Apologies for Absence
Councillor Andrew Rule – substituted by Councillor Kevin Clarke.
Every time Nottingham's minutes name Councillor Rule, as the council published it.
Councillor Andrew Rule – substituted by Councillor Kevin Clarke.
Face coverings Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Leader of the Council:
Thank you Lord Mayor , and can I thank Councillor Rule for his question.
Councillor Andrew Rule (Chair)” and amend all other ordinary members of the Committee accordingly.
Councillor Kirsty L Jones proposed the following motion, which was seconded by Councillor Andrew Rule:
In advance of the 25 th November Executive Board meeting, Councillor Andrew Rule was told that he no longer had speaking rights, despite this he chose to attend anyway and despite being a member of scrutiny committees and the Leader of a minority political group, found himself evicted when exempt items were discussed. This appears prima facie to councillors’ right to access information under Section 100F Local Government Act 1972 (as amended).
In the interests of transparency in relation to agenda item 5 (Community Centre Transformation Project Update), Councillor David Mellen stated that he is the Chair of the Bakersfield Community Centre management committee, and Councillor Andrew Rule stated that he is invited to attend the meetings of the Clifton Community Centre management committee.
Councillor Steve Battlemuch – leave Councillor Farzanna Mahmood – work commitments Councillor Sarita-Marie Rehman-Wall - personal Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments Bevis Mackie
Councillor Audrey Dinnall - work commitments Councillor Andrew Rule - work commitments
Resolved that the: 1) following appointments to the Fire and Rescue Authority are noted; Nottingham City Council: Councillor Liaqat Ali (Labour) Councillor Steve Battlemuch (Labour) Councillor Nayab Patel for this meeting only, then Councillor Nick Raine (Labour) Councillor Samina Riaz (Labour) Councillor Andrew Rule (Independent) Councillor Audra Wynter (Labour)
With an amendment to Minute 81 to reflect that Councillor Andrew Rule abstained in the vote on the Council’s budget, the minutes of the Council meeting held on 3 March 2025 were confirmed as an accurate record and signed by the Chair.
Councillor Andrew Rule asked a question for clarification about the cost of work to develop proposals.
Councillor AJ Matsiko - personal reasons Councillor Andrew Rule - work commitments
Councillor Andrew Rule presented a petition on behalf of residents of Wilford and the wider Clifton West area asking the Council for yellow hatch-boxing over the crossroads in Wilford Village and the introduction of sequencing and a filter light to assist traffic turning into Wilford Village.
1) the City Council has appointed Councillor Andrew Rule (stand-alone Independent), in place of Councillor Salma Mumtaz;
Councillor Andrew Rule - work commitments Councillor Naim Salim - personal reasons
(3) note that, in accordance with the allocation of seats to political groups as set out in Appendix 1, Councillor Salma Mumtaz is no longer a member of the Nottinghamshire and City of Nottingham Fire and Rescue Authority; and to appoint Councillor Andrew Rule as a member of the Nottinghamshire and City of Nottingham Fire and Rescue Authority.
Councillor Faith Gakanje-Ajala – work commitments Councillor Fozia Mubashar – personal reasons Councillor Salma Mumtaz – personal reasons Councillor Andrew Rule - work commitments
Councillor Andrew Rule - unwell
Councillor Andrew Rule – illness Councillor Patience Uloma Ifediora – annual leave Councillor Eunice Regan – personal
Councillor Imran Jalil – Work Commitments Councillor Sarita-Marie Rehman-Wall – Personal Councillor Andrew Rule – Unwell Councillor Naim Salim – Unwell
Councillor Patience Ifediora – Unwell Councillor Georgia Power – Work (Councillor Michael Edwards as substitute) Councillor Andrew Rule – Work (Councillor Kevin Clarke as substitute)
Councillor Andrew Rule presented a petition on behalf of residents asking the Council to approve a 20mph speed limit on the road known as New Rise, Lark Hill Village NG11 8DB;
Improvement Plan Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Leader of the Council:
Can I thank you Councillor Rule for your question. There are many challenges in delivering our Improvement Plan. I have been clear in this Chamber before that the next three years will make or break this Council.
In the interests of transparency, Councillor Andrew Rule highlighted that he attended the committee meetings at Park Gate Community Centre. This did not preclude him from speaking on any item.
In the interests of transparency in relation to item 6 – Community Centre Review, Councillor Andrew Rule highlighted that he was a Committee Member of Clifton Community Centre and Park Gate Community Centre. This did not preclude him from speaking on any item.
Chief Executive Pay Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Chair of the Appointments and Conditions of Service Committee:
Thank you Lord-Mayor , and I thank Councillor Rule for his question. As he will know, we are currently going through the process of recruitment for a new Chief Executive at the moment and in doing so we advertise salary and terms and conditions in line with the rules of the Local Government Association and the position that is adopted nationally – we don’t change the rules in Nottingham to adapt to that situation. So I’m quite happy to read a statement out that explains how we’re doing that, and that’s as follows: “The Chief Executive, Corporate Directors and Strategic Directors are currently paid on an all-inclusive, fixed spot salary drawn from a predetermined band.
