Minutes of the Previous Meeting
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Windram and RESOLVED THAT:
Every time North West Leicestershire's minutes name Councillor Geary, as the council published it.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Windram and RESOLVED THAT:
The motion was seconded by Councillor J Geary .
It was moved by Councillor M Burke, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
They were moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor D Everitt and RESOLVED THAT:
They were moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor C Beck and RESOLVED THAT:
They were moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M Burke and RESOLVED THAT:
The motion was seconded by Councillor J Geary.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor L Windram, and RESOLVED THAT:
Question from Councillor J Geary “Employee Joint Consultative Committee Each year at the Annual Council Meeting we appoint 5 members to the Employee Joint Consultative Committee, yet to my knowledge this Committee has not met in the past few years.
Cllr Geary is accurate in saying the Committee has not met.
Councillor J Geary declined the opportunity to ask a supplementary question.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M Burke and RECOMMENDED THAT:
Question from Councillor J Geary “Had it not been for the prompt action of the local Police Force travellers would have set up camp on The Scotland’s Playing Field last month. Should they have succeeded this Authority would have once again incurred cost of evicting them along with the costs of cleaning up the site and repairing damage caused to the grounds.
Councillor J Geary, objector, addressed the Committee. He advised that he had been involved with the application due to the illness of the previous Ward Member. He was broadly in favour of the proposal as the site was surrounded by development on three sides and the design was pleasing but he was greatly concerned about congestion and road safety.
It was moved by Councillor M Burke, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest as the Council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor L Windram and RESOLVED THAT:
During the consideration and voting on the application, Councillor J Geary would join the Committee as a substitute for Councillor Sewell.
Councillor J Geary declared he had been lobbied once he had joined the meeting as a substitute for this item.
Councillor J Geary joined the Committee as a substitute and declared that he had been lobbied without influence on the item.
He noted that this application crossed two wards, and the Committee should regard his contribution as representing the views of Councillor J Geary as well. They welcomed the substantial investment although they noted that there was some scepticism amongst residents. The two Ward Members hoped landscaping would be well considered, and the two Members would also be clearly communicated with throughout the process.
Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest in all items as Director of the Springboard Centre and as the Council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor L Windram and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest in all items as Director of the Springboard Centre and as the council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M Wyatt and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
He also declared a registerable interest in item A2 – Application number 22/01811/FULM as he was speaking o the application as the adjoining Ward Member During the consideration of this application, Councillor J Geary would join the committee as a substitute for Councillor D Bigby.
During the consideration of this application, Councillor J Geary would join the committee as a substitute for Councillor D Bigby.
Councillor J Geary joined the Committee as his substitute.
Councillor J Geary remained in the Committee as his substitute.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary that Councillor M Wyatt be appointed as Chair of the Working Party.
Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest in all items as Director of the Springboard Centre and as the council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Legrys formally nominated Councillor J Geary as the representative on this body as he has been for many years.
b) The authority to appoint Councillor J Geary to the Coalville Town Football Club Committee be delegated to the Chief Executive.
Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest in item 12, General Fund Budget and Council Tax 2023/24 as a Council representative on Coalville Town Football Club, and item 15, Corporate Leadership Team Restructure as a lifetime member of the GMB Union.
The motion was seconded by Councillor J Geary.
Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest as Director of the Springboard Centre and as the council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor E Allman and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT: The budget available in 2023/24 for Coalville events be noted.
Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest as a supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and the Council’s appointed representative on the Coalville Town Football Club Committee.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary, ward member, made his representations and highlighted concerns around the extra traffic which would need to exit the site via Highfield Street.
Councillor J Geary questioned the efficacy and accuracy of the traffic count and also noted the report’s reference to “the narrow nature of Highfield Street”. With regard to existing homes on Highfield Street which would be provided parking should the development be approved, it was asserted that this would be at a financial cost to residents which would not necessarily be possible for all given the current economic climate.
Councillor J Geary suggested that this application be declined or deferred for further consideration.
Question by Councillor J Geary “How much have the costs to NWLDC been to clear sites up after traveller trespass?" Response by Councillor A Woodman Council services in the form of housing, car parking, street cleansing, parks and property have not historically collected this data but will be doing so henceforth starting with the most recent tresspass onto Council land at Silver Street Car Park. Listed below are the incidents over the past five years.
Date Site location 10 May 2018 Coalville Park London Road Coalville 24 Jun 2018 Greenhill Park Cropston Drive Coalville 30 Jun 2018 A511 Stephenson Way Coalville 31 Jul 2018 Recreation Ground Ashburton Road Hugglescote 02 Aug 2018 Hermitage Leisure Centre Silver St Whitwick 17 Oct 2018 Bridge Street Car Park Coalville 08 May 2019 Covert Place Albert Village 06 Jun 2019 Hermitage Leisure Centre and Recreation Ground Whitwick Coalville 08 Sep 2019 Bridge Road Car Park Coalville 10 Sep 2019 A5324 Ashby Road Long Whatton 12 Oct 2019 Bridge Road Car Park Coalville 21 Oct 2019 Car Park Cropston Drive Greenhill Coalville 25 Oct 2019 NWLDC Visitor Car Park London Road Coalville 13 Nov 2019 Bridge Street Car Park Coalville 14 Nov 2019 Cropston Drive Coalville 21 Nov 2019 Bridge Road Car Park Coalville 07 Jun 2020 Scotland’s Playing Fields Car Park Forest Road Coalville 17 Aug 2020 Hermitage Leisure Centre Silver St Whitwick 10 Sep 2020 Hermitage Leisure Centre Playing Fields Hermitage Road Whitwick 23 Dec 2020 Rear Car Park Covert Place Albert Village 06 May 2021 Garage Site Coronation Avenue Moira 14 Jun 2021 Recreation Ground Cropston Drive Coalville 05 Sep 2021 Waterworks Road Coalville 28 Oct 2022 Hermitage Leisure Centre Silver Street Whitwick Supplementary question and response Councillor Geary asked if it was possible for him to have the figures for the latest incident on Silver Street once they had been collated.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 14 June 2022 be confirmed as an accurate record of the proceedings.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor E Allman and RESOLVED THAT The 2021/22 Draft Outturn figures and Coalville Special Expense balances as at 31 March 2022 be noted.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor J Geary ... view the full minutes text for item 14.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 6 “Local Plan Review: Response to Consultation – Employment Policies” as a Director of the Springboard Centre.
