Appointments to Committees and Outside Bodies
2) Councillor R Johnson be appointed as a representative on the Cliffe Hill Quarry Liaison Committee.
Every time North West Leicestershire's minutes name Councillor Johnson, as the council published it.
2) Councillor R Johnson be appointed as a representative on the Cliffe Hill Quarry Liaison Committee.
Councillor R Johnson be elected as Chair for the meeting.
Councillor R Johnson moved that the press and public be excluded during the consideration of the dual driver’s licence.
Councillor R Johnson declared a registerable interest in item 12, 2026/27 General Fund Budget and Council Tax, as the Chair of Hugglescote Parish Council.
It was moved by Councillor P Moult, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RECOMMENDED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson, speaking as ward member, addressed the Committee. He stated there was a lack of evidence supplied by the applicant to suggest there was a local need. It was noted that issues with waste collection could develop which may result in road hazards.
It was moved by Councillor A Barker, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Recommendation 2 was moved by Councillor P Moult, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson declared a registerable interest in item 14, Council Tax Resolution 2025/26, as the Chair of Hugglescote Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson left the meeting at the conclusion of the item.
It was moved by Councillor R Johnson, and seconded by Councillor R Sutton and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor A Barker, and seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor R Johnson, seconded by Councillor JG Simmons, and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor A Barker, seconded by Councillor R Johnson, and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He listed his concerns including the impact on the historical ponds, harm to biodiversity and habitat, felling of trees and hedgerows, flooding risk and width of access for emergency services. Sections of the National Planning Policy Framework designed to protect these matters were referenced.
It was moved by Councillor JG Simmons, seconded by Councillor R Johnson, and RESOLVED THAT:
The recommendation to approve the delegations at appendix A was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
Councillor R Johnson be appointed to the vacant seat on the Audit and Governance Committee for the remainder of the 2024/25 civic year.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He was disappointed that photographs of the ‘lean to’ he had submitted had not been included and therefore felt that the application was misleading. He felt that the report had many inaccuracies and he listed the policies from the Parish Council’s Neighbourhood plan that although included in the report were not applicable.
It was moved by Councillor A Barker, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
As the Ward Member, Councillor R Johnson, was unable to attend the meeting a written statement had been submitted and read out to the Committee by the Democratic Services Officer. It highlighted the proposed positioning of the puffin crossing and the effect it would have on the area due to the removal of trees including the Council’s climate change policy. It was questioned whether an ecology report had been undertaken due to the loss of habitat for breeding birds.
Councillor R Johnson declared a registerable interest in item 12 – General Fund budget and Council Tax 2024/25 as the Chair of Hugglescote and Donington Le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He expressed his disappointment with the officer’s report as he believed there were many inaccuracies. He referred to the residents’ objections and their concerns that approval of these applications would open the floodgates for more development in the area.
Councillor R Johnson concluded that both applications went against the national Planning Policy Framework in relation to protecting green belt and conserving and enhancing the historic environment. As well as being outside the limits to development in the Local Plan and Neighbourhood Plan.
[name removed], objector and Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, declined the opportunity to address the Committee again as they had made statements under the last application and had nothing different to add.
It was moved by Councillor N Smith, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He commented on the lack of parking provision, no turning circle within the carpark, narrow access road and restricted visibility. The lack of amenities in the area was also raised and the concerns of loss of light for the neighbour at number six due to the size of the development.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He stressed the dangers of crossing Grange Road and his disappointment that the originally proposed puffin crossing had been withdrawn. Members were informed about the poor visibility and the difficulty for residents when attempting to cross, many residents being children going to school, he felt this proposal would cause residents to be ‘landlocked’ in their homes unable to access the local amenities.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He expressed concerns in relation to pedestrian access to the railway line, healthy trees already removed during nesting season, removal of the offer of a pedestrian puffin crossing on a very busy road, and the lack of completion of phase one of the development, cycle paths and footways. He also had concerns with the proposed access from a busy road on which cars often travelled above the speed limit, adding this to the inability cross the road safely, he felt it was ‘an accident waiting to happen’.
Councillor Johnson take the chair for the remainder of the meeting.
Councillor R Johnson declared a registerable interest in item 12, General Fund Budget and Council Tax 2023/24 as Chair of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Question from Councillor R Johnson ‘Could the portfolio holder, inform me what the cost of heating the Current Council Offices has been in the last 3 months considering most staff are hybrid?’ Response by Councillor R D Bayliss Heating costs for the council offices over the period in question were £6,685.57 excluding vat. This includes standing charges of £1,150.72.
Supplementary question and response Councillor R Johnson stated that considering the building is mostly empty, he had noticed radiators on in empty rooms, therefore he felt was it money spent unnecessarily.