In response to a question for clarification asked by Councillor Andrew Rule, Councillor Corall Jenkins replied that it was unlikely that Vernon Coaker would be continuing as Chair of the Nottingham Community Safety Partnership Board following his recent appointment as Defence Secretary.
Councillor Kevin Clarke proposed Councillor Andrew Rule as Leader of the Council.
Councillor Andrew Rule presented a petition on behalf of residents of Garrett Grove and Farriers Green asking the Council to improve flood mitigation measures on Council owned land adjacent to Garrett Grove and Farriers Green through the installation of a ‘French Drain’ along the entirety of the boundary of the field from Garrett Grove to Farriers Green.
Councillor Liaqat Ali – on leave Councillor Sam Lux – on leave Councillor Nayab Patel – personal reasons Councillor Andrew Rule – on leave
Councillor Faith Gakanje-Ajala – on leave Councillor Neghat Khan – unwell Councillor AJ Matsiko – work commitments Councillor Nayab Patel – work commitments Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments
Councillor Andrew Rule presented a petition on behalf of citizens opposing the decision by Extracare to remove the ATM cash machine from Lark Hill Village, Clifton Estate and the safety concerns posed by the cash machines on Nobel Road. The petitioners consider that the decision will have a hugely detrimental impact on the Village and call on the Portfolio Holder for Adult Social Care and Health to join the residents of Lark Hill in lobbying Extracare to reverse the decision.
Councillor Andrew Rule presented a petition on behalf of citizens calling on the Portfolio Holder with responsibility for highways, the Portfolio Holder with responsibility for the environment and the Corporate Director for Communities, Environment and Resident Services to create a working group with their equivalents in Nottinghamshire County Council, Tramlink and Severn Trent Water to look at how this can be alleviated going forward and specifically address the following issues:
Councillor Liaqat Ali spoke in support of the nomination of Anne Peach; Councillor Andrew Rule spoke in support of the nomination of Roger Steel; and Councillor Georgia Power spoke in support of the nomination of David Trimble.
Councillor Andrew Rule (leave), Councillor Kevin Clark substituting Councillor Nayab Patel (work commitments)
Subject to showing that Councillor Andrew Rule was present, the exempt minutes of the meeting held on 27 March 2023 were confirmed as a true record and signed by the Chair.
Aspley ward – Councillor Graham Chapman, Councillor Patience Ifediora and Councillor Carole McCulloch Basford ward – Councillor Salma Mumtaz, Councillor Nick Raine and Councillor Linda Woodings Berridge ward – Councillor Angela Kandola, Councillor Sulcan Mahmood and Councillor Shuguftah Quddoos Bestwood ward – Councillor Jay Hayes, Councillor Georgia Power and Councillor Audra Wynter Bilborough ward – Councillor Faith Gakanje-Ajala , Councillor Sam Harris and Councillor Helen Kalsi Bulwell ward – Councillor Maria Joannou, Councillor Ethan Radford and Councillor Michael Savage Bulwell Forest ward – Councillor Cheryl Barnard, Councillor Sam Gardiner and Councillor Sarita -Marie Rehman -Wall Castle ward – Councillor Sam Lux and Councillor Matt Shannon Clifton East ward – Councillor Kevin Clarke, Councillor Kirsty M Jones and Councillor Maria Watson Clifton West ward – Councillor Andrew Rule and Councillor Hayley Spain Dales ward – Councillor Gul Khan, Councillor Neghat Khan and Councillor David Mellen Hyson Green and Arboretum ward – Councillor Liaqat Ali, Councillor Sana Nasir and Councillor Naim Salim Leen Valley ward – Councillor Audrey Dinnall and Councillor Nadia Farhat Lenton and Wollaton East ward – Councillor Imran Jalil , Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis and Councillor Samina Riaz Mapperley ward – Councillor Leslie Ayoola, Councillor Kirsty L Jones and Councillor Sajid Mohammed Meadows ward – Councillor Michael Edwards and Councillor Eunice Regan Radford ward – Councillor Far
Councillor Rosemary Healy Councillor Anne Peach Councillor Audra Wynter – on other Council Business Councillor Andrew Rule – personal Councillor Sajid Mohammed Malcolm Townroe Councillor Sam Gardiner for leaving the meeting early due to personal reasons.
Councillor Andrew Rule – personal Aila Barr Peter Ireson Nick Lee John Matravers Lynn Pearce Alison Platkiw Jane Richardson Audrey Taylor Catherine Underwood
Councillor Andrew Rule submitted a petition on behalf of residents asking the Council to request that Avant Homes conduct a more thorough consultation exercise and hold a public meeting for residents of the Barton Green estate to outline their plans in detail, before submission of any planning application for a 265 housing development off Hawksley Gardens.
Councillor Andrew Rule proposed the following amendment, which was seconded by Councillor Kevin Clarke:
Resolved to reject the amendment proposed by Councillor Rule.
In the interests of transparency Councillor Andrew Rule declared he was a member of the board of Silverdale and Parkdale Community Centres. He did not consider that this would require him to leave the meeting for this item.
Councillor Andrew Rule stated that he is a member of the Parkgate Community Centre.
Councillor Andrew Rule stated that he is a member of the Parkgate Community Centre and Clifton Community Centre.
