Declaration of Interests
Councillor S Sheahan declared an other interest in item 9 – Legacy Fund Grant, as a long ‑ term supporter of the Ashby Canal Trust.
Every time North West Leicestershire's minutes name Councillor Sheahan, as the council published it.
Councillor S Sheahan declared an other interest in item 9 – Legacy Fund Grant, as a long ‑ term supporter of the Ashby Canal Trust.
It was noted that this was a non ‑ pecuniary interest and Councillor Sheahan remained in the meeting for the item.
It was therefore moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RECOMMENDED THAT CABINET:
Councillor S Sheahan declared a registerable interest in item 10, Motions, due to the reference to HS2 and a property owner affected by the proposed route.
Leader, and Planning and Infrastructure Portfolio – Councillor J Legrys Housing Portfolio – Councillor A Morley Finance and Corporate Portfolio – Councillor S Lambeth Freeport Portfolio – Councillor C Sewell Community Services Portfolio – Councillor P Moult Environment, Net Zero and Waste Management Portfolio – Councillor D Bigby Customer Services Portfolio – Councillor C Beck Business and Regeneration Portfolio – Councillor G Rogers Policy and Research Lead – Councillor S Sheahan Councillor J Legrys thanked Councillor S Sheahan for his invaluable work in the previous years as Leader of the Labour Group.
The Chair invited Councillor S Sheahan to address the Cabinet.
Councillor Sheahan asked the following question, as set out in the additional papers:
Councillor S Sheahan thanked the Chair for his approach to the matter and the positive resolution achieved.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor A Morley, and RECOMMENDED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor D Bigby seconded by Councillor S Sheahan, and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor S Lambeth, and RESOLVED THAT:
It was also moved by Councillor S Sheahan that Councillor D Everitt be appointed as Chairman of the Council for 2024/25.
It was also moved by Councillor J Legrys that Councillor S Sheahan be appointed as Leader of the Council for 2024/25.
Councillor S Sheahan, Leader of the Labour Group, announced the Shadow Portfolio Holders as follows:
However, before the vote was taken, Councillor S Sheahan withdrew the nominations of Councillor A Wilson from the Charnwood Forest Regional Park Steering Group and Councillor A Barker from the Whitwick Quarry Liaison Committee. Therefore, a separate vote was no longer required for those bodies.
Councillor S Lambeth outlined the amendment to the budget as detailed in the additional papers and it was seconded by Councillor S Sheahan.
Councillor D Bigby outlined the amendment to the budget as detailed in the additional papers and it was seconded by Councillor S Sheahan.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor S Lambeth and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor S Sheahan concurred with Councillor K Merrie in relation to the announcement.
Councillor S Sheahan agreed to sign the letter and was happy to see that things were moving forward.
Question from Councillor Sheahan ‘The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has been reported by the BBC as saying councils are frequently failing to use their powers to tackle anti-social behaviour. In the same report, the Local Government Association were quoted as saying, “…it is vital all agencies – including the Government – ensure all measures in the ASB Plan launched earlier this year are adequately resourced.” Paragraph 40 of the Government’s ASB Plan, says, “while the police, local authorities and other agencies have a range of powers to tackle anti-social behaviour, they do not use them consistently, or, at times, enough.
Full details on the Council’s ASB policy can be found at Anti-social Behaviour Policy (nwleics.gov.uk) ’ Supplementary question and response Councillor S Sheahan asked for evidence including benchmarking information to prove that the council accords with best practice.
The following motion was received from Councillor S Sheahan:
Therefore, we call on him now – don’t obstruct democracy; do the right thing for the people of North West Leicestershire.’ Councillor S Sheahan spoke to and then formally moved the motion.
‘That Council approve the updated Capital Programme as detailed in appendix 1, including the new schemes as set out in paragraphs 3.2 and 3.3, It was seconded by Councillor S Sheahan. The Chair opened the debate on the proposed amendment.
It was also moved by Councillor J Legrys that Councillor S Sheahan be appointed as Leader of the Council for 2023/24.
Questions from Councillor S Sheahan.
Councillor Sheahan thanked the Leader for the opportunity to present his questions as the deadline for questions had passed when they were proposed.
He invited Councillor S Sheahan to put forward his amendment.
Councillor S Sheahan outlined the amended budget as detailed within the additional papers and thanked the Finance Team for assisting with the amended budget.
Councillor S Sheahan outlined the amendment as detailed within the additional papers and it was moved by Councillor D Everitt.
Therefore, an amendment was moved by Councillor S Sheahan and seconded by Councillor J Legrys to disregard the addition to the Constitution to not allow Members to sit on both the Audit and Governance Committee and Scrutiny Committees.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor E Allman and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor D Bigby , seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor E Allman and RESOLVED THAT 1) The outcome of the Policy Review and ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
It was moved by Councillor S Gillard, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
In relation to LED lighting in car parks, Councillor Sheahan sought an update on the position regarding Measham Library Car Park and whether works would be completed this year. He also asked for an update on the refurbishment of Queensway House and asked for a briefing on the regeneration works in Coalville.
It was moved by Councillor J Legrys, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
The recommendation to permit the application in accordance with the officer’s recommendation as amended in the update sheet and subject to the wording of conditions 11 and 12, and subject to the comments made by Councillor Sheahan in relation to requesting that LCC gave the area the highest priority in their planned flood alleviation scheme, was moved by Councillor J Legrys and seconded by Councillor J Hoult.
The application be permitted in accordance with the recommendations of the Head of Planning and Infrastructure as amended in the update sheet and subject to the wording of conditions 11 and 12, and subject to the comments made by Councillor Sheahan in relation to requesting that LCC gave the area the highest priority in their planned flood alleviation scheme.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor E Allman and RECOMMENDED THAT:
He invited Councillor S Sheahan to put forward his amendment.
Councillor S Sheahan outlined the amended budget as detailed in the additional papers and echoed Councillor N Rushton’s thanks to the Finance Team in assisting with the amended budget.
It was moved by Councillor J Hoult, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor J Hoult and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor J Simmons and RECOMMENDED THAT:
Following advice from the Monitoring Officer, Councillor S Sheahan declared an interest in item 6 – Draft Budget Proposals and Council Tax 2021/22 as a property owner affected by the proposed HS2 route. If a discussion was had on this matter directly during the item, he would leave the meeting and not take part in the debate.
There being 14 For, 21 Against and 1 Abstention, the motion was The second motion was received from Councillor S Sheahan and read:
In response to a question on the context for customer satisfaction figures, the Strategic Director agreed to obtain more detail on the matter and provide it to Councillor Sheahan outside of the meeting.
As requested during discussion, it was agreed to provide Councillor S Sheahan with further information on the number of customers that had difficulty in the repayment of business rates.
It was moved by Councillor J Clarke, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor Sheahan queried whether the request would be reconsidered if the Audit and Governance Committee had finished looking at it and asked the Scrutiny Committee to pick it up. The Chairman confirmed that in that case he would reconsider the request if there was outstanding work that Audit and Governance were not able to take any further
Having been moved by Councillor T Saffell and seconded by Councillor S Sheahan it was subsequently RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor V Richichi, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and it was RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor R Ashman, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:- The Council (1) Incorporates the lessons learnt into our existing Hate Crime work programme within the Council’s Equality and Diversity action plan ensuring we support Remembering Srebrenica to share the lessons learnt, to tackle hatred and intolerance, and to help build a better, safer and more cohesive society for everyone.
Councillor S Sheahan moved recommendation one within the report and that the Scrutiny Cross Party Working group should be continued.