Councillor R Johnson left the meeting at 8.30pm.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the committee and asserted that a development of this type of building and size would be detrimental at the entrance to the village of Hugglescote and highlighted to the meeting that a recent similar development only had a 56% occupancy. It was suggested that the proposed access and egress would be dangerous given its proximity to an active railway line and felt that by allowing this application, it would serve to undermine other parishes’ confidence in the authority with regard to Neighbourhood Plan Policy. The fact the development would be outside the limits to development was highlighted.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 5 “Local Plan Substantive Review – Development Strategy” as Chair of Hugglescote and Donington Le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson enquired whether neighbourhood plans would be protected and informed the meeting that the existing Hugglescote Neighbourhood Plan was currently under review. Officers advised that plans already in place would continue to hold weight, but once the new Local Plan was in place then there would be a need for Neighbourhood Plan groups to look at whether a review was necessary. He suggested that there was a need for an ongoing dialogue in order that there would be as few gaps as possible.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the committee highlighting that the site was an eyesore and currently had a detrimental impact on the village however, the application before them was not right for the site. He noted that the case law that was mentioned had no similarity to the application and the construction management plan needed to be in place before approval was given, as the site was located at the busiest crossroads in Leicestershire and the limited access would mean construction traffic having to park on the roads which was already limited and there were no public car parks in the vicinity. He concurred with the comments read out on behalf of the Parish Council.
The Chairman advised that he had received one question ahead of the meeting and invited Councillor R Johnson to ask his question addressed to Councillor A Woodman.
Councillor R Johnson asked “on April 16th we are to have an official opening of our New Leisure centre with Colin Jackson and former footballers to name but a few.
The Chairman invited Councillor R Johnson to ask a supplementary question.
Councillor R Johnson asked again why Gemma Steele had not been invited to join the line-up.
Councillor A Woodman responded by stating that it was a shame that Councillor R Johnson had not taken the time to contact him directly about this as he would have been able to advise him that Gemma Steele had been contacted and subsequently added to the line-up.
Parish Councillor R Johnson, on behalf of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council, addressed the committee highlighting the impact on the already heavily congested roads and the lack of mitigation to reduce pollution levels that would have a major effect on resident’s health. Reference was made to the dangerous access and egress to the site at which fatalities had occurred in the past. He also noted the lack of a construction management plan in place to control the construction traffic travelling through the village.
Councillor Johnson referred to the Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Neighbourhood Plan which includes a requirement for charging points on new developments and gave an example of where this had already been implemented. He argued that if the Parish Council could be forward thinking in this regard, then this Committee should be able to follow suit.
Councillor R Johnson considered that the assumption of 7-8,000 jobs was unrealistic; the land is contaminated and that the timescales are unachievable. He also referred to any future house building in the vicinity being impractical given the area was prone to flooding.
It was moved by Councillor J Geary seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT: - The response to the consultation on the as set out at appendix 1 to the report, be noted.
Councillor Johnson sought and received confirmation that the consultants referred to in the report had been used before and expressed his dismay at the number of houses being ‘thrown up’ in his ward.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the committee highlighting that the changes to the increase in number of bedrooms in the dwellings listed did not comply with the emerging neighbourhood plan or the Local Plan. He also noted that the increase would make the homes less affordable to young residents who wanted to stay within the local area.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the committee highlighting that there was currently no application on the site for the road before them to link up with and, that the Hugglescote & Donington le Heath Neighbourhood plan would carry weight with policy ENV 6, which related to site allocations and development proposals being expected to safeguard and enhance biodiversity. He supported the recommendations of the County ecologist in relation to wild flower planting but expressed concerns in relation to the blocking off of the public right of way and safety for those who would use it, whilst works were being carried out. He also expressed concerns over the impact that the construction of the road would have on the diminishing wildlife in the area.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the committee highlighting that the housing type changes in the application did not comply with the Local Plan or the Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Neighbourhood Plan, as 3 bed dwellings would suit the local communities, enabling family units to stay close together. He outlined an appeal decision from June 2017 that related to housing mix and noted that the footings were already in place for a number of the plots, without the relevant permission. He urged the committee to refuse the application.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the committee highlighting, that he had worked with officers to address many issues including, the proposed access points along Grange Road where there was no footpath and, that the draft Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Neighbourhood plan would carry weight when considering the application before them. He expressed concerns over the lack of bungalows and starter homes on the site and that all the affordable housing were to be located on to the furthest part of the development and not integrated with the other mix of dwellings.
The Chairman invited Councillor R Johnson to ask his question addressed to Councillor R Ashman.
I do not know the site that Cllr Johnson is concerned about and it would not be appropriate to discuss a specific complaint or enforcement case at Council.
However, if Cllr Johnson would like to provide me with details outside this meeting, I will work with officers to provide a specific response.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the committee highlighting that it was pleasing to see that the play areas were being considered before housing was built however, there appeared to have been little consideration given to equipment for older children. He expressed concerns over the use of bark and felt a bonded surface would be safer and better value for money in the long term.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 – Hugglescote & Donington le Heath Neighbourhood Plan (Submission Draft) and Neighbourhood Planning Update as the Chairman of the Parish Council.
It was moved by Councillor R Johnson, seconded by Councillor N Smith and RESOLVED THAT:
The complaint was made by Councillor Johnson, also a District Councillor of North West Leicestershire District Council.
Councillor Johnson considered that this conduct breached paragraph 3 of the Members’ Code of Conduct.
