CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/North West Leicestershire/Councillor Dave Bigby
DB

Councillor Dave Bigby

Follow Councillor Bigby's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
79%meetings attended176 of 224 since 2019, apologies 30
227times in the minutesAsked 14, said 42, moved 38, seconded 33
6recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
21declarations at meetingsInterests declared on agenda items
5committees in the last year8 committees in all

On the record

Every time North West Leicestershire's minutes name Councillor Bigby, as the council published it.

Moved29 Jun 2026Local Plan Committee

Review of the 2017 Good Design Guide for North West Leicestershire SPD

Councillor D Bigby moved the recommendation in the report.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 29 Jun 2026, item 18Open the meeting
Moved18 Jun 2026Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Annual Scrutiny Report 2025/26

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor M Ball and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 18 Jun 2026, item 66Open the meeting
Seconded12 May 2026Council

Appointment of Leader

The motion was seconded by Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Council, 12 May 2026, item 6Open the meeting
Moved14 Apr 2026Planning Committee

26/00004/FUL: Change of use of a dwellinghouse (C3) to a children's care home (C2) for up to three young people

Councillor D Bigby moved that the application be approved in accordance with the officer’s recommendations.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 14 Apr 2026, item 74Open the meeting
Moved10 Feb 2026Planning Committee

25/00916/PIP: Permission in principle for 1 self-build dwelling

Councillor D Bigby moved to refuse the application on the grounds that it would conflict with Policies S2 and S3 in the Local Plan and would have a visual impact on the area.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 10 Feb 2026, item 59Open the meeting
Moved10 Feb 2026Planning Committee

25/01465/FUL: Erection of a detached bungalow

Councillor D Bigby moved that the application be approved in accordance with the officer’s recommendations.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 10 Feb 2026, item 60Open the meeting
Seconded28 Jan 2026Local Plan Committee

New Local Plan - Diseworth and Isley Woodhouse Area of Separation

It was seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 28 Jan 2026, item 41Open the meeting
Moved21 Jan 2026Planning Committee

23/00883/FULM - Erection of 35 B8 units together with associated access, parking and servicing areas

Councillor D Bigby moved that the application be deferred to allow for clarification following further investigation of immediate demand, site access from the relief road and additional weight restriction signage.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 21 Jan 2026, item 52Open the meeting
Moved21 Jan 2026Planning Committee

25/01523/PIP - Permission in principle for the erection of two self-build dwellings

Councillor D Bigby moved that the application be refused on the grounds that it did not comply with Policy H2 of the Swannington Neighbourhood Plan, and Policies S2 and S3 of the Local Plan.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 21 Jan 2026, item 53Open the meeting
Declared9 Dec 2025Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared that he had previously been involved in discussions about item A2, application number 23/00427/OUTM, as part of Ashby Town Council’s Planning Committee but had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 9 Dec 2025, item 42Open the meeting
Moved9 Dec 2025Planning Committee

23/00427/OUTM: Development of up to 46,451 sq m GIA of B2 (industrial) and/or B8 (storage or distribution) units with ancillary E(g)(i) (offices) and service buildings, along with associated parking, highway infrastructure, landscaping and

Councillor D Bigby moved to refuse the application due to the availability of alternative sites.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 9 Dec 2025, item 46Open the meeting
Seconded4 Dec 2025Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Environmental Policy

It was therefore moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RECOMMENDED THAT CABINET:
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Dec 2025, item 32Open the meeting
Seconded26 Nov 2025Planning Committee

Planning consider the confirming of a tree preservation order (tpo) at land to the south of 28 bondgate, castle donington

It was moved by Councillor P Moult, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 26 Nov 2025, item 39Open the meeting
Moved26 Nov 2025Planning Committee

25/01135/PIP: Permission in principle for 1 self-build dwelling with associated garaging

After seeking advice from officers, Councillor D Bigby moved that the application be refused on the grounds that it conflicts with Policies S2 and S3 in the adopted Local Plan.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 26 Nov 2025, item 41Open the meeting
Moved19 Nov 2025Local Plan Committee

Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Local Plan - Regulation 18 Consultation

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor M Ball and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 19 Nov 2025, item 14Open the meeting
Seconded19 Nov 2025Local Plan Committee

Local Plan - Policies

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 19 Nov 2025, item 18Open the meeting
Seconded11 Nov 2025Planning Committee

25/00738/OUT - Erection of 1 no. single custom-build dwelling (Outline - all matters reserved)

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 11 Nov 2025, item 33Open the meeting
Named4 Nov 2025Council

Questions from Councillors

Question from Councillor D Bigby ‘In the light of Kemi Badenoch’s recent statements that she believes the UK’s 2050 net zero target is “impossible” to achieve and that, if ever elected again to government, the Conservative Party plans to repeal the Climate Change Act, as Council Leader and  Leader of the Conservative Group, can you confirm the Administration’s  continued commitment to the Council’s current net- zero policies including working towards a net-zero council by 2030 and a net zero district by 2050.’ Response from Councillor R Blunt ‘The Council declared a climate emergency on 25 June 2019 and adopted its Zero Carbon Roadmap and Action Plan on 31 March 2020. The Action Plan recommends activity to achieve the ambition of working towards a net Zero Carbon Council by 2030 and a net Zero Carbon district by 2050.
From the council's minutes: Council, 4 Nov 2025, item 52Open the meeting
Moved24 Sep 2025Local Plan Committee

New Local Plan – consideration of the consultation responses to policies

Councillor D Bigby moved to defer any decision on Policy AP4 (Reducing Carbon Emissions) pending further investigation into the feasibility of a carbon offset fund.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 24 Sep 2025, item 5Open the meeting
Declared9 Sep 2025Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Cllr D Bigby declared an interest as a member of Ashby Town Council, who had previously considered the matter, but he had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 9 Sep 2025, item 19Open the meeting
Moved8 Jul 2025Planning Committee

24/01376/FULM: Proposed battery energy storage system (BESS) and associated infrastructure

Councillor D Bigby moved that the application be refused on the grounds that the proposed would be detrimental to visual impact and would fail to safeguard and enhance the appearance and character of the landscape, contrary to criterion ( i ) of Policy S3 and criterion (b) of Policy Cc1 of the adopted Local Plan.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 8 Jul 2025, item 12Open the meeting
Moved26 Jun 2025Community Scrutiny Committee

Foundations Review - Disabled Facilities Grants Delivery

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor S Lambeth and RESOLVED  ...  view the full minutes text for item 5.
From the council's minutes: Community Scrutiny Committee, 26 Jun 2025, item 5Open the meeting
Named17 Jun 2025Council

Questions from Councillors

Question from Councillor D Bigby “In 2019 the council declared a Climate Emergency and subsequently agreed a Zero Carbon Roadmap and Action Plan. The Council Delivery Plan 2023-2028 identifies one of its four priorities as “clean, green and Zero Carbon…..looking after the environment we live in”. A key aim is ”We will aim to be carbon neutral as a council by 2030 and a district by 2050”.
From the council's minutes: Council, 17 Jun 2025, item 27Open the meeting
Moved11 Jun 2025Local Plan Committee

To consider the petition referred by Council on 13 May 2025

A motion was proposed by Councillor D Bigby to note the petition. This was accepted by Members of the Committee and a recorded vote was taken.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 11 Jun 2025, item 11Open the meeting
Moved11 Jun 2025Local Plan Committee

To consider the petition referred by Council on 13 May 2025

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Legrys.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 11 Jun 2025, item 11Open the meeting
Moved13 May 2025Council

Appointment of Deputy Chair

It was also moved by Councillor D Bigby that Councillor A Wilson be appointed as Deputy Chair of the Council for 2025/26.
From the council's minutes: Council, 13 May 2025, item 4Open the meeting
Named11 Mar 2025Local Plan Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby was lobbied on items 5 and 6 and attended the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 11 Mar 2025, item 37Open the meeting
Named20 Feb 2025Council

Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budget and Rent Setting - 2025/26

Councillor D Bigby was invited to put forward the amendment.
From the council's minutes: Council, 20 Feb 2025, item 76Open the meeting
Moved16 Dec 2024Local Plan Committee

Local Plan- Proposed Housing Allocations - Isley Woodhouse and Coalville Urban Area

A motion to amend the recommendation, so that 2250 houses were built at Isley Woodhouse by 2042, was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Legrys.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 16 Dec 2024, item 28Open the meeting
Moved16 Dec 2024Local Plan Committee

Local Plan- proposed employment allocations: consideration of responses to consultation

A motion to suspend Standing Order 9.1 was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor J Legrys, and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 16 Dec 2024, item 29Open the meeting
Moved1 Oct 2024Planning Committee

24/00007/FULM: The erection of 18 dwellings (100% affordable housing), access, landscaping and associated works

The officer’s recommendation to permit the application was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Legrys .
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 1 Oct 2024, item 26Open the meeting
Moved26 Sep 2024Local Plan Committee

Proposed reforms to the National Planning Policy Framework and Other Changes to the Planning System – response to consultation

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 26 Sep 2024, item 17Open the meeting
Seconded26 Sep 2024Local Plan Committee

Hinckley & Bosworth Local Plan (2020-41): Regulation 18 Consultation

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby, and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 26 Sep 2024, item 18Open the meeting
Moved19 Sep 2024Community Scrutiny Committee