She advised Councillor S Sheahan that she would provide him with an update on the crossroads at Albert Village outside the meeting.
Councillor S Sheahan advised the members of the Labour Group’s shadow portfolio holders.
Councillor S Sheahan joined the meeting as a substitute for Councillor D Bigby, who would address the committee as Ward Member and then leave the meeting.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest with regard to any broad reference in reports to HS2 on the proviso that if any verbal reference was made to it in the meeting, he would declare a pecuniary interest and leave the meeting.
Councillor S Sheahan echoed the sentiments of the Chairman and acknowledged the outstanding work of the vaccination centre at Measham Leisure Centre.
He invited Councillor S Sheahan to put forward his amendment.
Councillor S Sheahan outlined the amended budget as detailed in the additional papers and echoed Councillor N Rushton’s thanks to the Finance Team in assisting with the amended budget.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor V Richichi and by affirmation of the meeting it was RESOLVED THAT:
Having declared a pecuniary interest in the item, Councillor D Everitt stepped down from the meeting and was substituted by Councillor S Sheahan.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 – Draft General Fund and Special Expenses Revenue Budget with regard to any reference to HS2 due to the location of his home in relation to the route. If any verbal reference was made to it in the meeting, he would declare a pecuniary interest and leave the meeting.
The following responses were given to questions from Councillor S Sheahan:
Councillor S Sheahan asked for further clarification on the imbalances in relation to the acquisitions of sites and units. As a result, the Head of Housing agreed to provide a further report to the Committee detailing the different funding streams and acquisitions being used to improve the housing stock.
He also agreed to provide a summary of the current cost of acquiring properties in the various ways in comparison to building them to Councillor S Sheahan prior to consideration of the item by Cabinet.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Housing explained that due to the slow movement of the off street parking schemes in the district, the budget has been realigned and Members were assured that the funds allocated would not be lost but carried forward to the next financial year. The Head of Finance also assured Members that each underspend would be individually assessed to ensure it could be delivered. She added that in some cases, schemes might not have a carry forward in one financial year but over five years.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor D Bigby and by affirmation of the meeting it was RESOLVED THAT:
(1) Councillor S Sheahan moved the following motion, the wording of which had changed from that which was published in the agenda and was circulated in the additional papers.
The Chairman invited Councillor Sheahan to respond to exercise his right to reply.
Councillor Sheahan thanked Members for their supportive comments and hoped that by accepting this motion it would make a real difference.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Items for Inclusion in Future Work Programme and Item 7 – Budget Proposals 2021/22 as a Leicestershire County Councillor and a property owner affected by HS2. He confirmed that if any discussion took place regarding HS2 he would leave the meeting.
The following responses were given to a number of questions from Councillor S Sheahan :
A non-pecuniary interest was declared by Councillor Sheahan with regard to any reference in reports to HS2 on the proviso that if any verbal reference is made to it in the meeting, he would declare a pecuniary interest and leave the meeting.
Councillor S Sheahan moved the following motion in relation to issues surrounding the UK economy.
Councillor Sheahan declared non-pecuniary interests in item 8 and 9 – Council Delivery Plan 2020-21 and 2019/20 Q4 & 2020/21 Q1 Performance Reports in relation to his role as a member of Leicestershire County Council and references to HS2. Should the latter be discussed, he would declare a pecuniary interest and leave the meeting. In any other event, he would remain in the meeting and take part in the discussions.
With references to paragraphs 1.9 and 3.3 of the report, Councillor Sheahan asked for justification for the decision to reallocate £.09m of earmarked reserves to the self sufficiency fund and for confirmation if these were committed. He was advised that they were previously allocated for specific purposes but expenditure was not committed and that the earmarked reserves had been reviewed under delegated powers through a ‘COVID lense’ to identify those which could be reallocated by considering how long the reserves had been in existence and how long they had been set aside and for what reason. It was further noted that those earmarked reserves identified had not seen any expenditure in the last financial year.
Councillor Sheahan challenged this as he understood that earmarked reserves were attached to expenditure which had been identified for a purpose so it seemed strange to him to say that it had not been allocated.
Councillor Sheahan felt that if the money was uncommitted then it should be in the General Fund and this idea of moving money around which had been originally allocated for a set purpose, did not sit comfortably with him so he may want to address this again at a future meeting.
Councillor Sheahan moved on to the issue of thematic savings targets as referenced in paragraph 2.3 of the report and sought some clarity as to what these were. He was advised that these were the work streams as set out in the February budget reports and MTFP with themes around applying a more commercial approach to income and around contracts with a range of thematic savings. These were identified in the earlier part of the year as part of the Journey to Self Sufficiency Programme.
Councillor Sheahan conveyed his thanks for the report and presentation on business rates which has helped him gain a better understanding, accepting that it is extremely complicated, and he asked the Head of Finance to confirm his understanding of how it works.
Councillor Sheahan felt that DPS was not suitable for this type of contracting as he felt it would create a lot off administration with having to put each part of the work out to tender, which could result on having to work with a raft of different people which could be complicated. He also felt that contractors may cherry pick which pieces of work they wanted to do.
Councillor Sheahan felt that the framework agreement was the way forward with a clear and transparent selection process.
The recommendation as set out on page 37 of the agenda was moved by Councillor Tebbutt, seconded by Councillor Sheahan and by affirmation of the meeting:- RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor Sheahan asked for expected completion dates for Marlborough Square and Newmarket, to which he was advised that these would be made available once the dates have been firmed up.
Councillor Sheahan asked if he could be emailed the ‘best guess’ dates.
Councillor Sheahan asked what the targets were in terms of the objective to reduce the levels of obesity, and he was advised that more detail can be provided and the wording made clearer.
Turning attention to the new Leisure centre, Councillor Sheahan asked for construction timescales so members could see how it was panning out and whether the targets were being met. He was advised that the CDP does not contain this level of detail but the performance monitoring reports would have this. He then asked what was meant by dwell time and how might this be measured and he was advised that details would be provided outside the meeting.
Councillor Sheahan asked a question on behalf of Councillor Bigby in relation to the highest priority routes from the Ashby cycling strategy and asked when the objective might be available and was advised that if Councillor Bigby wanted to contact officers directly this would be provided.
Councillor Sheahan asked whether all the objectives and actions would be completed within the timescale and he was advised that the level of detail being sought would be picked up as part of the performance monitoring reports.
Councillor Sheahan finished off his questions by stating that there should be a complete section on ‘Clean and Green’ and specifically reducing carbon emissions; and at the very least there should be an objective, as reference to the Carbon reduction plan is a bit vague. He gave an example of switching over to electric vehicles ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Councillor Sheahan raised issues on behalf of Councillor Bigby in relation to off street parking in Ridgway Road, Ashby as planning permission was received in March but work had not yet started. He asked for the start and completion dates and whether a contractor had been appointed. He also asked for updates on a number of car parking issues referred to in the report and when the report on car parking improvement would be available.
The recommendation as set out on page 51 of the agenda was moved by Councillor Sheahan, seconded by Councillor J Hoult and by affirmation of the meeting:- RESOLVED THAT:
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan regarding the decision to invest more in Local Authorities rather than banks to lower the inherent investment risk, the Finance Team Manager explained that the decision was made at the advice of the Council’s external advisor as a safer investment. The Head of Finance confirmed this and added that this was due to “bail-in” risk.
Following a further comment from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Finance confirmed that assurances were sought on all advice given to ensure it was sound.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor D Harrison and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor S Sheahan declared non-pecuniary interests in item 10.2 – Motions, as a member of Leicestershire County Council, and item 14 – Appointment of Representatives on Community Bodies, as an LCC appointed member to the Redbank Liaison Committee and the New Albion Liaison Committee.
