses and elected members where Cllr Hakewill had been an enthusiastic participant.
The Chair thanked Cllr Reuby for his attendance before inviting Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill called for the matter to be considered by the Council’s scrutiny function to understand why the roads were failing so badly compared to neighbouring areas when a new highways contract had only been awarded in September.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the investment in Mawsley Primary School SEND Unit but requested improved communication with ward members on such projects due to a lack of awareness of the proposal coming forward.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments before inviting Cllr Lloyd Bunday, Executive Member for Finance and Transformation to introduce a report that requested approval for capital schemes that had come forward for inclusion in the Council’s Capital Programme. Approval of the funding would allow the schemes to move forward to procurement and delivery.
It was moved by Councillor Jim Hakewill and seconded by Councillor Valerie Anslow that a task and finish group be established to inform and develop a green burial policy. On being put to the vote, the motion was approved.
In order to ensure that all of the business of the meeting was completed, it was MOVED by Councillor Jim Hakewill and SECONDED by Councillor John McGhee that the Guillotine (Procedure Rule 10.1) be suspended until conclusion of all of the business on the agenda.
Councillor Hakewill on behalf of the Green Alliance Group provided a response to the budget proposals within the report.
An amendment to the substantive motion was MOVED by Councillor Jim Hakewill and SECONDED by Councillor Charlie Best. The amendment read: - “In view of the incredibly difficult cost of living circumstances our residents are currently enduring we propose that there be no increase in member allowances for 22-23 or 23-24 and that an Independent Panel Review be convened in 2024-25 to recommend Allowances for the new Council to be elected in May 2025.” Following debate, a recorded vote was taken on this amendment.
Further, to develop a Green Burial Ground policy to enable appropriate guidance to be given to interested operators with potential areas identified.” The motion was MOVED by Councillor Jim Hakewill and SECONDED by Councillor Charlie Best.
Council noted that there were a few existing sites in the local area, although few in North Northamptonshire, that catered for Green Burials, and Councillor Hakewill suggested that there was likely to be increasing interest and demand for sites in the future.
Councillor Hakewill was proposing that the Council, through its scrutiny process, seek to investigate in consultation with partners and the wider public whether any extension of existing facilities and creation of new facilities should be considered by the Council.
Councillor Hakewill concluded the debate on the substantive motion.
Councillor Hakewill proposed the motion within the report, which was seconded by Councillor Lee. On being put to the vote the motion was declared carried.
Councillor Hakewill suggested that ... view the full minutes text for item C/161
Councillor Hakewill felt it was important that scrutiny members received further training and considered opportunities for greater public interaction, a view supported by Councillor John McGhee.
Councillor Hakewill suggested that the motion could be referred to scrutiny for consideration, however after discussions this referral was withdrawn, and the mover and seconder of the motion sought permission to amend the tabled motion, so that the words were added at the end of the final paragraph “…and that a report be brought back to the next Council meeting or the meeting after that .” RESOLVED that: - (i) The motion (as amended) be approved.
It was moved by Councillor John Currall and seconded by Councillor Jim Hakewill that the Scrutiny Commission write to the Leader of the Council requesting that the Green Waste decision be deferred to enable the Scrutiny Commission to consider the proposed decision.
Councillor Hakewill expressed concern that the proposed course of action was not viable and did not meet the needs of local residents or travellers.
Councillor Hakewill felt that there had been insufficient consultation.
Councillor Jim Hakewill wished to put on record his concerns at how the last meeting had been chaired in relation to the vote taken on the item relating to major highways capital works, particularly the number of times the Chair had conducted the vote. He advised that he had raised his concerns with the Monitoring Officer following the meeting.
· Cllr Dorothy Maxwell – Items 8 and 10 · Cllr Jim Hakewill – Items 6, 10, 13 and 14
The Chair, Cllr Jason Smithers welcomed Cllr Jim Hakewill to the meeting to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the proposed enhancements to the Council’s Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system and sought confirmation that this would be rolled out to community hubs when operational.
Cllr Hakewill queried when face-to-face customer service provision would be re-established in Rothwell and other community libraries and referenced efficiency savings detailed within the report.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his contribution before Cllr Lloyd Bunday, Executive Member for Finance and Transformation introduced a report that sought Executive approval to commence the procurement process for a single CRM system for the Council as the first part of the development of a North Northamptonshire Council low-code digital platform .
The Chair thanked Cllr Maxwell for her attendance and invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to speak.
Cllr Hakewill spoke to query why there were no parking charges at the site and referenced the refreshed business plan.
Cllr Hakewill also called for profits from the project to be placed in the Council’s reserves with funding bids required for future utilisation.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his contribution before Cllr Helen Howell, Executive Member for Sport, Leisure, Culture and Tourism introduced a report that sought to up date Members with the current performance of the Chester House Estate since its opening in October 2021, including the projected year-end financial outturn, and to present a revised Business Plan for 2022-23 onwards based on current performance and the new programme of events for the forthcoming year.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the Executive.
Cllr Hakewill made reference to the final accounts of the former legacy councils, noting that figures for the former county council were not provided.