Leisure Centres Annual Review

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby seconded by Councillor S Sheahan, and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Community Scrutiny Committee, 19 Sep 2024, item 53Open the meeting
Said3 Sep 2024Planning Committee

24/00240/FULM Partial conversion of part of agricultural building to a mixed use for the purpose of a wedding venue and other functions and the erection of 10 holiday units

Councillor D Bigby, Ward Member, addressed the Committee.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 3 Sep 2024, item 21Open the meeting
Moved6 Aug 2024Planning Committee

24/00203/FUL: Erection of an outbuilding consisting of a games/play room, bedroom, office, garden storage and shower room

The officer’s recommendation to permit the application including the enhanced occupancy condition as agreed was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Legrys.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 6 Aug 2024, item 16Open the meeting
Named4 Jun 2024Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby and D Cooper also declared a registrable interest in Item A2, as Ashby Town Councillors, but they had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 4 Jun 2024, item 2Open the meeting
Named7 May 2024Council

Questions from Councillors

Question from Councillor D Bigby ‘At the last council budget meeting, the Conservative/Lib Dem Alliance removed the maintenance of Closed Churchyards from Special Expenses, spreading the cost across all Council Tax payers in the district, including the residents of my ward in Ashby.
From the council's minutes: Council, 7 May 2024, item 9Open the meeting
Named7 May 2024Council

Capital Update

Councillor D Bigby was invited to put forward his amendment.
From the council's minutes: Council, 7 May 2024, item 18Open the meeting
Said7 May 2024Council

Capital Update

Councillor D Bigby outlined the amendment as detailed in the additional papers and it was seconded by Councillor A Morley.
From the council's minutes: Council, 7 May 2024, item 18Open the meeting
Named22 Feb 2024Council

Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budget and Rent Setting 2024/25

He invited Councillor D Bigby to put forward his amendment.
From the council's minutes: Council, 22 Feb 2024, item 81Open the meeting
Said22 Feb 2024Council

Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budget and Rent Setting 2024/25

Councillor D Bigby outlined the amendment to the budget as detailed in the additional papers and it was seconded by Councillor S Sheahan.
From the council's minutes: Council, 22 Feb 2024, item 81Open the meeting
Declared6 Feb 2024Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in item A2 – application 23/01108/FUL, as he was speaking on application as adjoining Ward Member.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 6 Feb 2024, item 59Open the meeting
Named6 Feb 2024Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

During the consideration and voting on the application, Councillor T Eynon would join the Committee as a substitute for Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 6 Feb 2024, item 59Open the meeting
Named6 Feb 2024Planning Committee

23/01108/FUL: Works to an existing clubhouse to include raising the roof height to provide first floor accommodation, dormer windows and a balcony with the erection of a single storey building to provide changing room facilities, retention/extension to terrace stand and new pathway

Ashby Ivanhoe Football Club, Lower Packington Road, Ashby de la Zouch Officer’s recommendation: Permit Having declared an interest in the item, Councillor D Bigby removed himself from the meeting to join the public gallery prior to being invited to speak as the adjoining Ward Member.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 6 Feb 2024, item 63Open the meeting
Said6 Feb 2024Planning Committee

23/01108/FUL: Works to an existing clubhouse to include raising the roof height to provide first floor accommodation, dormer windows and a balcony with the erection of a single storey building to provide changing room facilities, retention/extension to terrace stand and new pathway

Councillor D Bigby , adjoining Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He stated that although he was in support of good sporting facilities in Ashby, his main concerns with this application were the access and highway safety. He commented that there was a strong argument that more club house space would lead to more events and activity, and it was disappointing that the club were reluctant to accept Section 106 Agreement suggestions.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 6 Feb 2024, item 63Open the meeting
Named30 Jan 2024Council

Electoral Boundary Review - Council Size Submission

Councillor D Bigby referred Members to the additional papers in which summary information and an alternative recommendation for an increase in council size to 39 Councillors was provided as submitted by the Labour Group. This explained the position of the Labour Group on the matter and the recommendation that would be proposed should the current motion be lost. A full discussion ensued in which Members spoke both in support and against the council size preferences as detailed within the report and additional papers.
From the council's minutes: Council, 30 Jan 2024, item 65Open the meeting
Named17 Jan 2024Local Plan Committee

Self-Build and Custom House Building - Draft Policy for Consultation

Councillor D Bigby referred to his proposed amendment as detailed at paragraph 2.3 of the report. He felt that the Committee were considering a major watering down of the policy and the wording used unclear, however, his proposed amendment would strengthen it, still provide the five percent self-build allocations, and protect the countryside. The Planning Policy and Land Charges Team Manager explained that officers were trying to find the most pragmatic way forward without making it difficult to deal with applications outside the limits to development.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 17 Jan 2024, item 26Open the meeting
Moved17 Jan 2024Local Plan Committee

Self-Build and Custom House Building - Draft Policy for Consultation

Councillor D Bigby moved the amendment as detailed at paragraph 2.3 of the report.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 17 Jan 2024, item 26Open the meeting
Declared5 Dec 2023Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a Registerable Interest in Item A4 - application number 23/01148/FUL, as an Ashby Town Parish Councillor and had taken part in discussions on the application but had come to the Planning Committee meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 5 Dec 2023, item 45Open the meeting
Moved5 Dec 2023Planning Committee

23/01048/OUT: Erection of three self-build detached dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved except for access)

A motion to refuse the application on the grounds that it contravened Planning Policies S2 and S3 of the Local Plan and policy H2 of the Swanington Neighbourhood Plan was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Legrys.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 5 Dec 2023, item 49Open the meeting
Named21 Nov 2023Licensing Sub Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor J Legrys declared that he knew Councillor D Bigby in a professional capacity from his work as a councillor.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 21 Nov 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said21 Nov 2023Licensing Sub Committee

XXX Buns - Application for a New Premise Licence

Councillor D Bigby presented a representation on behalf of Ashby Town Council. He advised the panel that the additional papers circulated showed sharply increasing crime rates, particularly around drug abuse, public-order offences, anti-social behaviour, and burglary offences. This is the context in which the representation had been made.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 21 Nov 2023, item 4Open the meeting
Named21 Nov 2023Licensing Sub Committee

XXX Buns - Application for a New Premise Licence

He said no residents had indicated to him any concerns with noise; he also advised that he was in regular contact with the owner of the nearby gym and Councillor Bigby was slightly  ...  view the full minutes text for item 4.
From the council's minutes: Licensing Sub Committee, 21 Nov 2023, item 4Open the meeting
Seconded15 Nov 2023Local Plan Committee

New Local Plan - Limits to Development

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 15 Nov 2023, item 19Open the meeting
Named7 Nov 2023Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby, Councillor R Canny, Councillor C Sewell, Councillor J Simmons, Councillor M Wyatt, Councillor R Morris and Councillor P Moult.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Nov 2023, item 35Open the meeting
Seconded18 Oct 2023Local Plan Committee

Revised Local Development Scheme

It was moved by Councillor P Moult, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 18 Oct 2023, item 11Open the meeting
Declared16 Aug 2023Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in item A3 – application number 22/01177/FUL as he was speaking on the application as Ward Member.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Aug 2023, item 17Open the meeting
Named16 Aug 2023Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

During the consideration of this application Councillor T Eynon would join the committee as a substitute for Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Aug 2023, item 17Open the meeting
Named16 Aug 2023Planning Committee

22/01177/FUL: Change of use of garden land (class C3) to beer garden (sui generis) and associated works (including new fencing and seating)

Having declared an interest in the item, Councillor D Bigby removed himself from the Committee to join the public gallery prior to being invited to speak as Ward Member.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Aug 2023, item 22Open the meeting
Said16 Aug 2023Planning Committee

22/01177/FUL: Change of use of garden land (class C3) to beer garden (sui generis) and associated works (including new fencing and seating)

Councillor D Bigby, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. Members were reminded of Planning Policy D2 in relation to amenity impact and it was suggested that the application be rejected for this reason. Concerns were raised regarding the acoustic report, which was commissioned by the applicant and therefore he felt was likely to reflect their needs, as the results did not replicate the usual noise from a public house garden.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 16 Aug 2023, item 22Open the meeting
Declared20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in item A1 – Application number 22/01552/FULM as he was speaking on the application as Ward Member.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 10Open the meeting
Named20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

He also declared a registerable interest in item A2 – Application number 22/01811/FULM as he was speaking o the application as the adjoining Ward Member During the consideration of this application, Councillor J Geary would join the committee as a substitute for Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 10Open the meeting
Declared20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in item A1 – Application number 22/01552/FULM as he was speaking on the application as Ward Member and therefore would not take part in any of the deliberation of voting.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 10Open the meeting
Named20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

During the consideration of this application, Councillor J Geary would join the committee as a substitute for Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 10Open the meeting
Named20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

22/01552/FULM: Erection of 17 townhouses with associated car parking access, landscaping and car park to hotel and associated amendments

Having declared an interest in the item, Councillor D Bigby removed himself from the Committee to join the public gallery prior to being invited to speak as Ward member.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 13Open the meeting
Said20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

22/01552/FULM: Erection of 17 townhouses with associated car parking access, landscaping and car park to hotel and associated amendments