Councillor S Sheahan stated that there was nothing really to disagree with and that the Labour Group would be supporting the motion.
It was moved by Councillor R Blunt, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and by affirmation of the meeting it was RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor S Sheahan asked what impact the change in Government plans on the re-opening of schools would have on staffing levels, what was the current situation with regard to the leisure contract and how far behind was the work on the major redevelopment projects such as Marlborough Square, Newmarket and the Leisure Centre?
Councillor S Sheahan take the chair for the remainder of the meeting.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the External Auditor provided further information around the plans to address the risks with regard to property, plant and equipment valuation as set out on page 11 of the report.
In response to a question from Councillor Sheahan, the Head of Finance confirmed that the risks associated with a ‘no deal’ Brexit had remained static whilst government negotiations on a future relationship were ongoing.
Councillor Sheahan acknowledged this response. On behalf of the Committee, he also stated that he was highly appreciative of the efforts being taken by Officers behind the scenes to ensure Council services remained operational.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 7 – 2019/20 Q3 Performance Report as the report referred to HS2.
Councillor S Sheahan would leave the meeting if any discussion took place on the topic.
Councillor S Sheahan was disappointed to see the low level of take up for training. He felt that there was a role for the group whips to encourage attendance at training sessions.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that it was important to engage members when putting together a training session to ensure it was what they wanted at a time that suited. He felt that training sessions should be more enticing and in an enjoyable format. He also suggested that certification be introduced, possibly jointly with other local councils, where credits could be earned.
At the request of Councillor S Sheahan, it was explained how the new telephony system would work and that overall would be more efficient with the ability to measure the quality of service. In addition, it would allow officers to use telephony wherever they were, therefore allowing for a more agile way of working.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan in relation to the plans for the redesign of the buildings reception area, the Head of Customer Services, Corporate Property and Assets reported that the environment for the reception area was not fit for purpose and changes would be considered. He added that the council building was being looked at as a whole as part of the accommodation review and this would be considered by the newly established cross party working group to help give the project some direction.
In response to a question in relation to agency staff from Councillor S Sheahan, it was clarified that agency costs were still within budget but were unfortunately over the target. It was explained that a number of service areas had struggled to recruit to permanent posts, specifically in Housing Maintenance and Refuse. In terms of Housing Maintenance, most of the work had been brought in house and agency staff would only be used in the short term whilst assessments were being undertaken on workloads.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that a plan was necessary to reduce the use of agency staff, as it seemed that they were currently employed on a reactive basis. The Strategic Director assured Members that plans were already moving forward.
He invited Councillor S Sheahan to put forward his amendment.
Councillor S Sheahan moved the amendment to the budget. He stated that the Labour group wanted to give the creative industries a boost and support aspiring artists to get new workshop spaces by researching empty units that were available and could be utilised for that purpose. It was also proposed to support public art festivals through grants.
In response to several questions from Councillor S Sheahan, the Environmental Health team Manager and Licensing Team Leader confirmed that two of the incidents detailed on page 2 of the report were in relation to the same location. It was confirmed that these incidents were due to a number of factors and monitoring was ongoing after recent improvements.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Finance explained that the proposed reduction in rent allowances was due to a lower demand for the benefit.
It was agreed to provide further information regarding the allowance to Councillor S Sheahan outside of the meeting.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Finance explained that the additional recharges to the Housing Revenue Account and Special Expenses are an accounting transaction, which annually recover the costs of providing corporate services to the Housing Service.
Councillor S Sheahan questioned the Corporate Portfolio Holder on the administration’s decision to once again, not increase Council Tax. The Corporate Portfolio Holder stated that this was a policy of the Conservative group and formed part of the election manifesto; there was no intention to change it.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that the increase in funds for car park improvements seemed to be balances brought forward rather than an increase. The Head of Finance confirmed that the proposal was to increase the level of funds over a three-year period and further information would be included in the report to Cabinet in February.
Councillor S Sheahan confirmed that he would like to see an increase in funds as it was needed.
In response to a further question regarding estate pilots in a council housing area from Councillor S Sheahan, the Chief Executive explained that the sites for improvement were not yet decided but were being considered.
Councillor S Sheahan requested the Riverside Estate be considered.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that the Council should be doing better at replacing the number of council homes that were being lost to Right to Buy. The Corporate Portfolio Holder agreed and was supportive of purchasing more houses to add to the stock, as there were plenty of properties available in the District. The Chief Executive explained that this was something that the newly appointed Strategic Director would be working on.
Councillor S Sheahan requested that this topic be scrutinised in the future.
Councillor S Sheahan agreed with the positive comments regarding the scrutiny function and took comfort in the fact that there would be a cross party working group used to shape how it would operate going forward.
It was moved by Councillor V Richichi, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
Further to the survey for Parish Council’s on their appetite for implementing Neighbourhood Plans, Councillor S Sheahan was aware that a workshop was being held in March to provide further information. He asked if this could be widened for district councillors to attend, as he believed it would be beneficial to join in the conversations with the parishes. The Chief Executives agreed to take that back to the service and for arrangements to be made to include District Councillors.
At the request of Councillor S Sheahan the Chief Executive agreed to provide further information on the sites being investigated for new build council properties, as well as a progress update on the former sheltered housing scheme sites.
Following the discussion on the call centre statistics for the quarter, the Chief Executive agreed to provide Councillor S Sheahan with further information so he could understand what effected the performance not just for this quarter but for the whole year to provide context.
With the permission of the Chairman, Councillor S Sheahan who was observing the meeting addressed the Committee. He pointed out that that the Cabinet report attached for information stated that the district had the second lowest particulate related deaths in Leicestershire, however [name removed] presentation indicated differently. He asked for clarification.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that David had shown great dedication to the role of district councillor over the past 46 years and standing in 13 elections. Making such a commitment required great fortitude; an understanding family and a willingness help the residents of his ward. David has given great service to this Council and both he and his vast experience will be missed.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, it was recognised that five from 33 private hire operators was a small sample size;
Councillor S Sheahan felt he would have more confidence if the sample size had been larger.
Following a further question from Councillor S Sheahan with regard to nuisance parking and how this would be identified and enforced, it was noted that any allegations of nuisance parking would be investigated over a period of time in order that an assessment be made.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan in relation to Charnwood Borough Council joining the shared service agreement, the Audit Manager stated that the practical implication was staff capacity. She reassured members that the delivery of services to Charnwood Borough Council would not start until a new Senior Auditor was in post. There was a benefit of the addition of another authority to the agreement in that there would be increased resilience once the Senior Auditor had been appointed, as there would be another qualified officer.
In response to a further question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Audit Manager confirmed that NWLDC would be the lead partner.
It was moved by Councillor Gillard and seconded by Councillor Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor Sheahan moved the motion as set out on the agenda and presented it to members.
Councillor Sheahan exercised his right to reply and responded to the comments made by members.
Councillor Sheahan stated that this was not ‘project fear’ but ‘project reality’ and regardless of whether we voted leave or remain, we should all be voting against ‘no deal’ Brexit.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the External Auditor explained that it was the shared opinion of all local authority auditors and the National Audit Office that the implications of the GMP and McCloud judgement should be taken into account, as there would be a future unavoidable material impact.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Finance Team Manager reported that there had been an increase in the amount of local authority investment due to the level of interest from local authorities at the moment. Both the Finance Team Manager and the Head of Finance gave assurances that this type of investment was safe.