Councillor J Geary asked officers how much of the unit space is currently unused or unoccupied and officers advised that as a district, the vacancy rate was below ‘normal’ averages. The meeting was informed that a certain amount of vacancy was positive as this allowed for movement and growth;
Councillor J Geary informed the meeting that the Springboard Centre had a waiting list for specific units and asked officers if the Centre had been considered as existing provision. Officers responded that it had been considered in the preparation of the evidence base and affirmed that there would be demand for this type of facility.
Councillor J Geary stated that he felt there was a need for more smaller industrial units but that few were available. Officers agreed to contact the authority’s Economic Development Team in order that the Springboard Centre can engage in a dialogue with them regarding the need for this type of provision.
During discussion on item 12 – Linden Way, Coalville – Highway Extension, Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest as a Director of the Springboard Centre that was located close to the site.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor C Benfield and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor T Eynon, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Hoult and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor A Black, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT Councillor M B Wyatt be appointed as Deputy Chair for the 2022/23 civic year.
Councillor J Geary declared registerable interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts, and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor A Black and RESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 27 April 2022 be confirmed as an accurate record of the proceedings.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:- 1) The progress update on the 2022/23 Capital Projects be noted 2) A report be brought back ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor J Geary declared registerable interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts, and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M Wyatt and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary requested a breakdown of the costings for the event and the importance of remaining within the authority’s financial means was reiterated.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary in item A1, application number 21/00596/FULM, as a Director of the Springboard Centre that was located close to the application site.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor R Morris and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary, ward member, addressed the committee highlighting the proposed service road at the back of Highfield Street, he felt it would not solve the on-street parking issues. It was also noted that the proposals did not provide off-street parking for every household on the street and this was imperative. He requested that any tree works undertaken be carried out by qualified tree surgeons and that any proposed boundary treatment discharge of condition submission be seen by himself as ward member before it was signed off.
Councillor Geary referred to restrictions which he felt may give way to developers manipulating figures to exempt them from their duty to provide charge points. He also felt that planning permission should not be granted where there is insufficient power to install charge points. The Chairman explained the difficulties faced by the Planning Committee in refusing planning applications on this ground where there are no objections from the energy companies.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT: - The response to the consultation on the as set out at appendix 1 to the report, be noted.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary seconded by Councillor J Hoult and RESOLVED THAT: - The contents of the report be noted.
Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts, and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M Wyatt and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor E Allman and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
Following a comment from Councillor J Geary on the future maintenance of the 20 trees that had been secured, once the 3 year maintenance had expired, it was noted that a budget was available from previous funding that had been secured for that reason.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor C Benfield and RESOLVED THAT:
The electoral ward of Thringstone to become a separate parished area with its own Parish Council.” The motion was seconded by Councillor J Geary.
He stated that he would take the point away for consideration It was moved by Councillor J Hoult, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary noted the large amount of industrial development that was taking place in the north of the district, which would employ staff on low wages, and the lack of affordable homes that were being built in those areas. He felt that when land was being earmarked for large employment development, land should also be earmarked for affordable housing for the employees. The Planning Policy and Land Charges Team Manager stated that the suggestion was one of the arguments in favour of a new settlement within the northern part of the district due to the continued economic growth in that area.
Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts, and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting.
Councillor Geary advised therefore that his ... view the full minutes text for item 14.
It was moved by Councillor J Hoult, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Clarke, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Clarke and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor M Wyatt, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT Councillor M French be appointed as Deputy Chairman for the 2021/22 civic year.
Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard centre, founder of Mantle Community Arts and a regular supporter of Coalvilel Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting.
It was seconded by Councillor J Geary.
Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any matters relating to them arise at the meeting.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M Wyatt and RESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 15 December 2020 be confirmed as an accurate record of the proceedings, subject to the inclusion of ‘and specifically at Bardon Road’ being added to the minutes under item 19.
It was moved by Councillor M Wyatt, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT The Coalville Special Expenses Working Party:
It was moved by Councillor M Wyatt, seconded by Councillor J Geary, and RESOLVED THAT The Working Party notes 1) The progress update on 2021/22 events 2) The opportunity for the 2022/23 event programme to include the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee Celebrations 3) The update for Christmas light installation procurement 4) The update for Needham’s Walk artwork 5) The progress update for 2020/21 Coalville Special Expenses Community Grant Scheme
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys, and RESOLVED THAT The Working Party note the contents of the report.
It was moved by Councillor M Wyatt, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT 1) The Working Party notes the monitoring options and costed plan.
It was seconded by Councillor J Geary. Following a point of order, the chairman retracted a statement in relation to voting on the proposed additional recommendation.
Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder of Mantle Community Arts and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor A Bridgen and RESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 13 October 2020 be confirmed as an accurate record of the proceedings.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M Wyatt and RESOLVED THAT The Working Party notes the progress update on 2020/21 events.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M B Wyatt and RECOMMENDED THAT CABINET:
Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests as a director of the Springboard Centre, Founder of Mantle Community Arts and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any matters relating to them arise at the meeting.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor A Bridgen and by affirmation of the meeting RESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 30 June 2020 be confirmed as an accurate record.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and by affirmation of the meeting RESOLVED THAT The Working Party notes the 2019/20 Final Outturn figures and the 2020/21 Period 3 Actuals and the forecast for the year.
Councillor J Geary noted that residents did not want any further development, however in the real world, it was not the case and the authority needed to start controlling what was required. He felt that many developments appeared to be ad ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
The Chairman invited Councillor J Geary to ask his question addressed to Councillor R Bayliss.
Councillor Geary expressed his concern that this level of tax-payers money was being held for improvements which were not being made. He asked whether anything could be done to help people with their travel arrangements in accessing medical facilities. He was advised that a case could be made although the monies were being held for health facilities rather than access to them.
Councillor Geary also asked what Section 106 monies were being held for reasons other than heath and he was advised that a report could be bought to a future meeting of the Committee setting this out.
The recommendation as set out on page 25 of the agenda was moved by Councillor Geary, seconded by Councillor Eynon and by affirmation of the meeting it was RESOLVED THAT :
It was moved by Councillor Geary, seconded by Councillor Eynon and by affirmation of the meeting RESOLVED THAT:
Councillors Legrys declared a non pecuniary interest in any items relating to the Town Centre given his role as a volunteer at Hermitage FM; and Councillor Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in any item which referred to the Springboard Centre given his role as a director there and also to any reference to Mantle Arts and Coalville Football Club given his role as a Council representative on these bodies. They both remained for the entirety of the meeting.