Councillor D Bigby, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. Although he had not objected to the application, he explained that he had several concerns including the robustness of the legal arrangements, the consequences should the applicant go out of business, the loss of trees and insufficient mitigation to replace them, lack of social housing and education contribution, and spoilt view between the hotel and the Bath Grounds. However, he acknowledged the need for the restoration of the hotel and that the proposals would enable that rather than demolition which local residents were opposed to.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 13Open the meeting
Named20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

22/01552/FULM: Erection of 17 townhouses with associated car parking access, landscaping and car park to hotel and associated amendments

Councillor D Bigby then left the meeting for the duration of the discussions and voting on the application.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 13Open the meeting
Named20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

22/01552/FULM: Erection of 17 townhouses with associated car parking access, landscaping and car park to hotel and associated amendments

At the conclusion of the item, Councillor D Bigby returned to the public gallery.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 13Open the meeting
Named20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

22/01811/FULM: Change of use of land to recreation use including the formation of sport pitches, parking area, improved access and landscaping

Having declared an interest in the item, Councillor D Bigby remained in the public gallery prior to being invited to speak as the adjoining Ward member.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 14Open the meeting
Said20 Jul 2023Planning Committee

22/01811/FULM: Change of use of land to recreation use including the formation of sport pitches, parking area, improved access and landscaping

Councillor D Bigby, adjoining Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He acknowledged the value of the club for the area but explained that he had called in the application due to the number of objections from residents. He shared his main concerns in relation to traffic and parking in the area due to the proposals leading to significantly more visits to the facility.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 14Open the meeting
Seconded6 Jun 2023Planning Committee

22/01312/FULM: Erection of an additional holiday lodge and change of use of grazing land for siting of caravan/motorhomes with electric hook ups, siting of glamping tents and associated amenity block/infrastructure

The officer’s recommendation was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor D Bigby .
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 6 Jun 2023, item 7Open the meeting
Seconded23 May 2023Council

Appointment of Chairman

The motion was seconded by Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 May 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Seconded23 May 2023Council

Appointment of Leader

It was seconded by Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 May 2023, item 5Open the meeting
Named23 May 2023Council

Appointments to Committees and Groups, Election of Chairs and Deputy Chairs

It was announced that the Labour Group was in favour of the nominations as circulated subject to the Chair of the Local Plan Committee, for which Councillor D Bigby was nominated. Therefore, a separate vote on this committee was required.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 May 2023, item 13Open the meeting
Moved7 Feb 2023Planning Committee

22/01571/FUL: Alteration to land levels (retrospective)

A motion to permit the application in accordance with the officer’s recommendation was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Legrys.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Feb 2023, item 52Open the meeting
Seconded7 Feb 2023Planning Committee

22/01568/FUL: Garage conversion, new electric gates, erection of new boundary treatment and insertion of rooflight to existing dwelling

A motion to permit the application in accordance with the officer’s recommendation was moved by Councillor D Harrison and seconded by Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Feb 2023, item 53Open the meeting
Moved7 Dec 2022Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Customer Services - Performance and Future Approach

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby , seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 7 Dec 2022, item 66Open the meeting
Declared1 Nov 2022Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in Item A1 as a member of Ashby Town Council’s Planning Committee but had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 1 Nov 2022, item 27Open the meeting
Asked1 Nov 2022Planning Committee

Planning Enforcement Update Q2 2022/23

Councillor D Bigby enquired whether it would be possible to know if these breaches had been by individuals undertaking a small extension or if had it been large developers taking advantage of the lack of enforcement staff and deliberately not complying. Officers responded that members of the public do not regularly break their conditions intentionally and tend to do so in error, whereby it would be a distinct possibility that some of the larger developers had been actively ignoring some of the conditions which had been imposed. It was confirmed that officers were aware of and pursuing such cases.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 1 Nov 2022, item 29Open the meeting
Named6 Sep 2022Council

Questions from Councillors

Question by Councillor D Bigby “What is the estimated cost of repairs expected to be necessary to ensure Hood Park Lido remains open to the public for the medium to long term?” Response by Councillor A Woodman “The Council’s leisure partner, Everyone Active (EA), has identified a potential issue with the lido pool tank at Ashby Leisure Centre and Lido. Under the terms of the contract and the lease, EA has a responsibility to ensure facilities are maintained and kept open to the public, and they continue to do that. In order to understand the nature of the issues, EA has so far had one contractor visit site who has offered an opinion as to what the issue is, a potential solution and an indicative cost rather than a formal quotation.
From the council's minutes: Council, 6 Sep 2022, item 26Open the meeting
Asked6 Sep 2022Council

Questions from Councillors

Supplementary question and response Councillor Bigby asked whether the authority was confident that Ashby Lido can remain open next year and that the maintenance costs would not be passed on to the users either directly or indirectly.
From the council's minutes: Council, 6 Sep 2022, item 26Open the meeting
Named8 Feb 2022Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby and J Legrys declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 20/00831/OUTM, as members of the Leicestershire and Rutland Wildlife Trust who were consultees on the application.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 8 Feb 2022, item 50Open the meeting
Seconded8 Feb 2022Planning Committee

To consider the making of a Tree Preservation Order (TPO) on land at the junction of Hepworth Road and Bridle Way Blackfordby

It was moved by Councillor J Legry, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 8 Feb 2022, item 53Open the meeting
Said26 Jan 2022Local Plan Committee

Electric Vehicle Charge Points

Councillor Bigby confirmed that there were a couple of charge points in the new car park in Ashby and was not aware that any had been included in any council houses. He had requested, unsuccessfully, that one be included in the new car park on the Willesley estate. He asked whether the requirements set out in the Local Plan would be any more stringent than those set out in the Building Regulations which would enable the Council to install more than the minimum requirement where it was deemed appropriate to do so.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 26 Jan 2022, item 41Open the meeting
Said26 Jan 2022Local Plan Committee

Electric Vehicle Charge Points

Councillor Bigby felt that we should be considering looking at evidence such as being a largely rural area and our reliance on the car due to lack of public transport. Furthermore, we could look at what other local authorities are doing in this regard.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 26 Jan 2022, item 41Open the meeting
Asked26 Jan 2022Local Plan Committee

Ratcliffe-on-Soar Power Station Proposed Local Development Order

Councillor D Bigby sought confirmation on the mention of housing as he couldn’t see any reference to it in the report and asked why the provision of housing had not been included in the plans, particularly given the number of jobs the proposal was said to be generating.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 26 Jan 2022, item 42Open the meeting
Asked26 Jan 2022Local Plan Committee

Planning Policy Update

Councillor D Bigby asked how much of the Section 106 monies had attached to it a timescale and whether any backlog of unspent monies had been cleared. He was advised that all the monies would have a timescale by which it must be spent, most of which would be within 5 years from the date of the payment, and some would be slightly longer. The situation is constantly monitored, and appropriate prompts are sent to the relevant bodies to establish whether the monies will be spent, or an extension is required.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 26 Jan 2022, item 43Open the meeting
Named26 Jan 2022Local Plan Committee

Planning Policy Update

Councillor Bigby referred to the Neighbourhood Plan in respect of Blackfordby which he advised included an area of separation between Blackfordby and Woodville which is not included in the Local Plan. This was considered encouraging for future Neighbourhood Plans.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 26 Jan 2022, item 43Open the meeting
Seconded12 Jan 2022Planning Committee

21/00095/LBC: Internal alterations including the removal and installation of partition walls, the permanent locking of some doors, insertion of new doors and the installation of sound insulation measures and external alterations including t

The recommendation to permit the application in accordance with the officer’s recommendation was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor D Bigby and The Chairman put the motion to the vote. A recorded vote being required, the voting was as detailed below.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 12 Jan 2022, item 48Open the meeting
Declared5 Jan 2022Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 6 – North West Leicestershire Visitor Economy Plan, as a member of Ashby Town Council and the Ashby Civic Society. He also declared that he had asked a question in relation to the closure of Ashby Tourist Information Centre at the Council meeting on 7 September 2021, as well as expressed his opinion on the matter at several meetings and in the press.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 5 Jan 2022, item 38Open the meeting
Said5 Jan 2022Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor Bigby confirmed that he would approach the item with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 5 Jan 2022, item 38Open the meeting
Seconded5 Jan 2022Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Recommendations of the Scrutiny Cross Party Working Group - Scrutiny Work Programming

It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 5 Jan 2022, item 44Open the meeting
Said9 Dec 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review : Employment Strategy Options

Councillor D Bigby stated that he felt putting options forward for consultation was the right way to go but expressed concerns over the tone of the wording in the report as he felt it could unduly influence people into a particular position. He was pleased to see the options in relation to the general employment land strategy had not got any particular preference.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 9 Dec 2021, item 33Open the meeting
Said9 Dec 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review : Employment Strategy Options

Councillor D Bigby noted that the numbers of the paragraphs that were to be included in option 1 should read 2.19 to 2.22, not 2.18 to 2.21 as stated in the report.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 9 Dec 2021, item 33Open the meeting
Moved9 Dec 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review : Employment Strategy Options

Subject to the change of paragraph numbers in (i) of the recommendations, it was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 9 Dec 2021, item 33Open the meeting
Named9 Dec 2021Local Plan Committee

Swannington Neighbourhood Plan - Proposed Response to Pre-Submission Draft (Regulation 14).