Councillor S Sheahan agreed with the approach and the possibility of a formal committee in the future.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan , the Audit Manager confirmed that she was satisfied with the controls that had been put in place so far in relation to the critical audit recommendations that were included within the report. She was confident that there should be no reoccurrences if the controls were maintained.
Councillor S Sheahan made reference to the supplements from business rates. With respect to Moira he suggested that consideration be given to expanding the number of workshops on site.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that there may be clear solutions but a longer term view was needed. He added that declaring a climate emergency brought the issue into focus. He felt it was important to involve the public in discussions about the solutions.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – 2018/19 Quarter 4 Performance Report due to the reference to HS2 within the report.
In addition, during the item, a further discussion ensued and therefore Councillor S Sheahan declared a pecuniary interest and left the meeting for the remainder of the debate.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Human Resources and Organisational Development confirmed that the total expenditure on agency staff did not include consultants. In response to a further question, it was reported that the increase in use of agency staff in recent years was mainly due to recruitment difficulties within the Housing repairs and waste teams. The Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services stated that he was confident that costs for agency staff would continue to reduce going forward as permanent staff continued to be recruited in the repairs team on the new terms and conditions for operatives which were agreed last year.
Regarding the performance of the call centre, Councillor S Sheahan was pleased that improvements in call waiting times had improved.
Councillor S Sheahan was pleased to see that the two Syrian families had settled in well and asked if any more families would be arriving in the district. It was confirmed that there would be a further two families by November 2019.
At this point Councillor S Sheahan left the meeting during the discussion which focussed on HS2, as he had a pecuniary interest.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor J Clarke and RESOLVED THAT:
In response to questions from Councillor S Sheahan , the Licensing Enforcement Officer advised that he could not say if two points per year was typical for drivers, however twenty-seven points was the most that he was aware of for any driver. He added that it was also the first time in the lifetime of the policy that a driver had to attend a Sub-Committee hearing for requiring three driving assessments within a 10 year period. This was unique.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 16 – Appointment of Representatives on Community Bodies, having been appointed to the New Albion Revised Liaison Committee and Redbank Manufacturing Liaison Committee as a member of Leicestershire County Council.
Councillor S Sheahan congratulated the Leader on his appointment and announced the Shadow Cabinet as follows:
Councillor S Sheahan moved the following motion:
Councillor S Sheahan spoke to the motion and stated that modern slavery was a crime resulting in the abhorrent abuse of human rights. He added that the Council must take action to guard against modern slavery.
Councillor N J Rushton seconded the motion and thanked Councillor S Sheahan for agreeing to the minor amendment. He ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Councillor S Sheahan made reference to the request for a member of the opposition to chair the scrutiny committees. He stated that he would bring this issue to the attention of the corporate peer review team.
Councillor S Sheahan asked if the revaluation of assets issue had been resolved and if there were any financial impacts. The Head of Finance reported that there were some issues with the migration of data and historical costs, therefore it was not yet resolved. She assured Members that there was no financial impact as it was in relation to accounting treatments only.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that he was cautious of the leisure centre project and asked for any guidance on what to monitor over the next few years. The External Auditor stated that Members would be monitoring process of the project through the risk register assurances and the 2019/20 Audit Plan. The Audit Manager informed Members that the leisure service procurement would be looked at in due course.
Councillor S Sheahan expressed concerns that the audits listed were mostly for the housing service, he asked if this would trigger an investigation into the possible causes for the problems. The Audit Manager explained that if more concerns arose during the audit then the decision could be taken to explore further.
Councillor S Sheahan asked if it was possible to invite the head of service to the next meeting to discuss the matter further. The Head of Legal and Commercial Services advised Members that an invitation could be made to the head of service if it was to discuss the outstanding audits, anything else would need to be taken through scrutiny.
Councillor S Sheahan was happy for the matter to be taken to scrutiny, in particular an investigation into the client and contractor relationship.
At the request of Councillor S Sheahan , the Housing Management Team Manager further explained the issues surrounding transferring a sole tenancy into joint names and assured Members that the legal rights of spouses/partners in relation to tenancy succession and the Right To Buy remained, even if they were not joint tenants. The proposal was intended to protect the rights of sole tenants who are sometimes pressurised into agreeing to a joint tenancy by a partner, a relationship breakdown may follow and the partner then completes a Notice to Quit which terminates the whole tenancy.
Councillor S Sheahan referred to evidence from Sweden that community defibrillators had an impact on the levels of heart attack survival rates and asked if the use of S106 money for this had been discussed with the CCG representative following the realisation that the ambulance service was responsible for the provision of the machines. The Planning Policy Team Manager confirmed that he had not yet raised it with the CCG representative but would do so as soon as possible.
Councillor S Sheahan was happy to see growth in the district, but noted that average wage levels in the district were below those in the County, and the wider East Midlands, and questioned whether more and more lower wage, distribution jobs were a real benefit to local people. He asked what was being done to support the creative industries and to support individuals to gain higher skills. The Business Focus Team Manager reported that there was a range of support programmes in place including start up exercises and these would continue going forward.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10 - Budget and Council Tax 2019/20, to any reference relating to HS2. He also declared a pecuniary interest in item 11 – HS2 Update, due to the location of his home in relation to the route.
Councillor S Sheahan recounted that Councillor D J Stevenson always addressed him as ‘my friend’, which he welcomed. He recalled the interesting advice he had provided and congratulated him on his long service so far.
Councillor S Sheahan welcomed the commitment to the drop-in sessions, however he felt it would be difficult to gauge the view of the residents of Coalville and to convince them that the Council ... view the full minutes text for item 49.
He invited Councillor S Sheahan to put forward his amendment.
Councillor S Sheahan spoke to the amendment. He stated that investing start-up grants in local talent could bring enormous benefits to the local area. He reminded members that the Council had agreed to support the Make a Stand campaign and the amendment sought a concrete commitment to provide a domestic abuse support worker.
The motion was seconded by Councillor N Clarke, who spoke in support of the motion, echoing the comments made by Councillor S Sheahan .
Councillor S Sheahan welcomed the proposal for an additional scrutiny committee and commented that good governance needed adequate scrutiny. He requested that one of the scrutiny chairmen be a member of the opposition group.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, Councillor N J Rushton advised that the decision to repay the maturity loans would ultimately be a matter for the new Council to decide, however the funding had been set aside to repay those loans.
Councillor S Sheahan commented on the recent increase in rough sleeping nationally in the cities due to people traveling in from smaller towns. He asked if information was shared between authorities to try to stop people going into the cities. The Housing Strategy and Systems Team Manager confirmed that there were links between authorities and rough sleepers were referred back to their home towns wherever possible.
Councillor S Sheahan felt it would be useful to have a log for these cases so that rough sleepers’ movements could be monitored. The Housing Strategy and Systems Team Manager reported that the authority had signed up to an agreement to contribute to a national database to track people’s movements and therefore a better provision of support.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that it was essential to be a leader on this subject within the community and it was important to put out the right message as part of the next steps.
Councillor T Eynon concurred with Councillor S Sheahan and believed it was a great policy, but only the beginning of a long process. She asked that regular updates, which would be supported by the Equality and Access Group, be provided to the community.
It was moved by Councillor T Eynon, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor S Sheahan was also pleased with the proposals for the scrutiny function and felt the split between the two committees was logical.
Councillor S Sheahan to take the chair for the remainder of the meeting.