By affirmation of the meeting, the minutes of the meeting held on 17 December 2019 be approved as a correct record subject to a minor amendment to show that Councillor Geary moved the minutes of the previous meeting.
Councillor Geary fully supported this view and asked that conversations not be held with the developer until their intentions for the site were fully understood. With reference to Remembrance 2020, he asked for clarification on the references in the report to plans A, B and C. The Cultural Services Team Manager advised that Plan A – life is normal and the delivery of the event would be as previously, Plan B – dependant on guidance on the lockdown position and ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Geary added that Thringstone once had a prime football club within Leicestershire which had rapidly declined and he had been following the circumstances around this very closely over the past few years and he urged caution on the provision of funding until they could prove beyond all reasonable doubt that they were capable of running a stable organisation. The Leisure Services Team Manager assured Members that the Club had now left the site and had no involvement whatsoever, so any funding would go to the Trustees and any resident clubs who would oversee any projects.
Before the close of the meeting, Councillor Geary reported that during the lockdown period, the Owen Street Pavilion had been refurbished from top to bottom at the Football Club’s expense which was welcome news. He also asked whether there would be any further meetings of the Events Sub Group before the end of the year. It was acknowledged that a date had been agreed for a meeting on 16 September at 5pm.
Councillor Geary asked if he could attend and was advised he would be welcome.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10.1 – Motions, as a qualified pyro-technician with experience in fireworks and firework displays.
Councillor Geary reported his dismay at his view of the site during a recent visit. He likened it to a refugee camp and argued that the Council should never have allowed it to get into such a state. [name removed] advised that he could not argue with this view and repeated that he was not proud of this site but that we were now moving forwards to do something about it.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest as a trustee of the newly formed Snibston Heritage Trust.
Councillor J Geary, Ward Member, addressed the committee highlighting that in principle he supported development on the site, however he had concerns over a number of issues with the application before the committee.
A motion to permit the application subject to an additional condition to install at least two car-charging points was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor J Geary.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 6 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club, a founder member of Mantle Lane Art and a Director for the Springboard Centre.
Councillor J Geary requested that Coalville in Bloom be placed on the next agenda as an item rather than be included in the update report.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M B Wyatt and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary commented on the artificial tree structure made out of lights in Hugglecote as it was very nice. He suggested that this kind of alternative be looked into for Marlborough Square in future, as the tree was disappointing this year.
Regarding the future events programme, Councillor J Geary suggested a Halloween event as he had seen a great community celebration on a recent holiday. He believed this would take young people away from knocking on doors and celebrating all together as a community. A number of Members supported this suggestion and put forward Coalville Park as a suitable venue.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
At the conclusion of the item, at 7.45pm, Councillor J Geary left the meeting. ... view the full minutes text for item 19.
Councillor J Geary, Ward Member, addressed the committee raising concerns in relation to the highway problems and the lack of an objection from the County Highway Authority, even though further consultation had taken place following the deferral of the application at the previous meeting. As the District Council were aware of the serious nature of the incidents that occurred on Belvoir Road, he questioned the authority’s duty and the possibility of negligence should further incidents occur if the application was permitted.
Councillor J Geary, Ward Member, addressed the committee highlighting the highway issues in the area. He also stated that the applicant had been serving hot food takeaway since the original permission had been granted, therefore the application in front of Members was a retrospective one. As such he expressed concerns, as the applicant might not adhere to any planning conditions imposed.
Councillor J Geary was disappointed that air quality was not being measured throughout the whole district. He particularly liked the DEFRA website demonstrated by [name removed] where you could see the air quality hotspots and asked for the link to be shared with Members.
The Chairman invited Councillor J Geary to ask his question addressed to Councillor R Ashman.
It is anticipated that a draft plan will be published in 2020 which will identify potential sites.” The Chairman invited Councillor J Geary to ask a supplementary question.
Councillor J Geary’s supplementary question was “As Portfolio Holder, can you guarantee that a site will be found in 2020 and planning permission applied for?” Councillor R Ashman thanked Councillor J Geary for the question and stated that he could not guarantee, however he said that it would be dealt with and viable sites would be put before the Local Plan Committee in 2020. He stated that whatever route was taken it would have to be dealt with very carefully. Anything put before the Local Plan Committee would be for a temporary site.
Councillor J Geary gave a brief history as to why the topic was put onto the work programme a few years ago and thanked [name removed] for his attendance.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, [name removed] provided information on the long-term aspiration to use hydrogen gas rather that methane.
Councillor J Geary made a statement on his opinion of the police force and that he did not believe it to be a deterrent any more. Sergeant Jon Sharpe provided information ... view the full minutes text for item 15.
Councillor J Geary asked that Public Transport be considered, as there was a lack in bus services, which was particularly effecting older people.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club, a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts and a Director for the Springboard Centre.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor E Allman and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary in relation to the use of funding and the ongoing maintenance costs, the Leisure Services Team Manager advised that the S106 money must be used on the park but felt that the concern was valid as the amount to deliver the project was great.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 19/00141/OUTM, as he had seen photos of flooding in the area and had been to visit the site. He further declared that he had come to the meeting with an open mind.
A motion to permit the application in accordance with the officer’s recommendation was moved by Councillor D Harrison and seconded by Councillor J Geary.
Councillor J Geary, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He highlighted that there would be no concerns if both properties were residential or the northern property was a retail unit. The issue was with a hot food takeaway which would generate noise and fumes and users of the business would park on the double yellow lines in front of the building causing a disruption to the neighbouring residents; therefore contrary to policy D2.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club, a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts and a Director for the Springboard Centre.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M B Wyatt and RESOLVED THAT:
Following a question from Councillor J Geary, Councillor M B Wyatt stressed that the idea was to hire the decorations not to purchase. He added that if they were a success then it could be budgeted for in future years. RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary expressed concerns regarding the significant increase in anti-social behaviour and asked if there had been any damage to the play equipment. The Head of Economic Regeneration explained that the anti-social behaviour was mainly related to the consumption of alcohol on the park, which had resulted in broken glass, and graffiti on the equipment. Officers were working with the Safer Stronger Communities team and the police to mitigate the issues.
Councillor J Geary requested a site visit for Members. It was agreed for the Leisure Services Team Manager to arrange.
It was seconded by Councillor J Geary.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Clarke and RESOLVED THAT:
Regarding the ‘Gas Supply in Rural Areas’ item on the work programme, Councillor J Geary expressed his disappointment that it had been on the agenda for a number of years and a representative from Cadent had still not attended. The Strategic Director of Place explained that Cadent had been invited to many meetings now but with no success. He added that it was difficult to force a company to attend a meeting but would persevere if members requested it.