Councillor Wendy Smith, Lord Mayor, and Councillor David Mellen, Leader of the Council, spoke in tribute to Queen Elizabeth II and this was followed by tributes from Councillor Kevin Clarke, Leader of the Nottingham Independents Group, and Councillor Andrew Rule, Leader of the Conservative Group. Councillors Rebecca Langton, Michael Edwards, Ethan Radford, Angharad Roberts, Cheryl Barnard, Eunice Campbell-Clark, Graham Chapman and Maria Watson then spoke. Councillors spoke about the Queen’s commitment to public duty, and her service to the country and the Commonwealth over many years including periods of significant change.
Councillor Radford – personal Councillor Rule – work commitments
Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis - unwell Councillor Rebecca Langton - maternity leave Councillor Andrew Rule - on leave Mel Barratt - Chief Executive Clive Heaphy - Interim Corporate Director for Finance and Resources Frank Jordan - Corporate Director for Resident Services Malcolm Townroe - Director for Legal and Governance
Councillor Andrew Rule stated that he was a Member of the Parkgate Comminute Centre Management Committee and the Good Companions Management Committee who both rent buildings from Nottingham City Council.
Councillor Barnard - leave Councillor Hayes - unspecified Councillor Jackson - personal Councillor Rule - work Ailsa Barr Kathryn Higgins Jasmine Howell Jon Rea
Councillor Andrew Rule presented a petition on behalf of residents of Lark Hill Retirement Village requesting more adequate recycling bins for the village to enable residents to support the Council in achieving its recycling targets.
For Against Councillor Hassan Ahmed ü Councillor Leslie Ayoola ü Councillor Cheryl Barnard ü Councillor Steve Battlemuch ü Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark ü Councillor Graham Chapman ü Councillor Azad Choudhry ü Councillor Kevin Clarke ü Councillor Michael Edwards ü Councillor Jay Hayes ü Councillor Nicola Heaton ü Councillor Patience Ifediora ü Councillor Corall Jenkins ü Councillor Kirsty Jones ü Councillor Angela Kandola ü Councillor Jawaid Khalil ü Councillor Gul Khan ü Councillor Neghat Khan ü Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis ü Councillor Jane Lakey ü Councillor AJ Matsiko ü Councillor David Mellen ü Councillor Toby Neal ü Councillor Anne Peach ü Councillor Georgia Power ü Councillor Ethan Radford ü Councillor Nick Raine ü Councillor Angharad Roberts ü Councillor Andrew Rule ü Councillor Wendy Smith ü Councillor Roger Steel ü Councillor Sam Webster ü Councillor Linda Woodings ü Councillor Cate Woodward ü Councillor Audra Wynter ü Resolved to:
Councillor Andrew Rule advised the Committee that the Companies working group had met twice and had discussed governance arrangements including the Conflict of Interest Policy for members sitting on company boards. There had also been focus on the need for a clear demarcation between the work of the overview and Scrutiny Committee and the Audit Committee to limit the duplication of work.
(b) Councillor Andrew Rule advised the Committee that the Companies working group had fed back on governance arrangements for Group Companies recommended inclusion of mechanisms in articles of association that prevent companies exposing the Council to risk, such as obtaining finance, without prior approval;
Councillor Jane Lakey provided an update from the Capital Working Group, highlighting that progress being made but there is a need to understand the key projects, statistics and KPIs are being monitored, and there will be updates on the district heating system and Broadmarsh at each meeting Councillor Andrew Rule provided an update from the Companies Working Group, highlighting that the Group is looking at the progress of evaluations of the companies, and two are expected by December. Work is being done to establish regular standard interactions with the companies, and standard principles for companies to follow in procuring Internal Audit are being established by the relevant officers.
Councillor David Mellen and Councillor Andrew Rule spoke in tribute to William Bradbury and a minute’s silence was held.
Councillor Andrew Rule provided an update from the Companies Working Group highlighting the following points:
Councillor Rebecca Langton and Councillor Andrew Rule spoke in tribute to Toni Price.
Property Realisation Strategy Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Leader of the Council:
Thank you Lord Mayor and can I thank Councillor Rule for his question.
Old Market Square Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and Schools:
Thank you very much Councillor Rule. All events staged within Old Market Square and across our public open spaces and parks are required to reinstate or meet the cost of any damage that occurs during the licenced period. A pre and post event site survey is undertaken to ensure this happens at all times.
Broadmarsh Site Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Leader of the Council:
Thank you Lord Mayor and thank you to Councillor Rule for his question. I thought what would be the question about the Broadmarsh ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
Councillor Sue Johnson – personal reasons Councillor Angharad Roberts – work commitments Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments
Councillor Andrew Rule confirmed that the Companies Working Group had met, and draft Terms of Reference circulated to members for comment.
Councillor Cheryl Barnard - Council Business Councillor Adele Williams - Council Business Councillor Andrew Rule - Personal Clive Heaphy - Interim Corporate Director of Finance and Resources Malcolm Townroe - Director of Legal and Governance Services
Central Library Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Leader of the Council:
Thank you Lord Mayor and can I thank Councillor Rule for this question. Firstly, I want to recognise the important roles that libraries play in our communities. Access to quality local library provision makes a massive difference to many peoples’ lives and their future life chances.