Councillor S Sheahan referred to the warning letters mentioned within paragraph 2.5 of the report and asked what the licensed driver had been warned about. The Licensing Enforcement Officer explained that the licensed driver had been sent letters regarding his breach of council conditions in relation to not informing Licensing about points received for exceeding statutory speed limit on a public road, as well as his failure to attend the depot test.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 12 – Marlborough Square Update as a Councillor for Leicestershire County Council. He also declared a pecuniary interest in item 8 – Draft 2019/20 General Fund and Special Expenses Revenue Budgets, as there was reference in the report to HS2. He advised that he would leave the room during any discussion on HS2.
In response to a number of questions from Councillor S Sheahan, the following was stated:
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Portfolio Holder explained that the additional steps implemented for investments and Local Authority lending was introduced to avoid any reputational embarrassment. The Head of Finance stated that she had previously given assurances to Members regarding inter local authority borrowing and that any such investments were safe. However, the issue was around the timing of claiming money back in the event that an invested local authority encountered financial difficulties and it was important to safeguard our finances.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Finance stated that the additional £5,000 contribution for Citizens Advice was put forward by the Team Manager following discussions with the Citizens Advice Bureaux.
It was agreed for the Finance Team Manager to provide further information to Councillor S Sheahan outside of the meeting. The Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services commented that the HRA Budget Proposals contained an additional investment to fund a support worker to work with residents experiencing financial hardship.
Regarding the budget proposal for no increase in council tax, Councillor S Sheahan commented that there was no indication as to the amount of money that could be received if there was an increase. The Head of Finance explained that in line with legislation, the most the Council tax could be increased by (without a local referendum) is 2.99 percent and referred to paragraph 4.5 of the report where the impact of not increasing council tax is outlined.
Councillor S Sheahan was disappointed with the decision to increase the shop leases. He understood that the Council was a business but felt that these small shops should be supported as much as possible, especially as some of these businesses were the only local shops available to residents in some areas.
Councillor S Sheahan expressed interest in the compartmentalisation recycling bin pilot, as any improvements to the current provision would be beneficial. He asked how quickly it would be rolled out across the district and when financial benefits would be seen. The Strategic Director of Place stated it was difficult to say what improvements to recycling rates or financial benefits would be at this stage.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services stated that the cost of land was an issue and that was the reason why council owned land was currently being developed, unless opportunities arose such as with the police station site in Coalville.
Councillor S Sheahan asked if there was anything that could be done via Planning to overcome the land costs. The Strategic Director for Housing and Customer Services was not sure if he could influence land prices but that feeding into the Local Plan, which allocates land for different purposes, including residential was perhaps one route to take. He agreed to look into the matter further of how affordable housing could be developed where high land prices existed.
Councillor S Sheahan referred to the amount of investments made in other Local Authorities and raised concerns regarding the level of security of the funds. The Head of Finance referred Members to the previous meeting where these concerns were also raised. She reiterated that the advice given in this area was that this type of investment was deemed the most secure as legal processes meant that the money was always safeguarded.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor J Cotterill and RESOLVED THAT:
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor G Hoult and RESOLVED THAT:
In response to questions from Councillor S Sheahan, it was clarified that the right of appeal in the existing process would not change.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10 - Leicester and Leicestershire Authorities’ Joint Strategic Growth Plan, as a member of Leicestershire County Council and due to the reference to HS2 in the report.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that he had taken part in the Remembrance day service and it was a very appropriately moving occasion. He added that those who went to war and did not return ought to be remembered every year. In respect of the voter ID pilot he acknowledged that alternative methods of voting needed to be considered however he did not believe there to be a problem with voter fraud in North West Leicestershire.
Councillor S Sheahan moved the following motion:
Councillor S Sheahan spoke to the motion. He stated that by adopting the Make a Stand pledge, the council would be making a clear statement to those suffering from domestic abuse. He stated that this was important because much domestic abuse was hidden and difficult to deal with as far less account was taken of verbal and emotional abuse, the impact of which could be cumulative and long lasting.
He commented that the role of drugs and alcohol in domestic abuse needed to be understood Councillor S Sheahan stated that victims of domestic abuse needed support, which meant publicising sources of advice, ensuring access to safe, affordable housing and refuges. He referred to the existing network of services designed to support victims of domestic abuse, the Make a Stand pledge being a key piece of the jigsaw which would help unite and co-ordinate the council’s response to domestic abuse. He concluded that signing the pledge would emphatically tell everyone concerned that we understand, we care and we are here to help.
Councillor S Sheahan stated that he was happy to support the recommendations, however he was not completely happy with the Strategic Growth Plan. He welcomed the explicit support for reopening the Leicester – Burton line and the regeneration of Coalville town centre. He commented that the district and Coalville in particular had been left behind with respect of infrastructure and would lag even further behind if the development was going elsewhere.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a pecuniary interest in item 7 – Quarter 2 Performance Management Report, due to the reference in the report to HS2. He advised that he would leave the room during any discussion on HS2.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that it would be interesting to see what other authorities did differently, for example, whether others offered a free bulky waste collection. He felt it would be more useful to look at the actual costs incurred by fly tips.
In response to comments from Councillor S Sheahan , the Environmental Protection Team Manager explained that the different reporting approaches used by other authorities made it difficult to compare on a like for like basis. She added that the work being undertaken was having a measurable positive impact. She explained that most fly tips were not large items and mainly occurred where people had paid someone to take away household waste.
Councillor S Sheahan welcomed the campaign and felt that prevention was the right approach. He requested more information on the cost of fly tips.
In response to questions from Councillor S Sheahan, the Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services advised that the allocation of newly built homes could only be restricted to a particular town or village if the new development was classified as a rural exception site. Otherwise the property would be let to anyone on the housing register, and it was necessary to prove a connection to North West Leicestershire in order to join the housing register.
Councillor S Sheahan expressed concerns regarding Queensway House in Measham, in particular regarding negotiations with the adjacent site and the risk of the site becoming derelict. He requested that prompt action be taken.
The Head of Housing and Customer Services agreed to provide an update with more detail to Councillor S Sheahan.
In response to questions from Councillor S Sheahan, the Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services advised that an architect had been employed to look at the design of the next phase of the off street parking improvement programme at Ridgeway Road, Ashby. It was not yet known how many parking spaces would be created.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services advised that the overall delivery of affordable housing and the housing need for the district was set out in the Local Plan. He reminded members that the housing need was being reviewed as part of the review of the Local Plan.
Councillor S Sheahan commented on the high level of sicknesses relating to back pain and asked how much of this was preventable. The Head of Human Resources and Organisation Development advised that it was not currently known what percentage of illnesses involving back pain were work related. He agreed to provide this information in future reports.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Strategic Director of Place advised that the work at Moira Furnace was focussed on the furnace itself and considering the use of the wider site to support the furnace. He added that this project was at a very early stage.
Councillor S Sheahan thanked the Head of Finance and her team for the work undertaken in a difficult financial year and resolving the capital accounting issue, he felt that the final accounts had been dealt with very well.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor J Cotterill and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor S Sheahan referred to the assessment of supporting principles in the assurance review and asked if there were any plans in place to improve the ‘fair’ ratings to ‘good’ in the future. The Head of Finance responded that anything rated as ‘fair’ was identified as requiring improvement and an improvement action was included in the main Annual Governance Statement. The Head of Finance confirmed that the Committee would receive regular quarterly updates on the progress of these improvement actions.
In response to a further question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Finance could not guarantee that the ‘fair’ ratings would be improved by next year as it was dependent on the timescale for each improvement but the aspiration was to move to ‘good’. She would provide estimated timescales in future reports.