Councillor J Geary, ward member, addressed the meeting. He expressed concerns regarding the adequacy of the noise insulation and fire risk insulation, and the checks that would be made following completion of the works. He noted that the extractor unit had already been fitted and had been cemented to the wall which would cause vibration in the wall.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts, and in any reference to the Springboard Centre as a director.
Councillor J Geary, ward member, addressed the meeting. He expressed concerns that the parking provision was not sufficient and questioned the number of parking spaces suggested by the Highway Authority. He also expressed concerns regarding the rights of access over the land, flooding, drainage and lighting issues.
Councillor J Geary emphasised the importance of the Snibston mine site, which was a world heritage ... view the full minutes text for item 55.
Councillor J Geary raised concerns that once the land at Cropston Drive had been sold to fund the leisure project there would be no remaining council owned land to fall back on if funds were required elsewhere in the future. He was also disappointed that the land was not being used for much needed council housing. The Portfolio Holder believed it was better to maximise the value of the land by selling it and funding capital projects.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, the Strategic Director of Housing Customer Services explained that the laundry room service charges had been increased, as they had been very low for some time and previously did not recover the costs being incurred. He added that new equipment had been installed and a consultation carried out with the users indicated that they were willing to pay the increase in charges for improved facilities.
Councillor J Geary did not agree with the increase in shop leases at a time when the Council should be encouraging small businesses to remain open. The Portfolio Holder stated that the increase was to gradually bring the charges in line with the market rate. The Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services added that the leases had been frozen at the previous rate for decades and was not near the market rate.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, the Head of Finance agreed to provide further information regarding the cost of Owen Street football floodlights and how it was to be funded.
It was moved by Councillor M Specht, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts, and in any reference to the Springboard Centre as a director.
Councillor J Geary agreed that the Bardon area could do with being enhanced and requested that proposals be brought to a future meeting.
Councillor J Geary put the following question to Councillor T J Pendleton:
As a supplementary question, Councillor J Geary requested an estimated timescale for the needs assessment and details of the 500 sites which had already been considered.
Councillor J Geary referred to the universal increases in commuting times. He emphasised the need to put infrastructure in place before development to ensure the situation did not get any worse.
Councillor J Geary welcomed his involvement in the cross-party working group and commented that many of the points he had raised had been taken on board. He was pleased to see how much progress had been made but expressed concern regarding the postponement of the next meeting as he felt it was important to maintain the momentum.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 18/00705/VCUM, as he had attended a site visit with the Ward Member prior to the meeting and item A3, application number 18/00819/FUL, as a member of the Sealed Knot, who had recently used the Rugby Club as a campsite for a recent event.
Councillor J Geary, Ward Member, questioned the substantial parking at the premises as he believed that the conditions as part of the planning permission allowed spaces for the bed and breakfast guests, not the restaurant. He advised the applicant to confirm this with the Planning Department. The Legal Advisor stated that it was for the applicant to ensure that the proper permissions were in place and therefore agreed it was in his best interests to confirm the matter with ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor J Geary, ward member, addressed the meeting. He expressed concerns regarding the lack of a turning head, the vehicle activated sign which had not yet been provided, and previous conditions which had not been met relating to parking spaces. He referred to a recent care home application which was refused due to lack of parking provision.
Councillor R Adams asked that Councillor J Geary be notified of the consultation as Chairman of the Coalville Special Expenses Working Party.
Councillor J Legrys moved that Councillor J Geary be appointed as Chairman for the ensuing year.
Councillor J Geary be appointed as Chairman for the ensuing year.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 8 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
Councillor J Geary felt it was fair to say that over the last few months, planning had failed to deliver the excellent service members hoped for. He added that behaviour and relationships required urgent attention and the general consensus of members of the public was that the Planning Committee was not fit for purpose. He felt however that the peer challenge would go a long way towards addressing these problems.
Councillor J Geary moved that CCTV provision be secured by a condition to ensure that this was in place and monitored before the site was opened up.
Councillor J Geary declared a no-pecuniary interest in item 5 – End of Year Performance Report as a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
Councillor J Geary made the following comments:
In relation to the ‘Gas Supply in Rural Areas’ item which had once again been deferred to the next meeting, the Chairman asked if Councillor J Geary could undertake a canvass of the area so that it was clearer who would be interested in a gas supply.
Councillor J Geary responded that this had already been undertaken and 97 percent of residents would like a gas supply. He also expressed his disappointment in the amount of time this item had been on the work programme. The Director of Housing and Customer Services explained that with regard to infrastructure providers such as Cadent Gas Ltd (formerly Transco), the information he had received was that they would charge an individual household a considerable amount of money to run a gas supply to the property.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in 7 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
It was moved by Councillor M B Wyatt, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor N Clarke, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys , seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7, Draft Capital Programmes 2018/19 – 2022/23 as it referred to Owen Street Recreation Ground, which he visited regularly as a supporter of Coalville Town Football Club.
Councillor J Geary referred to the forecast reduction in CCTV income and asked for further details as to why this was. The Financial Planning Team Manager agreed to provide the information outside of the meeting.
Regarding the Housing Revenue Account rent budgets, Councillor J Geary asked why only 58 percent of properties were at their target rent at the end of October 2017. The Director of Housing explained that when rent targets were introduced nationally, the Council decided to maintain rent at a lower level rather than making increases as other local authorities had, this meant that NWLDC was behind with targets. Now that the Government has stopped local authorities from increasing rent, NWLDC were unable to close the gap.
Councillor J Geary questioned why money was being put aside to make improvements to plumbing that was still running at Hermitage Leisure Centre when it has been agreed to build a new leisure facility. The Director of Housing explained that the pipework and tank referred to would not be replaced whilst it was still operational but as it was coming to the end of its lifespan, it was necessary to budget for replacement in case it was required.
Councillor J Geary enjoyed reading the report and all the detail included.
In reference to the redundant toilet block on Mantle Lane, Councillor J Geary reported that it had been broken into and hoped it would be fixed later in the week. He was also disappointed that there were so many negative comments in the young person survey as it was a shame to see that enthusiasm in the young had disappeared.
Regarding the number of homes to be built per year, Councillor J Geary asked how many would be affordable homes, as Section 106 Agreements were often made by the developers regarding numbers and then not delivered. The Head of Planning and Regeneration explained that the target for affordable homes would be calculated and set by the Local Plan, and that the Strategic Growth Plan was intended to address how many new homes and jobs were expected to be needed between 2031 and 2050, and where best to build them, but not local detail.