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby , The Planning Policy and Land Charges Team Manager explained the risks of Neighbourhood Plans going out of date following the review of the Local Plan.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 9 Dec 2021, item 35Open the meeting
Seconded9 Dec 2021Local Plan Committee

Statement of Common Ground - Charnwood Borough

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 9 Dec 2021, item 36Open the meeting
Named24 Nov 2021Community Scrutiny Committee

North West Leicestershire Cycling and Walking Draft Strategy

There were also several inaccuracies throughout the document, and it was suggested that an officer meet with Councillor D Bigby to help identify these as he had noted them. The other general comment made was that the timeframe of 10 years was too long, Members wanted to see more ambition and action sooner. Members were pleased to see the reference to the reopening of the Ivanhoe line and the link to the LMS line.
From the council's minutes: Community Scrutiny Committee, 24 Nov 2021, item 23Open the meeting
Named10 Nov 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Items for Inclusion in the Future Work Programme

Following a question in relation to the reporting timescales for the North West Leicestershire Visitor Economy report, it was agreed for further information to be provided to Councillor D Bigby outside of the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 10 Nov 2021, item 26Open the meeting
Asked10 Nov 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Review of Medium Term Financial Plan

Councillor D Bigby asked officers to address the environment and climate change target in the forthcoming budget, as well as the consideration of adequate funds to keep Ashby Tourist Centre open.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 10 Nov 2021, item 28Open the meeting
Declared2 Nov 2021Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 21/00471/REMM, as he had opposed the associated outline permission through his role on Ashby Town Council Planning Committee, but had come to the meeting with an open mind and would make his decision on the facts presented to him at the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 2 Nov 2021, item 38Open the meeting
Moved2 Nov 2021Planning Committee

21/00471/REMM: Erection of a road related storage, maintenance and management facility and associated site works (reserved matters to outline planning permission ref.17/01081/OUTM)

The recommendation to refuse the application on the grounds that it contravened policies S3 and D1 of the Local Plan as t he proposed development, by virtue of its scale, massing, visual dominance and appearance, together with its proposed siting immediately adjacent to an existing estate road, would be out of character with existing development within the road-related services area, to the detriment of visual amenity was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Hoult.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 2 Nov 2021, item 42Open the meeting
Asked27 Oct 2021Local Plan Committee

Development Strategy

Councillor D Bigby sought clarification as to why option 3, part of which had been selected as a preferable option for High 1, did not contain either the smaller villages or the new settlement. He felt that at least one option should contain those settlements to allow sensible provision to be made for development within those areas. The Planning Policy and Land Charges Team Manager advised that there was an infinite number of options and that new options following the consultation may need to be considered.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 Oct 2021, item 28Open the meeting
Asked27 Oct 2021Local Plan Committee

Development Strategy

Councillor D Bigby asked if the Authority was talking to neighbouring authorities to the north of the district to take some of North West Leicestershire’s housing requirements due to the large scale industrial development in that area. The Planning Policy and Land Charges Team Manager advised that they were talking, but that you could only request that another authority takes your growth if you could not accommodate it, which was the case with Leicester and surrounding authorities looking to take on the unmet need.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 Oct 2021, item 28Open the meeting
Said27 Oct 2021Local Plan Committee

Development Strategy

Councillor D Bigby raised concerns over the language in the recommendation that stated that scenario High 2 was the preferred option. He stated that he was not against including the scenario, but the wording did not sit right with him. He noted that the numbers were higher than all the figures other than the build out rate and with that number of proposed dwellings in the option, the market would become saturated.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 Oct 2021, item 28Open the meeting
Moved5 Oct 2021Planning Committee

20/00362/FUL: Continued use of caravan site for a mixture of permanent residential accommodation and short term holiday accommodation

The recommendation to refuse the application on the grounds that it contravened policy D2, due to the impact on residential amenity, was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor R Boam.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 5 Oct 2021, item 33Open the meeting
Moved8 Sep 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review – Housing Standards

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor N Smith and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 8 Sep 2021, item 19Open the meeting
Moved8 Sep 2021Local Plan Committee

Affordable Housing Supplementary Planning Document

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby , seconded by Councillor J Hoult and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 8 Sep 2021, item 20Open the meeting
Seconded8 Sep 2021Local Plan Committee

National Planning Policy Framework Update

It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 8 Sep 2021, item 22Open the meeting
Said7 Sep 2021Council

Questions from Councillors

A question was received from Councillor D Bigby addressed to Councillor T Gillard as follows:- “ Ashby Tourist Information Centre (TIC) has been closed during the Covid restrictions and staff deployed to other duties to assist with Covid recovery. I have been told by officers and the portfolio holder that:
From the council's minutes: Council, 7 Sep 2021, item 35Open the meeting
Named7 Sep 2021Council

Questions from Councillors

The TIC was closed and, as Cllr Bigby says, staff were redeployed. They were providing vital support to businesses to help them reopen and begin to grow again.
From the council's minutes: Council, 7 Sep 2021, item 35Open the meeting
Named7 Sep 2021Council

Questions from Councillors

In summary, I thank Cllr Bigby for his question but would suggests that he waits until the Service Review has concluded and we have an opportunity to debate the findings”    Councillor Bigby was invited to ask a supplementary question.
From the council's minutes: Council, 7 Sep 2021, item 35Open the meeting
Said7 Sep 2021Council

Questions from Councillors

Councillor Bigby replied “I thank Councillor Gillard for his reply to my question. I note that he has given us no reassurances whatsoever on the future of Ashby Tourist Information Centre and has not answered my question.
From the council's minutes: Council, 7 Sep 2021, item 35Open the meeting
Named1 Sep 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Items for Inclusion in the Future Work Programme

It was noted that a request had been received from Councillor Bigby for the inclusion of an item relating to the Council’s failure to claim grants from the RHI Scheme.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 1 Sep 2021, item 16Open the meeting
Said1 Sep 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Items for Inclusion in the Future Work Programme

It was further noted that this matter was being addressed by the Audit and Governance Committee and it was therefore deemed inappropriate to be discussed separately by a different committee Councillor Bigby expressed his disappointment at this decision adding that HR, IT and Finance issues were within the remit of the Committee and he urged the Chairman to reconsider so that the matter could be properly scrutinised. The Chairman advised that it remained his view that the Audit and Governance Committee was the appropriate place to deal with this matter.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 1 Sep 2021, item 16Open the meeting
Named1 Sep 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Items for Inclusion in the Future Work Programme

Councillor Bigby disagreed as he felt it did not have the right tools or powers to deal with the matter effectively but the Chairman was satisfied that he did not wish to revisit the request.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 1 Sep 2021, item 16Open the meeting
Seconded7 Jul 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Health and Wellbeing Policy

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 7 Jul 2021, item 14Open the meeting
Seconded22 Jun 2021Council

Ashby Business Improvement District (BID)

It was moved by Councillor T Gillard, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT: Council Notes the Ashby BID proposals set out in the report;
From the council's minutes: Council, 22 Jun 2021, item 28Open the meeting
Seconded9 Jun 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Scrutiny Annual Report

It was seconded by Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 9 Jun 2021, item 6Open the meeting
Declared2 Jun 2021Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 20/00316/OUTM, as he had previously expressed concerns in relation to the Council’s employment planning policies, but he had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 2 Jun 2021, item 2Open the meeting
Declared13 Apr 2021Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 19/02453/FULM, as Ward Member. He would speak to the item and then leave the meeting and take no further part in the consideration of or voting on the item.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 13 Apr 2021, item 65Open the meeting
Named13 Apr 2021Planning Committee

19/02453/FULM: Demolition of existing care home and redevelopment of site to erect a new secure residential institution care facility (use class C2A secure hospital) with parking

Councillor S Sheahan joined the meeting as a substitute for Councillor D Bigby, who would address the committee as Ward Member and then leave the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 13 Apr 2021, item 68Open the meeting
Said13 Apr 2021Planning Committee

19/02453/FULM: Demolition of existing care home and redevelopment of site to erect a new secure residential institution care facility (use class C2A secure hospital) with parking

Councillor D Bigby, Ward Member, addressed the committee highlighting that it was an emotive application and the overwhelming view was that the location was not appropriate for the facility due to the proximity to a large housing estate and primary school. He noted that no local need was evident and felt that the application should be refused as it was contrary to NPPF paragraphs 91 and 127, and the fear of crime would undermine the quality of life and community cohesion on the neighbouring housing estate. He also advised that the application was contrary to Local Plan policy D2 as the proposed development would be overbearing for the local area.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 13 Apr 2021, item 68Open the meeting
Named13 Apr 2021Planning Committee

19/02453/FULM: Demolition of existing care home and redevelopment of site to erect a new secure residential institution care facility (use class C2A secure hospital) with parking

Having declared a pecuniary interest in the item, Councillor D Bigby then left the meeting for the consideration of the item and the voting thereon.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 13 Apr 2021, item 68Open the meeting
Seconded31 Mar 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Substantive Review - Housing Requirements

The motion was seconded by Councillor D Bigby who then spoke in support.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 31 Mar 2021, item 39Open the meeting
Seconded31 Mar 2021Local Plan Committee

Hugglescote & Donington le Heath Neighbourhood Plan (Submission Draft) and Neighbourhood Planning Update

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and by affirmation of the meeting RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 31 Mar 2021, item 41Open the meeting
Moved9 Mar 2021Planning Committee

20/01823/FUL: Erection of office development (class E(g)) including new vehicular access