Following the meeting, Councillor Johnson confirmed that the statement made by Councillor Smith did not fully address his complaint, as, whilst it sought to clarify the statement made on 8 September, it did not include an apology for any offence, which may have been caused, and that he wished to pursue his complaint. Given that the informal resolution process had been unsuccessful, the matter had been referred to the Assessment Sub-Committee in order that it could consider the report and determine whether to:
The complaint be referred to the Monitoring Officer to take some other action, namely to work with Councillor Smith and Councillor Johnson to see whether agreement could be reached on a statement which could be made to the Council meeting in February 2021.
The Assessment Sub-committee noted the original complaint made by Councillor Johnson and the fact that Councillor Smith had made a statement at the Council meeting in November 2020.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the committee highlighting concerns over the residential travel plan in relation to the distance to the nearest bus stops, a new bus service, rail connection and walking distance to local amenities in the village and Coalville.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 11 - Seeking approval to remove NWLDC byelaws from parcels of land owned by Whitwick Parish Council, as reference is made to Hugglestone & Donington le Heath Parish Council of which he is the Chairman.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the committee highlighting concerns over the impact the development would have on the climate, potential flooding from the additional homes and that there was no air quality management plan in place. He felt that the play area for the site was not suitable and as local schools were full, questioned where the children from the development would attend. He expressed concerns over the travel plans that had been submitted as they outlined proposals that were not available in the area.
Councillor Johnson considered that new build homes which were replacing those which had been bought under ‘right to buy’ should be like for like in terms of numbers and size.
Councillor Johnson asked a question regarding the Marlborough Square project and reference to the construction having commenced and stated that nothing was happening on site so asked for clarification on when it would commence. He also asked why the spend on agency workers had increased.
The Chairman invited Councillor R Johnson to ask his question addressed to Councillor R Ashman.
If wheel washing facilities have not been provided on any of the sites I have mentioned, this could be the subject of an investigation by the Council’s Planning Enforcement scheme.” The Chairman invited Councillor R Johnson to ask a supplementary question.
Following advice from the Legal advisor Cllr Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 6 – Hugglescote and Donington-le-Heath Neighbourhood Plan as a Member of the Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson expressed how prudent the Neighbourhood Plan was for the village and was pleased with how the neighbourhood had engaged. He added that it had taken a lot of hard work but the result was a very good plan. He questioned some of the comments by officers, especially in relation to the community facilities and amenities as there was more than one shop in the village.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the committee highlighting that the site in question had always flooded and, with the building of 30 dwellings pursuant to this application, there would be no soakaway, but adjoining existing properties would be affected. He drew attention to the sewerage system that was already overburdened, the site being a greenfield site not in the Local Plan, the parish council’s un-adopted neighbourhood plan which seeks to retain the site as open space and that previous planning applications for the site had been refused on highways grounds. He added that the application was inappropriate and urged members to refuse.
A motion to permit the application in accordance with the officer’s recommendations was moved by Councillor V Richichi and seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
In response to the request for an update from Councillor Johnson, the Planning Policy Team Manager reported that a potential gypsy and traveller’s site had been identified in March 2018 but was not supported.
Councillor R Johnson raised concerns about his village of Hugglescote losing its identity and asked if there were plans to look at possible areas of separation in the near future. The Planning Policy Team Manager responded that officers would look at an area if a suggestion was put forward.
It was moved by Councillor Gillard and seconded by Councillor Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
(1) That Councillor Johnson be appointed to the Planning Committee to replace Councillor Tebbutt;
(2) That Councillor Bigby be appointed as a substitute on the Planning Committee to replace Councillor Johnson;
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 19/00747/REMM, as a ward member. He advised that he would address the committee and then take no further part in the meeting.
Having declared a non-pecuniary interest in the item as ward member Councillor R Johnson left the meeting and took no further part in the discussion and voting thereon.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the Committee.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the meeting, expressing concerns regarding the timing of the application, the viability assessment and the play area provision.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the meeting. He expressed concerns regarding the view of the local community and the Local Plan being ignored, healthcare contributions, education provision, the lack of mitigation for highway safety, the lack of planned infrastructure improvements, construction management plan, air quality management and the housing mix, in particular the low number of bungalows and lack of starter homes. He welcomed the proposed piece of artwork and suggested it could be used to remember the victims of the Whitwick mine disaster at the site.
Councillor R Johnson, ward member, addressed the meeting. He expressed concerns regarding safe access and egress, the fact that the application site was now in a conservation area, the width of the access and the negative impact on the character of the conservation area. In determining the application, members had regard to the concerns regarding the width of the access, landscaping matters, the possible options relating to bin collection, and the fact that should the conditions not be met, any subsequent variation application would be subject to fill consultation with the ward member and the parish council, and there was the opportunity for the application to be reported back to the Planning Committee if deemed necessary.
The Chairman asked Councillor Johnson to pass on his thanks and congratulations to all involved at Hugglescote Parish Council for making this special remembrance truly remarkable.
Councillor R Johnson felt that this was an important matter as villages needed to grow and have a proper infrastructure in place for development. He also commented that some contentious applications considered in the past under policy S2 were recommended refusal by officers.