Councillor S Sheahan asked if it was reasonable to expect the outstanding audits to be completed by the deadlines stated within the report. The Audit Manager referred to appendix D where it stated that delivery of the 2018/19 Audit Plan was currently below target for the financial year but it was expected to be back on track by the end of Quarter 3. She added that a further update would be provided at the next meeting.
Councillor S Sheahan asked why a fee was only charged on the older agreements. The Planning and Policy Team Manager believed that legally they were no longer allowed to charge a fee, although he would look into this further.
Councillor S Sheahan asked if the use of other local authorities as investment counterparties was the right direction to take in the current financial climate. The Head of Finance explained that the advice received from the Council’s treasury advisors was to move away from investment in banks to lower the inherent investment risk. She added that any loan to another local authority would be underwritten by the revenues (council tax and business rates) generated in that area, in the event of any financial problems.
Councillor S Sheahan felt it was important to monitor any investments of that kind.
At the request of Councillor S Sheahan, the Director of Housing and Customer Services gave an explanation on the differences between inherent risk and residual risk.
Councillor S Sheahan asked for an explanation for the drop in the percentage of the number of stage two complaints answered on time.
The Head of Legal and Commercial Services agreed to look into the matter further and report back to Councillor S Sheahan.
Councillor S Sheahan raised concerns regarding online gambling and the fact that there was no reference to it within the report. The Environmental Health Team Manager explained that this was not a function of the District Council and was regulated by the Gambling Commission.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a pecuniary interest in item 9 – HS2 Update, as a resident of Measham directly impacted by the proposed route.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that the information regarding the Customer Services Call Centre statistics was a little confusing and was concerned that the percentage of calls not being answered had risen from Quarter four. The Director of Housing and Customer Services explained that a Head of Service had been appointed to address the issues within the service and raise its corporate profile, and assured Members that improvements would be seen soon. He introduced Tom Shardlow, Head of Customer Services who would be presenting a report later in the meeting on the new Customer Services Strategy.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that it would be difficult to measure overall customer satisfaction across all services.
Councillor S Sheahan asked the following questions regarding the performance indicators at page 20 of the report:
Regarding the ‘Housing Benefit overpayment collection rate’ indicator, Councillor Sheahan felt that there was not enough information to explain the target, as 11 percent was a low figure. The Director of Housing and Customer Services explained that the arrangements made to collect the overpayments were normally a small amount each week and would therefore often take around 12 months to two years to claim the full amount back. He assured Members that it did not seem like much within this quarter but would rise throughout the year.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan , the Director of Housing and Customer Services agreed to provide further information outside of the meeting regarding the 100 percent satisfaction rates of the housing repairs service. He was aware that customers were called after having a repair completed at their property and this was how the figures had been obtained.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that it was important to monitor the commercial income closely over the coming years as the levels being received may not be the same from year to year. He added that it was essential to keep the primary focus on providing services for the local people and not get carried away with the commercial aspect of the authority. The Director of Housing and Customer Services ... view the full minutes text for item 16.
Councillor S Sheahan stated that he may want to discuss the appendix, therefore it was moved by Councillor M Specht, seconded by Councillor N Smith and RESOLVED THAT:
In pursuance of Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the press and public be excluded from the remainder of the meeting on the grounds that the business to be transacted involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in Paragraph 3 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Act and that the public interest in maintaining this exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Community Services reported that the weighting framework used as part of the bidding process was based on the best practice used by Sport England.
He explained that it was based on complex calculations and would share the detail with Councillor S Sheahan outside of the meeting if required.
Having declared a pecuniary interest in the item, Councillor S Sheahan left the meeting for the consideration and discussion thereon.
Councillor S Sheahan asked what the digital service would look like as at 15p per transaction, he felt that costs were low. The Head of Customer Services explained that 15p per transaction would be the optimum cost if there was no interaction at all. He wanted to make customers want to use the service rather than contact the call centre and therefore it needed to be a good, easy to use, system.
Regarding the care leavers proposals, Councillor S Sheahan asked if it was intended for the whole County to align. The Director of Housing and Customer Services reported that each authority has a slightly different timeline but it was the intention to be aligned across the County.
It was moved by Councillor S Sheahan, seconded by Councillor R Ashman and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor S Sheahan referred to the ‘Balance of Economy in NWL’ report which was discussed in January and asked if there had been any progress.
The Director of Housing and Customer Services reported that some economic profiles had been produced and he was happy to share these with Councillor S Sheahan outside of the meeting.
Councillor S Sheahan put the following question to Councillor R Blunt:
Councillor S Sheahan moved the following motion:
Councillor Sheahan spoke to the motion and stated that care leavers were one of the most vulnerable groups in society and were more likely to have abrupt transitions into adulthood than their peers. He added that when they turned 18, care leavers became liable for paying Council Tax, most of which went to the council which was responsible for their care. He highlighted research undertaken by the Childrens’ Society which showed that many care leavers experienced difficulties with managing a budget.
Councillor S Sheahan stated that the Labour Group were instrumental in bringing this to the attention of the council and he was pleased to see the potential £1 million windfall. He felt that these funds should remain allocated to leisure services if possible and he would like to see some of the other leisure centre in the district benefit from the savings.
Councillor S Sheahan stated that he was happy to support the recommendations and welcomed the outcomes particularly in respect of disabled access.
Councillor S Sheahan referred to his request at the last meeting for an update on the review of managing the risk of fraud and corruption, and asked for further information as it was not included within the report. The interim Audit Manager reported that the review had been undertaken and had now been passed to the Head of Finance for implementation. The Head of Finance stated that it was currently ongoing and would report back to the Committee in due course.
Councillor S Sheahan raised concerns that there were many deadlines for follow ups that had not been met and questioned if there were any problems. The Interim Audit Manager assured Members that there was nothing to be concerned about with regards to Internal Audit resources and many of the follow ups were in progress with the services but not yet completed.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that he would be happy to invite officers to the meetings if they needed some encouragement to implement the recommendations. The Interim Audit Manager was happy to take this forward as she felt it would make officers more accountable. The Head of Legal and Commercial Services agreed to invite the relevant director to ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor S Sheahan asked if there was an increase of risk due to the departure of the procurement officer. The Head of Finance did not feel that there was an increase of risk. She informed Members that interviews had taken place for a replacement and she was hoping to have confirmation of the appointment by the end of the week.
Councillor S Sheahan questioned what had failed with the process and asked for reasons why the error was not identified sooner. The Head of Finance explained that capital accounting was a complex area and since the introduction of the concept of revaluation accounting by CIPFA in 2007, issues had been discovered by external audit year on year. Due to this the Head of Finance made a commitment to undertake a review of the Council’s capital position and a weakness in that area was identified.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that it was important to learn from mistakes which was the reason for his questions.
The Leader invited Councillor S Sheahan to ask his question.
Councillor S Sheahan thanked the Leader for allowing him to ask the question.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that when attempting to target groups it was important to consider the two main barriers which was motivation and convenience. It was also important to consider the different levels of social interaction required by individuals. [name removed] reported that previous consultation raised the issue of isolation as a key challenge for people to be active.
Councillor S Sheahan added that social interaction was important but a leisure centre setting could be intimidating for some. The Leisure Services Team Manager felt that it was important to take a holistic approach when deciding on what to offer, both in the leisure centre and the community.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that the subject matter was hard to understand as there were no figures included for comparison. The Head of Finance stated that it would take approximately one to two weeks to collate the information requested and agreed to provide the figures for each case as detailed in table 1 of the report.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that it was important for Cabinet to also have the information before making its decision.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Head of Human Resources and Organisation Development explained that the consultation process with the Trade Unions was currently ongoing and therefore an official response was not included within the report. The Chief Executive assured Members that the results of the consultation would be available before a decision was made.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that he was disappointed that Members were not being asked to approve any recommendations within the report.