Children’s Services budget savings Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Children and Young People:
Thank you Lord Mayor and can I thank Councillor Rule for asking this question. Any plan for a child to return to their family or relative via rehabilitation will be based on a robust assessment which will include the views of their Independent Reviewing Officer and will be part of their agreed Care Plan. I would add that, in most cases, the aim at the outset of a child entering care should be reunification with their family.
Can I assure Councillor Rule that I have looked carefully at this decision and am confident that this approach will not compromise child safety. However, we face a national crisis in relation to children services. The Local Government Association reported as far back as August 2019 that children’s services across the country were facing a £1.4bn shortfall for 2021.
Councillor Andrew Rule, seconded by Councillor Kevin Clarke, proposed a further amendment, as set out below:
Councillor Andrew Rule, seconded by Councillor Roger Steel, proposed an amendment to the Recovery and Improvement Plan, as set out below.
Councillor Andrew Rule – Councillor Roger Steel as a substitute.
Councillor Andrew Rule reported that he asked about this at an Overview and Scrutiny Committee and was told that it is still scheduled in their programmes but they are prioritising repairs to Clifton Bridge.
Date approved Allocated Schemes Councillor(s) Amount (total) 14/10/2020 Summerwood Day Centre Cllrs Clarke, Jones, & Watson £500.00 10/12/2020 Christmas in Clifton Cllrs Clarke, Jones, & Watson £3,036.00 01/06/2020 Wilford Community Group – Covid Support Cllr Rule & Cllr Steel £1000,00 10/12/2020 Wilford Green Tree Cllr Rule & Cllr Steel £615.00 10/12/2020 Christmas in Clifton Cllr Rule £550.00
For Against Abstain Councillor Leslie Ayoola ü Councillor Cheryl Barnard ü Councillor Steve Battlemuch ü Councillor Merlita Bryan ü Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark ü Councillor Graham Chapman ü Councillor Kevin Clarke ü Councillor Michael Edwards ü Councillor Sam Gardiner ü Councillor Jay Hayes ü Councillor Rosemary Healy ü Councillor Nicola Heaton ü Councillor Patience Ifediora ü Councillor Maria Joannou ü Councillor Kirsty Jones ü Councillor Angela Kandola ü Councillor Jawaid Khalil ü Councillor Gul Khan ü Councillor Neghat Khan ü Councillor Zafran Khan ü Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis ü Councillor Rebecca Langton ü Councillor Chantal Lee ü Councillor Dave Liversidge ü Councillor Sally Longford ü Councillor AJ Matsiko ü Councillor Carole McCulloch ü Councillor David Mellen ü Councillor Sajid Mohammed ü Councillor Salma Mumtaz ü Councillor Toby Neal ü Councillor Lauren O’Grady ü Councillor Anne Peach ü Councillor Shuguftah Quddoos ü Councillor Ethan Radford ü Councillor Nick Raine ü Councillor Angharad Roberts ü Councillor Andrew Rule ü Councillor Wendy Smith ü Councillor Roger Steel ü Councillor Dave Trimble ü Councillor Maria Watson ü Councillor Sam Webster ü Councillor Adele Williams ü Councillor Linda Woodings ü Councillor Cate Woodward ü Councillor Audra Wynter ü Resolved to (1) approve i. the Interim Budget for 2020/21 ii. the recommendations of the Strategic Director of Finance/ Chief Finance Officer in respect of the robustness of the estimates made for the purpos
1) Councillor Audrey Dinnall replaced Councillor Shuguftah Quddoos as a member of the Regulatory and Appeals Committee 2) Councillor Andrew Rule replaced Councillor Roger Steel as a member of the Overview and Scrutiny Call In Panel 3) Councillor Roger Steel was appointed as a substitute member of the Overview and Scrutiny Call In Panel 4) Councillor Sajid Mohammed replaced Councillor Steve Battlemuch as a member of the Audit Committee 5) Councillor Jay Hayes replaced Councillor Lauren O’Grady as a member of the Audit Committee.
Councillor Andrew Rule – Trustee of the Bridges Trust Councillor Graham Chapman – Board Member of Nottingham City Transport, and member of the Nottinghamshire Pensions Committee (Non-Voting rights) Councillor Michael Edwards – Board Member of EnviroEnergy Councillor Anne Peach – Board member of Nottingham Ice Arena and Nottingham Play House and member of the Nottinghamshire Pensions Committee (Non-Voting rights) Councillor Jay Hayes – Member of Nottingham Education Trust Board Councillor Sajid Mohammed – Chair of the Bridges Trust
Councillor Andrew Rule, seconded by Councillor Roger Steel, proposed an amendment to the Action Plan, as detailed in the attached appendices.
The Leader of the Council offered to meet with Councillor Andrew Rule, Leader of the Conservative Group, and Councillor Kevin Clarke, Leader of the Nottingham Independents, to discuss their views on the Action Plan in more detail.