Subject to the above amendment, it was moved by Councillor J G Coxon, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
In relation to the neighbour notification letter used for consultation purposes, Councillor R Johnson expressed his disappointment that they were addressed to ‘the occupier’ rather than personalised with individual names. He felt it was disrespectful to a council taxpayer as this information could be cross-referenced from other departments. The Planning Policy Team Manager explained that the name of occupiers was not always known, for example because somebody has not registered on the register of electors, and so it was not possible to include a specific occupier’s name.
In relation to the granting of taxi driver licences, Councillor R Johnson asked if there was a way to cross reference with other Council’s regarding past history. The Licensing Team Leader reported that there was a register currently being compiled across all councils and North West Leicestershire was due to be signed up by the end of the year.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee highlighting concerns over the lack of affordable housing & bungalows on the site as a whole, the response of the County’s Archaeology officer and the lack of an enclosed bin collection store. He requested that consideration be given to imposing conditions in relation to restricted working hours, the raising of land levels and wheel washing facilities.
It was moved by Councillor M Specht, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
In response to comments made by Councillor R Johnson, the Senior Conservation Officer advised that in respect of places of worship, any built before 1751 were listed buildings and as such were protected. He added that St Mary’s Church at Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Manor House were listed buildings. He explained that the aim of the document was to identify those assets which were currently unlisted.
Councillor R Johnson commented on the lack of open spaces in his ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
It was moved by Councillor J G Coxon, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson put the following question to Councillor T J Pendleton on behalf of Councillor T Eynon:
It was moved by Councillor J G Coxon, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson welcomed the report however he commented that the photographs were all of Ashby de la Zouch rather than Coalville.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in items A2, application number 17/00320/REMM and A5, application number 17/01098/FUL, as a member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he had called the application in due to fear that the road was dangerous and that he had worked closely with officers on the application raising concerns over the footpath and street lights. He noted that LCC Highways had addressed the footpath but sought clarity on the street lights being installed. He expressed concerns over the mix of housing on the site and that there was only 7.5% affordable dwellings all clumped together and that there were only 2 bungalows when policy H6 stated that bungalows were needed.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10 – North West Leicestershire Local Plan, as Chairman of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A3, application number 17/01441/NMA, as Chairman of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson questioned the applicant’s statement that it would not now be possible to add chimneys to those dwellings previously granted permission due to the timber construction. He felt that the applicant should prove this as the design of the development had already been agreed. He questioned whether the council wasted its time agreeing the design of a development only for it to be changed by the developer for reasons which lacked supporting evidence. .
Councillor R Johnson referred to section 5.1 of the report and commented that the council had its own policies for affordable housing which never seemed to be enacted. He stated that the Housing White Paper had never been laid before parliament and until this happened, he felt the tail was wagging the dog. He stated that he was not happy with the proposals set out in the report.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee.
Councillor Johnson stated that the nearest shops would be the Shell garage on the A511, which was a mile away from the nearest access road or the shops in the centre of Hugglescote which were the same distance. He asked Members to look at the bigger picture as 3,500 new homes were to be built on both sides of Grange Road so the priority islands were needed to slow traffic for access and egress, and for the safety of all road users. He urged Members to say no to the development as it was not sustainable in the present form and asked that the Committee’s judgment not to be clouded by the developer’s pleas that the development was sustainable.
The Leader invited Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, to address the meeting.
Councillor T J Pendleton thanked Councillor R Johnson for his comments but stated that he had been aware of many similar consultations done in other areas of the district and only one had been challenged. He informed Members that the consultation had been held between 12 June and 21 July and that all twelve responses, of which seven were late, had all been considered.
Councillor R Blunt stated that he felt that Councillor R Johnson had added some value in his role as Chairman of the Parish Council in sharing the message and that he understood that home owners in the area had concerns over what they could do to the buildings in the area, but the value of properties tended to increase in a designated conservation area.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 17/00020/FUL, as the Chairman of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson moved that the application be refused.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he had observed a double garage had been built on the site. He felt that the development was excellent and the finish was exceptional. However he considered that the additional dwelling represented overdevelopment of the site and would spoil the intrinsic value of the streetscape.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson put the following question to Councillor T J Pendleton:
As a supplementary question, Councillor R Johnson commented that all members would not look at the PCC website and he ... view the full minutes text for item 23.
The motion was then seconded by Councillor R Johnson. The motion was then put to the vote and declared LOST.
Councillor T Gillard moved the nominations set out in the additional papers and thanked Councillor R Johnson for his co-operation in formulating the nominations.
Councillor R Johnson seconded the motion. He stated that he was pleased that the name of the Disability Action Group had been left in place and added that he was concerned about the change of name to Equity Group. He added that the Disability Action Group had not met for two years and he hoped more meetings would be scheduled.
Further to a question from Councillor R Johnson, it was clarified that the highways improvement referred to in the report was the widening of the footway.
This was seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
Councillor R Johnson agreed with the comments made and added that this was a sustainable village. The motion to refuse the application was then put to the vote and declared LOST.
It was moved by Councillor G Jones, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson expressed concerns in respect of developers not adhering to conditions imposed. He felt strongly that the conditions should be enforced, or they should not be imposed. The Head of Planning and Regeneration agreed that conditions should be enforced, however when taking enforcement action it was necessary to consider the public interest test.