Councillor J Geary commented that there was still no mention of re-using the Coalville to Burton railway line for mass transit, which was a shame as he felt it was needed. The Head of Planning and Regeneration explained that the consultation was a good opportunity to raise these type of comments, and noted that the Local Plan did support this in principle, if suitable proposals were to come forward, this would be fed back as he was aware it was a local aspiration.
Councillor J Geary stated that the Labour Party had always been in favour of strong and meaningful scrutiny. He expressed concerns in respect of the call-in arrangements which allowed a maximum of 4 call-ins per year and prevented a member from signing a further call-in request for a period of 3 months. He understood that the reason for these restrictions were to prevent abuse of the call-in process, however there had been no record of this taking place.
He referred to the point raised by Councillor J Geary in respect of the restrictions on call-in and said that he was not aware of a reason for these restrictions.
It was moved by Councillor M Specht, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
The Interim Director of Resources presented the report to Members highlighting the regular meetings with the Chairman and Councillor J Geary as the Labour Group’s scrutiny lead representative, the scoping report and proposed changes to the meeting schedule.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, the Deputy Monitoring Officer reported that there was a contracts register which was available for public viewing.
Councillor J Geary expressed concerns regarding the proposed changes to small contracts as he felt that obtaining three quotes was important to ensure that the Council was getting value for money. The Deputy Monitoring Officer explained that officers would still seek value for money, the change was intended to reduce the amount of unnecessary paperwork and give responsibility to officers.
He assured Councillor J Geary that the appropriate checks would still be undertaken through the purchase order system and the finance team would also be monitoring.
Councillor J Geary still believed a formal record of quotes obtained should be kept to ensure value for money.
Councillor J Geary drew officers’ attention to paragraph 13.1 on page 64 of the report as it was not gender neutral because of a reference to ‘her’. The Deputy Monitoring Officer acknowledged it and would make the amendment.
Councillor J Geary asked what the situation was with the attendance of a representative from the gas supplier to rural areas item as it had been on the work plan for many months. The Interim Head of Resources explained that he had been let down by the representative as they had been scheduled to attend for the last two meetings. He informed Members that he had made contact with the agency to express his disappointment and it was scheduled for the meeting in January.
Councillor R Adams moved that Councillor J Geary be appointed as Chairman for the ensuing year.
Councillor J Geary be appointed as the Chairman for the ensuing year.
Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 7 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
At this point discussion was had regarding Mantle Lane Arts and therefore due to his non procuniary interest, Councillor J Geary left the meeting.
Councillor J Geary returned to the meeting and to the Chair.
Councillor J Geary commented that there were areas within the District that were totally reliant on solid fuel heating and asked how this would impact on the air quality. [name removed] responded that it would have an impact but explained that there were options to improve such as installing a stove rather than an open fire.
Councillor J Geary commented that in the past every application was considered by the Planning Committee and therefore was more open and transparent. He acknowledged that delegating decisions to officers was designed to speed up the process but as the authority was currently exceeding national targets, he was unsure as to whether it was necessary. He was fully aware of which planning agent the proposals were aimed at and the fact that he was married to a previous District Councillor, however he still had connections to the authority through his brother in law.
Councillor J Geary also raised concerns regarding the proposed change in quorum for the Planning Committee as he believed it should be at least a third of the committee, which was in line with other committees. He was against the call-in of applications being restricted to the Ward Member as applications could be missed due to single Member Wards, especially as the call-in period was only five days. He felt this was not long enough.
Councillor J Geary felt that each year Councillors were being excluded more from the decision making process and he was bitterly disappointed with the report. The Head of Planning and Regeneration acknowledged that the authority did exceed national targets but he felt there was always room for improvements. He stated that the aim of the report was to have the right applications considered by Planning Committee.
Councillor J Geary reiterated the comments of Councillor T Eynon and requested that officers also consider the addition of more meetings in the schedule to ease the size of the agendas, as well as ensuring two large agenda meetings were not on consecutive evenings.
Councillor J Geary welcomed the private sector housing stock survey as he felt it was important to understand the condition of all housing stock. He thanked the Council for taking this initiative. He made reference to the scheme to replace solid fuel heating in non-gas areas and he hoped the advice would be made available to the private sector once the best solution was known.
Councillor J Geary commented that there were many crimes committed which did not get reported. He felt that elected members should be represented on the partnership to perform a scrutiny function and he gave an example highlighting the importance of receiving feedback from the grass roots.
Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 4 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
Councillor J Geary put the following question to Councillor A V Smith:
Councillor J Geary thanked Councillor T Eynon for raising the item for Member discussion. He expressed concerns that the meetings were time limited and speaking to the groups could take up a large part of the meeting, also that the possibility of being invited in to speak to Members may put off some applicants. The Interim Director of Resources believed that a restriction of 10 minutes for group presentations would be manageable within the current work plan.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, the Head of Community Services reported that there was approximately 40 small grants awarded each year.
Councillor J Geary referred to the management of complaints at section five of the policy and suggested that the timeframe specified should be ‘3 working days’ rather than ‘earliest possible time’ as he believed it was too loose. It would also then be aligned with other timeframes specified within the policy. The Head of Housing was happy to put the change to Cabinet when the policy was considered.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, the Head of Housing advised that the appropriate support agencies referred to in section 3.5 of the report in relation to vulnerable tenants were a Nottingham Community HA Support Service as well as housing officers. There was also specialist support available from other agencies.
Councillor J Geary questioned the contradicting comments that crime rates had fallen when the matrix within the report indicated that they had increased. The Stronger and Safer Communities Team Manager explained that overall crime rates had decreased even though in some individual areas there had been an increase.
Councillor J Geary asked how officers were planning on engaging within communities as stated in the report. The Stronger and Safer Communities Team Manager commented that it was an area he was working to improve as he also wanted to include feedback from young people. He explained that the Community Focus Team engaged with the community in a number of ways and another channel of engagement was the regular Parish Liaison meetings.
It was moved by Councillor M Specht, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary believed that the current state of the highways in the district was appalling. He commented that the road gully pot drainage was not working correctly as grass was often growing from them and even a tree from one that he was aware of. This lack of drainage caused flooding and in turn was dangerous for road users.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor J Legrys and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
It was moved by Councillor D Harrison, seconded by Councillor J Geary and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 4 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
Councillor J Geary clarified that in respect of Capital Projects Update, he had requested the details of the model of the timer due to the costly quotation. The Head of Community Services advised that three quotations had been obtained and a significantly reduced price had been secured after following this up.