It was moved by Councillor J Clarke, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
At the request of Councillor S Sheahan, the Licensing Enforcement Officer explained that there was not a set protocol regarding the issue of warnings, it was operated under officer discretion and warning letters were kept on the driver’s file indefinitely. He added that it was a combination of the number and nature of the warnings which led him to recommend a hearing to consider the application in this case.
Councillor S Sheahan questioned why so many warning letters were issued before any action was taken. The Licensing Enforcement Officer explained that in many cases it was the complainants word against the driver’s and therefore it was the responsibility of the officers to use their judgement as to the appropriate action to take.
Councillor S Sheahan suggested that the more letters a driver received, the less importance they held. The Licensing Officer agreed for this case as the warning letters were not effective.
Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 16, Appointment of representatives on community bodies, having been appointed to the New Albion Revised Liaison Committee and Redbank Manufacturing Liaison Committee as a member of Leicestershire County Council.
Councillor R Blunt stated that Councillor V Richichi had set an example and had been a credit to himself and the Council during his year as Chairman Councillor S Sheahan commented that Councillor V Richichi had always had something of an independent outlook as a Councillor and had never been afraid to speak his mind. He thanked him for his service in the past year.
Councillor S Sheahan congratulated the Leader on his appointment and announced the Shadow Cabinet as follows:
Councillor S Sheahan moved the following motion: “ That this Council adopts the following Construction Charter:
Councillor S Sheahan stated that he was pleased the planning system was being reformed. He welcomed the proposals to extend the call-in process and the progress made so far.
He advised that Councillor S Sheahan had made a comment in relation to the National Forest Line which would be noted and taken into account.
In relation to the value for money risk of the Medium Term Financial Planning, Councillor S Sheahan asked how external audit would approach the assessment of these risks. The External Auditor responded that they would work closely with the Head of Finance to challenge the assumptions made and to ensure that adequate arrangements were put in place to deal with the uncertainties. He added that it was not an exact science but the External Auditors used their knowledge and experience to ensure that the authority was aware of all factors and that these were clearly set out in all reports.
Councillor S Sheahan asked for the External Auditors opinion on the continued freeze on council tax levels. The External Auditor explained he could not become involved in the matter as it was a political decision, however it was important to ensure that the appropriate level of information was made available to members when making this decision and that the correct arrangements were in place to plan for the future once the decision had been made. He added that it was not his place to challenge political decisions.
Councillor S Sheahan asked if that decision put the authority at risk due to the reliance on other unsustainable forms of income such as the new homes bonus. The External Auditors agreed that there was some uncertainty around the new homes bonus and that was why it was important to have the correct plans in place, this was what External Audit looked ... view the full minutes text for item 34.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan , the Interim Audit Manager agreed to provide an update at the next meeting regarding the progress of the review of compliance with the CIPFA Code of Practice on managing the risk of fraud and corruption. The Strategic Director of Housing and Customer services confirmed that a full update on the development of the policy would be provided at the next meeting. He assured Members that lots of work had been undertaken on Cyber Security and he was confident that the right actions were being taken to protect the council systems.
Regarding the recent problems with Northamptonshire County Council, in that they had been issued with a Section 114 notice in light of the severe financial challenge facing the authority, Councillor S Sheahan asked how it would affect North West Leicestershire District Council if the same happened to an authority we had lent to. The External Auditor explained that the Section 114 notice had been issued to Northamptonshire County Council to restrict expenditure as they were unable to set a budget and it was the first notice of this kind to be issued in 18 years. He was not sure what the outcome would be as it had not occurred in such a long time, this was the reason that an advisory notice had been issued by the External Auditors of Northamptonshire County Council.
Councillor S Sheahan felt that the Corporate Risk Register was still too generic. He asked officers to consider using the same format as Leicestershire County Council as they give an indication of movement of the risk which was helpful. The Strategic Director of Housing and Customer Services took the comments on board and agreed to provide more information where possible.
In relation to the improvement action for the development of performance management system to be more intuitive and less administratively burdensome, Councillor S Sheahan asked for an update. The Head of Finance explained that the current system meant the process was very time-consuming and required many officers to input data. A new system had been purchased which linked into other systems, this stopped officers duplicating tasks and will make the process simpler.
It was moved by Councillor S Mckendrick, seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor S Sheahan asked how the MP enquiries were prioritised over councillor enquiries. The Head of Legal and Commercial Services explained that all complaints and enquiries followed the same timescales and there was no prioritisation.
The motion was seconded by Councillor S Sheahan who stated that what really mattered was the housing crisis and what the Council could do for the 750 people on the waiting list. It was proposed that the government be lobbied as the Right to Buy scheme was responsible for the net loss. He added that the Labour group believed the Council could do a lot more.
Councillor S Sheahan thanked the Chief Executive and all those who participated in the review process. He asked why the report was ... view the full minutes text for item 76.
Councillor S Sheahan welcomed the report and the commitment to develop an action plan.
Councillor S Sheahan, neighbouring ward member, addressed the Committee. He advised Members that the development of the site had been to Committee on several occasions. He welcomed the commitment from officers to consult with the neighbours over the boundary treatment, however it did not get away from the fact that the site was being over developed.
It was moved by Councillor P Purver , seconded by Councillor S Sheahan and RESOLVED THAT:
Councillor S Sheahan referred to the application form submitted, in particular the additional steps taken to promote the licensing objectives as parts have been left blank. He asked if there was a reason that this part of the form had been left bank. [name removed], responded that the conditions attached to the Licence addressed the steps that were taken, for example the CCTV provision and the use of door staff.
Councillor S Sheahan commented that this was a disgraceful amendment and felt that it would be one of the worst business practices to put such pressure ... view the full minutes text for item 64.
Regarding the guide to assist officers in determining an application following a revocation of a consent, Councillor S Sheahan questioned the wording of ‘Failings were minor’, as he felt there must be a limit and this was not clear. The Environmental Health Team Manager explained that this was in respect of a minor non-compliance to conditions which would not result in a revocation. He added that it would need to be a very serious failing for a revocation and the authority had only revoked one licence in the last nine years.
Councillor S Sheahan suggested the following wording ‘Failings were significant and occurred as an isolated incident.’ Councillor V Richichi asked if there would be a list of offences within the policy so that it was clear of the level of seriousness for the failings. The Environmental Health Team Manager explained that the decisions would be taken by officers whom would also take legal advice as part of the process and therefore there would not be a list of offences. The chairman felt that the officers should use their judgment on these matters, especially as legal advice would be sought.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan , the Environmental Health Team Manager confirmed that District ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
In response to a question from Councillor S Sheahan, the Chief Executive explained that in accordance with the Council’s Constitution, the approval of the was the decision of Cabinet and was agreed at the last meeting.
Councillor S Sheahan raised the following questions and comments:
· Councillor S Sheahan was pleased to see that officers were properly taking into account what might happen to finances, considering the sacrifice that had been made with freezing council tax and the future in-year deficits that were detailed at paragraph 3.3 of the report. He was very interested in how the Self-Sufficiency Reserve was going to be used for supporting local infrastructure and sustainable growth, and asked for some examples. The Chief Executive responded that the Self-Sufficiency Fund could be used for a multitude of things but focusing on sustainable growth, local businesses could be supported if needed within a number of areas such as productivity.