It was moved by Councillor M Specht, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson expressed concerns regarding the width of the road and the impact of construction traffic. He stated that an application for 9 bungalows would blend in with the rest of the community and therefore he would not be supporting the application.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
The officer’s recommendation was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in items A3 and A7, application numbers 16/01043/FUL and 16/01198/REM as Chairman of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
In response to a question from Councillor R Johnson, the Chairman clarified that the only matter currently under discussion was the proposed access.
Councillor R Johnson expressed concerns in respect of the access, the speed of traffic, the loss of parking spaces and the history of accidents on the junction. He stated vehemently that he could not support the proposals.
Councillor R Johnson expressed concerns regarding the lack of affordable housing provision over both applications.
Councillor R Johnson expressed concerns relating to the speed of additional traffic and water run-off.
Following a comment from Councillor R Johnson, Councillor J Bridges reminded members to confine their comments to the application before them.
As Councillor R Johnson was not present, his question was withdrawn and would be put to the next meeting of Council.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A3, application number 15/00951/OUTM, as a member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council, who had previously considered the application, but he had come to the meeting with an open mind.
It was seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
Councillor R Johnson expressed concerns that the applicant had not engaged with residents prior to submitting the application and agreed that the access to the proposed site was the worst that he had seen.
Councillor R Johnson declared a pecuniary disclosable interest in items A1, application number 13/00802/FULM and A2, application number 15/00641/FULM as his property was in close proximity to the proposed development sites and he would leave the meeting and take no part in the consideration and voting thereon.
Having declared a pecuniary interest in items A1 and A2 Councillor R Johnson left the meeting and took no part in the consideration and voting thereon.
Councillor R Johnson returned to the meeting.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he agreed with Councillor G Jones that self build sites were needed, but could not support the development as applications had been refused previously for the site and it would be unsustainable as the local shop did not sell the essentials, adding that planning policies should be stuck to.
The officer’s recommendation to refuse was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
Councillor R Johnson raised concerns regarding the steep incline of the proposed access and suggested using the existing access. He believed that officers did not have any concerns regarding the development of the site but it was the proposed size of the dwelling that caused the issue. The neighbouring house would lose the light from their bay window and he agreed with the officers that it was too large.
Councillor R Johnson asked how much of the £500,000 contribution from the Council in respect of the former Pick and Shovel pub had been spent.
Councillor R Johnson sought an update on the request at the last meeting to hold an additional exhibition in Hugglescote. The Planning Policy Team Manager reminded members that the response at the last meeting was that there were a number of events being held in the Coalville area and the officers’ view was that there was no need to hold an additional exhibition in Hugglescote. He felt that there was nothing more he could add to this.
It was moved by Councillor T Gillard, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
The officer’s recommendation was moved by Councillor J Bridges and seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
Councillor R Johnson felt that the authority required a Traveller Liaison Officer to oversee the need and development of traveller sites.
Following a question from Councillor R Johnson, the Head of Planning and Regeneration confirmed that the site was outside the defined centre boundary by 400m, but was within the Limits to Development.
A recommendation to refuse the application on the grounds that it would cause loss of residential amenity and would be overbearing was moved by Councillor R Adams and seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
Councillor R Johnson advised that Councillor T Eynon was a doctor on call and would be leaving the meeting at 7.00pm.
Councillor R Johnson expressed displeasure at the change of date of the Council meeting as councillors planned their holidays our holidays around full Council.
Councillor R Johnson put the following question to Councillor T J Pendleton:
I see no reason why the Council should alter this procedure rule which clearly provides the option of recorded votes should a member of the committee choose to request it.” Councillor R Johnson made reference to political leaflets distributed in the run up to the elections and the subsequent applications which had been permitted.
Councillor T J Pendleton responded that he did not feel that this demonstrated any bias, however he advised Councillor R Johnson to take the appropriate recourse if he felt he had evidence to suggest this.
Councillor R Johnson commented that the evidence was there and a recorded vote should be required for all planning applications.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he wore badges and was proud to do so. He made reference to the site visits and stated that it was his view that all members should attend these. He stated that he could not support the document in its present form and added that he would like the item to be deferred.
Councillor R Johnson moved the nomination for Councillor J Geary.
It was seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
Councillor R Johnson commented that he could not see any issues with the development of the site and although previous applications had been refused by the Planning Inspector, the site did have access to seven services in the area. He was also pleased that the applicant had listened to the comments of the Highway Authority.
Councillor R Johnson agreed with Councillor D Everitt adding that the developer wanted to change the original plans and that it was wrong and unethical. He stated that he had sat and read all the objections and that it appeared that the developer had not spoken to any of the residents and as a gesture Bellway should consider one fence not two.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 15/00032/FULM as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson highlighted that the report stated that there were no previous planning applications on the site and advised that an application in 1997 for a bungalow was refused. He felt that all previous planning applications were relevant for Members to consider.
Councillor R Johnson advised the Committee that he had called in the application and that the reason for doing so was threefold. Firstly he felt that the application was premature and prejudicial in the bigger picture of the development of south east Coalville. He stated that the second was that there was no area of separation, highlighting that the Masterplan clearly showed that the paddock of land was intended to be kept as a green buffer area from the Forest Road residents to the Davidsons first phase of 81 homes and the second phase of 190 homes application that he expected to come to Committee in the not too distant future, which were the first of many as permitted by the Committee in the previous December.
