Apologies for Absence
Councillor Andrew Rule – substituted by Councillor Kevin Clarke.
Every time Nottingham's minutes name Councillor Clarke, as the council published it.
Councillor Andrew Rule – substituted by Councillor Kevin Clarke.
Councillor Clarke requested that his vote against the above resolutions be recorded.
Councillor Kevin Clarke - work commitments Councillor Samina Riaz - unwell Councillor Adele Williams - work commitments
The Committee noted that Councillor AJ Matsiko has replaced Councillor Kevin Clarke as a member of the Committee.
Councillor Kevin Clarke - unwell Councillor Sam Harris - on leave
Councillor Kevin Clarke - work commitments Councillor Sam Harris - work commitments
Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments Councillor Corall Jenkins – personal reasons Councillor Neghat Khan – other council business Nicki Jenkins Lucy Lee Sajeeda Rose
Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments
Councillor Kevin Clarke - work commitments Councillor AJ Matsiko - work commitments Councillor Samina Riaz - personal reasons Councillor Adele Williams - personal reasons
Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments Vicky Murphy
Councillor Kevin Clarke - leave
Councillor Helen Kalsi – work Councillor Nayab Patel – leave Councillor Maria Watson – personal (Councillor Kevin Clarke subsituting ) Nigel Cullen
Councillor Kevin Clarke - work commitments.
Councillor Kevin Clarke - work commitments Councillor Adele Williams - work commitments
Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments Councillor Jay Hayes – leave Councillor Corall Jenkins - unwell Councillor Neghat Khan – other Council business Beth Brown Ross Brown Roz Howie Shabana Kausar
Councillor Patience Ifediora – Unwell Councillor Georgia Power – Work (Councillor Michael Edwards as substitute) Councillor Andrew Rule – Work (Councillor Kevin Clarke as substitute)
Councillor Kevin Clarke – personal reasons Councillor Corall Jenkins – unwell Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis – other Council business Ailsa Barr Beth Brown Roz Howie
Clifton Town Board Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Executive Member for Skills, Growth and Economic Development:
Thank you Lord Mayor and thank you Councillor Clarke for your question. For context, Clifton was selected by the previous government to be the recipient of funding from the Long Term Plan for Towns programme. In consultation with the community, the Council formed the Town Board with Stephen Hackney as Chair to deliver the long-term plan for Clifton by 1August 2024.
Councillor Leslie Ayoola – leave Councillor Graham Chapman - leave Councillor Kevin Clarke – unwell Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis - leave Councillor Sam Lux – leave
Councillor Steve Battlemuch – leave Councillor Kevin Clarke - leave Councillor Patience Ifediora - leave Councillor Helen Kalsi - leave Councillor Angela Kandola – personal Councillor Fozia Mubashar - leave Councillor Eunice Regan - leave Councillor Samina Riaz - unwell
Councillor Steve Battlemuch – leave Councillor Kevin Clarke – leave Councillor Audra Wynter - personal
Councillor Kevin Clarke – personal Councillor Sam Harris – personal Councillor Imran Jalil - personal
All employees of the Council are currently subject to annual individual performance reviews and further work will need to be undertaken to assess the cost implications and the options for the introduction of performance-related incremental progression for the Chief Executive, Corporate, and Strategic Directors.” Cleaning of the Council House Façade Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Executive Member for Skills, Growth and Economic Development:
Thank you Lord -Mayor, and thank you Councillor Clarke for your question. Given the extent of the financial challenges this Council currently faces, while grappling with huge demand pressures on our services, I must admit looking for funding to spruce up the façade of this building is not high up on our list of ... view the full minutes text for item 25.
Councillor Kevin Clarke requested that his vote against the recommendations be recorded.
Councillor Sam Lux – leave Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments
Councillor Kevin Clarke proposed Councillor Andrew Rule as Leader of the Council.
Councillor Graham Chapman – unwell Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments Councillor Ethan Radford - unwell
Councillor Clarke requested that his abstention from voting on the proposals be recorded.
Councillor Clarke requested that his vote against the proposals be recorded.
In the interests of transparency in relation to item 6 (Safety and Environmental Regulation), Councillor Kevin Clarke declared that he is a director of two Nottingham-based companies (NG11 Cars Limited and Clifton Cobs Limited).