Councillor J Geary advised that in respect of the mobile activated signage, the meeting with representatives in December had been cancelled and the rescheduled meeting date was Friday, 13 January.
This proposal was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor J Geary.
Councillor J Geary reminded members that this suggestion had not been consulted upon.
Councillor J Geary expressed concerns in respect of the consultation process and relayed problems he had experienced with logging on to cast his vote.
Councillor J Geary thanked Councillor M B Wyatt for his comments which he felt should be taken into consideration.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, the Head of Community Services advised that the reduced income from Broomleys Cemetery was not due to an increase in cremations. The Head of Community Services advised that the draft budget for the 2017/18 financial year was balanced and highlighted the note in respect of the assumed Council Tax base increase which would provide additional funding to the Special Expenses budget. He added that the exact figure was not yet known and an update would be provided at the next meeting.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor M Specht and RESOLVED THAT:
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, the Licensing Team Leader confirmed that drivers were not asked to present the vehicle service history.
Councillor J Geary commented that the Council were committed to ensuring the public were safe when travelling in licensed vehicles and he was concerned with some of the comments received from drivers as he felt there was some reluctance to use garages for inspections. He was alarmed as modern cars required special diagnostics due to the electronics and if drivers were inspecting for faults themselves without the appropriate equipment the car could become very dangerous for passengers. He believed that in the future officers needed to look at ensuring drivers regularly serviced their vehicles.
Councillor J Geary also expressed concerns regarding licensing older vehicles as he felt they could not withstand a collision like newer models and he believed if they were too old they were not fit for purpose.
Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 4 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
Councillor J Geary asked whether the Picnic/Proms in the Park had come in under budget.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, officers advised Members that it was intended to take the names to the schools for consideration and add any new ones that the pupils may come up with and it may be possible to bring the proposed names back to the next meeting.
Councillor J Geary expressed that it would be a shame if the new signage would not be in place until next summer at the earliest.
Councillor J Geary expressed concerns over the cost of the timers and asked officers to ensure that the best quote was found.
Councillor J Geary, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He advised Members that the residents had no objection to the applications in principle but favoured the proposal that included the shop as it was a densely populated area and the nearest shops required a car journey. He raised concerns over the demolition of the existing buildings and subsequent noise and dust from the crushing and felt that it should be done off site adding that he was pleased to see the additional condition in the update sheet.
Councillor J Geary expressed his concern that Members had only had a short amount of time to scrutinise the full and comprehensive draft strategy document as it was not available when the agenda was circulated. He also referred to a mistake at paragraph 4.7 as it referred to Ashby when it should be Whitwick, he expressed his disappointment as it made him question the accuracy of the document as a whole. He went on to make the following comments:
Councillor J Geary strongly disagreed with the statement as when the decision was made to introduce parking charges, when he was a Member of the Cabinet; it was to raise funds to maintain the parking facilities and was never meant to provide added income towards schemes and services.
Councillor J Geary agreed and was in favour of anything that could be done to help local businesses flourish.
Councillor J Geary agreed with the statement.
Councillor J Geary agreed that there was a lower level of public transport available which was constantly diminishing; he believed this would be a problem for the future.
Councillor J Geary reported that from his experience the public were not in support due to the loss of parking spaces, shops and the public house. He also felt that any development would detract from Stenson House. Paragraph 3.1.2 – This paragraph referred to the parking charges currently being at the lower end of the range of parking tariffs amongst comparator neighbouring authorities.
Councillor J Geary did not agree as according to his calculations, North West Leicestershire was towards the middle of the range. He did agree that coach parking spaces were needed.
Councillor J Geary noted that the car parking at the council offices was not included and ... view the full minutes text for item 12.
Councillor J Geary thanked the Housing Portfolio Holder for attending to listen to the Committee’s comments. He was very pleased that council houses were being built and that the residents who would be using the community centre at Linford Crescent and Verdon Crescent were being consulted. He felt strongly that the Right to Buy Scheme had contributed to the lower number of council houses now available and asked if the new builds would be protected against it.
Councillor J Geary expressed concerns that by allowing the sale of land, then there would be no where to build new homes in the future.
Councillor M Specht moved that Councillor J Geary be appointed as Chairman for the ensuing year.
Councillor J Geary be appointed as the Chairman for the ensuing year.
Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 7 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts.
Councillor J Geary corrected [name removed] statement that he had publicly stated that he was opposed to the application. He explained that when the plans were first submitted, he did show concern at the close proximity to neighbouring dwellings and these concerns had been addressed. He added that he had no objection in principle to development on this site, however he expressed concerns about the proposals casting a shadow over existing houses in the late afternoon.
He also explained that after discussion with the Labour Group Leader, it was decided to appoint Councillor J Geary as their Scrutiny Lead Member, who would work with the Chairman and the Interim Director of Resources to move things forward.
Councillor J Geary explained that he raised the issue at the previous meeting because he had read an article about the role of scrutiny and it referred to it as being ‘a talking shop’ and ‘toothless’. He felt that it sounded familiar and that the Cabinet did not listen to the views of the Committee. He gave a number of examples of matters that he believed should have been scrutinised but were missed including the closure of Snibston Discovery Park and the Council Offices move that did not occur.
Councillor R Blunt stressed that the article Councillor J Geary mentioned did not refer to North West Leicestershire. He valued the time committed by Members to scrutiny and agreed that issues such as Snibston Discovery Park should have been scrutinised. He added that if there was a particular issue that Members would like further information on, for example the proposed office move that did not come into fruition, he was happy for Members to contact him for further discussion and any information he could share, he would.
Following on from the discussion earlier in the meeting regarding the plans for installing a gas supply into the rural areas of the district, Councillor J Geary requested that the appropriate representative be invited to the next meeting of the group. This was to allow further discussion on any plans for connection, the costs involved and the process to be aware of.
Councillor J Geary stated that in principle he had no problem with the development however he raised concerns over the size of the play areas.
Councillor J Geary expressed concerns that there was to be only 7.6% affordable housing on the sites, which equated to 21 out of 275 homes and the Council had a policy of 20% affordable homes. He insisted that in future the Council ensured that the 20% was upheld, adding that housing requirement was need not greed.