Councillor R Johnson advised that a speed watch campaign ... view the full minutes text for item 46.
The officer’s recommendation to permit was moved by Councillor J Bridges and seconded by Councillor R Johnson.
The officer’s recommendation to permit was moved by Councillor R Johnson and seconded by Councillor J Legrys.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A3, application number 15/00527/VCI as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. Also he would be addressing the Committee as a Ward Member; therefore he would leave the meeting during the consideration and voting thereon.
Councillor R Johnson referred to the Parish Council’s request to place conditions on ... view the full minutes text for item 36.
Councillor R Johnson, Ward Member, addressed the Committee. He explained that since being elected in 2011 and being a Member of the Planning Committee he had always looked at the merits of applications and what was in the public’s best interest, it was his opinion that this application had neither.
As both a District and Parish Councillor, Councillor R Johnson had always supported the school and encouraged the applicant to engage with residents about everything the school was planning but on this occasion only minimal contact has been made. He reported that the school had admitted that it had breached the conditions already imposed on many occasions and as an authority, the Council should be protecting the resident’s amenities no matter what and enforcing the conditions.
Councillor R Johnson had experienced the noise disturbance personally due to living approximately a mile away from the school and had decided to approach the caretaker regarding the noise level. His main concern was the exposure to noise that the very young children had to endure. He asked Members to imagine what residents would have to cope with being in closer proximity of the facility.
Councillor R Johnson referred to a resident who was a carer for his long term seriously ill wife who needs the quietness to recuperate; the amended conditions would make their lives hell. He also referred to another resident who slept in the afternoon until he started work in the early hours of the morning as a long distance HGV driver, his sleep was affected by the noise which put his life in danger whilst driving.
At this point, as Councillor R Johnson had declared an interest in the item, he left the meeting and took no part in the consideration or voting thereon.
In response to a question from Councillor R Johnson, the Head of Planning and Regeneration advised Members that the woodland was approximately 500ms away.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson commented that Ibstock was growing rapidly and he felt that if the application was for the surgery only he would have been happy with it. His opinion was that the application should be deferred so that the Committee could see what the plans were for the future. He stated that the area deserved better and as the application had no merits, moved that the application be deferred.
Councillor R Johnson referred Members to the report he had circulated at the meeting regarding cemetery charges within the District. He was concerned about the differing level of contributions that residents were paying for the same service dependent on where they live. He believed that contributions should all be equal and asked for Members opinions.
Councillor R Johnson thanked the Members for all they had achieved while he had been Chairman of the group. He announced that he was not standing in a ward that fell within the Coalville special expenses area during the upcoming elections and therefore, if re-elected would not be part of the group.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he had called in the application due to the overlooking impacts on the site from Zetland Close and the land levels.
Councillor R Johnson moved that the application be deferred until the requisite work on the design was completed. This was seconded by ... view the full minutes text for item 123.
The officer recommendation was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and A recorded vote having ... view the full minutes text for item 116.
Councillor R Johnson stated that credit should be given to the applicant and officers for their work on the application as the previous application had been picked to pieces. He added that the applicants wished to move forward to be able to help relatives.
The officer’s recommendation was moved by Councillor R Johnson, seconded by Councillor T Neilson.
Councillor R Johnson commented that the application seemed to change every so often and had been amended as recently as yesterday. He added that 21 dwellings was acceptable to the developer in 2011, and questioned why this was not the case now. He commented that the developer seemed to want to squash in as much as possible and it was not acceptable that people were living in boxes.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he had voiced his approval of Councillor M B Wyatt’s proposal to hold a Proms in the Park event and asked that the minutes be amended to reflect this.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A4, application number 13/00956/OUTM, as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson requested that a condition be included in respect of the hours of construction, to restrict the working time to 7.30am to 5.30pm Monday to Friday, 7.30am to 1.30pm on Saturdays and no Sunday operating The Chairman advised that a note to the applicant could be included to that effect.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he concurred with Councillors J Legrys and A V Smith. He commented that he had been called out to visit residents as part of Gutteridge Street was in his Ward. He added that this was the second incident within his Ward and staff were on the ball.
The Chairman asked Councillor R Johnson to conclude as the five minute time period for Members to speak in respect of announcements had almost ... view the full minutes text for item 42.
Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A1, application number 14/00535/FULM and also a disclosable non-pecuniary interest in item A6, application number 14/00580/FUL as a member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
It was moved by Councillor J Bridges, seconded by Councillor R Johnson and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor R Johnson be elected Chairman of the Working Party for the ensuing municipal year.
Councillor R Johnson then took the chair.
Councillor R Johnson stated that the amount of litter at the event had dropped significantly from last year. He went on to say that it was good to see the public being more responsible in this respect.
Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of items A2, application number 14/00309/ FULM and A3, application number 14/00133/FUL, and also declared a Disclosable Non-Pecuniary interest in item A4, application number 14/00311/ VCI as he had been significantly involved in the application.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he was sceptical of the application, as the Committee had approved a similar application across the road from the site back in January 2012 and were advised that the work would be carried out within 3 months and it still had not been developed.