Councillor S Sheahan stated that it was not clear how ... view the full minutes text for item 42.
Showing the latest 300 of 512.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Sheahan attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Nov 2021 | Council | Motions | Lost | 14 for, 21 against, 1 abstained | |
| 16 Mar 2021 | Council | Update on Establishment of Company to be known as 'EM DEVCO Limited' | Carried | 31 for, 4 against | |
| 16 Mar 2021 | Council | North West Leicestershire Local Plan Partial Review - Proposed Adoption | Carried | 32 for, 4 against | |
| 17 Nov 2020 | Council | Council Delivery Plan 2020/21 | Carried | 19 for, 4 against, 12 abstained | |
| 17 Nov 2020 | Council | Establishment of Company to be Known as 'EM DEVCO LIMITED' | Carried | 30 for, 4 against | |
| 8 Sep 2020 | Council | Allocation of Seats on Committees (Political Balance) | Carried | 31 for, 4 against | |
| 13 Feb 2018 | Planning Committee | 17/00921/FUL: Erection of two first floor and single storey rear extensions, external staircase, new shop front to allow for the change of use to restaurant with hot food takeaway sales and an A2 (financial and professional services) use an | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Apr 2015 | Planning Committee | 15/01103/FUL: Proposed Conversion of attached outbuilding to form one residential dwelling | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Apr 2015 | Planning Committee | 15/00033/FUL: Erection of a single storey front extension | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Mar 2015 | Planning Committee | 14/00991/FULM: Erection of seventeen affordable dwellings, with access on to Wyggeston Road and North Avenue, associated groundworks and landscaping | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00898/FUL: Demolition of existing bungalow and the erection of three two storey dwellings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00862/FULM: Temporary change of use of land from agriculture to a solar farm with continued agriculture and associated infrastructure | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00934/FUL: Two storey side extension consisting of a residential annexe | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Aug 2014 | Planning Committee | 14/00450/FUL - Proposed new clubhouse and changing room | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Nov 2013 | Cabinet | Minutes of the Coalville Special Expenses Working Party | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Sheahan was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 6 of 11 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Sheahan declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Mar 2026 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 45 | Councillor S Sheahan declared an other interest in item 9 – Legacy Fund Grant, as a long ‑ term supporter of the Ashby Canal Trust. | |
| 13 May 2025 | Council, item 2 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a registerable interest in item 10, Motions, due to the reference to HS2 and a property owner affected by the proposed route. | |
| 8 Dec 2021 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 31 | Following advice from the Monitoring Officer, Councillor S Sheahan declared an interest in item 6 – Draft Budget Proposals and Council Tax 2021/22 as a property owner affected by the proposed HS2 route. If a discussion was had on this matter directly during the item, he would leave the meeting and not take part in the debate. | Took no part |
| 16 Mar 2021 | Council, item 64 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest with regard to any broad reference in reports to HS2 on the proviso that if any verbal reference was made to it in the meeting, he would declare a pecuniary interest and leave the meeting. | |
| 6 Jan 2021 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 18 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 7 – Draft General Fund and Special Expenses Revenue Budget with regard to any reference to HS2 due to the location of his home in relation to the route. If any verbal reference was made to it in the meeting, he would declare a pecuniary interest and leave the meeting. | |
| 11 Nov 2020 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 11 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Items for Inclusion in Future Work Programme and Item 7 – Budget Proposals 2021/22 as a Leicestershire County Councillor and a property owner affected by HS2. He confirmed that if any discussion took place regarding HS2 he would leave the meeting. | |
| 8 Sep 2020 | Council, item 19 | A non-pecuniary interest was declared by Councillor Sheahan with regard to any reference in reports to HS2 on the proviso that if any verbal reference is made to it in the meeting, he would declare a pecuniary interest and leave the meeting. | |
| 2 Sep 2020 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Councillor Sheahan declared non-pecuniary interests in item 8 and 9 – Council Delivery Plan 2020-21 and 2019/20 Q4 & 2020/21 Q1 Performance Reports in relation to his role as a member of Leicestershire County Council and references to HS2. Should the latter be discussed, he would declare a pecuniary interest and leave the meeting. In any other event, he would remain in the meeting and take part in the discussions. | |
| 23 Jun 2020 | Council, item 2 | Councillor S Sheahan declared non-pecuniary interests in item 10.2 – Motions, as a member of Leicestershire County Council, and item 14 – Appointment of Representatives on Community Bodies, as an LCC appointed member to the Redbank Liaison Committee and the New Albion Liaison Committee. | |
| 11 Mar 2020 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 38 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 7 – 2019/20 Q3 Performance Report as the report referred to HS2. | |
| 12 Jun 2019 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – 2018/19 Quarter 4 Performance Report due to the reference to HS2 within the report. | |
| 12 Jun 2019 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | In addition, during the item, a further discussion ensued and therefore Councillor S Sheahan declared a pecuniary interest and left the meeting for the remainder of the debate. | Left the room |
| 21 May 2019 | Council, item 2 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 16 – Appointment of Representatives on Community Bodies, having been appointed to the New Albion Revised Liaison Committee and Redbank Manufacturing Liaison Committee as a member of Leicestershire County Council. | |
| 26 Feb 2019 | Council, item 47 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10 - Budget and Council Tax 2019/20, to any reference relating to HS2. He also declared a pecuniary interest in item 11 – HS2 Update, due to the location of his home in relation to the route. | |
| 9 Jan 2019 | Policy Development Group, item 33 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 12 – Marlborough Square Update as a Councillor for Leicestershire County Council. He also declared a pecuniary interest in item 8 – Draft 2019/20 General Fund and Special Expenses Revenue Budgets, as there was reference in the report to HS2. He advised that he would leave the room during any discussion on HS2. | |
| 13 Nov 2018 | Council, item 33 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 10 - Leicester and Leicestershire Authorities’ Joint Strategic Growth Plan, as a member of Leicestershire County Council and due to the reference to HS2 in the report. | |
| 5 Nov 2018 | Policy Development Group, item 25 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a pecuniary interest in item 7 – Quarter 2 Performance Management Report, due to the reference in the report to HS2. He advised that he would leave the room during any discussion on HS2. | |
| 19 Sep 2018 | Policy Development Group, item 12 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a pecuniary interest in item 9 – HS2 Update, as a resident of Measham directly impacted by the proposed route. | |
| 15 May 2018 | Council, item 2 | Councillor S Sheahan declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 16, Appointment of representatives on community bodies, having been appointed to the New Albion Revised Liaison Committee and Redbank Manufacturing Liaison Committee as a member of Leicestershire County Council. |
Where Councillor Sheahan sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jan 2014 | 68 | |
| Corporate Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 39 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Observer | Jul 2013 | 61 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Observer | Mar 2016 | 33 | |
| Policy Development Group | Committee Member | Oct 2011 | 28 | |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2016 | 23 | |
| Planning Committee | Substitute | Feb 2014 | 21 | |
| Local Plan Advisory Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2014 | 8 | |
| Community Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jun 2019 | 7 | |
| Coalville Special Expenses Working Party | Observer | Oct 2018 | 6 | |
| Community Engagement Strategy Task and Finish Group | Committee Member | Oct 2014 | 3 | |
| Taxi and Private Hire Sub Committee | Committee Member | May 2018 | 3 | |
| Local Plan Committee | Observer | May 2020 | 2 | |
| Licensing Sub Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2018 | 1 | |
| the Council - Planning and Infrastructure Cabinet Member Meeting | Observer | May 2020 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.