Councillor J Geary declared non pecuniary interests in item 5 – Capital projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC, a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts and a member of Leicestershire and Rutland Playing Field Association Councillor J Legrys declared a non pecuniary interest in any reference to Hermitage FM due to his involvement with the organisation.
Councillor J Geary stated that the firework display was a scheduled event with wide publicity therefore residents knew when it was taking place.
Councillor J Geary stated that he had driven to the site, noticed that there was no signage and agreed that it should be a priority. He felt that the new name should include Coalville along with either Forest or Woodland.
Councillor M Specht agreed with Councillor J Geary that signage was required and to promote the site for family activities a basic requirement of running water was needed.
Councillor J Geary ... view the full minutes text for item 30.
Following a question from Councillor J Geary, the Head of Community Services advised that the reduced salaries may have been due to no appointment being made to a vacant position, but that would need to be confirmed.
Councillor J Geary noted that for contracts under £1,000, only a verbal quotation was required. He questioned whether this was good practice not to ensure a paper trail. He added that he did not consider it to be too onerous to obtain a written quotation even if this was via email.
Councillor J Geary commented that if tradespeople did not respond to tenders, they should be removed from the approved traders list.
Councillor J Geary stated that he felt scrutiny was toothless, positive recommendations were seldom made, and were not acted upon when they were made. He felt that members did not have the change to scrutinise things that concerned them. He felt that as a matter of importance, the way scrutiny was run in this authority should be scrutinised.
Councillor J Geary made reference to the recent changes to the Constitution. He stated that Policy Development Group had highlighted references to Ward Members and requested that the plural be deleted to reflect the current single member wards. He added that when the report was considered by Council, the plural form was still included, highlighting that the comments were not listened to.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary, seconded by Councillor A C Saffell and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor J Geary agreed that the existing development had greatly enhanced the village, that it was well laid out, a good design and in general there was no objection, however he could not support a development that could not contribute towards affordable housing.
Following a question from Councillor J Geary, the Planning and Development Team Manager advised that there were no limitations on the goods that could be sold in the farm shop and that there were no conditions restricting the shop.
Councillor J Geary felt that the shop would be an asset to the village.
In response to a request from Councillor J Geary, the Chief Executive assured Members that the planning service would stay within the District Council and Section 106 money would be ring fenced for the area.
In response to a further question from Councillor J Geary, the Chief Executive explained that the Planning Sub Committee referred to within the report was already in existence as the Members Advisory Group. It would ultimately work towards the growth plan and is made ... view the full minutes text for item 23.
In response to a question from Councillor J Geary, the Director of Housing explained that there were currently six business rental properties and as there had been no increase in rent for the last 12 to 15 years, an agreement had been made with the business owners for an incremental increase as detailed within the report.
Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 4 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC.
Councillor J Geary informed Members that Councillor M B Wyatt had advised that a visit would be arranged for May 2016 when the weather improved.
Councillor R Johnson moved the nomination for Councillor J Geary.
He thanked Councillor A V Smith for withdrawing her nomination and added that Councillor J Geary would be a good representative as he was well known in the town.
Councillor J Geary be appointed as the Council’s representative to the Coalville Town Football Club Committee.
Councillor J Geary declared a disclosable non pecuniary interest in Item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC.
Councillor J Geary commented that a visit to Broom Leys Allotments had still not been arranged, despite the suggestion at the last meeting that an open day would be held in September.
Councillor J Geary thanked Members for contributing to the sub groups that had been held since the last meeting. He referred to comments made at a recent Cabinet meeting where the number of sub groups that the Working Party had formed had been criticised. He countered that the sub groups were an effective way in which to conduct Working Party business.
It was explained by Councillor J Geary that, at a higher level of football, there was a greater media presence that required brighter lighting for their equipment.
Councillor J Geary, as Chairman of the Working Party, agreed to a request from Councillor M B Wyatt for an additional item to be discussed at the meeting regarding the public consultation that the combined fire authority was undertaking and specifically the changes that were being proposed for Coalville Fire Station.
Showing the latest 300 of 374.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Geary attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 27 Apr 2022 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party | Draft Schedule of Meetings 2022/23 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Nov 2021 | Council | Motions | Lost | 14 for, 21 against, 1 abstained | |
| 16 Mar 2021 | Council | Update on Establishment of Company to be known as 'EM DEVCO Limited' | Carried | 31 for, 4 against | |
| 16 Mar 2021 | Council | North West Leicestershire Local Plan Partial Review - Proposed Adoption | Carried | 32 for, 4 against | |
| 17 Nov 2020 | Council | Council Delivery Plan 2020/21 | Carried | 19 for, 4 against, 12 abstained | |
| 17 Nov 2020 | Council | Establishment of Company to be Known as 'EM DEVCO LIMITED' | Carried | 30 for, 4 against | |
| 8 Sep 2020 | Council | Allocation of Seats on Committees (Political Balance) | Carried | 31 for, 4 against | |
| 31 Jan 2017 | Planning Committee | 16/01059/OUT: Demolition of farm buildings and erection of five detached dwellings (outline with access and layout included) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Jun 2015 | Council | Leader's and Portfolio Holders' Announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Apr 2015 | Planning Committee | 15/01103/FUL: Proposed Conversion of attached outbuilding to form one residential dwelling | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Apr 2015 | Planning Committee | 15/00033/FUL: Erection of a single storey front extension | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Mar 2015 | Planning Committee | 14/00991/FULM: Erection of seventeen affordable dwellings, with access on to Wyggeston Road and North Avenue, associated groundworks and landscaping | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00898/FUL: Demolition of existing bungalow and the erection of three two storey dwellings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00862/FULM: Temporary change of use of land from agriculture to a solar farm with continued agriculture and associated infrastructure | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00934/FUL: Two storey side extension consisting of a residential annexe | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Sep 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00251/OUTM - Erection of 12 dwellings (Outline access and layout included for determination) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Sep 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00244/OUTM - Erection of 29 dwellings with new access, woodland planting and landscaping (Outline - Access included) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Sep 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00408/FULM - Installation of a 7.99MWp solar farm and associated infrastructure | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Sep 2014 | Planning Committee | Receipt of Advice in Respect of Application 12/00922/OUTM | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Aug 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00450/FUL - Proposed new clubhouse and changing room | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Nov 2013 | Cabinet | Minutes of the Coalville Special Expenses Working Party | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Geary was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 8 of 10 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Geary declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Dec 2023 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 20 | Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest as the Council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club. | |
| 5 Dec 2023 | Planning Committee, item 45 | Councillor J Geary declared he had been lobbied once he had joined the meeting as a substitute for this item. | |
| 10 Oct 2023 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 15 | Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest in all items as Director of the Springboard Centre and as the Council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club. | |
| 15 Aug 2023 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 10 | Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest in all items as Director of the Springboard Centre and as the council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club. | |
| 13 Jun 2023 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 4 | Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest in all items as Director of the Springboard Centre and as the council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club. | |