Councillor R Johnson returned to the meeting.
Councillor R Johnson felt that the Committee should support the application and support British farmers. The motion to amend the recommendation to include that the design of the cladding was such that it blended in with the landscape of the countryside was put to the vote and was LOST.
Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A3, application number 13/00335/OUTM, item A5, application number 13/00818/OUTM and item A7, application number 14/00219/FUL. He also declared a non pecuniary interest in item A4, application number 11/01054/FULM as a member of Hugglescote and Donington Le Heath Parish Councill.
Councillor R Johnson stated that he had looked at the merits of the application but was very disappointed that the developer had not engaged with the Parish Council in the last three years as they had promised. He referred to the Localism Act which stated that a developer should consult with the Parish Council as well as local residents and details of this should be included within the application when considered by the District Council, he believed the developers had not been transparent by not consulting. He then stated the following concerns:
Councillor R Johnson felt that the development would complement ... view the full minutes text for item 67.
Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A1, application number 13/00908/OUTM. He also declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 13/00671/OUTM as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Councillor R Johnson referred to the comments of the applicant and stated that Ibstock was no longer a rural centre but a small town and ... view the full minutes text for item 55.
Councillor R Johnson stated that it was a wonderful application in an area that needed development. He added that he had been heavily involved as part of the Parish Council and it was a brilliant development.
Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A1, application number 13/00060/FUL, item A2, application number 11/01054/FULM and item A3 application number 13/00829/OUT. He also declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 11/01054/FULM as a member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council and item A4, application number 13/00702/FULM as a member of the Central England Co-operative.
Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A2 application number 12/00922/OUTM as a Member of Hugglescote Parish Council and that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A1 application number 13/00335/OUTM, item A3 application number 13/00818/OUTM and item A4 application number 13/00266/FUL.
Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A2 application number 12/01094/FUL and item A7 application number 12/00922/OUTM. He also declared a non pecuniary interest in item A7 application number 12/00922/OUTM as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Johnson attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Nov 2021 | Council | Motions | Lost | 14 for, 21 against, 1 abstained | |
| 16 Mar 2021 | Council | Update on Establishment of Company to be known as 'EM DEVCO Limited' | Carried | 31 for, 4 against | |
| 16 Mar 2021 | Council | North West Leicestershire Local Plan Partial Review - Proposed Adoption | Carried | 32 for, 4 against | |
| 17 Nov 2020 | Council | Council Delivery Plan 2020/21 | Carried | 19 for, 4 against, 12 abstained | |
| 17 Nov 2020 | Council | Establishment of Company to be Known as 'EM DEVCO LIMITED' | Carried | 30 for, 4 against | |
| 8 Sep 2020 | Council | Allocation of Seats on Committees (Political Balance) | Carried | 31 for, 4 against | |
| 13 Feb 2018 | Planning Committee | 17/00921/FUL: Erection of two first floor and single storey rear extensions, external staircase, new shop front to allow for the change of use to restaurant with hot food takeaway sales and an A2 (financial and professional services) use an | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 31 Jan 2017 | Planning Committee | 16/01059/OUT: Demolition of farm buildings and erection of five detached dwellings (outline with access and layout included) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Jun 2015 | Council | Leader's and Portfolio Holders' Announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Apr 2015 | Planning Committee | 15/01103/FUL: Proposed Conversion of attached outbuilding to form one residential dwelling | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Apr 2015 | Planning Committee | 15/00033/FUL: Erection of a single storey front extension | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Mar 2015 | Planning Committee | 14/00991/FULM: Erection of seventeen affordable dwellings, with access on to Wyggeston Road and North Avenue, associated groundworks and landscaping | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00898/FUL: Demolition of existing bungalow and the erection of three two storey dwellings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00862/FULM: Temporary change of use of land from agriculture to a solar farm with continued agriculture and associated infrastructure | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00934/FUL: Two storey side extension consisting of a residential annexe | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Nov 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00692/FULM: Demolition of existing garage for proposed food and non-food retail (A1) development with additional restaurant uses (A3/A4), together with ancillary access, parking and servicing | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Aug 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00450/FUL - Proposed new clubhouse and changing room | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Johnson was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 10 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Johnson declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Feb 2026 | Council, item 60 | Councillor R Johnson declared a registerable interest in item 12, 2026/27 General Fund Budget and Council Tax, as the Chair of Hugglescote Parish Council. | |
| 20 Feb 2025 | Council, item 65 | Councillor R Johnson declared a registerable interest in item 14, Council Tax Resolution 2025/26, as the Chair of Hugglescote Parish Council. | |
| 22 Feb 2024 | Council, item 70 | Councillor R Johnson declared a registerable interest in item 12 – General Fund budget and Council Tax 2024/25 as the Chair of Hugglescote and Donington Le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 23 Feb 2023 | Council, item 45 | Councillor R Johnson declared a registerable interest in item 12, General Fund Budget and Council Tax 2023/24 as Chair of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 27 Sep 2022 | Local Plan Committee, item 12 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 5 “Local Plan Substantive Review – Development Strategy” as Chair of Hugglescote and Donington Le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 31 Mar 2021 | Local Plan Committee, item 36 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 – Hugglescote & Donington le Heath Neighbourhood Plan (Submission Draft) and Neighbourhood Planning Update as the Chairman of the Parish Council. | |