Councillor Andrew Rule – Trustee of the Bridges Trust Councillor Lauren O’Grady – Board Member of Robin Hood Energy Councillor Graham Chapman – Board Member of Nottingham City Transport, and member of the Nottinghamshire Pension Committee (Non-Voting rights) Councillor Michael Edwards – Board Member of EnviroEnergy Councillor Anne Peach – Board member of Nottingham Ice Arena and Nottingham Play House and member of the Nottinghamshire Pension Committee (Non-Voting rights)
Councillor Andrew Rule proposed an amendment to the budget as follows:
Councillor Andrew Rule - Council business Councillor Cate Woodward - unwell
Knife-related crime Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Leader of the Council:
Thank you Lord Mayor and can I thank Councillor Rule for his question.
During discussion of the item, Councillor Rule declared an interest in item 8, ‘Bridge Estate Property Update – exempt appendix’, insofar as he worked for a firm of insolvency practitioners.
During consideration of this item, Councillor Rule declared an interest (see minute 22 above).
Knife related crime Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Leader of the Council:
Thank you Lord Mayor, and can I thank Councillor Rule for his question. Keeping our City safe is a top priority and one that I am committed to delivering. The causes of crime often begin long before a crime is committed, and to truly make a difference we have to intervene early to prevent these underlying causes from emerging in our communities.
Lord Mayor, if Councillor Rule is committed truly to supporting continued reductions in serious crime in our City, then perhaps he will join me in asking for greater protection of public services following nine years of sustained cuts to Police budgets, which have led to the loss of 10,000 Police Officers on the streets up and down the country. The Tories never learn. Whilst a Labour Government increased Police and Police Community Support Officer (PCSO) numbers, championing community policing, and crime fell hugely, the Tories have cut the Police numbers and, lo and behold, crime has risen.
Councillor Sue Johnson - unwell Councillor Jane Lakey - work commitments Councillor Andrew Rule - on leave
RESOLVED to form a working group of Councillor Anne Peach, Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis and Councillor Carole McCulloch (with an invitation to join extended to Councillor Andrew Rule) to meet with Council officers to discuss what processes exist for citizen consultation on policy change; how cohesive, efficient, and broad the consultations are; how the full range of citizens are engaged with and how engagement is maximised; how consultations can be improved;
Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments Emma Crane, NG11 Childminders Group Mark Armstrong, Town Centre Co-ordinator
Councillor Barnard ) Councillor Raine ) Councillor Rule ) other City Council business Councillor Saghir ) Councillor Williams ) Councillor Kandola - no reason given Councillor Liversidge - personal Councillor Neal - annual leave
RESOLVED to appoint Councillor Andrew Rule as Vice-Chair of the Committee for the 2019/20 municipal year.
Councillor Sally Longford – Council Business Councillor Andrew Rule – Council Business Ian Curryer – Chief Executive
Councillor Andrew Rule proposed an amendment to the budget as follows:
Members of the Committee welcomed this approach and Councillor Andrew Rule requested that, as with Executive Board, the Lead Opposition Member is able to attend the meetings and allowed the opportunity to comment, even if voting powers are not permitted. The Chair agreed to progress this request.
Councillor Merlita Bryan - personal Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark - personal Councillor Andrew Rule - work commitments Councillor Chris Tansley - unwell Councillor Cate Woodward - unwell
Nottingham and Nottinghamshire Integrated Care System Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Adult Social Care and Health:
Can I thank Councillor Rule for his question. As I stated in the report to the Executive Board we remain fully committed to the integration of health and social care services where this is beneficial to Nottingham residents.
Councillor Andrew Rule requested that his objection to the granting of planning permission was recorded.
Councillor Andrew Rule – Work Commitments (Councillor Roger Steele attending as substitute) Councillor Gul Khan - leave
Councillor Andrew Rule – Work Commitments (Councillor Roger Steele attending as substitute) Councillor Linda Woodings – Council Business
Councillor Chris Tansey - personal Councillor Saghir - other Council business Councillor Andrew Rule - personal
For Against Abstained Councillor Liaqat Ali P Councillor Jim Armstrong P Councillor Cat Arnold P Councillor Leslie Ayoola P Councillor Ilyas Aziz Councillor Cheryl Barnard Councillor Steve Battlemuch Councillor Merlita Bryan P Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark P Councillor Graham Chapman P Councillor Azad Choudhry Councillor Jon Collins P Councillor Josh Cook Councillor Mike Edwards P Councillor Chris Gibson P Councillor Brian Grocock P Councillor John Hartshorne P Councillor Rosemary Healy P Councillor Nicola Heaton P Councillor Mohammed Ibrahim P Councillor Patience Ifediora P Councillor Corall Jenkins P Councillor Glyn Jenkins P Councillor Sue Johnson P Councillor Carole-Ann Jones P Councillor Gul Nawaz Khan P Councillor Neghat Khan P Councillor Ginny Klein P Councillor Dave Liversidge P Councillor Sally Longford P Councillor Carole McCulloch P Councillor Nick McDonald Councillor David Mellen Councillor Jackie Morris Councillor Toby Neal P Councillor Brian Parbutt Councillor Anne Peach P Councillor Sarah Piper P Councillor Georgia Power P Councillor Nick Raine P Councillor Andrew Rule P Councillor Mohammed Saghir P Councillor David Smith P Councillor Wendy Smith P Councillor Chris Tansley Councillor Dave Trimble P Councillor Jane Urquhart P Councillor Marcia Watson P Councillor Sam Webster P Councillor Adele Williams P Councillor Malcolm Wood P Councillor Linda Woodings P Councillor Cate Woodward P Councillor Steve Young P The minutes of the meeting held 9 July 2018 were ag
Councillor Andrew Rule spoke in tribute to former City Councillor, former MP, former County Councillor and Honorary Alderman Martin Brandon Bravo, and a minute’s silence was held.