Councillor Kevin Clarke presented a petition on behalf of residents about parking problems on Greencroft, Clifton, NG11 8FD and surrounding roads, and requesting the installation of a resident parking scheme or restricted line enforcement.
Councillor Kevin Clarke asked for his vote against the decision be recorded.
Councillor Kevin Clarke - personal reasons
Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments Councillor Sam Harris – other Council business Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis – other Council business Councillor Ethan Radford -
Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments Councillor Sarita-Marie Rehman-Wall – caring responsibilities
Councillor Kevin Clarke – Personal Reasons Ross Brown, Corporate Director, Finance and Resources
Councillor Kevin Clarke – Other Council business Councillor Faith Gakanje-Ajala – Other Council business Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis – Unwell Councillor Ethan Radford – Personal reasons Councillor Naim Salim - Unwell
Sa fety on the Tram Network Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Leader of the Council: Would the Leader of the Council agree with our Group that with the increase in knife crime in our city and the recent tragic death on the tram network, the time has come to introduce inspectors on all journeys to reassure the public it is safe to travel on the network?
Thank you Lord Mayor and thank you to Councillor Clarke for this question. The recent incident on the tram between Bulwell and Highbury Vale was indeed a tragic incident, and our thoughts are with those affected by the day’s events. The tram operator has been doing all it can to assist the Police with their ongoing inquiries, which are not yet complete.
Aspley ward – Councillor Graham Chapman, Councillor Patience Ifediora and Councillor Carole McCulloch Basford ward – Councillor Salma Mumtaz, Councillor Nick Raine and Councillor Linda Woodings Berridge ward – Councillor Angela Kandola, Councillor Sulcan Mahmood and Councillor Shuguftah Quddoos Bestwood ward – Councillor Jay Hayes, Councillor Georgia Power and Councillor Audra Wynter Bilborough ward – Councillor Faith Gakanje-Ajala , Councillor Sam Harris and Councillor Helen Kalsi Bulwell ward – Councillor Maria Joannou, Councillor Ethan Radford and Councillor Michael Savage Bulwell Forest ward – Councillor Cheryl Barnard, Councillor Sam Gardiner and Councillor Sarita -Marie Rehman -Wall Castle ward – Councillor Sam Lux and Councillor Matt Shannon Clifton East ward – Councillor Kevin Clarke, Councillor Kirsty M Jones and Councillor Maria Watson Clifton West ward – Councillor Andrew Rule and Councillor Hayley Spain Dales ward – Councillor Gul Khan, Councillor Neghat Khan and Councillor David Mellen Hyson Green and Arboretum ward – Councillor Liaqat Ali, Councillor Sana Nasir and Councillor Naim Salim Leen Valley ward – Councillor Audrey Dinnall and Councillor Nadia Farhat Lenton and Wollaton East ward – Councillor Imran Jalil , Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis and Councillor Samina Riaz Mapperley ward – Councillor Leslie Ayoola, Councillor Kirsty L Jones and Councillor Sajid Mohammed Meadows ward – Councillor Michael Edwards and Councillor Eunice Regan Radford ward – Councillor Far
Asset Management Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Strategic Regeneration and Communications:
Thank you Lord Mayor, and can I thank Councillor Clarke for his question. In accordance with the Council’s Together for Nottingham Plan, we are implementing a corporate landlord model as part of our Transformation Programme.
In the budget papers which I’m sure Councillor Clarke will have read, it is clear that our 4 year budget plan relies heavily on transformation, that process by where we look to operate in a different more efficient way in a way that gives good or better offers to our citizens, giving them the best possible value whilst saving money as a result of investing in the service.
Councillor Andrew Rule proposed the following amendment, which was seconded by Councillor Kevin Clarke:
Councillor Leslie Ayoola - leave Councillor Kevin Clarke – work commitments Councillor AJ Matsiko – other Council business Councillor Salma Mumtaz - leave Councillor Toby Neal – unwell Councillor Cate Woodward - unwell
Councillor N Khan – Personal Reasons Councillor Clarke – Work Commitments Malcolm Townroe. Director of Legal and Governance
Councillor Kevin Clarke – unwell Councillor Audrey Dinnall – leave Councillor Sue Johnson – unwell Councillor Rebecca Langton – personal Councillor Dave Liversidge – unwell Councillor Carole McCulloch – unwell Councillor Shuguftah Quddoos – unwell Councillor Mohammed Saghir – unwell Councillor Audra Wynter - personal
Victoria Embankment Paddling Pool Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Highways, Transport and Parks:
As Councillor Clarke was not in attendance at the meeting, the question received a written response after the meeting from Councillor Audra Wynter. That written response is attached to these minutes.