| 8 Sep 2020 | Council, item 19 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 11 - Seeking approval to remove NWLDC byelaws from parcels of land owned by Whitwick Parish Council, as reference is made to Hugglestone & Donington le Heath Parish Council of which he is the Chairman. | |
| 15 Jan 2020 | Local Plan Committee, item 21 | Following advice from the Legal advisor Cllr Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 6 – Hugglescote and Donington-le-Heath Neighbourhood Plan as a Member of the Parish Council. | |
| 2 Jul 2019 | Planning Committee, item 10 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 19/00747/REMM, as a ward member. He advised that he would address the committee and then take no further part in the meeting. | |
| 13 Feb 2018 | Planning Committee, item 66 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in items A2, application number 17/00320/REMM and A5, application number 17/01098/FUL, as a member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 21 Nov 2017 | Council, item 40 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10 – North West Leicestershire Local Plan, as Chairman of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 7 Nov 2017 | Planning Committee, item 47 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A3, application number 17/01441/NMA, as Chairman of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 4 Jul 2017 | Planning Committee, item 9 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 17/00020/FUL, as the Chairman of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 6 Dec 2016 | Planning Committee, item 65 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in items A3 and A7, application numbers 16/01043/FUL and 16/01198/REM as Chairman of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 4 Oct 2016 | Planning Committee, item 45 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A3, application number 15/00951/OUTM, as a member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council, who had previously considered the application, but he had come to the meeting with an open mind. | |
| 10 May 2016 | Planning Committee, item 121 | Councillor R Johnson declared a pecuniary disclosable interest in items A1, application number 13/00802/FULM and A2, application number 15/00641/FULM as his property was in close proximity to the proposed development sites and he would leave the meeting and take no part in the consideration and voting thereon. | |
| 8 Sep 2015 | Planning Committee, item 42 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 15/00032/FULM as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 4 Aug 2015 | Planning Committee, item 32 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A3, application number 15/00527/VCI as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. Also he would be addressing the Committee as a Ward Member; therefore he would leave the meeting during the consideration and voting thereon. | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee, item 78 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A4, application number 13/00956/OUTM, as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 7 Oct 2014 | Planning Committee, item 52 | Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A1, application number 14/00535/FULM and also a disclosable non-pecuniary interest in item A6, application number 14/00580/FUL as a member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 8 Jul 2014 | Planning Committee, item 12 | Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of items A2, application number 14/00309/ FULM and A3, application number 14/00133/FUL, and also declared a Disclosable Non-Pecuniary interest in item A4, application number 14/00311/ VCI as he had been significantly involved in the application. | |
| 6 May 2014 | Planning Committee, item 75 | Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A3, application number 13/00335/OUTM, item A5, application number 13/00818/OUTM and item A7, application number 14/00219/FUL. He also declared a non pecuniary interest in item A4, application number 11/01054/FULM as a member of Hugglescote and Donington Le Heath Parish Councill. | |
| 11 Mar 2014 | Planning Committee, item 52 | Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A1, application number 13/00908/OUTM. He also declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 13/00671/OUTM as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. | |
| 4 Feb 2014 | Planning Committee, item 42 | Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A1, application number 13/00060/FUL, item A2, application number 11/01054/FULM and item A3 application number 13/00829/OUT. He also declared a non-pecuniary interest in item A2, application number 11/01054/FULM as a member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council and item A4, application number 13/00702/FULM as a member of the Central England Co-operative. | |
| 3 Dec 2013 | Planning Committee, item 28 | Councillor R Johnson declared a non pecuniary interest in item A2 application number 12/00922/OUTM as a Member of Hugglescote Parish Council and that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A1 application number 13/00335/OUTM, item A3 application number 13/00818/OUTM and item A4 application number 13/00266/FUL. | |
| 12 Nov 2013 | Planning Committee, item 24 | Councillor R Johnson declared that he had been lobbied without influence in respect of item A2 application number 12/01094/FUL and item A7 application number 12/00922/OUTM. He also declared a non pecuniary interest in item A7 application number 12/00922/OUTM as a Member of Hugglescote and Donington le Heath Parish Council. |
Where Councillor Johnson sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Observer | Oct 2013 | 101 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Jan 2014 | 74 | |
| Local Plan Committee | Observer | Jun 2018 | 28 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 15 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2014 | 9 | |
| Assessment Sub Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2016 | 5 | |
| Taxi and Private Hire Sub Committee | Committee Member | May 2026 | 1 | |
| Cabinet | Observer | Jul 2013 | 29 | |
| Local Plan Advisory Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2014 | 21 | |
| Coalville Special Expenses Working Party | Observer | Dec 2006 | 16 | |
| Corporate Scrutiny Committee | Observer | Jun 2019 | 14 | |
| Policy Development Group | Observer | Jan 2014 | 13 | |
| Licensing Sub Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2018 | 8 | |
| Community Scrutiny Committee | Observer | Oct 2019 | 6 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.