Councillor Andrew Rule - personal (Councillor Jim Armstrong attended as substitute) Councillor Chris Tansley - personal
Councillor Sally Longford – other Council business (Councillor Cat Arnold attending as substitute) Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments
Bridge Date Approved Allocated schemes Councillor(s) Amount (total) 04/04/17 Hoodwinked Cllr Edwards, Cllr Heaton £250.00 17/04/18 Bridgeway Centre floral display Cllr Edwards, Cllr Heaton £2,642.05 02/05/18 AMCG Spring, Summer & Autumn events Cllr Edwards £600.00 25/05/18 26 th Nottingham (The Meadows) Scout Group Cllr Edwards £600.00 Manzil Cllr Edwards, Cllr Heaton £1,120.00 Balance brought forward from 2017/18 £4,215.00 Allocation 2018/19 £10,000.00 Total available allocation £14,215.00 Total de-committed £0.00 Total allocated at 21/05/18 £5,862.05 Total unallocated at 21/05/18 £8,352.95 Clifton North 01/03/18 Hoodwinked Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £500.00 22/03/18 Easter Fair at NG11 Foodbank Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £260.00 22/03/18 Replacement of damaged rugby posts- Nottingham Moderns RFU Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £550.00 13/04/18 Wilford Village floral display Cllr Rule £552.00 24/04/18 Wilford Community Group – May Day event Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £230.00 27/04/18 Ruddington Lane Family Funday 2018 Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £900.00 02/05/18 45 th Boys and Girls summer camp 2018 Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £300.00 10/05/18 Summerwood Community Gardens Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £1,750.00 10/05/18 Clifton Donation Group Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £512.00 10/05/18 Teddy Bears Picnic 2018 Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £800.00 10/05/18 Litterbins for Silverdale Cllr Rule £1,402.00 Balance bought forward 2017/18 £9,449.00 Allocation 2018/19 £15,000.00 Total av
Councillor Andrew Rule – leave Councillor Jim Armstrong (as substitute for Councillor Andrew Rule) – not specified.
Councillor Jones ) Councillor Rule ) annual leave Councillor Smith )
Councillor Cheryl Barnard – work commitments (Councillor Michael Edwards attending as substitute) Councillor Graham Chapman – Council business Councillor Josh Cook – Council Business Councillor Jackie Morris – Council business Councillor Brian Parbutt – Council business (attended from minute 7 onwards) Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments
Chargeable Parking Permits Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Neighbourhood Services and Local Transport:
Unfortunately, Councillor Rule, I have to tell you that t he review has not yet been completed. As soon as it is it will be discussed within the Executive, with a view to going public on any amendments to the current policy in due course.
Increased Allotment Rents Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Leisure and Culture:
Thank you Lord Mayor, and can I thank Councillor Rule for his question. The current consultation is proposing to increase rents over the next five years to bring them into line with other comparable authorities at this current time.
I’m not sure that Councillor Rule understands the finances of the allotment service, but 75% of that goes to the association, not the Council.
The Committee noted the appointment of Cllr Andrew Rule to the Committee and the resignation of Cllr Jon Collins from the Committee.
Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments.
Councillor Cheryl Barnard – personal Councillor Azad Choudhry – health Councillor Sally Longford – personal Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments (Councillor Jim Armstrong attending as substitute)
Councillor Andrew Rule proposed an amendment to the budget as follows:
Councillor Andrew Rule (one of the call-in signatories) outlined the reasons why the call-in had been requested:
Councillor Andrew Rule requested that his vote against the resolution be recorded.
Councillor Graham Chapman – other Council business Councillor Azad Choudhry – personal reasons Councillor Josh Cook – personal reasons Councillor Rosemary Healy – no reason given Councillor Andrew Rule – work commitments Councillor Linda Woodings – personal reasons
Chargeable Parking Permit Schemes Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Neighbourhood Services and Local Transport:
Thank you Councillor Rule for your question. The current adopted policy for residents parking schemes dates back to 1999, and is in need of a refresh. I have tasked officers with undertaking a review of the existing policy and to bring forward a revised policy for adoption as soon as practicable.
(a) Appointments and Conditions of Service Committee – the appointment of Councillor Andrew Rule to fill a vacancy;
(b) Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee – the appointment of Councillor Andrew Rule to fill a vacancy;
(f) Standards Committee – the appointment of Councillor Andrew Rule to fill a vacancy, and the appointment of Councillor Jim Armstrong as a substitute to fill a vacancy.
RESOLVED to note the appointment of Councillor Andrew Rule to the Committee
Councillor Andrew Rule asked that his abstention from voting on the scheme be recorded.
RESOLVED to note the appointment of Councillor Andrew Rule as a member of the Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Andrew Rule asked that his vote against the decision be recorded.