| 23 Feb 2023 | Council, item 45 | Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest in item 12, General Fund Budget and Council Tax 2023/24 as a Council representative on Coalville Town Football Club, and item 15, Corporate Leadership Team Restructure as a lifetime member of the GMB Union. | |
| 14 Feb 2023 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 29 | Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest as Director of the Springboard Centre and as the council’s representative for Coalville Town Football Club. | |
| 24 Jan 2023 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 25 | Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest as a supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and the Council’s appointed representative on the Coalville Town Football Club Committee. | |
| 27 Sep 2022 | Local Plan Committee, item 12 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 6 “Local Plan Review: Response to Consultation – Employment Policies” as a Director of the Springboard Centre. | |
| 29 Jun 2022 | Community Scrutiny Committee, item 41 | During discussion on item 12 – Linden Way, Coalville – Highway Extension, Councillor J Geary declared a registerable interest as a Director of the Springboard Centre that was located close to the site. | |
| 14 Jun 2022 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 4 | Councillor J Geary declared registerable interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts, and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting. | |
| 27 Apr 2022 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 24 | Councillor J Geary declared registerable interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts, and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting. | |
| 8 Mar 2022 | Planning Committee, item 59 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary in item A1, application number 21/00596/FULM, as a Director of the Springboard Centre that was located close to the application site. | |
| 14 Dec 2021 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 17 | Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts, and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting. | |
| 12 Oct 2021 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 11 | Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts, and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting. | |
| 15 Jun 2021 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 4 | Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard centre, founder of Mantle Community Arts and a regular supporter of Coalvilel Town Football Club should any reference to them arise at the meeting. | |
| 20 Apr 2021 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 23 | Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder member of Mantle Community Arts and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any matters relating to them arise at the meeting. | |
| 15 Dec 2020 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 16 | Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests in all items as a director of the Springboard Centre, founder of Mantle Community Arts and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club. | |
| 13 Oct 2020 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 10 | Councillor J Geary declared non-pecuniary interests as a director of the Springboard Centre, Founder of Mantle Community Arts and supporter of Coalville Town Football Club should any matters relating to them arise at the meeting. | |
| 30 Jun 2020 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 4 | Councillors Legrys declared a non pecuniary interest in any items relating to the Town Centre given his role as a volunteer at Hermitage FM; and Councillor Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in any item which referred to the Springboard Centre given his role as a director there and also to any reference to Mantle Arts and Coalville Football Club given his role as a Council representative on these bodies. They both remained for the entirety of the meeting. | Stayed and took part |
| 23 Jun 2020 | Council, item 2 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10.1 – Motions, as a qualified pyro-technician with experience in fireworks and firework displays. | |
| 25 Feb 2020 | Council, item 57 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest as a trustee of the newly formed Snibston Heritage Trust. | |
| 17 Dec 2019 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 16 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 6 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club, a founder member of Mantle Lane Art and a Director for the Springboard Centre. | |
| 22 Oct 2019 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 10 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club, a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts and a Director for the Springboard Centre. | |
| 1 Oct 2019 | Planning Committee, item 29 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 19/00141/OUTM, as he had seen photos of flooding in the area and had been to visit the site. He further declared that he had come to the meeting with an open mind. | |
| 11 Jun 2019 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 4 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club, a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts and a Director for the Springboard Centre. | |
| 3 Apr 2019 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 24 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts, and in any reference to the Springboard Centre as a director. | |
| 18 Dec 2018 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 18 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts, and in any reference to the Springboard Centre as a director. | |
| 16 Oct 2018 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 12 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 4 Sep 2018 | Planning Committee, item 17 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A1, application number 18/00705/VCUM, as he had attended a site visit with the Ward Member prior to the meeting and item A3, application number 18/00819/FUL, as a member of the Sealed Knot, who had recently used the Rugby Club as a campsite for a recent event. | |
| 19 Jun 2018 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 4 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 8 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 8 May 2018 | Policy Development Group, item 46 | Councillor J Geary declared a no-pecuniary interest in item 5 – End of Year Performance Report as a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 24 Apr 2018 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 24 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in 7 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 11 Jan 2018 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 18 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 10 Jan 2018 | Policy Development Group, item 27 | Councillor J Geary declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7, Draft Capital Programmes 2018/19 – 2022/23 as it referred to Owen Street Recreation Ground, which he visited regularly as a supporter of Coalville Town Football Club. | |
| 10 Oct 2017 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 11 | Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town Football Club and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 11 Jul 2017 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 3 | Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 7 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 25 Apr 2017 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 24 | Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 4 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 15 Dec 2016 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 18 | Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 4 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 13 Oct 2016 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 11 | Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 4 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 7 Jul 2016 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 4 | Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 7 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC and a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts. | |
| 19 Apr 2016 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 27 | Councillor J Geary declared non pecuniary interests in item 5 – Capital projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC, a founder member of Mantle Lane Arts and a member of Leicestershire and Rutland Playing Field Association Councillor J Legrys declared a non pecuniary interest in any reference to Hermitage FM due to his involvement with the organisation. | |
| 15 Dec 2015 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 20 | Councillor J Geary declared a non pecuniary interest in item 4 – Capital Projects update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC. | |
| 13 Oct 2015 | Coalville Special Expenses Working Party, item 11 | Councillor J Geary declared a disclosable non pecuniary interest in Item 5 – Capital Projects Update as a regular supporter of Coalville Town FC. |
Where Councillor Geary sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jan 2014 | 74 | |
| Coalville Special Expenses Working Party | Committee Member | Dec 2006 | 54 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Observer | Nov 2013 | 54 | |
| Cabinet | Observer | Jul 2013 | 35 | |
| Community Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jun 2019 | 23 | |
| Policy Development Group | Substitute | Jan 2014 | 21 | |
| Licensing Committee | Substitute | Nov 2013 | 5 | |
| Local Plan Committee | Substitute | Sep 2020 | 5 | |
| Local Plan Advisory Committee | Observer | Apr 2014 | 3 | |
| Licensing Sub Committee | Interested Party | Mar 2014 | 2 | |
| Assessment Sub Committee | Observer | Dec 2014 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.