A motion to refuse the application on the grounds that the application was contrary to S3k as it did not constitute small scale development was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Legrys.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 9 Mar 2021, item 62Open the meeting
Seconded9 Mar 2021Planning Committee

20/00689/FUL: Formation of new vehicular access (retrospective)

A motion to refuse the application in accordance with the recommendation of the Head of Planning and Infrastructure was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor D Bigby.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 9 Mar 2021, item 63Open the meeting
Declared9 Feb 2021Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 19/01496/OUTM, as he had previously made personal, public statements about the development of warehouses in general.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 9 Feb 2021, item 53Open the meeting
Declared27 Jan 2021Local Plan Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in all three Local Plan Review items (Item 5, 6 and 7) as he had commented on the Local Plan Review during the public consultation process prior to him becoming an Elected Member but   had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 Jan 2021, item 28Open the meeting
Seconded27 Jan 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Housing Requirements

‘Members of the Committee to receive a written briefing note on the progress of the local housing need requirement on a regular basis.’ It was seconded by Councillor D Bigby. The motion was put to the vote and was carried. A Member raised concerns with the intention to appoint consultants at this stage when the HEDNA was being prepared and would be   in available the Summer.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 Jan 2021, item 31Open the meeting
Seconded27 Jan 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Housing Requirements

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 Jan 2021, item 31Open the meeting
Moved27 Jan 2021Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review – Employment Land Requirements

During this discussion, Councillor D Bigby proposed that the following recommendation be added to those already stated within the report:
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 Jan 2021, item 32Open the meeting
Seconded20 Jan 2021Audit and Governance Committee

Treasury Management Activity Report April 2020 to December 2020

It was moved by Councillor M Hay, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and by affirmation of the meeting it was RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 20 Jan 2021, item 41Open the meeting
Declared13 Jan 2021Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 19/00652/FULM, as he had objected to the application in a personal capacity before being appointed to the Planning Committee.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 13 Jan 2021, item 46Open the meeting
Named6 Jan 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Draft General Fund and Special Expenses Revenue Budget

The following responses were given to questions from Councillor D Bigby:
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 23Open the meeting
Said6 Jan 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budget Proposals

Councillor D Bigby expressed concerns for the proposed increase of rents for tenants but reduction in the repairs budget. Although the report explained that the proposed reduction was due to lack of demand, he felt it was more likely because of the current Covid-19 climate and the issues in accessing properties. The Strategic Finance Manager reported that the reduction in the repairs budget was in response to a lower expenditure over several years due to fewer routine repairs because of the amount of work being completed under the decent homes programme.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 24Open the meeting
Named6 Jan 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budget Proposals

In response to a further comment from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Housing assured Members that it was categorically not the policy of the Council to refuse repairs due to lack of budget, if a repair was needed in a property it would definitely be undertaken. In response to a question regarding the lack of painting programme proposals, the Head of Housing acknowledged that there was painting required for several properties but the decision was taken to not use the funds in this financial year, however, the budget would be available for the programme in the 2022/23 financial year.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 24Open the meeting
Named6 Jan 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2021/22 - 2025/26 Draft Capital Programmes

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Finance confirmed that the funds allocated for electric charging points would be carried forward.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 25Open the meeting
Named6 Jan 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2021/22 Capital Strategy

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Strategic Finance Manager stated that there were currently 217 council homes forecasted to be sold under the Right to Buy Scheme over the next five years.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 26Open the meeting
Named6 Jan 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2021/22 Capital Strategy

In response to a question in relation to Right to Buy Capital Receipts from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Finance explained that due to the current Covid-19 climate, dispensations had been granted by national government to provide more time to spend them. The Strategic Finance Manger also informed Members that the Capital Receipts were continuously monitored to ensure the money was not lost. The Head of Housing added that several properties have been acquired in the last few years using capital receipts.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 26Open the meeting
Seconded6 Jan 2021Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Treasury Management Strategy Statement 2021/22-2023/24

It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and by affirmation of the meeting it was RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 6 Jan 2021, item 28Open the meeting
Moved10 Dec 2020Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Objectives

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor N Smith and RESOLVED THAT The Local Plan Committee notes the revised wording of draft Objective 4, as set out at paragraph 1.8 of the report, for inclusion in the next consultation stage of the Substantive Local Plan Review.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 10 Dec 2020, item 24Open the meeting
Seconded3 Nov 2020Planning Committee

Planning Enforcement Update

It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 3 Nov 2020, item 37Open the meeting
Named2 Sep 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Council Delivery Plan 2020-21

Councillor Sheahan asked a question on behalf of Councillor Bigby in relation to the highest priority routes from the Ashby cycling strategy and asked when the objective might be available and was advised that if Councillor Bigby wanted to contact officers directly this would be provided.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 2 Sep 2020, item 8Open the meeting
Named2 Sep 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2019/20 Q4 & 2020/21 Q1 Performance Reports

Councillor Sheahan raised issues on behalf of Councillor Bigby in relation to off street parking in Ridgway Road, Ashby as planning permission was received in March but work had not yet started. He asked for the start and completion dates and whether a contractor had been appointed. He also asked for updates on a number of car parking issues referred to in the report and when the report on car parking improvement would be available.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 2 Sep 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Declared4 Aug 2020Planning Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 20/00718/FULM, as he had expressed personal opinions in the past about warehouses in the district but had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 4 Aug 2020, item 8Open the meeting
Declared29 Jul 2020Local Plan Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in items 5, Local Plan Review – Update and 6, Local Plan Review – Draft Objectives, as he had previously commented on several aspects of the Local Plan Review during the consultation process, but had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 29 Jul 2020, item 2Open the meeting
Said29 Jul 2020Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Update

Councillor D Bigby noted that it would take some time to establish the figures and asked that if whilst waiting for the information, whether officers would begin work on identifying suitable sites for development. In relation to employment needs, he highlighted the work that was required following the changes to the NPPF and sought clarification on what the key changes were and its significance . He was pleased to see that the report mentioned the need for more carbon friendly distribution operations and the need to understand and use rail freight when possible, as there were railheads that could be used.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 29 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Named29 Jul 2020Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Draft Objectives

Following a submission of a question from Councillor D Bigby to that meeting, Cabinet agreed to amend objectives 2, 3 and 10 as set out in Councillor R Ashman’s response. He informed Members that, due to the Cabinet decision, they were being asked to note the decision of Cabinet with respect of the Draft Local Plan Objectives taking account of the changes to Objectives 2, 3 and 10 as set out on the additional paper.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 29 Jul 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Said29 Jul 2020Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Draft Objectives

Councillor D Bigby explained to the committee why he had submitted the question to Cabinet rather than consideration at the Committee first. He was pleased that Cabinet agreed the changes to objectives 2, 3 and 10 and, that the Council was making progress in developing the framework for the substantive review. He welcomed the new objective 7 that laid down the need to respond to the Climate Emergency but expressed disappointment that Cabinet had rejected the suggestions for objective 5.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 29 Jul 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Named29 Jul 2020Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Draft Objectives

The Planning Policy Team Manager advised that he appreciated the questions that were submitted by Councillor D Bigby. He noted that a consultation would then be held on the draft objectives and that there was a possibility that an amendment to objective 5 could come through that way, therefore the position regarding objective 5 was not set in stone.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 29 Jul 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Named23 Jul 2020Cabinet

Local Plan Substantive review - Objectives

Councillor Ashman advised Cabinet that he had received a number of questions from Councillor Bigby on this report which he had responded to; and details of the questions and responses had been circulated to Cabinet ahead of the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Jul 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Named23 Jul 2020Cabinet

Local Plan Substantive review - Objectives

Councillor Bigby was invited to ask a supplementary question.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Jul 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Said23 Jul 2020Cabinet

Local Plan Substantive review - Objectives

Councillor Bigby thanked Councillor Ashman for his reply and welcomed the agreed changes.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Jul 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Named23 Jul 2020Cabinet

Local Plan Substantive review - Objectives

Whilst accepting the challenges that COVID-19 will present, Councillor Bigby strongly disputed the assumption that the economic interests of businesses in general were compatible with the economic interests of local residents. He didn’t accept that the building of more large warehouses across the district which were likely to be encouraged by the draft policy as it currently stands, would necessary be in the interests of local people. He therefore advised that he would continue to give some thought to this particular objective with a view to a revised recommendation which he hoped would find agreement by the Local Plan Committee.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Jul 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Named23 Jul 2020Cabinet

Local Plan Substantive review - Objectives

Councillor Ashman thanked Councillor Bigby and advised that he stood by his original response and accepted that there is a balance to be struck between encouraging new businesses to settle in the district bringing with them local employment and building large warehouses in the countryside.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 23 Jul 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Asked22 Jul 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Progress Report

In relation to the Affordable Housing – S106/Commuted Sums recommendation at Appendix B, Councillor D Bigby asked if once completed, it would be published and available   both to councillors and the public. The Audit Manager was unable to confirm but believed that once formal agreement had been reached, it would be publically available.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 22 Jul 2020, item 5Open the meeting
Named22 Jul 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Annual Report

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Audit Manager explained that the last external inspection was carried out through CIPFA and this one would be conducted by Elizabeth Humphries, a very experienced assessor who carried out the previous inspection in 2015.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 22 Jul 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Seconded22 Jul 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Annual Report