Bridge Date approved Scheme Councillor(s) Amount (total) 05/10/17 Christmas Grotto – Meadows Library Cllrs Edwards & Heaton £780.00 08/09/17 3G Camera warranty x2 cameras Cllrs Edwards & Heaton £730.00 Balance brought forward 2017/18 Allocation 2017/18 Total available allocation Total allocated at 17/10/17 Total unallocated at 17/10/17 £7,296.00 £10,000.00 £17,296.00 £12,966.00 £4,330.00 Clifton North Date approved Scheme Councillor(s) Amount (total) 01/09/17 Clifton Community Association – External grounds improvements Cllrs Cook & Rule £1,100.00 21/09/17 Clifton All Whites bonfire Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £744.00 27/09/17 Silverdale Senior Citizens’ Christmas party Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £600.00 04/10/17 Wilford children’s bonfire Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £535.00 04/10/17 1 st Clifton (Lord Mayor’s own) Scouts group Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £750.00 13/10/17 Spring bulb planting Cllr Cook £120.00 17/10/17 Community notice boards Cllr Rule £740.00 20/10/17 Clifton Christmas light switch-on Cllrs Cook, Ferguson & Rule £2,000.00 Balance brought forward 2017/18 Allocation 2017/18 Total available allocation Total allocated at 20/10/17 Total unallocated at 20/10/17 £11,817.00 £15,000.00 £26,817.00 £10,169.00 £16,648.00 Clifton South Date approved Scheme Councillor(s) Amount (total) 31/08/17 Clifton summer events Cllrs Gibson & Jenkins £700.00 31/08/17 Jobs and opportunities fair Cllrs Gibson & Jenkins £367.00 01/09/17 Clifton Community Association – External grounds
Councillor John Hartshorne – leave Councillor Sue Johnson Councillor Sally Longford – unwell Councillor Carole McCulloch – leave Councillor Nick McDonald – work commitments Councillor Andrew Rule – personal
Enviroenergy Shutdown Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Energy and Sustainability:
Thank you Lord Mayor, and thanks to Councillor Andrew Rule for his question. Enviroenergy is a separate legal entity. The Council is aware of the extended shutdown of the district heating station as a result of complex engineering works on the system.
Station Street Regeneration Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Leader:
Parking Permit Policy Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Neighbourhood Services and Local Transport:
Councillor Andrew Rule – leave Councillor Steve Young – personal Councillor Anne Peach – for lateness
Councillor Rule asked that his vote against the above decision be recorded.
Councillor Andrew Rule – personal reasons Councillor Steve Young – unwell Mary Daley Miriam Gifford Richard Gutteridge Roy Nettleship Margaret Spencer Pat Thomas Dee Whitworth
Robin Hood Energy Funding Councillor Rule asked the following question of the Deputy Leader:
The following amendment was proposed by Councillor Andrew Rule, seconded by Councillor Jim Armstrong:
Councillor Alan Clark - personal reasons Councillor Andrew Rule - work commitments (substituted by Councillor Georgina Culley) Councillor Wendy Smith - annual leave (substituted by Councillor Liaqat Ali) Councillor Linda Woodings - work commitments Councillor Steve Young - unwell (substituted by Councillor Michael Edwards)
Councillor Steve Young ) Councillor Brian Parbutt ) Personal Reasons Councillor Alan Clark ) Councillor Andrew Rule - Leave Councillor Georgina Culley (as Substitute for Councillor Rule) - Health Issues
Regeneration of Clifton retail centre Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Deputy Leader:
It may sound like a frivolous point on the part of Councillor Rule to think that the removal of road humps will be the salvation of Clifton’s shopping centre, but I do believe that road humps in some cases can be a deterrent to shopping in Clifton. A further disadvantage of road humps is that they increase emissions of nitrous dioxide, as vehicles slow down. So, they are not universally a good thing and it would be lovely to live without them.
Councillor Malcolm Wood - Other Council Business Councillor Alan Clark ) Councillor Gul Khan ) Councillor Andrew Rule ) Personal Councillor Wendy Smith ) Councillor Steve Young ) Councillor Linda Woodings )
Subject to listing Councillor Andrew Rule as in attendance, the minutes of the meeting held on 9 February 2017 were confirmed as a true record and signed by the Chair.
Subject to listing Councillor Andrew Rule as in attendance, t he exempt minute of the meeting held on 9 February 2017 were confirmed and signed by the Chair.
Councillor Andrew Rule - personal Councillor Cat Arnold – health Councillor Steve Young - personal Councillor Alan Clark – personal Councillor Azad Choudhry - leave
Rob Percival included within his presentation, a representation from Planning Committee member Councillor Andrew Rule whom was unable to attend the meeting. The following points were highlighted:
· Ensure that locally elected representatives are put at the heart of proposed changes to health and social care.” The following amendment was proposed by Councillor Andrew Rule, seconded by Councillor Georgina Culley:
Councillor Alan Clark – personal reasons Councillor Josh Cook – personal reasons Councillor Brian Parbutt – unwell Councillor Andrew Rule – other Council business Councillor Steve Young – personal reasons
Councillor Andrew Rule and Councillor Jim Armstrong (Call-in signatories), responded with the following information:
Councillor Cat Arnold – illness Councillor Alan Clark - personal Councillor Brian Parbutt – personal Councillor Andrew Rule – personal Councillor Malcom Wood - illness
Councillor Glyn Jenkins – health issues Councillor Toby Neal – other Council business Councillor Andrew Rule – leave Councillor Dave Smith – health issues
Councillor Andrew Rule submitted two petitions on behalf of citizens:
Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Business, Growth and Transport:
Thank you Lord Mayor, and can I thank Councillor Rule for his question.