Cllr Hakewill queried when the outcome of a Covid-related funding bid made by the Children’s Trust would be known given its financial pressure of £3.390m and requested an update regarding the current position of the Council Tax Rebate agreed by Government for those in Council Tax Bands A to D.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments before Councillor Lloyd Bunday, Executive Member for Finance and Transformation introduced a report that set out the forecast outturn position for the Council based on the Period 11 monitoring forecasts for the General Fund and the Housing Revenue Account.
In response to Cllr Hakewill, it was heard that with regards to the Council Tax Rebate a significant level of work was required. Those customers who paid by Direct Debit would have their accounts credited, with a view for this to commence by the end of April. Approximately 50,000 Council Tax payers in North Northamptonshire did not pay by Direct Debit and would need to be contacted to seek their preferred payment method.
The Chair invited Cllr Jim Hakewill to address the meeting.
Cllr Hakewill welcomed the i nvestment at Thrapston Library as detailed in the report and queried whether Section 106 funding in areas served by community run libraries would go to those services.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his attendance before Cllr Lloyd Bunday, Executive Member for Finance and Transformation introduced the report that requested approval for capital schemes that had come forward for inclusion in the Council’s Capital Programme. Approval of the funding would allow the schemes to move forward to procurement and delivery.
A request had been received from Councillor J Hakewill to address the meeting on item 6 – Local Government Boundary Commission for England Review of Electoral arrangements proposed council size and item 7 – Independent Remuneration Panel – Review of Members’ Allowances.
The chair confirmed that Councillor Hakewill could speak and asked that he do so at the beginning of each item.
Councillor Hakewill addressed the meeting and thanked both members and officers who had worked tirelessly during the working group discussions.
The chair thanked Councillor Hakewill. The chair explained the work that had been undertaken by the working group, which had been considerable, and which had culminated in the recommendation to be put to Council, as detailed at Appendix A Council Size Submission document.
Councillor Hakewill addressed the meeting. He referenced the review of allowances, which had been agreed to be undertaken by the shadow council, after North Northamptonshire Council had been in place for a year. He noted that the review had been carried out but considered that there should be a freeze on any increases suggested therein.
It was moved by Councillor Matt Binley and seconded by Councillor Jim Hakewill that the Director of Governance and HR bring a report back to the ... view the full minutes text for item SC/30
Question 3 A question had been submitted by Councillor Jim Hakewill which read - "What are the initial predictions for increased expenditure with the announcement of new National Insurance (NI) taxation for both NNC and external contractors working for the Council? This to be based on this year’s NI bills projected forward for the financial year 2022-23".
Councillor Hakewill supported the report but also queried whether adequate resources would be applied by the Council to tackling climate change.
Councillor Hakewill felt that it was important that the Council set clear targets and felt that these needed to be challenging.
Previous sovereign authorities had set 2030 as a target, and Councillor Hakewill ... view the full minutes text for item C/30
Councillor Hakewill reminded Council that its car parks were assets, they were not free to repair and maintain. There was a need for all options to be examined carefully, potentially through the Scrutiny Commission.
The Chair, Councillor Jason Smithers, reported that there was one request to address the meeting, from Councillor Jim Hakewill in respect of the National Bus Strategy report (minute 7 refers).
The Chair welcomed Councillor Jim Hakewill to the meeting who wished to speak in favour of the principals within the report.
Cllr Hakewill noted the work undertaken by the prior County Council and four District and Borough Councils and hoped that such work would not be lost and be built upon in developing new strategies for North Northamptonshire Council.
Cllr Hakewill also hoped that work would continue in respect of provision of bus subsidies to rural communities where there were measures of deprivation, such as that of assistance to voluntary groups.
The Chair thanked Cllr Hakewill for his comments.
During debate, an amendment to the proposed recommendations contained in the report was duly MOVED by Councillor Jim Hakewill and SECONDED by Councillor Valerie Anslow. The amendment read “That the position of Vice Chair of the Finance and Resources Scrutiny Committee be offered to the opposition groups”.
Those FOR the amendment moved by Councillor Hakewill – Councillors Addison, Anslow, Armour, S Brown, Lyn Buckingham, Leanne Buckingham, Colquhoun, Dalziel, Dell, Fedorowycz, Hakewill, Keane, Lee, McEwan, J McGhee, Z McGhee, Pengelly, Rielly & Tubbs.
Those AGAINST the amendment moved by Councillor Hakewill – Councillors Allebone, Binley, D Brackenbury, W Brackenbury, C Brown, Bunday, Carr, Carter, Currall, de Capell Brooke, Dearing, Edwards, Ekins, Hallam, Harrington, H Harrison, K Harrison, L Henson, H Howell, D Howes, P Irwin, B Jackson, I Jelley, B Jenney, D Jenney, Lawal, G Lawman, L Lawman, Levell, Marks, Maxwell, A Mercer, G Mercer, Nichol, North, Pandey, Pentland, Powell, Prentice, Roberts, Rowley, Shacklock, Sims, Smithers, Smith-Haynes, Smyth, Tebbutt, Thurland, Tye, Ward, Waters, Watt, Wetherill & Wilkes.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Hakewill attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Hakewill's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Hakewill was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
North Northamptonshire has not published attendance for Councillor Hakewill's meetings yet.
What Councillor Hakewill declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Aug 2023 | Executive, item 471 | A personal interest was declared by Cllr Jim Hakewill prior to speaking in relation to agenda item 4. |
Where Councillor Hakewill sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Hakewill yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.