It was moved by Councillor J Clarke, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 22 Jul 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Named22 Jul 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Treasury Management Stewardship Report 2019/20

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Finance Team Manager explained that the same protection applied to local authority investments as to the investments.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 22 Jul 2020, item 7Open the meeting
Named22 Jul 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Review of Corporate Policies

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Finance confirmed that the policies predominantly related to staff but the Data Protection Policy and ICT/Cyber Security Policy also related to Members. The Head of Legal and Commercial Services reminded Members that they had signed to adhere to these policies after they were elected and information was provided in their induction packs. She added that once the policy changes had been agreed by Cabinet, Members would be sent the relevant updated policy documents with the changes highlighted for information.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 22 Jul 2020, item 9Open the meeting
Said22 Jul 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Update of the Council's Constitution

Councillor D Bigby welcomed the clarification of the allowance of questions by members of the public at the Local Plan Committee. He also referred to the provision of papers to Councillors in the Remote Meeting Procedure Rules, as he currently could not access all confidential reports.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 22 Jul 2020, item 15Open the meeting
Named22 Jul 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Update of the Council's Constitution

In response to a comment from Councillor D Bigby regarding paragraph 3.1 of the Remote Meeting Procedure Rules, it was agreed to look at the wording to make it clear that it was Members in attendance that would be regarded as present for the purposes of determining a quorum, not those authorised.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 22 Jul 2020, item 15Open the meeting
Moved7 Jul 2020Planning Committee

20/00676/FUL: Erection of three detached dwellings with garages

A motion to refuse the application in accordance with the officer recommendation was moved by Councillor D Bigby and seconded by Councillor J Legrys.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Jul 2020, item 6Open the meeting
Declared23 Jun 2020Council

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10.2 – Motions, as a supporting member of the campaign to re-open the Ivanhoe Line.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 Jun 2020, item 2Open the meeting
Declared27 May 2020Local Plan Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 3 – Public Question and Answer Session, as he had been quoted in the question as submitting a response during the 2018 consultation. He advised that it was in an independent manner before being elected and that he had come to the meeting with an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 May 2020, item 29Open the meeting
Said27 May 2020Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Self Build Policy

Councillor D Bigby stated that he supported the conclusion of not identifying specific sites for self-build. He expressed concerns over the policy as he felt that it was quite complex and cumbersome, and sought a better understanding of the word ‘seek’, as it could lead to misunderstanding by the planning committee as to what it meant. He noted that there were forty-four names on the self-build register and asked if the register noted what type of plot those that were interested were looking for, adding that he would be surprised that those on the register would be looking at living on housing estates.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 May 2020, item 32Open the meeting
Said27 May 2020Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Update

Councillor D Bigby stated that he felt that good points had been made on the need for transparency during the process and, as part of that, he asked that it was ensured that the committee was kept up to date on what was being discussed behind the scenes rather than the final figures just being put before the committee for agreement. He expressed concerns that the review was behind on the set timescales, which could not be helped, but felt that it would be useful for a revised timetable to be shared. He also felt that the committee was being drip-fed information but seeing a detailed roadmap as to how everything would be dealt with and when would be useful as there were a number big issues, such as the  ...  view the full minutes text for item 33.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 27 May 2020, item 33Open the meeting
Moved17 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Election of Chairman

It was proposed by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor S Gillard and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 17 Mar 2020, item 31Open the meeting
Named17 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Progress Report

In response to questions from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Finance confirmed the position on small capital items, wider asset disposal policy as outlined in Appendix C of the report. She also confirmed a report addressing the issue would be going to Corporate Scrutiny Committee at a later date.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 17 Mar 2020, item 35Open the meeting
Seconded17 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Progress Report

It was proposed by Councillor S Gillard, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 17 Mar 2020, item 35Open the meeting
Moved17 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Annual Report on Grants and Claims

It was proposed by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor M Hay RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 17 Mar 2020, item 37Open the meeting
Moved17 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee

External Audit Plan

It was moved by Councillor D Bigby, seconded by Councillor M Hay and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 17 Mar 2020, item 38Open the meeting
Named17 Mar 2020Audit and Governance Committee

Corporate Risk Update

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Finance clarified the criteria used to determine the Movement of Risk as set out in the report and the reasoning behind several of the assessments. She acknowledged that there was room for improvement to make the determination clearer.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 17 Mar 2020, item 40Open the meeting
Named11 Mar 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Member Development Annual Update

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Democratic Services Team Manager confirmed that there was a budget available for member training.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 11 Mar 2020, item 41Open the meeting
Said11 Mar 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2019/20 Q3 Performance Report

Councillor D Bigby commented that the time between reporting and the Committee recieveing was long, and asked for the timetabling to be reconsidered. In relation to the leisure centre project, he asked if the delay was due to highway issues, which was affecting the work required for the pedestrian bridge. He also suggested that the delay provided a good opportunity to investigate a greener heating system before building works began.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 11 Mar 2020, item 43Open the meeting
Named11 Mar 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2019/20 Q3 Performance Report

Councillor D Bigby was pleased that establishing a local housing trading company was being investigated but asked that it be brought to scrutiny before being considered by Cabinet. The Strategic Director confirmed that if it moved forward, a report would be submitted for scrutiny.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 11 Mar 2020, item 43Open the meeting
Named11 Mar 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Items for Inclusion in the Future Work Programme

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby regarding the Roadmap to Zero Carbon, the Strategic Director confirmed that a more detailed report would be brought back to the relevant scrutiny committee in due course.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 11 Mar 2020, item 44Open the meeting
Declared15 Jan 2020Local Plan Committee

Declaration of Interests

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 4 – Local Green Spaces as he had taken part in the consultation both as a member of the public and a member of Ashby de-la-Zouch Town Council.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 15 Jan 2020, item 21Open the meeting
Said15 Jan 2020Local Plan Committee

Local green spaces

Councillor D Bigby commented on the importance of protecting local green spaces and was concerned that not including the designation of these areas in the Local Plan would leave many of them unprotected, especially as there was a reluctance in many parishes for a Neighbourhood Plan. He understood the resource implication for the Planning Policy Team but did not feel that it was a reason to not include the designation in the Local Plan.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 15 Jan 2020, item 23Open the meeting
Said15 Jan 2020Local Plan Committee

Hugglescote and donington-le-heath neighbourhood plan

In relation to the officer comments within the report on the aspirations for universal vehicle charging points, Councillor D Bigby acknowledged that there was no national requirement for universal vehicle charging points but did not want this to be the reason it was removed. He felt it was something that was moving forward and an area where the Council’s Local Plan was falling behind. The Planning Policy Team Manager fully supported the aspirations of the Parish but reported that there were some technical issues at the present time which was why the comments were included as a note of caution.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 15 Jan 2020, item 25Open the meeting
Said15 Jan 2020Local Plan Committee

Authority monitoring report 2018/19

Councillor D Bigby raised concerns regarding the housing mix figures as he felt there were not enough two bedroom properties being provided. The Planning Policy Team Manager explained that it was very difficult to refuse an application on the grounds of lack of mixed use. However, he did understand the concerns and this data could be used to put pressure on developers if required.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 15 Jan 2020, item 27Open the meeting
Said15 Jan 2020Local Plan Committee

Authority monitoring report 2018/19

Councillor D Bigby commented on the importance of these types of government consultations and that they ought to be brought to Committee automatically without being raised by Members. The Planning Policy Team Manager assured Members that a response would have been supplied to the consultation but it would have been completed by the Building Control Team. He was pleased that it had been raised as it was also relevant to Planning.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 15 Jan 2020, item 27Open the meeting
Named8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Draft 2020/21 General Fund and Special Expenses Revenue Budgets

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Finance clarified that the consultation referred to within the report was the statutory consultation to parishes. The additional public consultation, a new process for this year, would begin week commencing 13 January 2020 and that comments would be considered by Cabinet when it considers the final budget proposals in February.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 27Open the meeting
Named8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Draft 2020/21 General Fund and Special Expenses Revenue Budgets

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby in relation to the Council’s journey to self-sufficiency, the Head of Finance explained that the figure was a new savings target linked to the Medium Term Financial Plan and was reviewed periodically. The Chief Executive appreciated that Members would be interested in the Self-Sufficiency Programme and it was agreed to include it in the work programme for a future meeting.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 27Open the meeting
Asked8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Draft 2020/21 General Fund and Special Expenses Revenue Budgets

Councillor D Bigby asked for assurances that the cost of the substantive review of the Local Plan had been taken into account, as it was essential that it was undertaken properly. The Corporate Portfolio Holder explained that the proposals reflected the programme and included estimated costs. He added that the Council was committed to the Local Plan and the funds for the substantive review remain in place.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 27Open the meeting
Said8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2020/21 Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budget Proposals

Councillor D Bigby requested that a list of all car parks being considered be shared with the Committee. He also suggested that the installation of electric car charging points be considered as part of the improvements.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 28Open the meeting
Named8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2020/21 Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budget Proposals

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Finance explained that the tenants involved in the consultation were those on specific tenant groups but there would also be a Council led consultation exercise and media plan to ensure engagement, this includes focus on tenants.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 28Open the meeting
Named8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2020/21 Capital Strategy