Councillor Lesley Ayoola - other council business Councillor Kevin Clarke - work commitments Councillor Corral Jenkins – leave Councillor Angela Kandola – other council business Councillor Gul Khan – leave Councillor Salma Mumtaz - other council business Councillor Toby Neal - other council business
Councillor Kevin Clarke - personal reasons Councillor Linda Woodings - unwell Councillor Audra Wynter - Council business Malcolm Townroe - Director for Legal and Governance
Councillor Wendy Smith, Lord Mayor, and Councillor David Mellen, Leader of the Council, spoke in tribute to Queen Elizabeth II and this was followed by tributes from Councillor Kevin Clarke, Leader of the Nottingham Independents Group, and Councillor Andrew Rule, Leader of the Conservative Group. Councillors Rebecca Langton, Michael Edwards, Ethan Radford, Angharad Roberts, Cheryl Barnard, Eunice Campbell-Clark, Graham Chapman and Maria Watson then spoke. Councillors spoke about the Queen’s commitment to public duty, and her service to the country and the Commonwealth over many years including periods of significant change.
Councillor Kevin Clarke – personal Councillor Jay Hayes – unwell Councillor AJ Matsiko – personal Councillor Toby Neal – personal Councillor Mohammed Saghir - other council business Councillor Angela Kandola
Councillor Kevin Clarke - personal reasons Councillor Rebecca Langton - maternity leave Councillor Sally Longford - Council business Councillor Linda Woodings - on leave Sajeeda Rose - Corporate Director for Growth and City Development Catherine Underwood - Corporate Director for People
Councillor Kevin Clarke (unwell) Councillor Rebecca Langton (maternity leave)
Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark – unwell Councillor Kevin Clarke - unwell Councillor Michael Edwards - unwell Councillor Sue Johnson – leave Councillor Jawaid Khalil – unwell Councillor Neghat Khan – personal reasons Councillor Zafran Khan – unwell Councillor Rebecca Langton – maternity leave Councillor Dave Liversidge – personal reasons Councillor Sally Longford - unwell Councillor AJ Matsiko – personal reasons Councillor David Mellen – personal reasons Councillor Angharad Roberts – personal reasons
Councillor Clarke abstained from the vote and requested that his abstention be recorded.
Councillor Kevin Clarke - electronic calendar invitation not received due to administrative error Councillor Rebecca Langton - maternity leave Councillor Sally Longford - unwell Councillor Adele Williams - unwell Councillor Audra Wynter - unwell Malcolm Townroe - Director of Legal and Governance
Libraries Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Leader of the Council:
Can I thank Councillor Clarke for his question. I would be happy to pay tribute to those involved in the “Save the Libraries” campaign as well as to thank all those who expressed their view on the proposals put forward by the Council as part of our consultation, brought about by the necessary duty to balance our Council budgets. Their efforts helped contribute towards achieving one of the largest consultation responses the Council has received to date on proposals for the transformation of our City’s library service and, in particular, discussion around three potential library closures.
Councillor Clarke ) leave Councillor Longford ) Councillor Ahmed ) personal Councillor Langton )
Councillor Michael Edwards - council business Councillor Sally Longford – leave Councillor Kevin Clarke - work commitments
Councillor Rebecca Langton – Maternity Leave Councillor Kevin Clarke – Work Commitments Clive Heaphy, Corporate Director for Finance and Resources – Leave The Committee took the opportunity to record their congratulations to Councillor Rebecca Langton on the recent birth of her baby.
Housing rents Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Housing, Planning and Heritage:
As Councillor Clarke is already aware, unlike Government budgets, NHS budgets and council budgets (including the Housing Revenue Account) have to balance every year on a revenue basis. Therefore, the rise in Council rent would have been necessary regardless of the sum transferred incorrectly into the Council’s General Fund. The final sum to be repaid has yet to be determined and awaits the outcome of further investigation.
For Against Councillor Hassan Ahmed ü Councillor Leslie Ayoola ü Councillor Cheryl Barnard ü Councillor Steve Battlemuch ü Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark ü Councillor Graham Chapman ü Councillor Azad Choudhry ü Councillor Kevin Clarke ü Councillor Michael Edwards ü Councillor Jay Hayes ü Councillor Nicola Heaton ü Councillor Patience Ifediora ü Councillor Corall Jenkins ü Councillor Kirsty Jones ü Councillor Angela Kandola ü Councillor Jawaid Khalil ü Councillor Gul Khan ü Councillor Neghat Khan ü Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis ü Councillor Jane Lakey ü Councillor AJ Matsiko ü Councillor David Mellen ü Councillor Toby Neal ü Councillor Anne Peach ü Councillor Georgia Power ü Councillor Ethan Radford ü Councillor Nick Raine ü Councillor Angharad Roberts ü Councillor Andrew Rule ü Councillor Wendy Smith ü Councillor Roger Steel ü Councillor Sam Webster ü Councillor Linda Woodings ü Councillor Cate Woodward ü Councillor Audra Wynter ü Resolved to:
Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark - personal reasons Councillor Kevin Clarke - work commitments Councillor Adele Williams - personal reasons Malcolm Townroe - Director of Legal and Governance Catherine Underwood - Corporate Director for People
Community Centres Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Neighbourhoods, Safety and Inclusion:
Thank you Lord Mayor and can I thank Councillor Clarke for his question. The Council has a number of properties that are let to community groups for minimal rents, often where this is the case without the renting organisation being responsible for either building liabilities or associated community outputs. As part of the Together for Nottingham Plan, previously known as the Recovery and Improvement Plan, which councillors will see later on today’s agenda, we are changing our approach to community asset leases to ensure asset values are maintained and community assets fully utilised.
Councillor Clarke, you make reference to Highbank Community Centre in Clifton where the current management committee has made the Council aware it wishes to dissolve and hand the keys back to the Council.
This is not due to rent, as Councillor Clarke is aware. The group currently pay £10 a year and have paid that figure for over 30 years without any inflation cost. Currently only one group is using the building.
Councillor Cheryl Barnard - personal reasons Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark - unwell Councillor Kevin Clarke - personal reasons Councillor Neghat Khan - personal reasons Councillor Sally Longford - personal reasons Councillor Adele Williams - personal reasons Mel Barrett - Chief Executive Malcolm Townroe - Director of Legal and Governance The Board noted that a number of members and officers who would normally have attended the meeting, but who did not have reports to present on this occasion, had submitted apologies in the interests of supporting Covid safety in the current context of rising infection levels.
Councillor Kevin Clarke requested that his vote against the above decision was recorded.
Councillor Hasan Ahmed - Personal Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark – Council Business Councillor Kevin Clarke – Personal Councillor Sally Longford – Personal
Councillor Leslie Ayoola – personal reasons Councillor Kevin Clarke – personal reasons Councillor Gul Nawaz Khan – personal reasons Councillor Sally Longford – personal reasons Councillor AJ Matsiko – other Council business Councillor Mohammed Saghir – personal reasons Councillor Cate Woodward - leave
Councillor Andrew Rule, seconded by Councillor Kevin Clarke, proposed a further amendment, as set out below:
Nottingham Christmas Market Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Leisure, Culture and IT:
Thank you Lord Mayor and can I thank Councillor Clarke for his question. In terms of the decision making process, Council officers put to me a much reduced event offer and I approved it. That was at a time when the Covid numbers in the City were reducing fast and Nottingham was lower than in areas that were in Tier 2.
Motion proposed by Councillor Kevin Clarke, and seconded by Councillor Maria Watson:
Councillor Clarke requested that his vote against the recommendation be recorded.
Schools Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question of the Portfolio Holder for Regeneration, Schools and Communications:
Thank you Lord Mayor and can I thank Councillor Clarke for his question. The premise of this question is not wholly accurate. All schools in the City did remain open for children of key workers and vulnerable pupils during the first lockdown and this has enabled schools to develop, refine and learn how best to ensure that risks are minimised and that all children and young people can benefit from physical attendance in school since September.
Councillor Clarke is correct that non-attendance will disproportionately affect disadvantaged pupils, which is why the local authority and school leaders have worked so hard to ensure that risk assessments, appropriate cleaning and hygiene practices, support for swift testing measures, social distancing and the use of face coverings as appropriate are all in place in order to keep schools open. Throughout the lockdown there has been regular and increased engagement with all recognised trade unions on the measures that have been implemented to keep schools open for pupils. All of the trade unions also recognise that the impact on disadvantaged pupils of school closures is detrimental.
Covid-19 Regulations Councillor Kevin Clarke asked the following question ... view the full minutes text for item 47.
For Against Abstain Councillor Leslie Ayoola ü Councillor Cheryl Barnard ü Councillor Steve Battlemuch ü Councillor Merlita Bryan ü Councillor Eunice Campbell-Clark ü Councillor Graham Chapman ü Councillor Kevin Clarke ü Councillor Michael Edwards ü Councillor Sam Gardiner ü Councillor Jay Hayes ü Councillor Rosemary Healy ü Councillor Nicola Heaton ü Councillor Patience Ifediora ü Councillor Maria Joannou ü Councillor Kirsty Jones ü Councillor Angela Kandola ü Councillor Jawaid Khalil ü Councillor Gul Khan ü Councillor Neghat Khan ü Councillor Zafran Khan ü Councillor Pavlos Kotsonis ü Councillor Rebecca Langton ü Councillor Chantal Lee ü Councillor Dave Liversidge ü Councillor Sally Longford ü Councillor AJ Matsiko ü Councillor Carole McCulloch ü Councillor David Mellen ü Councillor Sajid Mohammed ü Councillor Salma Mumtaz ü Councillor Toby Neal ü Councillor Lauren O’Grady ü Councillor Anne Peach ü Councillor Shuguftah Quddoos ü Councillor Ethan Radford ü Councillor Nick Raine ü Councillor Angharad Roberts ü Councillor Andrew Rule ü Councillor Wendy Smith ü Councillor Roger Steel ü Councillor Dave Trimble ü Councillor Maria Watson ü Councillor Sam Webster ü Councillor Adele Williams ü Councillor Linda Woodings ü Councillor Cate Woodward ü Councillor Audra Wynter ü Resolved to (1) approve i. the Interim Budget for 2020/21 ii. the recommendations of the Strategic Director of Finance/ Chief Finance Officer in respect of the robustness of the estimates made for the purpos
The Leader of the Council offered to meet with Councillor Andrew Rule, Leader of the Conservative Group, and Councillor Kevin Clarke, Leader of the Nottingham Independents, to discuss their views on the Action Plan in more detail.
Councillor Kevin Clarke (personal reasons), Councillor Maria Watson substituting.
Councillor Cheryl Barnard – leave Councillor Kevin Clarke - leave Councillor Sue Johnson – medical appointment Councillor Carole McCulloch - leave
(f) Councillor Clarke expressed concern that some manufacturers of steel are providing low quality steel that can be difficult to weld. He was reassured that any steel being used must meet British standards, and the steel supplier to the site has been happy with the standard;
Councillor Campbell - annual leave Councillor Clarke ) other Council business Councillor Jackson ) Councillor Garner ) personal Councillor Spencer )
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Clarke attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Clarke's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Clarke was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 13 of 23 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Clarke declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Mar 2024 | Communities and Environment Scrutiny Committee, item 33 | In the interests of transparency in relation to item 6 (Safety and Environmental Regulation), Councillor Kevin Clarke declared that he is a director of two Nottingham-based companies (NG11 Cars Limited and Clifton Cobs Limited). |
Where Councillor Clarke sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 36 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| City Council | Committee Member | May 2019 | 24 | |
| Homes, Economy and Infrastructure Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 7 | |
| Corporate Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Sep 2026 | 1 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Executive Board | Non-voting | May 2019 | 33 | |
| Service Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2020 | 31 | |
| Housing and City Development Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 6 | |
| City Council (Extraordinary) | Committee Member | Jan 2021 | 4 | |
| Clifton East and West Area Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 3 | |
| Communities and Environment Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Mar 2024 | 3 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.