The answer is no, and a colleague of mine noted that the Conservatives do seem to have something of an inconsistent position with regards to the Area Capital Fund, but actually can I thank Councillor Rule for his question and may I say it’s nice to get a question from an opposition member that is an attempt at a genuine debate about a genuine policy issue.
I’ve had that discussion with a number of Labour members, and I’m happy to have that discussion with Councillor Rule.
• Support the establishment of a referral pathway for the City” The following amendment was proposed by Councillor Jim Armstrong, seconded by Councillor Andrew Rule:
Moved by Councillor Andrew Rule, seconded by Councillor Jon Collins:
Councillor Andrew Rule (call-in signatory) highlighted his concerns as follows:
Councillor Jon Collins – other Council business Councillor Sue Johnson – other Council business Councillor Dave Liversidge – personal Councillor Alex Norris – annual leave Councillor Andrew Rule – personal Councillor David Smith - unwell Councillor Mick Wildgust – unwell
Councillor Sue Johnson – other Council business Councillor Dave Liversidge – personal Councillor Alex Norris – annual leave Councillor Andrew Rule – personal Councillor David Smith - unwell Councillor Mick Wildgust – unwell
Councillor Andrew Rule - personal
Councillor Andrew Rule (personal) Councillor Toby Neal (work) Councillor Liaqat Ali (leave)
Councillor Jon Collins – other council business Councillor Georgina Culley – unwell (Councillor Andrew Rule present as substitute) Councillor Jane Urquhart – work commitments
Land and Planning Policies Document – resident’s parking Councillor Andrew Rule asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Planning and Housing:
Thank you Lord Mayor, and thank you Councillor Rule for the question. Of course, at the beginning of the answer I should say that the only way in which our Land and Planning Policies document is likely to be found sound is if it’s found to be in accordance with the National Planning Policy Framework issued by the Tory government. I’ll come to that a little more in due course.
And the National Planning Policy Framework itself – perhaps that is where we will find the help that Councillor Rule is seeking, and against which of course, our own plan of course will be judged in terms of soundness. Perhaps it gives us that scope in the National ... view the full minutes text for item 76.
Councillor Andrew Rule (Other Council Business) Malcolm Townroe
Councillor Andrew Rule, Councillor Georgina Culley, and Councillor Jim Armstrong voted against the recommendation, and asked that their votes be recorded.
Councillor Andrew Rule, Councillor Georgina Culley, and Councillor Jim Armstrong voted against the recommendations, and asked that their votes be recorded.
2) Overview and Scrutiny Call-In Panel – Councillor Andrew Rule to be appointed to a vacant position on the Panel.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Rule attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Mar 2022 | Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Scrutiny Action Plan Update | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Rule was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 21 of 28 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Rule declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 21 Feb 2023 | Executive Board, item 100 | In the interests of transparency Councillor Andrew Rule declared he was a member of the board of Silverdale and Parkdale Community Centres. He did not consider that this would require him to leave the meeting for this item. | |
| 13 Dec 2019 | Trusts and Charities Committee, item 22 | During discussion of the item, Councillor Rule declared an interest in item 8, ‘Bridge Estate Property Update – exempt appendix’, insofar as he worked for a firm of insolvency practitioners. | |
| 13 Dec 2019 | Trusts and Charities Committee, item 28 | During consideration of this item, Councillor Rule declared an interest (see minute 22 above). |
Where Councillor Rule sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Council | Committee Member | May 2015 | 48 | |
| Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 46 | 27 Nov 2026 |
| Trusts and Charities Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 37 | 21 Dec 2026 |
| Corporate Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 12 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| People, Communities and Environment Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 7 | 6 Jan 2027 |
| Homes, Economy and Infrastructure Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jan 2026 | 2 | |
| Improvement Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2026 | 1 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | May 2016 | 36 | |
| Executive Board | Non-voting | May 2018 | 31 | |
| Area 8 Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2014 | 19 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2017 | 19 | |
| Service Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2016 | 12 | |
| Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | May 2018 | 9 | |
| Regulatory and Appeals Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 7 | |
| City Council (Extraordinary) | Committee Member | Jul 2016 | 7 | |
| Communities and Environment Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 7 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Call-In Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2016 | 6 | |
| Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2017 | 3 | |
| Clifton East and West Area Committee | Vice Chair | Jun 2019 | 3 | |
| Corporate Parenting Board | Committee Member | May 2022 | 3 | |
| Standards and Governance Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2018 | 2 | |
| Nottingham City Governance Improvement Board | Committee Member | Jan 2021 | 1 | |
| Nottinghamshire & City of Nottingham Fire & Rescue Authority | Committee Member | May 2025 | 1 | |
| Nottingham Fire and Rescue Authority - Finance and Resources | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.