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby regarding developer contributions, the Strategic Finance Manager clarified that the reducing developer contributions in the table detailed at paragraph 3.2 were what the council was spending and not what it was receiving. The Council was spending less because other funds in the HRA budget required spending.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 30Open the meeting
Asked8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Treasury Management Strategy Statement 2020/21 to 2022/23

Councillor D Bigby asked that the leisure centre contract be taken to the relevant scrutiny committee. The Chief executive was happy for this to be included in the work programme and offered to also provide quarterly updates.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 32Open the meeting
Named8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Corporate Peer Review

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Chief Executive explained that the gaps in the finance service raised during the review are currently being reviewed. Some temporary resource has been agreed and work was underway.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 34Open the meeting
Asked8 Jan 2020Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2019/20 Q2 Performance Report

Councillor D Bigby asked for further information about the neighbourhood plan consultation with parishes to be provided to the Local Plan Committee, as it would help in some important decisions in the near future. This was agreed.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 8 Jan 2020, item 35Open the meeting
Said7 Jan 2020Planning Committee

19/01256/FUL: Construction of new car parking areas and resurfacing of existing parking areas

Councillor D Bigby, Ward Member, addressed the committee highlighting that he welcomed the application as parking on the estate had become a contentious issue due to on road parking on both sides of the road, and therefore making it difficult for emergency vehicles to get through. He would have preferred a more imaginative redesign but urged that suitable tree planting was included and that he would like to know how the surface water drainage tanks would be managed. He noted the lack of electric car charging points and requested that some be installed to adhere to the Council’s climate emergency declaration.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Jan 2020, item 62Open the meeting
Seconded4 Dec 2019Audit and Governance Committee

Annual Audit Letter

It was moved by Councillor Richichi, seconded by Councillor Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 4 Dec 2019, item 24Open the meeting
Seconded4 Dec 2019Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Progress Report

It was moved by Councillor Harrison, seconded by Councillor Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 4 Dec 2019, item 25Open the meeting
Said19 Nov 2019Council

Notification of an Urgent Decision - North West Leicestershire Local Plan - Partial Review

Councillor D Bigby stated that as the mover of amendment at Local Plan Committee that led to the current situation, a short explanation was required. He advised that the amendment was carried by 5 votes to 2 cross party. He advised that there were 2 parts to the amendment, the first sought to delete or modify policy EC2 part 2, in order to avoid further erosion of countryside.
From the council's minutes: Council, 19 Nov 2019, item 54Open the meeting
Said13 Nov 2019Local Plan Committee

Money Hill Masterplan Consultation

Councillor D Bigby raised concerns that the report seemed to be ‘side stepping’ the requirement of the Ashby Neighbourhood plan, the wording of which stated that the masterplan had to be agreed in conjunction with the Town Council. He believed that the Town Council should have been involved in the discussions.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 13 Nov 2019, item 17Open the meeting
Named13 Nov 2019Local Plan Committee

Money Hill Masterplan Consultation

The Chairman, Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Planning and Infrastructure, the Planning Policy Team Manager and the Legal Advisor left the room during the adjournment. The meeting re-convened at 6.55pm.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 13 Nov 2019, item 17Open the meeting
Declared13 Nov 2019Local Plan Committee

Money Hill Masterplan Consultation

Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in the item as he had responded to the consultation as a member of the public.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 13 Nov 2019, item 17Open the meeting
Named13 Nov 2019Local Plan Committee

Money Hill Masterplan Consultation

Councillor D Bigby would like to see a reference to the Ashby Neighbourhood Plan in the recommendations of the report; specifically that developers should comply with this plan as well as the District Council’s Local Plan. He also pointed out that Ashby Town Council had requested that employment land should only consist of type B1 and B2, not B8. He felt that the employment land figures indicated that the area was already oversubscribed in accordance with the HEDNA requirements, therefore the shortfall was for type B1 a and b only, and there was no justification for type B8 in the area.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 13 Nov 2019, item 17Open the meeting
Named13 Nov 2019Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Partial Review

Councillor D Bigby was proud of the amendment he moved at the previous meeting as it pointed out the issues with putting the countryside at risk. He was disappointed that Cabinet had not taken on board the amendment as agreed by the committee. However, he did not want to see the Local Plan become out of date, so he had no intentions of proposing any further amendments.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 13 Nov 2019, item 18Open the meeting
Said7 Nov 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Items for Inclusion in the Future Work Programme

Councillor D Bigby requested that the contract between the Council and leisure provider, Everyone’s Active be considered by the Committee.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 7 Nov 2019, item 20Open the meeting
Named9 Oct 2019Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Progress Report

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby in relation to the shared services agreement, the Audit Manager confirmed that the current aim of the agreement was to increase resilience in the short term by growing the team but there could be commercial opportunities in the future.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 9 Oct 2019, item 16Open the meeting
Asked2 Oct 2019Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Partial Review

Councillor D Bigby asked officers if they were confident that the Planning Inspector  ...  view the full minutes text for item 12.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 2 Oct 2019, item 12Open the meeting
Named2 Oct 2019Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Area of Separation study

Councillor D Bigby referred to the three proposed areas of separation as indicated in the Ashby Neighbourhood Plan, which was rejected by the Planning Inspector because it was not supported by sufficient evidence and was outside the plan area. Therefore, he suggested that other areas of separation be considered, particularly those proposed in Ashby. The Planning Policy Team Manager explained how areas of separation were considered and reminded members that that the area between Coalville and Whitwick was unique as it was within an otherwise built up area.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 2 Oct 2019, item 13Open the meeting
Named2 Oct 2019Local Plan Committee

Local Plan Review - Area of Separation study

Councillor D Bigby appreciated the comments from the Planning Policy Team Manager but asked if officers could look into Policy S3 to see if it was possible make any changes to protect these areas between towns and villages. The Planning Policy Team Manager advised that the policy already did this.
From the council's minutes: Local Plan Committee, 2 Oct 2019, item 13Open the meeting
Named10 Sep 2019Council

Allocation of Seats on Committees

(2)        That Councillor Bigby be appointed as a substitute on the Planning Committee to replace Councillor Johnson;
From the council's minutes: Council, 10 Sep 2019, item 43Open the meeting
Named4 Sep 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Corporate Charging Policy

Councillor Bigby broadly welcomed the policy and considered that moving away from the percentage increase charges was a positive step although he recognised that this was included in the previous policy so did not see it as a change. He also welcomed reference to Equality Impact Assessments. However he did express concern regarding some of the phrasing in the policy document and considered that some of them were contradictory.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2019, item 11Open the meeting
Said4 Sep 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Corporate Charging Policy

Councillor Bigby expressed his disappointment at the wording of paragraph 2.3 of the report as he felt that it implied that the main focus of the Council was to generate profit over customer impact. He was also concerned at the level of reduction in authorisation which he felt, in turn would reduce the level of scrutiny for increasing fees and charges. He there asked if a report could be brought to this Committee on any charges which had been increased.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2019, item 11Open the meeting
Said4 Sep 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Corporate Asset Management Strategy

Councillor Bigby welcomed references to improvements to Moira Furnace, health and safety and carbon footprint. He stated that it appeared to him that the emphasis of the report was to maximise profitability from the Council assets yet it was not clear to him which assets the council intended to maximise its profitability from. His concern was again, whether the Council was placing its emphasis on profit over the needs of the community, for example those assets being utilised for useful purposes within the community both now and in the future.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2019, item 12Open the meeting
Named4 Sep 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Corporate Asset Management Strategy

In response to these comments, the Head of Housing and Property Services referred to paragraph 1.4 of the report which listed the different categories of assets but understood the point that Councillor Bigby was making and advised that each individual asset would be considered on its own merits. He added that the disposals policy gave the flexibility to allow for transfers of land where appropriate in order to facilitate local housing needs, adding that we also now have the opportunity of developing our own land for council housing which, historically we have never had, and would produce a commercial income as well as addressing a local housing need.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2019, item 12Open the meeting
Asked4 Sep 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Corporate Asset Management Strategy

Councillor Bigby sought clarification on the term ‘for regeneration purposes’ and made reference to the poorest performing asset being Ashby Market Hall and asked what measures were being put in place to address the constraints faced by such assets.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2019, item 12Open the meeting
Asked4 Sep 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

End of Year Report

Councillor Bigby asked for more information regarding the reason for not establishing a local housing trading company and it was acknowledged that, after detailed discussions with some neighbouring authorities on issues such as seeking additional benefits from sharing resources, it was considered that there was no evidence at this time to suggest that this approach would add any value to our current working practices. It is not off the agenda and these discussions will be continued to see if there is any scope for more collaborative working.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2019, item 13Open the meeting
Said4 Sep 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2019/20 Q1 Performance Report

Councillor Bigby welcomed the Chief Executive’s suggestion of the inclusion of regional and national context. He also welcomed the food waste trial and hoped that this would be successful, but expressed some surprise that we were not doing this already. He felt that the inclusion of the electric charging point in the new car park in Ashby should be rolled out with some urgency rather than wait for the outcome of a pilot report, especially as he envisaged that the uptake on electric cars was set to increase.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2019, item 14Open the meeting
Said4 Sep 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2019/20 Q1 Performance Report

Councillor Bigby reported that he was keen to see a stakeholders’ group established to oversee the works on Ashby Hood Park and that it was unfortunate that this was not set up at the outset. Mr  ...  view the full minutes text for item 14.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 4 Sep 2019, item 14Open the meeting
Named24 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee

Report to Those Charged with Governance

In response to a further question from Councillor D Bigby, it was reported that there was no way of knowing what the financial impact would be at this stage.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 24 Jul 2019, item 4Open the meeting
Named24 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Progress Report

Councillor D Bigby was pleased to see that the health and safety recommendations were being addressed. He asked for further information on the task group that was to be set up. The Head of Human Resources and Organisation Development explained that a task group had been created which was made up of managers from high-risk areas and three trade union representatives.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 24 Jul 2019, item 8Open the meeting
Named24 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee

Internal Audit Progress Report

In response to a further question from Councillor D Bigby, the Head of Human Resources and Organisation Development reported that the resourcing of the health and safety function was being reviewed and some initial benchmarking results had indicated that it was not widely different from other similar sized authorities. He added that the intention was to have a critical friend from a Nottinghamshire Authority;
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 24 Jul 2019, item 8Open the meeting
Named24 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee

Corporate Risk Update

Councillor D Bigby was pleased to see that two of the three high-risk areas had included updated control measures since it was presented to the Corporate Scrutiny Committee the previous month. He felt that this indicated the risk was being taken seriously.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 24 Jul 2019, item 10Open the meeting
Said24 Jul 2019Audit and Governance Committee

Standards and ethics - quarter 1 report

Councillor D Bigby commented on the significant increase in Freedom of Information requests and asked if a reason had been identified. The Head of Legal and Commercial Services reported that there had been a decrease over previous years and was unsure what had caused the recent spike in numbers. She agreed to look at recent trends and report her findings to Members.
From the council's minutes: Audit and Governance Committee, 24 Jul 2019, item 11Open the meeting
Named12 Jun 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

Workforce and Agency Costs - Annual Update

In response to a question from Councillor D Bigby, the Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services confirmed that as the number of full time equivalent permanent employees increased last year, the resulting increase in staff costs had offset the reduced expenditure on agency staff.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 12 Jun 2019, item 4Open the meeting
Named12 Jun 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2018/19 Quarter 4 Performance Report

In relation to the relaunch of ‘my account’ self-service system, Councillor D Bigby shared his experience of using it, as it was not simple. He wanted to change his bank details for his direct debit payments and it was unclear how it could be done.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 12 Jun 2019, item 5Open the meeting
Named12 Jun 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2018/19 Quarter 4 Performance Report

Councillor D Bigby referred to a new consultation document that had been published which included details of a large railhead site close to Ashby that would last approximately seven years. He asked how the Council was planning to respond and if they would be calling for the work undertaken to establish the railhead to be done with a view to facilitate the opportunity to open passenger services in the future. The Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services would ask the Head of Economic Regeneration to provide a response.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 12 Jun 2019, item 5Open the meeting
Said12 Jun 2019Corporate Scrutiny Committee

2018/19 Quarter 4 Performance Report

Councillor D Bigby felt that the target figure for affordable homes in the District should be revisited, as it was not directly related to the Section 106 requirement for affordable homes, the HEDNA or the Local Plan. The Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services responded that he would look at setting the target with a more scientific method. He explained that the current target was based on the knowledge of the number of houses being built by the Council and housing associations, and what the Section  ...  view the full minutes text for item 5.
From the council's minutes: Corporate Scrutiny Committee, 12 Jun 2019, item 5Open the meeting
Said21 May 2019Council

Council Delivery Plan 2019/20

Councillor D Bigby commented that the Council Delivery Plan appeared to reflect the pledges made in the last election. He requested a copy of the manifesto. He highlighted the pledges made on social media, and in particular the pledge to reopen the Royal Hotel, which was a matter of great local concern.
From the council's minutes: Council, 21 May 2019, item 13Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bigby attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
16 Nov 2021CouncilMotionsLost14 for, 21 against, 1 abstained
16 Mar 2021CouncilUpdate on Establishment of Company to be known as 'EM DEVCO Limited'Carried31 for, 4 against
16 Mar 2021CouncilNorth West Leicestershire Local Plan Partial Review - Proposed AdoptionCarried32 for, 4 against
17 Nov 2020CouncilCouncil Delivery Plan 2020/21Carried19 for, 4 against, 12 abstained
17 Nov 2020CouncilEstablishment of Company to be Known as 'EM DEVCO LIMITED'Carried30 for, 4 against
8 Sep 2020CouncilAllocation of Seats on Committees (Political Balance)Carried31 for, 4 against
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Bigby was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Planning Committee
58 of 75
Local Plan Committee
37 of 53
Council
33 of 41
Corporate Scrutiny Committee
28 of 30
Community Scrutiny Committee
8 of 13
Audit and Governance Committee
9 of 9
Cabinet
2 of 2
Licensing Sub Committee
1 of 1
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
+1
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 20 of 36 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Bigby declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

DateWhereWhat the minutes sayWhat happened
9 Dec 2025Planning Committee, item 42Councillor D Bigby declared that he had previously been involved in discussions about item A2, application number 23/00427/OUTM, as part of Ashby Town Council’s Planning Committee but had come to the meeting with an open mind.
9 Sep 2025Planning Committee, item 19Cllr D Bigby declared an interest as a member of Ashby Town Council, who had previously considered the matter, but he had come to the meeting with an open mind.
6 Feb 2024Planning Committee, item 59Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in item A2 – application 23/01108/FUL, as he was speaking on application as adjoining Ward Member.
5 Dec 2023Planning Committee, item 45Councillor D Bigby declared a Registerable Interest in Item A4 - application number 23/01148/FUL, as an Ashby Town Parish Councillor and had taken part in discussions on the application but had come to the Planning Committee meeting with an open mind.
16 Aug 2023Planning Committee, item 17Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in item A3 – application number 22/01177/FUL as he was speaking on the application as Ward Member.
20 Jul 2023Planning Committee, item 10Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in item A1 – Application number 22/01552/FULM as he was speaking on the application as Ward Member.
20 Jul 2023Planning Committee, item 10Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in item A1 – Application number 22/01552/FULM as he was speaking on the application as Ward Member and therefore would not take part in any of the deliberation of voting.Took no part
1 Nov 2022Planning Committee, item 27Councillor D Bigby declared a registerable interest in Item A1 as a member of Ashby Town Council’s Planning Committee but had come to the meeting with an open mind.
5 Jan 2022Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 38Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 6 – North West Leicestershire Visitor Economy Plan, as a member of Ashby Town Council and the Ashby Civic Society. He also declared that he had asked a question in relation to the closure of Ashby Tourist Information Centre at the Council meeting on 7 September 2021, as well as expressed his opinion on the matter at several meetings and in the press.
2 Nov 2021Planning Committee, item 38Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 21/00471/REMM, as he had opposed the associated outline permission through his role on Ashby Town Council Planning Committee, but had come to the meeting with an open mind and would make his decision on the facts presented to him at the meeting.
2 Jun 2021Planning Committee, item 2Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 20/00316/OUTM, as he had previously expressed concerns in relation to the Council’s employment planning policies, but he had come to the meeting with an open mind.
13 Apr 2021Planning Committee, item 65Councillor D Bigby declared a pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 19/02453/FULM, as Ward Member. He would speak to the item and then leave the meeting and take no further part in the consideration of or voting on the item.
9 Feb 2021Planning Committee, item 53Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 19/01496/OUTM, as he had previously made personal, public statements about the development of warehouses in general.
27 Jan 2021Local Plan Committee, item 28Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in all three Local Plan Review items (Item 5, 6 and 7) as he had commented on the Local Plan Review during the public consultation process prior to him becoming an Elected Member but   had come to the meeting with an open mind.
13 Jan 2021Planning Committee, item 46Councillor D Bigby declared a pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 19/00652/FULM, as he had objected to the application in a personal capacity before being appointed to the Planning Committee.
4 Aug 2020Planning Committee, item 8Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 20/00718/FULM, as he had expressed personal opinions in the past about warehouses in the district but had come to the meeting with an open mind.
29 Jul 2020Local Plan Committee, item 2Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in items 5, Local Plan Review – Update and 6, Local Plan Review – Draft Objectives, as he had previously commented on several aspects of the Local Plan Review during the consultation process, but had come to the meeting with an open mind.
23 Jun 2020Council, item 2Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10.2 – Motions, as a supporting member of the campaign to re-open the Ivanhoe Line.
27 May 2020Local Plan Committee, item 29Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 3 – Public Question and Answer Session, as he had been quoted in the question as submitting a response during the 2018 consultation. He advised that it was in an independent manner before being elected and that he had come to the meeting with an open mind.
15 Jan 2020Local Plan Committee, item 21Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 4 – Local Green Spaces as he had taken part in the consultation both as a member of the public and a member of Ashby de-la-Zouch Town Council.
13 Nov 2019Local Plan Committee, item 17Councillor D Bigby declared a non-pecuniary interest in the item as he had responded to the consultation as a member of the public.
Hover a line for the full wording.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Bigby sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
Planning CommitteeCommittee MemberOct 2019758 Dec 2026
Local Plan CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20195325 Nov 2026
CouncilCommittee MemberMay 201941
Corporate Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20193010 Dec 2026
Community Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJul 2020133 Dec 2026
Audit and Governance CommitteeCommittee MemberJul 20199
CabinetObserverOct 20192
Licensing Sub CommitteeInterested PartyNov 20231
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies